Introduction
We are interested in the existence and behavior around the origin of positive radial solutions of Fully Non Linear elliptic equations posed in punctured balls centered at the origin, namely equations of the form
∣ ∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) + μ u 1 + α ∣ x ∣ 2 + α = u p . (1) |\nabla u|^\alpha F(D^2u)+\mu\frac{u^{1+\alpha}}{|x|^{2+\alpha}}=u^p. \tag*{(1)} ∣∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) + μ ∣ x ∣ 2 + α u 1 + α = u p . (1)
Here α > − 1 \alpha>-1 α > − 1 , p > 1 + α p>1+\alpha p > 1 + α , μ \mu μ is a positive parameter to be precised later, and F F F is one of the Pucci’s operators, even if some of the results here enclosed are also valid for more general FNL operators. The definition of ∣ ∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) |\nabla u|^\alpha F(D^2u) ∣∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) is intended in the sense of [1 ] , [2 ] . Note that this type of operators is an extension of quasi linear operators as the p p p Laplacian operator with p = 2 + α p=2+\alpha p = 2 + α to a fully non linear framework.
When F F F is the Laplace operator and α = 0 \alpha=0 α = 0 problem (1) has been extensively studied, also in the case μ = 0 \mu=0 μ = 0 , see [6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 14 ] . However, the techniques employed rely on the variational structure of the problem, and they cannot immediately be extended to the fully nonlinear framework. Let us recall the definition of the extremal Pucci’s operators
M λ , Λ + ( M ) = Λ ∑ μ i > 0 μ i + λ ∑ μ i < 0 μ i = sup A ∈ A λ , Λ tr ( A M ) , M λ , Λ − ( M ) = λ ∑ μ i > 0 μ i + Λ ∑ μ i < 0 μ i = inf A ∈ A λ , Λ tr ( A M ) . (2) \mathcal{M}_{\lambda,\Lambda}^{+}(M)=\Lambda\sum_{\mu_i>0}\mu_i+\lambda\sum_{\mu_i<0}\mu_i=\sup_{A\in\mathcal{A}_{\lambda,\Lambda}}\operatorname{tr}(AM),\quad\mathcal{M}_{\lambda,\Lambda}^{-}(M)=\lambda\sum_{\mu_i>0}\mu_i+\Lambda\sum_{\mu_i<0}\mu_i=\inf_{A\in\mathcal{A}_{\lambda,\Lambda}}\operatorname{tr}(AM). \tag*{(2)} M λ , Λ + ( M ) = Λ μ i > 0 ∑ μ i + λ μ i < 0 ∑ μ i = A ∈ A λ , Λ sup tr ( A M ) , M λ , Λ − ( M ) = λ μ i > 0 ∑ μ i + Λ μ i < 0 ∑ μ i = A ∈ A λ , Λ inf tr ( A M ) . (2)
where μ 1 , … , μ N \mu_1,\ldots,\mu_N μ 1 , … , μ N are the eigenvalues of any matrix M M M belonging to the space S N \mathcal{S}_N S N of the N N N −squared symmetric matrices. In the sequel we will suppose λ \lambda λ and Λ \Lambda Λ fixe and denote M + ( M ) \mathcal{M}^{+}(M) M + ( M ) for simplicity in place of M λ , Λ + ( M ) \mathcal{M}_{\lambda,\Lambda}^{+}(M) M λ , Λ + ( M ) . When u u u is a radial C 2 C^2 C 2 function in R N ∖ { 0 } \mathbb{R}^N\setminus\{0\} R N ∖ { 0 } , using the abuse u ( x ) = u ( ∣ x ∣ ) = u ( r ) u(x)=u(|x|)=u(r) u ( x ) = u ( ∣ x ∣ ) = u ( r ) , the eigenvalues of D 2 u D^2u D 2 u are u ′ ′ u'' u ′′ of multiplicity 1 and u ′ r \frac{u'}{r} r u ′ of multiplicity N − 1 N-1 N − 1 . As a consequence for example when u u u is decreasing and convex (which will almost always be the case here).
M + ( D 2 u ) = Λ u ′ ′ + λ ( N − 1 ) u ′ ( r ) r . \mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}u)=\Lambda u^{\prime\prime}+\lambda(N-1)\frac{u^{\prime}(r)}{r}. M + ( D 2 u ) = Λ u ′′ + λ ( N − 1 ) r u ′ ( r ) .
The purely eigenvalue problem associated with the operator ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M ± ( D 2 u ) |\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{\pm}(D^{2}u) ∣∇ u ∣ α M ± ( D 2 u ) and the singular potential r − 2 − α r^{-2-\alpha} r − 2 − α ie
{ ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M ± ( D 2 u ) + λ ± u 1 + α r 2 + α = 0 in B 1 ∖ { 0 } u = 0 on ∂ B 1 . \begin{cases}
|\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{\pm}(D^{2}u)+\lambda^{\pm}\dfrac{u^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}=0 & \text{in } B_{1}\setminus\{0\} \\
u=0 & \text{on } \partial B_{1}.
\end{cases} ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ∣∇ u ∣ α M ± ( D 2 u ) + λ ± r 2 + α u 1 + α = 0 u = 0 in B 1 ∖ { 0 } on ∂ B 1 .
has been recently studied in [11 ] . The case α = 0 \alpha=0 α = 0 is treated in [3 ] . Let us recall the definitions of N + N^{+} N + and N − N^{-} N − which are the N N N dimension adapted to Pucci’s operators, see for example Cutri and Leoni [10 ] :
N + = Λ λ ( N − 1 ) + 1 , N − = λ Λ ( N − 1 ) + 1. N^{+}=\frac{\Lambda}{\lambda}(N-1)+1,\quad N^{-}=\frac{\lambda}{\Lambda}(N-1)+1. N + = λ Λ ( N − 1 ) + 1 , N − = Λ λ ( N − 1 ) + 1.
We explicitely determined in [11 ]
λ ˉ + = Λ ( N + − 1 2 + α ) 2 + α ( 1 + α ) 1 + α , \bar{\lambda}^{+}=\Lambda\left(\frac{N^{+}-1}{2+\alpha}\right)^{2+\alpha}(1+\alpha)^{1+\alpha}, λ ˉ + = Λ ( 2 + α N + − 1 ) 2 + α ( 1 + α ) 1 + α ,
in the case of M + \mathcal{M}^{+} M + while in the case of M − \mathcal{M}^{-} M − we exchange λ \lambda λ and Λ \Lambda Λ , N + N^{+} N + and N − N^{-} N − . In the sequel we will focus on the case of M + \mathcal{M}^{+} M + , the changes to bring to the case of M − \mathcal{M}^{-} M − being simple and left to the reader. For this reason we have denoted λ ˉ \bar{\lambda} λ ˉ in place of λ ˉ + \bar{\lambda}^{+} λ ˉ + . The equation we will then refer to is
∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) + μ u 1 + α ∣ x ∣ 2 + α = u p . (3) |\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}u)+\mu\frac{u^{1+\alpha}}{|x|^{2+\alpha}}=u^{p}. \tag*{(3)} ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) + μ ∣ x ∣ 2 + α u 1 + α = u p . (3)
By exploiting the invariance of the equation with respect to the scaling
u γ ( r ) = γ 2 + α 1 + α − p u ( r γ ) for all γ > 0 , u_{\gamma}(r)=\gamma^{\frac{2+\alpha}{1+\alpha-p}}u\left(\frac{r}{\gamma}\right)\qquad\text{for all }\gamma>0, u γ ( r ) = γ 1 + α − p 2 + α u ( γ r ) for all γ > 0 ,
we will consider without loss of generality equation (3) posed in B 1 ∖ { 0 } B_{1}\setminus\{0\} B 1 ∖ { 0 } , and we will refer to smooth, positive, radial solutions simply as solutions.
In order to state our main results, let μ < λ ˉ \mu<\bar{\lambda} μ < λ ˉ and let us introduce τ ± \tau^{\pm} τ ± the two positive zeros of
X 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) X 1 + α + μ Λ . X^{2+\alpha}-(N^{+}-2)X^{1+\alpha}+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda}. X 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) X 1 + α + Λ μ .
We have
τ − < τ : = ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) ( 2 + α ) − 1 < τ + < N + − 2. \tau^{-}<\tau:=(1+\alpha)(N^{+}-2)(2+\alpha)^{-1}<\tau^{+}<N^{+}-2. τ − < τ := ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) ( 2 + α ) − 1 < τ + < N + − 2.
We need also to introduce the critical values p ⋆ = 1 + α + 2 + α τ + p^{\star}=1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{+}} p ⋆ = 1 + α + τ + 2 + α , p ⋆ ⋆ = 1 + α + 2 + α τ − p^{\star\star}=1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{-}} p ⋆⋆ = 1 + α + τ − 2 + α . Note that 1 + α < p ⋆ < p ⋆ ⋆ 1+\alpha<p^{\star}<p^{\star\star} 1 + α < p ⋆ < p ⋆⋆
Our first result is an existence’s result of radial positive solutions having the desired behavior near zero. Let us define for simplicity the value
β = 2 + α p − 1 − α . (4) \beta=\frac{2+\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}. \tag*{(4)} β = p − 1 − α 2 + α . (4)
Theorem 1.1. If μ < λ ˉ \mu< \bar{\lambda} μ < λ ˉ and p > 1 + α p > 1+\alpha p > 1 + α ,
If p < p ⋆ p < p^{\star} p < p ⋆ the equation (3) has at least one solution so that
r β u ( r ) → K , r^{\beta}u(r) \to K, r β u ( r ) → K , where
K p − 1 − α = ( Λ β α + 1 ( β − ( N + − 2 ) ) + μ ) , K^{p-1-\alpha} = \left(\Lambda\beta^{\alpha+1}(\beta-(N^{+}-2))+\mu\right), K p − 1 − α = ( Λ β α + 1 ( β − ( N + − 2 )) + μ ) , and for any c ± > 0 c^{\pm}>0 c ± > 0 at least solutions u u u satisfying
r τ ± u ( r ) → c ± . r^{\tau^{\pm}}u(r) \to c^{\pm}. r τ ± u ( r ) → c ± . If p ⋆ ≤ p < p ⋆ ⋆ p^{\star} \le p < p^{\star\star} p ⋆ ≤ p < p ⋆⋆ , for any c > 0 c>0 c > 0 , there exists u u u , solution of (3) satisfying
u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − . u(r) \sim cr^{-\tau^{-}}. u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − . If p = p ⋆ ⋆ p=p^{\star\star} p = p ⋆⋆ there exists at least one solution of (3) satisfying
r τ − ( − log r ) τ − 2 + α u ( r ) → K ~ , r^{\tau^{-}}(-\log r)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}}u(r) \to\widetilde{K}, r τ − ( − log r ) 2 + α τ − u ( r ) → K , where
K ~ = ( Λ ( τ − ) 1 + α ( τ − τ − ) ) τ − 2 + α . \widetilde{K}=\left(\Lambda(\tau^{-})^{1+\alpha}(\tau-\tau^{-})\right)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}}. K = ( Λ ( τ − ) 1 + α ( τ − τ − ) ) 2 + α τ − . If p > p ⋆ ⋆ p>p^{\star\star} p > p ⋆⋆ there exists at least one solution of (3) satisfying
r β u ( r ) → K . r^{\beta}u(r) \to K. r β u ( r ) → K .
The second Theorem says that there is no other possible behaviors than those described in Theorem 1.1 .
Theorem 1.2. If μ < λ ˉ \mu< \bar{\lambda} μ < λ ˉ and p > 1 + α p>1+\alpha p > 1 + α , let u u u be a positive radial solution of (3) in B 1 ∖ { 0 } B_1 \setminus\{0\} B 1 ∖ { 0 } . Then
If p < p ⋆ p<p^{\star} p < p ⋆ , u u u satisfies either
r β u ( r ) → K , r^{\beta}u(r) \to K, r β u ( r ) → K , or there exist some positive constants c ± c^{\pm} c ± so that
r τ ± u ( r ) → c ± . r^{\tau^{\pm}}u(r) \to c^{\pm}. r τ ± u ( r ) → c ± . if p ⋆ ≤ p < p ⋆ ⋆ p^{\star} \le p < p^{\star\star} p ⋆ ≤ p < p ⋆⋆ , u u u satisfies for some positive constant c c c
u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − . u(r) \sim cr^{-\tau^{-}}. u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − . If p = p ⋆ ⋆ p=p^{\star\star} p = p ⋆⋆ , u u u satisfies
r τ − ( − log r ) τ − 2 + α u ( r ) → K ~ . r^{\tau^{-}}(-\log r)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}}u(r) \to\widetilde{K}. r τ − ( − log r ) 2 + α τ − u ( r ) → K .
If p > p ∗ ∗ p > p^{**} p > p ∗∗
r β u ( r ) → K . r^{\beta}u(r) \to K. r β u ( r ) → K .
Even if the Emdem Fowler transform (see [13 ] for example) does not permit to make explicit calculations of the solutions as in the case α = 0 \alpha= 0 α = 0 , (see [4 ] ) we will frequently use the change of unknown
x ( t ) = r β u ( r ) , r = e t . x(t)=r^{\beta}u(r), r=e^t. x ( t ) = r β u ( r ) , r = e t .
In particular the convergence r β u ( r ) → 0 r^{\beta}u(r) \to0 r β u ( r ) → 0 means x ( t ) → 0 x(t) \to0 x ( t ) → 0 at − ∞ -\infty − ∞ . This change of functions reduces the initial problem for u u u to a two dimensional differential system of order one:
{ x ′ = β x + ∣ Y ∣ 1 1 + α − 1 Y , Y ′ 1 + α = ( β + 1 ) Y + 1 λ ( − λ ( N − 1 ) Y + x p − μ x 1 + α ) + − 1 λ ( − λ ( N − 1 ) Y + x p − μ x 1 + α ) − . \left\{
\begin{aligned}
x'&=\beta x+|Y|^{\frac{1}{1+\alpha}-1}Y,\\
\frac{Y'}{1+\alpha}&=(\beta+1)Y+\frac{1}{\lambda}\left(-\lambda(N-1)Y+x^p-\mu x^{1+\alpha}\right)^+-\frac{1}{\lambda}\left(-\lambda(N-1)Y+x^p-\mu x^{1+\alpha}\right)^-.
\end{aligned}
\right. ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ x ′ 1 + α Y ′ = β x + ∣ Y ∣ 1 + α 1 − 1 Y , = ( β + 1 ) Y + λ 1 ( − λ ( N − 1 ) Y + x p − μ x 1 + α ) + − λ 1 ( − λ ( N − 1 ) Y + x p − μ x 1 + α ) − .
The proofs of Theorem 1.1 and 1.2 will be obtained with the aid of some preliminary results: In section 2 we give two comparison Theorems: The first one is valid not only for the Pucci’s operators, nor only for radial solutions. In section 3 we prove the existence of solutions with the desired behavior. In section 4, after some preliminary observations on the behavior of non trivial solutions we prove that any solution satisfies the behavior described in the existence’s Theorem. An essential difference with the case α ≠ 0 \alpha\ne0 α = 0 treated in [4 ] is that we will need technical propositions which permit to ”linearize” in some sort the higher order part of derivation of the equation, in order to provide a complete asymptotic behavior when u ( r ) r β u(r)r^\beta u ( r ) r β goes to zero.
In conclusion, let us finally mention that the results of the present paper can be regarded as a first step into the study of fully nonlinear uniformly elliptic equations having coefficients with isolated singularities. Many questions remain open, ranging from the analysis of non radially symmetric solutions to the extension of the results to more general elliptic operators and zero order terms. In particular, the study of the limit case μ = λ ˉ \mu=\bar{\lambda} μ = λ ˉ is postponed to a future work, as well as the case μ > λ ˉ \mu>\bar{\lambda} μ > λ ˉ .
Note that a big amount of papers are interested in the case where u p u^p u p is replaced by − u p -u^p − u p . One good reference in the case of the Laplacian is [6 ] , while we consider in [5 ] the Fully Non linear case with α = 0 \alpha=0 α = 0 . The case of Fully Non linear operators, treated in [12 ] in the case μ = 0 \mu=0 μ = 0 , gives an idea of the problems encountered, even if here the singularity at zero brings additional difficulties. One difference with the ”absorbing” case, is the existence of periodic orbits for some particular values of p p p , more precisely in the case p ∈ [ p ∗ , 4 N + − 2 ] p\in[p^*,\frac{4}{N_+-2}] p ∈ [ p ∗ , N + − 2 4 ] . We can expect to have similar results when α ≠ 0 \alpha\ne0 α = 0 , but the highest non linearity of the equation brings new technical difficulties. This will be the object of a future work.
Preliminary results
We begin with the two comparison Theorems announced in the introduction:
Theorem 2.1. Suppose that u ≥ 0 u\ge0 u ≥ 0 and v v v positive are respectively viscosity sub and super-solutions of the equation
∣ ∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) + μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α = u p |\nabla u|^\alpha F(D^2u)+\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}=u^p ∣∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) + μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α = u p
with p > 1 + α p > 1 + \alpha p > 1 + α , and both are continuous on the annulus ] r 1 , r 2 [ ]r_1,r_2[ ] r 1 , r 2 [ with r 1 > 0 r_1 > 0 r 1 > 0 . Then if u ≤ v u \leq v u ≤ v on r i r_i r i , i = 1 , 2 i = 1,2 i = 1 , 2 one has
in all the annulus.
Proof. Let us suppose by contradiction that sup ∣ r 1 , r 2 ∣ u v = γ ′ > 1 \sup_{|r_1,r_2|} \frac{u}{v} = \gamma' > 1 sup ∣ r 1 , r 2 ∣ v u = γ ′ > 1 . Let us take γ ∈ ] 1 , γ ′ [ \gamma\in]1,\gamma'[ γ ∈ ] 1 , γ ′ [ close enough to γ ′ \gamma' γ ′ so that
μ ( ( γ ′ γ ) 1 + α − 1 ) ≤ inf [ r 1 , r 2 ] ( r 2 + α v p − 1 − α ) ( γ p − 1 − α − 1 ) . \mu\left(\left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma}\right)^{1+\alpha}-1\right) \leq\inf_{[r_1,r_2]} \left(r^{2+\alpha}v^{p-1-\alpha}\right)\left(\gamma^{p-1-\alpha}-1\right). μ ( ( γ γ ′ ) 1 + α − 1 ) ≤ [ r 1 , r 2 ] inf ( r 2 + α v p − 1 − α ) ( γ p − 1 − α − 1 ) .
The supremum of u − γ v u-\gamma v u − γ v is positive and achieved inside the open intervall ] r 1 , r 2 [ ]r_1,r_2[ ] r 1 , r 2 [ . Then using the fact that u u u and v v v are sub- and super-solution one gets on a point where sup ( u − γ v ) \sup(u-\gamma v) sup ( u − γ v ) is achieved, (see [1 ] for a complete proof using test functions) :
u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ≤ ∣ ∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) ≤ ∣ ∇ ( γ v ) ∣ α F ( D 2 γ v ) ≤ γ 1 + α v p − μ γ 1 + α v 1 + α r − 2 − α . u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha} \leq|\nabla u|^\alpha F(D^2u) \leq|\nabla(\gamma v)|^\alpha F(D^2\gamma v) \leq\gamma^{1+\alpha}v^p-\mu\gamma^{1+\alpha}v^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}. u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ≤ ∣∇ u ∣ α F ( D 2 u ) ≤ ∣∇ ( γ v ) ∣ α F ( D 2 γ v ) ≤ γ 1 + α v p − μ γ 1 + α v 1 + α r − 2 − α .
This contradicts the assumption on γ \gamma γ .
Theorem 2.2. Suppose that u u u and v v v are respectively positive radial sub-and super-solutions and that there exist some constants c i c_i c i , i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 so that
c 1 ≤ v p − 1 − α r 2 + α ≤ c 2 , and u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ≤ c 2 . c_1 \leq v^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha} \leq c_2,\quad\text{and}\quad u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha} \leq c_2. c 1 ≤ v p − 1 − α r 2 + α ≤ c 2 , and u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ≤ c 2 . Suppose in addition that v v v satisfies ∣ v ′ ∣ ≤ c r − p + 1 p − 1 − α |v'| \leq cr^{-\frac{p+1}{p-1-\alpha}} ∣ v ′ ∣ ≤ c r − p − 1 − α p + 1 . Then if u ≤ v u \leq v u ≤ v on r o r_o r o , u ≤ v u \leq v u ≤ v in all B ( 0 , r o ) ∖ { 0 } B(0,r_o)\setminus\{0\} B ( 0 , r o ) ∖ { 0 } .
Proof. Suppose that sup u v = γ ′ > 1 \sup\frac{u}{v}=\gamma' > 1 sup v u = γ ′ > 1 . Let γ \gamma γ which is so that γ > 1 \gamma> 1 γ > 1 and γ ′ \gamma' γ ′ first so that
γ < 1 + γ ′ 2 \gamma< \frac{1+\gamma'}{2} γ < 2 1 + γ ′ and γ \gamma γ will be close to γ ′ \gamma' γ ′ , chosen later. The supremum of u − γ v u-\gamma v u − γ v is > 0 >0 > 0 . Suppose that the supremum is achieved on r ˉ ≠ 0 \bar r \neq0 r ˉ = 0 . In that case we easily reach the contradiction γ ′ ≤ 1 \gamma' \leq1 γ ′ ≤ 1 by arguing as in the proof of Theorem 2.1.
There remains to do the case where there exists some sequence coming to zero, so that ( u − γ v ) ( r n ) (u-\gamma v)(r_n) ( u − γ v ) ( r n ) converges to the supremum. In particular ( u − γ v ) ( r n ) > 0 (u-\gamma v)(r_n)>0 ( u − γ v ) ( r n ) > 0 . We claim that there exits n 1 n_1 n 1 so that u ( r ) > γ v ( r ) u(r)>\gamma v(r) u ( r ) > γ v ( r ) for any r < r n 1 r<r_{n_1} r < r n 1 . If not for all r 1 r_1 r 1 , there exist σ < s < r 1 \sigma<s<r_1 σ < s < r 1 so that ( u − γ v ) ( σ ) = ( u − γ v ) ( s ) = 0 (u-\gamma v)(\sigma)=(u-\gamma v)(s)=0 ( u − γ v ) ( σ ) = ( u − γ v ) ( s ) = 0 and u − γ v > 0 u-\gamma v>0 u − γ v > 0 inside. On the other hand we have
M + ( ∣ ∇ u ∣ α D 2 u ) − ∣ ∇ ( γ v ) ∣ α D 2 ( γ v ) ≥ ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) − ∣ γ ∇ v ∣ α M + ( D 2 ( γ v ) ) \mathcal{M}^{+}(|\nabla u|^\alpha D^2u)-|\nabla(\gamma v)|^\alpha D^2(\gamma v) \geq|\nabla u|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2u)-|\gamma\nabla v|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2(\gamma v)) M + ( ∣∇ u ∣ α D 2 u ) − ∣∇ ( γ v ) ∣ α D 2 ( γ v ) ≥ ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) − ∣ γ ∇ v ∣ α M + ( D 2 ( γ v )) ≥ u p − γ 1 + α v p − μ u 1 + α − γ 1 + α v 1 + α r 2 + α \geq u^p-\gamma^{1+\alpha}v^p-\mu\frac{u^{1+\alpha}-\gamma^{1+\alpha}v^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}} ≥ u p − γ 1 + α v p − μ r 2 + α u 1 + α − γ 1 + α v 1 + α ≥ ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) v p − μ ( γ ′ ) 1 + α − γ 1 + α r 2 + α v 1 + α \geq(\gamma^p-\gamma^{1+\alpha})v^p-\mu\frac{(\gamma')^{1+\alpha}-\gamma^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}v^{1+\alpha} ≥ ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) v p − μ r 2 + α ( γ ′ ) 1 + α − γ 1 + α v 1 + α ≥ ( ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p − μ ( ( γ ′ ) 1 + α − γ 1 + α ) c 2 1 + α ) r − ( 2 + α ) p p − ( 1 + α ) . \geq\left((\gamma^p-\gamma^{1+\alpha})c_1^p-\mu\left((\gamma')^{1+\alpha}-\gamma^{1+\alpha}\right)c_2^{1+\alpha}\right)r^{-\frac{(2+\alpha)p}{p-(1+\alpha)}}. ≥ ( ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p − μ ( ( γ ′ ) 1 + α − γ 1 + α ) c 2 1 + α ) r − p − ( 1 + α ) ( 2 + α ) p .
We impose to γ \gamma γ to be so that
μ ( ( γ ′ γ ) 1 + α − 1 ) c 2 1 + α < ( ( γ ′ + 1 2 ) p − 1 − α − 1 ) c 1 p 2 \mu\left(\left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma}\right)^{1+\alpha}-1\right)c_2^{1+\alpha}<\frac{\left(\left(\frac{\gamma'+1}{2}\right)^{p-1-\alpha}-1\right)c_1^p}{2} μ ( ( γ γ ′ ) 1 + α − 1 ) c 2 1 + α < 2 ( ( 2 γ ′ + 1 ) p − 1 − α − 1 ) c 1 p
We have obtained that such σ \sigma σ and s s s do not exist since if they are, there exists some t ∈ ] σ , s [ t\in]\sigma,s[ t ∈ ] σ , s [ so that
( u ′ − γ v ′ ) ( t ) = 0 (u'-\gamma v')(t)=0 ( u ′ − γ v ′ ) ( t ) = 0
and
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ) ′ ( t ) ≤ 0. \left(|u'|^\alpha u'-\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v'\right)'(t)\leq0. ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ) ′ ( t ) ≤ 0.
This contradicts the previous computations, in particular u − γ v > 0 u-\gamma v>0 u − γ v > 0 for r < r n 1 r<r_{n_1} r < r n 1 . We also get that there exists c 3 > 0 c_3>0 c 3 > 0 so that for r r r small enough
M + ( ∣ ∇ u ∣ α D 2 u − ∣ γ ∇ v ∣ α D 2 ( γ v ) ) ≥ c 3 r − p ( 2 + α ) p − 1 − α = c 3 r − β p \mathcal{M}^{+}(|\nabla u|^\alpha D^2u-|\gamma\nabla v|^\alpha D^2(\gamma v))\geq c_3r^{-\frac{p(2+\alpha)}{p-1-\alpha}}=c_3r^{-\beta p} M + ( ∣∇ u ∣ α D 2 u − ∣ γ ∇ v ∣ α D 2 ( γ v )) ≥ c 3 r − p − 1 − α p ( 2 + α ) = c 3 r − β p
with c 3 = ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p 2 c_3=\frac{(\gamma^p-\gamma^{1+\alpha})c_1^p}{2} c 3 = 2 ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p . Arguing as in the proof of Proposition 4.1, u ′ − γ v ′ u'-\gamma v' u ′ − γ v ′ has a constant sign in a neighborhood of zero. Since
lim n → + ∞ u ( r n ) − γ v ( r n ) = lim v ( r n ) ( u ( r n ) v ( r n ) − γ ) = + ∞ , \lim_{n\to+\infty}u(r_n)-\gamma v(r_n)=\lim v(r_n)\left(\frac{u(r_n)}{v(r_n)}-\gamma\right)=+\infty, n → + ∞ lim u ( r n ) − γ v ( r n ) = lim v ( r n ) ( v ( r n ) u ( r n ) − γ ) = + ∞ ,
this sign is ≤ 0 \leq0 ≤ 0 . One has
c r − p ( 2 + α ) p − 1 − α + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ ( ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ . (5) cr^{-\frac{p(2+\alpha)}{p-1-\alpha}+(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}
\leq\left((|u'|^\alpha u'-\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v')r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\right)'. \tag*{(5)} c r − p − 1 − α p ( 2 + α ) + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ ( ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ . (5)
Integrating between r r r and 2 r 2r 2 r the inequality (5) , and using 2 k − 1 k > 0 \frac{2^k-1}{k}>0 k 2 k − 1 > 0 for k = ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + 1 − p β k=(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)+1-p\beta k = ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + 1 − pβ when it is ≠ 0 \ne0 = 0 , and also using ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( 2 r ) − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ( 2 r ) ≤ 0 |u'|^\alpha u'(2r)-\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v'(2r)\leq0 ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( 2 r ) − γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ ( 2 r ) ≤ 0 , we obtain that:
If k ≠ 0 k\ne0 k = 0
( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) p − 1 − α = c r − ( β + 1 ) p . \left(\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v'-|u'|^\alpha u'\right)(r)\geq cr^{-\frac{(p+1)(1+\alpha)}{p-1-\alpha}}=cr^{-(\beta+1)p}. ( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − p − 1 − α ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) = c r − ( β + 1 ) p .
While if k = 0 k=0 k = 0 , (ie N + − 2 = 2 + α p − 1 − α N^+-2=\frac{2+\alpha}{p-1-\alpha} N + − 2 = p − 1 − α 2 + α ), we get
( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c log 2 r − ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) = c log 2 r − ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) p − 1 − α . \left(\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v'-|u'|^\alpha u'\right)(r)\geq c\log2r^{-(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}=c\log2r^{-\frac{(p+1)(1+\alpha)}{p-1-\alpha}}. ( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c log 2 r − ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) = c log 2 r − p − 1 − α ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) .
When α ≤ 0 \alpha\leq0 α ≤ 0 we use, depending on the signs of u ′ u' u ′ and v ′ v' v ′ the inequalities when x , y , x − y > 0 x,y,x-y>0 x , y , x − y > 0
x 1 + α ≤ y 1 + α + ( x − y ) 1 + α x^{1+\alpha}\leq y^{1+\alpha}+(x-y)^{1+\alpha} x 1 + α ≤ y 1 + α + ( x − y ) 1 + α
and when x > 0 , y < 0 x>0,y<0 x > 0 , y < 0
x 1 + α + ∣ y ∣ 1 + α ≤ 2 − α ( x + ∣ y ∣ ) 1 + α x^{1+\alpha}+|y|^{1+\alpha}\leq2^{-\alpha}(x+|y|)^{1+\alpha} x 1 + α + ∣ y ∣ 1 + α ≤ 2 − α ( x + ∣ y ∣ ) 1 + α
lead to
γ v ′ − u ′ ≥ 2 α c r − ( p + 1 ) p − 1 − α . \gamma v'-u'\geq2^\alpha cr^{-\frac{(p+1)}{p-1-\alpha}}. γ v ′ − u ′ ≥ 2 α c r − p − 1 − α ( p + 1 ) .
In the case α > 0 \alpha>0 α > 0 we use the additional assumption on v ′ v' v ′ and the fundamental calculus Theorem to get
( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≤ ( 1 + α ) sup ] 0 , r [ ∣ γ v ′ ∣ α ( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) ≤ c r − ( p + 1 ) α p − 1 − α ( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) . \left(\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^\alpha v'-|u'|^\alpha u'\right)(r)\leq(1+\alpha)\sup_{]0,r[}|\gamma v'|^\alpha(\gamma v'-u')(r)\leq cr^{-\frac{(p+1)\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}}(\gamma v'-u')(r). ( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≤ ( 1 + α ) ] 0 , r [ sup ∣ γ v ′ ∣ α ( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) ≤ c r − p − 1 − α ( p + 1 ) α ( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) .
We derive from this that
( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − ( p + 1 ) ( − α ) p − ( 1 + α ) ( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − ( p + 1 ) ( − α ) p − ( 1 + α ) r − ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) p − 1 − α = c r − p + 1 p − ( 1 + α ) (\gamma v' - u')(r) \ge cr^{-\frac{(p+1)(-\alpha)}{p-(1+\alpha)}}\left(\gamma^{1+\alpha}|v'|^{\alpha}v' - |u'|^{\alpha}u'\right)(r) \ge cr^{-\frac{(p+1)(-\alpha)}{p-(1+\alpha)}}r^{-\frac{(p+1)(1+\alpha)}{p-1-\alpha}} = cr^{-\frac{p+1}{p-(1+\alpha)}} ( γ v ′ − u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − p − ( 1 + α ) ( p + 1 ) ( − α ) ( γ 1 + α ∣ v ′ ∣ α v ′ − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) ≥ c r − p − ( 1 + α ) ( p + 1 ) ( − α ) r − p − 1 − α ( p + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) = c r − p − ( 1 + α ) p + 1
in both cases α > 0 \alpha> 0 α > 0 and ≤ 0 \le0 ≤ 0 . Integrating between r r r and 2 r 2r 2 r sufficiently small once more, one gets that for some constant c c c depending only on α \alpha α
( u − γ v ) ( r ) ≥ c c 3 r − β (u-\gamma v)(r) \ge cc_3r^{-\beta} ( u − γ v ) ( r ) ≥ c c 3 r − β
always with some constant independant of γ ′ − γ \gamma' - \gamma γ ′ − γ . On the other hand one has by the definition of γ \gamma γ and γ ′ \gamma' γ ′
c ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p 2 r β ≤ ( u − γ v ) ( r ) ≤ ( γ ′ − γ ) v ( r ) ≤ c 2 ( γ ′ − γ ) r − β . c\frac{(\gamma^p-\gamma^{1+\alpha})c_1^p}{2}r^\beta\le(u-\gamma v)(r) \le(\gamma'-\gamma)v(r) \le c_2(\gamma'-\gamma)r^{-\beta}. c 2 ( γ p − γ 1 + α ) c 1 p r β ≤ ( u − γ v ) ( r ) ≤ ( γ ′ − γ ) v ( r ) ≤ c 2 ( γ ′ − γ ) r − β .
We have obtained a contradiction, since γ \gamma γ and γ ′ \gamma' γ ′ can be taken arbitrarily close.
Proof of Theorem 1.1 : Existence of solutions with the desired asymptotic behaviour
We begin to observe that if z = c r − γ z=cr^{-\gamma} z = c r − γ , with γ > 0 \gamma>0 γ > 0 , z z z satisfies
∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ z 1 + α r 2 + α = c 1 + α ( γ 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) γ 1 + α + μ Λ ) r − ( γ + 1 ) α − γ − 2 |z'|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2z)+\mu\frac{z^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}=c^{1+\alpha}\left(\gamma^{2+\alpha}-(N^+-2)\gamma^{1+\alpha}+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda}\right)r^{-(\gamma+1)\alpha-\gamma-2} ∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ r 2 + α z 1 + α = c 1 + α ( γ 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) γ 1 + α + Λ μ ) r − ( γ + 1 ) α − γ − 2
In particular, if γ ≤ τ − \gamma\le\tau^- γ ≤ τ − or γ ≥ τ + \gamma\ge\tau^+ γ ≥ τ +
∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ z 1 + α r 2 + α ≥ 0 , |z'|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2z)+\mu\frac{z^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}\ge0, ∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ r 2 + α z 1 + α ≥ 0 ,
while if γ ∈ ] τ − , τ + [ \gamma\in]\tau^-,\tau^+[ γ ∈ ] τ − , τ + [
∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ z 1 + α r 2 + α < 0. |z'|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2z)+\mu\frac{z^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}<0. ∣ z ′ ∣ α M + ( D 2 z ) + μ r 2 + α z 1 + α < 0.
This implies that if γ = β \gamma=\beta γ = β , if ( β − τ − ) ( β − τ + ) > 0 (\beta-\tau^-)(\beta-\tau^+)>0 ( β − τ − ) ( β − τ + ) > 0 and c ≤ K c\le K c ≤ K , (respectively c > K c>K c > K ) z z z is a sub-solution, (respectively a super-solution). For c = K c=K c = K , z z z is an exact solution. This proves the existence of solution behaving as K r − β Kr^{-\beta} K r − β in the cases p < p ⋆ p<p^\star p < p ⋆ or p > p ⋆ ⋆ p>p^{\star\star} p > p ⋆⋆ .
We are now interested in the existence of solutions which satisfy lim inf u ( r ) r β = 0 \liminf u(r)r^\beta=0 lim inf u ( r ) r β = 0 .
Proposition 3.1. Suppose that p < 1 + α + 2 + α τ + p<1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^+} p < 1 + α + τ + 2 + α . Then for A > 0 A>0 A > 0 , and a > 0 a>0 a > 0 there exists δ > 0 \delta>0 δ > 0 small enough, and r o ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) > 0 r_o(a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,N^+,\delta)>0 r o ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) > 0 so that in r < r o r<r_o r < r o , w = A r − τ + − a r − τ + + δ w=Ar^{-\tau^+}-ar^{-\tau^++\delta} w = A r − τ + − a r − τ + + δ is a sub-solution of the equation.
Suppose that p < 1 + α + 2 + α τ − p<1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-} p < 1 + α + τ − 2 + α , then for A > 0 A>0 A > 0 , and for a > 0 a>0 a > 0 , there exists δ > 0 \delta>0 δ > 0 small enough and r o : = r o ( a , A , δ , τ − , N + ) > 0 r_o:=r_o(a,A,\delta,\tau^-,N^+)>0 r o := r o ( a , A , δ , τ − , N + ) > 0 so that in r < r o r<r_o r < r o , w = A r − τ − + a r − τ − + δ w=Ar^{-\tau^-}+ar^{-\tau^-+\delta} w = A r − τ − + a r − τ − + δ is a sub-solution of the equation.
Proof. We will use the inequalities: For κ = α \kappa=\alpha κ = α or 1 + α 1+\alpha 1 + α , there exists some positive constant C ( κ ) C(\kappa) C ( κ ) so that for any u ∈ ] 0 , 1 2 [ , u\in]0,\frac{1}{2}[, u ∈ ] 0 , 2 1 [ ,
1 − κ u − C ( κ ) u 2 ≤ ( 1 − u ) α ≤ 1 − κ u + C ( κ ) u 2 1-\kappa u-C(\kappa)u^2\le(1-u)^\alpha\le1-\kappa u+C(\kappa)u^2 1 − κ u − C ( κ ) u 2 ≤ ( 1 − u ) α ≤ 1 − κ u + C ( κ ) u 2
We denote for simplicity τ 1 = τ + − δ \tau_1=\tau^+-\delta τ 1 = τ + − δ . We choose δ \delta δ small enough in order that δ < ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) \delta<(2+\alpha)(\tau^+-\tau) δ < ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) and p τ + < τ + ( 1 + α ) − δ + α + 2 p\tau^+<\tau^+(1+\alpha)-\delta+\alpha+2 p τ + < τ + ( 1 + α ) − δ + α + 2 . We suppose first that r o δ < A τ + 2 ( τ 1 + 1 ) 2 a r_o^\delta<\frac{A\tau^+}{2(\tau_1+1)^2a} r o δ < 2 ( τ 1 + 1 ) 2 a A τ + , and r < r o r<r_o r < r o . Then w w w is positive, decreasing and convex. Having in mind that μ = − Λ ( τ + ) 1 + α ( τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) \mu=-\Lambda(\tau^+)^{1+\alpha}(\tau^+-(N^+-2)) μ = − Λ ( τ + ) 1 + α ( τ + − ( N + − 2 )) and
τ 1 ( τ 1 − ( N + − 2 ) ) = − μ Λ ( τ + ) α − δ ( 2 τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) + δ 2 \tau_1(\tau_1-(N^+-2))=-\frac{\mu}{\Lambda(\tau^+)^\alpha}-\delta(2\tau^+-(N^+-2))+\delta^2 τ 1 ( τ 1 − ( N + − 2 )) = − Λ ( τ + ) α μ − δ ( 2 τ + − ( N + − 2 )) + δ 2
One has
w ′ = − τ + A r − τ + − 1 ( 1 − a τ 1 A τ + r δ ) w'=-\tau^+Ar^{-\tau^+-1}\left(1-\frac{a\tau_1}{A\tau^+}r^\delta\right) w ′ = − τ + A r − τ + − 1 ( 1 − A τ + a τ 1 r δ )
∣ w ′ ∣ α ≤ ( τ + A ) α r − ( τ + + 1 ) α ( 1 − α a A ( 1 − δ τ + ) r δ + C ( α ) ( a τ 1 A τ + r δ ) 2 ) \lvert w'\rvert^\alpha\leq(\tau^+A)^\alpha r^{-(\tau^++1)\alpha}\left(1-\frac{\alpha a}{A}\left(1-\frac{\delta}{\tau^+}\right)r^\delta+C(\alpha)\left(\frac{a\tau_1}{A\tau^+}r^\delta\right)^2\right) ∣ w ′ ∣ α ≤ ( τ + A ) α r − ( τ + + 1 ) α ( 1 − A α a ( 1 − τ + δ ) r δ + C ( α ) ( A τ + a τ 1 r δ ) 2 )
w ′ ′ + w ′ N + − 1 r = A r − τ + − 2 ( − μ ( τ + ) α Λ + a A ( μ ( τ + ) α Λ + δ ( 2 τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) − δ 2 ) r δ ) w''+w'\frac{N^+-1}{r}=Ar^{-\tau^+-2}\left(-\frac{\mu}{(\tau^+)^\alpha\Lambda}+\frac{a}{A}\left(\frac{\mu}{(\tau^+)^\alpha\Lambda}+\delta(2\tau^+-(N^+-2))-\delta^2\right)r^\delta\right) w ′′ + w ′ r N + − 1 = A r − τ + − 2 ( − ( τ + ) α Λ μ + A a ( ( τ + ) α Λ μ + δ ( 2 τ + − ( N + − 2 )) − δ 2 ) r δ )
w 1 + α ∣ ≥ ( A r − τ + ) 1 + α ( 1 − a A ( 1 + α ) r δ − C ( 1 + α ) ( a A r δ ) 2 ) \frac{w^{1+\alpha}}{\vphantom{\big|}} \geq(Ar^{-\tau^+})^{1+\alpha}\left(1-\frac{a}{A}(1+\alpha)r^\delta-C(1+\alpha)\left(\frac{a}{A}r^\delta\right)^2\right) w 1 + α ≥ ( A r − τ + ) 1 + α ( 1 − A a ( 1 + α ) r δ − C ( 1 + α ) ( A a r δ ) 2 )
From this one obtains that there exist some constants c 1 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) c_1(a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,N^+,\delta) c 1 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) and c 2 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) > 0 c_2(a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,N^+,\delta)>0 c 2 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) > 0 , so that
∣ w ′ ∣ α ( w ′ ′ + w ′ N + − 1 r ) + μ w 1 + α Λ r α + 2 ≥ δ A α a ( τ + ) α ( τ + ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) − δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2 \begin{aligned}
\lvert w'\rvert^\alpha\left(w''+w'\frac{N^+-1}{r}\right)+\mu\frac{w^{1+\alpha}}{\Lambda r^{\alpha+2}} \\
&\geq\delta A^\alpha a(\tau^+)^\alpha\left(\tau^+(2+\alpha)-(1+\alpha)(N^+-2)-\delta\right)r^{-\tau^+(1+\alpha)+\delta-\alpha-2}
\end{aligned} ∣ w ′ ∣ α ( w ′′ + w ′ r N + − 1 ) + μ Λ r α + 2 w 1 + α ≥ δ A α a ( τ + ) α ( τ + ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) − δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2
− c 1 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) − α − 2 + 2 δ ≥ c 2 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2 \begin{aligned}
\qquad-c_1(a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,N^+,\delta)r^{-\tau^+(1+\alpha)-\alpha-2+2\delta} \\
&\geq c_2(a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,N^+,\delta)r^{-\tau^+(1+\alpha)+\delta-\alpha-2}
\end{aligned} − c 1 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) − α − 2 + 2 δ ≥ c 2 ( a , A , α , τ + , N + , δ ) r − τ + ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2
as soon as r < r 1 r<r_1 r < r 1 , where r 1 r_1 r 1 is chosen small enough depending on a , A , α , τ + , δ , N + a,A,\alpha,\tau^+,\delta,N^+ a , A , α , τ + , δ , N + . On another hand,
w p ≥ A p r − p τ + . w^p\geq A^pr^{-p\tau^+}. w p ≥ A p r − p τ + .
Choosing r 2 r_2 r 2 so that r 2 τ + ( p − ( 1 + α ) ) − α − 2 + δ > A p c 2 r_2^{\tau^+(p-(1+\alpha))-\alpha-2+\delta}>\frac{A^p}{c_2} r 2 τ + ( p − ( 1 + α )) − α − 2 + δ > c 2 A p , r 2 < r 1 r_2<r_1 r 2 < r 1 , and r < r 2 r<r_2 r < r 2 we get the desired result.
For the second assertion, it is sufficient to replace in the calculation above τ + \tau^+ τ + by τ − \tau^- τ − and a a a by − a -a − a . One gets that there exists some constant c 1 ( a , A , α , τ − , N + , δ ) c_1(a,A,\alpha,\tau^-,N^+,\delta) c 1 ( a , A , α , τ − , N + , δ ) , c 2 ( a , A , α , τ − , N + , δ ) > 0 c_2(a,A,\alpha,\tau^-,N^+,\delta)>0 c 2 ( a , A , α , τ − , N + , δ ) > 0 , c 3 ( a , A , p , δ ) > 0 c_3(a,A,p,\delta)>0 c 3 ( a , A , p , δ ) > 0 so that
∣ ∇ w ∣ α M + ( D 2 w ) + μ w 1 + α Λ r α + 2 = − δ a A α ( τ − ) α ( τ − ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) − δ ) r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2 \lvert\nabla w\rvert^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2w)+\mu\frac{w^{1+\alpha}}{\Lambda r^{\alpha+2}}
=-\delta aA^\alpha(\tau^-)^\alpha\left(\tau^-(2+\alpha)-(1+\alpha)(N^+-2)-\delta\right)r^{-\tau^-(1+\alpha)+\delta-\alpha-2} ∣ ∇ w ∣ α M + ( D 2 w ) + μ Λ r α + 2 w 1 + α = − δ a A α ( τ − ) α ( τ − ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) − δ ) r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2
− c 1 ( a , A , τ − , α , N + , δ ) ( r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + 2 δ − α − 2 ) ≥ c 2 ( a , A , τ − , α , N + , δ ) r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2 ≥ c 3 ( a , A , p , δ ) r − p τ − ≥ w p \begin{aligned}
\qquad-c_1(a,A,\tau^-,\alpha,N^+,\delta)\left(r^{-\tau^-(1+\alpha)+2\delta-\alpha-2}\right) \\
&\geq c_2(a,A,\tau^-,\alpha,N^+,\delta)r^{-\tau^-(1+\alpha)+\delta-\alpha-2} \\
&\geq c_3(a,A,p,\delta)r^{-p\tau^-} \\
&\geq w^p
\end{aligned} − c 1 ( a , A , τ − , α , N + , δ ) ( r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + 2 δ − α − 2 ) ≥ c 2 ( a , A , τ − , α , N + , δ ) r − τ − ( 1 + α ) + δ − α − 2 ≥ c 3 ( a , A , p , δ ) r − p τ − ≥ w p
using τ − ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) < 0 \tau^-(2+\alpha)-(1+\alpha)(N^+-2)<0 τ − ( 2 + α ) − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) < 0 , as soon as δ \delta δ is small enough in order that p τ − < τ − ( 1 + α ) − δ + α + 2 p\tau^-<\tau^-(1+\alpha)-\delta+\alpha+2 p τ − < τ − ( 1 + α ) − δ + α + 2 , and choosing r o r_o r o conveniently. ∩ევნ
Proof. of Theorem 1.1
We provide a solution by using a decreasing sequence ( r n ) (r_n) ( r n ) coming to zero, and constructing a sequence v n v_n v n on [ r n , r o ] [r_n,r_o] [ r n , r o ] in the following way: Let r o r_o r o be small enough and v ‾ \underline{v} v and v ‾ \overline{v} v respectively ordered sub- and super-solutions in ] 0 , r o [ ]0,r_o[ ] 0 , r o [ . The first element of the sequence is v ‾ \underline{v} v . We define v 1 v_1 v 1 on [ r 1 , r o ] [r_1,r_o] [ r 1 , r o ] as the radial solution of the equation
{ − ∣ ∇ v 1 ∣ α M + ( D 2 v 1 ) + ∣ v 1 ∣ p − 1 v 1 = μ v ‾ 1 + α r 2 + α on [ r 1 , r o [ v 1 ( r o ) = v ‾ ( r o ) , v 1 ( r 1 ) = v ‾ ( r 1 ) \left\{
\begin{aligned}
-|\nabla v_1|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2v_1)+|v_1|^{p-1}v_1&=\mu\frac{\underline{v}^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}} &&\text{on }[r_1,r_o[\\
v_1(r_o)&=\underline{v}(r_o),\qquad v_1(r_1)=\underline{v}(r_1)
\end{aligned}
\right. ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ − ∣∇ v 1 ∣ α M + ( D 2 v 1 ) + ∣ v 1 ∣ p − 1 v 1 v 1 ( r o ) = μ r 2 + α v 1 + α = v ( r o ) , v 1 ( r 1 ) = v ( r 1 ) on [ r 1 , r o [
The existence of v 1 v_1 v 1 is a consequence of the existence's results in [1 ] , [2 ] . Furthermore, by the comparison principle in [1 ] , v 1 ≥ v ‾ > 0 v_1\geq\underline{v}>0 v 1 ≥ v > 0 on [ r 1 , r o ] [r_1,r_o] [ r 1 , r o ] . Once v n v_n v n is defined on [ r n , r o ] [r_n,r_o] [ r n , r o ] we define v n + 1 v_{n+1} v n + 1 on [ r n + 1 , r o ] [r_{n+1},r_o] [ r n + 1 , r o ] by
{ − ∣ ∇ v n + 1 ∣ α M + ( D 2 v n + 1 ) + ∣ v n + 1 ∣ p − 1 v n + 1 = { μ v ‾ 1 + α r 2 + α on [ r n , r o [ , μ v ‾ 1 + α r 2 + α on [ r n + 1 , r n [ v n + 1 ( r o ) = v ‾ ( r o ) , v n + 1 ( r n + 1 ) = v n ( r n + 1 ) \left\{
\begin{aligned}
-|\nabla v_{n+1}|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^2v_{n+1})+|v_{n+1}|^{p-1}v_{n+1}
&=
\begin{cases}
\mu\frac{\overline{v}^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}} & \text{on }[r_n,r_o[,\\
\mu\frac{\underline{v}^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}} & \text{on }[r_{n+1},r_n[
\end{cases}\\
v_{n+1}(r_o)&=\underline{v}(r_o),\qquad v_{n+1}(r_{n+1})=v_n(r_{n+1})
\end{aligned}
\right. ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ − ∣∇ v n + 1 ∣ α M + ( D 2 v n + 1 ) + ∣ v n + 1 ∣ p − 1 v n + 1 v n + 1 ( r o ) = { μ r 2 + α v 1 + α μ r 2 + α v 1 + α on [ r n , r o [ , on [ r n + 1 , r n [ = v ( r o ) , v n + 1 ( r n + 1 ) = v n ( r n + 1 )
v n + 1 v_{n+1} v n + 1 is well defined and positive. By the classical comparison principle in [1 ] , ( v n ) n (v_n)_n ( v n ) n is increasing, and v ‾ ≤ v n ≤ v ‾ \underline{v}\leq v_n\leq\overline{v} v ≤ v n ≤ v on [ r n , r o ] [r_n,r_o] [ r n , r o ] . Standard stability and regularity results in [1 ] then imply that the monotone locally uniformly bounded sequence { v n } \{v_n\} { v n } converges in C l o c 2 ( ( 0 , r o ] ) C^2_{\mathrm{loc}}((0,r_o]) C loc 2 (( 0 , r o ]) to a radial solution v v v of equation (3) . Furthermore using Proposition 3.1 and choosing A < B A<B A < B , and a > 0 a>0 a > 0 , for r o r_o r o convenient, w ‾ = B r − τ + \overline{w}=Br^{-\tau^+} w = B r − τ + and w ‾ = A r − τ + − a r − τ + + δ \underline{w}=Ar^{-\tau^+}-ar^{-\tau^++\delta} w = A r − τ + − a r − τ + + δ are respectively super- and sub-solutions of the equation, on ] 0 , r o [ ]0,r_o[ ] 0 , r o [ , so that w ‾ ≤ w ‾ \underline{w}\leq\overline{w} w ≤ w . We get that we can construct a solution such that for r r r small enough and for some positive constants c i c_i c i , i = 1 ; 2 i=1;2 i = 1 ; 2 :
c 1 ≤ v r τ + ≤ c 2 c_1\leq vr^{\tau^+}\leq c_2 c 1 ≤ v r τ + ≤ c 2
It is left to prove that v ( r ) v(r) v ( r ) is asymptotic to r − τ + r^{-\tau^+} r − τ + as r → 0 r\to0 r → 0 . By the bounds above, there exists a decreasing sequence { r n } \{r_n\} { r n } converging to zero such that v ( r n ) r n τ + → c 1 v(r_n)r_n^{\tau^+}\to c_1 v ( r n ) r n τ + → c 1 for some c 1 > 0 c_1>0 c 1 > 0 . For ϵ > 0 \epsilon>0 ϵ > 0 arbitrarily small, and δ \delta δ as in Proposition 3.1, let ν ≥ 1 \nu\geq1 ν ≥ 1 such that c 1 − ϵ ≤ v ( r n ) r n τ + ≤ c 1 + ϵ c_1-\epsilon\leq v(r_n)r_n^{\tau^+}\leq c_1+\epsilon c 1 − ϵ ≤ v ( r n ) r n τ + ≤ c 1 + ϵ for n ≥ ν n\geq\nu n ≥ ν and, moreover, r ν < r o ( ϵ , c 1 − ϵ , τ + , N + , δ ) r_\nu<r_o(\epsilon,c_1-\epsilon,\tau^+,N^+,\delta) r ν < r o ( ϵ , c 1 − ϵ , τ + , N + , δ ) as in Proposition 3.1. Then, for all n ≥ ν n\geq\nu n ≥ ν , we can consider on the interval [ r n + 1 , r n ] [r_{n+1},r_n] [ r n + 1 , r n ] the supersolution z ‾ = ( c 1 + ϵ ) r − τ + \overline{z}=(c_1+\epsilon)r^{-\tau^+} z = ( c 1 + ϵ ) r − τ + and the subsolution z ‾ = ( c 1 − ϵ ) r − τ + − ϵ r − τ + + δ \underline{z}=(c_1-\epsilon)r^{-\tau^+}-\epsilon r^{-\tau^++\delta} z = ( c 1 − ϵ ) r − τ + − ϵ r − τ + + δ . Since
z ‾ ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n − τ + ≤ v ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n − τ + = z ‾ ( r n ) , \underline{z}(r_n)\leq(c_1-\epsilon)r_n^{-\tau^+}\leq v(r_n)\leq(c_1+\epsilon)r_n^{-\tau^+}=\overline{z}(r_n), z ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n − τ + ≤ v ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n − τ + = z ( r n ) ,
and
z ‾ ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ + ≤ v ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ + = z ‾ ( r n + 1 ) , \underline{z}(r_{n+1})\leq(c_1-\epsilon)r_{n+1}^{-\tau^+}\leq v(r_{n+1})\leq(c_1+\epsilon)r_{n+1}^{-\tau^+}=\overline{z}(r_{n+1}), z ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ + ≤ v ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ + = z ( r n + 1 ) ,
the comparison principle given by Proposition 2.1 yields z ‾ ≤ v ≤ z ‾ \underline{z}\leq v\leq\overline{z} z ≤ v ≤ z in [ r n + 1 , r n ] [r_{n+1},r_n] [ r n + 1 , r n ] for all n ≥ ν n\geq\nu n ≥ ν , which implies that finally
c 1 − 2 ϵ ≤ v ( r ) r τ + ≤ c 1 + ϵ c_1-2\epsilon\leq v(r)r^{\tau^+}\leq c_1+\epsilon c 1 − 2 ϵ ≤ v ( r ) r τ + ≤ c 1 + ϵ
If p < p ⋆ ⋆ p<p^{\star\star} p < p ⋆⋆ , in order to prove the existence of a solution equivalent to some constant r − τ − r^{-\tau^-} r − τ − , we use the same construction as in the first part concerning τ + \tau^+ τ + . We obtain a solution which satisfies c 1 ≤ v r τ − ≤ c 2 c_1\leq vr^{\tau^-}\leq c_2 c 1 ≤ v r τ − ≤ c 2 . To prove that v v v is asymptotic to r − τ − r^{-\tau^-} r − τ − , by the bounds above, there exists a decreasing sequence { r n } \{r_n\} { r n } converging to zero such that v ( r n ) r n τ − → c 1 v(r_n)r_n^{\tau^-}\to c_1 v ( r n ) r n τ − → c 1 for some c 1 > 0 c_1>0 c 1 > 0 . For ϵ > 0 \epsilon>0 ϵ > 0 arbitrarily small, let ν ≥ 1 \nu\geq1 ν ≥ 1 such that c 1 − ϵ ≤ v ( r n ) r n τ − ≤ c 1 + ϵ c_1-\epsilon\leq v(r_n)r_n^{\tau^-}\leq c_1+\epsilon c 1 − ϵ ≤ v ( r n ) r n τ − ≤ c 1 + ϵ for n ≥ ν n\geq\nu n ≥ ν and, moreover, r ν < r o ( ϵ , c 1 − 2 ϵ , δ , τ − , N + ) r_\nu<r_o(\epsilon,c_1-2\epsilon,\delta,\tau^-,N^+) r ν < r o ( ϵ , c 1 − 2 ϵ , δ , τ − , N + ) as in Proposition 3.1. Then, for all n ≥ ν n \ge\nu n ≥ ν , we can consider on the interval [ r n + 1 , r n ] [r_{n+1},r_n] [ r n + 1 , r n ] the supersolution z ‾ = ( c 1 + ϵ ) r − τ − \overline{z}=(c_1+\epsilon)r^{-\tau^-} z = ( c 1 + ϵ ) r − τ − and the subsolution z ‾ = ( c 1 − 2 ϵ ) r − τ − + ϵ r − τ − + δ \underline{z}=(c_1-2\epsilon)r^{-\tau^-}+\epsilon r^{-\tau^-+\delta} z = ( c 1 − 2 ϵ ) r − τ − + ϵ r − τ − + δ . One has z ‾ ≤ z ‾ \underline{z}\leq\overline{z} z ≤ z . Since
z ‾ ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n − τ − ≤ v ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n − τ + = z ‾ ( r n ) \underline{z}(r_n)\leq(c_1-\epsilon)r_n^{-\tau^-}\leq v(r_n)\leq(c_1+\epsilon)r_n^{-\tau^+}=\overline{z}(r_n) z ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n − τ − ≤ v ( r n ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n − τ + = z ( r n )
as well as
z ‾ ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ − ≤ v ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ − = z ‾ ( r n + 1 ) , \underline{z}(r_{n+1})\leq(c_1-\epsilon)r_{n+1}^{-\tau^-}\leq v(r_{n+1})\leq(c_1+\epsilon)r_{n+1}^{-\tau^-}=\overline{z}(r_{n+1}), z ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 − ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ − ≤ v ( r n + 1 ) ≤ ( c 1 + ϵ ) r n + 1 − τ − = z ( r n + 1 ) ,
the comparison principle given by Theorem 2.1 yields z ‾ ≤ v ≤ z ‾ \underline{z}\leq v\leq\overline{z} z ≤ v ≤ z in [ r n + 1 , r n ] [r_{n+1},r_n] [ r n + 1 , r n ] for all n ≥ ν n\geq\nu n ≥ ν , which implies that finally
c 1 − 2 ϵ ≤ v ( r ) r τ − ≤ c 1 + ϵ c_1-2\epsilon\leq v(r)r^{\tau^-}\leq c_1+\epsilon c 1 − 2 ϵ ≤ v ( r ) r τ − ≤ c 1 + ϵ
For the case p = p ⋆ ⋆ p=p^{\star\star} p = p ⋆⋆ it is sufficient to remark that for a < K ~ a<\widetilde{K} a < K , and for any c > 0 c>0 c > 0
w = a r − τ − ( − log r + c ) τ − 2 + α w=ar^{-\tau^-}(-\log r+c)^{\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}} w = a r − τ − ( − log r + c ) 2 + α τ −
is a sub-solution for r r r small enough, while if a > K ~ a>\widetilde{K} a > K it is a super-solution. We do not give the details of the proof: We just remark that for a < K ~ a<\widetilde{K} a < K
∣ w ′ ∣ α ( w ′ ′ + N + − 1 r w ′ ) + μ w 1 + α r − 2 − α = ( a τ − ) α ( a τ − ( τ − − τ − ) ) a − p w p + O ( r − τ − p ( c − log r ) − τ − p − 1 ) = Λ − 1 a 1 + α − p K ~ p − 1 − α w p + o ( w p ) ≥ Λ − 1 w p . \begin{aligned}
\left|w'\right|^\alpha\left(w''+\frac{N^+-1}{r}w'\right)+\mu w^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}
=(a\tau^-)^\alpha\left(a\tau^-(\tau^--\tau^-)\right)a^{-p}w^p+O\left(r^{-\tau^-p}(c-\log r)^{-\tau^-p-1}\right) \\
&=\Lambda^{-1}a^{1+\alpha-p}\widetilde{K}^{p-1-\alpha}w^p+o(w^p) \\
&\geq\Lambda^{-1}w^p.
\end{aligned} ∣ w ′ ∣ α ( w ′′ + r N + − 1 w ′ ) + μ w 1 + α r − 2 − α = ( a τ − ) α ( a τ − ( τ − − τ − ) ) a − p w p + O ( r − τ − p ( c − log r ) − τ − p − 1 ) = Λ − 1 a 1 + α − p K p − 1 − α w p + o ( w p ) ≥ Λ − 1 w p .
as soon as r r r is small enough. An analogous calculation permits to prove that for a > K ~ a>\widetilde{K} a > K , w ‾ = a r − τ − ( − log r + c ) τ − 2 + α \overline{w}=ar^{-\tau^-}(-\log r+c)^{\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}} w = a r − τ − ( − log r + c ) 2 + α τ − is a super-solution, as soon as r r r is small enough. The reasoning for the end of the proof is as in the case p < p ⋆ ⋆ p<p^{\star\star} p < p ⋆⋆ .
Proof of Theorem 1.2
We begin with some preliminary observations.
First of all, we note that if u u u is a nonnegative solution of equation (3) , by the equation in radial coordinates, one gets that on a point r o ≠ 0 r_o\ne0 r o = 0 , if u ( r o ) = 0 u(r_o)=0 u ( r o ) = 0 , then u ′ ( r o ) = 0 u'(r_o)=0 u ′ ( r o ) = 0 since r o r_o r o is a minimum and then by Cauchy Lipschitz Theorem, u u u vanishes identically or it is strictly positive in B 1 ∖ { 0 } B_1\setminus\{0\} B 1 ∖ { 0 } . Thus, in the sequel, by a solution we mean a positive radial solution.
Proposition 4.1. Suppose that ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) \lvert\nabla u\rvert^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2u) ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) has a sign for r r r small enough, and u u u is unbounded. Then u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 .
Proof. If ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≥ 0 \lvert\nabla u\rvert^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2u)\geq0 ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≥ 0 , since u u u is radial, this can be written as
Λ ( ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ 1 + α ) + − λ ( ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ 1 + α ) − + Λ N − 1 r ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) + − λ N − 1 r ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) − ≥ 0 \Lambda\left(\frac{(\lvert u'\rvert^\alpha u')'}{1+\alpha}\right)^+
-\lambda\left(\frac{(\lvert u'\rvert^\alpha u')'}{1+\alpha}\right)^-
+\Lambda\frac{N-1}{r}(\lvert u'\rvert^\alpha u')^+
-\lambda\frac{N-1}{r}(\lvert u'\rvert^\alpha u')^-\geq0 Λ ( 1 + α (∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ) + − λ ( 1 + α (∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ) − + Λ r N − 1 (∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) + − λ r N − 1 (∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) − ≥ 0
Suppose that u ′ u' u ′ changes sign indefinitely, then in particular there exists ( r n ) n (r_n)_n ( r n ) n coming to zero so that u ′ ( r n ) = 0 u'(r_n)=0 u ′ ( r n ) = 0 and u ′ < 0 u'<0 u ′ < 0 in ] r n + 1 , r n [ ]r_{n+1},r_n[ ] r n + 1 , r n [ . By the mean value’s theorem there exists s n ∈ ] r n + 1 , r n [ s_n\in]r_{n+1},r_n[ s n ∈ ] r n + 1 , r n [ so that u ′ ′ ( s n ) = 0 u''(s_n)=0 u ′′ ( s n ) = 0 , a contradiction since by the equation Λ ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ′ ( s n ) > 0 \Lambda|u'|^\alpha u''(s_n)>0 Λ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′′ ( s n ) > 0 . The reasoning is analogous if ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ 0 |\nabla u|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2u)\leq0 ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ 0 . Then u ′ u' u ′ has constant sign near zero, but if u ′ ≥ 0 u'\geq0 u ′ ≥ 0 , this would contradict u u u unbounded. □ \square □
We prove that any non trivial positive radial solution satisfies :
Proposition 4.2. There exists some constant C C C so that
u ( r ) ≤ C r − 2 − α p − 1 − α = C r − β u(r)\leq Cr^{\frac{-2-\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}}=Cr^{-\beta} u ( r ) ≤ C r p − 1 − α − 2 − α = C r − β
Proof. We preliminarily observe that if u ( r ) r β u(r)r^\beta u ( r ) r β is bounded along a decreasing sequence { r n } \{r_n\} { r n } converging to zero, then it is bounded in a neighborhood of zero. Indeed, let us assume that there exists C > 0 C>0 C > 0 such that
u ( r n ) r n − β ≤ C . u(r_n)r_n^{-\beta}\leq C. u ( r n ) r n − β ≤ C .
By using the computation made at the beginning of the section, we know that, for C > 0 C>0 C > 0 sufficiently large, the function C r − 2 − α p − 1 − α Cr^{\frac{-2-\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}} C r p − 1 − α − 2 − α is a super-solution of equation (3) . Then, by applying Theorem 2.1 in every annulus B r n ∖ B r n + 1 B_{r_n}\setminus B_{r_{n+1}} B r n ∖ B r n + 1 , we obtain
u ( r ) ≤ C r − β for 0 < r ≤ r 1 . u(r)\leq Cr^{-\beta}\qquad\text{for }0<r\leq r_1. u ( r ) ≤ C r − β for 0 < r ≤ r 1 .
Hence, if we assume that u ( r ) r β u(r)r^\beta u ( r ) r β is unbounded along a decreasing sequence { r n } \{r_n\} { r n } converging to zero then we deduce
lim r → 0 u ( r ) r β = + ∞ . \lim_{r\to0}u(r)r^\beta=+\infty. r → 0 lim u ( r ) r β = + ∞.
This implies that, for r r r small enough, one has
∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) = u p − μ u 1 + α r 2 + α ≥ u p 2 > 0. |\nabla u|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2u)=u^p-\mu\frac{u^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}\geq\frac{u^p}{2}>0. ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) = u p − μ r 2 + α u 1 + α ≥ 2 u p > 0.
Then, by Proposition 4.1, since u u u is unbounded, u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 . Then u ′ ′ ≥ 0 u''\geq0 u ′′ ≥ 0 and by the equation there exists some positive constant c c c so that ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ′ ≥ c u p |u'|^\alpha u''\geq cu^p ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′′ ≥ c u p . Multiplying by u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 one gets for another positive constant c c c
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 − c u p + 1 ) ′ ≤ 0 , \left(|u'|^{\alpha+2}-cu^{p+1}\right)'\leq0, ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 − c u p + 1 ) ′ ≤ 0 ,
integrating one gets for r < r o r<r_o r < r o
∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 ( r o ) − c u p + 1 ( r o ) ≤ ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 ( r ) − c u p + 1 ( r ) . |u'|^{\alpha+2}(r_o)-cu^{p+1}(r_o)\leq|u'|^{\alpha+2}(r)-cu^{p+1}(r). ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 ( r o ) − c u p + 1 ( r o ) ≤ ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 ( r ) − c u p + 1 ( r ) .
Using u p + 1 → + ∞ u^{p+1}\to+\infty u p + 1 → + ∞ , there exists some constant c c c which can vary from one line to another so that for r o r_o r o small enough and r < r o r<r_o r < r o ,
∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 u p + 1 ≥ c , \frac{|u'|^{\alpha+2}}{u^{p+1}}\geq c, u p + 1 ∣ u ′ ∣ α + 2 ≥ c ,
which means
u ′ u p + 1 α + 2 ≤ − c . \frac{u'}{u^{\frac{p+1}{\alpha+2}}}\leq-c. u α + 2 p + 1 u ′ ≤ − c .
Integrating one gets using lim r → 0 u 1 − p + 1 2 + α = 0 \lim_{r\to0}u^{1-\frac{p+1}{2+\alpha}}=0 lim r → 0 u 1 − 2 + α p + 1 = 0 that
u 1 − p + 1 2 + α ≥ c r , u^{1-\frac{p+1}{2+\alpha}}\ge cr, u 1 − 2 + α p + 1 ≥ cr ,
but this contradicts the assumption.
The following estimate on u ′ u' u ′ will be needed for some of the results. It also permits to obtain the results in most of the cases by an alternative proof, with the aid of the Theorem of Poincaré Bendixson.
Proposition 4.3. Suppose that β ≠ N + − 2 \beta\ne N^+-2 β = N + − 2 . Suppose that u u u is a positive radial solution, so that u ′ ≤ 0 u'\le0 u ′ ≤ 0 . There exists some constant C C C so that
∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ C r − β − 1 . |u'|\le Cr^{-\beta-1}. ∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ C r − β − 1 .
Proof. Let us observe that whatever is the sign of u ′ ′ u'' u ′′
∣ u ′ ∣ α ( Λ u ′ ′ + λ ( N − 1 ) u ′ r ) ≤ u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α |u'|^\alpha\left(\Lambda u''+\lambda\frac{(N-1)u'}{r}\right)\le u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha} ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( Λ u ′′ + λ r ( N − 1 ) u ′ ) ≤ u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α
Then
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≤ c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − 1 + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) . (6) \left(|u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\right)'\le cr^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)-1+(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}. \tag*{(6)} ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≤ c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − 1 + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) . (6)
On the other hand, if u ′ ′ ≤ 0 u''\le0 u ′′ ≤ 0 by the equation,
∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′ ′ + λ Λ ( N − 1 ) u ′ r ) ≥ ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′ ′ + ( N − 1 ) u ′ r ) = 1 λ ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) |u'|^\alpha\left(u''+\frac{\lambda}{\Lambda}\frac{(N-1)u'}{r}\right)\ge|u'|^\alpha\left(u''+\frac{(N-1)u'}{r}\right)=\frac{1}{\lambda}\left(u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}\right) ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′′ + Λ λ r ( N − 1 ) u ′ ) ≥ ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′′ + r ( N − 1 ) u ′ ) = λ 1 ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α )
and if u ′ ′ ≥ 0 u''\ge0 u ′′ ≥ 0
∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′ ′ + ( N + − 1 ) u ′ r ) = 1 Λ ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) |u'|^\alpha\left(u''+\frac{(N^+-1)u'}{r}\right)=\frac{1}{\Lambda}\left(u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}\right) ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( u ′′ + r ( N + − 1 ) u ′ ) = Λ 1 ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α )
Then for some positive constant c c c
∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≥ inf ( 1 λ ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) , 1 Λ ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) ) ≥ − c r − β p |\nabla u|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2u)\ge\inf\left(\frac{1}{\lambda}(u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha}),\frac{1}{\Lambda}(u^p-\mu u^{1+\alpha}r^{-2-\alpha})\right)\ge-cr^{-\beta p} ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≥ inf ( λ 1 ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) , Λ 1 ( u p − μ u 1 + α r − 2 − α ) ) ≥ − c r − β p
and then
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≥ − c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − 1 + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) . (7) \left(|u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\right)'\ge-cr^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)-1+(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}. \tag*{(7)} ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≥ − c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − 1 + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) . (7)
Suppose first that β > N + − 2 \beta>N^+-2 β > N + − 2 , Integrating (6) between r r r and r o > r r_o>r r o > r one gets
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r o ) r o ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ − c β − N + + 2 ( r o ( N + − 2 − β ) ( 1 + α ) − r ( N + − 2 − β ) ( 1 + α ) ) (|u'|^\alpha u')(r_o)r_o^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}-(|u'|^\alpha u')(r)r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}
\le\frac{-c}{\beta-N^++2}\left(r_o^{(N^+-2-\beta)(1+\alpha)}-r^{(N^+-2-\beta)(1+\alpha)}\right) ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r o ) r o ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ( r ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ β − N + + 2 − c ( r o ( N + − 2 − β ) ( 1 + α ) − r ( N + − 2 − β ) ( 1 + α ) )
and then for some constants c 1 c_1 c 1 , and c 2 > 0 c_2>0 c 2 > 0
∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) ≥ c 1 r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − c 2 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≥ − c 3 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^\alpha u'(r)\ge c_1r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}-c_2r^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)}\ge-c_3r^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) ≥ c 1 r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) − c 2 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≥ − c 3 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α )
If β < N + − 2 \beta<N^+-2 β < N + − 2 , (7) implies that ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) has a limit since
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≥ 0 \left(|u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}+cr^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)+(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\right)'\ge0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + c r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≥ 0
and r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)+(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)} r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) + ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) tends to zero by the assumption on β \beta β . Note that if ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^{\alpha}u'r^{(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) does not tend to zero, one has for some constant c > 0 c>0 c > 0
∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ − c |u'|^{\alpha}u'r^{(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)}\leq-c ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ − c
which implies that u ′ ≤ − c r 1 − N + u'\leq-cr^{1-N^{+}} u ′ ≤ − c r 1 − N + and then u ≥ c r 2 − N + u\geq cr^{2-N^{+}} u ≥ c r 2 − N + , a contradiction with u ≤ c r − β u\leq cr^{-\beta} u ≤ c r − β . Then ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^{\alpha}u'r^{(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) tends to zero, and integrating (7) between 0 0 0 and r r r one gets
∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≥ − c 3 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^{\alpha}u'r^{(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)}\geq-c_{3}r^{-(\beta+1)(1+\alpha)}r^{(N^{+}-1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≥ − c 3 r − ( β + 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α )
which implies u ′ ≥ − c r − β − 1 u'\geq-cr^{-\beta-1} u ′ ≥ − c r − β − 1 . In particular in each of the cases, x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) x(\log r)=r^{\beta}u(r) x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) satisfies ( x , x ′ ) (x,x') ( x , x ′ ) is bounded.
Proposition 4.4. Suppose that u u u is a positive radial solution of the equation. Suppose that x = u ( r ) r β x=u(r)r^{\beta} x = u ( r ) r β tends to l ≠ 0 l\ne0 l = 0 , l ≠ μ 1 p − 1 − α l\ne\mu^{\frac{1}{p-1-\alpha}} l = μ p − 1 − α 1 , or tends to μ 1 p − 1 − α \mu^{\frac{1}{p-1-\alpha}} μ p − 1 − α 1 monotonically. Then ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) |\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}u) ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) has a sign for r r r small enough, and then u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 .
Proof. The hypothesis implies u u u unbounded. If l ≠ μ 1 p − 1 − α l\ne\mu^{\frac{1}{p-1-\alpha}} l = μ p − 1 − α 1 , ∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) |\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}u) ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) has the sign of l p − 1 − α − μ l^{p-1-\alpha}-\mu l p − 1 − α − μ as soon as r r r is small enough. If x → μ 1 p − 1 − α x\to\mu^{\frac{1}{p-1-\alpha}} x → μ p − 1 − α 1 and x ′ ≤ 0 x'\leq0 x ′ ≤ 0 (resp. < 0 <0 < 0 ), the right hand side has still a sign and we conclude as before.
Theorem 4.5. Suppose that u u u is a non trivial solution which satisfies
lim u ( r ) r β = 0 \lim u(r)r^{\beta}=0 lim u ( r ) r β = 0 then
u ′ ≤ 0 , and ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0. u'\leq0,\quad\text{and}\quad(|u'|^{\alpha}u')'\geq0. u ′ ≤ 0 , and ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0.
Proof. From the equation one gets for r r r small enough
∣ ∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ 0. |\nabla u|^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}u)\leq0. ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ 0.
By Proposition 4.1, u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 . We prove that ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ (|u'|^{\alpha}u')' ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ does not change sign. Suppose that we have a sequence r n r_n r n coming to zero, so that ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r n ) = 0 (|u'|^{\alpha}u')'(r_n)=0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r n ) = 0 , and ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ > 0 (|u'|^{\alpha}u')'>0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ > 0 inside the intervall. Then one must have ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ′ ( r n + 1 ) > 0 (|u'|^{\alpha}u')''(r_{n+1})>0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′′ ( r n + 1 ) > 0 while ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ′ ( r n ) < 0 (|u'|^{\alpha}u')''(r_n)<0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′′ ( r n ) < 0 .
To get a contradiction, it is sufficient to prove that
r ↦ − λ ( N − 1 ) r − 1 ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) u ′ ( r ) + u p ( r ) − μ u 1 + α ( r ) r − 2 − α r\mapsto-\lambda(N-1)r^{-1}|u'|^{\alpha}u'(r)u'(r)+u^{p}(r)-\mu u^{1+\alpha}(r)r^{-2-\alpha} r ↦ − λ ( N − 1 ) r − 1 ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) u ′ ( r ) + u p ( r ) − μ u 1 + α ( r ) r − 2 − α
has a derivative > 0 >0 > 0 on a point where ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ (|u'|^{\alpha}u')' ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ is zero. We consider
φ ( r ) = − λ ( N − 1 ) r 1 + α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + u p r 2 + α − μ u 1 + α . \varphi(r)=-\lambda(N-1)r^{1+\alpha}|u'|^{\alpha}u'+u^{p}r^{2+\alpha}-\mu u^{1+\alpha}. φ ( r ) = − λ ( N − 1 ) r 1 + α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + u p r 2 + α − μ u 1 + α .
Then
φ ′ ( r ) = − λ ( N − 1 ) r 1 + α ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ + p u p − 1 u ′ r 2 + α − μ ( 1 + α ) u α u ′ r 2 + α − λ ( N − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + ( 2 + α ) r 1 + α u p \varphi'(r)=-\lambda(N-1)r^{1+\alpha}(|u'|^{\alpha}u')'+pu^{p-1}u'r^{2+\alpha}-\mu(1+\alpha)u^{\alpha}u'r^{2+\alpha}-\lambda(N-1)(1+\alpha)r^{\alpha}|u'|^{\alpha}u'+(2+\alpha)r^{1+\alpha}u^{p} φ ′ ( r ) = − λ ( N − 1 ) r 1 + α ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ + p u p − 1 u ′ r 2 + α − μ ( 1 + α ) u α u ′ r 2 + α − λ ( N − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + ( 2 + α ) r 1 + α u p
has the sign of − u α u ′ ( μ ( 1 + α ) − p u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ) − λ ( N − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + ( 2 + α ) r 1 + α u p -u^{\alpha}u'\left(\mu(1+\alpha)-pu^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}\right)-\lambda(N-1)(1+\alpha)r^{\alpha}|u'|^{\alpha}u'+(2+\alpha)r^{1+\alpha}u^{p} − u α u ′ ( μ ( 1 + α ) − p u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ) − λ ( N − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) r α ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ + ( 2 + α ) r 1 + α u p on a point where ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ = 0 (|u'|^{\alpha}u')'=0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ = 0 , hence > 0 >0 > 0 , a contradiction on r n r_n r n . Since u u u is unbounded, and ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) (|u'|^{\alpha}u') ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) is monotone and negative, it tends to − ∞ -\infty − ∞ . If we now suppose by contradiction that ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ < 0 \left(|u'|^\alpha u'\right)' < 0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ < 0 , this leads to a contradiction with the fundamental calculus Theorem. Indeed, since u ′ → − ∞ u' \to-\infty u ′ → − ∞ , there exists r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o ∣ u ′ ∣ 1 + α ( r o ) < ∣ u ′ ∣ 1 + α ( r ) 2 |u'|^{1+\alpha}(r_o) < \frac{|u'|^{1+\alpha}(r)}{2} ∣ u ′ ∣ 1 + α ( r o ) < 2 ∣ u ′ ∣ 1 + α ( r ) , then
0 < ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r o ) − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) r o − r = ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r 1 ) 0 < \frac{|u'|^\alpha u'(r_o)-|u'|^\alpha u'(r)}{r_o-r} = \left(|u'|^\alpha u'\right)'(r_1) 0 < r o − r ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r o ) − ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ( r ) = ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r 1 )
for some r 1 < r o r_1<r_o r 1 < r o . We have obtained that ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r ) ≥ 0 \left(|u'|^\alpha u'\right)'(r) \geq0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ( r ) ≥ 0 for r r r small enough.
In order to precise the differential equation satisfied by x x x in the sequel, let us devote a few lines to precise the region in the phase space ( x , x ′ ) (x,x') ( x , x ′ ) which corresponds to the region where ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0 \left(|u'|^\alpha u'\right)' \geq0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0 . Note that
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0 \left(|u'|^\alpha u'\right)' \geq0 ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ ) ′ ≥ 0
if and only if
{ x p − 1 − α ≥ μ , Or x p − 1 − α ≤ μ , and x ′ ≤ β x − ( μ x 1 + α − x p Λ ( N + − 1 ) ) 1 1 + α . (8) \left\{
\begin{aligned}
x^{p-1-\alpha} &\geq\mu,\\
\text{Or }x^{p-1-\alpha} &\leq\mu,\quad\text{and }x' \leq\beta x-\left(\frac{\mu x^{1+\alpha}-x^p}{\Lambda(N^+-1)}\right)^{\frac{1}{1+\alpha}}.
\end{aligned}
\right. \tag*{(8)} ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ x p − 1 − α Or x p − 1 − α ≥ μ , ≤ μ , and x ′ ≤ β x − ( Λ ( N + − 1 ) μ x 1 + α − x p ) 1 + α 1 . (8)
Note for further purposes that if p < p ⋆ ⋆ p<p^{\star\star} p < p ⋆⋆ , β 1 + α > μ Λ − 1 \beta^{1+\alpha}>\mu\Lambda^{-1} β 1 + α > μ Λ − 1 and then a point t ˉ \bar t t ˉ where x ′ = 0 x'=0 x ′ = 0 is in the region where u ′ ′ ( e t ˉ ) ≥ 0 u''(e^{\bar t})\geq0 u ′′ ( e t ˉ ) ≥ 0 . Indeed, p < p ⋆ ⋆ p<p^{\star\star} p < p ⋆⋆ implies β 1 + α > ( τ − ) 1 + α \beta^{1+\alpha}>(\tau^-)^{1+\alpha} β 1 + α > ( τ − ) 1 + α and
μ Λ ( N + − 1 ) = ( τ − ) α + 1 ( N + − 2 − τ − ) ( N + − 1 ) − 1 ≤ ( τ − ) α + 1 \frac{\mu}{\Lambda(N^+-1)}=(\tau^-)^{\alpha+1}(N^+-2-\tau^-)(N^+-1)^{-1}\leq(\tau^-)^{\alpha+1} Λ ( N + − 1 ) μ = ( τ − ) α + 1 ( N + − 2 − τ − ) ( N + − 1 ) − 1 ≤ ( τ − ) α + 1
(This permits to prove in particular, -even if we will not need this here- that there is no periodic orbit for the equation, for t < T t<T t < T large enough negative).
The case where lim u ( r ) r β = 0 \lim u(r)r^\beta=0 lim u ( r ) r β = 0 .
The following theorem proves the last assertions in item 1.
Theorem 4.6. Suppose that p < 1 + α + 2 + α τ + p<1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^+} p < 1 + α + τ + 2 + α . Then any positive solution u u u of (1.3) so that lim u ( r ) r 2 + α p − 1 − α = 0 \lim u(r)r^{\frac{2+\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}}=0 lim u ( r ) r p − 1 − α 2 + α = 0 satisfies
u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + . u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^+}. u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + .
The proof of Theorem 4.6 is the consequence of several propositions:
Proposition 4.7. Suppose that p ≤ p ⋆ ⋆ p\leq p^{\star\star} p ≤ p ⋆⋆ . Let u u u be a positive solution of (1.3). Let x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) x(\log r)=r^\beta u(r) x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) and y = β − x ′ x y=\beta-\frac{x'}{x} y = β − x x ′ . If x → 0 x\to0 x → 0 at − ∞ -\infty − ∞ there exists T T T so that for t < T t<T t < T , y ′ ( t ) ≠ 0 y'(t)\neq0 y ′ ( t ) = 0 , and then y y y has a limit when t t t goes to − ∞ -\infty − ∞ .
Proof. If x → 0 x\to0 x → 0 , we know that u ′ ′ > 0 u''>0 u ′′ > 0 , for r r r small enough, then we are on a region where u ( r ) u(r) u ( r ) , x ( log r ) x(\log r) x ( log r ) and also then y ( log r ) y(\log r) y ( log r ) are C ∞ C^\infty C ∞ . We also have y ≥ 0 y\geq0 y ≥ 0 , since u ′ ≤ 0 u'\leq0 u ′ ≤ 0 . The equation satisfied by y y y is
( y 1 + α ) ′ ( 1 + α ) − 1 = y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α + μ − x p − 1 − α Λ . (9) (y^{1+\alpha})'(1+\alpha)^{-1}=y^{2+\alpha}-(N^+-2)y^{1+\alpha}+\frac{\mu-x^{p-1-\alpha}}{\Lambda}. \tag*{(9)} ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( 1 + α ) − 1 = y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α + Λ μ − x p − 1 − α . (9)
Note that
ψ ( y ) = y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α + Λ − 1 μ (10) \psi(y)=y^{2+\alpha}-(N^+-2)y^{1+\alpha}+\Lambda^{-1}\mu \tag*{(10)} ψ ( y ) = y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α + Λ − 1 μ (10)
satisfies ψ ( τ ± ) = 0 \psi(\tau^{\pm})=0 ψ ( τ ± ) = 0 and is > 0 >0 > 0 in ] 0 , τ − [ ∪ ] τ + , + ∞ [ ]0,\tau^{-}[\cup]\tau^{+},+\infty[ ] 0 , τ − [ ∪ ] τ + , + ∞ [ and is < 0 <0 < 0 in ] τ − , τ + [ ]\tau^{-},\tau^{+}[ ] τ − , τ + [ . We prove that ( y 1 + α ) ′ (y^{1+\alpha})' ( y 1 + α ) ′ has constant sign for t t t large enough negative. Indeed if not there exists a sequence t n t_n t n coming to − ∞ -\infty − ∞ , so that ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( t n ) = ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( t n + 1 ) = 0 (y^{1+\alpha})'(t_n)=(y^{1+\alpha})'(t_{n+1})=0 ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( t n ) = ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( t n + 1 ) = 0 and ( y 1 + α ) ′ > 0 (y^{1+\alpha})'>0 ( y 1 + α ) ′ > 0 in ] t n + 1 , t n [ ]t_{n+1},t_n[ ] t n + 1 , t n [ . Let ϵ > 0 \epsilon>0 ϵ > 0 so that ∣ ψ ( y ) ∣ < ϵ |\psi(y)|<\epsilon ∣ ψ ( y ) ∣ < ϵ implies inf ( ∣ y − τ + ∣ , ∣ y − τ − ∣ ) < β − τ + 2 \inf(|y-\tau^{+}|,|y-\tau^{-}|)<\frac{\beta-\tau^{+}}{2} inf ( ∣ y − τ + ∣ , ∣ y − τ − ∣ ) < 2 β − τ + and let T T T be large enough in order that t < T t<T t < T implies x p − 1 − α ( t ) < Λ ϵ x^{p-1-\alpha}(t)<\Lambda\epsilon x p − 1 − α ( t ) < Λ ϵ . Then if T 1 < T T_1<T T 1 < T is so that ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( T 1 ) = 0 (y^{1+\alpha})'(T_1)=0 ( y 1 + α ) ′ ( T 1 ) = 0 , by the equation ψ ( y ( T 1 ) ) = x p − 1 − α Λ < ϵ \psi(y(T_1))=\frac{x^{p-1-\alpha}}{\Lambda}<\epsilon ψ ( y ( T 1 )) = Λ x p − 1 − α < ϵ , and then inf ( ∣ y ( T 1 ) − τ + ∣ , ∣ y ( T 1 ) − τ − ∣ ) < β − τ + 2 \inf(|y(T_1)-\tau^{+}|,|y(T_1)-\tau^{-}|)<\frac{\beta-\tau^{+}}{2} inf ( ∣ y ( T 1 ) − τ + ∣ , ∣ y ( T 1 ) − τ − ∣ ) < 2 β − τ + , implying x Λ ( T 1 ) > β − τ + 2 > 0 \frac{x}{\Lambda}(T_1)>\frac{\beta-\tau^{+}}{2}>0 Λ x ( T 1 ) > 2 β − τ + > 0 . Then derivating the equation in y y y one gets
( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ ′ ( T 1 ) = ( y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α ) ′ ( T 1 ) − ( p − 1 − α ) x p − 1 − α x ′ x Λ ( T 1 ) < 0 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)''(T_1)=\left(y^{2+\alpha}-(N^{+}-2)y^{1+\alpha}\right)'(T_1)-(p-1-\alpha)x^{p-1-\alpha}\frac{x'}{x\Lambda}(T_1)<0 ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′′ ( T 1 ) = ( y 2 + α − ( N + − 2 ) y 1 + α ) ′ ( T 1 ) − ( p − 1 − α ) x p − 1 − α x Λ x ′ ( T 1 ) < 0
This yields a contradiction when T 1 = t n + 1 T_1=t_{n+1} T 1 = t n + 1 . We have obtained that y ′ y' y ′ does not change sign.
The two following propositions precise the exact behavior of u u u when x x x goes to zero:
Proposition 4.8. Suppose that u u u is a positive solution of (3) . Suppose that τ + < β \tau^{+}<\beta τ + < β and
u ′ r u = − τ + + φ , \frac{u'r}{u}=-\tau^{+}+\varphi, u u ′ r = − τ + + φ , and that for r r r small enough, φ , r φ ′ \varphi,r\varphi' φ , r φ ′ have the same constant sign, and both tend to zero. (In particular lim u r β = 0 \lim ur^{\beta}=0 lim u r β = 0 ). There exist positive constants c 1 + , c 2 + , c 3 + c_1^{+},c_2^{+},c_3^{+} c 1 + , c 2 + , c 3 + and r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o
if φ , φ ′ > 0 , r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≥ c 2 + u p − 1 − α r 2 + α , if φ , φ ′ < 0 , r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≤ c 3 + u p − 1 − α r 2 + α . \text{if }\varphi,\varphi'>0,\quad r\varphi'-c_1^{+}\varphi\ge c_2^{+}u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha},\quad\text{if }\varphi,\varphi'<0,\quad r\varphi'-c_1^{+}\varphi\le c_3^{+}u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}. if φ , φ ′ > 0 , r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≥ c 2 + u p − 1 − α r 2 + α , if φ , φ ′ < 0 , r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≤ c 3 + u p − 1 − α r 2 + α . As a consequence there exists c 4 + , c 5 + c_4^{+},c_5^{+} c 4 + , c 5 + positive so that for r r r small enough
∣ φ ∣ ≤ c 4 + r c 5 + . |\varphi|\le c_4^{+}r^{c_5^{+}}. ∣ φ ∣ ≤ c 4 + r c 5 + . More precisely, for all ϵ \epsilon ϵ we can choose r o r_o r o small enough in order that the inequality above holds for r < r o r<r_o r < r o with ∣ c 5 + − inf ( ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) , 2 + α − τ + ( p − 1 − α ) ) ∣ = O ( ϵ ) \left|c_5^{+}-\inf((2+\alpha)(\tau^{+}-\tau),2+\alpha-\tau^{+}(p-1-\alpha))\right|=O(\epsilon) c 5 + − inf (( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) , 2 + α − τ + ( p − 1 − α )) = O ( ϵ ) , in particular c 5 + > 0 c_5^{+}>0 c 5 + > 0 .
Finally in each of the cases there exists some constant c > 0 c>0 c > 0 so that
u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + . u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^{+}}. u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + .
Remark 4.9. The fact that φ \varphi φ and φ ′ \varphi' φ ′ have a sign is not necessary, but Proposition 4.8 will be used later only in these situations.
Proposition 4.10. Suppose that u u u is a positive solution of (3) , and that τ − < β \tau^{-}<\beta τ − < β , and
u ′ r u = − τ − + φ , \frac{u'r}{u}=-\tau^{-}+\varphi, u u ′ r = − τ − + φ , with φ ≥ 0 \varphi\ge0 φ ≥ 0 , r φ ′ ≥ 0 r\varphi'\ge0 r φ ′ ≥ 0 for r r r small enough, and both tend to zero. There exist positive constants c ˉ 1 > 0 , c ˉ 2 > 0 \bar c_1>0,\bar c_2>0 c ˉ 1 > 0 , c ˉ 2 > 0 so that
r φ ′ + c ˉ 1 φ ≤ c ˉ 2 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α . r\varphi'+\bar c_1\varphi\le\bar c_2u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}. r φ ′ + c ˉ 1 φ ≤ c ˉ 2 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α . As a consequence, for all ϵ \epsilon ϵ , there exists c ˉ 3 \bar c_3 c ˉ 3 , and r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o φ ( r ) ≤ c ˉ 3 r − τ − ( p − 1 − α ) + 2 + α − ϵ ( p − 1 − α ) \varphi(r)\le\bar c_3r^{-\tau^{-}(p-1-\alpha)+2+\alpha-\epsilon(p-1-\alpha)} φ ( r ) ≤ c ˉ 3 r − τ − ( p − 1 − α ) + 2 + α − ϵ ( p − 1 − α ) .
Finally one has, for some positive constant c c c
u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − . u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^{-}}. u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − .
Proof. of Proposition 4.8
u ′ ′ r 2 u = ( u ′ ) 2 r 2 u 2 − u ′ r u + φ ′ r = ( τ + − φ ) 2 + ( τ + − φ ) + φ ′ r \frac{u''r^2}{u}=\frac{(u')^2r^2}{u^2}-\frac{u'r}{u}+\varphi'r=(\tau^+-\varphi)^2+(\tau^+-\varphi)+\varphi'r u u ′′ r 2 = u 2 ( u ′ ) 2 r 2 − u u ′ r + φ ′ r = ( τ + − φ ) 2 + ( τ + − φ ) + φ ′ r
and then
( τ + ) α ( 1 − α φ τ + + O ( φ 2 ) ) ( r φ ′ + ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + ) φ + φ 2 + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) ) + Λ − 1 μ = ∣ u ′ r u ∣ α ( ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + ) φ + r φ ′ + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) + φ 2 ) + Λ − 1 μ = ∣ u ′ r u − 1 ∣ α ( u ′ ′ r 2 u + ( N + − 1 ) u ′ r u ) + Λ − 1 μ = Λ − 1 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α \begin{aligned}
(\tau^+)^\alpha\left(1-\alpha\frac{\varphi}{\tau^+}+O(\varphi^2)\right)\left(r\varphi'+(N^+-2-2\tau^+)\varphi+\varphi^2\right.\\
\left.+\tau^+(\tau^+-(N^+-2))\right)+\Lambda^{-1}\mu
&=\left|\frac{u'r}{u}\right|^\alpha\left((N^+-2-2\tau^+)\varphi+r\varphi'+\tau^+(\tau^+-(N^+-2))+\varphi^2\right)+\Lambda^{-1}\mu\\
&=\left|u'ru^{-1}\right|^\alpha\left(\frac{u''r^2}{u}+(N^+-1)\frac{u'r}{u}\right)+\Lambda^{-1}\mu\\
&=\Lambda^{-1}u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}
\end{aligned} ( τ + ) α ( 1 − α τ + φ + O ( φ 2 ) ) ( r φ ′ + ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + ) φ + φ 2 + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 )) ) + Λ − 1 μ = u u ′ r α ( ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + ) φ + r φ ′ + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 )) + φ 2 ) + Λ − 1 μ = u ′ r u − 1 α ( u u ′′ r 2 + ( N + − 1 ) u u ′ r ) + Λ − 1 μ = Λ − 1 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α
If φ ≥ 0 \varphi\geq0 φ ≥ 0 , using φ , r φ ′ \varphi,r\varphi' φ , r φ ′ tend to zero and τ + ≤ N + − 2 \tau^+\leq N^+-2 τ + ≤ N + − 2 , for all ϵ > 0 \epsilon>0 ϵ > 0 , ϵ < inf ( 1 4 , ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) 4 ( N + − τ + ) ) \epsilon<\inf\left(\frac{1}{4},\frac{(2+\alpha)(\tau^+-\tau)}{4(N^+-\tau^+)}\right) ϵ < inf ( 4 1 , 4 ( N + − τ + ) ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) ) there exists r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o ,
1 + ∣ α ∣ τ + ( ∣ N + − 2 − 2 τ + ∣ + 1 ) φ ( r ) < ϵ (11) \frac{1+|\alpha|}{\tau^+}\left(|N^+-2-2\tau^+|+1\right)\varphi(r)<\epsilon \tag*{(11)} τ + 1 + ∣ α ∣ ( ∣ N + − 2 − 2 τ + ∣ + 1 ) φ ( r ) < ϵ (11)
( 1 − ( α + ϵ ) φ τ + ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + + ϵ ) + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) ) + μ Λ ( τ + ) α ≥ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ( τ + ) α Λ \left(1-(\alpha+\epsilon)\frac{\varphi}{\tau^+}\right)\left(r\varphi'+\varphi(N^+-2-2\tau^++\epsilon)+\tau^+(\tau^+-(N^+-2))\right)+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda(\tau^+)^\alpha}\geq\frac{u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}}{(\tau^+)^\alpha\Lambda} ( 1 − ( α + ϵ ) τ + φ ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + + ϵ ) + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 )) ) + Λ ( τ + ) α μ ≥ ( τ + ) α Λ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α
Using the value of μ \mu μ , the hypothesis on ϵ \epsilon ϵ and c 1 = − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) + ( 2 + α ) τ + = ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) > 0 c_1=-(1+\alpha)(N^+-2)+(2+\alpha)\tau^+=(2+\alpha)(\tau^+-\tau)>0 c 1 = − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) + ( 2 + α ) τ + = ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) > 0 , there exists r 1 < r o r_1<r_o r 1 < r o so that for r < r 1 r<r_1 r < r 1
r φ ′ ( 1 + ϵ ) − ( c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + ) ) φ ≥ 1 Λ ( τ + ) α u p − 1 − α r 2 + α . r\varphi'(1+\epsilon)-(c_1+2\epsilon(\tau^+-N^+))\varphi\geq\frac{1}{\Lambda(\tau^+)^\alpha}u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}. r φ ′ ( 1 + ϵ ) − ( c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + )) φ ≥ Λ ( τ + ) α 1 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α .
We get immediately with c 1 + : = c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + ) 1 + ϵ c_1^+:=\frac{c_1+2\epsilon(\tau^+-N^+)}{1+\epsilon} c 1 + := 1 + ϵ c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + )
( r − c 1 + φ ) ′ ≥ 0 , (r^{-c_1^+}\varphi)'\geq0, ( r − c 1 + φ ) ′ ≥ 0 ,
which implies by integrating between r r r and r o r_o r o
φ ( r ) ≤ φ ( r o ) r o − c 1 + r c 1 + . \varphi(r)\leq\varphi(r_o)r_o^{-c_1^+}r^{c_1^+}. φ ( r ) ≤ φ ( r o ) r o − c 1 + r c 1 + .
If φ , φ ′ ≤ 0 \varphi,\varphi'\leq0 φ , φ ′ ≤ 0 , for all ϵ > 0 \epsilon>0 ϵ > 0 there exists r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o
( 1 − ( α + ϵ ) φ τ + ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + + ϵ ) + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 ) ) ) + μ Λ ( τ + ) α ≤ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ( τ + ) α Λ \left(1-(\alpha+\epsilon)\frac{\varphi}{\tau^+}\right)\left(r\varphi'+\varphi(N^+-2-2\tau^++\epsilon)+\tau^+(\tau^+-(N^+-2))\right)+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda(\tau^+)^\alpha}\leq\frac{u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}}{(\tau^+)^\alpha\Lambda} ( 1 − ( α + ϵ ) τ + φ ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ + + ϵ ) + τ + ( τ + − ( N + − 2 )) ) + Λ ( τ + ) α μ ≤ ( τ + ) α Λ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α
Using the value of μ \mu μ , choosing ϵ \epsilon ϵ and r o r_o r o as in (11) , and c 1 = − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) + ( 2 + α ) τ + = ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) > 0 c_1=-(1+\alpha)(N^+-2)+(2+\alpha)\tau^+=(2+\alpha)(\tau^+-\tau)>0 c 1 = − ( 1 + α ) ( N + − 2 ) + ( 2 + α ) τ + = ( 2 + α ) ( τ + − τ ) > 0 , there exists r 1 < r o r_1<r_o r 1 < r o so that for r < r 1 r<r_1 r < r 1
( τ + ) α ( r φ ′ ( 1 + ϵ ) − ( c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + ) ) φ ) ≤ 1 Λ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α (12) (\tau^+)^\alpha\left(r\varphi'(1+\epsilon)-(c_1+2\epsilon(\tau^+-N^+))\varphi\right)\leq\frac{1}{\Lambda}u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha} \tag*{(12)} ( τ + ) α ( r φ ′ ( 1 + ϵ ) − ( c 1 + 2 ϵ ( τ + − N + )) φ ) ≤ Λ 1 u p − 1 − α r 2 + α (12)
On the other hand, by the definition of φ \varphi φ , fixing ϵ < τ + \epsilon< \tau^{+} ϵ < τ + and so that p < 1 + α + 2 + α τ + + ϵ p < 1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{+}+\epsilon} p < 1 + α + τ + + ϵ 2 + α and ϵ < c 1 4 ( − τ + + N + ) \epsilon< \frac{c_{1}}{4(-\tau^{+}+N^{+})} ϵ < 4 ( − τ + + N + ) c 1 , since φ \varphi φ tends to zero, there exist positive constant c , C c,C c , C so that for r 2 < r 1 r_{2}<r_{1} r 2 < r 1 and for r < r 2 r<r_{2} r < r 2
c r − τ + + ϵ ≤ u ( r ) ≤ C r − τ + − ϵ cr^{-\tau^{+}+\epsilon}\leq u(r)\leq Cr^{-\tau^{+}-\epsilon} c r − τ + + ϵ ≤ u ( r ) ≤ C r − τ + − ϵ
We obtain with c 1 + : = c 1 + ϵ ( τ + − N + ) 1 + ϵ c_{1}^{+}:=\frac{c_{1+\epsilon}(\tau^{+}-N^{+})}{1+\epsilon} c 1 + := 1 + ϵ c 1 + ϵ ( τ + − N + ) , replacing in (12) ,
( φ ( r ) r − c 1 + ) ′ ≤ C p − 1 − α Λ ( τ + ) α ( 1 + ϵ ) r − c 2 ′ − c 1 + − 1 , (\varphi(r)r^{-c_{1}^{+}})'\leq\frac{C^{p-1-\alpha}}{\Lambda(\tau^{+})^{\alpha}(1+\epsilon)}r^{-c_{2}'-c_{1}^{+}-1}, ( φ ( r ) r − c 1 + ) ′ ≤ Λ ( τ + ) α ( 1 + ϵ ) C p − 1 − α r − c 2 ′ − c 1 + − 1 ,
with c 2 ′ : = − ( p − 1 − α ) ( τ + + ϵ ) + ( 2 + α ) > 0 c_{2}':=-(p-1-\alpha)(\tau^{+}+\epsilon)+(2+\alpha)>0 c 2 ′ := − ( p − 1 − α ) ( τ + + ϵ ) + ( 2 + α ) > 0 . We obtain by integrating (note that we can choose ϵ \epsilon ϵ so that c 1 + ≠ c 2 ′ c_{1}^{+}\neq c_{2}' c 1 + = c 2 ′ )
φ ( r o ) r o − c 1 + − φ ( r ) r − c 1 + ≤ C p − 1 − α Λ ( τ + ) α ( 1 + ϵ ) r o c 2 ′ − c 1 + − r c 2 ′ − c 1 + c 2 ′ − c 1 + , \varphi(r_{o})r_{o}^{-c_{1}^{+}}-\varphi(r)r^{-c_{1}^{+}}\leq\frac{C^{p-1-\alpha}}{\Lambda(\tau^{+})^{\alpha}(1+\epsilon)}\frac{r_{o}^{c_{2}'-c_{1}^{+}}-r^{c_{2}'-c_{1}^{+}}}{c_{2}'-c_{1}^{+}}, φ ( r o ) r o − c 1 + − φ ( r ) r − c 1 + ≤ Λ ( τ + ) α ( 1 + ϵ ) C p − 1 − α c 2 ′ − c 1 + r o c 2 ′ − c 1 + − r c 2 ′ − c 1 + ,
and then there exists c 6 c_{6} c 6 so that
φ ( r ) ≥ − c 6 r inf ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) . (13) \varphi(r)\geq-c_{6}r^{\inf(c_{2}',c_{1}^{+})}. \tag*{(13)} φ ( r ) ≥ − c 6 r i n f ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) . (13)
Let now ζ ( r ) = u ( r ) r τ + \zeta(r)=u(r)r^{\tau^{+}} ζ ( r ) = u ( r ) r τ + . We obtain that for example if φ ( r ) ≤ 0 \varphi(r)\leq0 φ ( r ) ≤ 0 , ζ ′ ≤ 0 \zeta'\leq0 ζ ′ ≤ 0 and using (13)
ζ ′ ( r ) ≥ − c 6 r inf ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) − 1 ζ ( r ) . \zeta'(r)\geq-c_{6}r^{\inf(c_{2}',c_{1}^{+})-1}\zeta(r). ζ ′ ( r ) ≥ − c 6 r i n f ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) − 1 ζ ( r ) .
Then log ζ \log\zeta log ζ has a finite limit at zero and then ζ \zeta ζ has a finite limit l l l at zero different from zero. If φ ≥ 0 \varphi\geq0 φ ≥ 0 and φ ′ ≥ 0 \varphi'\geq0 φ ′ ≥ 0 , so are ζ \zeta ζ and ζ ′ \zeta' ζ ′ . In that case we get
ζ ′ ( r ) ≤ c 6 r inf ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) − 1 ζ . \zeta'(r)\leq c_{6}r^{\inf(c_{2}',c_{1}^{+})-1}\zeta. ζ ′ ( r ) ≤ c 6 r i n f ( c 2 ′ , c 1 + ) − 1 ζ .
Then ζ ( 0 ) \zeta(0) ζ ( 0 ) is finite. In any cases we have
u ( r ) ∼ l r τ + . u(r)\sim lr^{\tau^{+}}. u ( r ) ∼ l r τ + .
Proof. of Proposition 4.10
Here acting as before (replacing τ + \tau^{+} τ + by τ − \tau^{-} τ − ) one gets
( 1 − ( α − ϵ ) φ τ − ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ − − ϵ ) + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 ) ) ) + μ Λ ( τ − ) α ≤ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ( τ − ) α Λ \left(1-(\alpha-\epsilon)\frac{\varphi}{\tau^{-}}\right)\left(r\varphi'+\varphi(N^{+}-2-2\tau^{-}-\epsilon)+\tau^{-}(\tau^{-}-(N^{+}-2))\right)+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}}\leq\frac{u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}}{(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}\Lambda} ( 1 − ( α − ϵ ) τ − φ ) ( r φ ′ + φ ( N + − 2 − 2 τ − − ϵ ) + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 )) ) + Λ ( τ − ) α μ ≤ ( τ − ) α Λ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α
Choosing r o r_{o} r o small enough in order that for r < r o r<r_{o} r < r o ,
( 1 + ∣ α ∣ ) φ ( r ) τ − ≤ ϵ < inf ( 1 4 , 2 + α ( τ − τ − ) N + − 1 − τ − ) , (1+|\alpha|)\frac{\varphi(r)}{\tau^{-}}\leq\epsilon<\inf\left(\frac{1}{4},\frac{2+\alpha(\tau-\tau^{-})}{N^{+}-1-\tau^{-}}\right), ( 1 + ∣ α ∣ ) τ − φ ( r ) ≤ ϵ < inf ( 4 1 , N + − 1 − τ − 2 + α ( τ − τ − ) ) ,
one derives that
r φ ′ ( 1 − ϵ ) + ( ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) + ϵ ( τ − − N + ) ) φ ≤ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α ( τ − ) α Λ r\varphi'(1-\epsilon)+((2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^{-})+\epsilon(\tau^{-}-N^{+}))\varphi\leq\frac{u^{p-1-\alpha}r^{2+\alpha}}{(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}\Lambda} r φ ′ ( 1 − ϵ ) + (( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) + ϵ ( τ − − N + )) φ ≤ ( τ − ) α Λ u p − 1 − α r 2 + α
Here since r φ ′ r\varphi' r φ ′ and φ ≥ 0 \varphi\geq0 φ ≥ 0 we can drop r φ ′ r\varphi' r φ ′ and obtain immediately that for some positive constant c 3 c_{3} c 3
φ ( r ) ≤ c 3 r − ( τ − + ϵ ) ( p − 1 − α ) + 2 + α \varphi(r)\leq c_{3}r^{-(\tau^{-}+\epsilon)(p-1-\alpha)+2+\alpha} φ ( r ) ≤ c 3 r − ( τ − + ϵ ) ( p − 1 − α ) + 2 + α
which is the desired result. We obtain the estimate on u u u as in the previous proof.
Proof. of Theorem 4.6 Let us recall that β = 2 + α p − 1 − α \beta= \frac{2+\alpha}{p-1-\alpha} β = p − 1 − α 2 + α . Let x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) x(\log r)=r^\beta u(r) x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) and y ( t ) = β − x ′ x y(t)=\beta-\frac{x'}{x} y ( t ) = β − x x ′ . y ( t ) > 0 y(t)>0 y ( t ) > 0 since u ′ ( e t ) < 0 u'(e^t)<0 u ′ ( e t ) < 0 as soon as t t t is large enough negative. Since x x x goes to zero, by Theorem 4.5 , one has u ′ ′ ≥ 0 u'' \ge0 u ′′ ≥ 0 around zero and y y y satisfies (9) . Using Proposition 4.7, we get that y ′ y' y ′ has a sign, in particular y 1 + α y^{1+\alpha} y 1 + α has a limit. Suppose that ( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ > 0 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)'>0 ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′ > 0 , then y 1 + α y^{1+\alpha} y 1 + α has a finite limit, and so has y y y . Suppose that it is ≠ τ ± \ne\tau^\pm = τ ± then there exists δ > 0 \delta>0 δ > 0 and T T T so that for t < T t<T t < T , ψ \psi ψ defined in (10) satisfies ψ ( y ) > δ \psi(y)>\delta ψ ( y ) > δ . Since x x x goes to zero, let T 1 < T T_1<T T 1 < T so that for t < T 1 t<T_1 t < T 1 , x p − 1 − α < δ 2 x^{p-1-\alpha}<\frac{\delta}{2} x p − 1 − α < 2 δ . Then for t < T 1 t<T_1 t < T 1 ,
( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ > δ 2 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)'>\frac{\delta}{2} ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′ > 2 δ
but this contradicts the fact that y 1 + α y^{1+\alpha} y 1 + α has a finite limit. Note that since ( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ > 0 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)'>0 ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′ > 0 , the limit cannot be τ − \tau^- τ − since it would imply that y ∈ ] τ − , τ + [ y\in]\tau^-,\tau^+[ y ∈ ] τ − , τ + [ for t t t large enough, a contradiction with the equation. We have then y → τ + y\to\tau^+ y → τ + .
If ( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ < 0 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)'<0 ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′ < 0 suppose first that y y y tends to + ∞ +\infty + ∞ . Then for t < T t<T t < T large enough negative,
ψ ( y ) − Λ − 1 x p − 1 − α ≥ y 2 + α 2 , \psi(y)-\Lambda^{-1}x^{p-1-\alpha}\ge\frac{y^{2+\alpha}}{2}, ψ ( y ) − Λ − 1 x p − 1 − α ≥ 2 y 2 + α ,
and this contradicts the equation, since ( y 1 + α 1 + α ) ′ < 0 \left(\frac{y^{1+\alpha}}{1+\alpha}\right)'<0 ( 1 + α y 1 + α ) ′ < 0 . Then once more y 1 + α y^{1+\alpha} y 1 + α has a finite limit and it cannot be else than τ ± \tau^\pm τ ± . Here the limit can be τ − \tau^- τ − . There remains to prove that x ∼ c e ( β − τ ± ) t x\sim ce^{(\beta-\tau^\pm)t} x ∼ c e ( β − τ ± ) t , or that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ ± u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^\pm} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ ± .
Suppose that we are in the case where y → τ + y\to\tau^+ y → τ + , we introduce φ ( r ) \varphi(r) φ ( r ) so that
u ′ r u = − τ + + φ ( r ) \frac{u'r}{u}=-\tau^++\varphi(r) u u ′ r = − τ + + φ ( r )
Note that if y → τ + y\to\tau^+ y → τ + , and y ′ ≥ 0 y'\ge0 y ′ ≥ 0 , y ≥ τ + y\ge\tau^+ y ≥ τ + , (for t < T t<T t < T large enough negative) and then both φ \varphi φ and φ ′ \varphi' φ ′ are negative (for r r r small enough). If y ′ ≤ 0 y'\le0 y ′ ≤ 0 , y ≤ τ + y\le\tau^+ y ≤ τ + , and then φ , φ ′ ≥ 0 \varphi,\varphi'\ge0 φ , φ ′ ≥ 0 . Moreover y ′ y' y ′ tends to zero by the equation, which ensures that r φ ′ → 0 r\varphi'\to0 r φ ′ → 0 . Using Proposition 4.8 , we get that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^+} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + .
In the case y → τ − y\to\tau^- y → τ − we have y ′ ≤ 0 y'\le0 y ′ ≤ 0 , φ \varphi φ defined by
u ′ r u = − τ − + φ ( r ) \frac{u'r}{u}=-\tau^-+\varphi(r) u u ′ r = − τ − + φ ( r )
is ≥ 0 \ge0 ≥ 0 as well as φ ′ \varphi' φ ′ , r φ ′ r\varphi' r φ ′ and φ \varphi φ tend to zero, and then we use Proposition 4.10 and get that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^-} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − .
We now consider the case where lim sup u ( r ) r β > 0 \limsup u(r)r^\beta>0 lim sup u ( r ) r β > 0 , or the first assertion in item 1:
Proposition 4.11. Suppose that p < p ⋆ p<p^\star p < p ⋆ or p > p ⋆ ⋆ p>p^{\star\star} p > p ⋆⋆ . Suppose that lim sup u ( r ) r β > 0 \limsup u(r)r^\beta>0 lim sup u ( r ) r β > 0 , then lim inf u ( r ) r β > 0 \liminf u(r)r^\beta>0 lim inf u ( r ) r β > 0 and finally u ( r ) r β u(r)r^\beta u ( r ) r β converges to K K K
Proof. Let l > 0 l>0 l > 0 and r n r_n r n so that u ( r n ) r n β = l n → l u(r_n)r_n^\beta=l_n\to l u ( r n ) r n β = l n → l . Let u ‾ = min ( K , l 2 ) r − β \underline{u}=\min(K,\frac{l}{2})r^{-\beta} u = min ( K , 2 l ) r − β . It is immediate that u ‾ \underline{u} u is a sub-solution. Furthermore u ‾ ( r n ) ≤ u ( r n ) \underline{u}(r_n)\le u(r_n) u ( r n ) ≤ u ( r n ) and then applying the first comparison principle, u ≥ u ‾ u\ge\underline{u} u ≥ u on ] r n + 1 , r n [ ]r_{n+1},r_n[ ] r n + 1 , r n [ . Finally u ‾ ≥ u ‾ \underline{u}\ge\underline{u} u ≥ u and lim inf u > 0 \liminf u>0 lim inf u > 0 . We now prove that lim inf ≥ K \liminf\ge K lim inf ≥ K and lim sup ≤ K \limsup\le K lim sup ≤ K . Arguing by contradiction, let l 1 < K l_1<K l 1 < K , so that lim inf u ( r ) r β = l 1 \liminf u(r)r^\beta=l_1 lim inf u ( r ) r β = l 1 . Let δ \delta δ fixe positif, δ < β \delta<\beta δ < β . Suppose ϵ \epsilon ϵ depending on α , p \alpha,p α , p first so that for any u ∈ ] 0 , 2 ϵ [ u\in]0,2\epsilon[ u ∈ ] 0 , 2 ϵ [ one has
1 − 2 ∣ α ∣ u ≤ ( 1 − u ) α ≤ 1 + 2 ∣ α ∣ u , 1 − 2 ( 1 + α ) ∣ u ∣ ≤ ( 1 − u ) 1 + α ≤ 1 − 1 + α 2 u (14) 1-2|\alpha|u\leq(1-u)^\alpha\leq1+2|\alpha|u,\quad1-2(1+\alpha)|u|\leq(1-u)^{1+\alpha}\leq1-\frac{1+\alpha}{2}u \tag*{(14)} 1 − 2∣ α ∣ u ≤ ( 1 − u ) α ≤ 1 + 2∣ α ∣ u , 1 − 2 ( 1 + α ) ∣ u ∣ ≤ ( 1 − u ) 1 + α ≤ 1 − 2 1 + α u (14)
and
1 − 2 p u ≤ ( 1 − u ) p ≤ 1 − p u 2 . (15) 1-2pu\leq(1-u)^p\leq1-\frac{p u}{2}. \tag*{(15)} 1 − 2 p u ≤ ( 1 − u ) p ≤ 1 − 2 p u . (15)
Let
c ( α , β , δ , N + ) = β α ( 1 + 2 ∣ α ∣ ) ( ∣ β ∣ ∣ β − N + + 2 ∣ + ∣ β − δ ∣ ∣ β − δ − N + + 2 ∣ ) + 2 μ ( 1 + α ) Λ . (16) c(\alpha,\beta,\delta,N^+)=\beta^\alpha(1+2|\alpha|)(|\beta||\beta-N^++2|+|\beta-\delta||\beta-\delta-N^++2|)+\frac{2\mu(1+\alpha)}{\Lambda}. \tag*{(16)} c ( α , β , δ , N + ) = β α ( 1 + 2∣ α ∣ ) ( ∣ β ∣∣ β − N + + 2∣ + ∣ β − δ ∣∣ β − δ − N + + 2∣ ) + Λ 2 μ ( 1 + α ) . (16)
We impose to ϵ \epsilon ϵ to be also such that ϵ < 1 4 \epsilon<\frac14 ϵ < 4 1 , small in order that (15) , (14) hold and l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) < K + l 1 2 l_1(1+\epsilon)<\frac{K+l_1}{2} l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) < 2 K + l 1 and so that
2 ϵ ( c ( α , β , δ , N + ) − p 2 l 1 p − 1 − α ) < K p − 1 − α − ( K + l 1 2 ) p − 1 − α (17) 2\epsilon\left(c(\alpha,\beta,\delta,N^+)-\frac{p}{2}l_1^{p-1-\alpha}\right)<K^{p-1-\alpha}-\left(\frac{K+l_1}{2}\right)^{p-1-\alpha} \tag*{(17)} 2 ϵ ( c ( α , β , δ , N + ) − 2 p l 1 p − 1 − α ) < K p − 1 − α − ( 2 K + l 1 ) p − 1 − α (17)
and r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o u ( r ) r β > l 1 ( 1 − ϵ ) u(r)r^\beta>l_1(1-\epsilon) u ( r ) r β > l 1 ( 1 − ϵ ) . We take a = 2 ϵ r o − δ a=2\epsilon r_o^{-\delta} a = 2 ϵ r o − δ and define
u ‾ ( r ) = l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) r − β ( 1 − a r δ ) . \underline{u}(r)=l_1(1+\epsilon)r^{-\beta}(1-ar^\delta). u ( r ) = l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) r − β ( 1 − a r δ ) .
In particular
u ‾ ( r o ) < u ( r o ) . \underline{u}(r_o)<u(r_o). u ( r o ) < u ( r o ) .
By the choice of ϵ \epsilon ϵ , u ‾ \underline{u} u is a sub-solution in r < r o r<r_o r < r o . Indeed, an easy calculation proves that, using (17)
∣ ∇ u ‾ ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ‾ ) + μ r − 2 − α u ‾ 1 + α ≥ ( l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) r − β ) 1 + α r − α − 2 ( K p − 1 − α − c ( α , β , δ , N + ) a r δ ) ≥ r − β p ( l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) ) p ( 1 − p 2 a r δ ) ≥ u ‾ p \begin{aligned}
|\nabla\underline{u}|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2\underline{u})+\mu r^{-2-\alpha}\underline{u}^{1+\alpha}\geq\left(l_1(1+\epsilon)r^{-\beta}\right)^{1+\alpha}r^{-\alpha-2}\left(K^{p-1-\alpha}-c(\alpha,\beta,\delta,N^+)ar^\delta\right) \\
&\geq r^{-\beta p}(l_1(1+\epsilon))^p\left(1-\frac{p}{2}ar^\delta\right)\geq\underline{u}^p
\end{aligned} ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) + μ r − 2 − α u 1 + α ≥ ( l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) r − β ) 1 + α r − α − 2 ( K p − 1 − α − c ( α , β , δ , N + ) a r δ ) ≥ r − β p ( l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) ) p ( 1 − 2 p a r δ ) ≥ u p
If β ≠ N + − 2 \beta\neq N^+-2 β = N + − 2 using the second comparison Theorem 2.2 one gets that u ≥ u ‾ u\geq\underline{u} u ≥ u which implies in particular that lim inf u ≥ l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) \liminf u\geq l_1(1+\epsilon) lim inf u ≥ l 1 ( 1 + ϵ ) , a contradiction with the hypothesis.
If β = N + − 2 \beta=N^+-2 β = N + − 2 we observe that the additional assumption in Theorem 2.2 , say ∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ c r − β p − 1 2 + α |u'|\leq cr^{\frac{-\beta p-1}{2+\alpha}} ∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ c r 2 + α − β p − 1 holds for the super-solution u u u . Indeed, in that case K p − 1 − α = μ K^{p-1-\alpha}=\mu K p − 1 − α = μ . Then if l 1 < K l_1<K l 1 < K
M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ − c r − β p . \mathcal{M}^+(D^2u)\leq-cr^{-\beta p}. M + ( D 2 u ) ≤ − c r − β p .
Replacing in radial coordinates,
( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≤ − c r − 1 ≤ 0. \left(|u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\right)'\leq-cr^{-1}\leq0. ( ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ) ′ ≤ − c r − 1 ≤ 0.
In particular ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) |u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)} ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) has a limit ≤ 0 \leq0 ≤ 0 , which cannot be else than finite, since for all r > 0 r>0 r > 0
∣ u ′ ∣ α ( r ) u ′ ( r ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ lim r → 0 ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) . |u'|^\alpha(r)u'(r)r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\leq\lim_{r\to0}|u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}. ∣ u ′ ∣ α ( r ) u ′ ( r ) r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ≤ r → 0 lim ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) .
We have then ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ∼ l ≤ 0 |u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}\sim l\leq0 ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ∼ l ≤ 0 which implies that ∣ ∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ∣ ≤ C ||u'|^\alpha u'r^{(N^+-1)(1+\alpha)}|\leq C ∣∣ u ′ ∣ α u ′ r ( N + − 1 ) ( 1 + α ) ∣ ≤ C , or equivalently here ∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ C 1 1 + α r − β − 1 |u'|\leq C^{\frac{1}{1+\alpha}}r^{-\beta-1} ∣ u ′ ∣ ≤ C 1 + α 1 r − β − 1 . We end the proof as in the case β ≠ N + − 2 \beta\neq N^+-2 β = N + − 2 .
We now suppose l 1 = lim sup > K l_1=\limsup>K l 1 = lim sup > K . Let ϵ \epsilon ϵ so that ϵ < inf ( l 1 − K 2 l 1 , 1 4 ) \epsilon<\inf\left(\frac{l_1-K}{2l_1},\frac14\right) ϵ < inf ( 2 l 1 l 1 − K , 4 1 ) , and also so that for 0 ≤ u ≤ 2 ϵ 0\leq u\leq2\epsilon 0 ≤ u ≤ 2 ϵ
1 + ∣ α ∣ 2 u ≤ ( 1 + u ) α ≤ 1 + 2 ∣ α ∣ u , 1 + 1 + α 2 u ≤ ( 1 + u ) α ≤ 1 + 2 ( 1 + α ) u , 1+\frac{|\alpha|}{2}u\leq(1+u)^\alpha\leq1+2|\alpha|u,\quad1+\frac{1+\alpha}{2}u\leq(1+u)^\alpha\leq1+2(1+\alpha)u, 1 + 2 ∣ α ∣ u ≤ ( 1 + u ) α ≤ 1 + 2∣ α ∣ u , 1 + 2 1 + α u ≤ ( 1 + u ) α ≤ 1 + 2 ( 1 + α ) u ,
and
2 ε c ( α , β , δ , N + ) < ( K + l 1 2 ) p − 1 − α − K p − 1 − α 2\varepsilon c(\alpha,\beta,\delta,N^+) < \left(\frac{K+l_1}{2}\right)^{p-1-\alpha}-K^{p-1-\alpha} 2 ε c ( α , β , δ , N + ) < ( 2 K + l 1 ) p − 1 − α − K p − 1 − α
We take r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o
u ( r ) r β ≤ l 1 ( 1 + ε 2 ) , u(r)r^\beta\le l_1\left(1+\frac{\varepsilon}{2}\right), u ( r ) r β ≤ l 1 ( 1 + 2 ε ) ,
we define a = 2 ε r o − δ a=2\varepsilon r_o^{-\delta} a = 2 ε r o − δ and
u ‾ = l 1 ( 1 − ε ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) . \overline{u}=l_1(1-\varepsilon)r^{-\beta}(1+ar^\delta). u = l 1 ( 1 − ε ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) .
We have
u ‾ ( r o ) r o β = l 1 ( 1 − ε ) ( 1 + 2 ε ) ≥ l 1 ( 1 + ε / 2 ) ≥ u ( r o ) r o β . \overline{u}(r_o)r_o^\beta=l_1(1-\varepsilon)(1+2\varepsilon)\ge l_1(1+\varepsilon/2)\ge u(r_o)r_o^\beta. u ( r o ) r o β = l 1 ( 1 − ε ) ( 1 + 2 ε ) ≥ l 1 ( 1 + ε /2 ) ≥ u ( r o ) r o β .
An analogous calculation as the one done in the case of the sub-solution, proves that u ‾ \overline{u} u is a super-solution in r < r o r<r_o r < r o . Using the second comparison Theorem 2.2 one gets that u ≤ u ‾ u\le\overline{u} u ≤ u and this implies lim sup u ( r ) r β ≤ l 1 ( 1 − ε ) \limsup u(r)r^\beta\le l_1(1-\varepsilon) lim sup u ( r ) r β ≤ l 1 ( 1 − ε ) a contradiction. We have obtained that lim u ( r ) r β = K \lim u(r)r^\beta=K lim u ( r ) r β = K .
The case p ∈ [ 1 + α + 2 + α τ + , 1 + α + 2 + α τ − [ p\in[1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^+},1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-}[ p ∈ [ 1 + α + τ + 2 + α , 1 + α + τ − 2 + α [
The proposition below proves item 2 in Theorem 1.2
Proposition 4.12. Suppose that p ∈ [ 1 + α + 2 + α τ + , 1 + α + 2 + α τ − [ p\in[1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^+},1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-}[ p ∈ [ 1 + α + τ + 2 + α , 1 + α + τ − 2 + α [ . Then lim u ( r ) r 2 + α p − 1 − α = 0 \lim u(r)r^{\frac{2+\alpha}{p-1-\alpha}}=0 lim u ( r ) r p − 1 − α 2 + α = 0 , and there exists some positive constant c c c so that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^-} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ −
Proof. We suppose first that β ≠ τ + \beta\ne\tau^+ β = τ + . Then ψ ( β ) < 0 \psi(\beta)<0 ψ ( β ) < 0 . To prove that x x x goes to zero, let us suppose by contradiction that lim sup u ( r ) r β = l > 0 \limsup u(r)r^\beta=l>0 lim sup u ( r ) r β = l > 0 . Let 0 < δ < β 0<\delta<\beta 0 < δ < β , Let
ε < inf ( 1 4 , c ( α , β , N + , δ ) − 1 ∣ ψ ( β ) ∣ 4 ) \varepsilon<\inf\left(\frac{1}{4},c(\alpha,\beta,N^+,\delta)^{-1}\frac{|\psi(\beta)|}{4}\right) ε < inf ( 4 1 , c ( α , β , N + , δ ) − 1 4 ∣ ψ ( β ) ∣ )
and so that {(xref}(4.9)} and {(xref}(4.10)} hold (see the proof of Proposition 4.11 ), and c ( α , β , N + , δ ) c(\alpha,\beta,N^+,\delta) c ( α , β , N + , δ ) has been defined in {(xref}(4.12)}. Let r o r_o r o be small enough in order that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o , u ( r ) r β < l ( 1 + ε 2 ) u(r)r^\beta<l(1+\frac{\varepsilon}{2}) u ( r ) r β < l ( 1 + 2 ε ) . Let a = 2 ε r o − δ a=2\varepsilon r_o^{-\delta} a = 2 ε r o − δ , and u ‾ ( r ) = l ( 1 − ε ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) \overline{u}(r)=l(1-\varepsilon)r^{-\beta}(1+ar^\delta) u ( r ) = l ( 1 − ε ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) . Then
u ‾ ( r o ) = l ( 1 − ε ) ( 1 + 2 ε ) r o − β > u ( r o ) . \overline{u}(r_o)=l(1-\varepsilon)(1+2\varepsilon)r_o^{-\beta}>u(r_o). u ( r o ) = l ( 1 − ε ) ( 1 + 2 ε ) r o − β > u ( r o ) .
With the assumptions on ε \varepsilon ε , one has
∣ ∇ u ‾ ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ‾ ) + μ u ‾ 1 + α r 2 + α = r − β p ( ψ ( β ) + a r δ c ( α , β , N + , δ ) ) ≤ ψ ( β ) 2 r − β p < 0 < u ‾ p |\nabla\overline{u}|^\alpha\mathcal{M}^+(D^2\overline{u})+\mu\frac{\overline{u}^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}=r^{-\beta p}\left(\psi(\beta)+ar^\delta c(\alpha,\beta,N^+,\delta)\right)\le\frac{\psi(\beta)}{2}r^{-\beta p}<0<\overline{u}^{p} ∣∇ u ∣ α M + ( D 2 u ) + μ r 2 + α u 1 + α = r − β p ( ψ ( β ) + a r δ c ( α , β , N + , δ ) ) ≤ 2 ψ ( β ) r − β p < 0 < u p
and then u ‾ \overline{u} u is a super-solution. Then using the second comparison Theorem 2.2 one gets that u ≤ u ‾ u\le\overline{u} u ≤ u in r < r o r<r_o r < r o , and this contradicts lim sup u ( r ) r β = l \limsup u(r)r^\beta=l lim sup u ( r ) r β = l . We have obtained that lim sup u r β = 0 \limsup ur^\beta=0 lim sup u r β = 0 .
Using Proposition 4.7 one gets that y ′ y' y ′ has constant sign, hence y y y converges, and as proved in Theorem 4.6 , y → τ ± y\to\tau^\pm y → τ ± . We observe that y y y cannot tend to τ + \tau^+ τ + . Indeed, if it was the case one would have x ′ x ∼ β − τ + < 0 \frac{x'}{x}\sim\beta-\tau^+<0 x x ′ ∼ β − τ + < 0 , this would imply that x ′ ≤ − c x x'\le-cx x ′ ≤ − c x and integrating one would get that x x x would be negative large, as soon as t t t is large enough negative, a contradiction. We have then y → τ − y\to\tau^- y → τ − and using Proposition 4.10 one gets that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^-} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − .
There remains to do the case p = p ⋆ p=p^{\star} p = p ⋆ , or equivalently β = τ + \beta=\tau^{+} β = τ + . In that case ψ ( β ) = 0 \psi(\beta)=0 ψ ( β ) = 0 . Suppose that lim sup u ( r ) r τ + = l > 0 \limsup u(r)r^{\tau^{+}}=l>0 lim sup u ( r ) r τ + = l > 0 . we fix δ ∈ ] 0 , β [ \delta\in]0,\beta[ δ ∈ ] 0 , β [ , suppose that ϵ \epsilon ϵ is so that ϵ < 1 4 \epsilon<\frac{1}{4} ϵ < 4 1 ,
2 ϵ c ( α , β , N + , δ ) < ( l 2 ) p − 1 − α , 2\epsilon c(\alpha,\beta,N^{+},\delta)<\left(\frac{l}{2}\right)^{p-1-\alpha}, 2 ϵc ( α , β , N + , δ ) < ( 2 l ) p − 1 − α ,
and r o r_{o} r o so that for r < r o r<r_{o} r < r o , u ( r ) r β < l ( 1 + ϵ 2 ) u(r)r^{\beta}<l(1+\frac{\epsilon}{2}) u ( r ) r β < l ( 1 + 2 ϵ ) . Let a = 2 ϵ r o − δ a=2\epsilon r_{o}^{-\delta} a = 2 ϵ r o − δ , and u ‾ ( r ) = l ( 1 − ϵ ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) \overline{u}(r)=l(1-\epsilon)r^{-\beta}(1+ar^{\delta}) u ( r ) = l ( 1 − ϵ ) r − β ( 1 + a r δ ) . Then
\frac{\lvert\nabla\overline{u}\rvert^{\alpha}\mathcal{M}^{+}(D^{2}\overline{u})+\mu\frac{\overline{u}^{1+\alpha}}{r^{2+\alpha}}\leq(l(1-\epsilon))^{1+\alpha}ar^{\delta}c(\alpha,\beta,N^{+})r^{-\beta p}\leq(l(1-\epsilon))^{p}r^{-\beta p}<\overline{u}^{p}.}
Since u ‾ ( r o ) = l ( 1 − ϵ ) ( 1 + 2 ϵ ) r o − β > u ( r o ) \overline{u}(r_{o})=l(1-\epsilon)(1+2\epsilon)r_{o}^{-\beta}>u(r_{o}) u ( r o ) = l ( 1 − ϵ ) ( 1 + 2 ϵ ) r o − β > u ( r o ) , using the second comparison Theorem 2.2 one gets also in that case that lim u ( r ) r β = 0 \lim u(r)r^{\beta}=0 lim u ( r ) r β = 0 . By Proposition 4.7 one gets that y → τ ± y\to\tau^{\pm} y → τ ± . If y → τ + y\to\tau^{+} y → τ + , we cannot have y ′ ≥ 0 y'\geq0 y ′ ≥ 0 since this would imply x ′ x ≤ 0 \frac{x'}{x}\leq0 x x ′ ≤ 0 , hence x ′ ≤ 0 x'\leq0 x ′ ≤ 0 , and x x x tends to 0 0 0 and x ≥ 0 x\geq0 x ≥ 0 would imply x ≡ 0 x\equiv0 x ≡ 0 . Then y ′ ≤ 0 y'\leq0 y ′ ≤ 0 , y < τ + y<\tau^{+} y < τ + (for t < T t<T t < T large enough negative) and φ > 0 \varphi>0 φ > 0 for r r r small enough. We have by the proof in proposition 4.8,
r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≥ 0 r\varphi'-c_{1}^{+}\varphi\geq0 r φ ′ − c 1 + φ ≥ 0
then φ ≤ C r c 1 + \varphi\leq Cr^{c_{1}^{+}} φ ≤ C r c 1 + and this would imply that u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^{+}} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ + , with c > 0 c>0 c > 0 , a contradiction with lim u ( r ) r β = 0 \lim u(r)r^{\beta}=0 lim u ( r ) r β = 0 . Then y → τ − y\to\tau^{-} y → τ − and using proposition 4.10, we get u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − u(r)\sim cr^{-\tau^{-}} u ( r ) ∼ c r − τ − .
The case p = 1 + α + 2 + α τ − p = 1 + \alpha+ \frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{-}} p = 1 + α + τ − 2 + α
Here we will prove that
Proposition 4.13. If p = 1 + α + 2 + α τ − p=1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{-}} p = 1 + α + τ − 2 + α
u ( r ) ∼ K ~ r − τ − ( − log r ) τ − 2 + α u(r)\sim\widetilde{K}r^{-\tau^{-}}(-\log r)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}} u ( r ) ∼ K r − τ − ( − log r ) 2 + α τ − with K ~ = ( Λ ( τ − ) 1 + α ( τ − τ − ) ) 1 p − ( 1 + α ) \widetilde{K}=\left(\Lambda(\tau^{-})^{1+\alpha}(\tau-\tau^{-})\right)^{\frac{1}{p-(1+\alpha)}} K = ( Λ ( τ − ) 1 + α ( τ − τ − ) ) p − ( 1 + α ) 1 .
The idea is to compare u u u with sub- and super-solutions which behave as r − τ − ( − log r ) τ − 2 + α r^{-\tau^{-}}(-\log r)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}} r − τ − ( − log r ) 2 + α τ − near zero. Note that here we cannot employ the comparison principle in Theorem 2.2 since the bound from below of the super-solution is not satisfied. We need another ”comparison result” about sub- and super-solutions of an auxiliary equation.
Lemma 4.14. Suppose that β = p ⋆ ⋆ \beta=p^{\star\star} β = p ⋆⋆ and u u u is a positive radial solution of (3) . Let v = r τ − u v=r^{\tau^{-}}u v = r τ − u . Then v ′ r v → 0 \frac{v'r}{v}\to0 v v ′ r → 0 , v ′ ′ r 2 v − 1 → 0 v''r^{2}v^{-1}\to0 v ′′ r 2 v − 1 → 0 .
Proof. of Lemma 4.14
We begin to observe that x ′ x → 0 \frac{x'}{x}\to0 x x ′ → 0 . For that aim, since x x x goes to zero, (see proposition 4.12) we prove as before that y ′ y' y ′ does not change sign and then y y y tends to τ ± \tau^{\pm} τ ± . We prove that it cannot tend to τ + \tau^{+} τ + . If it is the case then x ′ x ∼ ( τ − − τ + ) = : − γ < 0 \frac{x'}{x}\sim(\tau^{-}-\tau^{+})=:-\gamma<0 x x ′ ∼ ( τ − − τ + ) =: − γ < 0 . Then for t t t large enough negative one gets the contradiction x < 0 x<0 x < 0 . Then y y y tends to τ − \tau^{-} τ − and then x ′ x \frac{x'}{x} x x ′ tends to zero. Note that this is equivalent to say that r v ′ v \frac{rv'}{v} v r v ′ tends to zero. From the equation (9) , y ′ → 0 y'\to0 y ′ → 0 , which means that r 2 v ′ ′ v − 1 r^{2}v''v^{-1} r 2 v ′′ v − 1 tends to zero.
Proof. of Proposition 4.13 Observe that v ( 0 ) = 0 v(0)=0 v ( 0 ) = 0 since x → 0 x\to0 x → 0 . An easy calculation proves that v v v satisfies
( τ − v ) α ( r 2 v ′ ′ + ( N + − 1 − 2 τ − ) v ′ r + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 ) ) v ) + μ Λ v 1 + α = v p Λ (\tau^{-}v)^{\alpha}(r^{2}v''+(N^{+}-1-2\tau^{-})v'r+\tau^{-}(\tau^{-}-(N^{+}-2))v)+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda}v^{1+\alpha}=\frac{v^{p}}{\Lambda} ( τ − v ) α ( r 2 v ′′ + ( N + − 1 − 2 τ − ) v ′ r + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 )) v ) + Λ μ v 1 + α = Λ v p
We prove below that v ′ v' v ′ does not change sign, near zero, and since v ( 0 ) = 0 v(0)=0 v ( 0 ) = 0 and v > 0 v>0 v > 0 this implies that v ′ ≥ 0 v'\geq0 v ′ ≥ 0 . Indeed suppose that we have a sequence r n r_n r n coming to zero, so that v ′ ( r n ) = v ′ ( r n + 1 ) = 0 v'(r_n)=v'(r_{n+1})=0 v ′ ( r n ) = v ′ ( r n + 1 ) = 0 , and v ′ < 0 v'<0 v ′ < 0 in ] r n + 1 , r n [ ]r_{n+1},r_n[ ] r n + 1 , r n [ , then by the equation
( τ − v ) α ( r 2 v ′ ′ + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 ) ) v ) + μ Λ v 1 + α = ( τ − v ) α r 2 v ′ ′ = v p Λ (\tau^{-}v)^{\alpha}(r^{2}v''+\tau^{-}(\tau^{-}-(N^{+}-2))v)+\frac{\mu}{\Lambda}v^{1+\alpha}=(\tau^{-}v)^{\alpha}r^{2}v''=\frac{v^{p}}{\Lambda} ( τ − v ) α ( r 2 v ′′ + τ − ( τ − − ( N + − 2 )) v ) + Λ μ v 1 + α = ( τ − v ) α r 2 v ′′ = Λ v p
in particular v ′ ′ ( r n + 1 ) > 0 v''(r_{n+1})>0 v ′′ ( r n + 1 ) > 0 , a contradiction since v ′ v' v ′ is negative after r n + 1 r_{n+1} r n + 1 , close to it.
Claim v ′ r v − 1 ≤ C v p − 1 − α v'rv^{-1}\leq C v^{p-1-\alpha} v ′ r v − 1 ≤ C v p − 1 − α
Using r v ′ v \frac{rv'}{v} v r v ′ and r 2 v ′ ′ v \frac{r^{2}v''}{v} v r 2 v ′′ tend to zero, there exist constants d 1 : = d 1 ( α , N + , τ − ) d_1:=d_1(\alpha,N^{+},\tau^{-}) d 1 := d 1 ( α , N + , τ − ) , d 2 : = d 2 ( α , N + , τ − ) d_2:=d_2(\alpha,N^{+},\tau^{-}) d 2 := d 2 ( α , N + , τ − ) , d 3 : = d 3 ( α , N + , τ − ) d_3:=d_3(\alpha,N^{+},\tau^{-}) d 3 := d 3 ( α , N + , τ − ) d 4 : = d 4 ( α , N + , τ − ) d_4:=d_4(\alpha,N^{+},\tau^{-}) d 4 := d 4 ( α , N + , τ − ) so that, for any ϵ \epsilon ϵ , there exists r o r_o r o so that r < r o r<r_o r < r o
( τ − v ) α ( v ′ ′ r 2 + v ′ r ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) ) + v ′ r d 1 ϵ + v ′ ′ r 2 d 2 ϵ ) ≤ v p Λ , (\tau^{-}v)^{\alpha}(v''r^{2}+v'r(1+(2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^{-}))+v'rd_1\epsilon+v''r^{2}d_2\epsilon)\leq\frac{v^{p}}{\Lambda}, ( τ − v ) α ( v ′′ r 2 + v ′ r ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − )) + v ′ r d 1 ϵ + v ′′ r 2 d 2 ϵ ) ≤ Λ v p ,
and
v p Λ ≤ ( τ − v ) α ( v ′ ′ r 2 + v ′ r ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) ) + v ′ r d 3 ϵ + v ′ ′ r 2 d 4 ϵ ) . \frac{v^{p}}{\Lambda}\leq(\tau^{-}v)^{\alpha}(v''r^{2}+v'r(1+(2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^{-}))+v'rd_3\epsilon+v''r^{2}d_4\epsilon). Λ v p ≤ ( τ − v ) α ( v ′′ r 2 + v ′ r ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − )) + v ′ r d 3 ϵ + v ′′ r 2 d 4 ϵ ) .
From this one derives assuming ϵ \epsilon ϵ small enough, but fixе in order that γ 1 : = 1 + d 1 ϵ + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) 1 + d 2 ϵ > 1 \gamma_1:=\frac{1+d_1\epsilon+(2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^{-})}{1+d_2\epsilon}>1 γ 1 := 1 + d 2 ϵ 1 + d 1 ϵ + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) > 1 ,
( r γ 1 v ′ ) ′ ≤ 1 Λ ( τ − ) α ( 1 + d 2 ϵ ) v p − α r γ 1 − 2 (18) (r^{\gamma_1}v')'\leq\frac{1}{\Lambda(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}(1+d_2\epsilon)}v^{p-\alpha}r^{\gamma_1-2} \tag*{(18)} ( r γ 1 v ′ ) ′ ≤ Λ ( τ − ) α ( 1 + d 2 ϵ ) 1 v p − α r γ 1 − 2 (18)
Using v ′ r γ 1 = v ′ r r γ 1 − 1 ≤ c r γ 1 − 1 v v'r^{\gamma_1}=v'rr^{\gamma_1-1}\leq cr^{\gamma_1-1}v v ′ r γ 1 = v ′ r r γ 1 − 1 ≤ c r γ 1 − 1 v one has v ′ r γ 1 → 0 v'r^{\gamma_1}\to0 v ′ r γ 1 → 0 when r r r tends to zero. Integrating, and using v v v increasing one gets
v ′ ≤ 1 Λ ( τ − ) α ( 1 + d 2 ϵ ) ( γ 1 − 1 ) v p − α r − 1 . v'\leq\frac{1}{\Lambda(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}(1+d_2\epsilon)(\gamma_1-1)}v^{p-\alpha}r^{-1}. v ′ ≤ Λ ( τ − ) α ( 1 + d 2 ϵ ) ( γ 1 − 1 ) 1 v p − α r − 1 .
Coming back to (18) one also gets that
∣ v ′ ′ r 2 ∣ ≤ c ( v ′ r + v p − α ) ≤ c v p − α . |v''r^{2}|\leq c(v'r+v^{p-\alpha})\leq cv^{p-\alpha}. ∣ v ′′ r 2 ∣ ≤ c ( v ′ r + v p − α ) ≤ c v p − α .
To summarize, there exists d 5 d_5 d 5 depending on N + , α , τ − N^{+},\alpha,\tau^{-} N + , α , τ − so that, for all ϵ \epsilon ϵ , there exists some r o r_o r o so that for r < r o r<r_o r < r o ,
( 1 − d 5 ϵ ) v p − α ( τ − ) α Λ ≤ v ′ ′ r 2 + ( v ′ r ) ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) ) ≤ ( 1 + d 5 ϵ ) v p − α ( τ − ) α Λ . (19) (1-d_5\epsilon)\frac{v^{p-\alpha}}{(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}\Lambda}\leq v''r^{2}+(v'r)(1+(2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^{-}))\leq(1+d_5\epsilon)\frac{v^{p-\alpha}}{(\tau^{-})^{\alpha}\Lambda}. \tag*{(19)} ( 1 − d 5 ϵ ) ( τ − ) α Λ v p − α ≤ v ′′ r 2 + ( v ′ r ) ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − )) ≤ ( 1 + d 5 ϵ ) ( τ − ) α Λ v p − α . (19)
Let w = K ( c o − log r ) τ − 2 + α w=\frac{K}{(c_o-\log r)^{\frac{\tau^{-}}{2+\alpha}}} w = ( c o − l o g r ) 2 + α τ − K , K < K ~ K<\widetilde K K < K and let ϵ \epsilon ϵ small enough in order that K p − 1 − α 1 + d 5 ϵ < K ~ p − 1 − α \frac{K^{p-1-\alpha}}{1+d_5\epsilon}<\widetilde K^{p-1-\alpha} 1 + d 5 ϵ K p − 1 − α < K p − 1 − α , let r o r_o r o so that (19) holds, and
c o = log r o + ( K v ( r o ) ) 2 + α τ − c_o=\log r_o+\left(\frac{K}{v(r_o)}\right)^{\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^{-}}} c o = log r o + ( v ( r o ) K ) τ − 2 + α
With that choice, w > 0 w>0 w > 0 in ] 0 , r o [ ]0,r_o[ ] 0 , r o [ and w ( r o ) ≤ v ( r o ) w(r_o)\le v(r_o) w ( r o ) ≤ v ( r o ) . Furthermore w ( 0 ) = 0 w(0)=0 w ( 0 ) = 0 and it satisfies for r < r o r<r_o r < r o
w ′ ′ r 2 + w ′ r ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) ≥ K τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 1 ≥ w p − α ( 1 + d 5 ε ) Λ − 1 ( τ − ) − α w''r^2+w'r\left(1+(N^+-2)(1+\alpha)-(2+\alpha)\tau^-\right)\ge K\tau^-(\tau-\tau^-)(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-1}\ge w^{p-\alpha}(1+d_5\varepsilon)\Lambda^{-1}(\tau^-)^{-\alpha} w ′′ r 2 + w ′ r ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) ≥ K τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 1 ≥ w p − α ( 1 + d 5 ε ) Λ − 1 ( τ − ) − α
Let us suppose by contradiction that inf ( v − w ) < 0 \inf(v-w)<0 inf ( v − w ) < 0 on ] 0 , r o [ ]0,r_o[ ] 0 , r o [ . Then let r 1 r_1 r 1 so that the minimum is achieved. We have on r 1 r_1 r 1 , ( v − w ) ′ ( r 1 ) = 0 (v-w)'(r_1)=0 ( v − w ) ′ ( r 1 ) = 0 , and ( v − w ) ′ ′ ( r 1 ) ≥ 0 (v-w)''(r_1)\ge0 ( v − w ) ′′ ( r 1 ) ≥ 0 , so
Λ − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) v p − α ( r 1 ) ( τ − ) − α ≥ r 1 2 v ′ ′ ( r 1 ) + r 1 v ′ ( r 1 ) ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) ≥ r 1 2 w ′ ′ ( r 1 ) + r 1 w ′ ( r 1 ) ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) ) ≥ Λ − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) w p − α ( r 1 ) ( τ − ) − α \begin{aligned}
\Lambda^{-1}(1+d_5\varepsilon)v^{p-\alpha}(r_1)(\tau^-)^{-\alpha}
&\ge r_1^2v''(r_1)+r_1v'(r_1)\left(1+(N^+-2)(1+\alpha)-(2+\alpha)\tau^-\right)\\
&\ge r_1^2w''(r_1)+r_1w'(r_1)\left(1+(2+\alpha)(\tau-\tau^-)\right)\\
&\ge\Lambda^{-1}(1+d_5\varepsilon)w^{p-\alpha}(r_1)(\tau^-)^{-\alpha}
\end{aligned} Λ − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) v p − α ( r 1 ) ( τ − ) − α ≥ r 1 2 v ′′ ( r 1 ) + r 1 v ′ ( r 1 ) ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) ≥ r 1 2 w ′′ ( r 1 ) + r 1 w ′ ( r 1 ) ( 1 + ( 2 + α ) ( τ − τ − ) ) ≥ Λ − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) w p − α ( r 1 ) ( τ − ) − α
a contradiction since v ( r 1 ) < w ( r 1 ) v(r_1)<w(r_1) v ( r 1 ) < w ( r 1 ) . We have obtained that v ≥ K ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α v\ge K(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}} v ≥ K ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − .
To prove some reverse inequality, let K ‾ > K ~ \overline{K}>\widetilde{K} K > K and let ε \varepsilon ε small enough in order that K ‾ p − 1 − α > K ~ p − 1 − α ( 1 − 2 d 5 ε ) − 1 \overline{K}^{p-1-\alpha}>\widetilde{K}^{p-1-\alpha}(1-2d_5\varepsilon)^{-1} K p − 1 − α > K p − 1 − α ( 1 − 2 d 5 ε ) − 1 . Let r o r_o r o small in order that (19) holds and also so that (since v ( 0 ) = 0 v(0)=0 v ( 0 ) = 0 )
τ − 2 + α ( τ − 2 + α + 1 ) ( v ( r o ) K ~ ) 2 + α τ − < d 5 ε Λ ( τ − ) α . (20) \frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}\left(\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}+1\right)\left(\frac{v(r_o)}{\widetilde{K}}\right)^{\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-}}<\frac{d_5\varepsilon}{\Lambda(\tau^-)^\alpha}. \tag*{(20)} 2 + α τ − ( 2 + α τ − + 1 ) ( K v ( r o ) ) τ − 2 + α < Λ ( τ − ) α d 5 ε . (20)
We define w ‾ = K ‾ ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α \overline{w}=\overline{K}(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}} w = K ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − with
c o = ( K ‾ v ( r o ) ) 2 + α τ − − ( − log r o ) c_o=\left(\frac{\overline{K}}{v(r_o)}\right)^{\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-}}-(-\log r_o) c o = ( v ( r o ) K ) τ − 2 + α − ( − log r o )
Then w ‾ > 0 \overline{w}>0 w > 0 , is decreasing and convex, w ‾ ( 0 ) = 0 \overline{w}(0)=0 w ( 0 ) = 0 and v ( r o ) ≤ w ‾ ( r o ) v(r_o)\le\overline{w}(r_o) v ( r o ) ≤ w ( r o ) . Furthermore
w ‾ ′ ′ r 2 + w ‾ ′ r ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) = K ‾ τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 1 + K ‾ ( τ − 2 + α ) ( τ − 2 + α + 1 ) ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 2 ≤ K ‾ τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 1 + K ‾ ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 1 τ − 2 + α ( τ − 2 + α + 1 ) ( v ( r o ) K ‾ ) 2 + α τ − ≤ K ‾ τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − τ − 2 + α − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) ≤ ( 1 − d 5 ε ) w ‾ p − α Λ − 1 ( τ − ) − α \begin{aligned}
\overline{w}''r^2+\overline{w}'r\left(1+(N^+-2)(1+\alpha)-(2+\alpha)\tau^-\right)
&=\overline{K}\tau^-(\tau-\tau^-)(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-1}\\
&\quad+\overline{K}\left(\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}\right)\left(\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}+1\right)(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-2}\\
&\le\overline{K}\tau^-(\tau-\tau^-)(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-1}\\
&\quad+\overline{K}(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-1}\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}\left(\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}+1\right)\left(\frac{v(r_o)}{\overline{K}}\right)^{\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-}}\\
&\le\overline{K}\tau^-(\tau-\tau^-)(c_o-\log r)^{-\frac{\tau^-}{2+\alpha}-1}(1+d_5\varepsilon)\\
&\le(1-d_5\varepsilon)\overline{w}^{p-\alpha}\Lambda^{-1}(\tau^-)^{-\alpha}
\end{aligned} w ′′ r 2 + w ′ r ( 1 + ( N + − 2 ) ( 1 + α ) − ( 2 + α ) τ − ) = K τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 1 + K ( 2 + α τ − ) ( 2 + α τ − + 1 ) ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 2 ≤ K τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 1 + K ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 1 2 + α τ − ( 2 + α τ − + 1 ) ( K v ( r o ) ) τ − 2 + α ≤ K τ − ( τ − τ − ) ( c o − log r ) − 2 + α τ − − 1 ( 1 + d 5 ε ) ≤ ( 1 − d 5 ε ) w p − α Λ − 1 ( τ − ) − α
by using (20) and the definition of c o c_o c o . Using the same argument of comparison as above but now with v v v and w ‾ \overline{w} w , one obtains that v ≤ w ‾ v\le\overline{w} v ≤ w and by the arbitrariness of K ‾ \overline{K} K and K K K , one gets the desired equivalent for v v v and then for u u u .
The case p > 1 + α + 2 + α τ − p>1+\alpha+\frac{2+\alpha}{\tau^-} p > 1 + α + τ − 2 + α
We still suppose that u u u is a positive solution of (1.3), and x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) x(\log r)=r^\beta u(r) x ( log r ) = r β u ( r ) . In that case we just observe that we cannot have x → 0 x\to0 x → 0 . Indeed if it is the case, y ′ y' y ′ does not change sign, and then y y y converges to τ ± \tau^\pm τ ± . But β − τ ± < 0 \beta-\tau^\pm<0 β − τ ± < 0 and this contradicts y ≥ 0 y\ge0 y ≥ 0 . So x x x does not tend to zero, we then use Proposition 4.11 . We obtain that u ( r ) ∼ K r − β u(r)\sim Kr^{-\beta} u ( r ) ∼ K r − β . We could also have used Theorem of Poincaré Bendixson: x x x must converge to the only stationary point, which is K K K (recall that there is no periodic orbit for t t t large negative).