WorksPhysics and Astronomy
How Elasticity and Chiral Damping Shape Domain-Wall Creep
Abstract
Asymmetric domain-wall expansion in the creep regime provides an experimentally accessible probe of the interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (iDMI) and, in principle, chiral damping. However, severe discrepancies with complementary measurement techniques and the lack of a model describing the full experimental phenomenology of the creep of chiral domain walls, limits the application of these measurements. Here, using a symmetry decomposition of the velocity curve, we derive an analytical model describing the coupled influence of domain-wall stiffness and chiral damping in the creep regime. Their interplay generates the antisymmetric distortion that shifts the velocity minimum away from the DMI field. Applied to Co-based magnetic multilayers, the model yields iDMI values consistent with BLS and flow-regime benchmarks and identifies the reasons for the longstanding discrepancy. The model provides insights for possible strategies to measure chiral damping via creep dynamics of domain walls.
The interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (iDMI) [1, 2, 3, 4] is a key ingredient in the stabilization and dynamics of chiral magnetic textures in heavy-metal/ferromagnet multilayers with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, including homochiral domain walls [5, 6, 7, 8, 9] and skyrmions [10, 11, 12]. More recently, chiral damping has emerged as a distinct contribution to domain-wall motion, with possible implications for the mobility of magnetic textures [13, 14, 15]. The quantitative determination of both effects is therefore relevant to the fundamental understanding of chiral magnetism and to the design of future spintronic devices [16, 17, 18] [19].
Field-driven domain-wall expansion in the creep regime, in which an out-of-plane field drives the wall in the presence of an in-plane field [14] [20, 21, 22] holds promise because it couples experimental accessibility and, in principle, sensitivity to both effects [13] [23]. To date, however, creep measurements have mainly been used to determine the iDMI. In the conventional analysis, the minimum of the domain-wall velocity curve is identified with the DMI effective field, , and the DMI constant is obtained as , where is the domain-wall width parameter [20, 24–26].
Cross-laboratory comparisons have however highlighted an important discrepancy [19, 27]: Brillouin light scattering (BLS) determines iDMI through spin-wave nonreciprocity [28, 29], and its estimates agree quantitatively with those obtained from DW flow-regime measurements [30, 31]; values obtained from conventional DW creep analysis, instead, often show substantial over- or underestimates [27, 32] (see Fig. 1). This ambiguity limits both DMI extraction and the use of creep dynamics to probe chiral damping, whose quantitative experimental determination remains challenging. Domain-wall elasticity [33–35], and chiral damping [13, 14] have all been investigated as possible corrections to the conventional creep interpretation, including through numerical treatments [23, 36]. Nevertheless, an analytical description of the coupled influence of domain-wall elasticity and chiral damping is still missing.
Here, following a symmetry decomposition of the DW velocity curve [37], we derive a unified model describing the coupled action of domain-wall stiffness and chiral damping. We show why this discrepancy is specific to the creep regime and demonstrate that these contributions shift the creep-velocity minimum away from the DMI field, shedding light on the controversies associated with the conventional extraction method. [20]
We test this description on five magnetron-sputtered Pt/Co/ multilayers with different capping layers -
Figure 1. iDMI values extracted from BLS and conventional DW creep analysis for the investigated Pt/Co multilayers. The experimental data are from Ref. [27]; the creep values were obtained using the conventional model of Ref. [20]. Lines are guides to the eye.
Figure 2. Geometry of asymmetric bubble expansion, defining , , the wall-normal angle , and the internal wall angle .
Pt/Co/Pt(3), Pt/Co/Pt(1), Pt/Co/Ir(3), Pt/Co/Ir(1), and Pt/Co/Ta — and on a structurally distinct Si/SiO/TiN(10)/HfZrO(10)/Co(0.7)/Pt(6) sample, denoted HZO/Co/Pt. Growth details, structural and magnetic characterization of all samples are reported in the Suppl. Mater. [49]. Across the investigated samples, the symmetry-decomposed DW creep analysis yields iDMI values consistent with the BLS benchmarks and, where available, the DW flow benchmarks. The resulting physical picture improves DMI determination from creep measurements and provides insight to extend creep regime measurements to probe chiral damping.
Domain wall creep in the presence of domain wall stiffness and chiral damping —
We now develop an analytical framework for the combined effects of chiral damping and domain-wall elasticity on creep-regime motion. At low driving fields, the domain-wall velocity is governed by an Arrhenius law [38–40], . Here, the dimensionless exponent represents the field-dependent activation energy in units of . In the following, we adopt a semi-phenomenological approximation in which the activation-energy coefficient is controlled by the domain-wall stiffness , whereas the prefactor depends on the equilibrium wall energy . Since the stiffness introduces an angular-curvature correction to the equilibrium wall energy, its influence is amplified in the creep exponent, while its contribution to the algebraic prefactor is expected to be comparatively smaller. We therefore retain this correction in the activation barrier while neglecting it in the prefactor [22]. The domain-wall energy density is
where and represent the azimuthal angles of the DW normal and magnetization (see Fig. 2). is the Bloch wall energy, is the domain-wall width parameter, is the exchange stiffness, is the effective perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, is the saturation magnetization, is the DMI field, and is the effective magnetic thickness. represents the uniaxial magnetocrystalline anisotropy. In this approximation, we write
where is the creep scaling coefficient at , and describes the scaling of the velocity prefactor with the equilibrium domain-wall energy density [41]. We model the DW stiffness according to the description of Refs. [23, 33],
Here, . We couple this expression with the chiral damping parametrization
where labels the two wall chiralities, is the dimensionless relative chiral-damping strength, and is ordinary Gilbert damping [41, 42]. Assuming , the logarithmic velocity, up to irrelevant constants, is
To translate this coupled expression into a functional tool, we decompose the velocity curve about the field , at which the applied in-plane field compensates the DMI contribution to the wall energy [37]. The symmetric component is even and the antisymmetric component is odd about this decomposition center. Under the approximations of small in-plane-field-induced variations of the equilibrium domain-wall energy and stiffness, and retaining chiral damping up to second order ,
Eq. (5) reduces to a minimal semi-phenomenological model (see [49] for the full derivation). Combining all variables not directly related to and defining as the DW anisotropy field, we identify as the mixed Bloch-Néel region, in which the equilibrium wall magnetization rotates continuously between the two limiting configurations. The symmetric component of the velocity is governed by two parameters, and :
The antisymmetric component, under these approximations, is governed by a single parameter :
Introducing the reduced variables
and defining for compactness, where carries the dependence of the elastic creep contribution, we obtain
We can now analytically express the shift of the velocity minimum. In the mixed Bloch-Néel region, the velocity minimum is located at
While derived under specific approximations, this expression captures the phenomenology observed experimentally. First, it explicitly shows how the minimum is shifted from the compensation field whenever . The shift is controlled by the antisymmetric amplitude , which contains two contributions: the chiral-damping term , and the elastic term generated by the DMI-dependent DW stiffness in the activation exponent Eq. (11). The sign of the chiral-damping term is sample dependent and not necessarily related to the sign of DMI [15] [42]. We also highlight the field dependence of the velocity minimum [40], which in this formalism can be clearly attributed to the elastic contribution in .
Chiral damping and domain-wall elasticity in BLS and DW flow measurements
As shown above, creep domain-wall dynamics are particularly sensitive to the coupled effects of chiral damping and DW stiffness [41]. It is therefore important to assess whether the same effects bias BLS and DW flow measurements. DW stiffness is not relevant in the interpretation of BLS spectra, as the technique probes propagating spin waves rather than domain-wall motion [43, 44]. The Stokes/anti-Stokes peak positions and linewidths nevertheless contain signatures of both the iDMI and chiral damping. As discussed by Kim et al. [45], the iDMI produces a nonreciprocal frequency shift and, through the frequency dependence of ordinary Gilbert damping, also contributes to the linewidth asymmetry. Chiral damping, instead, introduces an additional odd-in-wave-vector contribution to the linewidth asymmetry. Defining where and represent the Stokes and Anti-Stokes peak frequencies [Fig. 3(i)], the DMI constant is obtained as , where is the spin-wave wave vector and is the gyromagnetic ratio in frequency units, for the sign convention used here. Defining the measured linewidth sum and difference [Fig. 3(i)], we can isolate the chiral-damping contribution via
Figure 3. i) Representative BLS spectrum (sample Pt/Co/Ir(1)) showing both the Stokes/anti-Stokes frequencies , used to extract , and the peak-widths . ii) relative chiral damping contributions obtained from (left axis) and DMI values measured from BLS spectra (right axis).
where [49]. Here, denotes the chiral contribution to the damping. The resulting chiral-damping contributions for our sample series are shown in Fig. 3(ii). Within the Pt/Co/X series, the sign and magnitude of the linewidth asymmetry broadly track those of . This suggests a sample-dependent correlation rather than a general proportionality: DMI and chiral damping correspond to distinct energetic and dissipative responses and can vary independently [45], as illustrated here by the weak linewidth asymmetry of sample HZO/Co/Pt despite its sizable DMI.
DW flow measurements – The domain-wall stiffness correction governing the creep activation barrier does not enter the flow regime, where the motion is no longer controlled by thermally activated depinning [46, 47]. In the strong-DMI limit, the Walker-velocity plateau provides a direct estimate of the DMI strength [48],
Since Eq. (15) contains no damping parameter at leading order, this estimate is insensitive to chiral damping within the present approximation [41, 42]. A second DW flow estimate of is obtained from the minimum of the precessional-flow velocity as a function of [30]. Chiral damping weakly breaks the symmetry of this velocity curve. Expanding the average drift velocity [30, 31] to first order in yields the following field corresponding to the velocity minimum
The derivation and comparison with the full numerical minimum are given in the Supplementary material [49]. Equation (16) shows that the displacement is suppressed by . For the parameters of the investigated samples, the calculated shift is of the order of 1 mT and is comparable to the experimental resolution of the in-plane-field coils. To summarize, domain-wall elasticity does not enter the flow physics, the Walker velocity is damping independent to leading order, and the chiral-damping-induced displacement of the drift-velocity minimum is experimentally negligible. We conclude that DW flow measurements are expected to agree with BLS, providing a reference for the present analysis of iDMI strength [48].
Experimental interpretation – We now apply the symmetry-decomposed DW creep model of Eqs. (6)–(7) to the samples introduced above. We test whether the model yields iDMI values consistent with BLS and DW flow measurements and whether the fitted antisymmetric response helps identify the physical origin of the discrepancies found with conventional DW creep analysis.
The symmetry-decomposed estimates are obtained by fitting each measured as
where come from Eqs. (6)–(7). We see how is the symmetry axis of , while displaces the velocity minimum from this center. In Fig. 4(i), The blue circles represent BLS measurements, the green squares are the DW flow estimate extracted from the Walker-velocity plateau using Eq. (15), the red triangles are the conventional DW creep estimate [20], and the black stars are the symmetry-decomposed DW creep estimate [Eq. (17)]. We immediately notice how the symmetry-decomposed DMI estimates agree with independent BLS measurements and, where available, DW flow estimates. The conventional DW creep estimates, on the other hand, show substantial discrepancies. An in depth discussion of the error estimation of for each sample as well as the fitted values of and are reported in [49]. We can now discuss some representative cases: sample Pt/Co/Pt(3) [Fig. 4(iii)] has a small antisymmetric component and a symmetric part centered close to zero, with a weakly biased conventional DW creep estimate. Sample Pt/Co/Ta [Fig. 4(iv)] has a large antisymmetric component and a symmetric part centered at large , with a large displacement of the minimum from the symmetry axis. Sample HZO/Co/Pt [Fig. 4(v)] combines a small antisymmetric component with a symmetric part centered at large , yet retains a finite discrepancy between the conventional DW creep and BLS estimates [inset of Fig. 4(v)]. The inverted sign of in this sample follows from the inverted layer stacking: Pt is on top of Co, in contrast to the Pt/Co/ series.
Figure 4. i) iDMI constant values measured with different techniques. No Flow comparison was possible for sample HZO/Co/Pt. ii) Normalized log of the velocity in the asymmetric bubble expansion on sample Pt/Co/Ta performed at different OOP fields ranging from mT to 50 mT. A vertical offset is applied to improve clarity. The inset on the top shows the location of the minimum as a function of the applied OOP field . Representative velocity decompositions according to Eqs. (6)–(7) for samples iii) Pt/Co/Pt(3), iv) Pt/Co/Ta, and v) HZO/Co/Pt. The arrows identify the magnetization directions of the two domains and the intervening DW. The blue dashed line represents the symmetric part (6) of the curve, while the orange dashed line represents its antisymmetric component (7). The shaded area represents the mixed Bloch-Néel regime.
Comparing these decompositions with the BLS spectra provides further insights. As shown in Fig. 3(i), the spectra provide both the Stokes/anti-Stokes frequency shift used to extract DMI and the relative linewidth asymmetry , which we associate with chiral damping [45, 49] via Eq. (14). Across the Pt/Co/ series [Fig. 3(ii)], the largest linewidth asymmetries occur in the samples where the discrepancy between conventional DW creep analysis and BLS is largest. However, sample HZO/Co/Pt in Fig. 4(v) shows that this correspondence is not one-to-one: a sizable minimum displacement persists at large
DMI even when the BLS chiral damping signature is weak [Fig. 3(ii)], consistent with an elastic contribution to the asymmetry . Its discrepancy is nevertheless smaller than that of Pt/Co/Ta, but accounting for the asymmetric part yields a DMI value closer to the BLS benchmark. Combining these observations, we conclude that elastic and chiral damping contributions mix with sample-dependent weights, obscuring the origin of the discrepancy in the full creep velocity curve.
We emphasize, in fact, how the magnitude of the antisymmetric component alone cannot establish the relative roles of DW elasticity and chiral damping. At a single , the fit determines the net of Eq. (11), but does not separate its elastic and dissipative contributions. Such a separation would require extracting from velocity curves measured over a range of , since the elastic term varies through .
The different dependencies of elasticity and chiral damping in (see Eq. (11)) provide a way to test this interpretation. Fig. 4(ii) shows that the conventional DW creep minimum is not a fixed material observable. In sample Pt/Co/Ta, the normalized DW creep curves , measured over OOP fields spanning – mT (all values below the depinning field for sample Pt/Co/Ta, mT [49]), display a systematic displacement of with the out-of-plane driving field. This trend, summarized in the inset, is consistent with Eq. (13): changing modifies the activation-barrier contribution through , and therefore changes the relative weight of the elastic term in the shift of the velocity minimum.
Conclusion - In this work, we analyzed how domain-wall elasticity and chiral damping collectively affect the creep dynamics of chiral domain walls. The derived model shows that the antisymmetric component responsible for shifting the domain-wall creep-velocity minimum away from the DMI field arises from a nontrivial interplay of these contributions. Moreover, because the domain-wall stiffness contribution depends on the out-of-plane driving field, the position of this minimum can vary with the measurement conditions rather than representing an intrinsic material parameter. Fits to velocity curves measured in a series of Pt/Co samples with different overlayers and growth procedures yield DMI values consistent with BLS and the available DW flow benchmarks, whose iDMI signatures are not affected by the same interplay between elasticity and chiral damping. With additional measurement of the dependence of the component of the velocity curves (see Eq. (11)), creep measurements could also serve as a probe of chiral damping in magnetic thin films, providing a basis for future quantitative comparisons with BLS.
Acknowledgments - We acknowledge R. Lavrijsen for the fruitful discussions. This project is supported by the European Union (EU) and the Italian ministry of University and Research (MUR) under the grant PRIN 2022 “Metrology for spintronics: A machine learning approach for the reliable determination of the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (MetroSpin)”. Project code: 2022SA-YARY. Yasser Shokr gratefully acknowledges financial support from TÜBİTAK under grant number 124C509, which supported his work. This work was supported by the France 2030 government plan managed by the Agence Nationale de la Recherche (project PEPR SPIN CHIREX ANR-22-EXSP-0002). This work was supported in part by the European Metrology Programme for Innovation and Research (EMPIR) Programme co-financed by the Participating States under Project 17FUN08-TOPS.
Supplementary Material: How Elasticity and Chiral Damping Shape Domain-Wall Creep
A. Di Pietro; A. Magni; S. Pizzini; G. Gandini; F. Dörr; Y. Shokr; M. Erkovan; G. Durin; S. Tacchi; M. Madami; G. Carlotti; E. Darwin; A. J. Huxtable; C. Rinaldi; C. H. Marrows; B. J. Hickey; V. Puliafito; M. Kuepferling
Supplementary.pdf
Sample Preparation and Magnetic Characterization
Previously characterized Co-based samples
Samples a1-a5 are ultrathin Co-based heterostructures previously prepared and characterized in Ref. [1]. All samples contain a nominally -nm-thick Co layer deposited on a common underlayer, while the material and thickness of the upper interface were varied. The nominal layer sequences, listed from bottom to top and with all thicknesses expressed in nanometers, are reported in Table I. The complete fabrication and initial characterization were reported previously in Ref. [1]; here we summarize only the information required for the analysis presented in this work.
| Sample ID | Layer structure |
| a1 | Ta(5)/Pt(3)/Co(0.8)/Pt(3)/Ta(3) |
| a2 | Ta(5)/Pt(3)/Co(0.8)/Pt(1)/Ta(3) |
| a3 | Ta(5)/Pt(3)/Co(0.8)/Ir(3)/Ta(3) |
| a4 | Ta(5)/Pt(3)/Co(0.8)/Ir(1)/Ta(3) |
| a5 | Ta(5)/Pt(3)/Co(0.8)/Ta(3) |
| a6 | HfZrO(10)/Co(0.7)/Pt(6.0) |
Table I. Layer structures of the investigated samples. Layer thicknesses are given in nanometers.
HZO sample
The a6 sample consists of an stack fabricated at the Fraunhofer Institute Dresden and characterized at the Politecnico di Milano. Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) was used for TiN and (HZO), while in-situ Physical Vapour Deposition (PVD) was used for the metallic layers (Co/Pt).
Brillouin Light Scattering Measurements
DMI evaluation
Independent measurements of the interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction were performed by Brillouin light scattering on samples taken from the same wafers as those used for the domain-wall measurements.
In a typical BLS experiment, a monochromatic laser beam is focused onto the sample surface, and the backscattered light is collected by the same objective and frequency analyzed by a high-resolution spectrometer. BLS measurements were performed in the Damon–Eshbach (DE) geometry by applying an external magnetic field , sufficiently large to magnetize the ferromagnetic film in-plane, and sweeping the spin-wave wave vector perpendicular to the magnetization direction (Fig. 1). During the BLS scattering process, magnons can be either created (Stokes process) or annihilated (anti-Stokes process), resulting in a redshift or blueshift of the scattered light relative to the incident beam. In wave-vector space, Stokes and anti-Stokes processes correspond to magnons with opposite wave vectors. In the presence of DMI, the frequency difference between DE modes propagating in opposite direction can be written as:
where is the in-plane spin-wave wave vector and is the gyromagnetic ratio. The sign of was assigned using the field, wave-vector, and Stokes/anti-Stokes conventions described below. The BLS measurements probe an area with a lateral dimension of approximately 10-40 and spin waves with wavelengths of the order of 0.5 . The technique therefore provides a spatially averaged measurement that is complementary to domain-wall creep, which is particularly sensitive to disorder and pinning on nanometer length scales.
Extraction of chiral damping from the BLS linewidths
The Stokes and anti-Stokes components of each Brillouin-light-scattering spectrum were fitted independently with Lorentzian line shapes. Their linewidths, denoted by and , characterize the dissipation of counterpropagating spin waves. Following Kim et al. [5], the linewidths for the field, magnetization, and wave-vector convention adopted here can be
| Sample ID | (MA/m) | (pJ/m) | (nm) | (MJ/m) |
| a1 | b | b | b | b |
| a2 | b | b | b | b |
| a3 | b | a | a | b |
| a4 | b | a | a | b |
| a5 | b | a | a | b |
| a6 | 20 \pm 55.4 \pm 0.9 | $0.69 \pm 0.07 |
Table II. Saturation magnetization , Exchange stiffness , Domain wall (DW) width parameter , effective anisotropy for the full sample series of Table I.
written as
where is the common wave-vector-even linewidth prefactor, is the ordinary Gilbert-damping coefficient, and is its wave-vector-odd contribution. The DMI frequency contribution is determined from
We define the sum and difference of the measured linewidths as
Equation (2) then gives

Figure 1 (PDF p. 13). Schematic diagram of the BLS interaction setup. The bottom panel shows a typical BLS spectrum in the absence of iDMI (dashed line) and with iDMI (solid line) for negative (left) and positive (right) values of , respectively. Here denotes the incident light wave numbers, while and are the applied in-plane field and magnetization, respectively.
Eliminating the common prefactor yields the relative chiral-damping contribution directly:
This expression removes the DMI-induced contribution.
Flow-Regime Characterization
At sufficiently large driving fields, domain-wall motion is no longer governed by the thermally activated energy barriers characteristic of the creep regime [6]. The dynamics of chiral domain walls can instead be described within the two-dimensional framework developed for chiral domain walls [2]. Flow-regime measurements therefore provide a reference determination of the DMI that is substantially less sensitive to the pinning and elasticity effects that complicate the interpretation of asymmetric bubble expansion in the creep regime (see Main text).
| Sample | |||||
| (GHz) | (GHz) | (GHz) | (-) | (%) | |
| a1 | |||||
| a2 | |||||
| a3 | |||||
| a4 | |||||
| a5 | |||||
| a6 |
Table III. Stokes () and anti-Stokes linewidths (), fitted DMI frequency splitting , normalized frequency asymmetry and extracted relative chiral damping .
Figure 2 (PDF p. 14). (i) Stokes and anti-Stokes BLS linewidths, and , for samples a1-a5 and a6. (ii) Relative chiral-damping contribution , obtained after removing the DMI-induced frequency contribution from the measured linewidth asymmetry according to Eq. (6).
Flow-regime measurements were performed on all Co-base samples described in § 3 A (i.e. samples a1-a5). For each sample, two complementary measurements were carried out. First, the DW velocity was measured as a function of the out-of-plane field in order to identify the characteristic Walker or high-velocity plateau regime. From the full velocity measurements (see Fig. 3), the depinning fields were extracted according to the procedure detailed in Ref.[7]. Second, the domain-wall velocity was measured as a function of the in-plane field at a fixed out-of-plane driving field within the flow regime.
DMI constant from the Walker/plateau velocity
A first and independent estimate of the DMI strength was obtained from the OOP field dependence of the domain-wall velocity plateaus. In systems with sufficiently strong DMI, the conventional velocity drop expected immediately above the Walker field is replaced by an extended high-velocity saturation field region. The characteristic Walker or plateau velocity is related to the DMI constant through [2, 8]
where is the characteristic Walker velocity, is the gyromagnetic ratio, is the interfacial DMI energy density, and is the saturation magnetization.
The domain-wall velocity was measured as a function of for every sample in the a1-a5 series, allowing the corresponding characteristic velocity to be determined. The complete set of measurements is shown in Fig. 3. The DMI constants obtained using Eq. (7) are listed in Table IV.
| Sample | |||||
| (mT) | (mT) | (mT) | (mJ/m) | (pJ/m) | |
| 40 | n.o. | n.o. | |||
| 40 | n.o. | n.o. | |||
| 50 | |||||
| 50 | |||||
| 100 | |||||
| n.m. | n.m. | n.m. | n.m. | n.m. |
Table IV. Applied OOP field , DMI field , depinning field , DMI constant , and exchange stiffness obtained from flow-regime domain-wall velocity measurements. The DMI field is determined from the compensation minimum in the in-plane-field-dependent velocity. When a Walker or high-velocity plateau is observed, the DMI constant is obtained from Eq. (7), and the exchange stiffness is subsequently calculated using Eq. (12). A relative uncertainty of 10% is assigned to the graphically extracted values of and . The uncertainty in additionally includes the propagated uncertainties in and (see Table I). No Walker plateau was observed for samples and , preventing the extraction of and by this procedure. No flow-regime measurements were performed on the sample. Here, n.o. denotes “not observed” and n.m. denotes “not measured”.
The DMI constants obtained from the flow-regime velocity measurements are reported in Table IV and compared with the independently determined BLS values in Table VI. The general agreement between the two techniques supports the DMI values obtained in the creep-regime analysis presented in the main text.
| Sample | [1] | |||
| (mJ/m) | (mJ/m) | (mJ/m) | (mJ/m) | |
| a1 | 0.084 0.005 | n.o. | 0.043 0.005 | 0.060 0.008 |
| a2 | 0.170 0.006 | n.o. | 0.022 0.004 | 0.05 0.02 |
| a3 | ||||
| a4 | ||||
| a5 | ||||
| a6 | 0.8 0.1 | n.m. | 0.5 0.1 | 0.7 0.2 |
Table VI. DMI values obtained from BLS (), Walker-field (), conventional-creep [18] () and new-creep analyses ().
Creep characterization of the a6 sample
We were not able to measure the a6 sample up to the depinning regime as the same setup used for samples a1-a5 was unavailable. To check the validity of the creep regime, we performed low field bubble expansion measurements to confirm the linear scaling of [9]
The results are shown in Fig. 4.
Figure 3 (PDF p. 16). Out-of-plane-field-dependent domain-wall dynamics the samples investigated in this work. (a) Domain-wall velocity as a function of . The characteristic Walker or high-velocity plateau value is used to determine the DMI constant through Eq. (7). (b) Corresponding creep-law representation, versus . (c) Depinning fields extracted from the full creep-to-depinning [7] fitting procedure for each sample.
DMI field from in-plane-field compensation
For each sample, asymmetric bubble expansion was measured as a function of the applied in-plane field , while maintaining the out-of-plane driving field within the flow regime (see Table IV). The velocities of the up-down and down-up portions of the expanding bubble were evaluated independently. The velocity curves exhibit a minimum near the compensation condition at which the applied in-plane field balances the DMI effective field [2, 8, 10],
Figure 4 (PDF p. 17). Out-of-plane-field-dependent domain-wall dynamics the a6 sample. The dashed line represents the linear fit of Eq. (8)
The flow-regime asymmetric bubble-expansion measurements for all samples are shown in Figure 5. The recorded depinning fields for the a1-a5 samples and are reported in Table IV alongside the recorded values of the effective DMI field .
Figure 5. Domain-wall velocity measured as a function of the in-plane field in the flow regime for samples –. For each sample, the velocities of the up-down (u/d) and down-up (d/u) portions of the expanding bubble domain are shown separately. The position of the velocity minimum identifies the compensation condition [10].
Exchange-stiffness consistency check
The two flow-regime measurements described above provide complementary information. The in-plane-field-dependent asymmetric bubble expansion determines the DMI effective field , whereas the out-of-plane-field-dependent velocity provides an independent estimate of the DMI energy density . With the sign convention adopted in this work, the DMI constant and the corresponding effective field are related by
where
is the domain-wall-width parameter. Combining Eqs. (10) and (11) gives
The extraction of is not the primary purpose of the flow measurements. Nevertheless, Eq. (12) provides an independent consistency check on the material parameters entering the creep-regime calculations. This is particularly useful in ultrathin multilayers, where direct measurements of the exchange stiffness are experimentally challenging. Conventional approaches determine the exchange stiffness from the temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization, using Bloch-law or related spin-wave analyses of [11, 12], or from the exchange contribution to spin-wave spectra measured by ferromagnetic resonance, perpendicular standing spin-wave spectroscopy, or Brillouin light scattering [4, 13]. In ultrathin multilayers, however, these methods can be affected by interface anisotropy, magnetic dead layers, proximity-induced magnetic moments, finite-size effects, and uncertain exchange boundary conditions. Applying Eq. (12) to the samples of the a1-a5 series provides the exchange-stiffness estimates reported in Table IV.
Effect of chiral damping in the precessional regime
We consider the one-dimensional precessional dynamics with an angle-dependent damping
The deviation from the DMI compensation field is defined as
so that the compensation point corresponds to . The internal torque entering the - equations is written as
The cycle-averaged drift velocity is
where
and
To perform the asymptotic expansion, we introduce the dimensionless parameters
so that
Multiplying the denominator integral by , we define , giving
The integrands are expanded simultaneously in the small parameters , and . After integration over one full precessional cycle, all terms linear in vanish by symmetry, yielding
and
Series division then gives
The position of the extremum is obtained from
Differentiating the expanded velocity gives
which gives
Since the numerator and denominator have been calculated only up to second order in , their ratio must be consistently re-expanded to the same order. This yields
Finally, using
the displacement of the minimum from the DMI compensation field is
For , this simplifies to the expressions used in the main text (Eq. (17))
In Figure 6 we report both the minimum obtained numerically from Eq. (16) and the analytical estimate of Eq. (49).
Figure 6. Difference between the minimum of the domain-wall velocity in the flow regime and the DMI effective field as computed via the full numerical minimum of Eq. (16) and the analytical estimate Eq. (49). The magnetic parameters used in the calculation are from the Pt/Co/X series. We set Gilbert damping and mT for all samples. The selected field ensures correspondence with the precessional flow regime in all samples. See Table IV for the depinning field analysis of the Pt/Co/X series
Derivation of the Three-Amplitude Model
In this section, we derive the symmetry-decomposed model used in the main text. We start from a creep-velocity Ansatz of the form
Here, is a field-independent attempt-frequency prefactor, is the equilibrium domain-wall energy density, and is the domain-wall stiffness in the long-wavelength limit [14, 15].
The quantity is the creep scaling parameter at , whereas is an effective exponent describing the dependence of the velocity prefactor on the equilibrium wall energy [15]. It should not be confused with the reduced in-plane field introduced below. Taking the natural logarithm of the velocity normalized at gives
For compactness, we define the relative variations
Equation (52) can then be expressed as
Considering the experimentally accessible IP field ranges is asymmetric bubble domain expansions ( mT) we assume small in-plane-field-induced variations,
Since direct evaluation of , accounting for both mixed and saturated zero-field configurations, shows that the first-order fourth-root expansion is accurate to better than 0.3% for samples a2–a5 over their respective experimental field ranges. Sample a1 provides the most restrictive case, with a maximum error of approximately 3.6 %. With the mentioned assumption, we obtain
where
To retain the correct normalizations of the two energy-dependent terms, we define
where
is the Bloch-wall energy density. Equation (56) then becomes
The two reference values and are generally different: the prefactor contribution is normalized by the equilibrium wall energy at , whereas the activation-barrier contribution is normalized by the stiffness at . We introduce the dimensionless quantities
In terms of these quantities, the domain-wall energy density is
For notational compactness, we introduce
The reference axis for all the subsequent symmetry decompositions of the velocity curve is therefore , while the mixed Bloch-Néel region corresponds to
For the right-hand side of the expanding bubble, we set . Minimizing Eq. (62) with respect to gives
The corresponding equilibrium wall energy is
It is therefore symmetric around the compensation axis:
Consequently, the equilibrium-energy contribution to the velocity prefactor contributes only to the symmetric part of the creep curve. Using Eq. (51), the symmetric part of the stiffness is
whereas its antisymmetric part is
The normalization point corresponds to . The normalization constants are therefore obtained by evaluating the full equilibrium energy and stiffness at this point:
Explicitly,
and
The effective damping is written as
where labels the two domain-wall chiralities and is the relative chiral-damping strength [16, 17]. Expanding the logarithmic damping contribution to second order in gives
The first-order term is antisymmetric in , whereas the second-order term is symmetric. Since is a convention-dependent chirality label, we absorb the minus sign in the linear term into the definition of from this point onward. With the convention used in the main text, the linear contribution to the antisymmetric amplitude is therefore written as . Collecting all symmetric contributions, and removing one common field-independent offset, symmetric part of the function can be written as
The antisymmetric part is
The three amplitudes appearing in Eqs. (74) and (75) are
Thus, has units of , is dimensionless, and has units of . Dimensionless versions of the amplitudes can be derived by multiplying the values obtained from the fit by the DW anisotropy field , , . A complete set of the dimensionless fitting amplitudes is reported in Table V. Equations (74) and (75) define the symmetric and antisymmetric shape functions about the compensation axis , with their vertical origin chosen such that both shape functions vanish at . No independent vertical-offset parameter is introduced in the fit.
| Sample | |||||||
| (mT) | (−) | (−) | (−) | (−) | (mT) | (mT) | (mT) |
| 12.6 | |||||||
| 11.2 | |||||||
| 10.5 | |||||||
| 12.4 | |||||||
| 35 | |||||||
| 20 | n.m. |
Table V. Fitting parameters obtained from the three-amplitude creep model.
The experimental and calculated velocity curves are instead normalized at . Defining the total symmetry-centered shape as
the function compared with the normalized experimental velocity is
Indeed, at the experimental normalization point , the shifted field is , and therefore
The term is a single parameter-dependent constant evaluated at the normalization point. It is recalculated for each trial set of fitting parameters, but it does not constitute an additional fit parameter. In particular, it does not modify the amplitudes , , or : it only fixes the vertical origin of the complete model. Since a field-independent constant is symmetric under the transformation , the strict symmetry decomposition of the normalized curve may equivalently be written as
Thus, the normalization affects only the constant level of the symmetric component. It does not alter the symmetric curvature , the high-field slope , the antisymmetric amplitude , or the position of the velocity minimum. In the mixed Bloch-Néel region, the field-dependent part of the velocity is
The apparent minimum is therefore located at
Equation (85) applies provided that the stationary point remains inside the mixed Bloch-Néel region and is a minimum:
Normalization regimes
When the normalization point lies in either saturated Néel branch, , one has
For the positive saturated branch, , this reduces to . The corresponding coefficients are
If instead the normalization point lies inside the mixed Bloch-Néel region, , then
The coefficients become
Additional fits and full dataset
The complete three-amplitude fits for all investigated samples are shown in Figure 7, while the corresponding fitting parameters are summarized in Table V. The parameter is treated as an effective crossover field delimiting the central mixed Bloch-Néel region, rather than as a direct measurement of the microscopic domain-wall anisotropy field. Its extraction is most reliable when the experimental range samples both crossover boundaries, , together with sufficient data in the outer branches. When one or both boundaries lie outside the accessible field range, becomes correlated with and the fitted amplitudes and is consequently more sensitive to the imposed bounds. In these cases, independently calculated magnetic parameters provide a useful physical constraint, but the resulting DMI field should be interpreted in light of the limited transition coverage.
Figure 7. Complete sample series fits with the three amplitude model of Eqs. (6-7) performed on the normalized velocity . Panels i)-v) show the fits for samples a1-a5 while panel vi) shows the fit of sample a6. The red line represent the full fitted curve, while the blue and orange dashed lines represent the symmetric and antisymmetric components respectively. The vertical dashed line represents the fitted field reported in Table. Table V. The shaded region displays the mixed Bloch-Néel transition region.
A useful check for the model validity is provided by comparing the DMI values discrepancy and the predicted shift of Eq. (11) in the main text. As can be seen in Figure 8, there is a clear correlation between the discrepancy of the DMI values (see Table. Table VI) and the factor which quantifies the displacement of the DMI field from the velocity curve minimum.
Figure 8. Comparison of the DMI discrepancy between BLS and conventional creep-regime measurements (left axis) with the fitted shift scale (right axis). Here, denotes the crossover field between mixed Bloch–Néel and saturated Néel domain-wall configurations. Error bars represent propagated uncertainties; lines are guides to the eye.
Smoothing procedure and bootstrap uncertainty
The fitting procedure used to extract from the creep-regime velocity curves is based on the three-amplitude model derived above. In this model the logarithmic velocity is written as the sum of a symmetric and an antisymmetric contribution with respect to the shifted
TABLE V: Fitting parameters obtained from the three-amplitude creep model. We report the applied bubble expansion fields , the dimensionless amplitudes , the fitted crossover field , and the fitted DMI effective field . The uncertainties in and include the propagated uncertainty in , assuming the fitted quantities are statistically independent. We also include the effective DMI field measured in the flow regime (see III B) for comparison.
field coordinate
The ideal analytical form contains piecewise branches separated by the boundaries
which delimit the mixed Bloch-Néel region. While this piecewise form is useful for identifying the physical origin of the different contributions, the sharp transition at the boundaries can make numerical error estimation unstable. In particular, small changes of the fitting parameters can move experimental points across the boundary between branches, producing a non-smooth local optimization landscape. To avoid this purely numerical instability, the antisymmetric contribution was regularized by replacing the sharp transition between the central linear branch and the saturated outer branches with a smooth interpolation. The unsmoothed form is
In the numerical implementation, the three branches were blended using smooth switching functions of the form
where is a fixed smoothing width. The smoothed antisymmetric contribution can then be written schematically as
The smoothing width was kept small compared with the field scale over which the velocity varies and was not treated as a free fitting parameter. Its role is only to regularize the branch boundaries for numerical minimization and uncertainty estimation.
Parameter uncertainties were estimated using a residual bootstrap. First, the model was fitted to the experimental data, yielding the best-fit parameter vector
The fitted values are
where , and the residuals are
A synthetic bootstrap dataset was generated by sampling the residuals with replacement,
where each is randomly drawn from the original residual set. The model was then refitted to each synthetic dataset, producing a bootstrap parameter vector . Repeating this procedure times gives an ensemble
The statistical uncertainty of each fitted parameter was estimated from the spread of this ensemble. For the DMI field, we report
Since the bootstrap distribution was approximately symmetric, this standard deviation was used as the one-sigma statistical uncertainty. The quoted uncertainty should therefore be interpreted as the statistical fitting uncertainty within the adopted smoothed three-amplitude model.
Uncertainty estimation of D
The uncertainty in the value is then obtained through standard uncertainty propagation of the relevant physical quantities through the formula , i.e.
Given the rather complex ensemble of experimental data, we summarize here the source of all the relevant quantities for each sample. For a1 and a2, , and , are taken from Ref.[1]. For a3, a4 and a5, , is taken from Ref.[1], while and are taken from the comparison of flow measurements as discussed in Sec. III. For sample a6, , and , are measured while the exchange stiffness , is taken from a literature survey on similar stacks [3, 4]. The DW width and its standard uncertainty are obtained by propagating the uncertainty in and in .
References
- [1]A. Magni, G. Carlotti, A. Casiraghi, E. Darwin, G. Durin, L. H. Diez, B. J. Hickey, A. Huxtable, C. Y. Hwang, G. Jakob, C. Kim, M. Klaui, J. Langer, C. H. Marrows, H. T. Nembach, D. Ravelosona, G. A. Riley, J. M. Shaw, V. Sokalski, S. Tacchi, and M. Kuepferling, Key Points in the Determination of the Interfacial Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya Interaction From Asymmetric Bubble Domain Expansion, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 58, 1 (2022).DOI
- [2]T. Ha Pham, J. Vogel, J. Sampaio, M. Vañatka, J.-C. Rojas-Sánchez, M. Bonfim, D. S. Chaves, F. Choueikani, P. Ohresser, E. Otero, A. Thiaville, and S. Pizzini, Very large domain wall velocities in Pt/Co/GdOx and Pt/Co/Gd trilayers with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 113, 67001 (2016).
- [3]B. Zimmermann, G. Bihlmayer, M. Böttcher, M. Bouhassoune, S. Lounis, J. Sinova, S. Heinze, S. Blügel, and B. Dupe, Comparison of first-principles methods to extract magnetic parameters in ultrathin films: Co/Pt(111), Physical Review B 99, 10.1103/PhysRevB.99.214426 (2019), arXiv: 1904.06954.
- [4]T. Devolder, J.-V. Kim, L. Nistor, R. Sousa, B. Rodmacq, and B. Diény, Exchange stiffness in ultrathin perpendicularly magnetized CoFeB layers determined using the spectroscopy of electrically excited spin waves, Journal of Applied Physics 120, 183902 (2016).DOI
- [5]D.-Y. Kim, I. Berrai, T. Suraj, Y. Roussigné, S. Yang, M. Belmeguenai, F. Hu, G. Shi, H. R. Tan, J. Huang, A. Soumyanarayanan, K.-W. Kim, S. Mourad Cherif, and H. Yang, Chiral Damping of Magnons, Physical Review Letters 133, 156704 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2409.04713
- [6]P. J. Metaxas, J. P. Jamet, A. Mougin, M. Cormier, J. Ferré, V. Baltz, B. Rodmacq, B. Dieny, and R. L. Stamps, Creep and Flow Regimes of Magnetic Domain-Wall Motion in Ultrathin Pt/Co/Pt Films with Perpendicular Anisotropy, Physical Review Letters 99, 217208 (2007), publisher: American Physical Society.DOI
- [7]V. Jeudy, A. Mougin, S. Bustingorry, W. Savero Torres, J. Gorchon, A. B. Kolton, A. Lemaître, and J. P. Jamet, Universal Pinning Energy Barrier for Driven Domain Walls in Thin Ferromagnetic Films, Physical Review Letters 117, 1 (2016), arXiv: 1603.01674.DOI
- [8]J. P. Garcia, A. Fassatoui, M. Bonfim, J. Vogel, A. Thiaville, and S. Pizzini, Magnetic domain wall dynamics in the precessional regime: Influence of the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction, Physical Review B 104, 014405 (2021).DOI
- [9]S. Lemerle, J. Ferré, C. Chappert, V. Mathet, T. Giamarchi, and P. Le Doussal, Domain wall creep in an Ising ultrathin magnetic film, Physical Review Letters 80, 849 (1998).DOI
- [10]V. Krizakova, J. P. Garcia, J. Vogel, N. Rougemaille, D. D. S. Chaves, S. Pizzini, and A. Thiaville, Study of the velocity plateau of Dzyaloshinskii domain walls, Physical Review B 100, 214404 (2019).DOI
- [11]I. A. Yastremsky, O. M. Volkov, M. Kopte, T. Kosub, S. Stienen, K. Lenz, J. Lindner, J. Fassbender, B. A. Ivanov, and D. Makarov, Thermodynamics and Exchange Stiffness of Asymmetrically Sandwiched Ultrathin Ferromagnetic Films with Perpendicular Anisotropy, Physical Review Applied 12, 064038 (2019), publisher: American Physical Society.DOI
- [12]M. D. Kuz’min, K. P. Skokov, L. V. B. Diop, I. A. Radulov, and O. Gutfleisch, Exchange stiffness of ferromagnets, The European Physical Journal Plus 135, 301 (2020).DOI
- [13]H. J. Waring, Y. Li, N. A. B. Johansson, C. Moutafis, I. J. Vera-Marun, and T. Thomson, Exchange stiffness constant determination using multiple-mode FMR perpendicular standing spin waves, Journal of Applied Physics 133, 063901 (2023).
- [14]J. P. Pellegren, D. Lau, and V. Sokalski, Dispersive Stiffness of Dzyaloshinskii Domain Walls 10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.027203 (2017).DOI
- [15]D. Lau, J. P. Pellegren, H. T. Nembach, J. M. Shaw, and V. Sokalski, Disentangling factors governing Dzyaloshinskii domain-wall creep in Co/Ni thin films using PtₓIr₁₋ₓ seed layers, Physical Review B 98, 184410 (2018).DOI
- [16]C. A. Akosa, I. M. Miron, G. Gaudin, and A. Manchon, Phenomenology of chiral damping in noncentrosymmetric magnets, Physical Review B 93, 214429 (2016).DOI
- [17]C. A. Akosa, G. Tatara, A. Manchon, and M. Mochizuki, Decoupling the influences of chiral damping and Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction in chiral magnetic domain walls, Physical Review B 110, 024420 (2024).DOI
- [18]S. G. Je, D. H. Kim, S. C. Yoo, B. C. Min, K. J. Lee, and S. B. Choe, Asymmetric magnetic domain-wall motion by the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction, Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 88, 1 (2013).DOI










