betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Carrier mobilities of Janus transition metal dichalcogenides monolayers studied by Born effective charge and first-principles calculation

Abstract

Two-dimensional (2D) Janus transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) are a new class of materials with unique physical properties. However, the carrier mobility of most Janus TMDs calculated by deformation potential theory (DPT) is not reliable due to the unconsidered part of lattice scattering. In this work, we propose a new method of Born effective charge (BEC) to calculate the carrier mobility of Janus TMDs by including the important factors that neglected in the DPT. The BEC could be used in the calculation of both pure and defective Janus TMDs by employing density functional perturbation theory. We have figured out the relationship between the carrier mobility and the value of BEC, which is the lower the absolute BEC, the higher the electron or hole mobility. Using the new method, we have calculated the carrier mobility of commonly studied Janus TMDs with and without defect. The method may shed light on the high-throughout calculation of selecting high carrier mobility 2D materials.

Introduction

Two-dimensional TMDs crystals, such as H-MoS2_2 and H-MoTe2_2 have been extensively studied by experiment and first-principles calculations [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. Two-dimensional (2D) Janus materials are a new class of materials with unique physical, chemical, and quantum properties [7]. Janus TMDs of MoSSe was firstly synthesized and confirmed by means of scanning transmission electron microscopy and energy-dependent X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy [8, 9]. The structure of MoSSe was based on single-crystalline triangular MoS2_2 monolayers, through chemical vapour deposition, Se atoms replace the S atoms, forming a structurally stable Janus MoSSe monolayer in which the Mo atoms are covalently bonded to underlying S and top-layer Se atoms.

From then on, the interesting Janus 2D materials attracting a lot of attentions [10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. Janus WSSe has been synthesized and it’s novel physical properties were also revealed [15, 16]. Then the VSSe [17], the ZrSSe [18], and the SnSSe [19] have been systematically studied, and a lot of interesting intrinsic physical properties were revealed. Single-layer PtSSe exhibits a high absorption coefficient in the visible light region, appropriate band edge positions and strong ability for carrier separation and transfer [20]. Besides the experiments, first-principles calculations have also been applied to study the stabilities of the Janus structures [21, 22]. Obviously, the symmetry of Janus structure is lower than 2D TMDs materials, which indicate that the multi-layer Janus TMDs may have high out-of-plane piezoelectric effect [6, 23]. The electron and hole mobilities of Janus TMDs are important descriptors for selecting good candidates for advanced 2D materials design.

The deformation potential theory (DPT) is frequently used to calculate the intrinsic mobility of semiconductors [24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30] and the Janus 2D materials [19, 31, 32]. However, the application of DPT must satisfy the following requirements [25, 33]. One is that the lowest valence band of the material should be parabolic, and the other one is about the scattering of the carrier, which should be mainly caused by longitudinal acoustic wave of the lattice. Besides, to obtain the carrier mobility in DPT, the effective mass should be calculated from averaging all directions of materials. Therefore, using DPT to calculate carrier mobility of anisotropic materials is challengeable.

As we all know, electron-phonon coupling (EPC) is the relative accurate method to calculate the carrier mobility of 2D materials [34, 35, 36, 37]. However, the calculation of EPC is very expensive, and the cell is limited within ten atoms without defects. Therefore, it is necessary to find a new way to calculate the mobility effectively, especially for the structure with defects. The BEC can affect the vibration of the longitudinal optical branch which cause a considerable change in polarization, resulting in stronger carrier scattering through coulomb interaction, thus has been applied to predict the carrier mobility of a amount of 2D TMDs [38]. BEC can be calculated by applying changes in polarization divided by the displacement of the atoms. In this work, we use first-principles density functional perturbation theory to calculate BEC, then predict the carrier mobility of perfect and defective hexagonal Janus structure (H-) of H-MoSSe, H-MoSTe, H-MoSeTe, H-WSSe, H-WSTe, H-WSeTe and triangular Janus structure (T-) of T-HfSSe, T-ZrSSe, T-SnSSe, T-PtSSe, T-PtSTe, T-PtSeTe.

Methods

The calculations of band structure and carrier mobility are based on density functional theory (DFT) using the plane-wave basis within projection augmented wave (PAW) method. The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) in the Perdew-Burke Ernzerhof (PBE) form is used as the exchange correlation potential implemented in the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) [39, 40, 41, 42]. On the premise of ensuring the accuracy of the calculation results, we set the cutoff energy of all related calculations to 350 eV, the convergence criterion between the two electronic steps in the self-consistent process to 10−610^{-6} eV and the force convergence is set to 0.01 eV/Å, the K-points are set to 9×9×19 \times9 \times1 and 15×11×115 \times11 \times1 for relaxation and energy calculation, respectively.

We obtain the phonon spectrum using the density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) method [43] as implemented in VASP and post-processed by using the Phonopy package [44]. In order to improve the precise of the calculation, we increase the energy convergence criteria for electronic and force convergence, which were set to be 10−1010^{-10} eV and 0.001 eV/Å, respectively. A vacuum layer with a thickness of 20 Å is added along the z-axis in order to avoid interaction between adjacent layers.

The phonon-limited formula is used to estimate carrier mobility in low dimensional materials [25, 45, 46]:

μ=eℏ3C2DKBTm∗mdEi2md=mx∗my∗(1)\mu= \frac{e\hbar^{3}C_{2D}}{K_{B}Tm^{*}m_{d}E_{i}^{2}}m_{d} = \sqrt{m_{x}^{*}m_{y}^{*}} \tag*{(1)}

where m∗m^{*} is the effective mass along the transmission direction (mx∗m_{x}^{*} or my∗m_{y}^{*} is along xx or yy direction, respectively), and the mean effective mass was defined as md=mx∗my∗m_{d} = \sqrt{m_{x}^{*}m_{y}^{*}}. C2DC_{2D} is the elastic modulus of the simplex deformed crystal, which is used to simulate the lattice distortion caused by strain, which is given by

C2D=1S0∂2E∂(Δl/l0)2∣l=l0,C_{2D} = \left.\frac{1}{S_{0}}\frac{\partial^{2}E}{\partial(\Delta l/l_{0})^{2}}\right|_{l=l_{0}},

EE is the total energy of the system and S0S_{0} is the equilibrium area of the unit cell, l0l_{0} is the lattice constant, Δl=l−l0\Delta l = l-l_{0} is corresponding lattice distortion. Here the applied deformation varies from 0 to 0.6%. EiE_{i} is the deformation potential, which can be expressed as the following formula

Ei=∂Eedge∂(Δl/l0),E_{i} = \frac{\partial E_{\mathrm{edge}}}{\partial(\Delta l/l_{0})},

which represents of the strain-induced band edge displacement (the minimum electron-conducting band, the maximum hole valence band) along the direction of electron transport. The temperature used for the mobility calculations was 300 K.

Density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) is used to calculate the BEC of two-dimensional Janus structures. The BEC of an atom ss is defined as the change in polarization pp in the α\alpha direction linearly induced by a sublattice displacement us,βu_{s,\beta} in the β\beta direction in zero macroscopic electric field as shown in below formula [47]:

Zs∗α,β=V∂Pα∂us,β(2)Z_{s}^{*\alpha,\beta}=V\frac{\partial P_{\alpha}}{\partial u_{s,\beta}} \tag*{(2)}

where VV is the unit volume, PαP_{\alpha} is the α\alpha component of the polarization and us,βu_{s,\beta} is the displacement of the sths^{th} atom in the direction of β\beta. For two dimensional Janus structures with low symmetry, BEC is not symmetric in the Cartesian directions. Since any rigid translation of the entire system does not cause macroscopic polarization, the BEC tensor follows acoustics and rules. The sum rule thus was given as [47, 48]:

∑sZs∗α,β=0(3)\sum_{s} Z_{s}^{*\alpha,\beta}=0 \tag*{(3)}

i.e., the sum of BEC of all the atoms in certain system is zero.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The failure of the mobility from DPT

From previous work, we could find that the CBM of TMDs satisfy the parabolic requirement [38]. However, most existing electron mobilities of TMDs predicted by DPT are much larger than the available experimental results, except for MoS2_2 as shown in Table 1. From the calculations, we found that the anisotropy of the electron mobilities of TMDs can’t be neglected, especially for that of the T-phase of TMDs. However, the lower mobility of two directions (xx and yy) still much higher than the related experimental results. Hence, some important factors should be considered in to the method of DPT, which at present is not good enough for the electron mobility calculations of the majority of TMDs.

SystemsPresent work (μe\mu_e) (cm2^2/Vs)Experimental results available (μe\mu_e) (cm2^2/Vs)
T-ZrS2_2μx=261.27, μy=549.32\mu_x=261.27,\ \mu_y=549.32
T-ZrSe2_2μx=1252.70, μy=2549.70\mu_x=1252.70,\ \mu_y=2549.70
T-HfS2_2μx=428.77, μy=1110.00\mu_x=428.77,\ \mu_y=1110.00
T-HfSe2_2μx=2763.00, μy=7323.00\mu_x=2763.00,\ \mu_y=7323.000.22 [49]
T-SnS2_2μx=156.58, μy=491.98\mu_x=156.58,\ \mu_y=491.98
T-SnSe2_2μx=423.60, μy=312.33\mu_x=423.60,\ \mu_y=312.338.6 [50]
T-PtS2_2μx=392.12, μy=254.06\mu_x=392.12,\ \mu_y=254.06
T-PtSe2_2μx=884.47, μy=459.92\mu_x=884.47,\ \mu_y=459.9218 [51]
T-PtTe2_2μx=1021.00, μy=1204.00\mu_x=1021.00,\ \mu_y=1204.00
H-MoS2_2μx=169.47, μy=165.44\mu_x=169.47,\ \mu_y=165.44200 [52]
H-MoSe2_2μx=110.16, μy=108.70\mu_x=110.16,\ \mu_y=108.7050 [53]
H-MoTe2_2μx=101.55, μy=98.32\mu_x=101.55,\ \mu_y=98.3240 [54]
H-WS2_2μx=277.21, μx=272.05\mu_x=277.21,\ \mu_x=272.05100 [55]
H-WSe2_2μx=278.00, μx=266.33\mu_x=278.00,\ \mu_x=266.33142 [56]

Table 1. The electron mobility (μe\mu_e) of T- and H-TMDs calculated by employing DPT.

How about the electron mobilities of Janus TMDs from DPT? Table II shows that the electron mobilities of Janus TMDs from DPT are still not satisfactory for describing the affects from lattice scattering, i.e., the electron mobilities are unreasonably high although the band structure of the system satisfies the parabolic properties, as shown in Figure 1. In order to get reliable data of carrier mobility of Janus TMDs, new methods or factors should be employed in the calculations.

Band structures of H and T types of Janus TMDs monolayers

Figure 1. The band structures of H (a-f) and T(g-l) types of Janus TMDs monolayers. The Fermi level is set to zero.

The bridge between mobility and BEC

As we all know, EPC is a relatively precise way to calculate the carrier mobility recently. However, this method is very expensive and not suitable for a large system not to mention the system with defects. Hence, finding a new way to describe the main contribution from lattice scattering is necessary for building a method for high-throughout calculation. BEC is such a quantity that could describe the lattice scattering effectively and then obtain the carrier mobility.

The electron mobility of TMDs from both experiment and EPC are summarized in Figure 3. After fitting the data from EPC, we find that the electron mobility from EPC has polynomial function with BEC in system of TMDs. Besides, the experimental results approximately meet the fitting values. It is easy to conclude that the lower the absolute BEC, the higher the electron mobility, which is similar to that of hole mobility, as shown in Figure 4. In this bridge, the carrier mobility of the TMDs can be obtained through BEC.

Relationship between BEC and electron mobility

Figure 3. The relationship between the BEC and electron mobility. The blue squares represent values calculated by EPC which are fitted by blue lines. The red five-pointed stars are available experimental values.

The relationship between the BEC and hole mobility

Figure 4. The relationship between the BEC and hole mobility. The blue squares represent values calculated by EPC which are fitted by blue lines. The red five-pointed stars are available experimental values.

System(μe)(\mu_e) (cm2^2/Vs)(μh)(\mu_h) (cm2^2/Vs)
T-ZrSSeμx=1971.80, μy=3646.70\mu_x=1971.80,\ \mu_y=3646.70μx=495.48, μy=500.73\mu_x=495.48,\ \mu_y=500.73
T-HfSSeμx=2033.40, μy=4864.50\mu_x=2033.40,\ \mu_y=4864.50μx=452.84, μy=487.95\mu_x=452.84,\ \mu_y=487.95
T-SnSSeμx=231.91, μy=883.48\mu_x=231.91,\ \mu_y=883.48μx=0.74, μy=0.19\mu_x=0.74,\ \mu_y=0.19
T-PtSSeμx=707.26, μy=377.51\mu_x=707.26,\ \mu_y=377.51μx=17.71, μy=407.89\mu_x=17.71,\ \mu_y=407.89
T-PtSTeμx=59.28, μy=51.57\mu_x=59.28,\ \mu_y=51.57μx=0.64, μy=1.40\mu_x=0.64,\ \mu_y=1.40
T-PtSeTeμx=389.28, μy=590.72\mu_x=389.28,\ \mu_y=590.72μx=14.23, μy=14.33\mu_x=14.23,\ \mu_y=14.33
H-MoSSeμx=120.38, μy=117.25\mu_x=120.38,\ \mu_y=117.25μx=233.23, μy=236.76\mu_x=233.23,\ \mu_y=236.76
H-MoSTeμx=46.53, μy=45.41\mu_x=46.53,\ \mu_y=45.41μx=2.25, μy=1.91\mu_x=2.25,\ \mu_y=1.91
H-MoSeTeμx=68.90, μy=68.91\mu_x=68.90,\ \mu_y=68.91μx=87.62, μy=90.92\mu_x=87.62,\ \mu_y=90.92
H-WSSeμx=267.31, μy=261.47\mu_x=267.31,\ \mu_y=261.47μx=513.85, μy=533.27\mu_x=513.85,\ \mu_y=533.27
H-WSTeμx=158.94, μy=145.67\mu_x=158.94,\ \mu_y=145.67μx=15.14, μy=15.29\mu_x=15.14,\ \mu_y=15.29
H-WSeTeμx=183.50, μy=177.66\mu_x=183.50,\ \mu_y=177.66μx=267.66, μy=273.97\mu_x=267.66,\ \mu_y=273.97

Table 2. The calculated electron (μe)(\mu_e) and hole (μh)(\mu_h) mobility of Janus TMDs from DPT.

Then let’s promote the method to Janus TMDs which require the bandstructure and phonon spectrum of Janus TMDs have similar characters as that of TMDs. From Figure 1 and Figure 2, we could know that the bandstructure and phonon spectrum of Janus TMDs do like that of TMDs [38]. Thus, the mobility of Janus structures could be predicted from the BEC safely. The quantitative electron and hole mobility of Janus structures can be found in Table III and Table IV, respectively.

Phonon spectra of H- and T-type Janus TMD monolayers

Figure 2. The phonon spectrum of H (a-f) and T(g-l) types of Janus TMDs monolayers.

Prediction for Janus structure

In this section, we want to predict the carrier mobility by applying the above functions with the BEC. For H types of Janus TMDs, the order of the values of metal atom for ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert are H-WSTe<<H-MoSTe<<H-WSeTe<<H-MoSeTe, in which H-WSTe has the largest electron mobility of 129.72 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, while H-MoSeTe has the lowest electron mobility of 64.79 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, as shown in Table III. Like the relationship between ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert and the electron mobility for H-phase, the smaller the value of ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of nonmetal atom, the larger the hole mobility. As shown in Table IV, H-MoSeTe has the lowest hole mobility of 36.52 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} related to the largest ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of 2.60 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert, while H-WSSe has the largest hole mobility of 382.05 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} related to the smallest ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of 0.89 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert. We further found that for the TMDs of H-MXY (M refers to metal atom, X and Y are distinct element), the H-WXY has larger carrier mobility relative to H-MoXY because W has the highest Pauling electronegativity among all metal elements [38].

For T-phase of Janus, the order of the values for ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of metal atom is T-PtSTe<<T-PtSeTe<<T-PtSSe<<T-SnSSe<<T-HfSSe<<T-ZrSSe, in which T-PtSTe has the largest electron mobility of 109.38 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} relate to the lowest ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of 1.83 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert, and T-ZrSSe has the lowest electron mobility of 25.98 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, as shown in Table III. Similarly to electron mobility, the largest hole mobility for T-PtSTe is 6.28 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, as shown in Table IV.

This correlation is understandable, because a large BEC suggests a large change in the polarization, resulting in a stronger carrier scattering through Coulomb interaction. It’s worth mentioning that all the calculated BEC for H-phase is different from that of the chemical charge, which the metals has negative ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert but not positive ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert. This can be explained from the local changes of polarization around atoms by establish π\pi backbonding model [57]. By the way, this method is not suitable for calculating the carrier mobility of H-WSSe and H-MoSSe which is mainly influenced by optical branch rather than acoustic branch in phonon spectrum [38].

Janus TMDsZBZ_B (e)Mobility μe\mu_e (cm2^2/Vs)
H-MoSSe-1.48156.14
H-MoSTe-2.2778.44
H-MoSeTe-2.6064.79
H-WSSe-0.89394.69
H-WSTe-1.65129.72
H-WSeTe-2.5765.82
T-ZrSSe7.7125.98
T-SnSSe4.9333.18
T-HfSSe7.2426.65
T-PtSSe2.5366.80
T-PtSTe1.83109.38
T-PtSeTe2.0790.08

Table 3. The calculated BEC of metal atom (ZBZ_B) and the related electron mobility (μe\mu_e) of H and T types of Janus TMDs monolayers.

SystemZBZ_B(e)Mobility μh\mu_h (cm2^2/Vs)
H-MoSSe1.48125.43
H-MoSTe2.2749.16
H-MoSeTe2.6036.52
H-WSSe0.89382.05
H-WSTe1.6598.86
H-WSeTe2.5737.46
T-ZrSSe-7.715.26
T-SnSSe-4.935.26
T-HfSSe-7.245.26
T-PtSSe-2.535.26
T-PtSTe-1.836.28
T-PtSeTe-2.075.35

Table 4. The calculated BEC of nonmetal atom (ZBZ_B) and the related hole mobility (μe\mu_e) of H and T types of Janus TMDs monolayers.

We have calculated the mobilities of 12 types of MXY, unfortunately, we do not find a MXY with a mobility higher than H-WS2_2. However, we could deduce that the high-mobility 2D semiconductor maybe more likely exist in materials having zero BEC, which could be easily calculated from first-principles calculations. Besides, it is possible to find higher-mobility candidates by including more 2D materials from database into consideration [58].

The mobility of TMDs with point defects

The prediction of mobility of TMDs with point defects by EPC are challengeable due to a large supercell should be employed in the DFT calculations. Herein we try to use the new method to determine the mobility of TMDs with one substitutional point defect due to the formation of Janus TMDs monolayer origins from substituting one chalcogen atom of TMDs.

In order to simulate the point defect, we expand the primitive cell of TMDs by 3×33 \times3 to form a supercell with 27 atoms, then substituting one chalcogen atom (S, Se, Te) by another chalcogen atom to form a defective supercell, and then we calculate the BEC of these defective cells to obtain corresponding carrier mobility. According to the calculations, we found that the BEC of H-W9_9Se17_{17}S is 1.19 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert, thus its electron mobility and hole mobility are 230.02 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and 202.23 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, respectively, as shown in Table VI and Table VII. While for T-Zr9_9Se17_{17}Te, it has relative large BEC as 8.28 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert, which result in related electron mobility and hole mobility of 25.32 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and 5.26 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, respectively. We further found that the carrier mobility is related to chalcogen element (S, Se, Te) of TMDs. Generally, the order of the carrier mobility with the addition of chalcogen element is S>Se>Te. However, in T-Ptx1_{x1}Yx2_{x2} (X and Y are distinct element) is an exception, the order turns out inversely to be Te>Se>S. For example, the ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of H-Mo9_9Se18_{18} is calculated as 1.84 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert. When one of its chalcogenides changes, its BEC changes simultaneously. The ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}S change to a smaller value of 1.80 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert, and the ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert of H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}Te change to a bigger value of 1.92 ∣e∣\lvert e\rvert. The order of their ∣ZB∣\lvert Z_B\rvert satisfy the rule as H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}S < H-Mo9_9Se18_{18} < H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}Te. The mobility of electron and hole of H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}S is 112.36 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and 81.70 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, and that of H-Mo9_9Se18_{18} are 108.43 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and 77.86 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, and that of H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}Te are 101.30 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and 70.94 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1}, respectively, as shown in Table VI and Table VII.

Janus TMDsZBZ_B (e)Mobility μe\mu_e (cm2^2/Vs)Janus TMDsZBZ_B (e)Mobility μe\mu_e (cm2^2/Vs)
H-Mo9_9Se18_{18}-1.84108.43T-Hf9_9Se18_{18}7.6026.12
H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}S-1.80112.36T-Hf9_9Se17_{17}S7.5826.15
H-Mo9_9Se17_{17}Te-1.92101.30T-Hf9_9Se17_{17}Te7.7325.95
H-Mo9_9Te18_{18}-3.2848.51T-Zr9_9S18_{18}7.2626.62
H-Mo9_9Te17_{17}S-3.1750.46T-Zr9_9S17_{17}Se7.3026.55
H-Mo9_9Te17_{17}Se-3.2049.90T-Zr9_9S17_{17}Te7.4026.41
H-W9_9Se18_{18}-1.23216.65T-Zr9_9Se18_{18}8.1725.43
H-W9_9Se17_{17}S-1.19230.02T-Zr9_9Se17_{17}S8.1325.48
H-W9_9Se17_{17}Te-1.31193.48T-Zr9_9Se17_{17}Te8.2825.32
T-Sn9_9S18_{18}4.8933.38T-Pt9_9S18_{18}2.6862.21
T-Sn9_9S17_{17}Se4.9033.32T-Pt9_9S17_{17}Se2.6662.83
T-Sn9_9S17_{17}Te4.8033.84T-Pt9_9S17_{17}Te2.6662.83
T-Sn9_9Se18_{18}4.9832.94T-Pt9_9Se18_{18}2.3674.15
T-Sn9_9Se17_{17}S4.9832.94T-Pt9_9Se17_{17}S2.3873.26
T-Sn9_9Se17_{17}Te4.9932.94T-Pt9_9Se17_{17}Te1.9698.05
T-Hf9_9S18_{18}6.8827.25T-Pt9_9Te18_{18}1.56142.63
T-Hf9_9S17_{17}Se6.9127.20T-Pt9_9Te17_{17}S1.64131.05
T-Hf9_9S17_{17}Te7.0027.04T-Pt9_9Te17_{17}Se1.61135.19

Table VI. The calculated BEC of metal atom (ZBZ_B) and the related electron mobility (μe\mu_e) of H and T types of Janus TMDs monolayers. The size of supercells used in calculation of the impurity is 3×33 \times3.

SystemZBZ_B(e)Mobility μh\mu_h (cm2^2/Vs)SystemZBZ_B(e)Mobility μh\mu_h (cm2^2/Vs)
HH-Mo9Se18Mo_9Se_{18}1.8477.86TT-Hf9Se18Hf_9Se_{18}-7.605.26
HH-Mo9Se17SMo_9Se_{17}S1.8081.70TT-Hf9Se17SHf_9Se_{17}S-7.585.26
HH-Mo9Se17TeMo_9Se_{17}Te1.9270.94TT-Hf9Se17TeHf_9Se_{17}Te-7.735.26
HH-Mo9Te18Mo_9Te_{18}3.2821.95TT-Zr9S18Zr_9S_{18}-7.265.26
HH-Mo9Te17SMo_9Te_{17}S3.1723.66TT-Zr9S17SeZr_9S_{17}Se-7.305.26
HH-Mo9Te17SeMo_9Te_{17}Se3.2023.17TT-Zr9S17TeZr_9S_{17}Te-7.405.26
HH-W9Se18W_9Se_{18}1.23188.10TT-Zr9Se18Zr_9Se_{18}-8.175.26
HH-W9Se17SW_9Se_{17}S1.19202.23TT-Zr9Se17SZr_9Se_{17}S-8.135.26
HH-W9Se17TeW_9Se_{17}Te1.31163.86TT-Zr9Se17TeZr_9Se_{17}Te-8.285.26
TT-Sn9S18Sn_9S_{18}-4.895.26TT-Pt9S18Pt_9S_{18}-2.685.26
TT-Sn9S17SeSn_9S_{17}Se-4.905.26TT-Pt9S17SePt_9S_{17}Se-2.665.26
TT-Sn9S17TeSn_9S_{17}Te-4.805.26TT-Pt9S17TePt_9S_{17}Te-2.665.26
TT-Sn9Se18Sn_9Se_{18}-4.985.26TT-Pt9Se18Pt_9Se_{18}-2.365.27
TT-Sn9Se17SSn_9Se_{17}S-4.985.26TT-Pt9Se17SPt_9Se_{17}S-2.385.26
TT-Sn9Se17TeSn_9Se_{17}Te-4.995.26TT-Pt9Se17TePt_9Se_{17}Te-1.965.54
TT-Hf9S18Hf_9S_{18}-6.885.26TT-Pt9Te18Pt_9Te_{18}-1.5620.54
TT-Hf9S17SeHf_9S_{17}Se-6.915.26TT-Pt9Te17SPt_9Te_{17}S-1.6412.13
TT-Hf9S17SeHf_9S_{17}Se-7.005.26TT-Pt9Te17SePt_9Te_{17}Se-1.6114.53

Table VII. Calculated impurities in TMDs(3×3) of the hole mobility (μh\mu_h), BEC of nonmetal atom(ZBZ_B).

Therefore, one want to find a new TMDs with high mobility, the BEC of the material should be small. The addition of S atoms can reduce the BEC, and obtain a relative small BEC, thus a large mobility of TMDs. On the contrary, for T-PtX2_2 (X=S, Se and Te), the addition of Te results in a relative large mobility.

Summary

We have calculated the carrier mobility of pure and defective Janus structural materials using first-principles calculation and BEC. It is shown that the method of BEC is more suitable for calculating the carrier mobility of Janus TMDs than that of DPT. Our study reveals the reason of effective BEC, which is the carrier mobility of most Janus structural materials are mainly affected by longitudinal optical branch except H-MoSSe and HWSSe. For the pure Janus structural materials, H- WSTe has the largest electron mobility of 129.72 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and hole mobility of 382.05 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} due to the lowest BEC. While for Janus structural materials with defects, H-W9_9Se17_{17}S has the highest electron mobility of 230.02 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} and hole mobility of 202.23 cm2^2V−1^{-1}s−1^{-1} due to the lowest BEC as well.

SystemZBZ_B (e)Mobility μe\mu_e (cm2^2/Vs)ZBZ_B (e) from work [38]Mobility μe\mu_e (cm2^2/Vs) from work [38]
H-MoS2_21.00296.001.09219.00
H-MoSe2_21.8081.701.8983.10
H-MoTe2_23.3820.563.3727.30
H-WS2_20.521239.490.65764.50
H-WSe2_21.23188.101.29189.90
T-ZrS2_2-7.155.26-6.138.50
T-ZrSe2_2-8.175.26-6.458.20
T-SnS2_2-4.905.26-4.854.60
T-SnSe2_2-4.985.26-4.963.00
T-HfS2_2-6.845.26-6.036.70
T-HfSe2_2-7.605.26-6.336.00
T-PtS2_2-2.695.26-2.451.90
T-PtSe2_2-2.355.27-2.123.20
T-PtTe2_2-1.5522.16-1.27115.20

Table V. The calculated TMDs of the electron mobility (μe\mu_e) and BEC of metal atom (ZBZ_B).

Conflicts of interest

The authors declared that they have no conflicts of interest to this work.

acknowledgments

The authors are grateful for financial support from National Natural Science Foundation of China (General program 51671086) and Hunan Provincial Education Department (Key project 19A324).

References

References

  1. [1]Jin, Hao and Wang, Tao and Gong, Zhi-Rui and Long, Chen and Dai, Ying, Nanoscale, 2018, 10, 19310
  2. [2]Shi, Wenwu and Wang, Zhiguo, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter, 2018, 30, 215301
  3. [3]Xia, Congxin and Xiong, Wenqi and Du, Juan and Wang, Tianxing and Peng, Yuting and Li, Jingbo, Phys. Rev. B, 2018, 98, 165424
  4. [4]Liu, Huating and Huang, Zongyu and He, Chaoyu and Wu, Yanbing and Xue, Lin and Tang, Chao and Qi, Xiang and Zhong, Jianxin, J. Appl. Phys., 2019, 125, 082516
  5. [5]Guo, San-Dong and Dong, Jun, Semicond. Sci. Tech., 2018, 33, 085003
  6. [6]Dong, Liang and Lou, Jun and Shenoy, Vivek B, Acs Nano, 2017, 11, 8242
  7. [7]Yagmurcukardes, M and Qin, Y and Ozen, S and Sayyad, M and Peeters, François M and Tongay, S and Sahin, H, Appl. Phys. Rev., 2020, 7, 011311
  8. [8]Lu, Ang-Yu and Zhu, Hanyu and Xiao, Jun and Chuu, Chih-Piao and Han, Yimo and Chiu, Ming-Hui and Cheng, Chia-Chin and Yang, Chih-Wen and Wei, Kung-Hwa and Yang, Yiming and others, Nat. Nanotechnol., 2017, 12, 744
  9. [9]Zhang, Jing and Jia, Shuai and Kohlmanov, Iskandar and Dong, Liang and Er, Dequan and Chen, Weibing and Guo, Hua and Jin, Zehua and Shenoy, Vivek B and Shi, Li and others, Acs. Nano, 2017, 11, 8192
  10. [10]Sant, Roberto and Gay, Maxime and Marty, Alain and Lisi, Simone and Harrabi, Rania and Vergnaud, Céline and Dau, Minh Tuan and Weng, Xiaorong and Coraux, Johann and Gauthier, Nicolas and others, Mpj. 2D Mater. Appl., 2020, 4, 1
  11. [11]Ghobadi, Nayereh and Touski, Shoeib Babaee, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter, 2020, 33, 085502
  12. [12]Paez-Ornelas, JL and Ponce-Perez, R and Fernández-Escamilla, HN and Hoat, DM and Murillo-Bracamontes, EA and Armenta, Ma Guadalupe Moreno and Galván, Donald H and Guerrero-Sánchez, J, Research Square, 2021
  13. [13]Xu, Haowei and Wang, Hua and Zhou, Jian and Guo, Yunfan and Kong, Jing and Li, Ju, Npj. Comput. Mater., 2021, 7, 1
  14. [14]Petrić, Marko M and Kremser, Malte and Barbone, Matteo and Qin, Ying and Sayyad, Yasir and Shen, Yuxia and Tongay, Sefaattin and Finley, Jonathan J and Botello-Méndez, Andrés R and Müller, Kai, Phys. Rev. B, 2021, 103, 035414
  15. [15]Trivedi, Dipesh B and Turgut, Guven and Qin, Ying and Sayyad, Mohammed Y and Hajra, Debarati and Howell, Madeleine and Liu, Lei and Yang, Sijie and Patoary, Naim Hossain and Li, Han and others, Adv. Mater., 2020, 32, 20006320
  16. [16]Lin, Yu-Chuan and Liu, Chenze and Yu, Yiling and Zarkadoula, Eva and Yoon, Mina and Puretzky, Alexander A and Liang, Lian gbo and Kong, Xiangru and Gu, Yiyi and Strasser, Alex and others, Acs. Nano, 2020, 14, 3896
  17. [17]Zhang, Chunmei and Nie, Yihan and Sanvito, Stefano and Du, Aijun, Nano. Lett., 2019, 19, 1366
  18. [18]Vu, Tuan V and Tong, Hien D and Tran, Duy Phu and Binh, Nguyen TT and Nguyen, Chuong V and Phuc, Huynh V and Do, Hoat M and Hieu, Nguyen N, Rsc. Adv., 2019, 9, 41058
  19. [19]Guo, San-Dong and Guo, Xiao-Shu and Han, Ru-Yue and Deng, Ye, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2019, 21, 24620
  20. [20]Peng, Rui and Ma, Yandong and Huang, Baibiao and Dai, Ying, J. Mater. Chem. A, 2019, 7, 603
  21. [21]Kandemir, Ali and Sahin, Hasan, Phys. Rev. B, 2018, 97, 155410
  22. [22]Cheng, YC and Zhu, ZY and Tahir, Muhammad and Schw ingenschlögl, Udo, Europhys. Lett., 2013, 102, 57001
  23. [23]Yagmurcukardes, M and Sevik, C and Peeters, FM, Phys. Rev. B, 2019, 100, 045415
  24. [24]Bardeen, J and Shockley, W, Phys. Rev., 1950, 80, 72
  25. [25]Xi, Jinyang and Long, Mengqiu and Tang, Ling and Wang, Dong and Shuai, Zhigang, Nanoscale, 2012, 4, 4348
  26. [26]Qiao, Jingsi and Kong, Xianghua and Hu, Zhi-Xin and Yang, Feng and Ji, Wei, Nat. Commun., 2014, 5, 1
  27. [27]Yang, Ji-Hui and Zhang, Yueyu and Yin, Wan-Jian and Gong, XG and Yakobson, Boris I and Wei, Su-Hui, Nano. Lett., 2016, 16, 1110
  28. [28]Cai, Yongqing and Zhang, Gang and Zhang, Yong-Wei, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2014, 136, 6269
  29. [29]Zhu, Zhili and Cai, Xiaolin and Yi, Seho and Chen, Jinglei and Dai, Yawei and Niu, Chunyao and Guo, Zhengxiao and Xie, Maohai and Liu, Feng and Cho, Jun-Hyung and others, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2017, 119, 106101
  30. [30]Long, Meng-Qiu and Tang, Ling and Wang, Dong and Wang, Linjun and Shuai, Zhigang, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2009, 131, 17728
  31. [31]Yin, Wen-Jian and Wen, Bo and Nie, Guo-Zheng and Wei, Xiao-Lin and Liu, Li-Min, J. Mater. Chem. C, 2018, 6, 1693
  32. [32]Patel, Abhishek and Singh, Deobrat and Sonyane, Yogesh and Thakor, PB and Ahuja, Rajeev, Acs. Appl. Mater. Inter., 2020, 12, 46212
  33. [33]Price, PJ, Ann. Phys.: New York, 1981, 133, 217
  34. [34]Kaasbjerg, Kristen and Thygesen, Kristian S and Jacobsen, Karsten W, Phys. Rev. B, 2012, 85, 115317
  35. [35]Li, Wu, Phys. Rev. B, 2012, 92, 075405
  36. [36]Gunst, Tue and Markussen, Troels and Stokbro, Kurt and Brandbyge, Mads, Phys. Rev. B, 2016, 93, 035414
  37. [37]Hinsche, Nicki Frank and Ngankeu, Arlette S and Guiloy, Kevin and Mahatha, Sanjoy K and Čabo, Antonija Grubišić and Bianchi, Marco and Dendzik, Maciej and Sanders, Charlotte E and Miwa, Jill A and Bana, Harsh and others, Phys. Rev. B, 2017, 96, 121402
  38. [38]Cheng, Long and Liu, Yuanyue, J. Ame. Chem. Soc., 2018, 140, 17895
  39. [39]Perdew, John P and Burke, Kieron and Ernzerhof, Matthias, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1996, 77, 3865
  40. [40]Perdew, John P and Burke, Kieron and Ernzerhof, Matthias, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1997, 78, 1396
  41. [41]Kresse, Georg and Hafner, Jürgen, Phys. Rev. B, 1993, 47, 558
  42. [42]Kresse, Georg and Hafner, Jürgen, Phys. Rev. B, 1994, 49, 14251
  43. [43]Baroni, Stefano and De Gironcoli, Stefano and Dal Corso, Andrea and Giannozzi, Paolo, Rev. Mod. Phys., 2001, 73, 515
  44. [44]Togo, Atsushi and Tanaka, Isao, Scripta. Mater., 2015, 108, 1
  45. [45]Bruzzone, Samantha and Fiori, Gianluca, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2011, 99, 222108
  46. [46]Takagi, Shin-ichi and Toriumi, Akira and Iwase, Masao and Tango, Hiroyuki, IEEE. T. Electron. Dev., 1994, 41, 2357
  47. [47]Resta, R. , Ferroelectrics, 1992, 136, 51
  48. [48]Pick, R. M. and Cohen, M. H. and Martin, R. M. , Phys. Rev. B, 1970, 1, 910
  49. [49]Kang, Moonshik and Rathi, Servin and Lee, Inyeal and Lim, Dongsuk and Wang, Jianwei and Li, Lijun and Khan, Muhammad Atif and Kim, Gil-Ho, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2015, 106, 143108
  50. [50]Su, Yang and Ebrish, Mona A and Olson, Eric J and Koester, Steven J, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2013, 103, 263104
  51. [51]Yang, Yajie and Li, Jinshu and Choi, Seunghyuk and Jeon, Sumin and Cho, Jeong Ho and Lee, Byoung Hun and Lee, Sungjoo, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2021, 118, 081303
  52. [52]Radisavljevic, Branimir and Radenovic, Aleksandra and Brivio, Jacopo and Giacometti, Valentina and Kis, Andras, Nat. Nanotechnol., 2011, 6, 147
  53. [53]Wang, Xingli and Gong, Yongji and Shi, Gang and Chow, Wai Leong and Keyshar, Kunttal and Ye, Gonglan and Vajtai, Robert and Lou, Jun and Liu, Zheng and Ringe, Emilie and others, Acs. Nano, 2014, 8, 5125
  54. [54]Keum, Dong Hoon and Cho, Suyeon and Kim, Jung Ho and Choe, Duk-Hyun and Sung, Ha-Jun and Kan, Min and Kang, Haeyong and Hwang, Jae-Yeol and Kim, Sung Wng and Yang, Heejun and others, Nat. Phys., 2015, 11, 482
  55. [55]Wang, Yimeng and Sohier, Thibault and Watanabe, K and Taniguchi, T and Verstraete, MJ and Tutuc, E, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2021, 118, 102105
  56. [56]Liu, Wei and Kang, Jiahao and Sarkar, Deblina and Khatami, Yasin and Jena, Debdeep and Banerjee, Kaus-tav, Nano. lett., 2013, 13, 1983
  57. [57]Pike, Nicholas A and Van Troeye, Benoit and Dewandre, Antoine and Petretto, Guido and Gonze, Xavier and Rignanese, Gian-Marco and Verstraete, Matthieu J, Phys. Rev. B, 2017, 95, 201106
  58. [58]Mounet, Nicolas and Gibertini, Marco and Schwaller, Philippe and Campi, Davide and Merkys, Andrius and Marrazzo, Antimo and Sohier, Thibault and Castelli, Ivano Eligio and Cepellotti, Andrea and Pizzi, Giovanni and others, Nat. Nanotechnol., 2018, 13, 246

Paper details

vlnc:W_vre5qy7m
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents