betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Non-Unitary Quantum Butterfly Effect: Theory and Experiment

Abstract

We present a generalization of the out of time order correlator (OTOC) for non-unitary systems. For a Haar-random brickwork qudit-circuit, peppered with local, projective measurement, we calculate the infinite-temperature, ensemble-average OTOC. Utilizing transfer matrix machinery, we find that the OTOC asymptotically decays exponentially and that the decay depends on the rate of measurement. In the thermodynamic limit, with sparse measurement, the OTOC approximately exhibits a Gaussian shape. Phenomenologically, this corresponds to the development of a causal scrambling front where unlike the unitary case, the signal decays in the bulk of the causal cone. We develop a Monte Carlo framework to compute the OTOC. We then estimate the OTOC directly via quantum simulation and on Quantinuum's trapped-ion quantum computer. We resolve the unitary and non-unitary OTOC phenomenology despite the presence of hardware noise. Our analytic results characterize how local nonunitary channels affect OTOC decay, providing a quantitative benchmark for the cumulative effects of a broad class of hardware noise on many-body dynamics.

Introduction

The out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC) has emerged as a central diagnostic of quantum chaos and information scrambling. Inspired by the work of Larkin and Ovchinnikov in the context of superconductivity [1], the OTOC acquired renewed significance through the work of Kitaev [2] and Maldacena, Shenker, and Stanford [3], which connected its early-time growth to quantum information scrambling and established a bound on the rate of quantum chaos in certain systems [4]. More recently, developments in quantum information and computing have made it possible to study scrambling directly in quantum circuits [5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. At the same time, mid-circuit measurement has become the enabling primitive for quantum error correction, adaptive and feedforward algorithms, and measurement-based architectures in which measurement is a computational resource rather than a nuisance [13]. Yet how a measurement disturbs qubits other than the one measured remains among the least characterized aspects of present-day hardware.

Furthermore, random quantum circuits have become powerful metaphors for nonequilibrium many-body physics. Such circuits provide minimal yet nontrivial models of many-body evolution: locality gives rise to a causal light-cone structure, while their statistical structure permits analytical and numerical access to otherwise complicated processes such as operator spreading, scrambling, and measurement-induced dynamics [14, 15, 16].

For Haar-random unitary circuits, Nahum et al. showed that the OTOC exhibits a propagating scrambling front characterized by a butterfly velocity and a front whose fluctuations and broadening encode the underlying operator dynamics [9]. These results provide a transparent description of scrambling in closed, unitary many-body systems. Here, we extend this framework to non-unitary monitored dynamics by introducing local measurements into the random-circuit evolution. This allows us to investigate how measurement modifies the propagation and decay of the OTOC, thereby connecting the physics of measurement-induced dynamics with that of quantum chaos and information scrambling. We derive a number of analytical results and numerically calculate the OTOC utilizing a Monte Carlo technique. Furthermore, we experimentally measure the OTOC using Quantinuum’s H2 trapped-ion quantum computer and find results broadly consistent with theory. The central physical result admits a simple interpretation. In the unitary circuit, the OTOC saturates behind the propagating front: the system retains a persistent memory of the local perturbation even as information scrambles throughout the degrees of freedom. Measurement qualitatively changes this behavior. Although the perturbation continues to propagate causally, repeated measurements progressively erase its signature from the OTOC. In this sense, monitoring induces a form of dynamical “amnesia”: the circuit progressively forgets the perturbation. Operationally, the monitored OTOC therefore measures how far, and for how long, the backaction of an unrecorded measurement is felt elsewhere in the register.

Theory

Consider a system of NN qudits, which we refer to as sites and label j=0,1,…,N−1j = 0,1,\ldots,N-1. Throughout this work, indices are understood modulo the size of the lattice on which they are defined. Each qudit has local Hilbert-space dimension qq. We designate sites xx and yy as the probe and perturbation sites, respectively. The full Hilbert space is H=(Cq)⊗N\mathcal{H} = (\mathbb{C}^{q})^{\otimes N}. Let L(H)\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{H}) denote the space of linear operators on H\mathcal{H}, and let ε\varepsilon be a quantum channel acting on the full system; that is a completely positive, trace preserving linear map (CPTP) ε:L(H)→L(H)\varepsilon:\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{H})\to\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{H}). Let WW be a single-qudit channel. Its action on site yy, with the identity channel acting elsewhere, is denoted Wy=Iq⊗y⊗W⊗Iq⊗N−y−1W_y = I_q^{\otimes y} \otimes W \otimes I_q^{\otimes N-y-1} where IqI_q is the single-qudit identity channel. Let VV be a single-qudit Hermitian operator and define Vx=Iq⊗x⊗V⊗Iq⊗N−x−1V_x = I_q^{\otimes x} \otimes V \otimes I_q^{\otimes N-x-1}. We refer to ε\varepsilon, WyW_y, and VxV_x as the evolution channel, perturbation channel, and probe operator, respectively.

Every quantum channel ε\varepsilon on L(H)\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{H}) has a unique adjoint map ε†\varepsilon^\dagger, defined by

Tr⁡(Oε(ρ))=Tr⁡(ε†(O)ρ)(1)\operatorname{Tr}(O\varepsilon(\rho)) = \operatorname{Tr}(\varepsilon^\dagger(O)\rho) \tag*{(1)}

for every state ρ\rho and system operator OO. We define the response operator Δx,y\Delta_{x,y} by

Δx,y=Wy†(ε†(Vx))−ε†(Vx).(2)\Delta_{x,y} = W_y^\dagger(\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x))-\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x). \tag*{(2)}

For a given density operator ρ\rho, we call the expectation value of Δx,y2\Delta_{x,y}^2 the generalized out of time order correlator (OTOC), or simply the OTOC, and write

Cρ(x,y)=Tr⁡(ρΔx,y2).(3)C_\rho(x,y) = \operatorname{Tr}\left(\rho\Delta_{x,y}^2\right). \tag*{(3)}

When the perturbation channel is unitary, with Wy(O)=WyOWy†W_y(O)=W_y O W_y^\dagger for a unitary operator WyW_y, the generalized OTOC reduces to the form used in [17]

Cρ(x,y)=Tr⁡(ρ[ε†(Vx),Wy]†[ε†(Vx),Wy]).(4)C_\rho(x,y) = \operatorname{Tr}\left(\rho[\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x),W_y]^\dagger[\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x),W_y]\right). \tag*{(4)}

When the evolution channel is also unitary, this expression reduces to the conventional squared commutator OTOC. The OTOC Cρ(x,y)C_\rho(x,y) bounds the change in a probe expectation value at site xx caused by a perturbation at site yy. Consider two NN-qudit quantum circuits depicted in Figure 1(a) and (b). For (a), an initial state ρ\rho evolves under the channel ε\varepsilon, after which the observable VxV_x is measured. The resulting expectation value is mA(x)=Tr⁡(ρε†(Vx))m_A(x)=\operatorname{Tr}(\rho\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x)). Circuit (b) differs from (a) only by the insertion of the channel WyW_y immediately before the evolution channel. The expectation value of this measurement is mB(x,y)=Tr⁡(ρWy†(ε†(Vx)))m_B(x,y)=\operatorname{Tr}(\rho W_y^\dagger(\varepsilon^\dagger(V_x))). The generalized OTOC gives the upper bound

Schematic representation of the two circuit protocols

Figure 1. Schematic representation of the two circuit protocols. (a) Evolution under ε\varepsilon followed by measurement of VV at site qxq_x. (b) The local perturbation WW is applied at site qyq_y before evolution under ε\varepsilon, followed by the same measurement of VV at site qxq_x.

(mB(x,y)−mA(x))2=∣Tr⁡(ρΔx,y)∣2≤Tr⁡(ρΔx,y2)=Cρ(x,y).(5)\begin{aligned} (m_B(x,y)-m_A(x))^2 &= \left|\operatorname{Tr}(\rho\Delta_{x,y})\right|^2\\ &\leq\operatorname{Tr}(\rho\Delta_{x,y}^2)=C_\rho(x,y). \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

This follows from the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product, applied to ρ\sqrt{\rho} and ρΔx,y\sqrt{\rho}\Delta_{x,y}. Moreover, when the perturbation channel is unitary, the average of (mB(x,y)−mA(x))2(m_B(x,y)-m_A(x))^2 over Haar-random pure input states satisfies

Eψ[(mB(x,y)−mA(x))2]=Cρ∞(x,y)qN+1,(6)\mathbb{E}_{\psi}\left[(m_B(x,y)-m_A(x))^2\right] = \frac{C_{\rho_\infty}(x,y)}{q^N+1}, \tag*{(6)}

where ρ∞\rho_\infty denotes the maximally mixed (infinite-temperature) density operator

ρ∞=q−NIH.(7)\rho_\infty= q^{-N}I_{\mathcal{H}}. \tag*{(7)}

The average is over states ∣ψ⟩=U∣ψ0⟩|\psi\rangle=U|\psi_0\rangle, where ∣ψ0⟩|\psi_0\rangle is any fixed pure state and UU is Haar random. This follows from the second Haar moment for random pure states and from the fact Tr⁡(ρ∞Δx,y)=0\operatorname{Tr}(\rho_\infty\Delta_{x,y})=0 when WyW_y is unitary [18]. Equations (5) and (6) provide model-independent operational interpretations of the generalized OTOC in Eq. (3). For many physical systems, we expect the spatial and temporal dependence of the non-unitary OTOC, like that of its unitary counterpart, to serve as a useful proxy for more direct diagnostics of sensitivity to local perturbations and information spreading.

In what follows, we fix the input state for the OTOC to be the infinite-temperature density operator. For any system operator OO, let ∥O∥2=Tr⁡(O†O)\lVert O\rVert_2=\sqrt{\operatorname{Tr}(O^\dagger O)} denote the Hilbert-Schmidt norm. The infinite-temperature OTOC can be expressed as

C(x,y)=Cρ∞(x,y)=1qN∥Δx,y∥22.(8)C(x,y)=C_{\rho_\infty}(x,y)=\frac{1}{q^N}\lVert\Delta_{x,y}\rVert_2^2. \tag*{(8)}

In this work, we compute the ensemble-averaged OTOC for a monitored random circuit. The circuit consists of brickwork layers of two-qudit gates interspersed with local projective mid-circuit measurements. Each gate is drawn independently from the Haar measure. The unitary layers alternate between even and odd bonds. Even layers act on the pairs of sites $(0,1),(2,3),\ldots,(N2,N−12, N-1). Under open boundary conditions (OBC), odd layers act on sites (1,2),(3,4),…,(N−3,N−2)(1,2),(3,4),\ldots,(N-3,N-2); under periodic boundary conditions (PBC), they additionally include the pair (N−1,0)(N-1,0).

Between successive unitary layers, each site is independently measured with probability pp, so measurement events are not correlated between sites and layers. Measurements are performed in the eigenbasis of the qudit clock operator ZZ, a generalization of the Pauli ZZ operator:

Z=∑n=0q−1ωn∣n⟩⟨n∣,ω=e2πi/q.(9)Z=\sum_{n=0}^{q-1}\omega^n\lvert n\rangle\langle n\rvert,\qquad\omega=e^{2\pi i/q}. \tag*{(9)}

We label the circuit depth by the integer time tt. We take t=0t=0 to denote the time immediately after the first, even unitary layer and before the first measurement layer. Subsequent values of tt correspond to the analogous time immediately after each successive unitary layer. Thus, even and odd values of tt correspond to even and odd unitary layers, respectively.

We calculate the OTOC averaged over realizations of the random circuit. Let UU collectively denote the realization of the Haar-random gates, Γ\Gamma the spacetime pattern of measurement locations, and μΓ\mu_{\Gamma} the corresponding measurement outcomes. We write εt(U,Γ,μΓ)\varepsilon_t^{(U,\Gamma,\mu_{\Gamma})} for the trajectory-resolved evolution through time tt, and C[ε]C[\varepsilon] for the OTOC associated with the evolution map ε\varepsilon. Because C[ε]C[\varepsilon] is nonlinear in ε\varepsilon, averaging the OTOC and evaluating the OTOC of the averaged evolution are generally not equivalent. Throughout the remainder of the paper, we assume that the measurement outcomes have been pre-averaged, yielding an effective dephasing channel. Appendix B shows the relation, with the dependence on the measurement probability explicit:

EU[C[EμΓ[εt(U,Γ,μΓ)]]](p)=EU,Γ[C[EμΓ[εt(U,Γ,μΓ)]]](p(2−p)).(10)\mathbb{E}_{U}\left[C\left[\mathbb{E}_{\mu_{\Gamma}}\left[\varepsilon_t^{(U,\Gamma,\mu_{\Gamma})}\right]\right]\right](p) = \mathbb{E}_{U,\Gamma}\left[C\left[\mathbb{E}_{\mu_{\Gamma}}\left[\varepsilon_t^{(U,\Gamma,\mu_{\Gamma})}\right]\right]\right](p(2-p)). \tag*{(10)}

Henceforth, C‾\overline{C} denotes

C‾=EU,Γ[C[EμΓ[εt(U,Γ,μΓ)]]](11)\overline{C}=\mathbb{E}_{U,\Gamma}\left[C\left[\mathbb{E}_{\mu_{\Gamma}}\left[\varepsilon_t^{(U,\Gamma,\mu_{\Gamma})}\right]\right]\right] \tag*{(11)}

and we suppress the labels (U,Γ,μΓ)(U,\Gamma,\mu_{\Gamma}) on the evolution channel.

In Appendix A, we show that the dependence of the average OTOC on the perturbation channel factorizes into a channel dependent amplitude and a universal spatiotemporal profile. Let

W(r,s)=XrZs,(r,s)∈Zq2∖{(0,0)}(12)W^{(r,s)}=X^rZ^s,\qquad(r,s)\in\mathbb{Z}_q^2\setminus\{(0,0)\} \tag*{(12)}

be any nonidentity Weyl operator, and let U(r,s)(O)=W(r,s)O(W(r,s))†\mathcal{U}^{(r,s)}(O)=W^{(r,s)}O(W^{(r,s)})^\dagger denote the corresponding unitary perturbation channel acting on a system operator OO. For an arbitrary single-qudit perturbation channel W\mathcal{W},

References

  1. [1]A. I. Larkin and Y. N. Ovchinnikov, Soviet Physics JETP 28, 1200 (1969).
  2. [2]A. Kitaev, Hidden correlations in the hawking radiation and thermal noise, Talk at the Fundamental Physics Prize Symposium (2014), stanford, November 10, 2014.
  3. [3]J. Maldacena, S. H. Shenker, and D. Stanford, Journal of High Energy Physics 2016, 106 (2016), arXiv:1503.01409 [hep-th].
  4. [4]Y. Liao and V. Galitski, Phys. Rev. B 98, 205124 (2018).
  5. [5]N. Y. Yao, F. Grusdt, B. Swingle, M. D. Lukin, D. M. Stamper-Kurn, J. E. Moore, and E. A. Demler, Interferometric approach to probing fast scrambling (2016), arXiv:1607.01801 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1607.01801
  6. [6]B. Swingle, G. Bentsen, M. Schleier-Smith, and P. Hayden, Physical Review A 94, 10.1103/physreva.94.040302 (2016).
  7. [7]M. Gärtner, J. G. Bohnet, A. Safavi-Naini, M. L. Wall, J. J. Bollinger, and A. M. Rey, Nature Physics 13, 781 (2017).
  8. [8]B. Swingle, Nature Physics 14, 988 (2018).
  9. [9]A. Nahum, S. Vijay, and J. Haah, Physical Review X 8, 021014 (2018).
  10. [10]C. W. von Keyserlingk, T. Rakovszky, F. Pollmann, and S. L. Sondhi, Phys. Rev. X 8, 021013 (2018).
  11. [11]X. Mi, M. Ippoliti, C. Quintana, A. Greene, Z. Chen, J. Gross, F. Arute, K. Arya, J. Atalaya, R. Babbush, et al., Science 374, 1479 (2021).
  12. [12]Google Quantum AI and Collaborators, Nature 646, 825 (2025).
  13. [13]P. Argyle, D. Lakhdar-Hamina, S. H. Miller, and V. Galitski, arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.19200 10.48550/arXiv.2603.19200 (2026), arXiv:2603.19200 [quant-ph], arXiv:2603.19200 [quant-ph].
  14. [14]A. Nahum, J. Ruhman, S. Vijay, and J. Haah, Phys. Rev. X 7, 031016 (2017).
  15. [15]C. Jonay, D. A. Huse, and A. Nahum, Coarse-grained dynamics of operator and state entanglement (2018), arXiv:1803.00089 [cond-mat.stat-mech].arxiv.org/abs/1803.00089
  16. [16]B. Skinner, J. Ruhman, and A. Nahum, Phys. Rev. X 9, 031009 (2019).
  17. [17]P. Zanardi and N. Anand, Physical Review A 103, 062214 (2021).
  18. [18]B. Collins and P. Śniady, Communications in Mathematical Physics 264, 773 (2006).
  19. [20]A. Altland and J. Sonner, SciPost Phys. 11, 034 (2021), arXiv:2108.02271.
  20. [21]Y. Liao and V. Galitski, Phys. Rev. B 105, L140202 (2022), arXiv:2104.05721.
  21. [22]T. Schuster and N. Y. Yao, Physical Review Letters 131, 160402 (2023).
  22. [23]T. Yoshimura and L. Sá, Physical Review B 113, 144306 (2026).
  23. [24]S. Moses, C. Baldwin, M. Allman, R. Ancona, L. Ascar-runz, C. Barnes, J. Bartolotta, B. Bjork, P. Blanchard, M. Bohn, J. Bohnet, N. Brown, N. Burdick, W. Bur-ton, S. Campbell, J. Campora, C. Carron, J. Chambers, J. Chan, Y. Chen, A. Chernoguzov, E. Chertkov, J. Col-lina, J. Curtis, R. Daniel, M. DeCross, D. Deen, C. De-laney, J. Dreiling, C. Ertsgaard, J. Esposito, B. Estey, M. Fabrikant, C. Figgatt, C. Foltz, M. Foss-Feig, D. Fran-cois, J. Gaebler, T. Gatterman, C. Gilbreth, J. Giles, E. Glynn, A. Hall, A. Hankin, A. Hansen, D. Hayes, B. Higashi, I. Hoffman, B. Horning, J. Hout, R. Ja-cobs, J. Johansen, L. Jones, J. Karcz, T. Klein, P. Lau-ria, P. Lee, D. Liefer, S. Lu, D. Lucchetti, C. Ly-tle, A. Malm, M. Matheny, B. Mathewson, K. Mayer, D. Miller, M. Mills, B. Neyenhuis, L. Nugent, S. Ol-son, J. Parks, C. Price, Z. Price, M. Pugh, A. Rans-ford, A. Reed, C. Roman, M. Rowe, C. Ryan-Anderson, S. Sanders, J. Sedlacek, P. Shevchuk, P. Siegfried, T. Skripka, B. Spaun, R. Sprenkle, R. Stutz, M. Swal-lows, R. Tobey, A. Tran, T. Tran, E. Vogt, C. Volin, J. Walker, A. Zolot, and J. Pino, Physical Review X 13, 10.1103/physrevx.13.041052 (2023).
  24. [25]Quantinuum, System model h2 emulators, Quantinuum Systems User Guide (2025), accessed: 2026-08-27.
  25. [26]Galitski Group, Schmetterling effect: Code for measurement-induced butterfly effect, https://github.com/Galitski-group/schmetterling-effect (2026), gitHub repository.
  26. [27]J. Watrous, The Theory of Quantum Information (Cambridge University Press, 2018).DOI
  27. [28]I. L. Chuang and M. A. Nielsen, Journal of Modern Optics 44, 2455 (1997).
  28. [29]R. A. Horn and C. R. Johnson, Matrix Analysis, 2nd ed. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2012).
  29. [30]C. M. Grinstead and J. L. Snell, Introduction to Probability, 2nd ed. (American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1997).

Paper details

vlnc:W_vunthbjz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents