betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

EMU/GAMA: Understanding the link between dust geometry and star formation rate in galaxies

Abstract

We investigate the link between dust obscuration and star formation rate (SFR) estimators using Halpha luminosities, L_Halpha and radio luminosities, L_radio. While the Balmer Decrement (BD) is the standard tool for attenuating Halpha, it can fail to account for optically thick dust regions from which Halpha cannot escape. The ratio of SFRs estimated from radio luminosity and L_Halpha corrected for dust attenuation using the BD can be used as a probe of the degree of optically thick dust affecting Halpha. We explore this combining Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) Early Science data at 887.5MHz in the Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA) G23 field with the GAMA data. We draw on dust estimates using both the BD and the dust mass, M_d, demonstrating systematic underlying dependencies with L_radio/L_Halpha. By combining the BD and M_d, we quantify how they relate to L_radio/L_Halpha and other galaxy properties. We use this approach to establish an Halpha SFR (SFR_Halpha) estimator that accounts for optically thick dust, demonstrating its consistency with conventional SFR indicators. Rather than proposing a replacement for standard correction methods, we aim to demonstrate the effectiveness of a dust geometry model that integrates both BD and M_d parameters. This H_dust parameter provides a more physically complete representation of optically thick environments that traditional methods may overlook, and can produce SFR estimates consistent with traditional techniques.

Introduction

The star formation rate (SFR) is a fundamental parameter in understanding galaxy formation and evolution. Extensive work has established numerous approaches for estimating the SFR through diverse observational methods. These include the analysis of nebular emission lines (e.g., Glazebrook et al. 2004; Westra et al. 2009), which trace the presence of massive stars (Bauer et al. 2013; Jaiswal & Omar 2016) as well as investigations into ultraviolet (UV), and infrared (IR) emission (e.g., Schiminovich et al. 2005; Reddy et al. 2008; Leahy et al. 2025) sensitive to the direct emission from young star forming regions and from emission reradiated by dust, respectively.

Additionally, the SFR can be probed through radio emission originating in supernova remnants (e.g., Seymour et al. 2008), X-ray emission (e.g., Georgakakis et al. 2003; Grimm et al. 2003) produced by high mass X-ray binaries, and gamma-ray bursts (e.g., Kistler et al. 2009) stemming from massive stellar explosions.

Galaxy spectral energy distributions (SEDs) encapsulate the physical properties of galaxies, such as their SFR, stellar mass, M⋆M_\star, and dust mass, MdM_d. SED fitting is a standard technique to measure these galaxy properties (e.g., [109, 89] (Bellstedt et al. 2020b; Pacifici et al. 2023)). The Balmer decrement (BD) provides a measure of dust attenuation in the HII regions such that higher ratio indicates more attenuation (Garn & Best 2010; Groves et al. 2012; Domínguez et al. 2013; Reddy et al. 2016; Nelson et al. 2016; Greener et al. 2020). Conversely, MdM_d is typically estimated through sub-mm/IR measurements [96] (Santini et al. 2010; Skibba et al. 2011; Calura et al. 2017; Shivaei et al. 2022) or modelling the galaxy’s SED [109, 89]. The cold dust population constitutes the bulk of MdM_d in galaxies, shaping the SED particularly at far-infrared (FIR)/sub-mm wavelengths (Witt & Gordon 2000; Misselt et al. 2001). Unlike the BD, SED fitting incorporates various parameters, across different wavelengths, that influence how dust attenuates the stellar light emitted by galaxies. These dust related parameters are fitted, together with other stellar population parameters, to find the best fit model that reproduces the observed SED of the galaxy.

In the absence of IR constraints for galaxies, obtaining robust SED parameters requires navigating the inherent degeneracies between stellar age, dust attenuation, and star formation history. A primary alternative is the IRX-β\beta relation (e.g., Meurer et al. 1999; Reddy et al. 2012), though this method remains sensitive to the choice of attenuation law (e.g., Calzetti et al. 2000; Calzetti et al. 1994). Recently, Osborne & Salim (2024) (and references therein) demonstrated that even without IR data, reliable recovery of parameters such as total IR luminosity and dust corrected SFRs is possible by optimising SED fitting strategies against known ground truth samples from deep surveys. To mitigate uncertainties, studies increasingly employ SED tools such as PROSPECT [89] (Bellstedt et al. 2020b), MAGPHYS [109] or CIGALE (Boquien et al. 2019), which physically link the energy absorbed in the UV/optical to the re-emitted dust luminosity. Furthermore, the use of empirical proxies, such as the FIR-radio correlation (e.g., Delhaize et al. 2017) allows for a statistical grounding of SFR across broad populations.

Farley et al. (2025) presented a new method to quantify dust in galaxies by combining the BD and MdM_d. They introduced two new parameters that link BD and MdM_d using SFR across multiple wavelengths, including UV, Hα\alpha, and FIR. These novel metrics are sensitive to optically thick dust that affects short wavelength emission. Farley et al. (2025) examined how these new “dust geometry” parameters vary with galaxy mass, SFR, and specific SFR. Their results showed that they effectively trace dust geometry and support the “maximal foreground screen” model in starburst galaxies. Continuing from that analysis, the work presented here explicitly links these two tracers of dust properties in galaxies, BD and MdM_d, to address discrepancies between SFR indicators. Motivated by the early work of Hopkins et al. (2001), we apply this method to minimise the discrepancy between the SFR measurements from LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}. This approach enables us to demonstrate Hα\alpha based SFR measurements by accounting for emission that is otherwise obscured by optically thick dust, thus providing star formation rates that remain consistent with established indicators.

Many studies have made comparisons between different SFR indicators at different wavelengths, and established detailed relations in between those indicators (e.g., [31] (Hopkins et al. 2001; Sullivan et al. 2001; Buat et al. 2002; Bell 2003)). For a comprehensive understanding of the star formation history (SFH) of the universe, it is typical to rely on estimates of the SFR in galaxies arising from different methods, including commonly from radio, IR, optical, and UV (see, e.g., the review by Condon 1992; Kennicutt & Evans 2012, and references therein). These methods arise from different physical processes, which can lead to variations in the derived SFR values. UV and optical wavelengths are heavily attenuated by dust, leading to under-estimation of SFR in highly obscured regions. In contrast, IR and radio wavelengths are less affected by dust obscuration and may provide more reliable estimates in dusty environments. Variations in stellar populations, dust properties, and metallicity can introduce systematic biases that complicate comparisons between SFR estimates derived from these various methods. Individual tracers are sensitive to the chosen stellar initial mass function (IMF) and UV and Hα\alpha depend on differential attenuation between young birth clouds and the diffuse interstellar medium (ISM) (e.g., Charlot & Fall 2000). Multi-wavelength approaches, including SED fitting, that incorporate radio and IR data provide a more robust approach by accounting for dust obscured star formation and reducing systematic uncertainties associated with single component attenuation models.

The current study explores the relationship between the radio SFR and Hα\alpha SFR (SFRHα\mathrm{SFR}_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}) by incorporating additional dust properties. Radio luminosities (LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}) provide a measure of SF unaffected by dust, presuming that active galactic nuclei (AGN) emission has been excluded. LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, which is sensitive to dust obscuration, offers complementary insights upon correction for dust effects. In order to compare LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} to LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}, we need to make dust corrections to the Hα\alpha measurements. Such dust corrections are well-established, and many authors have introduced different dust models to accurately account for dust obscuration. For example, the influential early work of Calzetti et al. (1994), Calzetti et al. (2000), and Calzetti (2001) (see also, e.g., Natta & Panagia 1984; Disney et al. 1989; Witt et al. 1992) defines and explores conceptual models for the geometric distribution of dust in galaxies. Moreover, Disney et al. (1989) concluded that incorrect evaluations of luminosities and SFR may result from an insufficient consideration of dust geometry. Rather than replacing standard correction techniques, we show how a dust geometry model can be validated by combining both BD and MdM_d parameters. By linking these two values, we can better account for the ways dust is distributed. While traditional Balmer based corrections are widely used, they often face limitations in the most obscured regions of a galaxy. We show that the HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} parameter provides a more physically complete representation of these optically thick environments that traditional methods may overlook. Our approach can be used to make reliable SFR corrections, acting as a complementary tool to established empirical relations. This method is a novel way to represent an optically thick dust measure, consistent with other approaches.

The structure of the paper is as follows. We provide a brief introduction to the dataset from the GAMA and EMU surveys, and describe the sample selection criteria in § 2. The analysis of the Hα\alpha-radio SFR correlation is presented in § 3.1, and the BD dependencies on luminosity ratios are discussed in § 3.3. In § 4, we detail our key findings on the link between these new dust parameters and SFR estimates, and the relation between dust geometry and SFR in the radio detected subsample. We present our conclusions in § 5. Throughout we assume cosmological parameters of H0=70H_0 = 70 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}, ΩM=0.3\Omega_M = 0.3, ΩΛ=0.7\Omega_\Lambda= 0.7 and Ωk=0\Omega_k = 0. Spectral index α\alpha is defined such that flux density SS scales with frequency ν\nu in the sense S∝ναS \propto\nu^\alpha.

Data

In this analysis we begin with the same dataset as in Ahmed et al. (2024), and briefly reiterate the details here. We use photometric and spectroscopic data from two main surveys to identify the host galaxies of radio detected SFGs. The multiwavelength catalogue has been created starting with data from the Galaxy and Mass Assembly survey (GAMA; Driver et al. 2011; Bellstedt et al. 2020a; Driver et al. 2022). This is combined with the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS; [110]) and the VISTA¹ Kilo-degree Infrared Galaxy survey (VIKING; Sutherland 2012) datasets. The resulting matched dataset is referred to as the GAMA-KiDS-VIKING catalogue (GKV; Bellstedt et al. 2020a). This has been combined with radio data from the Evolutionary Map of the Universe survey (EMU; Norris et al. 2011, 2021; Hopkins et al. 2025). The EMU data used here is from early science observations in the GAMA G23 field (Gürkan et al. 2022), at 887.5 MHz. We use the latest radio observations of G23 (Gürkan et al. 2022), which replace earlier data (Leahy et al. 2019) obtained using the Australian SKA Pathfinder (ASKAP) telescope (Hotan et al. 2021). For our radio-IR correlation (see § 2.3, for details), we use IR data from the ALLWISE catalogue (Cutri & et al. 2012) for the GKV sample, as identified by Yao et al. [108].

Galaxy and Mass Assembly

GAMA (Driver et al. 2011, 2022) is a wide-field, multi-wavelength survey, achieving 98.5% redshift completeness independent of the target density (Liske et al. 2015). The GAMA survey consists of 300 000 galaxy spectra across five regions of the sky (G02, G09, G12, G15, and G23) covering a total area of 286 deg2^{2} (Baldry et al. 2010; Robotham et al. 2010; Driver et al. 2011; Hopkins et al. 2013; Liske et al. 2015; Baldry et al. 2018). This study analyses the galaxies within just one of the fields, G23 with a redshift completeness of 94.2% (Liske et al. 2015). The G23 sample has a limiting magnitude of i<19.2i < 19.2 (Liske et al. 2015). This field was selected as it has been observed as part of the ASKAP commissioning (Leahy et al. 2019; Hotan et al. 2021) and again later for EMU early science (Gürkan et al. 2022).

We use the GAMA DR4 database (Driver et al. 2022), which includes photometry and measurements following the methodology outlined by Ahmed et al. (2024). This database contains the gkvScience-v02 (GKV) catalogue, which is the standard UV–IR dataset for GAMA DR4 and we use its precomputed photometry-to-spectroscopy matches. Accurate emission line measurements are needed to select our SFG sample, so we adopt optical line fluxes from GaussFitComplexv05 within the SpecLineSFR data management unit (DMU; Gordon et al. 2017). This DMU provides line fluxes, equivalent widths, and redshifts, the latter sourced from SpecAllv27 within the SpecCat DMU (Liske et al. 2015). We chose to use the measurements from GaussFitComplexv05 instead of GaussFitSimplev05 as this catalogue employs multiple Gaussian fits to enhance accuracy. Nevertheless, Ahmed et al. (2024) demonstrated that simpler fitting approaches produce quantitatively similar outcomes. At the spectral resolution of GAMA (Hopkins et al. 2013, R∼1300R \sim1300), Hα\alpha is not blended with the [NII] lines, and the multiple Gaussian fits of GaussFitComplexv05 ensure that the lines are separately and accurately measured.

Of the 41 115 galaxies from the G23 field in the gkvScience-v02 catalogue, there are 40 088 galaxies that meet the redshift quality flag, nQ≥3nQ \ge3 high quality redshift standard, forming our “GKV (nQ≥3nQ \ge3)” sub-sample (Table 1). We further limit our sample by imposing a series of quality restrictions. We require that Hα\alpha and Hβ\beta are in emission and that we have detections of the [OII] and [NII] lines. We also require the IS_BEST flag to be true, to select the highest S/N spectrum if multiple spectra are available. This leaves 17 547 sources. Next, we select only sources with line fitting flags NPEG = 0 for both Hα\alpha and Hβ\beta, ensuring that none of the fitted parameters were forced to the limits of their allowed ranges. This results in a sample of 9774 sources. Finally, we impose signal-to-noise thresholds on the Balmer lines, S/NS/N (Hα\alpha) ≥3\ge3, and S/NS/N (Hβ\beta) ≥3\ge3. Given these S/NS/N thresholds, we have very few low EW objects in our sample. This means we can be confident that any Hα\alpha derived SFRs are not erroneously dominated by diffuse ionised gas, which may be the case for low EW emission line objects (e.g. Cid Fernandes et al. 2010). This finally produces the 5 154 galaxies referred to as the “GKV (gold)” sample in Table 1. The additional selections indicated in Table 1 are discussed further below in § 2.2 and § 2.3.

CatalogueNumber of Sources
GKV41 115
GKV (nQ2≥3nQ^{2} \ge3)40 088
GKV (gold)5154
GKV (gold) (Md S/N≥3M_{d}\ S/N \ge3)1077
GKV – Radio7123
GKV – Radio (nQ≥3nQ \ge3)6999
GKV – Radio (gold)1700
GKV – Radio (gold) (Md S/N≥3M_{d}\ S/N \ge3)688

Table 1. The number of galaxies in GKV and GKV - Radio from our cross-matched optical parent, and radio samples.

Evolutionary Map of the Universe

EMU (Hopkins et al. 2025) is a radio continuum sky survey providing the most sensitive radio view of the entire Southern Sky, with sensitivity of σ=20 μ\sigma= 20\,\muJy beam−1^{-1} and resolution of ∼15\sim15″ FWHM. EMU expects to deliver a catalogue of about 20 million radio sources at 943 MHz (Norris et al. 2021). This analysis uses the EMU early science observations of G23 (Gürkan et al. 2022) combined with the optical spectroscopy from GAMA. The G23 field is an 82.7 deg2^{2} region, spanning right ascension 338.1∘<RA<351.9∘338.1^{\circ} < \mathrm{RA} < 351.9^{\circ}, and declination −35∘<δ<−30∘-35^{\circ} < \delta< -30^{\circ} with σ∼0.038\sigma\sim0.038 mJy beam−1^{-1}, at 887.5 MHz (Leahy et al. 2019; Gürkan et al. 2022). The catalogue for these observations includes 55 247 radio sources of which 39 812 have S/N≥5S/N \ge5 (Gürkan et al. 2022).

In this analysis, we consider only the sources common to both GAMA and the EMU early science radio data in G23. A 5 arcsec matching radius with the EMU catalogue is adopted, following the success curves reported in Ahmed et al. (2024). This results in a catalogue of 7 123 “GKV–Radio” galaxies, of which 6 999 galaxies have reliable redshifts (nQ≥3nQ \ge3) (Table 1). Within this group, a “GKV–Radio (gold)” sub-sample of 1 700 galaxies (Table 1) is defined by applying the more rigorous spectroscopic quality criteria outlined in § 2.1. We also convert radio luminosities from the measured 887.5 MHz to a frequency of 1.4 GHz using a spectral index\3 of α=−0.7\alpha= -0.7, in order that we can subsequently use the SFR calibrations appropriate at 1.4 GHz luminosities. The adoption of α=−0.7\alpha= -0.7 is commonly used, as it is the typical spectral index for synchrotron radiation, which is appropriate for radio emission in star forming galaxies. If we adopted more extreme values of spectral index (ranging from α=−0.9\alpha= -0.9 to α=−0.5\alpha= -0.5), the inferred 1.4 GHz radio luminosities would only increase or decrease by 10%. Any errors in the adopted spectral index would appear as a small random scatter within the dataset, rather than a significant systematic.

Final Sample

In this work, we choose the SED fitting tool ProSpect (Robotham et al. [89]; Bellstedt et al. 2020b) as a generative galaxy SED package, because ProSpect measurements are available as part of the GAMA G3 data set. ProSpect uses the BC03 (Bruzual & Charlot 2003) and EMILES (Vazdekis et al. 2016) stellar population libraries. It uses a fixed Chabrier IMF (Chabrier 2003), the Charlot & Fall (Charlot & Fall 2000) dust attenuation model, as well as the dust re-emission library of FIR templates by Dale et al. (2014). ProSpect has been applied to the GAMA data, fitting the photometry from the far-UV (FUV) to the FIR (Bellstedt et al. 2020b). We draw on these existing measurements of the G23 galaxies to obtain their M∗M_\ast and the MdM_d for our analysis. The performance of the ProSpect measurements has been analysed and quantified by Robotham et al. [89]; Bellstedt et al. (2020b); Thorne et al. (2021, 2022).

Figure 1 presents the ProSpect M∗M_\ast distribution of our sample as a function of redshift for the full GKV sample (blue), and radio counterparts (GKV - Radio, in red), which form the basis of our subsequent analysis. The full sample spans a redshift range 0<z≤0.3450 < z \le0.345. The black boundary lines in Figure 1 represent the four independent volume limited samples. The M∗M_\ast range sampled by the radio counterparts lies toward the higher mass end of the galaxy mass distribution, an effect explored in detail by Ahmed et al. (2024). We use four volume limited samples for the bulk of our analysis, selected from those labelled as “GKV (gold)” and “GKV - Radio (gold)”. Constructing such samples enables an investigation of any potential evolutionary or mass dependent effects. For this analysis we construct our volume limited samples using a M∗M_\ast limit rather than the rr-band absolute magnitude limit adopted by Ahmed et al. (2024). We choose to use a M∗M_\ast limit here in order to cleanly analyse our results in terms of galaxy M∗M_\ast. Our M∗M_\ast cut provides a physically consistent basis for comparing galaxies across different evolutionary stages. Choosing a sample based on M∗M_\ast instead of luminosity prevents our analysis from being biased by extreme dust obscuration that might otherwise hide such galaxies in an (observed) absolute magnitude limited sample. The redshift bins, M∗M_{*} limits imposed, and numbers of objects in each range are summarised in Table 2.

Figure 1. Distribution of ProSpect M⋆M_{\star} of all galaxies in the sample as a function of redshift, illustrating the four volume limited samples with all the optical parent GKV galaxies (blue), and GKV - Radio detections (red). The black boundary lines are the redshift-dependent M⋆M_{\star} cuts for each redshift bin, with an apparent trend of increasing mass with redshift.

zz rangelog⁡(M∗/M⊙)\log(M_\ast/M_\odot)GKV (gold)GKV - Radio (gold)
0<z≤0.10 < z \le0.19.2697231
0.1<z≤0.20.1 < z \le0.29.61332302
0.2<z≤0.30.2 < z \le0.310.21042252
0.3<z≤0.3450.3 < z \le0.34510.435790

Table 2. The M∗M_\ast lower limits, number of galaxies in GKV (gold), and GKV - Radio (gold), in each of the four mass-limited redshift bins.

We define our final sample by retaining only those galaxies with PROSPECT MdM_{d} estimates having S/N≥3S/N \geq3. From our GKV (gold) sample with 5039 SFGs, we are left with 1077 galaxies, and from the GKV-Radio (gold) sample we have 688 galaxies (Table 1). Figure 2 shows PROSPECT MdM_{d} as a function of PROSPECT M∗M_{*} for these, with the optical parent sample (blue) overlaid with the radio counterparts (red). The radio detected subset is deficient in lower mass galaxies in comparison to the optical parent sample, as detailed by Ahmed et al. (2024), and accordingly is also missing the lower MdM_{d} systems. The radio detected subset has a correlation coefficient of 0.79, while the optical parent sample has a correlation coefficient of 0.8 between MdM_{d} and M∗M_{*}. This will be important in our subsequent analysis where we choose to draw on a dust measurement that captures an underlying correlation with stellar mass.

Figure 2. ProSpect MdM_d as a function of ProSpect M∗M_\ast for SFGs with MdM_d having S/N≥3S/N \ge3 in the optical parent GKV (gold) sample (blue), and the radio counterparts GKV-Radio (gold) (red). The radio detected sample has fewer low mass galaxies compared to the optical parent sample. These lower mass galaxies are missing the lower MdM_d systems as well. The radio detected population favours higher mass galaxies compared to the optical parent sample, as detailed by Ahmed et al. (2024). The radio detected subset has a correlation coefficient of 0.79.

Figure 2 displays both the parent and the radio samples together, to illustrate the similarities and differences, as detailed in Ahmed et al. (2024). We do this as we rely only on the radio subsample in our remaining analysis because the radio measurements are required for our SFR calculations. It has been noted (e.g., Witstok et al. (2023)) that the MdM_{d}-M∗M_{*} relation may show increased dispersion for low stellar masses. This effect is not present in our current sample and will not affect any of our analysis, but it may be important to consider for samples at very low stellar mass.

Our initial sample contains both SFGs and AGN. Radio detections, in particular, often include AGN. As we aim to measure obscuration in SFG, we separate and exclude AGN dominated systems. Figure 3 illustrates the standard diagnostic diagram of Baldwin, Phillips and Terlevich (BPT; Baldwin et al. 1981; Veilleux & Osterbrock 1987; Kewley et al. 2001), as detailed in Ahmed et al. (2024) showing the optical parent sample and the radio counterparts. The data points in red stars, yellow circles and magenta triangles represent the radio SFGs, composites, and AGN, respectively, overlaid on the optical parent sample shown in blue (stars, circles, and triangles, respectively). The solid and dashed lines follow Kewley et al. (2001) and Kauffmann et al. (2003). Galaxies below the dashed line are star forming. Those above the solid line are AGN. Systems that lie between the two are classified as composites. We keep these composite objects, but they are few and do not affect our conclusions.

Figure 3. Spectral diagnostic diagram illustrating the selection of star forming galaxies (SFGs), composite, and AGN populations. The selection boundaries are defined by the criteria given by Kewley et al. (2001) (solid line) and Kauffmann et al. (2003) (dashed line). Symbols represent the parent GKV sample in blue stars for SFGs, blue circles for composite objects, and blue triangles for AGNs. The GKV–Radio sample is highlighted in colour coded markers: red stars for SFGs, yellow circles for composite objects, and magenta triangles for AGNs.

To assess the effectiveness of excluding AGN using the BPT diagram, we use optical spectra and redshifts from the IR-radio sample to investigate the radio–IR correlation. To identify the IR matches for our GKV parent sample, we used data from the ALLWISE catalogue (Cutri et al. 2012). This catalogue comes from the WISE mission, which mapped the entire sky across four IR bands: W1 (3.4 μ\mum), W2 (4.6 μ\mum), W3 (12 μ\mum), and W4 (22 μ\mum). To identify the IR counterparts to our parent sample, we used positional cross-matching. If a WISE source was found within 3 arcseconds of a galaxy’s location, we recorded it as a successful match.

Figure 4 shows the radio-IR correlation for our sample using the W2 luminosity LW2L_{\mathrm{W2}} and the 1.4 GHz radio flux density L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}}. The relationship is consistent with the tight correlation expected between L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}} and LW2L_{\mathrm{W2}} for SFGs. Any strong radio AGN would appear as outliers above the correlation. This relation is effectively the same if LW4L_{\mathrm{W4}} is used instead of LW2L_{\mathrm{W2}}, but the number of sources with W4 detections is dramatically smaller. We retain LW2L_{\mathrm{W2}} here to maximise the sample size. A systematic trend of AGN contamination in higher radio luminosity galaxies would lead to a tilt in the correlation, making it steeper than the one-to-one relation expected for star formation. Given that we do not see any such outliers, or such a tilt, this implies that there is no significant contribution to the radio luminosity by any AGN emission. Even if there is a low-luminosity AGN present that is contributing to the radio emission in a small number of galaxies, the dominant component of the radio emission will be associated with star formation.

Figure 4. The radio-IR correlation for our sample of radio-detected SFGs. The correlation between L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}} and LW2L_{\mathrm{W2}} reflects the tight relationship expected for SFGs, with an absence of outliers above the main sequence. This lack of radio excess sources suggests that AGN activity does not contribute significantly to the measured radio luminosities.

We summarise the selection of our final sample under the following criteria:

  • (i) The redshift quality flag nQ≥3nQ \geq3,

  • (ii) Signal-to-noise (S/NS/N) limits on the Hα\alpha and Hβ\beta Balmer lines of S/NS/N (Hα\alpha) ≥3\geq3, and S/NS/N (Hβ\beta) ≥3\geq3,

  • (iii) Positive detections of the [OIII] and [NII] emission lines, for precise categorization of the galaxies into SF or AGN.

  • (iv) Well-fitting of emission lines indicated by NPEG (Hα\alpha) = 0, and NPEG (Hβ\beta) = 0 as line fitting flags,

  • (v) Redshifts between 0<z≤0.3450 < z \leq0.345 (Table 2),

  • (vi) Stellar masses above the limits given in Table 2,

  • (vii) Classification as SFG using the BPT diagram (Figure 3).

RESULTS AND ANALYSIS

Star formation rates

We are interested here in understanding the impact of dust on SFR estimates, and we investigate this using SFRs derived from Hα\alpha and radio measurements (e.g., [31, 32] (Hopkins et al. 2001; Afonso et al. 2003; Hopkins et al. 2003b; Seymour et al. 2008)). Part of this investigation is to understand the origins of the apparent SFR-dependent dust obscuration, identified differently by many authors using different samples and techniques (e.g., Hopkins et al. 2001; Sullivan et al. 2001; Afonso et al. 2003; Ahmed et al. 2024).

In order to investigate how galaxy obscuration characteristics are linked to SFR, we adopt the dust quantification approach previously developed by Farley et al. (2025). This approach combines the BD and the MdM_{d}, motivated by attempting to quantify and account for the presence of dust which is optically thick to Hα\alpha emission. This approach can be considered as a way to quantify the dust geometry and is detailed further below in § 3.4. We begin first with a comparison of SFRs estimated from LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}} and the dependence on BD.

Radio emission from galaxies is insensitive to dust obscuration, making LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}} an advantageous tool for estimating SFRs in galaxies, once the presence of emission from any active galactic nucleus is excluded.

We first convert the LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}} and the LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} into SFRs using the common calibrations, reiterated briefly here. To calculate the SFR from Hα\alpha, we follow Hopkins et al. (2003a). This begins with applying a stellar absorption correction to the Hα\alpha equivalent width, EWHαEW_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}:

SHα=EWHα+EWcEWHα×FHα,(1)S_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} = \frac{EW_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}+EW_{\mathrm{c}}}{EW_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}} \times F_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, \tag*{(1)}

where SHαS_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} is the stellar absorption–corrected line flux for Hα\alpha and FHαF_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} is the observed line flux. EWcEW_{\mathrm{c}} denotes the Balmer line equivalent width correction for stellar absorption (EWc=2.5EW_{\mathrm{c}}=2.5 Å, following [52] (Hopkins et al. 2013)). An equivalent relation is used to correct the Hβ\beta flux, using the same equivalent width correction. The BD is calculated from these corrected line fluxes, BD =SHα/SHβ=S_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}/S_{\mathrm{H}\beta}, where the nominal Case B value of BD =2.86=2.86 (Brocklehurst 1971; Osterbrock 1989) indicates no obscuration.

In estimating SFR (Hopkins et al. 2003a) from the Hα\alpha luminosity we adopt the calibration of Kennicutt [64]:

SFRHα[M⊙ yr−1]=LHα1.27×1034 W,(2)SFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}[M_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}] = \frac{L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}}{1.27 \times10^{34}\,\mathrm{W}}, \tag*{(2)}

where LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, the luminosity of the Hα\alpha emission line corrected for stellar absorption and dust obscuration is given by

LHα(W)=(EWHα+EWc)×10−0.4(Mr−34.10)L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}(\mathrm{W}) = (EW_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}+EW_{\mathrm{c}}) \times10^{-0.4(M_r-34.10)}
×3×1018[6564.61(1+z)]2×(BD2.86)2.36,(3)\qquad\times\frac{3 \times10^{18}}{[6564.61(1+z)]^2} \times\left(\frac{\mathrm{BD}}{2.86}\right)^{2.36}, \tag*{(3)}

where MrM_r is the rr-band absolute magnitude ([51] (Hopkins et al. 2003a)). This equation implicitly assumes foreground screen dust, the attenuation curve of Calzetti et al. (1994), and that we can correct for this using the BD. This is the standard approach commonly used in making dust corrections using the BD.

Following Bell (2003), we adopt the calibration between 1.4 GHz luminosity and SFR:

SFR1.4GHz[M⊙ yr−1]=fL1.4GHz1.81×1021 W Hz−1,(4)SFR_{1.4GHz}[M_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}] = \frac{fL_{1.4GHz}}{1.81 \times10^{21}\,\mathrm{W\,Hz}^{-1}}, \tag*{(4)}

where

f={1L1.4GHz>Lc(0.1+0.9(L1.4GHz/Lc)0.3)−1L1.4GHz≤Lc,(5)f = \begin{cases} 1 & L_{1.4GHz} > L_{\mathrm{c}} \\ (0.1 + 0.9(L_{1.4GHz}/L_{\mathrm{c}})^{0.3})^{-1} & L_{1.4GHz} \le L_{\mathrm{c}}, \end{cases} \tag*{(5)}

and Lc=6.4×1021 W Hz−1L_{\mathrm{c}}=6.4 \times10^{21}\,\mathrm{W\,Hz}^{-1}. Adopting different calibrations (e.g., [31, 13]) for the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} does not substantially change our findings. While there would be small quantitative differences, the qualitative results remain the same.

Both of these calibrations assume a Salpeter IMF. While choosing an alternative IMF would result in different scalings, they would make the same change to both equations 2 and 4. Consequently, comparisons between the SFRs using ratios of these quantities should be unaffected by the particular IMF chosen.

Figure 5a illustrates the comparison between the SFRs estimated from the uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}, while Figure 5b presents the comparison between the SFRs estimated from the LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} corrected for dust attenuation using the BD and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}. Both the figures are colour coded by BD, and the one-to-one line is represented by the solid black line. The apparent excess in the radio SFR compared to that inferred from Hα\alpha is not a consequence of any AGN contribution to the radio luminosities, as evidenced by the tight radio-IR correlation shown in Figure 4. This effect is strongly consistent with the infrared excess seen in Figure 5 of Kennicutt et al. [66], which compares 24μ\mum luminosities with Hα\alpha.

Figure 5. Comparison between the SFR derived from LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}} and from uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} in panel (a) and BD-corrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} in panel (b) for the radio sample, GKV-Radio (gold) colour coded by BD. The solid black line is the one-to-one line. The intrinsic scatter either side of the one-to-one line in panel (a) is ≈0.34\approx0.34 dex and panel (b) is ≈0.49\approx0.49 dex. There is no BD gradient in the SFR comparison in panel (a) before applying the BD correction to LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. The correlation is tighter here, however, this correlation shows a deviation from the one-to-one line that increases with higher SFR, similar to observations in Hopkins et al. (2001). The trend in the BD in panel (b) is a result of applying the BD correction to LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. BD generally increases with increasing LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} but decreases with higher SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} and SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. This causes low BD points to shift slightly upward, while high BD points, originating from either end of the distribution, undergo a more significant shift.

This effect is also not driven by bursty or stochastic star formation histories. Bauer et al. (2013) demonstrate that irregular recent starbursts are only significant for M∗<1010M⊙M_* < 10^{10}M_{\odot} galaxies. Our sample contains only 22% of galaxies in that mass range, but this is also the range where the Hα\alpha and radio SFR estimates are most closely aligned (Figure 5). This suggests that bursty star formation histories are not a significant factor.

Another potential explanation for a radio excess compared to Hα\alpha in the SFRs is due to a timescale delay coming from radio emission associated with SF at somewhat earlier times compared to the current SFR traced by Hα\alpha. This, too, cannot simply explain the offset between the Hα\alpha and radio SFRs in Figure 5. If that were the explanation, it would imply a highly unlikely coincidence between radio luminosity and star formation history. It would mean that the highest radio luminosity systems (those showing the greatest excess relative to HαH\alpha) are all tracing an equally large excess of recent star formation, rather than (as might be expected) a significant variation. The latter should show up instead as an increased scatter around a one-to-one relation, not a systematic offset.

In Figure 5a, it is apparent that there is no gradient of BDBD in the SFR comparison before the BD correction to LHαL_{H\alpha}. The correlation is tight having a standard deviation orthogonal to the one-to-one line of ≈0.34\approx0.34 dex. The correlation here exhibits a deviation from the one-to-one line that increases with higher SFR (as also observed in Hopkins et al. 2001). This deviation is important for our analysis, and it varies depending on the BD correction applied. In addition, without any BD correction applied in Figure 5a, it is evident that at higher luminosities, the suppression of HαH\alpha relative to radio is more pronounced compared to lower luminosities. We include the BD along with the MdM_d because it provides insight into the underlying cause of the tilt in this relationship, which cannot be fully resolved by solely applying a BD correction. We could reproduce the empirical approach from Hopkins et al. (2001) to make such a correction, however, our method (§ 4.1) aims to explain it by incorporating the dust properties.

In Figure 5b, the BD-dependent gradient is a consequence of applying the BD correction. It is apparent that there is a broad agreement between the two SFRs, although with the substantial intrinsic scatter that has been long recognised. We measure the scatter for this sample as having a standard deviation orthogonal to the one-to-one line of ≈0.49\approx0.49 dex. There are an equal number of high BD points distributed across the bottom and top ends of the distribution, scattered throughout. The gradient emerges after applying the correction because higher BD values correspond to higher SFRs, resulting in the observed gradient. While the general trend is evident, as expected, the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} tend to exceed those from the HαH\alpha, particularly at higher luminosities or SFRs (Cram et al. 1998; Hopkins et al. 2001; Sullivan et al. 2001).

There is also a clear and strong trend visible with the BD. In general BD increases with increasing LHαL_{H\alpha}, but there is also a dependence on the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}}. At a fixed SFRHαSFR_{H\alpha}, for larger SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} estimates the BD becomes lower. Additionally, the low BD points are slightly shifted upward, while the high BD points may begin at either end of the distribution, experiencing a more substantial shift. The BD correction contributes to the emergence of this gradient across the distribution. It is not immediately apparent why this should be the case, and this puzzle leads directly to the detailed exploration in the remainder of this analysis.

Consider that galaxies with a large SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} estimate compared to that from SFRHαSFR_{H\alpha} may actually have an apparent “radio excess” by virtue of missing some HαH\alpha emission due to its absorption by optically thick dust. If some of the HαH\alpha emission associated with high-mass stars never escapes its host galaxy, it cannot be accounted for by making dust corrections to any HαH\alpha that is actually observed. This leads us to draw on the concept of an “HαH\alpha deficit”, following Farley et al. (2025), by which we mean a relative underestimate in the HαH\alpha derived SFR compared to that from an indicator insensitive to dust obscuration, such as LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}. We discuss these concepts in more detail in § 3.3.

It may be the case that there are other physical explanations for the clear and luminosity-dependent deviation between SFRHαSFR_{H\alpha} and SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}}, such as variations in dust attenuation curves between galaxies, or the different timescales probed by the two indicators. It seems more likely that such effects would contribute a stochastic scatter within the relation than a strong and luminosity-dependent systematic offset.

In any case, while we discuss the effect as arising from optically thick dust here, we are in effect simply quantifying an empirical relationship between the two SFR indicators. The results of our analysis are independent of the actual underlying physical cause. We refer the reader to Farley et al. (2025) for further discussion of the origin of this effect.

Radio SFR limitations

The use of radio luminosities as SFR estimates has a long history (Condon 1992), and the limitations are well known. Clearly the biggest issue is to ensure that the galaxies are not hosting any AGN that may contribute to the radio emission. The BPT method is a reliable approach for identifying optical AGN, although it may not always be conclusive due to the absence of any of the four BPT lines (see, e.g., Cid Fernandes et al. 2010). When considering radio AGN (Pratap et al. 2024), it becomes more challenging, because weak accretion can produce radio emission without strongly ionising the ISM. Consequently, there are cases where galaxies classified as SF based on the BPT diagram may actually harbour radio AGN. While such instances are relatively rare, they should be noted as potential contaminants (Best & Heckman 2012).

Excluding these AGN through standard diagnostics such as the BPT is perhaps the most common method, and this is the approach used here to ensure our sample consists of SFGs. We have used the radio-IR correlation (Figure 4 to confirm there are no AGNs with significant radio excesses present in our sample, that might otherwise explain an apparent HαH\alpha deficit. While there is a possibility we have overlooked some low luminosity AGNs by solely relying on the BPT diagnostic, their inclusion in our sample would not significantly alter any of our findings.

Even for SFGs, though, there is a history of exploring systematics in the degree to which radio emission traces SFR. At low M∗M_*, for example, a deviation from a simple linear scaling is seen (Condon et al. 1991) and quantified differently by different authors ([13] (Bell 2003)). We have adopted here the scaling by Bell (2003), although using that of Brown et al. [13] changes our results only negligibly. Gürkan et al. (2018) discuss alternative mechanisms for the generation of radio luminosity in low SFR galaxies, including pulsars or type Ia supernovae, as well as the role of enhanced magnetic fields in high-SFR galaxies, and their potential impact on radio SFR estimators.

While these and other limitations must be borne in mind, when we attempt to identify a reference SFR estimator that is independent of dust obscuration we are forced to the long wavelength regime, and the LFIRL_{\mathrm{FIR}} and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}. Despite their limitations, and fully anticipating that future work will go a long way toward improving their use as SFR probes, they currently provide the best starting point in estimating a total reference SFR in order to account for optically thick dust obscuration in galaxies.

BD - luminosity ratio dependencies

Here we explore the origins of the BD variations seen in Figure 5 between the two SFR indicators. To address this, we assess how BD correlates with the ratio of the two SFR measures. Rather than using SFRs explicitly though, we instead use the underlying luminosity measurements for simplicity. This eliminates the extra step of incorporating SFR calibration factors, keeping the analysis as close to direct observables as possible. Throughout the manuscript, LHαL_{H\alpha} and SFRHαSFR_{H\alpha} refer to BD-corrected values unless stated otherwise.

Many authors have explored luminosity or flux ratios for similar purposes, either exploring links with obscuration (e.g., Kewley et al. 2002; Cortese et al. 2006; Domínguez Sánchez et al. 2014; Koyama et al. 2015), or probing SFHs (e.g., Emami et al. 2019; Rezaee et al. 2023). In almost all such cases it is the obscuration probed by a BD or similar optical attenuation parameter, such as E(B−V), being explored.

Motivated to explore the BD dependence seen in Figure 5, Figure 6 shows the distribution of BD as a function of the Hα\alpha deficit (the ratio of the LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}} and the LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}), colour coded by M∗M_\ast. Figure 6a illustrates the distribution using uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, while Figure 6b presents the distribution using the BD-corrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. The horizontal dashed line in both the figures represents the nominal Case B value of BD = 2.86. Throughout our analysis, the colour bar for M∗M_\ast spans the range 9.4≤log⁡(M∗M⊙)≤119.4 \leq\log\left(\frac{M_\ast}{M_\odot}\right) \leq11 to provide a consistent reference for the M∗M_\ast range between figures. Although no clear relationship is evident in Figure 6a between the observed Hα\alpha deficit and BD, applying a BD correction to the Hα\alpha introduces a correlation (Figure 6b). This correlation arises due to the BD providing an insufficient correction to LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} in the presence of optically thick dust. This is also reflected in the fact that BD corrections alone do not fully correct the discrepancy between uncorrected Hα\alpha and SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} (Figure 5). This underestimate is particularly relevant given the widespread practice of relying solely on BD corrections for inferring LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} and SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. Our focus lies in resolving these discrepancies.

Figure 6. The distribution of BD as a function of Hα\alpha deficit (the ratio of the radio and Hα\alpha luminosities) from uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} in panel (a) and BD-corrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} in panel (b), colour coded by M∗M_\ast. The horizontal dashed line represents the nominal Case B value of BD = 2.86. No clear relationship is apparent between the uncorrected Hα\alpha and radio parameters and BD in panel (a). The tight correlation, in panel (b), is due to the high BD values significantly increasing the Hα\alpha, which shifts the Hα\alpha deficit to the left, thereby inducing the correlation.

Looking in more detail at Figure 6b, in addition to the strong BD correlation with the Hα\alpha deficit, there is an equally strong M∗M_* dependence, seen in the colour gradient. The higher Hα\alpha deficit values occur for the lowest values of BD, but for a given BD, a higher Hα\alpha deficit corresponds to higher M∗M_*. If optically thick dust is present, some Hα\alpha emission cannot escape the galaxy to be measured, leading to an effective deficit in LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} compared to the LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}. This would correspond to data on the right in Figure 6b which clearly show low values of BD. As explored by Farley et al. (2025) we similarly interpret this as an indication that the measured Hα\alpha in these systems arises only through the emission related to stars toward the outskirts of a “distributed dust” geometry, and hence the detected Hα\alpha experiences little obscuration, although there may be significant Hα\alpha that is fully obscured. Conversely, where the Hα\alpha deficit is low, the BD is high. This would be consistent with a dust distribution arranged such that the emitted Hα\alpha passes through the large proportion of it, producing the elevated BD, while suffering minimal optically thick losses, i.e., a “foreground screen” geometry. See Farley et al. (2025) for more discussion of this effect.

We should note that our use of the phrases “distributed dust” and “foreground screen” are really just convenient descriptors of the dust distribution in the different regimes, and should not necessarily be taken too literally. The essential difference is that the former allows some of the SFR (and hence Balmer lines) to be totally blocked by dust and some to be visible through only slight extinction. The BD can therefore be small even though much of the Hα\alpha is lost. The latter has dust moderately obscuring all the emission regions (not necessarily equally), so that BD can be larger yet a significant level of Hα\alpha gets through.

Figure 7 shows the same distributions in our four mass-limited samples spanning redshifts between 0<z≤0.3450 < z \le0.345. This shows clearly that the BD dependence appears in each of the volume limited samples, each probing a somewhat different M∗M_* range. As redshift increases, the trend remains consistent, but it shifts to the right, a consequence of higher M∗M_* values in progressively higher redshift bins.

Figure 7. The distribution of BD as a function of Hα\alpha deficit colour coded by M∗M_\ast in four mass-limited samples. The horizontal dashed lines represent the nominal Case B value of BD = 2.86. In these mass-limited samples, higher redshifts are associated with subsets restricted to higher M∗M_\ast limits. BD dependence is present in each volume-limited sample, each probing a slightly different M∗M_\ast, and with the increase in redshift, the trend shifts to the right, reflecting higher M∗M_\ast in higher redshift bins.

It is apparent in Figure 6 (also in Figure 7) that there are values of BD with high signal to noise line measurement that are still below the case B value. This occurrence in our sample is not a limitation of the measurements or the data; rather, it is common within similar galaxy samples. These measurements, although below the case B value, are reliable and not biased by artifacts in the spectra. The implication is that these galaxies probe slightly different physical conditions (temperature and electron density) from that assumed in case B. For these galaxies where the BD lies below the case B value, the physical conditions may differ, for example increased ISM temperatures would act to lower the BD values (Osterbrock 1989). Some of these values may, however, be too extreme to be explained in this way. If we simply chose to omit any measurements with BD < 2.86, none of our analysis or conclusions would be altered. We retain them here for completeness, and further investigation into their detailed origin is deferred to future work.

Dust Geometry Metrics

We are motivated to link BD and MdM_d because relying solely on BD corrections does not fully rectify the attenuation of Hα\alpha emission. The Hα\alpha deficit is attributed to optically thick dust, for which the BD alone is insufficient to compensate. Likewise, the MdM_d alone does not provide a straightforward means of correction, as it does not specify the extent of Hα\alpha attenuation by the dust. Introducing the concept of dust geometry as used here, following Farley et al. (2025) in linking the BD and MdM_d, may enable a novel approach in accounting for optically thick dust. We test that idea here by using HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} in estimating the SFR from the Hα\alpha emission, to demonstrate, by comparison to the radio-derived SFR, that it accounts for the optically thick dust, in a way not possible by using the BD alone.

Following Farley et al. (2025), Figure 8 shows the distribution of BD as a function of MdM_d, for our analysis of the radio detected sub-sample. The nominal Case B value of BD = 2.86 is represented by the horizontal dashed line. This figure illustrates how galaxy obscuration spans the entire range of measurable BD values at the highest MdM_d, but for lower MdM_d is restricted to lower levels of BD. This effect is seen more clearly in Farley et al. (2025), where dust masses more than an order of magnitude smaller are being probed than in this sample.

Figure 8. The distribution of BD as a function of MdM_d colour coded by M∗M_* for those with radio detection. The horizontal dashed line represents the nominal Case B value of BD = 2.86. The BD spans a wide range of values at the highest MdM_d, whereas only relatively low BD values are observed at low MdM_d, as shown also by Farley et al. (2025), who interpret this in terms of a dust geometry effect.

As discussed by Farley et al. (2025), this relationship between BD and MdM_d illustrates the distribution between the two extremes, interpreted there as (a) a maximal foreground screen geometry, if all the dust is arrayed in such a screen, and (b) a maximal distributed dust geometry, allowing for high optical depths. The low optical depth foreground screen geometry is situated at the lower end of the distribution, characterised by low BD and low MdM_d. Conversely, a high optical depth foreground screen geometry is located at the higher end of the envelope, characterised by high BD and high MdM_d. The absence of data in the upper left of the diagram is consistent with the idea that a sufficient amount of MdM_d distributed entirely in a foreground screen would become totally optically thick to Hα\alpha.

Given that the BD correction alone is not sufficient to account for the deviation between the uncorrected Hα\alpha and the radio SFR, (Figure 5), we now draw on the approach of Farley et al. (2025), that links both the BD and MdM_d in our aim to validate dust corrections. Recall the strong BD dependence on Hα\alpha deficit, which also shows a clear evidence of M∗M_* dependence (Figure 6). This implies that there is a parameter that relies on both BD and M∗M_* that should correlate strongly with the Hα\alpha deficit. As in Farley et al. (2025), we construct such a parameter by using MdM_d explicitly, due to its tight correlation with M∗M_*, and linking it with the BD represented through the optical depth parameter τ\tau (e.g., Calzetti et al. 1994). This is physically motivated by linking the MdM_d (as an M∗M_* sensitive tracer) with the BD as an effective probe for sampling the dust properties, which should encapsulate both optically thick and thin dust corrections. We then calculate the same HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} as in Farley et al. (2025):

Hdust=Md10τBI.(6)H_{\mathrm{dust}} = \frac{M_d}{10^{\tau_B^I}}. \tag*{(6)}

Here MdM_d is the dust mass (in M⊙M_\odot). We can also rewrite HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} to substitute an expression for BD in place of τBI\tau_B^I in Equation (6) giving

Hdust=101.0578MdBD2.303.(7)H_{\mathrm{dust}} = 10^{1.0578}\frac{M_d}{\mathrm{BD}^{2.303}}. \tag*{(7)}

The factor of 2.303 in the exponent of the BD accounts for the conversion from natural logarithms to base-10 logarithms, consistent with the formulation of extinction laws in terms of optical depths. We return now to the Hα\alpha deficit, showing in Figure 9 and Figure 10 how HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} behaves. To assess whether the correlation arises simply from a mutual dependence on BD, we consider the relationships between MdM_d and the Hα\alpha deficit, and HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and the Hα\alpha deficit as shown in Figure 9. In this case, we use Hα\alpha values that are uncorrected for dust attenuation. In both comparisons, a strong correlation persists. This suggests that the trend is not solely an artifact of the BD dependence, but likely reflects an underlying physical connection.

Figure 9. The correlation between (a) MdM_d and the Hα\alpha deficit, and (b) HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and the Hα\alpha deficit, using uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}. These figures demonstrate that the observed correlations, such as that in Figure 6b, are not merely a consequence of both axes sharing a dependence on BD, as an equally strong correlation is seen here using the uncorrected LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, which has no BD dependence.

Figure 10. The distribution of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} as a function of Hα\alpha deficit, colour coded by M∗M_*. The correlation between HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and Hα\alpha deficit is significantly tighter compared to that of the correlation between BD and Hα\alpha deficit in § 3.3. The correlation coefficient between HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and Hα\alpha deficit is 0.81. The scatter compared to Figure 6 is reduced to ≈0.31\approx0.31 dex. The solid black lines represent the lines fit as discussed in the text.

Discussion

Using HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} to improve SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} estimates

The very tight correlation seen in Figure 10 for HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} (a scatter now of ≈0.31\approx0.31 dex, compared to ≈0.55\approx0.55 dex in Figure 6) emphasises that HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} is directly associated with the optical depth of the dust, corresponding to the Hα\alpha deficit. The correlation seen here is not a consequence of both axes sharing a dependence on BD, since there is an equally strong correlation seen between MdM_d and the Hα\alpha deficit calculated before making BD corrections to Hα\alpha (Figure 9). The M∗M_* gradient orthogonal to the trend seen in Figure 6 is essentially removed, although there is also a residual M∗M_* dependence for HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}}, in

the sense that M∗M_* increases with increasing HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}}. This arises from the use of MdM_d in the definition of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} indirectly introducing this scaling with M∗M_*. To reiterate, at a given value of MdM_d larger values of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} correspond to the maximal distributed dust model and the most optically thick dust for Hα\alpha.

We model the relationships for HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} with the Hα\alpha deficit using orthogonal regression line fitting. The fitted line is shown in Figure 10, and is given by:

log⁡10Hdust=1.165×log⁡10L1.4GHzLHα,corr+22.564,(8)\log_{10} H_{\mathrm{dust}} = 1.165 \times\log_{10}\frac{L_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}}}{L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha,\mathrm{corr}}} + 22.564, \tag*{(8)}

This same fit is reproduced in Figure 11, showing the mass-limited samples in each of the redshift bins. For HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}}, while the M∗M_* ranges sampled in each redshift bin are reflected in the data distribution moving to higher masses at higher redshift, there is no apparent systematic shift in the overall trend as a function of redshift. This implies that there is no evolution in redshift for this correlation in the redshift range sampled here. For these reasons, we argue that the definition of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} is a self-consistent approach in defining a new parameter that is sensitive to the Hα\alpha deficit, with minimal underlying M⋆M_\star and redshift dependencies.

Figure 11. The distribution of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} as a function of Hα\alpha deficit, colour coded by M∗M_\ast in four mass-limited samples. The solid black lines in each panel represent the same line fit as in Figure 10. As redshift increases, the M∗M_\ast range sampled shifts to higher masses. However, there is no noticeable systematic change in the overall trend with redshift. This suggests that within the sampled redshift range, there is no redshift evolution in this correlation.

We are in a position now to use this new parameter to validate the SFR estimates from Hα\alpha, in essence to effectively correct for the emission otherwise lost to optically thick dust.

Early work by Hopkins et al. (2001) recognised the discrepancy between SFRs obtained from UV and Hα\alpha compared to those derived from FIR luminosities (LFIRL_{\mathrm{FIR}}) and LradioL_{\mathrm{radio}}, which is more pronounced at high SFRs. The FIR and radio derived SFRs are unaffected by extinction, and the standard obscuration corrections to the UV and Hα\alpha measurements are insufficient to fully address the discrepancies. They analyse the approach of incorporating a SFR dependent correction to these estimators. By introducing this empirical correction to a SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} estimate, in order to better link it to the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}}, they effectively accounted for Hα\alpha otherwise missing due to obscuration by optically thick dust. Our approach follows the same philosophy by relying on the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} as a reflection of the full underlying SFR, but uses a more physically motivated approach to account for the optically thick dust affecting the Hα\alpha estimators.

This relation can be rearranged as an expression for L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}}, giving

log⁡10L1.4GHz=log⁡10Hdust−22.5641.165+log⁡10LHα,corr(9)\log_{10} L_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}} = \frac{\log_{10} H_{\mathrm{dust}} - 22.564}{1.165} + \log_{10} L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha,\mathrm{corr}} \tag*{(9)}

If we use this expression with known values of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, we can estimate a predicted “L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}}”, which may be considered to effectively be a refined estimate of LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, and hence SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, that now accounts for emission otherwise missing through obscuration by optically thick dust. This predicted L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}} is then converted to a SFR using Equation (4).

Figure 12a shows the comparison of this newly defined SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} derived from Equation (9) against the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}}, again colour coded by BD. This is contrasted against the original relation of Figure 5. The solid black line represents the one-to-one relation between the SFRs, and the comparison now shows a significantly tighter correlation with a standard deviation in the scatter orthogonal to the one-to-one line of ≈0.25\approx0.25 dex. This is a significant improvement over the previous scatter of ≈0.49\approx0.49 dex. We evaluated the linear relationship using the Pearson correlation coefficient (r=1.00r = 1.00) and and confirmed consistency with the Spearman rank correlation coefficient (ρ>0.999\rho> 0.999). Notably, the previously observed BD dependence in Figure 5 is no longer apparent.

Figure 12. Comparison between the updated Hα\alpha SFR estimates from Equation (9) together with Equation (4) and (a) the radio SFR; and (b) the composite SFR calibration from Kennicutt & Evans (2012). The solid black line represents the one-to-one relation and the measurements show a significantly tighter correlation, having a standard deviation in the scatter orthogonal to the one-to-one line of (a) ≈0.25\approx0.25 dex and (b) ≈0.24\approx0.24 dex. The previously observed BD dependence is no longer apparent. The Pearson correlation coefficient in both panels is 1.0.

It is worth noting that an alternative empirical approach to composite SFR calibration was proposed by Kennicutt et al. [66]. Their approach is based on a linear combination of the observed Hα\alpha and IR or radio luminosities. This combination effectively reproduces the true unattenuated Hα\alpha luminosity. We explicitly test our new method by comparing our results against the results from the composite SFR calibrations of Kennicutt et al. [66], (their equation 11 and Table 4), and Kennicutt & Evans (2012), their Table 2):

SFR[M⊙yr−1]=7.9×10−35[LHα,uncorr+0.39×1013(L1.4GHz)](10)SFR[M_\odot\mathrm{yr}^{-1}] = 7.9 \times10^{-35} [L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha,\mathrm{uncorr}} + 0.39 \times10^{13}(L_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}})] \tag*{(10)}

where LHα,uncorrL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha,\mathrm{uncorr}} (in W) is the observed Hα\alpha luminosity without correction for internal dust attenuation, αI=0.39×1013\alpha_{\mathrm{I}} = 0.39 \times10^{13} is the appropriate scaling coefficient (from Table 2 of Kennicutt & Evans (2012)) for the respective luminosity, for which we adopt L1.4GHzL_{1.4\mathrm{GHz}}, given here in units of W Hz−1\mathrm{W\,Hz}^{-1}.

Figure 12b shows the comparison of our newly defined SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} against this SFR calibrations by Kennicutt & Evans (2012), derived from Equations 10, colour coded by BD. The solid black line represents the one-to-one relation between the SFRs, and the results show a very tight correlation, with a correlation coefficient of 1.0. Our new method gives SFR estimates consistent with the approach of Kennicutt & Evans (2012). By adopting a physically motivated approach that incorporates MdM_d, we reproduce their empirical approach to combining Hα\alpha and the radio data. Our method, however, is now driven directly by dust parameters and the Hα\alpha only, so that it can be applied without explicit need for the radio or FIR data. Having Hα\alpha, MdM_d, and BD alone should be sufficient to estimate the SFR. While MdM_d estimates themselves may in many cases originate from data that include FIR measurements, it may also be possible to draw on SED fitting from the UV and optical alone to derive MdM_d, where no FIR is available, although the uncertainties may be larger. The slight residual tilt observed in the relation is likely to be a consequence of our radio detected sample missing the low mass, least obscured objects at the low SFR end (Ahmed et al. 2024).

This result demonstrates an approach to correcting the SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} estimates, which are now in much greater agreement, by construction, with the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}}. This refinement can be considered as a way to account, using the combination of BD and MdM_d encoded within the HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} parameter, for optically thick dust obscuration to Hα\alpha that is otherwise not accessible. This method can be used to refine any SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} measurements, independent of the existence of any radio data, as long as both BD and MdM_d are available. Since these data are typically accessible through optical spectroscopy and photometry, this approach can be applied to large Hα\alpha samples regardless of radio detection.

Of course, this approach explicitly assumes that the SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} estimate is a reliable tracer of the full underlying SFR in a galaxy, and our finding suggests an enhancement in the accuracy of the SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} estimates. This assumption has limitations, some of which are discussed below. But, while acknowledging these, the method presented here is put forward as a novel approach to improving the internal self-consistency of SFR indicators that allows for a way to account and correct for optically thick dust absorption. Based on our understanding of the HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} parameter, this improvement serves to address optically thick dust obscuration affecting Hα\alpha, which would otherwise remain undetected.

Conclusion

In this analysis, we have validated the dust geometry metrics presented by Farley et al. (2025), that link BD and MdM_d, by demonstrating that they can be used in reliably correcting Hα\alpha SFR estimates. Rather than replacing existing SFR estimation techniques, we have demonstrated that using the HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} parameter can provide a physically complete representation of optically thick environments that traditional methods may overlook.

We start with a galaxy sample following Ahmed et al. (2024) that provides the necessary optical and radio measurements. Using the dust geometry metric, HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}}, we identify a clear link with the Hα\alpha deficit, and use that directly to develop an improved SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} estimate (§ 4.1). Here we refer to the ratio Lradio/LHαL_{\mathrm{radio}}/L_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} as the Hα\alpha deficit. We explore the effectiveness of drawing on the combination of BD and MdM_d as quantified through the definition of HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} in our analysis. We demonstrate that using HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} in this way proves to be a robust and effective approach in making obscuration corrections to Hα\alpha SFRs. Estimating HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} simply requires a measurement of BD and MdM_d (Equation (7)). The BD measurements are standard in most large spectroscopic surveys, and the dust mass may be estimated in a va... variety of ways, such as using SED modelling or direct measurement from FIR luminosities, depending on the sample.

We investigate the relationship between obscuration properties of radio detected galaxies and SFR in the local universe, using a sample of SFGs from the GAMA G23 region combined with the EMU early science data, following Ahmed et al. (2024). The consistency between our results and independent radio and IR indicators confirms that this approach is effective for accurately estimating SFRs. This approach successfully captures the physical conditions of optically thick environments, making it a valuable addition to the standard tools used for estimating star formation.

Our main results can be summarised as:

  1. We use the novel dust geometry metric HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} (Farley et al. 2025) to quantify the properties of dust in galaxies.

  2. We establish a significant and tight correlation between HdustH_{\mathrm{dust}} and Hα\alpha deficit, which we interpret as due to the presence of optically thick dust.

(iii) We used this tight correlation to define an estimate of LHαL_{\mathrm{H}\alpha}, and hence SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} (Figure 12). This reduces the scatter between the SFR estimators from an initial value of ≈0.49\approx0.49 dex to ≈0.25\approx0.25 dex.

If SFRs estimated from Hα\alpha and UV are systematically underestimated, and more so at higher SFRs, that will have significant implications for many analyses. For example, SFRs at high redshift may need to be increased, perhaps by factors up to 5 or more (the effective underestimate in SFRHαSFR_{\mathrm{H}\alpha} compared to SFRradioSFR_{\mathrm{radio}} at high SFRs in Figure 5). This will exacerbate the inconsistency between the cosmic SFR and mass density histories (Hopkins & Beacom 2006; Wilkins et al. 2008). It will have broader implications in terms of understanding SFHs for individual galaxies, and will also impact many areas of high-mass SF and evolution. Future work will begin to explore these implications in more detail. Such explorations will investigate the properties of dust in galaxies as a function of parameters including mass, SFR, redshift, galaxy type, and environmental factors. We plan to extend this work to resolved spectroscopy of galaxies using both current and upcoming integral field spectroscopy survey initiatives. These include surveys such as SAMI (Croom et al. 2012), CALIFA (Sánchez et al. 2012), MANGA (Bundy et al. 2015), MAGPI (Foster et al. 2021), and TYPHOON (Grasha et al. 2022). This extension will enable us to gain a deeper understanding of the physical distribution of optically thick dust within galaxies.

Data Availability

All of the data are publicly available through GAMA and EMU. The paper includes archived data obtained through the CSIRO ASKAP Science Data Archive, CASDA (http://data.csiro.au).

Acknowledgements

We thank the anonymous referee for important suggestions, which helped improve the quality of this paper.

We thank Ian Smail, Alister Graham, and Tayyaba Zafar for helpful feedback and input as this work was being prepared. D.J.B. acknowledges funding from the German Science Foundation DFG, via the Collaborative Research Center SFB1491 ‘Cosmic Interacting Matters – From Source to Signal’.

GAMA is a joint European-Australasian project based around a spectroscopic campaign using the Anglo-Australian Telescope. The GAMA input catalogue is based on data taken from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and the UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey. Complementary imaging of the GAMA regions is being obtained by a number of independent survey programmes including GALEX MIS, VST KiDS, VISTA VIKING, WISE, Herschel-ATLAS, GMRT and ASKAP providing UV to radio coverage. GAMA is funded by the STFC (UK), the ARC (Australia), the AAO, and the participating institutions. The GAMA website is http://www.gama-survey.org/. Based on observations made with ESO Telescopes at the La Silla Paranal Observatory under programme IDs 179.A-2004 and 177.A-3016.

This scientific work uses data obtained from Inyarrimanha Ilgari Bundara / the Murchison Radio-astronomy Observatory. We acknowledge the Wajarri Yamaji People as the Traditional Owners and native title holders of the Observatory site. The Australian SKA Pathfinder is part of the Australia Telescope National Facility (https://ror.org/05qjv d42) which is managed by CSIRO. Operation of ASKAP is funded by the Australian Government with support from the National Collaborative Research Infrastructure Strategy. ASKAP uses the resources of the Pawsey Supercomputing Centre. Establishment of ASKAP, the Murchison Radio-astronomy Observatory and the Pawsey Supercomputing Centre are initiatives of the Australian Government, with support from the government of Western Australia and the Science and Industry Endowment Fund.

References

  1. [13]Brown M. J. I., et al., 2017, ApJ, 847, 136
  2. [31]Davies L. J. M., et al., 2016, MNRAS, 461, 458
  3. [32]Davies L. J. M., et al., 2018, MNRAS, 480, 768
  4. [51]Gunawardhana M. L. P., et al., 2011, MNRAS, 415, 1647
  5. [52]Gunawardhana M. L. P., et al., 2013, MNRAS, 433, 2764
  6. [64]Kennicutt Robert C. J., 1998, ApJ, 498, 541
  7. [66]Kennicutt Robert C. J., et al., 2009, ApJ, 703, 1672
  8. [89]Robotham A. S. G., Bellstedt S., Lagos C. d. P., Thorne J. E., Davies L. J., Driver S. P., Bravo M., 2020, MNRAS, 495, 905
  9. [96]Smith M. W. L., et al., 2012, ApJ, 748, 123
  10. [108]Yao H. F. M., et al., 2020, ApJ, 903, 91
  11. [109]da Cunha E., Charlot S., Elbaz D., 2008, MNRAS, 388, 1595
  12. [110]de Jong J. T. A., et al., 2015, A&A, 582, A62

Paper details

vlnc:W_vfcudepm
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents