betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A proof of Nakamura's conjecture

Abstract

We prove Nakamura's conjecture on the relation between the 2D Toda model and solutions of the Ernst equation, using the Pfaffian solutions obtained in our previous work arXiv:2610.27420.

Introduction

In this paper we prove Nakamura’s conjecture, concerning the relation between the 2D Toda model and Yamazaki-Hori solutions of the Ernst equation. Recall that the Ernst equation is formulated in terms of a complex potential ξ\xi, which allows reconstruction of metric functions for stationary axisymmetric gravitational fields. It has the form [2]:

(ξξ∗−1)∇2ξ=2ξ∗∇⃗ξ⋅∇⃗ξ.(1)(\xi\xi^{*} - 1) \nabla^{2}\xi= 2\xi^{*}\vec{\nabla}\xi\cdot\vec{\nabla}\xi. \tag*{(1)}

The Yamazaki-Hori solutions to (1) are rational solutions parametrized by n∈Z≥0n \in\mathbb{Z}_{\geq0}, and have the form [3, 4]:

ξn=gn(x,y,p,q)fn(x,y,p,q)(2)\xi_n = \frac{g_n(x,y,p,q)}{f_n(x,y,p,q)} \tag*{(2)}

where x,yx, y are the prolate spheroidal coordinates and p,qp, q are two parameters satisfying p2+q2=1p^2+q^2=1.1 The semi-infinite 2D Toda molecule is described in terms of the τ\tau-functions τn=τn(η,ζ)\tau_n=\tau_n(\eta,\zeta) by the Hirota bilinear equation [5]:

DηDζτn⋅τn=2τn+1τn−1,τ0=1.n=1,2,…,(3)D_\eta D_\zeta\tau_n\cdot\tau_n=2\tau_{n+1}\tau_{n-1},\qquad\tau_0=1.\qquad n=1,2,\ldots, \tag*{(3)}

with the solutions given by the following two-directional Wronskian:

τn(Φ)=det⁡T(n)(Φ),Tkl(n)(Φ):=(∂∂η)k−1(∂∂ζ)l−1Φ(η,ζ),1≤k,l≤n.(4)\tau_n(\Phi)=\det T^{(n)}(\Phi),\qquad T_{kl}^{(n)}(\Phi):=\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\eta}\right)^{k-1}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\zeta}\right)^{l-1}\Phi(\eta,\zeta),\qquad1\leq k,l\leq n. \tag*{(4)}

Here Φ(η,ζ)\Phi(\eta,\zeta) is an arbitrary seed function.2

Nakamura conjectured and verified numerically for the first values of nn in [5] that the polynomials gng_n and fnf_n can be obtained from the τ\tau-function of the 2D Toda model, thus establishing a relation between the two models. Fukuyama, Kamimura and Yu [6] proved the conjecture for the nonrotating Weyl case q=0q=0. Subsequently, Fukuyama and Koizumi [7] established the conjectured relations for the highest and lowest orders in an expansion in the rotation parameter. More recently, Fukuyama [8] investigated the underlying determinant structure and its relation to the conjecture.

In this paper we prove the conjecture for arbitrary values of the parameter s=q/ps=q/p,3 using the Pfaffian solutions to the Ernst equation obtained in [1]. We recall the main result of [1] in the following theorem.

Theorem 1 (Pfaffian form of the Yamazaki-Hori solutions). The Yamazaki-Hori solutions are expressed in terms of the polynomials fnf_n and gng_n, each given by a product of Pfaffians, while the corresponding Ernst potential ξn=gn/fn\xi_n=g_n/f_n is given by the ratio of two Pfaffians. In particular, we have the following two cases.

Even case (m=n−1=2km=n-1=2k):

fn=C(f)pf⁡‾(ω(s))pf⁡(ω(s)),C(f)=(−1)np2n−2C(n)2n−1,(5)f_n=C^{(f)}\overline{\operatorname{pf}}(\omega^{(s)})\operatorname{pf}(\omega^{(s)}),\qquad C^{(f)}=\frac{(-1)^n p^{2n-2}C(n)}{2n-1}, \tag*{(5)}
gn=C(g)pf⁡‾(ω(s))pf⁡(Ω(e)),C(g)=(−1)np2n−1C(n).(6)g_n=C^{(g)}\overline{\operatorname{pf}}(\omega^{(s)})\operatorname{pf}(\Omega^{(e)}),\qquad C^{(g)}=(-1)^n p^{2n-1}C(n). \tag*{(6)}

Thus, for the Ernst potential:

ξn=p(2n−1)pf⁡(Ω(e))pf⁡(ω(s)).(7)\xi_n=p(2n-1)\frac{\operatorname{pf}(\Omega^{(e)})}{\operatorname{pf}(\omega^{(s)})}. \tag*{(7)}

Odd case (m=n−1=2k+1m=n-1=2k+1):

fn=C~(f)pf⁡‾(ω^(s))pf⁡(ω^(s)),C~(f)=(−1)np2n−2C(n)2(2n−1),(8)f_n=\widetilde{C}^{(f)}\overline{\operatorname{pf}}(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)})\operatorname{pf}(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}),\qquad\widetilde{C}^{(f)}=\frac{(-1)^n p^{2n-2}C(n)}{2(2n-1)}, \tag*{(8)}
gn=C~(g)pf⁡‾(ω^(s))pf⁡(Ω(o)),C~(g)=(−1)np2n−1C(n).(9)g_n=\widetilde{C}^{(g)}\overline{\operatorname{pf}}(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)})\operatorname{pf}(\Omega^{(o)}),\qquad\widetilde{C}^{(g)}=(-1)^n p^{2n-1}C(n). \tag*{(9)}

Thus, for the Ernst potential:

ξn=2p(2n−1)pf⁡(Ω(o))pf⁡(ω^(s)).(10)\xi_n = 2p(2n-1)\frac{\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right)}{\operatorname{pf}\left(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}\right)}. \tag*{(10)}

In these formulas, the constant C(n)C(n) is given by the following expression:

C(n):=∏j=1n−1[−2(2j−1)]=(−1)n−1Γ(2n−1)Γ(n),(11)C(n) := \prod_{j=1}^{n-1}\left[-2(2j-1)\right] = (-1)^{n-1}\frac{\Gamma(2n-1)}{\Gamma(n)}, \tag*{(11)}

and the explicit forms of the Pfaffians in the above formulas are collected in Appendix A.

We use the above theorem in order to prove Nakamura’s conjecture, which we formulate as follows:

Theorem 2 (Nakamura’s conjecture). The Yamazaki-Hori Ernst potential is related to the τ\tau-functions of the 2D Toda model by:

ξn=−τn(Φ)τn−1(Φ′),n≥1.(12)\xi_n = -\frac{\tau_n(\Phi)}{\tau_{n-1}(\Phi')}, \qquad n \ge1. \tag*{(12)}

More precisely, setting m=n−1m=n-1, the following identities hold:

Even case (m=2km=2k):

τm(Φ′)=Nmpf⁡(ω(s)),(13)\tau_m(\Phi') = \mathcal{N}_m \operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right), \tag*{(13)}
τn(Φ)=−p(2m+1)Nmpf⁡(Ω(e)).(14)\tau_n(\Phi) = -p(2m+1)\mathcal{N}_m \operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(e)}\right). \tag*{(14)}

Odd case (m=2k+1m=2k+1):

τm(Φ′)=Nmpf⁡(ω^(s)),(15)\tau_m(\Phi') = \mathcal{N}_m \operatorname{pf}\left(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}\right), \tag*{(15)}
τn(Φ)=−2p(2m+1)Nmpf⁡(Ω(o)).(16)\tau_n(\Phi) = -2p(2m+1)\mathcal{N}_m \operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right). \tag*{(16)}

Here the normalization factor Nm\mathcal{N}_m is given by

Nm=2⌊m/2⌋pm∏j=1m(2j−1)(2j)!,N0=1,(17)\mathcal{N}_m = 2^{\lfloor m/2\rfloor}p^m\prod_{j=1}^{m}(2j-1)(2j)!, \qquad\mathcal{N}_0=1, \tag*{(17)}

where ⌊m/2⌋\lfloor m/2\rfloor denotes the integer part of m/2m/2. The two seed functions Φ\Phi and Φ′=∂ζ∂ηΦ\Phi'=\partial_\zeta\partial_\eta\Phi are given by:

Φ(x,y)=−px+iqy,(18)\Phi(x,y)=-px+iqy, \tag*{(18)}
Φ′(x,y)=−2px(x2−1)−2iqy(y2−1).(19)\Phi'(x,y)=-2px(x^2-1)-2iqy(y^2-1). \tag*{(19)}

Proof of Nakamura's conjecture

Polynomial identities and the Toda matrix

First, we consider the even case corresponding to m=n−1=2km=n-1=2k, and the polynomial fnf_n. According to Theorem 1:

fn=C(f)pf⁡(ω(s))‾pf⁡(ω(s)),C(f)=(−1)np2n−2C(n)2n−1,(20)f_n=C^{(f)}\overline{\operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right), \qquad C^{(f)}=\frac{(-1)^n p^{2n-2}C(n)}{2n-1}, \tag*{(20)}

where (see Appendix A for details):

ωij(s)=ωij−is2[Γi(x)Γj(y)−Γi(y)Γj(x)],Γk(w):=12k−1[w2k−1−w2k+1](21)\omega_{ij}^{(s)}=\omega_{ij}-\frac{\mathrm{i}s}{2}\left[\Gamma_i(x)\Gamma_j(y)-\Gamma_i(y)\Gamma_j(x)\right],\qquad\Gamma_k(w):=\frac{1}{2k-1}\left[w^{2k-1}-w^{2k+1}\right] \tag*{(21)}
ωij=12Iij(x)+s22Iij(y),Iij(z):=∫1z[Γi(w)Γj′(w)−Γi′(w)Γj(w)] dw(22)\omega_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}I_{ij}(x)+\frac{s^2}{2}I_{ij}(y),\qquad I_{ij}(z):=\int_1^z\left[\Gamma_i(w)\Gamma_j'(w)-\Gamma_i'(w)\Gamma_j(w)\right]\,\mathrm{d}w \tag*{(22)}

We now relate the polynomials Γk(z)\Gamma_k(z) to the polynomials Pn(z)P_n(z), which arise in the Toda τ\tau-function associated with the seed Φ′\Phi' and are defined by the following recurrence relation.4

Pk+1(z)=(z2−1)ddzPk(z),P0(z)=z,(23)P_{k+1}(z)=(z^2-1)\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}z}P_k(z),\qquad P_0(z)=z, \tag*{(23)}

For the seed function Φ′\Phi' (19), one finds:5

∂ηa∂ζbΦ′=−p[Pa+b+2(x)+is(−1)bPa+b+2(y)].(24)\partial_\eta^a\partial_\zeta^b\Phi'=-p\left[P_{a+b+2}(x)+\mathrm{i}s(-1)^bP_{a+b+2}(y)\right]. \tag*{(24)}

Denoting:

Uj=Pj+2(x)+isPj+2(y),(25)U_j=P_{j+2}(x)+\mathrm{i}sP_{j+2}(y), \tag*{(25)}
Vj=Pj+2(x)−isPj+2(y).(26)V_j=P_{j+2}(x)-\mathrm{i}sP_{j+2}(y). \tag*{(26)}

the τ\tau-function of the 2D Toda model can be written in the form:

τ2k(Φ′)=(−p)2kdet⁡T2k(Φ′),(27)\tau_{2k}(\Phi')=(-p)^{2k}\det\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')}, \tag*{(27)}

where the 2k×2k2k\times2k Toda matrix T2k(Φ′)\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')} has the form:

T2k(Φ′)=(U0V1U2V3⋯Um−2Vm−1U1V2U3V4⋯Um−1VmU2V3U4V5⋯UmVm+1⋮⋮⋮⋮⋱⋮⋮Um−2Vm−1UmVm+1⋯U2m−4V2m−3Um−1VmUm+1Vm+2⋯U2m−3V2m−2),m=2k.(28)\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')}= \begin{pmatrix} U_0 & V_1 & U_2 & V_3 & \cdots& U_{m-2} & V_{m-1}\\ U_1 & V_2 & U_3 & V_4 & \cdots& U_{m-1} & V_m\\ U_2 & V_3 & U_4 & V_5 & \cdots& U_m & V_{m+1}\\ \vdots& \vdots& \vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots& \vdots\\ U_{m-2} & V_{m-1} & U_m & V_{m+1} & \cdots& U_{2m-4} & V_{2m-3}\\ U_{m-1} & V_m & U_{m+1} & V_{m+2} & \cdots& U_{2m-3} & V_{2m-2} \end{pmatrix},\qquad m=2k. \tag*{(28)}

Noting that deg⁡Pj=j+1\deg P_j=j+1 and deg⁡Γj=2j+1\deg\Gamma_j=2j+1, and writing P2j−1(z)=∑ℓ=0ja2ℓ(j)z2ℓP_{2j-1}(z)=\sum_{\ell=0}^{j}a_{2\ell}^{(j)}z^{2\ell}, for j=1,…,mj=1,\ldots,m, it follows directly from the recurrence relation (23) that the two polynomial sequences are related by:

P2j(z)=∑ℓ=1jΛjℓ(m)Γℓ(z),j=1,…,m,(29)P_{2j}(z)=\sum_{\ell=1}^{j}\Lambda_{j\ell}^{(m)}\Gamma_\ell(z),\qquad j=1,\ldots,m, \tag*{(29)}
Λjℓ(m)=−2ℓ(2ℓ−1)a2ℓ(j),1≤ℓ≤j≤m.(30)\Lambda_{j\ell}^{(m)}=-2\ell(2\ell-1)a_{2\ell}^{(j)},\qquad1\leq\ell\leq j\leq m. \tag*{(30)}
∂η=(x2−1)∂x+(y2−1)∂y,\partial_\eta=(x^2-1)\partial_x+(y^2-1)\partial_y,
∂ζ=(x2−1)∂x−(y2−1)∂y.\partial_\zeta=(x^2-1)\partial_x-(y^2-1)\partial_y.

Thus, Λ(m)\Lambda^{(m)} is a lower-triangular matrix. Since a2j(j)=(2j−1)!a_{2j}^{(j)}=(2j-1)!, we find:

det⁡Λ(m)=(−1)m∏ℓ=1m(2ℓ)!(2ℓ−1)(31)\det\Lambda^{(m)}=(-1)^m\prod_{\ell=1}^{m}(2\ell)!(2\ell-1) \tag*{(31)}

With the explicit formulas relating the polynomial sequences PnP_n and Γn\Gamma_n, we can evaluate ω(s)\omega^{(s)} in terms of the polynomials PnP_n, which is the first step to compare pf⁡(ω(s))\operatorname{pf}(\omega^{(s)}) with the determinant of the matrix T2k(Φ′)T_{2k}^{(\Phi') }. Defining (cf (21)):

Iij(P)(z):=∫1z[Pi(w)Pj′(w)−Pi′(w)Pj(w)] dw(32)\mathcal{I}_{ij}^{(P)}(z):=\int_{1}^{z}\left[P_i(w)P_j'(w)-P_i'(w)P_j(w)\right]\,\mathrm{d}w \tag*{(32)}

and using the relation between P2iP_{2i} and Γj\Gamma_j (29), we find:

I2r,2s(P)(z)=∑i,j=1mΛri(m)Λsj(m)Iij(z),1≤r,s≤m.(33)\mathcal{I}_{2r,2s}^{(P)}(z)=\sum_{i,j=1}^{m}\Lambda_{ri}^{(m)}\Lambda_{sj}^{(m)}\mathcal{I}_{ij}(z),\qquad1\le r,s\le m. \tag*{(33)}

Integration by parts and the recurrence relation (23) give:

Irs(P)(z)=Pr(z)Ps(z)−Pr+1(z)Ps−1(z)−Ir+1,s−1(P)(z).(34)\mathcal{I}_{rs}^{(P)}(z)=P_r(z)P_s(z)-P_{r+1}(z)P_{s-1}(z)-\mathcal{I}_{r+1,s-1}^{(P)}(z). \tag*{(34)}

Applying repeatedly the above formula, and noting that for even s−rs-r, the iteration terminates with I(r+s)/2,(r+s)/2(P)(z)=0\mathcal{I}_{(r+s)/2,(r+s)/2}^{(P)}(z)=0, one obtains (note that the products Pr+jPs−jP_{r+j}P_{s-j} with 1≤j<(s−r)/21\le j<(s-r)/2 occur twice, while PrPsP_rP_s and P(r+s)/22P_{(r+s)/2}^{2} occur only once):

Irs(P)(z)=∑j=0s−r−1(−1)jPr+j(z)Ps−j(z),0≤r<s,s−r even.(35)\mathcal{I}_{rs}^{(P)}(z)=\sum_{j=0}^{s-r-1}(-1)^jP_{r+j}(z)P_{s-j}(z),\qquad0\le r<s,\quad s-r\ \text{even}. \tag*{(35)}

Using the above formula, and the definitions of UjU_j and VjV_j, we find:

2∑i,j=1mΛai(m)Λbj(m)ωij(s)=∑ℓ=02(b−a)−1(−1)ℓU2a−2+ℓV2b−2−ℓ,1≤a<b≤m.(36)2\sum_{i,j=1}^{m}\Lambda_{ai}^{(m)}\Lambda_{bj}^{(m)}\omega_{ij}^{(s)} =\sum_{\ell=0}^{2(b-a)-1}(-1)^\ell U_{2a-2+\ell}V_{2b-2-\ell},\qquad1\le a<b\le m. \tag*{(36)}

Extended Cusick identities

The following generalized Cusick identity was established in [9]:

Theorem 3 (Generalized Cusick identity). Let ϕr,ψr\phi_r,\psi_r, r≥1r\ge1 be arbitrary sequences, and C(ϕ,ψ)=(cab)C(\phi,\psi)=(c_{ab}) the antisymmetric matrix of order 2k2k, with entries:

cab=∑ℓ=1b−aϕa+ℓ−1ψb−ℓ,1≤a<b≤2k.(37)c_{ab}=\sum_{\ell=1}^{b-a}\phi_{a+\ell-1}\psi_{b-\ell},\qquad1\le a<b\le2k. \tag*{(37)}

The generalized Cusick identity states that:

pf⁡C(ϕ,ψ)=det⁡(ϕi+j+1)i,j=0k−1det⁡(ψi+j+1)i,j=0k−1.(38)\operatorname{pf} C(\phi,\psi)=\det\left(\phi_{i+j+1}\right)_{i,j=0}^{k-1}\det\left(\psi_{i+j+1}\right)_{i,j=0}^{k-1}. \tag*{(38)}

Setting uj=ϕj+1u_j=\phi_{j+1}, vj=ψj+1v_j=\psi_{j+1}, and shifting the summation index ℓ→ℓ+1\ell\to\ell+1, we define the antisymmetric matrix C(u,v)C(u,v) of arbitrary order mm by

C(u,v)ab:=∑ℓ=0b−a−1ua−1+ℓvb−2−ℓ,1≤a<b≤m,(39)C(u,v)_{ab}:=\sum_{\ell=0}^{b-a-1}u_{a-1+\ell}v_{b-2-\ell},\qquad1\le a<b\le m, \tag*{(39)}

with antisymmetric extension to a>ba>b. In this notation, the generalized Cusick identity becomes:

pf⁡C(u,v)=det⁡Udet⁡V,(40)\operatorname{pf}C(u,v)=\det\mathcal{U}\det\mathcal{V}, \tag*{(40)}

where Uij=ui+j\mathcal{U}_{ij}=u_{i+j} and Vij=vi+j\mathcal{V}_{ij}=v_{i+j}, for 0≤i,j<k0\le i,j<k.

We now show that the sum in (36) can be expressed as a difference of two generalized Cusick sums. To this end, we introduce four sequences:

uj=U2j,pj=V2j+1,qj=U2j+1,vj=V2j+2.(41)u_j=U_{2j},\qquad p_j=V_{2j+1},\qquad q_j=U_{2j+1},\qquad v_j=V_{2j+2}. \tag*{(41)}

Then, the equation (36) becomes:

2∑i,j=1mΛai(m)Λbj(m)ωij(s)=∑ℓ=0b−a−1(ua−1+ℓvb−2−ℓ−qa−1+ℓpb−2−ℓ),1≤a<b≤m.(42)2\sum_{i,j=1}^{m}\Lambda_{ai}^{(m)}\Lambda_{bj}^{(m)}\omega_{ij}^{(s)} =\sum_{\ell=0}^{b-a-1}\left(u_{a-1+\ell}v_{b-2-\ell}-q_{a-1+\ell}p_{b-2-\ell}\right),\qquad1\le a<b\le m. \tag*{(42)}

Using the definition of C(u,v)C(u,v), we write the formula (42) in the matrix form:6

2Λ(m)ω(s)(Λ(m))T=C(u,v)−C(q,p).(43)2\Lambda^{(m)}\omega^{(s)}\left(\Lambda^{(m)}\right)^{T}=C(u,v)-C(q,p). \tag*{(43)}

This relation motivates the following extension of Dale’s generalized Cusick identity to four arbitrary sequences.

Theorem 4 (Extended Cusick identity). Let m=2km=2k, let uj,pj,qj,vju_j,p_j,q_j,v_j, 0≤j≤m−20\le j\le m-2, be four arbitrary sequences, and let C(u,v)C(u,v) and C(q,p)C(q,p) be antisymmetric matrices of order mm, defined as above. Then:

pf⁡[C(u,v)−C(q,p)]=det⁡(UPQV),(44)\operatorname{pf}[C(u,v)-C(q,p)]=\det\begin{pmatrix}\mathcal{U}&\mathcal{P}\\\mathcal{Q}&\mathcal{V}\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(44)}

where U,P,Q,V\mathcal{U},\mathcal{P},\mathcal{Q},\mathcal{V} are k×kk\times k Hankel matrices with entries

Uij=ui+j,Pij=pi+j,Qij=qi+j,Vij=vi+j,0≤i,j<k.(45)\mathcal{U}_{ij}=u_{i+j},\qquad\mathcal{P}_{ij}=p_{i+j},\qquad\mathcal{Q}_{ij}=q_{i+j},\qquad\mathcal{V}_{ij}=v_{i+j},\qquad0\le i,j<k. \tag*{(45)}

Setting pj=qj=0p_j=q_j=0, the determinant on the right-hand side becomes block diagonal, and we recover the generalized Cusick identity of [9]. The extended Cusick identity also implies a corresponding bordered identity for odd m=2k+1m=2k+1.

Theorem 5 (Bordered extended Cusick identity). Let m=2k+1m=2k+1, let uju_j, 0≤j≤2k0\le j\le2k, and pj,qj,vjp_j,q_j,v_j, 0≤j≤2k−10\le j\le2k-1, be arbitrary sequences, and let Cm=C(u,v)−C(q,p)C_m=C(u,v)-C(q,p) be the antisymmetric matrix of order mm, defined as above. Introducing the column vector

u=(u0,u1,…,um−1)T,(46)\mathbf{u}=(u_0,u_1,\ldots,u_{m-1})^{T}, \tag*{(46)}

we have

pf⁡(Cmu−uT0)=det⁡(UPQV)(47)\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix} C_m & \mathbf{u} \\ -\mathbf{u}^{\mathsf{T}} & 0 \end{pmatrix}=\det\begin{pmatrix} \mathcal{U} & \mathcal{P} \\ \mathcal{Q} & \mathcal{V} \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(47)}

where the four Hankel blocks U,P,Q,V\mathcal{U},\mathcal{P},\mathcal{Q},\mathcal{V} have dimensions (k+1)×(k+1)(k+1)\times(k+1), (k+1)×k(k+1)\times k, k×(k+1)k\times(k+1), and k×kk\times k, respectively, with entries:

U=(ui+j)i,j=0k,P=(pi+j)0≤i≤k0≤j<k(48)\mathcal{U}=(u_{i+j})_{i,j=0}^{k},\qquad\mathcal{P}=(p_{i+j})_{\substack{0\leq i\leq k\\0\leq j<k}} \tag*{(48)}
Q=(qi+j)0≤i<k0≤j≤k,V=(vi+j)i,j=0k−1.(49)\mathcal{Q}=(q_{i+j})_{\substack{0\leq i<k\\0\leq j\leq k}},\qquad\mathcal{V}=(v_{i+j})_{i,j=0}^{k-1}. \tag*{(49)}

The proofs of both extended Cusick identities are given in Appendix B.

Nakamura’s conjecture follows from the two extended Cusick identities stated above. We consider each case corresponding to the seed functions Φ′\Phi' and Φ\Phi separately.

Proof for the seed Φ′\Phi'

Lemma 6. Let m=n−1m=n-1, and consider the Toda τ\tau-function associated with the seed Φ′\Phi'. Then.7

det⁡Tm(Φ′)={2kdet⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(ω(s)),m=2k,2kdet⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(ω^(s)),m=2k+1.(50)\det\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')}= \begin{cases} 2^k\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right), & m=2k,\\ 2^k\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}\right), & m=2k+1. \end{cases} \tag*{(50)}

where Λ(m)\Lambda^{(m)} is the lower-triangular matrix defined in (30), and ω(s)\omega^{(s)}, ω^(s)\widehat{\omega}^{(s)} are antisymmetric matrices defined in Appendix A.

Proof.

Even case (m=2km=2k). By elementary row and column permutations, the Toda matrix T2k(Φ′)\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')} (28) can be brought into the block-Hankel form:

det⁡T2k(Φ′)=det⁡(UPQV),(51)\det\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')}=\det\begin{pmatrix}\mathcal{U}&\mathcal{P}\\\mathcal{Q}&\mathcal{V}\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(51)}

where, for 0≤i,j<k0\leq i,j<k,

Uij=U2(i+j),Pij=V2(i+j)+1,Qij=U2(i+j)+1,Vij=V2(i+j)+2.(52)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{U}_{ij}&=U_{2(i+j)},&\mathcal{P}_{ij}&=V_{2(i+j)+1},\\ \mathcal{Q}_{ij}&=U_{2(i+j)+1},&\mathcal{V}_{ij}&=V_{2(i+j)+2}. \tag*{(52)} \end{aligned}

Thus, the four sequences in the extended Cusick identity are:

uj=U2j,pj=V2j+1,qj=U2j+1,vj=V2j+2.(53)u_j=U_{2j},\qquad p_j=V_{2j+1},\qquad q_j=U_{2j+1},\qquad v_j=V_{2j+2}. \tag*{(53)}

Then, applying the extended Cusick identity and using (43), we find

det⁡T2k(Φ′)=pf⁡[C(u,v)−C(q,p)]=pf⁡[2Λ(m)ω(s)(Λ(m))T]=2kdet⁡(Λ(m))pf⁡(ω(s)).(54)\det\mathcal{T}_{2k}^{(\Phi')}=\operatorname{pf}\left[C(u,v)-C(q,p)\right]=\operatorname{pf}\left[2\Lambda^{(m)}\omega^{(s)}\left(\Lambda^{(m)}\right)^{\mathsf{T}}\right]=2^k\det\left(\Lambda^{(m)}\right)\operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right). \tag*{(54)}

Odd case (m=2k+1m=2k+1). The corresponding Toda matrix has the form:

T2k+1(Φ′)=(U0V1U2⋯Um−1U1V2U3⋯Um⋮⋮⋮⋱⋮Um−1VmUm+1⋯U2m−2),m=2k+1.(55)\mathcal{T}_{2k+1}^{(\Phi')}= \begin{pmatrix} U_0&V_1&U_2&\cdots&U_{m-1}\\ U_1&V_2&U_3&\cdots&U_m\\ \vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\ddots&\vdots\\ U_{m-1}&V_m&U_{m+1}&\cdots&U_{2m-2} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad m=2k+1. \tag*{(55)}

The definitions of uu, pp, qq, vv and the relation (43) are valid for arbitrary mm, so we now use them with m=2k+1m=2k+1. Then as in the even case, by elementary row and column permutations, the Toda matrix Tm(Φ′)\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')} can be brought into the block-Hankel form. Applying the bordered extended Cusick identity, we obtain

det⁡Tm(Φ′)=det⁡(UPQV)=pf⁡(C(u,v)−C(q,p)u−uT0)(56)\det\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')}=\det\begin{pmatrix}\mathcal{U}&\mathcal{P}\\\mathcal{Q}&\mathcal{V}\end{pmatrix}=\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix}C(u,v)-C(q,p)&u\\-\mathbf{u}^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(56)}

where u=Λ(m)Γ(+)=(u0,…,um−1)T\mathbf{u}=\Lambda^{(m)}\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}=(u_0,\ldots,u_{m-1})^{\mathsf{T}}. Using (43), we find:

det⁡Tm(Φ′)=pf⁡(2Λ(m)ω(s)(Λ(m))TΛ(m)Γ(+)−(Γ(+))T(Λ(m))T0).(57)\det\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')}=\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix}2\Lambda^{(m)}\omega^{(s)}(\Lambda^{(m)})^{\mathsf{T}}&\Lambda^{(m)}\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}\\-(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}(\Lambda^{(m)})^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(57)}

Defining D=diag⁡(Λ(m),1)D=\operatorname{diag}(\Lambda^{(m)},1), we obtain:

det⁡Tm(Φ′)=pf⁡[D(2ω(s)Γ(+)−(Γ(+))T0)DT]=2kdet⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(ω(s)Γ(+)−(Γ(+))T0).(58)\det\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')}=\operatorname{pf}\left[D\begin{pmatrix}2\omega^{(s)}&\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}\\-(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix}D^{\mathsf{T}}\right]=2^{k}\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix}\omega^{(s)}&\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}\\-(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(58)}

Using the relation between ω\omega and ω(s)\omega^{(s)}:

ω=ω(s)+12[Γ(x)(Γ(+))T−Γ(+)(Γ(x))T],(59)\omega=\omega^{(s)}+\frac{1}{2}\left[\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(x)}(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}-\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(x)})^{\mathsf{T}}\right], \tag*{(59)}

and introducing the triangular matrix:

L=(Im−12Γ(x)001),det⁡L=1,(60)L=\begin{pmatrix}I_m-\frac{1}{2}\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(x)}&0\\0&1\end{pmatrix},\qquad\det L=1, \tag*{(60)}

we obtain:

ω^(s)=L(ω(s)Γ(+)−(Γ(+))T0)LT.(61)\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}=L\begin{pmatrix}\omega^{(s)}&\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}\\-(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix}L^{\mathsf{T}}. \tag*{(61)}

Since det⁡L=1\det L=1, the Pfaffian identity pf⁡(MAMT)=det⁡(M)pf⁡(A)\operatorname{pf}(MAM^{\mathsf{T}})=\det(M)\operatorname{pf}(A) gives:

pf⁡(ω^(s))=pf⁡(ω(s)Γ(+)−(Γ(+))T0).(62)\operatorname{pf}(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)})=\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix}\omega^{(s)}&\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)}\\-(\boldsymbol{\Gamma}^{(+)})^{\mathsf{T}}&0\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(62)}

Therefore,

det⁡Tm(Φ′)=2kdet⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(ω^(s)),m=2k+1.(63)\det\mathcal{T}_{m}^{(\Phi')}=2^{k}\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}),\qquad m=2k+1. \tag*{(63)}

Next, we prove analogous results for the seed Φ\Phi.

Proof for the seed Φ\Phi

Lemma 7. Let m=n−1m=n-1, and consider the Toda τ\tau-function associated with the seed Φ\Phi. Then

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)={2k(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(Ω(e)),m=2k,2k+1(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(Ω(o)),m=2k+1,(64)\det\mathcal{T}_{m+1}^{(\Phi)}= \begin{cases} 2^{k}(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(e)}\right),&m=2k,\\ 2^{k+1}(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right),&m=2k+1, \end{cases} \tag*{(64)}

where Λ(m)\Lambda^{(m)} is defined in (30), and Ω(e),Ω(o)\Omega^{(e)},\Omega^{(o)} are given in Appendix A.

Proof. Even case (m=2km=2k). For the seed Φ=−px+iqy\Phi=-px+iqy, we introduce the sequences

Aj=Pj(x)−isPj(y),Bj=Pj(x)+isPj(y).(65)A_j=P_j(x)-isP_j(y),\qquad B_j=P_j(x)+isP_j(y). \tag*{(65)}

The corresponding normalized Toda matrix has the form:

Tm+1(Φ)=(A0B1A2⋯AmA1B2A3⋯Am+1⋮⋮⋮⋱⋮AmBm+1Am+2⋯A2m),m=2k.(66)\mathcal{T}_{m+1}^{(\Phi)}= \begin{pmatrix} A_0 & B_1 & A_2 & \cdots& A_m\\ A_1 & B_2 & A_3 & \cdots& A_{m+1}\\ \vdots& \vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\ A_m & B_{m+1} & A_{m+2} & \cdots& A_{2m} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad m=2k. \tag*{(66)}

As in the denominator case, by elementary row and column permutations, the Toda matrix can be brought into block-Hankel form:

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=det⁡(UPQV),(67)\det\mathcal{T}_{m+1}^{(\Phi)} =\det\begin{pmatrix} U & P\\ Q & V \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(67)}

where

Uij=A2(i+j),Pij=B2(i+j)+1,U_{ij}=A_{2(i+j)},\qquad P_{ij}=B_{2(i+j)+1},
Qij=A2(i+j)+1,Vij=B2(i+j)+2,(68)Q_{ij}=A_{2(i+j)+1},\qquad V_{ij}=B_{2(i+j)+2}, \tag*{(68)}

with block dimensions (k+1)×(k+1)(k+1)\times(k+1), (k+1)×k(k+1)\times k, k×(k+1)k\times(k+1), and k×kk\times k, respectively. Thus, the four sequences entering the extended Cusick identity are

uj=A2j,pj=B2j+1,qj=A2j+1,vj=B2j+2.(69)u_j=A_{2j},\qquad p_j=B_{2j+1},\qquad q_j=A_{2j+1},\qquad v_j=B_{2j+2}. \tag*{(69)}

Applying the bordered extended Cusick identity, we obtain

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=pf⁡(C(u,v)−C(q,p)u−uT0),(70)\det\mathcal{T}_{m+1}^{(\Phi)} =\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix} C(u,v)-C(q,p) & \mathbf{u}\\ -\mathbf{u}^{T} & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(70)}

where u=(A0,A2,…,A2m)T\mathbf{u}=(A_0,A_2,\ldots,A_{2m})^T.

To express this Pfaffian in terms of the Ernst matrices, we first note that the same calculation leading to (36) gives:8

[C(u,v)−C(q,p)]ab=∑ℓ=02(b−a)−1(−1)ℓA2a−2+ℓB2b−2−ℓ=I2a−2,2b−2(P)(x)+s2I2a−2,2b−2(P)(y)+is[P2a−2(x)P2b−2(y)−P2a−2(y)P2b−2(x)],1≤a<b≤m+1.(71)\begin{aligned} \left[C(u,v)-C(q,p)\right]_{ab} =\sum_{\ell=0}^{2(b-a)-1}(-1)^\ell A_{2a-2+\ell}B_{2b-2-\ell} \\ &=\mathcal{I}^{(P)}_{2a-2,2b-2}(x)+s^2\mathcal{I}^{(P)}_{2a-2,2b-2}(y) +is\left[P_{2a-2}(x)P_{2b-2}(y)-P_{2a-2}(y)P_{2b-2}(x)\right], \qquad1\leq a<b\leq m+1. \tag*{(71)} \end{aligned}
∑ℓ=0d−1(−1)ℓPr+ℓ(y)Pt−ℓ(x)=∑ℓ=1d(−1)ℓPr+ℓ(x)Pt−ℓ(y).\sum_{\ell=0}^{d-1}(-1)^\ell P_{r+\ell}(y)P_{t-\ell}(x) =\sum_{\ell=1}^{d}(-1)^\ell P_{r+\ell}(x)P_{t-\ell}(y).

Thus, since dd is even, all intermediate terms cancel, leaving Pr(x)Pt(y)−Pr(y)Pt(x)P_r(x)P_t(y)-P_r(y)P_t(x). We have also used the fact that the identity (35) remains valid for r=0r=0, since Pj(1)=0P_j(1)=0 for j≥1j\geq1, and therefore the boundary terms at z=1z=1 vanish.

Note that unlike the denominator case, the polynomial sequence now begins with P0(z)=zP_0(z)=z. From the definition of Γj\Gamma_j, we have:

P0(z)=∑j=1m(2j−1)Γj(z)+(2m+1)F(z),F(z)=z2m+12m+1.(72)P_0(z)=\sum_{j=1}^{m}(2j-1)\Gamma_j(z)+(2m+1)F(z),\qquad F(z)=\frac{z^{2m+1}}{2m+1}. \tag*{(72)}

Introducing the vector

d=(1,3,…,2m−1)T,(73)\mathbf{d}=(1,3,\ldots,2m-1)^T, \tag*{(73)}

and using (29), we obtain

\begin{pmatrix} P_0\\ P_2\\ \vdots\\ P_{2m} \end{pmatrix} =M^{(m)} \begin{pmatrix} \Gamma_1\\ \vdots\\ \Gamma_m\\ F \end{pmatrix}, \qquad M^{(m)}= \begin{pmatrix} \mathbf{d}^T & 2m+1\\ \Lambda^{(m)} & \mathbf{0} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(74)}\end{pmatrix}

Expanding along the last column, we find

det⁡M(m)=(−1)m(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m).(75)\det M^{(m)}=(-1)^m(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}. \tag*{(75)}

Substituting the polynomial transformation (74) into (71), the terms involving Γi\Gamma_i and Γj\Gamma_j give:

∫1x(ΓiΓj′−Γi′Γj) dw+s2∫1y(ΓiΓj′−Γi′Γj) dw+is[Γi(x)Γj(y)−Γi(y)Γj(x)]=2ωij(−s).(76)\int_1^x(\Gamma_i\Gamma_j'-\Gamma_i'\Gamma_j)\,dw+s^2\int_1^y(\Gamma_i\Gamma_j'-\Gamma_i'\Gamma_j)\,dw+is[\Gamma_i(x)\Gamma_j(y)-\Gamma_i(y)\Gamma_j(x)] =2\omega_{ij}^{(-s)}. \tag*{(76)}

Similarly, the terms involving Γi\Gamma_i and FF, after integration by parts using F′(w)=w2mF'(w)=w^{2m} and Γi(1)=0\Gamma_i(1)=0, give:

∫1x(ΓiF′−Γi′F) dw+s2∫1y(ΓiF′−Γi′F) dw+is[Γi(x)F(y)−Γi(y)F(x)]=2[∫1xΓi(w)w2m dw+s2∫1yΓi(w)w2m dw]−γ‾βi=2ρi−γ‾βi=−2σi,(77)\begin{aligned} &\int_1^x(\Gamma_iF'-\Gamma_i'F)\,dw+s^2\int_1^y(\Gamma_iF'-\Gamma_i'F)\,dw+is[\Gamma_i(x)F(y)-\Gamma_i(y)F(x)]\\ &=2\left[\int_1^x\Gamma_i(w)w^{2m}\,dw+s^2\int_1^y\Gamma_i(w)w^{2m}\,dw\right]-\overline{\gamma}\beta_i\\ &=2\rho_i-\overline{\gamma}\beta_i=-2\sigma_i, \tag*{(77)} \end{aligned}

where the quantities ρi\rho_i, βi\beta_i, γ\gamma, and σi\sigma_i are defined in Appendix A. Thus, (71) takes the matrix form:

C(u,v)−C(q,p)=2M(m)(ω(−s)−σσT0)(M(m))T,(78)C(u,v)-C(q,p)=2M^{(m)} \begin{pmatrix} \omega^{(-s)}&-\boldsymbol{\sigma}\\ \boldsymbol{\sigma}^T&0 \end{pmatrix} (M^{(m)})^T, \tag*{(78)}

where σ=(σ1,…,σm)T\boldsymbol{\sigma}=(\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_m)^T. The polynomial transformation (74) also gives the border vector:

u=M(m)(βγ),β=(β1,…,βm)T.(79)\mathbf{u}=M^{(m)} \begin{pmatrix} \boldsymbol{\beta}\\ \gamma \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \boldsymbol{\beta}=(\beta_1,\ldots,\beta_m)^T. \tag*{(79)}

Introducing D=diag⁡(M(m),1)D=\operatorname{diag}(M^{(m)},1), we then find:

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=pf⁡[D(2ω(−s)−2σβ2σT0γ−βT−γ0)DT]=2kdet⁡M(m)pf⁡(ω(−s)−σβσT0γ−βT−γ0).(80)\det\mathcal{T}_{m+1}^{(\Phi)} =\operatorname{pf}\left[ D \begin{pmatrix} 2\omega^{(-s)}&-2\boldsymbol{\sigma}&\boldsymbol{\beta}\\ 2\boldsymbol{\sigma}^T&0&\gamma\\ -\boldsymbol{\beta}^T&-\gamma&0 \end{pmatrix} D^T \right] =2^k\det M^{(m)}\operatorname{pf} \begin{pmatrix} \omega^{(-s)}&-\boldsymbol{\sigma}&\boldsymbol{\beta}\\ \boldsymbol{\sigma}^T&0&\gamma\\ -\boldsymbol{\beta}^T&-\gamma&0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(80)}

Now, from the definitions of ω(s)\omega^{(s)} and σi\sigma_i, we have

ω(s)=ω(−s)+12[βˉβT−ββˉT],−σ=ρ−γ2βˉ.(81)\omega^{(s)}=\omega^{(-s)}+\frac{1}{2}\left[\bar{\beta}\beta^{T}-\beta\bar{\beta}^{T}\right],\qquad-\sigma=\rho-\frac{\gamma}{2}\bar{\beta}. \tag*{(81)}

Introducing the triangular matrix

L=(Im0−12βˉ010001),det⁡L=1,(82)L=\begin{pmatrix} I_m & 0 & -\frac{1}{2}\bar{\beta} \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix},\qquad\det L=1, \tag*{(82)}

we obtain

Ω(e)=L(ω(−s)−σβσT0γ−βT−γ0)LT.(83)\Omega^{(e)}=L\begin{pmatrix} \omega^{(-s)} & -\sigma& \beta\\ \sigma^{T} & 0 & \gamma\\ -\beta^{T} & -\gamma& 0 \end{pmatrix}L^{T}. \tag*{(83)}

Since det⁡L=1\det L=1, the Pfaffian is unchanged by this transformation. Using (75), we conclude that

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=2k(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(Ω(e)),m=2k.(84)\det T_{m+1}^{(\Phi)}=2^{k}(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(e)}\right),\qquad m=2k. \tag*{(84)}

Odd case (m=2k+1m=2k+1). The Toda matrix now has even order m+1=2k+2m+1=2k+2. Using the same definitions of uu, pp, qq, vv as in the even case, we can bring it into block-Hankel form, with all four blocks having size (k+1)×(k+1)(k+1)\times(k+1). Applying the extended Cusick identity and using (78), we obtain:

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=pf⁡[C(u,v)−C(q,p)]=pf⁡[2M(m)(ω(−s)−σσT0)(M(m))T]=2k+1det⁡M(m)pf⁡(ω(−s)−σσT0).(85)\begin{aligned} \det T_{m+1}^{(\Phi)}&=\operatorname{pf}[C(u,v)-C(q,p)]\\ &=\operatorname{pf}\left[2M^{(m)}\begin{pmatrix}\omega^{(-s)}&-\sigma\\ \sigma^{T}&0\end{pmatrix}(M^{(m)})^{T}\right]\\ &=2^{k+1}\det M^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix}\omega^{(-s)}&-\sigma\\ \sigma^{T}&0\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(85)} \end{aligned}

The last matrix differs from Ω(o)\Omega^{(o)} only by the sign of its final row and column, so its Pfaffian is −pf⁡(Ω(o))-\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right). Since mm is odd, (75) also gives det⁡M(m)=−(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m)\det M^{(m)}=-(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}. Hence, we obtain:

det⁡Tm+1(Φ)=2k+1(2m+1)det⁡Λ(m)pf⁡(Ω(o)),m=2k+1.(86)\det T_{m+1}^{(\Phi)}=2^{k+1}(2m+1)\det\Lambda^{(m)}\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right),\qquad m=2k+1. \tag*{(86)}

Proof of Theorem 2. Using the relation τℓ(Ψ)=(−p)ℓdet⁡Tℓ(Ψ)\tau_{\ell}(\Psi)=(-p)^{\ell}\det T_{\ell}^{(\Psi)}, the two lemmas give:

τn(Φ)τn−1(Φ′)={−p(2n−1)pf⁡(Ω(e))pf⁡(ω(s)),m=2k,−2p(2n−1)pf⁡(Ω(o))pf⁡(ω^(s)),m=2k+1.(87)\frac{\tau_n(\Phi)}{\tau_{n-1}(\Phi')}= \begin{cases} -p(2n-1)\dfrac{\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(e)}\right)}{\operatorname{pf}\left(\omega^{(s)}\right)}, & m=2k,\\ -2p(2n-1)\dfrac{\operatorname{pf}\left(\Omega^{(o)}\right)}{\operatorname{pf}\left(\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}\right)}, & m=2k+1. \end{cases} \tag*{(87)}

Comparing these expressions with Theorem 1, we obtain

τn(Φ)τn−1(Φ′)=−gnfn=−ξn,(88)\frac{\tau_n(\Phi)}{\tau_{n-1}(\Phi')}=-\frac{g_n}{f_n}=-\xi_n, \tag*{(88)}

which proves Nakamura’s conjecture.

Conclusion

We have proved Nakamura’s conjecture for the Yamazaki-Hori rational solutions of the Ernst equation for arbitrary nn. The proof establishes explicit identities between the Toda τ\tau-functions associated with the seeds Φ\Phi and Φ′\Phi' and the Pfaffians representing the corresponding Ernst solutions. These identities hold for general values of p,qp,q satisfying p2+q2=1p^2+q^2=1.

The main algebraic ingredient is an extension of the generalized Cusick identity to four arbitrary sequences. This identity expresses the Pfaffian of an antisymmetric matrix formed from convolution sums as the determinant of a block-Hankel matrix. We have also established a bordered version, needed for the odd-dimensional Toda matrices. Both identities hold independently of the Ernst equation and may be useful in establishing other determinant–Pfaffian correspondences.

An interesting question is whether the Pfaffian representations obtained in our previous work can be shown to satisfy the Ernst equation directly, without using their equivalence to the Yamazaki-Hori solutions. This would require deriving differential identities for the Pfaffians and using them to establish the bilinear equations associated with the Ernst equation.

Another question is whether other choices of the seed function Φ\Phi in the 2D Toda molecule lead to solutions of the Ernst equation. It would be interesting to identify the conditions on Φ\Phi under which such a correspondence exists.

Pfaffian forms for the polynomials fnf_n and gng_n

In this appendix, we collect the explicit formulas for the antisymmetric matrices appearing in the Pfaffian representations of the Ernst polynomials fnf_n and gng_n, obtained in our previous work [1].9

We begin with the matrices ω\omega and SS, defined by:

ωij:=12∫1x[Γi(w)Γj′(w)−Γi′(w)Γj(w)] dw+s22∫1y[Γi(w)Γj′(w)−Γi′(w)Γj(w)] dw,(89)\omega_{ij}:=\frac{1}{2}\int_1^x\left[\Gamma_i(w)\Gamma'_j(w)-\Gamma'_i(w)\Gamma_j(w)\right]\,dw+\frac{s^2}{2}\int_1^y\left[\Gamma_i(w)\Gamma'_j(w)-\Gamma'_i(w)\Gamma_j(w)\right]\,dw, \tag*{(89)}
Sij:=12Γi(x)Γj(x)+s22Γi(y)Γj(y).(90)S_{ij}:=\frac{1}{2}\Gamma_i(x)\Gamma_j(x)+\frac{s^2}{2}\Gamma_i(y)\Gamma_j(y). \tag*{(90)}

Here the polynomials Γi\Gamma_i are given by:

Γi(w):=12i−1[w2i−1−w2i+1].(91)\Gamma_i(w):=\frac{1}{2i-1}\left[w^{2i-1}-w^{2i+1}\right]. \tag*{(91)}

We further define the antisymmetric matrix ω(s)\omega^{(s)}:

ωij(s):=ωij−is Γ^ij,Γ^ij:=12[Γi(x)Γj(y)−Γi(y)Γj(x)].(92)\omega^{(s)}_{ij}:=\omega_{ij}-\mathrm{i}s\,\widehat{\Gamma}_{ij},\qquad\widehat{\Gamma}_{ij}:=\frac{1}{2}\left[\Gamma_i(x)\Gamma_j(y)-\Gamma_i(y)\Gamma_j(x)\right]. \tag*{(92)}

For odd m=n−1m=n-1, we define the bordered antisymmetric matrix:

ω^(s)=(ω11⋯ω1mΓ1(+)ω21⋯ω2mΓ2(+)⋮⋮⋱⋮ωm1⋯ωmmΓm(+)−Γ1(+)⋯−Γm(+)0).(93)\widehat{\omega}^{(s)}= \begin{pmatrix} \omega_{11} & \cdots& \omega_{1m} & \Gamma^{(+)}_1\\ \omega_{21} & \cdots& \omega_{2m} & \Gamma^{(+)}_2\\ \vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\ \omega_{m1} & \cdots& \omega_{mm} & \Gamma^{(+)}_m\\ -\Gamma^{(+)}_1 & \cdots& -\Gamma^{(+)}_m & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(93)}

where

Γj(+)(x,y):=Γj(x)+isΓj(y).(94)\Gamma_j^{(+)}(x,y) := \Gamma_j(x) + \mathrm{i}s\Gamma_j(y). \tag*{(94)}

For even m=n−1m=n-1, the corresponding (m+2)×(m+2)(m+2)\times(m+2) antisymmetric matrix entering the Pfaffian representation of gng_n is:

Ω(e)=(0ω12(s)⋯ω1m(s)ρ1β1−ω12(s)0⋯ω2m(s)ρ2β2⋮⋮⋱⋮⋮⋮−ω1m(s)−ω2m(s)⋯0ρmβm−ρ1−ρ2⋯−ρm0γ−β1−β2⋯−βm−γ0).(95)\Omega^{(e)} = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & \omega_{12}^{(s)} & \cdots& \omega_{1m}^{(s)} & \rho_1 & \beta_1 \\ -\omega_{12}^{(s)} & 0 & \cdots& \omega_{2m}^{(s)} & \rho_2 & \beta_2 \\ \vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots& \vdots& \vdots\\ -\omega_{1m}^{(s)} & -\omega_{2m}^{(s)} & \cdots& 0 & \rho_m & \beta_m \\ -\rho_1 & -\rho_2 & \cdots& -\rho_m & 0 & \gamma\\ -\beta_1 & -\beta_2 & \cdots& -\beta_m & -\gamma& 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(95)}

For odd m=n−1m=n-1, the corresponding antisymmetric matrix has the form:

Ω(o)=(0ω12(−s)⋯ω1m(−s)σ1−ω12(−s)0⋯ω2m(−s)σ2⋮⋮⋱⋮⋮−ω1m(−s)−ω2m(−s)⋯0σm−σ1−σ2⋯−σm0).(96)\Omega^{(o)} = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & \omega_{12}^{(-s)} & \cdots& \omega_{1m}^{(-s)} & \sigma_1 \\ -\omega_{12}^{(-s)} & 0 & \cdots& \omega_{2m}^{(-s)} & \sigma_2 \\ \vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots& \vdots\\ -\omega_{1m}^{(-s)} & -\omega_{2m}^{(-s)} & \cdots& 0 & \sigma_m \\ -\sigma_1 & -\sigma_2 & \cdots& -\sigma_m & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(96)}

Here the quantities βj\beta_j, ρj\rho_j, γ\gamma, and σj\sigma_j are defined by

βj=Γj(x)−isΓj(y),γ=x2m+1−isy2m+12m+1,(97)\beta_j = \Gamma_j(x) - \mathrm{i}s\Gamma_j(y), \qquad\gamma= \frac{x^{2m+1}-\mathrm{i}s y^{2m+1}}{2m+1}, \tag*{(97)}
ρj=∫1xΓj(w)w2m dw+s2∫1yΓj(w)w2m dw,(98)\rho_j = \int_1^x \Gamma_j(w)w^{2m}\,\mathrm{d}w + s^2\int_1^y \Gamma_j(w)w^{2m}\,\mathrm{d}w, \tag*{(98)}
σj=γ2βj−ρj,1≤j≤m.(99)\sigma_j = \frac{\gamma}{2}\beta_j-\rho_j,\qquad1\leq j\leq m. \tag*{(99)}

Proofs of the extended Cusick identities

Proof of Theorem 4

We prove Theorem 4 by first establishing a convenient two-vector identity. Let

fr=(fr(1)fr(2)),gr=(gr(1)gr(2)),r≥1,(100)\mathbf{f}_r = \begin{pmatrix} f_r^{(1)} \\ f_r^{(2)} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \mathbf{g}_r = \begin{pmatrix} g_r^{(1)} \\ g_r^{(2)} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad r\geq1, \tag*{(100)}

be arbitrary sequences of two-dimensional vectors, and let A=A(f,g)\mathbf{A}=\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}) be the 2n×2n2n\times2n antisymmetric matrix with entries

[A(f,g)]ij={∑s=1j−ifs+i−1⋅gj−s,i<j,0,i=j,−[A(f,g)]ji,i>j.(101)[\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g})]_{ij} = \begin{cases} \sum_{s=1}^{j-i}\mathbf{f}_{s+i-1}\cdot\mathbf{g}_{j-s}, & i<j,\\ 0, & i=j,\\ -[\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g})]_{ji}, & i>j. \end{cases} \tag*{(101)}

where

fi⋅gj=fi(1)gj(1)+fi(2)gj(2)(102)\mathbf{f}_i \cdot\mathbf{g}_j = f_i^{(1)}g_j^{(1)} + f_i^{(2)}g_j^{(2)} \tag*{(102)}

is the standard bilinear pairing. Also define

Hf(a)=(fr+s−1(a))r,s=1n,Hg(a)=(gr+s−1(a))r,s=1n,a=1,2.(103)H_{\mathbf{f}}^{(a)} = \left(f_{r+s-1}^{(a)}\right)_{r,s=1}^{n}, \qquad H_{\mathbf{g}}^{(a)} = \left(g_{r+s-1}^{(a)}\right)_{r,s=1}^{n}, \qquad a = 1,2. \tag*{(103)}

We claim that

Φ(f,g):=pf⁡A(f,g)−det⁡(Hf(1)Hg(2)−Hf(2)Hg(1))≡0.(104)\Phi(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}) := \operatorname{pf} A(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}) - \det\begin{pmatrix} H_{\mathbf{f}}^{(1)} & H_{\mathbf{g}}^{(2)} \\ -H_{\mathbf{f}}^{(2)} & H_{\mathbf{g}}^{(1)} \end{pmatrix} \equiv0. \tag*{(104)}

We prove this below by polarization and atomic parametrization. For the algebraic arguments below, let K\mathbb{K} be a field of characteristic zero. All sequences, vectors, and matrices in this appendix are understood to have entries in K\mathbb{K}. The application to the Ernst problem is obtained by taking K=C\mathbb{K} = \mathbb{C}.

Proof of the auxiliary vector identity. The proof is based on two ingredients.

First, the matrix A(f,g)A(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}) is bilinear in f\mathbf{f} and g\mathbf{g}. Consequently, pf⁡A(f,g)\operatorname{pf} A(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}) is bihomogeneous of degree (n,n)(n,n) in (f,g)(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}). The determinant in the second term of (B.5) has the same bidegree: its first nn columns are linear in f\mathbf{f}, while its last nn columns are linear in g\mathbf{g}. Thus Φ\Phi is bihomogeneous of bidegree (n,n)(n,n).

We define its full polarization by

Φ~(F(1),…,F(n);G(1),…,G(n)):=[t1⋯tns1⋯sn]Φ(∑α=1ntαF(α),∑β=1nsβG(β)),(105)\widetilde{\Phi}\left(\mathbf{F}_{(1)},\ldots,\mathbf{F}_{(n)};\mathbf{G}_{(1)},\ldots,\mathbf{G}_{(n)}\right) := [t_1\cdots t_n s_1\cdots s_n]\Phi\left(\sum_{\alpha=1}^{n} t_\alpha\mathbf{F}_{(\alpha)}, \sum_{\beta=1}^{n} s_\beta\mathbf{G}_{(\beta)}\right), \tag*{(105)}

where [t1⋯tns1⋯sn][t_1\cdots t_n s_1\cdots s_n] denotes the coefficient of the product of all the distinct parameters. The polarized form is multilinear in all of its 2n2n arguments, and

Φ~(f,…,f;g,…,g)=(n!)2Φ(f,g).(106)\widetilde{\Phi}(\mathbf{f},\ldots,\mathbf{f};\mathbf{g},\ldots,\mathbf{g}) = (n!)^2\Phi(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g}). \tag*{(106)}

Consequently, it is enough to prove that Φ~≡0\widetilde{\Phi} \equiv0.

The second ingredient is the moment atomic representation. Put m=2n−1m = 2n - 1, and choose arbitrary distinct nodes z1,…,zmz_1,\ldots,z_m. The Vandermonde matrix

V(z)=(zrk−1)k,r=1m(107)V(z) = \left(z_r^{k-1}\right)_{k,r=1}^{m} \tag*{(107)}

is invertible. Therefore every vector-valued moment sequence {fk}k=1m\{\mathbf{f}_k\}_{k=1}^{m} has an atomic representation

fk=∑r=1mprzrk−1,(108)\mathbf{f}_k = \sum_{r=1}^{m} \mathbf{p}_r z_r^{k-1}, \tag*{(108)}

with uniquely determined vector weights pr\mathbf{p}_r, for the chosen nodes. Hence the vector atoms

a(x,u):=(u,ux,…,ux2n−2),u∈K2,(109)\mathbf{a}(x,\mathbf{u}) := \left(\mathbf{u},\mathbf{u}x,\ldots,\mathbf{u}x^{2n-2}\right), \qquad\mathbf{u} \in\mathbb{K}^{2}, \tag*{(109)}

span the space of all moment sequences. Since Φ~\widetilde{\Phi} is multilinear, it is therefore enough to evaluate it when each of its arguments is one atom.

Choose atoms a(xα,uα)\mathbf{a}(x_\alpha,\mathbf{u}_\alpha), a(yβ,vβ)\mathbf{a}(y_\beta,\mathbf{v}_\beta), α,β=1,…,n\alpha,\beta=1,\ldots,n, and define

Fk(t):=∑α=1ntαuαxαk−1,Gk(s):=∑β=1nsβvβyβk−1.(110)F_k(\mathbf{t}) := \sum_{\alpha=1}^{n} t_\alpha\mathbf{u}_\alpha x_\alpha^{k-1}, \qquad G_k(\mathbf{s}) := \sum_{\beta=1}^{n} s_\beta\mathbf{v}_\beta y_\beta^{k-1}. \tag*{(110)}

It is enough to prove that Φ(F(t),G(s))\Phi(\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{t}),\mathbf{G}(\mathbf{s})) vanishes identically in the parameters tα,sβt_\alpha,s_\beta. The coefficient of t1⋯tns1⋯snt_1\cdots t_n s_1\cdots s_n will then give the desired polarized identity.

For i<ji<j, we have

[A(F(t),G(s))]ij=∑α,β=1ntαsβ(uα⋅vβ)∑r=1j−ixαr+i−2yβj−r−1=∑α,β=1ntαsβ(uα⋅vβ)xαi−1yβj−1−xαj−1yβi−1yβ−xα,(111)\begin{aligned} [\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{t}),\mathbf{G}(\mathbf{s}))]_{ij} = \sum_{\alpha,\beta=1}^{n} t_\alpha s_\beta(\mathbf{u}_\alpha\cdot\mathbf{v}_\beta) \sum_{r=1}^{j-i}x_\alpha^{r+i-2}y_\beta^{j-r-1} \\ &= \sum_{\alpha,\beta=1}^{n}t_\alpha s_\beta(\mathbf{u}_\alpha\cdot\mathbf{v}_\beta) \frac{x_\alpha^{i-1}y_\beta^{j-1}-x_\alpha^{j-1}y_\beta^{i-1}}{y_\beta-x_\alpha}, \tag*{(111)} \end{aligned}

where in the last equality we used the sum of a geometric progression.

Since the atom weights are arbitrary, we may absorb the parameters tαt_\alpha and sβs_\beta into them for the generic calculation below. After the resulting identity has been established for arbitrary weights, we restore the original parameters and extract the coefficient of t1⋯tns1⋯snt_1\cdots t_n s_1\cdots s_n. Thus, from now on, write

tαuα=(uα(1)uα(2)),sβvβ=(vβ(1)vβ(2)).(112)t_\alpha\mathbf{u}_\alpha= \begin{pmatrix} u_\alpha^{(1)}\\ u_\alpha^{(2)} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad s_\beta\mathbf{v}_\beta= \begin{pmatrix} v_\beta^{(1)}\\ v_\beta^{(2)} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(112)}

and relabel these absorbed weights again as uα\mathbf{u}_\alpha and vβ\mathbf{v}_\beta. Define the diagonal matrices

Pa:=diag⁡(u1(a),…,un(a)),Qa:=diag⁡(v1(a),…,vn(a)),a=1,2,(113)P_a:=\operatorname{diag}(u_1^{(a)},\ldots,u_n^{(a)}), \qquad Q_a:=\operatorname{diag}(v_1^{(a)},\ldots,v_n^{(a)}), \qquad a=1,2, \tag*{(113)}

as well as the Cauchy matrix

Cαβ:=1yβ−xα.(114)C_{\alpha\beta}:=\frac{1}{y_\beta-x_\alpha}. \tag*{(114)}

Then

Γαβ:=uα⋅vβyβ−xα(115)\Gamma_{\alpha\beta}:=\frac{\mathbf{u}_\alpha\cdot\mathbf{v}_\beta}{y_\beta-x_\alpha} \tag*{(115)}

can be written as

Γ=P1CQ1+P2CQ2.(116)\Gamma=P_1CQ_1+P_2CQ_2. \tag*{(116)}

Introduce the n×nn\times n Vandermonde matrices

(X)rα:=xαr−1,(Y)rβ:=yβr−1,r=1,…,n,(117)(X)_{r\alpha}:=x_\alpha^{r-1}, \qquad (Y)_{r\beta}:=y_\beta^{r-1}, \qquad r=1,\ldots,n, \tag*{(117)}

and the 2n×n2n\times n extended Vandermonde matrices

(X^)iα:=xαi−1,(Y^)iβ:=yβi−1,i=1,…,2n.(118)(\widehat{X})_{i\alpha}:=x_\alpha^{i-1}, \qquad (\widehat{Y})_{i\beta}:=y_\beta^{i-1}, \qquad i=1,\ldots,2n. \tag*{(118)}

Finally, put

W:=(X^ Y^).(119)\mathcal{W}:=(\widehat{X}\ \widehat{Y}). \tag*{(119)}

Using (B.12), we obtain

A(F,G)=WKWT,whereK:=(0Γ−ΓT0).(120)\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{F},\mathbf{G})=\mathcal{W}\mathcal{K}\mathcal{W}^{\mathsf{T}}, \qquad \text{where}\qquad \mathcal{K}:= \begin{pmatrix} 0 & \Gamma\\ -\Gamma^{\mathsf{T}} & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(120)}

Therefore, using the standard Pfaffian congruence property,

pf⁡A=det⁡Wpf⁡K=(−1)n(n−1)2det⁡Wdet⁡Γ.(121)\operatorname{pf} A = \det\mathcal{W}\operatorname{pf} K = (-1)^{\frac{n(n-1)}{2}}\det\mathcal{W}\det\Gamma. \tag*{(121)}

Let

Δ(x):=∏α<α′(xα′−xα),Δ(y):=∏β<β′(yβ′−yβ).(122)\Delta(x) := \prod_{\alpha<\alpha'}(x_{\alpha'}-x_\alpha), \qquad\Delta(y) := \prod_{\beta<\beta'}(y_{\beta'}-y_\beta). \tag*{(122)}

Since all the xx-columns precede all the yy-columns, we get

det⁡W=Δ(x)Δ(y)∏α,β=1n(yβ−xα).(123)\det\mathcal{W} = \Delta(x)\Delta(y)\prod_{\alpha,\beta=1}^{n}(y_\beta-x_\alpha). \tag*{(123)}

The Cauchy determinant formula, with our convention for CC, is

det⁡C=(−1)n(n−1)2Δ(x)Δ(y)∏α,β=1n(yβ−xα).(124)\det C = (-1)^{\frac{n(n-1)}{2}}\frac{\Delta(x)\Delta(y)}{\prod_{\alpha,\beta=1}^{n}(y_\beta-x_\alpha)}. \tag*{(124)}

For the moment, assume that P1,Q1,X,YP_1,Q_1,X,Y, and CC are invertible. Put

D:=P1−1P2,E:=Q2Q1−1.(125)D := P_1^{-1}P_2, \qquad E := Q_2Q_1^{-1}. \tag*{(125)}

Then

det⁡Γ=det⁡(P1C(1+C−1DCE)Q1)=det⁡P1det⁡Q1det⁡Cdet⁡(1+C−1DCE).(126)\det\Gamma= \det\left(P_1C(1+C^{-1}DCE)Q_1\right) = \det P_1\det Q_1\det C\det(1+C^{-1}DCE). \tag*{(126)}

Combining the last three equations gives

pf⁡A=Δ(x)2Δ(y)2det⁡P1det⁡Q1det⁡(1+C−1DCE).(127)\operatorname{pf} A = \Delta(x)^2\Delta(y)^2\det P_1\det Q_1\det(1+C^{-1}DCE). \tag*{(127)}

We now calculate the determinant in the second term of (B.5). By construction,

Hf(a)=XPaXT,Hg(a)=YQaYT.(128)H_f^{(a)} = X P_a X^{T}, \qquad H_g^{(a)} = Y Q_a Y^{T}. \tag*{(128)}

Therefore

det⁡(Hf(1)Hg(2)−Hf(2)Hg(1))=det⁡(X)2det⁡(Y)2det⁡R=Δ(x)2Δ(y)2det⁡R,(129)\det\begin{pmatrix} H_f^{(1)} & H_g^{(2)} \\ -H_f^{(2)} & H_g^{(1)} \end{pmatrix} = \det(X)^2\det(Y)^2\det R = \Delta(x)^2\Delta(y)^2\det R, \tag*{(129)}

where

R:=(P1X−1YQ2−Y−1XP2Q1).(130)R := \begin{pmatrix} P_1 & X^{-1}YQ_2 \\ -Y^{-1}XP_2 & Q_1 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(130)}

It remains to compare det⁡R\det R with the last factor in (B.28). Set

S:=Y−1X,Λ:=diag⁡(λ1,…,λn),λβ:=∏α=1n(yβ−xα),(131)S := Y^{-1}X, \qquad\Lambda:= \operatorname{diag}(\lambda_1,\ldots,\lambda_n), \qquad\lambda_\beta:= \prod_{\alpha=1}^{n}(y_\beta-x_\alpha), \tag*{(131)}

where SβγS_{\beta\gamma} are the Lagrange interpolation weights ℓβ(z)\ell_\beta(z), evaluated at z=xγz=x_\gamma

ℓβ(z):=∏δ≠βz−yδyβ−yδ,Sβγ=∏δ≠βxγ−yδyβ−yδ≡ℓβ(xγ).(132)\ell_\beta(z) := \prod_{\delta\ne\beta}\frac{z-y_\delta}{y_\beta-y_\delta}, \qquad S_{\beta\gamma} = \prod_{\delta\ne\beta}\frac{x_\gamma-y_\delta}{y_\beta-y_\delta} \equiv\ell_\beta(x_\gamma). \tag*{(132)}

By the Lagrange interpolation formula

pα(z):=∏ρ≠α(z−xρ)=∑β=1npα(yβ)ℓβ(z)≡∑β=1n∏ρ≠α(yβ−xρ)ℓβ(z).(133)p_{\alpha}(z) := \prod_{\rho\ne\alpha}(z-x_{\rho}) = \sum_{\beta=1}^{n}p_{\alpha}(y_{\beta})\ell_{\beta}(z) \equiv\sum_{\beta=1}^{n}\prod_{\rho\ne\alpha}(y_{\beta}-x_{\rho})\ell_{\beta}(z). \tag*{(133)}

By evaluating this at z=xγz=x_{\gamma}, we get the following elementary interpolation identity:

(CΛS)αγ=∑β=1nλβyβ−xαSβγ=∑β=1npα(yβ)ℓβ(xγ)=pα(xγ)(134)(C\Lambda S)_{\alpha\gamma} = \sum_{\beta=1}^{n}\frac{\lambda_{\beta}}{y_{\beta}-x_{\alpha}}S_{\beta\gamma} = \sum_{\beta=1}^{n}p_{\alpha}(y_{\beta})\ell_{\beta}(x_{\gamma}) = p_{\alpha}(x_{\gamma}) \tag*{(134)}

or

CΛS=diag⁡(∏ρ≠1(x1−xρ),…,∏ρ≠n(xn−xρ)).(135)C\Lambda S = \operatorname{diag}\left(\prod_{\rho\ne1}(x_{1}-x_{\rho}),\ldots,\prod_{\rho\ne n}(x_{n}-x_{\rho})\right). \tag*{(135)}

Since the diagonal matrix on the right-hand side of (B.36) commutes with DD, we obtain

SDS−1=Λ−1C−1DCΛ.(136)SDS^{-1} = \Lambda^{-1}C^{-1}DC\Lambda. \tag*{(136)}

Using the Schur complement of P1P_{1}, we find

det⁡R=det⁡P1det⁡(Q1+SDS−1Q2)=det⁡P1det⁡Q1det⁡(1+SDS−1E).(137)\det R = \det P_{1}\det(Q_{1}+SDS^{-1}Q_{2}) = \det P_{1}\det Q_{1}\det(1+SDS^{-1}E). \tag*{(137)}

By (B.37), and since both EE and Λ\Lambda are diagonal,

det⁡(1+SDS−1E)=det⁡(Λ−1(1+C−1DCE)Λ)=det⁡(1+C−1DCE).(138)\det(1+SDS^{-1}E) = \det\left(\Lambda^{-1}(1+C^{-1}DCE)\Lambda\right) = \det(1+C^{-1}DCE). \tag*{(138)}

Therefore

det⁡R=det⁡P1det⁡Q1det⁡(1+C−1DCE).(139)\det R = \det P_{1}\det Q_{1}\det(1+C^{-1}DCE). \tag*{(139)}

Thus (B.30) is equal to (B.28). Hence

Φ(F(t),G(s))=0(140)\Phi(F(t),G(s))=0 \tag*{(140)}

for arbitrary atomic data.

The identity was derived for generic choices for which the intermediate matrices are invertible. Since both sides are polynomial in the underlying parameters, and KK is infinite, the identity extends to all choices. Finally, extracting the coefficient of t1t2⋯tns1s2⋯snt_{1}t_{2}\cdots t_{n}s_{1}s_{2}\cdots s_{n} gives Φ~=0\widetilde{\Phi}=0 on all atomic arguments. Since the atoms span the moment space and Φ~\widetilde{\Phi} is multilinear, it vanishes identically. The diagonal relation for the polarization then gives Φ(f,g)=0\Phi(f,g)=0 for arbitrary sequences.

To recover Theorem 4, set n=kn=k and

fj=(uj−1−qj−1),gj=(vj−1pj−1),j=1,…,2k−1.(141)\mathbf{f}_{j}=\begin{pmatrix}u_{j-1}\\-q_{j-1}\end{pmatrix},\qquad\mathbf{g}_{j}=\begin{pmatrix}v_{j-1}\\p_{j-1}\end{pmatrix},\qquad j=1,\ldots,2k-1. \tag*{(141)}

Then

A(f,g)=C(u,v)−C(q,p),(142)A(\mathbf{f},\mathbf{g})=C(u,v)-C(q,p), \tag*{(142)}

while the block determinant in (B.5) is

det⁡(UPQV).(143)\det\begin{pmatrix}U&P\\Q&V\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(143)}

This proves Theorem 4. Finally, setting pj=qj=0p_j=q_j=0 and using uj=ϕj+1u_j=\phi_{j+1}, vj=ψj+1v_j=\psi_{j+1} gives Theorem 3, the generalized Cusick identity.

Proof of Theorem 5

Set

n=k+1,m=2k+1=2n−1.(144)n = k + 1,\qquad m = 2k + 1 = 2n - 1. \tag*{(144)}

Extend pp, qq, vv by zero:

p~2k=q~2k=v~2k=0,(145)\widetilde{p}_{2k} = \widetilde{q}_{2k} = \widetilde{v}_{2k} = 0, \tag*{(145)}

while p~j=pj\widetilde{p}_j = p_j, etc., for 0≤j≤2k−10 \le j \le2k - 1.

Introduce an auxiliary parameter tt and define the two-dimensional sequences required for the even theorem by

fr=(ur−1−q~r−1),gr(t)=(v~r−1+tδr,2k+1p~r−1),r=1,…,2k+1.(146)\mathbf{f}_r = \begin{pmatrix} u_{r-1}\\ -\widetilde{q}_{r-1} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \mathbf{g}_r(t) = \begin{pmatrix} \widetilde{v}_{r-1} + t\delta_{r,2k+1}\\ \widetilde{p}_{r-1} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad r = 1,\ldots,2k+1. \tag*{(146)}

The signs are chosen precisely so that

fr⋅gs(t)=ur−1v~s−1−q~r−1p~s−1+tur−1δs,2k+1.(147)\mathbf{f}_r\cdot\mathbf{g}_s(t) = u_{r-1}\widetilde{v}_{s-1} -\widetilde{q}_{r-1}\widetilde{p}_{s-1} +t u_{r-1}\delta_{s,2k+1}. \tag*{(147)}

Let A(t)\mathbf{A}(t) be the matrix in the auxiliary vector identity (B.5), with n=k+1n=k+1, constructed from these sequences. The upper-left m×mm \times m block is exactly

Cm=C(u,v)−C(q,p).(148)C_m = C(u,v) - C(q,p). \tag*{(148)}

Moreover, the parameter tt occurs only through the last moment of the first component of g\mathbf{g}. Therefore it can only affect the last column and row.

Ai+1,2k+2(t)=ci+tui,(149)A_{i+1,2k+2}(t) = c_i + t u_i, \tag*{(149)}

where

ci=∑s=12k−i(ui+sv~2k−s−q~i+sp~2k−s),i=0,…,2k,(150)c_i = \sum_{s=1}^{2k-i} \left(u_{i+s}\widetilde{v}_{2k-s} -\widetilde{q}_{i+s}\widetilde{p}_{2k-s}\right), \qquad i=0,\ldots,2k, \tag*{(150)}

where the sum is empty for i=2ki=2k, so that c2k=0c_{2k}=0. Thus

A(t)=(Cmc+tu−(c+tu)T0).(151)\mathbf{A}(t) = \begin{pmatrix} C_m & \mathbf{c}+t\mathbf{u}\\ -(\mathbf{c}+t\mathbf{u})^{T} & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(151)}

Since the Pfaffian is linear in the bordering vector,

[t]pf⁡A(t)=pf⁡(Cmu−uT0).(152)[t]\operatorname{pf}\mathbf{A}(t) = \operatorname{pf} \begin{pmatrix} C_m & \mathbf{u}\\ -\mathbf{u}^{T} & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(152)}

Applying the auxiliary vector identity (B.5) with n=k+1n=k+1, we obtain

pf⁡A(t)=det⁡(H^(u)H^(p~)H^(q~)H^(v~)+tE),(153)\operatorname{pf}\mathbf{A}(t) = \det \begin{pmatrix} \widehat{H}(u) & \widehat{H}(\widetilde{p})\\ \widehat{H}(\widetilde{q}) & \widehat{H}(\widetilde{v}) + tE \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(153)}

where, for a sequence aa,

H^(a):=(ai+j)i,j=0k.(154)\widehat{H}(a) := (a_{i+j})_{i,j=0}^{k}. \tag*{(154)}

is the (k+1)×(k+1)(k+1) \times(k+1) Hankel matrix, and EE is the (k+1)×(k+1)(k+1) \times(k+1) matrix with only its lower-right entry equal to 1. Indeed, the four blocks arise as

Hf(1)=H^(u),Hg(2)=H^(p~),−Hf(2)=H^(q~),Hg(1)=H^(v~)+tE,(155)H_f^{(1)} = \widehat{H}(u), \qquad H_g^{(2)} = \widehat{H}(\widetilde{p}), \qquad-H_f^{(2)} = \widehat{H}(\widetilde{q}), \qquad H_g^{(1)} = \widehat{H}(\widetilde{v}) + tE, \tag*{(155)}

where the sign in the third block follows from f(2)=−q~f^{(2)} = -\widetilde{q}. The parameter tt appears only in the lower-right corner of the full determinant. Deleting the last row and column leaves U\mathcal{U}, the first kk columns of H^(p~)\widehat{H}(\widetilde{p}), the first kk rows of H^(q~)\widehat{H}(\widetilde{q}), and the upper-left k×kk \times k block of H^(v~)\widehat{H}(\widetilde{v}), namely P\mathcal{P}, Q\mathcal{Q}, V\mathcal{V}, respectively. Hence:

[t]det⁡(H^(u)H^(p~)H^(q~)H^(v~)+tE)=det⁡(UPQV).(156)[t]\det\begin{pmatrix} \widehat{H}(u) & \widehat{H}(\widetilde{p}) \\ \widehat{H}(\widetilde{q}) & \widehat{H}(\widetilde{v}) + tE \end{pmatrix} = \det\begin{pmatrix} \mathcal{U} & \mathcal{P} \\ \mathcal{Q} & \mathcal{V} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(156)}

Taking the coefficient of tt in the even identity and using (B.53) and (B.57), we obtain

pf⁡(Cmu−uT0)=det⁡(UPQV).(157)\operatorname{pf}\begin{pmatrix} C_m & \mathbf{u} \\ -\mathbf{u}^{T} & 0 \end{pmatrix} = \det\begin{pmatrix} \mathcal{U} & \mathcal{P} \\ \mathcal{Q} & \mathcal{V} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(157)}

This completes the proof of Theorem 5.

References

  1. [1]A. Melikyan, A. Pinzul, Pfaffian solutions to the Ernst equation (2026). arXiv:2610.27420.arxiv.org/abs/2610.27420
  2. [2]F. J. Ernst, Complex potential formulation of the axially symmetric gravitational field problem, J. Math. Phys. 15 (9) (1974) 1409–1412. doi:10.1063/1.1666823.DOI
  3. [3]M. Yamazaki, On the Kerr–Tomimatsu–Sato family of spinning mass solutions, J. Math. Phys. 18 (12) (1977) 2502–2508. doi:10.1063/1.523213.DOI
  4. [4]M. Yamazaki, S. Hori, Generalization of the Tomimatsu-Sato solutions, Prog. Theor. Phys. 57 (2) (1977) 696–697. doi:10.1143/ptp.57.696.DOI
  5. [5]A. Nakamura, Relation between Tomimatsu-Sato black holes and semi-infinite Toda lattices, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 62 (1) (1993) 368–369. doi:10.1143/jpsj.62.368.DOI
  6. [6]T. Fukuyama, K. Kamimura, S. Yu, Toda Lattice and Tomimatsu-Sato Solutions, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 64 (9) (10 May 1995). doi:10.1143/JPSJ.64.3201.DOI
  7. [7]T. Fukuyama, K. Koizumi, Toda molecule and Tomimatsu–Sato solution–towards the complete proof of Nakamura’s conjecture, J. Phys. A Math. Theor. 44 (34) (2011) 345201. doi:10.1088/1751-8113/44/34/345201.DOI
  8. [8]T. Fukuyama, The Nakamura conjecture revisited: Toda molecules and stationary axisymmetric gravity, arXiv [nlin.SI] (14 Sep. 2026). arXiv:2609.16414, doi:10.48550/arXiv.2609.16414.DOI
  9. [9]R. Vein, P. Dale, Determinants and their applications in mathematical physics, Applied Mathematical Sciences, Springer, New York, NY, 2013.

Paper details

vlnc:W_v96vx3wp
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents