WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Investigation of superconducting gap of high-entropy telluride AgInSnPbBiTe5
Abstract
We performed transverse-field muon spin relaxation/rotation (TF-μSR) on a high-entropy-type (HE-type) superconductor AgInSnPbBiTe5. The emergence of bulk superconducting states was confirmed from magnetic susceptibility, specific heat, and μSR. The superconducting gap 2Δ(0) estimated from μSR was clearly larger than that expected from conventional weak-coupling phonon-mediated model, suggesting the strong-coupling nature of superconductivity. In addition, a long penetration depth of 3.21(7) μm was obtained. The strong-coupling nature of superconductivity and the long penetration depth are similar to the trends observed in the other HE-type superconductors (HE alloys and transition-metal zirconides), which may be universal feature of HE-type superconductors.
Statements and Declarations
The authors declare no competing interests.
Data availability statement
All the data presented in the paper can be provided from the corresponding author by a reasonable request.
Introduction
Recently, high-entropy (HE) materials, which are highly-disordered materials possessing multiple-element solution resulting in high configurational entropy, have been actively studied. The simplest HE materials are HE alloys (HEAs), which alloys typically containing five or more elements solving in a crystallographic site with a concentration of 5–35 at% [1–3]. The above-described criterion for element solution satisfies a high value of configurational entropy of mixing (), exceeding , where is gas constant. is defined as , where is composition of the component . HEAs and similar HE compounds, where one or more crystallographic sites of compounds are substituted by multiple elements, possess merit on the engineering aspects. For example, HEAs exhibit improved mechanical properties and stability or high performance in high temperature and/or extreme conditions [1,2]. Furthermore, superior catalytic and thermoelectric properties have been observed [4–9]. As well as the application merit, the highly disordered local structures and nearly-random bonding should be important issues in the field of materials science. Actually, HE superconductors with various types of crystal structures and constituent elements have been developed [10–23], and some of the HE superconductors exhibit robustness of superconductivity against applied external pressure [24,25]. In Ref. 26, we reported on the glassy atomic vibration and blurry electronic band structure in a superconductor, and the origin of the unconventional pressure dependence of transition temperature () is discussed with the anomalous glassy phonon and electronic states.
In this paper, we study the superconducting properties of a HE-type metal telluride with a NaCl-type structure (space group: , #225) using muon spin relaxation/rotation (SR), which is a powerful tool for discussing superconducting gap [27]. As shown in Figure 1(a), the metal site is in the HEA configuration with the solution of five different metals. From the temperature evolution of magnetic penetration depth (), the superconducting gap and pairing symmetry can be discussed. Several SR studies on superconducting properties of HEAs and HE compounds revealed that the HE superconductors [28,29] tend to show a value of greater than 3.53 expected from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) phonon-mediated weak-coupling model; and are a superconducting gap at 0 K and the Boltzmann constant, respectively [30]. The examples of estimated using SR are summarized in Figure S1. Furthermore, there was a clear trend that the increase in results in an increase in for transition-metal () zirconides [29], and the of HE-type samples deviates from the conventional line in the Uemura plot [28,29]. If another example of strong (or moderate) coupling characteristics of superconductivity in HE materials, universal features of HE superconductors would be obtained, and that will be useful for clarifying the essential effects of HE-alloying on superconducting states. Here, we show the strong-coupling nature of the superconductor.

Figure 1. (a) Schematic image of the crystal structure of . (b) Powder XRD pattern. The numbers are Miller indices. (c) EDX mapping results.

Figure S1. The result of Rietveld refinement for AgInSnPbBiTe. Green and purple solid lines represent the peak positions of AgInSnPbBiTe and BN, respectively.
Experimental methods
Polycrystalline powders of were firstly prepared by solid-state reaction in an evacuated quartz tube. High-pressure annealing of the prepared precursor powders was performed to obtain single-phase polycrystalline samples of using a cubic-anvil-type press system (CT factory). High-pressure annealing conditions were 3 GPa and 500°C for 30 min. The details of sample preparation are reported in Refs. 20, 23, and 25.
Powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) was performed using a MiniFlex600 (RIGAKU) diffractometer with Cu K radiation and a D/teX-Ultra detector by a conventional -2 method. The crystal-structure parameters were refined using the Rietveld method with RIETAN-FP software [31], and the crystal structure was visualized using VESTA software [32]. The chemical composition of the selected sample was examined by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) on a scanning electron microscope TM-3030 (Hitachi Hightech) equipped with an EDX-SwiftED analyzer (Oxford). The EDX analysis was performed at five different points. To investigate the superconducting properties of , the temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility () was measured using a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) with a Magnetic Property Measurement System (MPMS, Quantum Design) after both zero-field cooling (ZFC) and field cooling (FC) occurred.
Specific heat () measurements were performed using the thermal relaxation method with a Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS Dynacool, Quantum Design). The sample was fixed on a sample stage with the Apiezon N grease.
Transverse field (TF) SR measurements were performed using an ARTEMIS spectrometer installed on S1 area in MLF, J-PARC (proposal No.: 2024A0076). The measurements were performed under a TF of Oe using a cryostat.
Results and discussion
Sample characterization
Powder XRD pattern for is shown in Figure 1(b). Although the tiny diffraction peak of BN (, #160), which was used in the high-pressure annealing, was detected (see Figure S1 for the Rietveld fitting), the other peaks were assigned to the NaCl-type phase with no peak splitting, indicating that homogeneous was successfully synthesized. The lattice constant is estimated as 6.25405(5) Å. No compositional segregation was detected by EDX mapping (Figure 1(c)). The average chemical composition of the obtained sample is estimated as . The estimated for the M site using average chemical composition is .
Magnetic susceptibility and specific heat
Figure 2(a) shows the temperature dependence of of . The data is corrected by assuming the demagnetization effect. Large diamagnetic signals corresponding to the emergence of superconducting states are observed below 2.5 K, and the estimated was 2.44 K; was estimated as the crossing point of two lines as shown in the inset of Figure 2(a).

Figure 2. Temperature dependence of (a) Magnetic susceptibility () measured at Oe and (b) specific heat at – T for AgInSnPbBiTe. (c) Magnetic field-temperature phase diagram. (d) Temperature dependence of electronic specific heat in the form of .
Figure 2(b) shows the temperature dependences of under magnetic fields of – T. Clear jumps were observed at T, suggesting the emergence of bulk superconductivity. As shown in Figure 2(c), the estimated s were plotted, and the upper critical field at 0 K () was estimated as 0.74 T by assuming the Werthamer-Helfand-Hohenberg model [33]. The low-temperature specific heat can be described as , where , , and represent contributions of electron, lattice, and anharmonicity term of the lattice, respectively. The values of , , and were estimated as 2.6(2) mJ mol K, 0.70(6) mJ mol K, and 0.043(5) mJ mol K, respectively, from fitting the data for T. The Debye temperature of 177 K was calculated from , where is the number of atoms in the formula unit. To examine the magnitude of electronic specific heat jump (), the temperature dependence of is plotted by subtracting the lattice contribution () as shown in Figure 2(d). and at were estimated by considering the entropy balance, and the estimated values are and . The of AgInSnPbBiTe is slightly smaller than , which is expected from the BCS theory with a weak-coupling superconductor, but the comparable proves the emergence of bulk superconductivity.
TF-SR
To obtain information on the superconducting gap information, TF-SR measurement has been performed. Magnetic field of Oe, which is in between the lower critical field at 0 K () and the , was applied above the , followed by sample cooling to 0.69 K. Figure 3 shows the TF-SR asymmetry spectrum at 0.69 K for AgInSnPbBiTe. The spectrum exhibits damping oscillation, indicating that the sample falls into the flux-line-lattice state to exert strongly inhomogeneous internal field to implanted muons. The TF-SR signal is best fitted with the following model function [28]:

Figure 3. Obtained asymmetry spectrum at K and fitting result for AgInSnPbBiTe.
where and are the asymmetry contributions from sample and sample holder, and are relaxation rate contributions from sample and sample holder, is muon gyromagnetic ratio, and are mean field contributions from sample and sample holder, and is the initial phase offset. To accurately examine the small , fitting was performed with long time range spectrum (up to 15 s). The includes both the temperature-independent depolarization , which comes from the static field arising due to the nuclear magnetic moment, and the contribution of the field variation from the flux-line-lattice, given as . For a triangular lattice, the temperature dependence of the magnetic penetration depth can be expressed by
where MHz/T is the muon gyromagnetic ratio, and is a flux quantum. The temperature dependence of is shown in Figure 4. To examine the and , the data was fitted with a superconducting gap function. Assuming an isotropic -wave gap, the temperature dependent relation between the and can be described as

Figure 4. Temperature dependence of for AgInSnPbBiTe and the fitting result with a dirty-limit model.
which is relation derived within the BCS scheme, i.e. and in the dirty limit [29]. Here, we obtained of 1.88 K from the fitting. The lower than that shown in Figure 2 is due to the strain-release effect and applied magnetic field. In AgInSnPbBiTe, the flesh sample shows close to 2.5 K as shown in Figure 2, but after several weeks, the high-pressure-annealing strain is released, and decreases to about 2 K (See Figure S2 for the susceptibility data taken after 3 months from the high-pressure synthesis). The current SR measurements were performed after 16 days from the high-pressure annealing. The solid line in Figure 4 is the fit, and the long of 3.21(7) m and large of 10(2) are obtained. This large clearly larger than the BCS value suggests that the AgInSnPbBiTe is possibly possessing strong-coupling nature of superconductivity. The examples of large in Fe- and Cr-based samples are summarized in Table S1. The estimated in the current sample is close to the largest value in the Fe-based superconductors. The large penetration depth would be caused by highly inhomogeneous atomic alignments in HE-type material, and such inhomogeneity would influence the homogeneous formation of the superconducting gap, which has been observed in other HE-type superconductors examined by SR [29]. Therefore, the trend that HE-type superconductors have a strong-coupling nature would be the universal features when the HE configuration of the atoms largely affect the electronic and phonon characteristics and superconducting gap characterization. To confirm the universality, further experimental and theoretical studies are needed. In particular, for AgInSnPbBiTe, low-temperature measurements using a He or dilution system will be needed to examine superconducting gap.
Table S1. Information of estimated using SR of various high-entropy superconducting materials and examples of superconductors having a strong-coupling nature. Two values of are obtained from fitting using a multi-gap model.

Figure S2. Temperature dependence of Magnetic susceptibility () measured at Oe for AgInSnPbBiTe. Several weeks later from synthesis date, decreased due to the strain release.
Summary
We synthesized polycrystalline samples of AgInSnPbBiTe, which is a HE-type superconductor, using high-pressure annealing. From the powder XRD and EDX mapping, homogeneous single-phase quality of the obtained samples was confirmed. Bulk nature of superconductivity was confirmed using magnetic susceptibility and specific heat measurements. TF-SR was performed on AgInSnPbBiTe under TF of Oe. The emergence of bulk superconducting states was confirmed from SR, and the estimated of 10 suggested the strong-coupling nature of superconductivity. The trend that the HE-type samples exhibit strong-coupling nature of superconductivity would be a universal feature, which will create new research field of physics for highly disordered superconductors.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank E. Kenny, Y. Ikeda, and A. Bhattacharyya for discussion on the results. This project was partly supported by TMU Research Project for Emergent Future Society.
Investigation of superconducting gap of high-entropy telluride AgInSnPbBiTe
Asato Seshita; H. Okabe; Riad Kasem; Y. Watanabe; Jumpei G. Nakamura; Shoichiro Nishimura; Kensei Terashima; Ryo Matsumoto; Yoshihiko Takano; A. Yamashita; Masaki Fujita; Yoshikazu Mizuguchi
Supporting information
References
- [1][S1] C. Wang et al., Investigation of the high-entropy alloy superconductor XZr₂ (X = Fe, Co, Ni, Rh, Ir) using muon spin spectroscopy (μSR). In J. Kitagawa & Y. Mizuguchi (Eds.), Springer series in solid-state sciences: Vol. 202. High-entropy alloy superconductors. Exotic properties, applications and materials design (pp. 215-234) (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-97-4129-8
- [2][S2] K. Motla, et al., Phys. Rev. B 104, 094515 (2021).
- [3][S3] K. Motla, et al., Phys. Rev. B 105, 144501 (2022).
- [4][S4] M. Hiraishi et al., J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 78, 023710 (2009).
- [5][S5] M. Smidman et al., Phys. Rev. B 97, 060509 (2018).
- [6][S6] D. T. Adroja et al., J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 87, 124705 (2018).