betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Phenomenological explorations of a quasi-degenerate Z′Z' boson

Abstract

We do a general model-independent phenomenological analysis of the curious case of a Z′Z' boson with mass close to that of the Standard Model (SM) ZZ boson. From tree-level calculation alone we show that presence of such a quasi-degenerate or `practically' degenerate Z′Z' boson affects both the cross-section and forward-backward asymmetry of the process e+e−→ffˉe^+ e^- \to f \bar{f} where ff (with f≠e−f\neq e^-) can be a lepton or quark. Most importantly the effect on forward-backward asymmetry is found to be more prominent away from the ZZ-pole. We provide constraints on such a Z′Z' from the measurement of NνN_ν, the number of light neutrino species.

Introduction

Across a large number of theoretically and phenomenologically motivated proposals on extensions of the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics, an additional exotic electrically neutral, colorless, massive spin-1 gauge boson usually denoted as Z′Z' is hypothesized to exist, see e.g. the reviews [1, 2, 3] and references therein. Despite many past and ongoing experimental searches for it [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36], we do not have any clear, unambiguous, direct signals of its existence at present. A general trend in the experimental studies so far has been to push the lower limit on possible mass of the Z′Z' to ever increasing values. Nevertheless, it is an interesting question to ponder whether the Z′Z' might be lying within the experimental energy ranges searched so far, especially in the neighbourhood of the SM ZZ boson. As some recent findings suggest [37, 38], such a quasi-degenerate Z′Z' boson (i.e. a Z′Z' which is practically almost degenerate with the SM ZZ boson) is very much a viable possibility worth exploring in future experiments. Such theoretical possibilities were also explored earlier in Refs. [39, 40, 41]. However, the only experimental paper [42], in our knowledge, probing such a possibility was essentially motivated by possible quarkonium states which could affect the ZZ-pole characteristics [43, 44].

In this paper we concern ourselves with finding effective answers to the following set of phenomenologically relevant questions on detecting and characterizing such a unique quasi-degenerate Z′Z' possibility:

  1. Since the production and detection of the Z′Z^\prime would involve the strength of its couplings to SM fermions (say, `ff’), what would be the most general structure of a renormalizable Z′ffˉZ^\prime f\bar{f} interaction Lagrangian? We aim to keep our analysis model-independent, i.e. not dwell on any specific gauge group extension of the SM.

  1. What are the useful experimental observables that can probe such a quasi-degenerate Z′Z^\prime possibility? We specifically confine our analysis to production of the Z′Z^\prime from e+e−e^+e^- annihilation, and ask how those observables get affected by taking into account the interference from photon (γ\gamma), ZZ and Z′Z^\prime mediated diagrams?

  1. Keeping our analysis simple, by considering only tree-level contributions, we ask whether the parameters related to such a Z′Z^\prime can be constrained from existing experimental results? We also discuss some interesting possibilities which can evade existing experimental constraints and how can they possibly be constrained from future studies.

Our article is structured as follows. In Sec. 2 we discuss the model-independent most general Z′ffˉZ^\prime f\bar{f} interaction Lagrangian. Immediately we follow this up by analyzing various phenomenologically relevant observables in Sec. 3. This is followed by a numerical study and discussions in Sec. 4. Finally we conclude in Sec. 5 highlighting the important aspects of our analysis.

Interaction of Z′Z^\prime with SM fermions

For a direct production of the Z′Z^\prime boson as well as its detection in any collider experiment, the Z′Z^\prime must interact with the SM fermions. Imposing Lorentz invariance alone suggests the following structure for the interaction Lagrangian describing all possible interactions of the SM fermions with Z′Z^\prime,

LZ′ffˉ=−i∑f[(∂μψˉf)(gS1′f1+gP1′fγ5)ψf+ψˉf(gS2′f1+gP2′fγ5)(∂μψf)]Z′μ−i∑f[ψˉfγμ(gV′f1−gA′fγ5)ψf]Z′μ−i∑f[ψˉfσμν(gTT′f1+gPT′fγ5)ψf]FZ′μν−i∑f[(∂μψˉf)σμν(gTT1′f1+gPT1′fγ5)ψf+ψˉfσμν(gTT2′f1+gPT2′fγ5)(∂μψf)]Z′ν.(1)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}_{Z^\prime f\bar{f}}={}&-i\sum_f\left[\left(\partial_\mu\bar{\psi}_f\right)\left(g^{\prime f}_{S1}\mathbf{1}+g^{\prime f}_{P1}\gamma^5\right)\psi_f+\bar{\psi}_f\left(g^{\prime f}_{S2}\mathbf{1}+g^{\prime f}_{P2}\gamma^5\right)\left(\partial_\mu\psi_f\right)\right]Z^{\prime\mu}\\ &-i\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\gamma_\mu\left(g^{\prime f}_{V}\mathbf{1}-g^{\prime f}_{A}\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]Z^{\prime\mu} -i\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\sigma_{\mu\nu}\left(g^{\prime f}_{TT}\mathbf{1}+g^{\prime f}_{PT}\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]F_{Z^\prime}^{\mu\nu}\\ &-i\sum_f\left[\left(\partial^\mu\bar{\psi}_f\right)\sigma_{\mu\nu}\left(g^{\prime f}_{TT1}\mathbf{1}+g^{\prime f}_{PT1}\gamma^5\right)\psi_f+\bar{\psi}_f\sigma_{\mu\nu}\left(g^{\prime f}_{TT2}\mathbf{1}+g^{\prime f}_{PT2}\gamma^5\right)\left(\partial^\mu\psi_f\right)\right]Z^{\prime\nu}. \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

where ψf\psi_f denotes the fermion field corresponding to fermion ff (which can be any quarks and leptons of the SM, as encoded in the summation over ff), gSi′fg^{\prime f}_{Si}, gPi′fg^{\prime f}_{Pi}, gV′fg^{\prime f}_{V}, gA′fg^{\prime f}_{A}, gTT(i)′fg^{\prime f}_{TT(i)} and gPT(i)′fg^{\prime f}_{PT(i)} for i=1,2i=1,2 are called the scalar, pseudo-scalar, vector, axial-vector, ‘true’ tensor and ‘pseudo’-tensor coupling constants respectively, 1\mathbf{1} is the 4×44\times4 identity matrix, and FZ′μνF_{Z^\prime}^{\mu\nu} is the field-strength tensor for Z′Z^\prime defined as FZ′μν=∂μZ′ν−∂νZ′μF_{Z^\prime}^{\mu\nu}=\partial^\mu Z^{\prime\nu}-\partial^\nu Z^{\prime\mu}. Note that we are considering no tree-level violations of flavor in Eq. (1), e.g. there are no vertices of the type Z′ℓℓˉ′Z^\prime\ell\bar{\ell}^\prime or Z′qqˉ′Z^\prime q\bar{q}^\prime for leptons ℓ≠ℓ′\ell\ne\ell^\prime and quarks q≠q′q\ne q^\prime. We also note that gSi′fg^{\prime f}_{Si}, gPi′fg^{\prime f}_{Pi}, gTT(i)′fg^{\prime f}_{TT(i)} and gPT(i)′fg^{\prime f}_{PT(i)} for i=1,2i=1,2 are dimensionful coupling constants with mass dimension −1-1, while renormalizability criteria requires the coupling constants to be dimensionless. Therefore, if we impose Lorentz invariance and renormalizability, only vector and axial-vector interactions of Z′Z^\prime with SM fermions is allowed6. Thus, the most general model-independent, Lorentz invariant and renormalizable Lagrangian for the interaction of Z′Z' with SM fermions, assuming no lepton and quark flavor violations at the Z′ffˉZ'f\bar{f} vertex, is given by

LZ′ffˉ=−igZ′2∑f[ψˉfγμ(gV′f1−gA′fγ5)ψf]Z′μ,(2)\mathcal{L}_{Z'f\bar{f}}=-i\frac{g_{Z'}}{2}\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\gamma_\mu\left(g_V^{\prime f}1-g_A^{\prime f}\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]Z^{\prime\mu}, \tag*{(2)}

where we have introduced two new vector and axial-vector coupling constants gV′fg_V^{\prime f} and gA′fg_A^{\prime f} and here gZ′g_{Z'} is the new neutral-current coupling constant, such that

gV′f=(12gZ′)gVf,gA′f=(12gZ′)gAf.(3)g_V^{\prime f}=\left(\frac{1}{2}g_{Z'}\right)g_V^f,\qquad g_A^{\prime f}=\left(\frac{1}{2}g_{Z'}\right)g_A^f. \tag*{(3)}

Although Eq. (2) seems to suggest that we have three independent parameters: gV′fg_V^{\prime f}, gA′fg_A^{\prime f} and gZ′g_{Z'}, only the combinations gV′fg_V^{\prime f} and gA′fg_A^{\prime f}, as given in Eq. (2.3), are the two independent phenomenological parameters in Z′ffˉZ'f\bar{f} couplings7, and their physical relevance is clear as shown in Eq. (5) and onwards. Phenomenologically, one can consider $g_{Z'}/2$ as an overall constant factor common to all the vector and axial-vector coupling constants for all the fermions, as explicitly evident from Eq. (2.3).

The resemblance of Eq. (2.2) with the following part of the SM Lagrangian describing interaction of the SM ZZ boson with SM fermions is completely intentional,

LZffˉSM=−igZ2∑f[ψˉfγμ(gVf1−gAfγ5)ψf]Zμ,(4)\mathcal{L}^{\mathrm{SM}}_{Zf\bar{f}}=-i\frac{g_Z}{2}\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\gamma^\mu\left(g_V^f1-g_A^f\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]Z_\mu, \tag*{(4)}

where the neutral current weak coupling constant gZg_Z is given by gZ=gW/cos⁡θWg_Z=g_W/\cos\theta_W, with gWg_W being the weak coupling constant (gW=e/sin⁡θWg_W=e/\sin\theta_W, where ee is the electric charge of positron), θW\theta_W being the Weinberg angle (also called the weak mixing angle). In this article we assume that the coupling constants gV′fg_V^{\prime f} and gA′fg_A^{\prime f} are real. Thus our model-independent analysis respects CP symmetry.

It is important to note that the presence of both vector and axial-vector couplings do not necessarily require extending the SM gauge group by an additional SU(2)SU(2) group. For example, they can arise even in presence of an extra U(1)′U(1)' group under which the left-chiral and right-chiral fermions have different U(1)′U(1)' charges. Moreover, consideration of kinetic mixing of ZZ and Z′Z' can also contribute to vector and axial-vector couplings of Eq. (2) via appropriate redefinition of the fields. As far as our phenomenological study is concerned, it suffices to note that Lorentz invariance and renormalizability are necessary and sufficient for writing Eq. (2). It also helps our analysis remain agnostic to and independent of any specific new physics (NP) model.

An ‘equivalent’ set of independent parameters can be introduced by comparison with SM ZffˉZf\bar{f} couplings of Eq. (4) as follows,

κVf≡gZ′gV′fgZgVf,κAf≡gZ′gA′fgZgAf.(5)\kappa_V^f\equiv\frac{g_{Z'}g_V^{\prime f}}{g_Zg_V^f},\qquad\kappa_A^f\equiv\frac{g_{Z'}g_A^{\prime f}}{g_Zg_A^f}. \tag*{(5)}

Using Eq. (5) we can rewrite Eq. (2) as follows,

LZ′ffˉ=−i(gZ2)∑f[ψˉfγμ(κVfgVf1−κAfgAfγ5)ψf]Z′μ.(6)\mathcal{L}_{Z'f\bar{f}}=-i\left(\frac{g_Z}{2}\right)\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\gamma_\mu\left(\kappa_V^fg_V^f1-\kappa_A^fg_A^f\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]Z^{\prime\mu}. \tag*{(6)}

If κAf=0\kappa_A^f=0 (or κVf=0\kappa_V^f=0), then the Z′Z' has ‘purely vector’ (or ‘purely axial-vector’) coupling. To simplify our phenomenological analysis, without sacrificing the necessary rigor to study the observables later, we make the following two simplifying assumptions:

  1. The scaling parameters κVf\kappa_V^f and κAf\kappa_A^f are universal for all SM fermions, i.e.

κV≡κVf,κA≡κAf.(7)\kappa_V \equiv\kappa_V^f,\qquad\kappa_A \equiv\kappa_A^f. \tag*{(7)}
  1. The vector and axial-vector couplings are scaled similarly, i.e.

κ≡κV=κA.(8)\kappa\equiv\kappa_V=\kappa_A. \tag*{(8)}

With these simplifying assumptions, Eq. (6) is simplified to

LZ′ffˉ=−iκ(gZ2)∑f[ψˉfγμ(gVf1−gAfγ5)ψf]Z′μ.(9)\mathcal{L}_{Z'f\bar f}=-i\kappa\left(\frac{g_Z}{2}\right)\sum_f\left[\bar{\psi}_f\gamma_\mu\left(g_V^f\mathbf{1}-g_A^f\gamma^5\right)\psi_f\right]Z'^\mu. \tag*{(9)}

Since Eq. (9) essentially differs from Eq. (4) by the overall scaling factor κ\kappa and replacing the ZμZ^\mu field by Z′μZ'^\mu, we have only two NP parameters: the scaling factor κ\kappa and the mass of the Z′Z' boson mZ′m_{Z'}. Note that the choice κ=1\kappa=1 exactly corresponds to the popular phenomenological case referred to as sequential Standard Model (SSM) in the literature. And if we put κ=0\kappa=0, then the Z′Z' would have no interaction with SM fermions implying no collider access to such NP possibility. Therefore, all interesting NP possibilities in our model-independent analysis would correspond to 0<κ≤10<\kappa\leq1. Additionally, we shall consider mZ′m_{Z'} in the immediate neighbourhood of mZm_Z, the mass of the SM ZZ boson,

mZ−nΓZ≤mZ′≤mZ+nΓZ,(10)m_Z-n\Gamma_Z\leq m_{Z'}\leq m_Z+n\Gamma_Z, \tag*{(10)}

with ΓZ\Gamma_Z being the total decay width of the SM ZZ boson8, and n≤1n\leq1 corresponds to the quasi-degenerate Z′Z' case. Later in the article, for the sole purpose of illustration alone, we choose mZ′=mZ±0.8ΓZm_{Z'}=m_Z\pm0.8\Gamma_Z as representatives of the various possibilities for mZ′m_{Z'}. Thus, Eq. (9) together with the conditions 0<κ≤10<\kappa\leq1 and the one given in Eq. (10) constitute our phenomenological basis.

Phenomenological Observables

For our phenomenological study we assume that the Z′Z' boson couples to SM fermions alone, such that its total decay width is equal to the sum of its partial decay widths to all the SM fermion pairs, i.e. ΓZ′=∑fΓZ′→ffˉ\Gamma_{Z'}=\sum_f\Gamma_{Z'\to f\bar f}, where ff is a SM fermion. This assumption predicts a conservative minimum value for ΓZ′\Gamma_{Z'}, if the Z′Z' were to couple with any hitherto unknown non-SM exotic fermions and if its decay to such fermion pairs is kinematically allowed. Since we are purely working with a picture where the SM particle content is enhanced by an additional Z′Z' alone and we make no assumptions about specific gauge structure extension of the SM, we do not have any exotic fermions in our picture. Below, we investigate how the decay widths of ZZ and Z′Z', differential scattering cross-section and specifically forward-backward asymmetry can be used to probe its presence.

Total and partial (including invisible) decay widths

Starting from Eq. (9) and neglecting all effects from SM fermion masses9 we find that

ΓZ′=κ2GFmZ2mZ′62π∑fNcf((gVf)2+(gAf)2),(11)\Gamma_{Z'}=\kappa^2\frac{G_Fm_Z^2m_{Z'}}{6\sqrt{2}\pi}\sum_fN_c^f\left((g_V^f)^2+(g_A^f)^2\right), \tag*{(11)}

where GF/2=gZ2/(8mZ2)G_F/\sqrt{2}=g_Z^2/(8m_Z^2) is used to replace gZg_Z in terms of the Fermi coupling constant GFG_F, and NcfN_c^f is the color factor for fermion ff (it is equal to 3 for quarks and it is 1 for leptons). It is useful to compare Eq. (11) with the corresponding expression for decay rate of the SM ZZ boson,

ΓZ=GFmZ362π∑fNcf((gVf)2+(gAf)2),(12)\Gamma_Z=\frac{G_Fm_Z^3}{6\sqrt{2}\pi}\sum_f N_c^f\left((g_V^f)^2+(g_A^f)^2\right), \tag*{(12)}

which implies that

ΓZ′=κ2(mZ′/mZ)ΓZ.(13)\Gamma_{Z'}=\kappa^2\left(m_{Z'}/m_Z\right)\Gamma_Z. \tag*{(13)}

In the limit of considering the Z′Z' to be practically degenerate with the SM ZZ boson, we note that the experimentally inferred invisible width of the ZZ boson (Γinvexp\Gamma_{\mathrm{inv}}^{\mathrm{exp}}) could be contaminated from the presence of the near by Z′Z' decaying to SM neutrinos,

Γinvexp=∑ℓ=e,μ,τ(ΓZ→νℓνˉℓSM+ΓZ′→νℓνˉℓNP)=3ΓZ→νℓνˉℓSM(1+κ2mZ′/mZ),(14)\Gamma_{\mathrm{inv}}^{\mathrm{exp}}=\sum_{\ell=e,\mu,\tau}\left(\Gamma_{Z\to\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell}^{\mathrm{SM}}+\Gamma_{Z'\to\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell}^{\mathrm{NP}}\right)=3\Gamma_{Z\to\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell}^{\mathrm{SM}}\left(1+\kappa^2m_{Z'}/m_Z\right), \tag*{(14)}

which implies that the experimental observable NνN_\nu used as an estimate of the number of light neutrinos is given by,

Nν≡ΓinvexpΓZ→νℓνˉℓSM=3(1+κ2mZ′/mZ).(15)N_\nu\equiv\frac{\Gamma_{\mathrm{inv}}^{\mathrm{exp}}}{\Gamma_{Z\to\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell}^{\mathrm{SM}}}=3\left(1+\kappa^2m_{Z'}/m_Z\right). \tag*{(15)}

Therefore, the experimentally measured value Nν=2.9963±0.0074N_\nu=2.9963\pm0.0074 [3] constrains κ\kappa, for mZ−ΓZ≤mZ′≤mZ+ΓZm_Z-\Gamma_Z\leq m_{Z'}\leq m_Z+\Gamma_Z where we consider Eq. (14) to hold true as a phenomenological approximation. As shown in Figure 1, the scaling factor κ\kappa is constrained to be

Figure 1. The physically allowed region for κ\kappa corresponds to the experimentally measured value NνN_\nu, as shown in Eq. (15). We are considering the Z′Z' to be in the proximity of the SM ZZ boson so that Eq. (14) holds true as a phenomenological approximation.

0≤κ≤0.0356at 1σ level for mZ′=mZ−ΓZ,0\leq\kappa\leq0.0356 \qquad\text{at }1\sigma\text{ level for }m_{Z'}=m_Z-\Gamma_Z,
0≤κ≤0.0346at 1σ level for mZ′=mZ+ΓZ.0\leq\kappa\leq0.0346 \qquad\text{at }1\sigma\text{ level for }m_{Z'}=m_Z+\Gamma_Z.

We reiterate that in the current article we consider NP contribution solely arising from an extra physical Z′Z' boson ‘practically degenerate’ with the SM ZZ boson, i.e. the couplings of SM ZZ boson to fermions is not affected by having an extra Z′Z' in the picture. Of course, we can instead consider a new physics which comes directly into the SM ZZ boson, and affect the Z→ννˉZ\to\nu\bar{\nu} branching ratio and thus NνN_\nu, see e.g. [45] for model-independent constraints on such NP possibility.

Cross-section and forward-backward asymmetry

To see the effects of a quasi-degenerate Z′Z^\prime in a more clear manner, we need to consider both its on-shell production and decay. Regarding this, one might consider either e+e−e^+e^- collisions as done previously at LEP, or pppp collisions as currently done at LHC, or even μ+μ−\mu^+\mu^- collisions as envisioned in future muon colliders [47]. As e+e−e^+e^- colliders have played a vital role in the discovery of the ZZ boson and due to their much cleaner backgrounds, we choose to consider the production and decay of Z′Z^\prime in such a collider. Phenomenologically, the processes of our interest are the ss-channel events of e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+ \to f\bar{f} with f≠e−f \ne e^- (to avoid consideration of Bhabha scattering which has additional tt-channel contributions).

In our case, the process e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+ \to f\bar{f} with f≠e−f \ne e^- takes place via ss-channel γ\gamma, ZZ and Z′Z^\prime mediated Feynman diagrams at tree-level, see Figure 2. We confine ourselves to tree-level contributions alone as they are sufficient to show the signatures of the presence of Z′Z^\prime on the observables. Neglecting fermion masses with respect to the mass of the ZZ boson, we find that the differential cross-section for e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+ \to f\bar{f} can be written as,

Figure 2. Tree-level Feynman diagrams for the process e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+ \to f\bar{f} with f≠e−f \ne e^-. The square blobs on the vertices involving Z′Z^\prime denote the vertex factors from Eq. (9). In this article we do not consider any beyond tree-level contributions, such as those mediated via various quarkonium possibilities.

dσffˉ(s,κ)dcos⁡θ=π2sNcf(σEf(s,κ)(1+cos⁡2θ)+σOf(s,κ)cos⁡θ),(16)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f\bar{f}}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta} = \frac{\pi}{2s}N_c^f\left(\sigma_E^f(s,\kappa)\left(1+\cos^2\theta\right)+\sigma_O^f(s,\kappa)\cos\theta\right), \tag*{(16)}

where NcfN_c^f takes care of the color possibilities for fermion ff, s\sqrt{s} is the total energy in the center-of-momentum frame of e−e+e^-e^+, and the angle θ\theta is defined as the angle between directions of flights of e−e^- and ff in the center-of-momentum frame of e−e+e^-e^+. The differential cross-section of Eq. (16) has a part proportional to cos⁡θ\cos\theta which we have denoted by σOf(s,κ)\sigma_O^f(s,\kappa) and a part proportional to 1+cos⁡2θ1+\cos^2\theta which we have denoted by σEf(s,κ)\sigma_E^f(s,\kappa). Both σEf(s)\sigma_E^f(s) and σOf(s)\sigma_O^f(s) contain contributions from the individual diagrams of Figure 2 as well as their interference terms,

σEf(s,κ)=αEM2qf2−8αEMqfgVegVf(Re⁡(rZ(s))+κ2Re⁡(rZ′(s,κ)))+16((gVe)2+(gAe)2)((gVf)2+(gAf)2)∣rZ(s)+κ2rZ′(s,κ)∣2,(17)\begin{aligned} \sigma_E^f(s,\kappa)={}&\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}^2q_f^2-8\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}q_fg_V^eg_V^f\left(\operatorname{Re}(r_Z(s))+\kappa^2\operatorname{Re}(r_{Z^\prime}(s,\kappa))\right)\\ &+16\left((g_V^e)^2+(g_A^e)^2\right)\left((g_V^f)^2+(g_A^f)^2\right)\left|r_Z(s)+\kappa^2r_{Z^\prime}(s,\kappa)\right|^2, \tag*{(17)} \end{aligned}
σOf(s,κ)=−16αEMqfgAegAf(Re⁡(rZ(s))+κ2Re⁡(rZ′(s,κ)))+128gVegAegVfgAf∣rZ(s)+κ2rZ′(s,κ)∣2,(18)\begin{aligned} \sigma_O^f(s,\kappa)={}&-16\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}q_fg_A^eg_A^f\left(\operatorname{Re}(r_Z(s))+\kappa^2\operatorname{Re}(r_{Z^\prime}(s,\kappa))\right)\\ &+128g_V^eg_A^eg_V^fg_A^f\left|r_Z(s)+\kappa^2r_{Z^\prime}(s,\kappa)\right|^2, \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

with αEM=e2/(4π)\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}=e^2/(4\pi) being the electromagnetic fine-structure constant, qfq_f being the electric charge of the fermion ff, and rZ(s)r_Z(s), rZ′(s)r_{Z^\prime}(s) contain the ss-dependent Breit-Wigner resonance forms for ZZ and Z′Z^\prime respectively,10

rZ(s)=(gZ264π)(ss−mZ2+i sΓZ/mZ)=(GFmZ28π2)(ss−mZ2+i sΓZ/mZ),(19)r_Z(s)=\left(\frac{g_Z^2}{64\pi}\right)\left(\frac{s}{s-m_Z^2+\mathrm{i}\,s\Gamma_Z/m_Z}\right)=\left(\frac{G_Fm_Z^2}{8\pi\sqrt{2}}\right)\left(\frac{s}{s-m_Z^2+\mathrm{i}\,s\Gamma_Z/m_Z}\right), \tag*{(19)}
rZ′(s,κ)=(gZ′264π)(ss−mZ′2+i s ΓZ′/mZ′)=(GFmZ28π2)(ss−mZ′2+i κ2s ΓZ/mZ)(20)r_{Z'}(s,\kappa)=\left(\frac{g_{Z}^{\prime2}}{64\pi}\right)\left(\frac{s}{s-m_{Z'}^{2}+i\,s\,\Gamma_{Z'}/m_{Z'}}\right)=\left(\frac{G_Fm_Z^2}{8\pi\sqrt{2}}\right)\left(\frac{s}{s-m_{Z'}^{2}+i\,\kappa^2s\,\Gamma_Z/m_Z}\right) \tag*{(20)}

where we have used (13) to make the substitution ΓZ′/mZ′=κ2ΓZ/mZ\Gamma_{Z'}/m_{Z'}=\kappa^2\Gamma_Z/m_Z.

The total cross-section for e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+\to f\bar{f} is then given by,

σff(s,κ)≡∫−1+1(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ=4π3sNcfσEf(s,κ),(21)\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)\equiv\int_{-1}^{+1}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta=\frac{4\pi}{3s}N_c^f\sigma_E^f(s,\kappa), \tag*{(21)}

and the distribution asymmetry between forward (0≤cos⁡θ≤10\leq\cos\theta\leq1) and backward (−1≤cos⁡θ≤0-1\leq\cos\theta\leq0) regions, known as the forward-backward asymmetry is given by,

AFBff(s,κ)≡∫0+1(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ−∫−10(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ∫−1+1(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ=38σOf(s,κ)σEf(s,κ).(22)A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa)\equiv\frac{\int_{0}^{+1}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta-\int_{-1}^{0}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}{\int_{-1}^{+1}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}=\frac{3}{8}\frac{\sigma_O^f(s,\kappa)}{\sigma_E^f(s,\kappa)}. \tag*{(22)}

Note that in Eqs. (3.10) and (3.11) the angular integrations are done assuming an ideal detector with full 4π4\pi solid angle coverage around the point of collision. In reality, detectors do not cover the full 4π4\pi solid angle and the corresponding angular coverage should appropriately get reflected in the integration ranges. For a given arbitrary detector, let us assume that −x≤cos⁡θ≤+x-x\leq\cos\theta\leq+x with 0<x<10<x<1. In such a case, the total cross-section and the forward-backward asymmetry get modified as follows,

σffcut(s,κ)≡∫−x+x(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ=(x(x2+3)4)σff(s,κ),(23)\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)\equiv\int_{-x}^{+x}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta=\left(\frac{x(x^2+3)}{4}\right)\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa), \tag*{(23)}
AFBff,cut(s,κ)≡∫0+x(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ−∫−x0(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ∫−x+x(dσff(s,κ)dcos⁡θ)dcos⁡θ=(4xx2+3)AFBff(s,κ).(24)A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)\equiv\frac{\int_{0}^{+x}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta-\int_{-x}^{0}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}{\int_{-x}^{+x}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)}{\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}\right)\mathrm{d}\cos\theta}=\left(\frac{4x}{x^2+3}\right)A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa). \tag*{(24)}

Note that both the cross-section σff(s,κ)\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa) and forward-backward asymmetry AFBff(s,κ)A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa) as given in Eqs. (3.10) and (3.11), as well as σffcut(s,κ)\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa) and AFBff,cut(s,κ)A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa) as given in Eqs. (3.12a) and (3.12b) respectively, are analytic functions of ss, since we have used Breit-Wigner resonance factors for the ZZ and Z′Z' contributions.

Difference-over-sum ratios as observables

We note that imposition of angular cuts only introduce overall multiplicative factors, essentially scaling the un-cut cross-section and forward-backward asymmetry. Nevertheless, it is important to note that for κ≠0\kappa\neq0, the quantities σffcut(s,κ)\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa) and AFBff,cut(s,κ)A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa), or σff(s,κ)\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa) and AFBff(s,κ)A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa), contain both SM as well as NP (i.e. Z′Z') contributions. If we put κ=0\kappa=0, then we get the SM contribution alone. It is interesting to note that we can define the following two dimensionless observables defined as difference-over-sum (DoS) ratios which are especially insensitive to the specific angular cuts of any detector,

Aσff(s,κ)=σffcut(s,κ)−σffcut(s,0)σffcut(s,κ)+σffcut(s,0)=σff(s,κ)−σff(s,0)σff(s,κ)+σff(s,0),(25)\mathcal{A}_{\sigma}^{f f}(s,\kappa)=\frac{\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)-\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,0)}{\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)+\sigma_{f f}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,0)}=\frac{\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)-\sigma_{f f}(s,0)}{\sigma_{f f}(s,\kappa)+\sigma_{f f}(s,0)}, \tag*{(25)}
AFBff(s,κ)=AFBff,cut(s,κ)−AFBff,cut(s,0)AFBff,cut(s,κ)+AFBff,cut(s,0)=AFBff(s,κ)−AFBff(s,0)AFBff(s,κ)+AFBff(s,0).(26)\mathcal{A}_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa)=\frac{A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)-A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,0)}{A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa)+A_{FB}^{f f,\mathrm{cut}}(s,0)}=\frac{A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa)-A_{FB}^{f f}(s,0)}{A_{FB}^{f f}(s,\kappa)+A_{FB}^{f f}(s,0)}. \tag*{(26)}

By construction, −1≤Aσff(s,κ)≤+1-1 \le\mathcal{A}^{ff}_{\sigma}(s,\kappa) \le+1 as the cross-section is always non-zero in the mass region of our interest. But AAFBff(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{ff}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) can shoot beyond the range [−1,1][-1,1] as the forward-backward asymmetry can vanish for some value of ss and κ\kappa. Moreover, one can encounter singularity in AAFBff(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{ff}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) when (AFBff,cut(s,κ)+AFBff,cut(s,0))→0(A^{ff,\mathrm{cut}}_{FB}(s,\kappa)+A^{ff,\mathrm{cut}}_{FB}(s,0)) \to0 or (AFBff(s,κ)+AFBff(s,0))→0(A^{ff}_{FB}(s,\kappa)+A^{ff}_{FB}(s,0)) \to0. Nevertheless, the two quantities in Eq. (3.13) “contrast” the presence of NP signal with respect to the SM expectation.

It is important to note that probing the underlying NP parameter space using a set of complimentary but independent observables is a more robust and credible phenomenological approach than relying on one particular observable alone. From this perspective, all the observables mentioned thus far can be used together for probing the quasi-degenerate Z′Z' possibility. Most importantly, although NνN_{\nu} serves as an independent quantity extracted from precision ZZ-pole studies, the other observables σμμ(s,κ)\sigma_{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa), AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{FB}(s,\kappa), Aσμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\sigma}(s,\kappa) and AAFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) can be measured above, below and near the ZZ and Z′Z' poles.11

Numerical study and discussions

For a numerical study of the observables mentioned before, we consider the specific scattering process e+e−→μ+μ−e^{+}e^{-} \to\mu^{+}\mu^{-}. We consider two different quasi-degenerate Z′Z' possibilities corresponding to

mZ′=mZ±0.8 ΓZ,m_{Z'} = m_Z \pm0.8\,\Gamma_Z,

for illustration and further discussion. The effects of such a Z′Z' on the cross-section, forward-backward asymmetry as well as their corresponding DoS ratios are shown in Figure 3, Figure 4, Figure 5 and Figure 6. In Figure 3 and Figure 5 we consider a few representative values of κ\kappa satisfying κ≤0.07\kappa\le0.07 by taking into account the 3σ3\sigma allowed constraint from NνN_{\nu} as shown in Figure 1. The effects of the Z′Z' on the concerned distributions in Figure 3 and Figure 5 are localized in the neighbourhood of s=mZ′\sqrt{s}=m_{Z'}, i.e. close to the Z′Z' pole. It is plausible that for a smaller value of κ\kappa, the effects of Z′Z' might so localized that those become noticeable only when the experimental resolution of s\sqrt{s} is significantly improved. On the other hand, in Figure 4 and Figure 6 we consider larger values of κ\kappa (satisfying 0.07<κ<10.07 < \kappa< 1) with an aim to highlight the fact that such large values of κ\kappa could be constrained independently12 from observables other than the NνN_{\nu}. Figure 4 and Figure 6 clearly show that the forward-backward asymmetry and the DoS ratios corresponding to both the cross-section and the forward-backward asymmetry are capable of constraining even a quasi-degenerate Z′Z' by looking at experimental measurements farther from s=mZ′\sqrt{s}=m_{Z'} on both directions. Most importantly, the trend in Figure 6 implies that precision studies of AFBA_{FB} and its corresponding DoS ratio AAFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) can possibly constrain the quasi-degenerate Z′Z' possibilities even farther away from ZZ pole.

Figure 3. Illustration of how the cross-section σμμ(s,κ)\sigma_{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa) as well as the corresponding DoS ratio Aσμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\sigma}(s,\kappa) get affected in presence of a quasi-degenerate Z′Z^\prime with mass mZ′=mZ±0.8ΓZm_{Z^\prime}=m_Z\pm0.8\Gamma_Z. We have considered values of κ≤0.07\kappa\leq0.07 respecting the constraint from NνN_\nu as shown in Figure 1. The thin vertical light gray line corresponds to s=mZ\sqrt{s}=m_Z.

Figure 4. Similar illustration as given in Figure 3 but here we consider the possibility of κ>0.07\kappa> 0.07 by disregarding the constraint from NνN_\nu as shown in Figure 1. The thin vertical light gray line corresponds to s=mZ\sqrt{s}=m_Z. Notice that although the effect on σμμ(s,κ)\sigma_{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa) is visually localized in the neighbourhood of the Z′Z' resonance. On the other hand, the corresponding DoS ratio Aσμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\sigma}(s,\kappa) is visibly different even away from the Z′Z' resonances. No quarkonium states are considered here.

Figure 5. Illustration of how the forward-backward asymmetry AFBμμ(s,κ)A^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) as well as the corresponding DoS ratio AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) get affected in presence of a quasi-degenerate Z′Z' with mass mZ′=mZ±0.8ΓZm_{Z'} = m_Z \pm0.8\Gamma_Z. We have considered values of κ≤0.07\kappa\le0.07 respecting the constraint from NνN_\nu as shown in Figure 1. The thin vertical light gray line corresponds to s=mZ\sqrt{s} = m_Z. Note that we encounter singularities in AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) in the limit (AFBμμ(s,κ)+AFBμμ(s,0))→0\left(A^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) + A^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,0)\right) \to0, which in this case occurs at s≈91\sqrt{s} \approx91 GeV. The negative spikes that one observes around s=mZ′\sqrt{s} = m_{Z'} do not correspond to singularities in AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) but in plot (b) the value of AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) goes below −1-1 showing that AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{\mathrm{FB}}(s,\kappa) is not bounded in the region [−1,1][-1,1].

(a) (a)

Plots of $\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{FB}}^{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa)$ and related quantities for $m_{Z'}=m_Z-0.8\Gamma_Z=89.192$ GeV

(b) (b)

Figure 6. Similar illustration as given in Figure 5 but here we consider the possibility of κ>0.07\kappa> 0.07 by disregarding the constraint from NνN_\nu as shown in Figure 1. The thin vertical light gray line corresponds to s=mZ\sqrt{s}=m_Z. Once again note that we encounter singularities in AFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{FB}}^{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa) in the limit (AFBμμ(s,κ)+AFBμμ(s,0))→0(\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{FB}}^{\mu\mu}(s,\kappa)+\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{FB}}^{\mu\mu}(s,0))\to0. Most importantly, the visibility of the effect of an additional Z′Z' is not confined to the neighbourhood of mZ′m_{Z'} unlike Figure 3 and Figure 5. No quarkonium states are considered here.

The singularities in AAFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) in the limit (AFBμμ(s,κ)+AFBμμ(s,0))→0(A^{\mu\mu}_{FB}(s,\kappa)+A^{\mu\mu}_{FB}(s,0)) \to0 are quite clearly visible in the left-hand side panels of Figure 5 and Figure 6. The singularities appear at s≈91\sqrt{s}\approx91 GeV for almost all

values of κ\kappa and mZ′m_{Z'} we have considered in Figure 5 and Figure 6, as can also be seen from the values tabulated in Table 1. The negative spikes one finds near s=mZ′\sqrt{s}=m_{Z'} in the left-hand side panels of Figure 5 and Figure 6 do not correspond to any singularities, as can be seen from the zoomed-in plots on the right-hand panels of the corresponding figures. It can be easily seen from Figure 3, Figure 5, Figure 4 and Figure 6 (especially by looking at the right-hand panels of those figures) that the width of the peak or dip near s=mZ′\sqrt{s}=m_{Z'} increases with larger value of κ\kappa when mZ′m_{Z'} is kept fixed, ΓZ′∝κ2\Gamma_{Z'} \propto\kappa^2 in accordance with the expected from Eq. (13). This κ\kappa dependent ΓZ′\Gamma_{Z'} enters the Breit-Wigner form of the resonance via Eq. (3.9b).

mZ′m_{Z'}κ\kappa0.010.030.050.070.10.30.50.7
mZ−0.8 ΓZm_Z - 0.8\,\Gamma_Z91.006991.006691.005991.004991.002890.967190.889590.7811
mZ+0.8 ΓZm_Z + 0.8\,\Gamma_Z91.007091.007391.007891.008791.010491.037291.085691.1354

Table 1. The singularities of AAFBμμ(s,κ)\mathcal{A}^{\mu\mu}_{A_{FB}}(s,\kappa) as apparent in Figure 5 and Figure 6 happens at the s\sqrt{s} values as mentioned (in units of GeV) in this table, for the different mZ′m_{Z'} and κ\kappa values we have considered.

Cross-section σff(s,κ)\sigma_{ff}(s,\kappa) and forward-backward asymmetry AFBff(s,κ)A_{FB}^{ff}(s,\kappa) are well-known experimental observables in the literature. However, as mentioned before, they suffer from the limited angular coverage allowed by the detector of every experiment that studies the underlying process. It is important to note the DoS ratios of Eq. (3.13) can help one overcome that limitation to compare different experimental results more uniformly.

More importantly, the DoS ratios can be directly implemented for every experimental setup by observing that

  1. σffcut(s,κ)\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa) and AFBff,cut(s,κ)A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{cut}}(s,\kappa) are essentially the experimentally observed cross-section σffExpt(s)\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{Expt}}(s) and forward-backward asymmetry AFBff,Expt(s)A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{Expt}}(s) respectively, and

  1. σffcut(s,0)\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{cut}}(s,0) and AFBff,cut(s,0)A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{cut}}(s,0) essentially correspond to the SM theory predictions for cross-section σffSM Th(s)\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s) and forward-backward asymmetry AFBff,SM Th(s)A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s) respectively, taking into account the specific experimental constraints.

This implies that Eq. (3.13) can be rewritten in the following form,

Aσff(s)=σffExpt(s)−σffSM Th(s)σffExpt(s)+σffSM Th(s),AFBff(s)=AFBff,Expt(s)−AFBff,SM Th(s)AFBff,Expt(s)+AFBff,SM Th(s).(27)\mathcal{A}_{\sigma}^{ff}(s)=\frac{\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{Expt}}(s)-\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s)}{\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{Expt}}(s)+\sigma_{ff}^{\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s)}, \qquad\mathcal{A}_{FB}^{ff}(s)=\frac{A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{Expt}}(s)-A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s)}{A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{Expt}}(s)+A_{FB}^{ff,\mathrm{SM\ Th}}(s)}. \tag*{(27)}

We are of the opinion that it would be useful if in future these observables can also be studied along with the usual cross-sections and forward-backward asymmetries. We also clarify that taking all past experimental results on e+e−→μ+μ−e^+e^- \to\mu^+\mu^- and doing a phenomenological least-square analysis to constrain mZ′m_{Z'} and κ\kappa currently lies beyond our expertise. It must be done diligently by those well versed in the experimental matters taking care of all detector aspects, spread of beam energy etc. as well as higher-order theory contributions by going beyond our tree-level considerations done here.

Even if such careful studies in future could reveal stringent experimental constraints on such quasi-degenerate Z′Z's, those can be evaded if one were to assume that the Z′Z' boson does not have family universal couplings, such as say a muon-philic (or neutrino-philic) Z′Z' which couples to only muons (or neutrinos) and not other fermions such that it could not have been produced in e−e+e^-e^+ colliders, nor could it be produced in pppp colliders. The muon-philic Z′Z' could certainly be produced on-shell in a future μ−μ+\mu^-\mu^+ collider of appropriate center-of-momentum energy, and one could analyze the cross-section, forward-backward asymmetry as well as the corresponding DoS ratios for the process μ−μ+→μ−μ+\mu^-\mu^+ \to\mu^-\mu^+ mediated via both ss and tt channel exchanges of photon, ZZ and Z′Z'. A neutrino-philic Z′Z', on the other hand, would be impossible to produce and detect in any detector, as it couples exclusively to neutrinos and it remains to be explored whether such a Z′Z' could even be constrained indirectly. We reserve consideration of such exotic quasi-degenerate Z′Z's for future explorations if such a need arises.

Conclusion

The curious possibility of finding a Z′Z' boson around the SM ZZ-pole is a very interesting possibility that can be constrained in future. Instead of constructing a UV complete model with such a possible Z′Z^\prime, we dwell on a purely model-independent approach to study the phenomenology of this type of Z′Z^\prime. We show that such a quasi-degenerate Z′Z^\prime can potentially contribute to experimentally measured invisible width of the ZZ boson, and we find that the measured value of the number of light neutrinos NνN_\nu constrains the coupling of Z′Z^\prime to SM fermions. We also show how cross-section and forward-backward asymmetry for e−e+→ffˉe^-e^+ \to f\bar{f} scattering with ff being a SM fermion different from e−e^- can be used to look for signatures of presence of such a Z′Z^\prime. Moreover, we show that one can construct dimensionless difference-over-sum ratios from both cross-section and forward-backward asymmetry which are also useful observables robust against experimental angular cuts and can be used to study such a quasi-degenerate Z′Z^\prime if it exists.

Acknowldgements

The work is supported by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education (RS-2022-NR070836, RS-2026-25471898).

References

  1. [1]A. Leike, “The Phenomenology of extra neutral gauge bosons,” Phys. Rept. 317, 143-250 (1999).DOI
  2. [2]P. Langacker, “The Physics of Heavy Z′ Gauge Bosons,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 81, 1199-1228 (2009).DOI
  3. [3]F. Takahashi et al. [Particle Data Group], “Review of Particle Physics,” Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 41, no.22, 2630011 (2026).
  4. [4]D. Acosta et al. [CDF], “Search for new physics using high mass tau pairs from 1.96 TeV pp̄ collisions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 131801 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16197130
  5. [5]A. Abulencia et al. [CDF], “Search for high-mass resonances decaying to eμ in pp̄ collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 211802 (2006).
  6. [6]T. Aaltonen et al. [CDF], “Search for new particles decaying into dijets in proton-antiproton collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV,” Phys. Rev. D 79, 112002 (2009).DOI
  7. [7]T. Aaltonen et al. [CDF], “Search for WW and WZ Resonances Decaying to Electron, Missing E_T, and Two Jets in pp̄ Collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 241801 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20867293
  8. [8]V. M. Abazov et al. [D0], “Search for a Heavy Neutral Gauge Boson in the Dielectron Channel with 5.4 fb−1 of pp̄ Collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV,” Phys. Lett. B 695, 88-94 (2011).DOI
  9. [9]T. Aaltonen et al. [CDF], “Search for High Mass Resonances Decaying to Muon Pairs in √s = 1.96 TeV pp̄ Collisions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 121801 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21517299
  10. [10]T. Aaltonen et al. [CDF], “A Search for resonant production of tt̄ pairs in 4.8 fb−1 of integrated luminosity of pp̄ collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV,” Phys. Rev. D 84, 072004 (2011).DOI
  11. [11]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for high-mass dilepton resonances using 139 fb−1 of pp collision data collected at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” Phys. Lett. B 796, 68-87 (2019).
  12. [12]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for new resonances in mass distributions of jet pairs using 139 fb−1 of pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” JHEP 03, 145 (2020).
  13. [13]A. M. Sirunyan et al. [CMS], “Search for a Narrow Resonance Lighter than 200 GeV Decaying to a Pair of Muons in Proton-Proton Collisions at √s = 13 TeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, no.13, 131802 (2020).DOI
  14. [14]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for heavy Higgs bosons decaying into two tau leptons with the ATLAS detector using pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, no.5, 051801 (2020).DOI
  15. [15]R. Aaij et al. [LHCb], “Searches for low-mass dimuon resonances,” JHEP 10, 156 (2020).DOI
  16. [16]A. M. Sirunyan et al. [CMS], “Search for resonant and nonresonant new phenomena in high-mass dilepton final states at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 07, 208 (2021).
  17. [17]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for heavy particles in the b-tagged dijet mass distribution with additional b-tagged jets in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS experiment,” Phys. Rev. D 105, no.1, 012001 (2022).
  18. [18]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for Higgs bosons decaying into new spin-0 or spin-1 particles in four-lepton final states with the ATLAS detector with 139 fb−1 of pp collision data at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 03, 041 (2022).
  19. [19]A. Tumasyan et al. [CMS], “Search for heavy resonances and quantum black holes in eμ, eτ, and μτ final states in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 05, 227 (2023).
  20. [20]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for a new Z′ gauge boson in 4μ events with the ATLAS experiment,” JHEP 07, 090 (2023).
  21. [21]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for top-philic heavy resonances in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” Eur. Phys. J. C 84, no.2, 157 (2024).
  22. [22]A. Tumasyan et al. [CMS], “Search for Z′ bosons decaying to pairs of heavy Majorana neutrinos in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 11, 181 (2023).
  23. [23]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for lepton-flavour violation in high-mass dilepton final states using 139 fb−1 of pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” JHEP 10, 082 (2023).
  24. [24]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Search for a high-mass dimuon resonance produced in association with b quark jets at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 10, 043 (2023).
  25. [25]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Search for direct production of GeV-scale resonances decaying to a pair of muons in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV,” JHEP 12, 070 (2023).
  26. [26]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for resonant production of dark quarks in the dijet final state with the ATLAS detector,” JHEP 02, 128 (2024).
  27. [27]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Combination of searches for heavy spin-1 resonances using 139 fb−1 of proton-proton collision data at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” JHEP 04, 118 (2024).
  28. [28]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for a new Z′ gauge boson via the pp → W±(*) → Z′μ±νμ± process in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” Phys. Rev. D 110, no.7, 072008 (2024).
  29. [29]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for low-mass resonances decaying into two jets and produced in association with a photon or a jet at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector,” Phys. Rev. D 110, no.3, 032002 (2024) [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 113, no.11, 119901 (2026)].
  30. [30]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Dark sector searches with the CMS experiment,” Phys. Rept. 1115, 448-569 (2025).
  31. [31]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS], “Search for boosted low-mass resonances decaying into hadrons produced in association with a photon in \(pp\) collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13\) TeV with the ATLAS detector,” JHEP 01, 099 (2025).
  32. [32]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Search for charged lepton flavor violating \(Z\) and \(Z'\) boson decays in proton-proton collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13\) TeV,” Phys. Rev. D 112, no.11, 112011 (2025).
  33. [33]V. Chekhovsky et al. [CMS], “Search for a new neutral gauge boson produced in association with one or two b jets and decaying into a pair of muons in proton-proton collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13\) TeV,” JHEP 07, 008 (2026).
  34. [34]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Combination of searches for heavy vector boson resonances in proton-proton collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13\) TeV,” JHEP 07, 005 (2026).
  35. [35]A. Gevorgyan et al. [CMS], “Search for new particles decaying into top quark-antiquark pairs in proton-proton collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13\) TeV,” [arXiv:2603.23454 [hep-ex]].arxiv.org/abs/2603.23454
  36. [36]A. Hayrapetyan et al. [CMS], “Search for a top-philic \(Z'\) boson decaying into a \(t\bar{t}\) pair in a final state with jets and an electron or muon in proton-proton collisions at \(\sqrt{s}=13.6\) TeV,” [arXiv:2608.01251 [hep-ex]].
  37. [37]D. Qiu and Y. L. Tang, “Electroweak precision measurements of a nearly-degenerate \(Z'\)-\(Z\) system,” JHEP 05, 167 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2309.16794
  38. [38]P. Lo Chiatto and F. Yu, “Consistent electroweak phenomenology of a nearly degenerate \(Z'\) boson,” Phys. Rev. D 111, no.3, 035001 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2405.03396
  39. [39]A. Hook, E. Izaguirre and J. G. Wacker, “Model Independent Bounds on Kinetic Mixing,” Adv. High Energy Phys. 2011, 859762 (2011).arxiv.org/abs/1006.0973
  40. [40]R. Dermisek, S. G. Kim and A. Raval, “New Vector Boson Near the Z-pole and the Puzzle in Precision Electroweak Data,” Phys. Rev. D 84, 035006 (2011).DOI
  41. [41]R. Dermisek, S. G. Kim and A. Raval, “Z’ near the Z-pole,” Phys. Rev. D 85, 075022 (2012).DOI
  42. [42]O. Adriani et al. [L3], “Search for narrow vector resonances in the Z mass range,” Phys. Lett. B 313, 326-332 (1993).
  43. [43]P. J. Franzini and F. J. Gilman, “Mixing of Toponium With the Z Boson,” Phys. Rev. D 32, 237 (1985).
  44. [44]L. J. Hall, S. F. King and S. R. Sharpe, “Toponium-Z-mixing,” Nucl. Phys. B 260, 510-530 (1985).DOI
  45. [45]C. S. Kim, J. Rosiek and D. Sahoo, “Probing the non-standard neutrino interactions using quantum statistics,” Eur. Phys. J. C 83, no.3, 221 (2023).DOI
  46. [46]A. Denner, H. Eck, O. Hahn and J. Kublbeck, “Feynman rules for fermion number violating interactions,” Nucl. Phys. B 387, 467-481 (1992).DOI
  47. [47]C. Accettura et al. [International Muon Collider], “The Muon Collider,” [arXiv:2504.21417 [physics.acc-ph]].arxiv.org/abs/2504.21417

Paper details

vlnc:W_wma3yu8p
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents