betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A New GUT

Abstract

We present a new class of 4-dimensional Grand Unified Theories where the gauge sectors of the standard model have a novel embedding in the unified group that does not factor through an SU(5)SU(5) subgroup. The smallest example has gauge algebra su(12)\frak{su}(12) and an anomaly-free spectrum that produces the three standard model generations with no additional chiral matter. The embedding predicts the axion-photon anomaly ratio E/N=2/3E/N=2/3 and the weak mixing angle sin⁡2θW=1/2\sin^2θ_W=1/2 at the unification scale. Gauge-mediated proton decay proceeds through flipped-SU(5)SU(5)-like operators and the minimally charged smooth monopole carries two Dirac charge units. The global gauge group can be SU(12)SU(12) or SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2, with the former allowing color singlets of half-integer electric charge. We develop a GUT bootstrap to constrain SU(n)SU(n) embeddings with three generations and no additional chiral matter. For unified fermions in up to two-index representations, we prove that all new embeddings arise from the SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4) family, including flavor unified models for m≥2m \geq 2.

Grand Unification offers a compelling origin story for the Standard Model (SM). Unification explains why the SM gauge couplings are all of similar order and the pattern of charges of SM fermions, in particular the quantization of electric charge in integers [1, 2, 3, 4].

The classic example of a grand unified theory (GUT) is the SU(5)SU(5) GUT [1]. All the simple GUTs1 in the literature contain or branch through SU(5)SU(5) [5, 6, 7, 8, 9], e.g.

E6⊃SO(10)⊃SU(5).(1)E_6 \supset SO(10) \supset SU(5). \tag*{(1)}

For all these cases, the SM gauge group is [SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1)Y]/Z6[SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1)_Y]/\mathbb{Z}_6 [10]. Both SU(3)cSU(3)_c and SU(2)LSU(2)_L are embedded at equal levels, the hypercharge normalization factor relative to QCD is fixed to be the standard 5/35/3. The QCD axion couples to the photon with a coupling E/N=8/3E/N = 8/3 [11, 12].

We present a new GUT which departs from this paradigm. The unified gauge group is SU(12)SU(12) (or SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2 depending on the matter content) and has QCD embedded at level k3=3k_3 = 3, with k2=1k_2 = 1, kY=1k_Y = 1. This particle content appears in the literature [13, 14], but to our knowledge our work is the first GUT construction with a non-canonical SM embedding specified, c.f. [9, 15, 16]. Our embedding has immediate consequences: the weak mixing angle at the GUT scale is sin⁡2θW=1/2\sin^2\theta_W = 1/2 and the QCD axion-photon coupling is set by E/N=2/3E/N = 2/3.

The SU(12)SU(12) example is the first member of an infinite family of embeddings into SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4), with m≥1m \geq1. They share the ratio E/N=2/3E/N = 2/3 but have sin⁡2θW(MU)=3k2/(4m+2)\sin^2\theta_W(M_U) = 3k_2/(4m+2), with k2=1k_2 = 1 or 33 (the latter for m≥3m \geq3).

Explicit anomaly-free fermion spectra with three SM generations are given in Sec. S2 of the Supplemental Material. Remarkably, for m=2m = 2 we find that the theories do not need a 3-fold replication of UV fermions, but the minimal spectrum reproduces 3 SM generations, providing interesting candidates for flavor-unified GUTs.

Interestingly, we find that for SU(n)SU(n) with n≤37n \leq37 and any other compact simple Lie groups, E/N={2/3,8/3}E/N = \{2/3, 8/3\} are the only two possibilities, irrespective of the dimension of the representations! This result is achieved by considering general constraints on the SM embedding in the GUT, a kind of GUT bootstrap that can scan over large classes of GUTs and SM embeddings. We provide further details in the appendix S3 and a catalog of results as an application.

We comment on the novelty of our construction relative to the literature. Ref. [16] scanned all SM embeddings in SU(n)SU(n) for n≤12n \leq12 and, for 13≤n≤2013 \leq n \leq20, those that go through an SU(5)SU(5) subgroup. Besides the standard embedding, the latter include n→2⋅5+5‾+…n \to2\cdot5+\overline{5}+\ldots for n≥15n \geq15, with (k3,k2,kY)=(3,3,5)(k_3,k_2,k_Y)=(3,3,5), which corresponds to our family II (Sec. S4) of the Supplemental Material. All embeddings found there give E/N=8/3E/N = 8/3. Our SU(12)SU(12) embedding does not go through SU(5)SU(5) and is not found in the n≤12n \leq12 scan of Ref. [16]. QCD at level 3 also appears in the color-flavor unified models of Refs. [17, 18], where 9→3⋅39 \to3\cdot3 under SU(3)c⊂SU(9)SU(3)_c \subset SU(9), and in the SU(12)C×SU(2)L×SU(2)RSU(12)_C \times SU(2)_L \times SU(2)_R models of Ref. [19] (see also the classification in [20]). In these models the weak group is not unified, so neither sin⁡2θW\sin^2\theta_W nor E/NE/N is predicted. Family unification using spinors of the groups SO(4m+2)SO(4m+2) [21, 22], with m>2m > 2, provides an even number of SM generations. The additional standard and mirror families must be removed from the spectrum [23, 24].

In this paper we present the simplest version of the model, emphasizing the chiral content. There are a few interesting phenomenological consequences of this theory. If the gauge group is SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2, the SM gauge group is SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1)/Z6SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1)/\mathbb{Z}_6 and the usual electric charge quantization follows [10]. But if the group is SU(12)SU(12), we get a different global structure for the SM gauge group, SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1)/Z3SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1)/\mathbb{Z}_3, and vector-like fermions with 1/21/2 charges are allowed.2 For both SU(12)SU(12) and SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2 the smooth monopole carries two Dirac charge units as a consequence of the embedding, and there are no stable defects of higher dimension (strings or domain walls) associated to GUT symmetry breaking. B+LB+L is violated via dimension-6 operators similar to those in flipped-SU(5)SU(5) models and leads to proton decay that can be within current bounds [26] and could be distinguished from other GUTs. In contrast to GUTs based on SO(10)SO(10), there is no B−LB-L symmetry.

The axion-photon coupling is one of the most distinctive phenomenological consequences and is what ultimately can distinguish this theory from standard GUTs. The theory contains fractional instantons that can have a non-trivial impact in axion physics, too.

There are many future model building directions – characterizing the spectrum for different options for gauge coupling unification, the Higgs sector of the GUT (including, e.g. doublet-triplet splitting), flavor phenomenology (specially in the flavor unified models of App. S2), neutrino mass generation, and embedding in string theory. We note that the model can be made supersymmetric, but in this case the coupling runs strongly and leads to a Landau pole close to the unification scale.

The model. The GUT gauge algebra is g=su(12)\mathfrak{g}=\mathfrak{su}(12), and the embedding of the SM h=su(3)×su(2)×u(1)Y\mathfrak{h}=\mathfrak{su}(3)\times\mathfrak{su}(2)\times\mathfrak{u}(1)_Y can be shown by the branching of the fundamental representation of su(12)\mathfrak{su}(12):

12→2(3,1)1/6+(3ˉ,1)−1/6+(1,2)0+(1,1)−1/2.(2)12 \to2(3,1)_{1/6}+(\bar{3},1)_{-1/6}+(1,2)_0+(1,1)_{-1/2}. \tag*{(2)}

The indices of embedding are (k3,k2,kY)=(3,1,1)(k_3,k_2,k_Y)=(3,1,1) and can be obtained from the normalization of the generators [9, 28]

(tr⁡VTc2,tr⁡V(TL3)2,tr⁡VY2)=(3/2,1/2,1/2).(3)\left(\operatorname{tr}_V T_c^2,\operatorname{tr}_V (T_L^3)^2,\operatorname{tr}_V Y^2\right)=(3/2,1/2,1/2). \tag*{(3)}

We will use the indices i=1,…,5i=1,\ldots,5 to label the 5 SM representations in the branching of the 12 in eq. (2).

The fermion content organizes into three copies of the antisymmetric and (conjugate) symmetric two-index representations, 2×66+78‾2\times66+\overline{78}. Each of these contains exactly one SM family together with vector-like representations (denoted SS, see App. S1 for details),

2×66+78‾→Q+uc+dc+L+ec⏟one SM family+S.(4)2\times66+\overline{78}\to\underbrace{Q+u^c+d^c+L+e^c}_{\text{one SM family}}+S. \tag*{(4)}

The SS contains fermions that all admit SM-invariant masses, so the only chiral states below MUM_U are the three SM families.

The 6666 and 78‾\overline{78} representations have even 12-ality, which allows this model to have gauge group SU(12)SU(12) or SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2. Representations with even 12-ality have only SM-like charges, with integer electric charges. However, if the gauge group is SU(12)SU(12) it allows for fermions in the fundamental 12 representation. In that case, the low energy gauge group is

[SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1)]/Z3,(5)[SU(3)\times SU(2)\times U(1)]/\mathbb{Z}_3, \tag*{(5)}

and every color-singlet state from the fundamental has an electric charge which is an integer multiple of 1/21/2. This is therefore a GUT that would survive the discovery of exotic particles with fractional charges.

Predictions. The standard GUT predictions are modified due to the non-standard embedding of QCD. Below we briefly discuss the most salient features.

The weak mixing angle. —The gauge coupling matching condition is

αi−1(MU)=kiαGUT−1.(6)\alpha_i^{-1}(M_U)=k_i\alpha_{\mathrm{GUT}}^{-1}. \tag*{(6)}

The weak mixing angle at the GUT scale can also be written in terms of the levels of embedding as [12, 29]

sin⁡2θW(MU)=k2kY+k2=12.(7)\sin^2\theta_W(M_U)=\frac{k_2}{k_Y+k_2}=\frac{1}{2}. \tag*{(7)}

This is to be compared with 3/83/8 for standard GUT embeddings. This requires states below the unification scale to modify the running from the SM (or MSSM) predictions, see Figure 1. We give some representative examples of how this can be achieved below.

Two-loop running of gauge couplings

Figure 1. Two-loop running of αi−1/ki\alpha_i^{-1}/k_i, with ki=(3,1,1)k_i=(3,1,1) for MU=3×1016 GeVM_U=3\times10^{16}\,\mathrm{GeV} with one added 78+78‾\mathbf{78}+\overline{\mathbf{78}} pair. Solid: with the vector-like states L,ec,ucL,e^c,u^c and TT (gray lines mark their masses); dashed: SM content only. Inputs at MZM_Z from Ref. [35]. Above MUM_U (black) the SU(12)SU(12) coupling grows and reaches a formal pole at ≃4.6MU\simeq4.6M_U; the gray band lies above the species scale Λsp\Lambda_{\mathrm{sp}} [34].

The axion-photon coupling. —The ratio of the anomaly coefficients, which sets the axion-photon coupling, can be written in terms of the levels of embedding [12]

EN=kY+k2k3=23.(8)\frac{E}{N}=\frac{k_Y+k_2}{k_3}=\frac{2}{3}. \tag*{(8)}

The axion coupling to photons is given by [27]

gaγγ=αem2πfa(EN−1.92),(9)g_{a\gamma\gamma}=\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}}{2\pi f_a}\left(\frac{E}{N}-1.92\right), \tag*{(9)}

so that for a fixed decay constant, E/N=2/3E/N=2/3 gives a coupling 1.7 times larger than the standard GUT value E/N=8/3E/N=8/3 (see Figure 2).

Figure 2. Axion-photon coupling versus mass. Black: standard GUTs, E/N=8/3E/N=8/3. Solid red: this model, E/N=2/3E/N=2/3, with a QCD-dominated axion mass. Dashed and dotted red: the same with an aligned contribution from small SU(12)SU(12) instantons, ma2fa2=χ(1+R)m_a^2f_a^2=\chi(1+R), for R=102R=10^2 and 10410^4. Hatched: not allowed in this model. As in standard GUTs axion-like particles above the QCD line are forbidden [12]. Yellow: the QCD axion band, 0.25<∣E/N−1.92∣<12.750.25<|E/N-1.92|<12.75 [30]. Shaded regions and dashed curves: limits and projections from Ref. [31].

This provides a well-motivated target for experimental precision. The power in a haloscope experiment scales as gaγγ2ρag_{a\gamma\gamma}^2\rho_a. If a DM axion is detected, and its mass is measured accurately, the two embeddings differ by a factor ∼2.9\sim2.9 in the power. Distinguishing the non-standard GUT studied here from canonical unified models requires reaching sufficient precision, usually limited by the determination of the local DM abundance. The Gaia experiment may reduce it to 10% in a near future [32, 33].

Gauge-coupling unification

The prediction (7) is far from the SM or MSSM extrapolation. The running is sensitive to the details of the spectrum. Matching the gauge couplings requires αY−1\alpha_Y^{-1} to decrease faster than the SM predicts, requiring light states with hypercharge, as well as new colored states that slow down the evolution of the QCD coupling.

We find two representative options. With the minimal content, 6×66+3×786\times\mathbf{66}+3\times\mathbf{78}, a one-loop bound allowing arbitrary partial multiplets gives αU−1>0\alpha_U^{-1}>0 only for MU>1.75×1017 GeVM_U>1.75\times10^{17}\,\mathrm{GeV}, and αU−1≃8\alpha_U^{-1}\simeq8–1212 requires MU≃1018M_U\simeq10^{18}–2.4×1018 GeV2.4\times10^{18}\,\mathrm{GeV}, that is, a GUT scale close to the Planck scale. Adding one vector-like pair 78+78‾\mathbf{78}+\overline{\mathbf{78}} allows unification at MU=3×1016 GeVM_U=3\times10^{16}\,\mathrm{GeV} with αU−1≃11.4\alpha_U^{-1}\simeq11.4 at two loops. For this benchmark there exist new degrees of freedom at low energies, 4 Dirac pairs of L=(1,2)−1/2L=(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_{-1/2} and one Dirac ec=(1,1)1e^c=(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{1})_1 at 1 TeV, 4 Dirac uc=(3,1)−2/3u^c=(\mathbf{3},\mathbf{1})_{-2/3} at ∼105 GeV\sim10^5\,\mathrm{GeV} and 5 Weyl T=(1,3)0T=(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{3})_0 at ∼3×108 GeV\sim3\times10^8\,\mathrm{GeV} (see Figure 1). In both cases the remaining states are at MUM_U. Above MUM_U the large matter content makes the SU(12)SU(12) gauge coupling grow fast, and the theory must be completed within a factor of a few of MUM_U. This is comparable to the species scale Λsp∼M‾Pl/Nsp∼2MU\Lambda_{\mathrm{sp}}\sim\overline{M}_{\mathrm{Pl}}/\sqrt{N_{\mathrm{sp}}}\sim2M_U [34].

Unlike standard GUTs where the weak mixing angle is a successful prediction of unification, here it is an aspect that requires light vectorlike exotic states, some of which lie around the TeV scale and provide well-motivated collider benchmarks.

The scalar sector

A minimal scalar sector that suffices to break the GUT down to the SM contains a real adjoint P∈143P\in\mathbf{143}, a complex K∈66K\in\mathbf{66}, and a complex singlet ϕ\phi (responsible for PQ breaking in models with an axion). SU(12)SU(12) is broken to the SM by the vacuum expectation value (vev)

⟨P⟩=vdiag⁡(−313,213,−13,312,0),⟨K13⟩=⟨K23⟩=v13,⟨K44⟩=vϵ2,(10)\langle P\rangle=v\operatorname{diag}(-3\mathbf{1}_3,2\mathbf{1}_3,-\mathbf{1}_3,3\mathbf{1}_2,0), \qquad \langle K_{13}\rangle=\langle K_{23}\rangle=v\mathbf{1}_3, \qquad \langle K_{44}\rangle=v\epsilon_2, \tag*{(10)}

and ⟨ϕ⟩=v\langle\phi\rangle=v. The indices i,j=1,…,5i,j=1,\ldots,5 label the SM representations that make up the 12\mathbf{12} of SU(12)SU(12) in eq. (2). A more detailed analysis of the possible scalar sectors and the relations between fermion masses that result is beyond the scope of this letter.

PP and KK each contain one (1,2)1/2(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_{1/2} doublet which we call HP∼P54H_P\sim P^4_5 and HK∼(K45)∗H_K\sim(K^{45})^*. One combination is eaten by the (1,2)1/2(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_{1/2} gauge boson, and the orthogonal one is the candidate for the SM Higgs,

HSM=cPHP+cKHK.(11)H_{\mathrm{SM}}=c_P H_P+c_K H_K. \tag*{(11)}

The eaten combination is fixed by the broken generator in the (1,2)1/2(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_{1/2} direction acting on the vevs. We find cP2=2/11c_P^2=2/11 for the vevs in Eq. (10). More generally, for ⟨P⟩∝vP\langle P\rangle\propto v_P and ⟨K⟩∝vK\langle K\rangle\propto v_K, cP2=2vK2/(9vP2+2vK2)c_P^2=2v_K^2/(9v_P^2+2v_K^2). Only HPH_P has renormalizable Yukawa couplings. Giving all vectorlike spectator masses requires additional scalar representations or higher-dimensional operators; the physical SM Yukawas then depend on the resulting Higgs couplings and light-fermion mixing. The mass of HSMH_{\mathrm{SM}} is protected and must be tuned, as in standard GUTs. It would be nice to explore if this class of theories allows for new solutions to the analog of the doublet-triplet splitting problems of standard GUTs, and explore cases where the doublet arises as a pseudo-Goldstone.

Topological defects. — An element of SU(12)SU(12) that commutes with ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle is block diagonal, g=diag⁡(g1,…,g5)g=\operatorname{diag}(g_1,\ldots,g_5). Invariance of ⟨K13⟩\langle K_{13}\rangle and ⟨K23⟩\langle K_{23}\rangle requires g1=g2≡ug_1=g_2\equiv u and g3=u∗g_3=u^*, invariance of ⟨K44⟩\langle K_{44}\rangle requires det⁡g4=1\det g_4=1, and det⁡g=1\det g=1 fixes g5g_5. The unbroken subgroup of SU(12)SU(12) is therefore exactly

H={diag⁡(u,u,u∗,w,(det⁡u)−1)}≅U(3)×SU(2),(12)H=\left\{\operatorname{diag}\left(u,u,u^*,w,(\det u)^{-1}\right)\right\}\cong U(3)\times SU(2), \tag*{(12)}

for u∈U(3)u\in U(3), w∈SU(2)w\in SU(2), hypercharge the abelian factor of U(3)U(3), and SU(2)LSU(2)_L a direct factor. HH is connected and π1(H)=Z\pi_1(H)=\mathbb{Z}. The breaking therefore produces monopoles, π2(G/H)=Z\pi_2(G/H)=\mathbb{Z}, but no topologically stable strings or domain walls, π1(G/H)=π0(G/H)=0\pi_1(G/H)=\pi_0(G/H)=0. The same holds for G=SU(12)/Z2G=SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2, where H=[U(3)×SU(2)]/Z2H=[U(3)\times SU(2)]/\mathbb{Z}_2 is the SM group with its Z6\mathbb{Z}_6 quotient. In this respect the model resembles SU(5)SU(5) rather than the SO(10)SO(10), as in the latter monopoles can be attached by Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 strings and domain walls can be bounded by strings [36, 37].

The generator of π1(H)\pi_1(H) is the loop u=diag⁡(1,1,eit)u=\operatorname{diag}(1,1,e^{it}), 0≤t≤2π0\leq t\leq2\pi, with magnetic generator

QM=diag⁡(0,0,1∣0,0,1∣0,0,−1∣0,0∣−1)=2Y+λc,(13)Q_M=\operatorname{diag}(0,0,1\mid0,0,1\mid0,0,-1\mid0,0\mid-1)=2Y+\lambda_c, \tag*{(13)}

where λc=diag⁡(−13,−13,23)\lambda_c=\operatorname{diag}\left(-\frac{1}{3},-\frac{1}{3},\frac{2}{3}\right) on a color triplet. It winds one third of the hypercharge circle e6iYθe^{6iY\theta}, twice the minimal loop of the SM group (with Γ=Z6\Gamma=\mathbb{Z}_6). The lightest ’t Hooft–Polyakov monopole thus carries two Dirac units, g=4π/eg=4\pi/e, together with Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 color-magnetic charge and no weak charge: the long-range field of the doubly charged monopole of SU(5)SU(5). There is no singly charged soliton, so it is stable within the field theory.

The global form determines the remaining one-form symmetry [10, 38, 39]. For G=SU(12)G=SU(12) the minimal charge is e/2e/2, and the doubly charged monopole saturates Dirac quantization. For SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2, Dirac quantization allows g=2π/eg=2\pi/e, but there is no smooth field configuration with that charge. Since smooth monopoles have g=4π/eg=4\pi/e there is a magnetic Z2(1)\mathbb{Z}_2^{(1)} one-form symmetry in this case. Completeness of the spectrum [40] suggests that this symmetry is broken in the full gravitational theory and singly charged monopoles exist in the UV.

Proton decay channels. — Gauge bosons live in the adjoint representation. From the branching of the fundamental we see that the adjoint of SU(12)SU(12) will contain a (3,2)1/6(3,2)_{1/6} but no (3,2)−5/6(3,2)_{-5/6}. This differs from standard SU(5)SU(5) and SO(10)SO(10) GUTs [1, 5, 6] and resembles flipped SU(5)SU(5) [41, 42, 43]. Tree-level gauge boson exchange then generates the same operators as in the latter [44, 45], that is QLucdcQLu^cd^c but no operator with ece^c. The dominant proton decay modes are p→νˉπ+p\to\bar{\nu}\pi^+ and p→ℓ+π0p\to\ell^+\pi^0, with Γ(νˉπ+)≳2Γ(e+π0)\Gamma(\bar{\nu}\pi^+)\gtrsim2\Gamma(e^+\pi^0), depending on lepton mixing, see [44, 45]. In addition to the gauge-mediated processes there will be (model-dependent) scalar-mediated processes from the representation that breaks SU(12)SU(12) down to the SM.

Fractional instantons and the QCD axion. — Because the unified coupling is stronger than usual, GUT instantons are less suppressed than in normal GUTs [46, 47]. Their tree level action is

S=2παU=2πkiαi,(14)S=\frac{2\pi}{\alpha_U}=\frac{2\pi}{k_i\alpha_i}, \tag*{(14)}

and might spoil the axion solution to the strong CP problem [48, 49, 50].

For the SU(12)SU(12) theory, the instanton has an action S=2π/(3αs)S=2\pi/(3\alpha_s). Because QCD sits in SU(12)SU(12) at level 3, a unit SU(12)SU(12) instanton carries one third of the QCD topological charge. Fractional instantons near the GUT scale contribute to the axion potential as

V(a)=−χcos⁡θ−ΛU4cos⁡(θ/3+δ),(15)V(a)=-\chi\cos\theta-\Lambda_U^4\cos(\theta/3+\delta), \tag*{(15)}
ma2fa2=χ(1+R),R=ΛU4cos⁡δ9χ.(16)m_a^2f_a^2=\chi(1+R),\qquad R=\frac{\Lambda_U^4\cos\delta}{9\chi}. \tag*{(16)}

Here δ\delta is a model-dependent CP-violating phase indicating that the two contributions are not necessarily aligned. For δ∼1\delta\sim1, ∣θˉ∣<10−10|\bar{\theta}|<10^{-10} requires ΛU4/χ<10−10\Lambda_U^4/\chi<10^{-10}. The scale ΛU\Lambda_U follows from the constrained instanton density [51, 52, 53],

ΛU4≃C12∫dρρ5KU(2παU(1/ρ))24e−2π/αU(1/ρ)e−π2ρ2v2,(17)\Lambda_U^4\simeq C_{12}\int\frac{d\rho}{\rho^5}K_U\left(\frac{2\pi}{\alpha_U(1/\rho)}\right)^{24}e^{-2\pi/\alpha_U(1/\rho)}e^{-\pi^2\rho^2v^2}, \tag*{(17)}

where C12C_{12} is a calculable constant. If the SU(12)SU(12) theory is not asymptotically free above MUM_U, the integral may be dominated by the smallest instantons, ρ−1∼\rho^{-1}\sim a few MUM_U. The factor KUK_U accounts for the fermion zero modes of the ’t Hooft vertex, which must be lifted by fermion masses or Yukawa couplings. Since the SU(12)SU(12) content above carries many zero modes, KUK_U, and hence ΛU\Lambda_U, is very sensitive to the heavy vector-like spectrum. For R≫1R\gg1, the axion is heavier by ∼R\sim\sqrt{R} and the QCD line moves towards smaller gaγγ/mag_{a\gamma\gamma}/m_a.

Towards flavor unification. — In the SU(12)SU(12) model the three families come from three copies of 266+78{\bf266}+{\bf78}, as in standard GUTs. This is no longer required for larger members of the SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4) family (see S2). Anomaly cancellation fixes the fermion content to (m+1)(m+1) antisymmetric and mm conjugate symmetric representations, and for some embeddings this minimal spectrum already contains exactly three SM families (see S2). The first example is SU(20)SU(20) with 3×190+2×2103\times190+2\times210. Its embedding indices are (k3,k2,kY)=(5,1,7/3)(k_3,k_2,k_Y)=(5,1,7/3), which give E/N=2/3E/N=2/3 and sin⁡2θW(MU)=3/10\sin^2\theta_W(M_U)=3/10. In these theories the number of generations is fixed by the embedding rather than by replication, making them promising candidates for gauge and flavor unification.

Conclusions. —We presented the first 4D GUT in which the SM group does not factor through SU(5)SU(5). The embedding is characterized by the integers (k3,k2,kY)=(3,1,1)(k_3, k_2, k_Y) = (3, 1, 1) which control the main predictions. The SM spectrum arises from 6 66+3 786\,\mathbf{66}+3\,\mathbf{78} of SU(12)SU(12) and contains only three chiral families and vector-like matter.

The theory is characterized by the prediction sin⁡2θw=1/2\sin^2\theta_w = 1/2 and the absence of (3,2)−5/6(\mathbf{3},\mathbf{2})_{-5/6} gauge bosons. Proton decay occurs in a manner similar to flipped SU(5)SU(5) models. Minimal models achieve gauge coupling unification provided that there are vector-like states near the TeV scale. In these models, there are fermions transforming as L=(1,2)−1/2L=(1,2)_{-1/2} within the reach of HL-LHC and other future colliders, as shown in Figure 1. In the case the gauge group is SU(12)SU(12) instead of SU(12)/Z2SU(12)/\mathbb{Z}_2, the fundamental representation is allowed, and color-singlet states carry half of the electron charge. A particle of charge ±e/2\pm e/2 would then be consistent with this class of models, but charge ±e/3\pm e/3 would rule it out. The monopole spectrum contains only doubly charged smooth monopoles.

A robust prediction is the axion-photon coupling, determined by the ratio E/N=2/3E/N=2/3, rather than the prediction E/N=8/3E/N=8/3 which holds for GUTs which branch through SU(5)SU(5). We have shown that E/N=2/3E/N=2/3 is the only possible alternative to the standard E/N=8/3E/N=8/3 for GUTs with no chiral exotica, up to SU(n)SU(n) models with n>37n>37. In these theories, E/NE/N is a sharper test of unification than proton decay, as a value outside of E/N={2/3,8/3}E/N=\{2/3,8/3\} would rule out GUT models without chiral exotica and n<37n<37. The axion-photon coupling is a factor 1.7 larger if E/N=2/3E/N=2/3 relative to E/N=8/3E/N=8/3, which is potentially measurable in haloscope experiments in the event of an axion discovery and an improved estimate of the local dark matter density. As in standard GUTs an axion above the QCD line, would exclude it, too [12].

The non-standard embedding also has implications for the strong CP problem. Because αU=3αs(MU)\alpha_U=3\alpha_s(M_U), small SU(12)SU(12) instantons are less suppressed than standard GUTs. Their contribution depends strongly on the heavy spectrum, and how fermionic zero modes are saturated. These fractional instantons can spoil the solution of the strong CP problem unless they are subdominant or aligned with QCD. They can also easily make the QCD axion much heavier than standard predictions.

The SU(12)SU(12) theory that we studied in detail is the first member of an infinite family based on SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4). We have shown that using up to two-index representations, we can reduce all SU(n)SU(n) embeddings to the canonical SU(5)SU(5) embedding or our new embedding. We have also developed a simple GUT bootstrap, which explores the space possible GUTs and SM embeddings using general constraints, independent of representation. It is exciting to see that some of these, as the SU(20)SU(20) theory we briefly discuss in S2, generate three SM families from minimal UV spectra without flavor replication.

Several interesting directions remain. A detailed study of the symmetry breaking pattern classifying intermediate phases, a complete calculation of the impact of small instantons on the QCD axion, as well as neutrino mass generation via the singlets or flavor predictions (e.g. b−τb-\tau unification) are interesting follow-up directions.

The catalog in the appendix was built with extensive help of ChatGPT Astra, including generating the set of constraints for the bootstrap and the proof for the two-index theorem. The driving question was a group theory classification for the possible QCD axion-photon couplings. The novel embedding was found by the LLM as a counterexample to an E/N=8/3E/N=8/3 theorem. All explicit results and constraints have been checked by the authors. ChatGPT and Claude were used to help edit and check the manuscript; however it is almost entirely written by — the authors.

The research of PA is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy under the grant DE-SC0011702.

Acknowledgments

References

Branching and particle content for SU(12)SU(12)

In this appendix we provide the detailed spectrum for the SU(12)SU(12) branching in the main text. We label the familiar SM representations of left-handed Weyl fermions as QQ, ucu^{c}, dcd^{c}, LL, ece^{c}. In Table S1 we show the quantum numbers of the SM fermions, the spectator multiplets, and other multiplets that appear in the defining blocks used below. Bars denote conjugate representations (e.g. Q‾=(3‾,2)−1/6\overline{Q}=(\overline{3},2)_{-1/6}).

SM fermionsSpectator multipletsDefining blocks
LabelRepresentationLabelRepresentationLabelRepresentation
QQ(3,2)1/6(3,2)_{1/6}XX(6,1)1/3(6,1)_{1/3}CC(3,1)1/6(3,1)_{1/6}
ucu^{c}(3‾,1)−2/3(\overline{3},1)_{-2/3}OO(8,1)0(8,1)_0DD(1,2)0(1,2)_0
dcd^{c}(3‾,1)1/3(\overline{3},1)_{1/3}TT(1,3)0(1,3)_0σ\sigma(1,1)−1/2(1,1)_{-1/2}
LL(1,2)−1/2(1,2)_{-1/2}NN(1,1)0(1,1)_0F5F_{5}(3,1)−1/3+(1,2)1/2(3,1)_{-1/3}+(1,2)_{1/2}
ece^{c}(1,1)1(1,1)_1

Table S1. Notation for representations of SU(3)c×SU(2)L×U(1)YSU(3)_{c}\times SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y}. The spectator representations OO, TT, NN are real.

The defining embedding in Eq. (2) and its antisymmetric and conjugate symmetric two-index branchings are shown in Table S2. Here t3t_{3} and t2t_{2} are arbitrary traceless Hermitian matrices in the fundamental representations of SU(3)cSU(3)_{c} and SU(2)LSU(2)_{L}, respectively; I3I_{3} is the 3×33\times3 identity, and yy a real coefficient multiplying hypercharge.

A∈66A\in66S‾∈78‾\overline{S}\in\overline{78}
A3[dc]A_{3}[d^{c}]A3[dc]+S3[X]A_{3}[d^{c}]+S_{3}[X]O+NO+NQQdc‾\overline{d^{c}}S3[X‾]S_{3}[\overline{X}]A3[dc‾]+S3[X‾]A_{3}[\overline{d^{c}}]+S_{3}[\overline{X}]O+NO+NQ‾\overline{Q}dcd^{c}
∗*A3[dc]A_{3}[d^{c}]O+NO+NQ‾\overline{Q}dc‾\overline{d^{c}}∗*S3[X‾]S_{3}[\overline{X}]O+NO+NQ‾\overline{Q}dcd^{c}
∗*∗*A3[dc‾]A_{3}[\overline{d^{c}}]Q‾\overline{Q}ucu^{c}∗*∗*S3[X‾]S_{3}[\overline{X}]QQuc‾\overline{u^{c}}
∗*∗*∗*A2[N]A_{2}[N]LL∗*∗*∗*S2[T]S_{2}[T]L‾\overline{L}
∗*∗*∗*∗*00∗*∗*∗*∗*ece^{c}

Table S2. Defining embedding (top) and schematic tensor block decompositions. Ar[F]A_{r}[F] and Sr[F]S_{r}[F] are the antisymmetric and symmetric r×rr\times r matrices built linearly from the components of FF in the relevant block bases. Thus the triplet–triplet block contains A3[dc]+S3[X]A_{3}[d^{c}]+S_{3}[X]. Other entries label the SM representation content; repeated labels in different blocks denote independent field copies. Stars are fixed by AJI=−(AIJ)TA_{JI}=-(A_{IJ})^{T} and SJI=(SIJ)TS_{JI}=(S_{IJ})^{T}, where I,JI,J label the five defining blocks.

XSM=(t3+y6I300000t3+y6I300000−t3T−y6I300000t200000−y2).X_{\mathrm{SM}}= \begin{pmatrix} t_{3}+\frac{y}{6}I_{3} & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & t_{3}+\frac{y}{6}I_{3} & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & -t_{3}^{T}-\frac{y}{6}I_{3} & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & t_{2} & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -\frac{y}{2} \end{pmatrix}.

For the spectrum F=2×66+78‾\mathcal{F}=2\times66+\overline{78}, the net spectrum per UV family branches to

2×66+78‾↓H=Q+uc+dc+L+ec+S,(18)2\times66+\overline{78}\downarrow H =Q+u^{c}+d^{c}+L+e^{c}+S, \tag*{(18)}
Q+uc+dc+L+ec⏟one SM family\underbrace{Q+u^{c}+d^{c}+L+e^{c}}_{\text{one SM family}}
S=4(Q+Q‾)+(uc+uc‾)+7(dc+dc‾)+(L+L‾)+3(X+X‾)+6O+T+8N.S=4(Q+\overline{Q})+(u^{c}+\overline{u^{c}})+7(d^{c}+\overline{d^{c}}) +(L+\overline{L})+3(X+\overline{X})+6O+T+8N.

This corresponds to 210 = 15 + 195 Weyl components per family, or 630 = 45 + 585 in total. All spectators in SS, including NN, admit SM-preserving masses.

Five Families of SU(n) embeddings

The SU(12)SU(12) example in the text is a special case of a family of SM embeddings in SU(n)SU(n) for n=8m+4n = 8m+4, m≥1m \ge1. We will show a proof in section S4S4 that there are only five families of SU(n)SU(n) embedding up to two-index representations. Two of these are the canonical SU(5)SU(5) embeddings, and the other three families are based on SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4) and are closely related to the SU(12)SU(12) embedding in the text. The SU(n)SU(n) representations of interest are A2=∧2nA_2 = \wedge^2 n and S2=Sym⁡2nS_2 = \operatorname{Sym}^2 n. All fermions below are left-handed Weyl fields. The construction continues to arbitrarily large nn.

Embedding and predictions. The SU(8m+4)SU(8m+4) family of embedding is defined by 3 classes labeled by (k,d)∈{(1,1),(1,3),(3,1)}(k,d) \in\{(1,1),(1,3),(3,1)\}. Setting a=m+(d+1)/2a = m + (d+1)/2, b=m+(1−d)/2b = m + (1-d)/2, with a,b≥ka,b \ge k, the defining representation branches as

V=n⟶aC+bC‾+kD+(a−k)σ+(b−k)σ‾.(19)V = \mathbf{n} \longrightarrow aC + b\overline{C} + kD + (a-k)\sigma+ (b-k)\overline{\sigma}. \tag*{(19)}

Thus kk counts weak doublets and d=a−bd = a-b is the triplet–antitriplet imbalance in VV. The sum of dimensions of the SM representations dimension is nn and Tr⁡VY=0\operatorname{Tr}_V Y = 0. The physical hypercharge is defined as Q=T3L+YQ = T^L_3 + Y and nonabelian fundamental normalization Tr⁡TaTb=δab/2\operatorname{Tr} T^aT^b = \delta^{ab}/2. The embedding indices are

(k3,k2,kY)=(2m+1, k, 4m+23−k).(20)(k_3,k_2,k_Y) = \left(2m+1,\ k,\ \frac{4m+2}{3}-k\right). \tag*{(20)}

For a PQ symmetry commuting with the unified group and having a nonzero mixed gauge anomaly, and with tree-level gauge matching at MUM_U,

EN=kY+k2k3=23,sin⁡2θW(MU)=k2kY+k2=3k4m+2.(21)\boxed{\frac{E}{N} = \frac{k_Y+k_2}{k_3} = \frac{2}{3}}, \qquad \boxed{\sin^2\theta_W(M_U) = \frac{k_2}{k_Y+k_2} = \frac{3k}{4m+2}}. \tag*{(21)}

Three-generation fermion spectra. The fermion content for the GUT is

F=3dk[(m+1)A2+mS2].(22)\mathcal{F} = \frac{3}{d_k}\left[(m+1)A_2 + mS_2\right]. \tag*{(22)}

The three choices above give nonnegative integral multiplicities. Along with the SU(5)SU(5) embeddings, we get five families, shown in Table S3.

FamilynnV↓SMV\downarrow_{\mathrm{SM}}F\mathcal{F}(k3,k2,kY)(k_3,k_2,k_Y)E/NE/N
I5F5F_53A2+3V‾3A_2+3\overline{V}(1,1,5/3)(1,1,5/3)8/38/3
II152F5+F‾52F_5+\overline{F}_52A2+S‾2+3V‾2A_2+\overline{S}_2+3\overline{V}(3,3,5)(3,3,5)8/38/3
III8m+48m+4(m+1)C+mC‾+D+mσ+(m−1)σ‾(m+1)C+m\overline{C}+D+m\sigma+(m-1)\overline{\sigma}3[(m+1)A2+mS‾2]3[(m+1)A_2+m\overline{S}_2](2m+1,1,4m−13)(2m+1,1,\frac{4m-1}{3})2/32/3
IV8m+48m+4(m+2)C+(m−1)C‾+D+(m+1)σ+(m−2)σ‾(m+2)C+(m-1)\overline{C}+D+(m+1)\sigma+(m-2)\overline{\sigma}(m+1)A2+mS‾2(m+1)A_2+m\overline{S}_2(2m+1,1,4m−13)(2m+1,1,\frac{4m-1}{3})2/32/3
V8m+48m+4(m+1)C+mC‾+3D+(m−2)σ+(m−3)σ‾(m+1)C+m\overline{C}+3D+(m-2)\sigma+(m-3)\overline{\sigma}(m+1)A2+mS‾2(m+1)A_2+m\overline{S}_2(2m+1,3,4m−73)(2m+1,3,\frac{4m-7}{3})2/32/3

Table S3. Five families of two-index embeddings in SU(n)SU(n), with defining branching VV and UV Weyl-fermion spectrum F\mathcal{F}. The defining blocks are listed in Table S1. Family II corresponds to the higher-level-embedding found in [16]. Families III, IV and V have m≥1m \ge1, m≥2m \ge2 and m≥3m \ge3, and correspond to (k,d)=(1,1),(1,3),(3,1)(k,d) = (1,1),(1,3),(3,1), respectively. The table displays cores without neutral defining singlets.

The last two rows use different SM embeddings despite identical GUT fermion representations. It is worth emphasizing that families IV and V do not have a 3-fold replication, with the three SM generations coming from one copy of F\mathcal{F} in the UV theory. The smallest anomaly-free spectrum with A2,S2A_2,S_2 with this embedding naturally produces 3 generations of the SM; hence, these constitute a model of flavor unification as well! The smallest group for which this works is SU(20)SU(20).

Anomaly cancellation: Normalizing the cubic anomaly of n\mathbf{n} to one, the anomaly for these reps are AG(A2)=n−4\mathcal{A}_{G}(A_{2})=n-4 and AG(S‾2)=−(n+4)\mathcal{A}_{G}(\overline{S}_{2})=-(n+4), so FF satisfies anomaly cancellation,

AG(F)=3dk[(m+1)(n−4)−m(n+4)]=0.(23)\mathcal{A}_{G}(F)=\frac{3}{d_{k}}\left[(m+1)(n-4)-m(n+4)\right]=0. \tag*{(23)}

Chirality The branching of A2A_{2} and S‾2\overline{S}_{2} to the SM can be calculated by using

Λ2(⨁iciRi)=⨁iciΛ2Ri⊕⨁i(ci2)(Ri⊗Ri)⊕⨁i<jcicj(Ri⊗Rj).(24)\Lambda^{2}\left(\bigoplus_{i}c_{i}R_{i}\right)=\bigoplus_{i}c_{i}\Lambda^{2}R_{i}\oplus\bigoplus_{i}\binom{c_{i}}{2}(R_{i}\otimes R_{i})\oplus\bigoplus_{i<j}c_{i}c_{j}(R_{i}\otimes R_{j}). \tag*{(24)}

The same formula holds for the symmetric square upon replacing Λ2\Lambda^{2} by Sym⁡2\operatorname{Sym}^{2} on both sides. The branchings can be written in terms of the SM representations defined in appendix S1. The expression is,

A2↓SM=akQ+bkQ‾+b(a−k)uc+a(b−k)u‾c+[(a+12)+b(b−k)]dc+[(b+12)+a(a−k)]d‾c+k(a−k)L+k(b−k)L‾+(b−k2)ec+(a−k2)e‾c+(a2)X+(b2)X‾+abO+(k2)T+[ab+(a−k)(b−k)+(k+12)]N.(25)\begin{aligned} A_{2}\mathbin{\downarrow}_{\mathrm{SM}}={}&akQ+bk\overline{Q}+b(a-k)u^{c}+a(b-k)\overline{u}^{c}+\left[\binom{a+1}{2}+b(b-k)\right]d^{c}+\left[\binom{b+1}{2}+a(a-k)\right]\overline{d}^{c}\\ &+k(a-k)L+k(b-k)\overline{L}+\binom{b-k}{2}e^{c}+\binom{a-k}{2}\overline{e}^{c}+\binom{a}{2}X+\binom{b}{2}\overline{X}\\ &+abO+\binom{k}{2}T+\left[ab+(a-k)(b-k)+\binom{k+1}{2}\right]N. \tag*{(25)} \end{aligned}
S‾2↓SM=bkQ+akQ‾+a(b−k)uc+b(a−k)u‾c+[(b2)+a(b−k)]dc+[(a2)+b(b−k)]d‾c+k(b−k)L+k(a−k)L‾+(a−k+12)ec+(b−k+12)e‾c+(b+12)X+(a+12)X‾+abO+(k+12)T+[ab+(a−k)(b−k)+(k2)]N.(26)\begin{aligned} \overline{S}_{2}\mathbin{\downarrow}_{\mathrm{SM}}={}&bkQ+ak\overline{Q}+a(b-k)u^{c}+b(a-k)\overline{u}^{c}+\left[\binom{b}{2}+a(b-k)\right]d^{c}+\left[\binom{a}{2}+b(b-k)\right]\overline{d}^{c}\\ &+k(b-k)L+k(a-k)\overline{L}+\binom{a-k+1}{2}e^{c}+\binom{b-k+1}{2}\overline{e}^{c}+\binom{b+1}{2}X+\binom{a+1}{2}\overline{X}\\ &+abO+\binom{k+1}{2}T+\left[ab+(a-k)(b-k)+\binom{k}{2}\right]N. \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}

It is straightforward to check that the net chiral spectrum ΔR≡R−R‾\Delta R\equiv R-\overline{R} gives the SM,

Δ[(m+1)A2+mS‾2]=dk ΔFSM,(27)\Delta\left[(m+1)A_{2}+m\overline{S}_{2}\right]=dk\,\Delta F_{\mathrm{SM}}, \tag*{(27)}

where FSM=Q+uc+dc+L+ecF_{\mathrm{SM}}=Q+u^{c}+d^{c}+L+e^{c} is one SM generation. All other complex representations pair with their conjugates. Therefore those, as well as the real spectators OO, TT and NN all admit a SM-preserving mass. Since dk=3dk=3 for three SM families, we see that SU(2)SU(2) can only be embedded at k=1k=1 or k=3k=3.

Examples. We list selected examples in this family below.

Groupmm(k,d)(k,d)Fermion content(k3,k2,kY)(k_{3},k_{2},k_{Y})sin⁡2θW(MU)\sin^{2}\theta_{W}(M_{U})
SU(12)SU(12)11(1,1)(1,1)6 66+3 786\,\mathbf{66}+3\,\mathbf{78}(3,1,1)(3,1,1)1/21/2
SU(20)SU(20)22(1,3)(1,3)3 190+2 2103\,\mathbf{190}+2\,\mathbf{210}(5,1,7/3)(5,1,7/3)3/103/10
SU(28)SU(28)33(1,3)(1,3)4 378+3 4064\,\mathbf{378}+3\,\mathbf{406}(7,1,11/3)(7,1,11/3)3/143/14
SU(28)SU(28)33(3,1)(3,1)4 378+3 4064\,\mathbf{378}+3\,\mathbf{406}(7,3,5/3)(7,3,5/3)9/149/14

Table 1.

For SU(28)SU(28), we have two inequivalent embeddings, corresponding to (k,d)=(1,3)(k,d)=(1,3) and (3,1)(3,1), respectively. These are explicit anomaly-free fermion constructions with the required SM chirality.

A 3-index family with color sextets. Beyond the two-index family, there are new embeddings that use higher UV representations. We present an example of such a family (but we do not have a proof that this is the only possibility). The matter content of these theories is very large and it will probably prove challenging to build realistic models out of these embeddings.

The family of GUT groups is SU(n)SU(n) with n=12+20sn=12+20s, s=0,1,…s=0,1,\ldots, and defining branching Vs=V‾12+sB20V_{s}=\overline{V}_{12}+sB_{20}, where V12V_{12} is the m=k=d=1m=k=d=1 case of Eq. (19). Here B20=Sym⁡2(C+σ)+Sym⁡2(C+σ‾)B_{20}=\operatorname{Sym}^{2}(C+\sigma)+\operatorname{Sym}^{2}(C+\overline{\sigma}) is a charged real representation containing a color sextet–antisextet pair. Its indices and predictions, under the same PQ and matching assumptions as above, are

(k3,k2,kY)=(3+12s,1,1+8s),EN=23,sin⁡2θW(MU)=12+8s.(28)(k_{3},k_{2},k_{Y})=(3+12s,1,1+8s),\qquad\frac{E}{N}=\frac{2}{3},\qquad\sin^{2}\theta_{W}(M_{U})=\frac{1}{2+8s}. \tag*{(28)}

Writing Aj=∧jnA_j=\wedge^j\mathbf{n}, Sj=Sym⁡jnS_j=\operatorname{Sym}^j\mathbf{n}, and define the irreducible mixed tensors by S2⊗n‾=MS⊕nS_2\otimes\overline{\mathbf{n}}=M_S\oplus\mathbf{n} and A2⊗n‾=MA⊕nA_2\otimes\overline{\mathbf{n}}=M_A\oplus\mathbf{n}. An explicit left-handed fermion spectrum is

Fs=3[S2+2A‾2+s(S3+A3+M‾S+M‾A)].(29)\mathcal{F}_s=3\left[S_2+2\overline{A}_2+s\left(S_3+A_3+\overline{M}_S+\overline{M}_A\right)\right]. \tag*{(29)}

It obeys AG(Fs)=3(12−n+20s)=0\mathcal{A}_G(\mathcal{F}_s)=3(12-n+20s)=0 and the exact character identity Δ(Fs↓SM)=3ΔFSM\Delta(\mathcal{F}_s\mathord{\downarrow}_{SM})=3\Delta\mathcal{F}_{SM}. The remaining complex representations pair, and pseudoreal spectators have even multiplicity, so all spectators admit SM-preserving masses. The first new member is SU(32)SU(32), with sin⁡2θW=1/10\sin^2\theta_W=1/10; the sequence continues through SU(52)SU(52), SU(72)SU(72), …\ldots. These are not asymptotically free for any s>0s>0. We leave three-index families for future exploration.

A GUT bootstrap

The search for a consistent embedding of the SM into a unified gauge group is a classification task that is subject to several mathematical constraints. In this respect, it resembles a bootstrap program, where we can use these general constraints to explore the GUT landscape, and islands evading these constraints point to interesting possible new structures. Indeed, the SU(12)SU(12) case in the text is exactly such an example. In this appendix we derive the relevant constraints on embeddings that contain the SM, and scan over embeddings to find viable GUT models.

Assumptions and the odd-trace constraint

The criteria for the search are the following: we seek a compact, connected, simple gauge group GG to contain the Standard Model (SM) and admit an anomaly-free, finite Weyl-fermion spectrum F\mathcal{F} with exactly three SM generations and no additional chiral matter. The spectators must admit SM-preserving fermion bilinear masses, and hypercharge must generate a closed circle. For the axion prediction we assume a Peccei–Quinn symmetry commuting with GG, with a nonzero mixed gauge anomaly.

Complex spectators are paired, real spectators admit Majorana masses, and pseudoreal spectators must occur with even multiplicity. The odd traces for these representations cancel. For an SM Cartan element XX, the UV spectrum must therefore satisfy

Tr⁡FXr=3sr(X),sr(X)=Tr⁡FSMXr,r=1,3,5,…(30)\operatorname{Tr}_{\mathcal{F}}X^r=3s_r(X),\qquad s_r(X)=\operatorname{Tr}_{\mathcal{F}_{SM}}X^r,\qquad r=1,3,5,\ldots \tag*{(30)}

where FSM\mathcal{F}_{SM} is one SM generation. In particular, s1=s3=0s_1=s_3=0, but s5≠0s_5\ne0.

The fifth trace already gives a strong constraint on the embedding. The nonzero fifth SM trace requires a degree-five invariant of the UV algebra. The invariant-degree list [54], together with the SM rank, leaves only SU(n)SU(n), SO(10)SO(10) and E6E_6. For the latter two, the degree-seven invariant is the degree-five invariant times the unique quadratic form. Matching the SM fifth and seventh traces therefore fixes the relative color, weak and hypercharge normalizations to the canonical ones, giving E/N=8/3E/N=8/3. For SU(n)SU(n), additional independent invariants prevent this immediate conclusion; the remaining bootstrap is necessary.

The SU(n) bootstrap

In this section we describe a scan over the possible embeddings of the SM in SU(n)SU(n), and general constraints that such an embedding must satisfy. A key feature of the bootstrap is that the constraints do not require enumerating the fermion spectrum F\mathcal{F}, and therefore can rule out broad classes of GUTs.

For G=SU(n)G=SU(n), an embedding is specified by the branching of the fundamental representation V=nV=\mathbf{n} into color and weak irreducible blocks, with a given hypercharge. This parametrizes both standard and more exotic embeddings:

V↓SM=⨁ici(Ri,ℓi)Yi,V\mathord{\downarrow}SM=\bigoplus_i c_i(R_i,\ell_i)_{Y_i},
∑icidim⁡(Ri)ℓi=n,∑icidim⁡(Ri)ℓiYi=0.(31)\sum_i c_i\dim(R_i)\ell_i=n,\qquad\sum_i c_i\dim(R_i)\ell_iY_i=0. \tag*{(31)}

Here RiR_i is a color representation, ℓi\ell_i labels the SU(2)WSU(2)_W representation with dimension ℓi\ell_i, cic_i a positive integer multiplicity, and Yi∈QY_i\in\mathbb{Q} its hypercharge. Both nonabelian factors must act nontrivially. The two sums impose the dimension budget and traceless hypercharge. VV may be defined only on the simply connected cover, while F\mathcal{F} should be consistent with the chosen global group. The embedding indices are defined as:

k3=∑iciℓi 2T3(Ri),k2=∑icidim⁡(Ri)ℓi(ℓi2−1)6,kY=2∑icidim⁡(Ri)ℓiYi2.(32)k_{3}=\sum_{i}c_{i}\ell_{i}\,2T_{3}(R_{i}),\qquad k_{2}=\sum_{i}\frac{c_{i}\dim(R_{i})\ell_{i}(\ell_{i}^{2}-1)}{6},\qquad k_{Y}=2\sum_{i}c_{i}\dim(R_{i})\ell_{i}Y_{i}^{2}. \tag*{(32)}

We use Q=TL3+YQ=T_{L}^{3}+Y and fundamental normalization Tr⁡TaTb=δab/2\operatorname{Tr}T^{a}T^{b}=\delta^{ab}/2. Under the stated PQ assumption, the anomalous axion-photon coupling parameter is

EN=k2+kYk3.(33)\frac{E}{N}=\frac{k_{2}+k_{Y}}{k_{3}}. \tag*{(33)}

The defining traces are determined by this branching alone:

Pr(X)=Tr⁡VXr=∑iciTr⁡(Ri,ℓi)YiXr.(34)P_{r}(X)=\operatorname{Tr}_{V}X^{r}=\sum_{i}c_{i}\operatorname{Tr}_{(R_{i},\ell_{i})}Y_{i}X^{r}. \tag*{(34)}

Every trace in an arbitrary UV representation is an invariant polynomial of SU(n)SU(n), and can be expressed in terms of P2,…,PnP_{2},\ldots,P_{n}. For example, Tr⁡RX5\operatorname{Tr}_{R}X^{5} is a linear combination of P5P_{5} and P2P3P_{2}P_{3}, the only monomials of total degree five. Summing over any UV fermion spectrum and using Eq. (30) gives the constrain equation

3s5=AP5+BP2P3,A,B∈Z.(35)3s_{5}=AP_{5}+BP_{2}P_{3},\qquad A,B\in\mathbb{Z}. \tag*{(35)}

The integers AA, BB encode the unknown fermion multiplicities. If no choice of these constants makes the polynomial identity hold for every XX, the embedding is excluded, independently of the UV representation sizes.

We first allow arbitrary rational coefficients to obtain a necessary test; the additional integer constraints imposed by a physical UV spectrum are applied below. More generally, one must be able to write

3sr=∑ν1+⋯+νk=rcν1⋯νkPν1⋯Pνk,cν1⋯νk∈Q,r=5,7,9,…(36)3s_{r}=\sum_{\nu_{1}+\cdots+\nu_{k}=r}c_{\nu_{1}\cdots\nu_{k}}P_{\nu_{1}}\cdots P_{\nu_{k}},\qquad c_{\nu_{1}\cdots\nu_{k}}\in\mathbb{Q},\qquad r=5,7,9,\ldots \tag*{(36)}

The sum runs over distinct products of total degree rr, with 2≤νa≤n2\leq\nu_{a}\leq n and all product lengths kk.

Additional constraints

In this subsection we enumerate some of the restrictions on GUT completions of the SM that arise from the constraint equations derived in the previous section. We do not give full derivations of all of our results, instead summarizing the constraints. A detailed derivation of these constraints, together with the code used for the scan, will be presented in a forthcoming publication.

Integer constraints. Gauge-anomaly cancellation implies that the coefficients in Eq. (35) must be A=12uA=12u and B=10vB=10v, strengthening the degree-five matching condition to:

3s5=12uP5+10vP2P3,u,v∈Z.(37)3s_{5}=12uP_{5}+10vP_{2}P_{3},\qquad u,v\in\mathbb{Z}. \tag*{(37)}

These integers parametrize the UV spectrum, so are additional data on the embedding. Matching coefficients gives further constraints, including that k3k_{3} must be odd. There are seventh- and ninth-degree integral tests that can further restrict the embedding.

Charge realizability. For each proposed branching, the trace constraints must admit solutions with rational hypercharges for the specified blocks.

Character compatibility. The defining branching also determines the full set of eigenvalue of M(g)M(g). Here M(g)M(g) is the n×nn\times n matrix by which an element gg of a cover of the SM group, H~\widetilde{H}, acts on VV. Write ΔχR=χR−χ‾R\Delta\chi_{R}=\chi_{R}-\overline{\chi}_{R}, where χR(g)=Tr⁡Rg\chi_{R}(g)=\operatorname{Tr}_{R}g is the character of RR. For a given fermion spectrum, Δχ\Delta\chi is the sum of ΔχR\Delta\chi_{R} over its representations, with multiplicity. On the common cover H~\widetilde{H} of the SM where VV is defined, any UV completion must obey

M(g)∼SU(n)M(h)⟹ΔχFSM(g)=ΔχFSM(h),g,h∈H~.(38)M(g)\sim_{SU(n)}M(h)\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\Delta\chi_{\mathrm{FSM}}(g)=\Delta\chi_{\mathrm{FSM}}(h),\qquad g,h\in\widetilde{H}. \tag*{(38)}

Conjugate matrices have the same character in every UV representation, so violation of Eq. (38) rejects the embedding independently of the UV representation. Indeed, the character of any SU(n)SU(n) representation at gg depends only on the eigenvalues of M(g)M(g), which conjugation by SU(n)SU(n) transformations does not change. Decomposed under the SM, F\mathcal{F} consists of three generations plus spectators with vanishing Δχ\Delta\chi (vectorlike pairs, real and pseudoreal SM representations), so ΔχF=3ΔχFSM\Delta\chi_{\mathcal{F}} = 3\Delta\chi_{\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{SM}}}. Conjugate M(g)M(g) and M(h)M(h) thus give Eq. (38). The scan combines these tests with integral information through degree nine, enumerating nonabelian blocks at fixed nn while keeping charges symbolic. The tests are necessary but not sufficient to establish an anomaly free UV spectrum without chiral exotics. Embeddings which pass the tests highlight interesting candidates, leading to families of viable models, as we will see below.

Explicit checks used in the scan. At zero hypercharge, the integer constraint can be evaluated using three coefficients computed from the defining branching:

C3=∑iciℓiA3(Ri),C3,2=∑iciA3(Ri)ℓi(ℓi2−1)6,P5(Z)=56C5Tr⁡3Z2Tr⁡3Z3,(39)\begin{aligned} C_3 &= \sum_i c_i\ell_i\mathcal{A}_3(R_i), \qquad C_{3,2} = \sum_i c_i\mathcal{A}_3(R_i)\frac{\ell_i(\ell_i^2-1)}{6},\\ P_5(Z) &= \frac{5}{6}C_5\operatorname{Tr}_3 Z^2\operatorname{Tr}_3 Z^3, \tag*{(39)} \end{aligned}

where A3(3)=1\mathcal{A}_3(3)=1 and ZZ is a pure color Cartan element. For the classified triplet embeddings, C3C_3 equals the imbalance dd. The candidate is rejected unless u,vu,v simultaneously satisfy

uC5+vk3C3=0,12uC3,2+vk2C3=3.(40)uC_5+vk_3C_3=0,\qquad12uC_{3,2}+vk_2C_3=3. \tag*{(40)}

In particular, k2,C3k_2,C_3 are odd, and C3≡k3(mod2)C_3\equiv k_3\pmod{2} forces k3k_3 odd. For the SU(12)SU(12) branching in Eq. (2),

(n,k3,k2,kY;C3,C3,2,C5)=(12,3,1,1;1,0,1),u+3v=0,v=3.(41)(n,k_3,k_2,k_Y;C_3,C_{3,2},C_5)=(12,3,1,1;1,0,1),\qquad u+3v=0,\quad v=3. \tag*{(41)}

Thus u=−9u=-9. The spectrum 666+378666+378 realizes these coefficients. Its full branching in Sec. S1 confirms a possible UV construction.

Results and coverage

Theorem (two-index classification). For every n≥5n\geq5, the admissible SU(n)SU(n) embeddings and net chiral spectra with UV fermions carrying at most two indices in total, fundamental or antifundamental, consist of the two canonical and three noncanonical branches listed in Table S3 and proved in Sec. S4. These families of SU(n0)SU(n_0) admit simple extensions to SU(n0+r)SU(n_0+r) with rr additional singlets in the defining block. Together, this is an exhaustive classification. All five branches have exactly three chiral SM generations and vectorlike spectators. The canonical branches (families I & II) have E/N=8/3E/N=8/3, with k3=1k_3=1 for n≥5n\geq5 or k3=3k_3=3 for n≥15n\geq15 [16]. With K=k3K=k_3 odd, the three noncanonical branches project to

n=4K+r,K≥3,r≥0,E/N=2/3.(42)n=4K+r,\qquad K\geq3,\quad r\geq0,\qquad E/N=2/3. \tag*{(42)}

Here rr counts neutral singlets added to the charged core.

The family of Eqs. (28)–(29) instead gives

(n,k3)=(12+20s,3+12s),s≥1.(43)(n,k_3)=(12+20s,3+12s),\qquad s\geq1. \tag*{(43)}

The displayed spectrum uses three-index fermions, while Eq. (42) and the canonical branches exclude any two-index completion. These are constructions, not an exhaustive three-index classification.

UV tensorsDomainEstablished result
Up to two indicesAll nnEmbeddings and net chiral spectra classified
Up to three indicesn=12+20sn=12+20s, s≥1s\geq1New family; two-index completion excluded
Unrestrictedn≤37n\leq37 or k3≤7k_3\leq7E/N∈{2/3,8/3}E/N\in\{2/3,8/3\}
UnrestrictedTriplet-only colored blocks, all nnE/N∈{2/3,8/3}E/N\in\{2/3,8/3\}

Table 2.

In the last row, colored defining blocks are weak-singlet triplets or antitriplets; colorless blocks are arbitrary. The unrestricted finite-rank and low-index results include certified finite calculations. They fix the ratio if a completion exists, rather than classify all spectra. The unrestricted rank-two-value theorem remains open.

Beyond the two-index cutoff, UV-chiral sectors can be SM-nonchiral and anomaly-free [16], so classifying embeddings need not classify all UV spectra. The plot therefore distinguishes a complete low-degree classification from particular higher-degree constructions.

Bootstrap coverage and explicit families for $SU(n)$

Figure S1. Bootstrap coverage and explicit families for SU(n)SU(n). Each cell labels (n,k3)(n,k_3), with the background colors showing the status: ruled out, only E/N=2/3E/N=2/3, only 8/38/3, both ratios among surviving candidates, or unresolved. Ratio colors are necessary conditions. Solid teal and dashed blue horizontal lines show the exhaustive two-index constructions, starting at n=4k3n=4k_3. The canonical GUTs are (n,k3)=(5,1)(n,k_3)=(5,1) and (15,3)(15,3). Diamonds mark the known three-index family (n,k3)=(12+20s,3+12s)(n,k_3)=(12+20s,3+12s), s≥1s\geq1, admitting a three-index completion but no two-index completion. The vertical dashed line marks the n≤60n\leq60 catalogue boundary. Beyond it, only all-rank results are colored; white cells are outside coverage. We note that due to the matching condition in Eq. (6), models with k3≳α−1(MU)k_3\gtrsim\alpha^{-1}(M_U) correspond to strongly coupled theories αGUT>1\alpha_{\mathrm{GUT}}>1. All theories here contain three chiral SM families and vectorlike matter.

Classification with two-index fermions

In this section we outline the proof for the two-index classification given in Table S3 for every SU(n)SU(n), n≥5n\geq5 (up to trivial extensions such as adding singlets to the branching of VV). The two-index restriction means that the UV fermions may occupy the fundamental V=nV=n, its antisymmetric square A2=∧2VA_2=\wedge^2 V and symmetric square S2=Sym⁡2VS_2=\operatorname{Sym}^2 V, their conjugates, and the real singlet and adjoint, with arbitrary multiplicities. We require cancellation of the UV gauge anomaly and exactly three SM generations of net chirality, with all other fermions admitting SM-preserving vectorlike masses. The branching of VV, which specifies the embedding, is initially unrestricted.

The argument first bounds the weak content using a single group element and a weighted anomaly. Ordinary spin addition then excludes defining blocks carrying both color and weak charge. Finally, nonnegative charge multiplicities fix hypercharge. The result is the two canonical and three noncanonical families of Sec. S2.

Weighted Anomaly Matching

We show that a form of weighted anomaly matching can put a sharp restriction on the allowed embedding. Up to additional real and vectorlike components the GUT fermion spectrum can be written as

F=xV+yA2+zS2,(44)\mathcal{F}=xV+yA_2+zS_2, \tag*{(44)}

where xx, yy, zz are signed integers, with a negative coefficient denoting the conjugate representation. It will be useful to define p=y+zp=y+z. The SU(n)SU(n) anomaly coefficients in these representations are 11, n−4n-4, n+4n+4, so anomaly cancellation implies

x+(n−4)y+(n+4)z=0,x=−np−4(z−y).(45)x+(n-4)y+(n+4)z=0,\qquad x=-np-4(z-y). \tag*{(45)}

We can get additional constraints using a weighted anomaly equation. For a SU(n)SU(n) representation R\mathcal{R} branching to SM,

R↓SM=⨁ici(Ri,ℓi)yi,(46)\mathcal{R}\downarrow SM=\bigoplus_i c_i(R_i,\ell_i)_{y_i}, \tag*{(46)}

define

Ag(R)=∑iA3(ciRi)χℓi(g)(47)A_g(\mathcal{R})=\sum_i A_3(c_iR_i)\chi_{\ell_i}(g) \tag*{(47)}

where A3A_3 is the SU(3)3SU(3)^3 anomaly coefficient and the SU(2)SU(2) trace χℓ(g)=Tr⁡ℓg\chi_\ell(g)=\operatorname{Tr}_\ell g for some element gg. We will choose the weak group element

g=diag⁡(ω,ω2),ω=e2πi/3.(48)g=\operatorname{diag}(\omega,\omega^2),\qquad\omega=e^{2\pi i/3}. \tag*{(48)}

Its ω\omega and ω2\omega^2 eigenspaces in VV have equal dimension kk, since gg and g−1g^{-1} are conjugate in SU(2)SU(2). Thus

P:=Tr⁡Vg=n−3k.(49)P:=\operatorname{Tr}_V g=n-3k. \tag*{(49)}

Every nontrivial weak multiplet contributes at least one eigenvector to each of these eigenspaces. A defining block with color dimension dcd_c therefore contributes at least dcd_c to kk if it is a weak nonsinglet. In particular, kk is a positive integer.

Importantly, AgA_g depends only on the chiral spectrum (with contributions from vectorlike matter vanishing identically), so can be matched with the SM,

Ag(F)=3Ag(FSM)=−9(50)A_g(\mathcal{F})=3A_g(\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{SM}})=-9 \tag*{(50)}

where FSM\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{SM}} is the fermion content in one generation of SM fermions. The quark doublet contributes −1-1 and the antiquarks −2-2 to the weighted anomaly.

Define d=Ag(V)d=A_g(V). With A3(3)=1A_3(3)=1, the color anomaly coefficients and the weak characters at the chosen gg are integers, so d∈Zd\in\mathbb{Z}. To extract the weighted anomaly for the two-index representations, consider f(t)=Tr⁡V(etXcg)f(t)=\operatorname{Tr}_V(e^{tX_c}g), with XcX_c a color generator normalized so Tr⁡3Xc3=1\operatorname{Tr}_3 X_c^3=1. Then f′(0)=0f'(0)=0, f(0)=Pf(0)=P, and f′′′(0)=df'''(0)=d. Using the identity,

Tr⁡A2(etXcg)=12[f(t)2−Tr⁡V(e2tXcg2)](51)\operatorname{Tr}_{A_2}(e^{tX_c}g)=\frac{1}{2}\left[f(t)^2-\operatorname{Tr}_V(e^{2tX_c}g^2)\right] \tag*{(51)}
Tr⁡S2(etXcg)=12[f(t)2+Tr⁡V(e2tXcg2)](52)\operatorname{Tr}_{S_2}(e^{tX_c}g)=\frac{1}{2}\left[f(t)^2+\operatorname{Tr}_V(e^{2tX_c}g^2)\right] \tag*{(52)}

and differentiating the expression three times, we obtain (gg and g2g^2 are related by conjugation),

Ag(A2)=(P−4)d,Ag(S2)=(P+4)d.(53)A_g(A_2)=(P-4)d,\qquad A_g(S_2)=(P+4)d. \tag*{(53)}

These weighted anomaly formulae are the usual anomaly formulae with nn replaced by PP. Matching the weighted anomaly with the SM gives

[x+(P−4)y+(P+4)z]d=−3pkd=−9,pkd=3.(54)[x+(P-4)y+(P+4)z]d=-3pkd=-9,\qquad pkd=3. \tag*{(54)}

Consequently k=1k=1 or 33, independently of nn.

Restricting the defining blocks

Given the bound on kk, we can derive constraints on the branching of the fundamental representation.

No simultaneous color and weak charge. In the branching of the fundamental representation such a block contributes at least three to kk, therefore the bound permits just one copy with color R=3R=3 or 3‾\overline{3} with all other defining blocks being weak singlets. Such a branching cannot reproduce the SM chiral spectrum. More explicitly, let the weak representation of this block be labelled by its spin, j>0j>0. Then its square in the cross-product contained in A2A_{2} or S2S_{2} has a rep R~\widetilde{R} has weak spin 2j≥12j\geq1 and colour charge, while all other representations have weak spin 00 or jj. Thus, there is an exotic chiral fermion in the R~\widetilde{R} rep left over if representations in the branching of VV carry both color and weak charges.

Match quark doublets and antiquarks. With hypercharge omitted for the time being, write V=U⊕WV=U\oplus W, where UU contains the weak singlets and WW the colorless weak nonsinglets. All colored weak nonsinglets in the branching of the two-index representations arise from the cross product U⊗WU\otimes W. It appears once in each two-index representation, so its signed coefficient is p=y+zp=y+z. Since W‾=W\overline{W}=W when hypercharge is omitted, matching net chirality three quark doublets requires

p(U−U‾)⊗W=3(3−3‾)⊗2.p(U-\overline{U})\otimes W=3(\mathbf{3}-\overline{\mathbf{3}})\otimes\mathbf{2}.

The right-hand side contains only weak doublets, so WW must contain only doublets. Each contributes one to the eigenspace dimension kk. Since all colored blocks are weak singlets, d=Ag(V)d=\mathcal{A}_{g}(V) is now the ordinary color anomaly. Matching the color representations and multiplicities therefore gives

W=k 2,U−U‾=d(3−3‾),pkd=3.(55)W=k\,\mathbf{2},\qquad U-\overline{U}=d(\mathbf{3}-\overline{\mathbf{3}}),\qquad pkd=3. \tag*{(55)}

Choosing the convention d>0d>0, (k,d)=(1,1),(1,3),(3,1)(k,d)=(1,1),(1,3),(3,1) and p=3/(kd)p=3/(kd). We can thus conclude from eq. (32) that kk gives the weak embedding level, k=k2k=k_{2}.

We can also fix the unsigned color content as well. Define K=(y−z)/pK=(y-z)/p, which is well-defined since pkd=3pkd=3. Some algebra with symmetric and antisymmetric squares gives,

d(3−3‾)⊗[x 1+p2(U+U‾)−pK2(3+3‾+2 1)]=−6(3−3‾).(56)d(\mathbf{3}-\overline{\mathbf{3}})\otimes\left[x\,\mathbf{1}+\frac{p}{2}(U+\overline{U})-\frac{pK}{2}(\mathbf{3}+\overline{\mathbf{3}}+2\,\mathbf{1})\right]=-6(\mathbf{3}-\overline{\mathbf{3}}). \tag*{(56)}

Using Eqs. (45) and (S38), this simplifies to,

U+U‾=K(3+3‾)+(2n−6K−4k)1.(57)U+\overline{U}=K(\mathbf{3}+\overline{\mathbf{3}})+(2n-6K-4k)\mathbf{1}. \tag*{(57)}

Thus, every higher color irrep is also excluded. We can restrict the branching to,

V=a(3,1)+b(3‾,1)+k(1,2)+s(1,1),V=a(\mathbf{3},\mathbf{1})+b(\overline{\mathbf{3}},\mathbf{1})+k(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})+s(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{1}),
a−b=d,a+b=K.(58)a-b=d,\qquad a+b=K. \tag*{(58)}

The integers pp, KK are odd, since pkd=3pkd=3 and K=d+2bK=d+2b. By Eq. (57) the only colored blocks in VV are the aa triplets and bb antitriplets of Eq. (58), all of them weak singlets, and since each contributes ℓi 2T3(Ri)=1\ell_i\,2T_3(R_i)=1 to the color index in Eq. (32), we have k3=a+b=Kk_3=a+b=K.

Hypercharge and the surviving families

We now assign hypercharges to the defining blocks already found. The strategy is to use sextets that appear in the product representations and require they do not appear in the chiral spectrum, and to use the color and weak singlets.

Cancel the color sextets. Two defining (anti)triplet blocks can produce a (anti)sextet in a two-index representation. In the fermion spectrum, all sextets must be paired with antisextets of opposite hypercharge. Consider the defining branching of the fundamental representation. Each of the triplets and antitriplets can carry different hypercharges. Cancellation of chiral sextets forces all triplets to carry the same hypercharge hh and antitriplets to carry −h-h.

Explicitly, let aYa_Y be the multiplicity for each triplet with hypercharge YY, so that ∑aY=a\sum a_Y=a. Similarly, define bYb_Y as the multiplicity of antitriplets with hypercharge −Y-Y. Choose hh to be the highest hypercharge for which aY≠bYa_Y\ne b_Y. Such an hh exists since a≠ba\ne b. If there is a triplet with hypercharge H>hH>h in the spectrum, by definition of hh, aH≠bHa_H\ne b_H. Products of these hypercharged triplets/antitriplets with the blocks at hh then leave unequal numbers of sextets at H+hH+h and antisextets at −(H+h)-(H+h), which cannot be the case as we do not allow chiral exotica. Therefore, hh is the highest hypercharge for triplets in the defining branching.

This implies that sextets at Y=2hY=2h and antisextets at Y=−2hY=-2h arise from the triplets at hh and antitriplets at −h-h. Counting their pairs in the two-index representations gives

0=y[(ah2)−(bh2)]+z[(ah+12)−(bh+12)]=p2(ah−bh)(ah+bh−K),(59)\begin{aligned} 0 &= y\left[\binom{a_h}{2}-\binom{b_h}{2}\right]+z\left[\binom{a_h+1}{2}-\binom{b_h+1}{2}\right]\\ &=\frac{p}{2}(a_h-b_h)(a_h+b_h-K), \tag*{(59)} \end{aligned}

where z−y=−pKz-y=-pK. This means ah+bh=K=a+ba_h+b_h=K=a+b, the total number of colored defining blocks. Every defining triplet therefore has hypercharge hh, and every defining antitriplet has charge −h-h.

The SM quark doublet comes from a triplet–doublet product with total hypercharge 1/61/6, so the defining doublet that pairs with a triplet of charge hh has charge c=16−hc=\frac{1}{6}-h. The only hypercharges for the defining weak doublets are ±c\pm c; any other hypercharge will leave behind chiral exotica. For c≠0c\ne0, their multiplicities are fixed by asking for 3 quark doublets and cancelling the unwanted h−ch-c representations.

W=kaK(1,2)c+kbK(1,2)−c,c=16−h.(60)W=\frac{ka}{K}(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_c+\frac{kb}{K}(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{2})_{-c},\qquad c=\frac{1}{6}-h. \tag*{(60)}

If c=0c=0, the two contributions combine into kk hypercharge neutral doublets.

Use nonnegative singlet multiplicities. The final constraint comes from the hypercharges of the color and weak singlets. Let Y1,…,YsY_1,\ldots,Y_s be the hypercharges of the defining color-and-weak singlets, and denote such a singlet by 1Y\mathbf{1}_Y. Matching the antiquark charges −2/3-2/3 and 1/31/3, and adding the charge-conjugate equation, gives

∑i=1s(1Yi+1−Yi)=2(n−4K)10+K(13h+1−3h)−k(1h−2/3+1−h+2/3+1h+1/3+1−h−1/3).(61)\sum_{i=1}^{s}\left(\mathbf{1}_{Y_i}+\mathbf{1}_{-Y_i}\right)=2(n-4K)\mathbf{1}_0+K\left(\mathbf{1}_{3h}+\mathbf{1}_{-3h}\right)-k\left(\mathbf{1}_{h-2/3}+\mathbf{1}_{-h+2/3}+\mathbf{1}_{h+1/3}+\mathbf{1}_{-h-1/3}\right). \tag*{(61)}

The left side counts actual singlets and their conjugates, so all multiplicities are nonnegative. Each negative coefficient on the right must be cancelled by a positive coefficient at the same hypercharge. The only possible positive contributions are at 0 or ±3h\pm3h. Consequently

h−23, h+13∈{0,±3h}⟹h=−13 or 16.(62)h-\frac{2}{3},\ h+\frac{1}{3}\in\{0,\pm3h\}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad h=-\frac{1}{3}\ \text{or}\ \frac{1}{6}. \tag*{(62)}

Summing squared charges in Eq. (61) fixes the singlet contribution to the hypercharge index. Including the colored blocks and weak doublets gives

∑i=1sYi2=9Kh2−k[(h−23)2+(h+13)2],\sum_{i=1}^{s}Y_i^2=9Kh^2-k\left[\left(h-\frac{2}{3}\right)^2+\left(h+\frac{1}{3}\right)^2\right],
kY=2(3Kh2+2kc2+∑i=1sYi2)=24Kh2−k.(63)k_Y=2\left(3Kh^2+2kc^2+\sum_{i=1}^{s}Y_i^2\right)=24Kh^2-k. \tag*{(63)}

Since k3=Kk_3=K and k2=kk_2=k, a commuting PQ symmetry with nonzero mixed anomaly therefore has

EN=k+kYK=24h2∈{83,23}.(64)\frac{E}{N}=\frac{k+k_Y}{K}=24h^2\in\left\{\frac{8}{3},\frac{2}{3}\right\}. \tag*{(64)}

Five families

The constraints above leave behind five families of GUTs, each of which can be consistently realized at the level of fermion content. In the branchings, 10=(1,1)0\mathbf{1}_0=(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{1})_0. The anomaly condition fixes the UV multiplicities in Table S3 from the values of pp and KK already determined above. The table lists the gauge group, defining branching V↓SMV\downarrow SM, and UV Weyl fermion spectrum F0\mathcal{F}_0 together for each family. It displays the cores without neutral singlets in VV; their common neutral-singlet extension is given below. The only free integer in the list is mm for families III–V, with K=k3=2m+1K=k_3=2m+1. Of course, the matter content is defined up to vectorlike and real representations.

Families I and II: h=−1/3h=-1/3, E/N=8/3E/N=8/3. The doublet charges in Eq. (60) are ±1/2\pm1/2. Their squares give net weak-triplet multiplicity 3(k−K)/(2K)3(k-K)/(2K) at charge +1+1. Its absence requires k=Kk=K. Equation Eq. (61) then leaves only n−5Kn - 5K neutral singlets. The conditions pkd=3pkd = 3 and d≤Kd \le K give (K,k,d)=(1,1,1)(K, k, d) = (1, 1, 1) or (3,3,1)(3, 3, 1). These are families I and II in Table S3.

Families III–V: h=1/6h = 1/6, E/N=2/3E/N = 2/3. Equation (S44) fixes the total number of singlets at charges ±1/2\pm1/2, and traceless hypercharge fixes their difference. Thus

∑i=1s1Yi=(a−k)1−1/2+(b−k)11/2+(n−4K)10.(65)\sum_{i=1}^{s}\mathbf{1}_{Y_i} = (a-k)\mathbf{1}_{-1/2} + (b-k)\mathbf{1}_{1/2} + (n-4K)\mathbf{1}_{0}. \tag*{(65)}

Nonnegative multiplicities require a,b≥ka,b \ge k and n≥4Kn \ge4K. Together with Eq. (55), these give (k,d)=(1,1),(1,3),(3,1)(k,d) = (1,1), (1,3), (3,1), respectively. Substituting their fixed multiplicities and setting K=2m+1K = 2m + 1 gives families III–V in Table S3, all with group SU(8m+4)SU(8m + 4). All displayed multiplicities are nonnegative. Families III–V start at SU(12)SU(12), SU(20)SU(20) and SU(28)SU(28), respectively.

Extensions. Every listed SU(n0)SU(n_0) can be trivially extended to SU(n0+r)SU(n_0 + r) for any integer r≥0r \ge0: add r10r\mathbf{1}_0 to the defining branching, interpret VV, A2A_2, S2S_2 in the spectrum as representations of the larger group, and add 3rV3rV in families I and III, or rVrV in families II, IV and V. This gives SU(5+r)SU(5+r), SU(15+r)SU(15+r) and SU(8m+4+r)SU(8m+4+r), respectively. The extension preserves UV anomaly cancellation and adds only vectorlike or neutral SM fermions, so the net SM chirality and E/NE/N are unchanged. The general allowed UV spectrum can also contain arbitrary conjugate pairs of the allowed UV representations and arbitrary singlets and adjoints to F0F_0.

Chirality, masses, and scope Write ΔR=R−R‾\Delta R = R - \overline{R} for net chirality. For the canonical families, ΔF0=3Δ(∧2F5+F‾5)=3ΔFSM\Delta F_0 = 3\Delta(\wedge^2 F_5 + \overline{F}_5) = 3\Delta F_{\mathrm{SM}}. For the noncanonical ones, expanding the two-index representations gives

ΔF0=pkd Δ[(3,2)1/6+(3‾,1)−2/3+(3‾,1)1/3+(1,2)−1/2+(1,1)1]=3ΔFSM.(66)\begin{aligned} \Delta F_0 = pkd\,\Delta\left[(3,2)_{1/6} + (\overline{3},1)_{-2/3} + (\overline{3},1)_{1/3} + (1,2)_{-1/2} + (1,1)_1\right] \\ &= 3\Delta F_{\mathrm{SM}}. \tag*{(66)} \end{aligned}

The bracket is precisely one SM generation.

Complex spectators occur in conjugate pairs. All self-conjugate spectators are real: half-integer weak-spin states have nonzero hypercharge or complex color. Adding rr neutral defining singlets to V0V_0 adds yr(V0+V‾0)yr(V_0 + \overline{V}_0) and neutral singlets to the positive fermion spectrum. Thus pseudoreal spectators occur in even multiplicities as well. All spectators admit SM-preserving mass bilinears. Arbitrary UV-vectorlike pairs and real UV representations within the cutoff can of course also be added, since they already admit UV-invariant masses.

References

  1. [1]H. Georgi and S. L. Glashow, Unity of All Elementary Particle Forces, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 438 (1974).DOI
  2. [2]J. C. Pati and A. Salam, Lepton Number as the Fourth Color, Phys. Rev. D 10, 275 (1974).
  3. [3]H. Georgi, H. R. Quinn and S. Weinberg, Hierarchy of Interactions in Unified Gauge Theories, Phys. Rev. Lett. 33, 451 (1974).
  4. [4]P. Langacker, Grand Unified Theories and Proton Decay, Phys. Rept. 72, 185 (1981).DOI
  5. [5]H. Georgi, The State of the Art—Gauge Theories, AIP Conf. Proc. 23, 575 (1975).DOI
  6. [6]H. Fritzsch and P. Minkowski, Unified Interactions of Leptons and Hadrons, Annals Phys. 93, 193 (1975).
  7. [7]F. Gürsey, P. Ramond and P. Sikivie, A Universal Gauge Theory Model Based on E₆, Phys. Lett. B 60, 177 (1976).DOI
  8. [8]H. Georgi, Towards a Grand Unified Theory of Flavor, Nucl. Phys. B 156, 126 (1979).DOI
  9. [9]R. Slansky, Group Theory for Unified Model Building, Phys. Rept. 79, 1 (1981).DOI
  10. [10]D. Tong, Line Operators in the Standard Model, JHEP 07, 104 (2017), arXiv:1705.01853.DOI
  11. [11]M. Srednicki, Axion Couplings to Matter. 1. CP Conserving Parts, Nucl. Phys. B 260, 689 (1985).
  12. [12]P. Agrawal, M. Nee and M. Reig, Axion Couplings in Grand Unified Theories, JHEP 10, 141 (2022), arXiv:2206.07053.DOI
  13. [13]G. Cacciapaglia, A. Deandrea, K. Kollias and F. Sannino, Grand-unification Theory Atlas: Standard Model and Beyond, arXiv:2507.06368.
  14. [14]M. M. Anber and S. Y. L. Chan, 2-index chiral gauge theories, arXiv:2308.08052.arxiv.org/abs/2308.08052
  15. [15]M. Gell-Mann, P. Ramond and R. Slansky, Color Embeddings, Charge Assignments, and Proton Stability in Unified Gauge Theories, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, 721 (1978).
  16. [16]R. M. Fonseca, On the chirality of the SM and the fermion content of GUTs, Nucl. Phys. B 897, 757 (2015), arXiv:1504.03695.DOI
  17. [17]C. Córdova, S. Hong and S. Koren, Noninvertible Peccei- Quinn symmetry and the massless quark solution to the strong CP problem, Phys. Rev. X 15, 031011 (2025), arXiv:2402.12453.
  18. [18]A. Delgado and S. Koren, Quark-lepton color-flavor unification, Phys. Rev. D 114, 075021 (2026), arXiv:2605.30413.arxiv.org/abs/2605.30413
  19. [19]T. Li, A. Mansha and R. Sun, Generalized Supersymmetric Pati-Salam Models from Intersecting D6-branes, arXiv:1912.11633.arxiv.org/abs/1912.11633
  20. [20]B. C. Allanach, B. Gripaios and J. Tooby-Smith, Semisimple extensions of the Standard Model gauge algebra, Phys. Rev. D 104, 035035 (2021) [Erratum: Phys. Rev. D 106, 019901 (2022)], arXiv:2104.14555.DOI
  21. [21]F. Wilczek and A. Zee, Families from Spinors, Phys. Rev. D 25, 553 (1982).DOI
  22. [22]J. Bagger and S. Dimopoulos, O(18) Revived: Splitting the Spinor, Nucl. Phys. B 244, 247 (1984).DOI
  23. [23]G. F. Giudice and S. Raby, A New paradigm for the revival of technicolor theories, Nucl. Phys. B 368, 221 (1992).DOI
  24. [24]M. Reig, J. W. F. Valle, C. A. Vaquera-Araujo and F. Wilczek, A Model of Comprehensive Unification, Phys. Lett. B 774, 667 (2017), arXiv:1706.03116.DOI
  25. [25]S. Koren and A. Martin, Technically charged particles at the energy frontier: The SM gauge group and one-form global symmetry, SciPost Phys. 18, 004 (2025), arXiv:2406.17850.DOI
  26. [26]A. Takenaka et al. [Super-Kamiokande Collaboration], Search for proton decay via p → e+π0 and p → μ+π0 with an enlarged fiducial volume in the Super-Kamiokande I-IV, Phys. Rev. D 102, 112011 (2020), arXiv:2010.16098.DOI
  27. [27]G. Grilli di Cortona, E. Hardy, J. Pardo Vega and G. Villadoro, The QCD axion, precisely, JHEP 01, 034 (2016), arXiv:1511.02867.DOI
  28. [28]E. B. Dynkin, Semisimple subalgebras of semisimple Lie algebras, Mat. Sbornik 30, 349 (1952) [Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. Ser. 2 6, 111 (1957)].
  29. [29]P. H. Ginsparg, Gauge and Gravitational Couplings in Four-Dimensional String Theories, Phys. Lett. B 197, 139 (1987).DOI
  30. [30]L. Di Luzio, F. Mescia and E. Nardi, Redefining the Axion Window, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 031801 (2017), arXiv:1610.07593.DOI
  31. [31]C. O’Hare, cajohare/AxionLimits: AxionLimits, https://cajohare.github.io/AxionLimits/ (2020), doi:10.5281/zenodo.3932430.DOI
  32. [32]S. H. Lim, E. Putney, M. R. Buckley and D. Shih, Mapping Dark Matter in the Milky Way using Normalizing Flows and Gaia DR3, arXiv:2305.13358.DOI
  33. [33]E. Putney, D. Shih, S. H. Lim and M. R. Buckley, Clear-Potential: Revealing Local Dark Matter in Three Dimensions, arXiv:2512.09898.
  34. [34]G. D. Dvali, Black Holes and Large N Species Solution to the Hierarchy Problem, Fortsch. Phys. 58, 528 (2010), arXiv:0706.2050.DOI
  35. [35]S. Navas et al. [Particle Data Group], Review of Particle Physics, Phys. Rev. D 110, 030001 (2024).
  36. [36]D. I. Dunsky, A. Ghoshal, H. Murayama, Y. Sakaki-hara and G. White, GUTs, hybrid topological defects, and gravitational waves, Phys. Rev. D 106, 075030 (2022), arXiv:2111.08750.
  37. [37]W. Buchmuller, V. Domcke and K. Schmitz, Metastable cosmic strings, JCAP 11, 020 (2023), arXiv:2307.04691.arxiv.org/abs/2307.04691
  38. [38]D. Gaiotto, A. Kapustin, N. Seiberg and B. Willett, Generalized Global Symmetries, JHEP 02, 172 (2015), arXiv:1412.5148.DOI
  39. [39]O. Aharony, N. Seiberg and Y. Tachikawa, Reading between the lines of four-dimensional gauge theories, JHEP 08, 115 (2013), arXiv:1305.0318.DOI
  40. [40]J. Polchinski, Monopoles, duality, and string theory, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 19S1, 145 (2004), arXiv:hep-th/0304042.DOI
  41. [41]S. M. Barr, A New Symmetry Breaking Pattern for SO(10) and Proton Decay, Phys. Lett. B 112, 219 (1982).DOI
  42. [42]J. P. Derendinger, J. E. Kim and D. V. Nanopoulos, Anti-SU(5), Phys. Lett. B 139, 170 (1984).DOI
  43. [43]I. Antoniadis, J. R. Ellis, J. S. Hagelin and D. V. Nanopoulos, Supersymmetric Flipped SU(5) Re-vitalized, Phys. Lett. B 194, 231 (1987).
  44. [44]I. Dorsner and P. Fileviez Perez, Distinguishing between SU(5) and flipped SU(5), Phys. Lett. B 605, 391 (2005), arXiv:hep-ph/0409095.DOI
  45. [45]J. Ellis, M. A. G. Garcia, N. Nagata, D. V. Nanopoulos and K. A. Olive, Proton Decay: Flipped vs Unflipped SU(5), JHEP 05, 021 (2020), arXiv:2003.03285.DOI
  46. [46]B. Holdom and M. E. Peskin, Raising the Axion Mass, Nucl. Phys. B 208, 397 (1982).DOI
  47. [47]P. Agrawal and K. Howe, Factoring the Strong CP Problem, JHEP 12, 029 (2018), arXiv:1710.04213.DOI
  48. [48]M. Kamionkowski and J. March-Russell, Planck scale physics and the Peccei-Quinn mechanism, Phys. Lett. B 282, 137 (1992), arXiv:hep-th/9202003.DOI
  49. [49]R. Holman, S. D. H. Hsu, T. W. Kephart, E. W. Kolb, R. Watkins and L. M. Widrow, Solutions to the strong CP problem in a world with gravity, Phys. Lett. B 282, 132 (1992), arXiv:hep-ph/9203206.DOI
  50. [50]S. M. Barr and D. Seckel, Planck scale corrections to axion models, Phys. Rev. D 46, 539 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10014967
  51. [51]I. Affleck, On Constrained Instantons, Nucl. Phys. B 191, 429 (1981).
  52. [52]J. Fuentes-Martín, M. Reig and A. Vicente, Strong CP problem with low-energy emergent QCD: The 4321 case, Phys. Rev. D 100, 115028 (2019), arXiv:1907.02550.
  53. [53]C. Csáki, M. Ruhdorfer and Y. Shirman, UV Sensitivity of the Axion Mass from Instantons in Partially Broken Gauge Groups, JHEP 04, 031 (2020), arXiv:1912.02197.arxiv.org/abs/1912.02197
  54. [54]A. M. Perelomov, A simple construction of basic polynomials invariant under the Weyl group of the simple finite-dimensional Lie algebra, Commun. Math. 28, 301 (2020), doi:10.2478/cm-2020-0024.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_w9tfcgtp
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents