WorksMathematics
Koszul duality for boundary categories
Abstract
We study how Koszul duality relates two kinds of boundary constructions associated with a smooth category and a proper category. For a smooth category with a proper Koszul-dualizing subcategory, we construct a fully faithful functor from its categorical neighborhood of infinity to the singularity category associated to the proper category. We prove that this functor is an equivalence precisely when the smooth category is reflexive, meaning that it can be reconstructed from its finite-dimensional module theory. Under a Gorenstein condition, satisfied in the Calabi–Yau setting, the functor is induced by restriction of modules. We give algebraic criteria that ensure equivalence and obtain an identification of Hochschild cohomology.
Introduction
Background and motivation
Singularity categories measure the failure of coherent complexes to be perfect and thereby make singularities accessible to homological algebra [18]. Efimov’s categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity provides a way to study behavior at infinity directly from a category, without choosing a compactification [Efi17]. A relation between these constructions allows boundary phenomena in smooth geometry to be studied through the singularities of a proper algebraic model. Koszul duality suggests such a relation because, under suitable hypotheses, it exchanges perfect modules with modules having finite-dimensional cohomology. To turn this principle into a comparison of boundary categories, one must identify the subcategories being divided out and determine when the comparison recovers every object of the target. These are the two questions addressed in this paper.
The motivation is also particularly concrete in symplectic geometry. Ganatra–Gao–Venkatesh identify the Rabinowitz Fukaya category of a nondegenerate Liouville manifold with the categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity of its wrapped Fukaya category [GGV22, Theorem 1.1]. When compact Lagrangians supply an appropriate Koszul dual, a comparison with a singularity category offers an algebraic description of this Rabinowitz category. The essential-surjectivity question asks whether every object of the singularity category comes from the categorical boundary, so that this algebraic description is an equivalence.
Several earlier results establish the foundations of this comparison. Efimov relates categorical infinity to singularity categories arising from localizations of smooth proper dg categories [Efi17, Theorem 3.2]. For a proper scheme over a perfect field, he identifies the categorical formal punctured neighborhood of its dg category of bounded coherent complexes with the opposite of its singularity category [Efi17, Theorem 9.2]. His Proposition 9.3 gives a quotient description of infinity under categorical Koszul-duality hypotheses. Ganatra–Gao–Venkatesh formulate these hypotheses in terms of a proper Koszul-dualizing subcategory and identify the quotient by right-proper objects with the categorical formal punctured neighborhood [GGV22, Definition 2.12 and {xref}Proposition 2.13]. We use this quotient description to compare the boundary with the singularity category of the Koszul dual.
At the level of modules, the exchange of finiteness conditions is a familiar feature of Koszul duality. For Adams connected algebras with proper Koszul dual, Lu–Palmieri–Wu–Zhang prove an equivalence between perfect modules on one side and modules with finite-dimensional total cohomology on the other [LPWZ08, Theorem B and {xref}Corollary 7.2(b)]. The question of reconstructing a category from its pseudo-perfect modules is expressed more generally by *reflexivity*, introduced by Kuznetsov–Shinder {citep}[KS25, Definition 3.11]. Goodbody characterizes reflexivity in the Morita homotopy category and studies its consequences for Hochschild cohomology {citep}[Goo26, Theorems 4.4 and 5.1]. Booth–Goodbody–Opper develop its relationship with Koszul duality, generation, and completion, and establish criteria for connective and coconnective dg algebras {citep}[BGO25, Theorem 2.3.8 and § 3]`. These results provide the reconstruction property and the algebraic criteria used below.
Calabi–Yau structures give a further reason to compare the two boundaries. Brav–Dyckerhoff transfer a smooth Calabi–Yau structure to the subcategory of proper objects [BD19, Theorem 3.1], while Gao’s categorical residue produces a duality of dimension one less on the categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity [Gao25, Theorem 1.7]. Rivera–Takeda–Wang study the associated products on Hochschild complexes with boundary coefficients using pre-Calabi–Yau structures [19]. In his Oberwolfach report, Takeda conjectures compatibility of the products and duality structures appearing in Rabinowitz Floer theory, categorical infinity, and singular Hochschild cohomology under the relevant identifications [23 p. 3165], which leads to the general form of the following conjecture:
Conjecture 1.1. Let be a proper Koszul dualizing subcategory in a smooth -category . Then there is an isomorphism of rings:
The main purpose of this paper is to address the categorical identification needed for this perspective and give consequences for Hochschild invariants.
Main results
Fix a field . All starting categories are small and -linear, and we use dg module categories, passing to dg models for strictly unital categories when forming quotients. All tensor products and module Hom functors are computed in these models. For a category , write for its dg category of right modules, for the full subcategory of perfect modules, and for the full subcategory of pseudo-perfect modules, whose values are perfect -complexes. Smoothness gives , while properness gives the reverse inclusion. For proper , the dg singularity category is
Let be a Koszul-dualizing full inclusion in the sense of Definition 4.1, with smooth and proper. In particular, the graph bimodule is perfect over at every pair of objects. Writing for linear duality, define
For a perfect module , its value at is , where is the right Yoneda module. Equivalently,
where the rightmost functor is perfect-module duality and is restriction of left modules.
We will need the notion of reflexivity. The category is reflexive if the canonical evaluation functor
is a quasi-equivalence; see Definition 4.4 for further details. Write for the categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity of , using the essential-image construction of Definition 5.1. Under the present hypotheses, it is quasi-equivalent to by Proposition 5.2.
Theorem A. Let be smooth and let be a Koszul-dualizing full inclusion, with proper. The functor in (1) is quasi-fully faithful. Its composite with linear duality induces a quasi-fully faithful functor
The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) The functor (3) is a quasi-equivalence.
(ii) The functor is a quasi-equivalence.
(iii) The category is reflexive.
If also satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12), its Nakayama functor , where is the dual diagonal bimodule, is an autoequivalence of \operatorname{PsPerf}(\mathcal{B})$, and
on .
Restriction is then quasi-fully faithful on and induces a quasi-fully faithful functor
This functor is a quasi-equivalence precisely when (i)–(iii) hold. These conditions are also equivalent to coinduction, the right adjoint of , restricting to a quasi-equivalence
with quasi-inverse .
The proof separates reconstruction from passage to the quotient. Efimov’s generation result identifies with ; under this identification, the factorization (2) expresses through the evaluation functor defining reflexivity. For the quotients, sends to the Nakayama image , which linear duality identifies with . This determines the target in (3). The essential image of is thick, so quotienting by the corresponding full subcategories preserves and detects essential surjectivity, by Lemma 2.8. The Gorenstein condition identifies the Nakayama image with and gives the restriction functor in (4).
A weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure on identifies with . It therefore implies the Gorenstein condition and gives , so that . Combining Theorem A with the reflexivity criteria of Booth–Goodbody–Opper yields the following consequence. The degreewise finiteness required by those criteria follows from the Koszul-duality hypotheses: the tensor–Hom map in Definition 4.1(iii) is a biduality map, as in (54), and condition (ii) transfers this finiteness to morphisms between perfect -modules.
Corollary B. Let be smooth and let be a Koszul-dualizing full inclusion. Suppose that carries a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure and that has a split-generator whose dg endomorphism algebra satisfies either
or
Then restriction induces a quasi-equivalence
Moreover, and restrict to mutually inverse quasi-equivalences between and .
If itself carries a weak smooth -Calabi–Yau structure, Theorem 3.5 gives the weak proper structure on . When is reflexive, Theorem 5.5 transports Gao’s categorical residue through the restriction quasi-equivalence and equips with a weak generalized proper -Calabi–Yau structure in the sense of Remark 3.3. Corollary 7.2 gives the corresponding isomorphisms of Hochschild cohomology algebras, preserving cup products.
Structure of the paper
Structure of the paper. In Section 2, we recall module categories, the Nakayama functor, and the properties of dg quotients used below. In Section 3, we review weak smooth and weak proper Calabi–Yau structures and their relation to the Gorenstein condition. In Section 4, we prove that the comparison functor is quasi-fully faithful and characterize its essential surjectivity by reflexivity. In Section 5, we recall the two boundary constructions and prove Theorem A and its Calabi–Yau refinement, Theorem 5.5. In Section 6, we give algebraic criteria for the comparison to be a quasi-equivalence, apply them to Koszul duals of proper algebras, and discuss geometric examples. In Section 7, we deduce comparisons of Hochschild cohomology algebras and relate them to singular Hochschild cohomology under Keller’s hypotheses.
Acknowledgments
Acknowledgments. We thank Alex Takeda for sharing his inspiring perspective, and Zhengfang Wang for helpful discussion, especially for suggesting the reflexivity property for consideration.
Categorical preliminaries
We recall the finiteness conditions, duality functors, and properties of dg quotients. All starting categories are small (except for module categories) and -linear, complexes are cohomologically graded, and modules are right modules unless otherwise specified. Tensor products and Hom functors are derived. We use the standard module and Morita theory of dg and strictly unital categories; see [4, 5, 24, 20].
Basic definitions
Definition 2.1. Let be a small dg or strictly unital category.
is the dg category of right -modules, defined as the dg category of dg or functors .
is the split-closed pretriangulated envelope of the right Yoneda modules . Equivalently, it is the full subcategory of compact objects of , i.e. .
is the full subcategory of modules for which is a perfect -complex for every . Such modules are called or pseudo-perfect or proper.
An object is right proper if its right Yoneda module is proper. The full subcategory of right-proper objects is denoted .
There are following quasi-equivalences of module categories:
Remark 2.2. For a strictly unital category, the Yoneda embedding gives an quasi-equivalence from to the full dg subcategory of on its representable modules [20 Sections 2f–2g]. We use these dg models when forming tensor products of dg categories and Drinfeld quotients.
Set , and use the diagonal convention
Thus the diagonal bimodule is a right -module, covariant in and contravariant in .
Definition 2.3. The category is smooth if . It is proper if for all , or equivalently if . Over the field , the latter condition means that each morphism complex has finite-dimensional total cohomology.
The following elementary facts relate these finiteness conditions and will also be used to check preservation of pseudo-perfect modules.
Lemma 2.4. A module is pseudo-perfect if and only if for every . Moreover,
Proof. The first assertion follows from and closure of under finite cones and direct summands. If is proper, its right Yoneda modules are pseudo-perfect, and the same closure argument gives the first inclusion. If is smooth, tensor a finite resolution of from representable bimodules with a pseudo-perfect module . Since
is perfect, so is .
The Nakayama functor
The dual diagonal bimodule is defined to be . The Nakayama functor is
For , tensor–Hom duality gives
Its right adjoint is
Suppose now that is proper, and put
This is the image of the perfect modules under the Nakayama functor, which we will show in Lemma 2.7. We also recall the following definition.
Definition 2.5. A proper category satisfies the Gorenstein condition if
as full subcategories of . For proper dg algebras, this is the condition of [1 Definition 5.2].
Remark 2.6. For an ordinary finite-dimensional algebra , one has , where denotes the finitely generated injective right modules. Gorenstein condition (12) is equivalent to finite injective dimension of both regular modules and ; see [Che11, Corollary 3.9] and [1 Remark 5.3].
Lemma 2.7. If is proper, the Nakayama functor restricts to a quasi-equivalence
For and , there is a natural quasi-isomorphism
If satisfies the Gorenstein condition, then is a Serre functor on and an autoequivalence of preserving . Its inverse is .
Proof. On perfect modules, is the composite of the dualities in (7), using the inclusion since is proper. It is therefore quasi-fully faithful. Since it sends to and its source is idempotent complete, its essential image is precisely . For representable , (13) is the tensor–Hom adjunction
the general case follows by finite cones and direct summands.
Under (12), this gives a Serre autoequivalence of . The bar tensor functor preserves direct sums and cones and induces a quasi-equivalence on the compact objects, so its colimit-preserving extension gives an autoequivalence of [5 Lemma 3.10]. By Lemma 2.4, pseudo-perfectness is characterized by perfectness over of the Hom complexes from all perfect modules. This condition is preserved by and its inverse, proving the last assertion. □
Drinfeld quotient
Let be a full dg subcategory. The dg quotient is a dg category equipped with a functor
that annihilates and is universal with this property in the homotopy category of dg categories [Dri04, Theorem 1.6.2], [5 Theorem 4.8]. More precisely, precomposition with identifies morphisms in with morphisms that send every object of to a contractible object. Over the field , a concrete model has the same objects as and freely adjoins, for each , an endomorphism of degree with [Dri04, Section 3.1]. Its morphism complexes admit the description
where the arrow is induced by composition [Dri04, Section 1.3.1].
If and are pretriangulated, then is pretriangulated and there is an equivalence of triangulated categories
with the Verdier quotient [Dri04, Theorem 3.4]. In particular,
by [Dri04, Remark A.3(ii)] or [8 Proposition 4.6.2(3)]. Consequently, replacing by its thick closure inside gives a quasi-equivalent dg quotient. Quasi-equivalences of dg pairs also induce quasi-equivalences of their quotients [Dri04, Remark 3.6(ii)]. For categories, one may use dg models or the quotient constructions of [17, 16].
The following lemma shows that quotienting by a common subcategory preserves full faithfulness and, under a thickness hypothesis, detects essential surjectivity; see [Dri04, Lemma A.5], [8 Proposition 4.6.2, Lemma 4.7.1] for the arguments for triangulated categories.
Lemma 2.8. Let be full pretriangulated dg subcategories. The induced functor
is quasi-fully faithful. If is thick in , then is essentially surjective if and only if the inclusion is essentially surjective.
Proof. For , the cone descriptions (14) in and agree because both inclusions are full. Thus is quasi-fully faithful.
Suppose that is thick in . The quotient factors through . By the kernel description above, an object represented by vanishes in precisely when is isomorphic in to an object of . Hence
If is essentially surjective, every object of therefore belongs to up to isomorphism. Conversely, essential surjectivity of passes to the quotients, which have the same objects as their respective source categories. □
Remark 2.9. Under the thickness hypothesis of Lemma 2.8, the kernel as in (15) shows that the essential image of is thick. A quasi-fully faithful functor between pretriangulated dg categories is a Morita equivalence precisely when its image generates the target under shifts, cones, and direct summands [5 Lemma 3.10]. Thus is a Morita equivalence if and only if it is a quasi-equivalence.
Calabi–Yau structures
We recall weak smooth and weak proper Calabi–Yau structures, which will be used in Theorem 5.5 and Corollary B, respectively. Lemma 3.4 shows that a weak proper Calabi–Yau structure implies the Gorenstein condition (12) required in Theorem A for the functor (4).
Write for the Hochschild chain complex with diagonal coefficients, computed by the cyclic bar construction, and set
We regard as a cochain complex; the chain maps defining Calabi–Yau structures have degree zero. Thus a class in is represented by a chain map . For the cyclic bar construction, see [Gao25, Section 2.4].
The definition of a weak smooth Calabi–Yau structure uses the inverse dualizing bimodule , the -linear dual of , regarded as a right -module by exchanging the factors of . Explicitly,
The tensor product in the second argument is the bimodule whose value at is . If is smooth, perfect duality for gives a natural quasi-isomorphism
see [BD19, Section 3.2] and [Gan23, Remark 6.7].
Definition 3.1. Suppose that is smooth. A weak smooth -Calabi–Yau structure is a class , represented by
for which the bimodule morphism corresponding under (16) is a quasi-isomorphism
See [Gan23, Definition 6.5 and Remark 6.7].
The tensor–Hom adjunction gives a natural quasi-isomorphism
where the right-hand side is the morphism complex in ; see [BD19, Section 3.1] and [Gan23, Remark 6.2].
Definition 3.2. Suppose that is proper. A weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure is a chain map, called a Hochschild trace,
taken up to chain homotopy, for which the bimodule morphism corresponding under (19) is a quasi-isomorphism
For a trace as in (20), this quasi-isomorphism condition is equivalent to requiring that composition followed by the trace on length-zero Hochschild chains induce perfect pairings
for every and ; see [Gan23, Definition 6.1 and Remark 6.2].
Remark 3.3. In Definition 3.2, one can drop the a priori condition of properness on . The perfect pairing, induced by the Hochschild trace (20) which determines the bimodule quasi-isomorphism (21) via the derived tensor–Hom adjunction
implies the finiteness of Hom spaces on homology level at each degree
(whereas the total dimension of homology can nevertheless be infinite), and this means is a locally proper dg or category. In this spirit, we refer to this milder notion as weak (absolute) locally proper Calabi–Yau structure on ; this is also named a componentwise proper Calabi–Yau structure by Keller–Wang. There is an even weaker notion in [Gao25, Definition 2.27], obtained by requiring that the pairings (22) be nondegenerate rather than perfect. The corresponding bimodule morphism is then injective on cohomology, with no surjectivity requirement, and the morphism cohomology groups may be infinite-dimensional in each degree. We call such a structure a weak generalized proper -Calabi–Yau structure.
The next lemma verifies the Gorenstein hypothesis of Theorem A for the category in Corollary B.
Lemma 3.4. If carries a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure, then on . In particular, satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12), and the Serre functor on is the shift .
Proof. The quasi-isomorphism (21) gives . Substituting this identification into the definition (9) of the Nakayama functor yields
By Lemma 2.7, the essential image of on is . Since is an autoequivalence of , we obtain . The Serre duality for is (13) restricted to perfect modules. ∎
We also recall the transfer from weak smooth to weak proper Calabi–Yau structures underlying [BD19, Theorem 3.1], which will be used in Theorem 5.5.
Theorem 3.5 ([BD19, Theorem 3.1]). Let be a smooth dg or strictly unital category. A weak smooth -Calabi–Yau structure on , in the sense of Definition 3.1, induces a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure on , and hence on every full subcategory of .
For a Koszul-dualizing inclusion , condition (i) in Definition 4.1 says that every is right proper in . A weak smooth -Calabi–Yau structure on in the sense of Definition 3.1 therefore induces a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure on by Theorem 3.5. Lemma 3.4 then verifies the Gorenstein hypothesis in Proposition 4.3 and Theorem A.
Koszul duality and reflexivity
In this section, we prove that the functor in (1), for a Koszul-dualizing inclusion , is quasi-fully faithful, and furthermore that it is essentially surjective precisely when is reflexive. Under the Gorenstein condition (12), we also identify with and obtain the restriction and coinduction functors appearing in Theorem A.
Koszul-dualizing inclusions
Let be a full inclusion. The standard induction, restriction, and coinduction functors satisfy
see [5 Section 3.8]. With the right-module convention of § 2, these take the following explicit forms:
where , , and as in the introduction. Thus induction uses the left -module , whereas coinduction uses the right -module . Fullness of implies that the unit and the counit are quasi-isomorphisms. In particular, and are quasi-fully faithful.
We recall the notion of a Koszul-dualizing subcategory from [GGV22, Definition 2.12], based on the hypotheses of [Efi17, Proposition 9.3].
Definition 4.1. Suppose that is smooth and is proper. A full inclusion is Koszul-dualizing if the following conditions hold:
(i) Each is right proper in , in the sense of Definition 2.1; equivalently, for every and .
(ii) Restriction of left modules is quasi-fully faithful on perfect modules:
(iii) For , evaluation of module morphisms induces a quasi-isomorphism
Condition (i) ensures that the target in (25) is well defined. For the same reason, the formula
defines a pseudo-perfect right -module. By the dualities (7) and (8), condition (ii) makes the functor of (2) quasi-fully faithful.
Lemma 4.2. Let be Koszul-dualizing. Induction and restriction give mutually inverse quasi-equivalences
Consequently,
and restricts to a quasi-equivalence
where is defined in (11).
Proof. By Definition 4.1(i), is pseudo-perfect, and fullness of makes quasi-fully faithful. Conditions (ii)–(iii) give the remaining hypotheses of [Efi17, Proposition 9.3], whose categorical proof applies over any field. It follows that is a quasi-equivalence, with quasi-inverse by (23). Since , the generation statement (29) follows.
By fullness of and (27),
Since is quasi-fully faithful, (29) identifies its essential image on with the thick subcategory generated by these modules, which is as defined in (11).
Relation to the Nakayama functor
The Gorenstein condition allows us to recover restriction from by the inverse Nakayama functor. This identifies the additional functors in Theorem A without changing the essential-surjectivity question.
Proposition 4.3. Let be Koszul-dualizing, and suppose that satisfies (12). There is a natural quasi-isomorphism
In particular, restriction gives a quasi-fully faithful functor
whose restriction to is the quasi-inverse of in (28). The functor is essentially surjective if and only if coinduction restricts to a quasi-equivalence
When these conditions hold, and are mutually inverse on these subcategories.
Proof. For and , quasi-full faithfulness of , (31), and the adjunction give
These identifications are natural in and , so . By Lemma 2.7, the Gorenstein condition makes an autoequivalence of with inverse , and both functors preserve . This proves (32) and quasi-full faithfulness of on . Its assertion on pseudo-perfect modules is (28).
Since restricts to an autoequivalence of , (32) shows that is essentially surjective precisely when is. For , the unit is a quasi-isomorphism: at , this follows from
If is essentially surjective, every has the form up to quasi-isomorphism, and hence is perfect. The adjunction therefore restricts to the quasi-equivalences asserted in (33). Conversely, if (33) holds, then for every pseudo-perfect by fullness of , proving essential surjectivity of and of . □
Reflexivity
To characterize essential surjectivity of , we relate it to the notion of reflexivity in the sense of [BGO25, Definition 2.1.1 and Remark 2.1.5(2)]. For a small dg or strictly unital category , Lemma 2.4 ensures that the evaluation functor
is well defined.
Definition 4.4. The category is reflexive if (34) is a quasi-equivalence, and semireflexive if it is quasi-fully faithful.
Reflexivity is Morita invariant [2 Proposition 3.8] and invariant under passage to the opposite category [BGO25, Remark 2.1.5(1)]. For categories, we use the dg models fixed in Section 2; the induced equivalences of module categories identify their evaluation functors.
Proposition 4.5. Let be Koszul-dualizing. Then is semireflexive, and the functor in (1) is essentially surjective if and only if is reflexive.
Proof. By Lemma 4.2, the functor
is a Morita equivalence. Restriction along therefore induces a quasi-equivalence
see [2 Proposition 3.5]. For , the composite takes the value
It is thus naturally identified with
The first arrow is the duality (7), and the second is quasi-fully faithful by Definition 4.1(ii). Together with (35), this proves that is quasi-fully faithful. Moreover, is essentially surjective precisely when (36) is. Taking the opposite of (36) and applying the linear duality (8) gives , as in (2). These dualities preserve essential surjectivity, proving the assertion. □
Boundary categories and Koszul duality
We describe the two quotient categories in Theorem A, then use the results of Section 4 to construct the comparison functor and characterize when it is a quasi-equivalence. We also prove Theorem 5.5 by transporting the categorical residue through this equivalence. The final subsection recalls a trace on the singularity category obtained from Hochschild localization.
Categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity
The -linear Calkin dg category is the Drinfeld quotient
see [Efi17, Proposition 1.1] or [GGV22, Section 2.2]. For a small dg or strictly unital category , composition with gives the Calkin-valued Yoneda functor
Here denotes the dg category of strictly unital functors and natural transformations, which models the homotopy internal Hom; see [Efi17, Section 1 and Proposition 3.6] and [GGV22, Sections 2.1 and 2.3].
Definition 5.1. The categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity of is the full essential image
We use the full essential image before pretriangulated or idempotent completion, as in [Efi17, Definition 3.3(3)].
Since annihilates precisely the perfect -complexes, an object satisfies
where right-proper objects are defined in Definition 2.1; see also [GGV22, Lemma 2.8]. When is smooth, the right-proper objects of are exactly by Lemma 2.4; compare [Efi17, Proposition 4.1]. Under the Koszul-duality hypotheses, the functor induced on the corresponding quotient is a quasi-equivalence.
Proposition 5.2 ([Efi17, Proposition 9.3],[GGV22, Proposition 2.13]). Let be smooth and let be Koszul-dualizing in the sense of Definition 4.1. The Calkin-valued Yoneda functor induces quasi-equivalences
and
The induced functor is a Morita equivalence.
Singularity category
Let be a proper dg or strictly unital category, so that by Lemma 2.4. We use the dg version of the singularity category recalled in [Efi17, Section 2.1]. In that reference, local properness is the properness condition of Definition 2.3.
Definition 5.3. The dg singularity category of is the Drinfeld quotient
Its homotopy category is the Verdier quotient
by [Dri04, Theorem 3.4]. Since is thick in , the quotient vanishes precisely when every pseudo-perfect -module is perfect. In particular, it vanishes when is smooth, by Lemma 2.4.
For a Koszul-dualizing inclusion , the comparison functor sends to by (30). The following consequence of linear duality identifies the quotient by this subcategory.
Proof. The duality (8) identifies with . It sends each generator of to the representable left module , since is proper. It therefore identifies with and induces (41) on dg quotients. Pointwise double duality gives the inverse. □
If satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12), then , so Lemma 5.4 gives a linear-duality quasi-equivalence . For a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure, Lemma 3.4 further gives . Composing linear duality with this inverse Nakayama functor gives the normalization
Comparison under Koszul duality
We now apply to the quotient presentations (39) and (41) to prove Theorem A.
Proof of Theorem A. By Definition 4.1(ii) and the factorization (2), the functor is quasi-fully faithful. Lemma 4.2 identifies its restriction to pseudo-perfect modules with a quasi-equivalence
Thus, after identifying with the full essential image of , we have full pretriangulated subcategories
The essential image is thick on homotopy categories: exactness and full faithfulness give closure under shifts and cones, while idempotents lift to and split there. Lemma 2.8 therefore gives a quasi-fully faithful functor on the corresponding dg quotients. Using Proposition 5.2 and Lemma 5.4, we obtain
where is induced by . The composite is the functor (3).
The same application of Lemma 2.8 shows that is essentially surjective if and only if is, proving (i) (ii). Proposition 4.5 identifies essential surjectivity of with reflexivity of , giving (ii) (iii).
Suppose now that satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12). Then , and Lemma 2.7 makes an autoequivalence of preserving both and . Proposition 4.3 gives
Hence is quasi-fully faithful, and (28) identifies its restriction to with a quasi-equivalence onto . On the dg quotients, the functor induced by is therefore followed by the autoequivalence induced by . This proves the assertions about (4).
Finally, Proposition 4.3 identifies condition (ii) with the assertion that restricts to the quasi-equivalence (33), with quasi-inverse .
We next use the restriction functor of Theorem A to transport the categorical residue of [Gao25, Theorem 1.7] to the singularity category.
Theorem 5.5. Suppose that carries a weak smooth -Calabi–Yau structure and is reflexive, and let be a Koszul-dualizing full inclusion. Restriction induces a quasi-equivalence
The categorical residue transports through this quasi-equivalence to a weak generalized proper -Calabi–Yau structure on , in the sense of Remark 3.3.
Proof. Condition (i) in Definition 4.1 places in . Theorem 3.5 therefore gives a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure on . By Lemma 3.4, the category satisfies the Gorenstein condition and . Since is reflexive, Theorem A gives the quasi-equivalence (44). Moreover, by (32), so composing (3) with the duality (42) gives this same restriction functor: double duality recovers , and the shift cancels its Nakayama shift. The weak smooth structure extends to by Morita invariance. By [Gao25, Theorem 1.7 and equation (3.67)], it determines a residue trace
whose pairings on morphism cohomology are nondegenerate. The quasi-isomorphism identifies homotopy classes of traces by precomposition. There is therefore a unique homotopy class of traces on whose pullback is the class of (45). Its pairings are nondegenerate because identifies morphism cohomology and composition. This gives the asserted weak generalized proper Calabi–Yau structure. □
For a proper scheme over a perfect field , let denote the dg category of complexes with bounded coherent cohomology and let be its dualizing complex. Efimov’s geometric comparison is
see [Efi17, Theorem 9.2 and Proposition B.1] and [Gao25, Section 4]. The denominator is the full essential image of tensoring perfect complexes with , and the second quasi-equivalence is induced by Grothendieck–Verdier duality. For Gorenstein , the denominator is ; if moreover has dimension and , then [Gao25, Theorem 1.6] gives the corresponding weak generalized proper -Calabi–Yau structure on . In characteristic zero, the chosen trivialization supplies the weak smooth structure on by [BD19, Section 5.2 and Proposition 5.12].
Traces on the singularity category
For a proper category with a weak proper -Calabi–Yau structure, Hochschild localization gives a trace directly on . We recall this construction and the finiteness condition under which its pairings are perfect. By Morita invariance, regard the trace (20) as a trace on . Localization for Hochschild chains gives an exact triangle
see [5 Theorem 5.2(a)]. Thus the induced trace is the composite
The following nondegeneracy statement is a specialization of [3 Theorem 4.3.1(b)].
Theorem 5.6. Let carry a weak proper -Calabi--Yau structure, and suppose that
Then the trace (48) induces a bimodule quasi-isomorphism
It therefore defines a weak locally proper -Calabi--Yau structure in the sense of Remark 3.3.
Proof. Put and . Condition (49) makes the canonical map a quasi-isomorphism. Moreover, the restricted Yoneda functor
is quasi-fully faithful, since it is the restriction of the quasi-equivalence of dg module categories induced by . These verify the two hypotheses of [3 Theorem 4.3.1(b)] for . Apply that theorem with the shifted diagonal , corresponding to the shift autoequivalence in its notation. The weak proper Calabi--Yau structure gives , and the theorem identifies its image under the connecting morphism with a quasi-isomorphism
Shifting by gives the assertion. □
The finiteness hypothesis (49) cannot be omitted from this general statement.
Example 5.7. Let have objects , , with concentrated in degree zero. It is proper, and the trace
defines a weak proper -Calabi--Yau structure. A pseudo-perfect module is a sequence of perfect -complexes; it is perfect over precisely when only finitely many components are nonzero up to quasi-isomorphism. Thus is pseudo-perfect, and (14) gives
Its cohomology is concentrated in degree zero, where it is the nonzero vector space . A weak generalized proper -Calabi--Yau structure would give a nondegenerate pairing between and . Hence no such structure exists.
Algebraic criteria
We express the hypotheses of Theorem A in terms of endomorphism algebras, prove Corollary B, and apply the comparison to Koszul duals of proper algebras. We use the dg module models fixed in Section 2, and write Hom for their morphism complexes. For an algebra , the category consists of modules with finite-dimensional total cohomology.
Split generators and endomorphism algebras
Let be a full inclusion, with smooth and proper. Choose split-generators and , and put
Smoothness supplies by [Efi10, Lemma 2.5]; the existence of is an additional assumption. The Morita equivalences induced by and identify with
where is an –-bimodule with action ; see [5 Section 3].
Proposition 6.1. Assume that each is right proper in , as in Definition 4.1(i). Then takes values in , and it is quasi-fully faithful if and only if its action morphism
is a quasi-isomorphism. In this case its essential image, under the preceding Morita equivalence, is .
Suppose that (51) is a quasi-isomorphism. If
then is essentially surjective and hence a quasi-equivalence. If, moreover,
then is Koszul-dualizing and is reflexive.
Proof. The right-properness assumption and (27) imply that takes values in . The map (51) is the map on endomorphism complexes of the generator . Closure under shifts, finite cones, and direct summands in both variables shows that is quasi-fully faithful precisely when this map is a quasi-isomorphism. In that case its essential image is . By (2), quasi-full faithfulness of is equivalent to condition (ii) of Definition 4.1.
Assume that (51) is a quasi-isomorphism and that (52) holds. The description of the essential image then shows that is essentially surjective. Thus it induces a quasi-equivalence
Assume in addition (53). Closure under shifts, finite cones, and direct summands extends degreewise finiteness from to all morphism complexes in . The preceding quasi-equivalence and linear duality therefore imply this finiteness for all morphism complexes in . For , tensor–Hom adjunction gives
Under this identification, the map (26) is the canonical biduality map for . Degreewise finiteness makes this map a quasi-isomorphism, proving condition (iii). Condition (i) holds by assumption, and condition (ii) follows from quasi-full faithfulness of . Hence is Koszul-dualizing. Since is essentially surjective, Proposition 4.5 now implies that is reflexive. □
The following reflexivity criteria supply the two cases in Corollary B.
Proposition 6.2. ([BG025, Corollaries 3.4.3, 3.3.2, 3.3.6]). A algebra , or a strictly unital algebra through its model, is reflexive in either of the following cases:
(i) and for every ;
(ii) , is semisimple, and either is proper, or is smooth with for every .
Now we are ready to prove Corollary B.
Proof of Corollary B. Apply Proposition 6.1, Proposition 6.2, Morita invariance [2 Proposition 3.8] and Theorem A. □
To check the generation condition in (52), let , with standard idempotents , and put . A strictly unital minimal algebra over is positive if and ; projection to is an augmentation [22 Section 4.2].
Proposition 6.3. One has in either of the following cases:
(i) is augmented over , , is finite-dimensional, and its augmentation identifies with ;
(ii) is positive.
In either case, a module whose cohomology is as a graded -module is quasi-isomorphic to the corresponding shifted augmentation module.
Proof. Case (i) follows by truncation and composition series over [BGO25, Proposition 2.2.2 and Corollary 2.2.3]. Case (ii) and the assertion about module structures are [22 Lemmas 4.2–4.3]. □
Consequently, once (51) is a quasi-isomorphism, essential surjectivity is equivalent to in these cases. For example, suppose and , with corresponding to . Writing , formula (27) gives
If is as a graded -module and every index occurs among the , Proposition 6.3 gives
Koszul duals of proper algebras
The following proposition identifies the subcategory that must be divided out when starting from the other direction of the Koszul duality functor.
Proposition 6.4. Let be proper and let split-generate . Suppose that is smooth and for every . Then is reflexive, and the quasi-equivalence identifies the following pairs of dg categories:
Its inverse is , and it induces quasi-equivalences
If satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12), the first quotient is identified with .
Proof. Since split-generates , the functor is a quasi-equivalence with quasi-inverse . Tensor–Hom adjunction gives
Consequently, the identification of subcategories in (56) reduces to proving
We establish this equality and reflexivity of by verifying the hypotheses of Proposition 6.1.
Since is proper, belongs to , so the preceding identification shows that is perfect as a right -module. The –-bimodule structure on gives a –-bimodule structure. Under , its left -action corresponds to the left action on , and its right -action corresponds to precomposition on . Linear duality and quasi-full faithfulness of therefore give quasi-isomorphisms of dg algebras
Thus the generators of and of have endomorphism algebras and , respectively. These are the algebra models used in Proposition 6.1, and the corresponding graph bimodule is
Since , is also perfect over . This verifies the pseudo-perfectness hypothesis on the graph bimodule.
The dual graph bimodule is as an –-bimodule. Hence the comparison functor in Proposition 6.1 is , the quasi-inverse of already established above. Its action morphism (51) is the defining identification , and the density condition (6.3) is the assumption $\operatorname{PsPerf}(B)=\operatorname{thick}_{B}(P)$. Together with the assumed smoothness and degreewise finiteness of $A$, these verifications allow us to apply Proposition 6.1. It proves that $A$ is reflexive and supplies the Koszul duality hypotheses of {xref}Lemma 4.2. The generation statement {xref}(4.7)` then gives
which proves (56).
Passing to dg quotients and applying (39) gives the first quasi-equivalence in (57). Linear duality sends to , so Lemma 5.4 gives the second. Finally, under the Gorenstein condition (12), one has , and the first quotient is therefore . □
Corollary 6.5. Let be a finite-dimensional positive algebra over with . Then has a nonpositive smooth dg model with and finite-dimensional cohomology in every degree. The conclusions of Proposition 6.4 hold with .
Proof. Put . The relative bar construction gives a dg model for whose underlying graded algebra is ; compare [15 Section 2.2 and Lemma 5.3(b)]. Since is finite-dimensional and , the space is finite-dimensional and concentrated in strictly negative degrees. Consequently, only finitely many tensor lengths contribute to each graded piece. In particular, this model is nonpositive and has finite-dimensional cohomology in every degree.
The augmentation excludes constant terms, and minimality of excludes linear terms in the differential of each generator. Thus, for a homogeneous generator , the differential is a finite sum of words with . Each such word has degree , and all its factors have negative degree. It follows that
Hence involves only generators of strictly greater degree than .
To deduce smoothness of , let be the universal relative derivation. As a graded -bimodule, one has
with corresponding to . Its differential satisfies
By the Leibniz rule, the right-hand side is a sum of bimodule multiples of elements with . Thus, when the generators are adjoined in decreasing order of degree, the differential of each new generator lies in the bimodule generated by those already adjoined. Since is finite-dimensional, this gives a finite filtration of by dg sub-bimodules whose successive quotients are finite direct sums of shifts of . These quotients are perfect, so is a perfect -bimodule.
Since , the bimodule is also a finite direct sum of perfect bimodules . The exact sequence
therefore shows that the diagonal bimodule is perfect, hence smooth. Moreover, , and because the differential of a degree generator has no constant term. Thus .
Finally, Proposition 6.3(ii) gives . Since is proper and is smooth with finite-dimensional cohomology in every degree, Proposition 6.4 applies with . □
Remark 6.6. Degreewise finiteness can also hold when . For a finite-dimensional positive , the reduced bar construction is
where the opposite is taken for the forward convolution product. If the degree-one arrows, indexed by bases of from to , form an acyclic quiver, blocks of degree-zero bar letters have bounded length; see [ASS06, Section II.1 and Lemma II.1.4(c)]. Each graded piece of is then finite-dimensional, giving the finiteness required in Proposition 6.1.
Geometric examples
For a finite-type Weinstein manifold , let and denote its wrapped and compact Fukaya categories of exact graded branes with finite-rank local systems. is smooth with a smooth -Calabi–Yau structure and is generated by cocores, while Poincaré duality gives a proper -Calabi–Yau structure on ; see [Gan13; GPS24a; CDRGG24] and [Gan23, Theorem 2].
The following examples illustrate the algebraic criteria and the scheme comparison (46), giving
By [GGV22, Theorem 1.1], this also identifies the Rabinowitz Fukaya category up to Morita equivalence. In the first two examples, we first apply the criteria to the full subcategory on the chosen compact cores and then verify that these cores split-generate .
(1) Cotangent bundles. Let be a closed simply connected spin manifold, with coefficients in any field and zero background class. A cotangent fibre and the zero section give
see [Abol1, Theorem 1.1] and [Ekl23, Introduction] for the compatible Yoneda and Koszul actions. A finite minimal model of is positive with , so Corollary 6.5 applies. Since is nonpositive with , Proposition 6.3(i) places every compact object’s fibre Yoneda module in . Thus the zero section split-generates , giving (58) for the full compact category. (2) Tree plumbings. Let be a finite tree plumbing of cotangent bundles of closed simply connected spin -manifolds, , with the same coefficient convention. Take to be the sum of the cocores and the sum of the cores. Grade the cores so that opposite intersection generators have degrees . Then is proper and admits a positive minimal model with acyclic degree-one quiver, and the summands of are the augmentation modules . The action map (51) is a quasi-isomorphism by [EkL23, Theorems 66, 68, and 83, Section 6.1.4]. Proposition 6.3 and Remark 6.6 verify (52). Moreover, is nonpositive with finite-dimensional , and the cocore Yoneda modules of the cores represent all simple -modules. The same truncation argument therefore proves compact generation and yields (58).
(3) Punctured tori. Over a perfect field, the standard graded torus with punctures has a quasi-equivalence of pairs
where is the split nodal cubic and is the cycle of projective lines for ; see [LekPer15, Theorem 9.1] and [LekPo17, Corollary 3.4.1 and Theorem 3.7.2]. Since its dualizing complex is , formula (46) gives (58), with target . Calculations for double-bubble plumbings appear in [21 Proposition 5.2 and Corollaries 5.7–5.8], and for Milnor fibres in [LekUe21, Section 3] and [LekUe22, Theorem 6.11]. For the description of double suspensions by cluster categories, see [LekUe26, Theorems 2.2 and 4.1].
Hochschild cohomology
We deduce multiplicative comparisons of Hochschild cohomology from Theorem A, then relate them to singular Hochschild cohomology under Keller’s hypotheses. All module Hom and tensor products use the dg models fixed in § 2.
The boundary comparison
For a small dg category and a -bimodule , write
and omit for diagonal coefficients; see [5 Section 5.4] for the Hochschild bar model and cup product. Let be a dg localization, meaning that restriction is quasi-fully faithful; dg quotients have this property [6 Section 3.9]. Set
Composition in and the map induced by give this bimodule a multiplication and unit, hence a cup product on .
Proposition 7.1. Restriction gives a quasi-isomorphism
and an isomorphism of unital graded algebras on cohomology.
Proof. By [6 Proposition 3.10(a)], extension of scalars along sends to . Adjunction therefore gives the quasi-isomorphism (60). On bar cochains, its arity- component is
for composable morphisms in . The cup product uses deconcatenation of these inputs and composition in , so this formula preserves products and sends the diagonal unit to . ∎
Under the hypotheses of Theorem A, apply this proposition to
For the Yoneda functor , define the boundary coefficient bimodule by
Proposition 5.2 identifies it with the pullback of the diagonal of along (37).
Corollary 7.2. Under the hypotheses of Theorem A, there are natural isomorphisms of unital graded algebras
If is reflexive, these algebras are isomorphic to . If is reflexive and satisfies the Gorenstein condition (12), the functor (4) induces an isomorphism of unital graded algebras
Proof. The Yoneda Morita equivalence preserves Hochschild cohomology with corresponding coefficients and their cup products by [6 Proposition 3.10(e)]. Together with Proposition 7.1, it identifies with . Proposition 5.2 gives (62), and Theorem A gives the comparisons with the singularity categories. □
After translating the opposite-category and grading conventions, this is the cup product of [19 Definition 4.2 and Remark 4.3]; the boundary restriction map is the unital map of [Gao25, Proposition 3.10]. The same argument applies to the algebraic pairs (56) and the geometric equivalences (58).
Singular Hochschild cohomology comparison
For proper , its diagonal is pseudo-perfect over by Definition 2.3. Denote its image in by , and define
with product induced by composition; for ordinary finite-dimensional algebras, this is singular Hochschild cohomology as in [7 Section 1].
For a finite-dimensional ordinary algebra with separable over , Keller’s canonical comparison is an isomorphism of unital graded algebras
Indeed, [ELS20, Theorem 3.7] gives smoothness of , which is the hypothesis required by [7 Theorem 1.1]. Consequently, when in Corollary 7.2, is reflexive, and satisfies (12), composing (64) with (63) identifies with as unital graded algebras. If is split, meaning , [XZ26, Theorem 1.1], applied to for our right-module convention, lifts (64) to the homotopy category of -algebras.
The complete multiplicative solution to Conjecture 1.1 requires further structure on . For example, also carries a nondegenerate 4-truncated -pre-Calabi–Yau structure, in the sense of [19 Definitions 2.9 and 2.11], its induced Calabi–Yau duality identifies
With the Koszul signs for this regrading, [19 Proposition 5.8 and Theorem 5.11] identify the cup product with their product of homological degree .
References
School of Mathematics, Nanjing University, Nanjing, Jiangsu, 210093, China Email address: [email protected]
Institut für Mathematik, Universität Augsburg, Germany Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]Isambard Goodbody. Reflecting perfection for finite-dimensional differential graded algebras. In: Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society 56.12 (2024), pp. 3689–3707. DOI: 10.1112/blms.13160.DOI
- [2]Isambard Goodbody. Reflexivity and Hochschild cohomology. In: Journal of Algebra 705 (2026), pp. 32–60. DOI: 10.1016/j.jalgebra.2026.04.050.DOI
- [3]Norihiro Hanihara and Junyang Liu. Calabi–Yau structures on derived and singularity categories of symmetric orders. 2026. arXiv: 2512.03836v2 [math.RT]. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.03836v2.
- [4]Bernhard Keller. A-infinity algebras, modules and functor categories. In: Trends in Representation Theory of Algebras and Related Topics. Vol. 406. Contemporary Mathematics. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, 2006, pp. 67–93. DOI: 10.1090/conm/406/07654.DOI
- [5]Bernhard Keller. On differential graded categories. In: International Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. II. Zürich: European Mathematical Society, 2006, pp. 151–190. DOI: 10.4171/022-2/8. arXiv: math/0601185v5 [math.KT]. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0601185v5.
- [6]Bernhard Keller. Deformed Calabi–Yau completions. In: Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik 654 (2011). With an appendix by Michel Van den Bergh, pp. 125–180. DOI: 10.1515/crelle.2011.031. See also the erratum (2018).DOI
- [7]Bernhard Keller. Singular Hochschild cohomology via the singularity category. 2020. arXiv: 1809.05121v10 [math.RT]. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.05121v10.
- [8]Henning Krause. Localization theory for triangulated categories. In: Triangulated Categories. Ed. by Thorsten Holm, Peter Jørgensen, and Raphaël Rouquier. Vol. 375. London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010, pp. 161–235. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9781139107075.005. arXiv: 0806.1324v2 [math.CT]. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/0806.1324v2.
- [15]Di Ming Lu, John H. Palmieri, Quan Shui Wu, and James J. Zhang. Koszul equivalences in A∞-algebras. In: New York Journal of Mathematics 14 (2008), pp. 325–378.
- [16]Volodymyr Lyubashenko and Oleksandr Manzyuk. Quotients of unital A∞-categories. In: Theory and Applications of Categories 20.13 (2008), pp. 405–496. DOI: 10.70930/tac/z2jgorg4.DOI
- [17]Volodymyr Lyubashenko and Sergiy Ovsienko. A construction of quotient A∞-categories. In: Homology, Homotopy and Applications 8.2 (2006), pp. 157–203. DOI: 10.4310/HHA.2006.v8.n2.a9.DOI
- [18]Dmitri Orlov. Triangulated categories of singularities and D-branes in Landau–Ginzburg models. In: Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics 246 (2004), pp. 227–248.arxiv.org/abs/math/0302304
- [19]Manuel Rivera, Alex Takeda, and Zhengfang Wang. Algebraic string topology from the neighborhood of infinity. 2024. arXiv: 2308.09684v3 [math.AT]. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.09684v3.
- [20]Paul Seidel. Fukaya Categories and Picard-Lefschetz Theory. Zürich Lectures in Advanced Mathematics. Zürich: European Mathematical Society, 2008. ISBN: 978-3-03719-063-0. DOI: 10.4171/063.DOI
- [21]Ivan Smith and Michael Wemyss. Double bubble plumbings and two-curve flops. In: Selecta Mathematica (New Series) 29.2, 29 (2023). DOI: 10.1007/s00029-023-00828-z.DOI
- [22]Hao Su and Dong Yang. From simple-minded collections to silting objects via Koszul duality. In: Algebras and Representation Theory 22.1 (2019), pp. 219–238. DOI: 10.1007/s10468-018-9763-y.DOI
- [23]Alex Takeda. Efimov’s categorical formal punctured neighborhood of infinity, Rabinowitz Fukaya category, CY and pre-CY structures. In: Mini-Workshop: Flavors of Rabinowitz Floer and Tate Homology. Vol. 20. Oberwolfach Reports 4. Report 56/2023. EMS Press, 2023, pp. 3164–3166. DOI: 10.4171/OWR/2023/56.
- [24]Bertrand Toën. The homotopy theory of dg-categories and derived Morita theory. In: Invent. Math 167.3 (2007), pp. 615–667. DOI: 10.1007/s00222-006-0025-y.DOI