betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Multichannel Phonon Interconversion Drives 90 Polarization Rotation for Stable Domain Walls in Hafnium Oxide

Abstract

Polarization rotation is a fundamental mechanism in ferroelectric materials, yet how such rotation arises microscopically in fluorite ferroelectrics and gives rise to distinct domain walls (DW) remains unresolved. Phonon modes offer a microscopic route to such structural transformations, as geometric orientations can modify their frequencies, dispersion relations, and vibrational eigenstates when their characteristic wavelengths become comparable to relevant physical dimensions. Here, by combining condensed phonon mode decomposition with first-principles calculations, we investigate the origin of 90 polarization rotation in the ferroelectric phase of HfO2. Using the cubic parent phase as reference, we show that polarization rotation originates from multiple symmetry equivalent phonon modes of distinct eigenstates at different wavevectors in the Brillouin zone, whose coupling and cooperative reorientation continuously evolve to generate distinct 90 Pca21 variants and switching pathways. Among the 90 variants, the lowest-energy switching pathway through the Pmn21 exhibits an energy barrier comparable to, but slightly lower than, that of the 180 polarization reversal pathway through the P42/nmc phase, indicating that 90 polarization rotation is an energetically accessible alternative switching route. We further analyze 90 DW and find that frustrated phonon modes emerge at the wall center, where the coexistence and competition of condensed modes promote local reconfiguration of the lattice distortions, contributing to the elevated DW energies. Importantly, experimental observations with STEM imaging provide direct evidence of atomic mode distortions in stable 90 DW, consistent with the theoretically identified low-energy DW. These findings provide the fundamental structural mechanism underlying 90 switching dynamics, competing domain-wall physics, and macroscopic ferroelectric behavior.

Introduction

Polarization rotation, in which the spontaneous polarization reorients between crystallographically equivalent directions, is a fundamental mechanism governing switching in ferroelectric materials [1]. In conventional perovskite ferroelectrics such as BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_3 and PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_3, symmetry breaking from a high symmetry parent phase produces multiple energetically equivalent polarization variants, enabling both 180∘180^\circ polarization reversal and non-180∘180^\circ switching, including 90∘90^\circ polarization rotation [2, 3]. Correspondingly, 90∘90^\circ domain walls provide the structural boundaries between differently oriented variants and can play an active role in polarization switching through their nucleation and motion [4, 5]. First-principles studies of BaTiO3_3 have further shown that polarization switching can proceed through successive 90° reorientation processes, demonstrating that polarization rotation can provide an energetically competitive alternative to direct polarization reversal [6]. In many conventional perovskite ferroelectrics, polarization originates from a B site cation off-centering displacement relative to the surrounding oxygen octahedron. This makes polarization rotation a change in the dominant cation displacement vector. However, in other ferroelectric materials, such as the fluorite HfO2_2, the atomic scale origin of polarization is fundamentally different; the polar Pca21Pca2_1 structure is characterized primarily by collective oxygen-anion displacements relative to the Hf sublattice, making polarization rotation a complex mechanism [7,8].

Since ferroelectricity discovery in hafnium oxide (HfO2_2), it has emerged as a technologically important material owing to its robustness at the nanoscale and compatibility with complementary-metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) technology [9,10]. To understand the switching dynamics, the macroscopic origin of the Pca21Pca2_1 phase from phonon analysis is important [11,12]. Using the unit cell (12 atoms) of cubic phase as reference, there are eight phonon modes that contribute to the formation of the Pca21Pca2_1 phase, these are Γ15z\Gamma_{15}^{z}, X2′X_{2}^{\prime}, X5yX_{5}^{y}, Y5zY_{5}^{z}, Z5xZ_{5}^{x}, Z5′yZ_{5}^{\prime y}, Z5xZ_{5}^{x}, and Y3′yY_{3}^{\prime y} correspondingly [13-16]. These oxygen and hafnia condense modes represent the collective displacement of respective atoms in the out of plane unit cell of the Pca21Pca2_1 phase. Amongst these modes the dynamically unstable and principal instability at ω=−i228\omega=-i228 cm−1^{-1} of the Brillouin zone boundary XX point condensing at X2′X_{2}^{\prime} mode, produces the centrosymmetric tetragonal (P42/nmcP4_2/nmc) phase, which is the conventional intermediate structure upon cooling from the cubic phase [17,18]. Importantly, the instability is dominated largely by oxygen displacements, reflecting the unusual lattice dynamical origin of hafnia compared with conventional perovskite ferroelectrics [19]. The orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 phase stabilization involves cooperative coupling between several symmetry allowed phonon modes. In particular, several discussions on trilinear coupling in HfO2_2 have acknowledged Γ15z\Gamma_{15}^{z}, X2′xX_{2}^{\prime x}, X5yX_{5}^{y} to easily stabilized the Pca21Pca2_1 phase by lowering the energy cost through non polar coupling [20,21]. These polarization discussions have however been centered on switching proceeding predominantly through conventional 180° polarization reversal, mediated by domain wall motion, or electric field induced phase transitions.

For non-180° switching, experimental studies have established the orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 phase and revealed multiple polarization orientation variants, providing direct evidence that polarization rotation are intrinsic to the switching behavior of fluorite HfO2_2 [22-24]. Also, theoretical studies have suggested that charged oxygen vacancies promote a fatigue resistant 90° polarization rotation pathway under [111] fields, highlighting charged defects as a key control parameter that can favor rotation over conventional 180° reversal [25]. At the mesoscale, 90° domain walls play a dual role in switching, facilitating 180° domain nucleation while impeding domain wall propagation because of their higher migration barrier, thereby influencing the overall switching pathway [26,27]. Despite this growing body of experimental and theoretical evidence, the microscopic lattice dynamical origin of 90° polarization rotation in hafnia remains unresolved. In particular, it remains unclear how the collective atomic distortions of one Pca21Pca2_1 variant reorganize into those of its symmetry equivalent 90° rotated counterpart, how this reorganization connects the diverse switching pathways, and how the same structural transformation determines the formation of distinct 90° domain wall configurations.

In this work, we demonstrate that 90° polarization rotation in HfO2_2 arises from multiple symmetry equivalent phonon modes of distinct eigenvectors leading to rotated variants. Using condensed phonon mode analysis and first-principles calculations, we identify pristine 90° rotated HfO2_2 symmetry variants of the Pca21Pca2_1 phase, and investigate their phonon modes as well as their microscopically different switching pathways and show that these pathways are microscopically different. We further reveal that the multichannel phonons have distinct switching pathways and amongst the variants can provide an alternative low energy pathway through a distorted polar Pmn21Pmn2_1 intermediate structure, reducing the energetic cost of 90° switching. The lowered energy in these rotational variants can have a slight comparable energy barrier to conventional 180° polarization reversal. Extending the phonon-mediated mechanism to 90° domain walls, we constructed and analyzed eight domain walls from the 90° Pca21Pca2_1 variants. Although electrostatic interactions contribute to the energetics of some walls, they do not fully account for the elevated domain wall energies. Instead, the coexistence and competition of multiple condensed phonon modes at the wall centers induce phonon-mode frustration, hindering local lattice relaxation and providing an additional microscopic contribution to the energetic cost of domain wall formation. Finally, we confirm atomic scale displacements with experimental evidence with atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) of the formation of stable 90° domains, consistent with the theoretically identified. low energy domains. These results provide the microscopic origin of 90° polarization switching and domain wall formation in fluorite HfO2_2.

Results

Symmetry equivalent Phonon Modes of distinct Eigenstates

The ferroelectric Pca21Pca2_1 phase and its rotated variants originate from symmetry breaking lattice distortions of the parent fluorite Fm3ˉmFm\bar{3}m structure of HfO2_2. The reciprocal-space geometry of this cubic parent phase provides a natural framework for identifying the symmetry related instabilities underlying these distortions (see Figure S1 [29])[28]. In the face centered cubic (FCC) Brillouin zone, the high symmetry XX point lies on a square face and hosts an unstable zone boundary branch. Consequently, the cubic lattice symmetry distortion generates two equivalents XX point realizations, conventionally denoted YY and ZZ, with wave vectors X=(0,12,12)X=(0,\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}), Y=(12,0,12)Y=(\frac{1}{2},0,\frac{1}{2}), Z=(12,12,0)Z=(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},0). Although these wave vectors correspond to different orientations in reciprocal space, they are symmetry equivalent in the cubic parent structure. This can be realized using reduced reciprocal coordinates for FCC square faces described by ∣kx∣=1|k_x|=1, ∣ky∣=1|k_y|=1, and ∣kz∣=1|k_z|=1, indicating that the sum of the wave vector should be 1. Therefore, the associated soft modes, X2′xX_2^{\prime x}, Y2′yY_2^{\prime y}, and Z2′zZ_2^{\prime z}, constitute three equivalent distortion channels, distinguished not by their energetic stability but by the vector orientation and character of their atomic displacement patterns. These dominant zone boundary instabilities couple with other multiple symmetry equivalent modes across the Brillouin zone providing the symmetry allowed ingredients for constructing the polar Pca21Pca2_1 distortions. This symmetry equivalence is conveniently described in Fig. 1(a), where a single atom schematically represents the collective mode displacement of Qm1Q_{m1}, Qm2Q_{m2}, and Qm3Q_{m3} where m1m1, m2m2 and m3m3 represents separate phonon modes and describe distinct collective atomic distortions modes associated with different wave vectors and phonon eigenvectors. In a cubic unit cell structure, the collective dominant oxygen distortion can be related using a set of mode amplitudes, for instance {QX2′x,QY2′y,QZ2′z}\{Q_{X_2^{\prime x}},Q_{Y_2^{\prime y}},Q_{Z_2^{\prime z}}\}, where each QQ denotes the amplitude of a distinct phonon mode. The symmetry equivalent states are therefore determined by the dominant condensed channel, with the corresponding mode acquiring a substantial amplitude while the other channels are suppressed. Notably, this interconversion of phonon modes mechanism is not restricted to the soft modes; polar Γ15x\Gamma_{15}^{x}, Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y}, Γ15z\Gamma_{15}^{z} modes, zone boundary X5yX_5^y, X5zX_5^z, Y5xY_5^x, Y5zY_5^z,

Reciprocal-space origin of cubic HfO₂

Figure S1. Reciprocal-space origin of cubic HfO₂. Brillouin zone of the FCC cubic fluorite reference structure showing the high-symmetry k points and reciprocal-space directions associated with the zone-boundary modes.

Z5xZ_5^x, Z5yZ_5^y, Y5xY_5^x, Y5zY_5^z, X5yX_5^y, X5zX_5^z, oxygen atom modes and X3xX_3^x, Y3yY_3^y, Z3zZ_3^z hafnia atom modes also participate in this interconversion, contributing to the formation of symmetry related rotated variants of the Pca21Pca2_1 phase. Importantly, these are not merely geometrically distinct displacement patterns, they are energetically degenerate because they are connected by the symmetry of the cubic parent lattice. The corresponding energy landscapes exhibit equivalent double well potentials in Fig. 1(b), demonstrating that each mode channel independently provides an equivalent route from the centrosymmetric reference to a polar distorted state.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Symmetry equivalent phonon modes and their distortion energy profile of cubic HfO2_2. (a) Schematic representation of symmetry equivalent phonon modes along distinct collective direction but same mode amplitude QQ, illustrating the collective distortion space spanned by the X2′xX_2^{\prime x}, Y2′yY_2^{\prime y}, and Z2′zZ_2^{\prime z} soft modes at the XX high symmetry point of the Brillouin zone. (b) Relative energy as a function of the mode amplitude QQ for the symmetry equivalent X2′xX_2^{\prime x}, Y2′yY_2^{\prime y}, and Z2′zZ_2^{\prime z} modes.

The multichannel phonon framework provides a microscopic mechanism for polarization rotation in fluorite HfO2_2, in contrast with conventional perovskite ferroelectrics, where symmetry equivalent eigenvectors of a single Γ\Gamma-point polar instability facilitate polarization reorientation (Figure S2 [29]). Consequently, a change in polarization orientation is accompanied by a reorientation of the collective distortion vector in mode space, such that the dominant condensed instability can transfer between symmetry equivalent channels. Thus, the rotated Pca21Pca2_1 variants are distinct minima associated with different directions of the multichannel distortion vector, rather than simple rigid rotations of a single real space polarization pattern. Polarization rotation thus emerges from the cooperative reorientation of symmetry equivalent phonon distortions whose eigenvectors are anchored at different but symmetry related points of the cubic Brillouin zone.

Mechanism of 90° polarization rotation in BaTiO3

Figure S2. Mechanism of 90° polarization rotation in BaTiO3_3. (a) Phonon dispersion of instability in cubic BaTiO3_3 along Γ−X∣Y\Gamma-X|Y, highlighting the three symmetry-equivalent degenerate components of the unstable Γ15\Gamma_{15} polar mode, which condenses to produce the ferroelectric distortion. (b) Atomic displacement patterns of the three Γ15\Gamma_{15} polar mode components Γ15x\Gamma^{x}_{15}, Γ15y\Gamma^{y}_{15}, and Γ15z\Gamma^{z}_{15}. (c) Schematic atomic structures of two 90° rotated ferroelectric domains and their intervening domain wall.

Phonon modes interconversion analysis of 90° rotated Pca21Pca2_1 variants of HfO2_2

Subsequently, the origin of various polarization rotation variants can be understood by identifying the phonon modes of the ferroelectric switching process. Figure 2 shows the atomic scale mechanism of 90° polarization rotation in ferroelectric HfO2_2 through the evolution of symmetry equivalent orthorhombic unit cell variants. We describe the variants by OmNO^N_m where OO denotes the Pca21Pca2_1 structure, mm represents the polarization direction and NN is the dominant soft mode (X2′X'_2, Y2′Y'_2 and Z2′Z'_2) (see Figure S3 [29]). Starting from the OzXO^X_z configuration, polarization rotation proceeds toward the OyXO^X_y, OyZO^Z_y, OxXO^X_x, and OxZO^Z_x variants via a reorganization of the oxygen sublattice while the Hf framework remains nearly invariant. The 90° rotated Pca21Pca2_1 variants are connected by a collective phonon mode interconversion, where the structural distortion alternates between symmetry equivalent phonon channels without change in amplitude.

Phonon modes decomposition of rotated 90° ferroelectric $Pca2_1$ variants of HfO$_2$

Figure 2. Phonon modes decomposition of rotated 90° ferroelectric Pca21Pca2_1 variants of HfO2_2. Starting from the OzXO_z^X unit cell, polarization rotates to symmetry equivalent orthorhombic variants (OyZO_y^Z, OyZO_y^Z, OxYO_x^Y, and OxZO_x^Z). The accompanying mode decomposition plots show the amplitudes of the symmetry adapted lattice distortions. OmNO_m^N denotes a Pca21Pca2_1 structure, with polarization along the mm-direction and soft mode of N2′N_2'.

Schematic of the symmetry-related $Pca2_1$ phase variants

Figure S3. Schematic of the symmetry-related Pca21Pca2_1 phase variants generated from the reference state OzXO_z^X. Here, OmNO_m^N denotes a Pca21Pca2_1 structure, with polarization along the mm-direction and soft mode of N2N_2. The four resulting configurations, OyXO_y^X, OyZO_y^Z, OxYO_x^Y, and OxZO_x^Z illustrate the distinct combinations of polar and anti-polar-mode orientations associated with polarization rotation.

structural distortion alternates between symmetry equivalent phonon channels without change in amplitude. The polar Γ15\Gamma_{15} modes couples with the unstable soft modes and accompanying zone boundary distortions, with their eigenvector contributions being redistributed to condense specific combinations of modes that stabilize each Pca21Pca2_1 variant. Each Pca21Pca2_1 variant is characterized by a set of eight condensed modes which interconvert to form other rotated variant. These eight sets are {Γ15,X2′,X5′,Y5′,Z5′,Z5′,Z5′,Y3′}\{\Gamma_{15}, X'_2, X'_5, Y'_5, Z'_5, Z'_5, Z'_5, Y'_3\}, {Γ15,X2′,X5′,Y5′,Z5′,Y5′,Y5′,Z3′}\{\Gamma_{15}, X'_2, X'_5, Y'_5, Z'_5, Y'_5, Y'_5, Z'_3\}, {Γ15,X5′,Y5′,Z5′,Y5′,Y5′,X3′}\{\Gamma_{15}, X'_5, Y'_5, Z'_5, Y'_5, Y'_5, X'_3\}, {Γ15,Y2′,X5′,Y5′,X5′,X5′,Z3′}\{\Gamma_{15}, Y'_2, X'_5, Y'_5, X'_5, X'_5, Z'_3\}, and {Γ15,Z2′,X5′,Y5′,Z5′,X5′,Y3′}\{\Gamma_{15}, Z'_2, X'_5, Y'_5, Z'_5, X'_5, Y'_3\} corresponding to OzXO^X_z, OyXO^X_y, OyZO^Z_y, OxXO^X_x, and OxZO^Z_x respectively. The mode decomposition results in Figure 2 and its detailed related amplitude in Table S1[29] reveal that each unit cell state is characterized by a distinct combination of condensed modes, demonstrating that polarization reorientation is driven by changes in alternating phonon modes but similar amplitudes. Visualization of atomic displacement patterns of the condensed modes associated with the orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 phase of HfO2_2 is shown in Figure S4-Figure S5 [29]. The plots further demonstrate that the 90° rotation pathway is heavily determined by the dominant zone boundary soft mode X2′X'_2, Y2′Y'_2 and Z2′Z'_2 accompanied by alternation and redistribution of the relative contributions from the additional modes in their respective vector directions. The phonon dispersion plot of the cubic phase of HfO2_2 path Γ−Y∣X−W−Z\Gamma- Y \mid X - W - Z in Figure S6[29] shows the related branches.

StructureΓ15x\Gamma_{15}^{x}Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y}Γ15z\Gamma_{15}^{z}X2′xX_{2}^{\prime x}Y2′yY_{2}^{\prime y}Z2′zZ_{2}^{\prime z}X5yX_{5}^{y}X5zX_{5}^{z}Y5xY_{5}^{x}Y5zY_{5}^{z}Z5xZ_{5}^{x}Z5zZ_{5}^{z}X5′yX_{5}^{\prime y}X5′zX_{5}^{\prime z}Y5′xY_{5}^{\prime x}Y5′zY_{5}^{\prime z}Z5′xZ_{5}^{\prime x}Z5′zZ_{5}^{\prime z}
OzXO_z^X Q(Å)000.4020.488000.397000.3940.3770000000.110
OyXO_y^X Q(Å)00.40200.4880000.3970.377000.3940000.11000
OyZO_y^Z Q(Å)00.4020000.4880.394000.3770.3970000.110000
OxYO_x^Y Q(Å)0.4020000.48800.377000.3970.394000.1100000
OxZO_x^Z Q(Å)0.40200000.48800.3770.394000.3970.11000000
StructureX3′xX_{3}^{\prime x}Y3′yY_{3}^{\prime y}Z3′zZ_{3}^{\prime z}X5′yX_{5}^{\prime y}X5′zX_{5}^{\prime z}Y5′xY_{5}^{\prime x}Y5′zY_{5}^{\prime z}Z5′xZ_{5}^{\prime x}Z5′yZ_{5}^{\prime y}
OzXO_z^X Q(Å)00.089000000.1730
OyXO_y^X Q(Å)000.089000.173000
OyZO_y^Z Q(Å)0.089000000.17300
OxYO_x^Y Q(Å)000.0890.17300000
OxZO_x^Z Q(Å)00.089000.1730000

Table S1. 5 variants of OO phases of HfO2_2. Computed amplitudes (Å) of each phonon mode of structures are listed in the table. Oxygen modes and hafnia modes are separate for clarity.

Structural visualizations of oxygen phonon modes with grey Hf spheres, green O spheres, and displacement arrows

Figure S4. Structural visualization of oxygen phonon modes associated with the orthorhombic Pca21\mathrm{Pca}2_1 phase of HfO2\mathrm{HfO_2} and its rotated variants with the cubic phase as reference. Grey and green spheres represent Hf and O atoms, respectively, while arrows indicate the direction and relative amplitude of the corresponding atomic displacements. The visualized modes capture the distinct polar and nonpolar distortions that characterize the o-phase and provide the microscopic structural basis for its polarization and mode-coupling behavior.

Structural visualizations of hafnia phonon modes with grey Hf spheres, green O spheres, and displacement arrows

Figure S5. Structural visualization of hafnia phonon modes associated with the orthorhombic Pca21\mathrm{Pca}2_1 phase of HfO2\mathrm{HfO_2} and its rotated variants with the cubic phase as reference. Grey and green spheres represent Hf and O atoms, respectively, while arrows indicate the direction and relative amplitude of the corresponding atomic displacements. The visualized modes capture the distinct polar and nonpolar distortions that characterize the Pca21\mathrm{Pca}2_1 phase and provide the microscopic structural basis for its polarization and mode-coupling behavior.

Phonon dispersion of the orthorhombic phase of HfO₂ along the high-symmetry path Γ−Y | X−W−Z

Figure S6. Phonon dispersion of the orthorhombic phase of HfO₂ along the high-symmetry path Γ−Y | X−W−Z. The branches identify the symmetry-labeled phonon modes relevant to the structural distortions of the Pca21Pca2_{1} phase, including the zone-center polar mode and the zone-boundary modes. The imaginary frequency indicated in red represent the zone boundary soft modes instability associated with the phase transition distortion from nonpolar and polar phase.

Significantly, while the overall distortion magnitude remains comparable among the symmetry related variants, the dominant mode amplitudes are selectively enhanced or suppressed depending on the final polarization direction. This behavior recognizes polarization rotation as a phonon mediated transformation between equivalent free energy minima, where the condensation and coupling of multiple lattice instabilities stabilize distinct orthorhombic variants (Figure S7 [29]). Figure 2 therefore provides direct evidence that 90° switching in HfO2_2 is a collective condense mode reconfiguration driven primarily by mode interconversion.

Two-dimensional energy map of trilinear coupled lattice-distortion modes

Figure S7. Two-dimensional energy map of trilinear coupled lattice-distortion modes. (a) Energy contour map of Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y} and X5yX_{5}^{y} with the amplitude of Y2y′Y_{2}^{y'} fixed at its maximum value. (b) Energy of Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y} and X5zX_{5}^{z} with the amplitude of Z2z′Z_{2}^{z'} fixed at its maximum value. (c) Energy of Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y} and X5yX_{5}^{y} with the amplitude of Z2z′Z_{2}^{z'} fixed at its maximum value. (d) Energy of Γ15y\Gamma_{15}^{y} and X5yX_{5}^{y} with the amplitude of X2x′X_{2}^{x'} fixed at its maximum value.

Energy landscape for phonon-mediated evolution of 90° switching in variant orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 HfO2_2

The calculated switching energy landscapes reveal that polarization rotation in orthorhombic HfO2_2 is intrinsically anisotropic amongst different variants. As shown in Figure 3(a), all four 90° switching pathways exhibit individual barrier energy profiles, indicating distinct polarization rotation between equivalent ferroelectric states. Among the investigated pathways, the OzX→OxYO_z^X \rightarrow O_x^Y and OzX→OyZO_z^X \rightarrow O_y^Z transformation possesses the largest energy barrier of 0.53 eV, whereas the OzX→OyXO_z^X \rightarrow O_y^X pathway exhibits the lowest energetic cost of 0.302 eV, suggesting this path as a preferred switching mechanism. Thus, the existence of multiple energetically distinct rotational pathways demonstrates that 90° polarization switching is promoted not only by the symmetry variants but by cooperative condensed modes. In contrast, the conventional 180° switching pathway has a comparable energy barrier of 0.31 eV passing through the non-polar tetragonal phase, P42/nmcP4_2/nmc as shown in Figure 3(b), highlighting a competitive switching mechanism between 90° and 180° pathway [30,31].

Energy landscapes and condensed mode evolution for 90° polarization switching

Figure 3. Energy landscapes and condense mode evolution for 90° polarization switching in orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 HfO2_2. (a) Calculated minimum energy pathways for the four symmetry-distinct 90° polarization rotation processes between orthorhombic variants (OzX→OyXO_z^X \to O_y^X, OzX→OyZO_z^X \to O_y^Z, OzX→OxYO_z^X \to O_x^Y, and OzX→OxZO_z^X \to O_x^Z). (b) Comparison of the minimum energy pathways for 90° polarization rotation and conventional 180° polarization reversal. (c) Symmetry adapted phonon mode decomposition of the intermediate structures along the 90° switching pathways, showing the evolution of the dominant condensed modes and their corresponding crystal structures.

The energetically preferred OzX→OyXO_z^X \rightarrow O_y^X pathway proceeding through the Pmn21Pmn2_1 intermediate phase, largely preserves the dominant condensed X2′X_2' oxygen distortion while requiring only a gradual redistribution of the vectors in X5X_5 mode and Γ15\Gamma_{15} polar distortions. However, because the primary oxygen framework remains nearly intact, only a small lattice rearrangement is required to rotate the polarization vector, resulting in the lowest switching barrier among all four pathways. Thus, the Pmn21Pmn2_1 intermediate phase provides a structurally compatible bridge between the initial and final ferroelectric variants, allowing the polarization to rotate continuously with minimal distortion of the oxygen configuration.

Also, we further analyze the distortion modes along the intermediate phases of the switching pathways in Figure 3(c). Although all pathways originate from the same ferroelectric OzXO_z^X variant, they evolve through distinct symmetry selected intermediate structures, namely Pmn21Pmn2_1, R3R3, Pa3ˉPa\bar{3}, and CmCm, before reaching the rotated polarization state. These intermediate phases exhibit distinct profiles of condensed phonon modes, reflecting their different symmetries and underlying lattice distortions. The switching process therefore involves the selective condensation and reorganization of phonon modes as the structure evolves along each pathway. Hence, the intermediate phases represent transient geometries states along the multichannel phonon energy landscape.

Phonon mode mechanism in 90° domain wall configuration and its energetics

Unlike conventional 180° domain walls, 90° domains in HfO2_2 possess continuous alternation and redistribution of condensed phonon modes at the wall center (see Figure S8[29]). Thus, to elucidate the microscopic origin of the distinct energetics of 90° domain walls, we constructed eight domain wall configurations connecting the different 90° Pca21Pca2_1 variants in Figure 4(a). Out of these eight DW, two are charged-neutral (OzX/OxXO_z^X/O_x^X, OzY/OxYO_z^Y/O_x^Y) and six are charged (OzX/OyXO_z^X/O_y^X, OzX/OyZO_z^X/O_y^Z, OyX/OxYO_y^X/O_x^Y, OyX/OxZO_y^X/O_x^Z, OyY/OxYO_y^Y/O_x^Y, and OyY/OxZO_y^Y/O_x^Z). Although electrostatic interactions contribute substantially to the excess energy of charged domain walls, an additional structural penalty arises from the differently oriented condensed phonon modes in adjacent domains. This mode mismatch induces local reorganization of the underlying lattice distortions, leading to mode competition accommodating the 90° interface.

90° domain wall configurations and associated energetics in HfO2

Figure 4. 90° domain wall configurations and its associated energetics in HfO2_2. (a) Atomistic structures of 90° domain wall variants, constructed from Pca21Pca2_1 distinct rotated variants. (b) Schematic illustration of the mode interconversion mechanism across a 90° domain wall, where multiple modes acquire substantial amplitudes and progressively interconvert. Their simultaneous activation and competition of coexisting modes produce phonon mode frustration at the wall center. Q represents the amplitude of modes (m1,m2,m3m1,m2,m3) (c) Domain Wall Energies of all 90° domain structures generated from rotated variants. (d) Spatial variation of the symmetry mode amplitudes across selected generated 90° domain walls. The units of these structural order parameters are that of distance (in Å) because they are measuring the amount of distortion.

Domain wall mode evolution

Figure S8. Domain wall Mode evolution. (a) 180° domain wall mode evolution, where mode across the domain undergoes mode sign change, with mode at the domain center exerting no amplitude. (b) 90° domain wall mode evolution, where the modes across the domain interconvert and coexist at the domain wall center with substantial amplitude.

The two equivalent variants of the 90° bidomain are moreover connected by a mixed mode motif state in which modes coexist at the wall, enabling a structurally compatible but energetically complex domain due to stress distortion at the wall. As shown in the schematic diagram in Figure 4(b) the left domain can be characterized by the dominant mode distortion Qm1Q_{m1}, whereas the right domain is described by an equivalent dominant mode oriented along Qm2Q_{m2} or Qm3Q_{m3}, where Q represents the amplitude of a mode (m1,m2,m3m1,m2,m3). At the wall center, both order parameters coexist promoting the formation of variant 90° domain walls.

This reorganization in 90° domains proceeds through a mode interconversion where the dominant mode characters of each domain progressively evolve across the wall, while modes that are suppressed become increasingly activated toward the interface. Crucially, the wall center represents a highly constrained region in which several modes coexist with substantial amplitudes. Their simultaneous activation and competition prevent the local structure from optimizing all mode contributions independently, giving rise to pronounced phonon mode frustration [32-34]. Here, we define phonon mode frustration as the incompatibility among multiple condensed phonon modes that retain substantial amplitudes at the DW center but compete to accommodate their preferred atomic displacements within the local lattice structure. This mode frustration has a direct energetic consequence, thus, if the local structural constraints force, coupled modes into a configuration that is not their preferred energetic minimum, the coupling terms and distortion energies can produce an excess energy. Studies on HfO2_2 domain walls explicitly demonstrates that different ways of combining or reversing condensed phonon modes produce different domain wall energies, with appropriate mode coupling capable of compensating the wall energy in some configurations [35].

The Domain Wall Energy (DWE) is analyzed to determines the stability and energetic cost of the 90° domain walls.

In Figure 4(c), the calculated domain wall energies (DWE) reveal a highly anisotropic energy landscape for 90° domain variants of the orthorhombic HfO2_2. The eight 90° domain wall variants exhibit substantially different domain wall energies with, OzX/OxYO_z^X/O_x^Y, OzX/OyZO_z^X/O_y^Z, OzX/OxYO_z^X/O_x^Y, OzX/OxZO_z^X/O_x^Z, OyX/OyXO_y^X/O_y^X, OyX/OzXO_y^X/O_z^X, OyX/OxO_y^X/O_x, and OyX/OzXO_y^X/O_z^X, having energies of 567.1, 674.3, 484.7, 469.6, 779.8, 663.7, 834.6 and 570.0 mJm−2^{-2}, respectively (see Table S2[29]).

Domain wallPolarizationCharge stateDWE (mJm−2^{-2})
OzX/OyXO_{z}^{X}/O_{y}^{X}+z→+y+z \to+yCharged567.1
OzX/OyZO_{z}^{X}/O_{y}^{Z}+z→−y+z \to-yCharged674.3
OzX/OxYO_{z}^{X}/O_{x}^{Y}+z→−x+z \to-xNeutral484.7
OzX/OxZO_{z}^{X}/O_{x}^{Z}+z→+x+z \to+xNeutral469.6
OyX/OxYO_{y}^{X}/O_{x}^{Y}+y→−x+y \to-xCharged779.8
OyX/OxZO_{y}^{X}/O_{x}^{Z}+y→+x+y \to+xCharged663.7
OyZ/OxYO_{y}^{Z}/O_{x}^{Y}−y→−x-y \to-xCharged834.6
OyZ/OxZO_{y}^{Z}/O_{x}^{Z}−y→+x-y \to+xCharged570.0

Table S2. Calculated domain-wall energies for different 90° domain configurations in orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_{1} of HfO2_{2} using Hf_sv Standard potential. The values represent the energy cost of forming domain walls between different polarization variants.

The elevated DWE of charged 90° domain walls is primarily attributed to the electrostatic penalty associated with polarization discontinuities, whereas the two charge-neutral walls exhibit lesser energies of 484.7 and 469.6 mJm−2^{-2}. Nevertheless, all 90° domain walls exhibit phonon mode frustration arising from the coexistence and competition of condensed modes at the wall center, which induces local mode mismatch and contributes to the wall energy. The mode amplitude profiles across the domain wall in Figure 4(d) and Figure S10[29] directly reveals this distinction for all the 90° domain variants. At their domain wall center, the coexistence of zone center and zone boundary modes with substantial amplitudes indicates the influence of mode competition and local structural incompatibility. Since these modes favor different atomic displacement patterns, their simultaneous activation can prevent optimal lattice relaxation, increasing energetic cost. The resulting phonon mode frustration therefore contributes to the excess domain wall energy, with stronger mode overlap and competition generally associated with a larger energetic penalty. This trend is consistent with the OzX/OxZO_z^X/O_x^Z domain wall, which exhibits the lowest DWE and fewer coexisting modes at the wall center.

Spatial evolution of the symmetry mode amplitudes across all generated 90° domain walls

Figure S10. Spatial evolution of the symmetry mode amplitudes across all generated 90° domain walls. The units of these structural order parameters are that of distance (in Å) because they are measuring the amount of distortion.

Experimental formation of low energy 90° domain wall in HfO2_2

To establish an experimental connection with our theoretical predictions, we investigate the atomic-scale domain structure of HfO2_2. Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) imaging reveals adjacent ferroelectric domains in HfO2_2 with polarization orientations rotated by 90°, meeting at a well-defined interface in Figure 5(a) and 5(c). The two domains correspond to Pca21Pca2_1 variants, distinguished by the orientation of their polarization and the associated collective oxygen displacements. In the OzXO_z^X variant, the dominant Z2z′ZZ_{2z}^{\prime Z} soft mode distortion stabilizes the orthorhombic ferroelectric structure with polarization along the z-direction. In the OxXO_x^X variant, the corresponding X2xXX_{2x}^X distortion stabilizes the rotated structure with polarization along x-direction.

Experimental observation of 90° domain wall in HfO2

Figure 5. Experimental observation of 90° domain wall in HfO2_2. (a) Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image showing 5 nm resolution of two ferroelectric domains with regions forming 90° orientation matching to OzX/OzZO_{z}^{X}/O_{z}^{Z}. (b) Corresponding Fourier-transform patterns and atomic-resolution images from the two domain regions, illustrating their distinct crystallographic orientations. Structural model illustrating the OzX/OzZO_{z}^{X}/O_{z}^{Z} domain. (c) Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image showing 2 nm resolution of 90° OzX/OzZO_{z}^{X}/O_{z}^{Z} ferroelectric domains (d) Enlarged atomic-resolution images across the domain wall, highlighting the local atomic arrangement on either side of the interface. (e) Simulated Annular Bright Field (ABF) images of the OzX/OzZO_{z}^{X}/O_{z}^{Z} domain structure.

Therefore, the observed interface corresponds to OzX/OzXO_z^X/O_z^X 90° domain wall. Thus, the experimentally observed 90° domain configuration reflects the interconversion between symmetry-related distortion channels rather than a rigid rotation of an otherwise unchanged polarization state.

The atomic scale origin of this distinction is further illustrated by the local diffraction patterns and enlarged structural images in Figure 5(b) and 5(d), respectively, together with the simulated annular-bright-field (ABF) image in Figure 5(e).

The Fourier-transformed patterns reveal distinct sets of orthorhombic reflections in the two domains, including the ((002)o), ((201)o), and ((200)o) reflections in one orientation and the ((200)o), ((110)o), and ((020)o) reflections in the other. These differences identify the distinct crystallographic orientations of the neighboring domains and provide reciprocal-space evidence for the experimentally observed 90° reorientation. The corresponding inverse-space atomic arrangements further reveal differences in the local oxygen-sublattice configuration, connecting the crystallographic rotation to the underlying lattice distortions.

These observations provide a structural basis for interpreting the different oxygen displacement patterns associated with the two variants. Within our phonon mode framework, condensation of the Z2z′ZZ_{2z}^{\prime Z} and X2xXX_{2x}^{X} modes, coupled to the corresponding polar Γ15Z\Gamma_{15}^{Z} and Γ15X\Gamma_{15}^{X} modes and accompanying zone-boundary distortions, generates the distinct oxygen-dominated lattice configurations. The observed domain orientations and interfacial atomic arrangement are therefore consistent with the calculated mode interconversion mechanism, in which the collective oxygen displacements reorganize cooperatively to stabilize the rotated Pca21Pca2_1 variants.

At the interface, the two distortion patterns must be accommodated within a common lattice, requiring the local reorganization of mode amplitudes. The coexistence of modes associated with both variants introduces competing atomic displacement requirements, promoting phonon mode frustration where the local structure cannot simultaneously optimize all condensed mode contributions.

These results are consistent with our theoretical framework, in which the interconversion of distinct phonon modes enables polarization rotation and facilitates the formation of alternative domain orientations. The calculated DWE suggests that the 90° configuration is energetically accessible, though not necessarily favored. Its prevalence in experiments may also depend on strain, defects and electrostatic boundary conditions. The agreement between experimental observations and theoretical predictions thus supports the physical plausibility of the OzX/OzZO_{z}^{X}/O_{z}^{Z} 90° domain wall configuration in HfO2_2.

Conclusion

In summary, we establish a microscopic framework for understanding 90° polarization rotation in fluorite ferroelectric HfO2_2 by connecting condensed phonon mode evolution to polarization switching and domain wall energetics. Our results reveal that polarization rotation emerges from the cooperative reorientation and coupling of multiple symmetry equivalent phonon modes with distinct eigenstates across the Brillouin zone. Their collective evolution generates distinct Pca21Pca2_{1} variants and enables competing switching pathways through structurally and symmetrically distinct intermediate phases, including Pmn21Pmn2_{1}, R3R3, Pa3Pa3, and CmCm. In particular, the relatively low-energy pathway through Pmn21Pmn2_{1} demonstrates that 90° polarization rotation can compete energetically with conventional 180° polarization reversal through P42/nmcP4_{2}/nmc, establishing an alternative route for polarization switching in hafnia.

Extending this microscopic background to domain walls, we show that the energetic stability of 90° interfaces is determined by the interplay between local phonon mode frustration, structural compatibility, and electrostatics. The coexistence and competition of condensed modes at the wall center generate local structural distortions and contribute to the domain wall energy, whereas electrostatic interactions provide the dominant additional energetic penalty for charged configurations. These results establish a direct connection between the bulk switching landscape and the energetics of spatially inhomogeneous polarization textures. Importantly, experimental observations of stable 90° domain walls provide structural evidence consistent with our theoretically identified low-energy configurations, linking the predicted atomistic mechanisms to domain structures realized in HfO2_2. These results establish condensed mode reorientation and phonon mode frustration as fundamental structural mechanisms driving polarization rotation and domain wall formation in fluorite ferroelectrics, providing a unified framework for understanding 90° switching, domain wall stability, and their contributions to the macroscopic behavior of HfO2_2-based ferroelectrics.

Acknowledgement. This work is supported by the project of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Program No. 12474061, 52372113,), the support from the Youth Project of Shanxi High-level Talents Introduction Plan (51132400032), the Innovation Capability Support Program of Shaanxi (Program No. 2024RS-CXTD-30). This work was also supported by the Advanced Materials-National Science and Technology Major Project (2026ZD0623501), and the funding from Suzhou National Laboratory (SK-1902-2026-004).

These authors contributed equally: Fatoye Sawyerr & Hamoon Fahrvandi

Multichannel Phonon Interconversion Drives 90∘90^\circ Polarization Rotation for Stable Domain Wall in Hafnium Oxide

Fatoye Sawyerr; Hamoon Fahrvandi; Pawan Kumar; Zekun Zhang; Shuning Lv; Yue Yu; Xuan Gao; Kang Jia; Shifeng Wen; Zheng Wen; Li-Min Liu; Xiaoli Fan; Jun Hee Lee; Tengfei Cao

Computational Method

We conducted first-principles calculations based on density-functional theory (DFT) using VASP code [1]. We adopted a generalized gradient approximation (GGA) for describing exchange correlation energy functional and pseudopotentials generated under projector-augmented planewave (PAW) scheme by Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof for solids (PBEsol) [2], [3], [4]. Energy cut-off for plane wave basis was set to 500 eV and force tolerance for the structure optimization was 0.01 eV/Å. For HfO2\mathrm{HfO}_{2}, (4×4×4)(4 \times4 \times4) kk-point grid was chosen under Monkhorst-Pack (MP) method for sampling integrations over the Brillouin zone [5]. The unit cell contained four formula units, orthorhombic HfO2\mathrm{HfO}_{2} with a=5.2733a = 5.2733 Å, b=5.0551b = 5.0551 Å and c=5.085c = 5.085 Å, consistent with theoretical and experimentally measured values. The DW structure is simulated within the supercell consisting of two ferroelectric domains with different polarization orientations. Thus, the DW supercell contains 8-10 HfO2\mathrm{HfO}_{2} unit cells and 2 DWs. The 6×1×66 \times1 \times6 and 8×1×88 \times1 \times8 Monkhorst Pack kk-meshes are used for the structural optimization and self-consistence calculations, respectively.

Sample Preparation

Sr doped HfO2\mathrm{HfO}_{2} thin films and ITO bottom electrodes were grown on (001)-oriented YSZ substrates by pulsed laser deposition (PLD) using a KrF excimer laser. The approximately 20-nm-thick ITO layer was deposited at a substrate temperature of 600 °C, an oxygen pressure of 0.02 mbar, a laser fluence of ~2.5 J/cm², and a pulse repetition rate of 5 Hz. Subsequently, SHO films were deposited at the same substrate temperature of 600 °C, with an oxygen pressure of 0.1 mbar, a laser fluence of ~3 J/cm², and a repetition rate of 4 Hz. Film thickness was regulated by controlling the number of laser pulses. Finally, Pt top electrodes with a diameter of approximately 50 μm and a thickness of ~30 nm were fabricated by DC magnetron sputtering through a shadow mask.

Characterizations

HAADF-STEM imaging was performed at an accelerating voltage of 200 kV using a spherical aberration corrected ThermoFisher Spectra 300 scanning transmission electron microscope equipped with a Super-X energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) detector and a GatanContinuum 1065 spectrometer. TEM lamellae were prepared by focused ion beam milling using a Ga ion source, followed by further thinning with a precision argon ion polishing system. During HAADF-STEM acquisition, the detector collection angle was set to approximately ∼\sim50-200 mrad, with a probe convergence angle of ∼\sim21 mrad. Ferroelectric domain configurations were characterized by vector piezoresponse force microscopy (PFM) using an Asylum Research MFP-3D atomic force microscope equipped with conductive Pt/Ir-coated tips.

The reciprocal-space geometry of cubic Fm3ˉmFm\bar{3}m HfO₂ provides the foundation for identifying its symmetry-related phonon instabilities. As shown in Figure S1, the first Brillouin zone of the fluorite structure is that of an fcc lattice (lattice constant aa) and forms a truncated octahedron bounded by six square and eight hexagonal faces. The square faces satisfy ∣kx∣=∣ky∣=∣kz∣=2π/a|k_x|=|k_y|=|k_z|=2\pi/a, whereas the hexagonal faces are defined by ∣kx∣+∣ky∣+∣kz∣=3π/a|k_x|+|k_y|+|k_z|=3\pi/a. In reduced reciprocal coordinates, k∗=(a/2π)kk^*=(a/2\pi)k, the square faces are described by ∣kx∗∣=1|k_x^*|=1, ∣ky∗∣=1|k_y^*|=1, and ∣kz∗∣=1|k_z^*|=1, while the hexagonal faces satisfy ∣kx∗∣+∣ky∗∣+∣kz∗∣=3/2|k_x^*|+|k_y^*|+|k_z^*|=3/2. The high-symmetry points of the fcc Brillouin zone, including Γ\Gamma, KK, LL, UU, WW, and XX, are indicated in Figure S6. Of particular interest is the XX point, located at the square face of the Brillouin zone. In the reduced reciprocal coordinate representation (∣kx∗∣=1|k_x^*|=1), its symmetry equivalent realizations can be expressed along the Cartesian basis vectors (x^,y^,z^\hat{x},\hat{y},\hat{z}).[6] The corresponding XX, YY, and ZZ wave vectors X=(0,12,12)X=(0,\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}), Y=(12,0,12)Y=(\frac{1}{2},0,\frac{1}{2}), Z=(12,12,0)Z=(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},0) are related by the rotational symmetry of the cubic lattice and therefore represent equivalent directions in reciprocal space. This symmetry equivalence provides the basis for the degenerate phonon modes observed at the corresponding high-symmetry points in the phonon dispersion reveals different unstable branches at these symmetry related wave vectors, including the polar (Γ15x,Γ15y,Γ15z\Gamma^{x}_{15},\Gamma^{y}_{15},\Gamma^{z}_{15}) modes, zone boundary soft modes (X2x,Y2y,Z2zX^{x}_{2},Y^{y}_{2},Z^{z}_{2}), and additional (X5(y,z),Y5(x,z),Z5(x,y)X_{5}^{(y,z)},Y_{5}^{(x,z)},Z_{5}^{(x,y)}) modes.

90° Polarization rotation in BaTiO3_3

The microscopic mechanism underlying 90° polarization rotation in BaTiO3_3 differs fundamentally from that in HfO2_2 because of the distinct origins of their ferroelectric instabilities. In cubic BaTiO3_3, ferroelectricity originates from a single unstable zone-center Γ15\Gamma_{15} polar mode. Its three degenerate components, Γ15x\Gamma^{x}_{15}, Γ15y\Gamma^{y}_{15}, and Γ15z\Gamma^{z}_{15} describe symmetry-equivalent polar distortions along the three Cartesian directions. Condensation of any one component breaks the cubic symmetry and establishes a spontaneous polarization along the corresponding direction. Consequently, 90°-rotated ferroelectric variants can be formed by switching the condensed polarization component from one direction to another within the same underlying polar-mode manifold. The rotation therefore does not intrinsically require coupling between distinct phonon modes to establish the ferroelectric phase, although anharmonic mode coupling and elastic interactions can still influence the rotation pathway. Thus, the mechanism at the 90° domain wall requires less energy to form due to single mode change. In HfO2_2, by contrast, the ferroelectric orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_1 phase cannot be understood simply through the condensation of a single polar mode. Its stabilization involves the cooperative interplay of the Γ\Gamma-point polar distortion with unstable zone-boundary soft modes and additional dominated lattice distortions. These modes collectively establish the polar structure and its characteristic oxygen sublattice displacements. A 90° polarization rotation therefore involves more than selecting another component of a single polar instability. Hence, it requires the interconversion and reorganization of multiple coupled phonon modes to construct the symmetry equivalent, rotated Pca21Pca2_1 variant. The mode amplitudes and displacement patterns must reorganize cooperatively while preserving the essential structural features of the ferroelectric phase.

90° domain wall variants of Pca2₁ phase of HfO₂

Figure S9. 90° Domain wall variants of Pca21Pca2_{1} phase of HfO2HfO_{2}. The distinct combinations of variant 90° single domain to form domain walls. The labels and symbols denote the respective polarization and mode directions. The configurations illustrate how polarization rotation is accompanied by a

corresponding reorientation of the structural mode.

The Domain Wall Energy (DWE) is analyzed to determines the stability of the 90° domain walls which expressed as

DWE=EDW−Ebulk2ADWE = \frac{E_{DW} - E_{bulk}}{2A}

with EDWE_{DW} and EbulkE_{bulk} denoting the total energies of the domain wall EDWE_{DW} and corresponding bulk supercells EbulkE_{bulk}, respectively, and the cross-sectional area of a single domain wall AA.

Structural transformation from the parent cubic phase to orthorhombic $Pca2_{1}$ variants of HfO$_2$ with their respective intermediate phases and dominant modes

Figure S11. Structural transformation from the parent cubic phase to orthorhombic Pca21Pca2_{1} variants of HfO2_2 with their respective intermediate phases and dominant modes.

The coexistence of multiple lattice-distortion modes is dictated by symmetry-allowed interactions in the free energy, with trilinear coupling playing a particularly important role in HfO2_2. To investigate the energetic interactions among the relevant phonon modes associated with the rotated orthorhombic variants of fluorite HfO2_2, we construct a Landau-type energy expansion in terms of the corresponding symmetry-mode amplitudes. The cubic fluorite phase (Fm3ˉmFm\bar{3}m) serves as the reference structure. Five rotated variants, denoted (OzX)(O_z^X), (OyX)(O_y^X), (OyZ)(O_y^Z), (OxY)(O_x^Y), and (OxZ)(O_x^Z), are considered. For each variant, the energy is expressed as a function of eight mode amplitudes, including the zone-center polar mode and selected zone-boundary modes. {Γ15z,X2,x′,X5y,Y5z,Z5x,Z5y,Z5x,Y3y}\{\Gamma_{15}^z, X_{2,x}^{\prime}, X_5^y, Y_5^z, Z_5^x, Z_5^y, Z_5^x, Y_3^y\}, {Γ15y,X2,x′,X5z,Y5x,Z5y,Y5x,Y5z,Z3z}\{\Gamma_{15}^y, X_{2,x}^{\prime}, X_5^z, Y_5^x, Z_5^y, Y_5^x, Y_5^z, Z_3^z\}, {Γ15y,Z2,z′,X5y,Y5z,Z5x,Y5x,Y5z,X3x}\{\Gamma_{15}^y, Z_{2,z}^{\prime}, X_5^y, Y_5^z, Z_5^x, Y_5^x, Y_5^z, X_3^x\}, {Γ15x,Y2,y′,X5y,Y5z,Z5x,X5y,X5z,Z3z}\{\Gamma_{15}^x, Y_{2,y}^{\prime}, X_5^y, Y_5^z, Z_5^x, X_5^y, X_5^z, Z_3^z\}, and {Γ15x,Z2,z′,X5z,Y5x,Z5y,X5y,X5z,Y3y}\{\Gamma_{15}^x, Z_{2,z}^{\prime}, X_5^z, Y_5^x, Z_5^y, X_5^y, X_5^z, Y_3^y\} corresponding to OzXO_z^X, OyXO_y^X, OyZO_y^Z, OxYO_x^Y, and OxZO_x^Z respectively.

The allowed trilinear coupling terms are expressed as the following Equation.

(a) OzXO_z^X

Etri(OzX)=a1QΓ15zQX2,x′QX5y+a2QΓ15zQY3,y′QY5z+a3QΓ15zQZ5,y′QZ5x+a4QΓ15zQZ5,x′QZ5x+a5QX2,x′QY3,y′QZ5x+a6QX2,x′QY5zQZ5,y′+a7QX2,x′QY5zQZ5,x′+a8QX5yQY5zQZ5x+a9QX5yQY3,y′QZ5,y′+a10QX5yQY3,y′QZ5,x′\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(O_z^X)}={}&a_1Q_{\Gamma_{15}^z}Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{X_5^y}+a_2Q_{\Gamma_{15}^z}Q_{Y_{3,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}\\ &+a_3Q_{\Gamma_{15}^z}Q_{Z_{5,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_4Q_{\Gamma_{15}^z}Q_{Z_{5,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_5Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_{3,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_6Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Z_{5,y}^{\prime}}\\ &+a_7Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Z_{5,x}^{\prime}}+a_8Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_9Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Y_{3,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_{5,y}^{\prime}}+a_{10}Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Y_{3,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_{5,x}^{\prime}} \end{aligned}

(b) OyXO_y^X

Etri(OyX)=a1QΓ15yQX2,x′QX5z+a2QΓ15yQZ3,z′QY5x+a3QΓ15yQY5,x′QZ5y+a4QΓ15yQY5,z′QZ5y+a5QX2,x′QZ3,z′QZ5y+a6QX2,x′QY5xQY5,x′+a7QX2,x′QY5xQY5,z′+a8QX5zQY5xQZ5y+a9QX5zQZ3,z′QY5,x′+a10QX5zQZ3,z′QY5,z′\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(O_y^X)}={}&a_1Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{X_5^z}+a_2Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^x}\\ &+a_3Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^y}+a_4Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^y}\\ &+a_5Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^y}+a_6Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^x}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}\\ &+a_7Q_{X_{2,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^x}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}}+a_8Q_{X_5^z}Q_{Y_5^x}Q_{Z_5^y}\\ &+a_9Q_{X_5^z}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}+a_{10}Q_{X_5^z}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}} \end{aligned}

(c) OyZO_y^Z

Etri(OyZ)=a1QΓ15yQZ2,z′QX5y+a2QΓ15yQX3,x′QY5z+a3QΓ15yQY5,x′QZ5x+a4QΓ15yQY5,z′QZ5x+a5QZ2,z′QX3,x′QZ5x+a6QZ2,z′QY5zQY5,x′+a7QZ2,z′QY5zQY5,z′+a8QX5yQY5zQZ5x+a9QX5yQX3,x′QY5,x′+a10QX5yQX3,x′QY5,z′\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(O_y^Z)}={}&a_1Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Z_{2,z}^{\prime}}Q_{X_5^y}+a_2Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{X_{3,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}\\ &+a_3Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_4Q_{\Gamma_{15}^y}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_5Q_{Z_{2,z}^{\prime}}Q_{X_{3,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_6Q_{Z_{2,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}\\ &+a_7Q_{Z_{2,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}}+a_8Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_9Q_{X_5^y}Q_{X_{3,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_{5,x}^{\prime}}+a_{10}Q_{X_5^y}Q_{X_{3,x}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_{5,z}^{\prime}} \end{aligned}

(d) OxYO_x^Y

Etri(OxY)=a1QΓ15xQY2,y′QX5y+a2QΓ15xQZ3,z′QY5z+a3QΓ15xQX5,y′QZ5x+a4QΓ15xQX5,z′QZ5x+a5QY2,y′QZ3,z′QZ5x+a6QY2,y′QY5zQX5,y′+a7QY2,y′QY5zQX5,z′+a8QX5yQY5zQZ5x+a9QX5yQZ3,z′QX5,y′+a10QX5yQZ3,z′QX5,z′\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(O_x^Y)}={}&a_1Q_{\Gamma_{15}^x}Q_{Y_{2,y}^{\prime}}Q_{X_5^y}+a_2Q_{\Gamma_{15}^x}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}\\ &+a_3Q_{\Gamma_{15}^x}Q_{X_{5,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_4Q_{\Gamma_{15}^x}Q_{X_{5,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_5Q_{Y_{2,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{Z_5^x}+a_6Q_{Y_{2,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{X_{5,y}^{\prime}}\\ &+a_7Q_{Y_{2,y}^{\prime}}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{X_{5,z}^{\prime}}+a_8Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Y_5^z}Q_{Z_5^x}\\ &+a_9Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{X_{5,y}^{\prime}}+a_{10}Q_{X_5^y}Q_{Z_{3,z}^{\prime}}Q_{X_{5,z}^{\prime}} \end{aligned}

(e) OxZO_x^Z

Etri(Ozx)=a1QΓ15xQZ2′zQX5z+a2QΓ15xQY3′yQY5x+a3QΓ15xQX5′yQZ5y+a4QΓ15xQX5′zQZ5z+a5QZ2′zQY3′yQZ5y+a6QZ2′zQY5xQX5′y+a7QZ2′zQY5xQX5′z+a8QX5zQY5xQZ5z+a9QX5zQY3′yQX5′y+a10QX5zQY3′yQX5′z.E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(O_z^x)} = a_1Q_{\Gamma_{15}}^xQ_{Z_2'}^zQ_{X_5}^z + a_2Q_{\Gamma_{15}}^xQ_{Y_3'}^yQ_{Y_5}^x + a_3Q_{\Gamma_{15}}^xQ_{X_5'}^yQ_{Z_5}^y + a_4Q_{\Gamma_{15}}^xQ_{X_5'}^zQ_{Z_5}^z + a_5Q_{Z_2'}^zQ_{Y_3'}^yQ_{Z_5}^y + a_6Q_{Z_2'}^zQ_{Y_5}^xQ_{X_5'}^y + a_7Q_{Z_2'}^zQ_{Y_5}^xQ_{X_5'}^z + a_8Q_{X_5}^zQ_{Y_5}^xQ_{Z_5}^z + a_9Q_{X_5}^zQ_{Y_3'}^yQ_{X_5'}^y + a_{10}Q_{X_5}^zQ_{Y_3'}^yQ_{X_5'}^z.

Here, (Etri(v)E_{\mathrm{tri}}^{(v)}) denotes the trilinear coupling contribution to the Landau free energy for the polarization variant (vv), where (v∈Ozx,Oyx,Oyz,Oxy,Oxzv \in O_z^x, O_y^x, O_y^z, O_x^y, O_x^z). The quantities (QλαQ_{\lambda}^{\alpha}) represent the amplitudes of symmetry-adapted phonon modes, with (λ\lambda) identifying the corresponding phonon-mode irreducible representation or Brillouin-zone wavevector label (e.g., (Γ15\Gamma_{15}), (X5X_5), (Y5Y_5), and (Z5Z_5)), and (α\alpha) denoting the Cartesian component of the mode. The coefficients (aia_i) ((i=1,…,10i = 1, \ldots, 10)) quantify the strengths of the respective trilinear interactions among three phonon-mode amplitudes. Each product describes a coupling between three modes that contribute to the stabilization of a particular structural variant.

Mult panel microscopy and schematic images showing polarization variants and phonon-mode couplings

Figure 1 (PDF p. 22).

Image not extracted

Figure 12. Experimental observation of 90∘90^\circ domain wall in HfO2\mathrm{HfO}_{2}. (a) Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image showing 5 nm resolution of two ferroelectric domains with regions forming 90∘90^\circ orientation matching to Ozx/OxzO_{z}^{x}/O_{x}^{z}. (b) Corresponding Fourier-transform patterns and atomic-resolution images from the two domain regions, illustrating their distinct crystallographic orientations. Structural model illustrating Ozx/OxzO_{z}^{x}/O_{x}^{z} domain. (c) Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image showing 2 nm resolution of 90∘90^\circ Ozx/OxzO_{z}^{x}/O_{x}^{z} ferroelectric domains (d) Enlarged atomic-resolution images across the domain wall, highlighting the local atomic arrangement on either side of the interface. (e) Simulated Annular Bright Field (ABF) images of the Ozx/OxzO_{z}^{x}/O_{x}^{z} domain structure.

References

  1. [1]R. A. Vargas-Hernández, “Bayesian Optimization for Calibrating and Selecting Hybrid-Density Functional Models,” J. Phys. Chem. A, vol. 124, no. 20, pp. 4053–4061, 2020, doi: 10.1021/acs.jpca.0c01375.
  2. [2]J. P. Perdew, K. Burke, and Matthias Ernzerhof *, “Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple,” Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 77, no. 18, p. 3865, 1996, doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.77.3865.
  3. [3]P. E. Blöchl, “Projector augmented-wave method,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 50, no. 24, pp. 17953–17979, 1994, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.50.17953.DOI
  4. [4]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, “From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented-wave method,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 59, no. 3, pp. 1758–1775, 1999, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.59.1758.DOI
  5. [5]J. D. Pack and H. J. Monkhorst, ““special points for Brillouin-zone integrations’-a reply,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 1748–1749, 1977, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.16.1748.DOI
  6. [6]Z. Wang and X. Ruan, “Phonon spectral energy density analysis of solids : the k point reduction in the first Brillouin zone of FCC crystals and a case study on solid argon,” pp. 1–12, 2016.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_w5nunkjs
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents