betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Performance enhancement of electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution through coalescence-induced bubble dynamics

Abstract

The evolution of electrogenerated gas bubbles during water electrolysis can significantly hamper the overall process efficiency. Promoting the departure of electrochemically generated bubbles during (water) electrolysis is therefore beneficial. For a single bubble, a departure from the electrode surface occurs when buoyancy wins over the downward-acting forces (e.g. contact, Marangoni, and electric forces). In this work, the dynamics of a pair of H2_2 bubbles produced during hydrogen evolution reaction in 0.5 M H2_2SO4_4 using dual platinum micro-electrode system is systematically studied by varying the electrode distance and the cathodic potential. By combining high-speed imaging and electrochemical analysis, we demonstrate the importance of bubble-bubble interactions for the departure process. We show that bubble coalescence may lead to substantially earlier bubble departure as compared to buoyancy effects alone, resulting in considerably higher reaction rates at constant potential. However, due to continued mass input and conservation of momentum repeated coalescence events with bubbles close to the electrode may drive departed bubbles back to the surface beyond a critical current, which increases with the electrode spacing. The latter leads to the resumption of bubble growth near the electrode surface, followed by buoyancy-driven departure. While less favourable at small electrode spacing, this configuration proves to be very beneficial at larger separations increasing the mean current up to 2.4 times compared to a single electrode under the conditions explored in this study.

Introduction

Water electrolysis is likely to become a central technology in the CO2\mathrm{CO}_{2}-neutral energy system of the future. Apart from being a potential energy carrier and fuel, hydrogen gas serves as a feedstock for the chemical (e.g. ammonia production for fertilisers) and steel industries (coal replacement), and refineries (methanol, synthetic fuels). [1, 2, 3] Yet, the process efficiency requires further improvement to compete on the energy market and enable large-scale hydrogen production. In both conventional alkaline and proton exchange membrane water electrolyzers a considerable part of the overpotentials and hence losses can be attributed to the formation of H2\mathrm{H}_{2} and O2\mathrm{O}_{2} bubbles, present at the electrodes and in the bulk. 4–7 These bubbles block the electrodes by masking their active surface area, reducing the number of nucleation sites. Additionally, they raise ohmic resistance by blocking the ion-conducting pathways. 8–10 It is therefore vital to maintain a bubble-free electrode area for continuous catalytic activity. Enhanced removal of gas bubbles and deeper insights into their evolution processes will benefit further optimization of the system’s energy efficiency. 11

Various methods have been developed to aid bubble departure, categorized as active (e.g., sonication, centrifugal forces, mechanical convection, pressure modulation, external magnetic fields) and passive approaches. 5,7,12,13 Passive methods, preferred for their energy-efficiency, primarily involve surface modifications to alter the wettability14 of the catalytic surface.15 For example, superhydrophilic surfaces facilitate earlier bubble departure due to the reduced contact angle at liquid-solid interfaces.16–22

The bubble removal process can also benefit from hydrophobic surfaces. One example is the bubble-free electrolysis concept that employs a hydrophobic porous layer adjacent to a porous electrode. This prevents bubble formation within the catalyst, guiding the generated gas by capillary effects through the hydrophobic layer.23–26 A different concept to enhance gas removal, which was shown to hold promise based on theoretical analysis,27 is the use of hydrophobic islands on the electrode as preferential nucleation sites. Also practically, this has been shown to be feasible using electrodes partially covered with hydrophobic spots made of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE).28–30 This allows to guide the produced gas away from the active areas of the electrode with the potential to lower the bubble-induced overpotentials.28,29 Brussieux et al.30 demonstrated that, depending on the size of and distance between islets, parameters of the gas release such as bubble size and location can be controlled, but did not study the effect on electrode performance. More recently, Lake et al.31 found that densely packed Pt-coated micropost arrays promote consistent release of smaller bubbles through their mutual coalescence. While this enhanced the stability of the current compared to untextured electrodes, it did not lead to performance gains when normalising by the active surface area in this system, due to additional bubbles forming in between the pillars. In this context, coalescence induced removal of bubbles is of particular interest. Coalescence leads to a reduction in surface energy and this difference is in part converted to kinetic energy, causing the bubble to jump off the surface without having to rely on buoyancy. This makes this removal process also highly attractive in microgravity applications.32–38

However, a detailed understanding of the mechanism and quantification of the extent to which coalescence-induced dynamics can be exploited to improve the performance of gas-evolving electrodes is still lacking. This also applies to parameter optimisation, which in view of complications such as a possible bubble return to the electrode surface, 38–44 is highly nontrivial. We address these open questions in the present work by studying the coalescence-driven dynamics of hydrogen bubbles produced at a dual micro-electrode during water electrolysis. This new setup allows precise control of important parameters such as the bubble size during coalescence, while also providing excellent observability of the dynamics. We demonstrate that coalescence events may lead to both premature bubble departure compared to buoyancy effects alone and the return of departed bubbles to the surface of the electrode, substantially altering the reaction rates. The dual micro-electrode configuration shows, depending on the applied potential and inter-electrode distance, up to a 2.4-fold increase in current compared to a single micro-electrode.

Methods

The pairs of H2\mathrm{H}_2 bubbles sketched in Figure 1a were generated at the surface of a dual platinum micro-electrode during the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). The experiment was performed in a three-electrode electrochemical cell filled with 0.5 M H2SO4\mathrm{H}_2\mathrm{SO}_4.

Schematic of the dual micro-electrode and two H$_2$ bubbles, and top view of five dual micro-electrodes

Figure 1. (a) Schematic of the dual micro-electrode and two H2_2 bubbles sitting on the carpet of micro-bubbles. Each growing bubble is subject to a force balance including buoyancy, electric, and Marangoni forces. The red lines represent current density (jj) and the black streamlines on the right represent the Marangoni convection with velocity uMu_M. EkE_k is the kinetic energy released during the coalescence of the left (RlR_l) and right (RrR_r) bubbles. (b) Top view of the five dual micro-electrodes with different interelectrode distance (HH).

The fabrication of dual micro-electrodes followed a previously established method. 45 Briefly, two Pt wires (∅\varnothing100 μm\mu\mathrm{m}, 99.99%, Goodfellow) were sealed into a soda-lime glass capillary (outer diameter ∅\varnothing1.4mm\mathrm{mm}, inner diameter ∅\varnothing1.12mm\mathrm{mm}, Hilgenberg) by gently softening the capillary in a flame. Five different values for the interelectrode distance HH were established and tested, as shown in Figure 1b. The electrode surface underwent electrochemical cleaning (potential cycling between 0.03...1.35 V vs. RHE, repeated 50 times) after being mechanically polished with sandpaper (2000 grit), sonicated and rinsed with ultrapure water. The cell used here closely resembles that used in earlier studies. 44–46 The dual micro-electrode (cathode) is inserted horizontally facing upward in the base of a cuboid. glass cuvette (Hellma) with dimensions of 10 ×\times 10 ×\times 40 mm3\,\mathrm{mm}^{3}. The system is completed by the reference electrode (Ag/AgCl) and counter electrode (∅\varnothing 0.5 mm Pt wire) both inserted vertically from the top. The electrochemical cell is controlled by a potentiostat (BioLogic, VSP-300, 6 channels) at a constant potential of -0.2 to -2.8 V (vs. RHE). Each of the two electrodes is connected to and controlled by a separate channel of the potentiostat. For each experimental run, the electric current was recorded with a sampling rate of at least 1 kHz over a period of 30 s. The optically transparent cell allows visualization of the bubble dynamics using a shadowgraphy system.

It consists of LED illumination (SCHOTT, KL 2500) with a microscope, connected to a high-speed camera (Photron, FASTCAM NOVA S16), providing a spatial resolution of 996 pix/mm. Image recording was typically performed at 5 kHz, unless otherwise stated. High-speed recording up to 264 kHz was used to resolve individual coalescence events. The bubble radius was extracted by standard image processing routine based on the Canny edge detection method in Matlab R2022b (for further details see Supplemental Material in Bashkatov et al. 47). To measure the velocity fields around H2_2 bubbles presented in Figure 6, monodisperse polystyrene particles (microParticles GmbH) of ∅\varnothing5 μ\mum were seeded into the electrolyte. These particles are neutrally buoyant with a mass density of 1.05 g/cm3^{3}. The resulting series of images, recorded at 1000 frames per second, were processed by the software DaViS 10, which employs a Particle Tracking Velocimetry (PTV) algorithm to track each particle over 25 ms shortly before departure. Due to the limited number of particles close to or at the bubble-electrolyte interface, the resulting tracks of the particles were collected for 60 bubbles. Subsequently, the tracks were converted into a vector field using a binning function that interpolates local tracks on a specified fine grid.

Departure radius and electric current for Modes I and II, and velocity fields representing Marangoni convection

Figure 6. Departure radius (a) R^I\hat{R}_{I}, (c) R^II\hat{R}_{II} and electric current (b) IˉI\bar{I}_{I}, (d) IˉII\bar{I}_{II} for Modes I and II, respectively. R^I\hat{R}_{I} is given as a function of HH. R^II\hat{R}_{II}, IˉI\bar{I}_{I} and IˉII\bar{I}_{II} are shown as functions of potential and for various HH. Grey curves are for single electrode. (e) and (f) Velocity fields, ∣uM∣|u_{M}|, representing Marangoni convection during mode II at −2.8-2.8 V and H=117 μmH=117\ \mu\mathrm{m} and H=270 μmH=270\ \mu\mathrm{m}, respectively. The velocity is measured in a period of 25 ms before the bubble departure.

Single electrode

To set the baseline, we briefly report the results for the case where only a single electrode is operated, which has been studied previously. 38,44,46–55 As an example, Figure 2a shows the transient current (IsI_s) and radius (RsR_s) of the bubble for three complete bubble evolution cycles at -1.0 V. Shadowgraphs corresponding to a complete cycle from nucleation56–58 to departure are included in Figure 2b. This process is highly periodic with a bubble lifetime TsT_s. The evolution of the bubble has a strong influence on the reaction current, for which the maxima in cathodic current marked by the red circles coincide with the departure of the bubble. This is immediately followed by the nucleation of a new bubble, whose growth in the vicinity of the electrode leads to a considerable reduction in IsI_s of up to 50% in this case. This continues until the next bubble departure, after which the cycle repeats itself.

Electric current and bubble radius over time, shadowgraphs of bubble evolution, and averaged current, departure radius, and lifetime versus potential

Figure 2. (a) The electric current and radius over time representing three complete cycles of bubble evolution at ϕ=−1.0\phi= -1.0 V at a single micro-electrode. The red circles mark nucleation and departure instants of time. (b) Shadowgraphs displaying the evolution cycle, marked in grey in (a). (c) The averaged electric current (circles), departure radius (triangles) and lifetime (squares) versus the potential for the right (black) and left (orange) electrodes, run separately. Image recording performed at 500 frames/second.

Finally, Figure 2c summarizes how the average electric current Iˉs\bar{I}_s, where the overline denotes an average over tt, the departure radius (R^s\hat{R}_s), and lifetime (T^s\hat{T}_s) varies for different cathodic potentials (ϕ\phi). All statistics are averaged over multiple bubble cycles with error bars representing the standard deviation. The figure also confirms that consistent results are obtained from both electrodes.

In this system, bubble formation occurs already at low overpotentials. Micron-sized bubbles form on the electrode surface and continuously coalesce to form a single larger bubble. This larger bubble is typically not in direct contact with the electrode surface, but rather resides on the layer of microbubbles. 44 It continues to grow via the intensive coalescence with these microbubbles and via gas diffusion.59 In this case, departure of the bubble occurs once the retaining forces due to the electric field,44 thermal60–63 and solutal45 Marangoni effects are overcome by buoyancy (see Figure 1a). The thermal Marangoni effect is related to the Joule heating caused by the locally high current density (jj) at the bubble foot as indicated in Figure 1a. The effect therefore scales (via Ohm’s law) with j2j^{2} and prevails at high overpotentials. The solutal effect due to the depletion of the electrolyte at the electrode is expected to depend linearly on jj and therefore dominates at lower overpotentials (ϕ≳−0.7\phi\gtrsim-0.7 V in the present case).45 The electric force is directly proportional to ϕ\phi and therefore all retaining forces diminish as the overpotential is reduced, which explains the decreasing trend of the departure radius R^s\hat{R}_{s} as ∣ϕ∣|\phi| is made less negative. Since the bubble captures almost all the produced gas,45,46 the departure period follows from the time it takes to produce the gas contained in the bubble volume and TsT_s is therefore proportional to Rs3/IR_s^{3}/I.

Dual electrode

Modes of bubbles evolution

From now on, both electrodes are operated simultaneously, independently of each other, and at the same potential. Initially, we will only consider the pair with a separation of H=117 μmH = 117\,\mu\mathrm{m}. The measured currents for this configuration are plotted in Figure 3a for different potentials. Time traces of the current for both electrodes (’left’ and ’right’) are included and for reference we also show the current signal measured when only a single electrode is operated at the same potential (grey line). Focusing initially on the lowest overpotential, ϕ=−0.3\phi= -0.3 V, the current oscillations remain periodic during dual operation; however, both the period and amplitude are notably diminished. The reason for this can be understood from the corresponding shadowgraphs presented in Figure 3b, which illustrate the bubble dynamics over one period (shown by black box in Figure 3a).

Electric current measurements and bubble evolution

Figure 3. (a) Electric current over 2 seconds (out of 30 seconds) of the experimental run at various potentials (ϕ\phi). The black and orange curves represent the electric current measured at the right and left electrodes, respectively. Grey lines represent corresponding results for single electrode operation. (b) Snapshots depict the bubble evolution following mode I as indicated in (a) by the black rectangular inset at -0.3 V. (c) Snapshots detailing the coalescence-driven departure process recorded at -0.5 V. t0t_0 is one frame before the coalescence process begins. (d) A zoomed-in view of the current at -0.7 V, shown by the green rectangle in (a), with corresponding evolution of R(t)R(t). The orange and blue shades correspond to modes I and II, respectively. (e) Mode II of bubble evolution from (d). The red line indicates the maximum height reached by the departed bubble. Recordings in (b) and (e) were performed at 5 kHz, and at 264 kHz in (c).

Similar to what is observed for a single electrode, a larger bubble forms and grows initially at each of the two electrodes, leading to a gradual reduction in the current. This process continues until the two bubbles touch and coalesce, which is followed by the departure of the merged bubble along with a spike in the current (see inset at -0.3 V in Figure 3a). Figure 3c details this coalescence process, which happens on the order of micro-seconds, and the emerging deformations of the bubble shape. The coalescence induced jump-off is powered by the released surface energy. 38,64,65 While the majority of this energy is dissipated through the capillary waves seen in Figure 3c, 37,66 the fraction that is transformed into kinetic energy (less than 1%, for details see Supporting Information) can cause bubble departure at much smaller radii than in the buoyancy-driven scenario, for the newly formed bubble. Together with the fact that each of the coalescing bubbles only contributes half the volume, this explains the significantly enhanced departure frequency.

At higher overpotential at ϕ=−0.5\phi= -0.5 V, events with a much longer period length start appearing intermittently in the current traces. These events become more frequent and dominate the signal at ϕ=−0.7\phi= -0.7 V, before almost fully superseding the high-frequency coalescence pattern at ϕ≤−1.0\phi\le-1.0 V. In order to elucidate the underlying bubble dynamics, we provide an enlarged view of a segment of the current signal at ϕ=−0.7\phi= -0.7 V (green box) in

Figure 3d along with the size evolution of the bubbles. The first bubble departure included in Figure 3d proceeds analogously to the one shown in Figure 3b, and the bubble continues to rise away from the electrode after the coalescence induced take-off. We will refer to this as ’mode I’ from now on. However, as the corresponding shadowgraphs in Figure 3e show, even though the bubble also jumps off after the second coalescence event, it is eventually brought back to the surface through repeated coalescence with newly formed bubbles at both electrodes (see period between t=0.8854 st = 0.8854\ \mathrm{s} and t=0.8862 st = 0.8862\ \mathrm{s}). Following this return, the bubble rests between the two electrodes just above the surface. There, it continues to grow until a buoyancy driven departure (at RII=158 μmR_{II} = 158\ \mathrm{\mu m} vs. RI=72 μmR_{I} = 72\ \mathrm{\mu m}), which explains an order of magnitude longer lifetime (TII=104.4 msT_{II} = 104.4\ \mathrm{ms} vs. TI=8.4 msT_{I} = 8.4\ \mathrm{ms}) of the bubble in this instance. We will denote this as ’comeback mode’ or ’mode II’.

It is evident from Figure 3a that the dynamics induced by coalescence have a strong impact not only on the current fluctuations, but also on the mean current at a specific potential. To analyse this, we compare period averaged currents for the two modes (IˉI\bar{I}_{I} and IˉII\bar{I}_{II}, taken to be the sum of the currents at both electrodes) to 2×Iˉs2 \times\bar{I}_{s} in Figure 4. Note that

Electric current versus potential for single electrode and modes I and II at dual micro-electrode

Figure 4. Electric current (Iˉ\bar{I}) vs. potential (ϕ\phi) for single electrode (black) and for modes I (blue) and II (red) at dual micro-electrode. Both IˉI\bar{I}_{I} and IˉII\bar{I}_{II} are the sum of the currents at the left and right electrodes.

it is possible to determine III_{\mathrm{I}} even at high potentials where mode II prevails by considering only the time until the first coalescence, leading to temporary departure of the bubble (see Figure 3d). Despite the much faster gas removal, the current at low overpotentials (ϕ≳−0.7\phi\gtrsim-0.7 V) remains the same or even slightly decreases in dual operation compared to the single electrode case. This can be attributed to the additional shielding by the second bubble in the vicinity of the electrode and the diffusive competition between the two reaction sites, both of which lower performance. However, the benefits of the accelerated gas removal increasingly outweigh these effects as the overpotential is increased. This is particularly true for mode I, where the current is more than double than that of the single electrode at the same potential for the most negative values of ϕ\phi investigated. While this clearly demonstrates the potential for performance enhancement through coalescence-induced gas removal, the effective performance enhancement is reduced to less than 50% for the current electrode spacing due to the prevalence of bubble return (mode II) at higher overpotentials. The currents in mode II are consistently lower compared to mode I because the electrode separation is so small, that the returning bubble still blocks a large part of both electrodes (see Figure 3e), even though it is located half-way between them.

Phase diagram

To better understand under what conditions under which the return of the bubble after jump-off happens, Figure 5 documents the probability (PP) of return for different interelectrode distances (HH) and as a function of ϕ\phi (Figure 5a) and I‾I\overline{I}_{\mathrm{I}} (Figure 5b). As HH is increased, the transition from mode I (P<5%P < 5\%, circles), to a mixed regime (5%≤P≤95%5\% \le P \le95\%, triangles) and finally to mode II (P>95%P > 95\%, squares) occurs at increasingly larger values of ∣ϕ∣|\phi|. In fact, the dependence on HH is quite strong: for a fixed potential of ϕ=−1.3\phi= -1.3 V, PP changes from about 100% at H=117 μmH = 117\,\mu\mathrm{m} to almost 0 when the distance is increased to H=270 μmH = 270\,\mu\mathrm{m}. The sketch in Figure 5c illustrates the relevant mechanism for the bubble return. A newly formed bubble (with radius R0R_0) on one of the electrodes catches up and coalesces with the departed bubble with radius R^I\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}. Due to momentum conservation, the resulting bubble is then located at the joint center of mass of the two coalescing bubbles, which implies a downward shift by Δz\Delta z compared to the location of the bubble with radius R^I\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}. Repeated coalescence events from both sides then bring the bubble back to the surface as seen in Figure 3e. The transition

Phase diagram showing comeback probability, relevant bubble-return geometry, and vertical jump velocity

Figure 5. Phase diagram representing the probability (PP) of the bubble coming back after initial departure shown in terms of (a) Potential and (b) Current vs. HH. The color bar scales the probability from 0 to 100%. The circles denote Scenario I, i.e. when PP is less than 5%, and squares denote Scenario II, with PP more than 95%. The triangles are for a mixed regime, where the probability varies widely from 5 to 95%. The red lines plot 2×Ic∗2 \times I_c^* using eq. 1. (c) The sketch illustrating the relevant geometry for the bubble return. (d) Vertical jump velocity uˉI.0.5 ms\bar{u}_{\mathrm{I}.0.5\ \mathrm{ms}} averaged over the first 0.5 ms of the jump vs. HH for numerous bubbles. The line represents the averaged values at each HH, completed with standard deviation.

between mode I and mode II is therefore governed by a competition between the departure or ‘jump’ velocity of a bubble after coalescence and the growth rate of bubbles at the electrode. A larger magnitude of electric current, increasing approximately linearly with ϕ\phi (see Figure 6), enables faster formation of new bubbles which then increases the likelihood of their interaction with the previously departed bubble. Upon increasing HH the bubble-successor needs to grow to a larger size, hence for a longer time before interacting with the already departed bubble, allowing the latter to move farther away. This will dramatically increase the current required for comeback mode. We can capture this in a simple model based on the geometry sketched in Figure 5c to predict the minimum current IcI_c for bubble return. Our analysis considers the situation where the new bubble with radius R0R_0 has grown large enough to get in contact with the departing bubble. The time it takes for the bubble to grow to the radius R0R_0 is Δt=kR03/Ic\Delta t = kR_0^3/I_c, where k=8πFPg3RgTk = \frac{8\pi FP_g}{3R_gT} is a prefactor containing the Faraday constant FF, the pressure inside the bubble PgP_g, the gas constant RgR_g and the temperature TT (see Supporting Information for details). During this time interval, the departing bubble travels the distance Δt⋅uI\Delta t \cdot u_I, with uIu_I denoting the effective jump velocity. Based on the geometry of the triangle spanned by the centers of the two bubbles and the point A in Figure 5c, the critical current for the mode transition as a function of R0R_0 is given by

Ic(R0;uI,H)=uIR03k[(R^I+R0)2−(H2)2]1/2−R^I+R0.(1)I_c(R_0;u_I,H)=\frac{u_I R_0^3 k}{\left[(\hat{R}_I+R_0)^2-\left(\frac{H}{2}\right)^2\right]^{1/2}-\hat{R}_I+R_0}. \tag*{(1)}

For any HH, a value of R0R_0 can be determined for which IcI_c reaches a minimum value, Ic∗I_c^*. To obtain the value of the current Ic∗I_c^* in this critical configuration, an estimate of the jump velocity is required. To obtain this, we tracked bubbles departing after coalescence and then averaged their vertical velocity over the first 0.5 ms to obtain u‾I,0.5 ms\overline{u}_{I,0.5\,\mathrm{ms}}. Note that uIu_I varies widely depending on the position of both bubbles before coalescence (see Supporting Information for details). The results for this quantity are shown in Figure 5d as a function of HH. From these data, typical values for uIu_I are found to be in the range from 60 mm/s to 110 mm/s with a slight tendency towards higher velocities as the bubble size increases at larger electrode separations HH. In Figure 5b, we have included results for 2×Ic∗2 \times I_c^* as a function of HH and for different values of uIu_I. It can be seen that the model very well captures the increase of the critical current as the electrode separation increases. The best agreement between the model and the data is for uI=60u_I = 60 mm/s, which is close to, although slightly lower, than the measured jump velocities in Figure 5d. Among potentially other factors, a reason for this slight difference is the fact that the new bubble with radius R0R_0 is also formed by coalescence and therefore also jumps off the electrode. Additionally, we do not account for shape oscillations of the larger bubbles, which become more prevalent at larger HH.

Performance vs. Inter-electrode distance, HH

To understand how the current varies at different electrode separations, it is useful to first consider how the departure size of the bubbles changes for different HH. In mode I, the departure is coalescence-driven so that R^I\hat{R}_I is independent of ϕ\phi and varies only with the interelectrode distance HH. Due to lateral oscillations of the bubble position on the electrode and possibly a slight inclination of the electrode surfaces, the results for R^I\hat{R}_I shown in Figure 6a are about 10% lower than 2−2/3H2^{-2/3}H, i.e. the value for the coalescence of two bubbles each with a radius of H/2H/2. This small difference was taken into account when evaluating R^I\hat{R}_I in equation 1.

Compared to the single electrode, the current in mode I shown in Figure 6b is most enhanced at high overpotential and small HH, because in this case the reduction in bubble departure size is maximal. There is only moderate decrease of IˉI\bar{I}_I for larger HH primarily due to the relatively small range in HH and, consequently, in R^I\hat{R}_I, which is minor compared to variations observed in R^s\hat{R}_s at different potentials. At low overpotentials, R^I≈R^s\hat{R}_I \approx\hat{R}_s for the larger electrode separations studied and there is no increase of the current compared to IsI_s, just as was observed at H=117 μmH = 117\,\mu\mathrm{m} in Figure 4.

In mode II, the departure radius strongly depends on the potential but at most weakly on HH, as shown in Figure 6c. Remarkably, R^II\hat{R}_{II} is approximately the same as for the single electrode case at the same potential (see grey symbols representing R^s\hat{R}_{s}). An investigation of the force balance 67–69 leading to these trends in R^II\hat{R}_{II} are beyond the scope of this study. Nevertheless, we present clear evidence of Marangoni convection (see Figure 6(e,Figure 6f)), consistent with the presence of thermocapillary effects in the same potential range on single electrodes.51,63 Based on the flow direction, a resulting downward Marangoni force on the bubble is expected (see Figure 1a). The convective motion is much more pronounced at H=270 μmH=270\ \mu\mathrm{m} (Figure 6f) compared to the narrower spacing of H=117 μmH=117\ \mu\mathrm{m} in Figure 6e, which is in line with the difference in current between the two cases (IˉII=5.33\bar{I}_{II}=5.33 mA vs. 8.46 mA, respectively). Interestingly, this does not result in a noticeable difference in R^II\hat{R}_{II} for the different interelectrode distances, which is presumably due to differences in the geometry dependent electric force.69 We confirmed that the continued coalescence with small bubble

does not exert a significant apparent force on the bubble (see Supporting Information for details).

In contrast to mode I, the current in mode II shown in Figure 6d shows a clear dependence on the electrode separation and increases strongly for larger HH. This is because the bubble is now centered in between the two electrodes. Therefore the electrodes become more exposed as the distance between them increases, even if the bubble size remains the same. The continuous removal of the smaller bubbles on the electrode by coalescence with the larger one proves to be very beneficial and leads to maximum currents of more than twice Iˉs\bar{I}_s, equalling the largest currents observed in mode I.

To quantify the performance gain and to compensate for the ϕ\phi dependence of the current, we normalise the current on the dual electrode by Iˉs\bar{I}_s. This also accounts for small differences in Iˉs\bar{I}_s between the different electrodes used in this study (see Supporting Information). In Figure 7a, the ratio IˉI/Iˉs\bar{I}_I/\bar{I}_s is plotted for different HH as a function of ϕ\phi. As the figure shows, the interference effects at low overpotentials already discussed in the context of Figure 3, cause IˉI\bar{I}_I to even fall below Iˉs\bar{I}_s for ϕ≳−0.5\phi\gtrsim-0.5 V. This does not improve noticeably for larger electrode spacing, presumably due to a trade-off between reduced interference effects and the increase in the bubble size with HH. For larger overpotentials, the benefits of the enhanced gas removal prevail, reflected in a ratio IˉI/Iˉs>1\bar{I}_I/\bar{I}_s > 1 which also consistently increases with increased overpotential exceeding a value of 2 at ϕ=−2.8\phi= -2.8 V. Approximately the same values are also encountered for this potential for the ratio IˉII/Iˉs\bar{I}_{II}/\bar{I}_s in Figure 7b. While the performance in mode II also improves slightly for higher overpotential, it most strongly depends on HH. As the inset in Figure 7b shows, the ratio IˉII/Iˉs\bar{I}_{II}/\bar{I}_s increases approximately linearly with HH at constant potential.

Electric current measurements and snapshots throughout bubble evolution

Figure 7. The electric current (a) IˉI\bar{I}_I, (b) IˉII\bar{I}_{II} and (c) Iˉd\bar{I}_d, all in dimensionless form with reference to Iˉs\bar{I}_s. Data are presented as a function of potential (ϕ\phi) and interelectrode distance (HH). The inset in (b) shows IˉII/Iˉs\bar{I}_{II}/\bar{I}_s vs. HH at -1.8, -2.3 and -2.8 V. The inset in (c) documents IˉI/IˉII\bar{I}_I/\bar{I}_{II} vs. ϕ\phi. Iˉd\bar{I}_d is the current averaged over both mode I (III_I) and mode II (IIII_{II}). (d) Snapshots throughout the bubble evolution at -2.8 V and H=270 μmH = 270\,\mu\mathrm{m}. t0=0t_0 = 0 marks an instant of time one image before the coalescence of two bubbles (with radii RlR_l and RrR_r, respectively) followed by the jump of the merged bubble off the electrode and its consecutive return. The inset shows the electric current throughout the entire evolution, with the red circles marking the corresponding snapshots.

Finally, Figure 7c shows how the resulting effective current on the dual electrode Iˉd\bar{I}_d changes relative to Iˉs\bar{I}_s. In addition to variations in III_I and IIII_{II}, this quantity is also influenced by the probability P(H,ϕ)P(H,\phi) of bubble return (mode II). Given the results in Figure 5a, the ratio Iˉd/Iˉs\bar{I}_d/\bar{I}_s is therefore dominated by mode I at low and by mode II at large overpotentials. This implies that the performance gains in mode I at high ∣ϕ∣|\phi| are not practically realisable. However, this is only a limitation at smaller electrode separations, since the current in mode II even exceeds that of mode I for H=242H = 242 µm and H=270H = 270 µm (see inset of Figure 7c). For these cases, the mode transition is therefore even beneficial.

Figure 7d shows snapshots for the parameter combination H=270H = 270 µm and ϕ=−2.8\phi= -2.8 V for which the highest ratio Iˉd/Iˉs=2.4\bar{I}_d/\bar{I}_s = 2.4 was observed. Having the returned bubble located at the center in between the electrodes avoids the formation of larger bubbles directly on the electrodes. Notably, only a slight drop in the current is observed (see inset at t0=0t_0 = 0) as the outline of the bubble moves beyond the electrode positions. This contradicts the common practice of considering the region under the bubble as inactive but is in line with earlier conjectures.31,70

Conclusions

We have explored the coalescence dynamics of electrogenerated bubbles and their influence on the electrochemical reaction rate using dual platinum micro-electrodes. We found that the coalescence of two adjacent bubbles leads to an initial jump-off of the merged bubble and premature escape from the surface. However, the continued coalescence with newly formed successors may result in a return to the electrode, hence prolonged growth. The latter mode is increasingly prevalent the higher the current and the smaller the interelectrode distance. We proposed a simple model to capture these trends and predict the critical magnitude of the current required to initiate the return process. This comeback mode negates the potential performance improvement achieved through direct departure following the coalescence event at smaller HH (up to a 1.7- vs. 2.3-fold increase in current at constant potential when compared to a single electrode). However, even in cases of bubble return, the effective current at larger HH increased by up to 2.4 times because the bubble was then located between the electrodes, exposing a greater electrode area for the reaction. Therefore, this mode is promising, especially since, given the dependence on electrode separation, even greater performance gains can be expected by further increasing HH. In practice, a similar configuration may be achieved on extended electrodes using hydrophobic islands, which should be spaced to favour coalescence-based departure and minimize the probability of bubble return, thus avoiding the blocking of the active surface area.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Acknowledgements

This research received funding from the Dutch Research Council (NWO) with a co-funding acquired from Nobian and Helmholtz-Zentrum Dresden-Rossendorf (HZDR) in the framework of ElectroChemical Conversion and Materials (ECCM) KICkstart DE-NL (KICH1.ED04.20.009).

S.P. acknowledges the support by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education (2021R1A6A3A14039678).

D.K., D.L. and M.T.M.K. received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) (BU-PACT grant agreement number 950111, ERC Advanced grant number 740479-DDD and ERC Advanced Grant ‘FRUMKIN’ number 101019998, respectively). We thank V. Sanjay for insightful discussions on the subject.

Supporting Information:

Single electrode: characterization

Figure S1 documents the electric current over 5 seconds (out of 30 seconds) of the experimental run at various potentials (ϕ\phi). The currents are shown for H=117 μmH = 117\,\mathrm{\mu m} for left and right electrodes (see Figure 1a in the manuscript), run separately.

Electric current over time for left and right electrodes

Figure S1. The electric current over time for left and right electrodes.

Figure S2 characterizes five electrodes in terms of the electric current (2×Iˉs2 \times\bar{I}_s), lifetime (T^s\hat{T}_s), and radius at the departure (R^s\hat{R}_s) vs. ϕ\phi. Iˉs\bar{I}_s is averaged over 30 seconds and the left and right electrodes. T^s\hat{T}_s and R^s\hat{R}_s are averaged for multiple bubbles and accompanied by the standard deviations. The low standard deviation for R^s\hat{R}_s and T^s\hat{T}_s demonstrates the highly

Electric current, lifetime and departure radius for hydrogen bubbles produced at a single electrode

Figure S2. The electric current, lifetime and departure radius for H2_2 bubbles produced at single electrode vs. ϕ\phi for different electrodes (HH). The error bars represent standard deviation.

periodical evolution of bubbles. The quite similar current between various HH suggests that the surfaces of these electrodes are alike. However, the small differences are enough to affect the dynamics of H2_2 bubbles and significantly alter the lifetime and size at the departure.

Dual electrode: characterization

For completeness of the results presented in the manuscript Figure S3 and Figure S4 document the electric current (II) vs. time plotted for 1 second out of 30 seconds of the experiment run. II is plotted for various potentials (ϕ\phi) and interelectrode distance (HH). Figure S3, Figure S3 and

Electric current versus time for various potentials and interelectrode distances

Figure S3. The electric current vs. time plotted for 1 second out of 30 seconds of the experimental run for various potentials ϕ\phi and interelectrode distance: (a) H=117μmH = 117\mu\mathrm{m}, (b) H=140μmH = 140\mu\mathrm{m}, (c) H=161μmH = 161\mu\mathrm{m}.

Electric current versus time for various potentials and interelectrode distances

Figure S4. The electric current vs. time plotted for 1 second out of 30 seconds of the experimental run for various potentials ϕ\phi and interelectrode distance: (a) H=242 μmH = 242\,\mu\mathrm{m}, (b) H=270 μmH = 270\,\mu\mathrm{m}.

c are for H=117 μmH = 117\,\mu\mathrm{m}, H=140 μmH = 140\,\mu\mathrm{m}, H=161 μmH = 161\,\mu\mathrm{m}, respectively. Figure S4 and Figure S4 are for H=242 μmH = 242\,\mu\mathrm{m} and (b) H=270 μmH = 270\,\mu\mathrm{m}.

Figure S5 documents the lifetime of the bubbles produced at dual electrode vs. potential (ϕ\phi) for Modes I (left) and II (right) and for different electrodes. T^\hat{T} is averaged for multiple bubbles and accompanied by the standard deviations. Two main trends can be observed: (i) Since the departure radius in mode I is independent of the ϕ\phi, T^I\hat{T}_{I} reduces at larger overpotentials, owing to higher electric current. It also increases together with HH, especially at larger ϕ\phi. — This is because the pair of bubbles need to grow to a bigger size before coalescence at larger HH; (ii) On the other hand, T^II\hat{T}_{II} increases at larger overpotentials and reduces at larger HH. As already mentioned in the manuscript, larger overpotentials imply larger downward-acting forces increasing the departure size of the bubble. Therefore the bubble would grow for a longer time. However, the separation of two electrodes away from each other for larger distances (HH) enables higher currents, hence faster H2_2 production rate.

Lifetime at dual electrode as a function of potential and interelectrode distance

Figure S5. The lifetime at dual electrode as a function of potential (ϕ\phi) and interelectrode distance (HH). T^I\hat{T}_{I} and T^II\hat{T}_{II} are for mode I and mode II, respectively. The error bars represent standard deviation.

Figure S6 demonstrates the traveling distance in vertical direction of the merged bubble in the first 5 milliseconds after the jump-off of the electrode driven by the coalescence event at H=117 μmH = 117\ \mu\mathrm{m}. The results are shown for ϕ=−0.3\phi= -0.3 and −0.5 V-0.5\ \mathrm{V} and three bubbles in each case. The curves document that the jumping velocity notably decays over time (Δt\Delta t) due to the effects of drag force, particularly in the moments following the jump. Interestingly, the ”terminal” velocity of the bubble, which can be read from the slope of the curves and i.e. ca. after 2 ms, increased at a larger overpotential (-0.5 V). This might be explained by the wake behind the rising bubble-predecessor. This flow drags, hence accelerates the merged bubble in the moment of departure. The wake enhances with the faster departure of bubbles-predecessors (smaller TT) which is the case at a more negative potential.

Trajectory of bubble at −0.3 V and −0.5 V over the first 5 milliseconds after coalescence-driven jump-off

Figure S6. The trajectory of bubble at -0.3 V and -0.5 V over the first 5 milliseconds after coalescence driven jump-off. t0=0t_0 = 0 is one frame before coalescence. Each potential is presented by three bubbles. The interelectrode distance H=117 μmH = 117\ \mu\mathrm{m}.

Figure S7 represents the vertical jumping velocity uˉI,0.5 ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5\ \mathrm{ms}} for numerous bubbles, averaged over the first 0.5 ms of the jump, vs. parent size ratio Rs/RlR_s/R_l. The experiments performed at H=117H = 117 and (a) ϕ=−0.5 V\phi= -0.5\ \mathrm{V}, (b) ϕ=−1.0 V\phi= -1.0\ \mathrm{V}. RsR_s and RlR_l are radii for smaller and larger bubbles, respectively. The geometric parameters are shown in Figure S7. The color bar scales another geometric parameter Ymax⁡Y_{\max} given in dimensionless form. It represents the relative position of the bubble i.e. the distance from the bubble bottom to the electrode, chosen as the maximum value between the smaller and bigger bubbles. The bubble sits at the electrode if Y=1Y = 1 and is away from the electrode if Y>1Y > 1. The circles represent mode I, i.e. when the bubble departs into the bulk following the coalescence event, and squares denote mode II, i.e. when the once departed bubble following the coalescence event comes back to the surface, continues to grow, and departs at a later stage due to buoyancy. Note that uIu_I varies widely depending on the position of both bubbles before coalescence and their size ratio.

Vertical jumping velocity versus bubble-size ratio and relative position

Figure S7. (a),(b) The vertical jumping velocity (uˉI,0.5ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5\mathrm{ms}}) vs.. Rs/RlR_s/R_l at ϕ=−0.5\phi= -0.5 V and ϕ=−1.0\phi= -1.0 V. The color bar scales the relative position of the bubble shown in (c), i.e. the maximum of either smaller or bigger bubbles, prior to coalescence at H=117H = 117. Image recording performed at 10 kHz.

Figures S7a and b demonstrate two general trends: (i) uˉI,0.5ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5\mathrm{ms}} reduces as per reduction in Rs/RlR_s/R_l and as per increase in Ymax⁡Y_{\max}; (ii) at higher potential, hence current, the bubble would come back to the electrode more often moving away with even higher jumping velocity, as already emphasized in the manuscript (see Figure 5).

Upon coalescence of two bubbles, there is a release of surface energy (ΔGs\Delta G_{\mathrm{s}}) given as

ΔGs=4πγ(Rl2+Rr2−Rl2),(2)\Delta G_{\mathrm{s}} = 4\pi\gamma\left(R_{\mathrm{l}}^{2} + R_{\mathrm{r}}^{2} - R_{\mathrm{l}}^{2}\right), \tag*{(2)}

where RlR_{\mathrm{l}}, RrR_{\mathrm{r}} and RIR_{\mathrm{I}} are the left, right and merged bubbles, respectively. γ≈0.072\gamma\approx0.072 N/m is the surface tension of the electrolyte. The released energy partly dissipates by the bubble oscillations, working against viscous drag. When in the proximity to the surface, the remaining energy is converted to the kinetic energy (EkE_{\mathrm{k}}) driving the resultant (merged) bubble to jump off the electrode.1 The kinetic energy is

Ek=12CMρl43πRI3uI2,(3)E_{\mathrm{k}} = \frac{1}{2}C_{\mathrm{M}}\rho_{\mathrm{l}}\frac{4}{3}\pi R_{\mathrm{I}}^{3}u_{\mathrm{I}}^{2}, \tag*{(3)}

where CMC_{\mathrm{M}} is added mass coefficient, ρl\rho_{\mathrm{l}} electrolyte density and uIu_{\mathrm{I}} is the initial jumping velocity. For a spherical bubble CM=0.5C_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.5, however, when the bubble is in proximity to the wall the coefficient is larger.2 In detail, when two bubbles approach each other, the thin film of electrolyte separating them gradually drains O(μs)\mathcal{O}(\mu\mathrm{s}) and eventually ruptures. This leads to the formation of a neck, i.e. an open cavity, and a series of capillary waves of varying strengths that propagate along the electrolyte-gas interface. These waves move away from the neck region until they meet at the opposite apex of the coalescence point (see manuscript, Figure 3c). The strength of these waves decreases as they travel along the interface due to continuous viscous dissipation.3 Meanwhile, the surface tension γ\gamma drives the retraction of the remaining capillary waves towards a spherical shape, deforming the bubble shape. Once the excess surface energy overcomes the work done by the bubble against viscous drag (WμW_{\mu}) during the expansion and retraction processes, the resultant net component of momentum perpendicular to the surface causes the bubble to jump off the electrode. As neither of the bubbles is attached to the electrode, the adhesion energy WaW_{\mathrm{a}} is neglected. The process is controlled by surface tension and viscosity and is often characterized in terms of the Ohnesorge number (Oh=μργRIOh = \frac{\mu}{\sqrt{\rho\gamma R_I}}).[3] μ\mu is the dynamic viscosity of the electrolyte. The influence of gravity during the coalescence, before lift-off, is negligible.[2] While the process is considered highly inefficient, with only a small portion of surface energy translating into kinetic energy,[2] it is sufficient for a resultant bubble (RIR_I) to jump off the electrode acquiring an initial velocity uIu_I.

Figure S8 documents an estimation of the ratio between the translated kinetic energy (EkE_k) and the released surface energy (ΔGs\Delta G_s) as a function of (a) RIR_I and (b) HH. The data points in fig. S8a is calculated using eq. 1 and eq. 2 by taking corresponding RlR_l, RrR_r, RIR_I and uˉI,0.5ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5ms} for the bubbles presented in fig. S7a, i.e. at H=117 μmH = 117\ \mu\mathrm{m} and ϕ=−0.5 V\phi= -0.5\ \mathrm{V}. The circles represent the bubbles following mode I and squares mode II. The data points in fig. S8b is based on the R^I\hat{R}_I from fig. 6a and uˉI,0.5ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5ms} from fig. 5d in the manuscript, assuming that Rl=RrR_l = R_r, hence Rl=R^I21/3R_l = \frac{\hat{R}_I}{2^{1/3}}.

Ratio between translated kinetic energy and released surface energy as a function of $R_I$ and $H$

Figure S8. The ratio between the translated kinetic energy (EkE_k) and the released surface energy (ΔGs\Delta G_s) as a function of (a) RIR_I and (b) HH.

Although the taken velocity uˉI,0.5ms\bar{u}_{I,0.5ms} is smaller than the initial jumping velocity and is further affected by the wake behind the departed bubble-predecessor, fig. S8 confirms the inefficiency of the coalescence process, as the translated kinetic energy is below 1% of the released surface energy.

Phase diagram: model

To provide a general understanding of the relationship between probability (PP), interelectrode distance (HH), and electric current (II) presented in Figure 5 (see manuscript), we propose a simple model based on the velocity of the departing bubble and the growth rate of the bubble-successor. The model predicts the critical magnitude of the current Iˉc\bar{I}_c required to produce hydrogen quickly enough to guarantee the coalescence between the departing bubble (R^I\hat{R}_I) and its successor (R0R_0). The time it takes for the new bubble to grow to the radius R0R_0 is Δt\Delta t which can be found from Faraday’s and ideal gas laws.

The ideal gas law given as

PgV=mMRgT,(4)P_g V = \frac{m}{M} R_g T, \tag*{(4)}

where PgP_g is the pressure inside the bubble, VV is the volume of the gas, mm is the total mass of the gas, MM is the molar mass, RgR_g is the ideal gas constant and TT is temperature of the gas. The produced charge is

Q=Iˉc⋅Δt.(5)Q = \bar{I}_c \cdot\Delta t. \tag*{(5)}

The Faraday’s law reads

mQ=1FMν,(6)\frac{m}{Q} = \frac{1}{F}\frac{M}{\nu}, \tag*{(6)}

where FF is the Faraday’s constant and ν\nu is the valency of the ions (+1) multiplied by number of protons (2).

By substituting Eqs. (5) and Eq. (6) in Eq. (4)

Δt=R03Iˉc⋅8π3FPRgT=R03Iˉc⋅k,(7)\Delta t = \frac{R_0^3}{\bar{I}_c} \cdot\frac{8\pi}{3}\frac{F P}{R_g T} = \frac{R_0^3}{\bar{I}_c}\cdot k, \tag*{(7)}

with k=8π3FPRgTk = \frac{8\pi}{3}\frac{F P}{R_g T}. During this time interval Δt\Delta t, the departing bubble travels the distance Δt⋅uI\Delta t \cdot u_{\mathrm{I}}, with uIu_{\mathrm{I}} denoting the effective jump velocity. Based on the geometry of the triangle spanned by the centers of the two bubbles and the point A in figure 5c (see manuscript), the following relation can be expressed:

[(R^I+uI⋅Δt)−R0]2+(H2)2=(R^I+R0)2(8)\left[\left(\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}+u_{\mathrm{I}}\cdot\Delta t\right)-R_{0}\right]^{2}+\left(\frac{H}{2}\right)^{2}=\left(\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}+R_{0}\right)^{2} \tag*{(8)}

where R^I=21/3⋅H2\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}=2^{1/3}\cdot\frac{H}{2} or is taken from experiment (see figure 6a).

By substituting Δt\Delta t into eq. (8), the critical current for the mode transition as a function of R0R_{0} is given by:

Ic(R0;uI,H)=uIR03k[(R^I+R0)2−(H2)2]1/2−R^I+R0(9)I_{\mathrm{c}}(R_{0};u_{\mathrm{I}},H)=\frac{u_{\mathrm{I}}R_{0}^{3}k}{\left[\left(\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}+R_{0}\right)^{2}-\left(\frac{H}{2}\right)^{2}\right]^{1/2}-\hat{R}_{\mathrm{I}}+R_{0}} \tag*{(9)}

Apparent force: bubble-carpet interaction

It was shown that the H2_{2} bubble grows while seated on a carpet of microbubbles, undergoing a continuous intensive coalescence with it. Throughout numerous coalescence events, the mother bubble experiences a shift in the mass center, resulting in acceleration towards the electrode surface. This acceleration can be considered as an apparent force Fg−gF_{g-g}. An estimate for this apparent force is derived from the principle of momentum conservation, given as

mcM=m0c0+m˙tc,(10)mc_{M}=m_{0}c_{0}+\dot{m}tc, \tag*{(10)}

where mm and cmc_{m} represent the total mass and mass center of the bubble at time tt, respectively; m0m_{0} and c0c_{0} denote the initial mass and mass center of the bubble at an arbitrary time t0=0t_{0}=0; and m˙\dot{m} stands for the mass injection rate due to continuous coalescence with the carpet of microbubbles with the center of mass at cc. m0m_{0} and c0c_{0} are constant. All mass centers are with reference to the electrode surface. The mass of the bubble mm at any given moment is

m=m0+m˙t.(11)m = m_0 + \dot{m}t. \tag*{(11)}

By substituting m˙=m−m0\dot{m}=m-m_0 from eq. (10) into eq. (11)

mcM=m0c0+mc−m0c.(12)mc_M = m_0c_0 + mc - m_0c. \tag*{(12)}

Given that cc at a given current II is a constant (as well as m0m_0 and c0c_0)

mc˙M=m˙(c−cM).(13)m\dot{c}_M = \dot{m}(c-c_M). \tag*{(13)}

We further assume that m˙\dot{m} is also constant at given II. By performing differentiation one more time using eq. (13)

mc¨M=−2m˙c˙M.(14)m\ddot{c}_M = -2\dot{m}\dot{c}_M. \tag*{(14)}

By substituting eq. (13) in eq. (14)

Fg−g=mc¨M=−2m˙mm˙(c−cM).(15)F_{g-g}=m\ddot{c}_M=-2\frac{\dot{m}}{m}\dot{m}(c-c_M). \tag*{(15)}

When considering only a short interval tt, we can approximate cM≈Rc_M \approx R and eq. (15) reads

Fg−g=21m(mt)2R.(16)F_{g-g}=2\frac{1}{m}\left(\frac{m}{t}\right)^2R. \tag*{(16)}

cc, which is the thickness of the carpet, is also neglected. Using the Faraday’s and ideal gas laws

m˙=mt=ρgVV=ρgItkt=ρgIk,(17)\dot{m}=\frac{m}{t}=\frac{\rho_g V}{V}=\frac{\rho_g Itk}{t}=\rho_g Ik, \tag*{(17)}

where k=RgT2PgFk=\frac{R_gT}{2P_gF}.

Finally, by substituting eq. (17) into eq. (16) the apparent force reads

Fg−g=32ρgI2k2πR2.(18)F_{g-g} = \frac{3}{2}\frac{\rho_g I^2 k^2}{\pi R^2}. \tag*{(18)}

Figure S9 documents a comparison between the buoyancy force and apparent force, calculated using eq. (18) at I=−8I = -8 mA (which corresponds to approximately the maximum current observed in this study), against the bubble radius RR. The buoyancy force defined as Fb=(ρg−ρH2)gVF_b = (\rho_g - \rho_{H_2})gV, where gg represents gravitational acceleration. Figure S9 demonstrates that the continued coalescence with the carpet of microbubbles does not impose a significant apparent force on the bubble. — This force decays rapidly with increasing RR and becomes smaller than the buoyancy force at at approximately R=16R = 16 µm.

Buoyancy and apparent forces as a function of bubble radius

Figure S9. Buoyancy and apparent forces as a function of bubble radius at I=−8I = -8 mA.

References

  1. [1]Lᵥ, P.; Peñas, P.; Eijkel, J.; Van Den Berg, A.; Zhang, X.; Lohse, D.; others Self-propelled detachment upon coalescence of surface bubbles. Physical Review Letters 2021, 127, 235501.
  2. [2]Raza, M. Q.; Köckritz, M. v.; Sebilleau, J.; Colin, C.; Zupancic, M.; Bucci, M.; Troha, T.; Golobic, I. Coalescence-induced jumping of bubbles in shear flow in microgravity. Physics of Fluids 2023, 35.DOI
  3. [3]Sanjay, V.; Lohse, D.; Jalaal, M. Bursting bubble in a viscoplastic medium. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 2021, 922, A2.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wa5u7yeb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents