betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Tidally-induced vertical asymmetries in the LMC bar and disk

Abstract

Past observations and simulations have shown that the bar in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) may be tilted with respect to the disk plane, and that the outer LMC disk could be warped. These studies propose that the tilted bar and the warp in the LMC are induced by the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) pericentric passages. We analyze and quantify the effect of the SMC passage on the vertical position and kinematic asymmetries of both the bar and disk, as a function of different impact parameters or initial conditions. We used seven representative simulations from the KRATOS suite of NN-body simulations of the LMC, SMC and Milky Way (MW) system for this analysis. To classify bar particles and analyze the bar and disk separately, we adopted a classification method based on persistent homology. To quantify the vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the LMC-like galaxy, we applied Fourier decomposition. We constructed Gaia DR3 mock catalogs to study whether the observed vertical asymmetries in Gaia DR3 are caused by astrometric uncertainties. We detect strong m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the LMC-like galaxy for all interacting simulations after the pericentric passage of the SMC-like galaxy, indicative of a warped bar and disk. We also detect m=2m=2 vertical asymmetries in the bar of the LMC-like galaxy for some simulations, indicative of a buckling bar. We conclude that the SMC passages induce vertical asymmetries in both the bar and the disk of the LMC, compatible to those measured in Gaia DR3. Tidal interactions naturally give rise to a warped and buckling LMC bar, and a warped LMC disk. Comparison between our results and Gaia DR3 suggest that models with a higher mass ratio between the SMC and the LMC may be favorable for reproducing the observed tilt of the LMC bar, and that the most recent SMC pericentric passage occurred at most 210 to 300 Myr ago.

Introduction

The Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) and Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) are the largest and closest satellite galaxies of the Milky Way (MW). The LMC, a Barred Magellanic Spiral galaxy, exhibits asymmetric morphology. It has an off-centered bar (e.g., [42, 37, 20, 36]), which is likely tilted (e.g., [43, 4, 7, 31, 19]), and a warped outer disk (e.g., [38, 4, 7, 34, 19, 28]). These asymmetries could be a result of the ongoing interactions between the Magellanic Clouds (MCs), as estimated by the in-plane kinematic asymmetries in the LMC bar and outer disc ([36]). In particular, the LMC has undergone a close encounter (within 5 kpc) with the SMC approximately 150 – 300 Myr ago (e.g., [29, 8, 9]).

Regarding the effect of the tidal interactions on the vertical component, we consider the bar and the disk as two separate kinematic components of the LMC. Choi et al. [7] and Jiménez-Arranz et al. [19] estimate a 5°-15° tilt of the LMC bar with respect to the disk plane. In Model 2 of the NN-body smoothed-particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulation of the LMC, SMC and MW system in Besla et al. [4], where a recent direct collision between the MCs occurs, the authors detect a 10°-15° tilt in the LMC bar. Recently, Rathore et al. [31] use isodensity ellipse fitting and measure a ∼8.6∘\sim8.6^\circ tilt at the present time in the LMC bar in Model 2 from the same simulation, consistent with the observations.

On the other hand, several studies indicate that the LMC disk is warped (e.g., [39, 4, 7, 34, 19, 28]). This fact is supported by both observational studies (e.g., [38, 7]) and by numerical simulations, where Besla et al. [4] find that both the outer stellar and gas disks of the LMC are warped and distorted in Model 2 of their simulations. Jiménez-Arranz et al. [19] construct three-dimensional models of the LMC using SDSS and Gaia DR3 data, which qualitatively reproduce both the tilted bar and the warped outer disk. Using red clump stars from Gaia DR3 data, Oden et al. [28] find that the warp in the outer LMC is U-shaped.

In this work, we use seven representative simulations with varying initial conditions from KRATOS (Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20]), a suite of NN-body simulations of the LMC, SMC and MW system system. We search for vertical position and velocity asymmetries in the bar and disk of the simulated LMC-like galaxy, and relate them with the tidal interaction between the SMC-like galaxy and the LMC-like galaxy. To analyze vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the simulated LMC-like galaxy separately, we adopt the topology-based bar classification method in Sánchez-Martín et al. [33]. We investigate whether vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk are a direct result of interactions between the two galaxies, and how different tidal interaction parameters and initial conditions could affect the amplitudes of the vertical asymmetries. We qualitatively compare the detected vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the LMC-like galaxy in KRATOS simulations to those in Besla et al. [4] and observational studies (e.g., Choi et al. [7]; Jiménez-Arranz et al. [19]), which allows us to constrain the mass ratio between the two galaxies, and to estimate the time since the last SMC pericentric passage. Finally, we analyze the vertical asymmetries in the kinematic maps of the LMC in Gaia DR3, and use Gaia mock catalogs to provide caveats on how to interpret the results.

This paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, we review the main characteristics of the simulations used in this work. In Sect. 3, we describe the bar classification method, the centering and aligning strategy and the Fourier decomposition method, which allows us to quantify the vertical asymmetries. We present our main results in Sect. 4 and Sect. 5. In Sect. 6, we compare our results with Model 2 of the numerical simulations in Besla et al. [4], Gaia DR3 observations and Gaia mock catalogs. We summarize our results in Sect. 7.

Simulations

In this work, we analyzed seven simulations of KRATOS (Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20]), which consists of a suite of 28 pure NN-body simulations that model the evolution of an isolated or interacting LMC-like galaxy, denoted by GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} following Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20], with varying parameters. These simulations are K5, K6, K10, K11, K12, K20, and K21. Each simulation models an isolated GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (K10), a GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} interacting with an SMC-like galaxy, GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} (GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}}; K5, K11, or K20), or a GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} interacting with both a SMC- and an MW-like galaxy, GMWG_{\mathrm{MW}} (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}; K6, K12, K21). The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} system is modeled as a stellar disk with an exponential profile embedded in a live Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW, Navarro et al. 1996) dark matter halo. The GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} system is modeled as a live NFW halo, which comprises both the stellar and the dark matter components. The GMWG_{\mathrm{MW}} is modeled as a live NFW dark matter halo.

These seven simulations are chosen due to the presence of a consistently strong bar (Σ2/Σ0>0.2\Sigma_2/\Sigma_0 > 0.2, see Figure 7 of Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20]) in their evolved GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}. They can be grouped into three sets based on their initial conditions: K5 and K6 have lower Toomre parameters (Q=1.0Q = 1.0) than the other simulations (Q=1.2Q = 1.2); K10, K11, K12, K20, and K21 have less massive GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} dark matter halos (MLMC,halo=0.8×1011M⊙M_{\mathrm{LMC,halo}} = 0.8 \times10^{11} M_\odot) than in K5 and K6 (MLMC,halo=1.8×1011M⊙M_{\mathrm{LMC,halo}} = 1.8 \times10^{11} M_\odot); K20 and K21 have less massive GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} stellar disks (MLMC,disk=3×109M⊙M_{\mathrm{LMC,disk}} = 3 \times10^9 M_\odot) than the other simulations (MLMC,disk=5×109M⊙M_{\mathrm{LMC,disk}} = 5 \times10^9 M_\odot). All simulations have the same mass for the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} (MSMC,stellar=2.6×108M⊙M_{\mathrm{SMC,stellar}} = 2.6 \times10^8 M_\odot and MSMC,halo=1.9×1010M⊙M_{\mathrm{SMC,halo}} = 1.9 \times10^{10} M_\odot) and the GMWG_{\mathrm{MW}} (MMW,halo=1012M⊙M_{\mathrm{MW,halo}} = 10^{12} M_\odot). The initial conditions of these simulations are provided in Tables 1 and 2 in Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20].

Time evolution of the vertical position and velocity asymmetries in the GLMC bar and disk

Figure 7. From top to bottom: time evolution of the m=1m = 1 vertical position (first and third panels) and velocity (second and fourth panels) asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (first and second panels) and disk (third and fourth panels) in the simulation set K10 (dotted), K11 (dashed) and K12 (solid lines). Uncertainty bars of the vertical asymmetries in the simulations obtained by bootstrapping 100 times are approximately the size of the lines, so they are not shown in the figure. All lines are fitted using cubic splines as implemented in scipy [41]. The m=1m = 1 vertical velocity asymmetry measured in Gaia DR3 observations is denoted by the horizontal purple line, where the shaded region denotes the uncertainties estimated by bootstrapping 100 times. We discuss the vertical velocity asymmetries in Gaia DR3 in Sect. 6.2. The vertical grey (dashed) solid lines correspond to the pericenters of (K11) K12.

The simulations are run for 4.68 Gyr, with a time cadence of 75 Myr. Following Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20], we set the present time of the simulation as the snapshot 4 Gyr after the initial conditions, which matches the number of GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}–GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passages and qualitatively resembles the morphology of the observed LMC disk (see their Sect. 3.2).

For the interacting models, we provide the time evolution of the distance between the center of mass of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} stars (dLMC−SMCd_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}}) in Figure 1. The pericentric passage is closer for models with lower MLMCM_{\mathrm{LMC}} that are interacting with only the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}, K11 and K20. Because the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passage in K5 and K6 is too distant to produce significant effects on the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, we study snapshots close to and after the second pericentric passage of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. For all models, we study the snapshots after the full formation of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar.

Time evolution of the distance between the LMC-like galaxy and the SMC-like galaxy

Figure 1. Time evolution of the distance between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The solid (dashed) lines correspond to the GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}) models. Colors denote the different sets of simulations, following Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20]. The vertical grey dashed lines correspond to the pericenters of the GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} models (K5, K11, K20). The vertical grey solid lines correspond to the pericenters of the GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}} models (K6, K12, K21). The pericenters before the full formation of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (or the first pericenters for K5 and K6) are denoted by light grey lines.

Method

Bar classification

In order to study the vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk individually, it is crucial to separate the two components. Although methods based on Fourier decomposition (e.g., Elmegreen & Elmegreen [11]), isophotal ellipse fitting (e.g., Abraham et al. [1]), or machine-learning (e.g., Abraham et al. 2018) have been proposed to classify bars, bar classification remains a non-trivial task. Recently, Sánchez-Martín et al. [33] developed a novel, topology-based method for bar classification which only uses the positions and velocities of the star particles in a single snapshot. To identify bar particles in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, we adapt their bar classification algorithm and apply it to the three dimensional positions and velocities of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} star particles.

We first perform K-means clustering on the absolute Galactocentric radial velocities (∣VR∣|V_R|) of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} star particles and divide them into two groups. Three dimensional positions of the star particles belonging to the high absolute radial velocity group form the point cloud in our topological analysis. We perform Voronoï tesselation on the point cloud, creating a graph that connects two points with neighboring Voronoï cells whose distance is smaller than the maximal distance parameter dmax⁡d_{\max} (ranges from 0 to ∞\infty) by an edge. For a certain dmax⁡d_{\max}, we identify the component with the largest number of connected points, also known as the largest connected component (LCC). Sánchez-Martín et al. [33] tested the number of star particles within the LCC, the number of retrograde star particles within the LCC, and the semimajor axis length aa as possible detectors for bar limits (see their Figs. 5, 6 and 10), and determined the number of retrograde star particles within the LCC to be the best one empirically. Therefore, we plot the number of retrograde star particles contained within the LCC versus a range of dmax⁡d_{\max} values (see Fig. A.1). As dmax⁡d_{\max} increases, the number of (retrograde) star particles within the corresponding LCC increases steeply, connecting the dense inner region of the galaxy. After the bar is fully included in the LCC, dmax⁡d_{\max} reaches a limit (corresponding to the knee of the plot), where increasing it further will only include fewer high radial velocity retrograde outliers in the disk region. We define the bar particles as those contained within the LCC corresponding to this limiting dmax⁡d_{\max}. Details of applying this method are provided in App. A.§ 1. For a full description of the method, we refer the reader to Sánchez-Martín et al. [33].

As an example, in Figure 2, we show the face-on density plot of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (top left), the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} with bar particles removed (bottom left) and the extracted GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (bottom right) in the K11 simulation at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage (t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr) after applying the bar classification method, centering and aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (details will be discussed in the next subsection). In the bottom left panel of Figure 2, some residual particles remain within the central region of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} after removing the bar particles, suggesting that our method prioritizes purity over completeness. Figure 2 demonstrates the effectiveness of our classification method.

Face-on log density plots of the LMC bar and disk

Figure 2. The face-on log density plot of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (top left), the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} with bar particles removed (bottom left) and the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (bottom right) in the K11 simulation at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage (t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr) after applying the bar classification method, centering and aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk.

Finally, to check the performance of the method implemented in this work, we also tested a recent star-by-star bar classification method from Iles et al. [18], which is based on the failure of conservation of the total action for bar particles. We determined that the topology-based method is preferable for this study, considering the relatively low cadence of the KRATOS simulations (Δt=75\Delta t = 75 Myr) compared to that in Iles et al. [18], where Δt=10\Delta t = 10 Myr. Additionally, in our interacting models, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk could be severely disrupted by the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages, making it difficult to distinguish between bar and disk particles

based solely on the conservation of total action. The implementation of the action-based bar classification method and the differences between the two methods are discussed in App. A.§ 2.

Centering and aligning the GLMC

Here, we present the centering and alignment method for the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} used for the rest of the work. We first center the reference frame at the density center of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar following Jiménez-Arranz et al. [20]. We perform principal component analysis (PCA) on the three dimensional positions of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} star particles in the region within R=5R = 5 kpc using scikit-learn (Pedregosa et al. [30]). The normal vector of this region is the smallest principal component. We align the zz-axis of the reference frame with the normal vector, requiring that the vertical component of the total angular momentum vector of all the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} star particles has positive zz. We obtain bar particles using the topology-based bar classification method (see Sect. 3.1). Then we center the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk particles (bar particles removed) at their center of mass (COM). We refine our alignment by aligning the reference frame with the re-centered disk particles within 5 kpc. Henceforth, we denote the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in-plane Cartesian coordinates as (x′,y′,z′)(x', y', z'). In this coordinate system, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} rotates counterclockwise.

Figure 3 illustrates the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} before and after centering and aligning in the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr. The left panel shows the unprocessed snapshot, the right panel shows the snapshot after centering at the density center of the bar, aligning with the region within R=5R = 5 kpc, and finally aligning with the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (bar particles removed, centered at the COM of the disk) within 5 kpc.

Unprocessed and centered and aligned side-on density plots of the GLMC

Figure 3. The unprocessed side-on density plot of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (left), and the density plot after centering and aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (right). The contour lines highlight the overdensities in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}.

Figure 4 shows the centered and aligned GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} at t=−1.46t = -1.46 Gyr (before the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, top panels) and at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, bottom panels), respectively, in the K11 simulation in the side-on view, color-coded by density (left panels) and in the face-on mean vertical velocity plot (right panels). The plot demonstrates that before the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk is flat and the reference frame aligns well with the disk plane. However, the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage violently disrupts the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk, making it difficult to determine a single GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk plane.

Centered and aligned GLMC density and mean vertical velocity plots

Figure 4. The centered and aligned GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} at t=−1.46t = -1.46 Gyr (before the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, top panels) and at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, bottom panels), respectively, in the K11 simulation in the side-on view, color-coded by density (left panels) and in the face-on mean vertical velocity plot (right panels) after applying the bar classification method, centering and aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk. For illustration purposes, we align the x′x'-axis with the semi-major axis of the bar.

Centering and aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk is a crucial step for the following morphological and kinematic analysis. The analysis of a highly-disrupted disk might suffer from systematics due to not having a fully aligned disk. Therefore, we have tested an alternative alignment method of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk where we iteratively obtain bar particles after aligning the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and center consistently on the density center of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}. We find no significant differences between the results obtained using the two methods (see App. § 9).

Fourier decomposition

To quantitatively study the asymmetry in the vertical position, z′z', and vertical velocity, Vz′V_{z'}, of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk, we use Fourier decomposition. The vertical asymmetry of a Fourier mode mm has amplitude

Am,z′=1N∣∑jzj′eimϕj∣,orAm,Vz′=1N∣∑jVz′,j′eimϕj∣,(1)A_{m,z'} = \frac{1}{N}\left|\sum_j z'_j e^{im\phi_j}\right|,\qquad\text{or}\qquad A_{m,V_{z'}} = \frac{1}{N}\left|\sum_j V'_{z',j} e^{im\phi_j}\right|, \tag*{(1)}

where zj′z'_j, Vz′,j′V'_{z',j}, and ϕj\phi_j are the vertical position, velocity and azimuth of a particle jj, respectively. We associate the m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry for positions with the warp, and the m=2m = 2 asymmetry in the bar with bar buckling (e.g., [10]).

Case study with K10, K11 and K12

In this section, we show the detected vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. As an example, we present the morphological analysis and Fourier decomposition results for a set of simulations K10 (isolated GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}), K11 (GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}}) and K12 (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}).

Time evolution of the GLMC morphology and kinematics

Pre-processing the simulations (Sect. 3) allows us to track the morphological and kinematic evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. The figures below illustrate the complex morphological and kinematic evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} when interacting with the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. In particular, vertical asymmetries arise in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} after each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage.

In the left panels of Figure 5, we show the side-on density distribution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in selected snapshots of K11. The text in the upper left corner of each panel denotes the time of the simulation, while the orange text highlights the time of the pericentric passage of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The panels illustrate that at the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar remains relatively flat (first and second panels, from top left to bottom right). The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar buckles shortly afterwards, characterized by the downward curve (banana shape, third panel). The second pericentric passage induces an additional warp to the already buckling bar (characterized by the upward curve, fourth and fifth panels, also see Fig. D.2), and the bar appears lopsided. The effect of applying an additional m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry to a buckling bar is demonstrated by a simple model in App. § 11. In the end, a vertically symmetric box bulge emerges at the center of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (sixth panel).

Time evolution of the side-on density distribution of the $G_{\mathrm{LMC}}$ bar and disk in the K11 simulation

Figure 5. Time evolution of the side-on density distribution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (left panels) and disk (right panels) in the K11 simulation. For illustration purposes, the x′x'-axis is aligned with the semi-major axis of the bar. The text in the upper left corner denotes the time of the snapshot, while the orange text highlights the time at the first and second pericentric passages of GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The grey dashed line denotes the radius cut for the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk region, 3≤R≤63 \le R \le6 kpc.

The right panels of Figure 5 shows the time evolution of the side-on density distribution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (bar particles removed, 3≤R≤63 \le R \le6 kpc) in the K11 simulation. After the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, the outer GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk displays a clear S-shaped warp (first and second panels). The direct collision between the galaxies at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage (dLMC−SMC=0.26d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} = 0.26 kpc) exerts an additional tidal torque (fourth and fifth panels) to the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, heating and drastically distorting the whole disk.

To illustrate the kinematic evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, we show the face-on mean vertical velocity map of the whole GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in selected snapshots of the K11 simulation in Figure 6. Evidently, the two passages of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} (first and fourth panels) induce a dipole asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk. After the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, a weak quadrupole pattern emerges in the bar region of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (third panel), characteristic of a buckling bar (fourth subplot of the left panels in Figure 5, also see [24]). The direct collision with the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} at the second passage (fourth panel) near the center of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} produces large vertical velocity asymmetries in both the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. The quadrupole pattern in the bar region persists after the direct collision, though it becomes lopsided (fifth panel). The pattern winds up (sixth panel), as a boxy bulge forms at the center of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (sixth subplot of the left panels in Figure 5, also see [24]).

Time evolution of the face-on mean vertical velocity map of the GLMC in the K11 simulation

Figure 6. Time evolution of the face-on mean vertical velocity map of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in the K11 simulation. The text in the upper left corner denotes the time of the snapshot, while the orange text highlights the time at the first and second pericentric passages of GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The x′x^\prime-axis is aligned with the semi-major axis of the bar. The gray circle denotes the region R=3R = 3 kpc.

The warped and buckling GLMC bar

In order to quantify the detected vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk in the previous subsection, we present the results of the Fourier decomposition method. We first study the vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set.

The top two panels of Figure 7 shows the time evolution of the m=1m = 1 vertical position (first panel) and velocity (second panel) asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar. Uncertainty bars of the vertical asymmetries in the simulations obtained by bootstrapping 100 times are approximately the size of the lines, so they are not shown in the figure. The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the isolated model, K10, shows A1,z′∼0A_{1,z}^{\prime} \sim0 and A1,Vz′∼0A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} \sim0 in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar throughout the simulation, indicative of vertical symmetry, as expected. Before the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passage, the bars in interacting models K11 and K12 also have A1,z′∼0A_{1,z}^{\prime} \sim0 and A1,Vz′∼0A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} \sim0. For K11, both GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages result in a sudden increase in A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} and A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime}. The first peaks in A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} and A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} correspond to a slightly asymmetric GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (first subplot of the left panels in Figure 5). A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} reaches another peak at ∼−0.4\sim-0.4 Gyr, corresponding to the buckling GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (third subplot of the left panels in Figure 5). The second passage induces a significantly stronger m=1m = 1 asymmetry due to the direct collision of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} with the SMC (dLMC−SMC=0.26d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} = 0.26 kpc), corresponding to a lopsided GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (fourth subplot). The m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetries in the bar significantly decrease after the collision, as a vertically symmetric bulge forms in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (sixth subplot). Due to inclusion of the GMWG_{\mathrm{MW}} in K12, there is only one late pericentric passage of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The single GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage in K12 occurs at a larger distance (see Figure 1, dLMC−SMC=13.45d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} = 13.45 kpc) compared to any GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages in K11. Therefore, the m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in K12 at the single GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage is smaller than those in K11. Approximately 400 Myr after the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, both A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} and A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the bar in K12 reach a peak, corresponding to a warped bar. The m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar then oscillates but remains relatively large due to the buckling bar.

The top panel of Figure 8 shows the time evolution of the velocity dispersion ratio σz/σR\sigma_z/\sigma_R in the inner GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (R≤2R \leq2 kpc). Buckling is characterized by an initial drop and a drastic rise of the velocity dispersion ratio (e.g., [26]). The velocity dispersion ratios of the inner GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in both K11 and K12 display such characteristics. Combined with the morphological evolution (Figure 5), we conclude that the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in both K11 and K12 buckles after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage (third subplot of the left panels in Figure 5), while that in K10 never buckles. The middle and bottom panels of Figure 8 track the time evolution of the m=2m = 2 vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set, typically associated with bar buckling (e.g., [10, 24]). For K11, the buckling bar corresponds to an increase in A2,z′A_{2,z}^{\prime} and A2,Vz′A_{2,V_z}^{\prime} after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage. After the direct collision with the SMC, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar buckles violently, corresponding to a drastic increase of the velocity dispersion ratio and a peak in both A2,z′A_{2,z}^{\prime} and A2,Vz′A_{2,V_z}^{\prime}. For K12, buckling happens approximately 400 Myr after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, corresponding to a continuous rise in A2,z′A_{2,z}^{\prime} and a peak in A2,Vz′A_{2,V_z}^{\prime}.

Time evolution of the velocity dispersion ratio and vertical asymmetries in the GLMC bar

Figure 8. Time evolution of the velocity dispersion ratio in the inner GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (R≤2R \le2 kpc, top), as well as the m=2m = 2 vertical position (middle) and velocity (bottom) asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set K10, K11 and K12. Similar to Figure 7, uncertainties of the vertical asymmetries in the simulations obtained by bootstrapping are not shown in the figure. All lines are fitted using cubic splines. The m=2m = 2 vertical velocity asymmetry measured in Gaia DR3 observations is denoted by the horizontal purple line, and the discussion is deferred to Sect. 6.2.

The warped GLMC disk

The bottom two panels of Figure 7 shows the time evolution of the m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in the simulation set. The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in K10 remains flat throughout the simulation, as expected. Similarly to what happens to the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage results in a sudden rise in A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} and A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} for the interacting models K11 and K12. The increase in A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} corresponds to a warped GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (e.g., second and fourth subplots of the right panels in Figure 5). For K11, the direct impact at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage results in a larger warp in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (A1,z′∼0.1A_{1,z}^{\prime} \sim0.1 kpc, fourth subplot of the right panels in Figure 5). For K12, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} gradually decreases as the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk settles after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage. A1,z′A_{1,z}^{\prime} and A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} rise again near the end of the simulation, possibly due to a future second passage of the SMC, as suggested by Figure 1.

Figure 7 provides a comparison between the m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and that in the disk. The plot demonstrates that the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage induces m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetries in both the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. For both interacting models, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the disk is larger than that in the bar at the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage. For K11, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the bar increases and becomes similar to that in the disk at the direct impact of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} (dLMC−SMC=0.26d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} = 0.26 kpc). For K12, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk gradually returns to ∼0\sim0 after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage as the disk settles, while that in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar continues to rise, due to bar buckling. Cross-correlation analysis reveals that the increase in A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk at each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passage occurs without significant delay — the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk respond to each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage simultaneously.

The m = 1 asymmetry in the GLMC bar across the KRATOS suite

To understand the cause of m=1m = 1 vertical velocity asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (see Figure 7), we present a summary plot of A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the bar at each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage with respect to various parameters of tidal interactions and initial conditions for five interacting models in Figure 9. The dimensionless impact parameter SS [12] is calculated by

Amplitude of the $m = 1$ vertical velocity asymmetry versus impact parameter, distance, relative velocity, and mass ratio

Figure 9. Amplitude of the m=1m = 1 Vz′V_{z}^{\prime} asymmetry versus the impact parameter SS (in log scale), distance between GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and SMC, their relative velocity, and their mass ratio at each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, for all interacting simulation models. Circles denote the GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}+G_{\mathrm{SMC}} models, while stars denote the GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}}+G_{\mathrm{SMC}}+G_{\mathrm{MW}} models. The number label denotes the ii-th passage of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The K21 simulation has not formed a bar at the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, so it is not considered in this plot.

S=mSMCMLMC(RLMCdLMC−SMC)3ΔTP,(2)S = \frac{m_{\mathrm{SMC}}}{M_{\mathrm{LMC}}}\left(\frac{R_{\mathrm{LMC}}}{d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}}}\right)^3\frac{\Delta T}{P}, \tag*{(2)}

where mSMC/MLMCm_{\mathrm{SMC}}/M_{\mathrm{LMC}} is calculated by the ratio between the total mass (stellar component and dark matter) of the two galaxies, RLMCR_{\mathrm{LMC}} is the disk truncation radius of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, ΔT\Delta T is the interaction time, and PP is the time for the star particles in the outer GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk to rotate one radian in their orbits. VLMC−SMCV_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} is defined as the relative bulk velocity of the stellar component of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}. The K21 simulation is neglected in the plot, because it has not formed a bar at the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage.

In the top left panel of Figure 9, the amplitude of the m=1m = 1 vertical velocity asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar at each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passage shows a clear correlation with the impact parameter SS (Spearman coefficient rs=0.59r_s = 0.59), indicating that the vertical velocity asymmetries are indeed induced by the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages.

To assess the effect of each interaction parameter, we consider the other three panels. The top right panel shows that A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} decreases with the distance between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}, with a Spearman coefficient of rs=−0.77r_s = -0.77. As an example, at the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the bar for the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} models K5, K11 and K20 show a clear decline trend with dLMC−SMCd_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}}. At the third passage, A1,Vz′A_{1,V_z}^{\prime} in the bar in K20 is larger than that in K5 or K11, though the distance between the two galaxies is similar. This is likely due to the higher relative velocity of the galaxies at the third passage in K20 than in K11, and the larger mass ratio in K20 than in K5 or K11. For K20, A1,Vz′A'_{1,V_z} at the third GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage is smaller than that at the second passage, though the two passages occur at similar distances. This is likely due to the lower relative velocity at the third passage. For the GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}} models K6 and K12, A1,Vz′A'_{1,V_z} in the bar is generally smaller, either due to the large distance between the galaxies (K12), or the low mass ratio of the galaxies (K6).

In the bottom panels of Figure 9, A1,Vz′A'_{1,V_z} in the bar does not correlate strongly with the relative velocity of the galaxies (rs=0.31r_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.31), or the mass ratio between the two galaxies (rs=0.44r_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.44). Note that the galaxies at all passages in the same simulation set have the same initial mass ratio. However, we observe that GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages in simulations with the lowest mass ratio (K5 and K6) generally induce small A1,Vz′A'_{1,V_z} in the bar.

Figure 9 suggests that dLMC−SMCd_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} is the dominant interaction parameter for determining the amplitudes of the vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar. VLMC−SMCV_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} and mSMC/MLMCm_{\mathrm{SMC}}/M_{\mathrm{LMC}} only weakly affect the amplitudes of the induced vertical asymmetries.

Discussion

In this section, we compare our results with the simulations in Besla et al. [4] and put our results in context with respect to Gaia DR3 observations (Sect. 6.2). We estimate possible biases and systematics by applying the same method to Gaia mock catalogs (Sect. 6.3).

Qualitative comparison with 2012MNRAS.421.2109B

Here, we compare the results in this work with the ones from Model 2 in Besla et al. [4], and the more recent work by Rathore et al. [31] using the same simulation. While they perform a similar analysis to ours, there are some differences between their simulations and models and KRATOS, which are worth mentioning before the direct comparison.

First, at present time, Model 2 of Besla et al. [4] consists of a tilted bar and a warped disk. Second, the authors consider the bar as a rigid body, in particular, Rathore et al. [31] measure the angle between the ellipse fitted to the rigid bar and the disk plane in a side-on projection. It is also worth mentioning that the authors do not compare with simulations of an isolated GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, or a GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} interacting with only a GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}; or with simulations of varying initial conditions. Finally, Besla et al. [4] used an NN-body SPH simulation, while we use representative pure NN-body simulations from KRATOS. Because the LMC is a gas-rich galaxy, gas dynamics could play an important role in its evolution. A future NN-body SPH version of the KRATOS simulations will shed light on the effect of gas dynamics (Jiménez-Arranz, Roca-Fàbrega et al., in prep.).

In this study, we track the morphological evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar after extracting the bar particles. We find that the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passages induce vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, but have not observed a rigid tilt in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar with respect to the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk plane for all seven simulation models. In particular, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar may be deformed by buckling, and the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk may also be severely disrupted. For example, the fifth subplot of Figure 5 (∼150\sim150 Myr after the direct collision of the galaxies) is qualitatively similar to the middle right panel in Fig. 13 in Besla et al. [4] or the right panel in Fig. 2 in Rathore et al. [31]. Our analysis reveals that the direct collision with the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} induces an m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry to the already buckling GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar.

Because the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk are both deformed by tidal interactions, we cannot obtain a rigid tilt angle. We can, however, estimate a “tilt angle" by measuring the angle between the principal direction of the bar obtained by principal component analysis (PCA) and the disk plane (z′=0z^\prime= 0). Figure 10 illustrates the time evolution of the estimated tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set K10, K11 and K12, which can be compared to Fig. 8 in Rathore et al. [31]. The tilt angle of the bar at the

Time evolution of the tilt of the $G_{\mathrm{LMC}}$ bar in the simulation set K10, K11 and K12

Figure 10. Time evolution of the tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set K10 (dotted), K11 (dashed) and K12 (solid line). The tilt angle is estimated by the angle between the principal direction of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and the disk plane (z′=0z^{\prime}=0). The purple shaded region shows the estimated tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in Choi et al. [7] and Jiménez-Arranz et al. [19]. The purple dashed line denotes the tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar at the present time (∼8.6∘\sim8.6^\circ) in Model 2 of Rathore et al. [31]. The blue shaded region shows the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (∼1∘\sim1^\circ) in Model 1 of Rathore et al. [31].

present time (∼8.6∘\sim8.6^\circ) in Model 2 of Rathore et al. [31] is denoted by the purple dashed line, while the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the bar in Model 1 (∼1∘\sim1^\circ) is illustrated by the blue shaded region. In Figure 10, the tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the isolated model K10 remains below ∼1∘\sim1^\circ throughout the simulation, consistent with Model 1. The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in K12 does not show a significant tilt, either, being consistently within the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the bar in Model 1 before the end of the simulation. In K11, the first and third GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passages do not induce a significant tilt to the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, while the direct collision with the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} at the second passage induces a tilt within the range of 55-15∘15^{\circ}, consistent with observations [e.g. 7, 19]. The maximum tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (10.7∘10.7^{\circ}) occurs ∼150\sim150 Myr after the direct collision, slightly larger than that in Rathore et al. (2025, ∼9.5∘\sim9.5^{\circ}), possibly due to the smaller distance between the galaxies at the direct collision in this work (dLMC−SMC=0.26d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} = 0.26 kpc) compared to that in Rathore et al. (2025, dLMC−SMC∼2d_{\mathrm{LMC-SMC}} \sim2 kpc). The tilt angle remains observationally significant for ∼300\sim300 Myr after the direct collision, consistent with the current estimate of the recent close encounter between the LMC and the SMC (150150-300300 Myr ago, [e.g. 29, 8, 9]).

The estimated tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the other four simulation models is not observationally significant (see Fig. C.4 in App. § 10). In particular, the tilt in the models with low mass ratio between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} (mSMC/MLMC∼0.10m_{\mathrm{SMC}}/M_{\mathrm{LMC}} \sim0.10, compared to mSMC/MLMC∼0.22m_{\mathrm{SMC}}/M_{\mathrm{LMC}} \sim0.22 for the other models), K5 and K6, does not exceed the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the bar in Model 1 throughout the simulation. This is consistent with Figure 9 and the discussion in Sect. 5. Although we are unable to explore the full range of masses of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} due to the limitation of the KRATOS simulations, the current result suggests that models with a higher mass ratio between the

galaxies may be favorable for reproducing the observed tilt of the LMC bar.

Comparison with Gaia DR3 observation

Because the Gaia DR3 observations lack accurate distance measurements for the LMC stars, we hereafter focus on the analysis of the vertical velocity asymmetries in the LMC. We use the sample of LMC stars with available line-of-sight velocities in Gaia DR3 from Jiménez-Arranz et al. [21] for this analysis. The observed LMC stars are projected onto the LMC disk plane (z′=0z^{\prime} = 0) according to Jiménez-Arranz et al. [21]. The limited size of the sample (N=30 749N = 30\,749) makes it difficult to apply our topology-based bar classification method. Instead, following Schölch et al. [36], we use the ellipse fitting method to obtain the observed LMC bar, which contains N=9959N = 9959 stars. The face-on density (left) and vertical velocity maps (right) of the obtained LMC bar are shown in Figure 11. In the right panel of Figure 11, the vertical velocities of the LMC bar stars in the Gaia DR3 sample display a clear dipole asymmetry.

The face-on view of the LMC bar in the Gaia DR3 observation color-coded by density and vertical velocity

Figure 11. The face-on view of the LMC bar in the Gaia DR3 observation color-coded by density (left) and vertical velocity (right). The LMC bar is obtained using the ellipse fitting method in Schölch et al. [36].

We perform Fourier decomposition and illustrate the Gaia DR3 results as horizontal purple lines in Figure 7 and Figure 8. Uncertainties are estimated by bootstrapping 100 times, and therefore primarily reflects statistical errors. As a result, the total error is likely underestimated. Figure 7 shows that compared with the simulation models K11 and K12, there exists significant m=1m=1 vertical velocity asymmetry in the observed LMC bar in Gaia DR3. In particular, the m=1m=1 vertical velocity asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in K11 remains consistent with the Gaia DR3 observations (within 1σ1\sigma of the observed value) ∼210\sim210 Myr after the direct collision. The observed m=1m=1 vertical asymmetries are therefore in agreement with the recent passage of the SMC (e.g., Olsen et al. [29]; Choi et al. [8]; Cullinane et al. [9]). The significant m=1m=1 vertical asymmetries in the observed LMC bar are further supported by the Gaia mock observations in the following subsection.

In Figure 8, A2,Vz′A_{2,V_{z}^{\prime}} in the observation is relatively low compared to the simulations. Therefore, there is no clear m=2m=2 vertical asymmetry in the observed LMC bar.

The face-on density, radial, azimuthal, and vertical velocity maps of the LMC sample can be referred to in Figs. 15, 16 and 17 of Jiménez-Arranz et al. [21]. For the LMC disk (3≤R≤63 \le R \le6 kpc), we obtain A1,Vz′=1.92±0.38 km s−1A_{1,V_{z}^{\prime}}=1.92\pm0.38\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} and A2,Vz′=3.29±0.32 km s−1A_{2,V_{z}^{\prime}}=3.29\pm0.32\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}}. The observed disk asymmetries are significant compared to the simulations (see Figure 7 and Figure 8).

Gaia mock catalogs

In this section, we present the Gaia mock catalogs constructed from the simulations. We use Gaia mock catalogs to illustrate the limitations of our method and to provide caveats for interpreting the values we obtained from Gaia DR3 observations reported in Sect. 6.2.

We simulate Gaia observables and uncertainties for the KRATOS simulations using the mock catalog tool presented in Schölch et al. [36].1 We start by projecting the KRATOS simulations (centered and aligned as stated in Sect. 3.2) to the position and orientation of the LMC in the heliocentric reference frame. We use center coordinates (α0,δ0)=(81.28∘,−69.78∘)(\alpha_{0},\delta_{0})=(81.28^\circ,-69.78^\circ) according to van der Marel [38], and orient the simulation according to the LMC inclination angle i=34∘i=34^\circ and position angle θ=220∘\theta=220^\circ (Gaia Collaboration et al. [13]). We then apply a 3D galactic extinction model by Marshall et al. [25] and Lallement et al. [23]. Since the LMC stars are located beyond the model’s distance limit of 15 kpc, the applied extinctions correspond to the foreground extinction of the MW. To simulate observables of the stars in the LMC, we use a high purity LMC sample from Jiménez-Arranz et al. [21] that has line-of-sight velocities available, and model the distribution of apparent color GBP−GRPG_{BP}-G_{RP}, absolute magnitude MGM_G, and radial velocity uncertainty σVlos\sigma_{V_{\mathrm{los}}} with a kernel density estimation (KDE). We then draw randomly from this KDE to assign the observational parameters to the simulation particles, and from the absolute magnitude, color, and extinction we derive apparent GG magnitudes. Then we use the Gaia DR3 error model also implemented in PyGaia (Brown et al. [6]; Gaia Collaboration et al. [14]) to compute astrometric uncertainties in position (σα∗,σδ)(\sigma_{\alpha*},\sigma_{\delta}), parallax (σϖ)(\sigma_{\varpi}) and proper motion (σμα∗,σμδ)(\sigma_{\mu_{\alpha*}},\sigma_{\mu_{\delta}}). We apply the line-of-sight velocity uncertainties (σVlos)(\sigma_{V_{\mathrm{los}}}) corresponding to the color and absolute magnitude from the KDE described above to model the uncertainties directly on the LMC line-of-sight velocity distribution. In Gaia DR3, line-of-sight velocities are available only for stars with GRVS≤14G_{\mathrm{RVS}}\le14 (Katz et al. [22]). To apply a comparable cutoff to our simulated stars, we compute the GRVSG_{\mathrm{RVS}} magnitudes using the color-color relation between G−GRVSG-G_{\mathrm{RVS}} and GBP−GRPG_{BP}-G_{RP} from Sartoretti et al. [35] and exclude all stars above GRVS=14G_{\mathrm{RVS}}=14 from the mock catalog. Using the derived uncertainties for each star particle, we sample a new value for the position (α,δ)(\alpha,\delta), parallax (ϖ)(\varpi), proper motions (μα∗,μδ)(\mu_{\alpha*},\mu_{\delta}), and line-of-sight velocities (Vlos)(V_{\mathrm{los}}) from a Gaussian distribution centered on the true simulated value, with standard deviation of the computed uncertainty. Lastly, we convert the Gaia mock catalog back to the deprojected GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in-plane coordinate frame (for details, see Appendix A of Jiménez-Arranz et al. [21]). Due to the large uncertainties in the parallaxes at the distance of the Clouds, we assume all stars are located in an infinitely thin disk and have z′=0z^{\prime}=0 in the LMC in-plane coordinates.

In Figure 12, we show a comparison of the vertical velocity map of the K11 simulation at t=0.075t=0.075 Gyr (left panel) with its corresponding mock catalog (right panel), predicting the vertical signatures found in Gaia data. The snapshot was previously aligned according to the method described in Sect. 3.2 and presents the strongest asymmetry signatures due to the second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage (Figure 9). The asymmetric signature in the vertical velocity map is clearly present in this simulation snapshot, and the mock catalog reproduces velocities across the full disk.

Vertical velocity maps of the K11 simulation and corresponding mock catalog

Figure 12. Vertical velocity maps of the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (left panel), and its corresponding mock catalog (right panel).

Applying the same Fourier decomposition, we obtain A1,Vz′=5.71±0.13 km s−1A_{1,V_z^\prime} = 5.71 \pm0.13\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} for the bar, and A1,Vz′=4.09±0.04 km s−1A_{1,V_z^\prime} = 4.09 \pm0.04\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} for the disk region of the Gaia mock catalog, where the uncertainty is estimated by bootstrapping and therefore primarily reflects statistical errors. As a result, the total error is likely underestimated and the results are reasonably consistent with the simulation (A1,Vz′=5.84±0.07 km s−1A_{1,V_z^\prime} = 5.84 \pm0.07\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} for the bar, A1,Vz′=4.27±0.02 km s−1A_{1,V_z^\prime} = 4.27 \pm0.02\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} for the disk region).

From the mock catalogs, we can conclude that Gaia astrometric uncertainties and the lack of individual heliocentric distances for each source do not bias or create artificial systematics in the velocity maps. The main effect of these limitations is some blurring of the kinematic signatures in the outskirts of the disk, but the main trends and kinematic asymmetries remain visible.

Conclusions

In this work, we presented the vertical asymmetries detected in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} in seven NN-body simulations of the KRATOS suite. We tracked the morphological and kinematic evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk, and provided quantitative analysis of the detected asymmetries. The main results of this work are:

  • We tracked the morphological evolution of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk separately (Figure 2) using a topology-based classification method. We concluded that tidal interactions between the two interacting galaxies result in a warped and buckling GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and a warped GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk (Figure 5). Tidal interactions also induce vertical asymmetries in the kinematics of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (Figure 6).

  • We quantified the detected vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} using Fourier decomposition (Figure 7 and Figure 8), and found that the induced vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} occur simultaneously.

  • We performed correlation analysis with respect to various interaction parameters and initial conditions, which revealed that the impact parameter SS predicts well the amplitude of the vertical asymmetries, while the distance between the galaxies has the strongest effect on the induced asymmetries (Figure 9).

  • Compared to Model 1 and Model 2 of the NN-body SPH simulation in Besla et al. [4], we did not detect a rigidly tilted bar in all seven simulation models, but detected a GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar deformed by the pericentric passages of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} through buckling and warping. The differences between our results may be attributed to the gas dynamics, considering that the LMC is a gas-rich galaxy. A future NN-body SPH version of the KRATOS simulations (Jiménez-Arranz, Roca-Fàbrega et al., in prep.) will shed light on the effect of gas dynamics.

  • By estimating a tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar using PCA, we discovered that the direct collision between the galaxies in our high mass ratio model (mSMC/mLMC∼0.22m_{\mathrm{SMC}}/m_{\mathrm{LMC}} \sim0.22), K11, produces an observationally significant tilt (10.7∘10.7^\circ, Figure 10). Tidal interactions in our lower mass ratio models (mSMC/mLMC∼0.10m_{\mathrm{SMC}}/m_{\mathrm{LMC}} \sim0.10), K5 and K6, however, fail to produce a significant tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar throughout the simulation (Fig. C.4). Thus, models with a higher mass ratio between the SMC and the LMC may be favorable for reproducing the observed tilt of the LMC bar.

  • In K11, after the direct collision between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}, the estimated tilt angle remains observationally significant (within the range of 5∘5^\circ-15∘15^\circ) for ∼300\sim300 Myr.

  • We observed significant m=1m = 1 asymmetry in the vertical velocity map of the LMC bar in Gaia DR3 (Figure 11) compared to the simulations (Figure 7). In particular, the observed m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry remains significant compared with the K11 simulation ∼210\sim210 Myr after the direct collision. Therefore, our estimated upper limit for the time since the most recent SMC pericentric passage is approximately 210 to 300 Myr, consistent with the current observational estimate of the recent passage of the SMC (approximately 150–300 Myr ago).

  • Our Gaia DR3 mock catalogs are able to reproduce asymmetric kinematic signals from the simulations (Figure 12) and therefore suggest that astrometric uncertainties in the Gaia data do not bias the results.

In summary, we conclude that tidal interactions between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} induce significant vertical asymmetries in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk in the KRATOS simulations. We detect significant vertical asymmetries in the LMC bar in the Gaia DR3 observations, which is in agreement with the recent passage of the SMC. The upcoming Gaia DR42 and the NN-body SPH version of the KRATOS simulations will allow us to gain better understanding of the vertical asymmetries in the bar and disk of the LMC.

Acknowledgements. We thank the anonymous referee for providing suggestions that improved this paper. SW greatly appreciates the helpful discussions at the “Galactic bars, bulges and disks” workshop in Lipari. SW is grateful to P. Sánchez-Martín for her help with the bar classification algorithm. This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 101072454 (MWGaiaDN). OJA acknowledges funding from “Swedish National Space Agency 2023-00154 David Hobbs The GaiaNIR Mission” and “Swedish National Space Agency 2023-00137 David Hobbs The Extended Gaia Mission.” This work has made use of data from the European Space Agency (ESA) mission Gaia (https://www.cosmos.esa.int/gaia), processed by the Gaia Data Processing and Analysis Consortium (DPAC, https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/dpac/consortium). Funding for the DPAC has been provided by national institutions, in particular the institutions participating in the Gaia Multilateral Agreement. This work made use of the following software: scikit-learn [30], GUDHI (Rouvreau 2026, NetworkX [15], astropy [3, 2], matplotlib [17], scipy [41], numpy [16].

Histogram of radial velocities and $d_{\max}$ versus the number of retrograde star particles

Figure A.1. Left: histogram of the radial velocities of the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} star particles in the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr, after applying the K-means clustering algorithm. Pink highlights the high radial velocity group. Right: dmax⁡d_{\max} versus the number of retrograde star particles within the LCC. The pink dashed line corresponds to the knee of the plot.

Face-on and side-on views of the $G_{\rm LMC}$

Figure A.2. Top panels: Face-on and side-on view of the GLMCG_{\rm LMC}, overplotted by bar particles obtained using the action-based method (blue and pink scatter points) in the isolated K10 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr. Bottom panels: the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} in the same snapshot, overplotted by bar particles obtained using the topology-based method (blue scatter points.)

Bar classification

The topology-based bar classification method

In this section, we present the details and software used when applying the topology-based bar classification method in Sect. 3. As an example, we show the steps of applying the method to the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (the second GSMCG_{\rm SMC} pericentric passage).

The left panel in Fig. A.1 shows the histogram of the radial velocities of the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} star particles. We use scikit-learn to perform K-means clustering, dividing the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} star particles into a high radial velocity (pink) and a low radial velocity (blue) group. Three dimensional positions of the star particles belonging to the high radial velocity group form the point cloud in our topological analysis.

Persistent homology studies how topological features such as connected components evolve as the topological space changes. For simplicity, we consider the alpha complex version of persistent homology. We use GUDHI to construct the alpha complexes. We use NetworkX to create a graph from the point cloud and to identify the largest connected component (LCC). We present the plot of dmax⁡d_{\max} versus the number of retrograde star particles within the corresponding LCC in the right panel of Fig. A.1. We minimize the residual of fitting a Γ\Gamma shape to the plot following Sánchez-Martín et al. [33] to locate the knee (indicated by the pink dashed line), which corresponds to the dmax⁡d_{\max} delimiting the bar (dmax⁡=0.018d_{\max} = 0.018). Bar particles are those within the LCC corresponding to the limiting dmax⁡d_{\max}. We obtain 133 417 bar particles in the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr, as shown in the bottom right panel of Figure 2.

Face-on and side-on views of the $G_{\rm LMC}$

Figure A.3. Top panels: Face-on and side-on view of the GLMCG_{\rm LMC}, overplotted by bar particles obtained using the action-based method (blue and pink scatter points) in the K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (second pericentric passage of the GSMCG_{\rm SMC}). Bottom panels: the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} in the same snapshot, overplotted by bar particles obtained using the topology-based method (blue scatter points.)

Comparison with the action-based bar classification method

Here, we present the results of extracting bar particles using the action conservation method (Iles et al. [18]). We compute the radial (JRJ_R), vertical (JzJ_z), and azimuthal actions (JϕJ_\phi) of the GLMCG_{\rm LMC} star particles using the Stäckel fudge method (Binney [5]) implemented in agama (Vasiliev [40]). Note that Iles et al. [18] mainly used GALPY for their analysis, but they checked that using either package only produces slightly different results. We approximate the potential of both the dark matter halo and stellar component using multipole expansions. The total action is calculated by

J=JR2+Jz2+Jϕ2.J = \sqrt{J_R^2 + J_z^2 + J_\phi^2}.

Bar particles are those with high variation in total action within a short time interval Δt\Delta t.

As an example, we apply both methods to the snapshot at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr in the isolated K10 simulation, where the disk remains flat throughout the simulation, and disk particles have well-conserved total action. Figure A.2 shows the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar particles obtained using the action-based method (top panels) and the topology-based method (bottom panels, as discussed in Sect. 3). In the top panels, the (pink) blue scatter points denote the star particles with a change in total action (ΔJ≥80%\Delta J \ge80\%) ΔJ≥50%\Delta J \ge50\% within Δt=75\Delta t = 75 Myr. In the bottom panels, the blue scatter points are the bar particles we obtain using the topology-based method. Figure A.2 shows that the bar particles obtained using our topology-based method are much better constrained. The differences between the bar particles obtained by the two methods could be due to the relatively low cadence of the KRATOS simulations (Δt=75\Delta t = 75 Myr) compared to Δt=10\Delta t = 10 Myr in Iles et al. [18], see their Fig. 1.

In addition, the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in our interacting models could be strongly perturbed by the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passages, and disk star particles generally do not have well-conserved total action. Figure A.3 shows the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar particles obtained using the action-based method (top panels) and the topology-based method (bottom panels) in the interacting K11 simulation at t=0.075t = 0.075 Gyr (second GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passage). The plot demonstrates that, when the disk is strongly perturbed by tidal interactions, the action conservation method cannot cleanly separate the bar and disk particles, while the topology-based method still performs well. Therefore, we adopt the topology-based method in our analysis.

Alternative alignment method

In this section, we present an alternative alignment method used for comparison.

We follow the initial centering and alignment process as in Sect. 3. The aligned galaxy corresponds to the middle panel of Figure 3. We then align the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} with the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk within 5 kpc, without re-centering the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}. We iteratively obtain bar particles and realign the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}}, until the number of obtained bar particles converge within 1%. This is the final set of bar particles. We then align the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} with the principal direction of the annulus with radius R0<R<5R_0 < R < 5 kpc, where R0R_0 is the bar radius.

For comparison, we provide the time evolution of the vertical position asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk in the simulations K11 and K12 for both alignment methods in Figs. B.1 and B.2. The plots show that the alignment method in the main text slightly reduces the m=1m = 1 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. We verified that changing the alignment method does not affect the m=2m = 2 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk. In particular, the signatures of the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} pericentric passages are largely preserved, irrespective of the adopted alignment method.

Supplementary figures

Figure C.1 shows the time evolution of the m=0,1,2m = 0, 1, 2 vertical velocity asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulation set K11 and K12. The m=0m = 0 vertical asymmetry closely follows the m=2m = 2 vertical asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar. This is due to Fourier decomposing a long GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, where the majority of the bar particles have the same (or opposite) azimuthal angles.

Figures C.2 and C.3 present the results of Fourier decomposing the vertical velocities of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk for the

Time evolution of the m = 1 vertical position asymmetry in the GLMC bar

Figure B.1. Time evolution of the m=1m = 1 vertical position asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulations K11 and K12 for the alignment method in the main text (orange) and the alternative alignment method (blue).

Time evolution of the m = 1 vertical position asymmetry in the GLMC disk

Figure B.2. Time evolution of the m=1m = 1 vertical position asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in the simulations K11 and K12 for the alignment method in the main text (orange) and the alternative alignment method (blue).

Time evolution of the m = 0, 1, 2 vertical velocity asymmetry in the GLMC bar

Figure C.1. Time evolution of the m=0,1,2m = 0, 1, 2 VzV_z asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the K11 and K12 simulations.

remaining four simulations, K5 (GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}}), K6 (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}), K20 (GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}}) and K21 (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}). The top panels in Figs. C.2 and C.3 show that the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in K21 buckles after the first GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage, corresponding to a sudden rise in the velocity dispersion ratio and an increase in A2,VzA_{2,V_z}. The GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in K5, K6 and K20 does not buckle throughout the simulation. Due to the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar not being fully formed, we remove the first three snapshots in K20 and K21 in the bottom three panels of Fig. C.3. Figures C.2 and C.3 demonstrate that each GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}} passage induces vertical asymmetries in both the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and disk, consistent with the results in Sect. 4.

Figure C.4 illustrates the time evolution of the estimated tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the four simulations. The plot shows that the tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the these four simulation models is not observationally significant. In particular, the tilt in the models with the lowest mass ratio between the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} and the GSMCG_{\mathrm{SMC}}, K5 and K6, remains within the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in Model 1 throughout the simulation. Although the tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar at the end of the simulation K21 is close to that in Model 2, this is due to the bar being deformed by the strong buckling, which biases the estimation of the tilt angle.

Simple model of a buckling bar

In this section, we construct a simple model of a buckling bar. We first consider 1 000 particles on nearly elliptical orbits, undergoing harmonic oscillations (xx is aligned with the semi-major axis of the ellipse). The phase of each particle can be written as θx=ωt+P\theta_x = \omega t + P, where ω\omega is the in-plane frequency of the particle, and PP is the initial azimuth in the xx-yy plane, added for randomization. Therefore, the in-plane motion of the particle can be written as x=Rcos⁡(θx)x = R\cos(\theta_x), y=cRsin⁡(θx)y = cR\sin(\theta_x), where RR is the length of the semi-major axis of the ellipse and cc is the ratio between the semi-minor and semi-major axis of the ellipse. We set c=0.2c = 0.2, which forms the long bar in our model. To simulate the upward or downward-curved banana shape of a buckling bar, we relate the vertical position of the particle, zz, to xx by z∝x2z \propto x^2. When buckling, the vertical frequency ν\nu and the in-plane frequency ω\omega are in 2:12:1 resonance (e.g., Łokas [24]). Therefore, ν=2ω\nu= 2\omega, and z=cx2cos⁡(νt)z = cx^2\cos(\nu t).

We evolve these particles for t=2πt = 2\pi. The face-on density map (top left) and side-on density map (top right) of the buckling bar at a representative snapshot t=πt = \pi is shown in Fig. D.1. The top right panel shows the characteristic upward-curved banana shape.

As shown in the left panel of Fig. D.3, we perform Fourier decomposition on the vertical positions of these bar stars. The plot demonstrates that when Fourier decomposing the vertical positions where the majority of the particles have the same (or opposite) azimuthal angles, the resulting A0,z′A_{0,z^\prime} and A2,z′A_{2,z^\prime} have nearly the same trend with time. Note that for this simple model, A1,z′A_{1,z^\prime} is nonzero.

In order to simulate an m=1m = 1 perturbation to the buckling bar, we add a “tilting” component with a constant rate ωt\omega_t to the vertical position zz of the particle. Now, z=Rωtcos⁡(θx)+cx2cos⁡(νt)z = R\omega_t\cos(\theta_x) + cx^2\cos(\nu t). We set ωt=0.1\omega_t = 0.1. We show the buckling and tilting bar at t=πt = \pi in Fig. D.2. Note that the left right panel in Fig. D.2 qualitatively resembles the fifth subplot of the left panels in Figure 5, where the buckling bar appears to be lopsided.

The Fourier decomposition results are shown in the right panel of Fig. D.3. As the buckling bar becomes increasingly lopsided, A1,z′A_{1,z^\prime} linearly increases with time. The Fourier decomposition method separate the buckling (m=0m = 0 and m=2m = 2) and the tilting mode (m=1m = 1) well.

Time evolution of velocity dispersion ratios and vertical asymmetries for the bar and disk

Figure C.2. From top to bottom: time evolution of the velocity dispersion ratio in the inner GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (R≤2 kpcR \leq2\,\mathrm{kpc}), m=1m = 1 Vz′V_z^\prime asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, m=2m = 2 Vz′V_z^\prime asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and m=1m = 1 Vz′V_z^\prime asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in the simulations K5 and K6. The vertical grey dashed (solid) lines correspond to the pericenters of the GLMC+GSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} (GLMC+GSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{SMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}) models.

Time evolution of velocity dispersion and asymmetries

Figure C.3. From top to bottom: time evolution of the velocity dispersion ratio in the inner GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} (R≤2R \le2 kpc), m=1m = 1 Vz′V_z' asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar, m=2m = 2 Vz′V_z' asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar and m=1m = 1 Vz′V_z' asymmetry in the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} disk in the simulations K20 and K21. The vertical grey dashed (solid) lines correspond to the pericenters of the GLMC+GGSMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{GSMC}} (GLMC+GGSMC+GMWG_{\mathrm{LMC}} + G_{\mathrm{GSMC}} + G_{\mathrm{MW}}) models.

Time evolution of the tilt of the GLMC bar

Figure C.4. Time evolution of the tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in the simulations K5, K6, K20 and K21. The purple shaded region shows the estimated tilt of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar in Choi et al. [7] and Jiménez-Arranz et al. [19]. The purple dashed line denotes the tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar at the present time (∼8.6∘\sim8.6^\circ) in Model 2 of Rathore et al. [31]. The blue shaded region shows the 1σ1\sigma spread around the mean tilt angle of the GLMCG_{\mathrm{LMC}} bar (∼1∘\sim1^\circ) in Model 1 of Rathore et al. [31].

Face-on, side-on, and average vertical velocity views of the buckling bar particles

Figure D.1. Face-on (top left) and side-on (top right) view, as well as the face-on average vertical velocity map (bottom left) of the buckling bar particles at t=πt = \pi.

Side-on view and face-on average vertical velocity map of the buckling and tilting bar particles

Figure D.2. Side-on (left) view and the face-on average vertical velocity map (right) of the buckling and tilting bar particles at t=πt = \pi.

Fourier decomposition of the vertical position of the buckling particles and the buckling and tilting bar particles

Figure D.3. Fourier decomposition of the vertical position of the buckling particles (left) and the buckling and tilting bar particles (right) for m=0,1,2m = 0, 1, 2. The particles are evolved for t=2πt = 2\pi.

References

  1. [1]Abraham, R. G., Merrifield, M. R., Ellis, R. S., Tanvir, N. R., & Brinchmann, J. 1999, MNRAS, 308, 569 Abraham, S., Aniyan, A. K., Kembhavi, A. K., Philip, N. S., & Vaghmare, K. 2018, MNRAS, 477, 894
  2. [2]Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Sipocz, B. M., et al. 2018, AJ, 156, 123
  3. [3]Astropy Collaboration, Robitaille, T. P., Tollerud, E. J., et al. 2013, A&A, 558, A33
  4. [4]Besla, G., Kallivayalil, N., Hernquist, L., et al. 2012, MNRAS, 421, 2109
  5. [5]Binney, J. 2012, MNRAS, 426, 1324
  6. [6]Brown, A. G. A., Leiden University, & Gaia DPAC. 2012, PyGaia
  7. [7]Choi, Y., Nidever, D. L., Olsen, K., et al. 2018, ApJ, 866, 90
  8. [8]Choi, Y., Olsen, K. A. G., Besla, G., et al. 2022, ApJ, 927, 153
  9. [9]Cullinane, L. R., Mackey, A. D., Da Costa, G. S., et al. 2022, MNRAS, 510, 445
  10. [10]Debattista, V. P., Mayer, L., Carollo, C. M., et al. 2006, ApJ, 645, 209
  11. [11]Elmegreen, B. G. & Elmegreen, D. M. 1985, ApJ, 288, 438
  12. [12]Elmegreen, D. M., Sundin, M., Elmegreen, B., & Sundelius, B. 1991, A&A, 244, 52
  13. [13]Gaia Collaboration, Luri, X., Chemin, L., et al. 2021, A&A, 649, A7
  14. [14]Gaia Collaboration, Vallenari, A., Brown, A. G. A., et al. 2023, A&A, 674, A1
  15. [15]Hagberg, A. A., Schult, D. A., & Swart, P. J. 2008, in Proceedings of the 7th Python in Science Conference, ed. G. Varoquaux, T. Vaught, & J. Millman, Pasadena, CA USA, 11 – 15
  16. [16]Harris, C. R., Millman, K. J., van der Walt, S. J., et al. 2020, Nature, 585, 357
  17. [17]Hunter, J. D. 2007, Computing in Science & Engineering, 9, 90
  18. [18]Iles, E. J., Pal, F. A., Bland-Hawthorn, J., & Freeman, K. 2026, MNRAS, 548, stag611
  19. [19]Jiménez-Arranz, Ó., Horta, D., van der Marel, R. P., et al. 2025, A&A, 698, A88
  20. [20]Jiménez-Arranz, Ó., Roca-Fàbrega, S., Romero-Gómez, M., et al. 2024, A&A, 688, A51
  21. [21]Jiménez-Arranz, Ó., Romero-Gómez, M., Luri, X., et al. 2023, A&A, 669, A91
  22. [22]Katz, D., Sartoretti, P., Guerrier, A., et al. 2023, A&A, 674, A5
  23. [23]Lallement, R., Vergely, J. L., Babusiaux, C., & Cox, N. L. J. 2022, A&A, 661, A147
  24. [24]Łokas, E. L. 2019, A&A, 629, A52
  25. [25]Marshall, D. J., Robin, A. C., Reylé, C., Schultheis, M., & Picaud, S. 2006, A&A, 453, 635
  26. [26]Martinez-Valpuesta, I., Shlosman, I., & Heller, C. 2006, ApJ, 637, 214
  27. [28]Oden, S. J., Nidever, D. L., Povick, J., et al. 2026, ApJ, 1003, 9
  28. [29]Olsen, K. A. G., Zaritsky, D., Blum, R. D., Boyer, M. L., & Gordon, K. D. 2011, ApJ, 737, 29
  29. [30]Pedregosa, F., Varoquaux, G., Gramfort, A., et al. 2011, Journal of Machine Learning Research, 12, 2825
  30. [31]Rathore, H., Besla, G., Daniel, K. J., & Beraldo e Silva, L. 2025, ApJ, 988, 79
  31. [33]Sánchez-Martín, P., Amorós, J., & Masdemont, J. J. 2025, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulations, 149, 108923
  32. [34]Saroon, S. & Subramanian, S. 2022, A&A, 666, A103
  33. [35]Sartoretti, P., Marchal, O., Babusiaux, C., et al. 2023, A&A, 674, A6
  34. [36]Schölch, M., Jiménez-Arranz, Ó., Romero-Gómez, M., et al. 2025, A&A, 701, A227
  35. [37]Subramaniam, A. & Subramaniam, S. 2009, ApJ, 703, L37
  36. [38]van der Marel, R. P. 2001, AJ, 122, 1827
  37. [39]van der Marel, R. P. & Cioni, M.-R. L. 2001, AJ, 122, 1807
  38. [40]Vasiliev, E. 2019, MNRAS, 482, 1525
  39. [41]Virtanen, P., Gommers, R., Oliphant, T. E., et al. 2020, Nature Methods, 17, 261
  40. [42]Zaritsky, D. 2004, ApJ, 614, L37
  41. [43]Zhao, H. & Evans, N. W. 2000, ApJ, 545, L35

Paper details

vlnc:W_w6ms5hn4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents