betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Oscillating electroosmotic flow in channels and capillaries with modulated wall charge distribution

Abstract

Electrolyte-filled channels with modulated wall charge distribution subjected to an applied DC electric field, form time-independent vortices whose sense of circulation is determined by the field direction [Physical Review Letters 75,755,(1995) \mathbf{75}, 755, (1995)]. In this paper we show that an electrolyte in a channel or cylindrical capillary subjected to an external alternating (AC) electric field gives rise to various laminar flow structures, including vortices whose sense of circulation changes with the period of oscillation of the applied AC field. The introduction of a period of oscillation lifts certain degeneracies associated with its time-independent counterpart. Although, in general, the mass flux vanishes, the charge flux is nonzero. The flow is accompanied by a longitudinal (oscillating) advective current that displays hysteresis accompanied by a diverging and negative self-similar conductance that depends on the applied voltage [Nano Letters 10,2674,(2010)\mathbf{10}, 2674, (2010)]. We show that this behavior can be interpreted with respect to a ``memory retention time'', that depends on frequency, viscosity and the Debye length and could thus form the impetus for investigating control protocols of signal carriers.

Introduction

Microfluidic devices employ static channel networks to continuously activate liquids via time-independent drives. Such flows can be mediated by applied pressure gradients or electroosmosis in channels filled with ionic solutions. These static devices have been constructed using various methods such as lithography, micromilling, and injection moulding [1, 2, 3]. However, such predefined fabrications limit their functionalities in terms of applications that require an adjustable control of the fluid flow state. On the other hand, configurable microfluidic devices that are physically actuated by means of device assembly can be modified from a base state to a specified functional state. This has been achieved for example, through modular assembly, patterning hydrophobic surfaces, and paraffin structuring [4, 5]. Attaining regulated fluid flows in channels and capillaries that go beyond a fixed number of states is crucial for many microfluidic applications such as targeted solute delivery, mixing-induced chemical reactions, and volume-specified fluid transport.

Most studies of electrolyte transport assume that the channel walls are uniformly charged. However, acquired through fabrication or other routes, charge adsorption may change the surface charge distribution, for instance, during charged particle filtration, cf. [6]. Anderson [7] and Ajdari [8] determined the vortex flow structure of an electrolyte in channels with nonuniform charged walls. The vortices are time-independent and have a fixed sense of circulation determined by the direction of the (steady) applied DC electric field. These studies were followed up by experiments on patterning flows in soft-lithography polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) and glass wall channels [5, 9] establishing consistency of the experimental results with theoretical models. More recently Kamsma et al. [10] showed numerically, that an inhomogeneous wall charge distribution on a conical channel exhibited stronger current rectification and more pronounced memristive properties compared to uniformly charged conical channels [10], if the charge distribution changes sign when traversing the channel along its long axis (what they call “bipolar” surface charges). A theoretical framework for understanding the combined effect of active and charged boundaries relevant in biological or soft matter systems was recently developed in Ref. [11].

The steady character of the aforementioned flows leads a microfluidic device to be classified as static or configurable such that the state of flow is either fixed at the manufacturing level and/or formatted to attain only limited predefined states [4]. Current scientific and technological needs, however, require the state of devices to be reconfigurable so to attain many different desired states ad voluntatem and in real time, cf. [12]. To address this requirement we propose here a way to generate time-dependent vortex and other laminar flows by applying an alternating (AC) electric field on a rectangular channel or cylindrical capillary with modulated charged walls. As a result, this mode of reconfiguration generates a multitude of flow states that can be actuated as desired. This work suggests a reconfigurable way to tune and control electroosmotic flow in microfluidic devices that provides an efficient means for mixing, targeted solute transport, pumping and energy conversion.

Electrolyte Flow with Modulated Wall Charge Distribution

It is well known [21 §2.10] that there are low Reynolds number flows which are unsteady. This requires the “vibrational” Reynolds number ℓ2ω/ν\ell^{2}\omega/\nu to not be small in comparison to the translational Reynolds number ℓU/ν\ell U/\nu. Here ℓ,U\ell,U and ω\omega are characteristic length, translational velocity and frequency scales, respectively, while ν\nu is the liquid kinematic viscosity. With this understanding, the Navier-Stokes equations reduce to the form

ρ∂tv=−∇p+η∇2v+Fand∇⋅v=0,(1)\rho\partial_{t}\mathbf{v}=-\nabla p+\eta\nabla^{2}\mathbf{v}+\mathbf{F}\quad\text{and}\quad\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}=0, \tag*{(1)}

which can be employed to obtain estimates for the flow structure of time-dependent effects. Here, pp is the hydrodynamic pressure, ρ\rho is the mass density of the liquid, η\eta is its dynamic viscosity and F\mathbf{F} a body force. In the context of this paper the body force is induced by an electric field acting on the free charges of an electrolyte.

We consider an external alternating electric field E\mathbf{E} with (real) frequency ω\omega acting on a 1:11:1 electrolyte in a rectangular channel and in a cylindrical capillary. Because the walls are charged, an intrinsic electric field −∇ϕ-\nabla\phi forms (unrelated to the external field E\mathbf{E} in this discussion), providing the necessary equilibrium to the electrolyte charge species. When the potential ϕ\phi is small (the Debye-Hückel approximation), it satisfies the modified Helmholtz equation

∇2ϕ=κ2ϕ(2)\nabla^{2}\phi=\kappa^{2}\phi \tag*{(2)}

where κ−1\kappa^{-1} is the Debye length. As in Ajdari [8], it is implicit in (2) that the charge distribution in the electrolyte bulk is given by ρe=−ϵκ2ϕ\rho_{e}=-\epsilon\kappa^{2}\phi where ϵ\epsilon the dielectric constant (a consequence of the Debye-Hückel approximation, cf. Probstein [22]).

The total electric field E−∇ϕ\mathbf{E}-\nabla\phi exerts a body force F=ρe(E−∇ϕ)\mathbf{F}=\rho_{e}\left(\mathbf{E}-\nabla\phi\right) on the liquid electrolyte (fluid + ions), whose velocity v\mathbf{v} satisfies the Navier-Stokes equations (1)

ρ∂tv=−∇p~+η∇2v+ρeEand∇⋅v=0,(3)\rho\partial_{t}\mathbf{v}=-\nabla\widetilde{p}+\eta\nabla^{2}\mathbf{v}+\rho_{e}\mathbf{E}\quad\text{and}\quad\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}=0, \tag*{(3)}

where p~\widetilde{p} is an effective pressure. Since the expression ϵκ2ϕ∇ϕ\epsilon\kappa^{2}\phi\nabla\phi is the gradient of a scalar function, this contribution to the body force has been absorbed into the pressure and it does not affect the form of the streamlines and the commensurate velocity field.

Motivation for studying this configuration stems from the experiments of Stroock et al. [9 figure 2], who obtained qualitatively similar flow patterns to the ones obtained here (albeit theirs being steady and expressed with respect to different boundary conditions). For clarity, our notation follows that of Ajdari [8, 23] who showed that steady vortices, in a channel with cos⁡qx\cos qx wall charge variation, can form in a time-independent electric field. In the adiabatic limit (ω→0\omega\to0) our formulation recovers these time-independent results (this discussion is developed in Appendix A). In addition, we adopt the notation of Landau & Lifshitz [16, p.89] since our configuration features similarities with the corresponding problems of oscillating pressure-driven flows in a channel or capillary. For instance, the inertial term in (1) leads to the introduction of a penetration depth δ\delta and complex wavenumber k=(1+i)/δk = (1+i)/\delta, see Eq. (13).

Rectangular channel flow with applied field parallel to surface charge variation

We consider a channel of width 2h2h (see Figure 1) whose upper and lower walls are insulating and inhomogeneously charged with corresponding distributions σ±(x)\sigma^{\pm}(x) that only vary in the xx-direction, satisfying the boundary conditions

AC electroosmosis with charge-modulated walls in a rectangular channel

Figure 1. AC electroosmosis with charge-modulated walls in a rectangular channel: A uniform alternating electric field E∼e−iωtx^\mathbf{E} \sim e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}} of frequency ω\omega exerts a body force on a 1:11:1 electrolyte in a rectangular channel of width 2h2h with surface charge σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \cos qx on the upper and lower insulating walls, respectively. This gives rise to a system of vortices whose sense of rotation changes periodically in time according to the external electric field, cf. Figure 2.

∂zϕ(x,z=±h)=±σ±(x)ϵ(4)\partial_z \phi(x,z=\pm h)=\pm\frac{\sigma^{\pm}(x)}{\epsilon} \tag*{(4)}

There is an externally applied field E=E∥e−iωtx^\mathbf{E}=E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}} parallel to the wall charge wave-vector q=qx^\mathbf{q}=q\hat{\mathbf{x}}, and in the bulk there is the potential ϕ\phi generated by the surface charges and ions. The Navier-Stokes equations (3) become

ρ∂tv=−∇p~+η∇2v−ϵκ2ϕE∥e−iωtx^.(5)\rho\partial_t\mathbf{v}=-\nabla\tilde{p}+\eta\nabla^2\mathbf{v}-\epsilon\kappa^2\phi E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}}. \tag*{(5)}

Following [8] we consider two possible inhomogeneous surface charge distributions varying harmonically with wavevector q=qx^\mathbf{q}=q\hat{\mathbf{x}}, giving rise to the corresponding potentials as detailed below

σ±=σ0cos⁡qx,thenϕ=σ0ϵQcos⁡qxcosh⁡(Qz)sinh⁡(Qh),(6)\sigma^{\pm}=\sigma_0\cos qx,\qquad\text{then}\qquad\phi=\frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon Q}\cos qx\frac{\cosh(Qz)}{\sinh(Qh)}, \tag*{(6)}

and

σ±=±σ0cos⁡qx,thenϕ=σ0ϵQcos⁡qxsinh⁡(Qz)cosh⁡(Qh),(7)\sigma^{\pm}=\pm\sigma_0\cos qx,\qquad\text{then}\qquad\phi=\frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon Q}\cos qx\frac{\sinh(Qz)}{\cosh(Qh)}, \tag*{(7)}

where the symbol σ±\sigma^{\pm} denotes surface charge distribution at the upper and lower channel walls, respectively, (see Figure 1), and

Q=(q2+κ2)1/2.(8)Q=(q^2+\kappa^2)^{1/2}. \tag*{(8)}

To determine the velocity field we take the curl of the Navier-Stokes equations (5) and introduce the streamfunction ψ\psi

v=(u,0,w)=(∂ψ∂z,0,−∂ψ∂x).(9)\mathbf{v}=(u,0,w)=\left(\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial z},0,-\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial x}\right). \tag*{(9)}
Quantity (units)Definition
ω\omega (s−1\mathrm{s}^{-1})frequency of external field
ν\nu (m2s−1\mathrm{m}^{2}\mathrm{s}^{-1})electrolyte kinematic viscosity
δ=2νω\delta= \sqrt{\frac{2\nu}{\omega}} (m)liquid penetration depth (cf. Eq. (13))
qq (m−1\mathrm{m}^{-1})wall charge variation wavenumber
κ\kappa (m−1\mathrm{m}^{-1})inverse Debye length
Q=q2+κ2Q = \sqrt{q^{2}+\kappa^{2}} (m−1\mathrm{m}^{-1})
k=1+iδk = \frac{1+i}{\delta} (m−1\mathrm{m}^{-1})liquid oscillating complex wave number (cf. Eq. (13))
K=k2−q2K = \sqrt{k^{2}-q^{2}} (m−1\mathrm{m}^{-1})liquid complex wave number with charge variation (cf. Eq. (13))
η\eta (kg m−1s−1\mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm{m}^{-1}\mathrm{s}^{-1})electrolyte dynamic viscosity
2h,2a2h, 2a (m)channel width, capillary diameter
σ±∼σ0\sigma^{\pm} \sim\sigma_{0}wall charge distribution
ϵ\epsilondielectric constant
ϕ\phielectric potential
ψ\psistreamfunction, cf. (9)
p,p~p,\tilde{p}hydrodynamic and modified pressure
u,wu,w (m/s)channel horizontal and vertical electrolyte velocity components
vr,vzv_{r},v_{z} (m/s)capillary radial and axial electrolyte velocity components

Table 1. Definitions of generic parameters and wavenumbers. qq, QQ and κ\kappa as in [8]. kk and δ\delta as in [16 §24].

The vorticity equation, written in terms of the streamfunction ψ\psi, then takes the form

ρ∂t∇2ψ=η∇4ψ−ϵκ2E∥e−iωt∂zϕ.(10)\rho\partial_{t}\nabla^{2}\psi= \eta\nabla^{4}\psi- \epsilon\kappa^{2}E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\partial_{z}\phi. \tag*{(10)}

When the xx-variation of the velocity field is proportional to cos⁡qx\cos qx and the time variation is harmonic with frequency ω\omega (instantaneously following the field), the streamfunction

ψ(x,z,t)=ψ(z)e−iωtcos⁡qx(11)\psi(x,z,t) = \psi(z)e^{-i\omega t}\cos qx \tag*{(11)}

leads to the single equation for ψ(z)\psi(z) (with an abuse in notation)

∂z4ψ+(K2−q2)∂z2ψ−K2q2ψ−ϵκ2E∥η∂zϕ(z)=0,(12)\partial_{z}^{4}\psi+ (K^{2}-q^{2})\partial_{z}^{2}\psi- K^{2}q^{2}\psi- \frac{\epsilon\kappa^{2}E_{\parallel}}{\eta}\partial_{z}\phi(z) = 0, \tag*{(12)}

where, with a slight abuse of notation, we’ve set ϕ(x,z)=ϕ(z)cos⁡qx\phi(x,z)=\phi(z)\cos qx in (12), and it is understood that ϕ(x,t)\phi(x,t) is given by one of (6) or (7). Here,

K=k2−q2,iω=νk2,k=1+iδ,δ=2νω,ν=ηρ,(13)K = \sqrt{k^{2}-q^{2}}, \qquad i\omega= \nu k^{2}, \qquad k = \frac{1+i}{\delta}, \qquad\delta= \sqrt{\frac{2\nu}{\omega}}, \qquad\nu= \frac{\eta}{\rho}, \tag*{(13)}

is the familiar notation of the penetration depth δ\delta and complex wavenumber kk of the oscillating pressure-driven flow in a channel, cf. [16 p.84-89] and ν\nu is the kinematic viscosity of the electrolyte. Thus, the zz variation of ψ(z)∼eisz\psi(z) \sim e^{isz} has wavenumbers of the form

s=±iq,ands=k2−q2≡K,(14)s = \pm iq, \qquad\text{and} \qquad s = \sqrt{k^{2}-q^{2}} \equiv K, \tag*{(14)}

leading to a solution of the form ψ(z)=Acosh⁡(qz)+Bsinh⁡(qz)+Ccos⁡(Kz)+Dsin⁡(Kz)+ψp(z)\psi(z)=A\cosh(qz)+B\sinh(qz)+C\cos(Kz)+D\sin(Kz)+\psi_{p}(z), where ψp\psi_{p} is the particular solution associated with the last term in (12) and AA, BB, CC and DD are integration constants to be determined by the no-slip boundary condition at the channel walls

ψ(±h)=dψdz(±h)=0.(15)\psi(\pm h) = \frac{d\psi}{dz}(\pm h) = 0. \tag*{(15)}

For their calculation see Appendix A. Two features distinguish the eigenvalue set in (14) from previous studies. First, the oscillatory character of our system has lifted the degeneracy present in the time-independent counterpart (where the four eigenvalues ss in (14) are instead two pairs of imaginary wavenumbers ±iq\pm iq, cf. [8]). Second, the frequency of oscillation has introduced an additional length-scale to the problem (the penetration depth δ\delta, cf. Eq. (13)) which competes with the existing scales hh, κ−1\kappa^{-1} and q−1q^{-1}.

For instance, in the symmetric charge distribution case leading to the electric potential (6), the streamfunction (11) satisfying the vorticity equation (10), prompts the function ψ(z)\psi(z) (by solving Eq. (12)) to acquire the form

ψ(z)=σ0E∥sinh⁡(Qz)η(κ2+k2)sinh⁡(Qh)−Asinh⁡(qz)−Bsin⁡(Kz)(16)\psi(z)=\frac{\sigma_0 E_{\parallel}\sinh(Qz)}{\eta(\kappa^2+k^2)\sinh(Qh)}-A\sinh(qz)-B\sin(Kz) \tag*{(16)}

with

\begin{pmatrix} A \\ B \end{pmatrix} = \frac{\sigma_0 E_{\parallel}}{\eta(\kappa^2+k^2)\sinh(Qh)} \begin{pmatrix} \dfrac{K\cos(Kh)\sinh(Qh)-Q\sin(Kh)\cosh(Qh)}{K\sinh(qh)\cos(Kh)-q\cosh(qh)\sin(Kh)} \\ \dfrac{Q\cosh(Qh)\sinh(qh)-q\sinh(Qh)\cosh(qh)}{K\sinh(qh)\cos(Kh)-q\cosh(qh)\sin(Kh)} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(17)}\end{pmatrix}

This corresponds to the velocity components

u(x,z,t)=[σ0E∥Qcosh⁡(Qz)η(κ2+k2)sinh⁡(Qh)−Aqcosh⁡(qz)−BKcos⁡(Kz)]e−iωtcos⁡qx(18)u(x,z,t)=\left[\frac{\sigma_0E_{\parallel}Q\cosh(Qz)}{\eta(\kappa^2+k^2)\sinh(Qh)}-Aq\cosh(qz)-BK\cos(Kz)\right]e^{-i\omega t}\cos qx \tag*{(18)}

and

w(x,z,t)=[σ0E∥sinh⁡(Qz)η(κ2+k2)sinh⁡(Qh)−Asinh⁡(qz)−Bsin⁡(Kz)]e−iωtqsin⁡qx.(19)w(x,z,t)=\left[\frac{\sigma_0E_{\parallel}\sinh(Qz)}{\eta(\kappa^2+k^2)\sinh(Qh)}-A\sinh(qz)-B\sin(Kz)\right]e^{-i\omega t}q\sin qx. \tag*{(19)}

In Figure 2 we display the dimensionless instantaneous streamlines from (16) (left) and (C1) (right) associated, respectively, with the symmetric surface charges σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\sigma_0\cos qx and antisymmetric surface charges σ±=±σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\pm\sigma_0\cos qx, along the channel walls. It is easy to see that the transition from the left pattern to the right occurs as the relative phase of the charge distribution on each wall is continuously varied from (in the notation of [8]) γ−−γ+=0\gamma^- - \gamma^+=0 to π\pi. See the third column in [8 figure 2].

Oscillating vortex structure in a channel

Figure 2. Oscillating vortex structure in a channel of width h=1h=1, induced by a uniform alternating electric field E=E∥e−iωtx^\mathbf{E}=E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}} of frequency ω\omega that is parallel to the wall charge variation wavevector qx^q\hat{\mathbf{x}}, cf. Figure 1 for the coordinate system. Left: dimensionless instantaneous streamlines from (16) determined for symmetric surface charges σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\sigma_0\cos qx along the channel walls. Right: dimensionless instantaneous streamlines from (C1), determined for antisymmetric surface charges σ±=±σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\pm\sigma_0\cos qx. Compare with the upper and lower row of [8 figure 2]. It is thus clear that the pattern displayed on the left smoothly deforms and becomes the one to the right by continuously varying the relative phase of the charge distribution between the upper and lower channel walls (see discussion in the main text).

We introduce the velocity scaling factor

u0=σ0E∥ηκ.(20)u_0=\frac{\sigma_0E_{\parallel}}{\eta\kappa}. \tag*{(20)}

The unsteady streamfunction (18) reduces to its static counterpart (A3) in the limit ω→0\omega\to0. A distinguishing feature of the solution (16) in comparison with previous studies cf. Appendix A is that it has lifted another degeneracy; the one that exists in the time-independent problem when κ→0\kappa\to0 (although this limit is not expected to practically ever be reached), see the front factors of Eq. (A3)–(A4) in comparison to the front factors of (16) with (17).

Cylindrical capillary flow with axially applied field

The above analysis can be repeated for the case of a cylindrical capillary with circular cross-section of radius aa whose insulating wall carries a charge

σ=σ0cos⁡qz,at r=a,(21)\sigma= \sigma_0 \cos qz,\quad\text{at } r=a, \tag*{(21)}

cf. Figure 3. Again we consider the Debye-Hückel approximation where ρe=−ϵκ2ϕ\rho_e=-\epsilon\kappa^2\phi. Assuming ϕ(r,z)=ϕ(r)cos⁡qz\phi(r,z)=\phi(r)\cos qz, with a slight abuse of notation, Gauss law reduces to

AC electroosmosis in a cylindrical capillary with charge-modulated walls

Figure 3. AC electroosmosis in a cylindrical capillary with charge-modulated walls: A uniform alternating electric field E=Ee−iωtz^\mathbf{E} = E e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{z}} of frequency ω\omega exerts a body force on a 1 : 1 electrolyte in a cylindrical capillary of radius aa with inhomogeneous surface charges, σ=σ0cos⁡qz\sigma= \sigma_0 \cos qz on its insulating wall. This gives rise to a system of oscillating tori (whose cross-section are the displayed vortices) whose sense of rotation changes according to the external field’s, cf. Figure 4 for a calculated cross-section. Compare with figures 1 and 2 of the channel case.

∂r2ϕ+1r∂rϕ−(κ2+q2)ϕ=0,subject to ∂rϕ(a)=σ0ϵ.(22)\partial_r^2\phi+\frac{1}{r}\partial_r\phi-(\kappa^2+q^2)\phi=0,\quad\text{subject to }\partial_r\phi(a)=\frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon}. \tag*{(22)}

Thus, the potential acquires the form

ϕ(r,z)=σ0ϵI0(Qr)QI1(Qa)cos⁡qz(23)\phi(r,z)=\frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon}\frac{I_0(Qr)}{QI_1(Qa)}\cos qz \tag*{(23)}

where I0I_0 and I1I_1 are modified Bessel functions of the first kind and with Q2=κ2+q2Q^2=\kappa^2+q^2, defined in (8). If a uniform alternating electric field is applied along the axis of the cylinder E=Ee−iωtz^\mathbf{E}=Ee^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{z}} (cf. Figure 3), it exerts a torque on the liquid of the form

∇×(ρeE)=ϵκ2∂rϕEϕ^,(24)\nabla\times(\rho_e\mathbf{E})=\epsilon\kappa^2\partial_r\phi E\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}, \tag*{(24)}

where ϕ^\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}} is the azimuthal unit vector in a system of circular cylindrical coordinates. The vorticity equation in terms of a streamfunction ψ(r,z,t)\psi(r,z,t), expressed in cylindrical coordinates is well known cf. [21 §4.7] and we briefly revisit the salient points of its derivation. The vorticity equation can be written in the form

ρ∂t∇×v=−η∇×∇×∇×v+ϵκ2∂rϕEϕ^.(25)\rho\partial_t\nabla\times\mathbf{v}=-\eta\nabla\times\nabla\times\nabla\times\mathbf{v}+\epsilon\kappa^2\partial_r\phi E\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}. \tag*{(25)}

The flow is axisymmetric and only the radial and axial velocity components vrv_r and vzv_z, respectively, are non-vanishing. With a Stokes streamfunction ψ(r,z,t)\psi(r,z,t) satisfying

vr=1r∂ψ∂z,vz=−1r∂ψ∂r,(26)v_r=\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial z},\quad v_z=-\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial r}, \tag*{(26)}

the incompressibility condition is automatically satisfied and the ϕ^\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}} component of the vorticity can be written in the form

r(∇×v)⋅ϕ^=(∂r2−1r∂r+∂z2)ψ≡D2ψ(27)r(\nabla\times\mathbf{v})\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}=\left(\partial_r^2-\frac{1}{r}\partial_r+\partial_z^2\right)\psi\equiv D^2\psi \tag*{(27)}

and this defines the operator D2\mathcal{D}^2 (denoted by the symbol E2E^2 in [21], which however here is reserved to denote the electric field amplitude). It is then easy to show that the vorticity equation (25) becomes, cf. [21 Eq. (4-7.12)]

1ν∂tD2ψ=D4ψ+σ0κ2EηrI1(Qr)I1(Qa)e−iωtcos⁡qz.(28)\frac{1}{\nu}\partial_t\mathcal{D}^2\psi=\mathcal{D}^4\psi+\frac{\sigma_0\kappa^2 E}{\eta}\frac{rI_1(Qr)}{I_1(Qa)}e^{-i\omega t}\cos qz. \tag*{(28)}

Assuming a streamfunction of the form ψ(r,z,t)=ψ(r)e−iωtcos⁡qz\psi(r,z,t)=\psi(r)e^{-i\omega t}\cos qz (with a slight abuse of notation), its radially dependent factor satisfies

[d2dr2−1rddr−q2][d2dr2−1rddr+K2]ψ+σ0κ2EηrI1(Qr)I1(Qa)=0,(29)\left[\frac{d^2}{dr^2}-\frac{1}{r}\frac{d}{dr}-q^2\right]\left[\frac{d^2}{dr^2}-\frac{1}{r}\frac{d}{dr}+K^2\right]\psi+\frac{\sigma_0\kappa^2 E}{\eta}\frac{rI_1(Qr)}{I_1(Qa)}=0, \tag*{(29)}

which is the counterpart of (12), Q2=κ2+q2Q^2=\kappa^2+q^2 and K2=k2−q2K^2=k^2-q^2 defined in (8) and (13), respectively. The general solution of (29), that is finite at r=0r=0, is of the form

ψ(r)=r[AI1(qr)+BJ1(Kr)−σ0EI1(Qr)ηI1(Qa)(k2+κ2)],(30)\psi(r)=r\left[AI_1(qr)+BJ_1(Kr)-\frac{\sigma_0EI_1(Qr)}{\eta I_1(Qa)(k^2+\kappa^2)}\right], \tag*{(30)}

where J1J_1 is the Bessel function of the first kind and AA and BB are arbitrary constants to be determined by the boundary conditions. These are the no-slip conditions at the capillary walls

ψ(a)=dψdr(a)=0.(31)\psi(a)=\frac{d\psi}{dr}(a)=0. \tag*{(31)}

The two constants are

\begin{pmatrix} A \\ B \end{pmatrix} = \frac{\sigma_0E}{\eta(\kappa^2+k^2)I_1(Qa)} \begin{pmatrix} \frac{KJ_0(Ka)I_1(Qa)-QJ_1(Ka)I_0(Qa)}{KJ_0(Ka)I_1(qa)-qI_0(qa)J_1(Ka)}\\[6pt] \frac{QI_1(qa)I_0(Qa)-qI_1(Qa)I_0(qa)}{KJ_0(Ka)I_1(qa)-qI_0(qa)J_1(Ka)} \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(32)}\end{pmatrix}

where J0J_0 is the Bessel function of the first kind, of zeroth order.

In Figure 4 we display a cross-section of the flow in the r−zr-z plane. The flow consists of identical vortices, which, when extended along the azimuthal direction ϕ^\hat{\phi}, form tori which alternate in their sense of circulation as one moves parallel to the axis of the cylinder (in the zz-direction). The circulation direction changes periodically depending on the orientation of the electric field E=Ee−iωtz^E=E e^{-i\omega t}\hat{z}. Employing (26) and (32) shows that the radial velocity vrv_r is proportional to qq and thus vanishes when the wall charges are spatially uniform.

Oscillating toroidal vortex structure in a capillary

Figure 4. Oscillating toroidal vortex structure in a capillary of radius r=1r=1, induced by a uniform alternating electric field E=Ee−iωtz^E=E e^{-i\omega t}\hat{z} of frequency ω\omega that is parallel to the wall charge variation wavevector qz^q\hat{z} (parallel to the cylinder axis), cf. Figure 3 for the coordinate system. Here we display an r−zr-z slice of the dimensionless instantaneous streamlines ψ(r,z,t)=ψ(r)e−iωtcos⁡qz\psi(r,z,t)=\psi(r)e^{-i\omega t}\cos qz with ψ(r)\psi(r) from (29) and (32) determined for charges σ=σ0cos⁡qz\sigma=\sigma_0\cos qz on the capillary wall located at r=1r=1.

Rectangular channel flow with applied field perpendicular to surface charge variation

Next consider an external alternating electric field that is applied perpendicular to wall charge variation E=E⊥e−iωty^E=E_\perp e^{-i\omega t}\hat{y} with symmetric or antisymmetric wall distributions given corresponding potentials Eq. (6) and (7), satisfying Eq. (2) in the Debye-Hückel approximation as in the previous section. This configuration represents the oscillatory counterpart of Ajdari [8], Eq. (9) & Eq. (10).

The momentum equation becomes in this case

ρ∂tv=−∇p~+η∇2v−ϵκ2ϕE⊥e−iωty^,(33)\rho\partial_t\mathbf{v} = -\nabla\tilde{p} + \eta\nabla^2\mathbf{v} - \epsilon\kappa^2\phi E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{y}}, \tag*{(33)}

where v(x,z)=(u(x,z),v(x,z),w(x,z))\mathbf{v}(x,z) = (u(x,z),v(x,z),w(x,z)) in Cartesian coordinates. The vorticity equation shows that

(∂x,∂z)[ρ∂tv−η∇2v−ϵκ2ϕE⊥e−iωt]=(0,0),(34)(\partial_x,\partial_z)\left[\rho\partial_t\mathbf{v} - \eta\nabla^2\mathbf{v} - \epsilon\kappa^2\phi E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t}\right] = (0,0), \tag*{(34)}

and that (ρ∂t−η∇2)(∂zu−∂xw)=0(\rho\partial_t - \eta\nabla^2)(\partial_z u - \partial_x w) = 0. As in [8 Eq. (9) & (10)], a solution that satisfies no-slip boundary conditions at z=±hz = \pm h is u=w≡0u = w \equiv0. The velocity component vv satisfying ρ∂tv−η∇2v−ϵκ2ϕE⊥e−iωt=0\rho\partial_t v - \eta\nabla^2v - \epsilon\kappa^2\phi E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t} = 0 (34) obtains the form v(x,z,t)=Z(z)e−iωtcos⁡qxv(x,z,t) = Z(z)e^{-i\omega t}\cos qx, thereby

Z′′+(k2−q2)Z−σ0κ2E⊥ηQcosh⁡(Qz)sinh⁡(Qh)=0(35)Z^{\prime\prime} + (k^2-q^2)Z - \frac{\sigma_0\kappa^2E_{\perp}}{\eta Q}\frac{\cosh(Qz)}{\sinh(Qh)} = 0 \tag*{(35)}

where we employed the electric potential (6) determined when both walls carry the same charge (σ0cos⁡qx\sigma_0\cos qx). We recover the case where the electric potential employed is (7) (determined when the walls carry opposite charge), by performing the exchange cosh⁡↔sinh⁡\cosh\leftrightarrow\sinh in (35).

The resulting velocity is

v(x,z,t)=κ2E⊥σ0cos⁡qxη(κ2+κ2)Qsinh⁡(Qh)(cosh⁡(Qz)−cosh⁡(Qh)cos⁡(Kh)cos⁡(Kz))e−iωt(36)v(x,z,t) = \frac{\kappa^2E_{\perp}\sigma_0\cos qx}{\eta(\kappa^2+\kappa^2)Q\sinh(Qh)}\left(\cosh(Qz)-\frac{\cosh(Qh)}{\cos(Kh)}\cos(Kz)\right)e^{-i\omega t} \tag*{(36)}

where KK was defined in (13). The velocity profile that corresponds to the electric potential in Eq. (7), is obtained from (36) by performing the exchange cosh⁡↔sinh⁡\cosh\leftrightarrow\sinh and cos⁡↔sin⁡\cos\leftrightarrow\sin, leaving cos⁡qx\cos qx intact. It is clear that (36) recovers previous static results in the adiabatic limit ω→0\omega\to0. Thus, setting K=q2K=\sqrt{q^2} in (36) and employing the identity cos⁡Kz/cos⁡Kh≡cosh⁡qz/cosh⁡qh\cos Kz/\cos Kh \equiv\cosh qz/\cosh qh, we recover the (static) velocity profile of Ajdari [23 Eq. (26)].

A snapshot of the velocity profile (36), scaled by the factor (20) which here is denoted by v0v_0, that is,

v0=σ0E⊥ηκ,(37)v_0=\frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta\kappa}, \tag*{(37)}

is displayed in the bottom left panel of Figure 5 over half period (π/q)(\pi/q) in the xx-direction. This is reminiscent of the experimental results of Stroock et al. [9, figure 2]. Moreover, it is seen that the profile is oscillating but of single sign (in the chosen interval of the xx-axis) and can thus be employed for unidirectional transport of electrolytes, as discussed in the following section. The bottom right panel of Figure 5 displays the scaled velocity profile by v0v_0, when the upper and lower channel walls carry charges of opposite sign. Here the flow, averaged over the width of the channel, vanishes. Such a pattern can also be developed for a symmetric σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^\pm=\sigma_0\cosh qx wall charge distribution (cf. Figure 12 in Appendix § 17).

AC electroosmosis in a rectangular channel with applied field perpendicular to wall charge variation

Figure 5. AC electroosmosis in a rectangular channel with applied field perpendicular to wall charge variation. Top: An alternating electric field E∼e−iωty^\mathbf{E} \sim e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{y}} of frequency ω\omega exerts a body force on a 1 : 1 electrolyte in a rectangular channel of width 2h2h with symmetric inhomogeneous wall charges, σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \cos qx on the upper and lower insulating walls. Over each tile, the charge distribution gives rise to a non-vanishing velocity averaged over the channel width (36). Bottom: Oscillating velocity profile in a channel of width 2h2h, induced by a uniform alternating electric field E=E⊥e−iωty^\mathbf{E} = E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{y}} of frequency ω\omega that is perpendicular to the wall charge variation for the coordinate system. Snapshot of the velocity profile v(x,z,t)y^v(x,z,t)\hat{\mathbf{y}} from (36) at time t=1t = 1 when the surface charges at the channel walls z=±hz = \pm h are symmetric σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \cos qx (left). Snapshot of the velocity profile v(x,z,t)y^v(x,z,t)\hat{\mathbf{y}} (by exchanging the cosines with sines in (36), and vice-versa) at time t=1t = 1 when the surface charges at the channel walls z=±hz = \pm h are antisymmetric σ±=±σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0 \cos qx (right).

Four three-dimensional electrolyte velocity profiles

Figure 12. Electrolyte (oscillating) velocity profile v(x,z,t)y^v(x,z,t)\hat{\mathbf{y}} scaled by the factor v0=σ0E⊥ηκv_0 = \frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta\kappa}, in a channel of width hh, induced by a uniform alternating electric field E=E⊥e−iωty^\mathbf{E} = E_\perp e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{y}} that is perpendicular to the wall charge variation, cf. Figure 1 for the coordinate system. The left column displays the velocity profiles (G9) with symmetric charge distribution giving rise to corresponding potentials (G4). The right column displays the velocity profiles (G10) with symmetric charge distribution giving rise to corresponding potentials (G5). The upper left profile when the surface charges at the channel walls z=±hz = \pm h are symmetric σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^\pm= \sigma_0 \cos qx, can be employed for unidirectional transport of an electrolyte. This flow pattern is qualitatively similar to the ones obtained experimentally in [9 figure 2] (albeit theirs being steady and expressed with respect to different boundary conditions).

AC-INDUCED UNIDIRECTIONAL ELECTROLYTE MOTION IN CHANNELS AND CAPILLARIES

In addition to the vortex flow patterns of the previous sections, it is of practical interest to examine the presence of unidirectional electrolyte transport. In this section we calculate the velocity averaged over the channel width for the perpendicular field to the charge variation, and examine their limiting behaviors. The averaged velocity is

⟨v⟩=12h∫−hhv dz.(38)\langle v\rangle=\frac{1}{2h}\int_{-h}^{h}v\,dz. \tag*{(38)}

Consider the case of uniform wall charges σ±=σ0\sigma^\pm=\sigma_0 along both walls. The motivation for the choice of symmetric wall charge comes from the observation that an optimal unidirectional velocity is expected to arise when the wall excitations are identical and of the same phase [24]. The configuration where the velocity does not vanish when averaged over the channel width, is the one with symmetric charges along the channel walls.

Average velocity in rectangular channel with field perpendicular to charge variation

In the case of the perpendicular applied field, the velocity profile (36) associated with the symmetric charge on the walls z=±hz=\pm h, gives rise to unidirectional charge transport. Averaging (36) over the channel width we obtain

⟨v⟩∼σ0E⊥e−iωtηh(k2+κ2){κ2Q2[1−QKtan⁡(Kh)coth⁡(Qh)]cos⁡qx,q≠0,[1−1ktan⁡(kh)coth⁡(κh)],q→0.(39)\langle v\rangle\sim\frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp e^{-i\omega t}}{\eta h(k^2+\kappa^2)} \begin{cases} \frac{\kappa^2}{Q^2}\left[1-\frac{Q}{K}\tan(Kh)\coth(Qh)\right]\cos qx, & q\ne0,\\ \left[1-\frac{1}{k}\tan(kh)\coth(\kappa h)\right], & q\to0. \end{cases} \tag*{(39)}

In the left two panels of Figure 6 we display the absolute value of the amplitude contained in the square brackets of (39), for various values of the wall charge variation wavenumber qq.

Unidirectional channel averaged velocity with perpendicular applied AC field

Figure 6. Unidirectional channel averaged velocity with perpendicular applied AC field. Left panel displays the velocity amplitude versus the scaled frequency ωνκ2\frac{\omega}{\nu\kappa^2} for various wavenumbers qq of wall charge variation, where v0=σ0E⊥ηκv_0 = \frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta\kappa}. The plateau at the low frequency values denotes the plug-like adiabatic limit. Middle panel: Amplitude of the scaled unidirectional velocity (39) for the perpendicular case as a function of q/κq/\kappa for different values of frequency ω\omega, recovering the static case of Ajdari [23] in the adiabatic limit. The right panel displays the velocity (39) in the q→0q \to0 limit.

Of interest is also the adiabatic limit ω→0\omega\to0 (and thus k→0k\to0). Defining the Langevin function

L(x)=coth⁡x−1x,(40)\mathcal{L}(x)=\coth x-\frac{1}{x}, \tag*{(40)}

the q→0q\to0 limit of (39) becomes

⟨v⟩∼−σ0E⊥ηκL(kh)at q=0 and ω→0,(41)\langle v\rangle\sim-\frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta\kappa}\mathcal{L}(kh)\quad\text{at }q=0\text{ and }\omega\to0, \tag*{(41)}

(over times which satisfy ωt≪1\omega t\ll1). Since the argument khkh in this paper is considered to be rather large, the Langevin function appearing in (41) is approximately equal to 1. The resulting velocity ⟨v⟩∼−σ0E⊥ηκ\langle v\rangle\sim-\frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta\kappa} is of a type obtained in standard (static) electroosmosis formulations, cf. [25 p. 10.24]. We note that this is a plug-like induced by the large values of the inverse Debye wavelength κ\kappa and it differs from the plug-like flow that forms when ω→∞\omega\to\infty, cf. Appendix B.

In the right panel of Figure 6 we display the absolute value of the amplitude contained in (39) for q→0q\to0 versus the scaled frequency ωνκ2\frac{\omega}{\nu\kappa^2} where the velocity scale v0v_0 was defined in (37). For low scaled frequency values the velocity amplitude reaches a plateau (to the left of each curve) denoting the plug-like adiabatic limit (41), expressed with respect to a Langevin function (40) and resembles the standard (static) electroosmosis expression met in the literature. For large frequencies, in principle, the rapid oscillation of the complex exponential e−iωte^{-i\omega t} should also be taken into account.

Estimates

From figure 6 and the long wavelength expression (41) it can be seen that for low frequencies the electrolyte velocity is of the order of the scaled parameter v0v_0 defined in (37). For higher frequencies the velocity magnitude is reduced. Thus, we can employ

v∼v0=σ0Eηκ,(42)v \sim v_0 = \frac{\sigma_0 E}{\eta\kappa}, \tag*{(42)}

as an upper bound that the electrolyte velocity can attain. Employing standard parameter values for water ϵ=7×10−10 F/m\epsilon= 7 \times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{F/m}, η=0.001 kg/(m⋅s)\eta= 0.001\ \mathrm{kg/(m \cdot s)}, κ=107 m−1\kappa= 10^7\ \mathrm{m}^{-1} and E=9.5×104 V/mE = 9.5 \times10^4\ \mathrm{V/m} (as in [9]) and a surface charge with the nominal value σ0=ϵE\sigma_0 = \epsilon E we obtain the estimate

v∼0.63 mm/s.(43)v \sim0.63\ \mathrm{mm/s}. \tag*{(43)}

This value is of the same order of magnitude as standard electroosmosis velocity estimates (cf. Probstein [22 below (6.5.5)]) and one order of magnitude higher than those of the experiments of Stroock et al. [9].

Unidirectional velocity in rectangular channel with field parallel to charge modulation

In the limit q→0q \to0 the velocity in the rectangular and cylindrical cases becomes unidirectional and oscillatory in the x^\hat{x} direction (channel case) and in the z^\hat{z} direction (cylinder case). When averaged over the width of the channel/radius of cylinder, they both vanish. The convective current, however, is non-zero for all values of qq. This observation implies that the oscillatory electric field in a capillary with wall charge variation gives rise to hysteretic flow (evident from the presence of the renormalized Stokes wavenumber KK in (13)) and is thus endowed with traces of memory, a subject we develop in the ensuing sections.

Memory Effects

Recent work has focused on imitating physiological processes taking place in a synapse to create highly efficient iontronic computing devices, carrying information via ion transport in an aqueous environment rather than via electrons and holes in the crystal lattice, and will thus be manipulated by both chemical and electrical signals.

Figure 7. Left panel: Hysteresis loops of advective current II0≡1I0⟨ρℜ{u(z,t)}⟩\frac{I}{I_0} \equiv\frac{1}{I_0}\langle\rho\Re\{u(z,t)\}\rangle from Eq. (46) vs.-voltage for various values of the wall charge wavevector qq. Right panel: Area between advective current (46) and voltage. Currents in the left panel were evaluated at frequencies that maximize the respective areas. Thus, although the average velocity over the width of the channel vanishes, the current remains nonzero and gives rise to traces of memory, see the ensuing discussion. Both panels refer to the electrolyte oscillatory channel flow (18) developed in § 2 A when both walls carry the same charge distribution σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^\pm= \sigma_0 \cos qx giving rise to the potential (6).

The plot of II vs. VV in an iontronic device shows a hysteresis effect cf. [26 Fig. S13-S15], and this is interpreted as sign of “memory”. The largest the enclosed area, the largest the memory is. The area of the hysteresis loops can be calculated as a function of the frequency ω\omega of the applied voltage. The frequency that maximizes the area of the loop determines the characteristic ‘memory’ time τM\tau_M, cf. [27 Eq.(3) & Fig. 3C] and [10 Fig. 3(c)].

For the static case, Osterle and coworkers [28] pointed out that although the current in the transverse direction to the capillary walls vanishes, the current in the longitudinal direction (parallel to the walls) is nonzero, cf. [28 Eq. (23)]. This remains true in the present oscillatory configuration. We take advantage of this concept to show that rectangular channels or cylindrical capillaries in the presence of wall charge variation give rise to a current, which is hysteretic with respect to the applied voltage.

Hysteresis loops in the literature appear to be pinched (current vanishes when the voltage does). It was however argued by Pershin, Di Ventra and coworkers [17, 18, 29] that pinching is not a necessary defining characteristic displayed by a system with memory. In the context of ionic systems, it is evident from the experimental figures of Kamsma et al. [26 Fig. S13-S15] that hysteresis loops can be open. Open hysteresis loops, displaying capacitive behavior, can also be seen in recent theoretical studies, for instance, in Figures 6Aa/d and 11B of [30]. Below, we show that the natural behavior of an I−VI - V hysteresis loop emanating from the advective longitudinal current, within our approximate formulation, is not pinched.

Negative resistance or differential resistance has been documented in a number of recent works [19, 20, 30, 31, 32, 33]. Likewise, we will here show that the conductance displayed by our ionic system can become negative and divergent as the external voltage approaches zero. This behavior is reminiscent of capacitive systems, for instance see Figure 3 of [17] and Figure 3B of [19], both showing negative capacitance in experiments whose behavior resembles the right-most panel of Figure 8.

Figure 8. Channel geometry. Left panel: Advective current II0=1I0⟨ρRe{u(z,t)}⟩\frac{I}{I_0}=\frac{1}{I_0}\langle\rho\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\{u(z,t)\}\rangle from Eq. (47) and with the scaling I0I_0 from (44), with arrows denoting the direction of voltage sweep in time, vs.-voltage hysteresis loop evaluated at ω=0.26×νκ2\omega=0.26\times\nu\kappa^2 Hz which maximizes the loop area (i.e. maximum energy dissipation, cf. the area maximum in the center panel). Center panel: Area between advective current (47) and voltage. The frequency that maximizes the area of the loop determines the characteristic ‘memory’ time τM\tau_M (48). Right panel: Dimensionless memconductance vs. dimensionless voltage Eq. (49). Numbers indicate the order at which the voltage is swept (denoted by arrows). The memconductance diverges as the voltage approaches its zero value. This figure should be compared to Krems et al. [17 Figs. 4 & 5]. Inset: same figure but for small memconductance values. All panels refer to the electrolyte oscillatory channel flow developed in § 2 A when both walls carry the same charge distribution σ±=σ0cos⁡qx\sigma^\pm=\sigma_0\cos qx giving rise to the potential (6).

For discussion in this memory section, below we will need the following current and voltage scalings

I0=σ02Eη,andV0=EL,(44)I_0 = \frac{\sigma_0^2 E}{\eta}, \qquad\text{and} \qquad V_0 = EL, \tag*{(44)}

where LL is the length of the channel or cylindrical tube over which the voltage is applied.

Channel memory

The longitudinal current ixi_x, averaged over the width of the channel becomes

⟨ix⟩=⟨ρℜ{u(z,t)}⟩+ΣEcos⁡ωt(45)\langle i_x\rangle=\langle\rho\Re\{u(z,t)\}\rangle+\Sigma E\cos\omega t \tag*{(45)}

where uu is given by (18) and in the Debye-Hückel approximation Σ=ϵDκ2\Sigma=\epsilon D\kappa^2 is the bulk conductivity. With the scaling (44) we nondimensionalize the current (45) and obtain ⟨ix⟩I0=1I0⟨ρℜ{u(z,t)}⟩+ϵ(ϵσ0)2cos⁡ωt\frac{\langle i_x\rangle}{I_0}=\frac{1}{I_0}\langle\rho\Re\{u(z,t)\}\rangle+\frac{\epsilon}{\left(\frac{\epsilon}{\sigma_0}\right)^2}\cos\omega t. The coefficient ϵ(ϵσ0)2\frac{\epsilon}{\left(\frac{\epsilon}{\sigma_0}\right)^2} can be understood as an Osterle or Levinson number [34 Eq. (1.25)], and considering standard material parameters it can be shown that it is of O(1)O(1). Since this term represents an oscillation with the same phase as the driving field, it is of limited interest; we concentrate instead on the first term of the right hand side of (45) which is the advective current II0≡1I0⟨ρℜ{u(z,t)}⟩\frac{I}{I_0}\equiv\frac{1}{I_0}\langle\rho\Re\{u(z,t)\}\rangle in the channel with symmetric wall charge distribution, that is the electric potential is (6), $\rho=-\epsilon\kappa^2\phi$ and the velocity field is Eq. (18)`. Simple dimensional analysis arguments show that the advective current is self-similar

II0=F(δh,κh,qh)(46)\frac{I}{I_0}=\mathcal{F}\left(\frac{\delta}{h},\kappa h,qh\right) \tag*{(46)}

with respect to the stated dimensionless parameters, where δ=2νω\delta=\sqrt{\frac{2\nu}{\omega}} is the Stokes penetration depth defined in (13). In (46) we also averaged over one period of wall charge variation in the longitudinal direction xx. In the left panel of figure 7 we display the advective current (46) vs. the voltage V/V0=cos⁡ωtV/V_0=\cos\omega t for various values of the wall charge wavenumber qq. In the right panel of the same figure we display the area of the II-VV loops. This figure establishes what we have already stressed, that, although the average velocities over the channel width vanish, the advective current is non-zero.

The advective current (46) is a rather long expression, which simplifies somewhat in the limit of q→0q\to0

II0=ℜ{12(k2+κ2)2h(khcos⁡(kh)−sin⁡(kh))[(h(kκ2−κ3)coth⁡(kh)+h2κ2(k2+κ2)csch⁡(kh)2−2κ2)kcos⁡(kh)−2κsin⁡(kh)(hk2κcoth⁡2(kh)+(−3k2−κ2)coth⁡(kh)2+csch⁡(kh)2hk(k2+κ2)2)]e−iωt}(47)\frac{I}{I_0}=\Re\left\{\frac{1}{2(k^2+\kappa^2)^2h\left(kh\cos(kh)-\sin(kh)\right)} \left[ \left(h(k\kappa^2-\kappa^3)\coth(kh)+h^2\kappa^2(k^2+\kappa^2)\operatorname{csch}(kh)^2-2\kappa^2\right)k\cos(kh) -2\kappa\sin(kh)\left(hk^2\kappa\coth^2(kh)+\frac{(-3k^2-\kappa^2)\coth(kh)}{2}+\frac{\operatorname{csch}(kh)^2hk(k^2+\kappa^2)}{2}\right) \right]e^{-i\omega t}\right\} \tag*{(47)}

which, can likewise become of the same order as the second term in (45) by a prudent choice of the parameters. On the left-most panel of figure 8 we display the hysteresis loop formed by the advective current (47) and the applied voltage V/V0=cos⁡ωtV/V_0=\cos\omega t. On the center panel of the same figure we display the area between the advective current (47) and voltage vs. the dimensionless group ω/(νκ2)\omega/(\nu\kappa^2). The frequency that maximizes the area of the loop, determines the characteristic ‘memory’ time τM∼0.26νκ2\tau_M\sim\frac{0.26}{\nu\kappa^2}, cf. [27 Eq.(3) & Fig. 3C] and [10 Fig. 3(c)]. For standard material parameters, ν=10−5 m2 s−1\nu=10^{-5}\,\mathrm{m^2\,s^{-1}} and κ=107 m−1\kappa=10^7\,\mathrm{m^{-1}} we obtain the estimate

τM∼241 μs.(48)\tau_M\sim241\,\mu\mathrm{s}. \tag*{(48)}

We note that the above analysis can be repeated also for the antisymmetric wall charge distribution leading to the electric potential (7) and the corresponding velocity fields.

Channel memconductance

Following the definition of memconductance introduced by [13, 35], cf. Appendix E, we consider expression (47) (and thus for simplicity, we consider only the q=0q=0 case from now on) for the advective current and form the conductance G=IVG=\frac{I}{V}, which can take the somewhat simpler self-similar form

G(κh,kh;ωt)=G0I/I0V/V0,(49)G(\kappa h,kh;\omega t)=G_0\frac{I/I_0}{V/V_0}, \tag*{(49)}

where G0=Aσ02ηLG_0=\frac{A\sigma_0^2}{\eta\mathcal{L}}, AA is the channel cross-sectional area over which the current is flowing, and we remind the reader that k2=iωνk^2=\frac{i\omega}{\nu}, cf. Eq. (13). GG in (49) is history-dependent. In the left-most panel of figure 8 we display the current-voltage hysteresis loop as the voltage is swept and in the right-most panel we display the memconductance (49). It is clear that the conductance diverges as the voltage approaches its zero value and can become negative. This behavior should be contrasted to Figures 4 & 5 of Krems et al. [17] whereby the models employed and the molecular dynamics simulations displayed in the insets therein, have exactly the behavior displayed in Figure 8.

In Appendix F we argue that this behavior is generic for systems whose II-VV hysteresis loops are ellipses (as the present loops are).

Cylinder memory

We repeat the above for the case of the cylinder, whose axial velocity is (26) with (30). The advective current I/I0=⟨ρRe{vz(r,t)}⟩/I0I/I_0=\langle\rho\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\{v_z(r,t)\}\rangle/I_0 is again self-similar

II0=G(δa,κa,qa)(50)\frac{I}{I_0}=\mathcal{G}\left(\frac{\delta}{a},\kappa a,qa\right) \tag*{(50)}

with respect to the stated dimensionless parameters, where δ=2νω\delta=\sqrt{\frac{2\nu}{\omega}} is the Stokes penetration depth defined in (13) and in (50) we also averaged over one period of wall charge variation in the longitudinal direction zz. The advective current (50) again simplifies somewhat in the limit of q→0q\to0

II0=Re{1I1(κa)2(κ2+κ2)2(J0(ka)ak−2J1(ka))a[(2aκ2(κ2+κ2)J1(ka)−kJ0(ka)(a2κ2k2+a2κ4+4k2))I1(κa)2−2((−4k2−2κ2)J1(ka)+akκ2J0(ka))κI0(κa)I1(κa)+aκ2I0(κa)2((−4k2−2κ2)J1(ka)+J0(ka)ak(k2+κ2))]e−iωt}.(51)\frac{I}{I_0}=\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\left\{\frac{1}{I_1(\kappa a)^2(\kappa^2+\kappa^2)^2\left(J_0(ka)ak-2J_1(ka)\right)a}\left[\left(2a\kappa^2(\kappa^2+\kappa^2)J_1(ka)-kJ_0(ka)\left(a^2\kappa^2k^2+a^2\kappa^4+4k^2\right)\right)I_1(\kappa a)^2-2\left(\left(-4k^2-2\kappa^2\right)J_1(ka)+ak\kappa^2J_0(ka)\right)\kappa I_0(\kappa a)I_1(\kappa a)+a\kappa^2I_0(\kappa a)^2\left(\left(-4k^2-2\kappa^2\right)J_1(ka)+J_0(ka)ak\left(k^2+\kappa^2\right)\right)\right]e^{-i\omega t}\right\}. \tag*{(51)}

In the left panel of figure 9 we display the hysteresis loop between the advective current I/I0=⟨ρRe{vz(r,t)}⟩/I0I/I_0=\langle\rho\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\{v_z(r,t)\}\rangle/I_0 and the applied voltage V/V0=cos⁡ωtV/V_0=\cos\omega t. In the center panel of the same figure we display the area between the advective current (51) and voltage vs. the dimensionless group ω/(νκ2)\omega/(\nu\kappa^2). The frequency that maximizes the area of the loop, determines the characteristic ‘memory’ time τM\tau_M which is of the same order of magnitude as estimate (48) in the channel case.

The memconductance in the cylinder case is given again by Eq. (49) by effecting the change h→ah \to a and considering as cross-sectional area A=πa2A = \pi a^2. We display in the right-most panel of Figure 9 the memconductance which diverges as the voltage approaches its zero value and can become negative. This behavior can again be contrasted to Figure 4 & Figure 5 of Krems et al. [17].

Figure 9. Cylinder geometry. Left panel: Advective current II0≡1I0⟨ρRe{vz(r,t)}⟩\frac{I}{I_0} \equiv\frac{1}{I_0}\langle\rho\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\{v_z(r,t)\}\rangle from Eq. (51) and with the scaling I0I_0 from (44), with arrows denoting the direction of voltage sweep in time, vs.-voltage hysteresis loop evaluated at ω=0.29×νκ2\omega= 0.29 \times\nu\kappa^2 Hz which maximizes the loop area (i.e. maximum energy dissipation, cf. the area maximum in the center panel). Right panel: Area between advective current (51) and voltage. The frequency that maximizes the area of the loop determines the characteristic ‘memory’ time τM\tau_M. Right panel: Dimensionless memconductance vs. dimensionless voltage Eq. (49) (with h→ah \to a). Numbers indicate the order at which the voltage is swept (denoted by arrows). The memconductance diverges as the voltage approaches its zero value. This figure should be compared to Krems et al. [17 Figs. 4 & 5]. Inset: same figure but for small memconductance values. All panels refer to the electrolyte oscillatory flow in a cylinder developed in section II B when the wall carries the same charge distribution σ=σ0cos⁡qz\sigma= \sigma_0 \cos qz at r=ar = a, giving rise to the potential (23).

Discussion

Electroosmosis is an effective means of charge transport, whereby the electrolyte adjacent to a uniformly charged wall is set into motion by an externally applied (DC) electric field. Here we showed instead that in an AC field a capillary with nonuniformly charged walls, it will give rise to vortex and other laminar flow behavior. These types of flows can be employed for mixing and solute transport. The vortex flow patterns obtained resemble those observed in experiments with soft-lithography polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) and glass wall channels [5, 9]. In addition the non-vortex patterns shown in Appendix § 17 where the wall charge distribution can change sign (once) could lead to stronger current rectification as shown in a recent numerical comparative study [10]. We established the presence of unidirectional velocity as developed in Figure 6 and discussed in section III A.

All oscillatory systems we examined in sections II A and II B show traces of memory. Although the velocity field vanishes after averaging over the width of the channel or cylinder cross-section, the advective currents are non-zero, giving rise to II-VV hysteresis loops, which are thereby employed to develop a concept of memory time. The concept of memory developed in section IV, and in particular the negative and diverging conductance in the context of ionic solutions in a channel or cylindrical capillary, as displayed in the right-most panel of Figure 8, resembles the presence of negative and diverging capacitance in related theoretical [17] and experimental works [19]. Analogous concepts were developed in the past in the context of solid-state configurations, see for instance [18, 36].

Multiple alternative configurations can likewise be studied. For instance, one can envision flow in the annular region between two pipes of radii aa and b>ab>a with the same or opposite wall charge distribution. Then, in addition to the Bessel functions JnJ_n and InI_n employed in section II B, one has to consider their (diverging at the origin) counterparts YnY_n and KnK_n, respectively. Hence, the vortex pattern will resemble the left or right panel of Figure 2, depending on the relative phase of charge modulation between the inner and outer tubes.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the support of the NSF grant number DMR-2452280. We are grateful to an anonymous referee for suggesting the differential operator decomposition in Eq. (29) and for providing numerous comments that significantly improved the manuscript.

The steady streamfunction of Ajdari [23]

When the electric field is static [8, 23], the vorticity equation in terms of the streamfunction (9), acquires the form

η∇4ψ−ϵκ2E∥∂zϕ=0.(52)\eta\nabla^{4}\psi-\epsilon\kappa^{2}E_{\parallel}\partial_{z}\phi=0. \tag*{(52)}

When the xx-variation of the velocity field is proportional to cos⁡qx\cos qx, the streamfunction ψ(x,z)=cos⁡qxZ(z)\psi(x,z)=\cos qx Z(z) leads to the single equation for Z(z)Z(z)

∂z4Z−2q2∂z2Z+q4Z−ϵκ2E∥η∂zϕ=0,(53)\partial_{z}^{4}Z-2q^{2}\partial_{z}^{2}Z+q^{4}Z-\frac{\epsilon\kappa^{2}E_{\parallel}}{\eta}\partial_{z}\phi=0, \tag*{(53)}

which is the counterpart of Eq. (12) by setting ω=k=0\omega=k=0 in (13). This form of solution carries a certain degeneracy associated with the twice-repeated wavenumbers ±iq\pm iq. As shown by Ajdari [23 Eq. (9) & (15)-(19)], for the antisymmetric wall charge distribution giving rise to the electric potential (7), the stationary streamfunction becomes

ψ(x,z)=cos⁡qx[(As+Dsz)cosh⁡qz+(Bs+Csz)sinh⁡qz+E∥σ0ηκ2cosh⁡Qhcosh⁡Qz],(54)\psi(x,z)=\cos qx\left[(A_s+D_s z)\cosh qz+(B_s+C_s z)\sinh qz+\frac{E_{\parallel}\sigma_0}{\eta\kappa^{2}\cosh Qh}\cosh Qz\right], \tag*{(54)}

where the subscript ss denotes the integration constants of the static problem, Bs=Ds=0B_s=D_s=0, and

\begin{pmatrix} A_s \\ C_s \end{pmatrix} = \frac{E_{\parallel}\sigma_0}{\eta\kappa^{2}\cosh Qh} \begin{pmatrix} \frac{\sinh(qh)\sinh(Qh)Qh-(\cosh(qh)hq+\sinh(qh))\cosh(Qh)}{qh+\sinh(qh)\cosh(qh)} \\ \frac{q\sinh(qh)\cosh(Qh)-Q\cosh(qh)\sinh(Qh)}{qh+\sinh(qh)\cosh(qh)} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(55)}\end{pmatrix}

Flow due to time-harmonic pressure gradient for channel and capillary

We follow the solution of [16 p.89]. A harmonic in time pressure gradient inside a rectangular channel gives rise to a flow in the xx-direction (in our notation) satisfying the xx-momentum equation

∂tu=ce−iωt+ν∂z2u,(56)\partial_t u=ce^{-i\omega t}+\nu\partial_z^2u, \tag*{(56)}

where the units of the scalar aa are implied. The solution, satisfying no-slip boundary conditions at z=±hz=\pm h is

u=icωe−iωt[1−cos⁡kzcos⁡kh](57)u=\frac{ic}{\omega}e^{-i\omega t}\left[1-\frac{\cos kz}{\cos kh}\right] \tag*{(57)}

where k2ν=iωk^{2}\nu=i\omega, as considered in this article. Its average value is

⟨u⟩=icωe−iωt[1−tan⁡khkh].(58)\langle u\rangle=\frac{ic}{\omega}e^{-i\omega t}\left[1-\frac{\tan kh}{kh}\right]. \tag*{(58)}

The adiabatic, small ω\omega limit leads to ⟨u⟩∼ch23νe−iωt\langle u\rangle\sim\frac{ch^{2}}{3\nu}e^{-i\omega t} which is of Poiseuille type. The opposite limit of fast frequencies leads to a plug-type velocity profile ⟨u⟩∼icωe−iωt\langle u\rangle\sim\frac{ic}{\omega}e^{-i\omega t} with a thin boundary layer adjacent to the channel walls.

For the case of an oscillating pressure gradient in a cylindrical capillary of radius aa we consider the solution derived by Drazin & Riley [37 §5.1.2]. The velocity field in the axial direction v=vz(r,t)z^\mathbf{v}=v_z(r,t)\hat{\mathbf{z}} satisfies the Navier-Stokes for a liquid in a cylinder of radius aa under an oscillating pressure gradient has the form

∂tvz=ce−iωt+ν(∂r2+1r∂r)vz.(59)\partial_t v_z = c e^{-i\omega t} + \nu\left(\partial_r^2 + \frac{1}{r}\partial_r\right)v_z . \tag*{(59)}

Its solution is

vz(r,t)=icω(1−J0(kr)J0(ka))e−iωt,(60)v_z(r,t)=\frac{ic}{\omega}\left(1-\frac{J_0(kr)}{J_0(ka)}\right)e^{-i\omega t}, \tag*{(60)}

where kk is given by the usual expression νk2=iω\nu k^2=i\omega, cf. (13).

Antisymmetric charge distribution in a channel

For the asymmetric charge distribution leading to the electric potential (7), the streamfunction ψ(x,z,t)=ψ(z)e−iωtcos⁡qx\psi(x,z,t)=\psi(z)e^{-i\omega t}\cos qx satisfying the vorticity equation (10), leads the function ψ(z)\psi(z) (solving Eq. (12)) to acquire the form

ψ(z)=Acosh⁡(qz)+Bsinh⁡(qz)+Ccos⁡(Kz)+Dsin⁡(Kz)+E∥σ0η(k2+κ2)cosh⁡(Qz)cosh⁡(Qh)(61)\psi(z)=A\cosh(qz)+B\sinh(qz)+C\cos(Kz)+D\sin(Kz)+\frac{E_{\parallel}\sigma_0}{\eta(k^2+\kappa^2)}\frac{\cosh(Qz)}{\cosh(Qh)} \tag*{(61)}

with B=D=0B=D=0, and

\begin{pmatrix} A \\ C \end{pmatrix} =-\frac{E_{\parallel}\sigma_0}{\eta(k^2+\kappa^2)\cosh(Qh)} \begin{pmatrix} \dfrac{\sin(Kh)\cosh(Qh)K+\cos(Kh)\sinh(Qh)Q}{\sinh(qh)q\cos(Kh)+\cosh(qh)K\sin(Kh)}\\[1em] \dfrac{\cosh(Qh)\sinh(qh)q-\sinh(Qh)\cosh(qh)Q}{\cosh(qh)K\sin(Kh)+\sinh(qh)q\cos(Kh)} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(62)}\end{pmatrix}

Limiting behaviors

Below we consider a limiting behavior that serves as reality check of our formulation. In the presence of DC electric field only, the above expressions for the streamfunction should reduce to the corresponding time-independent expressions of [8, 23]. We will perform this only for the unsteady streamfunction (C1) which was derived by consideration of antisymmetric channel wall charges leading to the electric potential (7). Let the complex wavenumber KK in (13) be given by K=K1+iK2K=K_1+iK_2 (KiK_i are real numbers), where

K1,2=12(ων)2+q4+q2∓12(ων)2+q4−q2,(63)K_{1,2}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{\sqrt{\left(\frac{\omega}{\nu}\right)^2+q^4}+q^2}\mp\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{\sqrt{\left(\frac{\omega}{\nu}\right)^2+q^4}-q^2}, \tag*{(63)}

and the ∓\mp sign corresponds to the real (K1K_1) and imaginary (K2K_2) parts of KK, respectively. First, it is clear that in the k=ω=0k=\omega=0 limit, the particular solutions in (A3) are identical. We thus consider the effect of the limit ω→0\omega\to0 on the combination Acosh⁡(qz)+Ccos⁡(Kz)A\cosh(qz)+C\cos(Kz) in the unsteady streamfunction. In this limit, each one of these terms gives rise to identical leading order expressions proportional to ω−1\omega^{-1}, but with the opposite sign, hence they cancel out. Retaining then the O(ω0)O(\omega^0) terms only, shows that they recover the steady streamfunction of Ajdari [23 Eq. (9) & (15)–(19)], denoted here by the terms Ascosh⁡(qz)+Cszsinh⁡(qz)A_s\cosh(qz)+C_sz\sinh(qz) in (A3), as a special case of our unsteady streamfunction.

Systems with memory

We repeat here the definition of systems with memory [35 Eq. (28) & (29)], driven by an applied voltage and resulting in a current

I(t)=G(x,V,t)V(t),x˙=f(x,V,t)(64)I(t)=G(x,V,t)V(t),\qquad\dot{x}=f(x,V,t) \tag*{(64)}

where GG is a memory conductance and xx is a vector of state variables.

Generic form of diverging conductance

A diverging conductance is expected to be present every time the current is nonzero when the voltage is zero. Here and in [17] it is clear that the current-voltage and charge-voltage loops are ellipses. This can be seen if we set the complex factor of e−iωte^{-i\omega t} in (47) to equal Re−iΘR e^{-i\Theta}, where RR and Θ\Theta are real. Thus, (47) becomes

II0=Rcos⁡(ωt+Θ).(65)\frac{I}{I_0}=R\cos(\omega t+\Theta). \tag*{(65)}

From elementary calculus it can now be shown that (F1) along with VV0=cos⁡ωt\frac{V}{V_0}=\cos\omega t constitute the parametric equation of an ellipse.

For small voltages and in normal coordinates, one has I/I0∼±(1−12(V/V0)2)I/I_0 \sim\pm(1-\frac{1}{2}(V/V_0)^2), where I/I0I/I_0 is the ordinate in normal coordinates and the sign denotes the branch of the ellipse. A diverging conductance at V=0V=0 ensues when one expresses this current-voltage relation as a linear function of voltage: I=GVI=GV, whereby

GG0=±(V0V−12VV0).(66)\frac{G}{G_0}=\pm\left(\frac{V_0}{V}-\frac{1}{2}\frac{V}{V_0}\right). \tag*{(66)}

We display Eq. (66) in Figure 10. The resemblance to the conductance that appears in the right-most panel of Figure 8 and Figure 9 is clear.

Figure 10. Conductance (F2) of an ellipse II-VV system expressed in normal coordinates. It resembles the conductance in the right-most panel of Figure 8 and Figure 9, as well as the memcapacitance of [17] and [19]. This is a generic feature of conductance (capacitance) when the current (charge) is finite at vanishing voltage. The positive (negative) branch of the ellipse corresponds to the plus (minus) sign expression in (F2).

Channel AC electroosmosis with hyperbolic wall charge distributions

Wall charge distributions alternative to the sinusoidal ones of section II may also be employed. Apart from leading to closed-form analytical predictions, another motivation behind such choice is that they are reminiscent of those recently employed [10], to numerically establish the preeminence of the commensurate current rectification in contrast to uniformly charged channel walls [10].

Consider an external uniform alternating electric field E=E∥e−iωtx^\mathbf{E}=E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}} with (real) frequency ω\omega acting on a 1:1 electrolyte in a rectangular channel of width 2h2h (Figure 1) whose upper and lower walls are insulating and inhomogeneously charged with one of the following symmetric or antisymmetric distributions: σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^\pm=\sigma_0\cosh qx, σ±=±σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0 \cosh qx, σ±=σ0sinh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \sinh qx and σ±=±σ0sinh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0 \sinh qx. Thus, there will be four distinct potentials associated with one of these distributions satisfying Eq. (2), in the Debye-Hückel approximation. These are displayed below and equations (G4) and (G5) for symmetric and antisymmetric charge distributions on the upper and lower walls, respectively.

The vorticity equation, written in terms of ψ\psi, again takes the form (10) Assuming a streamfunction of the form

ψ(x,z,t)=ψ(z)e−iωtcosh⁡qxorψ(z)e−iωtsinh⁡qx(67)\psi(x,z,t) = \psi(z)e^{-i\omega t}\cosh qx \quad\text{or} \quad\psi(z)e^{-i\omega t}\sinh qx \tag*{(67)}

leads to the single equation for ψ(z)\psi(z)

∂z4ψ+(k2+2q2)∂z2ψ+q2(q2+k2)ψ−ϵκ2E∥η∂zϕ(z)=0,(68)\partial_z^4\psi+ (k^2 + 2q^2)\partial_z^2\psi+ q^2(q^2 + k^2)\psi- \frac{\epsilon\kappa^2 E_{\parallel}}{\eta}\partial_z\phi(z) = 0, \tag*{(68)}

where kk is the complex wavenumber introduced in (13), ϕ(z)\phi(z) is defined through ϕ(x,z)=ϕ(z)cos⁡qx\phi(x,z) = \phi(z)\cos qx (or sinh⁡qx\sinh qx) and ϕ(x,z)\phi(x,z) is one of (G4) or (G5). The zz variation of ψ(z)∼eisz\psi(z) \sim e^{isz} has wavenumbers of the form

s=±q,ands=k2+q2=K+,(69)s = \pm q, \quad\text{and} \quad s = \sqrt{k^2 + q^2} = K_+, \tag*{(69)}

leading to a solution of the form ψ(z)=Acosh⁡(qz)+Bsinh⁡(qz)+Ccos⁡(K+z)+Dsin⁡(K+z)+ψp(z)\psi(z) = A\cosh(qz) + B\sinh(qz) + C\cos(K_+z) + D\sin(K_+z) + \psi_p(z), where ψp\psi_p is the particular solution associated with the last term in (G2) and thus determined accordingly to the form of one of the four potentials (G4) and (G5). AA, BB, CC, and DD are integration constants to be determined by the no-slip boundary condition at the channel walls (not shown). In Figure 11 we display streamlines (left and right columns), corresponding to symmetric and antisymmetric wall charge distributions, respectively.

Electrolyte oscillating laminar flow structure in a channel

Figure 11. Electrolyte (oscillating) laminar flow structure in a channel of width hh, induced by a uniform alternating electric field E=E∥e−iωtx^\mathbf{E}=E_{\parallel}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{x}}, determined by solving (G2), cf. Figure 1 for the coordinate system. Here we display the dimensionless instantaneous streamline pattern determined for symmetric (left column) surface charges and antisymmetric (right column) surface charges along the channel walls z=±hz=\pm h, corresponding to the potentials (G4) and (G5), respectively.

Below we only consider the symmetric wall charges of the form σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0\cosh qx which, in the limits q→0q \to0 and ω→0\omega\to0 could be employed for unidirectional electrolyte transport. The remaining three velocity profiles all vanish when averaged over the width of the channel. The motivation behind the study of these configurations lies in recent numerical experiments [10], which established that current rectification is preeminent when the charge wall changes sign, in comparison to uniformly charged channel walls.

Consider an external uniform alternating electric field E=E⊥e−iωty^\mathbf{E} = E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t}\hat{\mathbf{y}} with (real) frequency ω\omega acting on a 1:11:1 electrolyte in a rectangular channel of width 2h2h (see Figure 1) whose upper and lower walls are insulating and inhomogeneously charged with one of the following symmetric or antisymmetric distributions: σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0\cosh qx, σ±=±σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0\cosh qx, σ±=σ0sinh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0\sinh qx and σ±=±σ0sinh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0\sinh qx. Thus, there will be four distinct potentials associated with one of these distributions satisfying Eq. (2), in the Debye-Hückel approximation, having the form

ϕ(x,z)=σ0ϵQ−cosh⁡Q−zsinh⁡Q−h{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qx×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qxwhen σ±=σ0×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qx(70)\phi(x,z) = \frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon Q_-}\frac{\cosh Q_-z}{\sinh Q_-h} \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \quad\text{when } \sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \tag*{(70)}

and

ϕ(x,z)=σ0ϵQ−sinh⁡Q−zcosh⁡Q−h{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qx×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qxwhen σ±=±σ0×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qx.(71)\phi(x,z) = \frac{\sigma_0}{\epsilon Q_-}\frac{\sinh Q_-z}{\cosh Q_-h} \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \quad\text{when } \sigma^{\pm} = \pm\sigma_0 \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases}. \tag*{(71)}

The hyperbolic function charge distributions require a redefinition of the parameters QQ and KK which are

Q−=κ2−q2,andK+=k2+q2,(72)Q_- = \sqrt{\kappa^2 - q^2}, \quad\text{and} \quad K_+ = \sqrt{k^2 + q^2}, \tag*{(72)}

where kk was defined in (13).

Again, the velocity component v(x,z,t)v(x,z,t) satisfies (34) or

ρ∂tv−η∇2v−ϵκ2ϕE⊥e−iωt=0.(73)\rho\partial_t v - \eta\nabla^2 v - \epsilon\kappa^2 \phi E_{\perp}e^{-i\omega t} = 0. \tag*{(73)}

Assuming a velocity field of the form v(x,z,t)=Z(z)e−iωtsinh⁡qxv(x,z,t) = Z(z)e^{-i\omega t}\sinh qx (or cosh⁡qx\cosh qx), the function ZZ satisfies

Z′′+(k2+q2)Z−ϵκ2E⊥σ0ϕ(z)=0,(74)Z'' + (k^2 + q^2)Z - \epsilon\kappa^2 E_{\perp}\sigma_0\phi(z) = 0, \tag*{(74)}

where ϕ(z)\phi(z) is defined as ϕ(x,z)=ϕ(z)sinh⁡qx\phi(x,z) = \phi(z)\sinh qx (or cosh⁡qx\cosh qx) and ϕ(x,z)\phi(x,z) is one of the four potentials in (G4) and (G5). Thus, the velocity field acquires one of the following one forms

v(x,z,t)=κ2E⊥σ0e−iωtη(k2+κ2)Q−sinh⁡Q−h(cosh⁡Q−z−cosh⁡Q−hcos⁡K+hcos⁡K+z)×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qxwhen σ±=σ0×{cosh⁡qxsinh⁡qx(75)v(x,z,t) = \frac{\kappa^2 E_{\perp}\sigma_0 e^{-i\omega t}}{\eta(k^2+\kappa^2)Q_-\sinh Q_-h} \left(\cosh Q_-z - \frac{\cosh Q_-h}{\cos K_+h}\cos K_+z\right) \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \quad\text{when } \sigma^{\pm} = \sigma_0 \times \begin{cases} \cosh qx\\ \sinh qx \end{cases} \tag*{(75)}

for symmetric wall charges, and

v(x,z,t)=κ2E⊥σ0e−iωtη(k2+κ2)Q−cosh⁡Q−h(sinh⁡Q−z−sinh⁡Q−hsin⁡K+hsin⁡K+z)×{cosh⁡qxwhen σ±=+σ0cosh⁡qx,sinh⁡qxwhen σ±=+σ0sinh⁡qx(76)v(x,z,t)=\frac{\kappa^{2}E_{\perp}\sigma_{0}e^{-i\omega t}}{\eta(k^{2}+\kappa^{2})Q_{-}\cosh Q_{-}h}\left(\sinh Q_{-}z-\frac{\sinh Q_{-}h}{\sin K_{+}h}\sin K_{+}z\right)\times \begin{cases} \cosh qx & \text{when }\sigma^{\pm}=+\sigma_{0}\cosh qx,\\ \sinh qx & \text{when }\sigma^{\pm}=+\sigma_{0}\sinh qx \end{cases} \tag*{(76)}

for antisymmetric ones. In Figure 12 we display these four velocity profiles scaled by the factor (37). The left column displays the velocity profiles (G9) with symmetric charge distribution giving rise to corresponding potentials (G4). The right column displays the velocity profiles (G10) with symmetric charge distribution giving rise to corresponding potentials (G5). The upper left flow pattern is qualitatively similar to the ones obtained experimentally in [9 figure 2] (albeit theirs being steady and expressed with respect to different boundary conditions). We’ll show below that it can be employed for unidirectional electrolyte transport.

When σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\sigma_{0}\cosh qx, the velocity profile in (G9) averaged over the channel width leads to

⟨v⟩=κ2E⊥σ0cosh⁡qxη(k2+κ2)Q−2[1−Q−K+tan⁡(K+h)coth⁡(Q−h)]e−iωt,(77)\langle v\rangle=\frac{\kappa^{2}E_{\perp}\sigma_{0}\cosh qx}{\eta(k^{2}+\kappa^{2})Q_{-}^{2}}\left[1-\frac{Q_{-}}{K_{+}}\tan(K_{+}h)\coth(Q_{-}h)\right]e^{-i\omega t}, \tag*{(77)}

which is identical to (39) if we replace cos⁡qx\cos qx with cosh⁡qx\cosh qx and (Q,K)(Q,K) with (Q−,K+)(Q_{-},K_{+}). Below we only consider the symmetric wall charges of the form σ±=σ0cosh⁡qx\sigma^{\pm}=\sigma_{0}\cosh qx which, in the limits q→0q\to0 and ω→0\omega\to0 could be employed for unidirectional electrolyte transport. The remaining three velocity profiles all vanish when averaged over the width of the channel. In the limit q→0q \to0 it becomes

⟨v⟩∼σ0E⊥ηh(k2+κ2)[1−κktan⁡(kh)coth⁡(κh)]e−iωtas q→0.(78)\langle v\rangle\sim\frac{\sigma_0 E_\perp}{\eta h(k^2+\kappa^2)}\left[1-\frac{\kappa}{k}\tan(kh)\coth(\kappa h)\right]e^{-i\omega t}\quad\text{as }q\to0. \tag*{(78)}

Thus, in the long wavelength limit q→0q \to0 the behavior of the horizontal component of the velocity uu can also be described by the curves displayed in Figure 6 for the amplitude of the normalized average unidirectional velocity (G12), versus the scaled frequency ωνκ2\frac{\omega}{\nu\kappa^2}, and v0v_0 is defined in (37). The adiabatic limit ω→0\omega\to0 leads to same behavior expressed through the Langevin function defined in (40).

References

  1. [1]H. Stone, A. Stroock, and A. Ajdari, Engineering flows in small devices: microfluidics toward a lab-on-a-chip, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 36, 381 (2004).DOI
  2. [2]T. Squires and S. Quake, Microfluidics: Fluid physics at the nanoliter scale, Reviews of Modern Physics 77, 977 (2005).DOI
  3. [3]D. Erickson and D. Li, Integrated microfluidic devices, Analytica Chimica Acta 507, 11 (2004).DOI
  4. [4]F. Paratore, V. Bacheva, M. Bercovici, and G. Kaigala, Reconfigurable microfluidics, Nature Reviews Chemistry 6, 70 (2022).DOI
  5. [5]A. Stroock and G. Whitesides, Controlling flows in microchannels with patterned surface charge and topography, Accounts of Chemical Research 36, 597 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12924956
  6. [6]P. Chowdiah, D. Wasan, and D. Gidaspow, Electrokinetic phenomena in the filtration of colloidal particles suspended in nonaqueous media, AIChE Journal 27, 975 (1981).DOI
  7. [7]J. Anderson and W. Idol, Electroosmosis through pores with nonuniformly charged walls, Chemical Engineering Communications 38, 93 (1985).DOI
  8. [8]A. Ajdari, Electro-osmosis on inhomogeneously charged surfaces, Physical Review Letters 75, 755 (1995).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10060106
  9. [9]A. Stroock, M. Weck, D. Chiu, W. Huck, P. Kenis, R. Ismagilov, and G. Whitesides, Patterning electro-osmotic flow with patterned surface charge, Physical Review Letters 84, 3314 (2000).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11019078
  10. [10]T. Kamsma, W. Boon, T. ter Rele, C. Spitoni, and R. van Rooij, Iontronic neuromorphic signaling with conical microfluidic memristors, Physical Review Letters 130, 268401 (2023).DOI
  11. [11]A. Shrestha, E. Kirkinis, and M. Olvera de la Cruz, Self-generated electrokinetic flows from active-charged boundary patterns, Physical Review Research 7, 023223 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2412.15397
  12. [12]A. Shrestha, E. Kirkinis, and M. Olvera de la Cruz, Universal behaviour in boundary-driven electrokinetic flows, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1010, A50 (2025).DOI
  13. [13]L. Chua and S. Kang, Memristive devices and systems, Proceedings of the IEEE 64, 209 (1976).DOI
  14. [16]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics. Course of Theoretical Physics, Vol. 6 (Pergamon Press Ltd., London-Paris, 1987) pp. xii+515.
  15. [17]M. Krems, Y. Pershin, and M. Di Ventra, Ionic memcapacitive effects in nanopores, Nano Letters 10, 2674 (2010).DOI
  16. [18]J. Martinez-Rincon, M. Di Ventra, and Y. V. Pershin, Solid-state memcapacitive system with negative and diverging capacitance, Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 81, 195430 (2010).
  17. [19]D. Wang, M. Kvetny, J. Liu, W. Brown, Y. Li, and G. Wang, Transmembrane potential across single conical nanopores and resulting memristive and memcapacitive ion transport, Journal of the American Chemical Society 134, 3651 (2012).DOI
  18. [20]L. Luo, D. Holden, W.-J. Lan, and H. White, Tunable negative differential electrolyte resistance in a conical nanopore in glass, ACS Nano 6, 6507 (2012).DOI
  19. [21]J. Happel and H. Brenner, Low Reynolds number hydrodynamics with special applications to particulate media (Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1965) pp. xiii+553.
  20. [22]R. F. Probstein, Physical Hydrodynamics: An Introduction (John Wiley & Sons, 1994).
  21. [23]A. Ajdari, Generation of transverse fluid currents and forces by an electric field: Electro-osmosis on charge-modulated and undulated surfaces, Physical Review E 53, 4996 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9964829
  22. [24]H.-C. Yeh, R.-J. Yang, and W.-J. Luo, Analysis of traveling-wave electro-osmotic pumping with double-sided electrode arrays, Physical Review E 83, 056326 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21728666
  23. [25]J. Melcher, Continuum electromechanics (MIT press, Cambridge, MA, 1981).
  24. [26]T. Kamsma, J. Kim, K. Kim, W. Q. Boon, C. Spitoni, J. Park, and R. van Rooij, Brain-inspired computing with fluidic iontronic nanochannels, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 121, e2320242121 (2024).DOI
  25. [27]P. Robin, T. Emmerich, A. Ismail, A. Niguès, Y. You, G.-H. Nam, A. Keerthi, A. Siria, A. Geim, B. Radha, et al., Long-term memory and synapse-like dynamics in two-dimensional nanofluidic channels, Science 379, 161 (2023).DOI
  26. [28]F. Morrison and J. Osterle, Electrokinetic energy conversion in ultrafine capillaries, The Journal of Chemical Physics 43, 2111 (1965).DOI
  27. [29]Y. Pershin and M. Di Ventra, Comment on ‘if it’s pinched it’s a memristor’, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 34, 098001 (2019).DOI
  28. [30]J. Bisquert, Inductive and capacitive hysteresis of current-voltage curves: Unified structural dynamics in solar energy devices, memristors, ionic transistors, and bioelectronics, PRX Energy 3, 011001 (2024).DOI
  29. [31]J. Perez-Grau, P. Ramirez, V. Garcia-Morales, J. Cervera, S. Nasir, M. Ali, W. Ensing­er, and S. Mafe, Fluoride-induced negative differential resistance in nanopores: Experimental and theoretical characterization, ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 13, 54447 (2021).
  30. [32]J. Bisquert, Iontronic nanopore model for artificial neurons: The requisites of spiking, The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 14, 9027 (2023).DOI
  31. [33]R. Yang, Y. Balogun, S. Ake, D. Baram, W. Brown, and G. Wang, Negative differential resistance in conical nanopore iontronic memristors, Journal of the American Chemical Society 146, 13183 (2024).DOI
  32. [34]S. Levine, J. Marriott, G. Neale, and N. Epstein, Theory of electrokinetic flow in fine cylindrical capillaries at high zeta-potentials, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 52, 136 (1975).DOI
  33. [35]Y. Pershin and M. Di Ventra, Memory effects in complex materials and nanoscale systems, Advances in Physics 60, 145 (2011).DOI
  34. [36]E. Kirkinis, L. Bonds, A. Levchenko, and A. Andreev, Photogalvanic effect in hydrodynamic flows of nonreciprocal electron liquids, Physical Review B 112, 155413 (2025).DOI
  35. [37]P. Drazin and N. Riley, The Navier-Stokes equations: a classification of flows and exact solutions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wm8bnxwf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents