betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Stability of the first-order character of phase transition in HoCo2_2

Abstract

HoCo2_2 exhibits a giant magnetocaloric (MC) effect at its first-order magnetostructural phase transition around 77~K, and understanding the thermodynamic nature of this transition in response to external magnetic fields is crucial for its MC applications. In this study, we present a comprehensive investigation of specific heat and magnetization measurements of HoCo2_2 under varying magnetic fields. The specific heat measurements qualitatively indicate a transformation from first- to second-order behavior of this phase transition at higher magnetic fields. However, analysis of the power-law dependence of the magnetic entropy change (ΔSM∝ΔS_{\rm M} \propto Hn^n) and the breakdown of universal behavior in the temperature dependence of ΔSMΔS_{\rm M} suggest that the first-order nature remains intact, even up to 7 T. This stability of the first-order nature is further manifested through the distinctive non-linear behavior of modified Arrott plots, with a negative slope in the 6–7 T range.

Introduction

The Laves phase RCo2_2 (R = rare earth) compounds have attracted considerable attention over the last several decades due to their intriguing phase transitions and complex magnetic properties [1–3]. Among all RCo2_2 compounds, only three–HoCo2_2, DyCo2_2, and ErCo2_2 exhibit first-order magnetostructural transitions, whereas the magnetic transitions of the others are of the second-order type [2, 4, 5]. However, some theoretical studies suggest that the transitions in the R = Pr and Nd compounds are also first-order [6, 7], while others report a second-order nature for these transitions [2, 5, 8, 9]. The phase transitions in RCo2_2 compounds are associated with the induction of the Co moment, resulting from the internal field of the rare earth ions, and their coupling with the moments of the R atoms [10–14]. The magnetic moment of Co can vary from ∼1 μB\sim1\ \mu_{\mathrm{B}}/atom for magnetic rare earth ions, where the effective internal field (HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}) acting on the Co 3d3d electrons is higher than the critical field (HCH_{\mathrm{C}}) required to polarize the Co moments (∼100\sim100 T), to zero for non-magnetic rare earth ions (Y, Lu, or Sc) [14]. Therefore, the first-order transition in R = Dy, Ho, and Er can be transformed to a second-order transition by doping with non-magnetic rare earth ions, which decreases HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} and thus hinders the polarization of the Co moments [15, 16]. Furthermore, the Co moment can also be induced by applying a very high external magnetic field (H>HCH > H_{\mathrm{C}}) in the case of non-magnetic R atoms (R = Y and Lu), resulting in a metamagnetic transition [19, 20] [17, 18]. The relative alignment of Co and R moments is governed by the competition between intersub­lattice and Hund’s exchange energies. For example, the magnetic moment of Co aligns parallel to the rare earth moments for lighter atoms (R = Pr, Nd, Sm), whereas it aligns antiparallel for heavier atoms (R = Tb, Dy, Ho, Er) [21] [13]. All RCo2_2 compounds crystallize in the MgCu2_2-type (C15) cubic structure (space group Fd3ˉmFd\bar{3}m) at room temperature, which may or may not undergo a structural transition at TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, depending on the nature of the R ions [1, 3]. The R = Nd and Ho compounds also undergo an additional structural transition at the spin-reorientation temperature (TSRT_{\mathrm{SR}}), which is lower than TCT_{\mathrm{C}} [22, 23, 24, 25]. Both transitions in NdCo2_2 are second-order in nature; however, interestingly, HoCo2_2 under ambient conditions exhibits first-order and second-order transitions at high and low temperatures, respectively [26] [2]. The non-zero Co moments (μCo≈1μB\mu_{\mathrm{Co}} \approx1\mu_{\mathrm{B}}) in HoCo2_2 align antiparallel to the Ho moments (μHo≈9.5μB\mu_{\mathrm{Ho}} \approx9.5\mu_{\mathrm{B}}) below TC∼76T_{\mathrm{C}} \sim76 K (first-order) with an easy magnetization axis along ⟨100⟩\langle100\rangle, accompanied by a structural transformation from cubic to tetragonal symmetry [27, 28] [13]. Upon further cooling, HoCo2_2 undergoes a tetragonal-to-orthorhombic transition at TSR≈15T_{\mathrm{SR}} \approx15 K (second-order) with the easy magnetization axis reoriented along ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle [25, 27]. The nature and behavior of the low-temperature (LT) transition at TSRT_{\mathrm{SR}} have been extensively studied through detailed magnetization, specific heat, and temperature- and field-dependent x-ray diffraction measurements [24, 25]. However, an abrupt change in magnetization, electronic transport, and thermal properties has been observed at the high-temperature (HT) transition [29, 30, 31] [1, 5, 8], resulting in a giant magnetic entropy (ΔSM\Delta S_{\mathrm{M}}) and adiabatic temperature change (ΔTad\Delta T_{\mathrm{ad}}), which are required for magnetocaloric applications [32, 33, 34] [5]. This abrupt change in various thermodynamic properties at TCT_{\mathrm{C}} in HoCo2_2 is associated with the first-order nature of the paramagnetic-to-ferrimagnetic phase transition. Therefore, it is essential to investigate the possible change in the nature of this transition in response to external stimuli, such as hydrostatic pressure, chemical pressure (doping), and/or magnetic field, to tailor these materials for practical use in device applications [31, 35, 36] [8, 15].

The change from a first-order to a second-order phase transition at TCT_{\mathrm{C}} in HoCo2_2 has been well established through the substitution of other rare earth ions at the Ho site [35, 36] [15]. Interestingly, Syschshenko et al. demonstrated that this transition can also be transformed to second-order by applying hydrostatic pressure above a critical value, PC∼3P_{\mathrm{C}} \sim3 GPa [31]. This is because the ferrimagnetic (tetragonal) phase is the highvolume phase, meaning that the unit cell volume increases abruptly below TCT_{\mathrm{C}} [24, 26]. As a result, the applied hydrostatic pressure restrains this transformation, leading to a decrease in both TCT_{\mathrm{C}} and the sharpness of the transition [31] [8]. Various theoretical models have been proposed to explain this pressure-induced change in the order of the magnetic transition in HoCo2_2 by accounting for the modification in the itinerant dd electrons. The applied hydrostatic pressure was found to increase the critical field required for the metamagnetic transition (HCH_{\mathrm{C}}) of the Co moments [37] [4]. Moreover, PCP_{\mathrm{C}} decreases with temperature [37], resulting in a complex relationship between PCP_{\mathrm{C}}, HCH_{\mathrm{C}}, and TCT_{\mathrm{C}} in achieving the first-order transition in HoCo2_2. On the other hand, TCT_{\mathrm{C}} increases monotonically with an increase in the external magnetic field [24, 33]. The abrupt change in magnetization and the sharpness of the peak in the specific heat data at TCT_{\mathrm{C}} gradually decrease with increasing magnetic field, suggesting the possibility of a field-induced change in the thermodynamic nature of this phase transition in HoCo2_2 [24]. More strikingly, the discontinuity in the lattice parameters of HoCo2_2 at TCT_{\mathrm{C}} significantly diminishes with the application of even a 3 T magnetic field [24, 33], supporting the notion of a field-induced change in the order of the HT transition. However, previous calorimetric measurements claim the persistence of the first-order nature of this transition in HoCo2_2 up to 5 T [5]. Therefore, it is vital to investigate the influence of external magnetic fields on the thermodynamic nature of the HT transition in HoCo2_2.

The presence of latent heat at the phase transition can be directly estimated from specific heat measurements. However, a quantitative analysis is necessary to firmly establish the thermodynamic nature of the transition. In this report, we present detailed specific heat and magnetization measurements up to 7 T to investigate the field-induced changes in the first-order nature of the transition in HoCo2_2 at TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. Although the specific heat measurements show a suppression in the peak value and a reduction in latent heat at TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, a quantitative analysis of the magnetization data demonstrates the persistence of the first-order character of the magnetic transition in HoCo2_2 up to at least 7 T. Based on the magnetization measurements, we employ three distinct approaches to investigate the stability of the first-order nature of this phase transition in the high-field regime.

Experimental

The polycrystalline HoCo2_2 sample was synthesized by arc melting high-purity Ho (>99.7>99.7 at.%) procured from the Materials Preparation Center of Ames National Laboratory and Co (>99.9>99.9%) metal purchased from Alfa Aesar, in an argon (Ar) atmosphere. An additional 3 wt.% Ho was used to compensate for Ho evaporation during melting. Prior to sample preparation, a Zr getter was melted to minimize the presence of residual or impurity gases in the chamber. The sample was flipped and remelted 4-5 times to ensure homogeneity. The x-ray diffraction (XRD) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) measurements (not shown here) indicate the formation of the single phase MgCu2_2-type structure with the targeted stoichiometry. Temperature- and magnetic field-dependent magnetization measurements were conducted using a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) system from Quantum Design, USA (model MPMS XL-7). The temperature dependence of magnetization was measured using both temperature-stable (no overshoot) and sweep modes to elucidate the nature of the magnetic transition in this compound. The SQUID was also utilized to record field-dependent magnetization isotherms in the first quadrant at various temperatures across the magnetic transition. The magnetic field was increased from 0 to 7 T in “no overshoot” mode to obtain high-precision data, then reduced from 7 T to 0.05 T in linear mode, and finally from 0.05 T to 0 T in oscillatory mode before moving to the next temperature (in heating mode) to avoid remanence in the sample, given its low coercivity (∼\sim10 Oe). Temperature- and field-dependent specific heat measurements were performed using a Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS) from Quantum Design, Inc., employing both the standard 2τ2\tau relaxation technique and the long heat pulse method. Further details about the measurement protocols for both magnetization and specific heat are provided in the corresponding discussions.

Results and discussion

The temperature-dependent magnetic susceptibility (χ=M/H\chi= M/H vs. TT) of HoCo2_2, measured at 0.01 T during heating (after cooling in zero field) in a temperature-stable mode, is presented in Figure 1(a). A very sharp transition in magnetic susceptibility is observed at 76.8±\pm0.1K [see dχ/dTd\chi/dT in the lower inset of Figure 1(a)], which is consistent with the reported first-order ferrimagnetic (FiM) to paramagnetic (PM) transition in HoCo2_2 [24, 27, 33] [5]. An additional transition around 14 K (indicated by the solid blue arrow), attributed to spin reorientation, and a cusp around 45 K (indicated by the dashed red arrow), are also consistent with previous reports [24, 25, 33, 38]. No thermal hysteresis was observed at TCT_{\mathrm{C}} in the heating and cooling (not shown) χ\chi-TT curves recorded in the temperature-stable mode, consistent with Ref. [24]. Here, it is important to emphasize that HoCo2_2 is known to exhibit a very sharp transition with a small thermal hysteresis (≈\approx2 K [27]) at TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. Therefore, the χ\chi-TT curves recorded during heating and cooling, by stabilizing the temperature at each point, may introduce significant inaccuracies due to slight overshoots in the settled temperature, leading to additional transformations of the sample between the low- and high-temperature states. Thus, the temperature sweep mode is more appropriate in this case, where the data are recorded with a monotonic in】【。 crease or decrease in temperature [39]. Interestingly, the heating and cooling χ\chi-TT curves recorded in the temperature sweep mode clearly display a thermal hysteresis of approximately 0.9 K (recorded with a sweep rate of 0.1 K/min), as shown in the upper inset of Figure 1(a), confirming the first-order nature of this transition. However, this value is still lower than the 2 K reported in Ref. [27]. Note that unlike specific heat measurements, the instantaneous temperature of the sample during magnetization measurements in the SQUID magnetometer is not directly monitored or regulated. Instead, temperature control is mediated indirectly through an exchange gas, leading to a time lag before the sample reaches thermal equilibrium. Consequently, as the temperature sweep rate increases, thermal hysteresis also rises. Therefore, measurements conducted at varying sweep rates are essential to accurately extrapolate the thermal hysteresis at a near-zero sweep rate [39]. Furthermore, the temperature-dependent inverse susceptibility is shown on the right axis of Figure 1(a), which was fitted in the 80–300 K range using the Curie-Weiss (CW) law, χ=CT−Tθ\chi= \frac{C}{T-T_{\theta}} where CC and TθT_{\theta} are the Curie-Weiss constant and Curie temperature, respectively, as indicated by the solid red line. The best-fit curve gives Tθ=65T_{\theta} = 65 K and an effective magnetic moment (μeff\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}) of 9.53 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}/f.u. The slightly lower value of TθT_{\theta} compared to TC≈77T_{\mathrm{C}} \approx77 K is characteristic of very sharp first-order transitions, while the smaller value of μeff\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}, compared to the theoretical value for the free Ho3+^{3+} ion with the 5I8^{5}\mathrm{I}_{8} ground state (10.61 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}), may be attributed to crystal field effects in the lattice.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. (a) The temperature-dependent direct (left axis) and inverse (right axis) magnetic susceptibility (χ\chi-T) of HoCo2_2 measured in the temperature stable zero-field-cooled (ZFC) mode at 0.01 T. The solid red line represents the best fit using the Curie-Weiss law in the PM state. The upper inset represents the χ\chi-T data recorded using the temperature sweep mode at a rate of 0.1 K/min in field-cooled cooling (FCC) and field-cooled warming (FCW) protocols in the vicinity of TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. The lower inset shows the first derivative of the susceptibility in the transition region. (b) Field-dependent magnetization at 5 K. The inset shows an enlarged view of the low-field region.

In Figure 1(b), we present the field-dependent magnetization measurements at 5 K. We observe negligible coercivity in the sample, as can be seen from the enlarged view of the low field region presented in the inset of Figure 1(b). This makes HoCo2_2 a special case with very small thermal as well as magnetic hysteresis and a large change in the magnetization at TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, desirable for magnetocaloric applications [40]. Furthermore, the magnetic moment increases rapidly up to around 2 T and then increases very slowly up to the highest measured field of 5 T. The magnetic moment at 5 T is 7.6 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}/f.u., which is consistent with the reported value of 7.7 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}/f.u. along <110><110> at 4.2 K, resulting from the antiparallel alignment of the 9.3 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} Ho and -0.8 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} Co moments [27].

To further understand the behavior of the FiM to PM transition in HoCo2_2 in response to an external magnetic field, we performed specific heat (CPC_{\mathrm{P}}) measurements from 0 to 7 T in the vicinity of TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. The specific heat measurements performed using the conventional 2τ2\tau relaxation method assume that the value of CPC_{\mathrm{P}} remains constant during a given heat pulse and has the same value during the heating and cooling of the sample. However, for very sharp first-order transitions, as in the present case, these assumptions are not valid, leading to inaccurate values of CPC_{\mathrm{P}}, which obscure the true thermodynamic nature of such transitions [41, 42]. Therefore, a point-by-point time-dependent analysis of both heating and cooling curves separately, after applying a long heat pulse

which can capture the whole transition, is essential to precisely estimate the CPC_{\mathrm{P}} in the vicinity of FO transitions [42, 43]. We performed specific heat measurements of HoCo2_2 using the long heat pulse method to accurately probe the sharp features of the sample and their evolution with the magnetic field.

Figure 2(a) shows the time evolution of the sample temperature (tt-TT) in the vicinity of the phase transition during heating (indicated by the solid red arrow) and cooling (indicated by the dashed blue arrow) after applying and removing a long heat pulse to the sample at zero field. Interestingly, both heating and cooling curves exhibit a flat temperature region where the sample temperature does not increase (decrease) even when the sample heater was on (off). This clearly indicates the presence of a large latent heat in the system, confirming the first-order nature of this magnetostructural phase transition. We observe a thermal hysteresis of around 0.15 K between the heating and cooling curves, which is smaller than the hysteresis observed in the magnetization measurements discussed earlier. This discrepancy arises because, unlike in magnetization measurements, the sample is in direct contact with both the thermocouple and heater during specific heat measurements, allowing precise control and monitoring of the sample’s instantaneous temperature. In the absence of a magnetic field, this constant temperature region in the tt-TT curves results in a very large value of CPC_P at TCT_C [virtually infinite; see inset of Figure 2(a)]. We also observe a large negative specific heat due to small fluctuations in the sample temperature in the vicinity of the first-order transition [44, 45, 46, 47, 48]. With the application of the magnetic field, the tt-TT curves split into two distinct slopes, resulting in two corresponding peaks in the CPC_P curves, as shown in Figure 2(b–Figure 2n). This effect is clearly visible for B≥1B \ge1 T [see Figure 2(c–Figure 2n)]. These results are in nice agreement with those recorded

Image not extracted

Figure 2. (a) The time dependence of the sample temperature during heating (solid red arrow) and cooling (blue dashed arrow), after the application and removal of a fixed heat pulse, respectively, at 0 T and (b) 0.5 T magnetic fields. The insets show the resulting specific heat (CPC_P) curves of the sample during both heating and cooling cycles. (c–n) The temperature-dependent CPC_P data of HoCo2_2 in the vicinity of the magnetic transition at different magnetic fields.

using the conventional 2τ2\tau relaxation technique in high resolution, as compared in Figure 1 of supplementary material for B=2B=2 T. The two peaks are separated by approximately 1.5 K, and the separation between them remains constant as the magnetic field increases. However, the strength of the LT peak decreases relative to the HT peak as the magnetic field increases. The broadening of these features also increases with the magnetic field, and for B≥5B \ge5 T, the two features merge into a single broad peak [see Figure 2(k–Figure 2n)]. We used more than one heat pulse to capture the wide temperature range for B≥5B \ge5 T.

A two-peak feature in the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) results for HoCo2_2 was also observed in Ref. [5] in the low-field region (B<5B < 5 T), despite the isotropic nature of the transition temperature in this compound [27]. The authors attributed the two peaks to the presence of a small amount of off-stoichiometric component in the sample with a different transition temperature [27]. However, XRD and EDS measurements performed on the present sample, as well as in Ref. [5], show no traces of compositional inhomogeneity or a secondary phase in the compound within the instrumental limits. The sharp single transition in the absence of a magnetic field further discard the possibility of two different phases as the origin of the observed doublet in the CP(T)C_\mathrm{P}(T) curves in the present case. The first-order nature of the transition diminishes with increasing magnetic field: a significant decrease in the strength and an increase in the broadening of the CPC_\mathrm{P} curves (see Figure 2 of supplementary material), accompanied by the continuous change in the tt-TT curves (see Figure 3 of supplementary material) and a smaller thermal hysteresis at TCT_\mathrm{C}, have been observed. These observations point toward a possible field-induced transition from a first-order to

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (a) Virgin magnetization isotherms of HoCo2_2 from 0 to 7 T across TCT_\mathrm{C}. (b) The magnetic field derivative of the magnetization from 77 to 95 K. (c) The temperature dependence of the critical magnetic field. The red solid line represents the linear fit of the data. (d) The temperature-dependent magnetization at different fields, extracted from the virgin magnetization isotherms. (e) The temperature derivative of the magnetization at different fields. (f) Field dependence of the transition temperature, where the red line represents the linear fit.

a second-order nature of this phase transformation in HoCo2_2. However, the continuity in the tt-TT curves and the broadening of the CPC_\mathrm{P} curves are subjective indicators. Therefore, in-depth magnetization measurements are necessary to clearly determine the thermodynamic nature of this magnetic transition in HoCo2_2 at higher magnetic fields.

The high-precision virgin magnetization isotherms of HoCo2_2 were recorded from 0 to 7 T across TCT_\mathrm{C}, as presented in Figure 3(a). For T≤TCT \leq T_\mathrm{C}, the curves exhibit saturating behavior similar to that observed at 5 K; however, for T>TCT > T_\mathrm{C}, the magnetic moment increases almost linearly for lower applied magnetic fields and then shows a step-like jump with further increases in BB (see Figure 3(a)). The critical magnetic field for this jump in magnetization, i.e., the magnetic field required to ferrimagnetically align the spins, increases with temperature. To clearly illustrate this, we present the magnetic field derivative of the magnetization (dMM/dBB) in Figure 3(b) for T>TCT > T_\mathrm{C}, where a monotonic shift in the peak position toward higher fields is clearly observed with increasing sample temperature. We perform Gaussian fitting of the peaks near the transition to precisely estimate the peak position. In Figure 3(c), we plot this peak position as a function of temperature, which shows a linear increase for T>TCT > T_\mathrm{C}. A straight fit of the experimental data, represented by the red solid line in Figure 3(c), reveals a significant shift of 0.26 T/K.

The temperature-dependent magnetization extracted from the virgin magnetization isotherms is shown in Figure 3(d) for different magnetic fields. With increasing magnetic field, the transition becomes broader, and at B=7B = 7 T, it become almost continuous, suggesting that the magnetic field may have transformed the first-order FiM→\rightarrowPM transition into a second-order type. The temperature derivative of the magnetization (dMM/dTT) is plotted as a function of temperature in Figure 3(e) for different fields to illustrate the field evolution of TCT_\mathrm{C}. The field dependence of TCT_\mathrm{C} is shown in Figure 3(f), exhibiting linear behavior up to 7 T with a shift of 3.5 K/T, which is close to the values reported in [24] (3.3 K/T) and [33] (4.0 K/T). This linear dependence of the transition temperature of HoCo2_2 on the external field makes it a suitable candidate for device applications across a wide range of operating temperatures. Interestingly, dMM/dTT exhibits a single and symmetric peak at all fields, and its peak position almost coincides with the high-temperature peak of the CPC_\mathrm{P} curves (see Figure 4 of supplementary material), suggesting that a non-magnetic aspect may be associated with the low-temperature peak of the CPC_\mathrm{P} curves. However, a simultaneous study of the magnetic and structural changes is necessary to probe the origin of two peaks within a narrow temperature range [49, 50].

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (a) The temperature-dependent magnetic entropy change (ΔSM\Delta S_M) of HoCo2_2 at different magnetic fields. The inset shows the field dependence of the maximum magnetic entropy change (ΔSMmax⁡\Delta S_M^{\max}). (b) The temperature-dependent local field exponent (nn) of ΔSM\Delta S_M at different fields. The inset shows the field dependence of the maximum value of nn (nmax⁡n_{\max}) in the vicinity of TCT_C. (c) The normalized ΔSM\Delta S_M versus scaled temperature curves at different fields. The inset shows the field dependence of the vertical dispersion at θ=−4\theta=-4.

The specific heat and M-T measurements qualitatively suggest a change in the nature of the FiM to PM transition in HoCo2_2 from first-order to second-order at higher magnetic fields. Therefore, to quantitatively understand this, we calculate the temperature-dependent magnetic entropy change [ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T)] for different ΔH\Delta H values using the following Maxwell thermodynamic relation [51, 52]:

ΔSM(T,H)=∫0H(∂M(T,H)∂T)HdH(1)\Delta S_M(T,H)=\int_0^H\left(\frac{\partial M(T,H)}{\partial T}\right)_H dH \tag*{(1)}

The ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) curves for HoCo2_2 are shown in Figure 4(a), exhibiting a giant magnetocaloric effect with a maximum magnetic entropy change (ΔSMmax⁡\Delta S_M^{\max}) of 18.5 J/kg-K at ΔH=2\Delta H=2 T. The ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) curves remain almost symmetric up to H=1H=1 T and then gradually become asymmetric towards the PM region with further increases in the magnetic field [see Figure 4(a)]. It is interesting to note that

the value of ΔSMmax⁡\Delta S_M^{\max} increases rapidly up to ∼1\sim1 T and then increases at a much slower rate, as shown in the inset of Figure 4(a). Recently, J. Y. Law et al. [53] proposed a general criterion to distinguish between first- and second-order phase transitions based solely on magnetization measurements [53]. The authors proposed that the power exponent (nn) of the field dependence of magnetic entropy change (ΔSM∝Hn\Delta S_M \propto H^n) exhibits a value greater than 2 only for first-order phase transitions [53]. Therefore, we calculate the local field exponent of entropy, nn, defined as:

n(H,T)=d(ln⁡∣ΔSM∣)d(ln⁡H)(2)n(H,T)=\frac{d(\ln\lvert\Delta S_M\rvert)}{d(\ln H)} \tag*{(2)}

The n(T)n(T) values for HoCo2_2 are shown in Figure 4(b) for ΔH=1\Delta H=1–7 T. Note that for second-order FM to PM transitions, n=1n=1 in the FM state, attaining a minimum value at TCT_C, given by n(TC)=1+(1−β)−1δ−1n(T_C)=1+(1-\beta)^{-1}\delta^{-1}, where β\beta and δ\delta are the critical exponents, followed by n=2n=2 in the PM state, in accordance with the Curie-Weiss law [54]. In contrast, n>2n>2 represents the first-order nature of the magnetic transition [53]. Interestingly, in the present case, nn increases monotonically in the vicinity of TCT_C, reaches a maximum value of n∼6.5n\sim6.5 for H≈1.2H\approx1.2 T, and then decreases with further increases in the magnetic field [see Figure 4(b)]. Notably, in the vicinity of TCT_C, n>2n>2 even at ΔH=7\Delta H=7 T, indicating that the first-order nature of this phase transition in HoCo2_2 persists even up to the highest applied magnetic field (7 T). The inset of Figure 4(b) shows the field dependence of the maximum value of the exponent nn (nmax⁡n_{\max}), which clearly indicates that n>2n>2 for ΔH=7\Delta H=7 T [see Figure 5(a) of the supplementary material for more clarity].

Image not extracted

Figure 5. (a–e) The modified Arrott plots (MAPs) for different universality classes across the magnetic transition temperature. The inset shows a magnified view for the 6–7 T magnetic field and the 95–105 K temperature range. (f) The temperature-dependent normalized slope (NS) of the MAPs for different universality classes. The inset shows an enlarged view from 95 to 105 K.

Additionally, a criterion based on the extent of the collapse of all the ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) curves into a universal master curve (UMC), after properly rescaling the ΔSM\Delta S_M and temperature axes, has been proposed to distinguish the order of the phase transition [55]. For a second-order phase transition, curves at different fields collapse into a single UMC across the entire temperature range, whereas a vertical dispersion is observed for first-order transition materials below TCT_C [55]. Therefore, we construct a UMC of ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) at different fields by plotting scaled entropy (ΔSM/ΔSMmax⁡\Delta S_M/\Delta S_M^{\max}) versus scaled temperature (θ\theta), defined as:

θ={−(T−Tpk)/(Tr1−Tpk)T≤TC(T−Tpk)/(Tr2−Tpk)T>TC(3)\theta= \begin{cases} -(T-T_{pk})/(T_{r1}-T_{pk}) & T\leq T_C \\ (T-T_{pk})/(T_{r2}-T_{pk}) & T>T_C \end{cases} \tag*{(3)}

where Tr1T_{r1} and Tr2T_{r2} are two reference temperatures below and above TCT_C, respectively, for a certain value of h=ΔSM/ΔSMmax⁡h=\Delta S_M/\Delta S_M^{\max}, and TpkT_{pk} represents the temperature corresponding to ΔSMmax⁡\Delta S_M^{\max} [54]. The normalized entropy versus scaled temperature for HoCo2_2 is presented in Figure 4(c) for different applied magnetic fields for h=1/2h=1/2. We observe significant dispersion in the scaled entropy curves even up to 7 T, primarily below TCT_C. To clearly present this, we show the field dependence of the normalized entropy at θ=−4\theta=-4 in the inset of Figure 4(c), where a monotonic enhancement in the dispersion of the scaled curves, even up to 7 T, confirms the stability of the first-order nature of this phase transition in HoCo2_2 in response to the external magnetic field [see Fig. 5(b) of the supplementary material for more clarity].

Here, it is essential to highlight that the ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) curves calculated at higher magnetic fields may retain contributions from the low-field data (refer to Eq. (1)). Consequently, even when the magnetic transition shifts from first-order to second-order at elevated fields, the influence of the low-field data, where the transition is unequivocally first-order in nature, can affects the values of ΔSM(T)\Delta S_M(T) at higher fields, compared to a purely second-order transition. This may contribute to an overshoot in the power exponent nn and dispersion of the ΔSM\Delta S_M curves in the high-field region. Therefore, to further investigate this, we apply the Banerjee Criterion, which states that a negative (positive) slope in the Arrott plots (H/M vs. M2^2) signifies a first- (second-) order phase transition

[56, 57]. In Figure 5 (a), we present the Arrott plots over a wide temperature range from 60 to 120 K. A negative slope in the Arrott curves can be clearly observed even for H ≥\geq 6 T. In fact, the slope of the Arrott curves changes from positive to negative across TC_C in the 6-7 T range, as shown more clearly in the inset of Figure 5 (a), which indicates the first-order nature of the transition even at high magnetic fields. However, it is important to note that the Banerjee Criterion is only valid for materials following the mean-field theory with critical exponents β=0.5\beta=0.5 and γ=1\gamma=1. Consequently, we construct modified Arrott plots (MAPs) [M1/β^{1/\beta} vs. (H/M)1/γ^{1/\gamma}] using virgin magnetization isotherms for different universality classes with their respective critical exponents [58], as shown in Figure 5(b–Figure 5e). For the correct choice of critical exponents in the case of a second-order phase transition, the Arrott curves are expected to display linear behavior parallel to each other in the high-field region [59, 60, 61]. A similar approach has also been utilized to understand the field-induced first-order to second-order phase transition in Sm0.52_{0.52}Sr0.48_{0.48}MnO3_3, where MAPs show straight curves for H≥\geq4 T, indicating a transition to second-order [59]. Interestingly, in our case, none of the universality classes exhibit linear behavior in the Arrott curves near the transition temperature, even for H≥\geq6 T [see Figs. 5(b–e) and their insets]. The clear curvature in these curves is a characteristic feature of the first-order nature of this phase transition up to 7 T. We attempted to fit these curves linearly in the 6-7 T range (see Fig. 6 of the supplementary material) and plotted the normalized slopes (slope at a given temperature/slope at TC_C) of these curves in Figure 5(f). A sharp peak in the slope at TC_C is clearly observed, even within a narrow temperature range [see the inset of Fig. 5(f)]. This indicates that the critical exponents of the sample diverge at TC_C, further suggesting the persistence of the first-order nature of this transition at least up to 7 T.

Conclusion

A detailed investigation of specific heat and magnetization as functions of both temperature and applied magnetic fields has been conducted on polycrystalline HoCo2_2. We observe significant broadening of the CPC_P peak, accompanied by a reduction in its magnitude and thermal hysteresis at TCT_C as the magnetic field increases. This, along with the gradual change in magnetization at TCT_C at elevated fields, points towards a transformation from a first- to a second-order nature of the FiM to PM transition in HoCo2_2. However, the behavior of the field exponent of magnetic entropy, nn, and the dispersion in the scaling behavior of ΔSM\Delta S_M curves suggest the persistence of the first-order character of the phase transition up to at least 7 T. The first-order nature of the transition is also indicated by the non-linearity in the MAPs, even for fields of 6–7 T. These findings on the nature of the magnetic transition in HoCo2_2 under strong magnetic fields contribute valuable insights for its application in magnetocaloric technologies. Further, a sharp, single peak in the CPC_P curves at zero field splits into two components in the presence of a magnetic field, with their relative strengths varying with the field. Moreover, using HoCo2\mathrm{HoCo}_2 as an example, we demonstrate the importance of performing specific heat and magnetization measurements in sweep mode, i.e., continuously increasing or decreasing the sample temperature across the phase transition, to accurately probe the material’s response in the vicinity of first-order transitions, particularly those with small thermal hysteresis.

Supplementary material

See the supplementary material for the details of the specific heat and magnetization data.

Acknowledgments

This work was performed at Ames National Laboratory and was supported by the Division of Materials Science and Engineering of the Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Ames National Laboratory is operated for the U.S. DOE by Iowa State University of Science and Technology under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11358.

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

References

References

  1. [19]Matter 201, 127 (1994).
  2. [20]T. Goto, H. A. Katori, T. Sakakibara, H. Mitamura, K. Fukamichi, and K. Murata, Itinerant electron metamagnetism and related phenomena in Co-based intermetallic compounds (invited), J. Appl. Phys. 76, 6682 (1994).DOI
  3. [21]P. Hendy and E. W. Lee, A powder neutron diffraction study of some rare-earth-Co₂ compounds, Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 50, 101 (1978).
  4. [22]E. Gratz, Measurements of lattice distortion in RECo₂(RE = Ho, Nd) using X-ray powder diffraction, Solid State Commun. 48, 825 (1983).DOI
  5. [23]Y. G. Xiao, Q. Huang, Z. W. Ouyang, J. W. Lynn, J. K. Liang, and G. H. Rao, Crystal and magnetic structures of Laves phase compound NdCo₂ in the temperature range between 9 and 300 K, J. Alloys Compd. 420, 29 (2006).DOI
  6. [24]Y. Mudryk, D. Paudyal, A. K. Pathak, V. K. Pecharsky, and K. A. Gschneidner, Balancing structural distortions via competing 4f and itinerant interactions: A case of polymorphism in magnetocaloric HoCo₂, J. Mater. Chem. C 4, 4521 (2016).DOI
  7. [25]G. Aubert, D. Gignoux, F. Givord, R. Lemaire, and B. Michelutti, Magnetization reorientation in HoCo₂, Solid State Commun. 25, 85 (1978).DOI
  8. [26]R. Z. Levitin and A. S. Markosyan, Magnetoelastic properties of RE-3d intermetallics, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 84, 247 (1990).DOI
  9. [27]D. Gignoux, F. Givord, and R. Lemaire, Magnetic properties of single crystals of GdCo₂, HoNi₂, and HoCo₂, Phys. Rev. B 12, 3878 (1975).
  10. [28]M. Rubinstein, P. Lubitz, and N. C. Koon, ⁵⁹Co NMR study of NdCo₂, GdCo₂, TbCo₂ and HoCo₂, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 24, 288 (1981).DOI
  11. [29]E. Gratz, R. Resel, A. T. Burkov, E. Bauert, A. S. Markosyan, and A. Galatanu, The transport properties of RCo₂ compounds, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 7, 6687 (1995).
  12. [30]W. Steiner, H. Ortbauer, E. Gratz, and H. W. Camen, Magnetic properties, electrical resistivity and thermal expansion of (Ho,Y)Co₂, J. Phys. F: Met. Phys. 8, 1525 (1978).DOI
  13. [31]O. Syshchenko, T. Fujita, V. Sechovský, M. Diviš, and H. Fujii, Magnetism in HoCo₂ and ErCo₂ under high pressure, J. Alloys Compd. 317-318, 438 (2001).DOI
  14. [32]S. A. Nikitin and A. M. Tishin, Magnetocaloric effect in HoCo₂ compound, Cryogenics 31, 166 (1991).DOI
  15. [33]E. Bykov, A. Karpenkov, W. Liu, M. Strafheim, T. Niehoff, K. Skokov, F. Scheibel, O. Gutfleisch, C. Salazar Mejía, J. Wosnitza, T. Gottschall, Magnetocaloric effect in the Laves phases RCo₂ (R = Er, Ho, Dy, and Tb) in high magnetic fields, J. Alloys Compd. 977, 173289 (2024).DOI
  16. [34]N. A. de Oliveira, P. J. von Ranke, M. V. Tovar Costa, and A. Troper, Magnetocaloric effect in the intermetallic compounds RCo₂(R = Dy, Ho, Er), Phys. Rev. B 66, 094402 (2002).DOI
  17. [35]N. H. Duc, T. D. Hien, P. P. Mai, N. H. K. Ngan, N. H. Sinh, P. E. Brommer, and J. J. M. Franse, The magnetic phase transitions in (Tb, Ho)Co₂ and (Tb, Y)Co₂ compounds, Physica B Condens. Matter 160, 199 (1989).DOI
  18. [36]M. Balli, D. Fruchart, and D. Gignoux, Magnetocaloric effect and phase transformation in Ho₁₋ₓGdₓCo₂ and Ho₁₋ₓTbₓCo₂ compounds. Second IIF-IIR International Conference on Magnetic Refrigeration at Room Temperature, Apr 2007, Portoroz, Slovenia. ffhal-01185994
  19. [37]H. Yamada, Pressure effect in an itinerant-electron metamagnet at finite temperature, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 139, 162 (1995).DOI
  20. [38]T. D. Cuong, L. Havela, V. Sechovský, A. V. Andreev, Z. Arnold, J. Kamarad, and N. H. Duc, Magnetism and related phenomena in RE(Co₁₋ₓSiₓ)₂ compounds, J. Alloys Compd. 262-263, 141 (1997).
  21. [39]F. Guillou, A. K. Pathak, D. Paudyal, Y. Mudryk, F. Wilhelm, A. Rogalev, and V. K. Pecharsky, Non-hysteretic first-order phase transition with large latent heat and giant low-field magnetocaloric effect, Nat. Commun. 9, 2925 (2018).DOI
  22. [40]P. Z. Z. Nehan, O. Vitayaya, D. R. Munazat, M. T. E. Manawan, D. Darminto, and B. Kurniawan, The magnetocaloric effect properties for potential applications of magnetic refrigerator technology: A review, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 26, 14476 (2024).DOI
  23. [41]V. Hardy, Y. Bréard, and C. Martin, Derivation of the heat capacity anomaly at a first-order transition by using a semi-adiabatic relaxation technique, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 21, 075403 (2009).DOI
  24. [42]J. C. Lashley, M. F. Hundley, A. Migliori, J.L. Sarrao, P.G. Pagliuso, T.W. Darling, M. Jaime, J. C. Cooley, W. L. Hults, L. Morales, D. J. Thoma, J. L. Smith, J. Boerio-Goates, B. F. Woodfield, G. R. Stewart, R. A. Fisher, N.E. Phillips., Critical examination of heat capacity measurements made on a quantum design physical property measurement system, Cryogenics 43, 369 (2003).DOI
  25. [43]A. Kumar, P. Singh, A. Doyle, D. L. Schlagel, and Y. Mudryk, Multiple magnetic interactions and large inverse magnetocaloric effect in TbSi and TbSi₀.₆Ge₀.₄, Phys. Rev. B 109, 214410 (2024).DOI
  26. [44]M. Piazzi, C. Bennati, and V. Basso, Thermodynamics of the heat-flux avalanches at the first-order magnetic transition in magnetocaloric materials, Phys. Rev. Applied 8, 044023 (2017).DOI
  27. [45]F. Erbesdobler, C. R. H. Bahl, R. Bjørk, and K. K. Nielsen, Detailed isofield calorimetry of La(Fe,Si,Mn)H reveals distributed magnetocaloric phase transitions, J. Appl. Phys. 127, 095102 (2020).DOI
  28. [46]C. Bennati, L. Gozzelino, E. S. Olivetti, and V. Basso, Heterogeneous nucleation and heat flux avalanches in La(Fe, Si)₁₃ magnetocaloric compounds near the critical point, Appl. Phys. Lett. 109, 231904 (2016).
  29. [47]F. Guillou, H. Yibole, Z. Qu, Q. Eu, E. Bruck, and O. Tegus, Large recalescence-like event at the first cooling across the magnetic transition of (Mn,Fe)₂(P,Si) magnetocaloric materials, Scr. Mater. 160, 81 (2019).DOI
  30. [48]V. Hardy, R. Hamane, F. Veillon, M. Risser, and F. Guillou, “Two-steps” process in the first-order transformation of giant magnetocaloric materials, Acta Mater. 231, 117869 (2022).DOI
  31. [49]A. Aubert, K. Skokov, G. Gomez, A. Chirkova, I. Radulov, F. Wilhelm, A. Rogalev, H. Wende, O. Gutfleisch, and K. Ollefs, Simultaneous multi-property probing during magneto-structural phase transitions: An element-specific and macroscopic hysteresis characterization at ID12 of the ESRF, IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 71, 1 (2022).DOI
  32. [50]K. P. Skokov,1 A. Y. Karpenkov, D. Y. Karpenkov, I. A. Radulov, D. Gunzing, B. Eggert, A. Rogalev, F. Wilhelm, J. Liu, Y. Shao, K. Ollefs, M. E. Gruner, H. Wende, and O. Gutfleisch, A multi-stage, first-order phase tran- sition in LaFe₁₁.₈Si₁.₂: Interplay between the structural, magnetic, and electronic degrees of freedom, Appl. Phys. Rev. 10, 031408 (2023).DOI
  33. [51]M. H. Phan and S. C. Yu, Review of magnetocaloric effect in manganite materials, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 308, 325 (2007).
  34. [52]A. Kumar and R. S. Dhaka, Unraveling magnetic interactions and the spin state in insulating Sr₂₋ₓLaₓCoNbO₆, Phys. Rev. B 101, 094434 (2020).
  35. [53]J. Y. Law, V. Franco, L. M. Moreno-Ramírez, A. Conde, D. Y. Karpenkov, I. Radulov, K. P. Skokov, and O. Gut-fleisch, A quantitative criterion for determining the order of magnetic phase transitions using the magnetocaloric effect, Nat. Commun. 9, 2680 (2018).DOI
  36. [54]V. Franco, J. S. Blázquez, and A. Conde, Field dependence of the magnetocaloric effect in materials with a second order phase transition: A master curve for the magnetic entropy change, Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 222512 (2006).DOI
  37. [55]C. M. Bonilla, J. Herrero-Albillos, F. Bartolomé, L. M. García, M. Parra-Borderías, and V. Franco, Universal behavior for magnetic entropy change in magnetocaloric materials: An analysis on the nature of phase transitions, Phys. Rev. B 81, 224424 (2010).
  38. [56]A. Arrott and J. Noakes, Approximate Equation of State for Nickel Near its Critical Temperature, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 786 (1967).DOI
  39. [57]S. K. Banerjee, On a generalised approach to first and second order magnetic transitions, Phys. Lett. 12, 16 (1964).DOI
  40. [58]J. C. Le Guillou and J. Zinn-Justin, Critical exponents from field theory, Phys. Rev. B 21, 3976 (1980).
  41. [59]P. Sarkar, P. Mandal, A. K. Bera, S. M. Yusuf, L. S. Sharath Chandra, and V. Ganeshan, Field-induced first-order to second-order magnetic phase transition in Sm₀.₅₂Sr₀.₄₈MnO₃, Phys. Rev. B 78, 012415 (2008).DOI
  42. [60]S. Rößler, U. K. Rößler, K. Nenkov, D. Eckert, S. M. Yusuf, K. Dörr, and K.-H. Müller, Rounding of a first-order magnetic phase transition in Ga-doped La₀.₆₇Ca₀.₃₃MnO₃, Phys. Rev. B 70 104417 (2004).DOI
  43. [61]A. Biswas, A. Kumar, P. Singh, T. D. Rose, R. K. Chouhan, B. C. Margato, B. P. Alho, E. P. Nőbrega, P. J. von Ranke, P. O. Ribeiro, V. S. R. de Sousa, and Y. Mudryk, The influence of trivalent Ga doping on magnetic properties, magnetocaloric effect, and electronic structure of pseudo-binary GdZn₁₋ₓGaₓ (x = 0-0.1), arXiv:2410.22504.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wfzx7zxa
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents