betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Residual Curvature and Wald Calibration in Autocorrelation-Based Timescale Estimation

Abstract

Autocorrelation-based timescale estimation often fits a single exponential to a finite sample autocorrelation vector, even when the underlying process is not autoregressive of order one. We examine the first-order uncertainty of this fixed-lag projection under model misspecification. Standard extremum-estimation arguments yield a sandwich variance whose denominator is the full population curvature, including a residual-second-derivative term omitted by a Gauss-Newton approximation. A conditional sign rule and two stationary Gaussian examples with exact standard-error ratios 14/13 and 13/15 show that omission can underestimate or overestimate uncertainty. Full-to-Gauss-Newton population standard-error ratios are 1.34 and 1.45 in two K=36 noise-mixture models and range from 0.38 to 1.37 across an evaluated published-process parameter grid. In a follow-up experiment with 24,000 synthetic series, empirical standard deviations in four Gaussian models are consistent with the full-curvature scale at the main sample length, whereas the Gauss-Newton scale is substantially too small in the two noise-mixture models. In all 4,000 observed replicates of the primary condition, full-curvature intervals contained their Gauss-Newton counterparts, constraining the observed coverage gain to be nonnegative. Fixed-bandwidth HAC targets a smoothed long-run variance, and full sample curvature can worsen finite-sample coverage in an exactly specified model. Bandwidth-specific results, directional coverage errors, and oracle comparisons separate curvature effects from long-run variance estimation and transformation effects. These findings identify an application-specific discrepancy in a published autocorrelation-domain variance formula and characterize its asymptotic and finite-sample consequences.

Introduction

Fitting an exponential curve to an autocorrelation function provides a low-dimensional description of temporal dependence. When the observed autocorrelation is not exactly exponential, the fitted parameter describes a projection of the autocorrelation sequence. Uncertainty quantification must therefore refer to this projection target, which may differ from a latent autoregressive coefficient. This distinction is relevant to autocorrelation-domain (AD) methods for estimating timescales from functional magnetic resonance imaging.

Riegner et al. [1] define a fixed-KK exponential-ACF projection and propose a sandwich variance with a Gauss–Newton denominator for inference under model misspecification. We examine the first-order variance of this AD estimator and the finite-sample behavior of the associated Wald intervals. The time-domain (TD) linear projection estimates a different target and has a different estimating-equation sensitivity.

Misspecification-robust inference based on the full criterion Hessian is established for independent, identically distributed observations [2 Theorem 3.3]. The asymptotic theory of nonlinear least squares with dependent observations is also established [3]. Joint asymptotic inference for sample autocorrelations under weak dependence is classical [4]. For the ACF projection considered here, the derivation combines a joint sample-moment limit with the effect of ACF normalization. The resulting score variance is a long-run variance, commonly estimated by a heteroskedasticity- and autocorrelation-consistent (HAC) procedure [5]. Curvature and long-run variance estimation are distinct determinants of interval calibration.

Applying standard implicit-function and delta-method arguments, we obtain the fixed-KK influence expansion and its full curvature. We establish a conditional rule for the direction of the Gauss–Newton discrepancy and construct stationary Gaussian counterexamples in both directions. A simulation study compares empirical sampling variability with the population first-order scales and examines feasible Wald coverage across bandwidths. Fixed-bandwidth limits, oracle substitutions, and directional miss probabilities distinguish the denominator discrepancy from other sources of miscalibration.

Fixed-lag autocorrelation projection

Let (Xt)t∈Z(X_t)_{t\in\mathbb{Z}} be stationary with mean μ\mu. Write Yt=Xt−μY_t = X_t-\mu, γk=E(YtYt−k)\gamma_k = \mathbb{E}(Y_tY_{t-k}), and ρk=γk/γ0\rho_k = \gamma_k/\gamma_0, where γ0>0\gamma_0 > 0. For a fixed integer K≥1K \ge1,

SK(p)=∑k=1K{ρk−mk(p)}2,mk(p)=pk,p⋆=arg min⁡p∈P SK(p),(1)S_K(p) = \sum_{k=1}^{K}\{\rho_k-m_k(p)\}^2,\qquad m_k(p)=p^k,\qquad p^\star=\underset{p\in\mathcal{P}}{\operatorname{arg\,min}}\ S_K(p), \tag*{(1)}

where P\mathcal{P} is a compact interval in (−1,1)(-1,1). This is a projection of the first KK autocorrelations, not necessarily a generating autoregressive coefficient. We omit the factor 1/K1/K in the published objective [1]; a common scaling of the objective cancels from a consistently normalized sandwich variance.

With XˉT=T−1∑t=1TXt\bar{X}_T=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}X_t, the biased sample ACF and estimator are

ρ^k=∑t=k+1T(Xt−XˉT)(Xt−k−XˉT)∑t=1T(Xt−XˉT)2,p^=arg min⁡p∈P∑k=1K(ρ^k−pk)2.(2)\widehat{\rho}_k=\frac{\sum_{t=k+1}^{T}(X_t-\bar{X}_T)(X_{t-k}-\bar{X}_T)}{\sum_{t=1}^{T}(X_t-\bar{X}_T)^2},\qquad\widehat{p}=\underset{p\in\mathcal{P}}{\operatorname{arg\,min}}\sum_{k=1}^{K}(\widehat{\rho}_k-p^k)^2. \tag*{(2)}

All lags share the variance denominator. Standardizing the centered series by its sample standard deviation does not change this ACF.

Regularity and exact curvature

The asymptotic analysis uses the following joint moment conditions.

Assumption 2.1 (Fixed-lag regularity). The process is strictly stationary and ergodic, E∣Y0∣4<∞\mathbb{E}|Y_0|^4 < \infty, γ0>0\gamma_0 > 0, and TYˉT=Op(1)\sqrt{T}\bar{Y}_T=O_p(1). For

Vt=(Yt2,YtYt−1,…,YtYt−K)T,v=EVt,V_t=(Y_t^2,Y_tY_{t-1},\ldots,Y_tY_{t-K})^\mathsf{T},\qquad v=\mathbb{E}V_t,

the entries of the covariance series are absolutely summable and

T−1/2∑t=1T(Vt−v)→dN(0,ΣV),ΣV=∑h∈ZCov⁡(Vt,Vt−h).(3)T^{-1/2}\sum_{t=1}^{T}(V_t-v)\xrightarrow{d}N(0,\Sigma_V),\qquad\Sigma_V=\sum_{h\in\mathbb{Z}}\operatorname{Cov}(V_t,V_{t-h}). \tag*{(3)}

The minimizer p⋆p^\star is unique and interior to P\mathcal{P}. The quantities AA and Ω\Omega below satisfy A>0A>0 and 0<Ω<∞0<\Omega<\infty.

The Gaussian autoregressive-plus-noise and moving-average examples below satisfy these conditions. Throughout the analysis, KK is fixed.

Set Rk=ρk−mk(p⋆)R_k=\rho_k-m_k(p^\star) and bk=mk′(p⋆)b_k=m_k'(p^\star). Then

G(p;ρ)=∑k=1Kmk′(p){ρk−mk(p)},G(p⋆;ρ)=0,(4)G(p;\rho)=\sum_{k=1}^{K}m_k'(p)\{\rho_k-m_k(p)\},\qquad G(p^\star;\rho)=0, \tag*{(4)}
A=−∂pG(p⋆;ρ)=∑k=1K{bk2−Rkmk′′(p⋆)},q=∑k=1Kbk2.(5)A=-\partial_pG(p^\star;\rho)=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\{b_k^2-R_km_k''(p^\star)\},\qquad q=\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k^2. \tag*{(5)}

Here S′′(p⋆)=2AS''(p^\star)=2A; qq is the Gauss–Newton curvature. Derivatives are polynomial derivatives, so m1′′(p)=0m_1''(p)=0, including at p=0p=0. The sample counterparts are

A^=∑k=1K[{mk′(p^)}2−{ρ^k−mk(p^)}mk′′(p^)],q^=∑k=1K{mk′(p^)}2.(6)\widehat{A}=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\left[\{m_k'(\widehat{p})\}^2-\{\widehat{\rho}_k-m_k(\widehat{p})\}m_k''(\widehat{p})\right],\qquad\widehat{q}=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\{m_k'(\widehat{p})\}^2. \tag*{(6)}

The residual-curvature term pairs the residual with m′′m''. The first-order condition pairs it with m′m', a different vector.

The following result follows from the joint sample-moment central limit theorem by the ratio delta method and an implicit-function expansion of G(p;ρ)=0G(p;\rho)=0.

Theorem 2.2 (Delta-method limit for fixed-lag ACF projection). Under Assumption 2.1, p^→pp⋆\widehat{p}\to_p p^\star and

T(p^−p⋆)=1AT∑t=1Tut+op(1)→dN(0,ΩA2),(7)\sqrt{T}(\widehat{p}-p^\star)=\frac{1}{A\sqrt{T}}\sum_{t=1}^{T}u_t+o_p(1)\xrightarrow{d}N\left(0,\frac{\Omega}{A^2}\right), \tag*{(7)}

where

ut=1γ0∑k=1Kbk{YtYt−k−(p⋆)kYt2},(8)u_t=\frac{1}{\gamma_0}\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k\{Y_tY_{t-k}-(p^\star)^kY_t^2\}, \tag*{(8)}
Ω=∑h∈ZCov⁡(ut,ut−h).(9)\Omega=\sum_{h\in\mathbb{Z}}\operatorname{Cov}(u_t,u_{t-h}). \tag*{(9)}

Moreover, A^→pA\widehat{A}\to_p A and q^→pq\widehat{q}\to_p q.

Proof. The finite-dimensional law of large numbers and compactness give uniform convergence of the objective and consistency. The ACF ratio expansion, including centering and fixed-lag boundary terms, gives

T(ρ^k−ρk)=1γ0T∑t=1T(YtYt−k−ρkYt2)+op(1).\sqrt{T}(\widehat{\rho}_k-\rho_k)=\frac{1}{\gamma_0\sqrt{T}}\sum_{t=1}^{T}(Y_tY_{t-k}-\rho_kY_t^2)+o_p(1).

Details are in Appendix § 12.§ 1. Expanding G(p^;ρ^)=0G(\widehat{p};\widehat{\rho})=0 at (p⋆,ρ)(p^\star,\rho) gives T(p^−p⋆)=A−1∑kbkT(ρ^k−ρk)+op(1)\sqrt{T}(\widehat{p}-p^\star)=A^{-1}\sum_k b_k\sqrt{T}(\widehat{\rho}_k-\rho_k)+o_p(1). The replacement of ρk\rho_k by (p⋆)k(p^\star)^k in the weighted score is exact because ∑kbkRk=0\sum_k b_kR_k=0. Equation (3) gives the limit, and continuity gives the two curvature limits. ▫

The variance has the full-Hessian sandwich form of misspecified extremum estimation [2 Theorem 3.3]. For this ACF projection, the preceding expansion accounts for normalization and serial dependence through the joint moment central limit theorem. With the same consistent long-run variance estimator,

sefullseGN⟶qA.(10)\frac{\mathrm{se}_{\mathrm{full}}}{\mathrm{se}_{\mathrm{GN}}} \longrightarrow\frac{q}{A}. \tag*{(10)}

The same consistency result gives q^/A^→pq/A\widehat{q}/\widehat{A} \to_{p} q/A. On regular samples with A^>0\widehat{A}>0 and a common positive score-variance estimate, q^/A^\widehat{q}/\widehat{A} is exactly the ratio of the two fitted standard errors, irrespective of the HAC bandwidth. The quantity Ω/T/A\sqrt{\Omega/T}/A gives a first-order standard-deviation approximation. Convergence of finite-sample second moments additionally requires uniform integrability.

Correct specification of the fitted KK-lag vector is sufficient for A=qA=q, but is not necessary in general. The exact condition is ∑kRkmk′′(p⋆)=0\sum_k R_k m_k^{\prime\prime}(p^\star)=0; nonzero residuals alone do not prove inequality. For K=1K=1, A=q=1A=q=1 for every admissible process. Appendix A.6 gives a valid K=3K=3 example with nonzero residuals and A=qA=q. Estimation of the shared variance denominator contributes the term −ρkYt2-\rho_k Y_t^2. The first-order condition converts the weighted sum of these terms to (8). The disagreement with the general AD variance expression in [1 Eq. 17] concerns the Gauss–Newton denominator when residual curvature is nonzero.

For p⋆≠0p^\star\ne0, g(p)=−1/log⁡∣p∣g(p)=-1/\log|p| is smooth near the target and

g′(p)=1p{log⁡∣p∣}2,T{g(p^)−g(p⋆)}⟶dN(0,g′(p⋆)2ΩA2).(11)g'(p)=\frac{1}{p\{\log|p|\}^2}, \qquad\sqrt{T}\{g(\widehat{p})-g(p^\star)\}\mathrel{\overset{d}{\longrightarrow}}N\left(0,\frac{g'(p^\star)^2\Omega}{A^2}\right). \tag*{(11)}

Multiplication by the sampling interval converts the target and standard errors to physical time units and preserves Wald coverage exactly. Finite-sample coverage may differ between the pp and g(p)g(p) scales because gg is nonlinear.

The implementation’s lagged-square score

The implementation-compatible population score is

vt=1γ0∑k=1Kbk{YtYt−k−(p⋆)kYt−k2}.(12)v_t=\frac{1}{\gamma_0}\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k\{Y_tY_{t-k}-(p^\star)^kY_{t-k}^2\}. \tag*{(12)}

Its difference from (8) is

vt−ut=1γ0∑k=1Kbk(p⋆)k(Yt2−Yt−k2).(13)v_t-u_t=\frac{1}{\gamma_0}\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k(p^\star)^k(Y_t^2-Y_{t-k}^2). \tag*{(13)}

For fixed KK, the time sum consists of finitely many boundary terms, so T−1/2∑t(vt−ut)=op(1)T^{-1/2}\sum_t(v_t-u_t)=o_p(1). Under absolute covariance summability the scores have the same long-run variance Ω\Omega. They can nevertheless have different lag-specific covariances and different finite-bandwidth Bartlett functionals. The bandwidth calculations use vtv_t.

Error direction and regular counterexamples

Proposition 3.1 (A conditional single-crossing rule). Suppose p⋆>0p^\star>0, A>0A>0, and the first-order condition holds. If, for some j∈{1,…,K−1}j\in\{1,\ldots,K-1\}, Rk≤0R_k\le0 for k≤jk\le j and Rk≥0R_k\ge0 for k>jk>j, then q≥Aq\ge A. The inequality is strict for a nonzero residual vector. Reversing the signs gives q≤Aq\le A, also strictly for a nonzero residual vector.

Proof. Since bk>0b_k > 0 and mk′′(p⋆)=(k−1)bk/p⋆m_k^{\prime\prime}(p^\star) = (k - 1)b_k/p^\star, the first-order condition gives, for any real c0c_0,

q−A=1p⋆∑k(k−1−c0)bkRk.q - A = \frac{1}{p^\star}\sum_k (k - 1 - c_0)b_kR_k.

Take c0=j−1/2c_0 = j - 1/2. Every term is nonnegative under the first sign pattern, with at least one positive term for a nonzero residual vector. Reverse the signs for the second assertion.

Application to an oscillatory process requires verification of the stated residual sign condition.

Consider the variance-one Gaussian observation-noise family

Xt=cZt+1−cεt,Zt=aZt−1+1−a2ηt,(14)X_t = \sqrt{c}Z_t + \sqrt{1-c}\varepsilon_t,\qquad Z_t = aZ_{t-1} + \sqrt{1-a^2}\eta_t, \tag*{(14)}

where 0<a<10 < a < 1, 0<c<10 < c < 1, the innovation sequences are independent standard normal white noises, and ZtZ_t is stationary. Then ρk=cak\rho_k = ca^k for k≥1k \ge1. For this family take P=[−r,r]\mathcal{P} = [-r,r] with a<r<1a < r < 1. At a regular interior minimizer with K≥2K \ge2, 0<p⋆<a0 < p^\star< a, and Rk/(p⋆)k=c(a/p⋆)k−1R_k/(p^\star)^k = c(a/p^\star)^k - 1 is strictly increasing in kk. The first-order condition forces both signs, giving A<qA < q by Proposition 3.1. Appendix A.4 gives the details and the sign-symmetry argument for negative aa.

With a=3/4a = 3/4, c=4/7c = 4/7, and K=2K = 2, the exact values are

p⋆=12,q=2,A=137,Ω=5296310976,qA=1413.(15)p^\star= \frac{1}{2},\quad q = 2,\quad A = \frac{13}{7},\quad\Omega= \frac{52963}{10976},\quad\frac{q}{A} = \frac{14}{13}. \tag*{(15)}

A counterexample in the opposite direction is the Gaussian MA(1) process

Xt=εt+θεt−11+θ2,θ=27−24522.(16)X_t = \frac{\varepsilon_t + \theta\varepsilon_{t-1}}{\sqrt{1+\theta^2}},\qquad\theta= \frac{27-\sqrt{245}}{22}. \tag*{(16)}

It has ρ1=11/27\rho_1 = 11/27 and ρk=0\rho_k = 0 for k≥2k \ge2. For K=2K = 2,

p⋆=13,q=139,A=53,Ω=1121518531441,qA=1315.(17)p^\star= \frac{1}{3},\quad q = \frac{13}{9},\quad A = \frac{5}{3},\quad\Omega= \frac{1121518}{531441},\quad\frac{q}{A} = \frac{13}{15}. \tag*{(17)}

Both examples define stationary Gaussian processes with unique regular interior projection minima and positive long-run variances. Exact calculations are given in Appendix A.3.

With an otherwise consistent long-run variance estimate, a nominal 95% GN Wald interval has limiting coverage

2Φ(z0.975Aq)−1.(18)2\Phi\left(z_{0.975}\frac{A}{q}\right)-1. \tag*{(18)}

The analytically calculated coverage limits are 93.1236% in (15) and 97.6271% in (17). Thus the first-order discrepancy can have either direction.

Fixed-bandwidth HAC and Wald coverage

Curvature and long-run variance estimation are separate parts of the sandwich. Let n=T−Kn = T - K, and let v^t\hat{v}_t, t=K+1,…,Tt = K + 1,\ldots,T, denote (12) evaluated at the sample estimates of p⋆p^\star, μ\mu, and γ0\gamma_0. For a fixed integer 0≤M<n0 \le M < n, the noncentered Bartlett estimator of the score-mean variance is

V^M=1n2{∑t=K+1Tv^t2+2∑h=1M(1−hM+1)∑t=K+1+hTv^tv^t−h}.(19)\widehat{V}_M = \frac{1}{n^2}\left\{\sum_{t=K+1}^{T}\hat{v}_t^2 + 2\sum_{h=1}^{M}\left(1-\frac{h}{M+1}\right)\sum_{t=K+1+h}^{T}\hat{v}_t\hat{v}_{t-h}\right\}. \tag*{(19)}

This retains the normalization and lagged-square score of the implementation. The full and GN standard errors on regular samples are respectively V^M/A^\sqrt{\widehat{V}_{M}/\widehat{A}} and V^M/q^\sqrt{\widehat{V}_{M}/\widehat{q}}. Let

cv(h)=Cov⁡(vt,vt−h),ΩM=cv(0)+2∑h=1M(1−hM+1)cv(h),rM=ΩMΩ.(20)c_v(h) = \operatorname{Cov}(v_t,v_{t-h}), \qquad\Omega_M = c_v(0) + 2\sum_{h=1}^{M}\left(1-\frac{h}{M+1}\right)c_v(h), \qquad r_M = \frac{\Omega_M}{\Omega}. \tag*{(20)}

At the population target Evt=0\mathbb{E}v_t = 0; the sample estimator nevertheless retains the original noncentered products.

Proposition 4.1 (Coverage with fixed KK and MM). Under Assumption 2.1, with fixed K,MK,M and ΩM>0\Omega_M > 0, nV^M→pΩMn\widehat{V}_M \xrightarrow{p} \Omega_M. The limiting coverages of the full and GN nominal 1−α1-\alpha normal Wald intervals are

Cfull(M)=2Φ(z^1−α/2rM)−1,(21)C_{\mathrm{full}}(M) = 2\Phi\left(\widehat{z}_{1-\alpha/2}\sqrt{r_M}\right)-1, \tag*{(21)}
CGN(M)=2Φ(z^1−α/2AqrM)−1.(22)C_{\mathrm{GN}}(M) = 2\Phi\left(\widehat{z}_{1-\alpha/2}\frac{A}{q}\sqrt{r_M}\right)-1. \tag*{(22)}

For p⋆≠0p^\star\ne0, the delta-method Wald intervals for g(p⋆)g(p^\star) have the same respective coverage limits.

Proof. For fixed K,hK,h, v^tv^t−h\widehat{v}_t\widehat{v}_{t-h} is a finite linear combination of products of up to four observations, with coefficients continuous in the consistent estimates of p⋆p^\star, μ\mu, and γ0>0\gamma_0 > 0. Ergodicity and the fourth-moment condition give convergence of the empirical averages to E(vtvt−h)=cv(h)\mathbb{E}(v_tv_{t-h}) = c_v(h). Omitting finitely many boundary terms has no effect. Summing over the fixed set h≤Mh \le M gives nV^M→pΩMn\widehat{V}_M \xrightarrow{p} \Omega_M. Because T/n→1T/n \to1, Slutsky’s theorem and Theorem 2.2 give both coverage limits. The smooth, nonzero derivative in (11) cancels in the limiting studentized statistic.

When rM<1r_M < 1, the limiting coverage of the full-Hessian interval remains below nominal. Standard HAC consistency regimes combine increasing bandwidth and a vanishing relative window with additional dependence, moment, and plug-in regularity conditions [5].

The results hold for fixed KK. Extending them to K=⌊T/100⌋K = \lfloor T/100\rfloor requires control of the changing projection target, score, and boundary terms. For fixed KK, Ω/(T−K)\Omega/(T-K) and Ω/T\Omega/T are first-order equivalent variance approximations.

Synthetic experiments and analysis conventions

Simulation design

The simulations comprised a pilot and a pilot-informed follow-up study, analyzed separately. Pilot A contains 16,000 unique Gaussian series: two models at K=2K = 2, T∈{500,2000,8000}T \in\{500, 2000, 8000\} with 2,000 repetitions per cell, followed by two K=36K = 36, T=3600T = 3600 cells with 2,000 repetitions each. For the K=36K = 36 cells, the same series were evaluated at M=5M = 5 and M=8M = 8.

The follow-up, denoted A2, contains 24,000 new series in eight cells. At K=36K = 36, T=3600T = 3600, four models each have R=4000R = 4000 repetitions: exact AR1 with coefficient 0.5; exact AR1 with coefficient 0.75; an AR1-plus-independent-noise mixture with (a,c)=(0.75,4/7)(a,c) = (0.75, 4/7); and a more persistent mixture with (a,c)=(0.9,4/7)(a,c) = (0.9, 4/7). The first and third models additionally have T=1000T = 1000 and T=10000T = 10000 cells with R=2000R = 2000 each. The mixture is

Xt=cZt+1−cεt,Var⁡(Zt)=Var⁡(εt)=1,Corr⁡(Zt,Zt−k)=ak.(23)X_t = \sqrt{c}Z_t + \sqrt{1-c}\varepsilon_t,\qquad\operatorname{Var}(Z_t) = \operatorname{Var}(\varepsilon_t) = 1,\qquad\operatorname{Corr}(Z_t,Z_{t-k}) = a^k. \tag*{(23)}

where ZtZ_t is a stationary Gaussian AR1 process and εt\varepsilon_t is independent Gaussian white noise. Initial states are drawn from the stationary distribution. The exact-0.75 control matches the latent persistence aa of the main mixture, not its projection parameter p∗p^*. The models isolate temporal dependence and observation noise under tractable Gaussian assumptions.

A2 used a pilot-informed design with an analysis plan recorded locally before execution; the study was not publicly preregistered. All specified cells, bandwidths, and arms are reported. The designated primary A2 comparison is full versus Gauss–Newton sample bread with the same HAC estimate, for ϕ=p\phi= p coverage in the (0.75,4/7)(0.75, 4/7), T=3600T = 3600, M=5M = 5 cell. The transformed timescale τ\tau is secondary. The subsequent variability, nesting, directional-miss, and source-process analyses were post hoc and used saved outputs or deterministic calculations.

Common fit and common HAC estimate

Each series is centered over its full length and standardized with the population-denominator sample variance (ddof=0). The sample ACF uses the full lag-zero sum in the denominator and the available lag-kk product sum in the numerator. We minimize the same unweighted ACF objective for all uncertainty calculations. The implementation enumerates numerically real stationary roots of its derivative polynomial and compares their objective values with those at the endpoints ±(1−10−10)\pm(1 - 10^{-10}). This optimizer differs from the constrained curve_fit routine in the public implementation identified in Appendix § 13.§ 3. At K=36K = 36 the derivative polynomial has degree 71.

Both bread choices use the same fitted parameter and the same lagged-square score convention as the public implementation. With n=T−Kn = T - K, fitted scores v^t\hat{v}_t on the common window, and bandwidth MM, the score-mean variance estimate is

V^M=1n2{∑t=1nv^t2+2∑h=1M(1−hM+1)∑t=h+1nv^tv^t−h}.(24)\hat{V}_M = \frac{1}{n^2}\left\{\sum_{t=1}^{n}\hat{v}_t^2 + 2\sum_{h=1}^{M}\left(1-\frac{h}{M+1}\right)\sum_{t=h+1}^{n}\hat{v}_t\hat{v}_{t-h}\right\}. \tag*{(24)}

Scores are not additionally demeaned. A2 evaluates M∈{5,8,16,32,64}M \in\{5, 8, 16, 32, 64\} on the same series. The primary bandwidth M=5M = 5 follows the public AD analysis notebook; M=8,16,32,64M = 8, 16, 32, 64 are prespecified sensitivity settings.

For every cell, we flag nonfinite values, curvature at or below 10−1010^{-10}, a stationary-equation residual of at least 10−710^{-7}, and fitted values within 10−610^{-6} of zero or either unit boundary. All-repetition coverage treats invalid replicates as noncoverage; valid-only coverage is also retained. No fit or HAC failures occurred in the evaluated cells.

Factorial diagnostics and endpoints

The eight A2 arms cross (i) bread form, qq or A; (ii) bread source, sample or population; and (iii) score-mean variance source, V^M\hat{V}_M or a population oracle. The primary A2 oracle convention is Ω/n\Omega/n, to match the score-window denominator, while Ω/T\Omega/T is retained as a sensitivity corresponding directly to the fixed-KK expansion. Both are first-order diagnostics, not the exact finite-sample variance of the fitted estimator. Oracle quantities require knowledge of the generating model and are not feasible competitors for practical use.

Parameter intervals are unclipped normal Wald intervals. Timescale intervals use τ^=−1/log⁡∣p^∣\hat{\tau} = -1/\log|\hat{p}| and the absolute delta-method derivative 1/(∣p^∣log⁡2∣p^∣)1/(|\hat{p}|\log^2|\hat{p}|). Coverage was evaluated separately for the parameter and timescale intervals. A marginal coverage estimate has a Wilson Monte Carlo (MC) interval; paired differences use the sample standard deviation of Dr=Ir,full−Ir,GND_r = I_{r,\mathrm{full}} - I_{r,\mathrm{GN}} divided by R\sqrt{R}. Factorial contrasts and interactions are evaluated on these shared indicators. Their changes are conditional substitution effects, not additive percentages of the error attributable to individual components. MC intervals are condition-specific and are not simultaneous inferential guarantees over all diagnostic cells.

Exploratory analyses

Post hoc analyses of the saved replicate outputs compared the empirical standard deviation of p^\hat{p} with Ω/T/A\sqrt{\Omega/T}/A and Ω/T/q\sqrt{\Omega/T}/q, alongside the existing nn convention. These comparisons use the population LRV and isolate the scale implication of the bread from HAC estimation. We also computed the fraction of nested intervals, the two directional miss probabilities, and correlations between estimates and standard errors. These correlations describe associations rather than causal effects; correlations involving a constant oracle standard error are undefined.

The observation-noise and stationary AR2 specifications in Riegner et al. [1] were additionally evaluated by deterministic AD projection at K=36K = 36 and 4848. The original experiments evaluated TD estimation. Calculations use the printed parameter values and report finite-KK sensitivity.

Results

Sampling variability and population first-order scales

Write sA,T=Ω/T/As_{A,T} = \sqrt{\Omega/T}/A and sq,T=Ω/T/qs_{q,T} = \sqrt{\Omega/T}/q. These are known-model reference scales, not fitted HAC standard errors. At T=3600T = 3600, empirical SD divided by sA,Ts_{A,T} ranges from 0.990 to 1.009 across the four models (Table 1 and Figure 1). In the exactly specified controls the two population scales coincide. In the noise mixtures, empirical SD is about 1.327 and 1.451 times the Gauss–Newton scale, respectively. These gaps are much larger than the approximately one-percent MC uncertainty of an SD estimate with R=4000R = 4000.

Process and lengthRREmpirical SDsA,Ts_{A,T}sq,Ts_{q,T}s/sA,Ts/s_{A,T}s/sq,Ts/s_{q,T}
AR1 (.5), T=3600T = 360040000.019760.019630.019631.0071.007
AR1 (.75), T=3600T = 360040000.018090.017920.017921.0091.009
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=3600T = 360040000.027480.027750.020710.9901.327
AR1 (.9)+noise, T=3600T = 360040000.024150.024140.016641.0011.451
AR1 (.5), T=1000T = 100020000.036240.037250.037250.9730.973
AR1 (.5), T=10000T = 1000020000.011680.011780.011780.9910.991
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=1000T = 100020000.052560.052650.039290.9981.338
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=10000T = 1000020000.016870.016650.012421.0131.358

Table 1. Empirical variability and population first-order scales, K=36K = 36. The TT convention follows the asymptotic expansion. All eight cells are shown. The comparison is exploratory.

Empirical standard deviation ratios for full-curvature and Gauss–Newton methods

Figure 1. Empirical SD divided by the full-curvature or Gauss–Newton population scale. The vertical line marks equality. Bars are ±1.96 estimated MC standard errors, obtained by a delta calculation using the fourth empirical central moment of the replicate estimates. The bars quantify Monte Carlo uncertainty in the empirical-SD ratios.

Across all eight cells the empirical/full ratios range from 0.973 to 1.013. The original A2 n=T−Kn = T - K convention is also tabulated in the appendix. Agreement in an SD summary does not establish normal tails or balanced two-sided calibration.

The designated coverage comparison and nesting

In the designated mixture cell with T=3600T = 3600, M=5M = 5, parameter coverage increased from 77.825% to 90.500% after replacing sample qq with sample AA. The paired difference is 12.675 percentage points (MC 95% interval [11.644, 13.706]). However, all 4,000 fitted ratios q^/A^\hat{q}/\hat{A} exceeded one: every full-curvature interval contained its Gauss–Newton counterpart. The gain is therefore structurally constrained to be nonnegative. This nesting limits the use of the coverage gain as evidence for the variance formula; the population-scale comparison evaluates that formula directly.

Full-curvature coverage remains below 95% (Wilson MC interval [89.552, 91.370]%). For the timescale endpoint the rates are 78.200% and 89.675%. The parameter and timescale intervals therefore have different finite-sample coverage.

Fixed-bandwidth limits and remaining discrepancies

The canonical mixture has Ω5/Ω=0.705390\Omega_5/\Omega= 0.705390. Its full-curvature fixed-MM coverage limit is 90.026%, whereas the additional Gauss–Newton denominator discrepancy gives 78.064% (Figure 2). Some undercoverage therefore persists when TT increases with MM fixed; it is not solely a finite-sample error. For M=5,8,16,32,64M = 5, 8, 16, 32, 64, the full-curvature limits are 90.026, 91.930, 93.552, 94.303, and 94.658%; the observed rates are 90.500, 91.825, 93.050, 93.650, and 93.625%. At larger bandwidths the observations remain below their limits. HAC variability, plug-in dependence, estimator bias, and nonnormality may contribute; these data do not identify a unique decomposition.

Coverage (%) versus Bartlett bandwidth $M$; legend: GN observed, GN fixed-$M$ limit, Full observed, Full fixed-$M$ limit

Figure 2. Parameter coverage in the canonical T=3600T = 3600 mixture and the fixed-KK, fixed-MM limits. Dashed colored lines are deterministic limits for the implementation-compatible lagged-square score; points and Wilson MC intervals use the same 4,000 series across all bandwidths. The gray line denotes 95%. Finite-sample departures from a limit are not attributed to a single cause by this comparison.

Conditional substitutions and directional misses

At the same sample AA, replacing HAC with Ω/n\Omega/n changes primary-cell parameter coverage from 90.500% to 94.900%. In contrast, replacing sample AA with population AA while retaining HAC changes it to 89.100%. Using both population AA and oracle variance gives 95.275%. These are conditional substitution effects, not additive error contributions. The 94.900% sample-AA/oracle rate masks misses of 4.700% below the lower endpoint and 0.400% above the upper endpoint (Table 2). A total near 95% need not imply balanced two-sided calibration. The estimate–SE correlations describe associated changes in interval width and location.

Bread / score varianceCoverageBelow lowerAbove uppercor(p^\hat{p}, SE)
Sample AA / HAC90.5004.0505.450-0.18
Population AA / HAC89.1000.40010.5000.94
Sample AA / oracle94.9004.7000.400-0.95
Population AA / oracle95.2751.8752.850–

Table 2. Exploratory directional-miss analysis in the canonical T=3600T = 3600, M=5M = 5 cell. Below lower means p∗p^* is below the lower endpoint; above upper means it is above the upper endpoint. Rates are percentages. Oracle uses Ω/n\Omega/n. A dash indicates an undefined correlation for a constant SE.

Adverse controls, longer series, and the timescale endpoint

Full sample curvature is not uniformly beneficial. For exact AR1(0.5) at T=1000T = 1000, K=36K = 36, M=5M = 5, parameter coverage decreases from 93.750% to 92.300%, a paired difference of −1.450 percentage points (MC interval [−2.174, −0.726]). At M=64M = 64 it decreases from

92.650% to 91.450%. Population A=qA = q here, but sample residual curvature is variable. These results are specific to K=36K = 36; the source package’s default K=⌊T/100⌋K = \lfloor T/100 \rfloor would give K=10K = 10 and was not evaluated in these cells.

Exact AR1⁡(0.75)\operatorname{AR1}(0.75) at T=3600T = 3600, M=5M = 5 also undercovers (88.225% GN and 87.800% full). Its population Ω5/Ω=0.658356\Omega_5/\Omega= 0.658356 shows a short-bandwidth limitation without a population breadth discrepancy. This does not attribute all finite-sample error to HAC. In the persistent mixture, full parameter coverage is 77.775% at M=5M = 5 and 92.250% at M=64M = 64.

For the canonical mixture at T=10000T = 10000, full M=64M = 64 coverage is 92.950%. Even population-AA/oracle-nn coverage is 93.900% (Wilson interval [92.765, 94.867]%), versus 93.850% using Ω/T\Omega/T. Across the eight cells, population-full/oracle-nn rates span 93.900–96.500%. These condition-specific MC intervals are unadjusted for comparisons across diagnostic cells. In the persistent mixture, population-full/oracle-nn coverage is 94.675% for pp but 91.850% for τ\tau, showing a further delta-Wald limitation.

AD projections of published process specifications

The noise process in Eq. (22) of Riegner et al. [1] has latent AR1 coefficient 0.8 and innovation variance one, giving latent variance 1/(1−0.82)1/(1 - 0.8^2). Added noise variance σ2\sigma^2 thus implies c=[1+(1−0.82)σ2]−1c = [1 + (1 - 0.8^2)\sigma^2]^{-1}.

For the stationary AR2 specifications with TD target 0.8, we use ϕ2=−r2\phi_2 = -r^2 and ϕ1=0.8(1+r2)\phi_1 = 0.8(1 + r^2), treating the printed radii as exact. The r=0.5r = 0.5 case is a critically damped repeated-root boundary; the other radii are oscillatory. The source article evaluated these process designs for TD estimation. Table 3 reports the corresponding deterministic AD projections. The positive-noise-variance cases have q/A>1q/A > 1, while the zero-noise control has q/A=1q/A = 1 and the evaluated AR2 grid has q/A<1q/A < 1. Several AR2 residual sequences change sign repeatedly, so the single-crossing lemma does not establish their direction. Their signs follow from direct curvature calculations. Similarly, numerical stability of q/Aq/A as KK increases is not a growing-KK proof.

ProcessParameterp48∗p^{*}_{48}q/Aq/A (K=36K = 36)q/Aq/A (K=48K = 48)GN limit (%)
Noise0.0000.800001.000001.0000095.000
Noise0.5000.767761.087821.0878392.841
Noise1.0000.734141.179601.1796090.340
Noise1.5000.699091.273941.2739487.607
Noise2.0000.662701.368211.3682184.800
AR20.5000.697380.883110.8831197.354
AR20.6420.618780.747590.7475999.125
AR20.7580.540640.597000.5970099.897
AR20.8590.471090.469460.4694699.997
AR20.9490.413600.376320.37632>99.999> 99.999

Table 3. Deterministic AD projection of published process specifications. Noise parameter: σ2\sigma^2; AR2 parameter: r=ϕ2r = \sqrt{\phi_2}. Printed values are treated as exact inputs. GN limits assume a consistent common LRV and use K=48K = 48; they are not finite-sample observations. K=36K = 36 and 48 values are close but not necessarily identical.

Discussion

Implications for autocorrelation-based inference

The full sensitivity of the fixed-KK ACF estimating equation includes a residual-curvature term. This standard component of misspecified extremum estimation can be consequential for the AD variance formula of Riegner et al. [1]. The stationary Gaussian examples demonstrate both underestimation and overestimation of the first-order standard error when the term is omitted. Exact specification is sufficient for A=qA = q; more generally, equality holds whenever the residual-curvature inner product vanishes. At K=1K = 1, equality holds for every admissible process. Under the fixed-KK assumptions, the fitted ratio q^/A^\hat{q}/\hat{A} consistently estimates the curvature contribution to the standard-error ratio. It does not assess long-run variance estimation or overall interval calibration, may be unstable when the fitted curvature is small, and cannot establish correct specification when it is near one.

The analytical examples and empirical-SD comparisons assess the first-order scale independently of HAC estimation. Wald coverage also depends on estimation of the standard error and the distribution of the studentized statistic. In all 4,000 observed replicates of the primary mixture condition, full-curvature intervals contained their Gauss–Newton counterparts: they shared the same center and HAC estimate and had larger fitted standard errors. This nesting constrained the observed coverage gain to be nonnegative. In the exact-model control, sample residual curvature can instead reduce coverage. Thus a correct population curvature does not ensure superior finite-sample performance for every plug-in interval.

Fixed-bandwidth HAC introduces a separate discrepancy because it targets ΩM\Omega_M. Consistent estimation of Ω\Omega requires a suitable increasing-bandwidth regime and additional regularity conditions. Evaluation of a practical interval procedure must therefore address bandwidth selection, sample-curvature variability, and the transformation to the timescale endpoint jointly. Comparisons with adaptive-bandwidth and bootstrap procedures would help assess finite-sample calibration beyond the fixed procedures considered here.

Limitations

The simulations use four Gaussian processes with tractable LRV and Bartlett calculations. Performance under non-Gaussianity, censoring, motion, hemodynamic convolution, nonstationarity, and spatial multiplicity remains unassessed. The study contains no analysis of empirical fMRI maps or downstream imaging conclusions. Its residual-curvature result concerns the nonlinear AD projection; the TD linear projection has a different sensitivity.

All asymptotic results assume fixed KK. The source package’s default K=⌊T/100⌋K = \lfloor T/100 \rfloor requires additional control of boundary terms, normalization, and the changing projection target. Stability of the computed population ratios does not establish that extension. The deterministic AR2 results apply to the specified parameter grid and cannot be generalized to all damped oscillatory processes.

The follow-up design was informed by a pilot, and the variability, directional-miss, and source-process analyses were conducted post hoc. These diagnostics are exploratory. Raw simulated series and lag-specific sample ACF vectors were not retained; the independent computational audit therefore validates aggregation of saved replicate outputs rather than regenerating the underlying series.

Conclusion

For fixed-lag exponential-ACF projection, residual curvature is part of the estimating-equation sensitivity. Omitting it can shift a Gauss–Newton standard error above or below the correct first-order scale. Full-curvature substitution resolves this denominator discrepancy, while bandwidth estimation, finite-sample studentization, and the nonlinear timescale transformation remain determinants of Wald calibration.

Data and code availability

The companion archive (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24283730) contains the pilot and follow-up analysis plans, code, configurations, saved replicate outputs, and SHA-256 manifests. The follow-up simulations used Python 3.12.14, NumPy 2.3.5, PCG64 with disjoint cell-specific streams, and single-threaded BLAS settings. The seed was 20261116015702 and the batch size was 128; the configuration specifies the generation order. All data are synthetic.

Independent reaggregation of the saved outputs agreed with all 18,911 numerical summaries to within 8.89×10−168.89 \times10^{-16}. Raw simulated series and lag-specific sample ACF vectors are unavailable.

Declaration of generative AI use

GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI) assisted with study design, code development and implementation, and review. Claude Fable 5.2 (Anthropic) assisted with independent review, comparison with source texts and public code, mathematical derivations, and numerical cross-checking. The author takes responsibility for the scientific claims and final content of the manuscript.

Acknowledgments and funding

The author acknowledges OpenAI for providing complimentary access to ChatGPT through the ChatGPT for Academic Researchers program. No other funding was received for this work.

Competing interests

The author received the complimentary access described above and declares no other competing interests.

Moment expansion and Gaussian calculations

Centering, boundary terms, and the ACF ratio

Define

γ~k=T−1∑t=1TYtYt−k,γ^k=T−1∑t=k+1T(Yt−YˉT)(Yt−k−YˉT),1≤k≤K,\tilde{\gamma}_k = T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}Y_tY_{t-k}, \qquad\hat{\gamma}_k = T^{-1}\sum_{t=k+1}^{T}(Y_t-\bar{Y}_T)(Y_{t-k}-\bar{Y}_T), \qquad1 \leq k \leq K,

and γ^0=T−1∑t=1T(Yt−YˉT)2\hat{\gamma}_0=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}(Y_t-\bar{Y}_T)^2. The stationary extension to unobserved negative times introduces finitely many boundary products, whose sum is Op(1)O_p(1). For fixed kk, each truncated sample mean differs from YˉT\bar{Y}_T by Op(T−1)O_p(T^{-1}). The assumption YˉT=Op(T−1/2)\bar{Y}_T=O_p(T^{-1/2}) therefore yields

γ^k−γ~k=Op(T−1),k=0,…,K.\hat{\gamma}_k-\tilde{\gamma}_k=O_p(T^{-1}), \qquad k=0,\ldots,K.

For k=0k=0 the difference is exactly −YˉT2-\bar{Y}_T^2. The delta method for ρ^k=γ^k/γ^0\hat{\rho}_k=\hat{\gamma}_k/\hat{\gamma}_0 then gives

T(ρ^k−ρk)=γ0−1T{(γ~k−γk)−ρk(γ~0−γ0)}+op(1).\sqrt{T}(\hat{\rho}_k-\rho_k)=\gamma_0^{-1}\sqrt{T}\{(\tilde{\gamma}_k-\gamma_k)-\rho_k(\tilde{\gamma}_0-\gamma_0)\}+o_p(1).

In matrix notation the ACF covariance limit is

Σρ=DΣVDT,D=γ0−1[−ρ  IK],Ω=bTΣρb,\Sigma_\rho=D\Sigma_VD^{\mathsf T}, \qquad D=\gamma_0^{-1}[-\rho\ \ I_K], \qquad\Omega=b^{\mathsf T}\Sigma_\rho b,

where ρ=(ρ1,…,ρK)T\rho=(\rho_1,\ldots,\rho_K)^{\mathsf T} and b=(b1,…,bK)Tb=(b_1,\ldots,b_K)^{\mathsf T}. This ratio delta-method representation accounts for both autocovariance and variance estimation and is consistent with the classical treatment of sample autocorrelations under weak dependence [4]. The covariance ΣV\Sigma_V retains the fourth-order dependence of the process; a covariance-only Gaussian formula requires the additional Gaussian structure used below.

Consistency puts the sample minimizer in the interior with probability tending to one. The ordinary first-order condition then applies. A numerical approximation can be treated by the same argument if its score residual is op(T−1/2)o_p(T^{-1/2}) and it selects the consistent minimizer; numerical diagnostics in a finite run do not by themselves prove this asymptotic property.

Long-run variance of a Gaussian quadratic score

For a mean-zero stationary Gaussian process, set

b0=−∑k=1Kbk(p⋆)k,C(d)=∑h∈Zγhγh+d.b_0=-\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k(p^\star)^k, \qquad C(d)=\sum_{h\in\mathbb{Z}}\gamma_h\gamma_{h+d}.

Whenever the sums are absolutely convergent, Gaussian fourth-moment factorization applied to ut=γ0−1∑k=0KbkYtYt−ku_t=\gamma_0^{-1}\sum_{k=0}^{K}b_kY_tY_{t-k} gives

Ω=1γ02∑j=0K∑k=0Kbjbk{C(k−j)+C(k+j)}.(25)\Omega=\frac{1}{\gamma_0^2}\sum_{j=0}^{K}\sum_{k=0}^{K}b_jb_k\{C(k-j)+C(k+j)\}. \tag*{(25)}

Indeed,

Cov⁡(Y0Y−j,Y−hY−h−k)=γhγh+k−j+γh+kγh−j,\operatorname{Cov}(Y_0Y_{-j},Y_{-h}Y_{-h-k})=\gamma_h\gamma_{h+k-j}+\gamma_{h+k}\gamma_{h-j},

and summing over hh yields the two convolutions in (25). The expectation term cancels from the covariance.

For (14), γ0=1\gamma_0=1 and γh=ca∣h∣+(1−c)1{h=0}\gamma_h=ca^{|h|}+(1-c)1_{\{h=0\}}. For 0<a<10<a<1,

C(d)=c2a∣d∣(∣d∣+1+2a21−a2)+2c(1−c)a∣d∣+(1−c)21{d=0}.(26)C(d)=c^2a^{|d|}\left(|d|+1+\frac{2a^2}{1-a^2}\right)+2c(1-c)a^{|d|}+(1-c)^2 1_{\{d=0\}}. \tag*{(26)}

The first term follows by separating hh between the two endpoints from the two geometric tails; the other terms arise from the white-noise contribution at zero lag.

An alternative positivity check is useful for stable Gaussian autoregressive models. Under the convention γh=∫−ππeihωf(ω) dω\gamma_h=\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}e^{ih\omega}f(\omega)\,\mathrm{d}\omega, Parseval’s identity in (25) gives

Ω=4πγ02∫−ππ{b0+∑k=1Kbkcos⁡(kω)}2f(ω)2 dω.(27)\Omega=\frac{4\pi}{\gamma_0^2}\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\left\{b_0+\sum_{k=1}^{K}b_k\cos(k\omega)\right\}^2f(\omega)^2\,\mathrm{d}\omega. \tag*{(27)}

For a stable Gaussian AR(2) with positive innovation variance, f(ω)>0f(\omega)>0. The trigonometric polynomial is not identically zero, because its coefficient of cos⁡(ω)\cos(\omega) is b1=1b_1=1. Thus Ω>0\Omega>0. This argument establishes positivity, not numerical uniqueness of a projection minimizer or its curvature sign.

Exact counterexamples

For (14) with a=3/4a=3/4, c=4/7c=4/7, and K=2K=2, ρ1=3/7\rho_1=3/7 and ρ2=9/28\rho_2=9/28. The half derivative of the objective is

12S2′(p)=2p3+514p−37.\frac{1}{2}S_2'(p)=2p^3+\frac{5}{14}p-\frac{3}{7}.

Its derivative 6p2+5/146p^2+5/14 is strictly positive for every real pp. The half derivative vanishes at p=1/2p=1/2, so this is the unique global minimizer whenever the parameter interval contains it in its interior. The residuals are R1=−1/14R_1=-1/14 and R2=1/14R_2=1/14, giving q=2q=2 and A=13/7A=13/7. Substitution of b0=−3/4b_0=-3/4, b1=b2=1b_1=b_2=1 in (25)–(26) gives Ω=52963/10976>0\Omega=52963/10976>0. The process is a measurable function of a stationary Gaussian AR(1) state and independent Gaussian white noise. It has geometric mixing, moments of every order, and the finite-dimensional moment CLT used above. No boundary or zero-timescale singularity is involved. For the correctly specified AR(1) control with a=1/2a=1/2, c=1c=1, K=2K=2, the corresponding values are p⋆=1/2p^\star=1/2, q=A=2q=A=2, and Ω=57/16\Omega=57/16.

For (16), 0<θ<10<\theta<1 and θ/(1+θ2)=11/27=:r\theta/(1+\theta^2)=11/27=:r. The process has unit variance and is 1-dependent. Its objective is

S2(p)=(r−p)2+p4,12S2′(p)=p+2p3−r,12S2′′(p)=1+6p2>0.S_2(p)=(r-p)^2+p^4,\qquad\frac{1}{2}S_2'(p)=p+2p^3-r,\qquad\frac{1}{2}S_2''(p)=1+6p^2>0.

Since r=1/3+2/27r=1/3+2/27, the unique global minimum is p⋆=1/3p^\star=1/3, with q=13/9q=13/9 and A=5/3A=5/3. Here

C(0)=1+2r2=971729,C(1)=2r=2227,C(2)=r2=121729,C(d)=0(∣d∣≥3).C(0)=1+2r^2=\frac{971}{729},\qquad C(1)=2r=\frac{22}{27},\qquad C(2)=r^2=\frac{121}{729},\qquad C(d)=0\quad(|d|\ge3).

Using b0=−11/27b_0=-11/27, b1=1b_1=1, and b2=2/3b_2=2/3 in (25) yields Ω=1121518/531441>0\Omega=1121518/531441>0. Finite dependence and Gaussian moments verify the probabilistic input. Both counterexamples therefore satisfy regularity independently of a finite-sample optimizer or a HAC bandwidth choice.

Direction within the observation-noise family

Take P=[−r,r]\mathcal{P}=[-r,r] with a<r<1a<r<1 in (14). Replacing a negative pp by ∣p∣|p| strictly reduces the odd-lag squared residuals and leaves the even-lag terms unchanged, so a global minimizer is nonnegative. Moreover, G(0;p)=ca>0G(0;p)=ca>0, and G(p;p)<0G(p;p)<0 for p≥ap\ge a. A regular interior minimizer must therefore satisfy 0<p⋆<a0<p^\star<a. The sequence

hk=Rk(p⋆)k=c(a/p⋆)k−1h_k=\frac{R_k}{(p^\star)^k}=c(a/p^\star)^k-1

is strictly increasing. Since the first-order condition can be written ∑kk(p⋆)2k−1hk=0\sum_k k(p^\star)^{2k-1}h_k=0 with positive weights, its nonzero entries have the negative-to-positive sign pattern. The strict conclusion A<qA<q follows from Proposition 3.1. This argument does not claim uniqueness for every parameter choice; regularity is retained as a condition. For a<0a<0, simultaneous replacement of (a,p)(a,p) by (−a,−p)(-a,-p) preserves the objective and both curvatures on a symmetric parameter interval. Changing the sign of aa therefore does not by itself reverse the SE ratio within this family.

Population Bartlett and finite-window expectations

Let Wt=(Yt,Yt−1,…,Yt−K)TW_t=(Y_t,Y_{t-1},\ldots,Y_{t-K})^\mathsf{T} and define a symmetric matrix HH by

H0k=Hk0=bk/2,Hkk=−bk(p⋆)k(1≤k≤K),H00=0,H_{0k}=H_{k0}=b_k/2,\qquad H_{kk}=-b_k(p^\star)^k\quad(1\le k\le K),\qquad H_{00}=0,

with all other entries zero. Then vt=γ0−1WtTHWtv_t=\gamma_0^{-1}W_t^\mathsf{T}HW_t. If (Γh)ij=γh+j−i(\Gamma_h)_{ij}=\gamma_{h+j-i}, Gaussian quadratic-form covariance gives

cv(h)=2γ02tr⁡(HΓhHΓhT).(28)c_v(h)=\frac{2}{\gamma_0^2}\operatorname{tr}(H\Gamma_hH\Gamma_h^\mathsf{T}). \tag*{(28)}

It can also be checked by expanding each product bkYtYt−k−bk(p⋆)kYt−k2b_kY_tY_{t-k}-b_k(p^\star)^kY_{t-k}^2 and using the fourth-moment identity term by term.

For example, the lagged-square score in the MA(1) counterexample has

H=(01/21/31/2−1/301/30−2/27)H=\begin{pmatrix}0&1/2&1/3\\1/2&-1/3&0\\1/3&0&-2/27\end{pmatrix}

and exact covariances

cv(0)=10112059049,cv(1)=133439531441,cv(2)=−308059049,cv(h)=0(h≥3).c_v(0)=\frac{101120}{59049},\qquad c_v(1)=\frac{133439}{531441},\qquad c_v(2)=-\frac{3080}{59049},\qquad c_v(h)=0\quad(h\ge3).

Their bilateral sum equals 1121518/5314411121518/531441, agreeing with the current-square calculation despite different individual covariances.

Let VM0V_M^0 denote (19) calculated from the population score rather than a fitted score. Because Evt=0Ev_t=0,

nEVM0=cv(0)+2∑h=1M(1−hM+1)(1−hn)cv(h).(29)nEV_M^0=c_v(0)+2\sum_{h=1}^{M}\left(1-\frac{h}{M+1}\right)\left(1-\frac{h}{n}\right)c_v(h). \tag*{(29)}

This finite-window identity is exact for known p⋆p^\star, μ\mu, and γ0\gamma_0. It is not an exact expectation formula for the fitted, centered, standardized score used in a finite sample. The limit ΩM\Omega_M in Proposition 4.1 is nevertheless the same under its assumptions. This distinction separates an asymptotic fixed-bandwidth discrepancy from additional plug-in and finite-sample effects.

Equality of the curvatures without an exact fit

The sufficiency-versus-necessity distinction following Theorem 2.2 can be illustrated by a valid ACF. Start with a unit-variance AR(1) spectrum with coefficient 1/21/2, and add

tπ{34cos⁡ω−32cos⁡(2ω)+cos⁡(3ω)},t=1100.\frac{t}{\pi}\left\{\frac{3}{4}\cos\omega-\frac{3}{2}\cos(2\omega)+\cos(3\omega)\right\}, \qquad t=\frac{1}{100}.

The original spectral density is bounded below by 1/(6π)1/(6\pi), whereas the perturbation has absolute value at most 13t/(4π)13t/(4\pi). The resulting spectral density is strictly positive and integrates to one, so it defines a stationary Gaussian process. Its first three autocorrelations are (1/2,1/4,1/8)+t(3/4,−3/2,1)(1/2,1/4,1/8)+t(3/4,-3/2,1), and the remaining autocorrelations are unchanged. For K=3K=3 and P\mathcal{P} containing 1/21/2 in its interior,

S3(p)−S3(1/2)=(p−1/2)2{1+(p+1/2)2+(p2+p/2+1/4)2−2t(p−1/2)}.S_3(p)-S_3(1/2)=(p-1/2)^2\left\{1+(p+1/2)^2+(p^2+p/2+1/4)^2-2t(p-1/2)\right\}.

The expression in braces is positive for p∈(−1,1)p\in(-1,1). Thus p⋆=1/2p^\star=1/2 is the unique minimizer, but its residual vector t(3/4,−3/2,1)t(3/4,-3/2,1) is nonzero and orthogonal to both m′(p⋆)m'(p^\star) and m′′(p⋆)m''(p^\star). Consequently A=q=41/16A=q=41/16. This construction demonstrates that nonzero projection residuals are compatible with A=qA=q.

Complete numerical reporting and computation

The following tables present all specified A2 bandwidth results for the two feasible sample-bread procedures, the full primary-cell factorial comparison, and both population-full oracle conventions. The machine-readable summaries additionally retain all eight arms, paired contrasts, and interactions in every cell. Oracle arms repeat across MM because they do not use an estimated HAC bandwidth. Pilot results were analyzed separately and were not pooled with A2.

BreadScore-mean variancepp coverage (%)τ\tau coverage (%)
Sample qqHAC77.82578.200
Sample qqΩ/n\Omega/n87.37587.000
Population qqHAC79.32580.200
Population qqΩ/n\Omega/n86.72585.875
Sample AAHAC90.50089.675
Sample AAΩ/n\Omega/n94.90095.400
Population AAHAC89.10087.975
Population AAΩ/n\Omega/n95.27594.850

Table 4. Primary-cell factorial coverage, K=36K=36, T=3600T=3600, M=5M=5. Every row uses the same fitted parameter and 4,000 series. Population quantities are diagnostic substitutions.

Cellp: Ω/np:\ \Omega/np: Ω/Tp:\ \Omega/Tτ: Ω/n\tau:\ \Omega/nτ: Ω/T\tau:\ \Omega/T
C05-360094.92594.75094.85094.825
C075-360094.57594.47593.95093.850
N075-360095.27595.22594.85094.825
N09-360094.67594.50091.85091.775
C05-100096.50096.00095.35095.100
C05-1000095.85095.85095.45095.400
N075-100095.15094.65092.85092.700
N075-1000093.90093.85093.95093.850

Table 5. Population-full oracle coverage under the n=T−Kn = T - K and TT conventions (percent). Cell abbreviations are defined in Table 7. Neither oracle is an exact finite-sample sampling variance.

CellMMGN ppFull ppGN τ\tauFull τ\tauΔp\Delta p [MC 95%]
C05-3600592.82593.17593.20092.8500.350 [-0.010, 0.710]
C05-3600893.55093.67593.60093.4750.125 [-0.211, 0.461]
C05-36001694.02594.05094.02593.8250.025 [-0.318, 0.368]
C05-36003294.17594.05094.22594.000-0.125 [-0.482, 0.232]
C05-36006494.07593.67594.02593.925-0.400 [-0.804, 0.004]
C075-3600588.22587.80087.70087.600-0.425 [-0.927, 0.077]
C075-3600890.72590.37590.10089.650-0.350 [-0.850, 0.150]
C075-36001692.40092.00091.67591.425-0.400 [-0.865, 0.065]
C075-36003293.12592.67592.32592.150-0.450 [-0.888, -0.012]
C075-36006493.22593.02592.67592.025-0.200 [-0.627, 0.227]
N075-3600577.82590.50078.20089.67512.675 [11.644, 13.706]
N075-3600880.70091.82581.05091.37511.125 [10.150, 12.100]
N075-36001683.37593.05083.37592.8759.675 [8.759, 10.591]
N075-36003284.75093.65083.97593.4008.900 [8.017, 9.783]
N075-36006484.72593.62584.07593.4008.900 [8.017, 9.783]
N09-3600560.17577.77559.35076.90017.600 [16.420, 18.780]
N09-3600865.85082.72565.47582.12516.875 [15.714, 18.036]
N09-36001673.07588.85072.57586.90015.775 [14.645, 16.905]
N09-36003277.07591.57576.60089.62514.500 [13.409, 15.591]
N09-36006478.27592.25078.47590.42513.975 [12.900, 15.050]
C05-1000593.75092.30093.00091.600-1.450 [-2.174, -0.726]
C05-1000893.90093.00093.30091.850-0.900 [-1.578, -0.222]
C05-10001693.85093.05093.55092.200-0.800 [-1.546, -0.054]
C05-10003293.70092.90093.20091.850-0.800 [-1.533, -0.067]
C05-10006492.65091.45092.30090.950-1.200 [-1.891, -0.509]
C05-10000593.90094.30094.15094.1000.400 [0.091, 0.709]
C05-10000894.65094.55094.65094.450-0.100 [-0.410, 0.210]
C05-100001695.10094.95094.75094.800-0.150 [-0.503, 0.203]
C05-100003295.30095.00095.00095.250-0.300 [-0.667, 0.067]
C05-100006495.00095.25095.15095.2500.250 [-0.103, 0.603]
N075-1000577.50088.85076.55087.15011.350 [9.959, 12.741]
N075-1000879.50090.35078.95088.50010.850 [9.487, 12.213]
N075-10001681.10091.50080.90089.60010.400 [9.062, 11.738]
N075-10003282.00091.25080.95089.7009.250 [7.980, 10.520]
N075-10006481.45090.25080.15089.3008.800 [7.558, 10.042]
N075-10000577.95089.25077.60089.15011.300 [9.912, 12.688]
N075-10000880.55091.05080.10091.00010.500 [9.156, 11.844]
N075-100001682.80092.35082.55092.4009.550 [8.262, 10.838]
N075-100003283.75093.05084.10092.9009.300 [8.027, 10.573]
N075-100006484.50092.95084.10093.1008.450 [7.231, 9.669]

Table 7. All A2 bandwidth results. Rates are percentages. C05 and C075 are exact AR1 controls; N075 and N09 are noise mixtures with c=4/7c = 4/7. The number after the model code is TT. Each T=3600T = 3600 cell has R=4000R = 4000; other cells have R=2000R = 2000. All rows within a cell share the same series.

Process and lengthsA,ns_{A,n}sq,ns_{q,n}s/sA,ns/s_{A,n}s/sq,ns/s_{q,n}
AR1 (.5), T=3600T = 36000.019730.019731.0021.002
AR1 (.75), T=3600T = 36000.018010.018011.0041.004
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=3600T = 36000.027890.020810.9851.320
AR1 (.9)+noise, T=3600T = 36000.024260.016730.9961.444
AR1 (.5), T=1000T = 10000.037940.037940.9550.955
AR1 (.5), T=10000T = 100000.011800.011800.9900.990
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=1000T = 10000.053630.040010.9801.314
AR1 (.75)+noise, T=10000T = 100000.016680.012451.0111.356

Table 6. Empirical SD versus population scales using the original A2A2 nn convention. Compare with Table 1, which uses TT.

Monte Carlo uncertainty of an empirical standard deviation

For independent replicate estimates P1,…,PRP_1,\ldots,P_R, let ss be their empirical SD and vr=(Pr−Pˉ)2v_r = (P_r-\bar{P})^2. The post hoc SD error bars use the delta approximation

MCSE⁡^(s)=sd⁡(v1,…,vR)2sR.(30)\widehat{\operatorname{MCSE}}(s)=\frac{\operatorname{sd}(v_1,\ldots,v_R)}{2s\sqrt{R}}. \tag*{(30)}

For a ratio to a known population scale, this MCSE is divided by that scale. This large-RR approximation uses the empirical fourth moment. The normal-theory relative MCSE [2(R−1)]−1/2[2(R - 1)]^{-1/2} provides a reference value; the displayed error bars use the empirical-moment calculation.

Deterministic source-design calculations

Population targets were computed from the stated ACF and the same fixed-KK objective. Numerical validation combined enumeration of real stationary roots and endpoints, a dense grid, high-precision root refinement, and finite-difference curvature estimates. These calculations apply to the evaluated parameter grid.

For the source AR2 specification, the ACF starts at ρ0=1\rho_0 = 1, ρ1=0.8\rho_1 = 0.8 and satisfies ρk=ϕ1ρk−1+ϕ2ρk−2\rho_k = \phi_1\rho_{k-1} + \phi_2\rho_{k-2}. The printed radii 0.5, 0.642, 0.758, 0.859, 0.949 were treated as exact. Residual sign-change counts were computed to assess the applicability of the single-crossing condition.

Reference implementation

The comparison uses the public AD implementation at commit

cd0072ee3b42f271e49de3682d5f7a41bb9070d2

of the griegner/fmri-timescales repository (accessed 16 November 2026). At this commit, acf_utils.py centers and standardizes each series with a variance divisor of TT, computes lag products by convolution, and divides each lag sum by TT. For finite, nonconstant inputs, this gives the biased ACF in (2). The AD routine in timescale_utils.py uses the lagged-square score and normalization described in § 5. The original article’s execution commit is unknown.

References

  1. [1]Riegner G, Davenport S, Voytek B, Schwartzman A. Estimating fMRI timescale maps. Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2026;4:IMAG.a.1248. doi: 10.1162/IMAG.a.1248.DOI
  2. [2]White H. Consequences and detection of misspecified nonlinear regression models. J Am Stat Assoc. 1981;76(374):419-33. doi: 10.1080/01621459.1981.10477663.DOI
  3. [3]White H, Domowitz I. Nonlinear regression with dependent observations. Econometrica. 1984;52(1):143-62. doi: 10.2307/1911465.DOI
  4. [4]Romano JP, Thombs LA. Inference for autocorrelations under weak assumptions. J Am Stat Assoc. 1996;91(434):590-600. doi: 10.1080/01621459.1996.10476928.DOI
  5. [5]Newey WK, West KD. A simple, positive semi-definite, heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix. Econometrica. 1987;55(3):703-8. doi: 10.2307/1913610.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vs4jz9ug
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

GPT-6 Astra, Claude Fable 5.2

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents