WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Second Chern Number Protected Gapless Vortex Modes in Superconducting Weyl Semimetals
Abstract
We have studied the vortex bound states of superconducting linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals with time reversal symmetry. For vortex with vorticity (vortex line along direction) and Weyl semimetals with Weyl point chirality , there are gapless vortex modes around the location of each Weyl point in superconducting Weyl semimetals. We show that the appearance of gapless vortex modes originates from the imbalanced pumping of flux bound states between Chern insulators obtained at and in Weyl semimetals. Such a physical picture is verified by numerical calculations on lattice models. Moreover, the gapless modes around each Weyl point can be characterized by the second Chern number defined in a synthetic four-dimensional space based on the effective BdG Hamiltonian. Finally, these gapless vortex modes are found to be robust against rotational symmetry-breaking terms.
Introduction
Majorana zero modes (MZMs) are fascinating objects which obey non-Abelian statistics, and the braiding of MZMs can be used to construct fault-tolerant quantum gates [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. It is predicted that there are MZMs in the vortex cores of two-dimensional chiral -wave superconductors [1]. Subsequently, it is found that there is effective superconductivity on the interface of the -wave superconductor-TI heterostructure [8], and an MZM could be trapped at the vortex core in such a heterostructure [9]. Since then, the vortex bound states (VBSs) of superconducting (SC) topological insulators (TIs) [8] [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20], iron-based superconductors [21–31], and SC Dirac semimetals [31–45] have attracted a lot of attentions.
Recent years have also witnessed remarkable progress in the study of the VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals [42, 46–65]. It is found that the vortex line can host gapless chiral Majorana modes in the pair density wave phase of a Weyl semimetal breaking time reversal symmetry [61]. For time reversal symmetric Weyl semimetals with BCS pairing, it is predicted that if every constant- (the vortex is inserted along direction) plane contains zero chirality of Weyl points, the VBSs will be fully gapped, and if certain constant- planes contain a net chirality of Weyl points, there will be gapless modes [63]. The topological invariants have also been proposed to characterize the non-trivial fully gapped phase with vortex-end MZMs [42, 63]. However, previous studies have focused on the VBSs of superconducting linear Weyl semimetals, whereas those of superconducting quadratic Weyl semimetals remain less explored. Moreover, topological invariants characterizing the gapless vortex modes in time-reversal-symmetric superconducting linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals have yet to be proposed, and the physical origin of the appearance of these gapless modes hasn’t been thoroughly understood. Apart from the theoretical study, experimental progress about superconducting Dirac semimetals and Weyl semimetals has also been reported in the past decade [38, 66–68]. Some candidate materials of Weyl semimetals are found to be superconductors under high pressure [50, 52, 58], and technologies such as point contact [69] and selective ion sputtering [70] have also been developed to induce superconductivity in Dirac semimetals and Weyl semimetals. The experimental progress facilitates the study of VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals and calls for further theoretical exploration.
In this article, we study the VBSs of SC linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals [71, 72] with time reversal symmetry (TRS). As shown in Figure 1, we consider a flux inserted into a SC Weyl semimetal with chirality , and () corresponds to linear (quadratic) Weyl semimetal. Figure 1(c) shows the schematic figure of the
Figure 1. (a) The SC Weyl semimetal and inserted flux with vorticity . (b) The four Weyl points are located on the axis, and Weyl points colored in red (blue) have the chirality (). The first Chern numbers are labelled for two-dimensional insulators at different . (c) There are gapless propagating modes around the component of each Weyl point.
Model
In this section, we write down the model of linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals. First, the continuous model of the linear Weyl semimetal with TRS, and rotational symmetry is written under the basis , in which each state is the eigenstate of inversion and operations labelled by the corresponding eigenvalues.
Here , and . As shown in Figure 1(b), the gap-closing condition of the above Hamiltonian gives four Weyl points with chirality located on axis. The corresponding tight-binding lattice model is given in the supplemental materials [73], in which we also give the correspondence between the parameters in model and the parameters in tight-binding lattice model.
The model of the quadratic Weyl semimetal is written under the basis , in which each state is the eigenstate of inversion and operations labelled by the corresponding eigenvalues.
In the above Hamiltonian Eq. (2), we have , and . Eq. (2) describes a quadratic Weyl semimetal with four quadratic Weyl points with chirality located on the axis. The corresponding tight-binding lattice model is given in the supplemental materials [73].
The bases of the models of linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals can be written in a unified form , in which label the parity, and label the angular momentum . When we consider the Hamiltonian describing SC Weyl semimetals, we choose the Nambu basis as . Under this basis, the BdG Hamiltonian of the SC Weyl semimetal is , where
In the BdG Hamiltonian Eq. (3), is the normal state Hamiltonian of linear or quadratic Weyl semimetal. The vortex line adds the phase () to the pairing potential and preserves the translation symmetry in direction. Thus, is a good quantum number, and we can calculate the VBSs for each with open boundary condition in and directions. We consider the -wave singlet pairing and assume that the pairing potential at the vortex core is , and on other lattice sites. For SC linear Weyl semimetal, the parameters in the lattice model are set as , and for SC quadratic Weyl semimetal, the parameters in the lattice model are set as .
The VBSs Characterized by the Second Chern Number
We have performed numerical calculations of the VBSs of SC linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals, and the results are shown in Figure 2. Concretely, Figure 2(a) shows the VBSs of SC linear Weyl semimetal () with vorticity . Figure 2(b) shows the VBSs of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal () with vorticity . The red and blue points in the two sub-figures label the $k_z coordinates of Weyl points with opposite chirality. We notice that the gapless modes around each Weyl point can be characterized by the product . To be specific, the number of gapless modes around the component of each Weyl point is , and the propagating direction of gapless modes around each Weyl point is determined by the sign of the product . For example, there is gapless mode around each linear Weyl point in Figure 2(a), while there are gapless modes around each quadratic Weyl point in Figure 2(b). Besides, the propagating direction of gapless modes around each Weyl point in Figure 2(b) is opposite to that in Figure 2(a), which is consistent with the fact that we have in Figure 2(b) and in Figure 2(a). In fact, in the supplemental materials [73], there are more numerical examples demonstrating that the dependence of propagating direction and number of gapless modes on and can be characterized by the product .

Figure 2. The VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals. The red and blue points in the two sub-figures are Weyl points with opposite chirality. (a) The VBSs ( relation) of SC linear Weyl semimetal are calculated with , , and . (b) The VBSs of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal are calculated with , , and .
We find that the product is nothing but the emergent second Chern number [74–77] defined in a synthetic four-dimensional space that stems from the effective BdG Hamiltonian [78, 79]. For simplicity, we fix in the following discussions. In this case, the normal-state Fermi surface consists of isolated Weyl points. To derive the effective BdG Hamiltonian, we focus on the low-energy physics around the four Weyl points. The detailed derivations of the effective BdG Hamiltonian are given in the supplementary materials [73]. If we use () to denote the momentum relative to a Weyl point and assume , the final form of the effective BdG Hamiltonian is
For a region far away from the vortex core, we may assume it is a three-dimensional space with approximate constant . Then combining all such regions together leads to a synthetic four-dimensional space with periodic boundary condition in parameter [43, 74]. Therefore, we can define the second Chern number in this synthetic four-dimensional space.
To calculate of the above effective BdG Hamiltonian, we reformulate Eq. (4) as
Then we define , , , , . In this way, we can write the effective BdG Hamiltonian as , in which are five mutually anti-commuting matrices in Eq. (5). The definition of the second Chern number is
Here we have defined . If we substitute the explicit forms of the coefficients into the definition of the second Chern number, we will obtain after some algebra [73]. This expected topological invariant which describes the dependence of gapless modes on the vorticity and chirality in SC linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals.
The Pumping Picture
Now we provide a physical picture to understand such dependence of the VBSs on and . As shown in Figure 1(b), the Weyl semimetals we consider have four Weyl points on axis, and Chern numbers can be defined for the two-dimensional insulators obtained by fixing in the model of Weyl semimetals. Thus, the Weyl semimetals can be regarded as Chern insulators with different Chern numbers stacked along direction. The imbalanced pumping between Chern insulators at and in Weyl semimetals can lead to the appearance of gapless vortex modes around the location of each Weyl point in the VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals. Now we take the VBSs of SC linear Weyl semimetal as an example, and we consider inserting a flux into the linear Weyl semimetal along direction. Figure 3 shows the pumping of the spectra of Chern insulators at and . Here is a typical value of , at which the insulator has nonzero Chern number. The red dots are states which localize around the flux core, and they are dubbed flux bound states. Because of the existence of TRS, Chern insulators at and have opposite Chern numbers. As a result, we can find that the flux bound states at cross the Fermi level downwards, while the flux bound states at cross the Fermi level upwards. In fact, there is also the pumping of edge state. But to highlight the pumping of flux bound states, we don’t plot the edge states in this figure.

Figure 3. Understanding the appearance of the gapless modes from the -flux pumping of Chern insulators in a linear Weyl semimetal. The red dots are flux bound states localized at the flux core. This figure shows the pumping of flux bound states of two-dimensional insulators at and as the inserted flux increases from to . The results are calculated with and .
Although Figure 3 shows the -flux pumping, we should focus on the -flux pumping to understand the VBSs of SC linear Weyl semimetals. Combining the -flux pumping of the flux bound states of two Chern insulators at and , we conclude that depending on the value of chemical potential, the flux bound states at are pumped from occupied to unoccupied, or the flux bound states at are pumped from unoccupied to occupied. In the BdG Hamiltonian, there are both particle and hole degrees of freedom [62], so we have to consider the hole counterpart of the aforementioned pumping process. It turns out that for the -flux pumping in the hole part, we also obtain the result that the flux bound states at are pumped from occupied to unoccupied, or the flux bound states at are pumped from unoccupied to occupied. We assume that the pumping of flux bound states won’t be qualitatively changed in the weak pairing limit. Consequently, we have , where is the number of negative energy vortex bound states at . Meanwhile, as shown in Figure 2(a), we notice that around we have , because for insulators around with Chern number , there is no the pumping of flux bound states. However, if is greater than the coordinate of the right blue Weyl point in Figure 2(a), we will have according to the aforementioned argument. So we expect that there is a positive-energy VBS crossing the Fermi level and becoming a negative-energy VBS, resulting gapless vortex mode around the right blue Weyl point. Similarly, we can argue that there is gapless mode around the component of each of the four Weyl points.
Analogous to the pumping picture above, we can readily understand the dependence of the number of gapless modes on the chirality and the vorticity . For instance, for a quadratic Weyl semimetal with chirality , we can obtain Chern insulator at an appropriate value of . Similar to Figure 3, after inserting a flux with vorticity , there will be two flux bound states pumped from occupied to unoccupied at , or two flux bound states pumped from unoccupied to occupied at . Correspondingly, in the weak pairing limit we have , and there will be gapless modes around each Weyl point. On the other hand, if we keep (linear Weyl semimetal) and change the vorticity from to , there are effectively two fluxes. As a result, there will also be two flux bound states pumped from occupied to unoccupied at , or two flux bound states pumped from unoccupied to occupied at . Therefore, the number of gapless modes around each Weyl point also doubles. To sum up, we have shown that the number of gapless modes around each Weyl point is proportional to the product through the pumping picture.
The Robustness of Gapless Modes
The models of linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals above are written based on models of linear and quadratic Dirac semimetals, and they are rotational symmetric linear () and quadratic Weyl semimetals (). However, it is not necessary for a Weyl semimetal to be rotational symmetric. So it is natural to ask whether the multiple gapless modes around the Weyl points are robust against rotational symmetry-breaking perturbations. To answer this question, we add the rotational symmetry breaking term into both the linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals. As a result, the four Weyl points are no longer located on the axis. Instead, they are now located on the plane. The corresponding VBSs of rotational symmetry-breaking SC linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals are shown in Figure 4(a) and Figure 4(b), respectively. We find from the inset in Figure 4(a) that there is still one propagating gapless mode around each Weyl point, but the intersection of two counter-propagating modes is gapped by the rotational symmetry-breaking term. Similarly, Figure 4(b) shows that there are still two propagating gapless modes around each Weyl point, while the intersections of four counter-propagating modes are gapped by the rotational symmetry-breaking perturbation.

Figure 4. The robustness of multiple gapless modes against rotational symmetry-breaking perturbations. (a) The VBSs of SC linear Weyl semimetal without uniaxial rotational symmetry. Here we set , , , and . (b) The VBSs of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal without uniaxial rotational symmetry. The parameters are set as , , , and .
Although the intersection of counter-propagating modes are gapped, they are far away from Fermi energy. Since the main properties of a superconductor are determined by the low-energy spectra near the Fermi energy, the spectra around the intersections don’t play the main role in determining the physical properties. In this sense, we claim that the spectra in Figure 4 are still gapless, and the multiple gapless propagating modes around each Weyl point are robust against rotational symmetry-breaking perturbations.
Summary and Discussion
In summary, we have studied the VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals with time reversal symmetry. We show that the imbalanced pumping of flux bound states between Chern insulators obtained at and in Weyl semimetals can lead to the appearance of gapless modes around each Weyl point in the VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals. Such a physical picture is verified by numerical calculations based on lattice models. We also conclude from the numerical results that the gapless modes around each Weyl point can be characterized by the product , which is the second Chern number defined in a synthetic four-dimensional space spanned by parameters , , , and . Finally, we show these low-energy gapless modes are robust against rotational symmetry-breaking terms.
In this article, we have also used the pumping picture to understand the origin of gapless modes in the vortex line of SC Weyl semimetals. As a matter of fact, because the pumping of flux bound state is a generic feature for topological bands, it is natural to expect that topological VBSs will appear in not only SC Weyl semimetals but also SC topological insulators and SC Dirac semimetals, which have been extensively studied in recent years [16, 41, 42, 63]. Thus, the flux-pumping picture of the normal-state topological models may provide a unified framework for understanding VBSs in corresponding superconducting topological materials. A systematic exploration of this possibility is left for future work.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Shengshan Qin and Professor Xiong-Jun Liu sincerely for helpful discussions. J.P. Hu is supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology (Grant No. 2022YFA1403900), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. NSFC-12494594), and the New Cornerstone Investigator Program.
Supplemental Materials: Second Chern Number Protected Gapless Vortex Modes in Superconducting Weyl Semimetals
Zhicheng Zhang; Jiangping Hu
02_supplement.pdf
Supplemental Materials: Second Chern Number Protected Gapless Vortex Modes in Superconducting Weyl Semimetals
The Effective BdG Hamiltonians of SC Weyl Semimetals and Emergent Second Chern Number
In this section we will derive the effective BdG Hamiltonian [1, 2] describing the low-energy physics of SC Weyl semimetals, based on which we will define the emergent second Chern number [3, 4, 5, 6] in a synthetic four-dimensional space. We first derive the effective BdG Hamiltonian of SC linear Weyl semimetal with vorticity . Figure S1 shows the distribution of the four Weyl points of linear Weyl semimetals. We now focus on the effective BdG Hamiltonian with the pairing between electrons around Weyl points at and , which is shown in Figure S1.
Figure S1. The distribution of Weyl points and the schematic figure of the BCS pairing. (a) The distribution of the four Weyl points in our linear Weyl semimetal. (b) The pairing between electrons around two Weyl points with same chirality and opposite momentum.
The low-energy effective Hamiltonians around Weyl points (Eq. (16)) and (Eq. (17)) are derived in section S-3, based on which we can derive the effective BdG Hamiltonian. We consider the Nambu basis and write the effective BdG Hamiltonians under this basis. Taking the pairing term into consideration, the BdG Hamiltonian can be written as , in which
Here we have considered the BCS pairing term , in which electrons with opposite momentum and angular momentum are paired together.
If we consider the flux inserted along direction, the effective BdG Hamiltonian will become
in which the phase attached to describes the effect of the vortex line. Similarly, we can obtain the effective BdG Hamiltonian for SC Weyl semimetals with chirality and vorticity
in which () is the momentum relative to a Weyl point, and . If the Hamiltonian changes slowly as we change the parameter , the three spatial variables , , and together with the fourth variable constitute a synthetic four-dimensional space [3, 7], in which we can define the second Chern number . To calculate of the above effective BdG Hamiltonian, we reformulate Eq. (9) as
Then we define , , , , and . In this way, we can write the effective BdG Hamiltonian as . Here are five mutually anti-commuting matrices in Eq. (10). In this case, the definition of the second Chern number is
Here we have defined . If we substitute the explicit forms of the coefficients into Eq. (11), we will obtain
The integrand can be written in a more compact form
This is the expected topological invariant which describes the dependence of gapless vortex modes on the vorticity and chirality in SC linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals.
Dependence of VBSs on Chirality and Vorticity
In this section we will discuss how the chirality and vorticity affect the numbers and propagating directions of gapless modes in the vortex line of SC Weyl semimetals. Figure S2 and Figure S2 shows the VBSs ( relation) of SC linear Weyl semimetal () with vorticity and , respectively. Figure S2 and Figure S2 shows the VBSs of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal () with vorticity and , respectively. We find that there exist gapless modes in each of the four sub-figures.
Figure S2. The VBSs of SC Weyl semimetals calculated with various chirality and vorticity . (a) The VBS of SC linear Weyl semimetal () are calculated with , , and . (b) The VBS of SC linear Weyl semimetal () are calculated with , , and . (c) The VBS of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal () are calculated with , , and . (d) The VBS of SC quadratic Weyl semimetal () are calculated with , , and .
By comparing the VBSs in two figures with same () and different (), we can find how () affects the propagating direction and number of gapless modes around the component of one Weyl point. It turns out that the number of gapless modes around (the component of) each Weyl point is , and the propagating direction of the gapless modes around each Weyl point is determined by the sign of the product . For example, there is one gapless mode around each linear Weyl point in Figure S2, while there are two gapless modes around each quadratic Weyl point in Figure S2, which verifies that the number of gapless modes around each Weyl point is proportional to . There are four gapless modes around each quadratic Weyl point in Figure S2, while there are two gapless modes around each Weyl point in Figure S2, which shows that the number of gapless modes around each Weyl point is proportional to . The propagating directions of gapless modes around each linear Weyl point in Figure S2 are opposite to those in Figure S2, showing that the propagating directions of gapless modes are proportional to the sign of . We know that in our models the chirality of two inner Weyl points is opposite to that of two outer Weyl points on the axis. As a result, in each of the four sub-figures in Figure S2 the propagating direction of the inner two branches of gapless modes is opposite to that of the outer two branches of gapless modes, which shows that the propagating directions of the gapless modes are proportional to the sign of .
The Tight-binding Models of Linear and Quadratic Weyl Semimetals
In the main text, we have given the model of linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals. However, we use the lattice models rather than the models to calculate the vortex bound states. So in this section, we introduce the tight-binding lattice models of linear and quadratic Weyl semimetals. Since Dirac semimetals are well classified [8], we decide to break inversion symmetry in a Dirac semimetal to obtain a Weyl semimetal.
The Lattice Model and kp Model of a Linear Weyl Semimetal
The tight-binding model of the linear Dirac semimetal with TRS, inversion symmetry, and rotational symmetry is written under the basis , in which each state is the eigenstate of inversion and operations labelled by the corresponding eigenvalues. Adding the inversion symmetry breaking term into the model of linear Dirac semimetal leads to the tight-binding lattice model of linear Weyl semimetal
Here we consider the cubic lattice. and are the nearest-neighbor hopping terms in plane, and is the nearest neighbor hopping term in direction. is the next nearest neighbor hopping term, and is the third nearest neighbor hopping term. and are the on-site term and inversion symmetry breaking term, respectively. Here and represent spin and orbital degrees of freedom, respectively.
If we substitute with and substitute with (, , and ), we will obtain the model of linear Weyl semimetal
Here , and . The correspondence between parameters in the model and those in the lattice model is , , , , , and .
Next we show that the low-energy effective Hamiltonian is a Weyl Hamiltonian. The gap closing condition of above Hamiltonian leads to four Weyl points located on axis with and . When we consider the low-energy physics, we omit the higher-order term in the model of linear Weyl semimetal. Then the Hamiltonian will be decoupled into the upper-left block and the lower-right block. The Weyl point at is obtained from the gap closing condition in the upper-left block. So we expand the upper-left block of the Hamiltonian around the Weyl point located at
Here we use the notation and . The Weyl point at is obtained from the gap closing condition in the lower-right block. Then we expand the lower-right block around
Here we use the notation and . Obviously, Eq. (16) and Eq. (17) describe linear Weyl fermions. In fact, the low-energy Hamiltonians around other two Weyl points and are also Weyl Hamiltonians. Thus, Eq. (15) is indeed a Hamiltonian describing a Weyl semimetal.
The Lattice Model and Model of Quadratic Weyl Semimetal
According to the classification of Dirac semimetals [8], the appearance of a quadratic Dirac point requires the existence of symmetry. Therefore, the lattice model of the quadratic Dirac semimetal is written under the basis , in which each state is the eigenstate of inversion and operations labelled by the corresponding eigenvalues. After considering an inversion symmetry breaking term , we write down the tight-binding lattice model of a quadratic Weyl semimetal
Here we consider the three-dimensional hexagonal lattice. and are the nearest-neighbor hopping terms in plane, and is the nearest neighbor hopping term in direction. is the third nearest neighbor hopping term in plane, and is the next nearest neighbor hopping term. and are the on-site term and inversion symmetry-breaking term, respectively. Here and represent spin and orbital degrees of freedom, respectively.
If we substitute with and substitute with ( and ), we will obtain the model of quadratic Weyl semimetal
Here , and . The correspondence between parameters in the model and those in the lattice model is , , , , , and .
Next we show that the corresponding low-energy effective Hamiltonian is a quadratic Weyl Hamiltonian. The gap closing condition of above Hamiltonian leads to four Weyl points located on axis with and . When we consider the low-energy physics, we omit the higher-order term in the model of quadratic Weyl semimetal. Then the Hamiltonian will be decoupled into the upper-left block and the lower-right block. The Weyl point at is obtained from the gap closing condition in the upper-left block. So we expand the upper-left block of the Hamiltonian around the Weyl point located at
Here we use the notation and . We find that Eq. (20) describes quadratic Weyl fermions. It is not hard to derive the low-energy Hamiltonians around other three Weyl points, and all of them are quadratic Weyl Hamiltonians. Therefore, the Hamiltonian Eq. (19) is the model describing a quadratic Weyl semimetal.
References
References
- [1]G. Y. Cho, J. H. Bardarson, Y.-M. Lu, and J. E. Moore, Phys. Rev. B 86, 214514 (2012).
- [2]T. Meng and L. Balents, Phys. Rev. B 86, 054504 (2012).
- [3]J. C. Y. Teo and C. L. Kane, Phys. Rev. B 82, 115120 (2010).
- [4]B. A. Bernevig, in Topological Insulators and Topological Superconductors (Princeton university press, 2013).
- [5]X.-L. Qi, T. L. Hughes, and S.-C. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 78, 195424 (2008).
- [6]C. Chan and X.-J. Liu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 207002 (2017).
- [7]C. Chan, L. Zhang, T. F. J. Poon, Y.-P. He, Y.-Q. Wang, and X.-J. Liu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 047001 (2017).
- [8]B.-J. Yang and N. Nagaosa, Nature Communications 5, 4898 (2014).


