WorksMathematics
A co-sober Alexandrov space whose Scott power space is not co-sober
Abstract
We show that the Scott power construction does not preserve co-sobriety. For a dcpo , let be the poset of nonempty finitely generated upper sets ordered by reverse inclusion. We prove that co-sobriety of implies co-sobriety of . The proof adapts the point-saturation and union argument used for full compact saturated power posets; the finite step follows from a result of Heckmann and Keimel. Applying this transfer to a dcpo with a non-co-sober Scott space yields a co-sober Alexandrov space whose Scott power space is not co-sober. We also construct a countable example for which the Smyth power poset is countable. In the countable example, the same poset is co-sober under the upper Vietoris topology but not under the Scott topology.
Introduction
In [1 Definition 8.9 and Theorem 8.10], in order to provide an alternative approach to the theory of compactly generated spaces and establish a dual form of the Hofmann–Mislove Theorem, Escardó, Lawson and Simpson introduced the notion of co-sober spaces. A nonempty compact saturated subset is called -irreducible if it is not the union of two proper compact saturated subsets. A -space is co-sober if every -irreducible compact saturated subset is the saturation of a point. Despite the formal duality with sobriety, the two notions behave differently; in particular, a sober space need not be co-sober [6 Example 2.9]; see also [7 Example 2.8].
In an invited academic presentation1, Xu asked whether the Scott power space of a co-sober space is co-sober. In this paper, we give a negative answer to this question.
For a space , let be the set of its nonempty compact saturated subsets, ordered by reverse inclusion. The Scott power space of is
where is endowed with its Scott topology. We study whether this construction preserves co-sobriety. The Scott topology on can differ from the upper Vietoris topology, so the two power constructions must be treated separately.
Our first result shows that the Scott power construction does not preserve co-sobriety.
Theorem 1.1. There exists a Alexandrov co-sober space such that is not co-sober.
The construction can be made countable.
Theorem 1.2. There exists a space as in Theorem 1.1 such that both and are countable. For this example, the space endowed with the upper Vietoris topology is co-sober.
The proof of Theorem 1.1 uses a dcpo whose Scott space is sober but not co-sober, constructed by Shen, Wu, Xi and Zhao [6 Example 2.9]. We show that non-co-sobriety of passes to , where
is ordered by reverse inclusion. If is the Alexandrov space of the same poset, then is co-sober and .
Zhao, He and Wang proved related reflection results for full compact saturated power posets [10 Theorem 3.13 and Corollary 3.16]. Their argument uses point-saturation and union maps. We restrict these maps to the finite poset . The additional input is
which follows from Heckmann and Keimel’s finite Rudin result [4 Corollary 3.9].
For the countable version, we start with a countable non-sober complete lattice, whose existence was proved by Miao, Xi, Li and Zhao [5 Corollary 3.6]. An argument using the lower topology supplies a nonprincipal co-sobriety witness. We then realize the lower space as a saturated subspace of the Scott space of a countable dcpo and apply the finite transfer.
Scott power spaces have also been studied in connection with sobriety and well-filteredness [8]. In a 2026 preprint, Xu, Xu, Ji and Qiu constructed a co-sober space whose upper Vietoris Smyth power space is not co-sober [9]. Their result concerns a different topology.
Preliminaries
Let be a poset. For , write
We write and for the sets generated by singletons.
A subset is Scott open if it is an upper set and, whenever a directed set has a supremum with , one has . This definition applies to arbitrary posets; no dcpo assumption is imposed. The Scott topology is denoted by and the resulting space by . Its specialization order is the original order on [2, 3].
For a topological space , a subset is saturated if it is an upper set in the specialization preorder. Throughout the paper, members of are nonempty. A set is -irreducible if
@page 2/10 starts_mid=1 ends_mid=1 where is endowed with its Scott topology. We study whether this construction preserves co-sobriety. The Scott topology on can differ from the upper Vietoris topology, so the two power constructions must be treated separately.
Our first result shows that the Scott power construction does not preserve co-sobriety.
Theorem 1.1. There exists a Alexandrov co-sober space such that is not co-sober.
The construction can be made countable.
Theorem 1.2. There exists a space as in Theorem 1.1 such that both and are countable. For this example, the space endowed with the upper Vietoris topology is co-sober.
The proof of Theorem 1.1 uses a dcpo whose Scott space is sober but not co-sober, constructed by Shen, Wu, Xi and Zhao [6 Example 2.9]. We show that non-co-sobriety of passes to , where
is ordered by reverse inclusion. If is the Alexandrov space of the same poset, then is co-sober and .
Zhao, He and Wang proved related reflection results for full compact saturated power posets [10 Theorem 3.13 and Corollary 3.16]. Their argument uses point-saturation and union maps. We restrict these maps to the finite poset . The additional input is
which follows from Heckmann and Keimel’s finite Rudin result [4 Corollary 3.9].
For the countable version, we start with a countable non-sober complete lattice, whose existence was proved by Miao, Xi, Li and Zhao [5 Corollary 3.6]. An argument using the lower topology supplies a nonprincipal co-sobriety witness. We then realize the lower space as a saturated subspace of the Scott space of a countable dcpo and apply the finite transfer.
Scott power spaces have also been studied in connection with sobriety and well-filteredness [8]. In a 2026 preprint, Xu, Xu, Ji and Qiu constructed a co-sober space whose upper Vietoris Smyth power space is not co-sober [9]. Their result concerns a different topology.
Preliminaries
Let be a poset. For , write
We write and for the sets generated by singletons.
A subset is Scott open if it is an upper set and, whenever a directed set has a supremum with , one has . This definition applies to arbitrary posets; no dcpo assumption is imposed. The Scott topology is denoted by and the resulting space by . Its specialization order is the original order on [2, 3].
For a topological space , a subset is saturated if it is an upper set in the specialization preorder. Throughout the paper, members of are nonempty. A set is -irreducible if
implies or . A space is co-sober if each -irreducible member of is the saturation of a point [1 Definition 8.9].
The Smyth order on is
The upper Vietoris topology on is generated by the sets
We denote the corresponding space by . For a poset , denotes the Alexandrov space whose open sets are all upper subsets of .
The next two lemmas collect elementary facts needed below.
Lemma 2.1. Let be a poset.
(1) as Smyth ordered sets.
(2) The space is co-sober.
(3) The upper Vietoris topology on is the Alexandrov topology of the Smyth order. Hence is co-sober.
Proof. The saturated subsets of are the upper subsets of . If an upper set is compact, then is an open cover of , so for some nonempty finite . Conversely, each principal upper set is compact: any open set containing its least element contains the whole principal upper set. A finite union of compact sets is compact. This proves (1).
If is -irreducible, repeated application of the defining property gives for some . This proves (2).
Every upper Vietoris open is upper in the Smyth order. Conversely, for the set is open in and
Thus every principal Alexandrov open is upper Vietoris open, proving (3).
Lemma 2.2. Let be a topological space.
(1) The saturation of a compact subset of is compact.
(2) If is a saturated subspace of a space and is compact saturated and -irreducible in , then has the same properties in .
Proof. For (1), let an open cover of the saturation be given. A finite subfamily covers the original compact set. The union of this finite subfamily is open and contains the compact set, so it also contains its saturation.
For (2), compactness passes from the subspace to the ambient space. If and , saturation of gives , and saturation of in gives . Thus is saturated in . If with , then . Each is compact saturated in the subspace , so -irreducibility in gives for some .
A finite transfer argument
Let be a dcpo and order by reverse inclusion. The poset need not be a dcpo. Accordingly, every Scott topological argument below concerns only directed families whose supremum exists. The next proposition records the consequence of Heckmann and Keimel’s Corollary 3.9 that is needed here.
Proposition 3.1. If is Scott open in , then is Scott open in .
Proof. The set is upper in the Smyth order. Let be directed, suppose that its supremum exists in , and assume . First observe that
Indeed, for every . Conversely, if belongs to the intersection, then is an upper bound of in the reverse inclusion order. The least upper bound property gives , hence .
For each , choose a nonempty finite set with . On nonempty finite subsets of , write
Directedness of under reverse inclusion implies that is directed for . By (1),
Heckmann and Keimel’s Corollary 3.9 [4 Corollary 3.9] gives an such that . Since is upper, . Therefore .
Define
The map is monotone. If is directed, then is directed and its supremum exists in , with
Thus preserves directed suprema, and is Scott continuous as a map .
For and , put
These are the finite analogues of the point-saturation and union maps used for full compact saturated power posets; compare [10 Theorem 3.13].
Proposition 3.2. Let be a dcpo.
If , then and .
If , then .
For , the set is -irreducible if and only if is -irreducible.
For , the set is principal if and only if is principal in the Smyth order.
Proof. By Scott continuity of , the image is compact, and is its saturation in . Lemma 2.2(1) proves the first assertion in (1). If , then for some , so . Conversely, for every . Thus .
For (2), is nonempty and upper in . Let be a Scott open cover of . Each is a finite union of principal upper sets. Each principal upper set is compact in
, because every Scott open set containing its least element contains the whole principal upper set. Thus is compact. Therefore, for every , there is a finite set such that
By Proposition 3.1, is Scott open in . These sets cover . Compactness of gives with
It follows that is covered by the finitely many whose indices occur in . Thus is compact saturated.
Suppose that is -irreducible and
Parts (1) and (2) give
Assume . For , choose with . Since is upper, , or . Saturation of gives . Hence , and another use of saturation gives . Therefore .
Conversely, suppose that is -irreducible and with . Then
Thus for some , and applying gives . This proves (3).
If , then
Conversely, suppose . Every member of is contained in , and itself belongs to this set. Hence its union is , and (1) gives . Since , there is with . Because and is upper, . Hence . This proves (4).
Corollary 3.3. For every ,
Equivalently, non-co-sobriety of implies non-co-sobriety of .
Proof. If is not co-sober, choose a nonprincipal -irreducible member of . Proposition 3.2 shows that is a nonprincipal -irreducible member of .
Remark 3.4. The proof does not assert that is Scott continuous as a map between compact saturated power posets, or that and form a topological retraction. Proposition 3.1 is used to prove compactness of and supplies the finite step not contained in the identity .
A counterexample
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Shen, Wu, Xi and Zhao constructed a dcpo such that is sober but not co-sober [6 Example 2.9]. Let
By Lemma 2.1, is a co-sober space and . Corollary 3.3 shows that
is not co-sober.
The preceding argument uses no cardinality property of the dcpo in [6 Example 2.9]. The remainder of the paper gives a separate countable construction.
A countable witness in a lower topology
Miao, Xi, Li and Zhao proved that a countable non-sober complete lattice exists [5 Corollary 3.6]. Fix such a lattice . Since is and non-sober, there is a nonempty irreducible Scott closed set such that
Only the existence statement from [5 Corollary 3.6] is used; no witness from that paper is imported.
The lower topology is generated by the subbasic sets
Its specialization order is the reverse of the lattice order. Thus its saturated sets are precisely the lower subsets of , and the saturation of is .
We shall also use the elementary inclusion
Indeed, each lower subbasic set is an upper set in . If a filtered set has meet , then some satisfies ; otherwise would be a lower bound of and hence . Thus is Scott open in , and so is every lower open set.
Lemma 5.1. Let be a complete lattice and let be nonempty. Then is compact saturated in if and only if is Scott closed in .
Proof. Suppose first that is Scott closed. It is lower and therefore saturated. By Alexander’s subbase theorem, it is enough to consider a cover by lower subbasic opens. Let
and suppose that no finite subfamily covers . For every finite , choose with for all , and put
where . Since and is lower, . The family is directed, and Scott closedness gives
This element lies in every , contradicting the cover. Hence is compact.
Conversely, suppose that is compact saturated. Then is lower. Let be directed and set . If , then for every there is with ; otherwise would be an upper bound of , and lowerness would give . Hence
is an open cover of . A finite subcover corresponds to . Choose above all . Then belongs to none of the selected complements, a contradiction. Thus , and is Scott closed.
A nonempty closed set is irreducible exactly when it is not the union of two proper closed subsets. Lemma 5.1 and (4) give the following.
Corollary 5.2. The set is a nonprincipal -irreducible compact saturated subset of .
A countable staircase dcpo
Fix a sequence in which every element of occurs. For and , define
The empty intersection is . Each is a lower open neighbourhood of , the sequence is decreasing, and
Moreover, the sets form a neighbourhood base at in the lower topology, since every basic lower open neighbourhood involves only finitely many subbasic complements.
Let
Define a relation on by
We impose no other comparisons. Reflexivity and antisymmetry are immediate. Transitivity in the mixed cases follows from for and from lowerness of . Thus this relation is a partial order, and is countable.
Lemma 6.1. The poset is a dcpo. Let be directed.
(1) If contains a point , set
Then is filtered and
(2) If contains no point of the form , then all its elements lie on one staircase. If the occurring indices have a maximum , the supremum is ; if they are unbounded, the supremum is .
Proof. Suppose that contains . For each , directedness gives above both and . No staircase point lies above a point , so the point part of is cofinal. If , a common upper bound in has the form with . Hence is filtered. If , then is the least upper bound of the cofinal point part and therefore of .
Now suppose that contains only staircase points. Points with different labels have no common staircase upper bound, so directedness forces one label . If the set of indices is bounded, it has a maximum. If it is unbounded, every member of is below . Any upper bound must then have the form , and for every index occurring in . Unboundedness and the decreasing property of the sets give
Thus , proving that is the supremum.
Let
The point set is upper in , hence saturated in .
Proposition 6.2. The map
is a homeomorphism onto the saturated subspace .
Proof. The map is bijective. Let be Scott open in and put
If , the directed chain has supremum . Scott inaccessibility gives for some . If , then , so . Hence , and is lower open.
Conversely, let be lower open and define
The set is upper. If and , then , and lowerness of gives . If and , then . If and , then . These are all possible cases.
Let be directed and suppose . If is contained in one staircase and its indices are bounded, its supremum is its maximum and belongs to . If its indices are unbounded, say on the staircase, then and . Choose with . Some occurring index is at least , so . It remains to consider the case in which contains point elements. By Lemma 6.1,
The set is filtered in , hence directed in , and its supremum in is . Since and by (3), Scott inaccessibility gives some . Thus . Hence is Scott open. By construction, , which proves equality of the two topologies.
Corollary 6.3. The Scott space is not co-sober.
Proof. By Corollary 5.2 and Proposition 6.2, is compact saturated and -irreducible in the point subspace. Lemma 2.2(2) gives the same properties in .
The set is not principal. If and is a staircase point, then but . If , then
so , contradicting (2).
The countable counterexample
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Let
The space is countable, , and co-sober by Lemma 2.1. Moreover,
which is countable because is countable. Corollary 6.3 and Corollary 3.3 imply that
is not co-sober. Lemma 2.1(3) shows that the upper Vietoris space is the Alexandrov space of the same Smyth ordered set and is therefore co-sober.
Hence the upper Vietoris and Scott topologies have different co-sobriety behavior on the same countable Smyth power poset.
Concluding remarks
Theorem 1.1 shows that the Scott power construction does not preserve co-sobriety. The finite transfer uses the point-saturation and union maps from the full compact saturated setting and Heckmann and Keimel’s finite Rudin result at the compactness step. The separate staircase construction yields a countable example and, for the same countable Smyth power poset, distinguishes the upper Vietoris topology from the Scott topology.
References
- [1]M. Escardó, J. D. Lawson, A. Simpson, Comparing Cartesian closed categories of (core) compactly generated spaces, Topology Appl. 143 (2004), 105–145.DOI
- [2]G. Gierz, K. H. Hofmann, K. Keimel, J. D. Lawson, M. Mislove, D. S. Scott, Continuous Lattices and Domains, Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, vol. 93, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2003.DOI
- [3]J. Goubault-Larrecq, Non-Hausdorff Topology and Domain Theory: Selected Topics in Point-Set Topology, New Mathematical Monographs, vol. 22, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2013.
- [4]R. Heckmann, K. Keimel, Quasicontinuous domains and the Smyth powerdomain, Electron. Notes Theor. Comput. Sci. 298 (2013), 215–232.DOI
- [5]H. Miao, X. Xi, Q. Li, D. Zhao, Not every countable complete distributive lattice is sober, Math. Struct. Comput. Sci. 33 (9) (2023), 809–831.DOI
- [6]C. Shen, G. Wu, X. Xi, D. Zhao, Sober Scott spaces are not always co-sober, Topology Appl. 282 (2020) 107316.DOI
- [7]X. Wen, X. Xu, Sober is not always co-sober, Topology Appl. 250 (2018) 48–52.DOI
- [8]X. Xu, X. Wen, X. Xi, Scott topology on Smyth power posets, Math. Struct. Comput. Sci. 33 (9) (2023), 832–867.DOI
- [9]X. Xu, F. Xu, H. Ji, D. Qiu, Smyth power space of a co-sober space is not always co-sober, arXiv:2608.02047 [math.GN] (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2608.02047
- [10]B. Zhao, Z. He, K. Wang, On co-sober spaces, Houston J. Math. 49 (4) (2023) 971–988.DOI