betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Examining the justification for the introduction of a fermion localization function

Abstract

Becke and Edgecombe suggested in 1990 a theoretical tool to describe electron localization in atoms and molecules, an idea which was borrowed by a large number of nuclear theorists since 2011 to describe nucleon localization in nuclear systems. I argue here that these arguments are highly questionable and cannot be used in interacting systems, where effects beyond the naive mean field or the simple Hartree-Fock framework are important and the inclusion of correlations induced by particle interactions is necessary in order to introduce such a localization function. I also describe several aspects of the exchange and irreducible 2-body density matrices, which depend on the character and strength of the 2-particle interaction and, which can be useful in justifying the derivation of an appropriate energy density functional.

In nuclei lighter than 40Ca^{40}\mathrm{Ca} molecular-like states have been studied for a long time [1, 2]. The nuclear molecular clusters are in reality micro-crystals, as the relative separation between the clusters varies very little. In the crust of neutron stars the formation of the so-called pasta-like phase, another type of matter clusterization, or matter crystallization more accurately, is known for decades [3]. Obviously, the formation of fission fragments in nuclear fission [4] is another example of dynamical formation of nuclear clusters. In order to easily identify theoretically the formation of “clumps” of electronic matter in atoms and molecules Becke and Edgecombe [5] advocated the use in the Hartree-Fock approximation of the quantity

Dτ,σ(r)=ττ,σ(r)−14∣∇nτ,σ(r)∣2nτ,σ(r)−∣jτ,σ(r)∣2nτ,σ(r),(1)D_{\tau,\sigma}(r)=\tau_{\tau,\sigma}(r)-\frac{1}{4}\frac{\lvert\nabla n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)\rvert^2}{n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)}-\frac{\lvert\mathbf{j}_{\tau,\sigma}(r)\rvert^2}{n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)}, \tag*{(1)}

where the subscripts τ=n,p\tau=n,p and σ\sigma stand for isospin and spin respectively in case of nuclear systems, and ττ,σ(r)\tau_{\tau,\sigma}(r), nτ,σ(r)n_{\tau,\sigma}(r), jτ,σ(r)\mathbf{j}_{\tau,\sigma}(r) are the kinetic energy, nucleon and current number densities respectively. The current density term is required by Galilean invariance [6–12], the form used by nuclear theorists [13–30] (this is very likely an incomplete list of references). Readers will recognize that Dτ,σ(r)D_{\tau,\sigma}(r), related to the kinetic energy density without the last term was known to v. Weizsäcker [31] (here in the original form, without the current number density)

ττ,σ(r)=35(6π2)2/3nτ,σ5/3(r)+14∣∇nτ,σ(r)∣2nτ,σ(r).(2)\tau_{\tau,\sigma}(r)=\frac{3}{5}(6\pi^2)^{2/3}n_{\tau,\sigma}^{5/3}(r)+\frac{1}{4}\frac{\lvert\nabla n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)\rvert^2}{n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)}. \tag*{(2)}

The accuracy of second term in Eq. (2) was questioned many times over the years [35] [32, 33, 34], and gradient expansions lead to a pre-factor 1/361/36 instead of 1/41/4, and currently Padé approximants and other parametrizations are also considered. There are several reasons for this intense interest in the gradient term, which originates from the definition of the 2-body density matrix (see below), since in the Density Functional Theory (DFT) [34] the exchange and correlation energies, arising from interactions, are treated on an equal footing, unlike in the Hartree-Fock approximation, which was used in introducing Dτ,σ(r)D_{\tau,\sigma}(r) in Eq. (1). Eq. (1) is derived from the Hartree-Fock approximation of the 2-body number density for spin pairs with S=1S=1, Sz=±1S_z=\pm1, T=1T=1, Tz=±1T_z=\pm1 only, for which Pauli correlation exists

n2(ξ,ζ)=12[n1(ξ,ξ)n1(ζ,ζ)−n1(ξ,ζ)n1(ζ,ξ)],(3)n_2(\xi,\zeta)=\frac{1}{2}\left[n_1(\xi,\xi)n_1(\zeta,\zeta)-n_1(\xi,\zeta)n_1(\zeta,\xi)\right], \tag*{(3)}

where n1(ξ,ζ)=∑kϕk(ξ)ϕk∗(ζ)n_1(\xi,\zeta)=\sum_k\phi_k(\xi)\phi_k^*(\zeta) is the Hartree-Fock density matrix expressed through the single-particle wave-function ϕk(ξ)\phi_k(\xi), and ξ=(r1,σ′,τ′)\xi=(r_1,\sigma',\tau'), ζ=(r2,σ′,τ′)\zeta=(r_2,\sigma',\tau'). In the limit s=r1−r2→0s=r_1-r_2\to0 [5–7, 9, 11–13]

n2(ξ,ζ)=13nτ,σ(r)Dτ,σ(r)s2+O(s4)n_2(\xi,\zeta)=\frac{1}{3}n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)D_{\tau,\sigma}(r)s^2+\mathcal{O}(s^4)

and the conditional probability to find a particle with coordinate r′r' from a particle with coordinate rr and the same spin and isospin is proportional to Dτ,σ(r)D_{\tau,\sigma}(r). The fermion localization function (FLF) Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r) was introduced in Ref. [5, 13] basically as a measure of the accuracy of the zeroth-order Thomas-Fermi approximation for the kinetic energy density

Cτ,σ(r)=[1+(Dτ,σ(r)35(6π2)2/3nτ,σ5/3(r))2]−1.(4)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r)=\left[1+\left(\frac{D_{\tau,\sigma}(r)}{\frac{3}{5}(6\pi^2)^{2/3}n_{\tau,\sigma}^{5/3}(r)}\right)^2\right]^{-1}. \tag*{(4)}

It appears that in atomic and molecular systems, where the role of correlation energy is significantly less important than in nuclei and the Hartree-Fock approximation is sufficiently accurate [21], the spatial profiles of the electronic shells more pronounced in Cσ(r)C_{\sigma}(r) than in number density profiles nσ(r)n_{\sigma}(r). As the term proportional to ∣∇nτ,σ(r)∣2\lvert\nabla n_{\tau,\sigma}(r)\rvert^2 has a subdominant role in DFT [35] [32, 33, 34], likely it can be neglected, and in the case of static systems the quantity Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r) is defined basically by the ratio of the actual kinetic energy density to its Thomas-Fermi approximation. It is obvious that neither this ratio nor the quantity Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r) defines an observable and this is merely a somewhat arbitrary measure of the accuracy of the Thomas-Fermi approximation to the kinetic energy density alone. From many studies performed in nuclear physics over the years, it is clear that the Extended Thomas-Fermi approximation, including corrections up to O(ℏ4)\mathcal{O}(\hbar^4) for the kinetic energy density provides a pretty good approximation for densities and total energies of nuclear systems, see Section 4.4 in Ref. [35], where references to many more complete studies can be found. The (extended) Thomas-Fermi approximation however does not describe shell effects, or more generally the quantization of the single-particle motion in various geometries.

Does the quantity Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r) indeed help us better visualize clustering effects? Cluster formation are typically due to the existence of 2-, 3-, 4-body and higher interactions between particles, and not the result of the quantization of the single-particle motion in a finite system. The main part of the interaction between electrons is repulsive, and in any physical system (except hard balls at high density) clusters would form only if there will be an effective attractive interaction between the electrons. One might argue that the Fock exchange Coulomb energy between electrons is attractive, a result which is however accurate only for non-relativistic systems [34]. However, it is hard to make the argument that the “attractive” electron Coulomb exchange energy between electrons with the same spin, or in spin-polarized electron systems, leads to electron clusterization or electron shells. On the other hand, in nuclear systems, which are typically bound and therefore the interparticle interaction is mainly attractive, and volume and symmetry energies favor spin- and isospin unpolarized systems, the exchange interaction is repulsive, and again, one can hardly make the case that the spin- and isospin-polarized nuclear systems can clusterize or lead to quantization of the single-particle motion. One might bring as a counter-example the Wigner crystal [36] of a very low density electron gas, which however is basically a classical system, where exchange effects are negligible, see also below. The Wigner crystal is similar to a system of hard spheres, which does not clusterize, but the negligible effects of the exchange energy could lead to a disorder state of spins. Clearly, the quantity Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(r), which is sensitive to the quantization of the single-particle motion and is by definition a 1-body quantity, cannot describe the formation of clusters, which implies a very strong spatial correlation between various particles, and which therefore should be described by a 2-body or many-body number density.

In nuclei and in cold fermionic atomic systems, which are qualitatively similar to dilute neutron matter [37], the situation is much more complex. It makes sense to discuss at first the cold atom systems, where the interaction is very simple and both experimental and ab initio theoretical approaches are in complete agreement to a very high degree of accuracy. For a Fermi gas with the zero-range interaction the properties of the system are controlled by a single dimensionless parameter kFak_Fa, where aa is the ss-wave scattering length, kFk_F is the average Fermi momentum, and where there is a complete understanding of both infinite homogeneous systems as well as systems in external traps [10, 12]. Around unitarity, where the scattering length ∣a∣≫1/n3|a| \gg1/\sqrt[3]{n} only two fermions interact, one with spin up and the other with spin down, and in the

limit ∣a∣→+∞|a| \to+\infty the entire system is a gas of barely overlapping pairs with total spin S=0S = 0, thus a clusterized system. In such a Fermi system Cooper pairs are formed, with size ranging from extremely large to smaller than the average interparticle separation, depending on the actual value of aa, and these Cooper pairs freely collide with each other without being destroyed. The 2-body number density for a particle with spin-up and the other with spin-down has a universal behavior n2(r1,r2)∼1/∣r1−r2∣2n_2(r_1,r_2) \sim1/|r_1-r_2|^2 at any energy or temperature for ∣r1−r2∣≪∣a∣|r_1-r_2| \ll|a|. This behavior is related to a 1-body momentum distribution for large momenta np∼1/p4n_p \sim1/p^4 [37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49] [10, 12]. This system is very similar to the dilute neutron matter appearing in neutron stars [50, 51, 52]. These essentially independent “Cooper pairs” are clusters.

The method suggested by Becke and Edgecombe [5] and used in nuclear studies cannot capture this kind of clustering in either dilute neutron matter, nor in nuclei [13–30], since it considers the correlations or clustering between fermions with the same spin only. An ad hoc alternative was however adopted in nuclei to describe clustering or localization on nucleons, and one uses the product Cn,σ(r)Cp,σ(r)C_{n,\sigma}(r)C_{p,\sigma}(r). It is obvious on the other hand that a product of probabilities describes independent events and therefore the proton and neutron distributions cannot be correlated, and therefore this measure actually points to the absence of clustering. The clustering in nuclear systems cannot be explained through exchange effects, but through the interplay among volume energy, surface tension, and symmetry energy, in a region with a nuclear matter with both protons and neutrons, see for classical example the case of the nuclear pasta phase, which actually is a quantum crystal [3], as are the nuclear molecular states [1, 2] as well. A cluster has a well defined surface, which is characterized by a repulsive surface energy, due to nuclear surface tension. Surface tension can be counteracted by a stronger, typically proton-neutron attraction, iff proton and neutron densities are (almost) spin saturated.

The kinetic energy density for fermions with the same spin in a large momentum interval exhibits a power law behavior np∝1/p4n_p \propto1/p^4 in the presence of either pairing correlations and/or SRCs [38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 46, 47, 48, 49] [10, 12], and that would lead to a false signal using Eq. (4). The SRCs in nuclei are due to several effects, the tensor interaction between protons and neutrons [45, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58] and pairing correlations [37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 46, 47, 48, 49] [10, 12], the latter also leading to long-range correlations. It is important to appreciate that in the case of zero-range interactions the SRCs between two fermions, which for a dilute atomic gas are between fermions of the same kind, but with opposite spins, are present at any excitation energy [37, 41, 42, 43], even when a pairing condensate, characterized by long-range phase order, does not even exist for example in nuclear systems [47, 48, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64].

In order to describe such clustering or SRCs using Eq. (4) one has to consider the generalization of the FLF

Cτ(r)=[1+(Dτ(r)35(3π2)2/3nτ5/3(r))2]−1(5)C_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})=\left[1+\left(\frac{\mathcal{D}_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})}{\frac{3}{5}(3\pi^{2})^{2/3}n_{\tau}^{5/3}(\boldsymbol{r})}\right)^{2}\right]^{-1} \tag*{(5)}
Dτ(r)=ττ(r)−Δτ(r)κτ(r)−14∣∇nτ(r)∣2nτ(r)−∑τ∣jτ(r)∣2nτ(r)(6)\mathcal{D}_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})=\tau_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})-\Delta_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})\kappa_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})-\frac{1}{4}\frac{\lvert\nabla n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})\rvert^{2}}{n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})}-\sum_{\tau}\frac{\lvert\boldsymbol{j}_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})\rvert^{2}}{n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})} \tag*{(6)}

with the very critical important correction arising from the pairing interaction, here for nnnn- or pppp-pairs only. Here nτ(r)n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}), ττ(r)\tau_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}), κτ(r)\kappa_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}), and Δτ(r)\Delta_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}) are the regularized number, kinetic energy, anomalous densities, and the renormalized corresponding pairing potentials. In the case of zero-range pairing interaction the kinetic energy density and anomalous number density both diverge, but the combination ττ(r)−Δτ(r)κτ(r)\tau_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})-\Delta_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})\kappa_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}) in Eq. (5) is free of divergencies [39, 40, 65] [10]. Since in nuclei the SRCs are mostly due to the presence of the tensor interaction between the protons and neutrons, their effect can be described by introducing an effective pnpn-pairing field [47]. For nuclear systems, as experiments also amply demonstrate [53, 55, 56, 57, 58] there is always a momentum interval where the nucleon momentum distribution has power low behavior n(p)∝1/p4n(p)\propto1/p^{4} as obtained in various ab initio studies [45, 63, 66] and references therein. The correction due the presence of pairing or/and SRCs has never been considered in discussing nucleon localization in previous studies and it is clear that the definition of the function D(r)\mathcal{D}(\boldsymbol{r}) then depends on arbitrary cutoffs used in theoretical calculations [13–30]. The use of finite short-range interactions, such as Gogny interaction, might superficially mask the presence of divergences, as there is always a relatively large momentum interval contributing to the kinetic energy and anomalous densities controlled by the short radius of the interaction and where the momentum distribution has a power-law behavior.

Even after introducing the renormalized quantity Dτ(r)\mathcal{D}_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}), see Eq. (6), it is still not obvious that Cτ(r)C_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}) is satisfactory measure of clusterization in nuclear physics, since Cτ(r)C_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}) is not an observable. As Cτ(r)C_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}) is a measure of how good the Thomas-Fermi approximation only, and that since in DFT the gradient term of the nucleon density ∣∇nτ(r)∣2nτ(r)\frac{\lvert\nabla n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})\rvert^{2}}{n_{\tau}(\boldsymbol{r})} can likely be neglected [35] [32, 33, 34], and in the absence of any currents, the only thing left in Eq. (4) is the ratio of the renormalized kinetic energy density to its Thomas Fermi approximation, which again, it is not an observable, unlike the presence of a cluster.

The tensor interaction plays a very important role in nuclei, in particular it leads to a bound proton-neutron system. The role of SRCs in nuclei, due mainly to the tensor interaction between protons and neutrons has been known for a long time. Levinger [53, 54] pointed out more than 70 years ago that SRCs are critical to describe the nuclear photo-effect. Since photons are a weak probe of nuclear properties, the fact that a pair of neutron and proton is predominantly emitted clearly points

to the presence of short-range quasi-deuteron pairs in nuclei prior to the photon striking a nucleus. The presence of strong SRCs in nuclei has been persuasively demonstrated in the JLAB experiment in the last decade [55, 56, 57, 58]. Obviously, SRCs due predominantly to tensor interaction lead to the formation of clusters, as one can clearly see in light nuclei where α\alpha-like molecular clusters are routinely observed, and in which case both proton and neutron subsystems are spin saturated and symmetry energy effects dominate, leading to clusters with mainly equal proton and neutron numbers. A simple evaluation of the magnitude of the symmetry energy, shows that half of its magnitude is controlled by minimizing the kinetic energy and thus equalizing the spin-up and spin-down occupation probabilities of same type of nucleons, and the other half is due to the proton-neutron interaction. As the initial study of localization effects in nuclei [13] clearly shows, see Fig. 2 in this reference, the FLF Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(\boldsymbol{r}) simply very accurately predicts where the gradient of the number density nσ,τn_{\sigma,\tau} for a specific σ\sigma and τ\tau is largest. The volume and symmetry energy ensure that a subsystem is spin- and/or isospin unpolarized, unless Coulomb effects become relevant, as in the case of the pasta phase in neutron star crust [3]. The volume energy and the nuclear surface tension are largely spin and isospin independent. When an “internal” surface appears the single-particle quantization effects start playing a subdominant role and they appear to be amplified by the FLF Cσ,τ(r)C_{\sigma,\tau}(\boldsymbol{r}), however leading to unrealistic images of the nuclear matter distribution. Consider the example of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} discussed in Ref. [13], where the FLF Cn,σ(r)C_{n,\sigma}(\boldsymbol{r}) allegedly points to the existence of “spatial shell-like” structure of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} with an average radius of about 3 fm or larger and an very pronounced “inner density depression” with a radius of about 1.25 fm (estimated at half-density). One might surmise that the proton localization should be very similar. At the same time no conceivable density probe of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} ever revealed the existence of such a pronounced clustering effect, specifically the existence of a well-defined spherical shell structure in the number density. Is there any other type of probe to reveal the reality of this type of clustering? The FLF Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(\boldsymbol{r}) is at best some rather arbitrary measure of the accuracy of the Thomas-Fermi approximation to the spin and isospin kinetic energy density, and has a very tenuous relation with possible clustering effects, which are controlled by the interplay of the surface tension, the local spin and isospin saturation in a given nucleus. In larger nuclei and particularly in neutron star crust there are significant effects due to Coulomb interaction, which only indirectly reflect on the accuracy of the Thomas-Fermi approximation of the spin-isospin kinetic energy density “measured” by the FLF Cτ,σ(r)C_{\tau,\sigma}(\boldsymbol{r}).

The exact 2-body density matrix n2(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′)n_{2}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi') can be represented as a Hartree-Fock like contribution due to the 1-body density matrix n1(ξ,ζ)n_{1}(\xi,\zeta), plus an irreducible 2-body part ncorr(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′)n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi')

n2(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′)=⟨Φ∣ψ†(ξ′)ψ†(ζ′)ψ(ζ)ψ(ξ)∣Φ⟩=12[n1(ξ,ξ′)n1(ζ,ζ′)−n1(ξ,ζ′)n1(ζ,ξ′)]+ncorr(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′),(7)n_2(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi')=\langle\Phi|\psi^\dagger(\xi')\psi^\dagger(\zeta')\psi(\zeta)\psi(\xi)|\Phi\rangle =\frac{1}{2}\left[n_1(\xi,\xi')n_1(\zeta,\zeta')-n_1(\xi,\zeta')n_1(\zeta,\xi')\right]+n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi'), \tag*{(7)}
n1(ξ,ζ)=⟨Φ∣ψ†(ζ)ψ(ξ)∣Φ⟩=∑knkϕk(ξ)ϕk∗(ζ),0≤nk≤1,(8)n_1(\xi,\zeta)=\langle\Phi|\psi^\dagger(\zeta)\psi(\xi)|\Phi\rangle =\sum_k n_k\phi_k(\xi)\phi_k^*(\zeta),\qquad0\leq n_k\leq1, \tag*{(8)}
∫ξn1(ξ,ξ)=∑knk=N,⟨ϕk∣ϕl⟩=δkl,(9)\int_{\xi}n_1(\xi,\xi)=\sum_k n_k=N,\qquad\langle\phi_k|\phi_l\rangle=\delta_{kl}, \tag*{(9)}
nex(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′)=−12n1(ξ,ζ′)n1(ζ,ξ′),(10)n_{\mathrm{ex}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi')=-\frac{1}{2}n_1(\xi,\zeta')n_1(\zeta,\xi'), \tag*{(10)}
∫ξ,ζn2(ξ,ζ,ζ,ξ)=N(N−1)2,(11)\int_{\xi,\zeta}n_2(\xi,\zeta,\zeta,\xi)=\frac{N(N-1)}{2}, \tag*{(11)}
∫ξ,ζncorr(ξ,ζ,ζ,ξ)=−12∑knk(1−nk)≤0,(12)\int_{\xi,\zeta}n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta,\xi)=-\frac{1}{2}\sum_k n_k(1-n_k)\leq0, \tag*{(12)}

where NN is the particle number, nkn_k and ϕk(ξ)\phi_k(\xi) are the canonical occupation probabilities and canonical single-particle wave functions [48], also known as natural orbitals [67, 68], and ξ,ζ,ξ′,ζ′\xi,\zeta,\xi',\zeta' are the particle coordinates ξ=(r,σ,τ)\xi=(r,\sigma,\tau) and so forth. The irreducible 2-body part of the 2-body density matrix vanishes only in the case of a pure Hartree-Fock wave function, when nk=0n_k=0 or 1 only, and it is only the second rank of the general many-body Born-Bogoliubov-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy of many-body reduced density matrices [69]. Obviously the solution for the entire chain of these different rank density matrices is more complicated than the solution of the corresponding many-body Schrödinger equation an in practice the BBGKY hierarchy of equations is truncated in practice at the 1-, 2- or 3-body level at most [70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78]. The trace of the exchange + 2-body irreducible density matrices is independent of the particle interaction

∫ξ,ζ[nex(ξ,ζ,ζ,ξ)+ncorr(ξ,ζ,ζ,ξ)]≡−N2,(13)\int_{\xi,\zeta}\left[n_{\mathrm{ex}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta,\xi)+n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta,\xi)\right]\equiv-\frac{N}{2}, \tag*{(13)}

which justifies the Kohn-Sham introduction of the exchange-correlation energy density [79] and which naturally follows form the Kohn-Hohenberg theorem [80], which states that there is a one-to-one correspondence between the many-body wave function and the 1-body density distribution. There are many methods suggested over the years to go the beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation, and perhaps the most common is the shell model in different incarnations, the most recent version being the valence-space in-medium similarity renormalization group method (VS-IMSRG) in nuclear physics, recently extended to atomic systems, see Ref. [81] where comparison with other approaches, such as coupled clusters and configuration interaction, many-body perturbation theory, and earlier references are available. IMSRG framework requires however the construction of operators for observables in a reduced space, in this case for the density matrix n2(ξ,ζ,ζ′,ξ′)n_2(\xi,\zeta,\zeta',\xi'), which is not a simple and very transparent procedure [82]. The total, mean field, and correlation energies of a system with 2-body interactions V2bV_{2b} only are given by

Etot=Tr⁡(Tn1)+Tr⁡(n2V2b),(14)E_{\mathrm{tot}}=\operatorname{Tr}(Tn_1)+\operatorname{Tr}(n_2V_{2b}), \tag*{(14)}
Emf=Tr⁡(n2,mfV2b),n2,mf=n2−ncorr,(15)E_{\mathrm{mf}}=\operatorname{Tr}(n_{2,\mathrm{mf}}V_{2b}),\qquad n_{2,\mathrm{mf}}=n_2-n_{\mathrm{corr}}, \tag*{(15)}
Ecorr=Tr⁡(ncorrV2b),(16)E_{\mathrm{corr}}=\operatorname{Tr}(n_{\mathrm{corr}}V_{2b}), \tag*{(16)}

where TT is the kinetic energy and the trace is an integral over all spatial coordinates and a sum over spin-isospin coordinates. The correlation energy is negative for a repulsive V2bV_{2b} interaction and, together with the effect of the Fock contribution, leads to a bigger “Fermi hole,” particularly in the case of a short-ranged repulsive interaction, as one would expect (assuming the single-particle occupation probabilities nkn_k do not change). The opposite happens in the case of an attractive interaction. Eq. (13) suggests that the exchange and correlation effects act in opposite directions, a trend partially confirmed by microscopic calculations in the case of the homogeneous electron gas [78, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87].

For the sake of the following argument I introduce the coupling constant λ\lambda of the 2-body interaction λV2b\lambda V_{2b}, which is negative for attractive and positive for repulsive particle-particle interaction. In general an arbitrary 2-body interaction can have both attractive and repulsive parts, and for simplicity of the argument I define here a given 2-body interaction λV2b\lambda V_{2b} to be attractive if the interaction energy Tr⁡(λV2bncorr)<0\operatorname{Tr}(\lambda V_{2b}n_{\mathrm{corr}})<0 in the limit λ→−∞\lambda\to-\infty and repulsive otherwise. (For interactions with both repulsive and attractive parts this criterion should be applied with care.) The derivative of the correlation interaction energy with respect to the coupling constant (fixed nkn_k, thus first order perturbation in δλ\delta\lambda)

dEcorrdλ=Tr⁡(V2bncorr)≤0,(17)\frac{dE_{\mathrm{corr}}}{d\lambda}=\operatorname{Tr}(V_{2b}n_{\mathrm{corr}})\leq0, \tag*{(17)}

describes the effect of presence of 2-body correlations alone on the 2-particle distributions in the presence of 2-body interactions beyond the mean field. Eq. (17) shows that with increasing strength λ\lambda, from very strong attractive to very strong repulsive interaction, the correlation energy EcorrE_{\mathrm{corr}} decreases, which in the case of short-range interactions implies that the “Fermi hole” for two identical nucleons becomes bigger. The extreme values of the trace of Tr⁡(ncorr)\operatorname{Tr}(n_{\mathrm{corr}}), under the constraint ∑knk=N\sum_k n_k=N, are

−N2<−N2(1−NNsp)≤∫ξ,ζncorr(ξ,ζ,ζ,ξ)≤0(18)-\frac{N}{2}<-\frac{N}{2}\left(1-\frac{N}{N_{\mathrm{sp}}}\right)\leq\int_{\xi,\zeta}n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\zeta,\xi)\leq0 \tag*{(18)}

which are achieved for

nk=NNsp,for the minimum(19)n_k=\frac{N}{N_{\mathrm{sp}}},\qquad\text{for the minimum} \tag*{(19)}
nk=0ornk=1for the maximum(20)n_k=0\quad\text{or}\quad n_k=1\qquad\text{for the maximum} \tag*{(20)}

where NspN_{\mathrm{sp}} is the number of single-particle states, and which theoretically is infinite. The maximum value for Tr⁡(ncorr)=0\operatorname{Tr}(n_{\mathrm{corr}})=0 is achieved in the case of a Wigner crystal [36] for long-range very strong repulsive interactions (electron gas) [78, 83, 84, 85] or in the case of a gas for short-ranged very strong repulsive interactions. The minimum value is attained for a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer superconductor with very large attraction and zero spin polarization. In this limit, known as the Bore-Einstein Condensate (BEC) state, the unpolarized Fermi system is a gas of highly bound dimers/Cooper pairs) with sizes much smaller than the average interparticle separation and these dimers repel each other [88, 89]. In the limit of a Wigner gas (infinitely repulsive V2bV_{2b}) Tr⁡(nex)≡0\operatorname{Tr}(n_{\mathrm{ex}}) \equiv0 and in the opposite BEC limit (infinitely attractive V2bV_{2b}) Tr⁡(nex)=−N2/2Nsp\operatorname{Tr}(n_{\mathrm{ex}})=-N^{2}/2N_{\mathrm{sp}} is basically vanishing as well. In the case of attractive short-range interactions and finite spin polarization a wide range of phases are possible [39, 62, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97].

Since the main argument presented by Becke and Edgecombe [5] is based on the behavior of the 2-body number density in the limit when r1−r2→0r_{1}-r_{2}\to0 and equal spin and isospins, it becomes obvious that merely the presence of Pauli correlations is not a sufficient argument to judge the probability to find another particle nearby in a nuclear medium, in particularly when they have different spins and/or isospins. Correlations induced by the strong particle interactions are crucial and their character depends of whether the interaction is attractive or repulsive. The same rule in Eq. (12) for the 2-body irreducible density matrix is expected to be satisfied for any accurate many-body wave function ∣Φ⟩\lvert\Phi\rangle and since in the presence of interactions ∑knk(1−nk)≠0\sum_k n_k(1-n_k)\ne0 it becomes obvious that the procedure suggested in Ref. [5] and used quite extensively in nuclear physics [13–30] cannot describe the clusterization of matter. The ad hoc procedure adopted in these nuclear studies of the FLF as Cn,σ(r)Cp,σ(r)C_{n,\sigma}(r)C_{p,\sigma}(r) describes independent neutron and proton spin-number densities, and “does not describe correlated neutron-proton subsystems.” The recent study [29], pointing to the formation of α\alpha-like structures during nuclear fission is a clear example why the FLF is such an inadequate measure, as the authors of this study where unable to even determine whether either two 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}, 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He}, or 6He{}^{6}\mathrm{He} are present in the neck region. At the same time proton and neutron density distributions presented in the study [29] fail to show the presence of any cluster either before, during or after scission. One can fairly well decide that the cluster-like structures in the FLFs observed so far in these studies is fictitious or simply coincidental at best, since the FLF, which is a product Cn,σ(r)Cp,σ(r)C_{n,\sigma}(r)C_{p,\sigma}(r), cannot and does not describe correlations between proton and neutron subsystems, unlike the irreducible 2-body number density.

The nnnn- and pppp-pairing correlations (with S=0S=0 and T=1T=1) alone may lead to a significant correction the FLF. Similarly, the role of the npnp SRCs in localization effects is another aspect (summed over isospin), which cannot be described with the nuclear FLF Cn,σ(r)Cp,σ(r)C_{n,\sigma}(r)C_{p,\sigma}(r), but which can be simulated in a DFT framework by introducing a dynamic proton-neutron pairing [47, 49]. The presence of pairing correlations leads to another complication, due to the fact that the gauge or particle conservation symmetry is broken.In the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) approximation the 2-body density matrix has the structure

n2(ξ,ζ,ξ′,ζ′)=⟨ΦHFB∣ψ†(ξ)ψ†(ζ)ψ(ζ′)ψ(ξ′)∣ΦHFB⟩=12[n1(ξ,ξ′)n1(ζ,ζ′)−n1(ξ,ζ′)n1(ζ,ξ′)]+12κ(ξ,ζ)κ∗(ξ′,ζ′),(21)\begin{aligned} n_{2}(\xi,\zeta,\xi',\zeta')=\langle\Phi_{HFB}\lvert\psi^{\dagger}(\xi)\psi^{\dagger}(\zeta)\psi(\zeta')\psi(\xi')\rvert\Phi_{HFB}\rangle\\ &=\frac{1}{2}\left[n_{1}(\xi,\xi')n_{1}(\zeta,\zeta')-n_{1}(\xi,\zeta')n_{1}(\zeta,\xi')\right] +\frac{1}{2}\kappa(\xi,\zeta)\kappa^{*}(\xi',\zeta'), \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

where κ(ξ,ζ)=⟨ΦHFB∣ψ(ζ)ψ(ξ)∣ΦHFB⟩\kappa(\xi,\zeta)=\langle\Phi_{HFB}\lvert\psi(\zeta)\psi(\xi)\rvert\Phi_{HFB}\rangle is the anomalous density-matrix and the corresponding irreducible 2-body density matrix satisfies now the incorrect condition

12∑ξ,ζ∣κ(ξ,ζ)∣2≥0,(22)\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\xi,\zeta}\lvert\kappa(\xi,\zeta)\rvert^{2}\ge0, \tag*{(22)}

with the an opposite sign to Eq. (12) and as a result the corresponding 2-body density matrix do not satisfy anymore the expected sum rule defined in Eq. (11). This aspect can be corrected only after the particle projection of the HFB many-wave function ΦHFB\Phi_{HFB} is performed. Consequently, the improved Dτ(r)\mathcal{D}_{\tau}(r) introduced in Eq. (6) cannot be expected to lead to a correct outcome in the presence of pairing correlations, unless particle projection is performed when evaluating the 2-body density matrix. The particle projected occupation probabilities nkn_k and the corresponding particle projected HFB 2-body density matrix n2(ξ,ζ,ξ′,ζ′)n_{2}(\xi,\zeta,\xi',\zeta') can be easily evaluated [98]. Pairing correlations are particular example when the irreducible density matrix ncorr(ξ,ζ,ξ′,ζ′)n_{\mathrm{corr}}(\xi,\zeta,\xi',\zeta') plays a large role and the role of exchange effects is reduced.

In summary, I have shown that the use of the FLF introduced by Becke and Edgecombe [5] and widely used in theoretical nuclear studies [13–30] is ill-justified and cannot correctly describe clusterization effects, which require the knowledge of the irreducible 2-body number density ncorrn_{\mathrm{corr}} if a similar approach is adopted. The cases of the Wigner crystal and of the unitary Fermi gas in the BEC limit discussed above are clear examples where FLF fails to disentangle the “clusters.” Another example would be a system of two dimers, one a relatively strongly bound “S=1S=1 neutron dimer” and the other a relatively strongly bound “S=1S=1 proton dimer,” when either these two dimers repel in a trap or are weakly bound. Particularly large errors can be incurred when including pairing correlations within the energy density functional, which are ubiquitous nuclear systems discussed so far in literature, and which have a significant impact on various nuclear properties. The homogeneous electron gas [78, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87], neutron matter with chiral effective 2- and 3-body interactions [50, 51, 52] and the dilute Fermi gas, particularly in the unitary and BEC regime, are examples of microscopic well-studied systems [37, 39, 62, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97] [10, 12], where the role of both exchange, correlations , and temperature effects are important. The case of quarks localized inside hadrons is the most notable example of the dominant role of strong correlations effects.

Acknowledgements

I thank G. Scamps and M. Kafker for reading the paper and asking for clarifications on an initial version, which improved the present version. The funding from the US DOE, Office of Science, Grant No. DE-FG02-97ER41014 and also the support provided in part by NNSA cooperative Agreement DE-NA0003841 is greatly appreciated.

References

References

  1. [35]M. Brack and R. K. Bhaduri, Semiclassical Physics, Frontiers in Physics, Vol. 96 (Addison-Wesley, Reading Massuchustets, 1997).
  2. [36]E. Wigner, “On the Interaction of Electrons in Metals,” Phys. Rev. 46, 1002 (1934).
  3. [37]W. Zwerger, ed., The BCS-BEC Crossover and the Unitary Fermi Gas, Lecture Notes in Physics, Vol. 836 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg, 2012).
  4. [38]A. Bulgac, “Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approximation for finite systems,” (1980), arXiv:nucl-th/9907088.
  5. [39]A. Bulgac and Y. Yu, “Renormalization of the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov Equations in the Case of a Zero Range Pairing Interaction,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 042504 (2002).
  6. [40]A. Bulgac, “Local density approximation for systems with pairing correlations,” Phys. Rev. C 65, 051305 (2002).
  7. [41]S. Tan, “Energetics of a strongly correlated Fermi gas,” Ann. Phys. 323, 2952 (2008).
  8. [42]S. Tan, “Large momentum part of a strongly correlated Fermi gas,” Ann. Phys. 323, 2971 (2008).DOI
  9. [43]S. Tan, “Generalized virial theorem and pressure relation for a strongly correlated Fermi gas,” Ann. Phys. 323, 2987 (2008).DOI
  10. [44]S. Gandolfi, K. E. Schmidt, and J. Carlson, “BEC-BCS crossover and universal relations in unitary Fermi gases,” Phys. Rev. A 83, 041601 (2011).DOI
  11. [45]J. Carlson, S. Gandolfi, F. Pederiva, Steven C. Pieper, R. Schiavilla, K. E. Schmidt, and R. B. Wiringa, “Quantum Monte Carlo methods for nuclear physic,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 87, 1067 (2015).
  12. [46]A. Bulgac, “Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory for Fermionic Superfluids: from Cold Atomic gases, to Nuclei and Neutron Star Crust,” Physica Status Solidi B 256, 1800592 (2019).DOI
  13. [47]A. Bulgac, “Pure quantum extension of the semiclassical Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck equation,” Phys. Rev. C 105, L021601 (2022).DOI
  14. [48]A. Bulgac, M. Kafker, and I. Abdurrahman, “Measures of complexity and entanglement in many-fermion systems,” Phys. Rev. C 107, 044318 (2023).DOI
  15. [49]A. Bulgac, “Entanglement entropy, single-particle occupation probabilities, and short-range correlations,” Phys. Rev. C 107, L061602 (2023).DOI
  16. [50]A. Roggero, A. Mukherjee, and F. Pederiva, “Quantum Monte Carlo Calculations of Neutron Matter with Non-local Chiral Interactions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 221103 (2014).DOI
  17. [51]G. Wlazłowski, J. W. Holt, S. Moroz, A. Bulgac, and K. J. Roche, “Auxiliary-Field Quantum Monte Carlo Simulations of Neutron Matter in Chiral Effective Field Theory,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 182503 (2014).
  18. [52]I. Tews, S. Gandolfi, A. Gezerlis, and A. Schwenk, “Quantum Monte Carlo calculations of neutron matter with chiral three-body forces,” Phys. Rev. C 93, 024305 (2016).DOI
  19. [53]J. S. Levinger, “The High Energy Nuclear Photoeffect,” Phys. Rev. 84, 43 (1951).
  20. [54]J.S. Levinger, “Fifty years of the quasi-deuteron model,” Nuclear Physics A 699, 255–260 (2002), 3rd Int. Conf. on Perspectives in Hadronic Physics.DOI
  21. [55]O. Hen et al., “Momentum sharing in imbalanced Fermi systems,” Science 346, 614 (2014).DOI
  22. [56]O. Hen, G. A. Miller, E. Piasetzky, and L. B. Weinstein, “Nucleon-nucleon correlations, short-lived excitations, and the quarks within,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 89,DOI
  23. [57]R. Cruz-Torres, A. Schmidt, G.A. Miller, L.B. Weinstein, N. Barnea, R. Weiss, E. Piasetzky, and O. Hen, “Short range correlations and the isospin dependence of nuclear correlation functions,” Phys. Lett. B 785, 304 (2018).
  24. [58]R. Cruz-Torres, D. Lonardoni, R. Weiss, M. Piarulli, N. Barnea, D. W. Higinbotham, E. Piasetzky, A. Schmidt, L. B. Weinstein, R. B. Wiringa, and O. Hen, “Many-body factorization and position–momentum equivalence of nuclear short-range correlations,” Nature Physics 17, 306 (2021).DOI
  25. [59]A. Bulgac, P. Magierski, K. J. Roche, and I. Stetcu, “Induced Fission of 240Pu within a Real-Time Microscopic Framework,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 122504 (2016).DOI
  26. [60]A. Bulgac, S. Jin, K. J. Roche, N. Schunck, and I. Stetcu, “Fission dynamics of 240Pu from saddle to scission and beyond,” Phys. Rev. C 100, 034615 (2019).DOI
  27. [61]A. Bulgac, S. Jin, and I. Stetcu, “Nuclear Fission Dynamics: Past, Present, Needs, and Future,” Frontiers in Physics 8, 63 (2020).DOI
  28. [62]A. Richie-Halford, J. E. Drut, and A. Bulgac, “Emergence of a Pseudogap in the BCS-BEC Crossover,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 060403 (2020).
  29. [63]A. Bulgac, “New developments in fission studies within the time-dependent density functional theory framework,” EPJ Web of Conferences 284, 04001 (2023).DOI
  30. [64]P. Magierski, A. Makowski, M. C. Barton, K. Sekizawa, and G. Wlazłowski, “Pairing dynamics and solitonic excitations in collisions of medium-mass, identical nuclei,” Phys. Rev. C 105, 064602 (2022).DOI
  31. [65]P. J. Borycki, J. Dobaczewski, W. Nazarewicz, and M. V. Stoitsov, “Pairing renormalization and regularization within the local density approximation,” Phys. Rev. C 73, 044319 (2006).DOI
  32. [66]R. Schiavilla, R. B. Wiringa, S. C. Pieper, and J. Carlson, “Tensor forces and the ground-state structure of nuclei,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 132501 (2007).
  33. [67]P.-O. Löwdin, “Quantum Theory of Many-Particle Systems. I. Physical Interpretations by Means of Density Matrices, Natural Spin-Orbitals, and Convergence Problems in the Method of Configurational Interaction,” Phys. Rev. 97, 1474 (1955).DOI
  34. [68]P.-O. Löwdin and H. Shull, “Natural Orbitals in the Quantum Theory of Two-Electron Systems,” Phys. Rev. 101, 1730 (1956).
  35. [69]K. Huang, Statistical Mechanics (John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1987).
  36. [70]D. S. Koltun, “Total Binding Energies of Nuclei, and Particle-Removal Experiments,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 182 (1972).DOI
  37. [71]M. Bernheim, A. Bussière, A. Gilleber, J. Mougey, Phan Xuan Ho, M. Priou, D. Royer, I. Sick, and G. J. Wagner, “12C(e, e′p) Results as a Critical Test of an Energy Sum Rule,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 898 (1974).DOI
  38. [72]A. Faessler, S. Krewald, and G. J. Wagner, “Is there evidence of three-body forces from violation of the Koltun energy sum rule?” Phys. Rev. C 11, 2069 (1975).DOI
  39. [73]S. Adachi and P. Schuck, “Landau’s collision term in the memory function approach to the nuclear response function and the spreading width of giant resonances,” Nucl. Phys. A 496, 485 (1989).DOI
  40. [74]J. Dukelsky, G. Röpke, and P. Schuck, “Generalized Brückner-Hartree-Fock theory and self-consistent RPA,” Nucl. Phys. A 628, 17 (1998).
  41. [75]P. Schuck and M. Tohyama, “Progress in many-body theory with the equation of motion method: Time-dependent density matrix meets self-consistent RPA and applications to solvable models,” Phys. Rev. B 93, 165117 (2016).DOI
  42. [76]A. Cipollone, C. Barbieri, and P. Navrátil, “Isotopic Chains Around Oxygen from Evolved Chiral Two- and Three-Nucleon Interactions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 062501 (2013).
  43. [77]A. Carbone, A. Cipollone, C. Barbieri, A. Rios, and A. Polls, “Self-consistent Green’s functions formalism with three-body interactions,” Phys. Rev. C 88, 054326 (2013).DOI
  44. [78]J. J. Kas, T. D. Blanton, and J. J. Rehr, “Exchange-correlation contributions to thermodynamic properties of the homogeneous electron gas from a cumulant Green’s function approach,” Phys. Rev. B 100, 195144 (2019).DOI
  45. [79]W. Kohn and L. J. Sham, “Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects,” Phys. Rev. 140, A1133 (1965).
  46. [80]P. Hohenberg and W. Kohn, “Inhomogeneous Electron Gas,” Phys. Rev. 136, B864 (1964).
  47. [81]G. Tenkila, V. Chand, T. Miyagi, H. Patel, S. R. Stroberg, R. F. Garcia Ruiz, and J. D. Holt, “Ab initio in-medium similarity renormalization group for open-shell atomic systems,” (2022), arXiv:2212.08188 [physics.atom-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2212.08188
  48. [82]A. J. Tropiano, S. K. Bogner, R. J. Furnstahl, and M. A. Hisham, “Quasi-deuteron model at low renormalization group resolution,” Phys. Rev. C 106, 024324 (2022).DOI
  49. [83]V. V. Karasiev, T. Sjostrom, J. Dufty, and S. B. Trickey, “Accurate Homogeneous Electron Gas Exchange-Correlation Free Energy for Local Spin-Density Calculations,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 076403 (2014).
  50. [84]T. Chachiyo, “Simple and accurate uniform electron gas correlation energy for the full range of densities,” J. Chem. Phys. 145, 021101 (2016).DOI
  51. [85]V. V. Karasiev, “Comment on “Communication: Simple and accurate uniform electron gas correlation energy for the full range of densities”,” J. Chem. Phys. 145, 157101 (2016).
  52. [86]T. Dornheim, S. Groth, and M. Bonitz, “The uniform electron gas at warm dense matter conditions,” Phys. Rep. 744, 1 (2018).
  53. [87]M. Bonitz, T. Dornheim, Zh. A. Moldabekov, S. Zhang, P. Hamann, H. Kählert, A. Filinov, K. Ramakrishna, and J. Vorberger, “Ab initio simulation of warm dense matter,” Phys. of Plasmas 27, 042710 (2020).
  54. [88]M. Randeria, “Crossover from BCS Theory to Bose-Einstein Condensation,” in Bose-Einstein Condensation, edited by A. Griffin, D. W. Snoke, and S. Stringari (Cambridge University Press, 1995).
  55. [89]D. S. Petrov, C. Salomon, and G. V. Shlyapnikov, “Weakly Bound Dimers of Fermionic Atoms,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 090404 (2004).
  56. [90]A. Bulgac, “Dilute Quantum Droplets,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 050402 (2002).
  57. [91]A. Bulgac, M. M. Forbes, and A. Schwenk, “Induced P-Wave Superfluidity in Asymmetric Fermi Gases,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 020402 (2006).
  58. [92]A. Bulgac and M. M. Forbes, “Zero-temperature thermodynamics of asymmetric Fermi gases at unitarity,” Phys. Rev. A 75, 031605 (2007).DOI
  59. [93]A. Bulgac and M. M. Forbes, “Unitary Fermi Superfluid: The Larkin-Ovchinnikov Phase,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 215301 (2008).
  60. [94]P. Magierski, G. Wlazłowski, A. Bulgac, and J. E. Drut, “Finite-Temperature Pairing Gap of a Unitary Fermi Gas by Quantum Monte Carlo Calculations,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 210403 (2009).
  61. [95]P. Magierski, G. Wlazłowski, and A. Bulgac, “Onset of a Pseudogap Regime in Ultracold Fermi Gases,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 145304 (2011).
  62. [96]G. Wlazłowski, P. Magierski, J. E. Drut, A. Bulgac, and K. J. Roche, “Cooper Pairing Above the Critical Temperature in a Unitary Fermi Gas,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 090401 (2013).
  63. [97]P. Magierski, B. Tü zemen, and G. Wlazłowski, “Spin-polarized droplets in the unitary Fermi gas,” Phys. Rev. A 100, 036313 (2019).DOI
  64. [98]A. Bulgac, “Restoring broken symmetries for nuclei and reaction fragments,” Phys. Rev. C 104, 054601 (2021).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vuuzeakz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents