betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster study of systematic shifts and fine-structure constant sensitivity in {\rm Cf17+^{17+}}, {\rm Cm15+^{15+}} and {\rm Bk16+^{16+}} highly charged ions

Abstract

Highly charged ions (HCIs) are among the most promising candidates proposed for the development of next-generation optical clocks and the precision tests of fundamental physics. In this work, we investigate the clock-relevant properties of Cf17+\rm Cf^{17+}, Cm15+\rm Cm^{15+} and Bk16+\rm Bk^{16+} HCIs using Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster (FSRCC) theory. The corrections from Breit interaction, QED effects and perturbative triples are incorporated to improve the accuracy of results further. We compute excitation energies, transition amplitudes, lifetimes, hyperfine structure constants, electric quadrupole moments, and electric dipole polarizabilities for low-lying states of these ions. These properties are further used to characterize important clock transitions and estimate key systematic frequency shifts. Our calculations reveal that the proposed clock transitions exhibit strongly suppressed systematic frequency shifts. We also compute the sensitivity coefficients, qq, and enhancement factors, KαK_α, for the proposed clock transition as a probe to variation in the fine-structure constant, αα. Our calculations predict exceptionally large KαK_α of −55.3-55.3 and 57.557.5 for 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow 6p_{1/2} transition in Cf17+\rm Cf^{17+} and 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow 5f_{5/2} transition in Bk16+\rm Bk^{16+}, respectively. These giant KαK_αs place the proposed transitions among the most sensitive optical probes for the laboratory searches for αα variation. Further, a comparative analysis of proposed transitions in Cm15+\rm Cm^{15+} and Bk16+\rm Bk^{16+} shows that, 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow 5f_{7/2} transition possess smaller systematic shifts and is therefore attractive for precision frequency metrology, whereas 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow 5f_{5/2} transition exhibit significantly enhanced sensitivity to αα variation.

hci.pdf

Introduction—The extraordinary accuracy and stability of optical atomic clocks have enabled applications ranging from precision frequency metrology and relativistic geodesy [1] to the test of general relativity [3] [2] and the searches for physics beyond the Standard Model [4, 5]. Among the key applications, the search for possible temporal variation of fine-structure constant, α\alpha, has attracted a considerable interest [6, 7, 8]. Any detectable variation in α\alpha would provide evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model and can offer important insights into cosmology and the nature of dark matter. The sensitivity of a clock-comparison experiment is determined by the difference in the enhancement factors (KαK_{\alpha}) of the two clock transitions. For example, comparisons between 199Hg+{}^{199}\mathrm{Hg}^{+} and 27Al+{}^{27}\mathrm{Al}^{+} optical clocks, for which ΔKα≈2.95\Delta K_{\alpha} \approx2.95, constrained the temporal variation of α\alpha at the level of 10−17 yr−110^{-17}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} [9]. Further, recent measurements of the frequency ratio between E2 and E3 clock transitions in 171Yb+{}^{171}\mathrm{Yb}^{+}, characterized by ΔKα≈−6.95\Delta K_{\alpha} \approx-6.95, improved this limit to 10−18 yr−110^{-18}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} [10]. These remarkable achievements have motivated the search for atomic systems possessing substantially larger KαK_{\alpha}s.

Highly charged ions (HCIs) have emerged as promising candidates for probing α\alpha [11, 12, 13]. Their compact electronic structure leads to reduced sensitivities to external perturbations. In addition, the large nuclear charge, strong relativistic effects, and high ionization potentials in HCIs enhance their sensitivity to α\alpha variation. Among the proposed HCI based clocks, ions near the 5f5f-6p6p level crossing are of particular interest [14]. One of the most prominent examples is Cf17+^{17+}, which was identified by Berengut et al. [11] as a highly promising candidate for probing variation in α\alpha. The 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \to6p_{1/2} optical transition in this ion combines a narrow linewidth with one of the largest enhancement factors predicted for any optical-clock transition. Moreover recently, Porsev et al. [15, 16] carried out high-precision coupled-cluster (CC) calculations and demonstrated that Cf17+^{17+} possesses favorable clock characteristics together with extraordinary sensitivity to α\alpha variation. The neighboring ions Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} have also been proposed as attractive clock candidates by Dzuba et al. [17]. The states 6p1/26p_{1/2}, 5f5/25f_{5/2}, and 5f7/25f_{7/2} in these HCIs lie within the optical domain and are suitable for two potential clock transitions, 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \to5f_{5/2} and 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \to5f_{7/2}. The former one involves orbitals of markedly different relativistic character, whereas the latter corresponds to a fine-structure transition within the 5f5f manifold. These contrasting electronic configurations in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} make them interesting systems for investigating the interplay between clock accuracy and sensitivity to the variation in fundamental constants.

Despite their considerable promise, experimental information on the low-lying spectra and clock-relevant properties of these HCIs remains extremely limited. Consequently, the characterization of these systems presently relies almost entirely on theoretical predictions. However, the available theoretical studies are also limited. For Cf17+^{17+}, only the pioneering work of Berengut et al. [11] and the subsequent CC studies of Porsev et al. [15, 16] are available, whereas for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} the available data are largely restricted to the recent linearized CC calculations of Dzuba et al. [17]. Although these works established the exceptional potential of these ions, a comprehensive and uniform investigation of their clock-relevant properties is still lacking. In particular, while both 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \to5f_{5/2} and 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \to5f_{7/2} transitions were proposed as promising transitions in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, a quantitative comparison of their relative merits has not yet been carried out. Importantly, key properties such as transition amplitudes, lifetimes, hyperfine structure constants, electric quadrupole moments, dipole polarizabilities, and systematic frequency shifts have not been investigated consistently within a common high-precision many-body framework which systematically incorporates correlation and relativistic effects to the same level of accuracy. Moreover, the calculations reported for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} employ a linearized CC treatment, missing the important correlation effects from nonlinear terms.

In this work, we perform a systematic Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster (FSRCC) [18–20] investigation of the spectroscopic properties of low-lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. Electron-correlation effects are treated to all orders within the CC framework, while the corrections from the Breit interaction, QED effects and perturbative triples are incorporated to improve the accuracy of calculations further. We calculate the aforementioned clock’s relevant spectroscopic properties. Further, we estimate the dominant systematic shifts in clock transition frequencies, including blackbody-radiation (BBR), electric-quadrupole (EQ), quadratic Zeeman, and micromotion-induced (MI). In addition, relativistic sensitivity coefficients and enhancement factors are determined as a probe to α\alpha variation. Our work also enables a direct comparison of the competing clock transitions in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, providing a quantitative assessment of their suitability for high-accuracy clocks and as a probe for α\alpha variation.

Basis Set, Excitation Energy, Lifetime and Hyperfine Constants—We have used Gaussian type orbitals (GTOs) as basis function for FSRCC calculations [21]. The self-energy (SE) correction to orbitals’ energies is incorporated through the model Lamb-shift operator [22], whereas the correction from the vacuum polarization (VP) is accounted using Uehling potential [23]. The GTO parameters are optimized to reproduce the self-consistent field (SCF) and single-particle energies obtained from B-spline [24]. Tables ?? and ?? in Supplemental Material (SM) lists the optimized GTO parameters and comparison of GTO energies with B-spline data. We observe an excellent agreement for both single-particle as well as SCF energies with B-spline results. Further, Fig. ?? in SM demonstrates the convergence of computed properties with basis size.

Table I lists the excitation energies (EEs) for low-lying excited states of considered HCIs. As to be expected, Dirac-Fock (DF) constitutes the dominant part of EE in all three ions. For example, it accounts for approximately 53%, 118%, and 155% of total EE for first excited state in all three HCIs. The second largest contribution comes from the electron correlation due to residual Coulomb interaction. This exhibits a pronounced state dependence both in magnitude as well as sign due to different strengths of core-valence correlation effects. The largest cumulative Breit+QED contribution is observed to be ≈1.3%\approx1.3\% in 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+} (Fig. ?? in SM). This is a significant contribution and essential for high accuracy clocks. To the best of our knowledge, there are no reported values of experimental EEs for HCIs considered. In the case of Cf17+^{17+}, for 6p1/26p_{1/2}, there is a noticeable difference among previous results. The lowest and highest reported values differ by approximately 13%. Though Refs. [15, 16] employ the same CCSDT method, their results differ by about 4%. Our EE for 6p1/26p_{1/2} is lower than all previous values. The

StatesDFFSRCCBreit+ QEDTotalOthers
6p1/26p_{1/2}845016288−212-2121607618686a18686^{a}, 20611b20611^{b}, 21456c21456^{c}
6p3/26p_{3/2}233476240772−48-48240724242811a242811^{a}, 243081b243081^{b}, 244125c244125^{c}
5f7/25f_{7/2}2044821516−7-72150921848a21848^{a}, 20895b20895^{b}, 20870c20870^{c}
5f5/25f_{5/2}51258433021004340238375d38375^{d}
5f7/25f_{7/2}67020601011026020354730d54730^{d}
6p3/26p_{3/2}18328018439877184475182359d182359^{d}
5f5/25f_{5/2}2217614139127142668880d8880^{d}
5f7/25f_{7/2}40208332211173333827520d27520^{d}
6p3/26p_{3/2}203445203201106203307202403d202403^{d}

Table I. TABLE I. Excitation energies (cm−1^{-1}) of low-lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs using FSRCC theory. For a quantitative assessment of electron correlation, separate contributions from different correlation terms are also provided. Our final values are compared with other available theoretical results.

a^{a}Ref. [11][CI + MBPT], b^{b}Ref. [15][CCSDT], c^{c}Ref. [16][CCSDT], d^{d}Ref. [17][LCCSD].

lower value, compared to Ref. [11], could be attributed to the differences in the computational methodologies employed in the two works, whereas the difference with Ref. [16] may partly be attributed to different implementations of Breit interaction. For 6p3/26p_{3/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states, our results are consistent with previous results and, as to be expected, more closer to the CCSDT results from Refs. [15, 16]. The observed differences among previous results and ours can be attributed to the varying treatment of electron-correlation and relativistic effects. For Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, we observed large differences in the EEs for first two excited states compared to linearized coupled-cluster theory with single and double approximation (LCCSD) results of Ref. [17]. For example, for Cm15+^{15+}, our results are larger by ≈13%\approx13\% and 10%, respectively. For Bk16+^{16+}, the difference is even more. The reason could be attributed to the different treatment of electron correlations in the two works. In Ref. [17], core-core and core-valence correlations are treated using a linearized CC theory, whereas the present work uses a non-linear CC theory. Additional differences could also arise because of different implementation of Breit and QED effects.

Table II presents our results on transition rates (A) and lifetimes (τ\tau) for some low-lying excited states of HCIs considered. For a quantitative assessment, we have explicitly given the relevant decay channels and corresponding contributions. To the best of our knowledge, there are no experimental results on τ\tau for comparison for any of the considered HCIs. Our calculated τ\tau for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+} is observed to be approximately three times larger than that of only available result [15]. The reason for this could be attributed to the difference in EEs in the two works. In contrast, the EEs of 6p3/26p_{3/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states are in closer agreement with Ref. [15], resulting in good agreement between the corresponding τ\taus. A similar trend is also observed for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} ions, where we observe a noticeable difference for first excited state compared to LCCSD results of Ref. [17]. This difference could be attributed to the more accurate treatment of core-core and core-valence correlations in our calculations. The contributions from Breit and QED corrections are observed to be not very significant in all three ions (Fig ?? in SM). The largest Breit+QED contribution is observed to be −0.02%-0.02\% in the case of 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+}. Whereas, perturbative triples are observed to have non negligible contributions, with a largest contribution of 0.3%0.3\% in the case of 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+}.

Energy level diagrams of low-lying states of Cf$^{17+}$, Cm$^{15+}$ and Bk$^{16+}$ HCIs

Figure 1. Energy level diagrams of low-lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. Energies, lifetimes and wavelengths shown in the figures are obtained from present calculations. The proposed clock transitions are indicated by double-headed arrows.

Table III presents our results on magnetic-dipole (A/gIA/g_I) and electric-quadrupole (B/QB/Q) hyperfine structure (HFS) constants for low-lying states of HCIs. For A/gIA/g_I, our calculations show that the contributions from Breit, SE, and perturbative triples corrections are not very significant in all three ions (Fig. ?? in SM). Whereas, VP has a noticeable contribution of approximately 0.4%0.4\% to 6p1/26p_{1/2} state in all three ions. For B/QB/Q, we get negligible contributions from all higher-order relativistic and correlation corrections. To the best of our knowledge, no experimental measurements of AA or BB are available for any of the states considered. Theoretical calculations are too very few. Our calculated A/gIA/g_I for 5f5/25f_{5/2} state of Cf17+^{17+} is approximately 7.4%7.4\% smaller than Ref. [15], whereas for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state, the two calculations are closer. Since Ref. [15] does not provide separate contributions from higher-order corrections, a detailed term-by-term comparison is not feasible. It should, however, be noted that the uncertainty related to HFS constants in Ref. [15] is estimated to be 20-30%. Comparing our results for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, there are differences with only available calculation [17] using LCCSD theory. And, as mentioned earlier, the reason for this could be the missing non-linear correlation effects in Ref. [17], along with small differences Breit and QED corrections. For B/QB/Q, our calculations provide the first theoretical data for the HCIs considered. Since both AA and BBs serve as a probe for electronic wavefunction in nucleus region, they constitute a stringent test for the accuracy of many-body wavefunctions in HCIs.

Upper stateLower stateDecay channelAA (s−1^{-1})τ\tau (s) This workτ\tau (s) Other cal.
6p1/26p_{1/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}E25.115[−2]19.6076.0a^{a}
6p3/26p_{3/2}6p1/26p_{1/2}E22.825[4]6.7[−6]7.0[−6]a^{a}
M19.746[4]
5f5/25f_{5/2}E24.715[3]
M14.396[−1]
5f7/25f_{7/2}E21.894[4]
5f7/25f_{7/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}E27.427[−3]0.00840.0095a^{a}
M11.188[?]
5f5/25f_{5/2}6p1/26p_{1/2}E23.1580.3180.576b^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}E22.936[−3]0.0180.02b^{b}
M15.653[?]
6p3/26p_{3/2}6p1/26p_{1/2}E21.320[4]1.5[−5]
M15.352[4]
5f5/25f_{5/2}E24.476[?]
M19.561[−2]
5f7/25f_{7/2}E21.506[3]
5f5/25f_{5/2}6p1/26p_{1/2}E29.874[−3]101.388787b^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}E24.731[−3]0.0120.013b^{b}
M18.284[?]
6p3/26p_{3/2}6p1/26p_{1/2}E21.948[4]9.9[−6]
M17.271[4]
5f5/25f_{5/2}E21.679[3]
M12.237[−1]
5f7/25f_{7/2}E26.310[3]

Table II. FSRCC results for transition rates (AA) and lifetimes (τ\tau) for low lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. The values given for τ\tau from this work also include the contribution from Breit, QED and perturbative triples corrections.

Systematic shifts– Now we present and discuss our results on leading frequency shifts for proposed clock transitions and assess their suitability for high-precision optical clock applia^{a}Ref.[15][CCSDT], b^{b}Ref.[17][LCCSD].

cations. Within the static approximation, the BBR-induced frequency shift for a clock transition between ∣g⟩|g\rangle and ∣e⟩|e\rangle states at temperature TT is given by

ΔνBBR(T)=−12h⟨E2(T)⟩Δαs,(1)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}(T)=-\frac{1}{2h}\langle E^2(T)\rangle\Delta\alpha_s, \tag*{(1)}

where Δαs\Delta\alpha_s is the differential static scalar electric dipole polarizability between ∣g⟩|g\rangle and ∣e⟩|e\rangle states. ⟨E2(T)⟩=(831.9 V/m)2(T300K)4\langle E^2(T)\rangle=(831.9\,\mathrm{V/m})^2\left(\frac{T}{300\mathrm{K}}\right)^4 is the mean-squared electric field associated with blackbody radiation and hh is the Planck’s constant. As it is evident from Eq. (1), the accuracy of ΔνBBR(T)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}(T) is governed by the accuracy of Δαs\Delta\alpha_s.

Table ?? in SM lists αs\alpha_s for relevant states of considered HCIs. The dominant contribution is observed to originate from the closed-shell core. For example, in the case of Cf17+^{17+}, the core contributes approximately 82%, 94%, and 94% of total αs\alpha_s for 6p1/26p_{1/2}, 5f5/25f_{5/2}, and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states, respectively. Similar trends are also observed for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} ions. Among the valence-electrons, 6d3/26d_{3/2} state provides the largest contribution of approximately 17-18% to 6p1/26p_{1/2}. For 5f5/25f_{5/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2}, the dominant valence contributions arise mainly from 6d3/26d_{3/2} and 5g5g states and contribute only a few percent to total αs\alpha_s. The Briet and QED corrections are found to have a negligible influence on αs\alpha_s. In contrast, perturbative triples are observed to have more significant contributions, with the largest one of 0.3%.

To the best of our knowledge, no experimental measurements of αs\alpha_s are available for any of the states considered. Theoretical data are also too scarce. Our calculated αs\alpha_s for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+} is approximately 18% larger than Ref.

[15]. The αs\alpha_s for 5f5/25f_{5/2} state from two works are closer with a small difference of about 2%. For Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, the only available theoretical results are those in Ref. [17]. Relative to this, the present calculations differ by approximately 13%, 4%, and 4% for 6p1/26p_{1/2}, 5f5/25f_{5/2}, and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states, respectively. These differences could be attributed to more complete treatment of electron correlation in our work through nonlinear contributions in CC.

Using our calculated Δαs\Delta\alpha_s, we estimate the BBR shifts associated with proposed clock transitions in considered HCIs (Table IV). For 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow6p_{1/2} clock transition in Cf17+^{17+}, our estimated δνBBR/ν\delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}/\nu is approximately an order of magnitude larger than the value in Ref. [15]. This difference arises primarily due to the differences in Δαs\Delta\alpha_s used in the two calculations. The same trend is observed for 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} clock transition in Cm15+^{15+} with respect to Ref. [17]. In contrast, δνBBR/ν\delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}/\nu for 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition in Cm15+^{15+} is of the same order as that in Ref. [17]. For Bk16+^{16+}, our estimated δνBBR/ν\delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}/\nu for 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition is an order smaller than in Ref. [17]. Overall, our analysis indicates that 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition exhibit smaller δνBBR/ν\delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}/\nu than 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}. This is due to extremely small Δαs\Delta\alpha_s associated with fine-structure 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition.

IonTransitionΔαs\Delta\alpha_s (a.u.)δνBBR/ν\delta\nu_{\mathrm{BBR}}/\nuOthers
Cf17+^{17+}5f5/2−6p1/25f_{5/2}-6p_{1/2}0.1418−2.5×10−18-2.5\times10^{-18}5.9×10−195.9\times10^{-19} [a]
Cm15+^{15+}6p1/2−5f5/26p_{1/2}-5f_{5/2}−0.1595-0.15951.1×10−181.1\times10^{-18}−3.4×10−19-3.4\times10^{-19} [b]
Cm15+^{15+}5f5/2−5f7/25f_{5/2}-5f_{7/2}−0.0045-0.00457.8×10−207.8\times10^{-20}2.2×10−202.2\times10^{-20} [b]
Bk16+^{16+}6p1/2−5f5/26p_{1/2}-5f_{5/2}−0.1545-0.15453.2×10−183.2\times10^{-18}−1.5×10−18-1.5\times10^{-18} [b]
Bk16+^{16+}5f5/2−5f7/25f_{5/2}-5f_{7/2}−0.0005-0.00057.6×10−217.6\times10^{-21}3.4×10−203.4\times10^{-20}

Table IV. Relative frequency shift due to BBR in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs.

a^{a}Ref.[15][CCSDT], b^{b}Ref.[17][LCCSD].

Next, we estimate the EQ shift which originates due to an interaction between atomic quadrupole moment and an external electric-field gradient. In trapped-ion optical clocks, electric-field gradients generated by the trapping potential can perturb states with non-vanishing quadrupole moments, leading to shifts in the clock frequency. The interaction of electric quadrupole moment (Θ\Theta) with an external electric-field gradient gives rise to a frequency shift

ΔνQ=−12hΔ⟨Q0⟩∂Ez∂z,(2)\Delta\nu_Q=-\frac{1}{2h}\Delta\langle Q_0\rangle\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_z}{\partial z}, \tag*{(2)}

where Q0=∑i(32zi2−12ri2)Q_0=\sum_i\left(\frac{3}{2}z_i^2-\frac{1}{2}r_i^2\right) is the zero component of the electric quadrupole operator, Δ⟨Q0⟩\Delta\langle Q_0\rangle denotes the difference in the expectation values of Q0Q_0 between ∣g⟩|g\rangle and ∣e⟩|e\rangle states, and Θ=2⟨γJ,MJ=J∣Q0∣γJ,MJ=J⟩\Theta=2\langle\gamma J,M_J=J|Q_0|\gamma J,M_J=J\rangle.

The Θ\Theta from our calculations for low-lying states are listed in Table V. For Cf17+^{17+}, our calculated Θ\Theta for 5f5/25f_{5/2} state is in excellent agreement with the value reported in Ref. [15], except the sign difference which could arise due to different conventions used in the definition of single-electron quadrupole opa^{a}Ref. [15]-CCSDT, b^{b}Ref. [17]-LCCSD,

StatesCf17+^{17+} PresentCf17+^{17+} OthersCm15+^{15+} PresentCm15+^{15+} OthersBk16+^{16+} PresentBk16+^{16+} Others
5f5/25f_{5/2}−0.398-0.3980.39a0.39^{a}−0.464-0.464−0.459b-0.459^{b}−0.428-0.428−0.507b-0.507^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}−0.476-0.476−0.556-0.556−0.550b-0.550^{b}−0.512-0.512−0.604b-0.604^{b}
6p3/26p_{3/2}−0.666-0.666−0.754-0.754−0.708-0.708

Table V. The electric quadrupole moment (∣e∣a02|e|a_0^2) for low lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs.

erator. For Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, our results slightly differ from those reported in Ref. [17] due to the reasons discussed earlier. Since EQ shift is directly proportional to the differential Θ\Theta, Θ\Theta provides a measure of the intrinsic sensitivity of a clock transition to the electric-field gradients. The differential Θ\Theta are calculated to be 0.398 ∣e∣a020.398\ |e|a_0^2 for the 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow6p_{1/2} transition in Cf17+^{17+} and 0.464 ∣e∣a020.464\ |e|a_0^2 and 0.428 ∣e∣a020.428\ |e|a_0^2 for 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow5f_{5/2} transitions in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. In contrast, for 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition, since the two 5f5f states have very close Θ\Theta, differential Θ\Theta is very small; 0.092 ∣e∣a020.092\ |e|a_0^2, 0.084 ∣e∣a020.084\ |e|a_0^2 for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. These values are approximately five times smaller than those associated with 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow5f_{5/2} transitions. Therefore, from the perspective of EQ systematic effects, the 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition is expected to provide a more robust clock reference than 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition in both Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}. However, the EQ shift can be eliminated for clock transition in all three systems by choosing the F=3F=3, mF=±2m_F=\pm2 hyperfine sublevels, for which the angular factor vanishes, irrespective of the magnitude of the electronic quadrupole moments.

We now assess the micromotion-induced frequency shifts. In radio-frequency (RF) Paul trap, the oscillating trapping field induces a driven motion of confined ion, commonly referred to as the micromotion. This gives rise to two competing contributions to the clock frequency: the second-order Doppler shift associated with the ion velocity and, an AC Stark shift caused by oscillating electric field. These two effects can be made to cancel each other at a particular RF drive frequency, known as the magic trap drive frequency. Operation of trap at this frequency suppresses the net micromotion-induced frequency shift and hence improves the attainable clock accuracy. The magic trap drive frequency can be expressed as

Ω=∣e∣Mic−hνclockΔαs,(3)\Omega= \frac{|e|}{M_i c}\sqrt{-\frac{h\nu_{\mathrm{clock}}}{\Delta\alpha_s}}, \tag*{(3)}

where Mi≈AmpM_i \approx A m_p is the ion mass (mpm_p is the mass of proton) and Δαs\Delta\alpha_s is the differential polarizability of the clock states. As given in Table IV, Δαs\Delta\alpha_s are obtained as 0.14180.1418 a.u. for the 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow6p_{1/2} transition in Cf17+^{17+} and −0.1595-0.1595 a.u. and −0.1545-0.1545 a.u. for the 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. For 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition, Δαs\Delta\alpha_s is significantly smaller, −0.0045-0.0045 a.u. and −0.0005-0.0005 a.u., respectively in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}. It should be noted that, our computed Δαs\Delta\alpha_s for 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow6p_{1/2} transition in Cf17+^{17+} is of opposite sign compared to that in Ref. [15] due to a larger αs\alpha_s for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state in our work. Our computed αs\alpha_s for 5f5/25f_{5/2} state is, however, in close agreement with Ref. [15]. Since Δαs\Delta\alpha_s is positive for this clock transition, a magic trap drive frequency does not exist for Cf17+^{17+} ion.

Further, we evaluated Ω\Omega for the proposed clock transitions in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}. To the best of our knowledge, the present work provides the first theoretical estimates of Ω\Omega for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} ions. For 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition, Ω\Omega is obtained to be 117.64117.64 MHz and 67.9467.94 MHz for Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. In contrast, substantially larger values, 425.21425.21 MHz and 1391.281391.28 MHz, respectively are obtained for 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition in these ions. This considerably larger Ω\Omega could be attributed to their extremely small Δαs\Delta\alpha_s. Although these small Δαs\Delta\alpha_s reflect a strong cancellation of AC Stark contribution arising from trapping field, they simultaneously require much higher RF drive frequencies to achieve a complete cancellation of the micromotion-induced shift. So, the present analysis shows that the micromotion-induced frequency shift can be effectively suppressed in the proposed clock transitions in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} through operation at corresponding magic trap drive frequencies.

The magnetic-field induced frequency shifts are important sources of systematic uncertainty in the optical atomic clocks. In the weak-field regime, the Zeeman splitting to energy of a state is given by ΔEM=CM1B+CM2B2\Delta E_M=C_{M1}B+C_{M2}B^2, where CM1=μBgJMC_{M1}=\mu_B g_J M (μB\mu_B is the Bohr magneton and gJg_J is the Lande g-factor) is the first-order Zeeman coefficient. The first-order Zeeman shift can be suppressed by choosing clock transitions with MF=0M_F=0 states or by averaging it with equal and opposite first-order shifts. The quadratic Zeeman shift then leads to the dominant frequency shift. The coefficient CM2C_{M2} can be evaluated, within second-order perturbation theory [25],

CM2(F,M)=−(μBgJ)2∑F′≠F∣⟨F′MF∣Jz∣FMF⟩∣2EF′−EF,(4)C_{M2}(F,M)=-(\mu_B g_J)^2 \sum_{F'\ne F}\frac{|\langle F'M_F|J_z|FM_F\rangle|^2}{E_{F'}-E_F}, \tag*{(4)}

where only levels with F′=F±1F'=F\pm1 contribute. The expressions used in our calculations and the calculated hyperfine splitting energies and CM2C_{M2} coefficients are provided in the SM.

For 251^{251}Cf17+^{17+}, since the nuclear spin (II) is 1/21/2, the hyperfine structure is determined solely by the magnetic-dipole HFS constant AA. Using our calculated A/gIA/g_I values (Table III) and the nuclear magnetic moment μ=−0.571 μN\mu=-0.571\ \mu_N [26], the smallest differential coefficient is obtained to be ΔCM2=−5.87\Delta C_{M2}=-5.87 kHz/(mT)2^2 for 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \rightarrow6p_{1/2} with F=0→F=2F=0 \rightarrow F=2 or F=1→F=3F=1 \rightarrow F=3 clock transitions. For a clock frequency of 4.819×10144.819\times10^{14} Hz and the magnetic field of 10 μ10\ \muT, this corresponds to a fractional frequency shift (FFS) of −1.2173×10−15-1.2173\times10^{-15}. Our computed FFS in good agreement with Ref. [15].

StatesFSRCCBreit+QED +TriplesTotalOthers
Cf17+^{17+}
5f5/25f_{5/2}1764(3295)−4(9)1760(3304)1900a^{a}
6p1/26p_{1/2}198766(0)791(0)199557(0)195000a^{a}
6p3/26p_{3/2}10450(26362)−8(17)19442(26379)
5f7/25f_{7/2}1231(3857)3(11)1234(3868)
Cm15+^{15+}
6p1/26p_{1/2}157685(0)633(0)158314(0)154000b^{b}
5f5/25f_{5/2}1392(2381)9(6)1401(2387)1550b^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}1011(3324)2(12)1013(3336)689b^{b}
6p3/26p_{3/2}8821(24296)−7(17)8814(22120)
Bk16+^{16+}
6p1/26p_{1/2}178846(0)712(0)179558(0)174000b^{b}
5f5/25f_{5/2}1568(3138)8(6)1576(3144)1740b^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}1120(3673)0(10)1120(3683)772b^{b}
6p3/26p_{3/2}9644(24296)−6(18)9638(24314)

Table III. A/gI(B/Q)A/g_I(B/Q) in the units of MHz/μN\mu_N(MHz/eb) for low lying states of considered HCIs. The cumulative Breit, QED and perturbative triples corrections are listed separately. Values from previous works correspond to A/gIA/g_I.

For 247^{247}Cm15+^{15+} and 249^{249}Bk16+^{16+}, since the data on the nuclear quadrupole moments are not available, to evaluate the hyperfine splitting energies we use the dominant magnetic-dipole interaction. We used the nuclear magnetic moments μ=0.36 μN\mu=0.36\ \mu_N [27] and 2.0 μN2.0\ \mu_N [27], respectively, to obtain the smallest ΔCM2\Delta C_{M2} for 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} and 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transitions. For a^{a}Ref.[11]-CI + MBPT, b^{b}Ref.[17]-LCCSD.

Cm15+^{15+}, we get ΔCM2\Delta\mathrm{CM2} as 103.575 and 255.65 kHz/(mT)2^2, with corresponding fractional shifts obtained as 7.960×10−157.960 \times10^{-15} and 5.076×10−145.076 \times10^{-14} at 1.301×10151.301 \times10^{15} and 5.037×10145.037 \times10^{14} Hz clock frequencies, respectively. For Bk16+^{16+}, the corresponding ΔCM2\Delta\mathrm{CM2}s are 21.151 and 32.655 kHz/(mT)2^2, leading to fractional shifts of 4.945×10−154.945 \times10^{-15} and 5.711×10−155.711 \times10^{-15} at clock frequencies of 4.277×10144.277 \times10^{14} and 5.718×10145.718 \times10^{14} Hz, respectively. These results may be considered as estimates because the electric-quadrupole correction may modify the hyperfine splittings and, hence, ΔCM2\Delta\mathrm{CM2}. More precise predictions will require improved knowledge of the magnetic-field strength and nuclear magnetic moments.

Sensitivity to variation in the fine-structure constant

We now present and discuss our results on sensitivity coefficient (qq) and enhancement factor (KαK_{\alpha}) for the proposed clock transitions. The sensitivity coefficient is extracted by computing the gradient

q=dωdx∣x=0,(5)q=\left.\frac{d\omega}{dx}\right|_{x=0}, \tag*{(5)}

where ω\omega is the atomic transition frequency and x=(αα0)2−1x=\left(\frac{\alpha}{\alpha_0}\right)^2-1 is a perturbation arising due to change in α\alpha from its current value α0\alpha_0. The enhancement factor can be obtained from the sensitivity coefficient using the relation Kα=2q/ω0K_{\alpha}=2q/\omega_0.

To extract qq, transition energies were calculated for several values of xx in the vicinity of x=0x=0 and qq is extracted from fitting the EE vs. xx data. In all HCIs, our calculated energy exhibit an excellent linearity (Fig. ?? in SM), demonstrating that higher-order terms in the expansion of ω\omega are negligible over the investigated range. And hence, qq can be reliably identified as the slope of EE vs. xx curve. Since the fitting procedure utilizes multiple calculated points, it is less susceptible to numerical fluctuations than the two-points finite-difference estimates. Among the higher-order corrections in qq (discussed in SM), VP has the largest contribution, about 0.3% for 6p3/26p_{3/2} state in Cm15+^{15+}. Although small, these are important for obtaining reliable qq at accuracy commensurate with precision frequency standards.

For the HCIs considered here, a very few theoretical results on qq are available in the literature. Our computed qq is consistent with previously reported values for all HCIs, with minor differences due to more accurate treatment of electron correlation in our work. For example, in the case of Cf17+^{17+}, our computed qq differ by ≃0.2%\simeq0.2\%, 0.4%0.4\%, and −1.3%-1.3\% for corresponding states from CI+MBPT calculation [11]. Similarly, for Cm15+^{15+}, our calculated qq for 5f5/25f_{5/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states differ by ≃−0.7%\simeq-0.7\% and −0.5%-0.5\%, respectively, from LCCSD calculation [17]. Whereas, for Bk16+^{16+}, the corresponding differences are 0.8% and 0.6%, respectively. These deviations could be attributed to the inclusion of non-linear CC terms in present calculations, which are absent in the LCCSD method adopted in Ref. [17].

Our reported KαK_{\alpha} further highlights the suitability of the proposed clock transitions for probing possible variation in α\alpha. Transitions with larger ∣Kα∣\lvert K_{\alpha}\rvert provide stronger experimental signature for probing variation. As evident from Table VI, in particular, the established 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow6p_{1/2} clock transition in Cf17+^{17+} exhibits a remarkably large KαK_{\alpha} of −55.3-55.3, making it one of the most sensitive optical clock transitions proposed to date for the test of α\alpha-variation. Our obtained KαK_{\alpha} is in good agreement with the value, −48.1-48.1, reported in Ref. [11]. For Cm15+^{15+}, 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition possesses a KαK_{\alpha} of 16.8, whereas the 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} has a comparatively smaller value, 1.61. This is in good agreement with the values, 15 and 2, reported in Ref. [17], respectively. In the case of Bk16+^{16+}, our KαK_{\alpha} associated with 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition increases significantly to 57.5, while 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow5f_{7/2} transition exhibits a value of 1.62. The KαK_{\alpha} obtained in present work are substantially larger than those currently used in the state-of-the-art optical-clock comparisons for probing the variation in α\alpha. For example, the comparison between E2 and E3 transitions in 171Yb+^{171}\mathrm{Yb}^{+}, one of the most sensitive laboratory probes of α\alpha variation [10], is characterized by ΔKα≈7\Delta K_{\alpha}\approx7. In contrast, 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2}\rightarrow6p_{1/2} transition in Cf17+^{17+} and 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2}\rightarrow5f_{5/2} transition in Bk16+^{16+} exhibit ∣Kα∣\lvert K_{\alpha}\rvert exceeding 50. Such large values highlight the exceptional potential of these HCIs for future optical-clock experiments aimed at probing possible temporal variation of fundamental constants.

StatesqCCSDq^{\mathrm{CCSD}}Breit+QEDqfinalq^{\mathrm{final}}KαK_{\alpha}Others
5f5/25f_{5/2}00000
6p1/26p_{1/2}−449718(743)-449718(743)−854-854−450572-450572−55.3-55.3−449750a-449750^{a}
6p3/26p_{3/2}−115083(11)-115083(11)−103-103−115186-115186−1-1−115650a-115650^{a}
5f7/25f_{7/2}17667(19)17667(19)017667176671.617900a17900^{a}
6p1/26p_{1/2}00000
5f5/25f_{5/2}363891(1142)363891(1142)69236458336458316.8367000b367000^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}377463(1063)377463(1063)64237810537810512.6380000b380000^{b}
6p3/26p_{3/2}267941(12608)267941(12608)5362684772684772.9
6p1/26p_{1/2}00000
5f5/25f_{5/2}405387(1207)405387(1207)77040615740615757.5403000b403000^{b}
5f7/25f_{7/2}420950(1125)420950(1125)67442162442162425.4419000b419000^{b}
6p3/26p_{3/2}300037(866)300037(866)8403008773008772.9

Table VI. Relativistic sensitivity coefficients (qq) (in cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1}) and enhancement factors (KαK_{\alpha}) for the proposed clock transitions in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs with respect to their ground state. The uncertainties quoted for qCCSDq^{\mathrm{CCSD}} correspond to the asymptotic standard errors of the fit.

Conclusion

We have carried out a comprehensive FS-RCC investigation of the spectroscopic properties, systematic shifts, and sensitivity to α\alpha variation in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. To improve the accuracy of computed properties further, corrections from Breit interaction, QED effects and perturbative triples are incorporated. Further, we have estimated the systematic frequency shifts for the proposed clock transitions. Our obtained strongly suppressed frequency shifts indicate that the proposed clock transitions exhibit a remarkable robustness against external perturbations. These characteristics satisfy a key requirement for the realization of ultrahigh-accuracy optical clocks based on HCIs.

The relativistic sensitivity coefficients and enhancement factors determined in our work further reveal an exceptional sensitivity of considered HCIs to possible α\alpha variation. In particular, 5f5/2→6p1/25f_{5/2} \to6p_{1/2} clock transition in Cf17+\mathrm{Cf}^{17+} exhibits an enhancement factor of Kα=−55.3K_{\alpha}=-55.3, placing it among the most sensitive optical-clock transitions proposed to date. Similarly, 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \to5f_{5/2} transition in Bk16+\mathrm{Bk}^{16+} possesses an enhancement factor of Kα=57.5K_{\alpha}=57.5, demonstrating a comparable potential. Further, a comparison of the two proposed clock transitions in Cm15+\mathrm{Cm}^{15+} and Bk16+\mathrm{Bk}^{16+} reveals a clear distinction in their optimal applications. The 6p1/2→5f5/26p_{1/2} \to5f_{5/2} transition is observed to exhibit a giant enhancement factor and is therefore particularly attractive for laboratory searches for the variation in α\alpha. In contrast, 5f5/2→5f7/25f_{5/2} \to5f_{7/2} transition displays reduced systematic shifts, making it a more favorable transition for the realization of an ultra-precise optical frequency standard. The upper bound to theoretical uncertainty in E1, E2, M1 and HFS matrix elements is 1%, whereas it is 2% in the case of αs\alpha_s.

**Acknowledgments—**We thank Suraj Pandey for useful discussions. PG acknowledges funding support from UGC (BININ04154142), Govt. of India. BKM, acknowledges the funding support from SERB, DST (Grant No. CRG/2022/003845). Calculations are performed using High Performance Computing cluster Tejas at Indian Institute of Technology Delhi and PARAM Rudra at Inter-University Accelerator Centre, New Delhi.

Supplemental Material: Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster study of systematic shifts and fine-structure constant sensitivity in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} highly charged ions

Palki Gakkhar; D. Angom; B. K. Mani

supplementary.pdf

Supplemental Material: Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster study of systematic shifts and fine-structure constant sensitivity in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} highly charged ions

Methodology

We have employed a FSRCC theory to calculate the many-body wavefunctions which are used to calculate the relevant clock’s properties and systematic shifts. For a one-valence atomic system, the many-body wavefunction is obtained by solving the eigen value equation

HDC∣Ψv⟩=Ev∣Ψv⟩,(6)H^{\mathrm{DC}}|\Psi_v\rangle= E_v|\Psi_v\rangle, \tag*{(6)}

where ∣Ψv⟩|\Psi_v\rangle is the exact atomic state of a one-valence system and EvE_v is the corresponding energy. The Hamiltonian HDCH^{\mathrm{DC}} is the Dirac-Coulomb Hamiltonian [1]. In FSRCC, ∣Ψv⟩|\Psi_v\rangle is expressed as

∣Ψv⟩=eT(0)[1+S(0)]∣Φv⟩,(7)|\Psi_v\rangle= e^{T^{(0)}}\left[1+S^{(0)}\right]|\Phi_v\rangle, \tag*{(7)}

where T(0)T^{(0)} and S(0)S^{(0)} represent the unperturbed coupled-cluster (CC) operators for closed-shell and one-valence sectors, respectively. These are obtained by solving the nonlinear CC equations discussed in our previous works: Refs. [3] [2] for closed-shell and Ref. [3, 4] for one-valence systems. ∣Φv⟩|\Phi_v\rangle is the Dirac-Fock reference state for one-valence systems and is obtained by adding an electron to the closed-shell reference state, as ∣Φv⟩=av†∣Φ0⟩|\Phi_v\rangle= a_v^\dagger|\Phi_0\rangle. We have used CCSD approximation where T(0)T^{(0)} and S(0)S^{(0)} CC operators are truncated to have only one− and two−body operators as these alone provide a good description of the atomic properties. However, to improve the accuracy of our calculations further, we include the contributions from triples excitations perturbatively discussed in our previous works [4] [2].

Basis set and convergence of properties

To get reliable properties results using FSRCC theory, it is essential to use accurate single-electron basis. In this work, we have employed Gaussian-type orbitals (GTOs) [5] as the single-electron basis. GTOs form a finite basis set where single-particle wavefunctions are expressed as linear combinations of Gaussian-type functions (GTFs). The large component of the wavefunction is expressed as

gκpL(r)=CκpLrnκe−αpr2,(8)g_{\kappa p}^{L}(r)=C_{\kappa p}^{L}r^{n_{\kappa}}e^{-\alpha_p r^2}, \tag*{(8)}

where p=0,1,2,…,Np=0, 1, 2, \ldots, N refers to the GTO index and NN is the total number of GTFs. The exponent αp\alpha_p is further expressed as α0βp−1\alpha_0\beta^{p-1}, where α0\alpha_0 and β\beta are two independent parameters. Parameters α0\alpha_0 and β\beta are optimized to reproduce the self-consistent field (SCF) and single-particle energies obtained from B-spline [6] basis. Table S1 lists the optimized Gaussian parameters and S2 compares GTOs single-particle and SCF energies with B-spline data. As evident from the table, GTOs energies are in good agreement with B-spline energies. This confirms that a good quality basis is used in our FSRCC calculations.

Atomssppddff
α0\alpha_0β\betaα0\alpha_0β\betaα0\alpha_0β\betaα0\alpha_0β\beta
Cf17+^{17+}0.004001.8250.004281.8120.005551.8750.004351.885
Cm15+^{15+}0.003401.7830.004401.8230.005551.8750.004351.885
Bk16+^{16+}0.003001.8250.004381.8550.003551.8750.003351.885

Table S1. The α0\alpha_0 and β\beta parameters of the even tempered GTO basis used in our calculations.

Since GTO forms a mathematically incomplete basis, it is essential to check the convergence of the computed properties with basis size. Figure S1 shows the convergence of excitation energy with augmentation of orbitals in ss, pp, dd, ff, gg, hh, ii, and jj symmetries. As we observed from the figure, our excitation energy is well converged with respect to orbitals from each symmetries and the final converged basis contains 22s22p18d18f17g14h22i22j22s22p18d18f17g14h22i22j orbitals. However, from our calculations, we find that properties converge even faster with a basis set having 14s13p11d10f12g8h8i8j14s13p11d10f12g8h8i8j orbitals. This finalized basis is then used for the calculation of other properties. Corrections arising from the Breit interaction, QED effects and perturbative triple excitations are also evaluated and incorporated into the final results to improve their accuracy.

Figure S1. Panels illustrate the basis-set convergence for excitation energies of first excited states, 6p1/26p_{1/2} in Cf17+^{17+} and 5f5/25f_{5/2} in Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. Orbitals in ss, pp, dd, ff, gg, hh, ii, and jj symmetries are augmented until the excitation energy converges.

OrbitalsCf17+^{17+}Cm15+^{15+}Bk16+^{16+}
GTOB-splineGTOB-splineGTOB-spline
1s1/21s_{1/2}5011.012885011.032564759.469114759.405774883.950744884.00019
2s1/22s_{1/2}977.86177977.86519920.08034920.06781948.60129948.60991
2p1/22p_{1/2}944.60465944.61029887.98170887.98441915.91749915.92779
2p3/22p_{3/2}750.91545750.91510713.64752713.64746732.14492732.14424
3s1/23s_{1/2}265.60734265.60811247.24488247.24190256.30067256.30269
3p1/23p_{1/2}250.41982250.42134232.62204232.62284241.39478241.39757
3p3/23p_{3/2}204.62434204.62420191.60805191.60809198.05151198.05127
3d3/23d_{3/2}181.10269181.10257168.83682168.83686174.90626174.90604
3d5/23d_{5/2}172.23562172.23551160.78358160.78362166.45368166.45347
4s1/24s_{1/2}82.0744582.0746674.6365974.6357678.2993778.29990
4p1/24p_{1/2}75.0378875.0383167.9058667.9060871.4160171.41676
4p3/24p_{3/2}62.5283362.5282856.8194456.8194459.6376059.63751
4d3/24d_{3/2}51.4484851.4484446.1710746.1710748.7741048.77402
4d5/24d_{5/2}49.1868949.1868544.1477944.1477946.6342546.63418
4f5/24f_{5/2}34.5657634.5657130.0921130.0920932.2959732.29589
4f7/24f_{7/2}33.9526333.9525929.5521929.5521831.7203031.72023
5s1/25s_{1/2}29.5268429.5268925.8399325.8397027.6530327.65317
5p1/25p_{1/2}26.4985926.4987122.9908622.9910224.7147524.71494
5p3/25p_{3/2}23.1648023.1648120.1267420.1267521.6230221.62299
5d3/25d_{3/2}18.4980718.4980915.7386115.7386417.0957017.09569
5d5/25d_{5/2}17.9585817.9585915.2784915.2785216.5969416.59692
6s1/26s_{1/2}13.5732413.5732711.4667511.4666812.5005512.50059
VirtualsGTOB-splineGTOB-splineGTOB-spline
6p1/26p_{1/2}11.8098111.830819.845629.8658910.8083410.82901
6p3/26p_{3/2}10.7845210.799159.010549.024909.881449.89593
5f5/25f_{5/2}11.8483211.914519.612079.6743210.7073610.77163
5f7/25f_{7/2}11.7551511.818129.540269.5995510.6251910.68638
ESCFE_{\mathrm{SCF}}-32963.45287-32963.52204-31253.75038-31253.78154-32100.84541-32100.97833

Table S2. Comparison of single-particle and SCF energies (in Hartree) from GTO with B-Spline results.

Breit, QED and Perturbative Triples Contributions to Excitation energy, Lifetime and HFS constants

To further improve the accuracy of the calculated properties, corrections arising from the Breit interaction and QED effects, such as vacuum polarization and self-energy are incorporated. In this section, we provide some quantitative assessment of their contributions to these properties.

The dominant contributions from these higher-order relativistic effects to excitation energy are shown in Figure S2. Among the low-lying states, the largest Breit and QED corrections are observed for the first excited states. The Breit interaction contributes up to 0.4%, −0.1%, and −0.3% to the first excited states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. Whereas, the corresponding QED corrections amount to be −1.6%, 0.4%, and 1.2%. Although these corrections are considerably smaller than the dominant residual Coulomb interaction, their inclusion is important for achieving high-precision spectroscopic predictions.

Figure S2. Dominant contributions arising from Breit interaction, self-energy, and vacuum-polarization effects to the excitation energies of low-lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+} respectively.

Figure S3 shows the corresponding dominant contributions for lifetime. As it is discernible from the figure, contributions from these corrections are generally negligible for 6p3/26p_{3/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states in all three HCIs. The largest Breit contribution is found to be −0.009% for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+}. Similarly, the largest QED contribution is approximately −0.01% for the first excited states, 6p1/26p_{1/2} in Cf17+^{17+} and 5f5/25f_{5/2} in both Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+}. Among all the considered states, the largest perturbative triples correction to the lifetime is found for 6p1/26p_{1/2} state of Cf17+^{17+}, amounting to approximately 0.3%.

Figure S3. Dominant contributions arising from Breit interaction, self-energy, and vacuum-polarization effects to the lifetime of low-lying states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+} respectively.

The dominant contributions from Breit interaction, self-energy correction, and vacuum polarization to magnetic dipole HFS constants are shown in Figure S4. As can be observed from the figure, contributions from Breit and self-energy are negligible. In contrast, the vacuum-polarization correction exhibits a noticeable contribution of approximately 0.4% to 6p1/26p_{1/2} in all three systems. This behavior can be attributed to the significant electron density of 6p1/26p_{1/2} state in nuclear region, which enhances its sensitivity to short-range QED effects.

Figure S4. Largest contributions arising from the Breit interaction, self-energy and vacuum-polarization effects to the magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constant in Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} respectively.

Electric dipole polarizability

In Table S3, we provide our results on static electric dipole polarizability (αs\alpha_s) for clock relevant states using FSRCC theory. The corrections from Breit, QED and perturbative triples are listed separately for quantitative assessment of correlation effects.

Cf17+^{17+}
6p1/2_{1/2}5f5/2_{5/2}5f7/2_{7/2}
E1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_s
7s1/2_{1/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}0.35200.00996d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.79370.02476d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}0.88420.0225
8s1/2_{1/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}0.02380.06d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.17370.00115g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}0.19630.0007
6d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}1.24940.18865g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}1.10160.02595g9/2_{9/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}1.25050.0300
Core0.89070.89070.8907
CCSD1.08920.94240.9439
CCSD(T)1.08700.94430.9458
CCSD(T)+Breit1.08700.94430.9458
CCSD(T)+Breit+QED1.08590.94410.9454
Other theory0.919a^{a}0.961a^{a}
Cm15+^{15+}
6p1/2_{1/2}5f5/2_{5/2}5f7/2_{7/2}
E1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_s
7s1/2_{1/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}0.37790.01356d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.99580.04976d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}1.06680.0422
6d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}1.33110.24486d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.19130.00175g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}0.23350.0012
5g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}1.20330.04165g9/2_{9/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}1.44800.0459
Core1.10451.10451.1045
CCSD1.36281.19751.1938
CCSD(T)1.35871.19871.1950
CCSD(T)+Breit1.35871.19871.1950
CCSD(T)+Breit+QED1.35771.19821.1937
Other theory1.1998b^{b}1.2460b^{b}1.2433b^{b}
Bk16+^{16+}
6p1/2_{1/2}5f5/2_{5/2}5f7/2_{7/2}
E1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_sE1 transitionE1ampαs\alpha_s
7s1/2_{1/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}0.36420.01156d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.87400.03376d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}0.95830.0299
6d3/2_{3/2} →\rightarrow 6p1/2_{1/2}1.29540.21676d5/2_{5/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}0.18240.00145g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}0.21440.0009
5g7/2_{7/2} →\rightarrow 5f5/2_{5/2}1.10840.03295g9/2_{9/2} →\rightarrow 5f7/2_{7/2}1.34740.0371
Core0.99010.99010.9901
CCSD1.21831.05811.0580
CCSD(T)1.21461.05921.0591
CCSD(T)+Breit1.21461.05921.0591
CCSD(T)+Breit+QED1.21351.05901.0585
Other theory1.0685b^{b}1.1091b^{b}1.1069b^{b}

Table S3. Electric dipole polarizability (a.u.) for 6p1/2_{1/2}, 5f5/2_{5/2} and 5f7/2_{7/2} states of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+} and Bk16+^{16+} using sum-over-states approach. The dominant contributing E1 matrix elements are also provided to quantify the nature of electron correlations.

We have also provided the dominant contributing E1 transitions contributing to αS−V\alpha_{\mathrm{S-V}}.

Zeeman Shift

The second-order Zeeman shift arising from the coupling between hyperfine-structure levels can be evaluated using second-order perturbation theory:

CM2(F,M)=−(μBgJ)2∑F′≠F∣⟨F′M∣Jz∣FM⟩∣2EF′−EF.(9)C_{\mathrm{M2}}(F,M) = -(\mu_{\mathrm{B}}g_J)^2 \sum_{F'\ne F} \frac{\lvert\langle F'M|J_z|FM\rangle\rvert^2}{E_{F'}-E_F}. \tag*{(9)}

For the JzJ_z operator, only the terms satisfying F′=F±1F'=F\pm1 contribute to the second-order Zeeman coefficient. The corresponding matrix elements are expressed in terms of angular-momentum coupling coefficients as [9]

⟨F′M∣Jz∣FM⟩=I(I+1)(2I+1)(2F+1)(2F′+1)(F1F′−M0M){IFJF′I1}.(10)\langle F'M|J_z|FM\rangle= \sqrt{I(I+1)(2I+1)(2F+1)(2F'+1)} \begin{pmatrix} F & 1 & F' \\ -M & 0 & M \end{pmatrix} \begin{Bmatrix} I & F & J \\ F' & I & 1 \end{Bmatrix}. \tag*{(10)}

The hyperfine energies are calculated as [10]

EFhfs=A2K+B4N,(11)E_F^{\mathrm{hfs}} = \frac{A}{2}K+\frac{B}{4}N, \tag*{(11)}

where AA and BB are the magnetic-dipole and electric-quadrupole hyperfine-structure constants, respectively, and

K=F(F+1)−I(I+1)−J(J+1),(12)K = F(F+1)-I(I+1)-J(J+1), \tag*{(12)}

a^{a}Ref.[7]-CCSDT, b^{b}Ref.[8]-LCCSD

N=3K(K+1)−4I(I+1)J(J+1)2I(2I−1)J(2J−1)(13)N=\frac{3K(K+1)-4I(I+1)J(J+1)}{2I(2I-1)J(2J-1)} \tag*{(13)}

Using our calculated value of magnetic dipole hyperfine constants (AA), we determine the hyperfine-level energies EFE_F, which are subsequently employed in the evaluation of the second-order Zeeman coefficients. Table S4, S5, S6 lists the calculated hyperfine-level energies and CM2C_{M2} coefficients for the M=0M=0 hyperfine levels of the proposed clock states of 251^{251}Cf17+^{17+}, 247^{247}Cm15+^{15+} and 249Bk16+^{249}\mathrm{Bk}^{16+}, respectively.

6p1/2_{1/2}5f5/2_{5/2}
FFEF/hE_F/hCM2C_{M2}FFEF/hE_F/hCM2C_{M2}
0−149667.75-149667.75−0.109-0.1092−3080-3080−6.811-6.811
149889.2549889.250.1090.1093220022006.8116.811

Table S4. Hyperfine-structure and second-order Zeeman coefficients (CM2C_{M2}) for 6p1/2_{1/2} and 5f5/2_{5/2} states with M=0M=0 in 251^{251}Cf17+^{17+}. The values of EFE_F and CM2C_{M2} are given in terms of MHz ×gI\times g_I and kHz×gImT2\frac{\mathrm{kHz}\times g_I}{\mathrm{mT}^2}, respectively.

6p1/26p_{1/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}5f7/25f_{7/2}
FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}
4−435363.5-435363.5−0.275-0.2752−19263.75-19263.75−67.262-67.2621−19500.25-19500.25−486.216-486.216
5356206.5356206.50.2750.2753−15060.75-15060.758.5618.5612−17474.25-17474.25139.820139.820
4−9456.75-9456.7516.20916.2093−14435.25-14435.25102.085102.085
5−2451.75-2451.7515.67215.6724−10383.25-10383.2572.86372.863
65954.255954.2514.11914.1195−5318.25-5318.2555.53455.534
715761.2515761.2512.69912.6996759.75759.7544.85844.858
77850.757850.7537.90437.904
815954.7515954.7533.15133.151

Table S5. Hyperfine-structure and second-order Zeeman coefficients (CM2C_{M2}) for 6p1/26p_{1/2}, 5f5/25f_{5/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states with M=0M=0 in 247Cm15+^{247}\mathrm{Cm}^{15+}. The values of EFh\frac{E_F}{h} and CM2C_{M2} are given in terms of MHz ×gI\times g_I and kHz×gImT2\frac{\mathrm{kHz}\times g_I}{\mathrm{mT}^{2}}, respectively.

6p1/26p_{1/2}5f5/25f_{5/2}5f7/25f_{7/2}
FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}FFEFh\frac{E_F}{h}CM2C_{M2}
3−404005.5-404005.5−0.030-0.0301−17730-17730−102.736-102.7360−17640-17640−1199.359-1199.359
4314226.5314226.50.0300.0302−14578-1457833.15833.1581−16520-16520742.462742.462
3−9850-985024.73324.7332−14280-14280187.653187.653
4−3546-354618.27918.2793−10920-1092095.18895.188
54334433414.45914.4594−6440-644061.56361.563
6137901379012.10712.1075−840-84045.39645.396
65880588036.43736.437
7137201372030.75330.753

Table S6. Hyperfine-structure and second-order Zeeman coefficients (CM2C_{M2}) for 6p1/26p_{1/2}, 5f5/25f_{5/2} and 5f7/25f_{7/2} states with M=0M=0 in 249Bk16+^{249}\mathrm{Bk}^{16+}. The values of EFh\frac{E_F}{h} and CM2C_{M2} are given in terms of MHz ×gI\times g_I and kHz×gImT2\frac{\mathrm{kHz}\times g_I}{\mathrm{mT}^{2}}, respectively.

Sensitivity Coefficient

Figure S5 shows the linear fit of EE vs. xx data for considered HCIs, which is used to extract the sensitivity coefficients for the proposed clock transitions. We further account for the contributions arising from the Breit interaction, vacuum-polarization effect, and self-energy correction to obtain the final recommended sensitivity coefficients, qfinalq_{\mathrm{final}}. These corrections are shown in the Figure S6. The self-energy contribution is negligible for all the states considered, while the vacuum-polarization correction remains below 0.3% across the three ions. Its largest contribution, approximately 0.3%, occurs for the 6p3/26p_{3/2} state in Bk16+^{16+}. In Cf17+^{17+}, the vacuum-polarization correction is approximately 0.2% for the 6p1/26p_{1/2} state, while in Cm15+^{15+}, it is approximately 0.2% for all the states considered. The Breit contribution is even smaller, with the largest corrections being −0.009%-0.009\%, −0.03%-0.03\%, and −0.04%-0.04\% for the 6p1/26p_{1/2} state in Cf17+^{17+}, the 5f7/25f_{7/2} state in Cm15+^{15+}, and the 5f7/25f_{7/2} state in Bk16+^{16+}, respectively. Although these contributions are small relative to the dominant Coulomb-correlation effects, their consistent inclusion provides a more complete assessment of the sensitivity coefficients and strengthens the reliability of the recommended values for precision clock applications.

Fit of the transition energies versus $x$ data for Cf$^{17+}$, Cm$^{15+}$, and Bk$^{16+}$ HCIs

Figure S5. Fit of the transition energies vs. xx data for Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+} HCIs. Bullet points represent our computed data, whereas linear fit is represented by solid lines.

Figure S6. Dominant contributions arising from Breit interaction, self-energy, and vacuum-polarization to the sensitivity coefficient in the case of Cf17+^{17+}, Cm15+^{15+}, and Bk16+^{16+}.

Theoretical uncertainty

Based on the approximations used in our calculations, we identify four primary sources which contribute to the uncertainties of calculated one-body matrix elements. The first source of uncertainty arises from the truncation of basis set. Our computed properties are observed to converge well with a negligible change on further augmentation in the basis. Hence, we neglect the uncertainty associated with this source. The second contribution originates from truncating the dressed Hamiltonian to second order in T(0)T^{(0)} in the evaluation of atomic properties [11, 12]. In our earlier investigations [4], iterative inclusion of higher-order terms revealed that the contributions from third- and higher-order terms in T(0)T^{(0)} are below 0.1%. We, therefore, adopt 0.1% as an upper bound associated with this source. The third contribution arises from the partial treatment of triple excitations in FSRCC theory. Since perturbative triples account for dominant effects of triple excitations, the remaining higher-order contributions are expected to be relatively small. Among all transition properties computed in this work, the largest contribution of 0.3% is observed in the case of lifetime of 6p1/26p_{1/2} state in Cf17+^{17+}. Accordingly, we adopt 0.3% as an upper bound arising from this source. The fourth contribution stems from the omission of frequency-dependent Breit interaction. In our previous study of Ra [13], a series of GRASP2K calculations indicated that this effect contributes less than 0.13% to the calculated properties. Therefore, we take 0.13% as an upper bound from this source. Additional sources of uncertainty, such as higher-order couplings involving vacuum-polarization and self-energy corrections, quadruply excited cluster amplitudes, and other neglected higher-order many-body effects, are expected to contribute at a significantly lower level. Their cumulative contribution is estimated to be below 0.1%. Combining all these upper bounds, the overall theoretical uncertainty in our calculated E1, E2, and M1 transition matrix elements is estimated to be less than 1%.

Since the BBR shifts and magic rf-drive frequencies are derived from the calculated polarizabilities, uncertainties in these systematic shifts are governed primarily by the uncertainty in polarizability. To estimate this uncertainty, we refer to our previous work [14], in which we used a sum-over-states approach to calculate the scalar polarizabilities, αs\alpha_s, of the ground and excited clock states in Ca+^+ and Sr+^+. And, we estimated an uncertainty of approximately 2% in αs\alpha_s. We therefore adopt 2% as a conservative upper-bound estimate for the uncertainties in the calculated polarizabilities in the present work.

For the electric-quadrupole shift, the relevant quantity is the electric quadrupole moment of the clock state. Although a separate convergence analysis of the quadrupole moments is not presented, we have analyzed the convergence of E2 transition matrix elements. Since both the quantities are determined by same rank-2 electric-quadrupole operator [10], the observed convergence of E2 matrix elements provides strong evidence for the reliability of our calculated quadrupole moments.

References

References

  1. [3]B. Mani, S. Chattopadhyay, and D. Angom, RCCPAC: A parallel relativistic coupled-cluster program for closed-shell and one-valence atoms and ions in fortran, Computer Physics Communications 213, 136 (2017).DOI
  2. [4]B. K. Mani and D. Angom, Atomic properties calculated by relativistic coupled-cluster theory without truncation: Hyperfine constants of Mg⁺, Ca⁺, Sr⁺, and Ba⁺, Phys. Rev. A 81, 042514 (2010).DOI
  3. [5]A. K. Mohanty, F. A. Parpia, and E. Clementi, Kinetically balanced geometric gaussian basis set calculations for relativistic many-electron atoms, in Modern Techniques in Computational Chemistry: MOTECC-91, edited by E. Clementi (ESCOM, 1991).
  4. [6]O. Zatsarinny and C. F. Fischer, DBSR-HF: A B-spline Dirac-Hartree-Fock program, Computer Physics Communications 202, 287 (2016).DOI
  5. [7]S. G. Porsev, U. I. Safronova, M. S. Safronova, P. O. Schmidt, A. I. Bondarev, M. G. Kozlov, I. I. Tupitsyn, and C. Cheung, Optical clocks based on the Cf¹⁵⁺ and Cf¹⁷⁺ ions, Phys. Rev. A 102, 012802 (2020).
  6. [8]V. A. Dzuba and V. V. Flambaum, Cm¹⁵⁺ and Bk¹⁶⁺ ion clocks with enhanced sensitivity to new physics, Phys. Rev. A 109, L021101 (2024).DOI
  7. [9]I. I. Sobelman, Atomic Spectra and Radiative Transitions, Springer Series in Chemical Physics, Vol. 1 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979).
  8. [10]W. R. Johnson, Atomic structure theory. Lectures on atomic physics (Springer, Berlin, 2007).DOI
  9. [11]B. K. Mani and D. Angom, Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster calculations of two-valence atoms, Phys. Rev. A 83, 012501 (2011).DOI
  10. [12]R. Kumar, S. Chattopadhyay, D. Angom, and B. K. Mani, Relativistic coupled-cluster calculation of the electric dipole polarizability and correlation energy of Cn, Nh⁺, and Og: Correlation effects from lighter to superheavy elements, Phys. Rev. A 103, 062803 (2021).DOI
  11. [13]S. Chattopadhyay, B. K. Mani, and D. Angom, Electric dipole polarizability of alkaline-earth-metal atoms from perturbed relativistic coupled-cluster theory with triples, Phys. Rev. A 89, 022506 (2014).DOI
  12. [14]P. Gakkhar, D. Angom, and B. K. Mani, Fock-space relativistic coupled-cluster calculations of clock transition properties and systematic shifts in Ca⁺ and Sr⁺ optical clocks, Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 59, 185001 (2026).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vknyj6hd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents