WorksEngineering
PLL-Less Synchronization of Grid-Following Converters Using a Voltage-Driven Frenet Frame
Abstract
In grid-following converters, the synchronization path can transmit voltage disturbances to the current loop under weak or unbalanced grid conditions. This paper develops a Frenet-frame controller that derives its axes from the integral curve of the measured voltage at the point of common coupling. The tangential current governs active power, while the normal and binormal currents govern the transverse components of non-active power. Feedforward terms derived from the output filter model compensate curvature and torsion coupling, yielding identical nominal current dynamics across the axes. The controller operates without a phase-locked loop or sequence extraction. A reduced transverse model accounts for the finite bandwidth of geometric rate reconstruction and predicts a reduction in low-frequency coupling from voltage disturbances to current. Controller hardware-in-the-loop tests using real-time simulation of a three-phase four-wire converter show the shortest settling time after an active power reference step and the smallest peak power deviations during balanced voltage disturbances among the tested controllers. Under single-phase voltage unbalance, the method reduces peak binormal current and maximum phase-current total harmonic distortion relative to both benchmarks. It also settles to the commanded power in a weak-grid connection test where the phase-locked loop benchmark exhibits sustained oscillations.
Introduction
Grid-following (GFL) voltage-source converters are widely used as interfaces for renewable generation, battery energy storage, and other inverter-based resources because of their mature implementation and clear control structure [1, 2, 3]. Most implementations rely on phase-locked loop (PLL) synchronization and -frame current regulation [4, 5, 6]. Under balanced sinusoidal conditions, this structure transforms three-phase ac variables into approximately constant quantities in the synchronous frame and thereby simplifies current and power regulation. However, PLL synchronization and the associated voltage processing become increasingly challenging under weak grids, voltage unbalance, waveform distortion, and rapid transients [7, 8, 9].
Synchronization and estimation structures based on the second-order generalized integrator (SOGI) have been developed for nonideal voltage conditions, including SOGI-based PLLs [10] and dual second-order generalized integrator frequency-locked loops (DSOGI-FLLs) [11, 12]. These methods improve synchronization-variable and voltage-component estimation under unbalance and distortion, but retain a dedicated voltage-processing stage between the measured grid voltage and current regulation.
A different research direction removes the explicit PLL from the GFL control structure. Voltage-modulated direct power control regulates instantaneous active and reactive powers directly in stationary coordinates [13, 14, 15]. Linear parameter-varying power-synchronized control (LPV-PSC) establishes synchronization through active-power dynamics [16, 17], while other PLL-less approaches employ oscillator-based synchronization, predictive control, or reactive-power synchronization [18, 19, 20]. However, removing the PLL alone does not eliminate the dynamic interaction between voltage processing, synchronization, and current regulation [21]. A further issue is therefore how the current-control coordinates and the associated power channels are constructed from the measured three-phase voltage.
Conventional GFL controllers generally employ stationary coordinates or prescribed planar rotating coordinates. Such representations are well suited to conventional active- and reactive-power regulation. Under general nonideal three-phase conditions, however, the integral curve generated by the three-phase voltage is not guaranteed to remain in a fixed plane. In a prescribed planar representation, additional components of the multidimensional instantaneous non-active-power vector generally remain functions of the same in-plane current variables used for conventional active- and reactive-power regulation. They are therefore not explicitly separated into distinct orthogonal current-control channels. This motivates a control representation generated directly from the instantaneous three-phase voltage trajectory that explicitly separates the multidimensional power components within the current-control coordinates.
Alternative coordinate and frequency representations have been developed for nonideal three-phase conditions. The Tan-Sun transformation [22] maps unbalanced ac quantities into dc quantities without second-harmonic components, whereas the generalized - framework [23] provides time-invariant coordinates for prescribed phase- and magnitude-unbalanced waveforms. The complex-frequency framework [24] describes normalized voltage-magnitude and angular-frequency dynamics and has been further applied to converter synchronization and closed-loop estimation [25, 26]. These approaches provide useful representations of nonideal voltage dynamics, but they do not establish the voltage-trajectory-driven threedimensional coordinate representation and multidimensional power-channel structure considered in this paper.
The geometric-frequency framework provides a trajectory-based description of three-phase electrical quantities. In [27], frequency was interpreted through the local kinematics of three-phase trajectories in . The Frenet frame was subsequently shown to generalize the Park transform by defining tangent, normal, and binormal coordinates directly from the local trajectory without an externally specified synchronization angle [28], [29]. Geometric quantities have also been incorporated into control design [30], while the geometric interpretation of instantaneous power establishes a multidimensional representation of the non-active-power vector [31].
The three-phase voltage trajectory at the point of common coupling (PCC) defines a tangent-normal-binormal (TNB) frame. In this frame, the converter current components give distinct channels for active power and the two transverse non-active-power components. This paper develops the associated moving-frame model, decoupled current control, and analysis of converter–grid interaction.
The main contributions of this paper are summarized as follows.
A voltage-driven TNB current-control frame is constructed directly from the instantaneous three-phase PCC-voltage trajectory. The control axes require neither an explicit PLL synchronization angle nor positive-, negative-, or zero-sequence decomposition.
Combined with the geometric instantaneous-power representation, the TNB frame separates active-power transfer and the two transverse non-active-power components into distinct orthogonal current channels, providing a direct multidimensional power-regulation structure within the same moving frame.
The converter -filter dynamics are derived in the moving TNB frame, and curvature- and torsion-related coupling terms are explicitly compensated to obtain decoupled nominal current dynamics. A reduced transverse model is further developed to characterize converter–grid interaction around a balanced operating point.
Controller-hardware-in-the-loop (CHIL) tests compare the proposed method with PLL-based and PLL-less GFL benchmarks under matched plant, sampling, bandwidth, modulation, and current-limiting conditions. The tests cover reference changes, voltage disturbances, unbalance, and weak-grid operation.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II develops the voltage-driven Frenet frame, TNB power representation, and moving-frame current controller. Section III develops the comparative dynamic and grid-interaction analysis. Section IV presents the experimental validation and benchmark comparisons. Section V concludes the paper.
Voltage-Driven Frenet-Frame Current Control
The controller uses a voltage-driven Frenet frame for GFL converters. Primes denote time derivatives, denotes transpose, and is the Euclidean norm.
Voltage-Driven Frenet Coordinates
Let collect the instantaneous phase-to-neutral PCC voltages:
Following the geometric-frequency formulation, associate with the integral curve
Thus, the tangent of is aligned with the instantaneous voltage, rather than with the locus traced directly by .
For twice-differentiable satisfying and , the tangent, binormal, and normal unit vectors are defined as
The triad forms a right-handed orthonormal frame. Its time-domain curvature- and torsion-related rates are
Here, governs the local rotation within the osculating plane, whereas describes the evolution of that plane. The Frenet transformation from to TNB coordinates is
For any vector ,
The Frenet–Serret kinematics give
where
Since the tangential axis is aligned with the PCC voltage,
The converter-current vector is
and its TNB representation is
where , , and denote the tangential, normal, and binormal current components, respectively.
The PCC voltage thus determines both the frame and its geometric rates without an explicit synchronization angle.
Instantaneous Power Decomposition
Following the instantaneous-power formulation in [31], the scalar active power and vector non-active power are defined as
The vector is referred to as the non-active-power vector to distinguish it from the scalar reactive power conventionally used under balanced operation.
Since is orthonormal, the inner product is invariant under the coordinate transformation. Hence,
Using
the non-active-power vector becomes
Accordingly, two orthogonal components of are
The signs in (16) follow from the orientation of the frame. The dot product retains the tangential current because the PCC voltage is aligned with , while the cross product satisfies and . With the stated sign convention, , , and equal times , , and , respectively, as illustrated in Figure 1. The control scheme in Figure 2 uses this correspondence to assign each power reference to its associated current channel. Proportional-integral (PI) regulators track the current references, and the resulting converter-voltage commands are implemented through pulsewidth modulation (PWM).
Figure 1. Geometric interpretation of instantaneous power in the voltage-driven TNB coordinates.
Figure 2. Block diagram of the proposed Frenet-frame current control scheme.
Moving-Frame Model and Decoupled Current Control
Each converter phase is connected to the PCC through an output filter with resistance and inductance . Let denote the converter-side phase voltages, expressed with the same reference as . For this symmetric per-phase filter model, the voltage balance in coordinates is
From the product rule and (7), . Premultiplying (17) by then gives
Using , the componentwise dynamics are
Let , , and denote the outputs of the PI current regulators driven by , , and , respectively. The converter-voltage references are designed as
With exact feedforward and realizable voltage commands, (20) and (19) give identical nominal plants on the three axes:
The frame derivative in (18) produces two coupling pairs. Curvature couples the tangential and normal channels, while torsion couples the normal and binormal channels. The feed-forward commands include the PCC voltage on the tangential axis and cancel across the three axes. The resulting identical nominal plants allow the same current regulator to be used on each axis.
Current- and Power-Loop Parameter Design
Each decoupled current channel in (21) has the plant . The PI regulator cancels the plant pole and sets the closed-loop bandwidth to :
The nominal closed-loop response is . All three controllers use in the comparative tests.
For , linearization at the operating point gives
The gain design holds at . The outer-loop crossover is chosen to satisfy , with Hz in the tests. For with rad/s, unity open-loop gain at yields
Uppercase denotes a continuous-domain gain, and lowercase in Table II denotes a normalized digital signal processor (DSP) coefficient.
| Parameter | Symbol | Value |
| Common plant and operating conditions | ||
| Grid voltage and frequency | , | 380 V, 50 Hz |
| DC-link voltage | 1300 V | |
| Switching and sampling frequencies | , | 15 kHz, 15 kHz |
| Output-filter parameters | , | 0.02 , 4 mH |
| Nominal grid parameters | , | 0.0464 , 6.960 mH |
| Active-power reference | 22 kW | |
| Matched current- and power-loop settings | ||
| Outer-loop DSP PI coefficients | , | 0.1, 0.01 |
| Inner-loop DSP PI coefficients | , | 30, 3 |
| Current bandwidth and power crossover | , | 1 kHz, 100 Hz |
| Common rate-deviation bound | 5 Hz | |
| D-PLL controller | ||
| Reactive-power reference | 0 kVAr | |
| D-PLL code-domain PI gains | , | 0.24, 2.4 |
| PLL natural frequency and sequence bandwidth | , | 20 Hz, 80 Hz |
| D-PLL damping ratio | 0.9 | |
| LPV-PSC controller | ||
| Reactive-power reference | 0 kVAr | |
| Power-control bandwidth | 100 Hz | |
| Frenet controller | ||
| Non-active-power references | , | 0, 0 kVAr |
| Measurement-filter settings | , | 1.5 kHz, 2 |
| Differentiator cutoff | 1 kHz | |
| Geometric-rate bandwidth | 100 Hz |
Table II. Plant and controller parameters.
The second-order measurement filter attenuates switching ripple before differentiation while retaining the voltage dynamics required for reconstruction. The differentiator cutoff is kept above the geometric-rate bandwidth to limit attenuation and phase lag in the reconstruction band, and below one tenth of the sampling frequency to limit high-frequency gain. A higher speeds up reconstruction but passes more derivative noise to the feedforward terms. The settings in Table II place one decade below and .
Comparative Dynamic and Grid-Interaction Analysis
This section compares the decoupled phase-locked loop (D-PLL) and Frenet controllers under matched plant and current-loop conditions. The reduced analysis examines in-plane transverse coupling around a balanced operating point, synchronization response, PLL-bandwidth sensitivity, and weak-grid interaction.
D-PLL Benchmark Model
The positive- and negative-sequence decoupling stage of the D-PLL benchmark is represented by the equivalent sequence-extraction filter
where . The PLL regulator is
For a phase-detector gain , the proportional and integral gains set the second-order design targets before sequence-filter dynamics are included ():
where and are the design natural frequency and damping ratio, respectively. In the PLL-bandwidth sensitivity analysis, and the sequence-extraction bandwidth are held constant, while the proportional and integral gains are recalculated from (27).
Around a balanced operating point, the transverse voltage perturbation and estimated-angle perturbation satisfy
Eliminating the locking error and estimated-angle perturbation yields
Hence, the sequence extractor and angle-locking loop introduce additional synchronization modes into the D-PLL current-control path.
Reduced Transverse Transfer Functions
The two controllers use the same continuous-domain inner current regulator
Let denote the operating current magnitude. For D-PLL, the reduced transverse PCC-voltage-to-current response is
Thus, the sequence-extraction and angle-locking dynamics enter directly into the transverse current channel.
For the Frenet controller, consider a balanced planar operating trajectory with constant voltage magnitude . A small angular perturbation satisfies
The corresponding ideal transverse voltage-to-geometric-rate relation is therefore
Let and denote the differentiator and geometric-rate filter, with and . With residual delay , the corresponding transverse reconstruction model is
and the reconstruction residual becomes
The resulting estimator-inclusive transverse admittance is
The residual measures the difference between the ideal and reconstructed geometric-rate responses to the same transverse voltage perturbation. In (36), gives the corresponding coupling-voltage response, and relates that voltage to the transverse current.
Equations (31) and (36) thus preserve the dominant synchronization and reconstruction dynamics of the two control architectures within the same reduced-order framework. The responses in Fig. 3 are normalized by the balanced operating-point admittance , where and denote the Euclidean magnitudes of the balanced three-phase voltage and current vectors, respectively. Under balanced operation, and , where the subscript rms denotes root mean square (RMS). At 22 kW and zero non-active power, V gives V and A.
The nominal D-PLL uses Hz, , and an 80-Hz sequence-extraction bandwidth. The Frenet implementation uses Hz, kHz, and one sampling period of residual digital delay.
As shown in Figure 3, the D-PLL controller exhibits a pronounced low-frequency transverse-admittance peak associated with the sequence-extraction and angle-locking dynamics. Over 1–100 Hz, its maximum normalized magnitude is approximately −9.12 dB, compared with −21.93 dB for the Frenet controller, corresponding to an approximately 12.8-dB reduction in the dominant low-frequency transverse coupling.
Figure 3. Normalized transverse output-admittance characteristics. (a) Magnitude. (b) Phase.
The improvement is frequency dependent. The two magnitude characteristics intersect near 99 Hz, close to the selected geometric-rate bandwidth. Below this range, the Frenet reconstruction residual remains small, whereas at higher frequencies the differentiator, geometric-rate filter, digital delay, and current-loop dynamics increasingly determine the response. The proposed controller therefore primarily suppresses the low-frequency synchronization interaction rather than reducing the transverse admittance over the entire frequency range.
Synchronization-Related Response Comparison
The D-PLL angle-tracking channel is
For the Frenet controller, an equivalent angular-response channel can be constructed from the reconstructed geometric rate as
This channel provides an equivalent measure of the response time associated with geometric-rate reconstruction and does not represent an internal angle state of the Frenet controller. Figure 4 compares the two responses to the same 10° PCC-voltage angle step.
Figure 4. Equivalent synchronization responses to a 10° PCC-voltage angle step.
| (Hz) | Max. normalized (dB) | 2% settling time (ms) |
| 10 | −9.85 | 77.9 |
| 20 | −9.12 | 34.6 |
| 30 | −7.87 | 18.2 |
| 50 | −4.67 | 29.3 |
Table 1. Sensitivity to D-PLL bandwidth.
The nominal D-PLL response is underdamped and reaches the 2% settling band in approximately 34.6 ms. The equivalent Frenet response settles in approximately 6.4 ms, consistent with the first-order settling-time estimate ms at Hz. The latter response therefore reflects the implemented estimator dynamics, including the finite reconstruction bandwidth and digital delay.
D-PLL-Bandwidth Sensitivity
The influence of the D-PLL bandwidth is assessed by varying its natural frequency while maintaining , Hz, and unchanged current-loop parameters. Table I summarizes the maximum normalized transverse-admittance magnitude over 1–100 Hz and the corresponding 2% angle-tracking settling time.
Increasing the PLL natural frequency from 10 to 30 Hz shortens the angle-tracking settling time but simultaneously increases the transverse admittance. Further increasing the natural frequency to 50 Hz no longer improves the settling time because of the stronger interaction with the fixed sequence-extraction dynamics. The nominal 20-Hz setting therefore provides a practical compromise among angle-tracking speed, sequence filtering, and transverse coupling.
The results further indicate that the synchronization response cannot be characterized by the current-loop bandwidth alone. For the D-PLL controller, it is jointly shaped by the PLL and sequence-extraction dynamics, whereas for the Frenet controller it is governed by the derivative and geometric-rate reconstruction paths. These method-specific dynamics are therefore preserved in the subsequent CHIL evaluation, with the remaining converter and implementation conditions kept common.
Weak-Grid Interaction
The converter–grid interaction is assessed through
where and denote the converter output-admittance and grid-impedance matrices, respectively. For the transverse scalar reduction used in the subsequent sweep of the short circuit ratio (SCR), (39) becomes
The stronger low-frequency transverse coupling of the D-PLL controller shown in Figure 3 becomes increasingly influential as the grid impedance rises. The Frenet controller removes the PLL angle-locking path but does not eliminate converter–grid interaction. Below the geometric-rate bandwidth, the interaction is dominated by the reconstruction residual; at higher frequencies, the differentiator, geometric-rate filter, digital delay, and current-loop dynamics become increasingly important.
The controller formulations are independent of online knowledge of and . Grid strength is therefore varied directly through the external grid impedance in the subsequent SCR sweep.
The reduced models characterize the local small-signal converter–grid interaction around a balanced operating point and assume a stiff dc link and the adopted output filter. Switching-frequency effects, current limiting, modulation saturation, protection actions, and trajectory-validity transitions fall outside the scope of these models. Section IV-C compares the critical SCRs predicted from the closed-loop pole trajectories with those identified in the CHIL tests.
CHIL Validation
Experimental Platform and Comparison Conditions
The CHIL setup in Figure 5 pairs a real-time digital simulator (RTDS) with a TMS320C6657 DSP. The case study uses a three-phase four-wire converter. The RTDS models the converter, output filter, and Thevenin grid. It sends PCC voltages and converter currents to the DSP, which returns voltage commands at kHz, with . The grid impedance is , where . Table II lists the test parameters.

Figure 5. RTDS-based CHIL platform.
The experimental comparison includes the D-PLL-based controller, LPV-PSC, and the proposed Frenet controller.
All implementations use the same converter, grid, operating point, sampling and switching frequencies, measurement conditioning, modulation constraint, current limit, and disturbance conditions.
LPV-PSC retains the published gain-scheduled outer power-synchronization law [16], with the power-control bandwidth set to the common 100-Hz target. The method-specific sequence-extraction, gain-scheduled power-synchronization, and geometric-rate reconstruction dynamics are retained in their respective implementations.
The current- and power-loop parameters follow Section II-D. The Frenet estimator settings are listed in Table II. The D-PLL gains are obtained from (27). The common 5-Hz rate-deviation bound is implemented as a protective saturation and does not determine the nominal bandwidth of any controller.
Baseline Dynamic Comparison
Case 1: Power-Reference Tracking
The first case evaluates active-power tracking at SCR = 3. The reference is increased from 20 to 25 kW at s and restored to 22 kW at s, while the corresponding non-active-power references remain zero. Active-power settling time is evaluated using a 2% band around the final steady-state mean.
The non-active-power metric is for D-PLL and LPV-PSC and for Frenet. The synchronization-related deviation is reported in per unit (p.u.) as for the frequency estimated by D-PLL and LPV-PSC and as for Frenet.
Figure 6 shows that the phase-current amplitudes increase after the upward power step and return near their initial levels when the reference is restored. For Frenet, (13) relates this change in power to the tangential current.
Figure 6. Three-phase PCC-voltage and converter-current responses in Case 1.
As shown in Figure 7, all three controllers track both reference changes. D-PLL rises more slowly and briefly undershoots at recovery. The signed non-active-power excursions reverse direction between transitions, with dominant for Frenet. For the upward step, Table III reports settling times of 20, 10, and 6 ms for D-PLL, LPV-PSC, and Frenet, respectively. Frenet gives the smallest non-active-power excursion, 0.84 kVAr, compared with 1.12 kVAr for LPV-PSC and 2.05 kVAr for D-PLL. The peak normalized rate deviation is 0.011 p.u. for both PLL-less controllers and 0.033 p.u. for D-PLL.
Figure 7. Active-power, non-active-power, and synchronization-related rate responses in Case 1.
Case 2: Balanced Grid Disturbance
A balanced 20° voltage-angle step is applied at s. The source voltage magnitude is then reduced from 1.0 to 0.8 p.u. at s and restored at s. The voltage-driven trajectory remains planar, so this case primarily distinguishes the synchronization and reconstruction dynamics.
Figure 8 shows that the current amplitudes return near their pre-disturbance levels after the angle step. During the sag, the phase-current amplitudes increase for all three controllers as the PCC voltage falls. The active power returns near its pre-sag level while the current remains elevated, consistent with the higher tangential current required by (13) at lower voltage. The current amplitudes decrease as the voltage recovers.
Figure 8. Three-phase PCC-voltage and converter-current responses in Case 2.
Figure 9 shows a pronounced D-PLL active-power overshoot after the angle step and its largest non-active-power and rate excursions at voltage recovery. Frenet active power rises briefly at sag onset and dips at voltage recovery. The torsion-related rate stays close to zero, consistent with the planar trajectory. Over the full sequence, Table III reports the smallest peak active- and non-active-power deviations for Frenet, at 1.45 kW and 1.10 kVAr, respectively. Both PLL-less controllers reach 0.026 p.u. peak normalized rate deviation, compared with 0.050 p.u. for D-PLL.
Figure 9. Active-power, non-active-power, and synchronization-related rate responses in Case 2.
Case 3: Single-Phase Voltage Unbalance
A 0.5-p.u. magnitude reduction is applied to phase A of the Thevenin-source voltage from to s, reducing its magnitude from 1.0 to 0.5 p.u., while the other two phase magnitudes remain unchanged. The resulting single-frequency unbalanced voltage trajectory remains approximately planar but becomes noncircular, producing sustained oscillatory power and TNB-current components.
As shown in Figure 10, all three controllers maintain bounded phase currents during the disturbance. Figure 11 shows the largest non-active-power excursions for D-PLL. For Frenet, dominates the non-active-power response, with a plotted peak of about 0.22 kVAr. The normalized torsion-related rate stays close to zero during the sag and varies mainly at its onset and clearance.
Figure 10. Three-phase PCC-voltage and converter-current responses under the single-phase voltage unbalance in Case 3.

Figure 11. Active-power, non-active-power, and synchronization-related rate responses in Case 3.
Figure 12 resolves all phase currents in the same voltage-driven TNB frame. Frenet gives the smallest peak , with a plotted value of 0.75 A. Table III reports Case 3 peaks over 1.0–1.4 s and RMS values over 1.15–1.35 s from the plotted traces. Over these intervals, the peak and RMS non-active-power magnitudes are 2.9 and 1.9 kVAr for Frenet, 6.4 and 2.9 kVAr for D-PLL, and 4.3 and 2.5 kVAr for LPV-PSC.

Figure 12. Currents of the three controllers resolved in the common voltage-driven TNB frame in Case 3.
Current total harmonic distortion (THD) over 1.15–1.35 s is , where is the RMS current of harmonic and is the highest resolved order. Panel (a) of Figure 13 displays the second through fifteenth harmonics.
Figure 13. Current-quality comparison in Case 3. (a) Phase-A harmonic spectrum from the second to fifteenth orders. (b) THD of each phase current using all resolved harmonics.
The fifth and seventh harmonics dominate the displayed spectrum. The maximum phase-current THD is 4.25% for D-PLL, 3.05% for LPV-PSC, and 1.75% for Frenet.
Weak-Grid Stability Boundary
Grid strength is characterized with
where and denote the line-to-line voltage and apparent-power bases, respectively. The nominal ratio is retained while and are scaled proportionally to obtain SCR .
At each grid strength, an independent CHIL grid-connection test is performed for each controller to determine whether it can establish the kW steady operating point. No controller is redesigned or retuned for an individual SCR test point. A test point is classified as stable when grid connection is established, the phase currents remain bounded, and the active power enters and remains within the 2% band around 22 kW without sustained post-connection oscillation.
Figure 14 gives critical SCR values of 1.793 and 1.386 for the D-PLL and Frenet controllers, respectively. The corresponding critical oscillation frequencies are approximately 32.6 and 587.7 Hz. The lower critical SCR of the Frenet controller indicates an extended weak-grid stability range. The limiting mode shifts from the low-frequency PLL-dominated interaction toward a higher-frequency range increasingly governed by the estimator, digital delay, and current-loop dynamics.
Figure 14. Closed-loop pole trajectories from the reduced weak-grid models under decreasing SCR. (a) D-PLL-based control. (b) Frenet control.
| Case | Test condition | Performance index | D-PLL | LPV-PSC | Frenet |
| Case 1 | Upward active-power reference step | Active-power settling time | 20 ms | 10 ms | 6 ms |
| Case 1 | Upward active-power reference step | Peak non-active-power deviation | 2.05 kVAr | 1.12 kVAr | 0.84 kVAr |
| Case 1 | Upward active-power reference step | Peak normalized synchronization-related rate deviation | 0.033 p.u. | 0.011 p.u. | 0.011 p.u. |
| Case 2 | Balanced phase-angle step and voltage sag | Peak active-power deviation | 1.85 kW | 1.51 kW | 1.45 kW |
| Case 2 | Balanced phase-angle step and voltage sag | Peak non-active-power deviation | 1.89 kVAr | 1.45 kVAr | 1.10 kVAr |
| Case 2 | Balanced phase-angle step and voltage sag | Peak normalized synchronization-related rate deviation | 0.050 p.u. | 0.026 p.u. | 0.026 p.u. |
| Case 3 | Single-phase voltage-unbalance disturbance | Peak common-frame | 16.1 A | 12.4 A | 0.75 A |
| Case 3 | Single-phase voltage-unbalance disturbance | Peak non-active-power magnitude | 6.4 kVAr | 4.3 kVAr | 2.9 kVAr |
| Case 3 | Single-phase voltage-unbalance disturbance | RMS non-active-power magnitude | 2.9 kVAr | 2.5 kVAr | 1.9 kVAr |
| Case 3 | Single-phase voltage-unbalance disturbance | Maximum phase-current THD | 4.25% | 3.05% | 1.75% |
Table 3. Representative CHIL performance comparison.
Table 4 gives CHIL critical SCRs of about 1.8 for D-PLL and 1.4 for Frenet, close to the analytical values of 1.793 and 1.386, respectively. LPV-PSC exhibits a comparable experimental stability boundary of approximately 1.4. Over the stable test points, Frenet also retains shorter grid-connection settling times as the grid weakens.
| Controller | Grid-connection settling time at each SCR (ms) | Critical SCR | ||||
| 5 | 3 | 2 | 1.5 | 1.2 | ||
| D-PLL | 15 | 20 | 32 | U | U | 1.8 |
| LPV-PSC | 10 | 13 | 19 | 27 | U | 1.4 |
| Frenet | 8 | 10 | 14 | 23 | U | 1.4 |
Table 4. Grid-connection stability and active-power settling time under different SCRs. U denotes instability; the critical SCR is determined from a finer sweep.
The agreement among the pole trajectories, the response at SCR = 1.7 in Figure 15, and the CHIL sweep indicates that the reduced transverse model captures the dominant local weak-grid interaction around the tested operating point. At SCR = 1.2, all three controllers are unstable; lower SCR values are therefore omitted from the principal sweep.
Figure 15. CHIL grid-connection active-power responses at SCR = 1.7 for the D-PLL-based and Frenet controllers.
Conclusion
This paper develops a PLL-less synchronization and current-control method for GFL converters operating under weak and unbalanced grid conditions. The method constructs a TNB frame directly from the instantaneous PCC voltage. Aligning the tangent with the voltage assigns active power to the tangential current and the two non-active-power components to the normal and binormal currents.
The moving-frame filter model identifies the cross-axis voltage terms introduced by curvature and torsion. Feedforward compensation yields identical nominal plants on all axes, allowing the same inner-loop tuning. A reduced transverse model relates the residual from finite-bandwidth geometric-rate reconstruction to the current response. For a 10° voltage-angle step, the modeled equivalent synchronization response settles in 6.4 ms with Frenet and 34.6 ms with D-PLL. Over 1–100 Hz, Frenet reduces the peak normalized transverse admittance by 12.8 dB relative to D-PLL.
In CHIL tests, Frenet settles in 6 ms after the active-power reference step, compared with 10 ms for LPV-PSC and 20 ms for D-PLL. Frenet gives the smallest non-active-power excursion in this test and the smallest peak deviations in active and non-active power during the balanced angle step, voltage sag, and recovery test. During single-phase voltage unbalance, Frenet yields the lowest peak binormal current, 0.75 A, and the lowest maximum phase-current THD, 1.75%. Its RMS non-active-power magnitude is 1.9 kVAr, compared with 2.5 kVAr for LPV-PSC and 2.9 kVAr for D-PLL.
The model predicts critical SCRs of 1.386 for Frenet and 1.793 for D-PLL. The CHIL sweep finds comparable critical SCRs for Frenet and LPV-PSC, with shorter grid-connection settling times for Frenet at their common stable test points. At SCR = 1.7, Frenet establishes the 22-kW operating point while the D-PLL power response continues to oscillate. The pole-derived stability boundaries apply locally around the balanced operating point used for linearization.
References
- [1]F. Blaabjerg, R. Teodorescu, M. Liserre, and A. V. Timbus, “Overview of control and grid synchronization for distributed power generation systems,” IEEE Trans. on Industrial Electronics, vol. 53, no. 5, pp. 1398–1409, 2006.DOI
- [2]S. Golestan, J. M. Guerrero, and J. C. Vasquez, “Three-phase PLLs: A review of recent advances,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 1894–1907, 2017.DOI
- [3]M. Cespedes and J. Sun, “Impedance modeling and analysis of grid-connected voltage-source converters,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 29, no. 3, pp. 1254–1261, 2014.DOI
- [4]N. Jaalam, N. A. Rahim, A. H. A. Bakar, C. K. Tan, and A. M. A. Haidar, “A comprehensive review of synchronization methods for grid-connected converters of renewable energy source,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 59, pp. 1471–1481, 2016.DOI
- [5]Z. Ali, N. Christofides, L. Hadjidemetriou, E. Kyriakides, Y. Yang, and F. Blaabjerg, “Three-phase phase-locked loop synchronization algorithms for grid-connected renewable energy systems: A review,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 90, pp. 434–452, 2018.
- [6]P. Rodriguez, J. Pou, J. Bergas, J. I. Candela, R. P. Burgos, and D. Boroyevich, “Decoupled double synchronous reference frame PLL for power converters control,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 584–592, 2007.
- [7]ENTSO-E ICS Investigation Expert Panel, “Final report on the grid incident in Spain and Portugal on 28 April 2025,” European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E), Tech. Rep., Mar. 2026.
- [8]A. Derwiškadze, G. Frigo, and M. Paolone, “Beyond phasors: Modeling of power system signals using the Hilbert transform,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 2971–2980, 2020.
- [9]J. D. Lara, R. Henriquez-Auba, D. Ramasubramanian, S. Dhople, D. S. Callaway, and S. Sanders, “Revisiting power systems time-domain simulation methods and models,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 2421–2437, 2024.
- [10]M. Ciobotaru, R. Teodorescu, and F. Blaabjerg, “A new single-phase PLL structure based on second order generalized integrator,” in Procs of the 37th IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conf., 2006, pp. 1–6.DOI
- [11]P. Rodríguez, A. Luna, M. Ciobotaru, R. Teodorescu, and F. Blaabjerg, “Advanced grid synchronization system for power converters under unbalanced and distorted operating conditions,” in IECON 2006 - 32nd Annual Conf. on IEEE Industrial Electronics, 2006, pp. 5173–5178.DOI
- [12]P. Rodríguez, A. Luna, R. S. Muñoz-Aguilar, I. Etxeberria-Otadui, R. Teodorescu, and F. Blaabjerg, “A stationary reference frame grid synchronization system for three-phase grid-connected power converters under adverse grid conditions,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 99–112, 2012.DOI
- [13]Y. Gui, X. Wang, H. Wu, and F. Blaabjerg, “Voltage-modulated direct power control for a weak grid-connected voltage source inverter,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 34, no. 11, pp. 11 383–11 395, 2019.DOI
- [14]Y. Gui, Q. Xu, F. Blaabjerg, and H. Gong, “Sliding mode control with grid voltage modulated DPC for voltage source inverters under distorted grid voltage,” CPSS Trans. on Power Electronics and Applications, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 244–254, 2019.DOI
- [15]Z. Gong, C. Liu, L. Shang, Q. Lai, and Y. Terriche, “Power decoupling strategy for voltage modulated direct power control of voltage source inverters connected to weak grids,” IEEE Trans. on Sustainable Energy, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 152–167, 2023.DOI
- [16]M. Z. Mansour, M. H. Rav anji, A. Karimi, and B. Bahrani, “Linear parameter-varying control of a power-synchronized grid-following inverter,” IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 2547–2558, 2022.DOI
- [17]M. Z. Mansour, M. H. Rav anji, A. Karimi, and B. Bahrani, “Transient stability analysis of power-synchronized PLL-less grid-following inverters,” IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 39, no. 3, pp. 1851–1864, 2024.DOI
- [18]M. A. Awal and I. Husain, “Unified virtual oscillator control for grid-forming and grid-following converters,” IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 4573–4586, 2021.arxiv.org/abs/2007.06042
- [19]X. Dong and H. Li, “A PLL-less voltage sensorless direct deadbeat control for a Sic grid-tied inverter with LVRT capability under wide-range grid impedance,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 38, no. 8, pp. 9469–9481, 2023.DOI
- [20]Z. Tang, T. Hu, and G. Todeschini, “PLL-free approach: Reactive power-based synchronization in grid-following inverters,” IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 1813–1823, Sep. 2026.DOI
- [21]S. M. Hosseinizadeh, S. Oumi, H. Karimi, M. Karimi-Ghartemani, and K. L. Lian, “Comparison of PLL-based and PLL-less vector current controllers,” IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 436–445, 2022.
- [22]G. Tan, J. Cheng, and X. Sun, “Tan–Sun coordinate transformation system theory and applications for three-phase unbalanced power systems,” IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, vol. 32, no. 9, pp. 7325–7380, 2017.DOI
- [23]A. Tayyebi, W. Zhang, X. Huang, W. Jiang, D. Bormann, and M. Larsson, “A generalized time-domain framework for modeling and analysis of the unbalanced three-phase systems,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 235, p. 110809, 2024.DOI
- [24]F. Milano, “Complex frequency,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 37, no. 2, pp. 1230–1240, 2022.
- [25]X. He, V. Häberle, and F. Dörfler, “Complex-frequency synchronization of converter-based power systems,” IEEE Trans. on Control of Network Systems, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 787–799, 2025.DOI
- [26]X. Quan, J. Tang, T. Xu, Z. Wu, W. Gu, S. Pan, and A. Q. Huang, “Complex frequency locked loop for estimations of RoCoV and frequency,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 5476–5479, 2025.DOI
- [27]F. Milano, “A geometrical interpretation of frequency,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 816–819, 2022.arxiv.org/abs/2105.07762
- [28]F. Milano, “The Frenet frame as a generalization of the Park transform,” IEEE Trans. on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers, vol. 70, no. 2, pp. 966–976, 2023.DOI
- [29]F. Milano, G. Tzounas, I. Dassios, and T. Kerçi, “Applications of the Frenet frame to electric circuits,” IEEE Trans. on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers, vol. 69, no. 4, pp. 1668–1680, 2022.arxiv.org/abs/2112.03633
- [30]F. Sanniti, G. Tzounas, R. Benato, and F. Milano, “Curvature-based control for low-inertia systems,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 4149–4152, 2022.DOI
- [31]F. Milano, G. Tzounas, and I. Dassios, “Instantaneous power theory revisited with classical mechanics,” IEEE Trans. on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers, vol. 71, no. 12, pp. 6080–6093, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2401.15129











