betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

An analytic diffusion model for viewing-angle effects in explosive transients

Abstract

The tight observed relation between the peak bolometric luminosity, LpL_{\mathrm p}, and the width ratio L30/LpL_{30}/L_{\mathrm p} of Type Ia supernovae, with L30L_{30} the luminosity 30 d after explosion, makes viewing-angle effects a useful test of explosion models. We develop an analytic diffusion model for homologously expanding asymmetric ejecta with uniform density and grey opacity, based on a Green's-function solution and an Eddington surface-emission prescription, and obtain angle-dependent light curves for a displaced spherical source and for oblate ejecta. We validate them against Monte Carlo (MC) radiative transfer and derive geometric approximations to the peak-luminosity anisotropy. For a displaced spherical source, the quasi-steady approximation, equivalent to stationary diffusion in frozen ejecta, gives Lp(θ)/Lpavg≃1+(17/8)zoffcos⁡θL_{\mathrm p}(θ)/L_{\mathrm p}^{\mathrm{avg}}\simeq1+(17/8)z_{\mathrm{off}}\cosθ, where zoffz_{\mathrm{off}} is the displacement in units of the ejecta radius, θθ the viewing angle from the displacement axis, and LpavgL_{\mathrm p}^{\mathrm{avg}} the angle-averaged peak. This dipole is ≈10\mathord{\approx}10 per cent below the finite-time value in the tested configurations. For oblate ejecta, the leading term is quadrupolar and is set by a single shape parameter. Effective models of 19 off-centre sub-Chandrasekhar explosions recover the MC peak times, peak luminosities, and width ratios to median errors of 3, 4, and 6 per cent, and the extent in LpL_{\mathrm p} of the MC tracks, but underestimate the width-ratio variation with viewing angle by a factor of 2 to 3. An oblate construction captures the scale of peak luminosity variations in six equal-mass white-dwarf collisions. The model tracks remain inconsistent with the observed distribution, and for asymmetric models the transverse viewing-angle variation adds to the tension.

Introduction

The peak bolometric luminosity LpL_{\mathrm{p}} of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) correlates tightly with the width ratio L30/LpL_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}, where L30L_{30} is the bolometric luminosity 30 days after explosion (Sharon et al. 2025). This early-time relation complements the relation between the synthesized 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} mass, M56NiM_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}, and the γ\gamma-ray escape time, t0t_{0} (Wygoda et al. 2019a; Sharon & Kushnir 2020), which requires late-time observations (t∼100t\sim100 d), and for multidimensional models, radiative-transfer (RT) calculations whose uncertainties grow as the ejecta become optically thin (different RT codes applied to identical ejecta diverge increasingly with time, even in the bolometric light curve; Blondin et al. 2022). Because LpL_{\mathrm{p}} and L30/LpL_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}} correlate closely with M56NiM_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} and t0t_{0}, the early-time relation carries similar information about the explosion while using only the first 30 d, when the ejecta are optically thick, and the RT codes agree much better. An asymmetric explosion occupies a track in the luminosity–width plane as the viewing angle changes. The off-centre ignition models in Figure 1 move across the observed sequence: viewing the nickel-rich sides makes them brighter and reduces L30/LpL_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}. We seek an analytic relation between this variation and the source displacement or the ejecta shape.

Viewing-angle tracks in the luminosity–width plane

Figure 1. Viewing-angle tracks in the luminosity–width plane from (a) URILIGHT Monte Carlo RT (Wygoda et al. 2019a) and (b) the analytic toy models of this work, over the observed SNe Ia of Sharon et al. (2025) (grey, 1σ1\sigma error bars). Squares: the 19 off-centre ignition models (Table C1), coloured by the ignition offset ζig\zeta_{\rm ig} (in WD radii) and labelled by ejecta mass MM; circles: the six equal-mass WD collisions (Table D1), labelled by the WD masses in M⊙M_{\odot}. Small symbols are the ten bins in cos⁡θk\cos\theta_k, where θk\theta_k is the angle between the line of sight and the symmetry axis (cos⁡θk=+1\cos\theta_k=+1 faces the displaced 56^{56}Ni; the collision axis for the collisions), joined into a track; the large open symbol is the angle-averaged light curve. The URILIGHT collision tracks nearly retrace themselves (approximate equatorial symmetry), and the exactly symmetric analytic ones are folded onto ∣cos⁡θk∣|\cos\theta_k|. Toward the near-56^{56}Ni-facing pole the off-centre tracks become brighter and narrower, moving across the observed sequence. The same tracks are shown in Figure C4.

Figure 1 reproduces the observed relation together with the viewing-angle tracks of the models studied here. The observed sample separates into two regimes: faster-declining events with L30/Lp<0.5L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}<0.5, which form a rising sequence spanning Lp≈0.1L_{\mathrm{p}}\approx0.1–1.4×10431.4\times10^{43} erg s−1^{-1}, and slower, brighter events with L30/Lp>0.5L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}>0.5, which cluster at Lp∼1.2L_{\mathrm{p}}\sim1.2–1.65×10431.65\times10^{43} erg s−1^{-1}; the sub-Chandrasekhar models remain at L30/Lp<0.45L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}<0.45 over varying angle, whereas most of the collision models occupy L30/Lp>0.5L_{30}/L_{\mathrm{p}}>0.5. The angle-averaged properties of these models are in tension with the observations (Sharon et al. 2025), and their viewing-angle tracks are long: LpL_{\mathrm{p}} changes by tens of per cent between the extreme viewing angles of the asymmetric models of both families (§ 5–§ 7). Whether such transverse variations are consistent with the observed distribution is a question of the residuals about the relation (§ 8); answering it requires both reliable RT calculations of the spread and an understanding of its physical origin, which properties of the ejecta control it and how strongly. This is the main motivation for the present work.

We focus on the two families of multidimensional models analysed by Sharon et al. (2025). The first is the off-centre ignition of sub-Chandrasekhar white dwarfs (WDs), motivated by the double-detonation scenario, in which a helium-shell detonation drives a converging shock that ignites the carbon–oxygen (CO) core off centre (Nomoto 1982a,b; Livne 1990; Woosley & Weaver 1994; Fink et al. 2010; Shen & Bildsten 2014), possibly for thin helium shells (Bildsten et al. 2007; Fink et al. 2007; Moore et al. 2013; Shen & Moore 2014; Townsley et al. 2019; Boos et al. 2021). The models used by Sharon et al. (2025), and here, are those of Schinasi-Lemberg & Kushnir (2025), who isolate the effect of off-centre ignition by igniting bare CO WDs at prescribed points along the symmetry axis; the ejecta are approximately spherical, while the 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} distribution is displaced along the axis. The second family is the head-on collision of two WDs (Rosswog et al. 2009; Raskin et al. 2010; Kushnir et al. 2013), for which Sharon et al. (2025) used the two-dimensional models of Kushnir et al. (2013); here the ejecta themselves are flattened along the collision axis, together with the 56^{56}Ni-rich region. We represent the two cases by a displaced spherical source inside a spherical boundary and by concentric oblate source and boundary spheroids, respectively.

Numerical RT studies have established substantial viewing-angle effects in asymmetric supernova ejecta, for ellipsoidal ejecta (Höflich 1991; Sim 2007), two-dimensional detonating failed-deflagration models (Kasen & Plewa 2007) and head-on WD collisions (Sharon et al. 2025), as well as for aspherical kilonova ejecta (Darbha & Kasen 2020). In particular, Sim et al. (2007) found nearly linear angular variations of the peak magnitude and rise time for an offset 56^{56}Ni region in uniform-density ejecta. Analytic radioactive light-curve models describe the competition between heating, diffusion and expansion (Colgate & McKee 1969; Arnett 1982; Pinto & Eastman 2000a; Pinto & Eastman 2000b); Arnett’s solution retains the fundamental diffusion mode, with the corollary that the luminosity at maximum equals the instantaneous deposition rate, and Pinto & Eastman (2000a) showed with the full set of eigenmodes how the location of the 56^{56}Ni shapes the rise. The time-weighted energy constraint of Katz et al. (2013) is independent of geometry and of the diffusion approximation, and was used by Khatami & Kasen (2019) to relate the peak time and the peak luminosity, while Kushnir & Katz (2019) mapped diffusion in homologous expansion onto a static problem in general geometry and obtained explicit spherical solutions by convolving the eigenmode impulse response with the deposition history. Darbha & Kasen (2020) also give a simple analytic estimate of directional light curves from the projected photospheric area. Here we derive explicit eigenfunction diffusion solutions for the two asymmetric geometries.

We solve diffusion in homologously expanding uniform-density ejecta for a displaced spherical source and for concentric oblate source and boundary geometries, and an Eddington surface-emission law projects the emergent flux toward an observer. The leading quasi-steady signal is dipolar for a displaced sphere and quadrupolar for oblate ejecta; its accuracy at peak is tested against the time-dependent solutions. We caution that the displacement zoffz_{\rm off} is an effective parameter of a uniform-density toy model rather than a measure of the 56^{56}Ni centroid of a stratified ejecta (Section 5.2). Sections 2–4 develop and validate the framework. Sections 5–7 test effective representations of numerical explosions, separating agreement in peak luminosity from the larger errors in width-ratio variation: as Figure 1 shows, the analytic tracks reproduce the location, direction, and extent in LpL_{\rm p} of the URILIGHT tracks, and the dominant systematic mismatch is in the width-ratio variation. § 8 discusses the implications and limits; the derivations and complete model results are given in the appendices.

The Analytic Diffusion Framework

Following Kushnir & Katz (2019), we describe the diffusion of radiation energy within homologously expanding ejecta using velocity coordinates v=x/t\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{x}/t. By introducing scaled variables

eˉ=t4e,ρˉ=t3ρ,ϵˉ=t3ϵ,tˉ=12t2,(1)\bar{e}=t^{4}e,\qquad\bar{\rho}=t^{3}\rho,\qquad\bar{\epsilon}=t^{3}\epsilon,\qquad\bar{t}=\frac{1}{2}t^{2}, \tag*{(1)}

where ee is the radiation energy density per unit volume, ρ\rho the mass density, ϵ\epsilon the local energy generation rate per unit volume, and κ\kappa the effective opacity; the explicit time dependence from adiabatic expansion is absorbed. The problem transforms into a static diffusion equation. For the uniform velocity-space density and constant grey opacity adopted in the analytic solutions below, the diffusion coefficient D≡c/(3κρˉv)D \equiv c/(3\kappa\bar{\rho}v) is constant:

∂eˉ∂tˉ−D∇2eˉ=ϵˉ,D=c3κρˉv.(2)\frac{\partial\bar{e}}{\partial\bar{t}}-D\nabla^{2}\bar{e}=\bar{\epsilon},\qquad D=\frac{c}{3\kappa\bar{\rho}v}. \tag*{(2)}

The scaled global energy generation rate Qˉ\bar{Q}, luminosity Lˉ\bar{L}, and total radiation energy Eˉ\bar{E} are related to their physical counterparts by Qˉ=Q\bar{Q}=Q, Lˉ=L\bar{L}=L, and Eˉ=E/t\bar{E}=E/t.

To solve for an arbitrary heating source, we define the impulse response. When energy deposition occurs over a negligibly short interval at tˉδ\bar{t}_{\delta}, the source term is a delta function,

ϵˉ(v,t)=ϵˉδ(v)δ(t−tˉδ).(3)\bar{\epsilon}(v,t)=\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v)\delta(t-\bar{t}_{\delta}). \tag*{(3)}

Here ϵˉδ(v)\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v) is the spatial distribution of injected energy in velocity space, normalized to unit scaled energy, ∫ϵˉδ d3v=1\int\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}\,d^{3}v=1, so that the impulse response below is the response to unit deposited energy (in Appendix § 11 the impulse carries an arbitrary scaled energy Eˉδ\bar{E}_{\delta}, which divides out of the normalized response). For tˉ>tˉδ\bar{t}>\bar{t}_{\delta}, the system evolves according to the homogeneous diffusion equation with initial condition eˉ(v,tˉδ)=ϵˉδ(v)\bar{e}(v,\bar{t}_{\delta})=\bar{\epsilon}_{\delta}(v). This impulse solution serves as the Green’s function of the system. For a continuous, time-dependent heating rate Q(t)Q(t) with a fixed spatial distribution, the total luminosity is constructed via the convolution

L(tˉ)=∫0tˉdtˉ′ Q(tˉ′)Lδ(tˉ−tˉ′),(4)L(\bar{t})=\int_{0}^{\bar{t}}d\bar{t}^{\prime}\,Q(\bar{t}^{\prime})L_{\delta}(\bar{t}-\bar{t}^{\prime}), \tag*{(4)}

where Lδ(tˉ)L_{\delta}(\bar{t}) is the impulse-response luminosity.

The analytic solutions below assume a uniform density in velocity space, a constant grey opacity, and a sharp ejecta edge, on which we impose the absorbing (Dirichlet) condition eˉ=0\bar{e}=0, the standard optically thick approximation for a free surface. The diffusion operator on this bounded domain has a discrete set of eigenfunctions, so the solution is an eigenfunction expansion in which each mode decays exponentially in tˉ\bar{t} at a rate set by its eigenvalue; the general solution and the two geometries are derived in Appendix § 11, and the quasi-steady angular pattern reached under continuous heating in Appendix B2. Both the diffusion equation and the Eddington closure introduced below describe optically thick transport. For uniform-density ejecta the centre-to-surface optical depth is τ(t)=3κM/(4πvo2t2)\tau(t)=3\kappa M/(4\pi v_{o}^{2}t^{2}), which for the fiducial parameters of § 3 (M≈1 M⊙M\approx1\,M_{\odot}, κ=0.2 cm2 g−1\kappa=0.2\ {\rm cm}^{2}\,{\rm g}^{-1}, vo≈1.29×104 km s−1v_{o}\approx1.29\times10^{4}\ {\rm km}\,{\rm s}^{-1}) is ≈34\approx34 at 15 d, ≈8\approx8 at 30 d and unity at ≈90\approx90 d. The description is therefore accurate around maximum light and degrades gradually as the ejecta approach transparency; what fails first is the angular structure, since the RT viewing-angle contrast must decay as photons free-stream, whereas the diffusion solution holds it near its quasi-steady pattern, while the angle-averaged luminosity is expected to remain more accurate because both descriptions approach L→QL\rightarrow Q asymptotically (an asymptotic statement, not a guarantee at every epoch; Appendix E and § 5.3 quantify the residuals).

Radioactive Heating

The total energy deposition rate is Q(t)=Qγ(t)fdep(t)+Qpos(t)Q(t)=Q_{\gamma}(t)f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t)+Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t), where Qγ(t)Q_{\gamma}(t) is the direct γ\gamma-ray component, Qpos(t)Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t) accounts for positron kinetic energy, and fdep(t)f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t) is the γ\gamma-ray deposition fraction. The positron kinetic energy is assumed to be deposited locally and in full. The radioactive heating rates are (following Wygoda et al. 2019a, with lifetimes from Junde (1999) and mean decay energies from Ambwani & Sutherland (1988)),

Qγ(t)=M56NiM⊙[6.45e−t/8.76 d+1.38e−t/111.4 d]×1043 erg s−1,(5)Q_{\gamma}(t)=\frac{M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}{M_{\odot}}\left[6.45e^{-t/8.76\,\mathrm{d}}+1.38e^{-t/111.4\,\mathrm{d}}\right]\times10^{43}\ {\rm erg}\ {\rm s}^{-1}, \tag*{(5)}
Qpos(t)=4.64M56NiM⊙[e−t/111.4 d−e−t/8.76 d]×1041 erg s−1,(6)Q_{\mathrm{pos}}(t)=4.64\frac{M_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}}}{M_{\odot}}\left[e^{-t/111.4\,\mathrm{d}}-e^{-t/8.76\,\mathrm{d}}\right]\times10^{41}\ {\rm erg}\ {\rm s}^{-1}, \tag*{(6)}

where M56NiM_{{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}} is the initial 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} mass. We adopt the γ\gamma-ray deposition fraction from Jeffery (1999),

fdep(t)=1−e−t02/t2,(7)f_{\mathrm{dep}}(t)=1-e^{-t_{0}^{2}/t^{2}}, \tag*{(7)}

where t0t_{0} is the characteristic γ\gamma-ray escape time. The limit t0→∞t_{0}\rightarrow\infty corresponds to complete deposition, fdep=1f_{\mathrm{dep}}=1.

Viewing-Angle Luminosity: Eddington Grey-Atmosphere Closure

The diffusion solution provides the impulse surface flux Fδ(rs,t)F_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}_{s},t) emerging from each point rs\boldsymbol{r}_{s} on the sharp ejecta boundary ∂S\partial S. To determine the luminosity seen by a distant observer at a specific orientation, we relate the local flux to the emergent specific intensity using the Eddington grey-atmosphere closure. Assuming a quasi-static, semi-infinite grey atmosphere, the specific intensity at surface point rs\boldsymbol{r}_{s} is

References

  1. [1]Ambwani K., Sutherland P., 1988, ApJ, 325, 820
  2. [2]Arnett W. D., 1982, ApJ, 253, 785
  3. [3]Bildsten L., Shen K. J., Weinberg N. N., Nelemans G., 2007, ApJ, 662, L95
  4. [4]Black C. S., Fesen R. A., Parrent J. T., 2016, MNRAS, 462, 649
  5. [5]Blondin S., et al., 2022, A&A, 668, A163
  6. [6]Boos J. S., Townsley D. M., Shen K. J., Caldwell S., Miles B. J., 2021, ApJ, 919, 126
  7. [7]Colgate S. A., McKee C., 1969, ApJ, 157, 623
  8. [8]Darbha S., Kasen D., 2020, ApJ, 897, 150
  9. [9]DerKacy J. M., et al., 2023, ApJ, 945, L2
  10. [10]Diamond T. R., et al., 2018, ApJ, 861, 119
  11. [11]Dong S., Katz B., Kushnir D., Prieto J. L., 2015, MNRAS, 454, L61
  12. [12]Fink M., Hillebrandt W., Röpke F. K., 2007, A&A, 476, 1133
  13. [13]Fink M., Röpke F. K., Hillebrandt W., Seitenzahl I. R., Sim S. A., Kromer M., 2010, A&A, 514, A53

Paper details

vlnc:W_wpmzrsjv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents