betaFeedback

WorksComputer Science

High-Precision Docking of Differential-Drive Mobile Robots Through LiDAR and Vision Collaboration

Abstract

Precise docking requires a differential-drive robot to correct lateral offset through coupled rotation and translation within a short approach distance. We combine global navigation with terminal control using complementary LiDAR and visual observations. A line fitted to the cabinet front gives normal distance and heading. An AprilTag identifies the workstation; intersecting its center ray with the LiDAR plane determines tangential position. Taught observations define the docking reference and can cancel repeatable fixed biases under unchanged mounting and geometry. Lateral pre-alignment and continuous visual servoing coordinate the approach, with predictive stopping to account for low-speed actuation lag. Across two sessions using the same navigation and docking code at five workstations on Robot 2, all 111 tasks completed, including 101 on the first attempt. Relative to the taught observations, onboard longitudinal, lateral and heading residual root-mean-square values were 1.51 mm, 5.93 mm and 0.238 degrees, respectively. Joint acceptance within plus or minus 10 mm per position axis and plus or minus 1 degree heading was 96.4% (107/111), or 95.5% (106/111) with a plus or minus 0.5 degree heading limit.

Introduction

A differential-drive robot cannot translate sideways. Millimeter-scale lateral alignment at a workstation must therefore be achieved through coupled rotation and translation, while the remaining distance for correction shrinks near the endpoint. Turning in place can introduce additional lateral slip. For food-service robots retrieving ingredients or operating equipment at cabinet fronts, the controller must align position and heading within a confined approach region. Reaching a nearby map goal does not by itself establish the required pose relative to the physical interface.

Simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM) [1], SLAM Toolbox [2], and Navigation2 [3] support travel between workstations, with local motion controlled through methods such as model predictive control [4] and regulated pure pursuit (RPP) [5]. Terminal docking also requires observations of the workstation. V-shaped features [6] and reflective markers [7] make LiDAR targets identifiable but require dedicated geometry or reflective material. Fitting a scan line to an ordinary cabinet front yields normal distance and heading. Translation along that surface leaves the line unchanged, so tangential position requires another reference. AprilTag [8, 9] identifies the workstation and establishes a visual position reference. Perspective-nn-point (PnP) methods, including infinitesimal plane-based pose estimation (IPPE) [10], estimate pose from planar image features; refined tag edges improve feature measurement [11]. As the projected tag shrinks with range, pixel perturbations propagate differently into lateral position and depth. We retain the tag-center bearing and intersect its ray with the LiDAR surface, assigning heading feedback to LiDAR.

We implement this allocation with a taught reference and a terminal controller on Robot 2. Across two sessions with the same navigation and docking code, all 111 tasks completed and 107 met a unified onboard feedback residual criterion of ±10\pm10 mm per position axis and ±1∘\pm1^\circ in heading. The contributions are:

  1. A local three-degree-of-freedom feedback construction that combines surface normal distance and heading with tag-based tangential position, including a taught zero-residual condition and distance-dependent compensation.

  1. A differential-drive docking controller that combines affine lateral pre-alignment, distance-scheduled steering, and predictive stopping.

  1. A workstation-level evaluation of 111 same-version tasks that distinguishes completion, first-attempt success, and residual acceptance.

Related Work

LiDAR Targets and Local Geometry

V-shaped features [6], intensity markers [7], and passive guides [19] make relative pose observable through identifiable workstation structure. Multistage localization also couples global positioning with scan matching in the docking region [15]. We fit an existing planar cabinet front using random sample consensus (RANSAC) [18] and orthogonal refinement to estimate normal distance and heading. The tag bearing resolves the remaining translation along the surface, avoiding the need for a dedicated workstation profile.

Visual Fiducials and Multisensor Docking

AprilTag detection and layout methods [8, 9, 20] and square fiducials under occlusion [25] enable workstation identification; planar pose estimation [10, 11] recovers pose from image features. Dual tags have also supported LiDAR localization [21], while camera calibration determines the pixel-to-ray mapping [24]. Docking systems have combined visual recognition with LiDAR [12, 13], or depth-aided tag localization with LiDAR heading correction [14]. We instead compute tangential position from the intersection of the tag-center ray and the LiDAR plane. PnP initializes the search region and gates range and reprojection quality; heading feedback comes from the fitted LiDAR line.

Taught References and Differential-Drive Control

Visual teach and repeat stores observations along a route [22]; visual servoing updates motion from desired image features or pose errors [16, 23]; smooth pose control addresses differential-drive motion constraints [17]. Dedicated calibration can correct systematic wheel and wheelbase errors [27]. We instead define a fixed workstation endpoint through taught observations, compensate range-dependent tangential drift during approach, and learn the gain and offset of lateral correction maneuvers from local measurements. The resulting controller targets endpoint reproduction and approach alignment. Table I summarizes the sensing requirements and reported measurements of representative docking systems.

Method

Each workstation has a visible vertical cabinet front, a uniquely identified AprilTag and a taught reference. Global navigation brings the robot into the approach region. Local control starts only after the target observation is verified and navigation has stopped, then proceeds through lateral pre-alignment and continuous approach (Figure 1). We write ATB{}^{A}T_{B} for the transform that maps coordinates from frame BB into frame AA; Table II defines the frames. Implementation settings are listed in Appendix A, with the experimental version identified in Section IV-B.

LiDAR–vision docking with a taught reference

Figure 1. LiDAR–vision docking with a taught reference. Finishing settings shown here correspond to the implementation revised on 3 November; § 4-B specifies the historical settings used in the primary experiments.

DOF Allocation and Ray–Plane Intersection

A fitted cabinet line determines normal distance and heading. Tangential position comes from the tag center. To align the observations, we transform the image and LiDAR observations into odometry frame OO at their respective acquisition times, applying a fixed image-time offset. RANSAC selects the dominant surface line near the initial tag position; orthogonal least squares then refines the fit. For inliers pip_i, centroid cc, and unit normal nn pointing toward the LiDAR, the objective is

min⁡c,n∑i∈I[nT(pi−c)]2,∥n∥=1(1)\min_{c,n}\sum_{i\in I}\left[n^{\mathsf{T}}(p_i-c)\right]^2,\qquad\lVert n\rVert=1 \tag*{(1)}

After normalizing infrared intensity, we detect the tag and refine its corners. The quadrilateral diagonals intersect at the tag center, whose undistorted homogeneous coordinates are u~=[u,v,1]T\tilde{u}=[u,v,1]^{\mathsf{T}}. Let KK be the camera intrinsic matrix and (ORC,OtC)({}^{O}R_{C},{}^{O}t_{C}) its pose in OO. We extend the fitted LiDAR line vertically to form a plane. The ray origin, direction, and intersection are

o=OtC,r=ORCK−1u~,o={}^{O}t_{C},\qquad r={}^{O}R_{C}K^{-1}\tilde{u},
λ=−nT(oxy−c)nTrxy,q=o+λr.(2)\lambda=-\frac{n^{\mathsf{T}}(o_{xy}-c)}{n^{\mathsf{T}}r_{xy}},\qquad q=o+\lambda r. \tag*{(2)}

The horizontal intersection sets the origin of surface frame FF. Its xx-axis points into the surface and its yy-axis points leftward along it. Backward or nearly plane-parallel rays are rejected, along with observations that fail identity, reprojection, fit-quality or temporal-continuity checks. We take heading from the LiDAR line and use PnP for initialization and quality gating. Depth is inherited from the fitted plane, not independently measured from the intersection.

Lateral error propagation

Let DD denote the camera-to-plane normal distance and β\beta the horizontal bearing relative to the plane normal. The tangential intersection is s=Dtan⁡βs=D\tan\beta, with first-order perturbation

δs=tan⁡β δD+Dsec⁡2β δβ.(3)\delta s=\tan\beta\,\delta D+D\sec^{2}\beta\,\delta\beta. \tag*{(3)}

For a local model with the camera optical axis normal to the surface, tan⁡β=(u−cx)/fx\tan\beta=(u-c_x)/f_x. With independent pixel, distance, and effective angular errors,

σs,ray2≃(D/fx)2σu2+tan⁡2β σD2+D2sec⁡4β σα2.(4)\sigma_{s,\mathrm{ray}}^{2}\simeq(D/f_x)^2\sigma_u^2+\tan^2\beta\,\sigma_D^2+D^2\sec^4\beta\,\sigma_\alpha^2. \tag*{(4)}

Here, σα\sigma_\alpha represents uncertainty in extrinsic yaw and plane-normal direction; correlated terms require their covariances. For a frontoparallel tag of side length LL and image width w≃fxL/Zw\simeq f_xL/Z, a local approximation to the depth sensitivity in PnP is

δZ≃−Z2fxL δw,\delta Z\simeq-\frac{Z^2}{f_xL}\,\delta w,
δsPnP≃ZfxL δu+u−cxfx δZ.(5)\delta s_{\mathrm{PnP}}\simeq\frac{Z}{f_xL}\,\delta u+\frac{u-c_x}{f_x}\,\delta Z. \tag*{(5)}

tbl:3 gives L=0.150 mL=0.150\ \mathrm{m} and a 640×400640\times400 image, so the depth sensitivity is Z2/(0.150fx)Z^2/(0.150f_x). Away from the principal point, the second term couples depth uncertainty into lateral position. Ray–plane intersection replaces this depth estimate with the LiDAR plane constraint. Near the principal point, both methods have the same leading pixel term, so their relative uncertainty depends on the remaining terms. A full IPPE/PnP comparison also requires corner correlations and orientation coupling.

We checked local propagation against early static records from Robot 2 at P5 on 22 October. The recorded intrinsics were fx=fy=196.691 pxf_x=f_y=196.691\ \mathrm{px} with principal point (320.529,198.852) px(320.529,198.852)\ \mathrm{px}. Fourteen valid stops contained 370 frames (15–30 per stop), with mean cabinet distances of 0.456–0.850 m. Within-stop sample standard deviations were 0.022–0.103 px for horizontal image position and 0.246–0.364 mm for normal distance. Plane-heading variability ranged from 0.048° to 0.074°, and tangential variability from 0.704 to 1.218 mm. For the full ray–plane mapping, let JJ be the local Jacobian and Σ\Sigma the sample covariance of z=(u,v,d,θ)z=(u,v,d,\theta). Retaining cross-covariances gives σs=\sigma_s= JΣJT=0.705\sqrt{J\Sigma J^{\mathsf T}} = 0.705–1.2211.221 mm. These static records measure short-term variability at fixed extrinsics, separately from the 111-task cohort of 2 November; systematic extrinsic bias remains outside this check.

MethodSensorsExtra hardware / targetReported result and measurement
V-shaped features [6]LiDARV-shaped workstation profileApprox. ±20\pm20 mm (x/yx/y), ±1∘\pm1^\circ; two-stage physical tests; independent instrument and RMSE not specified
Intensity markers [7]LiDAR, odometry, ultrasoundReflective markers200 trials per scenario; docking success 99.5% / 98.5%; charging-bar positions inspected; no terminal pose-error statistics
Jia et al. [13]Camera, LiDARVisually recognized charging stationNo terminal error reported; 95% is charging-station image recognition accuracy; Gazebo and Husky demonstrations
Dai and Lee [14]Camera, depth, LiDARAprilTagNo terminal error statistics; ruler used for pixel-to-3-D validation; docking convergence shown in Gazebo
This workIR camera, 2-D LiDAROrdinary cabinet front and fixed AprilTagOnboard planar residual root-mean-square error (RMSE) 6.12 mm; 111 taught-observation reproduction tasks

Table 1. Docking approaches and measurement scope. Metrics and test conditions differ across studies; values do not constitute a common-benchmark ranking.

SymbolDefinition
MGlobal map frame
OOdometry frame
BRobot body frame base_link
CInfrared camera frame
FWorkstation surface frame
GTaught goal frame
g=[gx,gy]⊤g = [g_x, g_y]^\top, φ\varphiGoal position and heading in B
e=[ex,ey]⊤e = [e_x, e_y]^\top, ψ\psiRobot position and heading in G

Table 2. Coordinate frames and principal notation.

Taught Zero-Residual Condition and Distance Compensation

Teaching starts with the robot at an acceptable docking pose. We average valid translations arithmetically and orientations circularly to obtain B∗TF^{B^*}T_F, where B∗B^* is the taught body frame. During approach, the tangential reading s(t)s(t) varies with surface distance d(t)d(t). A workstation-specific slope aja_j compensates this drift:

Δsj(t)=−aj[d(t)−dj∗],scorr(t)=s(t)+Δsj(t).(6)\begin{aligned} \Delta s_j(t) &= -a_j\left[d(t)-d_j^*\right],\\ s_{\mathrm{corr}}(t) &= s(t)+\Delta s_j(t). \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

Distance sweeps initialize aja_j; approach trajectories refine it after accounting for lateral motion and heading change. The current P1–P5 coefficients are +0.058, +0.069, −0.025, −0.028, −0.022 m/m. At the taught distance dj∗d_j^*, the compensation is zero. The goal frame GG represents the taught body pose, so (B∗TF)−1\left(^{B^*}T_F\right)^{-1} maps goal-frame coordinates into the surface frame. Applying the tangential correction there and then transforming into OO gives

OTG(t)=OTF(t)Trans⁡y(Δsj(t))(B∗TF)−1,BTG(t)=(OTB(t))−1OTG(t).(7)\begin{aligned} {}^{O}T_G(t) &= {}^{O}T_F(t)\operatorname{Trans}_y(\Delta s_j(t))\left({}^{B^*}T_F\right)^{-1},\\ {}^{B}T_G(t) &= \left({}^{O}T_B(t)\right)^{-1}{}^{O}T_G(t). \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

Here, Trans⁡y\operatorname{Trans}_y translates along the surface frame. At the taught pose, the current and taught observations coincide and compensation vanishes; the transform chain reduces to BTG=I{}^{B}T_G=I. Repeatable fixed biases can therefore cancel at this reference pose under unchanged mounting and geometry. Away from it, error scaling depends on ray direction and calibration.

Equation (3) also tests whether fixed yaw miscalibration can explain aja_j. Near normal incidence, with normal translation and consistent signs, a yaw error δα\delta\alpha produces a drift slope a≃tan⁡δαa \simeq\tan\delta\alpha. The five coefficients imply approximately +3.32°, +3.95°, −1.43°, −1.60°, −1.26°. One fixed yaw cannot explain both sign groups under this simplified model. Different viewing directions, plane fitting, and residual motion coupling require synchronized observations to separate. We therefore retain empirical workstation-specific coefficients without identifying them as measured camera–LiDAR extrinsic errors.

Lateral Allocation and Predictive Stopping

Before continuous approach, the robot aligns its heading to the LiDAR line. We then evaluate lateral error in the goal frame and use a turn–translate–realign maneuver for larger offsets. To account for the maneuver’s response, we fit Δy=ku+c\Delta y = ku+c to observed error removal Δy\Delta y and commanded lateral shift uu. A requested correction qq yields u=clip⁡((q−u=\operatorname{clip}((q- c/κc/\kappa; −umax⁡,umax⁡)-u_{\max}, u_{\max}). The gain kk scales the commanded shift; the offset cc accounts for displacement caused by turning. Learning windows and bounds are listed in Appendix A.

Continuous servoing converts body-frame goal pose (g,φ)(g,\varphi) into goal-frame robot error (e,ψ)(e,\psi), separating remaining forward distance ℓ\ell from lateral error:

[exey]=−R(φ)T[gxgy],ψ=wrap⁡(−φ),ℓ=−ex.(8)\begin{aligned} \begin{bmatrix} e_x \\ e_y \end{bmatrix} &= -R(\varphi)^{\mathsf{T}} \begin{bmatrix} g_x \\ g_y \end{bmatrix}, \\ \psi&= \operatorname{wrap}(-\varphi), \qquad\ell=-e_x. \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

Define clip⁡(z;a,b)=min⁡[b,max⁡(a,z)]\operatorname{clip}(z;a,b)=\min[b,\max(a,z)]. Lateral correction consumes forward travel: e˙y=vsin⁡ψ\dot{e}_y=v\sin\psi. As the remaining distance shrinks, we reduce the allowable steering angle and finally command a straight approach:

ψd={clip⁡(−ky(ey−ηj);−ψlim⁡,ψlim⁡),ℓ≥ℓstraight,0,ℓ<ℓstraight.(9)\psi_d = \begin{cases} \operatorname{clip}(-k_y(e_y-\eta_j);-\psi_{\lim},\psi_{\lim}), & \ell\ge\ell_{\mathrm{straight}},\\ 0, & \ell<\ell_{\mathrm{straight}}. \end{cases} \tag*{(9)}
ψlim⁡(ℓ)=min⁡[ψcap,max⁡(ψmin⁡,γℓ)](10)\psi_{\lim}(\ell)=\min\left[\psi_{\mathrm{cap}},\max(\psi_{\min},\gamma\ell)\right] \tag*{(10)}

Only P2 uses the lateral steering target ηj\eta_j to compensate reading drift over the final straight segment. Before that segment, steering corrects lateral offset; afterwards, the desired heading is zero. The gains kyk_y, kψk_\psi and kvk_v act on lateral, heading and distance errors. Steering limits are set by ψcap\psi_{\mathrm{cap}} and ωlim⁡\omega_{\lim}, while γ\gamma scales the heading bound with distance. The transition occurs at ℓstraight\ell_{\mathrm{straight}}. Velocity commands are

ω=clip⁡[kψ(ψd−ψ);−ωlim,ωlim],\omega= \operatorname{clip}\left[k_{\psi}(\psi_d-\psi);-\omega_{\mathrm{lim}},\omega_{\mathrm{lim}}\right],
v=max⁡[vmin⁡,min⁡(vmax⁡,kvℓ)].(11)v = \max\left[v_{\min},\min(v_{\max},k_v\ell)\right]. \tag*{(11)}

The robot continues moving briefly after a zero-velocity command. We estimate this travel from the preceding command vk−1v_{k-1} and stop when

ℓ<max⁡(ℓstop,vk−1τstop).(12)\ell< \max\left(\ell_{\mathrm{stop}},v_{k-1}\tau_{\mathrm{stop}}\right). \tag*{(12)}

Once the robot settles, fresh observations guide heading correction followed by longitudinal correction. Observation loss stops motion. If the endpoint fails acceptance and a retry is permitted, the robot retreats to the staging pose and approaches again. Acceptance uses the componentwise means of valid endpoint observations:

∣qˉx∣≤εj,∣qˉy∣≤εj,∣φˉ∣≤1∘(13)\lvert\bar{q}_x\rvert\le\varepsilon_j,\qquad\lvert\bar{q}_y\rvert\le\varepsilon_j,\qquad\lvert\bar{\varphi}\rvert\le1^\circ \tag*{(13)}

The operational gate εj\varepsilon_j is 10 mm at P1–P4 and 20 mm at P5; retrospective evaluation applies 10 mm per axis everywhere. P2 adds a LiDAR-guided advance after reaching the taught pose. Its final xx and heading are remeasured, while yy retains the pre-advance visual reading, forming a composite endpoint record. Appendix A gives versioned settings and sample requests; § 4-C defines the analysis fields.

Experimental Setup

Experimental Platform and Workstations

The experiments evaluated LiDAR–vision docking on Robot 2, a two-wheel differential-drive platform operating at five fixed workstations in the site_b environment. The workstations were arranged along two cabinet rows; P3–P5 shared one row. Each workstation carried a unique tag36h11 AprilTag (IDs 20–24; black-border side length 150 mm) and a taught docking reference. LiDAR supplied cabinet-normal distance and heading, while the infrared image from the left camera supplied the tag-center observation for along-surface positioning.

Thor executed global navigation, terminal perception and docking supervision; the ECU handled chassis actuation and sensor acquisition. The software used ROS 2 Jazzy, slam_toolbox localization and Nav2 with regulated pure pursuit. Table III lists the documented operating configuration. The image and odometry rates are observed operating rates rather than accuracy specifications.

ComponentConfiguration
Drive and odometryDifferential drive; wheel–IMU fusion, ≈98\approx98 Hz
LiDARLDS-E210-E; ≈15\approx15 Hz; 180∘180^\circ; 0.15∘0.15^\circ per beam
CamerasTwo Orbbec DaBai Max cameras; left IR 640×400640 \times400, ≈10\approx10 Hz
Tagstag36h11; 150 mm side; P1–P5 correspond to IDs 20–24
ComputingThor and ECU; gigabit Ethernet
SoftwareROS 2 Jazzy; slam_toolbox; Nav2 RPP

Table III. Docking platform configuration.

Trials were conducted at fixed indoor workstations with emergency-stop supervision; the Limitations section specifies the safety configuration.

Trial Protocol and Version Grouping

A trial consisted of a dispatched docking goal, any associated departure, coarse transfer, local alignment and final verification. Start and goal identifiers, task timestamps, terminal readings, attempt counts, return codes and log identifiers were retained. Trials followed operational routes rather than a randomized, balanced design. The primary analysis combined two sessions on 2 November 2026 that used the same navigation and docking code: nine trials after startup and 102 executed goals from the platform-driven pressure test. The latter also contained 29 requests rejected before motion because the requested route was prohibited. These requests were reported separately and excluded from the executed-trial denominator.

The cohort contained 111 unique logged trials: 27, 28, 28, 1 and 27 at P1–P5, respectively. The pressure-test route repeatedly visited P1, P2, P3 and P5; P4 appeared in the startup session. Earlier sessions and the 3 November speed revisions are reported separately in Table IV; their error distributions and session totals were not pooled with the primary cohort.

GroupRecordsRejectedExecutedCompleted
2 Nov startup9099
2 Nov pressure13129102102
28 Oct robustness2202218
28 Oct platform140148
30 Oct platform146965044
30 Oct stability2002018
3 Nov speed revision3603633

Table IV. Recorded trial groups.

The navigation and docking code remained unchanged during the primary cohort, while learned runtime state continued to update. This state includes staging offsets, lateral-action models, adjacent-transfer corrections and the P2 steering target. The cohort therefore evaluates online operation. On 2 November, the finishing heading target was 0.5∘0.5^\circ and final acceptance used 1∘1^\circ; the P2 final advance used 0.020.02 m/s with an 8 mm margin. The implementation in Figure 1 and Appendix A includes the later speed revisions.

Feedback Residuals and Acceptance Criteria

The control formulation distinguishes goal pose g,φg,\varphi in body frame B from robot error e,ψe,\psi in goal frame G, related by (8). Statistical tables retain the signs of the logged fields: B records at P1 and P3–P5 originate from the body-frame goal pose, whereas P2 uses post-advance LiDAR distance and heading with the pre-advance visual lateral reading. We call these fields onboard feedback residuals and retain their logged signs.

Record A is acquired after coarse transfer when lateral pre-alignment is assessed; LiDAR heading pre-alignment may already have occurred. Its lateral value is projected onto the goal approach line, and its longitudinal field is empty. Record B is the final task feedback. The stage plot compares distributions of absolute lateral readings from the same tasks to describe convergence within the workflow.

The evaluated quantities are onboard feedback residuals relative to the taught state. The unified criterion is ∣x∣≤10|x| \le10 mm, ∣y∣≤10|y| \le10 mm, and ∣heading∣≤1∘|\text{heading}| \le1^\circ, with an additional strict evaluation using a 0.5∘0.5^\circ heading limit. The former is a common-threshold retrospective evaluation of the historical records. Backend completion is counted by return code 0. Although P5 used a 20 mm operational position gate, the primary analysis applies 10 mm per axis at every workstation.

Statistical and Timing Analysis

Each executed task contributes one endpoint record. Signed feedback residuals are summarized per workstation by mean, sample standard deviation, and axis-wise RMSE. Recorded planar residual magnitude is x2+y2\sqrt{x^2+y^2}, from which planar RMSE, P95, and maximum are calculated; P95 uses linear interpolation. Separate limits on the two position axes define a rectangular acceptance region. Completion, first-attempt success, and residual acceptance are counted separately, with Wilson 95% intervals [26], [28]. P4 has n=1n = 1, so its standard deviation is undefined. Sequential tasks share the robot and learned state; the intervals describe counts in this cohort.

First-attempt success required a successful return and a logged attempts value of one; auxiliary actions within that attempt were allowed. Task duration used the recorded total, including a matched departure when available, and excluded waiting between separate upstream requests. Coarse and fine durations came from stage timestamps. For the stacked time plot, recovery/other was the total minus the recorded departure, coarse and fine durations, covering recovery, localization checks and other unassigned overhead. Four trials lacked a matched departure entry; their recorded departure contribution was zero without imputing an unobserved duration. Error bars represent the sample standard deviation of total task duration.

Results and Discussion

Repeated Task Completion and Residual Acceptance

All 111 executed tasks across the two same-version sessions returned completion, with a Wilson 95% interval of 96.7–100%. Of these, 101 completed in one recorded attempt, corresponding to 91.0% (84.2–95.0%). The unified onboard residual criterion of ±10\pm10 mm per position axis and ±1∘\pm1^\circ heading was met by 107 tasks, giving 96.4% (91.1–98.6%); 106/111 met the stricter 0.5∘0.5^\circ heading criterion. Table V and Table VI report workstation-level signed feedback, planar residuals, and task duration.

PointNAccepted (95% CI)x mean ±\pm SD (mm)y mean ±\pm SD (mm)Heading mean ±\pm SD (∘^\circ)
P12727/27 (87.5–100.0%)-1.68 ±\pm 0.97-0.00 ±\pm 6.04-0.17 ±\pm 0.19
P22828/28 (87.9–100.0%)-0.37 ±\pm 0.46-5.21 ±\pm 2.15-0.07 ±\pm 0.17
P32828/28 (87.9–100.0%)-1.23 ±\pm 0.92+4.24 ±\pm 3.66-0.13 ±\pm 0.25
P411/1 (20.7–100.0%)-2.20 / —+5.89 / —-0.06 / —
P52723/27 (67.5–94.1%)-1.38 ±\pm 0.90+1.67 ±\pm 6.49-0.17 ±\pm 0.16
All111107/111 (91.1–98.6%)-1.17 ±\pm 0.96+0.21 ±\pm 5.95-0.14 ±\pm 0.20

Table V. Final recorded feedback residuals by workstation. P2 uses the composite endpoint record defined in § 4-C.

PointOne attemptRMSE (mm)P95 (mm)Maximum (mm)Time mean ±\pm SD (s)
P126/276.248.6010.2744.4 ±\pm 12.8
P228/285.658.619.5652.3 ±\pm 8.4
P321/285.768.479.1562.2 ±\pm 25.7
P41/16.286.286.2836.4 / —
P525/276.7911.3514.8646.7 ±\pm 13.6
All101/1116.129.9714.8651.4 ±\pm 17.6

Table VI. Recorded planar residual magnitude and task duration.

All records at P1–P3 met the unified residual criterion, as did the single P4 record. P5 met it in 23/27 trials; its four exceptions were confined to lateral residuals of 10.45–14.80 mm, with normal and heading residuals within the common limits. These four tasks completed under P5’s 20 mm operational position gate but exceeded the 10 mm threshold used for comparison across workstations.

Feedback Convergence with Complementary Observations

The final recorded planar residual RMSE was 6.12 mm, with P95 of 9.97 mm and a maximum of 14.86 mm. The x, y, and heading RMSE values were 1.51 mm, 5.93 mm, and 0.238∘0.238^\circ, respectively. Lateral residuals accounted for 93.9% of the planar sum of squares. We therefore regard lateral alignment as the main remaining control challenge: a differential-drive base must spend forward travel to correct this component. Figure 2 plots the endpoint residuals and the lateral readings before and after terminal control.

Recorded onboard feedback residuals

Figure 2. Recorded onboard feedback residuals (n=111n = 111). (a) Signed final position readings and the ±10\pm10 mm box. (b) Heading distribution and ±1∘\pm1^\circ band; P4 has n=1n = 1. (c) Cumulative distributions of absolute lateral readings at stages A and B for the same tasks; § 4-C defines the fields and coordinate conventions.

Across the 111 tasks, median absolute lateral readings were 10.60 mm at stage A and 5.03 mm in the final B records.

Task Duration and Recovery Behavior

The recorded task duration averaged 51.4±17.651.4 \pm17.6 s, with a median of 47.7 s. Among workstations with repeated trials, P1 had the shortest mean duration (44.4 s), while P3 had the longest (62.2 s) and the greatest variability (SD, 25.7 s; Table VI). The stage decomposition in Figure 3 places these differences in the full operating cycle, including departure, coarse navigation, fine alignment and recovery or other overhead. Because the routes and approach conditions differed across workstations, these totals characterize operational task time rather than a controlled comparison of servo speed.

Figure 3. Mean recorded duration by workstation. Segments represent recorded departure, coarse navigation, fine alignment and residual recovery/other overhead. Bars at the total-duration endpoints show one sample standard deviation. P4 has n=1n = 1 and no estimated standard deviation. All 111 trials, including the 158.7 s startup-localization case, are retained.

All ten tasks with two attempts ultimately completed: seven at P3, two at P5, and one at P1. At P3, lateral gate exceedance triggered all seven retries, with first-endpoint absolute residuals of 12.38–68.19 mm; longitudinal and heading readings remained within the common limits. Six lateral readings were negative and one was positive. Six recovery records included lateral pre-alignment; one did not trigger it after retreat. The longest task, 158.7 s, also included startup tag-based relocalization. Repeated approaches and associated overhead increased P3 cycle time, whereas P5 final lateral exceedances remained within its relaxed operational gate.

Workstation Biases and Their Interpretation

The longitudinal feedback mean was −1.17-1.17 mm, with a negative mean at all five workstations. The sign has different meanings across records: P1 and P3–P5 store body-frame goal readings, whereas P2 stores a surface-distance difference. It must therefore be interpreted using the corresponding frame and measurement definition before drawing conclusions about physical overshoot.

Mean lateral residuals of −5.21-5.21 mm at P2 and +4.24+4.24 mm at P3 partly cancel in the pooled mean of +0.21+0.21 mm. The near-zero pooled value masks workstation-specific offsets. We retain P2’s composite endpoint record to report the feedback available during operation. Its lateral value precedes the final advance, so we interpret it as workflow feedback rather than a simultaneous measurement of final pose. P3 records include updates to the lateral-action model. Predictive stopping, final pulses, turning motion, the taught reference and calibration can affect endpoint readings; their contributions remain unresolved in these aggregate records. Figure 4 shows variation across the two same-day sessions in task order.

Figure 4. Final recorded feedback residuals across two sessions on the same day: (a) longitudinal, (b) lateral, and (c) heading. The dotted boundary separates nine startup-session tasks from 102 pressure-test tasks. The horizontal axis is task order, and shaded bands indicate the common thresholds.

Limitations

Independent physical endpoint accuracy was not measured; the reported residuals compare onboard feedback with taught observations. The trials cover one site and two sessions on one day, with a single P4 record. Sequential tasks share the robot, and learned runtime state continued to update. P2’s composite endpoint lacks a visual lateral measurement after the final advance, while stage A/B readings differ in frame and timing. A simultaneous external pose measurement at the final stop would resolve whether the recorded residuals track physical alignment, particularly at P2.

RPP collision checking and active collision_monitor polygons were disabled under emergency-stop supervision, so completion rate does not quantify unattended operating safety. The evaluation concerns the integrated workflow; attributing gains to individual modules would require a Nav2-only comparison or module ablations.

Conclusion

A fitted cabinet line leaves translation along the surface unobserved. We resolve that component with the tag-center bearing and use the resulting local feedback to guide lateral pre-alignment and continuous visual servoing. All 111 tasks using the same navigation and docking code completed, including 101 on the first attempt. Onboard longitudinal, lateral and heading residual RMSE values were 1.51 mm, 5.93 mm and 0.238°, with 96.4% joint residual acceptance within ±10\pm10 mm per axis and ±1∘\pm1^\circ heading. An ordinary cabinet front and a fixed tag thus form the local reference for repeated docking at the taught workstation pose.

Implementation Parameters

Table VII summarizes key operating settings after the 3 November revisions. § 4-B gives the settings used for the 2 November primary cohort.

ItemValue
Image offset / matching0.055 / 0.30 s
Staging setbackb=0.30b = 0.30 m
Control rate10 Hz
Heading floor / slope2∘2^\circ; 100π/180100\pi/180 rad/m
Predictive stoppingℓstop=4\ell_{\mathrm{stop}} = 4 mm; τstop=0.35\tau_{\mathrm{stop}} = 0.35 s
Observation age / outage0.6 / 3 s
Approach timeout / travel40 s / 2.0 m
Operational position gateP1–P4: 10 mm; P5: 20 mm

Table VII. Key operating settings

Localization, Handover, and Pre-Alignment

Global localization uses the occupancy grid and pose graph stored by SLAM Toolbox [2]. A stationary LiDAR scan is aligned to the map through distance-field search and local pose refinement, followed by localization verification. Historical poses, manual hints, or tag-derived hints assist candidate selection in geometrically ambiguous scenes. Before the first docking task after each system boot, the controller checks localization against an observed workstation tag. It searches by rotation when necessary and initializes localization again if the discrepancy exceeds 0.25 m or 10∘10^\circ. Failure to obtain a valid tag-based check prevents departure.

Path tracking uses the Regulated Pure Pursuit controller [5]. Let (xj,yj,θj)(x_j, y_j, \theta_j) denote the taught docking goal for workstation jj in the map frame. The staging pose is defined as

\begin{bmatrix} x_s \\ y_s \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} x_j \\ y_j \end{bmatrix} -b \begin{bmatrix} \cos\theta_j \\ \sin\theta_j \end{bmatrix} +o_j \begin{bmatrix} -\sin\theta_j \\ \cos\theta_j \end{bmatrix}, \qquad \theta_s=\theta_j . \tag*{(14)}\end{bmatrix}

Here, b=0.30b = 0.30 m is the backward offset along the goal heading. The lateral offset ojo_j is learned separately for each workstation from its observed arrival offset. Successive estimates receive equal weights of 0.5, and the stored offset is limited to ±0.15\pm0.15 m.

Early handover requires a remaining Nav2 path distance below 0.15 m after a previous feedback value has exceeded 0.20 m, excluding an initial zero-distance report. The selected tag must have been received within 0.4 s, goal-frame lateral error must be within 50 mm, heading within 6∘6^\circ, odometry angular speed within 0.1 rad/s, and remaining forward distance within 0.12–0.40 m.

Cancellation must finish before local motion begins. The controller then requires odometry newer than 0.3 s, speeds below 0.01 m/s and 0.02 rad/s, and no navigation velocity command within the preceding 0.5 s. These conditions must persist for 0.3 s. If early visual handover is unavailable, a remaining-path threshold of 0.06 m permits a separately controlled final heading turn, subject to clearance checks.

Before continuous approach, LiDAR heading alignment precedes evaluation of lateral error in the goal frame, avoiding heading-induced contamination of body-frame lateral readings. Lateral pre-alignment is triggered above 15 mm at workstations 1 and 3, and above 30 mm at workstations 2, 4, and 5. A turn–translate–realign maneuver moves the robot toward the approach line when the observed turning region and translation corridor permit.

Pre-alignment compensates for turning-induced displacement with a workstation-specific affine model relating commanded lateral shift to measured error removal. The command subtracts the fitted offset from the required correction and divides by the fitted gain, with magnitude limited to 0.25 m. A least-squares fit uses up to 20 recent maneuvers and becomes active after four samples. The gain is bounded to 0.5–1.3 and the offset to ±80\pm80 mm. When command span is below 30 mm, gain is fixed at 0.85 and only the offset is fitted. Before enough samples are available, a bounded multiplicative gain is used.

Configured adjacent-workstation transfers reduce repeated global planning. The 1→2 transfer uses a reverse arc of radius 0.225 m after retreating to its start position. The 2→3 transfer retreats approximately 0.52 m and turns approximately 88∘88^\circ; the 3→4 transfer translates along the shared surface after reorientation. Transfer distances derive from workstation geometry and stored corrections. Each transfer is followed by local observation, pre-alignment when necessary, and the same terminal servo controller.

Observation Gating and Teaching

Relative pose estimation uses the cabinet geometry seen by LiDAR and the tag bearing seen by the camera. The sensors are asynchronous. We assign each image an effective acquisition time tc=timg−Δtt_c = t_{\mathrm{img}} - \Delta t, with Δt=0.055\Delta t = 0.055 s, and select the nearest LiDAR scan within 0.30 s. Each observation is transformed into odometry frame OO at its own acquisition time. This aligns frames using the fixed image offset and robot motion; individual LiDAR beams are not deskewed.

LiDAR points within 0.60 m of the initial tag position form the candidate surface region. RANSAC [18] uses 200 candidate point pairs and a 10 mm inlier threshold, followed by three orthogonal least-squares refinement iterations. Let II denote the retained inlier set and pip_i a LiDAR point. The fitted line has centroid cc and unit normal nn, with the objective in (1).

The normal points toward the LiDAR. Refinement uses a 20 mm residual threshold and a window extending 0.35 m on either side of the projected tag position. A valid fit requires at least 60 inliers, a segment length of at least 0.55 m, and a root-mean-square residual no greater than 8 mm.

OpenCV detects tag36h11 AprilTags [8] in infrared images after intensity normalization using the 1st and 99.5th percentiles. AprilTag corner refinement follows detection, with a local search around the previous tag position and full-image search if needed. IPPE [10] provides the initial tag pose and reprojection residual. The Robot 2 configuration accepts estimated tag ranges of 0.12–1.50 m and reprojection errors no greater than 3.5 pixels. Tangential position is then determined by ray–plane intersection.

To teach a target, we collect surface observations with the robot at the desired pose. A teaching request collects 200 usable frames by default. Translation is averaged arithmetically and orientation circularly, yielding B∗TFB^{*}T_{F}, where B* is the taught body frame. We also store mean normal distance, tangential position, tag identity and observation variability. In ray mode, standard deviation must stay within 1 mm for normal distance and each tag-position component, and within 0.05∘0.05^\circ for surface orientation. Held-tag frames and ambiguous detections are excluded. Tag-orientation variability is recorded but does not gate ray-mode teaching.

Goal estimates are rejected when consecutive odometry-frame targets differ by more than 20 mm or 1∘1^\circ. During brief tag loss, perception can retain the last valid tag position in odometry for up to 1 s while updating the surface from LiDAR. Compensation for a retained tag uses the surface distance at its last actual detection. These frames are marked as held-tag observations and are excluded from teaching, continuous visual control, and terminal visual acceptance.

Continuous Servoing and Endpoint Sampling

The initial lateral offset selects the steering schedule. Below 40 mm, the lateral gain is 12 rad/m, the heading cap is 10∘10^\circ, and the far-field angular-velocity limit is 0.06 rad/s. Otherwise, these values are 7 rad/m, 18∘18^\circ, and 0.10 rad/s. Within 0.10 m, the angular-velocity limit becomes 0.04 rad/s. The heading gain is 1.2 s−1^{-1}, the distance gain is 0.4 s−1^{-1}, and the minimum forward speed is 0.012 m/s. Maximum speed is 0.05 m/s at workstations 1–4 and 0.06 m/s at workstation 5. During the last 80 mm, the desired heading becomes zero, so lateral steering gives way to heading alignment.

The lateral steering target ηj\eta_j compensates for repeatable reading drift over the final straight segment. It is enabled only at workstation 2. After an accepted visual approach, the measured lateral drift from straight-segment entry to the taught endpoint updates the opposite steering offset with weight 0.5. The update is skipped if entry heading exceeds 3∘3^\circ or drift exceeds 15 mm, and the offset is limited to ±12\pm12 mm. This correction is separate from the distance-dependent observation compensation in (6).

Here, the preceding linear-velocity command determines the predicted stopping distance, with ℓstop=4\ell_{\mathrm{stop}} = 4 mm and τstop=0.35\tau_{\mathrm{stop}} = 0.35 s. After stopping, up to four adjustment rounds target 3 mm longitudinal error and 1∘1^\circ heading error. Each round first requests five valid observations. Heading error is corrected before longitudinal error; longitudinal correction uses 0.01 m/s pulses lasting 0.15–1.5 s. Pulse gain adapts to LiDAR-measured displacement and is bounded between 0.3 and 2.0. The pulse loop targets a remaining displacement within 1 mm. At workstation 2, longitudinal adjustment at the taught pose is skipped when its error is already within 10 mm, because the subsequent advance sets the final distance.

The continuous controller uses actual-tag observations received within 0.6 s. Without such observations, it commands zero velocity and waits; an outage exceeding 3 s ends the approach attempt. Each attempt also has a 40 s servo timeout and a 2.0 m cumulative travel limit. The deployed task controller allows one servo pass per invocation. If the endpoint fails acceptance and a retry is permitted, the robot retreats to the staging distance, performs lateral pre-alignment with an 8 mm threshold, and makes one further pass. Missing target observations after navigation can also trigger tag-based relocalization before another approach.

Terminal visual readings average the longitudinal, lateral and heading components of valid observations from the selected workstation. Held-tag frames are excluded. A settled five-frame reading from the final adjustment is used directly when it meets the adjustment targets. Otherwise, the controller requests eight observations within 4 s. If fewer arrive, the nonempty partial sample is retained and its actual count is recorded.

At workstation 2, acceptance at the taught pose is followed by LiDAR-guided advance toward a target surface distance of 0.3772 m. The robot advances at 0.04 m/s toward a point 12 mm short of that distance, with predictive braking, then applies adaptive pulses targeting 1 mm residual. After this motion, ten LiDAR scans are requested; componentwise medians of valid surface fits remeasure distance and heading. The final longitudinal residual is measured surface distance minus 0.3772 m; the heading residual is measured surface orientation minus its taught value. Because the tag is no longer visible at this close endpoint, the lateral component retains its pre-advance visual reading. These final components are checked again against the workstation thresholds, while the visual-pose record is retained separately.

State Consistency and Startup Checks

The docking backend connects to upstream scheduling through standard DockRobot and UndockRobot actions. At task start, it checks the stored state again: odometry displacement beyond 50 mm, rotation beyond 5∘5^\circ, or a map-position discrepancy exceeding 0.35 m from the recorded workstation invalidates that state and triggers planning from the current pose. Undocking motion requires confirmation of the corresponding workstation. A stop signal commands zero velocity before terminating the active action, providing a definite terminal state to the scheduler.

Startup checks include both localization availability and data-link availability. A link-check service attempts Ethernet renegotiation when the link rate falls below gigabit speed, followed by verification of infrared-image reception; this recovery action addresses link-negotiation faults. The system checks gigabit networking, infrared-image reception, and intercomputer clock offset, with the boot script waiting for an ECU–Thor difference below 50 ms; a timeout is logged as a warning and startup continues. The first task after boot then verifies map localization against tag identity and pose. This check identifies geometric matching ambiguities in symmetric scenes and returns a failure state when trustworthy observations are unavailable.

References

  1. [1]C. Cadena et al., “Past, Present, and Future of Simultaneous Localization and Mapping: Toward the Robust-Perception Age,” IEEE Trans. Robot., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 1309–1332, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1109/tro.2016.2624754
  2. [2]S. Macenski, and I. Jambrec̆ić, “SLAM Toolbox: SLAM for the dynamic world,” J. Open Source Softw., vol. 6, no. 61, Art. no. 2783, 2021. https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.02783
  3. [3]S. Macenski, F. Martín, R. White, and J. G. Clavero, “The Marathon 2: A Navigation System,” in Proc. IEEE/RSJ Int. Conf. Intell. Robots Syst. (IROS), 2020, pp. 2718–2725. https://doi.org/10.1109/iros45743.2020.9341207
  4. [4]G. Williams, P. Drews, B. Goldfain, J. M. Rehg, and E. A. Theodorou, “Information-Theoretic Model Predictive Control: Theory and Applications to Autonomous Driving,” IEEE Trans. Robot., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1603–1622, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1109/tro.2018.2865891
  5. [5]S. Macenski, S. Singh, F. Martín, and J. Ginés, “Regulated pure pursuit for robot path tracking,” Auton. Robots, vol. 47, no. 6, pp. 685–694, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10514-023-10097-6
  6. [6]S. Ç. Tekkök, B. Costanci, M. E. Söyünmez, and P. Oğuz Ekim, “A Novel Docking Algorithm Based On The LiDAR And The V-shape Features,” Eur. J. Sci. Technol., no. 26, pp. 35–40, 2021. https://doi.org/10.31590/ejosat.947521
  7. [7]Y. Liu, “A Laser Intensity Based Autonomous Docking Approach for Mobile Robot Recharging in Unstructured Environments,” IEEE Access, vol. 10, pp. 71165–71176, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2022.3188099
  8. [8]E. Olson, “AprilTag: A robust and flexible visual fiducial system,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Robot. Autom. (ICRA), 2011, pp. 3400–3407. https://doi.org/10.1109/icra.2011.5979561
  9. [9]J. Wang, and E. Olson, “AprilTag 2: Efficient and robust fiducial detection,” in Proc. IEEE/RSJ Int. Conf. Intell. Robots Syst. (IROS), 2016, pp. 4193–4198. https://doi.org/10.1109/iros.2016.77597617
  10. [10]T. Collins, and A. Bartoli, “Infinitesimal Plane-Based Pose Estimation,” Int. J. Comput. Vis., vol. 109, no. 3, pp. 252–286, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11263-014-0725-5
  11. [11]J. H. Richter, D. Bohlig, A. Nüchter, and K. Schilling, “Advanced Edge Detection of AprilTags for Precise Docking Maneuvers of Mobile Robots,” IFAC-PapersOnLine, vol. 55, no. 8, pp. 117–123, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ifacol.2022.08.020
  12. [12]R. C. Luo, C. T. Liao, and S. C. Lin, “Multi-sensor fusion for reduced uncertainty in autonomous mobile robot docking and recharging,” in Proc. IEEE/RSJ Int. Conf. Intell. Robots Syst. (IROS), 2009, pp. 2203–2208. https://doi.org/10.1109/iros.2009.5354445
  13. [13]F. Jia, M. A. Afaq, B. Ripka, O. Huda, and R. Ahmad, “Vision- and Lidar-Based Autonomous Docking and Recharging of a Mobile Robot for Machine Tending in Autonomous Manufacturing Environments,” Appl. Sci., vol. 13, no. 19, Art. no. 10675, 2023. https://doi.org/10.3390/app131910675
  14. [14]Y. Dai, and K. Lee, “Multi-Sensor Fusion for Autonomous Mobile Robot Docking: Integrating LiDAR, YOLO-Based AprilTag Detection, and Depth-Aided Localization,” Electronics, vol. 14, no. 14, Art. no. 2769, 2025. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics14142769
  15. [15]A. Yılmaz, and H. Temeltas, “A multi-stage localization framework for accurate and precise docking of autonomous mobile robots (AMRs),” Robotica, vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1885–1908, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0263574724000602
  16. [16]F. Chaumette, and S. Hutchinson, “Visual servo control. I. Basic approaches,” IEEE Robot. Autom. Mag., vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 82–90, 2006. https://doi.org/10.1109/mra.2006.250573
  17. [17]J. J. Park, and B. Kuipers, “A smooth control law for graceful motion of differential wheeled mobile robots in 2D environment,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Robot. Autom. (ICRA), 2011, pp. 4896–4902. https://doi.org/10.1109/icra.2011.5980167
  18. [18]M. A. Fischler, and R. C. Bolles, “Random sample consensus: a paradigm for model fitting with applications to image analysis and automated cartography,” Commun. ACM, vol. 24, no. 6, pp. 381–395, 1981. https://doi.org/10.1145/358669.358692
  19. [19]M. Kutan, and H. Çiğ, “A Multi-Stage 2D LiDAR-Based Reactive Docking Framework for Precision Alignment of Industrial Autonomous Mobile Robots,” Dicle Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi Mühendislik Dergisi, vol. 17, no. 3, 2026. https://doi.org/10.24012/dumf.1938367
  20. [20]M. Krogius, A. Haggenmiller, and E. Olson, “Flexible Layouts for Fiducial Tags,” in Proc. IEEE/RSJ Int. Conf. Intell. Robots Syst. (IROS), 2019, pp. 1898–1903. https://doi.org/10.1109/iros40897.2019.8967787
  21. [21]Y. H. Huang, and C. T. Lin, “Indoor Localization Method for a Mobile Robot Using LiDAR and a Dual AprilTag,” Electronics, vol. 12, no. 4, Art. no. 1023, 2023. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics12041023
  22. [22]P. Furgale, and T. D. Barfoot, “Visual teach and repeat for long-range rover autonomy,” J. Field Robot., vol. 27, no. 5, pp. 534–560, 2010. https://doi.org/10.1002/rob.20342
  23. [23]F. Chaumette, and S. Hutchinson, “Visual servo control. II. Advanced approaches,” IEEE Robot. Autom. Mag., vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 109–118, 2007. https://doi.org/10.1109/mra.2007.339609
  24. [24]Z. Zhang, “A flexible new technique for camera calibration,” IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell., vol. 22, no. 11, pp. 1330–1334, 2000. https://doi.org/10.1109/34.888718
  25. [25]S. Garrido-Jurado, R. Muñoz-Salinas, F. J. Madrid-Cuevas, and M. J. Marín-Jiménez, “Automatic generation and detection of highly reliable fiducial markers under occlusion,” Pattern Recognit., vol. 47, no. 6, pp. 2280–2292, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.patcog.2014.01.005
  26. [26]L. D. Brown, T. T. Cai, and A. DasGupta, “Interval Estimation for a Binomial Proportion,” Statist. Sci., vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 101–133, 2001. https://doi.org/10.1214/ss/1009213286
  27. [27]J. Borenstein, and L. Feng, “Measurement and correction of systematic odometry errors in mobile robots,” IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom., vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 869–880, 1996. https://doi.org/10.1109/70.544770
  28. [28]E. B. Wilson, “Probable Inference: the Law of Succession, and Statistical Inference,” J. Amer. Statist. Assoc., vol. 22, no. 158, pp. 209–212, 1927. https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.1927.10502953

Paper details

vlnc:W_vh4rmtsr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Computer Science

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents