Introduction
The peak bolometric luminosity L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) correlates tightly with the width ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p , where L 30 L_{30} L 30 is the bolometric luminosity 30 days after explosion (Sharon et al. 2025). This early-time relation complements the relation between the synthesized 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass, M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , and the γ \gamma γ -ray escape time, t 0 t_{0} t 0 (Wygoda et al. 2019a; Sharon & Kushnir 2020), which requires late-time observations (t ∼ 100 t\sim100 t ∼ 100 d), and for multidimensional models, radiative-transfer (RT) calculations whose uncertainties grow as the ejecta become optically thin (different RT codes applied to identical ejecta diverge increasingly with time, even in the bolometric light curve; Blondin et al. 2022). Because L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p correlate closely with M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni and t 0 t_{0} t 0 , the early-time relation carries similar information about the explosion while using only the first 30 d, when the ejecta are optically thick, and the RT codes agree much better. An asymmetric explosion occupies a track in the luminosity–width plane as the viewing angle changes. The off-centre ignition models in Figure 1 move across the observed sequence: viewing the nickel-rich sides makes them brighter and reduces L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p . We seek an analytic relation between this variation and the source displacement or the ejecta shape.
Figure 1. Viewing-angle tracks in the luminosity–width plane from (a) URILIGHT Monte Carlo RT (Wygoda et al. 2019a) and (b) the analytic toy models of this work, over the observed SNe Ia of Sharon et al. (2025) (grey, 1 σ 1\sigma 1 σ error bars). Squares: the 19 off-centre ignition models (Table C1), coloured by the ignition offset ζ i g \zeta_{\rm ig} ζ ig (in WD radii) and labelled by ejecta mass M M M ; circles: the six equal-mass WD collisions (Table D1), labelled by the WD masses in M ⊙ M_{\odot} M ⊙ . Small symbols are the ten bins in cos θ k \cos\theta_k cos θ k , where θ k \theta_k θ k is the angle between the line of sight and the symmetry axis (cos θ k = + 1 \cos\theta_k=+1 cos θ k = + 1 faces the displaced 56 ^{56} 56 Ni; the collision axis for the collisions), joined into a track; the large open symbol is the angle-averaged light curve. The URILIGHT collision tracks nearly retrace themselves (approximate equatorial symmetry), and the exactly symmetric analytic ones are folded onto ∣ cos θ k ∣ |\cos\theta_k| ∣ cos θ k ∣ . Toward the near-56 ^{56} 56 Ni-facing pole the off-centre tracks become brighter and narrower, moving across the observed sequence. The same tracks are shown in Figure C4 .
Figure 1 reproduces the observed relation together with the viewing-angle tracks of the models studied here. The observed sample separates into two regimes: faster-declining events with L 30 / L p < 0.5 L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}<0.5 L 30 / L p < 0.5 , which form a rising sequence spanning L p ≈ 0.1 L_{\mathrm{p}}\approx0.1 L p ≈ 0.1 –1.4 × 10 43 1.4\times10^{43} 1.4 × 1 0 43 erg s− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , and slower, brighter events with L 30 / L p > 0.5 L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}>0.5 L 30 / L p > 0.5 , which cluster at L p ∼ 1.2 L_{\mathrm{p}}\sim1.2 L p ∼ 1.2 –1.65 × 10 43 1.65\times10^{43} 1.65 × 1 0 43 erg s− 1 ^{-1} − 1 ; the sub-Chandrasekhar models remain at L 30 / L p < 0.45 L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}<0.45 L 30 / L p < 0.45 over varying angle, whereas most of the collision models occupy L 30 / L p > 0.5 L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}>0.5 L 30 / L p > 0.5 . The angle-averaged properties of these models are in tension with the observations (Sharon et al. 2025), and their viewing-angle tracks are long: L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p changes by tens of per cent between the extreme viewing angles of the asymmetric models of both families (§ 5 –§ 7 ). Whether such transverse variations are consistent with the observed distribution is a question of the residuals about the relation (§ 8 ); answering it requires both reliable RT calculations of the spread and an understanding of its physical origin, which properties of the ejecta control it and how strongly. This is the main motivation for the present work.
We focus on the two families of multidimensional models analysed by Sharon et al. (2025). The first is the off-centre ignition of sub-Chandrasekhar white dwarfs (WDs), motivated by the double-detonation scenario, in which a helium-shell detonation drives a converging shock that ignites the carbon–oxygen (CO) core off centre (Nomoto 1982a,b; Livne 1990; Woosley & Weaver 1994; Fink et al. 2010; Shen & Bildsten 2014), possibly for thin helium shells (Bildsten et al. 2007; Fink et al. 2007; Moore et al. 2013; Shen & Moore 2014; Townsley et al. 2019; Boos et al. 2021). The models used by Sharon et al. (2025), and here, are those of Schinasi-Lemberg & Kushnir (2025), who isolate the effect of off-centre ignition by igniting bare CO WDs at prescribed points along the symmetry axis; the ejecta are approximately spherical, while the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution is displaced along the axis. The second family is the head-on collision of two WDs (Rosswog et al. 2009; Raskin et al. 2010; Kushnir et al. 2013), for which Sharon et al. (2025) used the two-dimensional models of Kushnir et al. (2013); here the ejecta themselves are flattened along the collision axis, together with the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni-rich region. We represent the two cases by a displaced spherical source inside a spherical boundary and by concentric oblate source and boundary spheroids, respectively.
Numerical RT studies have established substantial viewing-angle effects in asymmetric supernova ejecta, for ellipsoidal ejecta (Höflich 1991; Sim 2007), two-dimensional detonating failed-deflagration models (Kasen & Plewa 2007) and head-on WD collisions (Sharon et al. 2025), as well as for aspherical kilonova ejecta (Darbha & Kasen 2020). In particular, Sim et al. (2007) found nearly linear angular variations of the peak magnitude and rise time for an offset 56 ^{56} 56 Ni region in uniform-density ejecta. Analytic radioactive light-curve models describe the competition between heating, diffusion and expansion (Colgate & McKee 1969; Arnett 1982; Pinto & Eastman 2000a; Pinto & Eastman 2000b); Arnett’s solution retains the fundamental diffusion mode, with the corollary that the luminosity at maximum equals the instantaneous deposition rate, and Pinto & Eastman (2000a) showed with the full set of eigenmodes how the location of the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni shapes the rise. The time-weighted energy constraint of Katz et al. (2013) is independent of geometry and of the diffusion approximation, and was used by Khatami & Kasen (2019) to relate the peak time and the peak luminosity, while Kushnir & Katz (2019) mapped diffusion in homologous expansion onto a static problem in general geometry and obtained explicit spherical solutions by convolving the eigenmode impulse response with the deposition history. Darbha & Kasen (2020) also give a simple analytic estimate of directional light curves from the projected photospheric area. Here we derive explicit eigenfunction diffusion solutions for the two asymmetric geometries.
We solve diffusion in homologously expanding uniform-density ejecta for a displaced spherical source and for concentric oblate source and boundary geometries, and an Eddington surface-emission law projects the emergent flux toward an observer. The leading quasi-steady signal is dipolar for a displaced sphere and quadrupolar for oblate ejecta; its accuracy at peak is tested against the time-dependent solutions. We caution that the displacement z o f f z_{\rm off} z off is an effective parameter of a uniform-density toy model rather than a measure of the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni centroid of a stratified ejecta (Section 5.2). Sections 2–4 develop and validate the framework. Sections 5–7 test effective representations of numerical explosions, separating agreement in peak luminosity from the larger errors in width-ratio variation: as Figure 1 shows, the analytic tracks reproduce the location, direction, and extent in L p L_{\rm p} L p of the URILIGHT tracks, and the dominant systematic mismatch is in the width-ratio variation. § 8 discusses the implications and limits; the derivations and complete model results are given in the appendices.
The Analytic Diffusion Framework
Following Kushnir & Katz (2019), we describe the diffusion of radiation energy within homologously expanding ejecta using velocity coordinates v = x / t \mathbf{v}=\mathbf{x}/t v = x / t . By introducing scaled variables
e ˉ = t 4 e , ρ ˉ = t 3 ρ , ϵ ˉ = t 3 ϵ , t ˉ = 1 2 t 2 , (1) \bar{e}=t^{4}e,\qquad\bar{\rho}=t^{3}\rho,\qquad\bar{\epsilon}=t^{3}\epsilon,\qquad\bar{t}=\frac{1}{2}t^{2}, \tag*{(1)} e ˉ = t 4 e , ρ ˉ = t 3 ρ , ϵ ˉ = t 3 ϵ , t ˉ = 2 1 t 2 , (1)
where e e e is the radiation energy density per unit volume, ρ \rho ρ the mass density, ϵ \epsilon ϵ the local energy generation rate per unit volume, and κ \kappa κ the effective opacity; the explicit time dependence from adiabatic expansion is absorbed. The problem transforms into a static diffusion equation. For the uniform velocity-space density and constant grey opacity adopted in the analytic solutions below, the diffusion coefficient D ≡ c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) D \equiv c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}v) D ≡ c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) is constant:
∂ e ˉ ∂ t ˉ − D ∇ 2 e ˉ = ϵ ˉ , D = c 3 κ ρ ˉ v . (2) \frac{\partial\bar{e}}{\partial\bar{t}}-D\nabla^{2}\bar{e}=\bar{\epsilon},\qquad D=\frac{c}{3\kappa\bar{\rho}v}. \tag*{(2)} ∂ t ˉ ∂ e ˉ − D ∇ 2 e ˉ = ϵ ˉ , D = 3 κ ρ ˉ v c . (2)
The scaled global energy generation rate Q ˉ \bar{Q} Q ˉ , luminosity L ˉ \bar{L} L ˉ , and total radiation energy E ˉ \bar{E} E ˉ are related to their physical counterparts by Q ˉ = Q \bar{Q}=Q Q ˉ = Q , L ˉ = L \bar{L}=L L ˉ = L , and E ˉ = E / t \bar{E}=E/t E ˉ = E / t .
To solve for an arbitrary heating source, we define the impulse response. When energy deposition occurs over a negligibly short interval at t ˉ δ \bar{t}_{\delta} t ˉ δ , the source term is a delta function,
ϵ ˉ ( v , t ) = ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) δ ( t − t ˉ δ ) . (3) \bar{\epsilon}(v,t)=\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v)\delta(t-\bar{t}_{\delta}). \tag*{(3)} ϵ ˉ ( v , t ) = ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) δ ( t − t ˉ δ ) . (3)
Here ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) \bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v) ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) is the spatial distribution of injected energy in velocity space, normalized to unit scaled energy, ∫ ϵ ˉ δ d 3 v = 1 \int\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}\,d^{3}v=1 ∫ ϵ ˉ δ d 3 v = 1 , so that the impulse response below is the response to unit deposited energy (in Appendix § 11 the impulse carries an arbitrary scaled energy E ˉ δ \bar{E}_{\delta} E ˉ δ , which divides out of the normalized response). For t ˉ > t ˉ δ \bar{t}>\bar{t}_{\delta} t ˉ > t ˉ δ , the system evolves according to the homogeneous diffusion equation with initial condition e ˉ ( v , t ˉ δ ) = ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) \bar{e}(v,\bar{t}_{\delta})=\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v) e ˉ ( v , t ˉ δ ) = ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) . This impulse solution serves as the Green’s function of the system. For a continuous, time-dependent heating rate Q ( t ) Q(t) Q ( t ) with a fixed spatial distribution, the total luminosity is constructed via the convolution
L ( t ˉ ) = ∫ 0 t ˉ d t ˉ ′ Q ( t ˉ ′ ) L δ ( t ˉ − t ˉ ′ ) , (4) L(\bar{t})=\int_{0}^{\bar{t}}d\bar{t}^{\prime}\,Q(\bar{t}^{\prime})L_{\delta}(\bar{t}-\bar{t}^{\prime}), \tag*{(4)} L ( t ˉ ) = ∫ 0 t ˉ d t ˉ ′ Q ( t ˉ ′ ) L δ ( t ˉ − t ˉ ′ ) , (4)
where L δ ( t ˉ ) L_{\delta}(\bar{t}) L δ ( t ˉ ) is the impulse-response luminosity.
The analytic solutions below assume a uniform density in velocity space, a constant grey opacity, and a sharp ejecta edge, on which we impose the absorbing (Dirichlet) condition e ˉ = 0 \bar{e}=0 e ˉ = 0 , the standard optically thick approximation for a free surface. The diffusion operator on this bounded domain has a discrete set of eigenfunctions, so the solution is an eigenfunction expansion in which each mode decays exponentially in t ˉ \bar{t} t ˉ at a rate set by its eigenvalue; the general solution and the two geometries are derived in Appendix § 11 , and the quasi-steady angular pattern reached under continuous heating in Appendix B2. Both the diffusion equation and the Eddington closure introduced below describe optically thick transport. For uniform-density ejecta the centre-to-surface optical depth is τ ( t ) = 3 κ M / ( 4 π v o 2 t 2 ) \tau(t)=3\kappa M/(4\pi v_{o}^{2}t^{2}) τ ( t ) = 3 κ M / ( 4 π v o 2 t 2 ) , which for the fiducial parameters of § 3 (M ≈ 1 M ⊙ M\approx1\,M_{\odot} M ≈ 1 M ⊙ , κ = 0.2 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.2\ {\rm cm}^{2}\,{\rm g}^{-1} κ = 0.2 cm 2 g − 1 , v o ≈ 1.29 × 10 4 k m s − 1 v_{o}\approx1.29\times10^{4}\ {\rm km}\,{\rm s}^{-1} v o ≈ 1.29 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 ) is ≈ 34 \approx34 ≈ 34 at 15 d, ≈ 8 \approx8 ≈ 8 at 30 d and unity at ≈ 90 \approx90 ≈ 90 d. The description is therefore accurate around maximum light and degrades gradually as the ejecta approach transparency; what fails first is the angular structure, since the RT viewing-angle contrast must decay as photons free-stream, whereas the diffusion solution holds it near its quasi-steady pattern, while the angle-averaged luminosity is expected to remain more accurate because both descriptions approach L → Q L\rightarrow Q L → Q asymptotically (an asymptotic statement, not a guarantee at every epoch; Appendix E and § 5.3 quantify the residuals).
Radioactive Heating
The total energy deposition rate is Q ( t ) = Q γ ( t ) f d e p ( t ) + Q p o s ( t ) Q(t)=Q_{\gamma}(t)f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t)+Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t) Q ( t ) = Q γ ( t ) f dep ( t ) + Q pos ( t ) , where Q γ ( t ) Q_{\gamma}(t) Q γ ( t ) is the direct γ \gamma γ -ray component, Q p o s ( t ) Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t) Q pos ( t ) accounts for positron kinetic energy, and f d e p ( t ) f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t) f dep ( t ) is the γ \gamma γ -ray deposition fraction. The positron kinetic energy is assumed to be deposited locally and in full. The radioactive heating rates are (following Wygoda et al. 2019a, with lifetimes from Junde (1999) and mean decay energies from Ambwani & Sutherland (1988)),
Q γ ( t ) = M 56 N i M ⊙ [ 6.45 e − t / 8.76 d + 1.38 e − t / 111.4 d ] × 10 43 e r g s − 1 , (5) Q_{\gamma}(t)=\frac{M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}{M_{\odot}}\left[6.45e^{-t/8.76\,\mathrm{d}}+1.38e^{-t/111.4\,\mathrm{d}}\right]\times10^{43}\ {\rm erg}\ {\rm s}^{-1}, \tag*{(5)} Q γ ( t ) = M ⊙ M 56 Ni [ 6.45 e − t /8.76 d + 1.38 e − t /111.4 d ] × 1 0 43 erg s − 1 , (5)
Q p o s ( t ) = 4.64 M 56 N i M ⊙ [ e − t / 111.4 d − e − t / 8.76 d ] × 10 41 e r g s − 1 , (6) Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t)=4.64\frac{M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}{M_{\odot}}\left[e^{-t/111.4\,\mathrm{d}}-e^{-t/8.76\,\mathrm{d}}\right]\times10^{41}\ {\rm erg}\ {\rm s}^{-1}, \tag*{(6)} Q pos ( t ) = 4.64 M ⊙ M 56 Ni [ e − t /111.4 d − e − t /8.76 d ] × 1 0 41 erg s − 1 , (6)
where M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni is the initial 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass. We adopt the γ \gamma γ -ray deposition fraction from Jeffery (1999),
f d e p ( t ) = 1 − e − t 0 2 / t 2 , (7) f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t)=1-e^{-t_{0}^{2}/t^{2}}, \tag*{(7)} f dep ( t ) = 1 − e − t 0 2 / t 2 , (7)
where t 0 t_{0} t 0 is the characteristic γ \gamma γ -ray escape time. The limit t 0 → ∞ t_{0}\rightarrow\infty t 0 → ∞ corresponds to complete deposition, f d e p = 1 f_{\mathrm{dep}}=1 f dep = 1 .
Viewing-Angle Luminosity: Eddington Grey-Atmosphere Closure
The diffusion solution provides the impulse surface flux F δ ( r s , t ) F_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},t) F δ ( r s , t ) emerging from each point r s \boldsymbol{r}_{s} r s on the sharp ejecta boundary ∂ S \partial S ∂ S . To determine the luminosity seen by a distant observer at a specific orientation, we relate the local flux to the emergent specific intensity using the Eddington grey-atmosphere closure. Assuming a quasi-static, semi-infinite grey atmosphere, the specific intensity at surface point r s \boldsymbol{r}_{s} r s is
I δ ( r s , μ , t ) = 3 4 π F δ ( r s , t ) ( μ + 2 3 ) , (8) I_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},\mu,t)=\frac{3}{4\pi}F_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},t)\left(\mu+\frac{2}{3}\right), \tag*{(8)} I δ ( r s , μ , t ) = 4 π 3 F δ ( r s , t ) ( μ + 3 2 ) , (8)
where μ = n ^ ⋅ k ^ \mu=\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{k}} μ = n ^ ⋅ k ^ is the direction cosine between the outward surface normal n ^ \hat{\boldsymbol{n}} n ^ and the unit vector toward the observer k ^ \hat{\boldsymbol{k}} k ^ . Relativistic Doppler shifts and aberration are neglected in accordance with the non-relativistic diffusion treatment (v ≪ c v\ll c v ≪ c ).
We consider a distant observer in the direction
k ^ = sin θ k x ^ + cos θ k z ^ , (9) \hat{\boldsymbol{k}}=\sin\theta_{k}\,\hat{\boldsymbol{x}}+\cos\theta_{k}\,\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}, \tag*{(9)} k ^ = sin θ k x ^ + cos θ k z ^ , (9)
where θ k \theta_{k} θ k is the viewing angle relative to the symmetry axis. Azimuthal symmetry allows us to set ϕ k = 0 \phi_{k}=0 ϕ k = 0 without loss of generality.
The isotropic equivalent luminosity inferred by this observer is obtained by integrating the emergent intensity over the visible ejecta surface:
L δ , i s o ( t , θ k ) = 4 π ∫ ∂ S v i s I δ ( r s , μ , t ) ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) d A , (10) L_{\delta,\mathrm{iso}}(t,\theta_{k})=4\pi\int_{\partial S_{\mathrm{vis}}}I_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},\mu,t)(\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{k}})\,dA, \tag*{(10)} L δ , iso ( t , θ k ) = 4 π ∫ ∂ S vis I δ ( r s , μ , t ) ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) d A , (10)
where ∂ S v i s \partial S_{\mathrm{vis}} ∂ S vis is the visible hemisphere defined by μ > 0 \mu>0 μ > 0 . Here L δ , i s o L_{\delta,\mathrm{iso}} L δ , iso is the luminosity a distant observer would infer under the assumption of isotropic emission; for aspherical ejecta or an off-centre source, it is not the true bolometric luminosity, and only its average over all viewing directions recovers the latter (§ 2.2 ).
For spherical ejecta, in spherical coordinates ( r , θ , ϕ ) (r,\theta,\phi) ( r , θ , ϕ ) , the outward unit normal at the ejecta boundary r = R ( t ) = v o t r=R(t)=v_{o}t r = R ( t ) = v o t is simply n ^ = e ^ r \hat{\boldsymbol{n}}=\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_{r} n ^ = e ^ r . The direction cosine toward an observer at k ^ = ( sin θ k , 0 , cos θ k ) T \hat{\boldsymbol{k}}=(\sin\theta_{k},0,\cos\theta_{k})^{T} k ^ = ( sin θ k , 0 , cos θ k ) T is
μ ( θ , ϕ ; θ k ) = sin θ cos ϕ sin θ k + cos θ cos θ k , (11) \mu(\theta,\phi;\theta_{k})=\sin\theta\cos\phi\sin\theta_{k}+\cos\theta\cos\theta_{k}, \tag*{(11)} μ ( θ , ϕ ; θ k ) = sin θ cos ϕ sin θ k + cos θ cos θ k , (11)
and the surface element is d A = R 2 ( t ) sin θ d θ d ϕ dA=R^{2}(t)\sin\theta\,d\theta\,d\phi d A = R 2 ( t ) sin θ d θ d ϕ . The visibility condition μ > 0 \mu>0 μ > 0 defines a perfect geometric hemisphere centred on the observer’s line of sight.
The standard, angle-averaged impulse bolometric luminosity is recovered by averaging over all observer orientations:
L δ a v g ( t ) = 1 4 π ∫ 4 π L δ , i s o ( t , θ k ) d Ω k . (12) L_{\delta}^{\mathrm{avg}}(t)=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int_{4\pi}L_{\delta,\mathrm{iso}}(t,\theta_{k})\,d\Omega_{k}. \tag*{(12)} L δ avg ( t ) = 4 π 1 ∫ 4 π L δ , iso ( t , θ k ) d Ω k . (12)
Substituting the definition of L δ , i s o L_{\delta,\mathrm{iso}} L δ , iso and the relation F δ = ∫ ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) I δ d Ω k F_{\delta}=\int(\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{k}})I_{\delta}\,d\Omega_{k} F δ = ∫ ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) I δ d Ω k recovers the standard total impulse luminosity:
L δ a v g ( t ) = ∮ ∂ S F δ ( r s , t ) d A = L δ ( t ) . (13) L_{\delta}^{\mathrm{avg}}(t)=\oint_{\partial S}F_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},t)\,dA=L_{\delta}(t). \tag*{(13)} L δ avg ( t ) = ∮ ∂ S F δ ( r s , t ) d A = L δ ( t ) . (13)
This confirms that the directional integration is globally consistent with diffusion theory: L i s o L_{\rm iso} L iso accounts for local surface-flux variations and the geometric projection of aspherical ejecta, while its orientation average remains constrained by the total energy emerging from ∂ S \partial S ∂ S .
Parameters of the analytic solution
Before applying the framework to numerical ejecta, we state the parameters that completely specify the solution for the two geometries used in this work; we refer to them as the toy-model parameters throughout. The 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni region is confined to a sharply bounded sub-volume within which the initial energy-deposition density is uniform.
For the off-centre spherical case, consider spherical ejecta of outer velocity v o v_{\rm o} v o containing a spherical 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source of radius x s v o x_{\rm s}v_{\rm o} x s v o displaced along the symmetry axis by z o f f v o z_{\rm off}v_{\rm o} z off v o . The solution is fully specified by five parameters: the fractional source radius x s ∈ ( 0 , 1 ] x_{\rm s} \in(0,1] x s ∈ ( 0 , 1 ] ; the fractional axial displacement z o f f z_{\rm off} z off ; the diffusion time-scale t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , defined through t ~ 2 ≡ v o 2 / D \tilde{t}^{2} \equiv v_{\rm o}^{2}/D t ~ 2 ≡ v o 2 / D ; the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni ; and the γ \gamma γ -ray escape time t 0 t_{0} t 0 . The source is contained within the ejecta only for x s + ∣ z o f f ∣ ≤ 1 x_{\rm s} + |z_{\rm off}| \le1 x s + ∣ z off ∣ ≤ 1 . Negative z o f f z_{\rm off} z off is handled by reflection: the solution for − z o f f -z_{\rm off} − z off follows from that for + ∣ z o f f ∣ +|z_{\rm off}| + ∣ z off ∣ by θ → π − θ \theta\to\pi-\theta θ → π − θ , so that the odd multipoles change sign, and the radial bounds of Appendix § 11.2 are written for z o f f ≥ 0 z_{\rm off} \ge0 z off ≥ 0 .
The impulse response depends on the geometry through ( x s , z o f f ) (x_{\rm s},z_{\rm off}) ( x s , z off ) and on time only through the ratio t / t ~ t/\tilde{t} t / t ~ , so t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ is the single time-scale of the homogeneous diffusion problem. The remaining two parameters enter exclusively through the convolution with the heating rate (Equation (4) ): M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni as the overall normalization of Q ( t ) Q(t) Q ( t ) , and t 0 t_{0} t 0 through the deposition fraction f d e p ( t ) f_{\rm dep}(t) f dep ( t ) (Equation (7) ).
For oblate spheroidal ejecta the two spherical shape parameters are replaced by three: the ejecta boundary coordinate ξ s \xi_{\rm s} ξ s , equivalently the axis ratio v p o l / v e q = tanh ξ s v_{\rm pol}/v_{\rm eq} = \tanh\xi_{\rm s} v pol / v eq = tanh ξ s ; the source boundary coordinate ξ 1 \xi_{1} ξ 1 ; and the ratio f f f between the focal length of the source spheroid and the focal length a a a of the ejecta spheroid. The diffusion time-scale is then defined by t ~ 2 ≡ a 2 / D \tilde{t}^{2} \equiv a^{2}/D t ~ 2 ≡ a 2 / D . The source is concentric with the ejecta and centred on the equatorial plane, so that z o f f = 0 z_{\rm off}=0 z off = 0 and the viewing-angle dependence arises entirely from the aspherical boundary and heating source.
Validation against Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer
We first test the transport treatment on idealized ejecta with the same density, opacity, source geometry, and deposition in both calculations, so that any difference measures the accuracy of the diffusion solution and the grey-atmosphere closure alone.
The reference calculations are performed with the URILIGHT code (Wygoda et al. 2019a,b), a multidimensional MCRT code based on the approximations of the SEDONA code (Kasen et al. 2006). URILIGHT assumes homologous expansion, local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) ionization and excitation, and Sobolev expansion opacities, with a thermalization parameter of ϵ t h = 0.8 \epsilon_{\rm th}=0.8 ϵ th = 0.8 . Because it neglects non-thermal ionization, it is expected to provide reliable bolometric light curves primarily during the first t ≲ 30 t \lesssim30 t ≲ 30 days after explosion (Sharon et al. 2025). This limitation applies only to the explosion models of § 5.1 –§ 7 , where the opacity is derived from the LTE ionization and excitation state, and not to the idealized calculations presented here, which adopt a constant grey opacity.
Both comparisons below are performed with a complete γ \gamma γ -ray deposition, f d e p = 1 f_{\rm dep}=1 f dep = 1 , imposed consistently in the analytic calculation and in URILIGHT. In addition, we verified that applying the Green’s-function solution to a spatially resolved source reproduces the light curves of the above-mentioned URILIGHT calculation, confirming that the impulse-response formulation can be used to construct the solution for arbitrary source distributions.
Off-centre spherical source
Figure 2 compares the analytic light curves with URILIGHT for an off-centre spherical 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source with x s = 0.8435 x_{\rm s}=0.8435 x s = 0.8435 , z o f f = 0.0999 z_{\rm off}=0.0999 z off = 0.0999 , t ~ = 31.503 \tilde{t}=31.503 t ~ = 31.503 d and M 56 N i = 0.604 M ⊙ M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}=0.604\,M_{\odot} M 56 Ni = 0.604 M ⊙ , with f d e p = 1 f_{\rm dep}=1 f dep = 1 ; the diffusion time-scale follows from M = 1.006 M ⊙ M=1.006\,M_{\odot} M = 1.006 M ⊙ , v o = 1.291 × 10 4 k m s − 1 v_{\rm o}=1.291\times10^{4}\ {\rm km\ s}^{-1} v o = 1.291 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 (corresponding to ρ ˉ v = 0.112 M ⊙ ( 10 4 k m s − 1 ) − 3 \bar{\rho}_{\rm v}=0.112\,M_{\odot}\,(10^{4}\ {\rm km\ s}^{-1})^{-3} ρ ˉ v = 0.112 M ⊙ ( 1 0 4 km s − 1 ) − 3 and κ = 0.2 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.2\ {\rm cm}^{2}\ {\rm g}^{-1} κ = 0.2 cm 2 g − 1 ). These are the exact parameters of the run; its solver configuration file is distributed with the data. The URILIGHT luminosities are collected in ten viewing-angle bins, uniform in cos θ k \cos\theta_{k} cos θ k over [ − 1 , 1 ] [-1,1] [ − 1 , 1 ] (bin centres cos θ k = ± 0.1 , ± 0.3 , ± 0.5 , ± 0.7 , ± 0.9 \cos\theta_{k}=\pm0.1,\pm0.3,\pm0.5,\pm0.7,\pm0.9 cos θ k = ± 0.1 , ± 0.3 , ± 0.5 , ± 0.7 , ± 0.9 ), and the analytic solution is evaluated at the bin centres; this binning is used throughout the paper.
Figure 2. Validation of the analytic off-centre diffusion solution (red dashed) against URILIGHT (solid black) for idealized uniform-density spherical ejecta with the parameters of § 3.1 and complete γ \gamma γ -ray deposition. The isotropic-equivalent luminosity L i s o L_{\mathrm{iso}} L iso is shown for five of the ten viewing-angle bins (cos θ k = − 0.9 , − 0.5 , − 0.1 , + 0.3 , + 0.7 \cos\theta_k=-0.9,-0.5,-0.1,+0.3,+0.7 cos θ k = − 0.9 , − 0.5 , − 0.1 , + 0.3 , + 0.7 ), with cos θ k = + 1 \cos\theta_k=+1 cos θ k = + 1 facing the displaced 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source; the curves brighten monotonically from − 0.9 -0.9 − 0.9 (labelled below its peak) to + 0.7 +0.7 + 0.7 (labelled above it).
The observables are measured separately in each viewing-angle bin, μ k = cos θ k \mu_{k}=\cos\theta_{k} μ k = cos θ k . The peak luminosity L p ( μ k ) = L i s o ( t p ( μ k ) , μ k ) L_{\rm p}(\mu_{k})=L_{\rm iso}(t_{\rm p}(\mu_{k}),\mu_{k}) L p ( μ k ) = L iso ( t p ( μ k ) , μ k ) is evaluated at the peak time of that bin, t p ( μ k ) t_{\rm p}(\mu_{k}) t p ( μ k ) , which depends on the viewing angle (for details of Figure 2 , t p t_{\rm p} t p decreases from 16.4 d at cos θ k = − 0.9 \cos\theta_{k}=-0.9 cos θ k = − 0.9 to 13.2 d at + 0.9 +0.9 + 0.9 in URILIGHT, and from 16.8 to 14.0 d in the analytic solution), whereas L 30 ( μ k ) = L i s o ( 30 d , μ k ) L_{30}(\mu_{k})=L_{\rm iso}(30\ {\rm d},\mu_{k}) L 30 ( μ k ) = L iso ( 30 d , μ k ) is evaluated at the same time after explosion for all bins. For each calculation we also form the angle-averaged light curve, ⟨ L ⟩ ( t ) = 1 2 ∫ − 1 1 L i s o ( t , μ k ) d μ k \langle L\rangle(t)=\frac{1}{2}\int_{-1}^{1}L_{\rm iso}(t,\mu_{k})\,d\mu_{k} ⟨ L ⟩ ( t ) = 2 1 ∫ − 1 1 L iso ( t , μ k ) d μ k . For the analytic solution, this is the angle-integrated luminosity L ( t ) L(t) L ( t ) of § 2.2 ; for URILIGHT it is the luminosity of all escaping packets, which equals the mean of the ten bin luminosities because the bins subtend equal solid angles. The angle-averaged peak luminosity and width ratio, L p a v g = max t ⟨ L ⟩ L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg}=\max_{t}\langle L\rangle L p avg = max t ⟨ L ⟩ and ( L 30 / L p ) a v g = ⟨ L ⟩ ( 30 d ) / L p a v g (L_{30}/L_{\rm p})^{\rm avg}=\langle L\rangle(30\,{\rm d})/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg} ( L 30 / L p ) avg = ⟨ L ⟩ ( 30 d ) / L p avg , are measured from ⟨ L ⟩ ( t ) \langle L\rangle(t) ⟨ L ⟩ ( t ) . Because the bins peak at different times, the mean of the ten per-bin peak luminosities exceeds L p a v g L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg} L p avg , by 0.9 per cent for the URILIGHT calculation of Figure 2 and by less than 0.7 per cent for every ejecta model of § 5 and 7. For the analytic solution, a second, smaller difference arises: L i s o L_{\rm iso} L iso is evaluated at the bin centres rather than averaged over each bin, so the equal-weight mean of the ten bins differs from the exact angle integral. For L p ( μ k ) / L p a v g = 1 + ∑ l β l P l ( μ k ) L_{\rm p}(\mu_{k})/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg}=1+\sum_{l}\beta_{l}P_{l}(\mu_{k}) L p ( μ k ) / L p avg = 1 + ∑ l β l P l ( μ k ) (notation of Figure 4 ) the dipole term cancels and, to leading order, the mean is lower by 0.005 b 2 0.005\,b_{2} 0.005 b 2 . This is at most 0.14 per cent for the ejecta models (b 2 ≤ 0.28 b_{2}\le0.28 b 2 ≤ 0.28 ) and about 0.25 per cent for the oblate test of Figure 3 . The viewing-angle variation of an observable Y Y Y is measured by the outer-bin extent, Δ Y = ∣ Y ( 0.9 ) − Y ( − 0.9 ) ∣ \Delta Y=|Y(0.9)-Y(-0.9)| Δ Y = ∣ Y ( 0.9 ) − Y ( − 0.9 ) ∣ for a displaced source and ∣ Y ( 0.9 ) − Y ( 0.1 ) ∣ |Y(0.9)-Y(0.1)| ∣ Y ( 0.9 ) − Y ( 0.1 ) ∣ for ejecta symmetric about the equatorial plane, normalized by Y a v g Y^{\rm avg} Y avg where stated. For Y = L p Y=L_{\rm p} Y = L p the two bins are therefore compared at their own peak times, Δ L p = ∣ L i s o ( t p ( 0.9 ) , 0.9 ) − L i s o ( t p ( − 0.9 ) , − 0.9 ) ∣ \Delta L_{\rm p}=|L_{\rm iso}(t_{\rm p}(0.9),0.9)-L_{\rm iso}(t_{\rm p}(-0.9),-0.9)| Δ L p = ∣ L iso ( t p ( 0.9 ) , 0.9 ) − L iso ( t p ( − 0.9 ) , − 0.9 ) ∣ , and not at a common time. The analytic light curves reproduce the MC results over the full range of viewing angles. Across the ten bins the largest L p L_{\rm p} L p exceeds the smallest by 56 per cent, and Δ L p / L p a v g = 45 \Delta L_{\rm p}/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg}=45 Δ L p / L p avg = 45 per cent; the peak luminosity is matched to better than 1.2 per cent (mean signed error − 0.1 -0.1 − 0.1 per cent) and the width ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p to better than 4.2 per cent (mean signed error + 1.1 +1.1 + 1.1 per cent) at every inclination. The largest early discrepancies arise from the MC initialization, its wavelength truncation, and the neglected light-travel time; dedicated tests that reduce the early residual to a few per cent are given in Appendix E.
Figure 3. Validation of the analytic oblate diffusion solution (red dashed) against URILIGHT (solid black) for idealized uniform-density oblate ejecta with the parameters of Section 3.2 and complete γ \gamma γ -ray deposition. L i s o L_{\mathrm{iso}} L iso is shown for the same five bins as in Figure 2 ; the configuration is symmetric about the equatorial plane, so the curves brighten with ∣ cos θ k ∣ |\cos\theta_k| ∣ cos θ k ∣ , from edge-on (cos θ k = − 0.1 \cos\theta_k=-0.1 cos θ k = − 0.1 , labelled below its peak) to pole-on (− 0.9 -0.9 − 0.9 , labelled above it).
Figure 4. Normalized peak luminosity L p ( θ k ) / L p a v g L_{\mathrm{p}}(\theta_k)/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}} L p ( θ k ) / L p avg against viewing angle in the analytic diffusion models (no URILIGHT calculations enter). Open markers are full finite-time analytic solutions; curves are the quasi-steady closed form. Left: off-centre spherical sources at several z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (Equation (17) ); at each of the markers vary the remaining parameters over 0.15 ≤ x s ≤ 0.90 0.15 \le x_s \le0.90 0.15 ≤ x s ≤ 0.90 , 16.4 ≤ t ˉ ≤ 36.6 16.4 \le\bar{t} \le36.6 16.4 ≤ t ˉ ≤ 36.6 d, 0.15 ≤ M 56 N i / M ⊙ ≤ 1.20 0.15 \le M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}/M_{\odot} \le1.20 0.15 ≤ M 56 Ni / M ⊙ ≤ 1.20 and 20 ≤ t 0 ≤ 45 20 \le t_0 \le45 20 ≤ t 0 ≤ 45 d (and t 0 = ∞ t_0 = \infty t 0 = ∞ ). Right: oblate spheroidal ejecta at a several X X X (Equation (20) ), with 0.77 ≤ ξ s ≤ 2.35 0.77 \le\xi_s \le2.35 0.77 ≤ ξ s ≤ 2.35 , 0.20 ≤ ξ 1 ≤ 2.10 0.20 \le\xi_1 \le2.10 0.20 ≤ ξ 1 ≤ 2.10 , 0.30 ≤ f ≤ 1.40 0.30 \le f \le1.40 0.30 ≤ f ≤ 1.40 , 11.6 ≤ t ˉ ≤ 40.1 11.6 \le\bar{t} \le40.1 11.6 ≤ t ˉ ≤ 40.1 d, 0.20 ≤ M 56 N i / M ⊙ ≤ 1.50 0.20 \le M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}/M_{\odot} \le1.50 0.20 ≤ M 56 Ni / M ⊙ ≤ 1.50 and 20 ≤ t 0 ≤ 60 20 \le t_0 \le60 20 ≤ t 0 ≤ 60 d (and t 0 = ∞ t_0 = \infty t 0 = ∞ ); only cos θ k ≥ 0 \cos\theta_k \ge0 cos θ k ≥ 0 is shown. Insets show the ratio of the measured Legendre coefficient b 1 b_1 b 1 of L p ( θ k ) / L p a v g = ∑ l b l P l ( cos θ k ) L_{\mathrm{p}}(\theta_k)/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}} = \sum_l b_l P_l(\cos\theta_k) L p ( θ k ) / L p avg = ∑ l b l P l ( cos θ k ) (Equation (107) ) to its closed form, b 1 / ( 3 w 1 z o f f ) b_1/(3w_1z_{\mathrm{off}}) b 1 / ( 3 w 1 z off ) against z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off and b 2 / ( w 2 X ) b_2/(w_2X) b 2 / ( w 2 X ) against X X X . The labelled f = 1.4 f = 1.4 f = 1.4 run at X = 0.09 X = 0.09 X = 0.09 (filled symbol, at a ratio of 0.03) is the exception discussed in the text. Models sharing z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (or X X X ) collapse onto nearly the same curve; the systematic offsets are the finite-time and shape corrections of Appendix B2. Shaded regions mark z o f f ≤ 0.1 z_{\mathrm{off}} \le0.1 z off ≤ 0.1 and X ≤ 0.80 X \le0.80 X ≤ 0.80 .
Oblate spheroidal ejecta
Figure 3 is the corresponding test of the oblate solution of Appendix A3. The idealized ejecta have uniform density and opacity, total mass M = 1.401 M ⊙ M=1.401\,M_\odot M = 1.401 M ⊙ , and an axis ratio tanh ξ s ≈ 0.73 \tanh\xi_s\approx0.73 tanh ξ s ≈ 0.73 (ξ s = 0.9245 \xi_s=0.9245 ξ s = 0.9245 , with v e q = 1.24 × 10 4 k m s − 1 v_{\mathrm{eq}}=1.24\times10^4\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} v eq = 1.24 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 and v p o l = 9.05 × 10 3 k m s − 1 v_{\mathrm{pol}}=9.05\times10^3\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} v pol = 9.05 × 1 0 3 km s − 1 ). The 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source is moderately off-con focal (ξ 1 = 0.7049 \xi_1=0.7049 ξ 1 = 0.7049 , f = 0.6966 f=0.6966 f = 0.6966 ) and carries M 56 N i = 0.2540 M ⊙ M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}=0.2540\,M_\odot M 56 Ni = 0.2540 M ⊙ , and the diffusion time-scale is t ^ = 30.426 d \hat{t}=30.426\ \mathrm{d} t ^ = 30.426 d (for κ = 0.2 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.2\ \mathrm{cm^2\ g^{-1}} κ = 0.2 c m 2 g − 1 ). As above, f d e p = 1 f_{\mathrm{dep}}=1 f dep = 1 is imposed in both calculations. Here, the source is centred on the equatorial plane and the configuration is symmetric about it, so the viewing-angle dependence is produced entirely by the aspherical boundaries, whereas in Figure 2 it is produced entirely by the displacement of the source within a spherical boundary. The two tests are therefore complementary.
The analytic solution reproduces the MC light curves to better than 3.8 per cent in L p L_p L p (mean signed error + 2.0 +2.0 + 2.0 per cent) and better than 1.5 per cent in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_p L 30 / L p (mean signed error + 0.4 +0.4 + 0.4 per cent) across the ten viewing angles, over which L p L_p L p varies by 74 per cent.
Over optically thick epochs, t ≈ 10 t\approx10 t ≈ 10 –40 d, the analytic solution reproduces the MC light curves to better than 5 (off-centre) and 12 (oblate) per cent at every viewing angle, over viewing-angle spreads in L p L_p L p of 56 and 74 per cent; at later times the residual is antisymmetric in viewing angle, because the MC contrast decays as the ejecta become optically thin while the analytic contrast approaches its quasi-steady pattern (Appendix E).
Viewing-Angle Dependence of the Peak Luminosity
The viewing-angle dependence can be separated into two steps: the angular structure of the diffusive surface flux, and the projection of that flux toward an observer through the Eddington surface-emission prescription of § 2.2 . Appendix B derives both steps and the quasi-steady limit used below; here we collect the resulting closed forms. Equivalently, the quasi-steady angular pattern can be obtained from a stationary diffusion problem in physical coordinates, with the ejecta frozen at a given epoch (Appendix B2).
For spherical ejecta, let F ( θ , t ) F(\theta,t) F ( θ , t ) denote the full surface flux after convolution with the heating history. Expanding F ( θ , t ) = ∑ l F l ( t ) P l ( cos θ ) F(\theta,t)=\sum_l F_l(t)P_l(\cos\theta) F ( θ , t ) = ∑ l F l ( t ) P l ( cos θ ) and defining a l ≡ F l / F 0 a_l\equiv F_l/F_0 a l ≡ F l / F 0 , the observer integral gives, exactly at every instant,
L i s o ( t , θ k ) = L ( t ) [ 1 + ∑ l ≥ 1 w l a l ( t ) P l ( cos θ k ) ] , (14) L_{\mathrm{iso}}(t,\theta_k)=L(t)\left[1+\sum_{l\geq1}w_l a_l(t)P_l(\cos\theta_k)\right], \tag*{(14)} L iso ( t , θ k ) = L ( t ) [ 1 + l ≥ 1 ∑ w l a l ( t ) P l ( cos θ k ) ] , (14)
where
w l = 3 2 ∫ 0 1 P l ( μ ) μ ( μ + 2 3 ) d μ , (15) w_l=\frac{3}{2}\int_0^1P_l(\mu)\,\mu\left(\mu+\frac{2}{3}\right)\,d\mu, \tag*{(15)} w l = 2 3 ∫ 0 1 P l ( μ ) μ ( μ + 3 2 ) d μ , (15)
so that w l = { 1 , 17 / 24 , 13 / 40 , 1 / 16 , − 1 / 48 , … } w_l=\{1,17/24,13/40,1/16,-1/48,\ldots\} w l = { 1 , 17/24 , 13/40 , 1/16 , − 1/48 , … } . These numbers contain only the observer-projection prescription; all information about the source and ejecta geometry is contained in the multipoles a l a_l a l . These projection identities are exact within the surface-emission prescription; the quasi-steady approximation enters below, when the finite-time multipoles a l ( t ) a_l(t) a l ( t ) are replaced by their zero-frequency values (Appendix B2).
For a uniform spherical source displaced by z o f f v 0 z_{\mathrm{off}}v_0 z off v 0 inside a spherical outer boundary, Appendix B2 shows that the quasi-steady flux multipoles are
a l q s = ( 2 l + 1 ) z o f f l . (16) a_l^{\mathrm{qs}}=(2l+1)z_{\mathrm{off}}^l. \tag*{(16)} a l qs = ( 2 l + 1 ) z off l . (16)
The leading anisotropy is therefore the dipole, a 1 q s = 3 z o f f a_1^{\mathrm{qs}}=3z_{\mathrm{off}} a 1 qs = 3 z off ; the quadrupole is a 2 q s = 5 z o f f 2 a_2^{\mathrm{qs}}=5z_{\mathrm{off}}^2 a 2 qs = 5 z off 2 and is second order in the displacement. Approximating the finite-time peak multipoles by their quasi-steady values, a l ( t p e a k ) ≃ a l q s a_l(t_{\mathrm{peak}})\simeq a_l^{\mathrm{qs}} a l ( t peak ) ≃ a l qs , as discussed in Appendix B2, gives
L p ( θ k ) L p a v g ≈ 1 + ∑ l ≥ 1 w l ( 2 l + 1 ) z o f f l P l ( cos θ k ) , (17) \frac{L_p(\theta_k)}{L_p^{\mathrm{avg}}}\approx1+\sum_{l\geq1}w_l(2l+1)z_{\mathrm{off}}^lP_l(\cos\theta_k), \tag*{(17)} L p avg L p ( θ k ) ≈ 1 + l ≥ 1 ∑ w l ( 2 l + 1 ) z off l P l ( cos θ k ) , (17)
or, retaining the first two terms,
L p ( θ k ) L p a v g ≈ 1 + 17 8 z o f f cos θ k + 13 8 z o f f 2 P 2 ( cos θ k ) . (18) \frac{L_p(\theta_k)}{L_p^{\mathrm{avg}}}\approx1+\frac{17}{8}z_{\mathrm{off}}\cos\theta_k+\frac{13}{8}z_{\mathrm{off}}^2P_2(\cos\theta_k). \tag*{(18)} L p avg L p ( θ k ) ≈ 1 + 8 17 z off cos θ k + 8 13 z off 2 P 2 ( cos θ k ) . (18)
To this order the viewing-angle dependence is controlled by z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off alone; in particular, the source radius x s x_s x s does not enter the quasi-steady multipoles. The quasi-steady replacement is the main approximation: measured against the finite-time dipole of the same analytic solutions, the coefficient 17 / 8 17/8 17/8 is low by 7–15 per cent (median 11 per cent; Appendix B2, where the deficit is defined as 1 − b 1 c l o s e d / b 1 1-b_{1}^{\mathrm{closed}}/b_{1} 1 − b 1 closed / b 1 , Equations (107) and (108) ), nearly independently of z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off and of the remaining parameters, so that the normalized anisotropy depends primarily on the displacement over the tested range rather than being strictly independent of the other parameters.
Equation (18) is the main result of this paper, and its most important feature is the steepness of the leading term: at the outermost bin centres, cos θ k = ± 0.9 \cos\theta_k=\pm0.9 cos θ k = ± 0.9 , the dipole term alone gives Δ L p / L p a v g = 2 × 0.9 × 17 8 ∣ z o f f ∣ ≃ 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ \Delta L_{\mathrm{p}}/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}}=2\times0.9\times\frac{17}{8}|z_{\mathrm{off}}|\simeq3.83|z_{\mathrm{off}}| Δ L p / L p avg = 2 × 0.9 × 8 17 ∣ z off ∣ ≃ 3.83∣ z off ∣ , so that a displacement of only z o f f = 0.1 z_{\mathrm{off}}=0.1 z off = 0.1 gives an outer-bin spread of 38 per cent in the peak luminosity (42.5 per cent, ( 17 / 4 ) z o f f (17/4)z_{\mathrm{off}} ( 17/4 ) z off , between cos θ k = ± 1 \cos\theta_k=\pm1 cos θ k = ± 1 ). This produces appreciable viewing-angle variation even for modest source offsets; assessing its consistency with the observed relation requires the residual comparison discussed in § 8 . How this effective displacement relates to the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution of actual ejecta, and to nebular line shifts, is discussed in Sections 5.2 and § 8 .
We now turn to oblate ejecta, treating both the boundary and the source as weakly deformed spheres; the exact two-spheroid solution of Appendix A3 is valid at any flattening, and Figure 4 quantifies the range over which the two agree. For a smooth convex boundary, the observer integral weights the surface flux by the area associated with each outward-normal direction, d A = d Ω n ^ / K \mathrm{d}A=\mathrm{d}\Omega_{\hat{\mathbf{n}}}/K d A = d Ω n ^ / K , where K K K is the Gaussian curvature of the boundary in velocity space (the physical curvature is K / t 2 K/t^2 K / t 2 ; the factor is common to all multipoles and cancels in their normalized ratios). Defining Φ ≡ F / K \Phi\equiv F/K Φ ≡ F / K as a function of the polar angle Θ \Theta Θ of the outward normal, Equation (14) carries over with a l a_l a l replaced by Φ l / Φ 0 \Phi_l/\Phi_0 Φ l / Φ 0 (Appendix B1). Equatorial symmetry removes the odd multipoles, so the leading anisotropy is the quadrupole. Writing the boundary and the source as v b ( θ ) = v o [ 1 + ε P 2 ( cos θ ) ] v_{\mathrm{b}}(\theta)=v_o[1+\varepsilon P_2(\cos\theta)] v b ( θ ) = v o [ 1 + ε P 2 ( cos θ )] and v s r c ( θ ) = x s v o [ 1 + ε s P 2 ( cos θ ) ] v_{\mathrm{src}}(\theta)=x_s v_o[1+\varepsilon_sP_2(\cos\theta)] v src ( θ ) = x s v o [ 1 + ε s P 2 ( cos θ )] with ∣ ε ∣ , ∣ ε s ∣ ≪ 1 |\varepsilon|,|\varepsilon_s|\ll1 ∣ ε ∣ , ∣ ε s ∣ ≪ 1 , Appendix B2 gives, to first order, three quadrupole contributions: the radioactive source, 3 ε s x s 2 3\varepsilon_sx_s^2 3 ε s x s 2 ; the deformed diffusion boundary, − 4 ε -4\varepsilon − 4 ε ; and the surface area per unit solid angle (the curvature), which contributes a second term equal to the boundary one. With ε = − 2 δ / 3 + O ( δ 2 ) \varepsilon=-2\delta/3+O(\delta^2) ε = − 2 δ /3 + O ( δ 2 ) and δ ≡ 1 − v p o l / v e q \delta\equiv1-v_{\mathrm{pol}}/v_{\mathrm{eq}} δ ≡ 1 − v pol / v eq ,
Φ 2 Φ 0 = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε − 4 ε ≈ 16 3 δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ≡ X , q ≡ v p o l v e q (19) \frac{\Phi_2}{\Phi_0}=3\varepsilon_sx_s^2-4\varepsilon-4\varepsilon
\approx\frac{16}{3}\delta-f^2(1-q^2)\equiv X,\qquad q\equiv\frac{v_{\mathrm{pol}}}{v_{\mathrm{eq}}} \tag*{(19)} Φ 0 Φ 2 = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε − 4 ε ≈ 3 16 δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ≡ X , q ≡ v eq v pol (19)
where the source term has been written in terms of the oblate-geometry parameters, 3 ε s x s 2 ≃ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) 3\varepsilon_sx_s^2\simeq-f^2(1-q^2) 3 ε s x s 2 ≃ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) . With w 2 = 13 / 40 w_2=13/40 w 2 = 13/40 , and replacing the finite-time peak quadrupole by its quasi-steady value as above,
L p ( θ k ) L p a v g ≈ 1 + 13 40 X P 2 ( cos θ k ) \frac{L_{\mathrm{p}}(\theta_k)}{L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}}}\approx1+\frac{13}{40}XP_2(\cos\theta_k) L p avg L p ( θ k ) ≈ 1 + 40 13 X P 2 ( cos θ k )
≈ 1 + [ 26 15 δ − 13 40 f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ] P 2 ( cos θ k ) (20) \approx1+\left[\frac{26}{15}\delta-\frac{13}{40}f^2(1-q^2)\right]P_2(\cos\theta_k) \tag*{(20)} ≈ 1 + [ 15 26 δ − 40 13 f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ] P 2 ( cos θ k ) (20)
For oblate ejecta (ε < 0 \varepsilon<0 ε < 0 ) the boundary and curvature terms brighten the poles, whereas an oblate radioactive source (ε s < 0 \varepsilon_s<0 ε s < 0 ) darkens them. The source enters only through f f f ; its size and its boundary coordinate ξ 1 \xi_1 ξ 1 do not appear, and for a confocal source (f = 1 f=1 f = 1 ), X ≃ 10 δ / 3 X\simeq10\delta/3 X ≃ 10 δ /3 . For the outer bins of this equatorially symmetric geometry, Equation (20) gives Δ L p / L p a v g = w 2 ∣ X ∣ [ ∣ P 2 ( 0.9 ) − P 2 ( 0.1 ) ∣ ] = ( 39 / 100 ) ∣ X ∣ \Delta L_{\mathrm{p}}/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}}=w_2|X|[|P_2(0.9)-P_2(0.1)|]=(39/100)|X| Δ L p / L p avg = w 2 ∣ X ∣ [ ∣ P 2 ( 0.9 ) − P 2 ( 0.1 ) ∣ ] = ( 39/100 ) ∣ X ∣ , and ( 39 / 80 ) ∣ X ∣ (39/80)|X| ( 39/80 ) ∣ X ∣ between pole and equator. Equation (20) combines the first-order shape expansion with the quasi-steady replacement. For the six collision toy models tested here (X ≤ 0.80 X\leq0.80 X ≤ 0.80 ), the closed form underestimates the peak spread of the full spheroidal solution by 3–11 per cent (§ 7 ), the combined finite-time and shape error of those configurations; it is not a uniform accuracy guarantee for every small-X X X source, as the example below shows.
Figure 4 compares the closed forms with the full analytic diffusion solutions: in the spherical case the two differ only through the quasi-steady replacement, whereas in the oblate case Equation (20) is additionally first order in the flattening, so we restrict the comparison to X < 1.5 X<1.5 X < 1.5 , which comfortably contains the six collision-model fits of Appendix D (all have X ≤ 0.80 X\leq0.80 X ≤ 0.80 ). This restriction is not by itself a sufficient accuracy criterion for arbitrary f f f : for one strongly non-confocal run (f = 1.4 f=1.4 f = 1.4 , ξ s = 1.73 \xi_s=1.73 ξ s = 1.73 , ξ 1 = 1.20 \xi_1=1.20 ξ 1 = 1.20 ) at small X = 0.09 X=0.09 X = 0.09 , the source and boundary terms of Equation (19) nearly cancel, and the measured quadrupole is only a few per cent of w 2 X w_2X w 2 X although the normalized luminosities differ from the closed curve by less than 3 per cent; a small luminosity residual can mask a large fractional anisotropy error (this run is marked in the inset of Figure 4 ). In both panels, models sharing the same z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (or the same X X X ) collapse onto nearly the same viewing-angle curve despite variations in the remaining toy-model parameters: the off-centre problem is predominantly dipolar and controlled by z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off , while the oblate problem is quadrupolar and controlled by X X X .
Two further finite-time approximations are measured in Appendix B2: the quasi-steady quadrupole of a slightly oblate boundary with f ≤ 1 f\leq1 f ≤ 1 is within 4.5 per cent of the finite-time one (median 1 per cent), and evaluating all viewing angles at the angle-averaged peak time introduces an error that is second order in the anisotropy but reaches 18 per cent for z o f f = 0.4 z_{\mathrm{off}}=0.4 z off = 0.4 (Table B1 ). We correct for none of these, so the closed forms contain no calibrated number.
Table B1. Error introduced by evaluating Equation (17) at the angle-averaged peak time rather than at each observer’s own maximum. Columns 2–3 give the deficit relative to the true maximum of the corresponding viewing-angle light curve, for the far side (θ k = π \theta_k = \pi θ k = π ) and near side (θ k = 0 \theta_k = 0 θ k = 0 ); columns 4–5 give each peak time relative to the angle-averaged peak time. The calculation uses M = 1 M ⊙ M = 1\,M_\odot M = 1 M ⊙ , v o = 10 4 k m s − 1 v_o = 10^4\ {\rm km\,s^{-1}} v o = 1 0 4 km s − 1 , κ = 0.1 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa= 0.1\ {\rm cm^2\,g^{-1}} κ = 0.1 c m 2 g − 1 , M 56 N i = 0.5 M ⊙ M_{56{\rm Ni}} = 0.5\,M_\odot M 56 Ni = 0.5 M ⊙ , x s = 0.3 x_s = 0.3 x s = 0.3 and t 0 = 35 d t_0 = 35\,{\rm d} t 0 = 35 d .
The Off-Centre Ignition Toy Model
We now test whether effective uniform-density ejecta can reproduce the angle-dependent light curves of stratified explosion models. For each off-centre ignition model (§ 5.1 ) we construct an effective model whose parameters are extracted from the ejecta (Section 5.2), compare the analytic light curves with URILIGHT across all viewing angles (§ 5.3 ), and characterize the systematic mismatch in the width ratio (§ 5.4 ).
The off-centre ignition models
We use the 19 bare-CO, off-centre ignition models of Schinasi-Lemberg & Kushnir (2025), introduced in § 1 . The progenitors are solar-metallicity CO WDs (uniform composition X ( 12 C ) = X ( 16 O ) = 0.4925 X({}^{12}\mathrm{C})=X({}^{16}\mathrm{O})=0.4925 X ( 12 C ) = X ( 16 O ) = 0.4925 , X ( 22 N e ) = 0.015 X({}^{22}\mathrm{Ne})=0.015 X ( 22 Ne ) = 0.015 ), spanning the mass range 0.8 0.8 0.8 –1.1 M ⊙ 1.1\,M_\odot 1.1 M ⊙ , and the explosions are computed with the FLASH code in two-dimensional axisymmetric geometry using a 38-isotope reaction network. These two-dimensional models are axisymmetric, so that observable properties depend only on the inclination angle θ k \theta_k θ k between the observer’s line of sight and the symmetry axis of the ejecta (θ k = 0 ∘ \theta_k=0^\circ θ k = 0 ∘ and 180 ∘ 180^\circ 18 0 ∘ correspond to viewing directions along the axis). The ignition location is parametrized by the dimensionless quantity z i g z_{\mathrm{ig}} z ig , defined as the displacement of the ignition point along the symmetry axis normalized by the WD radius. Across the model grid, we consider z i g = 0 z_{\mathrm{ig}}=0 z ig = 0 , 0.1 0.1 0.1 , 0.25 0.25 0.25 , 0.5 0.5 0.5 , and 0.75 0.75 0.75 , although not every WD mass is available at all five offsets; the final sample contains 19 ejecta models (Table C1 ). The case z i g = 0 z_{\mathrm{ig}}=0 z ig = 0 corresponds to central ignition. Off-centre ignition produces an asymmetric 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution, and the synthesized 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass ranges from M 56 N i ≈ 0.04 M ⊙ M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}\approx0.04\,M_\odot M 56 Ni ≈ 0.04 M ⊙ for the 0.8 M ⊙ 0.8\,M_\odot 0.8 M ⊙ models to ≈ 0.8 M ⊙ \approx0.8\,M_\odot ≈ 0.8 M ⊙ for the 1.1 M ⊙ 1.1\,M_\odot 1.1 M ⊙ models (Table C1 ).
Table C1. Toy-model representation of the sub-Chandrasekhar off-centre ignition models. M M M denotes the ejecta mass and z i g z_{\rm ig} z ig is the ignition location (see § 5.1 ). M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni is the total synthesized 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass. The parameter x s x_{\rm s} x s is the fractional radius of the nickel-rich region; z o f f z_{\rm off} z off is its fractional off-centre displacement along the symmetry axis, and z c o m , 56 N i z_{\rm com,^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} z com , 56 Ni is the fractional 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -mass-weighted mean axial velocity. The outer ejecta velocity v o v_{\rm o} v o is computed from M M M and the mean velocity-space density ρ ˉ v \bar{\rho}_{v} ρ ˉ v . The opacity κ \kappa κ is the effective Rosseland mean opacity at peak luminosity (Equation (25) ). The diffusion time-scale t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , defined through t ~ 2 ≡ v o 2 / D \tilde{t}^{2} \equiv v_{\rm o}^{2}/D t ~ 2 ≡ v o 2 / D with D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) D = c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}_{v}) D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) , is described in Section 5.2; t 0 t_{0} t 0 is the characteristic γ \gamma γ -ray escape time-scale. Bold columns are the inputs for the analytic diffusion framework (M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , x s x_{\rm s} x s , z o f f z_{\rm off} z off , t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , t 0 t_{0} t 0 ). The column z o f f v o z_{\rm off}v_{\rm o} z off v o gives the offset velocity of the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution of the toy model, and z c o m , 56 N i v o z_{\rm com,^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}v_{\rm o} z com , 56 Ni v o the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass-centroid velocity of the numerical ejecta (§ 8 discusses its relation to nebular-line velocity shifts).
Table C1.
Toy-model construction
The five toy-model parameters of § 2.3 are extracted from each ejecta as follows, starting with the ejecta mass and characteristic velocity.
The toy model is constructed to have the same total ejecta mass, M M M , and total 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass, M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , as the original ejecta. We first define an effective outer ejecta radius through the characteristic velocity
v o = ( 3 M 4 π ρ ˉ v ) 1 / 3 , (21) v_o = \left(\frac{3M}{4\pi\bar{\rho}_v}\right)^{1/3}, \tag*{(21)} v o = ( 4 π ρ ˉ v 3 M ) 1/3 , (21)
where
ρ ˉ v = ∑ i ρ v , i v i m i ∑ i m i (22) \bar{\rho}_v = \frac{\sum_i \rho_{v,i}v_i m_i}{\sum_i m_i} \tag*{(22)} ρ ˉ v = ∑ i m i ∑ i ρ v , i v i m i (22)
is the mass-weighted mean density in velocity space, each ρ v , i \rho_{v,i} ρ v , i being the velocity-space density t 3 ρ i p h y s t^3\rho_i^{\mathrm{phys}} t 3 ρ i phys of cell i i i of mass m i m_i m i . The corresponding uniform-density ejecta sphere is illustrated in the left panel of Figure 5 . Because v o v_o v o is set by the mean velocity-space density, the construction matches the ejecta mass but not its kinetic energy: the uniform sphere carries E k = 3 10 M v o 2 E_k = \frac{3}{10}Mv_o^2 E k = 10 3 M v o 2 , which for the 19 models of Table C1 falls short of the actual ejecta kinetic energy by 7–16 per cent (median 11 per cent).
Figure 5. Effective sphere geometry of the toy-model construction (Section 5.2) for a 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_{\odot} 1 M ⊙ , z i g = 0.5 z_{\mathrm{ig}} = 0.5 z ig = 0.5 off-centre ignition model (#13, Table C1), shown in velocity space, in the ( v r , v z ) (v_r,v_z) ( v r , v z ) plane. Both panels show the velocity-space density ρ t 3 \rho t^3 ρ t 3 in units of ρ 0 ( 10 4 k m s − 1 ) − 3 \rho_0 (10^4\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}})^{-3} ρ 0 ( 1 0 4 km s − 1 ) − 3 , with velocities in 10 4 k m s − 1 10^4\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} 1 0 4 km s − 1 , on a common colour scale, common axis ranges and common ticks, cropped at 2.0 × 10 4 k m s − 1 2.0 \times10^4\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} 2.0 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 . Left: total mass density in velocity space ρ t 3 \rho t^3 ρ t 3 , with the effective outer-velocity sphere of radius v 0 v_0 v 0 (red dashed). Right: the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass density X 56 N i ρ t 3 X_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}\rho t^3 X 56 Ni ρ t 3 , where X 56 N i X_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} X 56 Ni is the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass fraction, with the effective 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni sphere of radius x s v 0 x_s v_0 x s v 0 centred at an axial offset z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (red dashed). The thin white dashed lines show the other panel’s sphere, for comparison: the outer-velocity sphere (v 0 v_0 v 0 ) in the right panel, the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni sphere (x s v 0 , z o f f x_s v_0,z_{\mathrm{off}} x s v 0 , z off ) in the left panel. For this model, v 0 = 1.31 × 10 4 k m s − 1 v_0 = 1.31 \times10^4\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} v 0 = 1.31 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 , x s = 0.81 x_s = 0.81 x s = 0.81 , and z o f f = 0.09 z_{\mathrm{off}} = 0.09 z off = 0.09 (56 N i { }^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni centroid z c o m , 56 N i = 0.025 z_{\mathrm{com},{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} = 0.025 z com , 56 Ni = 0.025 ; Table C1).
We characterize the effective geometry of the radioactive material by fitting the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni density distribution in velocity space with a displaced hard-sphere model. The fit has three free parameters: the source displacement z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off , the dimensional source radius x s x_s x s , and the density normalization of the hard sphere A A A . The fit is performed on the two-dimensional axisymmetric ejecta that enter the URILIGHT calculations, on their uniform ( v r , v z ) (v_r,v_z) ( v r , v z ) mesh. We minimize the unweighted sum of squared residuals S S S
S = ∑ i [ A H i ( x s , z o f f ) − ρ v , i 56 N i , i max ρ v , 56 N i ] 2 , (23) S = \sum_i \left[A H_i(x_s,z_{\mathrm{off}}) - \frac{\rho_{v,i}^{56\mathrm{Ni},i}}{\max\rho_{v,^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}\right]^2, \tag*{(23)} S = i ∑ [ A H i ( x s , z off ) − max ρ v , 56 Ni ρ v , i 56 Ni , i ] 2 , (23)
where the sum runs over all cells i i i , ρ v , i 56 N i \rho_{v,i}^{56\mathrm{Ni}} ρ v , i 56 Ni is the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni density in velocity space, H i = 1 H_i = 1 H i = 1 if the cell centre lies within the displaced sphere and 0 otherwise, and A A A is the normalization. Every cell carries the same weight, so the residuals are weighted by area in the ( v r , v z ) (v_r,v_z) ( v r , v z ) plane, not by volume or mass. The minimum is found by differential evolution. The displacement z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off is defined as the offset of the equivalent 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni sphere’s centre along the symmetry axis, normalized by the characteristic velocity v o v_o v o . This construction is illustrated in the right panel of Figure 5 .
The fitted values of x s x_s x s and the density normalization do not, in general, reproduce the correct 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass, because the fit is based solely on the spatial distribution of the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni density and does not enforce mass conservation. We therefore retain only the fitted value of z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off , taken from the three-parameter fit without refitting after x s x_s x s is fixed. The source radius is instead fixed by requiring the toy model to contain the correct 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass,
x s = ( M 56 N i M ) 1 / 3 , (24) x_s = \left(\frac{M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}{M}\right)^{1/3}, \tag*{(24)} x s = ( M M 56 Ni ) 1/3 , (24)
which follows from mass conservation if the source is a pure 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni region at the uniform ejecta density (unit 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass fraction inside the source). The fitted displacements are small, z o f f ≤ 0.12 z_{\mathrm{off}} \le0.12 z off ≤ 0.12 , across the entire grid (Table C1 , which also lists the corresponding velocities). We note that the displaced source is fully contained within the analytic ejecta only when x s + ∣ z o f f ∣ ≤ 1 x_s + |z_{\mathrm{off}}| \le1 x s + ∣ z off ∣ ≤ 1 .
We compare the fitted displacement with the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni centre of mass computed directly from each ejecta model, z c o m , 56 N i = ⟨ v z ⟩ 56 N i / v o z_{\mathrm{com},^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} = \langle v_z\rangle_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}/v_o z com , 56 Ni = ⟨ v z ⟩ 56 Ni / v o , where ⟨ v z ⟩ 56 N i \langle v_z\rangle_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} ⟨ v z ⟩ 56 Ni is the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass-weighted mean axial velocity (Table C1 ). Both are close to zero for the four centrally ignited models. For the 14 models with z o f f > 0.01 z_{\mathrm{off}} > 0.01 z off > 0.01 , the fitted displacement exceeds the centroid in all but one case, with a median ratio z o f f / z c o m , 56 N i = 2.8 z_{\mathrm{off}}/z_{\mathrm{com},^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} = 2.8 z off / z com , 56 Ni = 2.8 (range 0.85–8.2), and the two scale differently. with the ignition offset: z c o m , 56 N i z_{\mathrm{com},{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} z com , 56 Ni stays within 0.013–0.025 for all models with z i g ≥ 0.25 z_{\mathrm{ig}} \ge0.25 z ig ≥ 0.25 , whereas z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off increases to 0.12. The difference arises because the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni density is not uniform within the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -rich region: its high-density part is displaced toward + z +z + z , while lower-density 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni extends to higher velocities at z < 0 z < 0 z < 0 , and the hard-sphere fit follows the high-density part whereas the centroid weights all of the mass (Appendix C quantifies this). Thus, z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off is an effective parameter that partially accounts for the density stratification of the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution, which the uniform-density toy model does not include; there is no universal conversion between the two.
Nebular line shifts trace the emissivity-weighted velocities of the emitting ions, which for some lines are the stable iron-group material rather than the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni (e.g. Maeda et al. (2010b)). They therefore test the ejecta models rather than the fitted z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (e.g. (Motohara et al. 2006; Maeda et al. 2010a; Silverman et al. 2013; Dong et al. 2015; Black et al. 2016; Graham et al. 2017; Diamond et al. 2018; Maguire et al. 2018; Vallely et al. 2020; Kumar et al. 2023; Kwok et al. 2023; DerKacy et al. 2023)).
The diffusion time-scale, t ~ 2 ≡ v 2 2 / D \tilde{t}_2 \equiv v_2^2/D t ~ 2 ≡ v 2 2 / D , is computed using the diffusion coefficient D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ˉ ) D = c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}\bar{v}) D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ˉ ) , where κ \kappa κ is the mass-weighted Rosseland mean opacity of the ejecta at τ > 2 \tau> 2 τ > 2 , evaluated at the peak of the angle-averaged URILIGHT light curve, following Sharon et al. (2025):
κ = ∑ τ i > 2 m i κ R , i ( t p a v g ) ∑ τ i > 2 m i , (25) \kappa= \frac{\sum_{\tau_i>2} m_i \kappa_{\mathrm{R},i}(t_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}})}{\sum_{\tau_i>2} m_i}, \tag*{(25)} κ = ∑ τ i > 2 m i ∑ τ i > 2 m i κ R , i ( t p avg ) , (25)
where m i m_i m i and κ R , i \kappa_{\mathrm{R},i} κ R , i are the mass and Rosseland mean opacity of cell i i i and τ i \tau_i τ i its optical depth from the outer edge. The optical depth is computed from a spherically averaged density and opacity profile by integrating inward from the outer boundary.
The characteristic γ \gamma γ -ray escape time t 0 t_0 t 0 , as defined by Equation (7) , is computed following Wygoda et al. (2019a), using the average column density of the ejecta as seen by the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni elements and an effective γ \gamma γ -ray opacity of κ e f f = 0.025 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa_{\mathrm{eff}} = 0.025\ \mathrm{cm^2\ g^{-1}} κ eff = 0.025 c m 2 g − 1 .
We emphasize that none of these parameters is calibrated to reproduce the URILIGHT light curves: four of the five are determined directly from the initial ejecta model, while t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ requires the RT calculation. This is because the effective opacity κ \kappa κ (and hence D D D ) is evaluated from the ejecta state at peak luminosity and therefore requires the URILIGHT calculation to have been completed. It is thus measured a posteriori from the simulation rather than fitted to the light curves. In practice, however, the measured values span the narrow range κ ≈ 0.10 \kappa\approx0.10 κ ≈ 0.10 –0.18 c m 2 g − 1 0.18\ \mathrm{cm^2\ g^{-1}} 0.18 c m 2 g − 1 across the grid (Table C1). Section 6 shows explicitly (by varying f ~ \tilde{f} f ~ , which is equivalent to varying κ \kappa κ ) that the modeled viewing-angle variability, the main quantity of interest here, is insensitive to this choice, although the absolute L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p are not. The full parameter table for all models is given in Table C1.
Comparison with URILIGHT on the numerical ejecta
Whereas Section 3 tests the diffusion solution in isolation, the comparison here tests the full toy-model construction of Section 5.2. We extract the five effective toy-model parameters from an actual sub-Chandrasekhar ejecta, the #13 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_{\odot} 1 M ⊙ , z i g = 0.5 z_{\mathrm{ig}} = 0.5 z ig = 0.5 model of Table C1, and compare the resulting analytic light curves directly with URILIGHT at each viewing angle. Figure 6 shows this comparison for five of the ten bins, with two analytic variants that differ only in the γ \gamma γ -ray deposition, Equation (7) with the single escape time t 0 t_0 t 0 or the f d e p ( t ) f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t) f dep ( t ) tabulated by the URILIGHT γ \gamma γ -ray transport of the same ejecta, which separates the error of the deposition prescription from that of the diffusion model; unless stated otherwise, the comparisons below refer to the former.
Figure 6. Bolometric light curves of the effective spherical off-centre toy model (red) compared with URILIGHT (solid black) for the 1 M ⊙ M_\odot M ⊙ , z i g = 0.5 z_{\rm ig}=0.5 z ig = 0.5 off-centre ignition model (#13; parameters in Table C1 ). L i s o L_{\rm iso} L iso is shown for the same five bins as in Figure 2 , with cos θ k = + 1 \cos\theta_k=+1 cos θ k = + 1 facing the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni offset; the curves brighten monotonically from − 0.9 -0.9 − 0.9 (labelled below its peak) to + 0.7 +0.7 + 0.7 (labelled above it). The two analytic curves differ only in the γ \gamma γ -ray deposition: the dashed curve uses Equation (7) with the tabulated t 0 t_0 t 0 , while the dotted curve uses the f d e p ( t ) f_{\rm dep}(t) f dep ( t ) from the URILIGHT γ \gamma γ -ray transport of the same ejecta, so their difference isolates the error of Equation (7) . The discrepant pair at the bottom is the bin facing away from the offset (cos θ k = − 0.9 \cos\theta_k=-0.9 cos θ k = − 0.9 ).
For this model, L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is reproduced to better than ≈ 5 \approx5 ≈ 5 per cent at nine of the ten inclinations (13 per cent at cos θ k = − 0.9 \theta_k = -0.9 θ k = − 0.9 , facing away from the offset), whereas L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p is overestimated at nine of the ten inclinations, by up to 10 per cent toward the offset; this overestimate is not specific to this model (Section 5.4).
At early times (t ≲ 7 d t \lesssim7\,\mathrm{d} t ≲ 7 d ) the analytic luminosity exceeds the MC one by tens of per cent, mainly because the uniform sphere misrepresents the outer ejecta, and at late times (t ≳ 30 d t \gtrsim30\,\mathrm{d} t ≳ 30 d ) the angle-averaged luminosity is reproduced to within 11 per cent while the analytic viewing-angle contrast stays near its quasi-steady value as the MC contrast decays; both residuals are quantified in Appendix C.
Figure 7 extends this comparison to the five 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_{\odot} 1 M ⊙ models, ordered by z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off ; across their 50 model-angle combinations, the analytic-deposition toy model reproduces L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p with a median relative error of ∼ 3 \sim3 ∼ 3 per cent and a maximum error of ∼ 13 \sim13 ∼ 13 per cent, while the corresponding errors in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p have a median of ∼ 4 \sim4 ∼ 4 per cent and a maximum of ∼ 12 \sim12 ∼ 12 per cent. The latter error is predominantly systematic rather than scatter about the RT result: the toy model overpredicts L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p in 43 of the 50 combinations. The bias is also strongly ordered with viewing angle, running from ≈ − 5 \approx-5 ≈ − 5 per cent at cos θ k = − 0.9 \cos\theta_k = -0.9 cos θ k = − 0.9 to ≈ + 9 \approx+9 ≈ + 9 per cent at + 0.9 +0.9 + 0.9 for the most displaced model, with a maximum of ≈ 10 \approx10 ≈ 10 per cent at cos θ k ≃ 0.1 \cos\theta_k \simeq0.1 cos θ k ≃ 0.1 –0.5.
Figure 7. Peak luminosity (top) and width ratio (bottom) against viewing angle for the five 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_\odot 1 M ⊙ off-centre ignition models (#10–#14, Table C1 ), one column per model in order of increasing z o f f z_{\rm off} z off ; the column titles give z o f f z_{\rm off} z off , the offset velocity z o f f v o z_{\rm off}v_o z off v o and the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni centroid velocity z c o m , 56 N i v o z_{\rm com,56Ni}v_o z com , 56Ni v o of the numerical ejecta (with a common v o = 1.31 × 10 4 k m s − 1 v_o=1.31\times10^4\ {\rm km\,s^{-1}} v o = 1.31 × 1 0 4 km s − 1 ). Solid black lines with circles: URILIGHT; red dashed and dotted: the analytic toy model with Equation (7) and with the tabulated f d e p ( t ) f_{\rm dep}(t) f dep ( t ) , respectively. All ten bins are shown, with cos θ k = + 1 \cos\theta_k=+1 cos θ k = + 1 facing the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni offset; rows share their vertical axis.
The mean level and angular variation of L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p are therefore reproduced with very different accuracy. The value obtained from the angle-averaged light curve is recovered to within 1.0–7.5 per cent, whereas the outer-bin spread Δ ( L 30 / L p ) \Delta(L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}) Δ ( L 30 / L p ) reaches only 27–43 per cent of the URILIGHT value for the four models with z o f f ≥ 0.02 z_{\mathrm{off}} \ge0.02 z off ≥ 0.02 . Replacing the analytic deposition prescription by the tabulated f d e p ( t ) f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t) f dep ( t ) generally improves the agreement, particularly in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p , but leaves the viewing-angle dependence of both quantities essentially unchanged.
The deposition prescription therefore contributes to the offset in the overall width ratio but does not explain the underprediction of the angular variation. We separate these two components of the discrepancy in § 5.4 .
In the L p L_{\rm p} L p –L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p plane (Figure 1 a), the off-centre ignition models remain at L 30 / L p ≤ 0.50 L_{30}/L_{\rm p}\leq0.50 L 30 / L p ≤ 0.50 at every viewing angle, in the regime of the faster-declining observed events, and their tracks run across the observed sequence rather than along it, as found by Sharon et al. (2025): toward the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -facing pole L p L_{\rm p} L p increases while L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p decreases. In URILIGHT the outer-bin extent of the tracks reaches 0.88 × 10 43 e r g s − 1 0.88\times10^{43}\ \mathrm{erg\ s^{-1}} 0.88 × 1 0 43 erg s − 1 in L p L_{\rm p} L p and 0.10 0.10 0.10 in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p (model #19; 26 per cent when normalized), and most model–angle combinations of the 1.1 M ⊙ 1.1\,M_\odot 1.1 M ⊙ models are brighter than the brightest observed event. The analytic toy model (Figure 1 b) reproduces the direction of the tracks and their extent in L p L_{\rm p} L p : for the 0.9 0.9 0.9 –1.1 M ⊙ 1.1\,M_\odot 1.1 M ⊙ models with z i g > 0 z_{\rm ig}>0 z ig > 0 (excluding model #9, Section 6), the ratio of the analytic to the URILIGHT outer-bin extent in L p L_{\rm p} L p , Δ L p a n a / Δ L p M C \Delta L_{\rm p}^{\rm ana}/\Delta L_{\rm p}^{\rm MC} Δ L p ana /Δ L p MC , which is the quantity visible in Figure 1 , is 0.70 0.70 0.70 –1.07 1.07 1.07 for ten of these 11 models and 0.53 0.53 0.53 for model #7, with a median of 0.79 0.79 0.79 over the 11 models. Its tracks are, however, flatter in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p , by the factor ∼ 2 \sim2 ∼ 2 –3 3 3 discussed in § 5.4 and 6.
The width-ratio mismatch
The width-ratio error has two components: a bias in its value and an underestimate of its viewing-angle variation. Figure 8 and Table 1 compare successive approximations for model #13: (0) URILIGHT with its full opacity and γ \gamma γ -ray transport; (i) URILIGHT on the same two-dimensional ejecta with the toy model’s grey opacity, κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.165\ \mathrm{cm^2\ g^{-1}} κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 , held fixed in space and time; (ii) the analytic toy model of Section 5.2 with the deposition fraction tabulated by the URILIGHT γ \gamma γ -ray transport; and (iii) the same with Equation (7) and t 0 = 31.1 t_0=31.1 t 0 = 31.1 d. Steps (0)–(i) use the original ejecta and (ii)–(iii) the effective spherical ejecta, so step (ii) changes both the geometry and the transport treatment. A separate matched test (iv) runs URILIGHT on the effective toy ejecta itself, with the same grey opacity and complete γ \gamma γ -ray deposition, and compares it with the analytic solution for identical ejecta, as in § 3.1 .
Table 1. Outer-bin spreads (Section 3.1) of L p L_{\rm p} L p and W ≡ L 30 / L p W\equiv L_{30}/L_{\rm p} W ≡ L 30 / L p for model #13 along the ladder of calculations of § 5.4 . Successive approximations for model #13: (0)–(i) use the original ejecta and (ii)–(iii) the effective spherical ejecta; the matched test (iv) compares URILIGHT (MC) and the analytic solution on the effective ejecta with complete deposition.
Figure 8. Viewing-angle sequences of model #13 in the L p L_{\rm p} L p –L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p plane for the ladder of calculations of Table 1 , each running from cos θ k = − 0.9 \cos\theta_k=-0.9 cos θ k = − 0.9 , facing away from the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni offset (open marker), to + 0.9 +0.9 + 0.9 , facing it (star). (a) Successive approximations, (0)–(i) on the original ejecta and (ii)–(iii) on the effective spherical ejecta: circles, URILIGHT with its full opacity and γ \gamma γ -ray transport; diamonds, URILIGHT with the constant κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.165\ {\rm cm^2\,g^{-1}} κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 ; pentagons (dotted), the analytic toy model with the tabulated f d e p f_{\rm dep} f dep ; triangles (dashed), the same with Equation (7) . (b) The matched test (iv) on the effective toy ejecta with complete deposition: squares, URILIGHT; crosses (dot-dashed), the analytic solution. Solid lines with filled markers are URILIGHT, broken lines with open markers analytic; the panels share the L p L_{\rm p} L p axis and cover equal ranges in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p .
Relative to the full calculation (0), the constant opacity of step (i) shifts L p L_{\rm p} L p by up to 10 and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p by up to 7 per cent (medians − 2 -2 − 2 and + 3 +3 + 3 per cent), with opposite signs at the two ends of the viewing-angle sequence, and reduces both spreads (Table 1 ). The contraction is expected: the effective opacity is measured at peak light, whereas by t = 30 t=30 t = 30 d the true effective opacity has dropped by a factor of 2–4, and holding it fixed suppresses the angle-dependent timing of the transition to transparency. Step (ii) replaces this MC calculation by the analytic toy model with the same opacity and the URILIGHT deposition history, and therefore changes the geometry and the transport treatment together. Relative to (i), it reproduces L p L_{\rm p} L p to within 3 per cent and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p to within 6.5 per cent at every viewing angle and recovers the spread in L p L_{\rm p} L p , but halves the spread in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p . Step (iii) replaces the tabulated deposition by Equation (7) ; it raises both L p L_{\rm p} L p and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p by ≈ 2 \approx2 ≈ 2 per cent at every viewing angle and leaves both spreads nearly unchanged. Since t 0 ≈ 30 t_0\approx30 t 0 ≈ 30 –36 d for all 19 models (Table C1 ), L 30 L_{30} L 30 is evaluated close to t 0 t_0 t 0 , where Equation (7) is least accurate. At the end of that sequence, the width ratio of (iii) exceeds that of (0) by up to 10.3 per cent (median 9 per cent over the ten bins). Because step (ii) changes geometry and transport at once, these comparisons do not isolate a separate geometry contribution. The matched toy-ejecta test (iv) shows that the diffusion approximation can account for much of the additional loss of width-ratio contrast in steps (ii) + (iii): for identical ejecta the analytic solution reproduces L p L_{\rm p} L p to within 1 per cent and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p to within 3.5 per cent at every viewing angle and recovers the spread in L p L_{\rm p} L p , yet retains only about half of the URILIGHT spread in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p (6.5 against 12.3 per cent). As the ejecta become transparent, the MC transport loses luminosity anisotropy at 30 d more rapidly than the diffusive surface model, whose Dirichlet boundary and grey-atmosphere closure hold the contrast nearly fixed (§ 3 ). Because test (iv) uses complete deposition, and hence a different heating history from the left-panel sequence, it establishes the mechanism without uniquely separating the geometric reduction from the transport treatment in the original problem; a definitive partition would require the intermediate MC calculation on the effective geometry with matched heating, including its spatial distribution. The decomposition has been carried out for this model only, since each ladder requires dedicated URILIGHT runs; it is consistent with the factor ∼ 2 \sim2 ∼ 2 –3 3 3 by which the analytic spread in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p falls below the URILIGHT one across the grid (Figure 10 ).
Figure 10. Normalized outer-bin spreads of the peak luminosity (top) and the width ratio (bottom) against the fitted source displacement for all 19 off-centre ignition models. Marker shape identifies the ejecta mass (circles, squares, triangles and diamonds for 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 and 1.1 M ⊙ M_\odot M ⊙ ); filled markers and solid curves are URILIGHT, open markers and dashed curves the analytic models. The red line is the leading quasi-steady prediction 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ 3.83\left|z_{\rm off}\right| 3.83 ∣ z off ∣ (Section 4). The analytic peak spread follows this relation with a finite-time correction, while the MC results include the non-monotonic cases discussed in Section 6; the analytic width-ratio spread is generally smaller than the MC value.
Isolating Geometric Effects
The question of this section is whether the remaining toy-model parameters change the normalized peak spread at fixed z o f f z_{\rm off} z off . Section 4 predicts that they do not to leading order: x s x_s x s , t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , t 0 t_0 t 0 and M 56 N i M_{56\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni are absent from the quasi-steady closed form. In the numerical application, these parameters are uncertain to different degrees; most importantly, t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ is not known a priori because it depends on the effective opacity. We therefore treat x s x_s x s , t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ and t 0 t_0 t 0 as nuisance parameters and vary them independently over broad ranges about the values extracted from the 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_\odot 1 M ⊙ models, and measure the outer-bin spreads Δ L p / L p a v g \Delta L_{\rm p}/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg} Δ L p / L p avg and Δ ( L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) a v g \Delta(L_{30}/L_{\rm p})/(L_{30}/L_{\rm p})^{\rm avg} Δ ( L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) avg defined in § 3.1 .
Figure 9 varies t 0 t_0 t 0 , t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ and x s x_s x s at fixed z o f f z_{\rm off} z off . The analytic curves nearly collapse and remain approximately parallel to the leading prediction Δ L p / L p a v g = 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ \Delta L_{\rm p}/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg}=3.83\,|z_{\rm off}| Δ L p / L p avg = 3.83 ∣ z off ∣ , so substantial changes in the deposition time-scale, the diffusion time-scale or the source size produce only modest corrections to the normalized peak spread; within the analytic model the normalized width-ratio spread is likewise far more sensitive to z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off than to these parameters. The fifth parameter, M 56 N i M_{56\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , need not be varied: at fixed geometry and deposition history it multiplies the light curve and cancels from the normalized anisotropy, although a physical change in M 56 N i M_{56\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni can also modify x s x_{\mathrm{s}} x s , t 0 t_0 t 0 and the effective opacity. These results confirm, in the full finite-time solution and against the RT calculations, that the normalized peak spread depends primarily on z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off over the tested ranges of the remaining parameters.
Figure 9. Outer-bin spreads Δ L p / ⟨ L p ⟩ a v g \Delta L_{\mathrm{p}}/\langle L_{\mathrm{p}}\rangle^{\mathrm{avg}} Δ L p / ⟨ L p ⟩ avg (top) and ( Δ L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) a v g (\Delta L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}})/(L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}})^{\mathrm{avg}} ( Δ L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) avg (bottom; § 3.1 ) against z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off for the 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_{\odot} 1 M ⊙ models. Each column varies one analytic parameter over the indicated values of the models: t 0 ∈ { 20 , 40 , ∞ } t_0 \in\{20,40,\infty\} t 0 ∈ { 20 , 40 , ∞ } (left; t 0 → ∞ t_0 \to\infty t 0 → ∞ is complete deposition), t ~ ∈ { 25 , 45 } \tilde{t} \in\{25,45\} t ~ ∈ { 25 , 45 } (middle) and x s ∈ { 0.60 , 0.70 , 0.90 } x_{\mathrm{s}} \in\{0.60,0.70,0.90\} x s ∈ { 0.60 , 0.70 , 0.90 } (right). Thin black curves (line styles in the top-row legend) are the parameter variations, the curve with open squares is the analytic solution with the parameters of the models, and the curve with filled circles is the URILIGHT result. The red line in the top row is the closed form Δ L p / ⟨ L p ⟩ a v g = 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ \Delta L_{\mathrm{p}}/\langle L_{\mathrm{p}}\rangle^{\mathrm{avg}} = 3.83\,|z_{\mathrm{off}}| Δ L p / ⟨ L p ⟩ avg = 3.83 ∣ z off ∣ of Section 4, not a fit; this lies ≈ 11 \approx11 ≈ 11 per cent below the analytic curves, the quasi-steady dipole deficit of Appendix B2, and the URILIGHT points lie further above it (§ 5.4 ). No closed form exists for L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p .
Figure 10 extends Figure 9 across ejecta mass: instead of varying one analytic parameter at a time for the 1 M ⊙ 1\,M_\odot 1 M ⊙ models, it shows the same outer-bin spreads against z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off for all 19 off-centre ignition models (0.8 0.8 0.8 –1.1 M ⊙ 1.1\,M_\odot 1.1 M ⊙ ), each with its own toy-model parameters (Table C1 ). The red line in the top panel is the same closed form, Δ L p / L p a v g = 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ \Delta L_{\mathrm{p}}/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}} = 3.83\,|z_{\mathrm{off}}| Δ L p / L p avg = 3.83 ∣ z off ∣ , which has no free parameter and no dependence on ejecta mass. Three models are clear exceptions in Figure 10 : models #4, #9 and #14, for which the URILIGHT L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is non-monotonic with viewing angle2 . In the 0.9 M ⊙ 0.9\,M_\odot 0.9 M ⊙ , z i g = 0.75 z_{\mathrm{ig}}=0.75 z ig = 0.75 model (#9), L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p peaks near cos θ k ≃ 0.5 \cos\theta_k \simeq0.5 cos θ k ≃ 0.5 and decreases toward the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -facing pole, so that its outer-bin spread (14.6 per cent) understates its full maximum-to-minimum variation (28 per cent) and falls well below the closed form; the decline from the maximum to the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -facing pole is ≃ 12 \simeq12 ≃ 12 per cent in model #9 and ≃ 4 \simeq4 ≃ 4 per cent in models #4 and #14. Repeating the URILIGHT calculations for these models with the grey opacity of the corresponding toy model, held fixed in space and time, removes the non-monotonicity of models #9 and #14, reduces it to 1 per cent in model #4, and improves the agreement with the overall trend, but does not eliminate the discrepancy with the closed form. The 0.8 M ⊙ 0.8\,M_\odot 0.8 M ⊙ models also depart from the closed form; since M 56 N i M_{56\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni cancels from the normalized anisotropy, their low 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass is not by itself the reason, and we have not isolated it.
Head-on White Dwarf Collisions
We now apply the oblate framework to the head-on WD collision models of Kushnir et al. (2013), whose ejecta are intrinsically oblate, in contrast to the approximately spherical ejecta of the off-centre ignition models. We consider six equal-mass collisions, from 0.6 + 0.6 0.6+0.6 0.6 + 0.6 to 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ 1.0+1.0\,M_\odot 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ , for which we compare angle-resolved URILIGHT light curves with the analytic solution. The two lighter equal-mass collisions, 0.5 + 0.5 0.5+0.5 0.5 + 0.5 and 0.55 + 0.55 M ⊙ 0.55+0.55\,M_\odot 0.55 + 0.55 M ⊙ , are excluded: both their total density and their 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution are prolate, whereas the analytic solution of Appendix A3 applies to oblate spheroids only (Appendix D2). For each of the six equal-mass collision models, we construct an effective oblate toy model in close analogy to Section 5.2, the construction, the resulting parameters, and the light-curve comparisons are given in Appendix D (Table D1 ). Across the ten viewing angles, the per-collision median absolute relative error in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is 0.8–5.5 per cent. The effective oblate construction also captures the magnitude of the peak-luminosity spread, despite the departures of the actual 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution from an oblate spheroid (Appendix D1). The width ratio has a systematic offset, but its variation with viewing angle is generally small, as discussed below.
Table D1. Toy-model representation of the equal-mass head-on WD collision models of Kushnir et al. (2013), constructed as described in Appendix D1. M M M is the total ejecta mass and M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni the synthesized 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass. The ejecta boundary coordinate ξ s \xi_{\rm s} ξ s fixes the axis ratio such that ξ s = v p o l / v e q \xi_{\rm s}=v_{\rm pol}/v_{\rm eq} ξ s = v pol / v eq , with v e q = a cosh ξ s v_{\rm eq}=a\cosh\xi_{\rm s} v eq = a cosh ξ s and v p o l = a sinh ξ s v_{\rm pol}=a\sinh\xi_{\rm s} v pol = a sinh ξ s and a a a the focal length; ξ 1 \xi_{1} ξ 1 is the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source coordinate and f f f the ratio of the source focal length to a a a . The mean velocity-space density is ρ ˉ v = M / ( 4 π v e q 3 / 3 ) \bar{\rho}_{v}=M/(4\pi v_{\rm eq}^{3}/3) ρ ˉ v = M / ( 4 π v eq 3 /3 ) and κ \kappa κ is the effective Rosseland mean opacity at peak luminosity (Equation (25) ). The diffusion time-scale is t ~ 2 = a 2 / D \tilde{t}^{2}=a^{2}/D t ~ 2 = a 2 / D with D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) D=c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}_{v}) D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) , and t 0 t_{0} t 0 is the γ \gamma γ -ray escape time. The last column is the combination X = ( 16 / 3 ) δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) X=(16/3)\delta-f^{2}(1-q^{2}) X = ( 16/3 ) δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) with δ = 1 − q 2 \delta=1-q^{2} δ = 1 − q 2 and q = tanh ξ s q=\tanh\xi_{\rm s} q = tanh ξ s , which is the only shape parameter entering the closed form of Section 4; it is determined by ξ s \xi_{\rm s} ξ s and f f f and is not an independent input. The running number # continues that of Table C1 . Bold columns are the inputs to the analytic diffusion solution (M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , ξ s \xi_{\rm s} ξ s , ξ 1 \xi_{1} ξ 1 , f f f , t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , t 0 t_{0} t 0 ). M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni and t 0 t_{0} t 0 are measured directly from the two-dimensional ejecta that enter the RT calculations. Table D2 of Sharon et al. (2025) lists the numerical values; the values here exceed those chosen by 3.4–8.5 per cent in M 56 N i M_{^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni and by 0.4–4.5 per cent in t 0 t_{0} t 0 , because that table is built from the spherically averaged (one-dimensional) versions of the same ejecta, which do not preserve the 56 N i ^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni content exactly.
Table D1.
Figure 11 shows the outer-bin spreads of all six collisions against the shape parameter X X X of Section 4 (Table D1 ), which plays the role of z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off for the off-centre models (Figure 10 ).
Figure 11. Normalized viewing-angle variability of the six equal-mass collisions (Table D1) against the single oblate shape parameter X = ( 16 / 3 ) δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) X=(16/3)\delta-f^2(1-q^2) X = ( 16/3 ) δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) of Equation (19) . Top: the peak-luminosity spread Δ L p / L p a v g \Delta L_{\rm p}/L_{\rm p}^{\rm avg} Δ L p / L p avg . Bottom: the width-ratio spread Δ ( L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) a v g \Delta(L_{30}/L_{\rm p})/(L_{30}/L_{\rm p})^{\rm avg} Δ ( L 30 / L p ) / ( L 30 / L p ) avg . Filled markers joined by solid lines are URILIGHT MC calculations; the same markers left open and joined by dashed lines are the analytic toy model; and each marker shape is one collision. Each is the outer-bin spread for equal-mass symmetric ejecta, pole-on (cos θ k = 0.9 \cos\theta_k=0.9 cos θ k = 0.9 ) minus edge-on (cos θ k = 0.1 \cos\theta_k=0.1 cos θ k = 0.1 ) (§ 3.1 ). The red line in the top panel is the closed form of Section 4, w 2 X Δ P 2 w_2X\Delta P_2 w 2 X Δ P 2 , with w 2 = 13 / 40 w_2=13/40 w 2 = 13/40 and no calibrated factor (Appendix B2), and Δ P 2 = P 2 ( 0.9 ) − P 2 ( 0.1 ) = 1.2 \Delta P_2=P_2(0.9)-P_2(0.1)=1.2 Δ P 2 = P 2 ( 0.9 ) − P 2 ( 0.1 ) = 1.2 the range of P 2 P_2 P 2 over the extreme folded bin centres, which is a prediction and not a fit. Marker shapes are assigned in order of X X X rather than of WD mass. There is no corresponding closed-form expression for the width ratio, so the bottom panel shows no red line. The analytic solution generally predicts a smaller width-ratio spread, but the absolute variation is small, as illustrated by the collision tracks in Figure 1 and quantified in the text.
The oblate toy model captures the scale of the URILIGHT peak variations, but does not reproduce their ordering with X X X (Table 2 ): the analytic spread in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p increases approximately with X X X , from 19 to 34 per cent, whereas the URILIGHT spreads range from 17 to 52 per cent with no such ordering. Figure 1 shows the same: the collision tracks of panels (a) and (b) cover comparable ranges in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p . The tracks have only a small net in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p in both calculations (Table 2 ); the analytic solution generally predicts a smaller width-ratio spread, but the absolute differences are comparable to the median measurement uncertainty of L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p in the observed sample, 0.03 (Sharon et al. 2025). Figure 1 also shows the systematic upward displacement of the analytic collision tracks in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p , by 0.06–0.10, which is distinct from their small variation with viewing angle.
Table 2. Outer-bin spreads of the six equal-mass collisions (pole-on, cos θ k = 0.9 \cos\theta_k=0.9 cos θ k = 0.9 , minus edge-on, cos θ k = 0.1 \cos\theta_k=0.1 cos θ k = 0.1 ; see § 3.1 ), in order of increasing X X X : the normalized spread of L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p and the absolute difference in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p , for URILIGHT (MC) and the analytic toy model. The last column is the offset of the analytic angle-averaged L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p from the URILIGHT one.
The closed form, Equation (20) in Figure 11 , lies 3–11 per cent below the analytic spread of these six configurations (median 7 per cent; all have X ≤ 0.80 X\leq0.80 X ≤ 0.80 ), the combined finite-time and shape error discussed in Appendix B2. The remaining differences from URILIGHT primarily reflect the effective representation of the numerical ejecta by the toy model.
Discussion and Conclusions
We derived viewing-angle-dependent diffusion light curves for homologously expanding, uniform-density ejecta with a displaced spherical source or concentric oblate source and boundary (Sections 2 and 4, Appendices § 11 and B). An Eddington surface-emission law converts the diffusive flux into the observer’s luminosity. The leading quasi-steady peak anisotropy is dipolar for a displaced sphere, L p ( θ ) / L p a v g ≃ 1 + ( 17 / 8 ) z o f f cos θ L_{\mathrm{p}}(\theta)/L_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{avg}}\simeq1+(17/8)\,z_{\mathrm{off}}\cos\theta L p ( θ ) / L p avg ≃ 1 + ( 17/8 ) z off cos θ , and quadrupolar for oblate ejecta, controlled by the single shape parameter X X X . The spherical coefficient is about 11 per cent below the finite-time value in the tested configurations.
The idealized Monte Carlo tests support the treatment near maximum light (§ 3 ). Effective representations of the 19 off-centre explosions of Schinasi-Lemberg & Kushnir (2025) recover peak time, peak luminosity and width ratio with median errors of 3, 4 and 6 per cent, and their normalized peak spread follows the closed form for z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off (§ 5 and 6). Six collision models also recover the scale of the peak-luminosity variation, although their MC spreads are not ordered by the effective shape parameter (§ 7 ). The main limitation is the angular variation of the width ratio, which the off-centre toy models typically underestimate by a factor of 2–3; the model-#13 comparisons identify contributions from the opacity and transport treatments without uniquely isolating the geometric reduction (§ 5.4 ).
The effective displacement describes the radioactive-source geometry of the toy model; it is not a universal estimator of the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass centroid, and nebular line shifts, which probe the emitting-ion distribution, must be compared with the ejecta models separately (Section 5.2). The model tracks remain inconsistent with the observed luminosity–width distribution of Sharon et al. (2025), and the transverse viewing-angle variation adds to the tension for asymmetric models; a quantitative exclusion would require an orientation-weighted comparison in the residual coordinate of the observed relation, including measurement errors. The solutions provide an interpretation of the peak-luminosity anisotropy within the tested optically thick regime, and their solvers are publicly available (see Data availability).
(of this paper). The light curves and light-curve observables used in the comparisons of this paper are provided as CSV files in the online supplementary material, which also contains typeset versions of the tables. For the 19 off-centre ignition models (Table C1 ) and the six equal-mass collision models (Table D1 ), they list, for each of the ten viewing-angle bins and for the angle average, the peak time t p e a k t_{\mathrm{peak}} t peak , the peak luminosity L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p and the ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p of URILIGHT and of the analytic calculations with both deposition prescriptions. They also contain the angle-resolved URILIGHT and analytic light curves L i s o ( t ) L_{\mathrm{iso}}(t) L iso ( t ) of Figure 2 , Figure 3 , Figure 6 and D2, together with their peak observables; the error-ladder calculations of Figure 8 ; the analytic parameter variations of Figure 9 ; the analytic calculations testing the closed-form peak anisotropy (Figure 4 ); and the weak-oblate relaxation calculations of Appendix B2, together with the exact oblate solutions they are compared with. The solver configuration files of the two validation runs of § 3 are included with the CSV files.
Acknowledgements
We thank Boaz Katz for valuable discussions. We also thank Avshalom Badash and Tal Wasserman for their helpful input. DK is supported by a research grant from The Abramson Family Center for Young Scientists, an ISF grant, the Minerva Stiftung, and the Pazi Foundation.
Data availability
The analytic diffusion solvers developed and used in this work are publicly available at https://github.com/danmydb/viewing-angle-lc (release v1.0, MIT licence, the version used for all analytic calculations
Analytic Derivation of the Diffusion Solutions
General solution of the diffusion equation
For t ˉ > t ˉ δ \bar{t} > \bar{t}_{\delta} t ˉ > t ˉ δ , the scaled radiation energy density satisfies the homogeneous diffusion equation. For the uniform velocity-space density and constant grey opacity assumed here, D D D is constant and can be taken outside the divergence:
∂ e ˉ ∂ t ˉ − D ∇ v 2 e ˉ = 0 , D ≡ c 3 κ ρ ˉ v (26) \frac{\partial\bar{e}}{\partial\bar{t}}-D\nabla_{\mathbf{v}}^{2}\bar{e}=0,\qquad D\equiv\frac{c}{3\kappa\bar{\rho}v} \tag*{(26)} ∂ t ˉ ∂ e ˉ − D ∇ v 2 e ˉ = 0 , D ≡ 3 κ ρ ˉ v c (26)
defined over a bounded domain S S S in velocity space, with boundary ∂ S \partial S ∂ S . We impose an absorbing boundary condition,
e ˉ ( v s , t ˉ ) = 0 , v s ∈ ∂ S . (27) \bar{e}(\mathbf{v}_{s},\bar{t})=0,\qquad\mathbf{v}_{s}\in\partial S. \tag*{(27)} e ˉ ( v s , t ˉ ) = 0 , v s ∈ ∂ S . (27)
We consider a general initial condition at deposition time t ˉ δ \bar{t}_{\delta} t ˉ δ ,
e ˉ ( v , t ˉ δ ) = ε ˉ δ ( v ) , (28) \bar{e}(\mathbf{v},\bar{t}_{\delta})=\bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v}), \tag*{(28)} e ˉ ( v , t ˉ δ ) = ε ˉ δ ( v ) , (28)
where ε ˉ δ ( v ) \bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v}) ε ˉ δ ( v ) is an arbitrary integrable function on S S S .
For constant D D D , the solution is obtained by expanding e ˉ \bar{e} e ˉ in the eigenfunctions of the Laplacian. Let { ψ n ( v ) } \{\psi_{n}(\mathbf{v})\} { ψ n ( v )} satisfy
− ∇ v 2 ψ n = k n 2 ψ n , (29) -\nabla_{\mathbf{v}}^{2}\psi_{n}=k_{n}^{2}\psi_{n}, \tag*{(29)} − ∇ v 2 ψ n = k n 2 ψ n , (29)
with boundary condition ψ n ( v s ) = 0 \psi_{n}(\mathbf{v}_{s})=0 ψ n ( v s ) = 0 on ∂ S \partial S ∂ S and orthogonality
∫ S ψ n ( v ) ψ m ( v ) d V = N n δ n m . (30) \int_{S}\psi_{n}(\mathbf{v})\psi_{m}(\mathbf{v})\,dV=N_{n}\delta_{nm}. \tag*{(30)} ∫ S ψ n ( v ) ψ m ( v ) d V = N n δ nm . (30)
The general solution for t ˉ > t ˉ δ \bar{t}>\bar{t}_{\delta} t ˉ > t ˉ δ is
e ˉ ( v , t ˉ ) = ∑ n A n ψ n ( v ) exp [ − D k n 2 ( t ˉ − t ˉ δ ) ] , (31) \bar{e}(\mathbf{v},\bar{t})=\sum_{n}A_{n}\psi_{n}(\mathbf{v})\exp\left[-Dk_{n}^{2}(\bar{t}-\bar{t}_{\delta})\right], \tag*{(31)} e ˉ ( v , t ˉ ) = n ∑ A n ψ n ( v ) exp [ − D k n 2 ( t ˉ − t ˉ δ ) ] , (31)
with expansion coefficients
A n = 1 N n ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ) ψ n ( v ) d V . (32) A_{n}=\frac{1}{N_{n}}\int_{S}\bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v})\psi_{n}(\mathbf{v})\,dV. \tag*{(32)} A n = N n 1 ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ) ψ n ( v ) d V . (32)
The physical radiative flux is related to the scaled solution by
f ( v , t ) = − c 3 κ ρ ∇ e = − D t 2 ∇ v e ˉ , (33) \mathbf{f}(\mathbf{v},t)=-\frac{c}{3\kappa\rho}\nabla e=-\frac{D}{t^{2}}\nabla_{\mathbf{v}}\bar{e}, \tag*{(33)} f ( v , t ) = − 3 κ ρ c ∇ e = − t 2 D ∇ v e ˉ , (33)
and the emergent surface flux is
F δ ( v s , t ) = − D t 2 n ^ ⋅ ∇ v e ˉ ∣ v = v s , v s ∈ ∂ S , (34) F_{\delta}(\mathbf{v}_{s},t)=-\frac{D}{t^{2}}\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf{v}}\bar{e}\bigg|_{\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{v}_{s}},\qquad\mathbf{v}_{s}\in\partial S, \tag*{(34)} F δ ( v s , t ) = − t 2 D n ^ ⋅ ∇ v e ˉ v = v s , v s ∈ ∂ S , (34)
which evaluates to
F δ ( v s , t ) = − D t 2 ∑ n A n n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ψ n ( v s ) exp [ − D k n 2 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (35) F_{\delta}(\mathbf{v}_{s},t)=-\frac{D}{t^{2}}\sum_{n}A_{n}\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf{v}}\psi_{n}(\mathbf{v}_{s})\exp\left[-\frac{Dk_{n}^{2}}{2}(t^{2}-t_{\delta}^{2})\right]. \tag*{(35)} F δ ( v s , t ) = − t 2 D n ∑ A n n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ψ n ( v s ) exp [ − 2 D k n 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (35)
Off-centre energy deposition
Initial condition
We specialize the general solution to the case of off-centre impulsive energy deposition. The ejecta occupy a sphere of radius v o v_{o} v o in velocity space, so the domain boundary ∂ S \partial S ∂ S of Appendix § 11.1 corresponds here to v s \mathbf{v}_{s} v s with ∣ v s ∣ = v o \lvert\mathbf{v}_{s}\rvert=v_{o} ∣ v s ∣ = v o . The initial condition ε ˉ δ ( v ) \bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v}) ε ˉ δ ( v ) is uniform within
a displaced sphere of radius x s v o x_{s}v_{o} x s v o whose centre is offset by z o f f v o z_{\mathrm{off}}v_{o} z off v o along the symmetry axis:
ε ˉ δ ( v ) = E ˉ δ 4 π 3 ( x s v o ) 3 { 1 , ∣ v − z o f f v o z ^ ∣ ≤ x s v o , 0 , otherwise . (36) \bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v})=
\frac{\bar{E}_{\delta}}{\frac{4\pi}{3}(x_{s}v_{o})^{3}}
\begin{cases}
1, & \lvert\mathbf{v}-z_{\mathrm{off}}v_{o}\hat{\mathbf{z}}\rvert\le x_{s}v_{o},\\
0, & \text{otherwise}.
\end{cases} \tag*{(36)} ε ˉ δ ( v ) = 3 4 π ( x s v o ) 3 E ˉ δ { 1 , 0 , ∣ v − z off v o z ^ ∣ ≤ x s v o , otherwise . (36)
Eigenfunctions
Because the initial condition is axisymmetric about the z z z -axis, only m = 0 m=0 m = 0 modes contribute. The eigenfunctions reduce to
ψ n l ( v , θ ) = j l ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o v ) P l ( cos θ ) , (37) \psi_{nl}(v,\theta)=j_{l}\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_{o}}v\right)P_{l}(\cos\theta), \tag*{(37)} ψ n l ( v , θ ) = j l ( v o α l + 1/2 , n v ) P l ( cos θ ) , (37)
where j l j_{l} j l are spherical Bessel functions, P l P_{l} P l are Legendre polynomials, and α l + 1 / 2 , n \alpha_{l+1/2,n} α l + 1/2 , n are the positive roots of j l ( α l + 1 / 2 , n ) = 0 j_{l}(\alpha_{l+1/2,n})=0 j l ( α l + 1/2 , n ) = 0 , enforcing the boundary condition at v = v o v=v_{o} v = v o .
General solution
Equation (A6) becomes
e ˉ ( v , θ , t ˉ ) = ∑ n , l A n l j l ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o v ) P l ( cos θ ) exp [ − D ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o ) 2 ( t ˉ − t ˉ δ ) ] . (38) \bar{e}(v,\theta,\bar{t})=\sum_{n,l}A_{nl}j_{l}\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_{o}}v\right)P_{l}(\cos\theta)\exp\left[-D\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_{o}}\right)^{2}(\bar{t}-\bar{t}_{\delta})\right]. \tag*{(38)} e ˉ ( v , θ , t ˉ ) = n , l ∑ A n l j l ( v o α l + 1/2 , n v ) P l ( cos θ ) exp [ − D ( v o α l + 1/2 , n ) 2 ( t ˉ − t ˉ δ ) ] . (38)
Expansion coefficients
Projecting the initial condition onto the eigenfunctions gives
A n l = 1 N n l ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ) j l ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o v ) P l ( cos θ ) d V , (39) A_{nl}=\frac{1}{N_{nl}}\int_{S}\bar{\varepsilon}_{\delta}(\mathbf{v})j_{l}\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_{o}}v\right)P_{l}(\cos\theta)\,dV, \tag*{(39)} A n l = N n l 1 ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ) j l ( v o α l + 1/2 , n v ) P l ( cos θ ) d V , (39)
with normalization
N n l = 2 π v o 3 2 l + 1 j l + 1 2 ( α l + 1 / 2 , n ) . (40) N_{nl}=\frac{2\pi v_{o}^{3}}{2l+1}j_{l+1}^{2}(\alpha_{l+1/2,n}). \tag*{(40)} N n l = 2 l + 1 2 π v o 3 j l + 1 2 ( α l + 1/2 , n ) . (40)
Using d V = v 2 sin θ d v d θ d ϕ dV=v^{2}\sin\theta\,dv\,d\theta\,d\phi d V = v 2 sin θ d v d θ d ϕ and integrating over ϕ \phi ϕ :
A n l = ( 2 l + 1 ) E ˉ δ v o 3 j l + 1 2 ( α l + 1 / 2 , n ) 4 π 3 ( x s v o ) 3 ∫ 0 θ max sin θ d θ P l ( cos θ ) ∫ v − ( θ ) v + ( θ ) j l ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o v ) v 2 d v . (41) A_{nl}=\frac{(2l+1)\bar{E}_{\delta}}{v_{o}^{3}j_{l+1}^{2}(\alpha_{l+1/2,n})\frac{4\pi}{3}(x_{s}v_{o})^{3}}\int_{0}^{\theta_{\max}}\sin\theta\,d\theta\,P_{l}(\cos\theta)\int_{v_{-}(\theta)}^{v_{+}(\theta)}j_{l}\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_{o}}v\right)v^{2}\,dv. \tag*{(41)} A n l = v o 3 j l + 1 2 ( α l + 1/2 , n ) 3 4 π ( x s v o ) 3 ( 2 l + 1 ) E ˉ δ ∫ 0 θ m a x sin θ d θ P l ( cos θ ) ∫ v − ( θ ) v + ( θ ) j l ( v o α l + 1/2 , n v ) v 2 d v . (41)
where the two radial bounds of the displaced sphere are
v ± ( θ ) = v o [ z o f f cos θ ± x s 2 − z o f f 2 sin 2 θ ] , (42) v_{\pm}(\theta)=v_{o}\left[z_{\mathrm{off}}\cos\theta\pm\sqrt{x_{s}^{2}-z_{\mathrm{off}}^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}\right], \tag*{(42)} v ± ( θ ) = v o [ z off cos θ ± x s 2 − z off 2 sin 2 θ ] , (42)
with v + ( θ ) = max [ v − ( θ ) , 0 ] v_{+}(\theta)=\max\left[v_{-}(\theta),0\right] v + ( θ ) = max [ v − ( θ ) , 0 ] , and where the polar integration is restricted to the cone subtended by the source,
θ max = { π , z o f f ≤ x s , arcsin ( x s / z o f f ) , z o f f > x s . (43) \theta_{\max}=
\begin{cases}
\pi, & z_{\mathrm{off}}\le x_{s},\\
\arcsin(x_{s}/z_{\mathrm{off}}), & z_{\mathrm{off}}>x_{s}.
\end{cases} \tag*{(43)} θ m a x = { π , arcsin ( x s / z off ) , z off ≤ x s , z off > x s . (43)
The two cases are distinguished by whether the heated region contains the origin. For z o f f ≤ x s z_{\mathrm{off}}\le x_{s} z off ≤ x s it does: the square root is real for every θ \theta θ , v − ≤ 0 v_{-}\le0 v − ≤ 0 , and the radial integral runs from the centre. For z o f f > x s z_{\mathrm{off}}>x_{s} z off > x s the origin lies outside the source, the square root is real only within θ max \theta_{\max} θ m a x , and both roots are positive, so the integral runs over the chord v − ( θ ) ≤ v ≤ v + ( θ ) v_{-}(\theta)\le v\le v_{+}(\theta) v − ( θ ) ≤ v ≤ v + ( θ ) .
Surface flux
On the boundary v = v o v = v_o v = v o , n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ψ n l = ( α l + 1 / 2 , n / v o ) j l ′ ( α l + 1 / 2 , n ) P l ( cos θ ) \hat{\mathbf{n}} \cdot\nabla v\psi_{nl} = (\alpha_{l+1/2,n}/v_o)j_l'(\alpha_{l+1/2,n})P_l(\cos\theta) n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ψ n l = ( α l + 1/2 , n / v o ) j l ′ ( α l + 1/2 , n ) P l ( cos θ ) , giving
F δ ( θ , t ) = − D t 2 ∑ n , l A n l α l + 1 / 2 , n v o j l ′ ( α l + 1 / 2 , n ) P l ( cos θ ) × exp [ − D 2 ( α l + 1 / 2 , n v o ) 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (44) F_\delta(\theta,t)=-\frac{D}{t^2}\sum_{n,l}A_{nl}\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_o}j_l'(\alpha_{l+1/2,n})P_l(\cos\theta)\times\exp\left[-\frac{D}{2}\left(\frac{\alpha_{l+1/2,n}}{v_o}\right)^2(t^2-t_\delta^2)\right]. \tag*{(44)} F δ ( θ , t ) = − t 2 D n , l ∑ A n l v o α l + 1/2 , n j l ′ ( α l + 1/2 , n ) P l ( cos θ ) × exp [ − 2 D ( v o α l + 1/2 , n ) 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (44)
Here j l ′ ( x ) j_l'(x) j l ′ ( x ) denotes the derivative of j l ( x ) j_l(x) j l ( x ) with respect to its argument. This impulse response is convolved with Q ( t ) Q(t) Q ( t ) through the convolution in Equation (4) to obtain the full luminosity evolution.
Oblate spheroidal ejecta geometry
We now derive the analogous solution for oblate spheroidal ejecta containing a concentric oblate spheroidal source: we introduce oblate spheroidal coordinates, record the observer projection for this geometry, and construct the eigenfunction expansion and the resulting surface flux.
Coordinate system and scale factors
We introduce oblate spheroidal coordinates ( ξ , η , ϕ ) (\xi,\eta,\phi) ( ξ , η , ϕ ) in velocity space, related to Cartesian coordinates by
v x = a cosh ξ sin η cos ϕ , v y = a cosh ξ sin η sin ϕ , v z = a sinh ξ cos η , (45) \begin{aligned}
v_x &= a\cosh\xi\sin\eta\cos\phi,\\
v_y &= a\cosh\xi\sin\eta\sin\phi,\\
v_z &= a\sinh\xi\cos\eta, \tag*{(45)}
\end{aligned} v x v y v z = a cosh ξ sin η cos ϕ , = a cosh ξ sin η sin ϕ , = a sinh ξ cos η , (45)
where ξ ≥ 0 \xi\ge0 ξ ≥ 0 , η ∈ [ 0 , π ] \eta\in[0,\pi] η ∈ [ 0 , π ] , ϕ ∈ [ 0 , 2 π ] \phi\in[0,2\pi] ϕ ∈ [ 0 , 2 π ] , and
a = v e q 2 − v p o l 2 (46) a=\sqrt{v_{\rm eq}^2-v_{\rm pol}^2} \tag*{(46)} a = v eq 2 − v pol 2 (46)
is the focal length, with v e q v_{\rm eq} v eq and v p o l v_{\rm pol} v pol the equatorial and polar velocities of the outer ejecta boundary. These coordinates parametrize the same velocity-space domain as in the general solution of Appendix § 11.1 ; the general boundary surface ∂ S \partial S ∂ S is here the single-coordinate surface ξ = ξ s \xi=\xi_s ξ = ξ s . The outer ejecta surface is defined by tanh ξ s = v p o l / v e q \tanh\xi_s=v_{\rm pol}/v_{\rm eq} tanh ξ s = v pol / v eq , so that v e q = a cosh ξ s v_{\rm eq}=a\cosh\xi_s v eq = a cosh ξ s and v p o l = a sinh ξ s v_{\rm pol}=a\sinh\xi_s v pol = a sinh ξ s .
The scale factors are
h ξ = h η = a sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η , h ϕ = a cosh ξ sin η , (47) h_\xi=h_\eta=a\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi+\cos^2\eta},\qquad h_\phi=a\cosh\xi\sin\eta, \tag*{(47)} h ξ = h η = a sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η , h ϕ = a cosh ξ sin η , (47)
and the volume element is
d V = a 3 ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d ξ d η d ϕ . (48) dV=a^3(\sinh^2\xi+\cos^2\eta)\cosh\xi\sin\eta\,d\xi\,d\eta\,d\phi. \tag*{(48)} d V = a 3 ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d ξ d η d ϕ . (48)
Viewing-angle projection for oblate ejecta
For completeness, we record here the oblate-spheroidal analogue of the spherical projection (§ 2.2 ). In the oblate spheroidal coordinate system the unit outward normal at the ejecta surface ξ = ξ s \xi=\xi_s ξ = ξ s is
n ^ = 1 sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η ( sinh ξ s sin η cos ϕ sinh ξ s sin η sin ϕ cosh ξ s cos η ) . (49) \hat{\mathbf{n}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi_s+\cos^2\eta}}
\begin{pmatrix}
\sinh\xi_s\sin\eta\cos\phi\\
\sinh\xi_s\sin\eta\sin\phi\\
\cosh\xi_s\cos\eta
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(49)} n ^ = sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η 1 sinh ξ s sin η cos ϕ sinh ξ s sin η sin ϕ cosh ξ s cos η . (49)
The direction cosine toward an observer at k ^ = ( sin θ k , 0 , cos θ k ) T \hat{\mathbf{k}}=(\sin\theta_k,0,\cos\theta_k)^{T} k ^ = ( sin θ k , 0 , cos θ k ) T is
μ ( η , ϕ ; θ k ) = sinh ξ s sin η cos ϕ sin θ k + cosh ξ s cos η cos θ k sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η , (50) \mu(\eta,\phi;\theta_k)=\frac{\sinh\xi_s\sin\eta\cos\phi\sin\theta_k+\cosh\xi_s\cos\eta\cos\theta_k}{\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi_s+\cos^2\eta}}, \tag*{(50)} μ ( η , ϕ ; θ k ) = sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η sinh ξ s sin η cos ϕ sin θ k + cosh ξ s cos η cos θ k , (50)
and the differential surface element in velocity space (the physical surface element is t 2 d A t^2dA t 2 d A ) is
d A = a 2 cosh ξ s sin η sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η d η d ϕ . (51) dA=a^2\cosh\xi_s\sin\eta\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi_s+\cos^2\eta}\,d\eta\,d\phi. \tag*{(51)} d A = a 2 cosh ξ s sin η sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η d η d ϕ . (51)
The isotropic equivalent luminosity is obtained by integrating over the visible surface μ > 0 \mu>0 μ > 0 .
Initial condition
We consider an oblate spheroidal source, centred on the origin and sharing the symmetry axis of the ejecta, with semi-axes v e q s r c = f a cosh ξ 1 v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src}=fa\cosh\xi_1 v eq src = f a cosh ξ 1 and v p o l s r c = f a sinh ξ 1 v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}=fa\sinh\xi_1 v pol src = f a sinh ξ 1 , where f > 0 f>0 f > 0 scales the overall source size relative to the ejecta focal length a a a and ξ 1 \xi_1 ξ 1 sets its axis ratio ( tanh ξ 1 = v p o l s r c / v e q s r c ) (\tanh\xi_1=v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}/v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src}) ( tanh ξ 1 = v pol src / v eq src ) . The only constraint on f f f is that the source lies within the ejecta. Since both spheroids are centred on the origin and share the symmetry axis, this requires f cosh ξ 1 ≤ cosh ξ s f\cosh\xi_1\le\cosh\xi_s f cosh ξ 1 ≤ cosh ξ s and f sinh ξ 1 ≤ sinh ξ s f\sinh\xi_1\le\sinh\xi_s f sinh ξ 1 ≤ sinh ξ s . The initial condition is
ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) = E ˉ δ V s r c { 1 , v x 2 + v y 2 ( v e q s r c ) 2 + v z 2 ( v p o l s r c ) 2 ≤ 1 , 0 , otherwise , (52) \bar{\epsilon}_\delta(\mathbf{v})=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{V_{\rm src}}
\begin{cases}
1, & \dfrac{v_x^2+v_y^2}{(v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src})^2}+\dfrac{v_z^2}{(v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src})^2}\le1,\\
0, & \text{otherwise},
\end{cases} \tag*{(52)} ϵ ˉ δ ( v ) = V src E ˉ δ ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 1 , 0 , ( v eq src ) 2 v x 2 + v y 2 + ( v pol src ) 2 v z 2 ≤ 1 , otherwise , (52)
where
V s r c = 4 π 3 ( v e q s r c ) 2 v p o l s r c = 4 π 3 f 3 a 3 cosh 2 ξ 1 sinh ξ 1 . (53) V_{\rm src}=\frac{4\pi}{3}(v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src})^2v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}=\frac{4\pi}{3}f^3a^3\cosh^2\xi_1\sinh\xi_1. \tag*{(53)} V src = 3 4 π ( v eq src ) 2 v pol src = 3 4 π f 3 a 3 cosh 2 ξ 1 sinh ξ 1 . (53)
For f = 1 f=1 f = 1 the source is confocal with the outer boundary and the membership condition simplifies to ξ ≤ ξ 1 \xi\le\xi_1 ξ ≤ ξ 1 .
Eigenfunctions of the Laplacian
For axisymmetric (m = 0 m=0 m = 0 ) modes, the eigenfunctions that vanish on ξ = ξ s \xi=\xi_s ξ = ξ s separate as
ψ n p ( ξ , η ) = R n ( 0 ) ( c n p , sinh ξ ) S n ( 0 ) ( c n p , cos η ) ≡ R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) , (54) \psi_{np}(\xi,\eta)=R_n^{(0)}(c_{np},\sinh\xi)S_n^{(0)}(c_{np},\cos\eta)
\equiv R_{np}(\sinh\xi)S_{np}(\cos\eta), \tag*{(54)} ψ n p ( ξ , η ) = R n ( 0 ) ( c n p , sinh ξ ) S n ( 0 ) ( c n p , cos η ) ≡ R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) , (54)
where R n m = 0 R_{n}^{m=0} R n m = 0 and S n m = 0 S_{n}^{m=0} S n m = 0 are the oblate spheroidal radial and angular functions of the first kind with spheroidal parameter c n p c_{np} c n p (following the conventions of Flammer (1957)). The Dirichlet boundary condition R n p ( sinh ξ s ) = 0 R_{np}(\sinh\xi_s)=0 R n p ( sinh ξ s ) = 0 determines c n p c_{np} c n p as the p p p th positive root for fixed n n n , with eigenvalue k n p 2 = c n p 2 / a 2 k_{np}^2=c_{np}^2/a^2 k n p 2 = c n p 2 / a 2 .
General solution
ϵ ˉ ( ξ , η , t ) = ∑ n , p A n p R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) exp [ − c n p 2 a 2 D ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (55) \bar{\epsilon}(\xi,\eta,t)=\sum_{n,p}A_{np}R_{np}(\sinh\xi)S_{np}(\cos\eta)\exp\left[-\frac{c_{np}^2}{a^2}D(t^2-t_\delta^2)\right]. \tag*{(55)} ϵ ˉ ( ξ , η , t ) = n , p ∑ A n p R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) exp [ − a 2 c n p 2 D ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (55)
Expansion coefficients
A n p = 2 π a 3 E ˉ δ V s r c N n p ∫ 0 π ∫ 0 ξ max ( η ) R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d ξ d η , (56) A_{np}=\frac{2\pi a^3\bar{E}_\delta}{V_{\rm src}N_{np}}\int_0^\pi\int_0^{\xi_{\max}(\eta)}R_{np}(\sinh\xi)S_{np}(\cos\eta)(\sinh^2\xi+\cos^2\eta)\cosh\xi\sin\eta\,d\xi\,d\eta, \tag*{(56)} A n p = V src N n p 2 π a 3 E ˉ δ ∫ 0 π ∫ 0 ξ m a x ( η ) R n p ( sinh ξ ) S n p ( cos η ) ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d ξ d η , (56)
with norm
N n p = 2 π a 3 ∫ 0 ξ s ∫ 0 π R n p 2 ( sinh ξ ) S n p 2 ( cos η ) ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d η d ξ . (57) N_{np}=2\pi a^3\int_0^{\xi_s}\int_0^\pi R_{np}^2(\sinh\xi)S_{np}^2(\cos\eta)(\sinh^2\xi+\cos^2\eta)\cosh\xi\sin\eta\,d\eta\,d\xi. \tag*{(57)} N n p = 2 π a 3 ∫ 0 ξ s ∫ 0 π R n p 2 ( sinh ξ ) S n p 2 ( cos η ) ( sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η ) cosh ξ sin η d η d ξ . (57)
and where ξ max ( η ) \xi_{\max}(\eta) ξ m a x ( η ) is the η \eta η -dependent upper limit defined implicitly by the source boundary condition,
( cosh ξ max ( η ) sin η f cosh ξ 1 ) 2 + ( sinh ξ max ( η ) cos η f sinh ξ 1 ) 2 = 1 , (58) \left(\frac{\cosh\xi_{\max}(\eta)\sin\eta}{f\cosh\xi_1}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\sinh\xi_{\max}(\eta)\cos\eta}{f\sinh\xi_1}\right)^2=1, \tag*{(58)} ( f cosh ξ 1 cosh ξ m a x ( η ) sin η ) 2 + ( f sinh ξ 1 sinh ξ m a x ( η ) cos η ) 2 = 1 , (58)
solved numerically for each η \eta η . Explicitly, with A s ≡ f cosh ξ 1 A_s \equiv f\cosh\xi_1 A s ≡ f cosh ξ 1 and C s ≡ f sinh ξ 1 C_s \equiv f\sinh\xi_1 C s ≡ f sinh ξ 1 (in units of the ejecta focal length), sinh 2 ξ max ( η ) = ( 1 − sin 2 η / A s 2 ) / ( sin 2 η / A s 2 + cos 2 η / C s 2 ) \sinh^2\xi_{\max}(\eta)=(1-\sin^2\eta/A_s^2)/(\sin^2\eta/A_s^2+\cos^2\eta/C_s^2) sinh 2 ξ m a x ( η ) = ( 1 − sin 2 η / A s 2 ) / ( sin 2 η / A s 2 + cos 2 η / C s 2 ) . Where the numerator is non-positive, sin 2 η ≥ A s 2 \sin^2\eta\ge A_s^2 sin 2 η ≥ A s 2 (possible only for f cosh ξ 1 < 1 f\cosh\xi_1<1 f cosh ξ 1 < 1 ), the source does not extend into that angular strip, which contributes zero to the integral; for the validation run of Section 3.2 (f = 0.7 f=0.7 f = 0.7 , ξ 1 = 0.7 \xi_1=0.7 ξ 1 = 0.7 ) this is the case for 61.5 ∘ ≲ η ≲ 118.5 ∘ 61.5^\circ\lesssim\eta\lesssim118.5^\circ 61. 5 ∘ ≲ η ≲ 118. 5 ∘ . For f = 1 f=1 f = 1 this reduces to ξ max ( η ) = ξ 1 \xi_{\max}(\eta)=\xi_1 ξ m a x ( η ) = ξ 1 for all η \eta η , recovering the confocal result; the Jacobian sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η \sinh^2\xi+\cos^2\eta sinh 2 ξ + cos 2 η is then a sum of separable products, so the coefficient integral becomes a sum of products of one-dimensional integrals. Because the source is centred at the origin and symmetric about the equatorial plane, only even-n n n modes contribute.
Surface flux
On the surface ξ = ξ s \xi=\xi_s ξ = ξ s , n ^ ⋅ ∇ v = ( 1 / h ξ ) ∂ / ∂ ξ = ( a sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η ) − 1 ∂ / ∂ ξ \hat{\boldsymbol n}\cdot\nabla v=(1/h_\xi)\partial/\partial\xi=(a\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi_s+\cos^2\eta})^{-1}\partial/\partial\xi n ^ ⋅ ∇ v = ( 1/ h ξ ) ∂ / ∂ ξ = ( a sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η ) − 1 ∂ / ∂ ξ , so
F δ ( η , t ) = − D cosh ξ s a t 2 sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η ∑ n , p A n p R n p ′ ( sinh ξ s ) S n p ( cos η ) × exp [ − D 2 ( c n p a ) 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (59) F_\delta(\eta,t)=-\frac{D\cosh\xi_s}{at^2\sqrt{\sinh^2\xi_s+\cos^2\eta}}\sum_{n,p}A_{np}R'_{np}(\sinh\xi_s)S_{np}(\cos\eta)
\times\exp\left[-\frac{D}{2}\left(\frac{c_{np}}{a}\right)^2(t^2-t_\delta^2)\right]. \tag*{(59)} F δ ( η , t ) = − a t 2 sinh 2 ξ s + cos 2 η D cosh ξ s n , p ∑ A n p R n p ′ ( sinh ξ s ) S n p ( cos η ) × exp [ − 2 D ( a c n p ) 2 ( t 2 − t δ 2 ) ] . (59)
where R n p ′ R'_{np} R n p ′ denotes the derivative of R n p R_{np} R n p with respect to its argument, the factor cosh ξ s \cosh\xi_s cosh ξ s arising from ∂ ξ s sinh ξ \partial_{\xi_s}\sinh\xi ∂ ξ s sinh ξ .
Section 4 states the closed forms for the viewing-angle dependence of the peak luminosity (Equations (17) and (20) ); here we derive them. We first derive the observer-projection weights (Appendix B1), then obtain the quasi-steady source, boundary, and curvature contributions from the time-integrated diffusion response (Appendix B2). The final part of Appendix B2 tests their accuracy at finite time.
The observer integral reduces to fixed weights
For spherical ejecta of radius R = v o t R=v_ot R = v o t , the surface element is d A = R 2 d Ω n ^ dA=R^2d\Omega_{\hat n} d A = R 2 d Ω n ^ , and substituting the Eddington closure into the definition of L i s o L_{\rm iso} L iso (§ 2.2 ) gives
L i s o ( θ k ) = 3 R 2 ∫ n ^ ⋅ k ^ > 0 F ( θ ) [ μ 2 + 2 3 μ ] d Ω n ^ , (60) L_{\rm iso}(\theta_k)=3R^2\int_{\hat n\cdot\hat k>0}F(\theta)\left[\mu^2+\frac{2}{3}\mu\right]d\Omega_{\hat n}, \tag*{(60)} L iso ( θ k ) = 3 R 2 ∫ n ^ ⋅ k ^ > 0 F ( θ ) [ μ 2 + 3 2 μ ] d Ω n ^ , (60)
with μ = n ^ ⋅ k ^ \mu=\hat n\cdot\hat k μ = n ^ ⋅ k ^ . Expand the surface flux in Legendre polynomials, F ( θ ) = ∑ l F l P l ( cos θ ) F(\theta)=\sum_l F_lP_l(\cos\theta) F ( θ ) = ∑ l F l P l ( cos θ ) , and note that cos θ = n ^ ⋅ z ^ \cos\theta=\hat n\cdot\hat z cos θ = n ^ ⋅ z ^ while the bracket depends on n ^ \hat n n ^ only through n ^ ⋅ k ^ \hat n\cdot\hat k n ^ ⋅ k ^ . The Funk–Hecke theorem then performs the angular integral exactly, for any function g g g :
∫ P l ( n ^ ⋅ z ^ ) g ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) d Ω n ^ = 2 π P l ( cos θ k ) ∫ − 1 1 P l ( μ ) g ( μ ) d μ . (61) \int P_l(\hat n\cdot\hat z)g(\hat n\cdot\hat k)d\Omega_{\hat n}
=2\pi P_l(\cos\theta_k)\int_{-1}^{1}P_l(\mu)g(\mu)d\mu. \tag*{(61)} ∫ P l ( n ^ ⋅ z ^ ) g ( n ^ ⋅ k ^ ) d Ω n ^ = 2 π P l ( cos θ k ) ∫ − 1 1 P l ( μ ) g ( μ ) d μ . (61)
Applying it to Equation (60) with g ( μ ) = 3 ( μ 2 + 2 3 μ ) g(\mu)=3(\mu^2+\frac{2}{3}\mu) g ( μ ) = 3 ( μ 2 + 3 2 μ ) for μ > 0 \mu>0 μ > 0 and g = 0 g=0 g = 0 otherwise, and using 4 π R 2 F 0 = ∮ F d A = L 4\pi R^2F_0=\oint F\,dA=L 4 π R 2 F 0 = ∮ F d A = L , gives Equations (14) and (15), with
w l = { 1 , 17 24 , 13 40 , 1 16 , − 1 48 , … } . (62) w_l=\left\{1,\frac{17}{24},\frac{13}{40},\frac{1}{16},-\frac{1}{48},\ldots\right\}. \tag*{(62)} w l = { 1 , 24 17 , 40 13 , 16 1 , − 48 1 , … } . (62)
The entire θ k \theta_k θ k dependence therefore factors into the Legendre polynomials. The original two-dimensional integral over the visible surface is reduced to a weighted sum with fixed coefficients w l w_l w l .
The same reduction applies to any smooth convex boundary after one geometric substitution. The outward normal is then in one-to-one correspondence with a surface point, and the Gauss map gives d A = d Ω n ^ / K dA=d\Omega_{\hat n}/K d A = d Ω n ^ / K , where K K K is the Gaussian curvature. Convexity also ensures that the visible surface is precisely the region μ > 0 \mu>0 μ > 0 , with no self-shadowing. Equations (B1) and (B2) therefore go through with R 2 F R^2F R 2 F replaced by Φ ≡ F / K \Phi\equiv F/K Φ ≡ F / K , giving
L i s o ( θ k ) = L [ 1 + ∑ l ≥ 1 w l Φ l Φ 0 P l ( cos θ k ) ] , L = 4 π Φ 0 . (63) L_{\rm iso}(\theta_k)=L\left[1+\sum_{l\ge1}w_l\frac{\Phi_l}{\Phi_0}P_l(\cos\theta_k)\right],\qquad L=4\pi\Phi_0. \tag*{(63)} L iso ( θ k ) = L [ 1 + l ≥ 1 ∑ w l Φ 0 Φ l P l ( cos θ k ) ] , L = 4 π Φ 0 . (63)
The sphere is the special case K = 1 / R 2 K=1/R^2 K = 1/ R 2 , for which Φ ∝ F \Phi\propto F Φ ∝ F and the substitution is invisible. All the shape information is carried by 1 / K ( n ^ ) 1/K(\hat n) 1/ K ( n ^ ) , the emitting area per unit solid angle of normal.
Quasi-steady flux multipoles from the Poisson problem
This subsection derives the angular multipoles of the surface flux without carrying the full time-dependent eigenfunction expansion. We first show that the time integral of an impulse response obeys an exact Poisson equation. We then identify the additional assumptions required to apply this zero-frequency response to continuously heated ejecta over a finite epoch. Only after making that distinction do we derive the spherical and weakly oblate multipoles. The accuracy of the quasi-steady replacement near maximum light is assessed at the end of the subsection.
The Eddington closure does not enter the derivation of the local diffusive flux; it is used only when that flux is projected toward the observer in Appendix B1. Likewise, for a non-spherical boundary, we keep separate the anisotropy of the local diffusive flux and the geometrical factor 1 / K 1/K 1/ K that converts physical surface area into solid angle of the outward normal.
Time-integrated response and the quasi-steady approximation
Consider a unit impulse deposited at transformed time t δ t_\delta t δ . Its subsequent evolution obeys Equation (26) ,
∂ e ˉ ∂ t ˉ − D ∇ 2 e ˉ = 0 , e ˉ ( v , t δ ) = e ˉ δ ( v ) , (64) \frac{\partial\bar e}{\partial\bar t}-D\nabla^2\bar e=0,\qquad\bar e(\mathbf v,t_\delta)=\bar e_\delta(\mathbf v), \tag*{(64)} ∂ t ˉ ∂ e ˉ − D ∇ 2 e ˉ = 0 , e ˉ ( v , t δ ) = e ˉ δ ( v ) , (64)
with e ˉ = 0 \bar e=0 e ˉ = 0 on ∂ S \partial S ∂ S . Define the zeroth temporal moment of the impulse response by
U ( v ) ≡ D ∫ t δ ∞ e ˉ ( v , t ˉ ) d t ˉ = D ∫ 0 ∞ e ˉ ( v , t δ + τ ′ ) d τ ′ . (65) \mathcal U(\mathbf v)\equiv D\int_{t_\delta}^{\infty}\bar e(\mathbf v,\bar t)\,d\bar t
=D\int_0^\infty\bar e(\mathbf v,t_\delta+\tau')\,d\tau'. \tag*{(65)} U ( v ) ≡ D ∫ t δ ∞ e ˉ ( v , t ˉ ) d t ˉ = D ∫ 0 ∞ e ˉ ( v , t δ + τ ′ ) d τ ′ . (65)
The second form is written in terms of the lag t ˉ ′ = t ˉ − t δ \bar t'=\bar t-t_\delta t ˉ ′ = t ˉ − t δ . Since D D D and ∂ S \partial S ∂ S do not depend on t ˉ \bar t t ˉ , e ˉ \bar e e ˉ depends on t ˉ \bar t t ˉ and t δ t_\delta t δ only through t ˉ − t δ \bar t-t_\delta t ˉ − t δ (each mode of (35) decays as exp [ − D k n 2 ( t ˉ − t δ ) ] \exp[-Dk_n^2(\bar t-t_\delta)] exp [ − D k n 2 ( t ˉ − t δ )] ), so U \mathcal U U does not depend on t δ t_\delta t δ . Integrating the diffusion equation over t ˉ \bar t t ˉ and using e ˉ ( v , ∞ ) = 0 \bar e(\mathbf v,\infty)=0 e ˉ ( v , ∞ ) = 0 gives
− ∇ 2 U = e ˉ δ ( v ) , U = 0 on ∂ S . (66) -\nabla^2\mathcal U=\bar e_\delta(\mathbf v),\qquad\mathcal U=0\quad\text{on }\partial S. \tag*{(66)} − ∇ 2 U = e ˉ δ ( v ) , U = 0 on ∂ S . (66)
(66) is therefore an exact identity for the time-integrated impulse response; no quasi-steady approximation has yet been made.
The integration to infinity defines the zero-frequency response of the diffusion problem.
To relate this identity to continuous radioactive heating, let F δ , l ( t ˉ ) F_{\delta,l}(\bar{t}) F δ , l ( t ˉ ) denote the l l l th surface-flux multipole produced a transformed time t ˉ \bar{t} t ˉ after a unit impulse. At epoch t ˉ \bar{t} t ˉ , the corresponding continuously forced multipole follows the same convolution as Equation (4) ,
F l ( t ˉ ) ∝ ∫ 0 t ˉ d t ˉ ′ Q ( t ˉ ′ ) F δ , l ( t ˉ − t ˉ ′ ) ≃ Q ( t ˉ ) ∫ 0 ∞ F δ , l ( t ˉ ′ ) d t ˉ ′ = − Q ( t ˉ ) [ n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] l . (67) \begin{aligned}
F_l(\bar{t}) \propto\int_0^{\bar{t}} \mathrm{d}\bar{t}'\,Q(\bar{t}')F_{\delta,l}(\bar{t}-\bar{t}') \\
&\simeq Q(\bar{t})\int_0^\infty F_{\delta,l}(\bar{t}')\,\mathrm{d}\bar{t}' \\
&= -Q(\bar{t})[\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U}]_l. \tag*{(67)}
\end{aligned} F l ( t ˉ ) ∝ ∫ 0 t ˉ d t ˉ ′ Q ( t ˉ ′ ) F δ , l ( t ˉ − t ˉ ′ ) ≃ Q ( t ˉ ) ∫ 0 ∞ F δ , l ( t ˉ ′ ) d t ˉ ′ = − Q ( t ˉ ) [ n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] l . (67)
where the last integral has been rewritten in terms of the lag t ˉ − t ˉ ′ \bar{t}-\bar{t}' t ˉ − t ˉ ′ . Here F δ , l F_{\delta,l} F δ , l denotes the scaled impulse-flux multipole, t ˉ 2 \bar{t}^2 t ˉ 2 times the physical flux, as a function of the lag; the physical multipole at the observation time follows on dividing by the observation-time t ˉ 2 \bar{t}^2 t ˉ 2 , a factor common to all l l l that cancels in the ratios F l / F 0 F_l/F_0 F l / F 0 . In the last line, [ ⋅ ] l [\cdot]_l [ ⋅ ] l is the l l l th Legendre coefficient on ∂ S \partial S ∂ S . By Equation (34) the scaled impulse flux is t ˉ 2 F δ = − D n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ε ˉ \bar{t}^2F_\delta=-D\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\bar{\varepsilon} t ˉ 2 F δ = − D n ^ ⋅ ∇ v ε ˉ on ∂ S \partial S ∂ S ; integrating it over the lag, exchanging the time integral with the gradient and using the second form of Equation (65) gives ∫ 0 ∞ F δ d t ˉ ′ = − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U \int_0^\infty F_\delta\,\mathrm{d}\bar{t}'=-\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U} ∫ 0 ∞ F δ d t ˉ ′ = − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U for a unit impulse (for general E ˉ δ \bar{E}_\delta E ˉ δ both sides scale with E ˉ δ \bar{E}_\delta E ˉ δ , which cancels in the ratios F l / F 0 F_l/F_0 F l / F 0 ). The normal derivative of U \mathcal{U} U is therefore the time-integrated impulse flux, not the instantaneous F δ , l F_{\delta,l} F δ , l . The second step contains the quasi-steady approximation. It requires two conditions. Let
τ n = 1 D k n 2 (68) \tau_n=\frac{1}{Dk_n^2} \tag*{(68)} τ n = D k n 2 1 (68)
be the relaxation time of eigenmode n n n in t ˉ \bar{t} t ˉ , and define the local physical heating time by t Q ≡ ∣ d ln Q / d t ∣ − 1 t_Q\equiv\lvert\mathrm{d}\ln Q/\mathrm{d}t\rvert^{-1} t Q ≡ ∣ d ln Q / d t ∣ − 1 . Since d t ˉ = t d t \mathrm{d}\bar{t}=t\,\mathrm{d}t d t ˉ = t d t , the heating varies on the transformed-time scale t ˉ Q = t t Q \bar{t}_Q=t\,t_Q t ˉ Q = t t Q . Mode n n n is quasi-steady when
η Q , n ≡ τ n t t Q ≪ 1 , η a g e , n ≡ τ n t ˉ = 2 τ n t 2 ≪ 1. (69) \eta_{Q,n}\equiv\frac{\tau_n}{t\,t_Q}\ll1,\qquad\eta_{\mathrm{age},n}\equiv\frac{\tau_n}{\bar{t}}=\frac{2\tau_n}{t^2}\ll1. \tag*{(69)} η Q , n ≡ t t Q τ n ≪ 1 , η age , n ≡ t ˉ τ n = t 2 2 τ n ≪ 1. (69)
The first condition allows Q ( t ˉ ′ ) Q(\bar{t}') Q ( t ˉ ′ ) to be treated as constant across the width of the response kernel, while the second allows the finite upper limit t ˉ \bar{t} t ˉ to be extended to infinity. When both conditions hold, the final integral in Equation (67) is given by the last line of that equation, i.e. by the surface derivative of U \mathcal{U} U . The angular dependence of the quasi-steady surface flux is therefore that of − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U -\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U} − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U , and common time-dependent factors cancel from the multipole ratios. We denote the resulting zero-frequency ratios by a l q s ≡ F l q s / F 0 q s a_l^{\mathrm{qs}}\equiv F_l^{\mathrm{qs}}/F_0^{\mathrm{qs}} a l qs ≡ F l qs / F 0 qs , below, the superscript is occasionally suppressed when the quasi-steady meaning is unambiguous.
Equivalence to stationary diffusion in physical coordinates
At a fixed but arbitrary epoch t t t , freeze the homologous ejecta and set x = t v \mathbf{x}=t\mathbf{v} x = t v . The boundary and source are then static; t t t only fixes their physical scale. Defining
U x ( x ; t ) ≡ 1 t U ( x t ) , ε δ , x ( x ; t ) ≡ 1 t 3 ε ˉ δ ( x t ) , (70) \mathcal{U}_x(\mathbf{x};t)\equiv\frac{1}{t}\mathcal{U}\left(\frac{\mathbf{x}}{t}\right),\qquad\varepsilon_{\delta,x}(\mathbf{x};t)\equiv\frac{1}{t^3}\bar{\varepsilon}_\delta\left(\frac{\mathbf{x}}{t}\right), \tag*{(70)} U x ( x ; t ) ≡ t 1 U ( t x ) , ε δ , x ( x ; t ) ≡ t 3 1 ε ˉ δ ( t x ) , (70)
the factor t − 3 t^{-3} t − 3 preserves the deposited energy, and ∇ v = t ∇ x \nabla_v=t\nabla_x ∇ v = t ∇ x maps Equation (66) to the Poisson form of a stationary diffusion problem,
− ∇ x 2 U x = ε δ , x , U x = 0 on ∂ S . (71) -\nabla_x^2\mathcal{U}_x=\varepsilon_{\delta,x},\qquad\mathcal{U}_x=0\quad\text{on }\partial S. \tag*{(71)} − ∇ x 2 U x = ε δ , x , U x = 0 on ∂ S . (71)
Its outward surface-flux pattern obeys
− n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x = − t − 2 n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U . (72) -\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_x\mathcal{U}_x=-t^{-2}\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U}. \tag*{(72)} − n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x = − t − 2 n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U . (72)
Because the factor t − 2 t^{-2} t − 2 is common to all angles, it cancels from the normalized multipoles. The quasi-steady counterparts of the multipole ratios a l ≡ F l / F 0 a_l\equiv F_l/F_0 a l ≡ F l / F 0 that enter the observer projection, Equation (14) , are therefore
a l q s ≡ F l q s F 0 q s = [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x ] l [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x ] 0 = [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] l [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] 0 . (73) a_l^{\mathrm{qs}}\equiv\frac{F_l^{\mathrm{qs}}}{F_0^{\mathrm{qs}}}=\frac{[-\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_x\mathcal{U}_x]_l}{[-\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_x\mathcal{U}_x]_0}=\frac{[-\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U}]_l}{[-\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla_v\mathcal{U}]_0}. \tag*{(73)} a l qs ≡ F 0 qs F l qs = [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x ] 0 [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ x U x ] l = [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] 0 [ − n ^ ⋅ ∇ v U ] l . (73)
Thus, a l q s a_l^{\mathrm{qs}} a l qs is obtained exactly by solving this static Poisson problem for the ejecta frozen at any epoch.
Spherical outer boundary: source multipoles
Let the outer boundary be the sphere v = v o v=v_o v = v o , with the deposited energy entirely contained inside it, and define
M l ≡ 1 E ˉ δ ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ′ ) ( v ′ v o ) l P l ( cos θ ′ ) d V ′ , E ˉ δ ≡ ∫ S ε ˉ δ d V . (74) M_l\equiv\frac{1}{\bar{E}_\delta}\int_S\bar{\varepsilon}_\delta(\mathbf{v}')\left(\frac{v'}{v_o}\right)^lP_l(\cos\theta')\,\mathrm{d}V',\qquad\bar{E}_\delta\equiv\int_S\bar{\varepsilon}_\delta\,\mathrm{d}V. \tag*{(74)} M l ≡ E ˉ δ 1 ∫ S ε ˉ δ ( v ′ ) ( v o v ′ ) l P l ( cos θ ′ ) d V ′ , E ˉ δ ≡ ∫ S ε ˉ δ d V . (74)
The normalization gives M 0 = 1 M_0=1 M 0 = 1 .
It is useful to separate the free-space field generated by the source from the correction required by the absorbing outer boundary. The free-space solution of − ∇ 2 U f r e e = ε ˉ δ -\nabla^2\mathcal{U}_{\mathrm{free}}=\bar{\varepsilon}_\delta − ∇ 2 U free = ε ˉ δ is
U f r e e ( v ) = 1 4 π ∫ ε ˉ δ ( v ′ ) ∣ v − v ′ ∣ d V ′ . (75) \mathcal{U}_{\mathrm{free}}(\mathbf{v})=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int\frac{\bar{\varepsilon}_\delta(\mathbf{v}')}{\lvert\mathbf{v}-\mathbf{v}'\rvert}\,\mathrm{d}V'. \tag*{(75)} U free ( v ) = 4 π 1 ∫ ∣ v − v ′ ∣ ε ˉ δ ( v ′ ) d V ′ . (75)
For a field point outside the source, the standard multipole expansion of ∣ v − v ′ ∣ − 1 \lvert\mathbf{v}-\mathbf{v}'\rvert^{-1} ∣ v − v ′ ∣ − 1 gives, for an axisymmetric source,
U f r e e , l ( v , θ ) = E ˉ δ 4 π v o M l ( v o v ) l + 1 P l ( cos θ ) . (76) \mathcal{U}_{\mathrm{free},l}(v,\theta)=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o}M_l\left(\frac{v_o}{v}\right)^{l+1}P_l(\cos\theta). \tag*{(76)} U free , l ( v , θ ) = 4 π v o E ˉ δ M l ( v v o ) l + 1 P l ( cos θ ) . (76)
This field does not in general vanish at v = v o v=v_o v = v o . We therefore add a boundary correction U b , l \mathcal{U}_{b,l} U b , l . The source is already accounted for by U f r e e \mathcal{U}_{\mathrm{free}} U free , so the correction is harmonic, meaning that it satisfies ∇ 2 U b , l = 0 \nabla^2\mathcal{U}_{b,l}=0 ∇ 2 U b , l = 0 . The regular axisymmetric harmonic of angular order l l l is proportional to v l P l ( cos θ ) v^lP_l(\cos\theta) v l P l ( cos θ ) ; imposing U f r e e , l + U b , l = 0 \mathcal{U}_{\mathrm{free},l}+\mathcal{U}_{b,l}=0 U free , l + U b , l = 0 at v = v o v=v_o v = v o therefore gives
U b , l ( v , θ ) = − E ˉ δ 4 π v o M l ( v v o ) l P l ( cos θ ) . (77) \mathcal{U}_{b,l}(v,\theta)=-\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o}M_l\left(\frac{v}{v_o}\right)^lP_l(\cos\theta). \tag*{(77)} U b , l ( v , θ ) = − 4 π v o E ˉ δ M l ( v o v ) l P l ( cos θ ) . (77)
The complete l l l th multipole in the source-free region next to the surface is thus
U l ( v , θ ) = E ˉ δ 4 π v o M l [ ( v o v ) l + 1 − ( v v o ) l ] P l ( cos θ ) . (78) \mathcal{U}_l(v,\theta)=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o}M_l\left[\left(\frac{v_o}{v}\right)^{l+1}-\left(\frac{v}{v_o}\right)^l\right]P_l(\cos\theta). \tag*{(78)} U l ( v , θ ) = 4 π v o E ˉ δ M l [ ( v v o ) l + 1 − ( v o v ) l ] P l ( cos θ ) . (78)
Differentiating at the surface gives
− ∂ U l ∂ v ∣ v o = E ˉ δ 4 π v o 2 [ ( l + 1 ) + l ] M l P l ( cos θ ) = E ˉ δ 4 π v o 2 ( 2 l + 1 ) M l P l ( cos θ ) . (79) -\left.\frac{\partial\mathcal{U}_l}{\partial v}\right|_{v_o}=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o^2}[(l+1)+l]M_lP_l(\cos\theta)=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o^2}(2l+1)M_lP_l(\cos\theta). \tag*{(79)} − ∂ v ∂ U l v o = 4 π v o 2 E ˉ δ [( l + 1 ) + l ] M l P l ( cos θ ) = 4 π v o 2 E ˉ δ ( 2 l + 1 ) M l P l ( cos θ ) . (79)
Since M 0 = 1 M_0=1 M 0 = 1 , the monopole is E ˉ δ / ( 4 π v o 2 ) \bar{E}_\delta/(4\pi v_o^2) E ˉ δ / ( 4 π v o 2 ) , so
a l q s = ( 2 l + 1 ) M l . (80) a_l^{\mathrm{qs}}=(2l+1)M_l. \tag*{(80)} a l qs = ( 2 l + 1 ) M l . (80)
This is the electrostatic problem of a charge distribution ε ˉ δ \bar{\varepsilon}_\delta ε ˉ δ enclosed by a grounded conducting sphere: U \mathcal{U} U plays the role of the potential, U b , l \mathcal{U}_{b,l} U b , l that of the image charges, and the surface flux − ∂ U / ∂ v -\partial\mathcal{U}/\partial v − ∂ U / ∂ v that of the induced surface charge (with opposite sign), whose multipoles are the familiar ( 2 l + 1 ) M l (2l+1)M_l ( 2 l + 1 ) M l . Equation (80) applies specifically to a spherical outer boundary. It maps multipole moments of the radioactive source onto multipoles of the surface flux; anisotropy arising from deforming the outer boundary must be treated separately.
Off-centre source
For the displaced uniform sphere of Equation (36) , the leading asymmetry is a dipole. Explicitly,
M 1 = 1 E ˉ δ v o ∫ ϵ ˉ δ ( v ′ ) v ′ cos θ ′ d V ′ = ⟨ z ′ ⟩ v o = z o f f , (81) M_1 = \frac{1}{\bar{E}\delta v_o}\int\bar{\epsilon}_\delta(v')v'\cos\theta' \,dV' = \frac{\langle z'\rangle}{v_o}=z_{\rm off}, \tag*{(81)} M 1 = E ˉ δ v o 1 ∫ ϵ ˉ δ ( v ′ ) v ′ cos θ ′ d V ′ = v o ⟨ z ′ ⟩ = z off , (81)
so Equation (80) gives
a 1 q s = 3 z o f f . (82) a_1^{\rm qs}=3z_{\rm off}. \tag*{(82)} a 1 qs = 3 z off . (82)
More generally, v ′ l P l ( cos θ ′ ) v'^{l}P_l(\cos\theta') v ′ l P l ( cos θ ′ ) is a solid harmonic. The mean-value theorem for harmonic functions states that its average over a sphere equals its value at the centre of that sphere. The displaced uniform source therefore has
M l = z o f f l , a l q s = ( 2 l + 1 ) z o f f l , (83) M_l=z_{\rm off}^{l},\qquad a_l^{\rm qs}=(2l+1)z_{\rm off}^{l}, \tag*{(83)} M l = z off l , a l qs = ( 2 l + 1 ) z off l , (83)
provided x s + ∣ z o f f ∣ ≤ 1 x_s+\lvert z_{\rm off}\rvert\leq1 x s + ∣ z off ∣ ≤ 1 . The quasi-steady pattern is therefore independent of x s x_s x s : outside a uniformly charged sphere the potential is that of a point charge at its centre, so the surface flux is that induced by a point source at z o f f v o z_{\rm off}v_o z off v o . Summing Equation (83) with ∑ l ( 2 l + 1 ) z l P l ( cos θ ) = ( 1 − z 2 ) / ( 1 + z 2 − 2 z cos θ ) 3 / 2 \sum_l(2l+1)z^lP_l(\cos\theta)=(1-z^2)/(1+z^2-2z\cos\theta)^{3/2} ∑ l ( 2 l + 1 ) z l P l ( cos θ ) = ( 1 − z 2 ) / ( 1 + z 2 − 2 z cos θ ) 3/2 gives the quasi-steady surface flux in closed form, the charge induced on a grounded sphere by a single point charge,
F 0 q s ( θ ) F 0 q s = 1 − z o f f 2 ( 1 + z o f f 2 − 2 z o f f cos θ ) 3 / 2 , (84) \frac{F_0^{\rm qs}(\theta)}{F_0^{\rm qs}}=\frac{1-z_{\rm off}^2}{\left(1+z_{\rm off}^2-2z_{\rm off}\cos\theta\right)^{3/2}}, \tag*{(84)} F 0 qs F 0 qs ( θ ) = ( 1 + z off 2 − 2 z off cos θ ) 3/2 1 − z off 2 , (84)
exact for every multipole. Thus a 1 q s = O ( z o f f ) a_1^{\rm qs}=O(z_{\rm off}) a 1 qs = O ( z off ) , whereas a 2 q s = 5 z o f f 2 = O ( z o f f 2 ) a_2^{\rm qs}=5z_{\rm off}^2=O(z_{\rm off}^2) a 2 qs = 5 z off 2 = O ( z off 2 ) . The leading off-centre anisotropy is therefore dipolar, although Equation (83) is exact for every multipole of a displaced uniform sphere that remains inside the ejecta. Inserting it into Equation (14) gives Equation (17) ; with w 1 = 17 / 24 w_1=17/24 w 1 = 17/24 and w 2 = 13 / 40 w_2=13/40 w 2 = 13/40 , the first two numerical coefficients are 3 w 1 = 17 / 8 3w_1=17/8 3 w 1 = 17/8 and 5 w 2 = 13 / 8 5w_2=13/8 5 w 2 = 13/8 , as in Equation (18) .
Weakly oblate source and outer boundary
For the oblate configuration, both the source and the ejecta are centred and symmetric under z → − z z\to-z z → − z . All odd multipoles therefore vanish, so the quadrupole is the leading anisotropic term. All multipoles in this and the following subsubsection are the quasi-steady ones of Equation (73) ; to lighten the notation we drop the superscript qs, writing F l F_l F l , Φ l \Phi_l Φ l and a 2 a_2 a 2 for F l q s F_l^{\rm qs} F l qs , Φ l q s \Phi_l^{\rm qs} Φ l qs and a 2 q s a_2^{\rm qs} a 2 qs . We write the ejecta boundary v b v_b v b and the heating-source boundary v s r c v_{\rm src} v src as weakly deformed spheres,
v b ( θ ) = v o [ 1 + ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] , v s r c ( θ ) = x s v o [ 1 + ϵ s P 2 ( cos θ ) ] , (85) v_b(\theta)=v_o\left[1+\epsilon P_2(\cos\theta)\right],\qquad v_{\rm src}(\theta)=x_sv_o\left[1+\epsilon_sP_2(\cos\theta)\right], \tag*{(85)} v b ( θ ) = v o [ 1 + ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] , v src ( θ ) = x s v o [ 1 + ϵ s P 2 ( cos θ ) ] , (85)
with ∣ ϵ ∣ , ∣ ϵ s ∣ ≪ 1 \lvert\epsilon\rvert,\lvert\epsilon_s\rvert\ll1 ∣ ϵ ∣ , ∣ ϵ s ∣ ≪ 1 . For an oblate ejecta, ϵ < 0 \epsilon<0 ϵ < 0 . If δ ≡ 1 − v p o l / v e q \delta\equiv1-v_{\rm pol}/v_{\rm eq} δ ≡ 1 − v pol / v eq , then fixing v o v_o v o by requiring that the deformed boundary enclose the same volume as the sphere of radius v o v_o v o (so that the deformation redistributes the ejecta without changing ρ ˉ v \bar{\rho}v ρ ˉ v ) gives ϵ = − 2 δ / 3 + O ( δ 2 ) \epsilon=-2\delta/3+O(\delta^2) ϵ = − 2 δ /3 + O ( δ 2 ) . At first order, the source and boundary perturbations may be calculated independently and then added.
Source quadrupole. First, keep the outer boundary spherical and deform only the uniform source. Equation (74) gives
M 2 = 1 V s r c v o 2 ∫ d Ω P 2 ( cos θ ) ∫ 0 v s r c ( θ ) v ′ 4 d v ′ = ( x s v o ) 5 5 V s r c v o 2 ∫ d Ω P 2 [ 1 + 5 ϵ s P 2 + O ( ϵ s 2 ) ] . (86) \begin{aligned}
M_2=\frac{1}{V_{\rm src}v_o^2}\int d\Omega P_2(\cos\theta)\int_0^{v_{\rm src}(\theta)}v'^4\,dv' \\
&=\frac{(x_sv_o)^5}{5V_{\rm src}v_o^2}\int d\Omega P_2\left[1+5\epsilon_sP_2+O(\epsilon_s^2)\right]. \tag*{(86)}
\end{aligned} M 2 = V src v o 2 1 ∫ d Ω P 2 ( cos θ ) ∫ 0 v src ( θ ) v ′4 d v ′ = 5 V src v o 2 ( x s v o ) 5 ∫ d Ω P 2 [ 1 + 5 ϵ s P 2 + O ( ϵ s 2 ) ] . (86)
Using ∫ P 2 d Ω = 0 \int P_2\,d\Omega=0 ∫ P 2 d Ω = 0 , ∫ P 2 2 d Ω = 4 π / 5 \int P_2^2\,d\Omega=4\pi/5 ∫ P 2 2 d Ω = 4 π /5 , and V s r c = 4 π ( x s v o ) 3 / 3 + O ( ϵ s 2 ) V_{\rm src}=4\pi(x_sv_o)^3/3+O(\epsilon_s^2) V src = 4 π ( x s v o ) 3 /3 + O ( ϵ s 2 ) yields
M 2 = 3 5 ϵ s x s 2 . (87) M_2=\frac{3}{5}\epsilon_sx_s^2. \tag*{(87)} M 2 = 5 3 ϵ s x s 2 . (87)
Because the outer boundary is spherical in this intermediate calculation, Equation (80) applies and gives
a 2 ( s r c ) = 5 M 2 = 3 ϵ s x s 2 . (88) a_2^{({\rm src})}=5M_2=3\epsilon_sx_s^2. \tag*{(88)} a 2 ( src ) = 5 M 2 = 3 ϵ s x s 2 . (88)
The factor 5 is simply 2 l + 1 2l+1 2 l + 1 evaluated at l = 2 l=2 l = 2 .
Outer-boundary quadrupole. Now keep the source spherical and centred and deform only the outer boundary. In the source-free region near the surface, the unperturbed monopole solution (the l = 0 l=0 l = 0 , source-free limit of Equation (74) ) is
U ( 0 ) ( v ) = E ˉ δ 4 π ( 1 v − 1 v o ) . (89) \mathcal{U}^{(0)}(v)=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi}\left(\frac{1}{v}-\frac{1}{v_o}\right). \tag*{(89)} U ( 0 ) ( v ) = 4 π E ˉ δ ( v 1 − v o 1 ) . (89)
Write the perturbed solution as U = U ( 0 ) + U ( 1 ) \mathcal{U}=\mathcal{U}^{(0)}+\mathcal{U}^{(1)} U = U ( 0 ) + U ( 1 ) . The source has not changed, so U ( 1 ) \mathcal{U}^{(1)} U ( 1 ) is harmonic, ∇ 2 U ( 1 ) = 0 \nabla^2\mathcal{U}^{(1)}=0 ∇ 2 U ( 1 ) = 0 . The Dirichlet condition must hold on the moved surface v = v o + v ( 1 ) v=v_o+v^{(1)} v = v o + v ( 1 ) , where v ( 1 ) = ϵ v o P 2 v^{(1)}=\epsilon v_oP_2 v ( 1 ) = ϵ v o P 2 . Expanding it about the spherical surface,
0 = U ( 0 ) ( v o ) + v ( 1 ) ∂ v U ( 0 ) ( v o ) + U ( 1 ) ( v o , θ ) , (90) 0=\mathcal{U}^{(0)}(v_o)+v^{(1)}\partial_v\mathcal{U}^{(0)}(v_o)+\mathcal{U}^{(1)}(v_o,\theta), \tag*{(90)} 0 = U ( 0 ) ( v o ) + v ( 1 ) ∂ v U ( 0 ) ( v o ) + U ( 1 ) ( v o , θ ) , (90)
and using U ( 0 ) ( v o ) = 0 \mathcal{U}^{(0)}(v_o)=0 U ( 0 ) ( v o ) = 0 gives
U ( 1 ) ( v o , θ ) = − v ( 1 ) ∂ v U ( 0 ) ( v o ) = ϵ E ˉ δ 4 π v o P 2 ( cos θ ) . (91) \mathcal{U}^{(1)}(v_o,\theta)=-v^{(1)}\partial_v\mathcal{U}^{(0)}(v_o)=\epsilon\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o}P_2(\cos\theta). \tag*{(91)} U ( 1 ) ( v o , θ ) = − v ( 1 ) ∂ v U ( 0 ) ( v o ) = ϵ 4 π v o E ˉ δ P 2 ( cos θ ) . (91)
The regular harmonic with this quadrupolar boundary value is unique and proportional to v 2 P 2 v^2P_2 v 2 P 2 ,
U ( 1 ) ( v , θ ) = ϵ E ˉ δ 4 π v o ( v v o ) 2 P 2 ( cos θ ) . (92) \mathcal{U}^{(1)}(v,\theta)=\epsilon\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o}\left(\frac{v}{v_o}\right)^2P_2(\cos\theta). \tag*{(92)} U ( 1 ) ( v , θ ) = ϵ 4 π v o E ˉ δ ( v o v ) 2 P 2 ( cos θ ) . (92)
The boundary deformation modifies the surface flux through two first-order contributions. First, the unperturbed monopole gradient must be evaluated at the displaced surface,
− ∂ v U ( 0 ) ∣ v o ( 1 + ϵ P 2 ) = E ˉ δ 4 π v o 2 [ 1 − 2 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] . (93) -\left.\partial_v\mathcal{U}^{(0)}\right|_{v_o(1+\epsilon P_2)}=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o^2}\left[1-2\epsilon P_2(\cos\theta)\right]. \tag*{(93)} − ∂ v U ( 0 ) v o ( 1 + ϵ P 2 ) = 4 π v o 2 E ˉ δ [ 1 − 2 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] . (93)
Second, the harmonic correction contributes
− ∂ v U ( 1 ) ∣ v o = − E ˉ δ 4 π v o 2 2 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) . (94) -\left.\partial_v\mathcal{U}^{(1)}\right|_{v_o}=-\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o^2}2\epsilon P_2(\cos\theta). \tag*{(94)} − ∂ v U ( 1 ) v o = − 4 π v o 2 E ˉ δ 2 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) . (94)
The tilt of the surface normal relative to e ^ v \hat{e}_v e ^ v contributes only at second order: the zeroth-order field is radial, while the angular gradient is already first order. Adding Equations (93) and (B35),
− n ^ ⋅ ∇ U = E ˉ δ 4 π v o 2 [ 1 − 4 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] + O ( ϵ 2 ) , (95) -\hat{n}\cdot\nabla\mathcal{U}=\frac{\bar{E}_\delta}{4\pi v_o^2}\left[1-4\epsilon P_2(\cos\theta)\right]+O(\epsilon^2), \tag*{(95)} − n ^ ⋅ ∇ U = 4 π v o 2 E ˉ δ [ 1 − 4 ϵ P 2 ( cos θ ) ] + O ( ϵ 2 ) , (95)
so the quadrupole generated by the outer diffusion boundary is
a 2 ( b n d ) = − 4 ϵ . (96) a_2^{({\rm bnd})}=-4\epsilon. \tag*{(96)} a 2 ( bnd ) = − 4 ϵ . (96)
The two contributions of − 2 ϵ -2\epsilon − 2 ϵ have different origins. One comes from evaluating the monopole gradient at the shifted radius; the other comes from the harmonic correction required to enforce the zero-energy-density boundary condition on the displaced surface.
Total diffusive quadrupole. The source and boundary corrections have the same angular dependence, P 2 ( cos θ ) P_2(\cos\theta) P 2 ( cos θ ) , and the Poisson equation is linear. Their first-order flux contributions therefore add:
F 2 F 0 ≡ a 2 = a 2 ( s r c ) + a 2 ( b n d ) = 3 ϵ s x s 2 − 4 ϵ . (97) \frac{F_2}{F_0}\equiv a_2=a_2^{({\rm src})}+a_2^{({\rm bnd})}=3\epsilon_sx_s^2-4\epsilon. \tag*{(97)} F 0 F 2 ≡ a 2 = a 2 ( src ) + a 2 ( bnd ) = 3 ϵ s x s 2 − 4 ϵ . (97)
The − 4 ε -4\varepsilon − 4 ε term is not part of M 2 M_2 M 2 . The moment M 2 M_2 M 2 describes only the radioactive source, whereas the relation a l = ( 2 l + 1 ) M l a_l=(2l+1)M_l a l = ( 2 l + 1 ) M l assumes a spherical outer boundary. Thus a centred spherical source has M 2 = 0 M_2=0 M 2 = 0 , yet still produces a quadrupolar surface flux if the outer diffusion boundary is oblate.
Curvature and the quantity projected to the observer
The previous result concerns the local diffusive flux. A second and conceptually distinct geometrical correction enters the observer integral. For a smooth convex surface, the natural variable in Equation (63) is Φ ≡ F / K \Phi\equiv F/K Φ ≡ F / K , because d A = d Ω n ^ / K \mathrm{d}A=\mathrm{d}\Omega_{\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}}/K d A = d Ω n ^ / K . As in the previous subsubsection, F F F and Φ \Phi Φ are quasi-steady; F δ F_\delta F δ remains reserved for the impulse-response kernel in Equation (67) . For the weakly oblate spheroid with equatorial and polar semi-axes A ≡ v e q A\equiv v_{\rm eq} A ≡ v eq and C ≡ v p o l C\equiv v_{\rm pol} C ≡ v pol (the short symbols are kept here only to keep the curvature algebra below readable),
A = v o ( 1 − ε / 2 ) , C = v o ( 1 + ε ) , (98) A=v_o(1-\varepsilon/2),\qquad C=v_o(1+\varepsilon), \tag*{(98)} A = v o ( 1 − ε /2 ) , C = v o ( 1 + ε ) , (98)
the curvature measure as a function of the normal polar angle Θ \Theta Θ , defined by cos Θ = n ^ ⋅ z ^ \cos\Theta=\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{z}} cos Θ = n ^ ⋅ z ^ , is 1 / K = A 4 C 2 / h 4 1/K=A^4C^2/h^4 1/ K = A 4 C 2 / h 4 , where h 2 = A 2 sin 2 Θ + C 2 cos 2 Θ h^2=A^2\sin^2\Theta+C^2\cos^2\Theta h 2 = A 2 sin 2 Θ + C 2 cos 2 Θ . Expanding to first order gives
1 K = v o 2 [ 1 − 4 ε P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] + O ( ε 2 ) . (99) \frac{1}{K}=v_o^2\left[1-4\varepsilon P_2(\cos\Theta)\right]+O(\varepsilon^2). \tag*{(99)} K 1 = v o 2 [ 1 − 4 ε P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] + O ( ε 2 ) . (99)
This produces a second − 4 ε -4\varepsilon − 4 ε quadrupole, but it is geometric rather than diffusive: it describes how much physical surface area corresponds to a fixed solid angle of outward normal. Since the difference between Θ \Theta Θ and the polar angle of the surface point is already O ( ε ) O(\varepsilon) O ( ε ) , it does not affect the first-order result.
To see explicitly how this curvature term enters the normalized multipole, write the diffusive surface flux from Equation (97) as
F ( Θ ) = F 0 [ 1 + a 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] , a 2 ≡ F 2 F 0 = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε . (100) F(\Theta)=F_0\left[1+a_2P_2(\cos\Theta)\right],\qquad a_2\equiv\frac{F_2}{F_0}=3\varepsilon_sx_s^2-4\varepsilon. \tag*{(100)} F ( Θ ) = F 0 [ 1 + a 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] , a 2 ≡ F 0 F 2 = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε . (100)
Using Equation (99) ,
Φ ( Θ ) ≡ F ( Θ ) K ( Θ ) = v o 2 F 0 [ 1 + a 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] [ 1 − 4 ε P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] = v o 2 F 0 [ 1 + ( a 2 − 4 ε ) P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] + O ( ε 2 , ε ε s , ε s 2 ) . (101) \begin{aligned}
\Phi(\Theta)&\equiv\frac{F(\Theta)}{K(\Theta)}=v_o^2F_0\left[1+a_2P_2(\cos\Theta)\right]\left[1-4\varepsilon P_2(\cos\Theta)\right]\\
&=v_o^2F_0\left[1+(a_2-4\varepsilon)P_2(\cos\Theta)\right]+O(\varepsilon^2,\varepsilon\varepsilon_s,\varepsilon_s^2). \tag*{(101)}
\end{aligned} Φ ( Θ ) ≡ K ( Θ ) F ( Θ ) = v o 2 F 0 [ 1 + a 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] [ 1 − 4 ε P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] = v o 2 F 0 [ 1 + ( a 2 − 4 ε ) P 2 ( cos Θ ) ] + O ( ε 2 , ε ε s , ε s 2 ) . (101)
The product − 4 ε a 2 P 2 2 -4\varepsilon a_2P_2^2 − 4 ε a 2 P 2 2 has been dropped because a 2 a_2 a 2 is already first order. Comparing Equation (101) with the Legendre expansion
Φ ( Θ ) = Φ 0 + Φ 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) + ⋯ (102) \Phi(\Theta)=\Phi_0+\Phi_2P_2(\cos\Theta)+\cdots \tag*{(102)} Φ ( Θ ) = Φ 0 + Φ 2 P 2 ( cos Θ ) + ⋯ (102)
gives, term by term,
Φ 0 = v o 2 F 0 , Φ 2 = v o 2 ( F 2 − 4 ε F 0 ) . (103) \Phi_0=v_o^2F_0,\qquad\Phi_2=v_o^2(F_2-4\varepsilon F_0). \tag*{(103)} Φ 0 = v o 2 F 0 , Φ 2 = v o 2 ( F 2 − 4 ε F 0 ) . (103)
The curvature term therefore survives in Φ 2 / Φ 0 \Phi_2/\Phi_0 Φ 2 / Φ 0 . Its P 2 P_2 P 2 variation multiplies the flux monopole F 0 F_0 F 0 and creates an additional quadrupole in Φ \Phi Φ ; only the constant factor v o 2 v_o^2 v o 2 cancels. Consequently,
Φ 2 Φ 0 = F 2 F 0 − 4 ε = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε − 4 ε = 3 ε s x s 2 − 8 ε . (104) \frac{\Phi_2}{\Phi_0}=\frac{F_2}{F_0}-4\varepsilon=3\varepsilon_sx_s^2-4\varepsilon-4\varepsilon=3\varepsilon_sx_s^2-8\varepsilon. \tag*{(104)} Φ 0 Φ 2 = F 0 F 2 − 4 ε = 3 ε s x s 2 − 4 ε − 4 ε = 3 ε s x s 2 − 8 ε . (104)
Equation (104) contains three physically distinct terms: 3 ε s x s 2 3\varepsilon_sx_s^2 3 ε s x s 2 from the quadrupole of the radioactive source, − 4 ε -4\varepsilon − 4 ε from the deformation of the outer diffusion boundary, and a second − 4 ε -4\varepsilon − 4 ε from the curvature, i.e. from the angular variation of surface area per unit solid angle of outward normal. For the source spheroid, with semi-axes v p o l s r c = C s = x s v o ( 1 + ε s ) v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}=C_s=x_sv_o(1+\varepsilon_s) v pol src = C s = x s v o ( 1 + ε s ) and v e q s r c = A s = x s v o ( 1 − ε s / 2 ) v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src}=A_s=x_sv_o(1-\varepsilon_s/2) v eq src = A s = x s v o ( 1 − ε s /2 ) , so
3 ε s x s 2 = C s 2 − A s 2 v o 2 + O ( ε s 2 ) . (105) 3\varepsilon_sx_s^2=\frac{C_s^2-A_s^2}{v_o^2}+O(\varepsilon_s^2). \tag*{(105)} 3 ε s x s 2 = v o 2 C s 2 − A s 2 + O ( ε s 2 ) . (105)
Using ε = − 2 δ / 3 + O ( δ 2 ) \varepsilon=-2\delta/3+O(\delta^2) ε = − 2 δ /3 + O ( δ 2 ) and A s 2 − C s 2 = f 2 a s 2 A_s^2-C_s^2=f^2a_s^2 A s 2 − C s 2 = f 2 a s 2 , together with a s 2 / v e q 2 = 1 − q 2 a_s^2/v_{\rm eq}^2=1-q^2 a s 2 / v eq 2 = 1 − q 2 and v o 2 = v e q 2 + O ( δ ) v_o^2=v_{\rm eq}^2+O(\delta) v o 2 = v eq 2 + O ( δ ) in a term that is already first order, we obtain
Φ 2 Φ 0 = − 8 ε + C s 2 − A s 2 v o 2 = 16 3 δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ≡ X . (106) \begin{aligned}
\frac{\Phi_2}{\Phi_0}=-8\varepsilon+\frac{C_s^2-A_s^2}{v_o^2} \\
&=\frac{16}{3}\delta-f^2(1-q^2)\equiv X. \tag*{(106)}
\end{aligned} Φ 0 Φ 2 = − 8 ε + v o 2 C s 2 − A s 2 = 3 16 δ − f 2 ( 1 − q 2 ) ≡ X . (106)
This is Equation (19) . The signs provide a useful consistency check. For oblate ejecta, ε < 0 \varepsilon<0 ε < 0 , so both outer-boundary terms are positive at the poles (P 2 = 1 P_2=1 P 2 = 1 ): the polar boundary lies closer to the source, and a larger physical area corresponds to each unit solid angle of polar normal. An oblate radioactive source has ε s < 0 \varepsilon_s<0 ε s < 0 and contributes with the opposite sign because its material is preferentially distributed toward the equatorial plane. Equation (63) then projects this multipole through the Eddington weight w 2 w_2 w 2 , yielding Equation (20) .
Finite-time accuracy and the late-time limit
The multipoles derived above are zero-frequency, or quasi-steady, ratios. The closed forms for the peak luminosity use these ratios as approximations to the finite-time multipoles at maximum light. At maximum light the quasi-steady conditions of Equation (69) are not well satisfied (the values of η Q \eta_Q η Q and η a g e \eta_{\rm age} η age quoted below are of order 0.2 0.2 0.2 –0.8 0.8 0.8 , not ≪ 1 \ll1 ≪ 1 ), so the replacement is an uncontrolled approximation at peak and must be checked against the full time-dependent diffusion solution.
For a spherical boundary, the slowest mode is the monopole, with k 01 = π / v o k_{01}=\pi/v_o k 01 = π / v o and therefore τ 01 = v o 2 / π 2 \tau_{01}=v_o^2/\pi^2 τ 01 = v o 2 / π 2 . As a representative example, model #13 of Table C1 has t = 1 M t=1\,\mathrm{M} t = 1 M d, k 01 = 28.3 k_{01}=28.3 k 01 = 28.3 , and t 0 = 31.1 t_0=31.1 t 0 = 31.1 d. At t = 15 t=15 t = 15 d the heating prescription of § 2.1 gives t Q ≃ 14.9 t_Q\simeq14.9 t Q ≃ 14.9 d, so η Q , 01 ≃ 0.37 \eta_{Q,01}\simeq0.37 η Q , 01 ≃ 0.37 and η a g e , 01 ≃ 0.72 \eta_{{\rm age},01}\simeq0.72 η age , 01 ≃ 0.72 (t / τ 01 ≃ 1.4 t/\tau_{01}\simeq1.4 t / τ 01 ≃ 1.4 ). At the same epoch, the 19 models in Table C1 span η Q , 01 = 0.19 \eta_{Q,01}=0.19 η Q , 01 = 0.19 –0.43 0.43 0.43 and η a g e , 01 = 0.39 \eta_{{\rm age},01}=0.39 η age , 01 = 0.39 –0.83 0.83 0.83 . Maximum light is therefore not an asymptotic quasi-steady regime for the monopole.
The anisotropic modes relax more rapidly. For the dipole, the first zero of j 1 j_1 j 1 is k 11 v o = 4.493 k_{11}v_o=4.493 k 11 v o = 4.493 , giving η Q , 11 ≃ 0.18 \eta_{Q,11}\simeq0.18 η Q , 11 ≃ 0.18 and η a g e , 11 ≃ 0.35 \eta_{{\rm age},11}\simeq0.35 η age , 11 ≃ 0.35 for model #13 at 15 d. The multipole ratios can consequently be substantially closer to their quasi-steady values than the monopole is to its own steady response. We measure the finite-time multipoles by expanding
L p ( θ k ) L p a v g = ∑ l ≥ 0 b l P l ( cos θ k ) , b l = 2 l + 1 2 ∫ − 1 1 L p ( μ ) L p a v g P l ( μ ) d μ , (107) \frac{L_p(\theta_k)}{L_p^{\rm avg}}=\sum_{l\geq0}b_lP_l(\cos\theta_k),\qquad b_l=\frac{2l+1}{2}\int_{-1}^{1}\frac{L_p(\mu)}{L_p^{\rm avg}}P_l(\mu)\,\mathrm{d}\mu, \tag*{(107)} L p avg L p ( θ k ) = l ≥ 0 ∑ b l P l ( cos θ k ) , b l = 2 2 l + 1 ∫ − 1 1 L p avg L p ( μ ) P l ( μ ) d μ , (107)
where μ = cos θ k \mu=\cos\theta_k μ = cos θ k , with peak luminosities defined in § 3.1 . Because L p a v g L_p^{\rm avg} L p avg is the peak of the angle-averaged light curve rather than the mean of the per-angle peaks, b 0 b_0 b 0 slightly exceeds unity (1.0004 1.0004 1.0004 –1.023 1.023 1.023 for the off-centre runs below, and 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 –1.0024 1.0024 1.0024 for the oblate ones), which is why the sum starts at l = 0 l=0 l = 0 . For Figure 4 , the integral is evaluated by Simpson’s rule on 21 equally spaced values of cos θ k \cos\theta_k cos θ k , including both poles. The quasi-steady predictions are
b 1 c l o s e d = 17 8 Z o f f , b 2 c l o s e d = 13 40 X . (108) b_1^{\rm closed}=\frac{17}{8}Z_{\rm off},\qquad b_2^{\rm closed}=\frac{13}{40}X. \tag*{(108)} b 1 closed = 8 17 Z off , b 2 closed = 40 13 X . (108)
We quote the dipole deficit as 1 − b 1 c l o s e d / b 1 1-b_1^{\rm closed}/b_1 1 − b 1 closed / b 1 , whereas the inset shows b 1 / b 1 c l o s e d b_1/b_1^{\rm closed} b 1 / b 1 closed . Evaluating all observers at the angle-averaged peak time changes b 1 b_1 b 1 by at most 0.4 per cent for these off-centre solutions. The accuracy at maximum light is best assessed directly from the finite-time analytic solutions, each against the quasi-steady limit of its own perturbative geometry, so that the two error sources stay separate: for a displaced spherical source the quasi-steady dipole is about 11 per cent below the finite-time dipole (range 7–15 per cent, 1 − b 1 c l o s e d / b 1 1-b_1^{\rm closed}/b_1 1 − b 1 closed / b 1 ), measured over the 24 solutions with z o f f = 0.05 z_{\rm off}=0.05 z off = 0.05 –0.30 0.30 0.30 (six at each z o f f z_{\rm off} z off ) shown in the inset of Figure 4 , whereas for the slightly oblate calculations with f ≤ 1 f \le1 f ≤ 1 , the quasi-steady quadrupole differs by at most 4.5 per cent (median 1 per cent), and stays flat in X X X out to X = 3.3 X=3.3 X = 3.3 ; this holds also for the runs whose distortions lie outside the first-order regime (∣ ϵ ∣ |\epsilon| ∣ ϵ ∣ or ∣ ϵ s ∣ > 0.35 |\epsilon_s|>0.35 ∣ ϵ s ∣ > 0.35 ), which are flagged in the released table. For strongly non-confocal sources (f > 1 f>1 f > 1 ) the first-order terms of Equation (19) can nearly cancel at small X X X , in which case the measured quadrupole is dominated by higher-order terms and is not reproduced by w 2 X w_2X w 2 X even though the normalized luminosity residual stays small (the f = 1.4 f=1.4 f = 1.4 , X = 0.09 X=0.09 X = 0.09 run of Figure 4 ); X < 1.5 X<1.5 X < 1.5 alone is therefore not a sufficient accuracy criterion for arbitrary f f f . At larger X X X , the dominant additional error is instead the first-order shape expansion, obtained directly as the ratio of the exact-oblate to the slightly-oblate quadrupole, whose median is 1.03 at X ≤ 0.5 X\le0.5 X ≤ 0.5 , 1.10 for 0.5 < X ≤ 1 0.5<X\le1 0.5 < X ≤ 1 , 1.22 for 1 < X ≤ 2 1<X\le2 1 < X ≤ 2 and 1.39 for X > 2 X>2 X > 2 . These ratios are measured from the finite-time analytic solutions; they are not inferred from the small parameters in Equation (69) .
At asymptotically late times, the situation within the analytic diffusion model is different. Both η Q , n \eta_{Q,n} η Q , n and η a g e , n \eta_{{\rm age},n} η age , n tend to zero, and the finite-time analytic multipoles converge to the zero-frequency Poisson result, by construction: the quasi-steady multipoles of Section 4 are defined as that zero-frequency limit (for the off-centre geometry, an outer-bin spread of 3 w 1 ∣ z o f f ∣ Δ P 1 = ( 153 / 40 ) ∣ z o f f ∣ 3w_1|z_{\rm off}|\Delta P_1=(153/40)|z_{\rm off}| 3 w 1 ∣ z off ∣Δ P 1 = ( 153/40 ) ∣ z off ∣ between the outermost bins, i.e. ≈ 38 \approx38 ≈ 38 per cent for z o f f = 0.1 z_{\rm off}=0.1 z off = 0.1 ). It should not, however, be interpreted as a prediction that the RT calculation must approach the same limit. By those epochs, the ejecta become optically thin, so the diffusion equation, the sharp diffusive boundary, and the surface-emission closure cease to provide an accurate description of the RT problem. Thus the quasi-steady approximation becomes increasingly accurate within the analytic diffusion model at late times, even while the underlying diffusion model becomes progressively less applicable to the physical radiative-transfer solution.
There is one further finite-time approximation in the peak-luminosity closed form: the angular pattern is evaluated at the angle-averaged peak time rather than at the maximum of each individual viewing-angle light curve. This is separate from the quasi-steady replacement. For weak anisotropy, its effect is second order; Table B1 shows how the error grows with source displacement.
Extended Results for the Off-Centre Ignition Models
This appendix compares the radiative-transfer light curves from URILIGHT against the diffusion-framework solution of the effective toy model for every combination of ejecta mass (0.8, 0.9, 1.0, 1.1 M ⊙ M_\odot M ⊙ ) and ignition offset z i g z_{\rm ig} z ig (0.00, 0.10, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75), that is, for the 19 models of Table C1 . Table C1 lists, for every sub-Chandrasekhar off-centre ignition model, the effective toy-model parameters (M 56 N i M_{56{\rm Ni}} M 56 Ni , x s x_s x s , z o f f z_{\rm off} z off , f ~ \tilde f f ~ , and t 0 t_0 t 0 ) used as inputs to the analytic diffusion solutions. Figure C1 and Figure C2 extend the 1 M ⊙ M_\odot M ⊙ comparison of Figure 7 to all ejecta masses, showing the peak luminosity L p L_p L p and the width ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_p L 30 / L p , respectively, as functions of viewing angle, one panel per model, ordered by z o f f z_{\rm off} z off . Figure 10 shows the corresponding normalized viewing-angle variability across all masses, confirming that z o f f z_{\rm off} z off remains the dominant driver of the scatter over the full mass range. The red line in the top panel of that figure is the dipole term of the closed form, Equation (18) , evaluated at the outermost bin centres cos θ k = ± 0.9 \cos\theta_k=\pm0.9 cos θ k = ± 0.9 , which gives Δ L p / L p a v g = 3.83 ∣ z o f f ∣ \Delta L_p/L_p^{\rm avg}=3.83\,|z_{\rm off}| Δ L p / L p avg = 3.83 ∣ z off ∣ ; it is a prediction of Section 4 and is not fitted to these models; it lies ≈ 11 \approx11 ≈ 11 per cent below the analytic points. Figure C3 decomposes the toy-model relative errors in t p e a k t_{\rm peak} t peak , L p L_p L p , and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_p L 30 / L p across the full model set as functions of z o f f z_{\rm off} z off , ejecta mass, and viewing angle.
Figure C1. Peak luminosity L p L_p L p as a function of the viewing angle cos θ k \cos\theta_k cos θ k for all 19 off-centre ignition models, comparing the analytic toy-model predictions (red dashed and dotted lines) with the full RT calculations performed with URILIGHT (solid black lines with circles). As in Figure 7 , the dashed analytic curve uses the deposition fraction of Equation (7) and the dotted one the f d e p ( t ) f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t) f dep ( t ) tabulated by the URILIGHT γ \gamma γ -ray transport. One panel per model: each row is an ejecta mass, as labelled on the left (0.8 − 1.1 M ⊙ 0.8-1.1\,M_\odot 0.8 − 1.1 M ⊙ ; the 0.8 M ⊙ 0.8\,M_\odot 0.8 M ⊙ row has four models, the others five), and the panels of a row are ordered by the nickel off-centre displacement z o f f z_{\mathrm{off}} z off , whose value is given in each panel. Rows share their vertical axis. All ten viewing-angle bins are shown, uniform in cos θ k \cos\theta_k cos θ k over [ − 1 , 1 ] [-1,1] [ − 1 , 1 ] , with cos θ k = + 1 \cos\theta_k=+1 cos θ k = + 1 facing the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni offset. Parameters for each model are listed in Table C1 .
Figure C2. Same as Figure C1 , but showing L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p instead of the peak luminosity L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p , where L 30 L_{30} L 30 is the bolometric luminosity at t = 30 t = 30 t = 30 days after explosion.
Figure C3. Relative error of the toy model against URILIGHT for the three peak quantities – the peak time t p e a k t_{\rm peak} t peak (left), the peak luminosity L p L_{\rm p} L p (centre), and the width ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\rm p} L 30 / L p (right) – as a function of the nickel off-centre displacement z o f f z_{\rm off} z off . The plotted quantity is the absolute relative error referenced to URILIGHT, ∣ Y a n a − Y n u m ∣ / Y n u m |Y_{\rm ana}-Y_{\rm num}|/Y_{\rm num} ∣ Y ana − Y num ∣/ Y num for each of the three quantities Y Y Y , for the analytic calculation that uses the deposition fraction of Equation (7) ; it carries no sign, so a point does not indicate whether the toy model over- or underpredicts. Marker shape encodes the ejecta mass (circles 0.8, squares 0.9, triangles 1.0 and diamonds 1.1 M ⊙ M_\odot M ⊙ ) and marker colour the viewing angle cos θ k \cos\theta_k cos θ k (a representative subset of five of the ten inclination bins is shown for clarity; the quoted statistics are computed over all 190 model-angle combinations). Note the different vertical scales of the three panels.
The hard-sphere fit follows the high-density part of the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni distribution, where the centroid weighs all of its mass. For example, in models #8, #13 and #18 the mean 56 ^{56} 56 Ni density at z > 0 z>0 z > 0 is ≈ 1.7 \approx1.7 ≈ 1.7 times that at z < 0 z<0 z < 0 , whereas the volume occupied by 56 ^{56} 56 Ni (density above 1 per cent of its maximum) at z > 0 z>0 z > 0 is smaller by 16–31 per cent; and using only the densest 75 per cent of the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni mass, the centroid reproduces z o f f z_{\rm off} z off with a median ratio of 1.0 across the 14 displaced models, but with a model-to-model scatter of 27 per cent (ratios 0.50–1.63).
For model #13 (Figure 6 ), the agreement at early and late times is poorer than near peak. At t = 3 t=3 t = 3 –7 d, the angle-averaged analytic luminosity exceeds the URILIGHT one by 41–63 per cent (63, 59 and 41 per cent over the sub-intervals 3–4, 4–5 and 5–7 d), and at t = 7 t=7 t = 7 –10 and 10–14 d by 19 and 4 per cent, respectively. The excess grows towards the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni side, reaching a factor of ∼ 3 \sim3 ∼ 3 at cos θ k = + 0.9 \cos\theta_k=+0.9 cos θ k = + 0.9 for t < 4 t<4 t < 4 d, whereas at cos θ k = − 0.9 \cos\theta_k=-0.9 cos θ k = − 0.9 the analytic luminosity is lower one until t ≈ 5.5 t\approx5.5 t ≈ 5.5 d. This deviation is much larger than the early-time effects discussed in § 3.1 , which change the luminosity by ≤ 12 \le12 ≤ 12 per cent at these times, and therefore cannot account for it. Nor is it a truncation effect of the analytic mode sum: doubling the number of eigenmodes changes the analytic light curves of this model by less than 0.03 per cent at every viewing angle over t = 3 t=3 t = 3 –7 d (Appendix E). Instead, the early light curve is set by the structure near the surface, where the effective sphere most likely deviates most from the numerical ejecta. The effective sphere has a uniform density and a sharp edge at v o v_o v o , whereas the density of the numerical ejecta decreases smoothly outward, with 20 per cent of the mass outside v o v_o v o , extending to ≈ 1.8 v o \approx1.8\,v_o ≈ 1.8 v o . The 56 ^{56} 56 Ni is also distributed differently: since the numerical ejecta are centrally concentrated, half of the 56 ^{56} 56 Ni mass lies within 0.53 v o 0.53\,v_o 0.53 v o , compared with 0.64 v o 0.64\,v_o 0.64 v o in the effective sphere. The excess luminosity is not due to the constant opacity approximation: relative to URILIGHT run on the same ejecta with the constant opacity κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa=0.165\ {\rm cm^2\,g^{-1}} κ = 0.165 c m 2 g − 1 (test (i) of § 5.4 ), the analytic luminosity is still higher, by 98, 54 and 25 per cent at t = 3 t=3 t = 3 –4, 4–5 and 5–7 d. Moreover, URILIGHT run on the same ejecta with the same opacity (right panel of Figure 8 ) is brighter than test (i) by 121, 74 and 36 per cent at the same epochs. We therefore attribute the early-time deviation mainly to the reduction of the numerical ejecta to the effective sphere. At late times, t ≥ 30 t\ge30 t ≥ 30 d, the angle-averaged luminosity is reproduced to within 11 per cent, but the viewing-angle contrast is not: the analytic ratio L i s o ( cos θ k = + 0.9 ) / L i s o ( cos θ k = − 0.9 ) L_{\rm iso}(\cos\theta_k=+0.9)/L_{\rm iso}(\cos\theta_k=-0.9) L iso ( cos θ k = + 0.9 ) / L iso ( cos θ k = − 0.9 ) remains at ≈ 1.4 \approx1.4 ≈ 1.4 , whereas in URILIGHT it drops to 1.22 at t = 35 t=35 t = 35 –50 d (and to 1.06 at t ≈ 60 t\approx60 t ≈ 60 d for constant opacity). This is the frozen angular pattern of the analytic solution discussed in § 3 and § 5.4 .
Figure C4 shows Figure 1 in magnitude space, as in fig. C2 of Sharon et al. (2025): the peak bolometric magnitude, M b o l p = − 2.5 log 10 ( L p / L 0 ) M_{\mathrm{bol}}^{\mathrm{p}}=-2.5\log_{10}(L_{\mathrm{p}}/L_{0}) M bol p = − 2.5 log 10 ( L p / L 0 ) with L 0 = 3.0128 × 10 35 e r g s − 1 L_{0}=3.0128\times10^{35}\,\mathrm{erg}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} L 0 = 3.0128 × 1 0 35 erg s − 1 , against M 30 b o l − M p b o l = − 2.5 log 10 ( L 30 / L p ) M_{30}^{\mathrm{bol}}-M_{\mathrm{p}}^{\mathrm{bol}}=-2.5\log_{10}(L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}) M 30 bol − M p bol = − 2.5 log 10 ( L 30 / L p ) .
Figure C4. As Figure 1 , but in magnitude space, as in fig. C2 of Sharon et al. (2025): the peak bolometric magnitude M p b o l M_{\rm p}^{\rm bol} M p bol against M 30 b o l − M p b o l = − 2.5 log 10 ( L 30 / L p ) M_{30}^{\rm bol}-M_{\rm p}^{\rm bol}=-2.5\log_{10}(L_{30}/L_{\rm p}) M 30 bol − M p bol = − 2.5 log 10 ( L 30 / L p ) , with M b o l = 0 M^{\rm bol}=0 M bol = 0 at 3.0128 × 10 35 3.0128\times10^{35} 3.0128 × 1 0 35 erg s− 1 ^{-1} − 1 . Both axes are reversed, so that brighter and slower events lie up and to the right. The observational errors are propagated to first order.
Head-on White Dwarf Collision Models
This appendix documents the oblate toy-model construction of § 7 for the head-on WD collision models (Kushnir et al. 2013), which produce oblate ejecta rather than the approximately spherical ejecta of the off-centre ignition models. The oblate diffusion solution itself is derived in Appendix A3 and validated against URILIGHT on idealized oblate ejecta in Section 3.2. What is tested here is the construction that reduces the collision ejecta to the six parameters of that solution representing the ellipsoid toy ejecta.
Toy-model construction for collision ejecta
For each collision ejecta, we construct an effective toy model using a procedure similar to that used for the off-centre spherical case (Section 5.2), with the spherical ejecta and 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source both replaced by oblate spheroids and all effective quantities evaluated at the epoch of bolometric peak. The model here is specified by six effective parameters: the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , the ejecta boundary coordinate ξ s \xi_{\mathrm{s}} ξ s , the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source coordinate ξ 1 \xi_{1} ξ 1 , the confocality parameter f f f , the diffusion time-scale t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ , and the γ \gamma γ -ray escape time t 0 t_{0} t 0 . The construction of these parameters is described below.
As in the spherical case, the toy model conserves the total ejecta mass M M M and the total 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni , both summed over the ejecta cells. The effective ejecta geometry, however, is not obtained from a mass-conserving fit, but directly from the total mass density distribution: we extract the outermost density contour at 10 per cent of the peak density and identify its maximal radial and axial extents with the equatorial and polar velocities v e q v_{\mathrm{eq}} v eq and v p o l v_{\mathrm{pol}} v pol of an oblate spheroid. These fix the focal length a = ( v e q 2 − v p o l 2 ) 1 / 2 a=(v_{\mathrm{eq}}^{2}-v_{\mathrm{pol}}^{2})^{1/2} a = ( v eq 2 − v pol 2 ) 1/2 and the ejecta boundary coordinate ξ s = arctanh ( v p o l / v e q ) \xi_{\mathrm{s}}=\operatorname{arctanh}(v_{\mathrm{pol}}/v_{\mathrm{eq}}) ξ s = arctanh ( v pol / v eq ) (Appendix A3), while the mean velocity-space density is ρ ˉ v = M / ( 4 π 3 v e q 2 v p o l ) \bar{\rho}_{v}=M/(\frac{4\pi}{3}v_{\mathrm{eq}}^{2}v_{\mathrm{pol}}) ρ ˉ v = M / ( 3 4 π v eq 2 v pol ) , the total mass divided by the spheroidal volume. The choice of the 10 per cent contour, and the reduction of the full density distribution to a single oblate boundary, are modelling choices of the effective toy-model construction; neither is uniquely determined by the underlying diffusion physics.
The 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni source region is chosen so that the source volume equals V s r c = M 56 N i / ρ ˉ v V_{\mathrm{src}}=M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}/\bar{\rho}_{v} V src = M 56 Ni / ρ ˉ v , the volume that contains the correct 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass at the mean ejecta density (Equation (52) ). This mirrors the spherical case, in which the fitted source radius is discarded, and ξ s \xi_{\mathrm{s}} ξ s is instead fixed by M 56 N i M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} M 56 Ni .
The remaining two parameters are obtained exactly as in the spherical case. The diffusion time-scale is t ~ 2 = a 2 / D \tilde{t}^{2}=a^{2}/D t ~ 2 = a 2 / D with D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) D=c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}_{v}) D = c / ( 3 κ ρ ˉ v ) , where the effective opacity κ \kappa κ is the mass-weighted Rosseland mean of Equation (25) . The γ \gamma γ -ray escape time t 0 t_{0} t 0 enters the radioactive heating through Equation (7) and is computed from the mean column density seen by the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni cells with an effective γ \gamma γ -ray opacity κ e f f = 0.025 c m 2 g − 1 \kappa_{\mathrm{eff}}=0.025\,\mathrm{cm}^{2}\,\mathrm{g}^{-1} κ eff = 0.025 cm 2 g − 1 .
As in the spherical case, none of these parameters is calibrated to reproduce the URILIGHT light curves, and only t ~ \tilde{t} t ~ requires the completed URILIGHT calculation, through the peak-light opacity κ \kappa κ . The resulting parameters for the six equal-mass collisions are listed in Table D1 .
Figure D1 illustrates the construction for the 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ 0.6+0.6\,M_{\odot} 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ collision. The total mass density (left panel) is enclosed reasonably well by a single oblate spheroid, but the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution (right panel) is not. The mismatch is of the same character in the other equal-mass collisions. Since the closed form of Section 4 shows that the viewing-angle dependence is set by the quadrupole moment of the source shape and by the curvature of the boundary, an inaccurate source shape translates directly into an inaccurate angular pattern. This is a plausible reason why the oblate construction reproduces the RT calculations less well than the off-centre construction of Section 5.2. We emphasize that this concerns the reduction of the ejecta to a toy model, and not the oblate diffusion solution itself, which is validated on ejecta that do satisfy its assumptions in Section 3.2.
Figure D1. Effective oblate geometry of the collision toy-model construction (Appendix D1) for the 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ 0.6 + 0.6\,M_\odot 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ collision (#20, Table D1 ), in the ( v r , v z ) (v_r,v_z) ( v r , v z ) velocity plane with the same units, colour scale and axes as Figure 5 . Left: total mass density, with the effective spheroid (semi-axes a cosh ξ s a\cosh\xi_s a cosh ξ s , a sinh ξ s a\sinh\xi_s a sinh ξ s ; thick red dashed) and its focal length a a a (red bar). Right: 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass density, with the effective source spheroid (semi-axes f a cosh ξ 1 f a\cosh\xi_1 f a cosh ξ 1 , f a sinh ξ 1 f a\sinh\xi_1 f a sinh ξ 1 ). Thin white solid curves are the 10 per cent density contours from which the shapes are fitted; thin white dashed curves show the other panel’s spheroid. The ejecta spheroid circumscribes its contour, whereas the source spheroid keeps only the contour’s shape, its scale being reset by 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass conservation; the markedly non-elliptical 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni contour is the geometric limitation of the oblate construction.
Comparison with URILIGHT on the numerical ejecta
We compare the analytic toy model with angle-resolved URILIGHT light curves for six equal-mass collisions of Kushnir et al. (2013), 0.6 + 0.6 0.6+0.6 0.6 + 0.6 , 0.64 + 0.64 0.64+0.64 0.64 + 0.64 , 0.7 + 0.7 0.7+0.7 0.7 + 0.7 , 0.8 + 0.8 0.8+0.8 0.8 + 0.8 , 0.9 + 0.9 0.9+0.9 0.9 + 0.9 and 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ 1.0+1.0\,M_{\odot} 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ . Two lighter equal-mass collisions, 0.5 + 0.5 0.5+0.5 0.5 + 0.5 and 0.55 + 0.55 M ⊙ 0.55+0.55\,M_{\odot} 0.55 + 0.55 M ⊙ , are excluded: both their total mass density and their 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution are prolate rather than oblate. Measured from the 10 per cent contours as in Appendix D1, their axis ratios are v p o l / v e q = 1.20 v_{\mathrm{pol}}/v_{\mathrm{eq}}=1.20 v pol / v eq = 1.20 and 1.01 for the ejecta boundary and 1.11 and 1.09 for the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni region; the diffusion solution of Appendix A3 therefore has no prolate branch, and the construction cannot be applied to them. Table D1 lists the six toy-model parameters extracted from each of them by the construction of Appendix D1, and Figure D2 compares the resulting analytic light curves with URILIGHT at each viewing angle for the 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ 0.6+0.6\,M_{\odot} 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ collision. Across the ten viewing angles, the peak luminosity L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is reproduced with a median relative error of 3.6 per cent, and the width ratio L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p with a median relative error of 11.2 per cent. Over the six collisions the per-collision medians span 0.8–5.5 per cent in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p and 9.6–17 per cent in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p , and the ordering follows neither the collision mass nor X X X : the smallest median error in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is that of the 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ 1.0+1.0\,M_{\odot} 1.0 + 1.0 M ⊙ collision (0.8 per cent) and the largest that of the 0.9 + 0.9 M ⊙ 0.9+0.9\,M_{\odot} 0.9 + 0.9 M ⊙ collision (5.5 per cent), which has at the same time the smallest median error in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p (9.6 per cent), while the largest error in L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} L 30 / L p (17.0 per cent) belongs to the 0.8 + 0.8 M ⊙ 0.8+0.8\,M_{\odot} 0.8 + 0.8 M ⊙ collision, whose median error in L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p is only 2.2 per cent. As for the sub-Chandrasekhar models, the peak luminosity is captured better than the width ratio.
Figure D2. Bolometric light curves of the effective oblate toy model (red) compared with URILIGHT (solid black) for the head-on collision of two 0.6 M ⊙ 0.6\,M_\odot 0.6 M ⊙ WDs (#20; parameters in Table D1 ). L i s o L_{\rm iso} L iso is shown for the same five bins as in Figure 2 , where θ k \theta_k θ k is measured from the collision axis; both calculations are (approximately) symmetric about the equatorial plane, so each curve also represents its mirror bin, and the peak luminosity increases with ∣ cos θ k ∣ |\cos\theta_k| ∣ cos θ k ∣ from edge-on (cos θ k = − 0.1 \cos\theta_k=-0.1 cos θ k = − 0.1 , labelled below its peak) to pole-on (− 0.9 -0.9 − 0.9 , labelled above it). As in Figure 6 , dashed uses Equation (7) and dotted the tabulated f d e p f_{\rm dep} f dep ; for this collision L p L_p L p is matched to a median of 3.6 per cent and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_p L 30 / L p to 11.2 per cent over the ten viewing angles.
Two effects plausibly contribute to the poorer match of the collision toy models (§ 7 ). The first is geometric: as discussed in Appendix D1 and shown in Figure D1 , the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni distribution in the collision ejecta is not a perfect oblate spheroid, so the reduction discards precisely the moment of the source that sets the angular pattern. A compact measure of this is the exponent n n n of the best-fitting superellipse ∣ v r / A ∣ n + ∣ v z / B ∣ n = 1 |v_r/A|^n+|v_z/B|^n=1 ∣ v r / A ∣ n + ∣ v z / B ∣ n = 1 , for which n = 2 n=2 n = 2 is an ellipse: fitted to the 10 per cent contours of Figure D1 , the total density gives n = 1.8 n=1.8 n = 1.8 for the 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ 0.6+0.6\,M_\odot 0.6 + 0.6 M ⊙ collision and n ≈ 1.8 n\approx1.8 n ≈ 1.8 –2.2 2.2 2.2 over the six equal-mass collisions, close to an ellipse throughout, whereas the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni gives n = 0.9 n=0.9 n = 0.9 and spans n ≈ 0.9 n\approx0.9 n ≈ 0.9 –3.3 3.3 3.3 , with no value near 2: the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni contour is alternately diamond-shaped and boxy, a deformation no spheroid can represent. The second is common to both geometries as already discussed in § 5.4 . Even for idealized ejecta that do satisfy the assumptions of the oblate solution, Figure 3 shows a residual between the analytic and RT light curves that grows after maximum, because the Dirichlet boundary condition and the grey-atmosphere closure hold the angular contrast fixed while the RT contrast decays as the ejecta become optically thin. The same mechanism, together with the constant effective opacity and the deposition prescription, was identified in § 5.4 as the origin of the width-ratio mismatch of the spherical models, and L 30 L_{30} L 30 is measured well inside the epoch where those approximations are weakest.
The relative errors of these six equal-mass collisions are, in places, comparable to those of some off-centre sub-Chandrasekhar models, but this comparison rests on low statistics: only six equal-mass collision ejecta, which most closely resemble an oblate spheroid, versus 19 sub-Chandrasekhar models.
The construction fails more fundamentally in the case of collisions between WDs of unequal mass. About half of the unequal-mass collisions of Kushnir et al. (2013) (8 of 15) show a prolate 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni region, inside an oblate boundary in five of them and a prolate one in the other three. In the first-order expression of Equation (19) , a prolate source (ε s > 0 \varepsilon_s>0 ε s > 0 ) inside an oblate boundary (ε < 0 \varepsilon<0 ε < 0 ) gives source and boundary quadrupoles of the same sign, which reinforce each other, whereas inside a prolate boundary the two are in opposition. Whether L p L_{\mathrm{p}} L p rises or falls with ∣ cos θ k ∣ \lvert\cos\theta_k\rvert ∣ cos θ k ∣ is then determined by the interplay between these two surfaces (although, again, a few models show no monotonicity at all). A treatment of these models is beyond the scope of this paper. For example, Figure D3 shows the mass density of one such ejecta, the 1.0 + 0.5 M ⊙ 1.0 + 0.5\,M_\odot 1.0 + 0.5 M ⊙ collision, in velocity space, together with the spheroids obtained from the same 10 per cent contour prescription used above (Appendix D1). Its ejecta boundary is oblate, ( v p o l / v e q = 0.98 ) (v_{\rm pol}/v_{\rm eq} = 0.98) ( v pol / v eq = 0.98 ) , and close to an ellipse ( n ≈ 2.1 ) (n \approx2.1) ( n ≈ 2.1 ) , whereas its 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni is prolate, v p o l s r c / v e q s r c = 1.13 v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}/v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src} = 1.13 v pol src / v eq src = 1.13 , and markedly non-elliptical ( n ≈ 1.3 ) (n \approx1.3) ( n ≈ 1.3 ) . The 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni is also not symmetric about the equatorial plane: 42 per cent of it lies above the plane and 58 per cent below, with a 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -mass-weighted mean axial velocity ⟨ v z ⟩ = − 1.1 k m s − 1 \langle v_z\rangle= -1.1\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} ⟨ v z ⟩ = − 1.1 km s − 1 , against ∣ ⟨ v z ⟩ ∣ ≤ 23 k m s − 1 \lvert\langle v_z\rangle\rvert\le23\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} ∣⟨ v z ⟩∣ ≤ 23 km s − 1 ( ≤ 0.2 (\le0.2 ( ≤ 0.2 per cent of v p o l ) v_{\rm pol}) v pol ) for the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni of the six equal-mass collisions. Thus, both approximations of Appendix D1 fail at once, and we do not attempt a quantitative comparison for these models.
Figure D3. As Figure D1 , but for the unequal-mass 1.0 + 0.5 M ⊙ 1.0+0.5\,M_\odot 1.0 + 0.5 M ⊙ head-on collision. Left: total mass density in velocity space, with the spheroid of semi-axes v e q v_{\rm eq} v eq and v p o l v_{\rm pol} v pol (thick red dashed) read off the density contour at 10 per cent of the peak (thin white solid). Right: 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni mass density, with the corresponding source spheroid. Unlike the six equal-mass collisions of Table D1 , this model admits no oblate toy model: the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni region is prolate, with polar-to-equatorial ratio v p o l s r c / v e q s r c = 1.13 v_{\rm pol}^{\rm src}/v_{\rm eq}^{\rm src}=1.13 v pol src / v eq src = 1.13 . The spheroids drawn here are therefore the measured contour semi-axes, not a fit: the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni one is the mass-conserving rescaling of its contour (similar construction of Section D1).
Early- and late-time residuals of the validation tests
The URILIGHT runs of Section 3 use 5 × 10 7 5 \times10^7 5 × 1 0 7 UVOIR energy packets; since f d e p = 1 f_{\rm dep} = 1 f dep = 1 is imposed, no γ \gamma γ -ray packets are transported. The runs on the explosion models (Sections 5–7) use 5 × 10 7 5 \times10^7 5 × 1 0 7 UVOIR energy packets for the off-centre ignition models and 4 × 10 7 4 \times10^7 4 × 1 0 7 for the collision models, together with 10 8 10^8 1 0 8 γ \gamma γ -ray packets.
In the off-centre test of Figure 2 , the largest discrepancies occur at early and late times. During the first few days, the discrepancy is dominated by numerical artefacts of the URILIGHT calculation and by light-travel-time (LTT) effects, which the analytic solution neglects. On the numerical side, the URILIGHT calculation starts at t i n i t = 2 d t_{\rm init} = 2\,\mathrm{d} t init = 2 d with no escaping radiation, so the emergent luminosity is underestimated until the radiation field has built up, and packets with wavelengths above λ max = 3 × 10 4 A ˚ \lambda_{\max} = 3 \times10^4\,\text{\AA} λ m a x = 3 × 1 0 4 A ˚ are discarded; in this grey, constant-opacity calculation, packets trapped in the ejecta are red-shifted beyond that limit, which biases the luminosity low. On the analytic side, neglecting LTT matters most at early times, when the light curve rises steeply. Averaged over 3–6 d, the URILIGHT lumi-
positivity exceeds the analytic one by ≃ 10 \simeq10 ≃ 10 per cent in the angle average and by 5–12 per cent depending on the viewing angle (here and below, the average is the ratio of the time-integrated luminosities). The analytic light curves are converged in the number of eigenmodes: doubling it in each index (from l ≤ 100 l\leq100 l ≤ 100 with 100 radial modes per l l l to l ≤ 200 l\leq200 l ≤ 200 with 200) changes them by less than 1 per cent at every viewing angle after t = 2.2 t=2.2 t = 2.2 d, and by 0.02 per cent averaged over 3–6 d, so the truncation of the mode sum does not contribute to this difference. Repeating the URILIGHT calculation with t i n i t = 0.5 t_{\rm init}=0.5 t init = 0.5 d and λ m a x = 10 6 \lambda_{\rm max}=10^{6} λ max = 1 0 6 Å, and removing LTT from the resulting light curves, reduces the difference to below 1 per cent in the angle average and to within 4 per cent at every viewing angle; we do not apply these
changes to the other calculations. Observed light curves include LTT, and starting URILIGHT earlier is computationally expensive given the dense grids and large numbers of packets required to keep the MC noise low. The wavelength limit, in turn, matters only for grey, pure-scattering calculations; with realistic opacities, packets are repeatedly absorbed and re-emitted with the local thermal spectrum, so their wavelengths do not drift redwards. At most 0.4 per cent (typically 0.1 per cent) of the created packets are discarded in our sub-Chandrasekhar and collision models. At later times, the analytic and MC light curves diverge: the MC viewing-angle contrast decays as the ejecta become optically thin, whereas the analytic solution holds it near its quasi-steady pattern. This expected limitation of the optically thick description was discussed in Section 2 and is quantified below.
In the oblate test of Figure 3 the same early-time differences appear, but later, because these light curves rise more slowly (peak at t ≈ 22 d t\approx22\,\mathrm{d} t ≈ 22 d , compared with ≈ 15 d \approx15\,\mathrm{d} ≈ 15 d in Figure 2 ). The luminosity stays below 1 per cent of L p L_p L p until t ≈ 6 d t\approx6\,\mathrm{d} t ≈ 6 d , so the late start of the URILIGHT calculation (t i n i t = 2 d t_{\rm init}=2\,\mathrm{d} t init = 2 d ) has no noticeable effect. To compare the two models at the same stage of their evolution, we average over 8–12 d, during which L L L grows from ≈ 0.1 \approx0.1 ≈ 0.1 to ≈ 0.4 L p \approx0.4\,L_p ≈ 0.4 L p , as it does over 3–6 d in Figure 2 . Over this interval, the URILIGHT luminosity exceeds the analytic one by ≈ 9 \approx9 ≈ 9 per cent in the angle average and by 7–12 per cent depending on the viewing angle, comparable to the ≈ 10 \approx10 ≈ 10 per cent found for Figure 2 . Doubling the number of eigenmodes (from even n ≤ 100 n\leq100 n ≤ 100 with 200 radial modes per n n n to n ≤ 200 n\leq200 n ≤ 200 with 400) changes the analytic light curves by less than 1 per cent at every viewing angle after t ≈ 5.3 d t\approx5.3\,\mathrm{d} t ≈ 5.3 d , and by 0.005 per cent averaged over 8–12 d.
Taken together, Figure 2 and Figure 3 establish that, for both of the asymmetries considered in this work, the analytic solution reproduces the MC light curve to better than 5 and 12 per cent, respectively, at every viewing angle between t ≈ 10 t\approx10 t ≈ 10 and 40 d. In the oblate test, the largest residuals occur on the rise, at t ≈ 10 t\approx10 t ≈ 10 d, and from t ≈ 15 t\approx15 t ≈ 15 d onward the residual is below 6 per cent; in the off-centre test the largest residual, 4.4 per cent, occurs at t ≈ 35 t\approx35 t ≈ 35 d towards the 56 N i {}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} 56 Ni -facing pole. These residuals are obtained over a maximal spread of L p L_p L p with viewing angles of 56 (off-centre) and 74 (oblate) per cent in the two tests.
The same test for the 19 off-centre ignition models and the six collision models gives convergence to 1 per cent at every viewing angle after t = 1.3 t=1.3 t = 1.3 –5.2 d (latest for the 0.8 M ⊙ 0.8\,M_\odot 0.8 M ⊙ models) and 2.0–3.0 d, respectively, well before the peak; t p e a k t_{\rm peak} t peak , L p L_p L p and L 30 / L p L_{30}/L_p L 30 / L p change by less than 0.02 per cent.
At later times, the residual is antisymmetric in viewing angle: the MC viewing-angle contrast decays as the ejecta become optically thin, whereas the analytic contrast does not. This is the expected breakdown of the optically thick description of the RT calculation discussed in Section 2: the analytic solution approaches a non-zero quasi-steady angular pattern, whose leading-multipole estimate is given in Appendix B2. For the off-centre test, the analytic solution at t ≈ 60 t\approx60 t ≈ 60 d has an outer-bin spread of 37.8 per cent, in close agreement with the 38.2 per cent leading-dipole estimate. For the oblate test, however, the exact analytic solution approaches a pole-on to edge-on spread of 58.8 per cent, rather than the 48 per cent predicted by the first-order quadrupole expression, ( 39 / 100 ) ∣ X ∣ (39/100)|X| ( 39/100 ) ∣ X ∣ with $X=1.22 for ξ s = 0.9245 \xi_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.9245 ξ s = 0.9245 and f = 0.6966 f = 0.6966 f = 0.6966 (Section 4). This difference is due to the first-order expansion in the flattening, rather than to the quasi-steady approximation. Those quasi-steady relations are discussed in Section 4. This is why the comparison is most meaningful over the optically thick epochs, where the agreement remains at the few-per-cent level.
This paper has been typeset from a TeX/LaTeX file prepared by the author.