betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Magnetic Power in Binaries: From Coalescing Binary Neutron Stars to Close-in Exoplanetary Systems

Abstract

A binary system containing two magnetic components ("stars") can be modeled as a circuit powered by the orbital motion, with the magnetic field lines linking the two stars serving as wires. When the total resistance in the binary components is small – as found in many astrophysical systems such as binary neutron stars and extra-solar hot-Jupiter or super-Earth systems – the connected field lines are twisted and open up in a quasi-cyclic manner, leading to quasi-periodic energy dissipation and flares. We derive analytic expressions for the average and episodic magnetic powers from such systems, providing a quantitative description on how the powers depend on the magnetic orientations of the two stars. The power can be much larger than in the case where one of the stars has a negligible magnetic field. It may manifest as pre-merger quasi-cyclic flares in coalescing neutron-star binaries and as orbit-regulated radio emissions in exoplanetary systems.

Introduction. The electrodynamic coupling of a magnetized body to its companion has a long history. Goldreich and Lynden-Bell [1] developed a DC circuit model for the magnetic interaction between Jupiter and its satellite Io. In this model, Io’s orbital motion through Jupiter’s rotating magnetosphere generates an electromotive force, driving a DC current between the two bodies, with the flux tube linking them acting as the conducting wire. This model helped explain Jupiter’s decametric radio emission that is modulated by Io’s orbital motion (e.g., [2]).

The Jupiter–Io system represents a high-resistance binary pair, where the flux tube connecting the planet and satellite is steady, with dissipation balancing the flux twisting driven by spin and orbital motion. By contrast, in most binary systems — including star–star and star–planet systems (e.g., [3, 4, 5, 6, 7]) and binary neutron stars or white dwarfs [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13] — the resistance associated with the binary components is likely small. Dissipation then occurs in the tenuous plasma between and around the binary, in the form of reconnection-driven flares [10, 14], and the circuit connecting the two bodies is expected to be in a quasi-cyclic state [11, 12, 15].

The Jupiter–Io system can be modeled as a magnetic body (planet) interacting with an unmagnetized conductor (Io). Many binary systems, however, have non-negligible magnetic fields in both components, so that the linked flux — and hence the magnetic power — depends on the relative orientation of the two magnetic dipoles. What, then, is the magnetic power in such systems?

In recent years, numerical simulations of such electrodynamic interactions have been carried out in different contexts, from close-in star–planet systems [6] to magnetic neutron-star binaries [10, 11, 12]. Although these simulations address specific magnetic configurations and parameters, they support the general picture of a quasi-cyclic DC circuit established by the field lines linking the two components, with the linkage interrupted by magnetic dissipation. However, a quantitative description of the power for generic magnetic configurations and parameters is still lacking.

Lai [15] derived the maximum magnetic power for a ”magnetic + non-magnetic” system in the low-resistance limit. Here we generalize the analysis to binary systems in which both components are magnetic, and obtain the average and episodic powers as functions of the relative dipole orientation.

Magnetic Torque and Power. Consider a binary system consisting of two stars: the primary has mass M1M_1, radius R1R_1, and magnetic dipole moment μ1\mu_1, and the secondary has M2M_2, R2R_2, and μ2\mu_2. We take μ1≥μ2\mu_1 \ge\mu_2. The orbital separation is aa, and the orbital angular frequency is Ω\Omega. The polar magnetic field strength at surface of the primary is B1=2μ1/R13B_1 = 2\mu_1/R_1^3, and similarly B2=2μ2/R23B_2 = 2\mu_2/R_2^3. The binary system is embedded in a tenuous plasma. For simplicity, we neglect stellar spin (see [16]).

The interaction of the two stars can be understood as follows. Suppose there are magnetic field lines connecting the two stars. An effective DC circuit is set up, with the EMF driven by the orbital motion, and the linked field lines serving as wires [1, 15]. When the system’s total resistance satisfies Rtot≲16vrel/c2R_{\rm tot} \lesssim16v_{\rm rel}/c^2, where vrelv_{\rm rel} is the relative orbital velocity, a steady-state DC circuit can not be maintained [15]. Based on the studies of solar flares and magnetic star-disk systems, where magnetic flux tubes connecting different regions of the system are twisted by differential motion (e.g., [17, 18, 19, 20, 21]), the magnetic binary system may exhibit the following quasi-cyclic behavior:

  • A magnetic flux tube naturally connects the two stars, establishing magnetic linkage between them.

  • The linked fields are twisted by the orbital motion, generating a toroidal field from the linked poloidal field.

  • Once the toroidal magnetic field becomes comparable to the poloidal field, the fields inflate as mag-

netic bubbles and the flux tube breaks, disrupting the magnetic linkage.

  • Reconnection between the inflated field lines relaxes the twist and restores the magnetic linkage between the two stars.

  • The cycle restarts.

This cyclic behavior has been observed in recent 3D simulations of specific magnetic binary systems [6, 11, 12].

To estimate the magnetic power based on the above picture, we first consider the case where both magnetic dipoles are perpendicular to the orbital plane and are anti-aligned with each other. A flux tube connects the two stars (see Figure 1). Note that because of the magnetic interaction, the effective size of the secondary, rm2r_{\mathrm{m2}}, is determined by magnetic pressure balance (assuming that the magnetic pressure dominates over the plasma ram pressure and thermal pressure), i.e. μ1/(a−rm2)3=μ2/rm23\mu_1/(a-r_{\mathrm{m2}})^3 = \mu_2/r_{\mathrm{m2}}^3, giving

Magnetic field configurations of two dipoles in vacuum

Figure 1. Magnetic field configurations of two dipoles in vacuum. The two dipoles (μ1\mu_1 and μ2\mu_2) are separated by a distance aa (the binary separation), are oriented from zz-axis (the binary orbital angular momentum axis) by the angles θ1\theta_1 and θ2\theta_2 (measured clockwise from the zz-axis). In these examples, the two dipole vectors are in the same plane, and μ2/μ1=0.01\mu_2/\mu_1 = 0.01 is assumed. In general, there are three types of field lines: closed field lines of μ1\mu_1 (blue), closed field lines of μ2\mu_2 (orange), and linked field lines that connect the two dipoles (purple). For the aligned configuration (the right panel), there are no directly linked field lines in the absence of dissipation.

rm2a=λ1+λ,with λ≡(μ2μ1)1/3.(1)\frac{r_{\mathrm{m2}}}{a} = \frac{\lambda}{1+\lambda}, \quad\text{with } \lambda\equiv\left(\frac{\mu_2}{\mu_1}\right)^{1/3}. \tag*{(1)}

The region r2≲rm2r_2 \lesssim r_{\mathrm{m2}} (where r2r_2 is the radius measured from the center of M2M_2) defines the secondary’s magnetosphere. Let Bz1(a)=μ1/a3B_{z1}(a) = \mu_1/a^3 be the vertical (perpendicular to the orbital plane) magnetic field from the primary at the location of the secondary. The azimuthal magnetic force per unit area (measured across the flux tube) acting on the secondary is Bz1Bϕ+/(2π)B_{z1}B_{\phi+}/(2\pi), where Bϕ+B_{\phi+} is the toroidal field on the upper side the flux tube around the secondary. For a given twist ζϕ≡−Bϕ+/Bz1\zeta_\phi\equiv-B_{\phi+}/B_{z1}, the magnetic torque on the secondary is

Tmag∼−12πζϕBz12πrm22a∼−ζϕ2πaBz1ΦL,(2)T_{\mathrm{mag}} \sim-\frac{1}{2\pi}\zeta_\phi B_{z1}^{2}\pi r_{\mathrm{m2}}^{2}a \sim-\frac{\zeta_\phi}{2\pi}aB_{z1}\Phi_L, \tag*{(2)}

where ΦL∼Bz1πrm22\Phi_L \sim B_{z1}\pi r_{\mathrm{m2}}^2 is the linked magnetic flux.

In this picture, the mechanical energy of the binary is converted to the magnetic energy (in the form of toroidal field) at the rate −TmagΩ-T_{\mathrm{mag}}\Omega. When the twist reaches ζϕ=ζϕ,max⁡∼π\zeta_\phi= \zeta_{\phi,\max} \sim\pi, the magnetic field inflates rapidly, generating a magnetic bubble (“flare”). The time-averaged magnetic dissipation power is then

Lˉmag=−TˉmagΩ∼ζˉϕ2πaΩBz1ΦL,(3)\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}} = -\bar{T}_{\mathrm{mag}}\Omega\sim\frac{\bar{\zeta}_\phi}{2\pi}a\Omega B_{z1}\Phi_L, \tag*{(3)}

where the time-averaged twist ζˉϕ∼ζϕ,max⁡/2∼π/2\bar{\zeta}_\phi\sim\zeta_{\phi,\max}/2 \sim\pi/2.

Thus, for general binary/magnetic geometry, we suggest the following parameterization for the time-averaged magnetic power and torque:

Lˉmag=−TˉmagΩ=12ζˉϕfϕaΩ(μ1a3)2rm22=12ζˉϕfϕ(λ1+λ)2Ωμ12a3,(4)\begin{aligned} \bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}} = -\bar{T}_{\mathrm{mag}}\Omega\\ &= \frac{1}{2}\bar{\zeta}_\phi f_\phi a\Omega\left(\frac{\mu_1}{a^3}\right)^2r_{\mathrm{m2}}^2 \\ &= \frac{1}{2}\bar{\zeta}_\phi f_\phi\left(\frac{\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)^2\Omega\frac{\mu_1^2}{a^3}, \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where fϕf_\phi is the dimensionless flux parameter

fϕ≡ΦLπrm22Bz1(a)=ΦLπrm22μ1/a3.(5)f_\phi\equiv\frac{\Phi_L}{\pi r_{\mathrm{m2}}^2B_{z1}(a)} = \frac{\Phi_L}{\pi r_{\mathrm{m2}}^2\mu_1/a^3}. \tag*{(5)}

The magnetic energy is released in quasi-periodic episodic flares. The stored energy in the twisted magnetic field is given by

Etwist=∫0Tdt Lmag≃14ζϕ,max⁡2fΦ(λ1+λ)2μ12a3,(6)\mathcal{E}_{\rm twist} = \int_0^T \mathrm{d}t\,L_{\rm mag} \simeq\frac{1}{4}\zeta_{\phi,\max}^{2} f_{\Phi}\left(\frac{\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)^2\frac{\mu_1^2}{a^3}, \tag*{(6)}

where TT is the twist-and-release period, and we have used ζϕ≃Ωt\zeta_\phi\simeq\Omega t and ζϕ,max⁡≃ΩT\zeta_{\phi,\max} \simeq\Omega T. If this energy is released on a short dissipative timescale tdisst_{\rm diss} (≪1/Ω\ll1/\Omega), the flare luminosity is

Lflare≃Etwist/tdiss.(7)L_{\rm flare} \simeq\mathcal{E}_{\rm twist}/t_{\rm diss}. \tag*{(7)}

Linked Magnetic Flux

Figure 2 shows fΦf_\Phi as a function of λ\lambda in the range from λ≪1\lambda\ll1 to λ=1\lambda= 1 for the anti-aligned configuration. We find that fΦf_\Phi increases from 3 for λ→0\lambda\to0 to 32/π32/\pi for λ=1\lambda= 1 (see Appendix).

Dimensionless linked magnetic flux as a function of $\lambda$

Figure 2. The dimensionless linked magnetic flux (defined by Eq. (5)) as a function of λ=(μ2/μ1)1/3\lambda= (\mu_2/\mu_1)^{1/3} for two anti-aligned dipoles (θ1=180∘\theta_1 = 180^\circ and θ2=0\theta_2 = 0). See the left panel of Figure 1.

In general, fΦf_\Phi depends on λ\lambda and on the orientations of the dipoles. For concreteness, we consider θ1=180∘\theta_1 = 180^\circ (so that μ1\boldsymbol{\mu}_1 is anti-aligned with the orbital axis z^\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}). The orientation of μ2\boldsymbol{\mu}_2 is specified by the polar angles (θ2,φ2)(\theta_2,\varphi_2). Figure 3 shows fΦf_\Phi as a function of θ2\theta_2 (assuming φ2=0\varphi_2 = 0) for several values of μ2/μ1=λ3\mu_2/\mu_1 = \lambda^3. In the limit of λ→0\lambda\to0, fΦf_\Phi is given by (to within 5.8%) (see Appendix)

Dimensionless linked magnetic flux as a function of $\theta_2$

Figure 3. The dimensionless linked magnetic flux (defined by Eq. (5)) of two dipoles as a function of θ2\theta_2, for several values of μ2/μ1\mu_2/\mu_1, assuming θ1=180∘\theta_1 = 180^\circ. The dotted lines correspond to the function fΦ(θ2=0)cos⁡(θ2/2)f_\Phi(\theta_2 = 0)\cos(\theta_2/2).

fΦ(λ,θ2)≃3cos⁡(θ2/2),(θ1=180∘, λ→0).(8)f_\Phi(\lambda,\theta_2) \simeq3\cos(\theta_2/2), \qquad(\theta_1 = 180^\circ,\ \lambda\to0). \tag*{(8)}

For general values of λ\lambda, we see that fΦf_\Phi is still well approximated (to within 10%) by

fΦ(λ,θ2)≃fΦ(λ,θ2=0)cos⁡(θ2/2),(θ1=180∘),(9)f_\Phi(\lambda,\theta_2) \simeq f_\Phi(\lambda,\theta_2 = 0)\cos(\theta_2/2), \qquad(\theta_1 = 180^\circ), \tag*{(9)}

with fΦ(λ,θ2=0)f_\Phi(\lambda,\theta_2 = 0) ranges from 3 to 32/π32/\pi for λ∈[0,1]\lambda\in[0,1]. Note that for λ≪1\lambda\ll1, fΦf_\Phi is independent of φ2\varphi_2. Even for

λ=1\lambda= 1, the dependence of fΦf_\Phi on φ2\varphi_2 is quite weak (see Figure 4).

Dimensionless linked magnetic flux as a function of $\varphi_2$

Figure 4. The dimensionless linked magnetic flux (defined by Eq. (5)) of two dipoles as a function of φ2\varphi_2 for several values of θ2\theta_2 (assuming θ1=180∘\theta_1 = 180^\circ and λ=1\lambda= 1).

Clearly, maximum power is achieved for θ2=0\theta_2 = 0 (anti-aligned configuration). For θ2=180∘\theta_2 = 180^\circ (aligned configuration), there is no linked flux in the “natural” (untwisted) state of the system. Also when rm2≲R2r_{\rm m2} \lesssim R_2 (non-magnetic secondary star), there is no linked flux in the absence of plasma dissipation. Such configurations tend to produce lower level of magnetic power compared to systems with naturally linked flux. For example, for system with rm2≪R2r_{m2} \ll R_2, the time-averaged magnetic power is expected to be [15]

Lˉmag(0)≃12ζϕΩμ12R22a5.(10)\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}}^{(0)} \simeq\frac{1}{2}\zeta_\phi\Omega\frac{\mu_1^2 R_2^2}{a^5}. \tag*{(10)}

For aligned system with magnetic components, turbulent dissipation could arise from Kelvin–Helmholtz instability at the interface of the stellar magnetospheres [13] – this effect is no captured in our analysis above.

Effect of Finite Stellar Sizes. In the above we have assumed a≫R1,R2a \gg R_1, R_2 and rm2≳R2r_{m2} \gtrsim R_2. Since magnetic interaction is likely most important when aa is not much larger than R1R_1 and R2R_2, it is necessary to consider the effect of finite stellar sizes. For concreteness, consider the anti-aligned configuration (θ1=180∘\theta_1 = 180^\circ and θ2=0\theta_2 = 0). Neglecting high-order (quadrupole or higher) effects, the magnetic field of μ1\mu_1 acting on the secondary (assumed to be a perfect conductor) induces a dipole μ2,ind=μ1(R23/2a3)\mu_{2,\mathrm{ind}} = \mu_1(R_2^3/2a^3) in the direction aligned with μ1\mu_1 (i.e. opposite to μ2\mu_2); similarly, the primary attains an induced dipole μ1,ind=μ2(R13/2a3)\mu_{1,\mathrm{ind}} = \mu_2(R_1^3/2a^3). Thus, in the natural (untwisted) state, the poloidal field of the system is produced by two effective dipoles

μ1,eff=μ1−(R13/2a3)μ2,(11)\mu_{1,\mathrm{eff}} = \mu_1 - (R_1^3/2a^3)\mu_2, \tag*{(11)}
μ2,eff=μ2−(R23/2a3)μ1.(12)\mu_{2,\mathrm{eff}} = \mu_2 - (R_2^3/2a^3)\mu_1. \tag*{(12)}

With this, the calculation of the linked flux can proceed in the same way as above.

As an example, for systems with μ1=μ2\mu_1 = \mu_2 and R1=R2R_1 = R_2, we find

Lˉmag≃18ζϕfϕΩμ12a3(1−R13a3),(λ=1, anti−aligned).(13)\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}} \simeq\frac{1}{8}\zeta_\phi f_\phi\Omega\frac{\mu_1^2}{a^3}\left(1-\frac{R_1^3}{a^3}\right), \qquad(\lambda= 1,\ \mathrm{anti-aligned}). \tag*{(13)}

Application: Neutron-Star Binaries. Gravitational wave (GW) emission drives the orbital decay of the neutron star (NS) binary, with timescale

tGW=(a∣a˙∣)GW=5c5a464G3M13q(1+q)≃1.47 s(a100 km)4(14)t_{\mathrm{GW}} = \left(\frac{a}{|\dot{a}|}\right)_{\mathrm{GW}} = \frac{5c^5a^4}{64G^3M_1^3q(1+q)} \simeq1.47\ \mathrm{s}\left(\frac{a}{100\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^4 \tag*{(14)}

where in last equality we have adopted M1=1.4M⊙M_1 = 1.4M_\odot and mass ratio q=M2/M1=1q = M_2/M_1 = 1. Note that the gravitational wave frequency is fGW=193 (a/100 km)−3/2 Hzf_{\mathrm{GW}} = 193\ (a/100\ \mathrm{km})^{-3/2}\ \mathrm{Hz}.

The time-averaged magnetic energy dissipation rate is

Lˉmag≃1.9×1042ζˉϕfΦ(2λ1+λ)2(B11013 G)2(R110 km)6(a100 km)−9/2 erg s−1.(15)\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}} \simeq1.9 \times10^{42}\bar{\zeta}_\phi f_\Phi\left(\frac{2\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)^2 \left(\frac{B_1}{10^{13}\ \mathrm{G}}\right)^2 \left(\frac{R_1}{10\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^6 \left(\frac{a}{100\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^{-9/2}\ \mathrm{erg\ s^{-1}}. \tag*{(15)}

Compared to the GW power, the ratio is

LˉmagLGW≃1.1×10−10ζˉϕfΦ(2λ1+λ)2(B11013 G)2(R110 km)6(a100 km)1/2.(16)\frac{\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}}}{L_{\mathrm{GW}}} \simeq1.1 \times10^{-10}\bar{\zeta}_\phi f_\Phi\left(\frac{2\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)^2 \left(\frac{B_1}{10^{13}\ \mathrm{G}}\right)^2 \left(\frac{R_1}{10\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^6 \left(\frac{a}{100\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^{1/2}. \tag*{(16)}

The magnetic power leads to a phase shift to the binary inspiral waveform, given by [15]

ΔΦGW≃−2π(LˉmagLGW)(dNdln⁡f)0,(17)\Delta\Phi_{\mathrm{GW}} \simeq-2\pi\left(\frac{\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}}}{L_{\mathrm{GW}}}\right)\left(\frac{dN}{d\ln f}\right)_0, \tag*{(17)}

where

(dNdln⁡fGW)0=23fGWtGW=5c5(1+q)1/396πqM15/3(πGfGW)5/3\left(\frac{dN}{d\ln f_{\mathrm{GW}}}\right)_0 = \frac{2}{3}f_{\mathrm{GW}}t_{\mathrm{GW}} = \frac{5c^5(1+q)^{1/3}}{96\pi qM_1^{5/3}(\pi Gf_{\mathrm{GW}})^{5/3}}
≃190(a100 km)5/2≃574(fGW100 Hz)−5/3(18)\simeq190\left(\frac{a}{100\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^{5/2} \simeq574\left(\frac{f_{\mathrm{GW}}}{100\ \mathrm{Hz}}\right)^{-5/3} \tag*{(18)}

is the usual leading-order point-mass GW cycles. We see that ∣ΔΦGW∣≪1|\Delta\Phi_{\mathrm{GW}}| \ll1 even for B1B_1 as large as 1015 G10^{15}\ \mathrm{G}.

On the other hand, the dissipation of the twisted fields is likely due to fast magnetic reconnection (with Alfven speed ≃c\simeq c), thus tdiss∼a/ct_{\mathrm{diss}} \sim a/c, and the flare luminosity is

Lflare≃4.7×1042ζϕ,max2fΦ(2λ1+λ)2(B11013 G)2×(R110 km)6(a100 km)−4(a/ctdiss) erg s−1.(19)\begin{aligned} L_{\mathrm{flare}} \simeq4.7 \times10^{42}\zeta_{\phi,\mathrm{max}}^2 f_\Phi\left(\frac{2\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)^2 \left(\frac{B_1}{10^{13}\ \mathrm{G}}\right)^2 \\ &\times\left(\frac{R_1}{10\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^6 \left(\frac{a}{100\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^{-4}\left(\frac{a/c}{t_{\mathrm{diss}}}\right)\ \mathrm{erg\ s^{-1}}. \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

For λ=1\lambda= 1 (which gives fΦ=32/πf_\Phi= 32/\pi) and R1=14.76 kmR_1 = 14.76\ \mathrm{km} (the radius adopted by [10]), we find

Lflare≃1.2×1045(ζϕ,maxπ)2(B11012 G)2×(a45 km)−4(a/ctdiss) erg s−1,(20)\begin{aligned} L_{\mathrm{flare}} \simeq1.2 \times10^{45}\left(\frac{\zeta_{\phi,\mathrm{max}}}{\pi}\right)^2\left(\frac{B_1}{10^{12}\ \mathrm{G}}\right)^2 \\ &\times\left(\frac{a}{45\ \mathrm{km}}\right)^{-4}\left(\frac{a/c}{t_{\mathrm{diss}}}\right)\ \mathrm{erg\ s^{-1}}, \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}

in good agreement with the numerical results of [10, 11]. Note that LflareL_{\mathrm{flare}} refers to the total energy dissipation rate; only a small fraction (∼10−4\sim10^{-4}) may go into radio emission.

Application: Close-in Exoplanetary Systems. For a planetary system with M1=M⋆M_1 = M_\star, R1=R⋆R_1 = R_\star, M2=mpM_2 = m_p, R2=RpR_2 = R_p, assuming λ≪1\lambda\ll1 (thus fΦ≃3f_\Phi\simeq3), we find that the magnetic torque induces orbital decay at the rate

a˙a≃−ζˉϕfΦλ2μ22mpa3(GM⋆a)1/2\frac{\dot{a}}{a} \simeq-\frac{\bar{\zeta}_\phi f_\Phi\lambda^2\mu_2^2}{m_p a^3(GM_\star a)^{1/2}}
≃2.5×10−15 yr−1ζˉϕ(M⋆M⊙)−1/2(B⋆R⋆3GR⊙3)4/3×(BpG)2/3(gcm3/ρp)(RJRp)(a0.04 AU)−7/2.(21)\begin{aligned} \simeq2.5 \times10^{-15}\ \mathrm{yr}^{-1}\bar{\zeta}_\phi\left(\frac{M_\star}{M_\odot}\right)^{-1/2}\left(\frac{B_\star R_\star^3}{G R_\odot^3}\right)^{4/3} \\ &\times\left(\frac{B_p}{G}\right)^{2/3}\left(\frac{g}{\mathrm{cm}^3}/\rho_p\right)\left(\frac{R_J}{R_p}\right)\left(\frac{a}{0.04\ \mathrm{AU}}\right)^{-7/2}. \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

where ρp=3mp/(4πRp3)\rho_p = 3m_p/(4\pi R_p^3) is the mean density of the planet. The above expression assumes

rm2Rp≃(μpμ⋆)1/3aRp=(BpB⋆)1/3aR⋆≳1.(22)\frac{r_{m2}}{R_p} \simeq\left(\frac{\mu_p}{\mu_\star}\right)^{1/3}\frac{a}{R_p} = \left(\frac{B_p}{B_\star}\right)^{1/3}\frac{a}{R_\star} \gtrsim1. \tag*{(22)}

If rm2/Rp≪1r_{m2}/R_p \ll1 (non-magnetic planet), the orbital decay rate is [15]

a˙a≃−ζˉϕμ⋆2Rp2a5mp(GM⋆a)1/2.(23)\frac{\dot{a}}{a} \simeq-\frac{\bar{\zeta}_{\phi}\mu_{\star}^{2}R_{p}^{2}}{a^{5}m_{p}(GM_{\star}a)^{1/2}}. \tag*{(23)}

Using these expressions, we see that a hot Jupiter (Rp∼RJR_p \sim R_J) or super-Earth (Rp∼0.2RJR_p \sim0.2R_J) in a P∼3P \sim3 d orbit (a≃0.04a \simeq0.04 AU) around a solar-type star (with a typical dipole field B⋆B_{\star} of a few Gauss) will suffer negligible orbital decay due to the magnetic torque. An ultra-short-period Earth-like planet (with a∼0.01a \sim0.01 AU, Rp∼0.1RJR_p \sim0.1R_J, Bp∼1B_p \sim1 G; see [22, 23]) around a high magnetic star (e.g. B⋆∼100B_{\star} \sim100 G) would have ∣a/a˙∣|a/\dot{a}| less than 10910^9 years. If super-Earths migrate to their close-in locations in the early T-Tauri phase of the star, when the stellar magnetic field is stronger (a few kG), they may experience appreciable orbital evolution due to magnetic interactions. We note that Eqs. (21) and (23) give the maximum orbital decay rate (for the assumed parameter values); if the planet has a sufficiently large internal resistance, the decay rate will be smaller [15].

The maximum energy stored in the twisted magnetic field is (again for λ≪1\lambda\ll1)

Etwist≃34ζϕ,max⁡2λ2μ12a3≃1.04×1028 erg(ζϕ,max⁡π)2(B⋆R⋆3GR⊙3)4/3×(BpRp3GRJ3)2/3(a0.04 AU)−3.(24)\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{twist}} &\simeq\frac{3}{4}\zeta_{\phi,\max}^{2}\lambda^{2}\frac{\mu_{1}^{2}}{a^{3}} \\ &\simeq1.04 \times10^{28}\ \mathrm{erg}\left(\frac{\zeta_{\phi,\max}}{\pi}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{B_{\star}R_{\star}^{3}}{G R_{\odot}^{3}}\right)^{4/3}\\ &\qquad\times\left(\frac{B_{p}R_{p}^{3}}{G R_{J}^{3}}\right)^{2/3}\left(\frac{a}{0.04\ \mathrm{AU}}\right)^{-3}. \tag*{(24)} \end{aligned}

For the canonical parameter values adopted in the above, this is smaller than the energy release of solar flares (1029−103210^{29}-10^{32} ergs) and of superflares from solar-type stars (≳1033\gtrsim10^{33} ergs; see [27]). For larger values of B⋆B_{\star} and/or BpB_p, or for small aa, the stored energy can be much larger. Some fraction of this energy can be released in the radio band and becomes detectable. Continued search for the signature of star-planet interaction would be useful (e.g., [28, 29, 30, 31, 32]).

Discussion. Our analytical study of magnetic power in binaries extends previous work to systems in which both binary components (“stars”) have intrinsic dipole magnetic fields. When the total resistance in the binary components is small — as is the case in most astrophysical systems — the magnetic field lines that connect the two stars are twisted by the orbital motion and open up once the twist angle exceeds ∼π\sim\pi, leading to quasi-periodic magnetic energy dissipation and flares. For a given binary separation and given magnetic dipole moments, the magnetic power from the binary is directly proportional to the magnetic flux linking the two stars in the natural (“untwisted”) state. This provides a quantitative description of how the power depends on the dipole orientations of the two stars (see Figure 3).

Applying our result to coalescing neutron-star binaries, we find that although the magnetic power is enhanced compared to the case in which one of the stars has a negligible magnetic field, it has a negligible effect on the orbital decay rate (thus the GW phase) even for magnetar-level magnetic fields. Our calculated pre-merger magnetic energy dissipation rate agrees well with the results of full numerical simulations [10, 11], subject to the uncertainties in the reconnection rate of the fully twisted magnetic fields. Similarly, applying our general result to close-in hot-Jupiter or super-Earth extrasolar systems, we find that for typical stellar and planetary fields (a few Gauss), magnetic interaction does not lead to appreciable orbital evolution, with the possible exception of the early T Tauri phase, when the stellar dipole magnetic field is stronger than 10310^3 G. The energy dissipation induced by the orbital motion of a magnetic planet around a strongly magnetized star can become comparable to the energies released in observed stellar flares, and orbit-correlated radio emission may be generated.

Our circuit model with linked field lines between the stars requires that the slippage of the flux tube during the round-trip Alfvén travel time along the flux tube (tA∼2a/vAt_A \sim2a/v_A, where vAv_A is the Alfvén speed of the poloidal field) be less than rm2r_{m2}, i.e. ΩtA≲rm2\Omega t_A \lesssim r_{m2}, or 2(GM12/a3)1/2≲(vA/c)(rm2/a)2(GM_{12}/a^3)^{1/2} \lesssim(v_A/c)(r_{m2}/a) (where M12=M1+M2M_{12}=M_1+M_2). When this condition is not satisfied, the “Alfvén wing” model may be applied: the disturbance generated by the secondary’s orbital motion propagates along the “external” field line as Alfvén waves and radiates away [24, 25]. Taking account of the internal magnetic field of the secondary, the Alfvén power is (Eq. (22) in Ref. [26])

LAlfven≃αvrel22πvABz1ΦL,(25)L_{\mathrm{Alfven}} \simeq\frac{\alpha v_{\mathrm{rel}}^{2}}{2\pi v_A}B_{z1}\Phi_L, \tag*{(25)}

with α≃1.68\alpha\simeq1.68 from numerical simulations. Here vrelv_{\mathrm{rel}} is the velocity of the secondary relative to the “external” medium (If the stellar-wind velocity from the primary star is negligible, then vrel=αΩv_{\mathrm{rel}}=\alpha\Omega is simply the orbital velocity), and ΦL\Phi_L is the magnetic field flux linked to the external field – in a binary, this external field is produced by the primary. Comparing with Eq. (4), we see that

LAlfvenLˉmag≃αΩζϕvA.(26)\frac{L_{\mathrm{Alfven}}}{\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}}} \simeq\frac{\alpha\Omega}{\zeta_{\phi}v_A}. \tag*{(26)}

These equations apply in the sub-Alfvénic regime (vrel≲vAv_{\mathrm{rel}} \lesssim v_A), where LAlfvenL_{\mathrm{Alfven}} is always less than Lˉmag\bar{L}_{\mathrm{mag}}. Thus, the general expressions presented in this paper represent the maximum magnetic interaction power in binaries.

Acknowledgments. The analytical derivations presented in the Appendix are obtained with the help of AI and checked by the authors.

Connected Flux in the Weak-Dipole Limit

We consider two point magnetic dipoles located at the origin and at ax^a\hat{x}, with moments

μ1=−μ1z^,μ2=μ2e^,(27)\boldsymbol{\mu}_1=-\mu_1\hat{z},\qquad\boldsymbol{\mu}_2=\mu_2\hat{e}, \tag*{(27)}

where μi>0\mu_i>0 and e^=(sin⁡ucos⁡φ2,sin⁡usin⁡φ2,cos⁡u)\hat{e}=(\sin u\cos\varphi_2,\sin u\sin\varphi_2,\cos u), with u=θ2u=\theta_2. For λ=(μ2/μ1)1/3≪1\lambda=(\mu_2/\mu_1)^{1/3}\ll1, we can set φ2=0\varphi_2=0, and the field of dipole 1 is approximately uniform across the connecting region near dipole 2. Writing r=rn^\boldsymbol{r}=r\hat{n} relative to dipole 2, the local field is

B(r)=B0z^+μ2r3[3(e^⋅n^)n^−e^],B0=μ1a3.(28)\boldsymbol{B}(\boldsymbol{r})=B_0\hat{z}+\frac{\mu_2}{r^3}\left[3(\hat{e}\cdot\hat{n})\hat{n}-\hat{e}\right],\qquad B_0=\frac{\mu_1}{a^3}. \tag*{(28)}

On a “separating” sphere of radius RR, the radial field is B⋅n^=v⋅n^\boldsymbol{B}\cdot\hat{n}=\boldsymbol{v}\cdot\hat{n}, where

v=B0z^+2μ2R3e^.(29)\boldsymbol{v}=B_0\hat{z}+\frac{2\mu_2}{R^3}\hat{e}. \tag*{(29)}

Requiring the field to be tangent to the separating circle r=Rr=R, i.e., r⋅v=0\boldsymbol{r}\cdot\boldsymbol{v}=0, gives

2t2−tcos⁡u−1=0,(30)2t^2-t\cos u-1=0, \tag*{(30)}

with

t=μ2B0R3=cos⁡u+cos⁡2u+84.(31)t=\frac{\mu_2}{B_0R^3}=\frac{\cos u+\sqrt{\cos^2u+8}}{4}. \tag*{(31)}

The leading linked flux is the outward flux through the hemisphere S+={r=R,n^⋅v>0}S_+=\{r=R,\hat{n}\cdot\boldsymbol{v}>0\}:

ΦL∝∫S+B⋅n^ dS=πR2∣v∣=3πμ1λ2ah(u),(32)\Phi_L\propto\int_{S_+}\boldsymbol{B}\cdot\hat{n}\,dS=\pi R^2|\boldsymbol{v}|=\frac{3\pi\mu_1\lambda^2}{a}h(u), \tag*{(32)}

with

h(u)=1+4t2+4tcos⁡u3t2/3,(33)h(u)=\frac{\sqrt{1+4t^2+4t\cos u}}{3t^{2/3}}, \tag*{(33)}

where dSdS is the surface-area element and the value at u=πu=\pi is understood by continuity. Consequently, the dimensionless connected flux is

fΦ=Φπ[λ/(1+λ)]2μ1/a≃3(1+λ)2h(u).(34)f_{\Phi}=\frac{\Phi}{\pi[\lambda/(1+\lambda)]^2\mu_1/a}\simeq3(1+\lambda)^2h(u). \tag*{(34)}

Using cos⁡u=2t−t−1\cos u=2t-t^{-1}, the angular dependence factors exactly as

h(u)=cos⁡u2R(u),R(u)=2(2t+1)3t1/3(t+1),(35)h(u)=\cos\frac{u}{2}\mathcal{R}(u),\qquad\mathcal{R}(u)=\sqrt{\frac{2(2t+1)}{3t^{1/3}(t+1)}}, \tag*{(35)}

with

1≤R(u)≤25/33=1.05827…(36)1\leq\mathcal{R}(u)\leq\frac{2^{5/3}}{3}=1.05827\ldots \tag*{(36)}

Neglecting this small correction gives

fΦ≃3(1+λ)2cos⁡u2⟶3cos⁡u2=3cos⁡θ22(λ→0).(37)f_{\Phi}\simeq3(1+\lambda)^2\cos\frac{u}{2}\longrightarrow3\cos\frac{u}{2}=3\cos\frac{\theta_2}{2}\qquad(\lambda\to0). \tag*{(37)}

Replacing h(u)h(u) by cos⁡(u/2)\cos(u/2) underestimates the uniform-field result by at most 5.8% for u<πu<\pi; both vanish at u=πu=\pi.

Connected Flux of Perpendicular Anti-Aligned Dipoles

Consider two point dipoles with centered at r1=0\mathbf{r}_1 = \mathbf{0} and r2=ax^\mathbf{r}_2 = a\hat{\mathbf{x}}. Their moments are μ1=−μ1z^\boldsymbol{\mu}_1 = -\mu_1\hat{\mathbf{z}} and μ2=μ2z^\boldsymbol{\mu}_2 = \mu_2\hat{\mathbf{z}}. Both moments are perpendicular to the separation axis and opposite to one another. With angles measured clockwise from +z+z in the xzxz plane, this configuration corresponds to (θ1,θ2)=(180∘,0∘)(\theta_1,\theta_2) = (180^\circ,0^\circ).

For a field point r=(x,y,z)\mathbf{r}=(x,y,z), let Ri=r−ri\mathbf{R}_i=\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_i and Ri=∣Ri∣R_i=|\mathbf{R}_i|. The magnetic scalar potential and field are therefore

V(r)=∑i=12μi⋅RiRi3=z(μ2R23−μ1R13),B=−∇V.(38)\mathcal{V}(\mathbf{r})=\sum_{i=1}^{2}\frac{\boldsymbol{\mu}_i\cdot\mathbf{R}_i}{R_i^3}=z\left(\frac{\mu_2}{R_2^3}-\frac{\mu_1}{R_1^3}\right),\qquad\mathbf{B}=-\nabla\mathcal{V}. \tag*{(38)}

The scalar potential identifies a useful cross-section of the connecting field lines. We can use the equipotential V=0\mathcal{V}=0 to calculate the connecting magnetic flux. Besides the plane z=0z=0, the equipotential V=0\mathcal{V}=0 contains the surface R2=λR1R_2=\lambda R_1. For λ≠1\lambda\ne1, this surface is the sphere

(x−cn)2+y2+z2=rn2,(39)(x-c_n)^2+y^2+z^2=r_n^2, \tag*{(39)}

where

cn=a1−λ2,rn=aλ∣1−λ2∣.(40)c_n=\frac{a}{1-\lambda^2},\qquad r_n=\frac{a\lambda}{|1-\lambda^2|}. \tag*{(40)}

To evaluate the flux, take 0<λ<10<\lambda<1, so that the sphere encloses dipole 2 and excludes dipole 1. The field is normal to this equipotential. The scalar potential drops along a field line; after crossing the equipotential the potential decreases below zero, so the line cannot return to the sphere or reach infinity, where the potential is again zero. See Figure 1 (left panel) in the main text. We can calculate the connecting flux by integrating over the hemisphere S+S_+ with z>0z>0, where the field lines point outward the sphere. The flux crossing S+S_+ therefore connects from dipole 2 to dipole 1.

Since S+S_+ avoids both dipole singularities, its flux can be evaluated by Stokes’ theorem. Introducing the vector potential A=∑i=12μi×Ri/Ri3\mathbf{A}=\sum_{i=1}^{2}\boldsymbol{\mu}_i\times\mathbf{R}_i/R_i^3, for which B=∇×A\mathbf{B}=\nabla\times\mathbf{A}, we obtain

ΦL=∫S+B⋅dS=∮CA⋅dℓ.(41)\Phi_L=\int_{S_+}\mathbf{B}\cdot\mathrm{d}\mathbf{S}=\oint_C\mathbf{A}\cdot\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{\ell}. \tag*{(41)}

We integrate the vector potential along the intersection between the equipotential sphere and xyxy plane. Parameterize the boundary by (x,y,z)=(cn+rncos⁡ψ,rnsin⁡ψ,0)(x,y,z)=(c_n+r_n\cos\psi,r_n\sin\psi,0), where 0≤ψ<2π0\le\psi<2\pi increases counterclockwise as viewed from +z+z, consistently with the outward surface normal. On CC, the relation R2=λR1R_2=\lambda R_1 reduces the vector potential to A∣C=−μ1y^/R13\left.\mathbf{A}\right|_C=-\mu_1\hat{\mathbf{y}}/R_1^3. The flux consequently becomes the one-dimensional integral

ΦL=−μ1aλ(1−λ2)2∫02πcos⁡ψ dψ(1+λ2+2λcos⁡ψ)3/2.(42)\Phi_L=-\frac{\mu_1}{a}\lambda(1-\lambda^2)^2\int_{0}^{2\pi}\frac{\cos\psi\,\mathrm{d}\psi}{(1+\lambda^2+2\lambda\cos\psi)^{3/2}}. \tag*{(42)}

Evaluating this integral gives the following expression:

Φ=2μ1(1+λ)a[(1+λ2)E(m)−(1−λ)2K(m)],(43)\Phi=\frac{2\mu_1(1+\lambda)}{a}\left[(1+\lambda^2)E(m)-(1-\lambda)^2K(m)\right], \tag*{(43)}

where

m=4λ(1+λ)2.(44)m=\frac{4\lambda}{(1+\lambda)^2}. \tag*{(44)}

Here KK and EE are the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds, respectively, with parameter mm:

K(m)=∫0π/2dχ1−msin⁡2χ,(45)K(m)=\int_{0}^{\pi/2}\frac{\mathrm{d}\chi}{\sqrt{1-m\sin^2\chi}}, \tag*{(45)}
E(m)=∫0π/21−msin⁡2χ dχ.(46)E(m)=\int_{0}^{\pi/2}\sqrt{1-m\sin^2\chi}\,\mathrm{d}\chi. \tag*{(46)}

The dimensionless flux factor is then

fΦ(λ)=2(1+λ)3πλ2[(1+λ2)E(m)−(1−λ)2K(m)].(47)f_\Phi(\lambda)=\frac{2(1+\lambda)^3}{\pi\lambda^2}\left[(1+\lambda^2)E(m)-(1-\lambda)^2K(m)\right]. \tag*{(47)}

This is the expression used for plotting Figure 2.

For λ=1\lambda=1 (with μ1=μ2≡μ\mu_1=\mu_2\equiv\mu), the condition R2=R1R_2=R_1 now defines the midplane x=a/2x=a/2, whose upper half-plane z>0z>0 is the corresponding flux cross-section. The field there points from dipole 2 towards dipole 1, so the positive linked flux follows directly from

B=−3μaz(a2/4+y2+z2)5/2x^,(48)\mathbf{B}=-\frac{3\mu az}{(a^2/4+y^2+z^2)^{5/2}}\hat{\mathbf{x}}, \tag*{(48)}

and

ΦL=3μa∫−∞∞dy∫0∞z dz(a2/4+y2+z2)5/2=8μa.(49)\Phi_L=3\mu a\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}y\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{z\,\mathrm{d}z}{(a^2/4+y^2+z^2)^{5/2}}=\frac{8\mu}{a}. \tag*{(49)}

Since rm2=a/2r_{m2}=a/2, we find

fΦ(1)=8μ/aπ(a/2)2μ/a3=32π.(50)f_\Phi(1)=\frac{8\mu/a}{\pi(a/2)^2\mu/a^3}=\frac{32}{\pi}. \tag*{(50)}

The equal-moment value is the continuous limit of the elliptic expression; it supplies the value at m=1m=1, where K(m)K(m) itself diverges. Source interchange gives fΦ(λ)=λfΦ(1/λ)f_\Phi(\lambda)=\lambda f_\Phi(1/\lambda), allowing values above unity to be obtained from those below unity. The weak-moment limit (λ≪1\lambda\ll1), we have

fΦ=3(1+λ)2[1−λ28+O(λ4)],(λ≪1).(51)f_\Phi=3(1+\lambda)^2\left[1-\frac{\lambda^2}{8}+O(\lambda^4)\right],\qquad(\lambda\ll1). \tag*{(51)}

References

  1. [1]P. Goldreich and D. Lynden-Bell, Astrophys. J. 156, 59 (1969).
  2. [2]J. T. Clarke et al., Science 274, 404 (1996).
  3. [3]A. F. Lanza, Astrophys. J. 493, 1127 (2009).
  4. [4]R. O. Laine and D. N. C. Lin, Astrophys. J. 745, 2 (2012).
  5. [5]A. Strugarek, A. S. Brun, S. P. Matt, and V. Réville, Astrophys. J. 795, 86 (2014).
  6. [6]A. Strugarek, Astrophys. J. 833, 140 (2016).
  7. [7]A. Strugarek, A. S. Brun, S. P. Matt, and V. Réville, Astrophys. J. 847, 36 (2017).
  8. [8]B. M. S. Hansen and M. Lyutikov, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 322, 695 (2001).
  9. [9]M. Lyutikov, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 483, 4168 (2019).
  10. [10]E. R. Most and A. A. Philippov, Astrophys. J. 901, L26 (2020).
  11. [11]E. R. Most and A. A. Philippov, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 515, 2710 (2022).
  12. [12]E. R. Most and A. A. Philippov, Astrophys. J. 955, 24 (2023).
  13. [13]J. F. Mahlmann and A. M. Beloborodov, Astrophys. J. 981, L17 (2025).
  14. [14]A. M. Beloborodov, Astrophys. J. 922, L7 (2021).
  15. [15]D. Lai, Astrophys. J. 757, L20 (2012).
  16. [16]S. A. Cherkis and M. Lyutikov, Astrophys. J. 910, 107 (2021).
  17. [17]J. J. Aly, Astron. Astrophys. 143, 19 (1985).
  18. [18]J. J. Aly and J. Kuijpers, Astron. Astrophys. 227, 473 (1990).
  19. [19]A. A. van Ballegooijen, Space Sci. Rev. 68, 299 (1994).
  20. [20]R. V. E. Lovelace, M. M. Romanova, and G. S. Bisnovatyi-Kogan, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 275, 244 (1995).
  21. [21]D. Uzdensky, A. Königl, and C. Litwin, Astrophys. J. 565, 1191 (2002).
  22. [22]E. J. Lee and E. Chiang, Astrophys. J. 842, 41 (2017).
  23. [23]B. Pu and D. Lai, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 488, 3566 (2019).
  24. [24]S. D. Drell, H. M. Foley, and M. A. Ruderman, J. Geophys. Res. 70, 3131 (1965).
  25. [25]N. Corso and D. Lai, Astrophys. J. 1002, 1 (2026).
  26. [27]H. Maehara et al., Nature 485, 478 (2012).
  27. [28]E. Shkolnik, D. A. Bohlender, G. A. H. Walker, and A. Collier Cameron, Astrophys. J. 676, 628 (2008).
  28. [29]I. Pillitteri et al., Astrophys. J. 741, L18 (2011).
  29. [30]J. R. Callingham, B. J. S. Pope, R. D. Kavanagh, S. Bellotti, S. Daley-Yates, et al., Nature Astronomy 8, 1359 (2024).
  30. [31]C. Elin, H. K. Vedantham, K. Poppenhäger, S. Bloot, J. R. Callingham, A. Branderker, and H. Chakraborty, Nature 643, 645 (2025).
  31. [32]J. S. Pineda, S. Bellotti, J. Villadsen, A. Vidotto, J. Morin, and C. P. Folsom, Astrophys. J. 997, 172 (2026).

Paper details

vlnc:W_vxn78jm5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

AI

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents