betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Dirac Structures and Reduction of Optimal Control Problems with Symmetries

Abstract

We study the symmetry reduction of optimal control problems using Dirac structures. The first-order conditions of the Pontryagin Maximum Principle are written as an implicit Dirac system on the Pontryagin bundle. For a problem invariant under a Lie group, we reduce both the Lagrange-Pontryagin variational principle and the underlying Dirac structure, and prove that they yield the same reduced equations, which we identify with the Hamiltonian equations on the dual of the Atiyah algebroid. Reconstruction, independence of the principal connection, and the relation between criticality and optimality complete the picture. Dropping regularity, we give the Gotay-Nester-Hinds constraint algorithm a Dirac-geometric form and prove that symmetry reduction commutes with it. For control-linear systems whose admissible directions are horizontal for a principal connection, abnormal extremals lie on the leaf where the base costate vanishes, and the first secondary constraint is the degeneracy of the curvature pairing. We also give a reduced criterion for strict abnormality and a metric-free index form. Examples: a spacecraft with rotors (flat connection), the Heisenberg group (nowhere-zero curvature) and the Martinet problem (curvature vanishing on a hypersurface).

Introduction

In this paper we study the role of Dirac structures in the geometric formulation and symmetry reduction of a class of optimal control problems. More specifically, we show how the reduction theory for Dirac structures developed by Yoshimura and Marsden [41] can be extended to optimal control systems admitting a Lie group of symmetries. We prove that, as in the case of implicit Hamiltonian and Lagrangian systems, the reduction of the variational principle and the reduction of the Dirac structure underlying the Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP) lead to the same reduced equations, and we then use the Dirac formulation to treat the singular case, in which the control cannot be eliminated and a constraint algorithm is required.

The reduced equations themselves are not new. They are the Hamiltonian equations on the dual of the Atiyah algebroid TP/GTP/G, obtained in that setting by Martínez [29] and, in the wider context of almost Lie algebroids, by Grabowski and Jóźwikowski [23]; for a Lie group they go back to Jurdjevic [27]. Section 3.7 records the dictionary explicitly. What the Dirac formulation adds is a framework in which the constraint algorithm and the symmetry reduction interact, and it is there that our main new result lies.

Optimal control problems often possess a rich geometric structure. Throughout this paper we restrict our attention to smooth geometric optimal control problems, where both the state space and the control space are smooth manifolds (assumed, for simplicity, to be without boundary), the controlled dynamics is described by a control-dependent vector field, and the cost functional is defined by a Lagrangian density. This setting naturally admits a differential-geometric description and provides the appropriate framework for studying additional geometric features, such as symmetries and reduction.

Suppose that a Lie group acts on the state and control spaces in such a way that both the dynamics and the cost functional are invariant under the action. We then say that the optimal control problem is symmetric with respect to the given Lie group. The presence of symmetry is a powerful tool for simplifying the analysis of dynamical systems. In Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics, conserved quantities associated with symmetries often allow one to reduce the dimension of the problem. More generally, reduction techniques replace the original system with a family of lower-dimensional systems whose solutions can later be reconstructed to recover the solutions of the original dynamics.

The theory of reduction for systems with symmetry has a long history, and we do not attempt to review it here. Instead, we focus on the work of Yoshimura and Marsden, who developed a unified framework for implicit Lagrangian and Hamiltonian systems based on Dirac structures. Their contributions include the formulation of implicit Lagrangian mechanics using Dirac structures [37, 38], the reduction of the canonical Dirac structure on the cotangent bundle of a Lie group [40], the treatment of implicit Hamiltonian and Lagrangian systems [39], and, ultimately, the reduction of Dirac structures on cotangent bundles [41]. These developments provide the main geometric inspiration for the present work.

The Pontryagin Maximum Principle admits a natural presymplectic formulation, which has been extensively developed in the literature (see, for example, [6, 5] and the references therein). Since every presymplectic manifold carries a canonical Dirac structure, the PMP can also be formulated entirely in terms of Dirac geometry. This observation makes it natural to ask whether the reduction theory for Dirac structures can be used to reduce optimal control problems while preserving not only the dynamics but also their variational character.

A straightforward approach would be to perform presymplectic reduction of the Hamiltonian system associated with the PMP. Although this reduces the number of degrees of freedom, it generally loses the variational information encoded in the original optimal control problem. Consequently, the reduced dynamics alone does not guarantee that its solutions correspond to extremals of the original cost functional. What is needed is a reduction procedure that simultaneously preserves the geometric dynamics and the underlying variational principle.

Dirac structures provide precisely such a framework. As shown by Yoshimura and Marsden, the reduction of Dirac structures is compatible with the reduction of the associated variational principles. This makes Dirac geometry particularly well suited to the study of symmetric optimal control problems, where one seeks a reduced formulation that retains both the geometric and variational content of the original problem.

Following this perspective, we extend the Dirac reduction framework of [41] to geometric optimal control. The geometric formulation of the PMP naturally leads to the introduction of the Pontryagin bundle, a bundle over the state manifold that plays a role analogous to the Pontryagin bundle TQ⊕T∗QTQ \oplus T^{*}Q arising in implicit Lagrangian mechanics. We formulate the first-order necessary conditions of the PMP as an implicit Hamiltonian system determined by the Pontryagin Hamiltonian and the canonical Dirac structure on this bundle. Assuming the optimal control problem admits a symmetry group GG, we study the reduction of both the variational principle and the associated Dirac structure.

The reduced PMP equations are obtained in two independent ways. First, we derive them by reducing the variational principle obtained through the method of Lagrange multipliers. Second, we obtain the same equations by directly reducing the Dirac structure defining the PMP, the reduced canonical Dirac structure being derived in Section 4.3 rather than postulated. The agreement between these two constructions shows that the reduced Dirac system provides the correct geometric realization of the reduced optimal control problem.

It may be helpful to state at the outset what we claim and what we do not. Our main new result is Theorem 5: symmetry reduction commutes with the constraint algorithm, so that for a singular problem the algorithm may be run on the reduced space and the unreduced constraint submanifolds recovered by pulling back. To formulate it we give a Dirac-geometric form of the algorithm, in which each stage is the Dirac structure induced by the constraint distribution and the constraint forces appear in its annihilator. Alongside this we supply the reduction picture in full: reconstruction (Theorem 1), independence of the choice of principal connection (Theorem 2), and the relation between criticality and optimality (Proposition 4). A second new result is Theorem 8, which decides in reduced terms whether an abnormal extremal is strictly abnormal: it is not, precisely when its projection to the base satisfies Wong’s equation for some parallel coadjoint multiplier. The criterion separates cleanly what the curvature alone determines from what the cost contributes, and it is decided by a second constraint algorithm run in the coadjoint fiber (Proposition 17). § 8.9 then supplies the second-order theory in the same variables: for an abelian structure group the index form of an abnormal extremal is ∫⟨μ,FA(∇z˙v,v)+(∇vFA)(z˙,v)⟩ dt\int\langle\mu,F_A(\nabla_{\dot{z}}v,v) + (\nabla_vF_A)(\dot{z},v)\rangle\,dt (Theorem 9), which involves the curvature and its covariant derivative but not the metric. The abelian hypothesis is not removable: for nonabelian holonomy the second variation acquires time-ordered commutator terms that we do not compute, and Remark 24 exhibits an SO(3)SO(3) example in which they destroy positivity on long arcs. Location, rigidity and strictness are then three reduced tests (Theorem 10), the first and third criteria and the second a sufficient certificate, and the deformed Martinet family of [1] together with the rank-two example of § 8.8 shows that the last two are genuinely independent.

By contrast, several ingredients are recastings of known results in the present language, and we have tried to attribute them carefully. The constraint algorithm is that of Gotay, Nester and Hinds [21], applied to the PMP in the presymplectic setting by Barbero-Li~nan and Mu~noz-Lecanda [5], who also identified its secondary constraints with the classical Goh and generalized Legendre–Clebsch conditions. The device of adjoining the running cost to the state, which brings abnormal extremals within the same framework, is due to Ohsawa [34] and Jóźwikowski and Respondek [25]; we only observe that it is itself an instance of the reduction theory developed here, the cost multiplier being a momentum map. The characterization of abnormal extremals in § 8.5 is the specialization to a principal bundle of criteria that are classical [2, 25]; what is ours is the observation that the obstruction is exactly the curvature term by which the reduced PMP differs from the unreduced one.

The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In § 2 we introduce the geometric framework for the class of optimal control problems under consideration. We review the necessary notions of Pontryagin bundles, Dirac structures, and symmetries, and establish the notation used throughout the paper.

In § 3 we study the reduction of the variational formulation of the Pontryagin Maximum Principle. We derive the reduced Pontryagin bundle, formulate the reduced variational principle, and obtain the corresponding first-order necessary conditions, which we refer to as the reduced Pontryagin Maximum Principle. The section closes with the four results that complete the reduction picture: reconstruction, independence of the connection, the relation between criticality and optimality, and the comparison with Lie algebroid reduction.

§ 4 approaches the reduction problem from the perspective of Dirac geometry. We construct the reduced Dirac structure associated with the Pontryagin bundle, derive its connection-dependent description, and relate it to the reduction of the canonical Dirac structure on the cotangent bundle. We show that the reduced Dirac formulation yields exactly the same reduced equations obtained from the variational approach.

We then illustrate the theory with two complementary examples. In § 5 we treat the optimal control of a rigid spacecraft carrying three internal reaction wheels, in which the symmetry group SO(3)SO(3) is nonabelian but the connection is flat, so that the reduced equations are governed by the coadjoint term. In § 7 we treat the sub-Riemannian geodesic problem on the Heisenberg group, in which the symmetry group is the abelian center and the coadjoint term vanishes, while the curvature of the natural connection is nowhere zero. Between them the two examples exercise both of the terms by which the reduced Pontryagin Maximum Principle differs from its unreduced counterpart.

§ 8 removes the regularity assumption made in § 2–§ 7. It is here that the Dirac formulation does work that the presymplectic one does not: we give the constraint algorithm in Dirac form, prove that reduction commutes with it, and show that for control-linear systems the abnormal extremals occupy the leaf on which the base costate vanishes, the first secondary constraint being the degeneracy of the curvature pairing. The Martinet problem, in which the curvature vanishes on a hypersurface and the abnormal extremals are exactly the curves lying in it, is worked out as a third example, in both its abnormal and its normal leaf. The section closes with the strictness criterion, with an example, of structure group R2\mathbb{R}^{2}, in which strictness is decided only at the second stage of the algorithm, and with the reduced index form and the resulting trichotomy.

Geometrical and Variational Aspects of Optimal Control Problems with Symmetry

As discussed in the introduction, we restrict our attention to a class of geometric optimal control problems for which the underlying differential-geometric structures can be described in a transparent way. Throughout the paper, all manifolds are assumed to be smooth and without boundary, and all maps, vector fields, differential forms, and curves are assumed to be smooth.

For simplicity, we consider in § 2–§ 7 only regular optimal control problems, excluding abnormal extremals and singular control systems (see, for example, [2, 26]); the regularity assumption is removed in § 8. Moreover, admissible controls are assumed to be smooth. These assumptions allow us to focus on the geometric aspects of the theory without addressing the additional analytical difficulties arising from nonsmooth controls or more general admissible classes. Most of the constructions presented here extend, with appropriate modifications, to more general settings, including systems defined on manifolds with boundary or singular optimal control problems.

We begin by recalling the geometric framework and fixing the notation used throughout the paper.

A geometric formulation of optimal control problems

We follow the standard geometric formulation of optimal control (see, for instance, [2, 26, 13]).

Definition 1 (Control system). A control system is a triple (P,C,Γ)(P,C,\Gamma) consisting of:

(i) A smooth manifold PP, called the state space. Local coordinates on PP are denoted by (xi)(x^i), i=1,…,ni=1,\ldots,n, and a generic point by xx.

(ii) A locally trivial fiber bundle π:C⟶P\pi:C\longrightarrow P, called the control bundle. For each state x∈Px\in P, the fiber Cx=π−1(x)C_x=\pi^{-1}(x) is the manifold of admissible controls at xx. Adapted local coordinates on CC are denoted by (xi,ua)(x^i,u^a), where a=1,…,ra=1,\ldots,r, and a generic point is written (x,u)(x,u).

(iii) A vector field along the projection π:C⟶P\pi:C\longrightarrow P, that is, a smooth map Γ:C⟶TP\Gamma:C\longrightarrow TP satisfying τP∘Γ=π\tau_P\circ\Gamma=\pi, where τP:TP⟶P\tau_P:TP\longrightarrow P denotes the canonical projection. The map Γ\Gamma describes the controlled dynamics; in local coordinates, Γ=fi(x,u)∂/∂xi\Gamma=f^i(x,u)\partial/\partial x^i, where natural coordinates on TPTP are denoted by (xi,vi)(x^i,v^i), or equivalently by (xi,x˙i)(x^i,\dot{x}^i). An admissible control is a smooth curve c:I⟶Cc:I\longrightarrow C, defined on an interval I⊂RI\subset\mathbb{R}, with state trajectory x=π∘c:I⟶Px=\pi\circ c:I\longrightarrow P. Writing locally c(t)=(x(t),u(t))c(t)=(x(t),u(t)), the controlled dynamics is described by

x˙i(t)=fi(x(t),u(t)),i=1,…,n.(1)\dot{x}^i(t)=f^i(x(t),u(t)),\qquad i=1,\ldots,n. \tag*{(1)}

Definition 2 (Optimal control problem). An optimal control problem (OCP)(OCP) is a quadruple (P,C,Γ,L)(P,C,\Gamma,L) consisting of

(i) A control system (P,C,Γ)(P,C,\Gamma).

(ii) A smooth cost function L:C⟶RL:C\longrightarrow\mathbb{R}, called the running cost (or Lagrangian), which defines the objective functional

S(c)=∫0TL(c(t)) dt=∫0TL(x(t),u(t)) dt,(2)S(c)=\int_0^T L(c(t))\,dt=\int_0^T L(x(t),u(t))\,dt, \tag*{(2)}

where c:[0,T]⟶Cc:[0,T]\longrightarrow C is an admissible control satisfying π(c(t))=x(t)\pi(c(t))=x(t), and the associated state trajectory x(t)x(t) satisfies the controlled dynamics (1) together with the prescribed boundary conditions x(0)=x0x(0)=x_0, x(T)=xTx(T)=x_T. The optimal control problem consists of finding admissible controls minimizing the functional (2).

The presymplectic formulation of optimal control problems

The fundamental tool in optimal control theory is the Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP), which provides first-order necessary conditions for optimality. Throughout this paper we assume that optimal trajectories exist and, until Section 7, restrict our attention to regular optimal control problems.

The geometric formulation of the PMP naturally leads to the introduction of the following bundle.

Definition 3 (Pontryagin bundle). The Pontryagin bundle associated with the control system (P,C,Γ)(P,C,\Gamma) is the fiber product M=T∗P×PCM=T^*P\times_P C, whose fiber over a point x∈Px\in P is Mx=Tx∗P×CxM_x=T_x^*P\times C_x. Equivalently,

M={(αx,cx)∈T∗P×C∣πP(αx)=π(cx)=x}.M=\{(\alpha_x,c_x)\in T^*P\times C\mid\pi_P(\alpha_x)=\pi(c_x)=x\}.

The Pontryagin bundle inherits natural local coordinates (xi,pi,ua)(x^i,p_i,u^a), induced from the canonical coordinates (xi,pi)(x^i,p_i) on T∗PT^*P and the adapted coordinates (xi,ua)(x^i,u^a) on the control bundle CC.

We denote by pr⁡P:M⟶T∗P\operatorname{pr}_P:M\longrightarrow T^*P and pr⁡C:M⟶C\operatorname{pr}_C:M\longrightarrow C the canonical projections onto the two factors,

pr⁡P(x,p,u)=(x,p),pr⁡C(x,p,u)=(x,u).(3)\operatorname{pr}_P(x,p,u)=(x,p),\qquad\operatorname{pr}_C(x,p,u)=(x,u). \tag*{(3)}

These maps fit into the commutative diagram

M=T∗P×PC→pr⁡CCpr⁡P↓↓πT∗P→πPP\begin{CD} M=T^*P\times_P C @>{\operatorname{pr}_C}>> C \\ @V{\operatorname{pr}_P}VV @VV{\pi}V \\ T^*P @>{\pi_P}>> P \end{CD}

The Pontryagin bundle carries a natural presymplectic form obtained by pulling back the canonical symplectic form ωP\omega_P on T∗PT^*P, namely

Ω=pr⁡P∗ωP=dxi∧dpi.(4)\Omega=\operatorname{pr}_P^*\omega_P=dx^i\wedge dp_i. \tag*{(4)}

The control vector field Γ\Gamma and the running cost LL determine the Pontryagin Hamiltonian

HP(x,p,u)=⟨p,Γ(x,u)⟩−L(x,u)=pifi(x,u)−L(x,u).(5)H_P(x,p,u)=\langle p,\Gamma(x,u)\rangle-L(x,u)=p_i f^i(x,u)-L(x,u). \tag*{(5)}

The presymplectic system (M,Ω,HP)(M,\Omega,H_P) provides a geometric formulation of the Pontryagin Maximum Principle. Indeed, its integral curves are precisely the extremals of the optimal control problem (P,C,Γ,L)(P,C,\Gamma,L). The characteristic distribution of Ω\Omega is

K=ker⁡Ω=ker⁡(pr⁡P)∗=span⁡{∂∂ua; a=1,…,r},K=\ker\Omega=\ker(\operatorname{pr}_P)_*=\operatorname{span}\left\{\frac{\partial}{\partial u^a};\ a=1,\ldots,r\right\},

that is, the vertical bundle of the projection pr⁡P:M⟶T∗P\operatorname{pr}_P:M\longrightarrow T^*P.

The dynamics is determined by the presymplectic equation

iXPΩ=dHP.(6)\mathord{\mathrm{i}}_{X_P}\Omega=dH_P. \tag*{(6)}

Since Ω\Omega is degenerate, solutions of (6) do not exist everywhere. A necessary condition for solvability [21] is ⟨Z,dHP⟩=0\langle Z,dH_P\rangle=0, ∀Z∈K\forall Z\in K, which, in local coordinates, becomes

φa=∂HP∂ua=0,a=1,…,r.(7)\varphi_a=\frac{\partial H_P}{\partial u^a}=0,\qquad a=1,\ldots,r. \tag*{(7)}

The functions φa\varphi_a are called the primary constraints, and their common zero set

M1={(x,p,u)∈M∣φa(x,p,u)=0, a=1,…,r}(8)M_1=\{(x,p,u)\in M\mid\varphi_a(x,p,u)=0,\ a=1,\ldots,r\} \tag*{(8)}

is the primary constraint submanifold. Under the regularity assumptions considered in this paper, M1M_1 is a smooth submanifold of codimension rr.

Let i1:M1↪Mi_1:M_1\hookrightarrow M denote the canonical inclusion. We write

Ω1=i1∗Ω,H1=i1∗HP,(9)\Omega_1=i_1^*\Omega,\qquad H_1=i_1^*H_P, \tag*{(9)}

for the induced presymplectic form and Hamiltonian on M1M_1, and by p1=pr⁡P∘i1:M1⟶T∗Pp_1=\operatorname{pr}_P\circ i_1:M_1\longrightarrow T^*P the restriction of pr⁡P\operatorname{pr}_P to M1M_1. Then

References

  1. [1]A. Agrachev, B. Bonnard, M. Chyba, and I. Kupka. Sub-Riemannian sphere in Martinet flat case. ESAIM: Control, Optimisation and Calculus of Variations, 2:377–448, 1997.DOI
  2. [2]A. A. Agrachev and Y. L. Sachkov. Control Theory from the Geometric Viewpoint. Springer, 2004.DOI
  3. [3]A. A. Agrachev and A. V. Sarychev. Abnormal sub-Riemannian geodesics: Morse index and rigidity. Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré C, Analyse Non Linéaire, 13(6):635–690, 1996.DOI
  4. [4]A. A. Agrachev and A. V. Sarychev. Sub-Riemannian submanifolds: Minimality of abnormal geodesics versus subanalyticity. ESAIM: Control, Optimisation and Calculus of Variations, 4:377–403, 1999.DOI
  5. [5]María Barbero-Liñán and Miguel C. Muñoz Lecanda. Geometric approach to Pontryagin’s maximum principle. Acta Applicandae Mathematicae, 108(2):429–485, 2009.
  6. [6]María Barbero-Liñán, Alberto Echevarría-Enríquez, David Martín de Diego, Miguel Muñoz-Lecanda, and Narciso Román-Roy. Skinner–rusk unified formalism for optimal control systems and applications. Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical, 40:12071–12093, 2007.
  7. [7]Ivan Beschastnyi and Alexandr Medvedev. Left-invariant sub-Riemannian Engel structures: Abnormal geodesics and integrability. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 56(5):3524–3537, 2018. arXiv:1611.03634.arxiv.org/abs/1611.03634
  8. [8]Guido Blankenstein and Tudor S. Ratiu. Singular reduction of implicit hamiltonian systems. Reports on Mathematical Physics, 53:211–260, 2004.DOI
  9. [9]Guido Blankenstein and Arjan J. van der Schaft. Symmetry and reduction in implicit generalized hamiltonian systems. Reports on Mathematical Physics, 47:57–100, 2001.DOI
  10. [10]A. M. Bloch, P. S. Krishnaprasad, J. E. Marsden, and R. Sánchez de Alvarez. Stabilization of rigid body dynamics by internal and external torques. Automatica, 28(4):745–756, 1992.DOI
  11. [12]Robert Bryant and Lucas Hsu. Rigidity of integral curves of rank 2 distributions. Inventiones Mathematicae, 114:435–461, 1993.DOI
  12. [13]Francesco Bullo and Andrew D. Lewis. Geometric Control of Mechanical Systems, volume 49 of Texts in Applied Mathematics. Springer, 2005.DOI
  13. [14]Hernán Cendra, Jerrold E. Marsden, Sergey Pekarsky, and Tudor S. Ratiu. Variational principles for Lie–Poisson and Hamilton–Poincaré equations. Moscow Mathematical Journal, 3(3):833–867, 2003.DOI
  14. [15]Hernán Cendra, Jerrold E. Marsden, and Tudor S. Ratiu. Lagrangian Reduction by Stages, volume 152 of Memoirs of the American Mathematical Society. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2001.DOI
  15. [16]Yacine Chitour, Frédéric Jean, and Emmanuel Trélat. Singular trajectories of control-affine systems. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 47, 2008. arXiv:math/0607455.arxiv.org/abs/math/0607455
  16. [17]Theodore Courant and Alan Weinstein. Beyond poisson structures. In Action Hamiltonienne des Groupes, volume 27 of Travaux en Cours, pages 39–49. Hermann, Paris, 1988.
  17. [18]Theodore J. Courant. Dirac manifolds. Transactions of the American Mathematical Society, 319:631–661, 1990.
  18. [19]Manuel Delgado-Téllez. Métodos Geométricos en Problemas de Control Óptimos Singulares: Fundamentos y Aplicaciones. PhD thesis, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, 2004.
  19. [20]Manuel Delgado-Téllez and Alberto Ibort. On the geometry and topology of singular optimal control problems and their solutions. Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems Supplement, pages 223–333, 2003.
  20. [21]Mark J. Gotay, James M. Nester, and George Hinds. Presymplectic manifolds and the dirac–bergmann theory of constraints. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 19:2388–2399, 1978.DOI
  21. [22]Katarzyna Grabowska and Janusz Grabowski. Variational calculus with constraints on general algebroids. Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical, 41:175204, 2008.
  22. [23]Janusz Grabowski and Michał Jóźwikowski. Pontryagin maximum principle on almost Lie algebroids. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 49(3):1306–1357, 2011.DOI
  23. [24]Lucas Hsu. Calculus of variations via the Griffiths formalism. Journal of Differential Geometry, 36(3):551–589, 1992.DOI
  24. [25]Michał Jóźwikowski and Witold Respondek. A contact covariant approach to optimal control with applications to sub-Riemannian geometry. Mathematics of Control, Signals, and Systems, 28(27), 2016.
  25. [26]Velimir Jurdjevic. Geometric Control Theory. Cambridge University Press, 1997.DOI
  26. [27]Velimir Jurdjevic. Optimal control, geometry and mechanics. In John Baillieul and Jan C. Willems, editors, Mathematical Control Theory, pages 227–267. Springer, 1999.DOI
  27. [28]Zhang-Ju Liu, Alan Weinstein, and Ping Xu. Manin triples for lie bialgebroids. Journal of Differential Geometry, 45:547–574, 1997.arxiv.org/abs/dg-ga/9508013
  28. [29]Eduardo Martínez. Reduction in optimal control theory. Reports on Mathematical Physics, 53:79–90, 2004.DOI
  29. [30]Thomas Mietton and Luca Rizzi. Branching geodesics in sub-Riemannian geometry. Geometric and Functional Analysis, 30:1139–1151, 2020. arXiv:2202.12293.
  30. [31]Richard Montgomery. Abnormal minimizers. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 32(6):1605–1620, 1994.DOI
  31. [32]Richard Montgomery. A survey of singular curves in sub-Riemannian geometry. Journal of Dynamical and Control Systems, 1(1):49–90, 1995.DOI
  32. [33]Richard Montgomery. A Tour of Subriemannian Geometries, Their Geodesics and Applications, volume 91 of Mathematical Surveys and Monographs. American Mathematical Society, 2002.
  33. [34]Tomoki Ohsawa. Contact geometry of the Pontryagin maximum principle. Automatica, 55:1–5, 2015.DOI
  34. [35]Nicola Paddeu and Alessandro Socionovо. Strictly abnormal geodesics with a degeneracy point in the interior of their domain. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 2025. arXiv:2505.11284; doi:10.1137/25M1793997, to appear.DOI
  35. [36]Alan Weinstein. A universal construction for particles in yang–mills fields. Letters in Mathematical Physics, 2:417–420, 1978.DOI
  36. [37]Hiroaki Yoshimura and Jerrold E. Marsden. Dirac structures in lagrangian mechanics. part i. Journal of Geometry and Physics, 57:133–156, 2006.DOI
  37. [38]Hiroaki Yoshimura and Jerrold E. Marsden. Dirac structures in lagrangian mechanics. part ii. Journal of Geometry and Physics, 57:209–250, 2006.DOI
  38. [39]Hiroaki Yoshimura and Jerrold E. Marsden. Dirac structures and the legendre transformation for implicit lagrangian and hamiltonian systems. In Lecture Notes in Control and Information Sciences, volume 366, pages 233–247. Springer, 2007.DOI
  39. [40]Hiroaki Yoshimura and Jerrold E. Marsden. Reduction of dirac structures and the hamilton–pontryagin principle. Reports on Mathematical Physics, 60:381–426, 2007.DOI
  40. [41]Hiroaki Yoshimura and Jerrold E. Marsden. Dirac cotangent bundle reduction. Journal of Geometric Mechanics, 1:87–158, 2009.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vq25j9eq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 3

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents