WorksMathematics
Algebraic matroids with non-algebraic duals exist in any positive characteristic
Abstract
We show that for every field of positive characteristic there exists an algebraic matroid over such that the dual matroid is not algebraic over any field. Our conceptual proof relies on the theory of matroids over one-dimensional algebraic groups. As an application, we deduce that the classes of supports of realizable volume polynomials and of realizable covolume polynomials differ in positive characteristic.
Introduction
Matroids were introduced by Whitney [Whi35] to put the similar properties of subsets of linearly independent vectors and trees in a graph into an abstract combinatorial framework. It was already noted earlier by van der Waerden that algebraically independent subsets in a field extension satisfy the same axioms [22]. Concretely, let be a matroid with a finite ground set and a rank function , see e.g. [19].
Definition 1.1. A matroid is algebraic over a field if there exists a field extension and for such that for all it holds that
Here, denotes the transcendence degree over and is the smallest subfield of containing and . Hence, is independent in , that is , if and only if the set is algebraically independent over .
If a matroid is representable over some field , it is also algebraic over . Lindström showed in [13] that being algebraic over depends only on the characteristic of . In characteristic 0, every algebraic matroid over is representable over a field extension of [11]. In positive characteristic however, Ingleton described a matroid on 11 elements of rank 3 which is algebraic over and has both the Fano and non-Fano matroids as restrictions; hence it is not representable over any field. It was only shown in 1975 that not all matroids are algebraic: Ingleton and Main proved that the Vámos matroid is not algebraic over any field [10].
In general, algebraic matroids are far less understood than linearly representable matroids. It was recently shown by Boege and Yashfe [5] that the problem of recognizing whether a given matroid is algebraic is undecidable. Algebraic matroids respect several prominent matroid operations. The class of algebraic matroids over a field is closed under taking minors, truncations, principal extensions, matroid unions, and matroid intersections [8, 15].
Recall that the dual of a matroid is the matroid on the same ground set with bases the complements of bases of . This notion is for instance motivated by the orthogonal complement of a vector space and by plane graph duality, since for a planar graph , where is the graphic matroid of a graph . Whether the dual of an algebraic matroid is again algebraic in general was recently answered negatively by Larson and Le [14]. However, their counterexample only works over a field of characteristic 2 and the proof relies on a computer calculation. Inspired by their counterexample, we construct counterexamples over every field of positive characteristic and give a conceptual proof. For this we use generalizations of the Fano and non-Fano matroids, called the Lazarson matroid and the non-Lazarson matroid over . Let be algebraically independent over . Then is represented by
where and . is represented by
where and . We show that every algebraic realization of the dual matroids and is algebraically equivalent to a realization over a one-dimensional algebraic group: over for , and over or an elliptic curve for . It follows that every algebraic matroid obtained by gluing and along a common basis is the intersection of and , each extended by coloops. Dually, is the union of and , each extended by loops. We then construct an algebraic matroid that has both and as contractions but is not such a union. Therefore the dual of is not algebraic over any field.
Theorem 1.2 (Theorem 6.2). Over any field of positive characteristic there is an algebraic matroid over such that the dual matroid is not algebraic over any field.
Aluffi [1] introduced the notion of covolume polynomials which were further developed in [8]. Matroids whose set of bases forms the support of some multiaffine realizable covolume polynomial over a field are exactly those matroids whose dual is an algebraic matroid over . To any covolume polynomial over we can associate a volume polynomial over by generalizing matroid duality.
Theorem 1.3 (Theorem 7.3). Let be a field of positive characteristic. There exists a realizable covolume polynomial over such that the support of is not the support of any realizable volume polynomial.
AI disclosure
AI disclosure. LLMs were used for proofreading and editing. Claude Opus 5 and 5.5 assisted us in finding the statement and the proof of Theorem 3.3.
Acknowledgements
The author thanks Giles Gardam, June Huh and Lukas Kühne for the many insightful discussions on algebraic matroids. The author was supported by the SPP 2458 ”Combinatorial Synergies”.
Matroids over one-dimensional groups
Throughout the whole article let be an algebraically closed field of positive characteristic and an algebraically closed field extending of infinite transcendence degree over .
We will use the theory of matroids over a connected one-dimensional algebraic group over first described by Evans and Hrushovski [7] and further developed in [2]. An algebraic group is said to be connected if it is irreducible. All algebraic groups appearing in this article will be connected. Let denote the endomorphism ring of . This is a possibly non-commutative ring without zero divisors and an Ore domain. Let be the corresponding division ring of . In all the commutative algebraic groups appearing we denote the addition with . For more on algebraic groups see [17]. There are the following equivalent definitions for a matroid over a one-dimensional group:
Definition 2.1. (a) Given a closed connected subgroup of of dimension . We write for the matroid whose independent sets are all the sets such that the projection of to is all of .
(b) Given a homomorphism of algebraic groups . Then is encoded by a matrix . Let be the matroid defined by the (left) row space of over .
(c) Given a generic -point . The image gives points . We denote with the algebraic matroid realized by those points.
I.e. we have . The equivalence of (a) and (b) follows from [2], Theorem 1.1 and the equivalence of (a) and (c) is easy to see. For any we write for the algebraic closure of . Here and corresponds to a point together with an embedding ; let be its image.
The one-dimensional algebraic groups over are completely classified. Such a group is either the additive group over , the multiplicative group over or an elliptic curve over . See [4], Theorem III.10.9 for a classification of affine connected one-dimensional algebraic groups. Thus the possible endomorphism rings are understood quite well. The endomorphism ring of or an elliptic curve has characteristic 0 while the endomorphism ring of has the same characteristic as . Matroids over one-dimensional groups share several properties with linear matroids over fields. For example, they can always be extended modularly.
Lemma 2.2. Let be a one-dimensional group over with endomorphism ring and division ring . For any generic and any write . If we are given such that the (left) -spans and have dimension and and has dimension , then is spanned by some $w_1,\ldots,w_k \in E^d
and the points are generic and independent with
Proof. We get the through the dimension formula for left vector spaces over . As matroids over are equivalent to algebraic matroids over the statement follows. □
We state some properties of algebraic groups which we will need later.
Lemma 2.3. Let be a connected one-dimensional algebraic group over .
(a) The action of any preserves the closure of a point . We have
(b) Let be a commutative connected algebraic group. For subvarieties we write . Let be closed and irreducible and . If , then and .
(c) If is either an elliptic curve or , then every connected closed subgroup of is a product where is a subgroup of and is a subgroup of .
Proof. (a) Consider the composition of morphisms . We get and as defines an isogeny the extension is finite. Hence .
(b) is irreducible and is the image under the morphism . Hence is also irreducible. For any we have and . With both varieties being closed and irreducible it follows for every . For we now get
and with that . It follows and .
(c) The statement is standard. Let be a closed connected subgroup of . For it follows from the unique decomposition of into a product of a unipotent subgroup and a subgroup of multiplicative type, see [17 Theorem 16.13]. For an elliptic curve it follows from the Rosenlicht decomposition, see [16 Theorem 6.2] and [21], that in an affine and anti-affine group. Here and . As these intersect trivially, we get the wanted result with and . □
To study the algebraic independence of elements in a field extension geometrically, we define the following:
Definition 2.4. Let be a variety over and be an -point. We call the irreducible closed subvariety
the locus of .
Lemma 2.5. Let be varieties over and an -point.
(a) .
(b) If is a morphism over , then .
(c) If we are given several points in varieties over and , then the locus splits as a product of loci, i.e. .
Proof. (a) The dimension of is just the transcendence degree of the residue field of its generic point. This is . (b) is closed and contains . Hence . The other inclusion follows by continuity. (c) We set . With (b) we get . Both sides are now irreducible and of the same dimension, hence we get an equality.
In Section 5.3 we glue together different realizations of the matroid of the complete graph on four vertices. For this we will need the following proposition which is a variant of [7], Theorem 2.2.2.
Proposition 2.6. Let be one-dimensional algebraic groups over . If for and we have
and are algebraically independent,
and ,
.
Then there is a closed connected one-dimensional subgroup and points such that there are constants with
Here are just the coordinate projections of . In addition and are isogenous.
Proof. Set . Set , , and , then and are irreducible curves in which dominate both factors with Lemma 2.5b. Using Lemma 2.5c follows in ; hence with Lemma 2.5b. Furthermore (1) and (3) give us . By Lemma 2.3b follows and . Set . By translating with some points , we get by using that and are irreducible
With follows and . The image of an algebraic group under a homomorphism is closed and dominates both factors; hence and . The kernels are zero-dimensional and hence finite, therefore and are isogenous through . The points are now and .
Intersecting matroids over division rings
An important operation on matroids in this article will be the intersection of matroids. The operation is defined in a purely combinatorial way. For two linear matroids over a common field the intersection is still linear over a sufficiently large extension of that field and for algebraic matroids the intersection is algebraic over the same field. Two matroids algebraic over the same field can however be linear over fields or division rings of different characteristic. This is the situation we need to understand. The dual notion of intersecting matroids is the union of matroids. The operations are defined in the following way:
Definition 3.1. Let and be matroids on a common ground set .
The union is the matroid on whose independent sets are the subsets of that can be expressed as a union , where is an independent set of and is an independent set of .
The intersection is the matroid on whose spanning sets are the subsets of that can be expressed as an intersection , where is a spanning set of and is a spanning set of $N_2.
The two constructions are related through matroid duality by . We say that has the expected rank if the set of bases of is
where is the set of bases of and is the set of bases of . Dually, we say that has the expected rank if the set of bases of is
Now let be a matroid of rank with ground set over a division ring and a matroid of the same rank with ground set over a division ring . We assume that the ground sets intersect in the standard unit vectors . Let be with the elements of added as coloops, and define in the same way for . We set with ground set . Set and . The dual of has rank . It follows that has rank and therefore has expected rank. This means that the set of bases of is
To characterize the bases of the intersection of two matroids over possibly different division rings we will use Rado’s theorem, see [19 Theorem 11.2.2] and [20].
Theorem 3.2 (Rado’s theorem). Given a matroid with ground set and rank function . Given further a index set and a family of subsets . Then the following are equivalent:
The family has a transversal which is an independent set of .
(2) For every subset we have .
Here we set .
Over a division ring , the left row rank of a matrix equals its right column rank; we denote it by .
In the setting above, let be the row matroid of a matrix over with rows indexed by and columns indexed by , and let be the row matroid of a matrix over with rows indexed by and columns indexed by , such that the rows indexed by are the standard unit vectors in both matrices. Let with , and for let be the submatrix of with rows and columns , and the submatrix of with rows and columns .
Theorem 3.3. is a basis of if and only if
Proof. Write , , , and , so that . We show that both conditions are equivalent to
there is a partition such that and are square and invertible.
The inequality is equivalent to . Let be the column matroid of on and the column matroid of on , and let . For set . For , the rank of in is . By Rado’s theorem, the inequality holds if and only if there is a partition such that the columns of and the columns of are independent. Then and , and forces equality, so and are square and invertible. The converse is clear.
implies that is a basis of . If , then the row of vanishes, so gives . Set , a set of size . The rows of indexed by are unit vectors, so eliminating them together with the columns shows that the rows of are independent if and only if is invertible. Hence is a basis of . Similarly, is a basis of . Then is a basis of and is a basis of , with and . Hence is a basis of .
If is a basis of , then holds. Let and be bases of and with and . Since consists of coloops of and of coloops of , we have and for bases of and of . Set and . Since , we get , so . Since and , we get and , where . Hence , and gives and . The same block elimination as above shows that and are invertible.
Remark 3.4. We note that Theorem 3.3 also follows from the formula for the rank function of a union of two matroids, see [Ox11], Theorem 11.3.1. The proof of the formula also uses Rado’s theorem.
Amalgams of algebraic matroids over one-dimensional groups
In [2] and [7] the authors use the notion of algebraically equivalent realizations of an algebraic matroid. Given some algebraic matroid represented by . If there are such that for all then the matroid equals and we call the representations algebraically equivalent. We write for if . The algebraic matroid represented by is algebraically equivalent to a representation over a one-dimensional algebraic group if there are points that are the image of a generic point under a homomorphism of algebraic groups such that for all .
Given a matroid realized by that is algebraically equivalent to a realization over and a matroid realized by that is algebraically equivalent to a realization over a group which is either or an elliptic curve. Assume that both matroids have rank and the basis . Let be the algebraic matroid realized by with the ground set . Let and be the endomorphism rings of and , with division rings and . Then there are generic points and and matrices , such that
Indeed, if , set and for the matrix with rows ; each row lies in the -span of the rows , so by the Ore condition for some and , and Lemma 2.3a gives . The same argument applies to . Set and denote with its locus. With it follows
Fix a subset with and collect the and appearing in into an matrix over . Collect all the appearing in into a matrix over .
We define the following homomorphism of algebraic groups
If we evaluate this morphism at the point , we get with Lemma 2.5
We set and since is a morphism of algebraic groups we have
For we set
The following lemma follows directly from the theory of matroids over one-dimensional algebraic groups.
Lemma 4.1. Let be an elliptic curve or . For we have and for we have .
Proposition 4.2. We have that if and only if for every
Proof. Suppose the inequality does fail for some . lies in the subgroup . And with Lemma 2.3b this subgroup has dimension . It follows
Suppose . We choose a minimal with . Hence we have for every and . Fix some . We want to show that lies in a coset of a connected subgroup. Set and . is closed and irreducible as the image of an irreducible variety. We can assume that is an irreducible curve, if is only a point there is nothing to show. Now Lemma 2.3b gives us . We fix some . With containing and being irreducible we have which denotes the identity component of the stabilizer. Hence . We can do this now for every and get for , since is closed. But we also have that for any that . Thus . It follows .
With Lemma 2.3c follows for closed subgroups and . We consider the projections and . Set
We have
and as each maps dominantly into we have that is dense in . We have that is a coset of , hence , which is already closed. Now
As both and are closed connected subgroups we have . The same argument gives us and it follows
and the inequality fails for . □
Corollary 4.3. If we use the notation of § 3, then it follows with Theorem 3.3 that .
Algebraic equivalence of realizations
We now want to show that the algebraic representations of certain matroids are all algebraically equivalent to a representation over a one-dimensional algebraic group . This is already known for the Fano and non-Fano matroids and also for every projective geometry in , see [7 Theorem 3.3.1] and [2 Example 6.2]. We will show the same for analogs of the dual Fano and non-Fano matroids over fields of characteristic . For this the following lemmas will be helpful.
Intersecting transcendental field extensions
The statements are well known, but we provide short proofs.
Lemma 5.1. Let be fields with algebraically closed and transcendental over . Then is algebraically closed in .
Proof. We have that and are free over . With [12 VIII. Theorem 4.3] and the fact that is regular the statement follows.
For subfields , let be the composite of and in , that is the smallest subfield of which contains both and .
Lemma 5.2. Let , be subfields. If is transcendental over then
Proof. We only prove the inclusion . The other inclusion is trivial. Set . Every can be written uniquely as with , monic, and in . Now let . Write with , monic, and in . Then in as well, and is the reduced form of over . Hence the coefficients of the reduced form of lie in . By the same argument, if , they lie in . Uniqueness of the reduced form means that for these are the same coefficients. So they lie in , and .
Lemma 5.3. Let , be algebraically closed subfields containing . If and is transcendental over , then .
Proof. Choose some and let be its minimal polynomial over and its minimal polynomial over . It follows that divides as polynomials over . Therefore all the coefficients of lie in . With Lemma 5.1 we have and it follows that all the coefficients of lie already in . Similarly, we can get that . With Lemma 5.2 we have and it follows that is algebraic over . Hence . The other inclusion is trivial.
The matroid
Consider the matroid of the complete graph on 4 vertices . That is a matroid of rank 3 with ground set and circuits , , and . The matroid has the partition , , into points not on a common 3-point line. We will call a subset of the partition a matching. With [7 Theorem 2.1.2] follows that every algebraic realization of is algebraically equivalent to a realization over a one-dimensional algebraic group . Using this one can show:
Lemma 5.4 ([7] Corollary 3.2.1). Suppose is realized by as an algebraic matroid over an algebraically closed subfield . Then the lines and meet in a point over . In other words, two matchings of always meet in a point over .
Lemma 5.5. Let be a simple matroid of rank 3 on where each circuit of is a dependent set in . Call them . Then those are the only dependent triples of and .
Proof. This is well known, by the enumeration of all matroids of rank 3 on 6 elements, but we state a short proof. We notice that any three of the sets cover . Let be a rank-2 flat of with . So contains two elements of some . Since is simple and is dependent we have .
Suppose , and pick . is matched to exactly one element of . So there are in such that lies in some different and lies in some different . As before we have . The three sets are distinct, so . This contradicts . Hence .
The dual Lazarson matroids are only realizable over algebraic groups
If we extend the field by some elements we will always assume that is already algebraically closed from now on in this section.
Given variables . For set . Let be the matroids realized by over or . The matroid is the dual of the so-called Lazarson matroid and the matroid is the dual of the non-Lazarson matroid . The two matroids can be seen as generalizations of the Fano and non-Fano matroids to characteristic . is only algebraic over fields of characteristic and is only linear over fields of characteristic not equal to .
Theorem 5.6. Let be either or and realized by some arbitrary elements
as an algebraic matroid over . Then there is an algebraically equivalent realization over some connected one-dimensional algebraic group . Furthermore for we have and for we have or is some elliptic curve.
Proof. We will construct several realizations of over from and glue them together into an algebraically equivalent realization of over a one-dimensional algebraic group. Fix . Set . Then the contraction has elements and all the with and are parallel to each other; we represent them by . Now consider the simplification . We have the lines , , and . Hence this matroid is isomorphic to with the matchings , and . Therefore we get the point
over . As is a flat in and is independent over we get with Lemma 5.3
has transcendence degree over and we can take to be points over . As the intersection of the flats spanned by and is empty in the elements are not parallel to any element of . Assume that is parallel to . It follows . But this can only happen if . Hence any two points are independent.
Now set
and
We have that and . These two fields are not equal and both have transcendence degree 3. Hence has rank 2 and is a line. In addition we have the lines
and
It follows with Lemma 5.5 that and both realize over . By [7 Theorem 2.1.2] each of them is algebraically equivalent to a realization over a connected one-dimensional algebraic group, and by projective uniqueness of over division rings we can fix the realization: for there are a group and algebraically independent points with
and similarly for with in place of $x_l.
We repeatedly use the following observation. Let be an isogeny, , and with . Then , since is finite and . Such lifts exist because is surjective and is algebraically closed.
Step 1: the elements and . We show by induction on that there are a connected one-dimensional algebraic group and points with
For this is the realization of . For the induction step, take the realization of , with . Apply Proposition 2.6 to and : the points are independent, and . We obtain a group such that the projections and are isogenies, together with and constants with and . Choose with for , and with . Since and differ from and only by constants, the observation gives for all , for , , and for . Rename each to .
Step 2: the elements . Let be as in Step 1, and let be the realization of . Apply Proposition 2.6 to and : these realize and , which are independent, and realizes in both factors. We obtain with isogenies , and points that project to the components of and up to constants. Choose with , set and , choose with for , and choose with . Then up to constants for all , so the relations of Step 1 still hold for the . Moreover, up to constants,
so , and .
Step 3: the remaining elements. Set . Since is a basis of , the point is generic. So far we have found with entries in such that for every . For , the element lies on the two distinct lines and , so . By Lemma 2.2 this intersection is for some , hence . Similarly, with we have , and applying Lemma 2.2 inductively gives for some . Collecting the rows , and into a matrix gives a homomorphism with coordinatewise. Hence is algebraically equivalent to a realization over . In particular, for , needs to be as is only linear over division rings of characteristic . For , needs to be or an elliptic curve as is only linear over division rings of characteristic not . □
Algebraic matroids which are not coalgebraic
The Lazarson matroid over is realized by
where and . The non-Lazarson matroid over is realized by
where and . Here the elements are algebraically independent over . That these matroids are actually dual to and is a routine check.
Consider the union of the following two matroids over :
and
with the ground set . Then is a basis of , as both are disjoint bases of and .
The algebraic matroids in the following theorem are inspired by the counterexample of Larson and Le in [14].
Theorem 6.1. Consider the matroid represented by
over . Then the dual of is not algebraic over any field.
Proof. The subset is already dependent. We can see this by using to transform
into
Now we have
and the set is dependent in . If we contract the in the matroid is equal to and if we contract the the matroid is equal to . Therefore is not the union of and where we leave the contracted elements as loops. Assume the dual matroid is algebraic. Then is algebraic over a field of characteristic , as the dual of the Lazarson matroid is only algebraic over a field of characteristic . Then the form a basis of , and . With Theorem 5.6 every algebraic realization of is algebraically equivalent to a realization over or an elliptic curve and every algebraic realization of is algebraically equivalent to a realization over . With Corollary 4.3 it follows that must be the intersection of and where we leave the deleted elements as coloops. This contradicts that is not the union of and where we leave the contracted elements as loops. It follows that the dual of is not algebraic over any field and proves Theorem 1.2. □
Our main theorem now follows directly.
Theorem 6.2. Over any field of positive characteristic there is an algebraic matroid over such that the dual matroid is not algebraic over any field.
Remark 6.3. There are several matroids similar to with non-algebraic dual. For example one could use different twists to glue the matroids and together. The twist we used just seems to be the easiest one that works. It does not work to glue and together with some twist and arrive at the same result.
Volume polynomials
In [6] the authors define algebraic polymatroids. Suppose we have a chain of field extensions for all for some finite set . Denote with the composite of field extensions for . This is the smallest subfield of containing for all .
Definition 7.1. Let be an integral polymatroid on the ground set with rank function . We call algebraic over if there are field extensions for such that
See [18 Chapter 4] for several equivalent definitions of integral polymatroids. We view integral polymatroids and -convex sets as the same objects and denote with the dual of a polymatroid .
Algebraic polymatroids are connected to a special family of polynomials coming from projective geometry called volume polynomials. These are a subclass of the so-called Lorentzian polynomials, see [3]. A Lorentzian polynomial is a homogeneous polynomial with non-negative coefficients satisfying a certain log-concavity property on the positive orthant. Given a projective variety over a field of dimension and a collection of semiample divisors. The realizable volume polynomial of is defined as
This is a homogeneous polynomial of degree . For a survey on volume polynomials, see [9]. The coefficients of volume polynomials obey additional inequalities compared to Lorentzian polynomials. While the support of a Lorentzian polynomial can be any polymatroid, we have the following restriction for volume polynomials:
Proposition 7.2 ([8], Proposition 5.4). The following statements are equivalent for any polymatroid with set of bases and any field .
(1) There is a realizable volume polynomial over whose support is .
(2) The polymatroid is algebraic over .
Theorem 1.2 immediately implies that the class of algebraic polymatroids is also not closed under duality.
Matroid duality can be generalized to the class of volume polynomials. Consider the dual pair of polynomial rings and where acts on $\mathbb{R}[x] via the usual rule of partial differentiation. Denote with all polynomials in of multidegree at most . Then is a realizable covolume polynomial over if and only if is a realizable volume polynomial over . This definition does not depend on . The above correspondence then yields an analogous statement for volume polynomials and their duals:
Theorem 7.3. Let be a field of positive characteristic. There exists a realizable covolume polynomial over such that the support of is not the support of any realizable volume polynomial.
Proof. Let be a realizable covolume polynomial such that the support of the dual is the set of bases of an algebraic polymatroid with non-algebraic dual . The dualization of to with respect to is the same operation as taking the support of the dual of with respect to . Hence, the support of is not the support of any realizable volume polynomial. □
References
Lukas Grund, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena, Fakultät für Mathematik und Informatik, Institut für Mathematik, Inselplatz 5, 07743 Jena, Germany
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]Paolo Aluffi. “Lorentzian polynomials, Segre classes, and adjoint polynomials of convex polyhedral cones”. In: Advances in Mathematics 437 (2024), p. 109440.DOI
- [2]Guus P Bollen, Dustin Cartwright, and Jan Draisma. “Matroids Over One-Dimensional Groups”. In: International Mathematics Research Notices 2022.3 (Feb. 2022), pp. 2298–2336.
- [3]Petter Brändén and June Huh. “Lorentzian polynomials”. In: Annals of Mathematics 192.3 (2020), pp. 821–891.arxiv.org/abs/1902.03719
- [4]Armand Borel. Linear algebraic groups. Springer Science & Business Media, 2012.
- [5]Tobias Boege and Geva Yashfe. “Recognition of algebraic matroids is undecidable”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.14907 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.14907
- [6]Federico Castillo, Yairon Cid-Ruiz, Binglin Li, Jonathan Montaño, and Naizhen Zhang. “When are multidegrees positive?” In: Advances in Mathematics 374 (2020), p. 107382.arxiv.org/abs/2005.07808
- [7]David M Evans and Ehud Hrushovski. “Projective planes in algebraically closed fields”. In: Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society 3.1 (1991), pp. 1–24.
- [8]Lukas Grund, June Huh, Mateusz Michałek, Hendrik Süss, and Botong Wang. “Linear operators preserving volume polynomials”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.22415 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2506.22415
- [9]June Huh. “Volume polynomials”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.13249 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2601.13249
- [10]A. W. Ingleton and R. A. Main. “Non-algebraic matroids exist”. In: Bull. London Math. Soc. 7 (1975), pp. 144–146.DOI
- [11]A. W. Ingleton. “Representation of matroids”. In: Combinatorial Mathematics and its Applications (Proc. Conf., Oxford, 1969). Academic Press, London-New York, 1971, pp. 149–167.
- [12]Serge Lang. Algebra. Springer Science & Business Media, 2012.
- [13]Bernt Lindström. “Matroids algebraic over F (t) are algebraic over F”. In: Combinatorica 9.1 (1989), pp. 107–109.
- [14]Matt Larson and Tuong Le. “Duals of algebraic matroids need not be algebraic”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.02834 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.02834
- [15]František Matuš. “Classes of matroids closed under minors and principal extensions”. In: Combinatorica 38.4 (2018), pp. 935–954.
- [16]James S Milne. “A proof of the Barsotti-Chevalley theorem on algebraic groups”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1311.6060 (2013).arxiv.org/abs/1311.6060
- [17]James S Milne. Algebraic groups: the theory of group schemes of finite type over a field. Vol. 170. Cambridge University Press, 2017.
- [18]Kazuo Murota. Discrete Convex Analysis. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, 2003.
- [19]James Oxley. Matroid theory. Second. Vol. 21. Oxford Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011, pp. xiv+684.
- [20]R. Rado. “A THEOREM ON INDEPENDENCE RELATIONS”. In: The Quarterly Journal of Mathematics os-13.1 (1942), pp. 83–89.DOI
- [21]Maxwell Rosenlicht. “Some basic theorems on algebraic groups”. In: American Journal of Mathematics 78.2 (1956), pp. 401–443.DOI
- [22]Bartel Leendert Van der Waerden. “Moderne algebra”. In: (1931).