WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Hidden variable topological order in a bilayer kagomé antiferromagnet
Abstract
Topological orders in realistic systems are quite rare, raising one fundamental question of whether they might be harbored with hidden degrees of freedom rather than directly exposed in conventional spins or electrons. We here propose a set of hidden variables and their effective interactions in a bilayer kagomé antiferromagnet. By properly organizing four local states of the spin dimer into two pseudospin- variables ( and ), we identify a regime where an effective Balents-Fisher-Girvin model emerges, realizing a topological order in the hidden sector while the auxiliary sector remains a trivial paramagnet. This hidden nature drastically alters the experimental manifestations. Physical spins map to composite objects, typically convolving fractionalized anyon continua with non-topological magnon excitations. Nevertheless, specific symmetry-selected channels, such as the longitudinal intralayer response, exclusively reveal the bare two-vison continuum without collective-mode dressing. Our findings demonstrate that the topological order could be buried in certain hidden and emergent degrees of freedom, pointing to a promising pathway for seeking elusive topological states disguised within hidden internal degrees of freedom.
Introduction
Topological order [1] remains exceedingly scarce in nature. Beyond the celebrated fractional quantum Hall effect [2, 3] with the recently observed fractional Chern insulators [4, 5, 6] largely representing lattice-based variants thereof, the unambiguous realizations of topological order in physical systems are virtually non-existent. From a mathematical and field-theoretic perspective, one can engineer an abundance of exact lattice models [7, 8]; yet these solvable constructions often inhabit idealized or physically unreachable Hilbert spaces, rendering their relevance to realistic materials rather tenuous. An exceptionally rare class of models that successfully bridges theoretical tractability with real-world materials is exemplified by the Kitaev honeycomb model [9, 10], accompanied by a few less widely heralded yet profound paradigms such as the Balents-Fisher-Girvin (BFG) model [11, 12] and the pyrochlore spin-1/2 XXZ model [13]. Setting these rare benchmark toy models aside, realistic quantum materials inevitably confront us with complex, bewildering experimental phenomena. In such systems, the microscopic parent Hamiltonians are rarely known with certainty, let alone analytically or numerically solvable. Consequently, the fundamental connections linking ambiguous experimental anomalies, underlying microscopic models, and any potential topological order remain thoroughly obscured.
A major thrust in the quest for topological order has centered on quantum spin liquids (QSLs) [14]. These strongly correlated magnetic phases evade conventional symmetry breaking and instead exhibit long-range quantum entanglement, fractionalized excitations, and emergent gauge fields [15]. The mainstream efforts across frustrated magnetism, however, have almost exclusively focused on conventional, bare spin degrees of freedom and their exchange interactions. Under this standard paradigm, a central experimental diagnostic is the presence of a broad spectral continuum [16], such as spinon continua in frustrated magnets [17, 18] or more specifi-
cally the Majorana continua in Kitaev materials [19, 20], arising when a single microscopic spin flip fractionalizes into multiple emergent quasiparticles. Despite decades of intense theoretical and experimental pursuit, indisputable confirmation of topological order in magnetic candidates remains notoriously difficult [21]. This longstanding impasse prompts a fundamental question. Is the apparent scarcity of topological order an intrinsic material limitation? Given the existence of fractional quantum Hall effects, we are more positive. Instead, we raise a different question. Could genuine topological order secretly reside in hidden internal degrees of freedom that evade direct exposure in conventional spin channels?
In this work, we provide a constructive answer to the above question by proposing a concrete paradigm in an AA-stacked bilayer kagomé magnet. In this architecture, each physical site hosts two vertically aligned spins, one in each layer, supplying a natural internal degree of freedom. Utilizing an exact pseudospin representation [22], we encode the four local spin configurations per site into two distinct pseudospin-1/2 variables, and . In the regime of a dominant antiferromagnetic local interlayer Ising coupling, the parallel alignment sector occurs at a very high energy, leaving the hidden variable as the active low-energy degree of freedom. Remarkably, by properly tailoring the inter-site exchange profile, the low-energy sector reduces exactly to the Balents-Fisher-Girvin (BFG) model [11, 23]. Consequently, a topological order, with emergent gauge fields, spinons, and visons, is successfully realized within the hidden sector, while the auxiliary sector remains a topologically trivial paramagnet.
This explicit realization provides a powerful demonstration of how hidden topological order fundamentally alters experimental manifestations and alters conventional diagnostic rules. By deriving a comprehensive physical operator dictionary that maps layer-resolved spin operators to the combined - Hilbert space, we reveal that physical spin probes typically capture composite objects. A standard spin flip convolving the fractionalized anyon continua with the non-topological magnon excitations yields broad, obscured profiles in the dynamic spin structure factor. Our example demonstrates that this hidden nature does not mean the state is undetectable. We identify specific symmetry-selected channels, most notably the longitudinal same-layer response , which satisfies a strict selection rule that completely strips away the magnon dressing, exclusively exposing the bare two-vison continuum. Our illustrative example ultimately establishes a new diagnostic principle for frustrated systems. The apparent absence of clean fractionalized continua in conventional spectra does not rule out topological order, pointing to a promising uncharted pathway for seeking elusive topological states disguised within hidden internal degrees of freedom.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we introduce the bilayer kagomé spin model and develop the - pseudospin representation for the four local spin states at each in-plane site. In Sec. III, we show how the hidden sector realizes a spin liquid in the Balents-Fisher-Girvin limit. In Sec. IV, we describe the fractionalized spinon and vison excitations alongside the auxiliary -sector magnons. In § 3.1, we establish the physical operator dictionary and derive the corresponding spectroscopic selection rules. In § 3.2, we compute the dynamic spin structure factors across various layer-resolved channels. Finally, in Sec. VII, we discuss experimental implications and summarize our main conclusions.
Bilayer Kagomé Model and Pseudospin Representation
To demonstrate how topological order can be sequestered within internal degrees of freedom, we consider an AA-stacked bilayer kagomé spin-1/2 XXZ model. At each spatial position , where denotes the triangular Bravais lattice vector and labels the three kagomé sublattices, the local Hilbert space is four-dimensional, spanned by the vertically aligned upper-layer and lower-layer spins, and . The total microscopic Hamiltonian is given by
where the individual layer contributions , , the local vertical interlayer coupling , the nonlocal interlayer coupling , and the Zeeman term are explicitly parameterized as,
Here, specifies the local vertical dimer exchange, while and characterize the intralayer and nonlocal interlayer interactions across successive coordination shells , respectively.
To explicitly separate the hidden topological degree of freedom from the conventional magnetic sector, we introduce a local change of variables that exactly maps the four-dimensional state space at each site onto two sets of pseudospin-1/2 operators, and . We define the quantized eigenstates of and via the physical spin configurations,
In this exact representation, selectively identifies the local interlayer antiferromagnetic (antiparallel) subspace, whereas identifies the ferromagnetic (parallel) subspace. Within either sector, the active variable acts as a hidden pseudospin that tracks the orientation of the upper-layer spin. This yields a mathematically exact operator dictionary across the entire Hilbert space, as listed in Table I.
We emphasize that the mapping in Table I constitutes an exact algebraic change of variables without any low-energy truncation. Substituting the relations in Table I into Eq. (1) reformulates the microscopic model into a coupled - quantum system with
where the longitudinal and local transverse terms read
and the nonlocal transverse couplings, which induce transitions between different interlayer alignment sectors, are given by
| Component | Upper layer | Lower layer |
Table 1. Exact local mapping from physical spin components to the pseudospin variables and .
Strong-Interlayer Projection and the Construction of the BFG Model
The mechanism for cloaking the topological order becomes operational in the strong-coupling limit, where the local interlayer antiferromagnetic Ising exchange dominates over all other energy scales. In this regime, the first term of acts as a massive longitudinal field that polarizes the auxiliary sector into the local antiparallel configuration at every site. This polarizes the sector into a topologically trivial product state, leaving a low-energy manifold separated from the parallel sector by a prominent bare gap of . The Zeeman term simply vanishes in this regime.
Projecting the full Hamiltonian onto this low-energy manifold at leading order amounts to freezing and evaluating matrix elements within this gapped subspace. Under this projection, the Zeeman term and the nonlocal transverse terms vanish entirely, contributing only via high-order virtual processes. The system collapses identically into an effective transverse-field Ising model (TFIM) governing only the hidden variables ,
where the effective inter-site exchange is uniquely dictated by the competition between intralayer and nonlocal interlayer interactions,
This TFIM arises from the intrinsic spin interactions rather than the external magnetic field. Thus, it is an example of intrinsic TFIM [24, 25].
To drive this active sector into a gapped spin liquid, we specialize to the coupling hierarchy introduced by Balents, Fisher, and Girvin (BFG). We retain interactions up to the intrahexagon third-neighbor shell () while strictly excluding interhexagon third-neighbor paths. By enforcing the BFG condition
which maps onto a constraint on the difference profile , the effective Hamiltonian can be neatly recast into an unfrustrated sum of corner-sharing hexagonal clusters,
where is the number of kagomé hexagons. In the limit , the classical ground-state manifold is strictly defined by a local ice-like constraint on every single hexagon,
Figure 2. Construction of the BFG limit after the microscopic couplings of Figure 1 have been projected to the effective model. (a) The equal-coupling condition penalizes nonzero charge on each kagomé hexagon. The shaded band denotes the low-energy three-up/three-down manifold. A single transverse-field flip creates constraint defects on two adjacent hexagons at an energy cost of order . (b) Four virtual flips around a triangular-lattice rhombus return the system to the constrained manifold and resonate the two alternating link configurations within the three-dimer constrained Hilbert space, with matrix element .
Figure 1. Bilayer kagomé lattice and couplings. (a) AA-stacked bilayer geometry. (b) Intralayer shells ; intrahexagon 3rd-neighbor couplings connect opposite vertices of the hexagon, while interhexagon 3rd-neighbor couplings (crossed out) are excluded. (c) The local exchange and nonlocal interlayer at in-plane separations .
requiring precisely three “up” and three “down” pseudospins per hexagon. Because a single transverse-field operator acts as a defect creator that violates the ice rule on two adjacent hexagons at a severe energy penalty [Fig. 2(a)], the low-energy physics within the macroscopically degenerate BFG manifold is driven by a four-body ring-exchange resonance around the elementary rhombi of the lattice [Fig. 2(b)]. This yields an effective dimer resonance amplitude,
This maps exactly onto a gapped quantum dimer model on the dual triangular lattice, ensuring that while the visible sector is a completely trivial paramagnet, the hidden sector hosts a fully functional, highly entangled topological order.
Fractionalized Excitations and Magnons
The highly disparate roles of the two sectors manifest sharply in their elementary excitations. The hidden sector hosts fractionalized, topological anyons, electric spinons and magnetic visons, whereas the auxiliary sector produces conventional, non-topological collective modes (magnons). We describe these excitations using a gauge-fixed spinon mean field, a dual vison model, and a spin-wave expansion for , respectively. The operator mappings below are exact within the stated gauge constraints, and the quadratic spectra are approximate descriptions of the excitations.
Spinons

Figure 3. Lattice dictionary for the gauge and duality descriptions. Kagomé sites (yellow) are midpoints of triangular-lattice links (blue), which carry gauge fields; triangular sites host spinons . The dual honeycomb sites and links (red) host the vison variables and . The highlighted kagomé site lies at the midpoint of and is crossed by .
We formalize the spinon matter fields by mapping the constrained sector onto a lattice gauge theory on the triangular lattice formed by the hexagon centers. Each kagomé site is identified as a link connecting nearest-neighbor triangular sites. We identify the longitudinal variable as the link gauge field , and introduce a hardcore bosonic matter field (with ) at the vertices to represent the spinons. The physical states are explicitly governed by the Gauss-law constraint,
where the product runs over the six links touching . With this constraint, the transverse operator is represented as . In the three-up-three-down manifold,
so the BFG liquid has an odd background gauge charge. A local flip changes this parity at the two adjacent hexagon centers, creating a spinon pair relative to that background. The parity condition retains less information than the three-dimer constraint, which also fixes the number of occupied links at each triangular site. The odd background fixes the flux experienced by visons, as discussed in Sec. IV B.
To formulate the spinon mean-field theory, we represent the link and matter variables by hardcore bosons,
Here the matter-boson vacuum is defined relative to the odd background. For a uniform real mean-field ansatz in a fixed gauge, we replace the link operator by and fix the auxiliary background at . Relaxing the matter hardcore constraint to a quadratic boson approximation gives
The hopping and pair-creation amplitudes have the common coefficient . The parameter sets the matter-boson energy and is fixed by an average number constraint in the saddle-point approximation described in Appendix A. We define , where runs over the six nearest-neighbor vectors. The Bogoliubov diagonalization gives a single spinon branch
Stability of this quadratic Hamiltonian requires and throughout the Brillouin zone. For the uniform ansatz, the band minimum is at for and at for . A gapped spinon saddle is a consistency condition for the assumed liquid; deconfinement also requires the vison sector to remain gapped.
We compare number-constrained spinon saddles with and . Here is the integer target in the softened constraint , and its parity labels the chosen background. This approximation does not impose the three-dimer constraint, even when is odd. The even background, included here for comparison, can be favored by a Zeeman term acting on that selects an even number of dimers at each triangular-lattice site. The scan variable is
At , this gives . The energy functional and stationarity equations used for this comparison are given in Appendix A.
The spinon gap is . We restrict the candidate set to uncondensed saddles with . For each and sign of , we enforce and minimize the energy along the resulting constraint curve. Brillouin-zone averages are evaluated in the thermodynamic limit. Among the admissible gapped minima, the selected sectors are successively , , , . Gapless and condensed solutions are excluded from this comparison. The boundaries thus mark the appearance of new gapped candidates, rather than energy crossings with ordered phases. Figure 4(a,Figure 4b) illustrates the selected sectors and their representative spinon dispersions; the onset values are listed in Table III.
Figure 4. Gapped spinon saddle selection and representative excitation spectra. (a) Lowest constrained energy among uncondensed, gapped spinon saddles, labelled by . Gray denotes the absence of a gapped interior minimum in this ansatz. (b) Spinon bands at , in the sector order shown in (a), with solid, dashed, dash-dotted, and dotted lines, respectively. Each curve is the single spinon band of a different self-consistent solution, identified by the legend; the colors are shared with (a). We use and fix . (c) Static vison-kernel eigenvalues for the odd background at . (d) Three auxiliary magnon bands for the effective coefficients , , and defined in Appendix C. All energies and effective coefficients are in units of . The vison and magnon panels use independently specified effective parameters. Panel (a) compares gapped candidates only, without selecting against competing condensed states.
| sign | Soft mode | ||
| 1 | 5.939 | ||
| 1 | 13.457 | ||
| 2 | 17.315 | ||
| 2 | 38.345 |
Table III. Onsets of gapped spinon minima in the softened mean-field ansatz. The endpoints themselves have zero gap. These are existence boundaries for the individual branches, not energy crossings with condensed states.
Visons
A vison changes the magnetic flux through a triangular plaquette. The plaquette centers form the dual honeycomb lattice, whose sites coincide with the kagomé triangle centers. We introduce Pauli operators for the dual matter and for the dual gauge field. Electric–magnetic duality maps the original magnetic flux to and the original electric charge to a dual hexagon flux [12]. The complete operator dictionary, both Gauss laws, and the transformed Hamiltonian are given in Appendix § 3.0.1. The relation relevant for the spectroscopy is
where the honeycomb link crosses the triangular link . The right-hand side is a gauge-invariant vison-pair operator. It changes at the two endpoints, and the link factor supplies the required gauge dressing. Thus the longitudinal operator creates two magnetic-flux excitations relative to the chosen background.
We describe the vison fluctuations by approximating the spinon charges as a static background. In a fixed dual gauge, we replace the gauge field by a prescribed mean-field pattern consistent with the Gauss law. We use a soft-spin approximation, which replaces the two-level Pauli component by a continuous real field [26]. This relaxes the exact identity and permits amplitude fluctuations of . The field describes vison excitations. Under these approximations, the vison Hamiltonian becomes quadratic in the soft field,
Here is the common neighbor of the next-nearest-neighbor pair. The microscopic origin and limitations of this truncation are discussed in Appendix § 3.0.1. In particular, dual links sharing a honeycomb site yield a quadratic term because , whereas disjoint links retain four-vison interactions. The latter also occur at the BFG point and cannot be discarded as weak further-neighbor corrections. Accordingly, , , and are treated as the phenomenological parameters of the quadratic vison theory. The microscopic symmetry restrictions on this parametrization are given in Appendix § 3.0.1. The odd constraint of the present model fixes the background flux to
Here labels a hexagonal plaquette of the dual honeycomb lattice around one triangular site.
For the odd BFG background, follows directly from Eq. (14). A convenient gauge doubles the honeycomb unit cell, and the vison kernel becomes a four-band matrix in the magnetic Brillouin zone. The enlarged unit cell reflects fractionalized translation symmetry of the vison, not symmetry breaking of the spin-liquid ground state. The gauge convention and quadratic kernel are given in Appendix § 3.0.1.
Diagonalizing the quadratic kernel gives the vison bands . The four odd-background bands are shown in Figure 4(c).
Auxiliary magnons
The sector supplies ordinary non-topological collective modes. The nonlocal transverse term , absent from the leading projected Hamiltonian but present in the exact model, gives these excitations a dispersion. We therefore expand about the polarized state ,
At zero field, we replace the operators by their equal-time expectation values in the symmetry-preserving spin-liquid ground state. Thus , while the single-site transverse expectation and bond correlators are retained. In the strictly constrained manifold, acting with on $\sum_{j\in\lozenge}\tau_j^z=0 gives
for each of the two hexagons containing site . This fixes the sum of the five bond correlators, not each correlator separately. A uniform value per bond is one possible approximation to the sum rule. Virtual constraint violations give corrections of order .
Changing from to removes the Ising interactions between site and its ten intrahexagon neighbors. In a frozen background, the on-site coefficient is therefore
The term follows from summing Eq. (23) over both hexagons. A single virtual flip has energy cost and matrix element , giving
The transverse contribution to is positive. Corrections to the bond correlators enter at the same order and must also be retained for a quantitative expansion through . Eq. (24) is an on-site estimate within the factorized background; the actual band gap includes dispersion and relaxation of the surrounding state.
The transverse intralayer and nonlocal interlayer couplings generate both normal and anomalous bilinears on the three-site kagomé unit cell. To formulate the quadratic Hamiltonian, we introduce the Nambu spinor
where annihilates an auxiliary magnon on sublattice . The quadratic Hamiltonian is a bosonic BdG problem,
with the matrix specified in Appendix § 3.0.2. The positive bosonic BdG energies define three branches , with the gap . In the strong-interlayer regime their bandwidth is small compared with the local scale . These modes carry no topological charge. Their role in dressing the physical spin response follows from the operator dictionary developed in § 3.1.
Physical Operator Dictionary and Spectroscopic Selection Rules
The response measured by a microscopic spin operator is determined by how that operator resolves into the hidden topological sector and the auxiliary sector. We use the Pauli-normalized notation for the auxiliary variable, and similarly write for local operators in the BFG sector. For a kagomé site lying at the midpoint of a triangular link and a dual honeycomb link , define
Here the superscripts label the topological sectors. and create spinon and vison pairs, respectively, while probes the composite channel. Because these local operators are strictly gauge invariant, they always excite anyon pairs or multi-anyon continua rather than isolated anyons.
Table II. Operator dictionary. The kagomé site is the midpoint of the triangular link and is crossed by the honeycomb link .
Table II summarizes the notation used to connect the microscopic spin variables, the auxiliary variables, and the emergent gauge-theory variables.
The physical spin operators follow by substituting these gauge-invariant objects into the exact local - dictionary of Table I,
Remarkably, the upper-layer longitudinal spin is proportional to alone, providing a direct, undressed probe of the vison-pair operator . By contrast, the lower-layer component is coupled to . Expanding around the polarized background as (with at large ), one sees that its static part still accesses the bare two-vison continuum, whereas the fluctuation introduces inelastic dressing from the sector. Meanwhile, the transverse spin components involve and thus act as purely composite operators at leading order, except for which directly measures the auxiliary magnons.
We denote the layer-resolved dynamic spin structure factor by , with specifying the layers and the spin components. The longitudinal same-layer response of the upper layer is thus , whose spectral representation is given in § 3.2.
Thus the special role of is not that it is the only longitudinal channel with a bare vison component. Rather, it is the simplest layer-resolved channel because its local operator is exactly proportional to . In a physical bilayer probe the natural diagnostics are the layer-even and layer-odd longitudinal combinations, which are fixed within the antiparallel manifold by the exact identities and . The low-energy longitudinal response resides entirely in the layer-odd combination, with four times the intensity of the single-layer channel, while the layer-even combination carries only -dressed weight above . This does not mean that the bare channel must carry the largest spectral weight in a real material. It means that its operator content has the fewest auxiliary-sector ambiguities.
Dynamic Spin Structure Factors
At zero temperature, the dynamic spin structure factor is given by the Lehmann representation
where , and denotes an eigenstate with energy ( being the ground state). Throughout this section, momenta are defined in the kagomé Brillouin zone unless specified otherwise.
Using the operator dictionary in Eq. (29), we evaluate the structure factors by decoupling the hidden topological sector from the auxiliary sector at leading order. A composite local operator then yields a momentum-energy convolution of the two sectors,
While residual inter-sector interactions beyond this leading factorization may redistribute spectral weight near the thresholds, they do not alter the kinematic onset or the fundamental distinction between bare and composite channels.
The elementary topological building blocks are the two-spinon, two-vison, and -sector spectral functions. In the spinon channel,
where is a kagomé bond form factor and is the Bogoliubov angle of Eq. (16). The lower edge is .
For visons, the generic two-particle response is
where the matrix element contains the dual gauge background and honeycomb sublattice form factors. The band indices run over the four odd-sector vison bands. The kinematic two-vison threshold is
where denotes the vison dispersion (see Appendix § 3.0.1), though form-factor zeros may suppress the spectral weight right at the kinematic edge. Neglecting potential spinon-vison bound states, we similarly approximate the -sector response as a four-anyon continuum formed by convolving the two-spinon and two-vison spectra,
The auxiliary sector contributes one- and two-magnon responses. In the Holstein-Primakoff expansion about , the transverse operators and are linear in , and whereas the connected part of is bilinear. Thus and couple to a single magnon,
while the connected part of starts as a two-magnon continuum,
The full response also contains a static contribution from . In the longitudinal lower-layer channel this static factor multiplies the vison operator and therefore contributes another copy of the bare two-vison continuum; only the connected fluctuation produces the dressed inelastic continuum.
Using Eq. (29), the layer-resolved channels become
Here denotes the momentum-energy convolution in Eq. (31). Notably, is completely free of auxiliary-sector convolutions. The interlayer longitudinal correlator also remains undressed at this order because the linear fluctuation vanishes in the factorized ground state, saturating the on-site sum rule dictated by .
The clean bare-vison channel is therefore . Its continuum onset follows Eq. (34), and its intensity is governed by the dual honeycomb form factor in Eq. (33). The same topological continuum also appears in and , but there it is folded with a two-magnon response or a one-magnon response. These convolutions raise and broaden spectral thresholds and can obscure the momentum structure of the underlying visons.
The three longitudinal channels combine into the response measured at interlayer momentum transfer for two layers separated by , with by layer symmetry and hermiticity,
The dressed term begins only above the bare two-vison threshold, so in the entire low-energy window Eq. (39) reduces, for , to
Thus the bare two-vison continuum has this interlayer modulation and vanishes at . At this expresses conservation of the total ; at general it follows from the projected identity .
The transverse channels have a different interpretation. The lower-layer channel is topologically trivial at leading order and measures the ordinary -magnon spectrum.
By contrast, the upper-layer channel contains the two-spinon continuum, but only after convolution with the one-magnon response. The upper-layer channel is still more composite because it probes the sector and the magnon simultaneously. These channels may carry sizable spectral weight, but their thresholds are not direct anyon thresholds.
Representative spectra across these channels are contrasted in Figure 5. For , we plot only the connected fluctuation-dressed contribution , since its static part simply duplicates . To illustrate the kinematic convolution features, we adopt the spinon saddle at (, , giving and ), alongside the phenomenological vison and -magnon parameters from Figure 4(c,d). Because the odd vison background carries flux per dual hexagon, the vison modes are computed in the magnetic Brillouin zone and folded back into the kagomé Brillouin zone on a grid (with Gaussian broadening ). This zone folding directly shapes the momentum profile of the bare two-vison continuum in , providing a sharp spectral benchmark against the broadened, magnon-dressed continua in the composite channels.
Figure 5. Representative layer-resolved diagonal dynamical structure factors along ---. The panels contrast the clean diagnostic with the connected fluctuation-dressed lower-layer longitudinal response and channels in which the same vison continuum is dressed by auxiliary -sector excitations, including and the connected part of , , together with the topologically trivial control channel . The full contains the static bare-vison term in addition to the connected contribution. Intensities are normalized within each panel on a logarithmic scale.
Discussion
The bilayer kagomé construction gives a concrete example in which a topological order is present but is not generically exposed with simple spin variables nor a simple fractionalized continuum in the physical spin response. In a conventional single-variable spin liquid, the spin operator often has a direct overlap with a pair of fractionalized quasiparticles. Here the topological sector is the hidden variable, while the measured microscopic spin contains both and the auxiliary interlayer-alignment variable . As a result, most spin structure factors probe composite operators. A broad continuum in such a channel need not be a bare spinon or vison continuum, and the absence of a clean continuum in a generic channel does not by itself exclude a spin liquid.
The most direct layer-resolved signature in this model is the upper-layer longitudinal response. The operator identity makes a direct probe of the two-vison continuum. The lower-layer longitudinal response contains the same bare continuum through the static value of , together with an additional connected dressing from fluctuations. Other channels contain useful information, but their interpretation requires the auxiliary spectrum. For example, contains the two-spinon continuum only after convolution with a one--magnon response, whereas is dominated by the ordinary -magnon branch. Experimentally, this structure favors probes that can resolve the spin polarization and layer content. Polarized inelastic neutron scattering is a natural starting point because it can separate the longitudinal and transverse spin components. In a bilayer material, the momentum dependence along the interlayer direction separates the layer combinations directly. By Eq. (39), the low-energy two-vison continuum is modulated as and vanishes at . Other layer-sensitive magnetic spectroscopies could play a similar role if they couple differently to the two kagomé layers. The central experimental target is not simply a broad continuum, but the contrast between the bare two-vison continuum in the longitudinal layer-odd channel and the dressed continua predicted in the remaining channels.
The concrete construction requires the kagomé bilayers, a strong local interlayer Ising coupling, and frustrated longer-range Ising interactions that can approximate the BFG condition in Eq. (9). Candidate platforms include bilayer kagomé transition-metal and rare-earth magnets. A quantitative material proposal would require the microscopic exchange estimates, crystal-field analysis, and a calculation of detailed neutron form factors. Those aspects are outside the scope of the present theory. The result here is instead a diagnostic principle. Hidden variables in a multi-component magnet [27] can relocate the topological continuum to a more convoluted and selected response channel.
In summary, we have constructed a bilayer kagomé lattice antiferromagnet in which the low-energy pseudospin realizes the BFG route to a topological order, while the auxiliary interlayer-alignment variable remains topologically trivial. The - mapping gives an exact local dictionary between physical spin operators and emergent operators of the hidden topological theory. This dictionary leads to the concrete spectroscopic selection rules. detects the bare two-vison continuum, whereas most other diagonal layer-resolved channels measure convolutions of topological continua and -magnon responses. Rather than advocating the specific and concrete construction in this work, we actually strongly hope this work to inspire the search and understanding of exotic and topological phases among the multi-component frustrated magnets and quantum materials where the topological orders and features are manifested with the most visible degrees of freedom, and are instead buried in the emergent and hidden variables. The current work is merely an example to illustrate this thinking, not a detailed and concrete case to be implemented.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the NSFC (Grant No. 92565110 and 12574061), the Quantum Science and Technology–National Science and Technology Major Project (Grant No. 2025ZD0300500), and the BJNSF (Grant No. F261004).
References
Spinon Mean-Field Theory
Let and . For a background sign , choose . The exact Gauss law becomes
The odd BFG vacuum has , , and three occupied links at every vertex. Here counts the complement of the occupied-link convention in Sec. III; both counts equal three in the constrained manifold.
In our mean-field treatment, we approximate and relax the exact parity constraint to the average number condition with . While the ansätze do not strictly enforce the local three-dimer constraint of the BFG manifold, they serve as tractable variational descriptions for the gapped spinon bands.
For the scan with fixed , let denote the number of triangular sites and use a normalized Brillouin-zone average . The constant term retained in Eq. (16) is
Writing and gives and vacuum occupation . The ground-state energy density is
where has been used. Stationarity with respect to and , at , gives
We select the lowest among gapped, uncondensed constrained minima. The multiplier enforces the
number constraint and is not an independent energy-minimization variable. Writing its solution as , we minimize and require positive curvature along this curve.
A convenient parametrization is . Positivity of the bosonic quadratic Hamiltonian requires and . Define the thermodynamic-limit Brillouin-zone averages
The number constraint then determines
and the energy on the constraint curve becomes
One reciprocal coordinate can be integrated analytically in terms of complete elliptic integrals, leaving a one-dimensional quadrature. Near the soft-mode boundary or , we use to resolve the small positive gap. Direct minimization of is followed by refinement with Eq. (43) and a check of the constrained curvature.
At , the regular-mode density is finite. Let and for or for . The gapped branch starts at
The resulting values are given in Table III. For , the corresponding branch has a gapped interior minimum. At the onset its gap closes at for or at for . Continuing below that onset requires treating the soft-mode occupation separately; such condensed branches are outside the gapped variational space considered here.
Vison Duality and Soft-Spin Approximation
Exact duality
Let be a triangular-lattice link and its crossing honeycomb link. The direct triangle is centered at , and the dual hexagon surrounds the direct vertex . Here denotes the boundary of a plaquette. Products over and run over the three and six links forming the respective boundaries.
All four sets of variables , , , are Pauli operators. The original physical Hilbert space obeys
Within the corresponding physical subspaces, we introduce the duality mapping
The first two lines exchange the gauge-invariant Pauli pair on each crossing link. Both operators square to one, anticommute on that link, and commute on distinct links. They also commute with their respective Gauss generators. This mapping therefore preserves the exact gauge-invariant operator algebra within the physical subspace.
The plaquette and star relations are consistent with the Gauss laws. Around a direct triangle, each endpoint factor appears twice and cancels, so the first line gives
This fixes the dual physical subspace through the Gauss law
where the product contains the three honeycomb links incident on . Conversely, multiplying the second line of Eq. (49) over the six links touching cancels every factor on the surrounding dual hexagon. Equation (B1) then gives the fourth line. Original electric charge is therefore dual magnetic flux, while original magnetic flux is dual electric charge. Excitations are defined as changes relative to the chosen charge and flux backgrounds.
The dual redundancy acts as
with . A single is gauge dependent, whereas the dressed pair in Eq. (19) is gauge invariant. More generally, an open product of along a dual path becomes a vison pair joined by an Wilson line. An open spinon Wilson line with endpoints becomes the corresponding product of . The two string operators anticommute when their paths cross an odd number of times, expressing the mutual statistical phase of spinons and visons.
The local identities do not fix the noncontractible loop operators on a torus. Their algebra must also be carried through the mapping, and any restriction to a fixed background must keep track of its global holonomies. The closed-lattice identities and enforce even total charge and flux parity. Keeping track of these global topological sectors ensures an exact one-to-one correspondence between the direct and dual Hilbert spaces.
Dual Hamiltonian and charge backgrounds
The duality acts on the sector; all auxiliary operators are unchanged. The full – Hamiltonian can be transformed using the same operator dictionary. Here we display its leading projected form. For the kagomé lattice site corresponding to , abbreviate the dressed dual bond by . Substitution into Eq. (7) gives the exact dual form of the projected Hamiltonian,
subject to Eq. (51), where each kagomé pair is counted once. Equation (B6) retains the full dual gauge dynamics, providing the exact starting point before introducing the static-flux and soft-spin approximations.
To describe visons in a static charge background, we fix a gauge and replace the original charges by . The background links must then satisfy
The three-dimer BFG constraint gives , producing one flux per dual hexagon. This establishes Eq. (21) directly from the original Gauss law. On a closed periodic lattice the chosen charges must obey ; the loop sectors remain additional data when selecting a background representative.
For an unordered kagomé pair, the Ising interaction is . If the corresponding dual links share a site, Eq. (19) therefore yields
using before making a soft-spin approximation. Thus the bare contribution from a kagomé nearest-neighbor bond is in the unordered-pair convention of Eq. (20). The second- and intrahexagon third-neighbor terms involve disjoint dual links and remain quartic.
Because all three shells have equal strength at the BFG point, these quartic terms are comparable to , motivating a phenomenological treatment of the effective quadratic vison hopping. Furthermore, in the exact Pauli representation, the nearest-neighbor term corresponds to a longitudinal field that is odd under layer exchange. We nevertheless include a phenomenological in Figure 4(c) to illustrate the generic structure of the four-band odd-flux vison kernel.
Soft-spin fields and quadratic kernels
Up to this point, is a Pauli operator with eigenvalues and the local identity . The soft-spin ap approximation replaces it by a real field , transforming as under the same dual gauge redundancy. Its amplitude is allowed to fluctuate, so is no longer an operator identity. This replacement retains fluctuations of the vison field and should not be read as taking the expectation value of .
Consequently, the shared-site cancellation used above must be carried out in the Pauli algebra before softening. Replacing all factors by first would leave an intermediate and would not give the same quadratic interaction. A spherical approximation can impose an average length constraint through once the dynamics is specified; it does not restore the exact local two-level Hilbert space.
Writing the static quadratic energy as , an odd-background gauge with four sites per magnetic unit cell has
where, with the magnetic Bravais vectors and , ,
The matrix sums two-link paths with their gauge signs. Let be the triangular Bravais vectors. We choose and , so the magnetic unit cell has twice the area of the original honeycomb unit cell. The four eigenvalues of give the static vison bands.
To turn such a kernel into a quantum soft-spin theory, one possible normalization of the Euclidean action is
which yields for and a positive kernel. For the spectral parametrization used in § 3.2, we adopt . This linear assignment is an independent phenomenological choice. In this parametrization, is also specified as an input rather than determined by a dynamical spherical constraint.
Auxiliary -Magnon Spin-Wave Theory
For real, translation-invariant bond correlators, write the quadratic real-space Hamiltonian as
Each pair is counted once, and the third-neighbor sum includes only intrahexagon pairs. Within the factorization used in Sec. IV, let and on shell . When mixed – correlators vanish, the microscopic transverse terms give
with the on-site energy given by Eq. (24). In Figure 4(d) and § 3.2, we treat , , and as effective phenomenological parameters to illustrate the magnon dispersion and its convolution with the topological continua.
Let be the set of cell displacements connecting sublattices by a shell- bond. Define
The normal and anomalous blocks are
Using the Nambu convention in Eq. (26), the matrix is
For a positive-definite , para-unitary diagonalization gives the three positive eigenvalues of , with The limit gives three modes of energy , which fixes the factor of in Eq. (27).
References
- [1]X.-G. Wen, Topological orders in rigid states, Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 4, 239 (1990).DOI
- [2]D. C. Tsui, H. L. Stormer, and A. C. Gossard, Two-Dimensional Magnetotransport in the Extreme Quantum Limit, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1559 (1982).
- [3]R. B. Laughlin, Anomalous Quantum Hall Effect: An Incompressible Quantum Fluid with Fractionally Charged Excitations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1395 (1983).
- [4]J. Cai, E. Anderson, C. Wang, X. Zhang, X. Liu, W. Holtzmann, Y. Zhang, F. Fan, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, Y. Ran, T. Cao, L. Fu, D. Xiao, W. Yao, and X. Xu, Signatures of fractional quantum anomalous Hall states in twisted MoTe2, Nature 622, 63 (2023).DOI
- [5]Y. Zeng, Z. Xia, K. Kang, J. Zhu, P. Knüppel, C. Vaswani, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, K. F. Mak, and J. Shan, Thermodynamic evidence of fractional Chern insulator in moiré MoTe2, Nature 622, 69 (2023).DOI
- [6]H. Park, J. Cai, E. Anderson, Y. Zhang, J. Zhu, X. Liu, C. Wang, W. Holtzmann, C. Hu, Z. Liu, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, J.-H. Chu, T. Cao, L. Fu, W. Yao, C.-Z. Chang, D. Cobden, D. Xiao, and X. Xu, Observation of fractionally quantized anomalous Hall effect, Nature 622, 74 (2023).DOI
- [7]A. Yu. Kitaev, Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons, Ann. Phys. 303, 2 (2003).DOI
- [8]M. A. Levin and X.-G. Wen, String-net condensation: A physical mechanism for topological phases, Phys. Rev. B 71, 045110 (2005).DOI
- [9]A. Kitaev, Anyons in an exactly solved model and beyond, Ann. Phys. 321, 2 (2006).DOI
- [10]G. Jackeli and G. Khaliullin, Mott Insulators in the Strong Spin-Orbit Coupling Limit: From Heisenberg to a Quantum Compass and Kitaev Models, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 017205 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19257237
- [11]L. Balents, M. P. A. Fisher, and S. M. Girvin, Fractionalization in an easy-axis Kagome antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 65, 224412 (2002).DOI
- [12]P. Zhao and G. v. Chen, Z2 topological orders in kagome dipolar systems: Feedback from Rydberg quantum simulator, SciPost Phys. 19, 040 (2025).DOI
- [13]M. Hermele, M. P. A. Fisher, and L. Balents, Pyrochlore photons: The U(1) spin liquid in a S=1/2 three-dimensional frustrated magnet, Phys. Rev. B 69, 064404 (2004).DOI
- [14]L. Balents, Spin liquids in frustrated magnets, Nature 464, 199 (2010).
- [15]L. Savary and L. Balents, Quantum spin liquids: A review, Rep. Prog. Phys. 80, 016502 (2017).DOI
- [16]J. Wen, S.-L. Yu, S. Li, W. Yu, and J.-X. Li, Experimental identification of quantum spin liquids, Npj Quantum Mater. 4, 12 (2019).DOI
- [17]T.-H. Han, J. S. Helton, S. Chu, D. G. Nocera, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, C. Broholm, and Y. S. Lee, Fractionalized excitations in the spin-liquid state of a kagome-lattice antiferromagnet, Nature 492, 406 (2012).
- [18]J. Becker and S. Wessel, Diagnosing fractionalization from the spin dynamics of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice by quantum Monte Carlo simulations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 077202 (2018).DOI
- [19]J. Knolle, D. L. Kovrizhin, J. T. Chalker, and R. Moessner, Dynamics of a Two-Dimensional Quantum Spin Liquid: Signatures of Emergent Majorana Fermions and Fluxes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 207203 (2014).DOI
- [20]A. Banerjee, J. Yan, J. Knolle, C. A. Bridges, M. B. Stone, M. D. Lumsden, D. G. Mandrus, D. A. Tennant, R. Moessner, and S. E. Nagler, Neutron scattering in the proximate quantum spin liquid α-RuCl3, Science 356, 1055 (2017).DOI
- [21]C. Broholm, R. J. Cava, S. A. Kivelson, D. G. Nocera, M. R. Norman, and T. Senthil, Quantum spin liquids, Science 367, eaay0668 (2020).
- [22]G. Chen, Emergent Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless and Kugel-Khomskii Physics in the Triangular Lattice Bilayer Cobaltate, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 136703 (2024).DOI
- [23]S. V. Isakov, Y. B. Kim, and A. Paramekanti, Spin-Liquid Phase in a Spin-1/2 Quantum Magnet on the Kagome Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 207204 (2006).
- [24]G. Chen, Intrinsic transverse field in frustrated quantum Ising magnets: Physical origin and quantum effects, Phys. Rev. Res. 1, 033141 (2019).DOI
- [25]C. Liu, C.-J. Huang, and G. Chen, Intrinsic quantum Ising model on a triangular lattice magnet TmMgGaO4, Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 043013 (2020).DOI
- [26]Y. Huh, M. Punk, and S. Sachdev, Vison states and confinement transitions of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice, Phys. Rev. B 84, 094419 (2011).DOI
- [27]G. v. Chen and C. Wu, Multifavor Mott insulators in quantum materials and ultracold atoms, npj Quantum Materials 9, 10.1038/s41535-023-00614-2 (2024).DOI



