betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

PIII Project Overview and Status

Abstract

The Proton Improvement Plan II (PIP-II) project is an essential upgrade to Fermilab's particle accelerator complex to enable the world's most intense neutrino beam for LBNF/DUNE and a broad particle physics program for many decades to come. PIP-II will deliver 1.2 MW of proton beam power from the Main Injector, upgradeable to multi-MW capability. The central element of PIP-II is an 800 MeV superconducting radio frequency (SRF) linac, which comprises a room temperature front end followed by an SRF section. The SRF section consists of five different flavors of cavities/cryomodules, including Half Wave Resonators (HWR), Single Spoke and elliptical resonators operating at, or above, state-of-the-art parameters. The first two PIP-II cryomodules, Half Wave Resonator (HWR) and Single Spoke Resonator 1 (SSR1) were installed in the PIP-II Injector Test facility (PIP2IT) and have accelerated beam to above 17 MeV. PIP-II is the first U.S. accelerator project that will be constructed with significant contributions from international partners, including India, Italy, France, United Kingdom and Poland. The project was baselined in April 2022, and the construction phase is underway.

INTRODUCTION

PIP-II will be a world-class SRF-based accelerator which will enhance performance and operational reliability of the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL) complex. It is the latest step to revitalization of the accelerators that power America’s High Energy Physics Program. The science objective is to enable the accelerator complex to provide 1.2 MW proton beam on the LBNF target (upgradeable to multi-MW) and to provide a flexible, multi-user capability for a broader reaching physics program. The Linac output will be 800 MeV when injecting into the existing Booster. The machine will run in pulsed mode initially but will be fully continuous wave (CW) compatible. Performance Goals are tabulated in Table 1.

Performance ParameterValueUnits
Delivered Beam Energy800MeV
Beam ParticlesH−H^{-}
Beam Pulse Length0.54ms
Particles per Pulse6.7101210^{12}
Pulse repetition Rate20Hz
Average Beam Current2mA
Maximum Bunch Intensity1.910810^{8}
Maximum Bunch Rep Rate162.5MHz
Bunch PatternProg and Arbitrary
RF Frequency162.5 harmonic
Bunch Length (RMS)< 4ps
Transverse Emittance≤0.3\le0.3mm-rad
Longitudinal Emittance (RMS)≤0.3\le0.3mm-rad

Table 1. PIP-II Performance Goals

The accelerator is being built in collaboration with several key International Partners including Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC), Commissariat à l’energie atomique (CEA), Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique/Institut national de physique nucléaire et de physique des particules (CNRS/IN2P3), Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Inter-University Accelerator Centre (IUAC), Raja Ramanna Centre for Advanced Technology (RRCAT), Science & Technology Facilities Council UK Research and Innovation (STFC UKRI), Lodz University of Technology (TUL), Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre (VECC), Wroclaw University of Science and Technology (WUST), and Warsaw University of Technology (WUT). The collaboration is functioning very well, and Partners are committed to delivering their scope of work. [2]

Additionally, FNAL is working with other Department of Energy (DOE) labs including Lawrence Berkeley National Lab (LBNL), Argonne National Lab (ANL), Thomas Jefferson National Lab (JLab) and SLAC National Accelerator Lab on various aspects of the machine.

The scope of the project includes extensive new civil construction, the SRF-based Linac, a 2.5 kW @2K cryoplant housed in a new standalone building, all necessary power and auxiliary equipment, and the connection into the Booster to allow injection. The Linac begins with a Warm Front End followed by multiple cryomodules including a Half Wave Resonator (HWR), nine Single Spoke Resonators (two SSR1 and seven SSR2), and thirteen 650 MHz Elliptical units (nine LB650 and four HB650). The beam then progresses through the Beam Transfer Line with various stages of collimation before injecting into the Booster. [1]

Upgrades to the Booster, Recycler Ring (RR) and Main Injector (MI) are also part of the Project. In particular, the Booster repetition rate will be increased from 15 Hz to 20 Hz. The injection time will be longer (550 microsec) and the area for injection will still be very tight, which requires new designs for magnets and the injection girder. The Main Injector will get an increase in Radiofrequency (RF) power by installing additional power tubes in the modulators in each of the twenty RF accelerating stations and updating the Solid-State drivers. The complex will accelerate 50% more beam in the Booster and Main Injector while reducing the (beam) power loss. [4]

Design Strategy

As part of the PIP-II Project Execution Plan, a design “Tailoring Strategy” was developed and approved by DOE. Readiness for project execution (DOE Critical Decision 3, CD-3) is defined as substantial completion of the final design of the Linac Complex civil construction, designs for Critical Technical Systems being sound and sufficiently mature to start civil construction, and designs being independently reviewed and well documented. Critical Technical Systems are defined as systems having the largest impact on the Linac Complex Conventional Facilities (CF) design. Excluding statutory building regulations, these PIP-II Critical Technical Systems completely determine the CD-3 CF scope. This allowed the construction of the Linac Complex to proceed without delays from other technical systems,

For the SRF cryomodules, a single prototype will be fabricated and tested. The schedule allows for some design iteration between prototype testing and the start of production. Other complex technical systems, such as magnets, high power RF amplifiers, and instrumentation, incorporate prototype or pre-series assemblies as well.

Designs are driven by Technical Requirement Specifications (TRS). Changes to the Technical Baseline are tracked per the Configuration Management Plan. All significant design changes must be processed through a Design Change Request (DCR) and approved by the Design Change Board, chaired by the Technical Integration Manager. Consistent with the Design Tailoring Strategy, initial designs were constrained by a “Not-to Exceed” envelope which allowed civil facility design and award to proceed. As designs were established, reviewed, and approved, the actual CAD models were

incorporated into the overall Linac CAD model to ensure compatibility.

Per the Systems Engineering Management Plan, the Design Authority is the Level 2 Subsystem Manager, while the governing institution responsible for final design of a component is the “Designer of Record”. Current assignments for the Designer of Record are shown in Table 2.

ItemDesigner of RecordProduction Entity
Cryoplant
CryoplantCommercialDAE-BARC
CDS
Distribution Valve BoxWUSTWUST
Tunnel Transfer Line ModulesWUSTWUST
SSR1 CM1-2
CMFNALFNAL
Jacketed CavitiesFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
CouplersFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
TunersFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
SC SolenoidsDAE-BARCDAE-BARC
SSR2 CM1-7
CM (including shipping)FNAL, DAE-BARCFNAL, DAE-BARC
Jacketed CavitiesFNALFNAL, IN2P3, DAE-BARC
CouplersFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
TunersFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
SC SolenoidsDAE-BARCDAE-BARC
LB650 CM1-9
CM (including shipping)CEAFNAL & CEA
Jacketed CavitiesFNAL, INFNINFN, DAE-VECC
CouplersFNALFNAL, DAE-BARC
TunersFNALFNAL, DAE-VECC
HB650 CM1-6
CM (including shipping)FNAL, CEA, DAE-RRCAT, UKRIFNAL, UKRI, DAE-RRCAT
Jacketed CavitiesFNALUKRI, DAE-RRCAT
CouplersFNALUKRI, DAE-BARC
TunersFNALUKRI, DAE-RRCAT
HPRF
325 MHz – 7 kW SSAs (SSR1)DAE-BARCDAE-BARC
325 MHz – 20 kW SSAs (SSR2)DAE-BARCDAE-BARC
650 MHz – 40 kW SSAs (LB650)DAE-RRCATDAE-RRCAT
650 MHz – 70 kW SSAs (HB650)DAE-RRCATDAE-RRCAT
Magnets
PIP-II MagnetsDAE-BARCDAE-BARC
650 MHz Warm unit magnets (quads+correctors)DAE-BARCDAE-BARC

Table 2. Designer of Record

Collaboration

Building a strong collaboration is an essential part of many modern-day large science projects, and PIP-II is no exception. Initial lessons learned from the PIP-II project collaboration include:

  • Define a collaborative relationship upfront and develop a management and evaluation style that reflects the core principle of “we are in this together”. For instance, Partners must have their voices heard and be part of the management team, otherwise it can become a customer/vendor relationship. Also, in a collaborative model there is

a shared responsibility to deliver the scope and solve problems, taking a fully integrated team approach. Communication is the key.

  • Each Party should be able to point to a benefit they are receiving from the Partnership to have strong arguments to their funding agencies for continued support.

The PIP-II Partnerships are key to the project’s success and are functioning very well. This is a testament to the collaborative spirit of the lead Technical Coordinators and the focus of the Subproject Managers and Coordinators on getting the work done. The scope of each Partners work is shown in Table 3.

ItemDAECEAIN2P3INFNUKRIWUST
Cryoplant
Cryoplant1
CDS
Distribution Valve BoxAll
Tunnel Transfer Line ModulesAll
SSR1 CMI-2
CM
Jacketed Cavities9
Couplers9
Tuners9
SC SolenoidsAll
SSR2 CMI-7
CMI (including shipping)1 kit
Jacketed Cavities5All Tests
Couplers5
Tuners5
SC SolenoidsAll
LB650 CMI-9
CM (excluding shipping)10
Jacketed Cavities440
Couplers4
Tuners4
HB650 CMI-6
CM (including shipping)1 kit3
Jacketed Cavities2018
Couplers2018
Tuners2018
HPRF
325 MHz - 7kW SSAs (SSR1)9
325 MHz - 20kW SSAs (SSR2)40
650 MHz - 40kW SSAs (LB650)40
650 MHz - 70kW SSAs (HB650)31
Magnets
PIP-II MagnetsAll
650 MHz Warm unit magnets (quads+correctors)All

Table 3. Partner Scope

Safety and Quality Control

Safety of the workers must be the first item on everyone’s agenda. Ensuring that the staff goes home safe and sound, is the number one priority. Overall, the PIP-II project has an excellent safety record. However, on May 25, 2023, a very serious construction accident occurred (involving a subcontractor for the primary civil contractor) and resulted in a shutdown of civil construction activities. The negative effects to the worker and to the project will be felt for some time to

come. It is of the highest importance that projects, such as PIP-II, take safety extremely seriously and not become complacent, ensure worker training is up to date, perform timely Hazard Analysis, and focus on Work Planning & Control procedures.

Another important aspect needed to successfully execute large international partnerships is Quality Control. It starts with having an integrated Quality Assurance Plan across all Partners. PIP-II achieved this by forming the Quality Control Coordination Group which is established to bring Quality representatives from each Partner together in a forum. This group meets frequently and discusses QA expectations and ensures alignment of QC activities for like contributions. Quality Control (QC) Plans are identified and tracked via a QC Plan Tracking Tool and are developed in accordance with the PIP-II Technical Review Plan. Travelers are developed across the Project to document results of QC checks. For SRF-based production projects, quality assurance and control, data traceability and record management are essential elements as are the ability to define what constitutes acceptable performance criteria. PIP-II is in the process of establishing Acceptance Criteria Documents for all critical components. The Systems Engineering Management Plan calls out for a System Acceptance Review at the partner’s institution (SAR1) and again, in most cases, at FNAL upon receipt of component (SAR2). Defining the acceptance criteria beforehand alleviates last minute decisions on what is acceptable. The acceptance criteria are tied into the Technical Requirements Specification and the required performance in the Linac.

Project STATUS

PIP-II is one year into the execution phase and has achieved several important technical milestones. There have also been challenges. The Cost Weighted Design Maturity is 92% as there are still several items awaiting Final Design Review. The most important achievement has been the successful fabrication, installation, and testing of the Front-End including the ion source, Low Energy Beam Transport (LEBT), Radio Frequency Quadrupole (RFQ), Medium Energy Beam Transport (MEBT), Half Wave Resonator (HWR) and prototype Single Spoke Resonator (SSR1) cryomodule. This configuration achieved 17 MeV energy with the beam parameters needed for LBNF/DUNE operations. The plan is to utilize all these components in the Linac. The operation of this part of the machine in the Injector Test Facility (PIP2IT) resulted in important feedback to the design teams and valuable experience for the operators.

The PIP-II scope of work remaining is still large, as there are many components needed to be fabricated and tested, including production cryomodules, magnets (both superconducting and conventional), power supplies (for cavities and magnets), instrumentation, controls, and cryogenic compo nents. There are also the extensive civil construction activities to restart and complete. A partial list of remaining components is shown in Table 4.

ComponentNumber Required
SSR1 cryomodules2
SSR2 cryomodules8
LB650 cryomodules10
HB650 cryomodules4
7 kW SSA16
20 kW SSA35
40 kW SSA36
70 kW SSA24
ORBUMP magnets6
Gradient magnets6
Painting magnets10
Gamma-t Quad magnets18
Superconducting solenoids33
Beam Current Monitors48
Bean Position Monitors126
Beam Loss Monitors235
Beam Profile Monitors47

Table 4. PIP-II By the Numbers

SRF Cavities and Cryomodules

The heart of the PIP-II Project is the SRF Linac. FNAL’s history with the SRF technology along with its strong collaborative ties with other SRF institutions around the world, place it in a solid position to perform this work. The combination of an ongoing R&D effort and cryomodule production (experienced gained from LCLS-II and LCLS-II HE) gives confidence to the activities needed to construct PIP-II. For each cryomodule type, a prototype will be assembled and tested before launching into production. The LB650 CM will be built by CEA/Saclay while the HB 650 CM will be built by STFC-UKRI. FNAL will assemble and test the SSR CM (both SSR1 and SSR2 [5]). DAE labs will contribute many critical components for each type of cryomodule including cavities, cryomodule part kits, and Solid-State Amplifiers (SSA) for powering cavities.

The cryomodule teams are working well together, sharing information, and holding weekly meetings to discuss issues and status. Communication is the key to making these partnerships work.

Cryomodule testing of the HWR and SSR1 pCM at PIP2IT progressed well. [7] Measurements of maximum gradients and heat loads showed good performance while uncovering several issues that can be easily fixed before installation in the Linac, see Table 5 and Table 6, and Figure 1. [6]

Cavity #Nominal Required Gradient (MV/m)Maximum Test Gradient (MV/m)Notes
11.3910.8No Residual FE or MP
21.8910.9No Residual FE or MP
33.916.5Coupler HV Bias Failure
44.7911.2No Residual FE or MP
57.1910.5No Residual FE or MP
69.7011.0No Residual FE or MP
79.7010.7No Residual FE or MP
89.7010.6No Residual FE or MP

Table 5. HWR Gradients

Image not extracted

Figure 1. SSR1 pCM Gradients

Prototype SSR1 CM2KLTTSHTTS
Design Values (W)25.444.2150.3
Measured Values (W)27.8±2.558.4±4.5222.1±8.0

Table 6. SSR1 pCM Static Heat Load

The HB 650 pCM testing is still ongoing but the cavities available at the time of string assembly were not of Linac quality. A second cooldown is planned after some in situ rework to reduce static heat load, but eventually the cavity string will be rebuilt. [3]

The HB 650 pCM testing is still ongoing but the cavities available at the time of string assembly were not of Linac quality. A second cooldown is planned after some in situ rework to reduce static heat load, but eventually the cavity string will be rebuilt. [3]

CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS

The cryoplant for PIP-II is being procured from Air Liquide advanced Technologies by India/DAE. It represents the largest single In-Kind Contribution for the project. The Final Design Review was recently held at BARC, and production is underway. Other parts of the cryogenic system include the Distribution Box and Tunnel Transfer Line (both planned to be In-Kind Contributions from Poland, the Intermediate Transfer Line (FNAL procurement), and auxiliary equipment for the cryoplant (gas storage, cooling water, air systems…). The cryoplant is scheduled for delivery at the end of calendar year 2024 and should be operational in 2025.

Some key information concerning the cryo capacity

  • 2.5 kW @ 2K (50% margin to baseline)

  • 1.5 kW @ 5K LTTS (120% margin to baseline)

  • 10.7 kW @ 40K HTTS (70% margin to baseline)

Given the cryogenic margins available, it is very important to understand any measurable level of unexpected heat loads to the system. Currently we are looking at remeasuring the SSR1 pCM heat load and lowering the HB650 pCM heat load by incorporating several small changes in thermal shorting and intercepting more heat at higher temperatures.

The cryoplant building is essentially complete and ready for the installation of various piping and electrical systems which will be done prior to installation of larger components such as compressor skids or the cold box. Power to the facility will be supplied using the main electrical feeds already in place and a refurbished transformer recovered from previously used FNAL areas. Short term use of existing equipment is a way to counteract supply chain delays,

Accelerator Complex Upgrades

Since PIP-II injects into the existing Booster which then ties to the Recycler Ring and the Main Injector, there are multiple upgrades that must be done to prepare for the new beam parameters. These upgrades include new Booster injection magnets, ORBUMP magnets and all associated power supplies, collimators, and a beam absorber. One major change is that the Booster is increasing its repetition rate from 15 Hz to 20 Hz, which means faster ramp up. A test station has been set up to test critical components at the new rep rate.

In the Recycler Ring, there is a need to do slip stacking at the 20 Hz rate. New 53 MHz cavities that can operate in CW mode are also being installed.

In the Main Injector, the upgrades include an increase in RF power by installing a second power tube in each of the Main Injector RF stations. Each of the modulators will be upgraded to accommodate another tube and the solid-state drivers in each station will be upgraded with additional power to drive the additional tube. Tubes are being supplied by Communications and Power Industries (CPI) and are arriving ahead of schedule. The first prototype modulator has been upgraded and is operational, as pictured in Figure 2.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Main Injector Dual-Tube Modulator

Accelerator Systems

Accelerator Systems encompasses a broad range of systems including the Machine Protection System, Personnel Safety Systems, High-Power and Low-Level RF (LLRF), warm magnets and power supplies, vacuum systems, instrumentation, and controls. Essentially this work package captures all the systems outside the cold systems that are necessary to operate the Linac. The High-Power Solid-State Amplifiers (SSA) are an In-Kind Contribution from India/DAE as are some of the warm magnets. The 7kW Solid State Amplifiers (SSA) for the Spoke Resonators were used to operate the PIP2IT Front-End test. A single 40kW SSA was used to test cavities for the HB650 pCM. A total of 11 SSAs are required for the Linac. These will be procured and fabricated in India and then shipped to FNAL for installation. Acceptance criteria are being developed to ensure the components meet specification and can be NRTL certified.

The LLRF system is a collaboration amongst FNAL, LBNL, SLAC, JLab, Poland (WUT and LUT), and commercial companies. Operating the system at the test stand for the HB650 pCM has given confidence that it will be able to perform as expected. This work builds on and expands the collaboration formed for the SLAC LCLS-II Project.

PIP-II will be operated using an EPICS based control system while keeping important functionality from the legacy accelerator control system. While EPICS allows for incorporating a more modern and open-source set of controls tools, there are challenges inherent in integrating the two systems to seamlessly operate PIP-II with the downstream machines it will feed. Already the PIP2IT cryomodule test area is EPICS-based and will continue to be the prime development area prior to the beginning of commissioning.

Vacuum pumping of the beamline in the cold Linac proper is planned to use a combination Non-Evaporable Getter (NEG) and Sputter Ion Pumps as this appears to be the best technology suited for particle-free environments. Warm sections of the complex, including the Warm Front End and Beam Transfer line will be pumped with traditional distributed ion pumps. Insulating vacuum for the cryomodules will similarly use distributed pump stations. Fore-pumping is planned to be accomplished with ‘dry’ pumping technology. Controls interfaces are being developed (and implemented at PIP2IT) that are EPICS-based.

For instrumentation, many of the components are of a standard design. However, measuring beam profiles in the superconducting RF section of PIP-II requires technology that does not generate extraneous particles which would degrade cavity performance. Thus, a laser-based profile monitor system is being developed with thirteen pick-off points down the length of the Linac, see Figure 3. At PIP2IT, a fibre-based laser system successfully generated both transverse and longitudinal profiles, but its resolution and quality were limited by low signal to noise ratio. For PIP-II, a free-space laser will be implemented within a containment pipe under slight vacuum running the length of the Linac tunnel. Full design of such a system has inherent challenges, including stability and alignment of the laser light, personnel, and equipment safety in the presence of a free-space laser, and the challenges in generating the profile signals.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Laser Profile Monitor

Conventional Facilities

The Conventional Facilities section of the project focuses on civil construction and utilities. The first part of the work was started with CD-3a approval and consisted of construction of the Cryogenic Plant Building and Site Prep Work. The second part is the main Linac Complex construction, including the Front-End Building, the Linac Tunnel, and the Gallery, which houses power supplies and solid-state amplifiers. The final part is the Beam Transfer Line (BTL) construction and the connection to the existing Booster. Since the BTL section traverses the Main Ring tunnel and involves a very congested area of the complex, this is the most challenging and it has a direct impact on current beam operation.

The Site Work and Cryogenic Plant Building are essentially complete (100% and 99%, respectively), see Figure 10. The final remaining work is affected by supply chain delays with respect to electrical transformers and exceptionally long times to deliver. The Linac Complex construction was making excellent progress until a very serious construction site accident resulted in a stop work order which has paused all construction on the PIP-II site. The Booster Transfer Line is not scheduled to start construction until late Calendar Year 2025.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Cryogenic Plant Building

CONCLUSION

The PIP-II Project moved into the execution phase with the DOE CD-3 approval in April 2022. The scheduled completion date for the early finish of the PIP-II Project is April 2029. Work is proceeding on all fronts, including SRF cryomodules, the cryogenic system, instrumentation, controls, RF amplifiers, magnets, and civil construction. Installation of Linac components is scheduled to begin in early 2025. International Partners play a key role in the machine construction and are also making good technical progress. Supply chain, and price inflation are creating challenges for the Project, but the collaboration is working to resolve them and is functioning very well together.

acknowledgEmentS

Work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics, under U.S. DOE Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11359.

References

  1. [1]A. Klebaner et al., “Proton Improvement Plan–II: Overview of Progress in the Construction”, in Proc. 20th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity (SRF2021), Virtual Conference, paper MOO-FAV05.DOI
  2. [2]L. Merminga et al., “In-Kind Contributions: The PIP-II Project at Fermilab”, in 13th Int. Particle Accelerator Conf. (IPAC 22), Bangkok, Thailand, June 2022, paper MOPOST020 pp. 98-100.DOI
  3. [3]V. Roger et al., “Design of the 650 MHz High Beta Prototype Cryomodule for PIP-II at Fermilab” in Proc. 20th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity (SRF2021), Virtual Conference WEPTEV015 pp. 671.DOI
  4. [4]A. Pathak et al., “Optimization of Superconducting Linac for Proton Improvement Plan-II (PIP-II)”, North American Particle Accelerator Conf. (NAPAC'22), Albuquerque, NM, USA , Aug. 2022, Paper MOPА36.
  5. [5]C. Boffo et al., “Final Design of the Pre-Production SSR2 Cryomodule for PIP-II Project at Fermilab”, in 31st Linear Accelerator Conf. (LINAC’22), Liverpool, UK, Aug.-Sep. 2022, TU-POGE12 pp. 511 - 514.arxiv.org/abs/2209.01282
  6. [6]D. Passarelli et al., “Test Results of the Prototype SSR1 Cryomodule for PIP-II at Fermilab”, in 12th Int. Particle Accelerator Conf. (IPAC’21), Campinas, Brazil, May 2021, THPAB343 pp. 4461 - 4465.
  7. [7]E. Pozdeyev et al., “Beam Commissioning and Integrated Test of the PIP-II Injector Test Facility”, in 31st Linear Accelerator Conf. (LINAC’22) Liverpool, UK, Aug.-Sep. 2022, MOP1A01 pp. 13 - 17.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vz38n59m
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents