betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Is Cu3−x_{3-x}P a semiconductor, a metal, or a semimetal?

Abstract

Despite the recent surge in interest in Cu3−x_{3-x}P for catalysis, batteries, and plasmonics, the electronic nature of Cu3−x_{3-x}P remains unclear. Some studies have shown evidence of semiconducting behavior, whereas others have argued that Cu3−x_{3-x}P is a metallic compound. Here, we attempt to resolve this dilemma on the basis of combinatorial thin-film experiments, electronic structure calculations, and semiclassical Boltzmann transport theory. We find strong evidence that stoichiometric, defect-free Cu3_3P is an intrinsic semimetal, i.e., a material with a small overlap between the valence and the conduction band. On the other hand, experimentally realizable Cu3−x_{3-x}P films are always p-type semimetals natively doped by copper vacancies regardless of xx. It is not implausible that Cu3−x_{3-x}P samples with very small characteristic sizes (such as small nanoparticles) are semiconductors due to quantum confinement effects that result in opening of a band gap. We observe high hole mobilities (276 cm2^2/Vs) in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films at low temperatures, pointing to low ionized impurity scattering rates in spite of a high doping density. We report an optical effect equivalent to the Burstein-Moss shift, and we assign an infrared absorption peak to bulk interband transitions rather than to a surface plasmon resonance. From a materials processing perspective, this study demonstrates the suitability of reactive sputter deposition for detailed high-throughput studies of emerging metal phosphides.

Introduction

Most binary compounds consisting of Cu(I) and a moderately electronegative element are semiconductors of high interest for optoelectronics and/or thermoelectrics. Cu2O\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{O}-based solar cells have reached photovoltaic efficiencies close to 10%.1 Cu2O\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{O} itself is the host of the largest excitonic wavefunctions ever discovered.2 Cu2S\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{S} was one of the prominent thin-film solar cell materials in the 1970s3 and later regained prominence in nanoparticle form as a semiconductor system with localized surface plasmon resonances in the near infrared.4 Cu2Se\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{Se} and Cu2Te\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{Te} are among the best p-type thermoelectric materials known today,5,6 with record zTzT values above 1 at high temperatures. CuI is currently the p-type transparent conductor with the highest figure of merit,7,8 and one of the highest-performing transparent thermoelectric materials.9 Cu3N\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{N} is a defect-tolerant semiconductor10 with an ideal band gap for photovoltaics.11 CuP2\mathrm{CuP}_{2} is an unconventional semiconductor containing P-P bonds, with optimal band gap and doping density for photovoltaics.12

Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} is another copper(I) phosphide, which has been synthesized in the form of single crystals,13,14 powders,15–18 thin films,[22, 23] [19, 20, 21] and especially nanoparticles and other nanostructured forms.[24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30] Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} is usually found to be strongly p-type due to substantial Cu deficiency,13,17 and is therefore often referred to as Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}. In recent years, Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} has been the subject of intense research as an electro- and photocatalyst for various reactions,[25, 27, 28, 30] [20, 21] as well as a battery anode.[31, 32] However, the current understanding of the electrical and optical properties of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} is surprisingly poor. Various authors have identified Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a metal,[22] [14, 18] but many others have classified it as a semiconductor[24, 26, 28, 29, 30, 33] [16] and one study labeled it a semimetal.[27] Device-level applications of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a semiconducting photovoltaic absorber[24] and as a metallic contact[22] have both been claimed. Furthermore, it is not clear if the electrical properties of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} are modified by changing the composition, and in particular whether Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} can be doped beyond non-stoichiometry. The single-phase region of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} has only been determined for bulk samples,13,17,18 with different results obtained in different studies. Finally, the effect of growth temperature and other parameters on the properties of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} has not been investigated.

Polycrystalline Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} thin films are an ideal platform to answer these questions. Unlike the case of nanoparticles, the properties of thin films are not affected by quantum confinement, and electrical and optical properties can be measured more precisely. Compared to single crystals and bulk powders, an advantage of thin films is that their properties can rapidly be characterized as a function of elemental composition and process conditions using high-throughput methods.34–36 Previous thin-film work on Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} is, however, limited to non-reactive sputter deposition from a Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} target,[22] chemical vapor deposition,20 electrodeposition,19,21 and phosphorization of metallic Cu[23] with only basic materials characterization. A deposition technique amenable to high-throughput experiments is reactive RF sputtering in a PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3}-containing atmosphere. Although this technique has rarely been applied to deposit metal phosphides, we have recently shown its feasibility for various phosphide compounds of current interest.1

In this work, we combine high-throughput experiments on reactively sputtered Cu3−xP, first-principles calculations, and semiclassical transport theory. The goal is to investigate the electronic nature of Cu3−xP films as a function of composition and growth conditions. We present strong evidence that Cu3−xP is a p-type semimetal natively doped by Cu vacancies regardless of overall composition and growth conditions. Its single-phase region is likely limited to a narrow range of Cu-deficient compositions. We find that the density of Cu vacancies increases with deposition temperature. We observe an anisotropic electrical conductivity in excellent agreement with the anisotropy of the hole effective masses. Finally, we identify a near-infrared absorption feature somewhat similar to a localized surface plasmon resonance previously reported in Cu3−xP nanoparticles. In thin-film samples, this peak is likely to be an intrinsic feature of bulk Cu3−xP due to interband transitions.

Results

Growth, composition, and structure

Growth routes and composition

We initially deposited Cu3−xP films by RF sputtering of a Cu3−xP target in pure Ar, but this process

route does not allow the exploration of a broad parameter space. The films rapidly lose P with increasing deposition temperature (Figure 1(a)) and Cu/P ratios below 3 are only achievable below ∼250 °C. Without intentional heating, films are x-ray amorphous (Figure 2). At 220 °C, polycrystalline Cu3−xP grows without detectable secondary phases (Figure 2). At 450 °C, polycrystalline Cu3−xP is still present but the film has lost most of its P (Cu/P ≃ 6.5) and mainly consists of large Cu islands (Figure 3). The changes in film morphology versus temperature are shown in greater detail in Figure S1.

Figure 1. Composition and phase analysis of Cu3−xP films under different deposition conditions. (a): Film composition versus deposition temperature. Each data set is indicated by a guiding line. (b): Combinatorial film compositions obtained at different PH3 partial pressures by co-sputtering a Cu and a Cu3−xP target. Left panel: Room temperature deposition. Right panel: 370 °C deposition. Data points are colored green, purple, and black when their corresponding XRD patterns contain Cu3−xP peaks only, Cu peaks only, and both types of peaks, respectively.

Figure 2. XRD patterns of Cu3−xP films deposited in pure Ar and in a PH3-containing atmosphere. Film compositions, deposition temperatures, and reference peaks from powder samples4 are indicated. At room temperature, the inclusion of PH3 yields polycrystalline (rather than amorphous) films. Including PH3 also prevents P losses at high temperatures.

SEM images of Cu$_{3-x}$P films deposited in pure Ar and in an Ar/PH$_3$-containing atmosphere

Figure 3. SEM images of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films deposited in pure Ar (left) and in a PH3_3-containing atmosphere (right). A polycrystalline rather than amorphous morphology is found when PH3_3 is included in the growth atmosphere at room temperature (top row). When depositing in pure Ar, most of the phosphorus is already lost at 450 °C, resulting in formation of metallic Cu islands (middle- and bottom left). When depositing in Ar/PH3_3, a homogeneous Cu3−x_{3-x}P film with grains larger than 500 nm can be grown at even higher temperatures (530 °C, middle- and bottom right).

SEM images of Cu₃₋ₓP films at different substrate temperatures

Figure S1. SEM images of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films sputter-deposited in pure Ar at different substrate temperatures. The films deposited at 25 °C, 100 °C, and 220 °C have composition close to Cu3_3P. The film deposited at 450 °C has composition Cu6.45_{6.45}P due to phosphorus evaporation from the growing film. Most crystal grains in the film deposited at 220 °C have hexagonal shapes (highlighted in yellow), in line with the hexagonal symmetry of the P63_{63}cm crystal structure of Cu3−x_{3-x}P.

Adding PH3 to the growth atmosphere significantly expands the conditions under which polycrystalline Cu3−xP can be grown. First, the deposition temperature can be increased up to at least 530 °C (Figure 2, Figure 3). Second, deposition of Cu3−xP by reactive sputtering of a metallic Cu target becomes possible in the same temperature range as for the Cu3−xP target (Figure 1(a)). This is a significant process advantage due to the lower cost, higher purity, and higher sputter rate of a metal target. Finally, polycrystalline (rather than amorphous) Cu3−xP is obtained when depositing at room temperature (Figure 2, Figure 3). This unexpected finding is an indication of a plasma-assisted crystallization process driven by the PH3 dissociation products5 in an RF plasma. In the remainder of the article, we will discuss the properties of Cu3−xP deposited in a PH3-containing atmosphere, unless otherwise specified.

When depositing films at room temperature, a broad range of Cu/P ratios is accessible by tuning the PH3 partial pressure (Figure 1(b)). By simultaneous sputtering of a Cu and a Cu3−x_{3-x}P target facing two opposite sides of the substrate, combinatorial films with a gradient in the Cu/P ratio can be obtained at a single PH3_3 partial pressure (Figure 1(b)). When depositing at 370 °C, P-rich compositions with Cu/P ratios significantly less than 3 are no longer accessible (Figure 1(b)). The lowest Cu/P ratios obtained at 370 °C, 450 °C, and 530 °C are 2.89, 2.87, and 2.91, respectively. Compatibly with our previous study on CuP2_2, 12 we assume that all Cu-P phases with higher P content than the Cu3−x_{3-x}P phase are unstable at these temperatures, due to the high driving force for P evaporation. All Cu3−x_{3-x}P films were found to be air-stable.

Phase analysis

Regardless of deposition temperature, the x-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of all our Cu3−x_{3-x}P films close to the stoichiometric point are consistent with the P63_3cm structure13,18 previously described for bulk samples (see Figure 2). We do not observe any peaks extraneous to the P63_3cm structure in any of the films with Cu/P < 3, not

even in the extremely P-rich films (up to Cu1.67_{1.67}P) deposited at room temperature. Although polycrystalline secondary phases are absent, we note that CuP2_2 and elemental phosphorus tend to form amorphous phases in bulk samples.17,41 Even for the case of thin films reactively sputtered at room temperature, we confirmed elsewhere that CuP2_212 and elemental phosphorus38 are in amorphous form. Thus, amorphous CuP2_2 and/or P secondary phases are very likely to exist when Cu/P < 2.9, which is the most P-rich composition obtainable at temperatures where CuP2_2 and P are no longer stable in the solid state.

In the Cu-rich region (Cu/P > 3), all films have a composition threshold beyond which XRD peaks from metallic Cu are observed. The range of Cu-rich compositions free of metallic Cu peaks becomes narrower with increasing PH3_3 partial pressure (Figure 1(b)). As argued in the Supporting Information, this is related to a shift in the prevalent formation mechanism of the Cu3−x_{3-x}P film, from deposition of Cu3−x_{3-x}P vapor to incomplete phosphorization of metallic Cu. In general, XRD results indicate that moderately Cu-rich Cu3−x_{3-x}P films can be grown without precipitation of polycrystalline Cu. However, SEM characterization reveals that some secondary phases are already present at Cu3.00_{3.00}P composition in films deposited above 370 °C (Figure S2). These phases are likely to be non-crystalline Cu. They are no longer visible by SEM at Cu2.95_{2.95}P composition (Figure S2). Thus, the single-phase region of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films deposited at 370 °C and above is probably not wider than the Cu2.9_{2.9}P–Cu3.0_{3.0}P range, based on our SEM results. Films deposited at room temperature might have an extended single-phase region on the Cu-rich side, since we could not clearly distinguish secondary phases by SEM in these films. In general, formation of amorphous CuP2_2 (at low temperatures) or P loss (at high temperatures) constrains the single-phase region on the P-rich side. Formation of a Cu secondary phase constrains the single-phase region on the Cu-rich side.

SEM images and composition-dependent resistivity of Cu$_{3-x}$P films

Figure S2. (a): SEM image of a film with overall Cu3.00_{3.00}P composition, where bright secondary phases are observed throughout the film surface. The diameter of the secondary phases is roughly 10 nm. The area coverage of the secondary phases is roughly 0.6%. Since metallic Cu is detected by XRD at slightly Cu-richer compositions, the phases observed in the SEM are also likely to consist of metallic Cu. This is compatible with their brighter appearance in the SEM, usually a sign of higher average atomic number. (b): SEM image of a film with overall Cu2.95_{2.95}P composition, where bright secondary phases are not observed. The films in (a) and (b) were deposited at 530 °C. (c): Composition-dependent resistivity of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films deposited at 370 °C. Samples in which no polycrystalline secondary phases were detected by XRD are shown in green. Samples which exhibited both Cu3−x_{3-x}P peaks and metallic Cu peaks in their XRD patterns are shown in black. Note that the presence or absence of polycrystalline Cu does not significantly affect the resistivity of films in the 3.2 < Cu/P < 3.6 range. This finding confirms that amorphous Cu is very likely to exist in the 3.2 < Cu/P < 3.6 range when polycrystalline Cu is not detected.

In qualitative agreement with our results, previous studies of bulk Cu3−x_{3-x}P found that single-phase samples always had Cu/P < 3,13,17,18,42 although different single-phase stability ranges were found in each study. The stability of these P-rich compositions was generally attributed to a high concentration of Cu vacancies (VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}}), responsible for the high p-type conductivity in Cu3−x_{3-x}P. Previous first-principles calculations confirmed that one VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} per 24-atom unit cell should be thermodynamically stable under a wide range of chemical potentials.[26] In the following sections, we will assume that VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} defects generate most of the charge carriers in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films. This assumption will, however, be justified throughout the article based on our own data.

Structural properties

To evaluate structural changes in Cu3−x_{3-x}P as a function of composition and deposition temperature, we analyze the position of the (113) XRD peak (Figure 4(a)). In general, the (113) peak shifts to higher diffraction angles (shorter interplanar distances) with increasing deposition temperature and with decreasing Cu/P ratio. The other peaks in the XRD patterns tend to shift in the same direction (see Figure 2 for some examples). The relative magnitude of the shifts in each XRD pattern is generally compatible with a multiplication of the three lattice constants by a common factor. Hence, we conclude that the (113) peak shifts are indicative of lattice contraction or expansion in all three dimensions. Our data confirm and extend the results by Wolff et al.,18 who reported contraction of the unit cell in all directions in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} powders with decreasing Cu/P ratios (Figure 4(a)).

Figure 4. Structural parameters of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films. (a): Position of (113) XRD peak as a function of film composition, grouped by deposition temperature. Analogous data from Cu3−x_{3-x}P powders grown at 200 °C by Wolff et al.18 are shown. The composition regions where metallic Cu peaks are observed in XRD are shaded in grey (room-temperature deposition) and in blue (370 °C deposition), following the data in Figure 1(b). (b): Estimated cc-axis texture coefficient versus deposition temperature, grouped by the target used for deposition. A coefficient of one indicates that the cc-axis is perpendicular to the substrate plane. A coefficient of zero indicates that the cc-axis lies in the substrate plane. The method used to estimate the texture coefficient is described in the Supporting Information.

For films deposited at 370 °C, the (113) peak stops shifting at high Cu/P ratios, roughly corresponding to the region where we observe precipitation of polycrystalline Cu (blue shaded area in Figure 4(a)). This suggests that all excess Cu precipitates as a secondary phase rather than being incorporated in the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} lattice. For films deposited at room temperature, the (113) peak shift is generally more pronounced up to the precipitation threshold for polycrystalline Cu. Hence, low-temperature-grown Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} may be able to incorporate substantial Cu excess in the form of defects. This would be a qualitative difference with Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} grown at higher temperatures, where evidence for Cu precipitation already at Cu/P = 3 has been shown in bulk samples13,17,18,42 and thin-film samples (this work). As will be shown later, changes in lattice constants are generally correlated to changes in the concentration of Cu vacancies in the different films.

The texture coefficient of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films is shown in Figure 4(b) as a function of deposition temperature. The cc-axis of the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} crystallites has an increasing tendency to align perpendicular to the substrate plane with increasing temperature. Similar cc-axis texturing effects are often observed in other uniaxially anisotropic materials.43–45 We also observe that films grown from the Cu target are generally more cc-axis textured than films grown from the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} target at the same temperature (Figure 4(b) and Figure S3).

Figure S3. Color map representing XRD intensity from a combinatorial Cu3−x_{3-x}P film deposited at 220 °C as a function of position on the substrate with respect to the two sputter targets. At 0 cm position, the substrate was mainly coated by the metallic Cu target. At 10 cm position, the substrate was mainly coated by the Cu3−x_{3-x}P target. This dataset was used for orientation-dependent resistivity measurements because of its wide range of texture coefficients, arising from the different intensity ratios between the (300) peak and the (113) peak at different positions.

Finally, Raman spectra of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films do not exhibit any peaks (Figure S4). Raman peaks compatible with a few previous studies[32, 33] can only be observed at very high laser excitation intensities above the ablation threshold of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}, raising questions on the validity of these previously reported spectra.

Figure S4. Raman spectra of a Cu2.95_{2.95}P film deposited at 370 °C. No peaks are observed at an excitation intensity of 200 W/mm2^{2}, which is very high for Raman spectroscopy, but still slightly below the ablation threshold of the film. The absence of Raman peaks in Cu3−x_{3-x}P is compatible with some of the existing literature.[30] [20] Three peaks compatible with other previous studies[31, 32, 33] appear at an excitation intensity of 1000 W/mm2^{2}. However, this extremely high excitation intensity leads to film ablation, as clearly seen by optical microscopy after the Raman measurement.

Electrical properties

Composition dependence

The resistivity of the Cu-P system can be mapped over a broad region (from Cu1.7P\mathrm{Cu}_{1.7}\mathrm{P} to Cu8.0P\mathrm{Cu}_{8.0}\mathrm{P}) in films deposited at room temperature (Figure 5(a)). A local resistivity minimum (1.4×10−4 Ω cm1.4 \times10^{-4}\ \Omega\ \mathrm{cm}) exists at Cu/P ≃2.83\simeq2.83.

Figure 5. Resistivity of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films. (a): Resistivity versus composition for two different deposition temperatures. (b): Resistivity versus deposition temperature (with boxplots) for films in the 2.8<Cu/P<3.02.8 < \mathrm{Cu}/\mathrm{P} < 3.0 composition range. (c): Resistivity near the Cu3_3P stoichiometric point as a function of PH3_3 partial pressure at 370 °C deposition temperature. The data comes from two combinatorial depositions with different PH3_3 partial pressure. Other material properties (composition ranges, thicknesses, texture coefficients) are very similar in the two datasets.

The position of the minimum is close to the most P-rich composition that could be obtained at temperatures above 370 °C (Cu2.87P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.87}\mathrm{P}). This result indicates that further electrical doping by nonstoichiometry is not possible for Cu/P ratios lower than this threshold. Thus, P excess is accommodated by secondary phases rather than defects, in line with the arguments in the previous section. The steep increase in resistivity on the left side of the minimum is due to the much higher resistivity of CuP2_2 (around 1 Ω cm1\ \Omega\ \mathrm{cm}) with respect to Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}, as shown elsewhere.12

On the right side of the minimum, the resistivity increases until the Cu3.8P\mathrm{Cu}_{3.8}\mathrm{P} composition is reached (Figure 5(a)). Since metallic Cu peaks begin to appear in XRD at a similar composition (Figure 1(b)), we assume that the resistivity increase is caused by changes in concentration of point defects up to the Cu precipitation threshold. These defects are also likely to be the cause of unit cell expansion up to a composition of roughly Cu4.5P\mathrm{Cu}_{4.5}\mathrm{P} (Figure 4(a)). Beyond this threshold, a parallel transport channel along highly conductive Cu percolation paths causes the resistivity to decrease again.

The composition dependence of the resistivity in films deposited at 370 °C (Figure 5(a)) has some qualitative differences. The minimum resistivity is still found in the vicinity of the stoichiometric point (4.6×10−5 Ω cm4.6 \times10^{-5}\ \Omega\ \mathrm{cm}). This value is very similar to the resistivity measured in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} single crystals (5×10−5 Ω cm5 \times10^{-5}\ \Omega\ \mathrm{cm})14 and a factor of two lower than in sintered powders (about 1.0×10−41.0 \times10^{-4} Ω cm).15,18 Hall measurements on a Cu2.95_{2.95}P film indicate p-type conductivity with hole concentration of 3.81×10213.81 \times10^{21} cm−3^{-3} and hole mobility of 28.828.8 cm2^2/Vs at room temperature (Figure 6). P-type conductivity is confirmed by measurement of a Seebeck coefficient of +11.2+11.2 µV/K in an analogously deposited film (Figure S5).

Figure 6. Temperature-dependent Hall carrier concentration (a) and Hall mobility (b) of a Cu2.95_{2.95}P film deposited at 370 °C. The hole concentration extracted from half- and one uncompensated Cu vacancy per 24-atom unit cell (single acceptor) is indicated in (a). Also shown in (a) is the simulated temperature dependence of the Hall hole concentration, as calculated by Boltzmann transport theory on Cu3_3P with a Fermi level 0.3 eV below its intrinsic value. The temperature-dependent mobility in (b) is fitted considering two parallel scattering channels (ionized impurities and optical phonons) resulting in the fitting equation shown in the upper part of (b). The results of the fit are shown in the lower part of (b).

Figure S5. Thermovoltage measurements on a Cu2.95_{2.95}P film grown in the same way as the sample used for Hall effect measurements (Figure 6 of the main article) and with similar electrical resistivity. Two corners of the film were contacted with In wire and one contact was heated to create a temperature gradient. The temperature difference and the voltage between the two contacts were measured after temperature stabilization. The Seebeck coefficient SS of Cu2.95_{2.95}P is extracted as the slope of the thermovoltage versus temperature difference curve, plus the known Seebeck coefficient of In. The positive sign of SS confirms that holes are majority charge carriers.

The Cu/P <2.9< 2.9 region is not experimentally available at 370 °C deposition temperature, as explained in the previous section. When Cu/P >3.0> 3.0, the resistivity continues to increase up to the boundary of the investigated composition range (Cu/P ∼6\sim6), despite the fact that Cu secondary phase are already observed at much lower Cu/P ratios (Figure 1(b)). This indicates that transport along Cu3_3P channels is a lower-resistance path in these films, even under a substantial presence of Cu secondary phases.

Interestingly, the resistivity of films in the 3.2<Cu/P<3.63.2 < \mathrm{Cu}/\mathrm{P} < 3.6 range does not depend on whether polycrystalline Cu is detected by XRD (Figure S2). This finding suggests that a certain amount of Cu secondary phases exist even when they are not detected by XRD, confirming the SEM observations in Figure S2. Thus, formation of metallic Cu appears to be favored over formation of compensating donors in Cu-rich films. The moderate increase in (113) interplanar spacing for Cu/P >3> 3 (Figure 4(a)) may simply be due to a decrease in VCu_\mathrm{Cu} concentration. As a consequence, the p-type doping effect of Cu vacancies is never fully compensated by native donors and Cu3−x_{3-x}P films are always p-type, even when Cu/P >3.0> 3.0. Accordingly, we did not measure any negative Seebeck coefficients in any film in the 2.9<Cu/P<3.62.9 < \mathrm{Cu}/\mathrm{P} < 3.6 range.

The average resistivity of films in the vicinity of the stoichiometric point (2.8<Cu/P<3.02.8 < \mathrm{Cu}/\mathrm{P} < 3.0) decreases with increasing deposition temperature up to 450 °C (Figure 5(b)). At a higher temperature (530 °C), a higher average resistivity and a much higher standard deviation are observed. This phenomenon is probably linked to an extrinsic effect, i.e., the microscopic cracks visible in SEM images (Figure 3), which are likely detrimental for electrical transport. Analysis of the optical properties (shown later) indicates that the general decrease in resistivity with increasing temperature is likely due to an increase in hole concentration rather than in hole mobility.

A detailed view of the composition-dependent resistivity data close to the stoichiometric point (Figure 5(c)) reveals that the resistivity depends on the PH3_3 partial pressure during deposition, but not on film composition. The overall decrease in resistivity with increasing PH3_3 partial pressure (20% lower resistivity with 3 times higher partial pressure) is expected, since a higher P chemical potential relative to the Cu chemical potential leads to formation energy lowering of acceptor defects such as Cu vacancies.[26] The complete lack of correlation between resistivity and film composition is more difficult to rationalize, since a higher concentration of Cu vacancies (and thus a lower resistivity) should result in more P-rich compositions. Possible explanations are provided in the Discussion section.

Temperature dependence

Hall effect measurements show that the hole concentration of a low-resistivity Cu3−x_{3-x}P film decreases by a factor 2 from 300 K to 10 K (Figure 6(a)), in quantitative agreement with previous measurements on powder samples.18 On the other hand, the hole mobility increases with decreasing temperature up to 276 cm2^2/Vs at 10 K, indicating that phonon scattering is the main mobility-limiting mechanism above a few tens of K. At lower temperatures, we expect ionized impurity scattering to be responsible for flattening of the mobility, due to the high density of acceptor defects in Cu3−x_{3-x}P.

We fit the experimental hole mobility μ(T)\mu(T) with the expression μ−1(T)=μi−1+μp−1(T)\mu^{-1}(T) = \mu_i^{-1} + \mu_p^{-1}(T). Here, μi\mu_i is the mobility resulting from the ionized impurity scattering channel and μp(T)\mu_p(T) is the mobility resulting from the phonon scattering channel. We assume that ionized impurity scattering is roughly temperature-independent in a highly doped material like Cu3−x_{3-x}P39,46 and that phonon-limited mobility can be described by a power law.47 The fit yields μi=279 cm2/Vs\mu_{\mathrm{i}} = 279\ \mathrm{cm^2/Vs} and μp=aT−2.08\mu_{\mathrm{p}} = aT^{-2.08}, where aa is a temperature-independent factor (Figure 6(b)).

The low-temperature mobility of this Cu3−x_{3-x}P film is remarkably high for a non-epitaxial polycrystalline thin-film material with such a high carrier concentration. An explicit comparison with other materials is provided in the Supporting Information. The mobility of the present Cu3−x_{3-x}P film is also much higher than the mobility of sintered Cu3−x_{3-x}P powders presented in a previous study (7.4 cm2/Vs7.4\ \mathrm{cm^2/Vs} at 300 K and 38 cm2/Vs38\ \mathrm{cm^2/Vs} at 2 K).18 Thus, we conclude that Cu3−x_{3-x}P films have very low ionized impurity scattering rates, despite the high density of such impurities (VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} acceptors). The ionized impurity scattering rate in a highly doped material is expected to scale with (m∗/εs)2(m^*/\varepsilon_{\mathrm{s}})^2, where m∗m^* is the carrier effective mass and εs\varepsilon_{\mathrm{s}} is the static dielectric constant.48 Since the calculated m∗m^* for holes in Cu3−x_{3-x}P at the observed carrier concentration is not unusually low (see Discussion section), it is likely that Cu3_3P has a high static dielectric constant. In fact, high values of εs\varepsilon_{\mathrm{s}} are often encountered in narrow band gap semiconductors and semimetals.49 We emphasize that the electrical properties extracted from Hall measurements are derived under the assumption of a single carrier type, i.e., with holes being much more abundant than electrons. The next sections show that this assumption is probably justified for Cu3−x_{3-x}P.

Metal, semimetal, or degenerately doped semiconductor?

The electrical properties of the present Cu3−x_{3-x}P films could be compatible with a metal or a degenerately doped semiconductor. However, previous studies do not agree on which of the two classes Cu3−x_{3-x}P belongs to. Some authors identified it as a metal,[22] [14, 18] others as a semiconductor.[24, 26, 28, 29, 30, 33] [16]

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations with the PBE exchange correlation functional50 yield metallic band structures, both for stoichiometric Cu3_3P51 and for Cu3−x_{3-x}P with 1 VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell.[26] This is not conclusive evidence that Cu3−x_{3-x}P is a metal, because semiconducting compounds are often incorrectly predicted to be metals at the PBE level due to the well-known ”band gap problem” of semilocal functionals.52 However, stoichiometric Cu3_3P is also predicted to be a metal using the hybrid HSE06 functional,53 with which band gaps are not systematically underestimated.54 This substantiates the hypothesis that Cu3−x_{3-x}P is intrinsically a metal rather than a degenerately doped semiconductor.

The total density of states (DOS) calculated for stoichiometric Cu3_3P at the PBE level (Materials Project ID: mp-7463)51 is shown in Figure 7(a). The DOS calculated at the HSE level is similar.53 The DOS at the Fermi level is low, with a minimum in its immediate vicinity. Metallic materials with these features (such as graphite,

Figure 7. Simulated electronic and transport properties of Cu3_3P at various doping levels. (a): Total electronic DOS of pristine Cu3_3P by DFT (PBE level), extracted from the Materials Project database.51 The calculated DOS with and without thermal broadening is shown. The low – but not zero – DOS at the Fermi level indicates semimetallicity. Also shown is the simulated Seebeck coefficient as a function of Fermi level position with respect to the intrinsic Fermi level of pristine Cu3_3P (zero of the energy scale). The experimental Seebeck coefficient of a Cu3−x_{3-x}P film (star marker) is shown for comparison. (b): Simulated absolute value of the net carrier concentration p−np-n and of the Hall carrier concentration nHn_H as a function of Fermi level position with respect to the intrinsic Fermi level of pristine Cu3_3P (zero of the energy scale). (c): Simulated Pisarenko plots based on the data in (a) and (b). The black data are plotted with the net carrier concentration as the abscissa (p-type for solid data points, n-type for hollow data points). The red data are plotted with the Hall carrier concentration as the abscissa. The star marker indicates the experimental Seebeck coefficient versus experimental Hall hole concentration.

As, and Bi) are often referred to as semimetals, to indicate that there is a small overlap between hole-like bands and electron-like bands at the Fermi level. The limited availability of states at the Fermi level results in smaller charge carrier concentrations than in conventional metals.55 In addition, semimetals may shift between n-type and p-type behavior with temperature or under relatively small changes in the Fermi level driven by perturbations such as doping, strain, or biasing.56

Semiclassical simulation of transport properties

It is desirable to check if the experimentally-determined properties of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films are compatible with a semimetal. For a direct comparison, we simulated transport properties of Cu3_3P at 300 K from the calculated band structure of Cu3_3P at the PBE level (Materials Project ID: mp-7463).51 Net carrier concentrations were derived from the DFT-computed density of states (Figure 7(a)) and the Fermi distribution function. Other transport quantities (electrical conductivity, conductivity effective masses, Hall carrier concentration, Seebeck coefficient) were calculated by semiclassical Boltzmann transport theory based on an interpolation of the DFT-calculated band structure.57,58 Two important approximations of the present implementation of Boltzmann transport theory are: (i) the carrier scattering time is constant across all bands and energies (we chose 10 fs for reasons explained in the Supporting Information); (ii) doping affects the Fermi level position, but not the band structure itself. The net carrier concentration is defined as ∣p−n∣|p-n|, where pp is the free hole concentration and nn is the free electron concentration (both are positive quantities). These carriers can be either intrinsic to the material due to a non-zero DOS at the Fermi level, or can be generated by doping.

The Fermi level of intrinsic, defect-free Cu3_3P is predicted to lie very close to the DOS minimum (Figure 7(a)). This intrinsic Fermi level is indicated as the zero of the energy scale in Figure 7(a,Figure 7b). The net carrier concentration in this hypothetical Cu3_3P without any dopants is 3×10203 \times10^{20} cm−3^{-3} (about one net electron per 250 atoms, see dashed line in Figure 7(b)). This intrinsic electron concentration arises from the non-zero DOS (and thus, non-zero free electron density) of Cu3_3P at the Fermi level. As the Fermi level shifts down through p-type doping, the net carrier concentration vanishes around 60 meV below the intrinsic Fermi level. At this energy, the intrinsic electrons are fully compensated by holes generated by doping. Upon further p-type doping, holes dominate the conductivity rather than electrons. This net carrier concentration is not directly measured by the Hall effect. Instead, the Hall carrier concentration (positive or negative) is defined as nH=1/eRHn_H = 1/eR_H, where RHR_H is the Hall coefficient and ee is the elementary charge. When both electrons and holes contribute to the conductivity

RH=pμh2−nμe2e(pμh+nμe)2(1)R_H = \frac{p\mu_h^2-n\mu_e^2}{e(p\mu_h+n\mu_e)^2} \tag*{(1)}

where μh\mu_h and μe\mu_e are the (positive) mobilities of holes and electrons, respectively.59 In the transport calculations, the mobilities are obtained from the conductivity effective masses me,h∗m^*_{e,h}57,58 and the assumed scattering time τ\tau as μh,e=eτ/me,h∗\mu_{h,e} = e\tau/m^*_{e,h}. From Eq. (1), it is apparent that the Hall concentration deviates from the simple net carrier concentration (p−n)(p-n), unless electrons and holes have very different concentrations. This discrepancy is highlighted by calculating (p−n)(p-n) and nHn_H in Cu3_3P as a function of Fermi level (Figure 7(b)). The discrepancy between (p−n)(p-n) and nHn_H is particularly evident in materials predicted to be semimetallic, (like Cu3_3P) because of the comparable concentrations of electrons and holes. Some counterintuitive features arise from this effect: 1) the Hall carrier concentration is predicted to always be above 1.5×10211.5 \times10^{21} cm−3^{-3} even when the net carrier concentration is very low; 2) the Hall carrier concentration is expected to diverge about 10 meV above the intrinsic Fermi level; 3) there is a small Fermi level range where the simulations predict that Cu3_3P will appear as p-type from a Hall measurement, even though electrons are more abundant than holes. These points are further discussed in the Supporting Information.

The calculated Seebeck coefficient SS changes sign at roughly the same Fermi level as RHR_H (Figure 7(a)). When both electrons and holes contribute to the conductivity

S=pμhSh+nμeSepμh+nμe(2)S = \frac{p\mu_hS_h+n\mu_eS_e}{p\mu_h+n\mu_e} \tag*{(2)}

where ShS_h (positive) and SeS_e (negative) are the Seebeck coefficients for holes and electrons alone, respectively.59 As expected, lowering and raising the Fermi level in the simulation leads to positive and negative Seebeck coefficients, respectively. In summary, a Hall effect measurement and a thermovoltage measurement on a Cu3−x_{3-x}P sample are expected to yield the same conductivity type.

Comparison with experiment

The experimentally measured Hall carrier concentration at 300 K (3.81×1021 cm−33.81 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) corresponds to a Fermi level 0.41 eV below the intrinsic Fermi level according to Figure 7(b). The experimental and calculated Seebeck coefficients at this Fermi level (+11.2 µV/K and +16.6 µV/K, respectively) are in reasonable agreement. This is also visualized in the Pisarenko plot (Seebeck coefficient versus carrier concentration) in Figure 7(c).

Our experimental results are consistent with the presence of approximately one Cu vacancy per 24-atom unit cell, for two reasons. First, we expect the Fermi level of Cu3−x_{3-x}P with 1 VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell to lie about 0.3 eV lower than the Fermi level of pristine Cu3_3P. This Fermi level position is estimated by aligning the localized Cu 3d states of the respective band structures,[26] following a standard methodology used in band alignment measurements by photoemission spectroscopy.60 The magnitude of the Fermi level shift is confirmed by quantifying the blue shift of the absorption coefficient spectrum of doped Cu3−x_{3-x}P versus pristine Cu3_3P (Figure 8(e), discussed later).

Optical properties of Cu3−xP films

Figure 8. Optical properties of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films. (a,b): Real (ε1\varepsilon_1) and imaginary part (ε2\varepsilon_2) of the dielectric function. Experimental spectra were measured by ellipsometry. Simulated spectra were calculated by DFT on intrinsic Cu3_3P and on doped Cu2.83_{2.83}P with 1 VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell. (c): NIR absorbance derived from transmission and reflection measurements. Previously reported absorbances of Cu3−x_{3-x}P nanoparticles[24, 26, 29] are also shown. (d): Photon energy of the peak found in experimental ε2\varepsilon_2 spectra (see Figure S6) as a function of deposition temperature. The shift in peak energy is attributed to a Burstein-Moss shift. (e): Absorption coefficient α\alpha. The experimental α\alpha from a high-resistivity Cu3−x_{3-x}P film is compared to the DFT-calculated α\alpha for intrinsic Cu3_3P (“low or no doping” label). The experimental α\alpha from a low-resistivity Cu3−x_{3-x}P film is compared to the DFT-calculated α\alpha for doped Cu2.83_{2.83}P (“high doping” label). (e, inset): Comparison of experimental and calculated α\alpha spectra in the IR. One calculated spectrum (dashed line) only includes interband transitions. The other calculated spectrum (dotted line) includes both intraband and interband transitions.

Second, the hole concentration corresponding to one ionized Cu vacancy per unit cell (3.3×1021 cm−33.3 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) minus the intrinsic free electrons concentration (3×1020 cm−33 \times10^{20}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) is 3.0×1021 cm−33.0 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}. This value is close to the experimentally determined Hall carrier concentration of 3.8×1021 cm−33.8 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} at 300 K (Figure 6(a)). At these p-type doping levels, p≫np \gg n and the Hall carrier concentration closely follows the net carrier concentration (Figure 7(b)). Hence, interpreting Hall effect data assuming a single carrier type is justified and the Hall mobility (Figure 6(b)) should reflect the mobility of holes. The experimentally-observed decrease in Hall hole concentration with decreasing temperature is confirmed by Boltzmann transport theory, although not quantitatively. A more detailed discussion is given in the Supporting Information. To conclude, the electrical properties of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films are generally compatible with a semimetallic band structure.

Optical properties

Optical signatures of semimetallicity

The optical properties of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films provide additional evidence that Cu3−x_{3-x}P is a semimetal rather than a semiconductor. The real and imaginary part of the dielectric function (ε1\varepsilon_1 and ε2\varepsilon_2, respectively) were measured on a low-resistivity films by ellipsometry (Figure 8(a,Figure 8b)). When the photon energy decreases from the visible to the infrared (IR), ε1\varepsilon_1 becomes negative and ε2\varepsilon_2 increases, as expected for a material with a high concentration of free carriers.

We also calculated the dielectric function by DFT using linear response theory and the random phase approximation61 (details in the Supporting Information). The calculation on intrinsic Cu3_3P is in reasonably good agreement with the experimental spectra (Figure 8(a,Figure 8b)). However, the sign change of ε1\varepsilon_1 in the IR occurs at ∼\sim0.5 eV lower photon energy than in the experimental spectrum. This may be due to the higher carrier concentration in the experimental sample (∼4×1021 cm−3\sim4 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) than in the intrinsic Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_3\mathrm{P} system considered in the calculation (∼3×1020 cm−3\sim3 \times10^{20}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}, see previous section). To test this hypothesis, we repeated the dielectric function calculation on structurally-relaxed Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P} with one Cu vacancy per unit cell. Indeed, the sign change of ε1\varepsilon_1 shifts to higher photon energies, and the agreement with experiment becomes very good over the whole 0.7 eV–6.5 eV spectral range (Figure 8(a,Figure 8b)). Again, we emphasize that the calculated dielectric functions were derived from semimetallic Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}. Thus, the agreement between experiment and theory is a further indication that Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films are intrinsically semimetallic rather than semiconducting. In addition, the calculation on defective Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P} confirms that Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} thin films are p-type doped by about one Cu vacancy per unit cell.

Near-infrared response

To obtain more experimental information on the optical properties of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films in the near infrared (NIR), we determined their absorbance from transmission and reflection measurements with an extended IR range (Figure 8(c)). Interestingly, the films exhibit a NIR absorption peak rather than the continuously increasing absorbance with decreasing photon energy characteristic of free carrier absorption. The peak maximum is around 1.7 μ\mum (0.73 eV). As shown in Figure 8(c), the peak position and width are compatible with previous reports of a localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) peak in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} nanoparticles[24, 26] [62], although its intensity relative to the main absorption band in the visible is lower than the LSPR peak.

Since our sample is a continuous film rather than disconnected nanoparticles, the NIR peak might be due to a (non-localized) surface plasmon polariton (SPP) instead of a LSPR. Surface plasmons cannot be excited by light at perfectly planar surfaces due to the requirement of momentum conservation between the plasmon and the photon.63 However, the presence of substantial surface roughness can relax this requirement, so SPPs have been observed, for example, in rough Ag films by simple reflection measurements.63,64

A problem with the interpretation of the NIR peak as a SPP is that this peak is observed in all our measured Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} samples – even in thinner films processed at room temperature, which have very low surface roughness. An alternative interpretation of the NIR peak is offered by plotting DFT-calculated absorption coefficients (Figure 8(e)), which do not include any plasmonic effects and are only representative of the bulk optical properties of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}. Intriguingly, the calculations for both intrinsic Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_3\mathrm{P} and p-type doped Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P} reveal a peak

centered at around 0.6 eV photon energy. When only interband transitions are included in the calculation on doped Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P} (inset of Figure 8(e), green dashed line), the NIR peak is still present but the absorption coefficient approaches zero at zero photon energy. When both interband and intraband transitions are included in the calculation (inset of Figure 8(e), blue dotted line), the NIR peak exists on top of an additional background of increasing absorption coefficient with decreasing photon energy. This background is due to free carrier absorption. Note that this free carrier absorption background occurs at much lower photon energies in intrinsic Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_3\mathrm{P} (below 0.3 eV in intrinsic Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_3\mathrm{P}; below 1.2 eV in doped Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P}) as expected from Drude theory.

To sum up, the NIR peak in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} is likely due to bulk interband transitions, which are independent of both plasmonic effects and the free carrier density. A simultaneous SPP response in the same spectral range cannot be excluded but it is difficult to deconvolve, due to overlap with the bulk response. The findings presented in this section can help rationalize why the NIR peak in thin films is much less intense than in nanoparticles, and why the absorbance sharply decreases again at longer wavelengths in nanoparticles but not in films (Figure 8(c)). The first effect occurs because the NIR peak has a different origin in the two cases (bulk interband transitions in the films, LSPR in the nanoparticles). The second effect occurs because intraband transitions in very small nanoparticles are obscured by their intense surface plasmonic response. This does not occur in a thicker film free of quantum confinement effects.

Burstein-Moss shift

Comparing again the measured absorption coefficients of the two Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films shown in Figure 8(e), we notice that the higher-doping (lower-resistivity) film exhibits an overall blue-shift of the absorption coefficient spectrum at all measured photon energies (Figure 8(e)). This effect is not related to absorption by free carriers or plasmons. Instead, it has a similar origin as the Burstein-Moss effect observed in degenerately doped semiconductors.65,66 It is caused by the lowering of the Fermi level with increasing p-type doping. The lower Fermi level causes optical transitions to collectively shift to higher photon energies, because the initial states of the transitions are shifted to deeper energies in the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} band structure, so higher-energy transitions are required to reach the same final states. Similar to other optical features of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}, the Burstein-Moss shift is also predicted by DFT, as evident by comparing the measured and calculated absorption coefficients in Figure 8(e).

We quantified the Burstein-Moss shift in the lowest-resistivity films at each deposition temperature by finding the photon energy at which their ε2\varepsilon_2 has a maximum (Figure S6). The Burstein-Moss shift become progressively larger as the temperature increases (Figure 8(d)), indicating that films deposited at higher temperatures are more p-type. This result shows that the electrically-probed decrease in resistivity with deposition temperature (Figure 5(b)) is at least partially due to an increase in hole concentration. It also shows that the increase in resistivity at 530 °C deposition temperature (Figure 5(b)) is due to a decrease in mobility, probably due to cracks in the films. If it were due to a decrease in hole concentration, the Burstein-Moss shift would not keep increasing at this temperature. The continuously increasing hole concentration with deposition temperature follows the previously predicted increase in Cu vacancy concentration with temperature beyond 1 VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell using Boltzmann statistics.[26]

Ellipsometry-measured imaginary part of the dielectric function $\varepsilon_2$ versus photon energy (eV) at 25 °C, 220 °C, 370 °C, 450 °C, and 530 °C

Figure S6. Ellipsometry-measured imaginary part of the dielectric function (ε2\varepsilon_2) for the lowest-resistivity sample at each deposition temperature. The position of the maximum occurring between 2 eV and 3 eV photon energy is used to plot Figure 8(d) in the main article. The blue-shift of this maximum, and the blue-shift of the onset of the increase in ε2\varepsilon_2 around 1.5 eV, are indications of a Burstein-Moss effect caused by the increasing hole concentration with increasing deposition temperature.

Finally, we note that the difference in Burstein-Moss shift between the films with the smallest and largest shifts (deposited at room temperature and 530 °C respectively) is 0.32 eV. This result is compatible with our calculations of carrier concentration versus Fermi level, which predicted a lowering of the Fermi level by 0.415 eV between intrinsic Cu3_3P and Cu3−x_{3-x}P with nH=3.8×1021 cm−3n_{\mathrm{H}} = 3.8 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} (Figure 7(b)). It is also compatible with the ∼0.3 eV Fermi level down-shift extracted from the previously calculated band structure of Cu2.83_{2.83}P with 1 VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell.[26]

Discussion

Effect of PH3_3 plasma on sputter deposition of Cu3−x_{3-x}P

Five important roles of PH3_3 in the sputter deposition of Cu3−x_{3-x}P can be identified. First, PH3_3 is a source of P that enables growth of Cu3−x_{3-x}P from a metallic Cu target. Second, the presence of PH3_3 counteracts the tendency of Cu3−x_{3-x}P to decompose at elevated temperatures, enabling relatively high-temperature deposition where large crystal grains, c-axis texturing, and a higher VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration can be achieved. Third, a very broad range of Cu/P ratios can be obtained at room temperature (Figure 5(a)), where P losses are minor. This possibility has allowed us to grow polycrystalline CuP2_2 films by a two-step process.12 Fourth, PH3_3 assists the crystallization of Cu3−x_{3-x}P even at room temperature, where films sputtered in pure Ar are amorphous (Figure 2). This effect is presumably caused by bombardment of the growing film by energetic species formed from the dissociation of PH3_3 in an RF plasma.40 Fifth, the net concentration of electrically-active defects can be tuned by adjusting the PH3_3 partial pressure, independently on the film composition (Figure 5(c)). This effect is a reminder that equilibrium defect concentrations ultimately depend on chemical potentials and not directly on film composition. These beneficial features demonstrate that reactive RF sputtering is a highly versatile route for both fundamental studies of new phosphides and their technological development.

Structural-electrical property relationships

In Figure 4, we identified large variations in lattice constants and preferential orientation in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films processed under different conditions. Here, we investigate possible relationships between these structural trends and the electrical properties of the films. In general, the lattice constants of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films tend to decrease with increasing electrical conductivity. This behavior is shown in Figure 9(a) by measuring the (113) plane spacing in combinatorial samples with different conductivities. As noted earlier in this article, changes in the interplanar spacing in other directions indicate an overall unit cell contraction or expansion in all directions, rather than strain in one particular direction.

Figure 9. Relationships between structural and electrical properties in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films. (a): Spacing between (113) planes (determined from XRD peak position) as a function of measured conductivity. Also shown is the DFT-calculated (113) plane spacing for the case of zero, half, and one Cu vacancy per 24-atom unit cell. The conductivity axis and the VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration axis are linked by assuming a constant mobility of 29 cm2^2/Vs Figure 6(b). (b): The P63_3cm crystal structure of Cu3_3P.67 The unit cell and the energetically preferred site for VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} are shown. (c): Experimentally measured resistivity as a function of the estimated c-axis texture coefficient. A coefficient of one indicates that the resistivity in the abab-plane is probed. A coefficient of zero indicates that the resistivity in a cc-axis-containing plane is probed. Only films deposited at 220 °C with 2.90 < Cu/P < 2.96 are considered. The average conductivity effective mass of Cu3−x_{3-x}P in the probed transport plane is also plotted versus the texture coefficient, showing that the changes in conductivity can be explained by changes in the effective mass with lattice direction.

A simple explanation for this phenomenon is that the unit cell contracts when Cu vacancies are formed. Unit cell contraction is expected since the atoms surrounding the Cu vacancy can be packed closer together due to the free space left by the missing Cu atom. Very limited charge transfer is expected between Cu and P, due to the semimetallic (rather than ionic) nature of Cu3−x_{3-x}P. Hence, the counteracting effect of anion-anion repulsion, which may lead to unit cell expansion, is likely negligible. To verify this behavior, we employed DFT to calculate the equilibrium lattice constants of Cu3−x_{3-x}P in the presence of zero, half, and one Cu vacancy per unit cell. The Cu vacancy was placed in one of the symmetry-equivalent Cu(1) lattice sites following Olofsson’s notation.13 This site is indicated in Figure 9(b) and was previously found to be the most energetically favorable site for CuCu_{\mathrm{Cu}}.[26] As expected, the structure relaxes to lower lattice constants with increasing VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration. For one vacancy per unit cell, the aa, bb, cc axes decrease by 0.56%, 0.65%, 0.63% with respect to the intrinsic cell, respectively. The resulting (113) plane spacing for the calculated structures is shown in Figure 9(a) as a function of VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration. The rate of change in the interplanar spacing is in quantitative agreement with the experimental behavior. The overall overestimation of lattice constants is a known problem of the PBE functional used for the relaxation.68 This result substantiates the hypotheses that (i) changes in VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration are the main source of conductivity changes in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films; and (ii) the estimate of 1–1.5 VCuV_{\mathrm{Cu}} per unit cell for the most electrically conductive films is reasonable.

Clearly, the decrease in lattice constants with increasing conductivity is only a rough experimental trend. Other factors such as defect compensation and variations in mobility are likely to affect the conductivity of a given film. For example, we may expect different hole mobilities μ\mu in the abab-plane and along the cc-axis, since the P63_3cm structure of Cu3−x_{3-x}P is uniaxially anisotropic (Figure 9(b)). Under a p-type doping density of 3×1021 cm−33 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} at room temperature, we find a conductivity effective mass of 0.54mem_{\mathrm{e}} in the abab-plane and of 1.28mem_{\mathrm{e}} along the cc-axis by applying Boltzmann transport theory. Assuming a direction-independent carrier scattering time τ\tau, one would expect the resistivity ρ\rho to be proportional to the effective mass m∗m^* in the transport direction, due to the ρ∝μ−1∝m∗\rho\propto\mu^{-1} \propto m^* relationships. To test this hypothesis, we consider the Cu3−x_{3-x}P samples deposited at 220 °C. They were grown in the same deposition run, have similar composition (Cu2.90_{2.90}P–Cu2.96_{2.96}P), but have large differences in orientation with respect to the substrate depending on the prevalence of Cu3−x_{3-x}P formation at the target or at the substrate (Figure S3). Indeed, we find that the resistivity measured in the plane of the substrate is proportional to the average effective mass in the plane of the substrate, derived from the estimated texture coefficient (Figure 9(c)). This correlation provides experimental evidence for enhanced hole mobility in the abab plane, and is an indirect indication that the carrier scattering time at room temperature is not strongly direction-dependent.

Consequences of nonstoichiometry

We have seen that the net concentration of acceptor defects increases with deposition temperature (Figure 5(b), Figure 8(d)) and PH3_3 partial pressure (Figure 5(c)). We have also gathered substantial evidence that these acceptors are Cu vacancies. However, an apparent discrepancy requires further discussion. A large fraction of films are expected to have a VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration between 1 and 1.5 per unit cell (Figure 6(a), Figure 9(a)). These concentrations would correspond to Cu/P ratios between 2.75 and 2.83 in films without secondary phases or compensating defects. Yet, the most P-rich composition obtained in low-resistivity films is Cu2.87_{2.87}P. This compositional discrepancy is only 4% and may well be due to a small systematic error in the evaluation of elemental composition (see the Supporting Information). However, we also find that the electrical resistivity and the overall composition in the 2.95 < Cu/P < 3.05 range are completely uncorrelated. This finding cannot be explained by measurement errors, because we estimate the error of relative composition measurements to be lower than 1% (more details in the Supporting Information).

A possible explanation is the existence of metallic Cu secondary phases for Cu/P > 2.75, so even in highly P-rich films. As discussed in the Supporting Information, this mechanism is incompatible with other experimental observations in this study. The presence of other point defects beyond Cu vacancies could be an alternative explanation for the composition-independent resistivity around the stoichiometric point. As discussed in the Supporting Information, different types of defects could potentially explain the experimental results – either extrinsic impurities or native defects, and either donor- or charge-neutral defects. Some defects that would be compatible with our results are CuP_{\mathrm{P}} (either donors or neutrals), Hi_i donors, or HCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} neutrals. Hydrogen-related defects may result from H incorporation in a reactive film deposition process involving PH3_3 such as ours.69 A more extensive qualitative discussion of possible defects is given in the Supporting Information.

Besides point defects, there are other mechanisms that may change the overall film composition without changing the net dopant concentration. They are intermediate between formation of isolated point defects and segregation of secondary phases. One mechanism is the formation of Cu-rich donor-acceptor defect clusters such as (VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} + CuP_{\mathrm{P}}). Another possible mechanism is extended clustering driven by entropy.70 A dedicated study of de‑ fect energetics in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} may help clarify which mechanism is dominant.

On the previous identification of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a semiconductor

As mentioned earlier in this article, many authors have identified Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a degenerately doped semiconductor, rather than a (semi)metal.[24, 26, 28, 29, 30, 33] [16] In many of these studies, the characterized samples were Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} nanoparticles or nanoplatelets with characteristic size of less than 10 nm. In these cases, it is possible that size effects (quantum confinement) result in the opening of a band gap in an otherwise (semi)metallic system. A similar effect is known for 1T1T-TiS2\mathrm{TiS}_{2}.71 However, the results of our study demonstrate that many criteria previously used to assign semiconducting behavior to Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} are not at all incompatible with a semimetal.

For example, several studies identified Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a semiconductor with a band gap in the 0.8 eV0.8\,\mathrm{eV}–1.7 eV1.7\,\mathrm{eV} range.[28, 30, 33] [16] This assignment was justified by the observation of an absorption onset in this photon energy range. However, Figure 8(e) demonstrates that the photon energy of the absorption onset is not related to a band gap, but it depends instead on the energy at which interband absorption becomes dominant over intraband (free-carrier) absorption. The photon energy of this apparent ”band gap” ultimately depends on the free carrier density in the semimetal. In a hypothetical Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} sample without free carriers, the absorption coefficient only approaches zero at zero photon energy (inset of Figure 8(e), green dashed line).

In other cases, identification of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as semiconductor was based on the detection of a positive Seebeck coefficient[26] or of a photovoltaic effect.[24] However, Boltzmann transport theory predicts positive Seebeck coefficients in semimetallic Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P}, both under intrinsic- and pp-type-doped conditions (Figure 7(a)). Many elemental metals also have positive Seebeck coefficients.55 A photovoltaic effect was observed in a Cu3−xP/CdS\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}/\mathrm{CdS} heterojunction.[24] However, CdS is itself a photovoltaic material and the reported photovoltaic parameters are compatible with a CdS-based solar cell in which Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} acts as a contact. In particular, the reported short-current density of 2.7 mA/cm22.7\,\mathrm{mA}/\mathrm{cm}^{2} is well within the Shockley-Queisser limit72 of 7.5 mA/cm27.5\,\mathrm{mA}/\mathrm{cm}^{2} for a CdS cell assuming a 2.4 eV2.4\,\mathrm{eV} band gap for CdS.73 In fact, Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} has recently been incorporated into a ZnSnP2\mathrm{ZnSnP}_{2} solar cell,[22] but rather as a hole contact than as an absorber.

Finally, one computational study found a small – but non-zero – band gap in pristine Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} by first-principles calculations using hybrid exchange correlation functionals and a Gaussian basis set.74 A band gap of 0.68 eV0.68\,\mathrm{eV} was obtained with the PBE0 functional, and a 0.18 eV0.18\,\mathrm{eV} gap was obtained with the HSE06 functional. However, unusually large values of the on-site Hubbard repulsion (UU) were necessary to reproduce these band gaps by the DFT+U approach75 using a plane wave basis set. It is also unusual that Hubbard repulsion had to be added on the P 3p orbitals rather than just on the Cu 3d orbitals. Most importantly, the complex dielectric function calculated from the DFT+U band structure in the same study74 is incompatible with our present experimental results. As an example, the constant value of the calculated ε1\varepsilon_{1} (around 4) up to 4 eV photon energy74 is in stark contrast with the high dispersion of the experimental ε1\varepsilon_{1} (Figure 8(a)) in this spectral region (negative, up to 15, and negative again).

To summarize this section, there is no conclusive evidence in favor of identification of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as a semiconductor without invoking quantum confinement effects.

Conclusion

We found strong evidence that reactively sputtered Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films are natively-doped pp-type semimetals over a broad composition- and process parameter range. Unlike the case of non-reactive sputtering, Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films could be synthesized at temperatures significantly higher than 200 °C, where a higher density of native acceptors can be stabilized and, therefore, the pp-type conductivity can be higher. We achieved room-temperature electrical resistivities down to 4.6×10−5 Ω cm4.6 \times10^{-5}\,\Omega\,\mathrm{cm}, the lowest reported for Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} samples in any form.

In films deposited at temperatures above 370 °C, the single-phase region of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} is likely not wider than the Cu2.9P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.9}\mathrm{P}–Cu3.0P\mathrm{Cu}_{3.0}\mathrm{P} composition range. However, we found some indications that polycrystalline Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films deposited at room-temperature may tolerate a higher deviation from stoichiometry on Cu-rich side (x<0x < 0).

The decreasing resistivity with increasing PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3} partial pressure, the preference for Cu-deficient compositions, and the unit cell contraction with decreasing resistivity substantiated the hypothesis that Cu vacancies are responsible for pp-type conductivity in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}. pp-type conductivity was retained even when Cu/P>3\mathrm{Cu}/\mathrm{P} > 3, indicating that Cu vacancies are more stable than any compensating donor even under Cu-rich conditions. Interestingly, stoichiometric defect-free Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} is also predicted to be a semimetal by DFT, though with a much lower carrier concentration and a net excess of electrons rather than holes. This ”intrinsic” Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P} may be very challenging to synthesize due to the high stability of Cu vacancies under all process conditions.

Despite the very high concentration of native dopants, the high mobility of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films at low temperatures (276 cm2/Vs276\,\mathrm{cm}^{2}/\mathrm{Vs} at 10 K) points to surprisingly low ionized scattering rates. By studying transport properties as a function of lattice direction, we observed anisotropy in the electrical conductivity of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}, with higher conductivities achieved along the abab-plane. This trend is in quantitative agreement with the expected inverse proportionality between hole effective masses (higher in the cc-axis direction) and hole mobility.

A NIR absorption feature somewhat similar to the previously identified LSPR peak of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} nanoparticles was found. Curiously, DFT calculations indicate that the interband transitions intrinsic to bulk Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} also give rise to an absorption peak in that spectral region. In thin-film samples, interband transitions are a more likely explanation for the experimentally observed peak, rather than a plasmonic response. Finally, Fermi level lowering in increasingly doped Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films gave rise an optical effect equivalent to the Burstein-Moss shift. From this effect, the carrier concentration can in principle be estimated from a simple optical transmission measurement.

Acknowledgments

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No 840751 (synthesis, characterization, simulation, and data analysis work). This work was authored in part at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, operated by Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC, for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. Funding supporting development and operation of synthesis and characterization equipment was provided by the Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences. We acknowledge Karen N. Heinselman for evaporation of metal contacts and RBS measurements. A.C. is grateful to Søren Raza, Mark K. Svendsen, and Francesco Ricci for useful feedback on optical properties, DFT calculations, and transport calculations.

Experimental details

Film growth

Amorphous and polycrystalline Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} thin films were deposited by radio-frequency (RF) sputtering, either by non-reactive sputtering in pure Ar or by reactive sputtering in PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3}/Ar, with PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3} concentration up to 5%. The sputter system (PVD Products) had a base pressure in the 10−710^{-7} Torr range. A Cu target (K. J. Lesker Company) and a Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} target (Princeton Scientific) were employed simultaneously. Both targets were 2″ in diameter, 0.25″ in thickness, and 99.99% pure. The two targets were co-sputtered at 5 mTorr total pressure, with RF powers of 40 W (Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} target) and 20 W (Cu target). The target-substrate distance was 16 cm and the deposition rate was about 0.7 Å s−1^{-1}. The deposition temperature was measured at the metallic platen onto which the substrates were clamped during deposition. In each deposition process, a film was simultaneously grown on two Corning Eagle XG borosilicate glass substrates placed next to each other, covering a total area of 10×510 \times5 cm2^{2}. The targets were oriented so that one of the short edges of the total substrate area would mainly be coated by the Cu target and the other short edge by the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} target. In this way, it was possible to obtain combinatorial gradients in film composition (Cu/P ratio) approximately parallel to the long edge. This combinatorial effect is evident in Figure 1(b) of the main article. Each data point, spectrum, and XRD pattern in the main article corresponds to one specific point in the combinatorial films, which has its unique composition and properties. This combinatorial data was managed with the COMBIgor tool,1 the Research Data Infrastructure,2 and was integrated into the High-Throughput Experimental Materials Database.3 The thickness of each film varied by about 10–15% across the long direction (10 cm long). The thickness of all films considered in this study was between 200 nm and 300 nm.

Film characterization

Elemental composition and film thickness were determined by x-ray fluorescence (XRF) in a Bruker Tornado M4 instrument at 15 Torr pressure using a Rh source. XRF spectra were fitted with the Bruker XMethod analysis program. The XRF data was calibrated by Rutherford backscattering spectroscopy (RBS) measurements of separate Cu-P films of different thicknesses and compositions deposited on Si. These RBS measurements and the calibration were described in a previous publication.4 The accuracy of RBS in determining composition is around 3%.5 However, there are other possible sources of error. One of them is the extra calibration step required to obtain composition information from XRF spectra. The other is the use of silicon substrates (rather than the glass substrates used for the rest of the characterization) for the calibration. Taking these factors into account, we estimate an overall systematic error in the ±5% range for the Cu/P ratios quoted in the main article. We expect the random error in the determination of composition by XRF to be much lower than 5%. The total x-ray counts in XRF measurements were sufficiently high to ensure better than 1% reproducibility. Variations in film thickness could be a source of ”random” error in the extracted composition. However, the films have rather similar thicknesses and there were no noticeable correlations between thickness and the extracted Cu/P ratios. Finally, a systematic error in the ±5% range can be assumed for the thickness determined by XRF. This error comes from uncertainty in modeling surface roughness when fitting RBS spectra, from film porosity (resulting in lower density than in ideal Cu3P\mathrm{Cu}_{3}\mathrm{P}) and from the XRF calibration step. The main consequence of this error is that it propagates to the resistivity. Hence, we also estimate a systematic error in the ±5% range for resistivity, Hall carrier concentration, and Hall mobility.

XRD measurements were conducted with a Bruker D8 diffractometer using Cu Kα_{\alpha} radiation and a 2D detector. To cover the desired 2θ2\theta range, two frames were collected with the incidence angle ω\omega fixed at 10∘10^\circ and 22.5∘22.5^\circ, and the detector center fixed at 2θ2\theta values of 35∘35^\circ and 60∘60^\circ, respectively. The diffraction intensity at each 2θ2\theta angle was integrated over the χ\chi range measured by the 2D detector. Since reflections from a range of 2θ2\theta angles are measured in parallel by the 2D detector, this XRD measurement is not strictly in the Bragg-Brentano configuration and the lattice planes probed by XRD are not strictly parallel to the substrate plane. However, the angles between the probed lattice planes and the substrate plane are rather small (in the 0°–19° range depending on the value of 2θ2\theta with respect to the detector’s center). Thus, we make the approximation that the lattice planes corresponding to XRD reflections are parallel to the plane of the substrate.

The cc-axis texture coefficient (TCTC) was estimated as

TC=I(113)I0(113)I(113)I0(113)+I(300)I0(300)(3)TC = \frac{\frac{I(113)}{I_0(113)}}{\frac{I(113)}{I_0(113)}+\frac{I(300)}{I_0(300)}} \tag*{(3)}

where I(113)I(113) and I(300)I(300) are the integrated intensities of the (113) and (300) peaks in the thin film, and I0(113)I_0(113) and I0(300)I_0(300) are the integrated intensities of the (113) and (300) peaks in a randomly oriented Cu3−x_{3-x}P powder, taken from Olofsson’s work.11 With this definition, a film with the (113) planes perfectly parallel to the substrate has a texture coefficient of 1, and a film with (300) planes perfectly parallel to the substrate has a texture coefficient of 0. Note that the [001] direction, rather than the [113] direction, corresponds to the cc-axis of the lattice. The reason for using the (113) peak rather than the (002) peak at ∼24.9∘\sim24.9^\circ 2θ2\theta for texture analysis is that the (002) reflection is very weak and not detectable in many samples (see Figure 2 in the main article). Conversely, the (113) reflections are detected in all samples and form a relatively small angle (18∘18^\circ) with the ideal (001) planes. Considering the two approximations described above, our derived texture coefficient should only be taken as a semi-quantitative estimation, so it is labeled ”estimated texture coefficient” in the figures of the main article. Nevertheless, the conclusions drawn in the article on the basis of the texture coefficient are also semi-quantitative. Hence, our approximations do not affect the high-level conclusions on preferential orientation (Figure 4(b) of the main article) and direction-dependent conductivity (Figure 9(c) of the main article).

Raman spectra were measured with a Renishaw inVia Raman microscope under laser light excitation at 532 nm wavelength with a 100× objective. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images were taken with a Hitachi S-3400N instrument with a field emission gun and 5 kV beam voltage.

Sheet resistance was measured in the substrate plane with a collinear four-point probe directly contacting the film. The sheet resistance was derived by multiplying the raw ohmic resistance by π/ln⁡(2)\pi/\ln(2), as appropriate for the collinear geometry. The electrical resistivity was derived by multiplying the sheet resistance by the XRF-determined thickness. Temperature-dependent Hall carrier concentration and mobility were measured in the substrate plane with a Lake Shore 8425 DC Hall System using the van der Pauw configuration. The Cu3−x_{3-x}P film employed for this measurement was deposited through a shadow mask to obtain a Hall cross shape, and Ti/Pt contacts were evaporated at the edges of the cross. The DC driving current and magnetic fields were 1 mA and 2 T respectively. The Hall voltage at each temperature was determined as the average of 8 measurements, by reversing sign of the current and of the magnetic field, and by considering two non-equivalent contact geometries. The Seebeck coefficient of an unpatterned sample with about the same electrical resistivity was measured in a custom-built setup using In contacts and four temperature differences in the vicinity of room temperature.

The complex dielectric function was extracted by spectroscopic ellipsometry using a J.A. Woollam M-2000 ellipsometer and three incidence angles. We modeled the system as a glass substrate of known optical functions, a Cu3−x_{3-x}P layer of unknown optical functions, and a roughness layer treated with Bruggeman effective medium theory. The optical functions of Cu3−x_{3-x}P were represented by a Kramers–Kronig-consistent b-spline function with 0.1 nodes/eV. The samples analyzed in this study were too absorbing and too thick for ellipsometry to yield thickness information (no light reflected from the film/glass interface). Hence, we fixed the Cu3−x_{3-x}P thickness to the XRF-measured value in the ellipsometry model. Ellipsometry spectra were fitted with the CompleteEASE software (J.A. Woollam). The absorption coefficient was derived from the complex dielectric function using standard optical relations. The absorbance shown in Figure 8(c) of the main article was derived by measuring transmission TT at normal incidence and reflection RR at near-normal incidence with a Cary 7000 spectrophotometer. The measurement was performed with an integrating sphere to include the diffuse component of both transmission and reflection. The absorbance AA was extracted as

A=−log⁡10(T1−R)(4)A = -\log_{10}\left(\frac{T}{1-R}\right) \tag*{(4)}

Computational details

Density functional theory calculations

First-principles calculations were performed using Density Functional Theory (DFT) within the Projector-Augmented Wave (PAW) formalism6 and a plane-wave basis set as implemented in the GPAW code,7,8 in combination with the Atomic Simulation Environment (ASE).9 The Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) exchange correlation functional10 was employed for structural relaxation. The plane-wave cutoff and k\mathbf{k}-mesh density were 450 eV and 8×8×48\times8\times4, respectively. The structures were relaxed until the forces were less than 0.05 eV/Å. For the calculations on Cu3−x_{3-x}P with one Cu vacancy/unit cell, the vacancy was introduced at one of the symmetry-equivalent Cu(1) sites (one of the two inequivalent sites at 6c Wyckoff positions), according to the notation of Olofsson.11 For the calculations on Cu3−x_{3-x}P with half a Cu vacancy/unit cell, a 2×1×12 \times1 \times1 (48-atom) supercell was constructed with a Cu vacancy at one of the Cu(1) sites.

Ground-state electronic structure calculations were performed with the GLLB-SC exchange correlation functional12,13 with a plane-wave cutoff of 450 eV and a k-mesh density of 16×16×816 \times16 \times8. Kramers-Kronig-consistent dielectric function spectra were calculated by linear response theory within the Random Phase Approximation (RPA) including local field effects, as implemented in GPAW. The absorption coefficient was derived from the dielectric function using standard relations.

Semiclassical transport calculations

Temperature- and doping density-dependent transport properties of Cu3−x_{3-x}P were estimated using Boltzmann transport theory as implemented in BoltzTraP2.14 The input of the calculations was an interpolation of the previously calculated PBE band structure of Cu3_3P available on the Materials Project database (mp-7463).15,16 The BoltzTraP2 code was interfaced with Materials Project through the pymatgen package.17,18 A constant carrier scattering time of 10 fs was assumed for all bands at all energies. The effective masses quoted in the main article are the eigenvalues of the conductivity effective mass tensor, calculated at a temperature of 300 K under a net p-type doping density of 3×1021 cm−33 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}. Assuming a hole mobility μ\mu of 29 cm2^2/Vs as measured by Hall effect (Figure 6(b), main article), a 10 fs scattering time τ\tau corresponds to a hole effective mass m∗m^* of 0.61 me0.61\,m_e using the relation μ=eτ/m∗\mu= e\tau/m^*. This value is close to the calculated effective mass of 0.54 me0.54\,m_e in the abab-plane of doped Cu3_3P at room temperature. These considerations justify the choice of the carrier scattering time.

The effective mass as a function of texture coefficient TCTC was estimated by assuming that the aa-axis is always lying on the substrate plane, that the component of the bb-axis vector parallel to the substrate plane is ∣b∣(TC)|b|(TC), and that the component of the cc-axis vector parallel to the substrate plane is ∣c∣(1−TC)|c|(1-TC). With this description, there are two relevant hole effective masses in the substrate plane (which is the transport plane probed by the resistivity measurement). One is ma∗=0.54 mem_a^* = 0.54\,m_e and the other is mb/c∗=(TC)mb∗+(1−TC)mc∗m_{b/c}^* = (TC)m_b^* + (1-TC)m_c^*, where ma∗=mb∗m_a^* = m_b^* due to symmetry, and mc∗=1.28 mem_c^* = 1.28\,m_e is the cc-axis effective mass. The overall effective mass in the substrate plane was simply taken as the arithmetic average between ma∗m_a^* and mb/c∗m_{b/c}^*.

Supplementary discussion

Cu secondary phases in Cu3−x_{3-x}P films

From the experimental data in Figure 1(b) of the main article, we note that the range of Cu-rich (Cu/P >3> 3) compositions free of metallic Cu peaks becomes narrower with increasing PH3_3 partial pressure. This observation can be explained as follows. A substrate reaction (phosphorization of metallic Cu) is dominant at substrate locations closer to the Cu target. Direct transport of Cu3−x_{3-x}P vapor from the target is dominant at substrate locations closer to the Cu3−x_{3-x}P target. As the PH3_3 partial pressure increases, a given Cu/P ratio in the films is obtained at locations closer and closer to the Cu target. Thus, the fraction of the incoming vapor consisting of metallic Cu rather than already-formed Cu3−x_{3-x}P increases. Since an additional reaction at the substrate is necessary to form Cu3−x_{3-x}P from metallic Cu, the segregation of Cu as a polycrystalline impurity is more likely.

Interpretation of Hall carrier concentrations in Cu3−x_{3-x}P

Semiclassical transport simulations have revealed that there can be a major discrepancy between the net carrier concentration (p−n)(p-n) in Cu3−x_{3-x}P and the carrier concentration nHn_H derived from a Hall measurement assuming a single carrier type. The reason the comparable concentrations of electrons and holes in Cu3−x_{3-x}P near its intrinsic Fermi level. The offset between the two quantities is illustrated in Figure 7(b) in the main article. Because of this discrepancy, the values of nHn_H as a function of Fermi level predicted by Boltzmann transport theory can be counterintuitive. Here we provide a list of potentially counterintuitive features.

  1. The calculated ∣nH∣|n_H| is always above 1.5×1021 cm−31.5 \times10^{21}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} regardless of the Fermi level position (Figure 7(b) in the main article). Hence, we expect that a Hall effect measurement on a Cu3−x_{3-x}P film will always indicate very high carrier concentrations nHn_H, even in a hypothetical film with a very low net carrier concentration.

  1. nHn_H diverges at the Fermi level when the numerator of RHR_H approaches zero and changes sign (about 10 meV above the intrinsic Fermi level).

  1. The Fermi level where nHn_H changes sign is ∼70 meV higher than the Fermi level of zero net carrier concentration. This implies that there is a ∼70 meV Fermi level range where Cu3_3P would appear as p-type from a Hall measurement (positive nHn_H), even though electrons are more abundant than holes. Intrinsic, defect-free Cu3_3P is one of such cases (p−n<0p-n<0 but nH>0n_H>0).

  1. If Sh/Se≃μh/μeS_h/S_e \simeq\mu_h/\mu_e, the numerators of Eq. (1) and Eq. (2) in the main article are zero at about the same net carrier concentration. Thus, intrinsic, defect-free Cu3_3P would also appear as p-type in a thermovoltage measurement (positive Seebeck coefficient).

Temperature dependence of carrier concentration in Cu3_3−xP films

The Hall hole concentration of a Cu3−x_{3-x}P film decreases by roughly a factor two with decreasing temperature from 300 K to 10 K (Figure 6(a) in the main article). A small decrease in Hall hole concentration with temperature is also predicted by Boltzmann transport theory on Cu3_3P with a Fermi level at 0.3 eV below the intrinsic value (Figure 6(a), main article). However, the theoretically predicted decrease is much smaller than the experimental one. Possible reasons for this discrepancy could be: (i) entropy-driven formation of additional Cu vacancies with increasing temperature, as quantified before;20 (ii) band structure modifications occurring at such a high defect concentrations; (iii) temperature-driven structural changes accompanied by a rearrangement of Cu vacancies, as previously reported;19 and (iv) a decrease in the Hall scattering factor rr with decreasing temperature. When a single type of carrier is dominant, the Hall carrier concentration is defined as nH=r/eRHn_H=r/eR_H, where RHR_H is the Hall coefficient, ee is the elementary charge, and the Hall scattering factor rr is assumed to be equal to 1.21 The Hall scattering factor depends on the energy dependence of the carrier scattering time (taken as a constant in our Boltzmann transport calculations). Thus, a decrease in Hall hole concentration by a factor 2 from 300 K to 10 K could be explained by a decrease in Hall scattering factor in the same temperature range. A decreasing Hall scattering factor with decreasing temperature occurs, for example, in various metals[22] and in graphene.[23]

Mobility of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films in comparison with other thin-film materials with similar doping levels

The room-temperature mobility of a Cu3−x_{3-x}P film (28.8 cm2^2/Vs) is not unusual for non-epitaxial polycrystalline thin-film materials with carrier concentrations above 102110^{21} cm−3^{-3}, such as transparent conductive oxides and elemental metals. However, the mobility of 276 cm2^2/Vs measured at 10 K is particularly high. Due to the high hole concentration in Cu3−x_{3-x}P, we expect ionized impurity scattering to dominate over grain boundary scattering. We estimated the ionized impurity scattering-limited mobility as μi=279\mu_i=279 cm2^2/Vs by fitting temperature-dependent mobility data (Figure 6(b) of the main article). Here, we compile values of the Hall mobility measured in non-epitaxial polycrystalline thin-film materials with carrier concentrations comparable to Cu3−x_{3-x}P.

In the chemically-related compound CaCuP – a p-type semiconductor degenerately doped by Cu vacancies and also deposited by RF reactive sputtering – μi\mu_i was only 45.2 cm2^2/Vs.[24] This is despite the fact that the hole concentration of CaCuP was over an order of magnitude lower than in Cu3−x_{3-x}P and that its room-temperature mobility was slightly higher (36.4 cm2^2/Vs).

In the heavily-doped (n-type) transparent conductive oxides In2_2O3_3:Sn (ITO) and ZnO:Al (AZO), μi\mu_i was in the 10 cm2^2/Vs–50 cm2^2/Vs range, even though their carrier concentration was lower, in the 102010^{20} cm−3^{-3} range.[25]

Non-epitaxial, n-type films of the doped narrow-gap semiconductors PbTe and Bi2_2Te3_3 deposited by RF sputtering had mobilities of 15 cm2^2/Vs–40 cm2^2/Vs at room temperature, and these mobilities decreased with decreasing temperature.

The low-temperature mobility of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films is even higher than the corresponding mobility of non-epitaxial polycrystalline films of elemental metals. For example, mobilities around 100 cm2^2/Vs were reported for evaporated Cu and Au films on glass at 77 K measurement temperature.[26] The mobility of Cu3−x_{3-x}P films at the same temperature is about 180 cm2^2/Vs (Figure 6(b) of the main article). The mobility measurements on metals were conducted on sufficiently thick films (>>100 nm), in which the mobility was not negatively affected by the limited thickness. Note that Cu and Au have more than an order of magnitude higher carrier concentrations than Cu3−x_{3-x}P, but their carriers are intrinsic instead of being provided by defects.

We emphasize, however, that both elemental metals and doped narrow-gap semiconductors can have much higher low-temperature mobilities (well above 10310^3 cm2^2/Vs) if grown epitaxially or as single crystals.

Possible causes of composition-independent resistivity of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films near Cu/P = 3

The electrical resistivity and the overall composition of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films in the 2.95 < Cu/P < 3.05 range are completely uncorrelated (Figure 5(c), main article). The conceptually simplest explanation for a composition-independent resistivity is the existence of metallic Cu secondary phases for Cu/P > 2.75, so even in highly P-rich films. This hypothesis can be summarized as follows: (i) the films consist of a Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} phase and a Cu phase regardless of the Cu/P ratio; (ii) the point defects present in the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} phase are Cu vacancies; (iii) the composition of the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} phase is dictated by the VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration but not by the overall Cu/P ratio, so for example when 1 VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell, the composition of the Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} phase is Cu2.83P\mathrm{Cu}_{2.83}\mathrm{P}; (iv) the observed variations in the overall composition are caused by varying concentrations of metallic Cu phases depending on process conditions.

A problem with this hypothesis is that we have indeed observed metallic Cu by SEM, but only in films with Cu/P > 3.0 (Figure S2). Another problem is that a film with overall Cu3.00P\mathrm{Cu}_{3.00}\mathrm{P} composition doped with 1.5 VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}}/unit cell would need to contain 6.5% metallic Cu by volume, if Cu secondary phases were fully responsible for deviations in the expected stoichiometry. However, the fraction of the top surface of a Cu3.00P\mathrm{Cu}_{3.00}\mathrm{P} film that is covered by secondary phases visible in the SEM can be estimated as being only 0.6% (Figure S2). Unless metallic Cu preferentially segregates at the bottom of the film, it seems unlikely that all the Cu in excess of the expected Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} composition exists in the form of a secondary phase.

A second possible reason for a composition-independent resistivity near Cu/P = 3 is the existence of additional point defects beyond Cu vacancies. Different types of defects could be plausible candidates for explaining the composition-independent resistivity – either extrinsic impurities or native defects, and either compensating donors or charge-neutral defects.

Native defects

The CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} antisite could be a possible candidate. In the related material CaCuP, defect calculations have shown that CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} can be in the singly or doubly ionized state (donor), or in the neutral state.39 If CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} exists in the singly ionized state in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P}, it may compensate the formation of additional VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} acceptors beyond a certain VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration threshold. Formation of one CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} donor for each VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} acceptor would then keep the resistivity constant, and it would increase the overall Cu/P ratio with increasing defect compensation (one less P atom per pair of compensating defects). Interestingly, in this scenario the Cu/P ratio would increase with increasing VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration at high defect concentrations.

Even if CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} is in the neutral state rather than in the ionized state, it could still be a possible candidate for a composition-independent resistivity. With CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} in the neutral state, an increasing concentration of CuP\mathrm{Cu}_{\mathrm{P}} defects would increase the overall Cu/P ratio (one extra Cu atom and one less P atom per defect) at constant VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration (constant resistivity).

VP\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{P}} donors could, in principle, be another possible compensating defect that would drive the overall composition towards higher Cu/P ratios. However, compensating VP\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{P}} donors would likely result in decreasing unit cell volume with increasing compensation. This would lead to more scattering in the conductivity versus lattice constant data (Figure 9(a)) at high conductivities, which is not observed. Cu interstitials (Cui\mathrm{Cu}_{i}) in the neutral state could also modulate the Cu/P ratio at constant VCu\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration. However, increasing Cui\mathrm{Cu}_{i} concentrations are likely to lead to increasing unit cell volumes. Thus, neither VP\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{P}} donors nor Cui\mathrm{Cu}_{i} neutrals are likely to cause the composition-independent resistivity of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films near the stoichiometric point.

Extrinsic defects

No impurities heavier than Na could be detected in XRF spectra of Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films. Among lighter elements, the only two impurities that may be present in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films at atomic concentrations above 1% are oxygen (from imperfect vacuum in the deposition chamber) and hydrogen (from PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3} decomposition). A small oxygen peak was detected in energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectra of most of our Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} samples, with overall O concentration estimated at below 2 at.%. Hydrogen content in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films could not be measured with the techniques available to us. A previous study on Zn3P2\mathrm{Zn}_{3}\mathrm{P}_{2} films deposited by reactive sputtering at 150 °C in a PH3\mathrm{PH}_{3}-containing atmosphere reported a H content of 4 at.% using secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS).[27] We expect a lower – but not insignificant – hydrogen content in our Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films due to the higher deposition temperature (370 °C), which usually facilitates hydrogen desorption.

Hence, both H and O are likely to be present at low but not negligible concentrations in most our Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} films. In the case that H and O are incorporated in Cu3−xP\mathrm{Cu}_{3-x}\mathrm{P} as point defects, we hypothesize that they are most likely to form interstitials (Hi_{\mathrm{i}} and Oi_{\mathrm{i}}). The reason is their small size compared to both Cu and P, as estimated by their covalent radii.[28] As an exception, the HCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} antisite may also be energetically favorable, due to the high availability of vacant Cu sites in Cu3−x_{3-x}P.

Hi_{\mathrm{i}} is typically found to be a compensating donor in p-type materials.[29] Thus, it is not implausible that Hi_{\mathrm{i}} donors may compensate VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} acceptors above a certain VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration threshold. In this scenario, the decrease in Cu/P ratio from 3.05 to 2.90 in Figure 5(c) of the main article may be due to an increase in VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration, which is however compensated by Hi_{\mathrm{i}} formation leading to a constant resistivity. In this case, the decrease in unit cell size by formation of additional VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} defects may be counteracted by an increase in unit cell size due to an equal concentration of interstitials. A change in Cu/P ratio from 3.05 to 2.90 due to increasing VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration would require H concentrations in the film around 4 at.%, assuming that all H impurities act as Hi_{\mathrm{i}} defects. As mentioned above, it cannot be excluded that our films have a H impurity concentration in this range. Oi_{\mathrm{i}} is rarely found to be a donor in other materials, so it is less likely to explain our experimental results.

If HCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} is a charge-neutral defect (as may be expected from oxidation state arguments), changes in HCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration at constant VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration could also explain the composition-independent resistivity close to Cu/P = 3. In this scenario, the VCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} concentration would be constant as a function of overall film composition (keeping the resistivity constant), but the Cu/P would decrease as the concentration of HCu_{\mathrm{Cu}} defects increases.

Supplementary figures

Supplementary references

  1. K. R. Talley, S. R. Bauers, C. L. Melamed, M. C. Papac, K. N. Heinselman, I. Khan, D. M. Roberts, V. Jacobson, A. Mis, G. L. Brennecka, J. D. Perkins, and A. Zakutayev, COMBIgor: Data-Analysis Package for Combinatorial Materials Science, ACS Combinatorial Science 21, 537 (2019).

  1. K. R. Talley, R. White, N. Wunder, M. Eash, M. Schwarting, D. Evenson, J. D. Perkins, W. Tumas, K. Munch, C. Phillips, and A. Zakutayev, Research data infrastructure for high-throughput experimental materials science, Patterns 2, 100373 (2021).

  1. A. Zakutayev, N. Wunder, M. Schwarting, J. D. Perkins, R. White, K. Munch, W. Tumas, and C. Phillips, An open experimental database for exploring inorganic materials, Scientific Data 5, 180053 (2018).

  1. A. Crovetto, D. Kojda, F. Yi, K. N. Heinselman, D. A. LaVan, K. Habicht, T. Unold, and A. Zakutayev, Crystallize It before It Diffuses: Kinetic Stabilization of Thin-Film Phosphorus-Rich Semiconductor CuP2CuP_{2}, Journal of the American Chemical Society 144, 13334 (2022).

  1. H. R. Verma, Atomic and nuclear analytical methods: XRF, mössbauer, XPS, NAA and ion-beam spectroscopic techniques (Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, 2007).

  1. P. E. Blöchl, Projector augmented-wave method, Physical Review B 50, 17953 (1994).

  1. J. Mortensen, L. Hansen, and K. Jacobsen, Real-space grid implementation of the projector augmented wave method, Physical Review B 71, 035109 (2005).

  1. J. Enkovaara, C. Rostgaard, J. J. Mortensen, J. Chen, M. Dulak, L. Ferrighi, J. Gavnholt, C. Glinsvad, V. Haikola, H. A. Hansen, H. H. Kristoffersen, M. Kuisma, A. H. Larsen, L. Lehtovaara, M. Ljungberg, O. Lopez-Acevedo, P. G. Moses, J. Ojanen, T. Olsen, V. Petzold, N. A. Romero, J. Stausholm-Møller, M. Strange, G. A. Tritsaris, M. Vanin, M. Walter, B. Hammer, H. Häkkinen, G. K. H. Madsen, R. M. Nieminen, J. K. Nørskov, M. Puska, T. T. Rantala, J. Schiøtz, K. S. Thygesen, and K. W. Jacobsen, Electronic structure calculations with GPAW: a real-space implementation of the projector augmented-wave method, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 22, 253202 (2010).

  1. A. H. Larsen, J. J. Mortensen, J. Blomqvist, I. E. Castelli, R. Christensen, M. Dulak, J. Friis, M. N. Groves, B. Hammer, C. Hargus, E. D. Hermes, P. C. Jennings, P. Bjerre Jensen, J. Kermode, J. R. Kitchin, E. Leonhard Kolsbjerg, J. Kubal, K. Kaasbjerg, S. Lysgaard, J. Bergmann Maronsson, T. Maxson, T. Olsen, L. Pastewka, A. Peterson, C. Rostgaard, J. Schiøtz, O. Schütt, M. Strange, K. S. Thygesen, T. Vegge, L. Vilhelmsen, M. Walter, Z. Zeng, and K. W. Jacobsen, The atomic simulation environment—A Python library for working with atoms, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 29, 273002 (2017).

  1. J. P. Perdew, K. Burke, and M. Ernzerhof, Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple, Physical Review Letters 77, 3865 (1996).

  1. O. Olofsson, The crystal structure of Cu3PCu_{3}P, Acta Chemica Scandinavica 26, 2777 (1972).

  1. M. Kuisma, J. Ojanen, J. Enkovaara, and T. T. Rantala, Kohn-Sham potential with discontinuity for band gap materials, Physical Review B 82, 115106 (2010).

  1. O. Gritsenko, R. van Leeuwen, E. van Lenthe, and E. J. Baerends, Self-consistent approximation to the Kohn-Sham exchange potential, Physical Review A 51, 1944 (1995).

  1. G. K. Madsen, J. Carrete, and M. J. Verstraete, BoltzTraP2, a program for interpolating band structures and calculating semi-classical transport coefficients, Computer Physics Communications 231, 140 (2018).

  1. A. Jain, S. P. Ong, G. Hautier, W. Chen, W. D. Richards, S. Dacek, S. Cholia, D. Gunter, D. Skinner, G. Ceder, and K. A. Persson, Commentary: The Materials Project: A materials genome approach to accelerating materials innovation, APL Materials 1, 011002 (2013).

  1. S. P. Ong, S. Cholia, A. Jain, M. Brafman, D. Gunter, G. Ceder, and K. A. Persson, The Materials Application Programming Interface (API): A simple, flexible and efficient API for materials data based on REpresentational State Transfer (REST) principles, Computational Materials Science 97, 209 (2015).

  1. S. P. Ong, W. D. Richards, A. Jain, G. Hautier, M. Kocher, S. Cholia, D. Gunter, V. L. Chevrier, K. A. Persson, and G. Ceder, Python Materials Genomics (pymatgen): A robust, open-source python library for materials analysis, Computational Materials Science 68, 314 (2013).

  1. F. Ricci, W. Chen, U. Aydemir, G. J. Snyder, G.-M. Rignanese, A. Jain, and G. Hautier, An ab initio electronic transport database for inorganic materials, Scientific Data 4, 170085 (2017).

  1. A. Wolff, T. Doert, J. Hunger, M. Kaiser, J. Pallmann, R. Reinhold, S. Yogendra, L. Giebeleler, J. Sichelschmidt, W. Schnelle, R. Whiteside, H. Q. N. Gunarathne, P. Nockemann, J. J. Weigand, E. Brunner, and M. Ruck, Low-Temperature Tailoring of Copper-Deficient Cu3−xPCu_{3-x}P — Electric Properties, Phase Transitions, and Performance in Lithium-Ion Batteries, Chemistry of Materials 30, 7111 (2018).

  1. L. De Trizio, R. Gaspari, G. Bertoni, I. Kriegel, L. Moretti, F. Scotognella, L. Maserati, Y. Zhang, G. C. Messina, M. Prato, S. Marras, A. Cavallari, and L. Manna, Cu3−xPCu_{3-x}P Nanocrystals as a Material Platform for Near-Infrared Plasmonics and Cation Exchange Reactions, Chemistry of Materials 27, 1120 (2015).

  1. F. Werner, Hall measurements on low-mobility thin films, Journal of Applied Physics 122, 135306 (2017).

  1. J. E. A. Alderson, T. Farrell, and C. M. Hurd, Hall Coefficients of Cu, Ag, and Au in the Range 4.2-300°K, *Physical

References

References

  1. [22]Review 174, 729 (1968).
  2. [23]F. Macheda, S. Poncé, F. Giustino, and N. Bonini, Theory and Computation of Hall Scattering Factor in Graphene, Nano Letters 20, 8861 (2020).DOI
  3. [24]J. Willis, I. Bravić, R. R. Schnepf, K. N. Heinselman, B. Monserrat, T. Unold, A. Zakutayev, D. O. Scanlon, and A. Crovetto, Prediction and realisation of high mobility and degenerate p-type conductivity in CaCuP thin films, Chemical Science 13, 5872 (2022).DOI
  4. [25]K. Ellmer and R. Mientus, Carrier transport in polycrystalline ITO and ZnO:Al II: The influence of grain barriers and boundaries, Thin Solid Films 516, 5829 (2008).DOI
  5. [26]K. L. Chopra and S. K. Bahl, Hall Effect in Thin Metal Films, Journal of Applied Physics 38, 3607 (1967).DOI
  6. [27]A. Weber, P. Sutter, and H. von Känel, Optical, electrical, and photoelectrical properties of sputtered thin amorphous Zn₃P₂ films, Journal of Applied Physics 75, 7448 (1994).DOI
  7. [28]P. Pyykkö and M. Atsumi, Molecular Single-Bond Covalent Radii for Elements 1-118, Chemistry - A European Journal 15, 186 (2009).DOI
  8. [29]C. G. Van de Walle and J. Neugebauer, Hydrogen in Semiconductors, Annual Review of Materials Research 36, 179 (2006).DOI
  9. [30]C.-C. Hou, Q.-Q. Chen, C.-J. Wang, F. Liang, Z. Lin, W.-F. Fu, and Y. Chen, Self-Supported Cedarlike Semimetallic Cu₃P Nanoarrays as a 3D High-Performance Janus Electrode for Both Oxygen and Hydrogen Evolution under Basic Conditions, ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces 8, 23037 (2016).DOI
  10. [31]S. Liu, X. He, J. Zhu, L. Xu, and J. Zeng, Cu₃P/RGO nanocomposite as a new anode for lithium-ion batteries, Scientific Reports 6, 1 (2016).DOI
  11. [32]X. Peng, Y. Lv, L. Fu, F. Chen, W. Su, J. Li, Q. Zhang, and S. Zhao, Photoluminescence properties of cuprous phosphide prepared through phosphating copper with a native oxide layer, RSC Advances 11, 34095 (2021).DOI
  12. [33]X. Peng, Y. Lv, and S. Zhao, Chemical Vapor Deposition and Thermal Oxidation of Cuprous Phosphide Nanofilm, Coatings 12, 68 (2022).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wanrpamz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents