betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Brittle to ductile transitions in glasses: Roles of soft defects and loading geometry

Abstract

Understanding the fracture toughness of glasses is of prime importance for science and technology. We study it here using extensive atomistic simulations in which the interaction potential, glass transition cooling rate and loading geometry are systematically varied, mimicking a broad range of experimentally accessible properties. Glasses' nonequilibrium mechanical disorder is quantified through AgA_{\rm g}, the dimensionless prefactor of the universal spectrum of nonphononic excitations, which measures the abundance of soft glassy defects that affect plastic deformability. We show that while a brittle-to-ductile transition might be induced by reducing the cooling rate, leading to a reduction in AgA_{\rm g}, iso- ⁣Ag\!A_{\rm g} glasses are either brittle or ductile depending on the degree of Poisson contraction under unconstrained uniaxial tension. Eliminating Poisson contraction using constrained tension reveals that iso- ⁣Ag\!A_{\rm g} glasses feature similar toughness, and that varying AgA_{\rm g} under these conditions results in significant toughness variation. Our results highlight the roles played by both soft defects and loading geometry (which affects the activation of defects) in the toughness of glasses.

Introduction

Glasses are intrinsically nonequilibrium materials whose properties may vary vastly with their thermomechanical history, e.g. the cooling rate at which they are formed from a melt [1]. The nonequilibrium nature of glasses is mesoscopically manifested through a broad range of disordered structures, which qualitatively differ from the corresponding ordered structures featured by their crystalline counterparts. Macroscopically, the nonequilibrium nature of glasses may be manifested in a substantial variability in various material properties, even for the very same composition.

One such important material property is the ability of a glass to resist catastrophic failure. The latter is commonly quantified by the fracture toughness, which measures the material resistance to failure in the presence of an initial crack [2]. The value of the fracture toughness reflects multitude of spatiotemporal processes that take place in the material prior to catastrophic failure. In one limit, failure is accompanied by rather localized plastic deformation (cf. Figure 1a, right) and is generally quite abrupt. The fracture toughness is typically small in this case, and failure is commonly termed brittle-like. In the opposite limit, failure is accompanied by significant spatially-extended plastic deformation (cf. Figure 1a, left) and is generally more gradual. The fracture toughness is typically larger in this case, and failure is commonly termed ductile-like.

Computer glasses span a broad range of macroscopic and mesoscopic material properties

Figure 1. Computer glasses span a broad range of macroscopic and mesoscopic material properties. (a) Snapshots of the non-affine plastic deformation during fracture tests with an initial diamond crack for ductile-like (left) and brittle-like (right) failure. The non-affine deformation is quantified by the widely-used Dmin⁡2D_{\min}^{2} field [3], here and throughout this paper, where a darker color is indicative of more intense plastic deformation. (b) The modified Lennard-Jones type potential φ(r)\varphi(r) used in this work (see Methods). φ\varphi is plotted vs. the normalized interparticle distance r/rmin⁡r/r_{\min}, where rmin⁡r_{\min} is the minimum of the potential. The parameter rcr_{\mathrm{c}} controls the strength and range of the attractive term. (c) The shear modulus μ\mu (reported in simulational units, see Methods) vs. the quench rate T˙\dot{T} for various rcr_{\mathrm{c}} values. The color code for the latter is detailed in the legend, and will be adopted throughout the paper. (d) Poisson’s ratio ν\nu vs. T˙\dot{T}. The meaning of the open orange squares is explained in panel (f) below. (e) The vibrational density of states (vDOS) of QLMs for T˙=0.05\dot{T}=0.05 and two values of rcr_{\mathrm{c}} (cf. color code in panel (c)). The peak in the vDOS corresponds to the first (phononic) shear wave. (f) The prefactor AgA_{\mathrm{g}} of the universal nonphononic vDOS D(ω)=Agω4D(\omega)=A_{\mathrm{g}}\omega^{4}, made dimensionless through scaling by ω05\omega_{0}^{5}, as a function of T˙\dot{T}. A narrow band of nearly equal AgA_{\mathrm{g}} values is highlighted by a blurry orange region, and the glasses within this narrow band are marked by open orange squares (the same glasses are marked in panel (d)). (g) The sample-to-sample shear modulus μs\mu_{\mathrm{s}} distributions P(μs/μ)P(\mu_{\mathrm{s}}/\mu) for the same glasses as in (e). μ\mu is the mean (plotted in panel (c)) and the width of one of the distributions, indicative of the magnitude of shear modulus fluctuations, is marked by Δμ\Delta\mu. (h) The dimensionless quantifier of shear modulus fluctuations χ\chi (see Methods for exact definition) is plotted against T˙\dot{T} for various rcr_{\mathrm{c}}’s. The blurry orange region marks iso-χ\chi states (similarly to the iso-AgA_{\mathrm{g}} states in panel (f)). As stated above, the same color code describing different values of rcr_{\mathrm{c}} is maintained throughout this paper.

Understanding the transition between these two modes of failure is an important challenge in materials science [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. Establishing, understanding and predicting structure-dynamics-properties relations in glasses, e.g. in the context of material failure, involve various challenges. First, one should develop tools to quantify the disordered structures featured by glasses. Second, one should identify a certain sub-class of structural degrees of freedom that is relevant for a given macroscopic material property. Third, one should understand the dynamic evolution of these relevant degrees of freedom under some prescribed conditions. Finally, one should be able to coarse-grain over mesoscopic structural degrees of freedom in order to understand how collective dynamics control the macroscopic material property.

Quantifying mesoscopic structural and mechanical disorder in glasses is challenging. One aspect of the challenge is that we generally lack tools and concepts to distinguish one disordered state from another, in sharp contrast to well established “order parameters” in other condensed-matter systems [10]. Another aspect of the challenge is the associated length scales; glassy disorder typically manifests itself on small length scales, usually corresponding to a few atomic distances, which are not directly accessible to currently available experimental techniques in molecular glasses. Consequently, computer glasses — where such length scales are readily accessible — have played important roles in our understanding of glassy disorder [11, 12, 13, 14].

Recently, computer studies revealed and substantiated the existence of low-frequency (soft) nonphononic vibrational modes in glasses [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. These soft vibrational modes (or excitations) have been shown to be quasilocalized in space [16, 17, 22], as opposed to the spatially-extended nature of low-frequency phonons (i.e. plane waves), hence they are termed here quasilocalized modes (QLMs). Moreover, QLMs have been shown to follow a universal vibrational density of states (vDOS) D(ω)∼ω4\mathcal{D}(\omega) \sim\omega^4, where ω\omega is the angular vibrational frequency [14, 15, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28] (cf. examples in Figure 1e). As the ω4\omega^4 law is universal — i.e. independent of the glass composition, interatomic interactions and dimensionality — all of the glass history dependence is encapsulated in the non-universal prefactor AgA_{\mathrm{g}}, defined through D(ω)≡Agω4\mathcal{D}(\omega) \equiv A_{\mathrm{g}} \omega^4. AgA_{\mathrm{g}}, once properly non-dimensionalized (see below), has been shown to provide a measure of the number density of QLMs in a glass [14, 15, 26, 29, 30].

QLMs, in turn, have been shown to correlate with the spatial loci of irreversible rearrangements in glasses, i.e. they statistically correlate with Shear-Transformation-Zones (STZs), the carriers of plasticity in glassy materials [18, 21, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36]. As such, the properly non-dimensionalized AgA_{\mathrm{g}} is directly relevant for plastic deformability, and consequently to the fracture toughness, as it provides a measure of the number of soft defects embedded inside glassy structures [14, 15, 29, 30]. Another measure of mesoscopic mechanical disorder in glasses can be defined using the fluctuations of the shear modulus μ\mu [7, 29, 37, 38, 39]. This measure, denoted hereafter by χ\chi (see Methods and Fig. 1g), has been recently shown to control the rate of wave attenuation in computer glasses [39, 41, 42], i.e. the amplitude of Rayleigh scattering rates in the low-frequency (long-wavelength) limit. In this paper, we will be using AgA_{\mathrm{g}} and χ\chi as quantifiers of mesoscopic glassy disorder, which are directly relevant to the fracture toughness.

AgA_{\mathrm{g}} and χ\chi allow one to compare on equal footing different glasses, either glasses of the same interatomic interactions/composition formed by different thermal protocols or glasses of different interatomic interactions/composition. While existing evidence clearly indicates that AgA_{\mathrm{g}} and χ\chi must play important roles in determining the fracture toughness of these materials, one obviously cannot exclude the possibility that other physical quantities and factors play a role as well. Indeed, some experimental and computational studies [4, 5, 6, 43, 44, 45, 46] suggested that Poisson’s ratio ν\nu plays an important role in determining the fracture toughness of glasses (though some other studies challenged this view [29, 47, 48]). A possible interpretation is that ν\nu is sensitive to the structure of a glass, and in particular that it may be indirectly related to plastic deformability and its sensitivity to shear versus tensile deformation [6, 49], and hence affects the toughness. As such, one can speculate that the observed effect of ν\nu is not qualitatively different from that of AgA_g and χ\chi — indeed we show below that well-defined relations between ν\nu and AgA_g (and χ\chi) exist. It remains unclear, however, whether ν\nu — or more precisely Poisson contraction/effect and other loading geometry effects — also play distinct roles in determining the toughness.

Our goal in this paper is to understand the roles played by soft defects, as quantified by AgA_g and indirectly by χ\chi, and by the loading geometry employed in mechanical tests on the fracture toughness of glasses, in particular on brittle-to-ductile transitions. This goal is achieved by employing extensive computer glass simulations in 3D, which offer a powerful and flexible platform to address the posed questions. To mimic glasses’ compositional variability we employ computer models based on Lennard-Jones interatomic pairwise potentials with a tunable parameter rcr_c (to be accurately defined below), shown recently to give rise to glasses of widely variable properties [29, 50, 51, 52]. We also apply a broad range of cooling rates T˙\dot{T} across the glass transition (to be accurately defined below). In addition, we employ cutting-edge algorithms that allow to generate deeply supercooled glasses [7], to a degree that is comparable or even surpasses that of laboratory glasses. Overall, the range of variability of the macroscopic properties (e.g. μ\mu and ν\nu, cf. Figure 1c-Figure 1d) of our computer glasses is comparable to that observed in laboratory glasses. Finally, we carefully and systematically vary the imposed loading geometry in the fracture toughness tests in order to quantify its effect on the toughness.

We find that the fracture toughness, and in particular brittle-to-ductile transitions, are controlled by both the abundance of soft defects — as quantified by AgA_g (and indirectly by χ\chi) — and by the loading geometry of the fracture test. The latter affects the relative magnitude of shear and tensile deformation experienced by the material, and consequently the emerging plastic dissipation, for a fixed AgA_g. That is, the loading geometry controls the activation of soft defects, whose abundance is controlled by AgA_g. Only under a certain choice of loading geometry, where Poisson contraction can take place, Poisson’s ratio ν\nu can be sensibly used to quantify the fracture toughness together with AgA_g (or χ\chi). These results provide basic insights into the physical origin of the failure resistance of glasses.

Results

In order to study the origin of brittle-to-ductile transitions in glasses, such as the one illustrated in Figure 1a, we first aim at generating computer glasses featuring a broad range of properties. This is achieved by employing the computer glass model put forward in [50], where particles interact via a tunable Lennard-Jones-like pairwise potential (a similar approach was taken in [53]). In particular, the strength and range of the attractive term of the pairwise potential are controlled by a parameter rcr_c, as shown in Figure 1b and accurately defined in Methods. Varying rcr_c, which may qualitatively correspond to varying the glass composition, results in dramatic changes in emergent material properties, as will be discussed and demonstrated soon (see also [29, 51]). In addition, we generate different glasses by quenching equilibrium liquids at a broad range of rates into their arrested glass phase. The cooling rate is quantified by T˙\dot{T}, the dimensionless absolute value of the rate of change of temperature during the quench (see Methods for precise definition). Yet another glass formation protocol, which is not quantified by T˙\dot{T}, is employed and discussed below.

In Figure 1c, we present the shear modulus μ\mu (in simulation units, see Methods) as a function of T˙\dot{T} for various values of rcr_c. The corresponding results for Poisson’s ratio ν\nu are shown in Figure 1d. The range of variation in ν\nu accessed by tuning rcr_c compares well with the one for which the so-called ductile-to-brittle transition is observed in bulk metallic glasses [54], and see Supplementary material for further comparisons between our model’s elastic properties and typical laboratory glasses’ elastic properties. While our model’s macroscopic linear response coefficients make direct contact with laboratory glasses, computer glasses offer unique access to various physical quantities that are not directly accessible to experiments, as highlighted above. In Figure 1e, we present the vDOS of QLMs for two values of rcr_c and a fixed T˙\dot{T}, both revealing the universal D(ω)=Agω4D(\omega)=A_g\omega^4 law. Here and elsewhere, we report frequencies in terms of ω0≡cs/a0\omega_0\equiv c_s/a_0, where csc_s is the (zero frequency) shear wave speed and a0≡(V/N)1/3a_0\equiv(V/N)^{1/3} (VV is the system’s volume containing NN particles). The observed prefactor AgA_g vastly varies between the two cases. AgA_g, made dimensionless through multiplication by ω05\omega_0^5, is presented in Figure 1f for all T˙\dot{T} and rcr_c values used in Figure 1c-Figure 1d. The dimensionless AgA_g (hereafter we exclusively refer to the dimensionless one) indeed reveals large variability. Interestingly, different combinations of T˙\dot{T} and rcr_c result in nearly identical AgA_g values (marked by open orange squares), a property that will be used below.

AgA_g, providing a measure of the abundance of soft defects inside a glass [15], serves as a disorder quantifier that is relevant for plastic deformability and fracture toughness. Another quantifier of mechanical disorder in glasses can be obtained by considering the distribution of the local shear modulus, probed by studying a large number of systems of size NN [39, 52]. In Figure 1h we present the shear modulus distributions corresponding to the two cases shown in Figure 1e. It is observed that smaller AgA_g glasses feature reduced shear modulus flucfluctuations Δμ/μ\Delta\mu/\mu. The latter can be used to construct an NN-independent quantifier of mechanical disorder in the form χ≡(Δμ/μ)N\chi\equiv(\Delta\mu/\mu)\sqrt{N} [39, 41, 42, 52]. The dependence of χ\chi on both rcr_c and T˙\dot{T} is presented in Figure 1g, and the relation between χ\chi and AgA_g is further discussed below (cf. Figure 3d and Supplementary material). Next, we start considering the fracture toughness of the glasses at hand.

Snapshots of non-affine plastic deformation, stress-strain curves, and phase diagrams

Figure 3. The fracture toughness depends on both the number of soft defects, quantified by AgA_g, and on Poisson contraction, quantified by ν\nu, under unconstrained uniaxial tension. (a) Snapshots of the non-affine plastic deformation at 15% strain in the rcr_c–T˙\dot{T} parametric plane. (b) Strain-strain curve for a poorly-annealed (high T˙\dot{T}, thin curves) and well-annealed (low T˙\dot{T}, thick curves) glasses with various rcr_c. (c) AgA_g vs. ν\nu, where ductile-like glasses correspond to full symbols and brittle-like to empty ones. The orange squares and the blurry region indicate glasses with a nearly identical density of OLMs (iso-AgA_g). (d) AgA_g vs. χ\chi, roughly following a power-law relation Ag∼χ10/3A_g \sim\chi^{10/3} for all glasses (see discussion in the Supplementary material).

Reduction in cooling rate can induce a ductile-to-brittle transition

In order to probe the fracture toughness we consider 3D glass samples containing an initial central crack of fixed geometry that cuts through the sample. In particular, we choose a diamond-shaped crack of fixed length and main vertex angle, which give rise to traction-free crack surfaces. The main vertex angle is chosen to be sufficiently small in order to reproduce the classical square root singularity of linear elastic fracture mechanics [2], see Supplementary material for additional details. The initial crack length is chosen to be sufficiently larger than the particle size and sufficiently smaller than the sample’s dimensions in order to ensure reasonable scale separation, though we cannot entirely exclude any finite size effects (see Supplementary material). All fracture toughness calculations are performed under quasi-static athermal conditions, i.e. vanishing applied strain-rate and zero temperature, as our focus is on the effect of glass structure and loading geometry on the toughness. We first consider the effect of varying the cooling rate T˙\dot{T}

on the glass resistance to failure under unconstrained uniaxial tension, where ‘unconstrained’ means that the lateral edges (perpendicular to the tensile axis) are traction-free and hence free to contract. We focus here on the rc=1.3r_c=1.3 glasses ensemble, and plot in Figure 2a the tensile stress-strain curves for four different cooling rates T˙\dot{T} (see legend). It is observed that for the two largest T˙\dot{T} values, the corresponding glasses feature gradual stress relaxation after reaching a peak stress, with no clear sign of catastrophic failure. For the two smallest T˙\dot{T} values, however, the glass appears to lose its load-bearing capacity at a well-defined strain level, indicating catastrophic failure. Consequently, there appears to exist a cooling rate that induces a ductile-to-brittle transition, as was also demonstrated in previous work [9, 55, 56, 57]. This is corroborated by the spatiotemporal dynamics of the deformed samples, as demonstrated in Figure 2b, where snapshots at 15% strain are shown. Consistent with the stress-strain curves, we observe that while glasses formed under the two highest cooling rates feature a blunted crack accompanied by large scale plastic deformation (darker regions, see figure caption), glasses cooled at the two lowest rates feature a crack that propagates through the samples, accompanied by rather localized plastic deformation.

Stress-strain curves and non-affine plastic deformation for glasses cooled at different rates

Figure 2. A ductile-to-brittle transition induced by varying the cooling rate through the glass transition. (a) Tensile stress-strain curves (unconstrained uniaxial tension) of glasses with rc=1.3r_c=1.3, prepared at various quench rates T˙\dot{T} (see legend). (b) The corresponding non-affine plastic deformation computed at ϵ=0.15\epsilon=0.15.

It is known that varying the cooling rate T˙\dot{T} leads to varying glass structures and consequently to variation in many material properties of a glass [14, 58, 59]. Our next goal is to understand which physical properties control the ductile-to-brittle transition observed in Figure 2, when T˙\dot{T} is varied.

Do soft defects exclusively control the ductile-to-brittle transition? The role of Poisson contraction under unconstrain

As explained in the Introduction, AgA_g — whose T˙\dot{T} dependence is presented in Figure 1f — is a natural candidate for controlling the observed ductile-to-brittle transition. To test this natural expectation, we cannot restrict ourselves to a single rcr_c value; rather, we employ glasses cooled at different quench rates T˙\dot{T} and of different interaction parameters rcr_c that nevertheless share nearly the same (dimensionless) AgA_g. These glasses, which are marked by open orange squares in Figure 1f, are expected to feature similar resistance to failure — if indeed AgA_g fully controls the fracture toughness of glasses. In Figure 3a we plot 15%-strain snapshots in the rcr_c–T˙\dot{T} parametric plane (covering the whole range of employed parameters) — similarly to Figure 2b (in fact, the latter is reproduced here in the third row from the top) —, where the nearly iso-AgA_g are highlighted by open orange rectangles. It is observed that iso-AgA_g glasses are either brittle-like or ductile-like, indicating that AgA_g does not exclusively control the fracture toughness under the present conditions (i.e. under unconstrained uniaxial tension). This conclusion is corroborated by the stress-strain curves presented in Figure 3b.

What additional physical quantities/factors/processes, which also vary with T˙\dot{T}, play a role in ductile-to-brittle transitions in glasses? These, once identified, should allow to differentiate between the qualitatively different behaviors observed among the iso-AgA_g glasses, highlighted by open orange rectangles in Figure 3a. As explained in the Introduction, there exists some evidence [4, 5, 6, 43, 44, 45, 46] that Poisson’s ratio ν\nu might affect the fracture toughness of glasses. The T˙\dot{T} dependence of ν\nu for our glasses is presented in Figure 1d, clearly indicating that iso-AgA_g glasses feature different ν\nu’s (marked by open orange squares). Consequently, we present in Figure 3c a brittle-ductile phase diagram in the AgA_g–ν\nu plane, where ductile-like glasses correspond to full symbols and brittle-like to empty ones (we include data for all of our glasses, across the full range of T˙\dot{T} and rcr_c values employed, as in Figure 1). It is observed that iso-AgA_g glasses of relatively high ν\nu are ductile-like, while those with smaller ν\nu are brittle-like. This indicates that ν\nu might indeed plays a role in the fracture toughness of glasses.

What is the physical (and causal) effect of ν\nu on the fracture toughness? Before setting out to address this important question, we aim at further substantiating the claim that both glassy disorder — as quantified by either AgA_g or χ\chi — and some effect that is related to ν\nu play a role in determining the fracture toughness of glasses.

in determining the fracture toughness of glasses. The results presented in Figure 3c clearly support this claim, yet for relatively large values of rcr_c it is impossible to reach sufficiently small AgA_g levels to probe the brittle regime using conventional Molecular Dynamics (in which glasses are formed by quenching their corresponding liquids). Consequently, we employ below recently introduced computer algorithms that allow the generation of glassy solids featuring Ag→0A_g \to0, qualitatively representing extreme supercooling conditions.

To this aim, we first note that as shown in Figure 3d, glasses form by quenching a liquid feature a clear relation between AgA_g and χ\chi (see also Supplementary material). The existence of such a relation, which appears to be weakly dependent on rcr_c, suggests that for these glasses one can approximately use AgA_g and χ\chi interchangeably. This is not the case for systems featuring Ag→0A_g \to0. The latter can be generated by a protocol that is referred to in what follows as the FSP algorithm, described in detail in Methods and in [7]; forming a computer glass using the FSP algorithm amounts to minimizing an augmented potential parameterized by a stiffness kλk_\lambda that controls the mechanical noise of the resulting glasses (while rcr_c can still be varied, see Methods), with lower-kλk_\lambda FSP glasses featuring less mechanical fluctuations [7]. As is now established, FSP glasses can feature a gap in their non-phononic vDOS [7] for sufficiently small kλk_\lambda, and in particular in this limit they do not feature the ω4\omega^4 law. That is, lower-kλk_\lambda FSP glasses essentially feature Ag→0A_g \to0. Yet, these glassy solids still exhibit a finite and well-defined χ\chi, as demonstrated in Figure 4a. Moreover, ν\nu also varies systematically with kλk_\lambda and rcr_c, as shown in Figure 4b.

Brittle-ductile phase diagram in the $\chi$-$\nu$ plane under unconstrained uniaxial tension

Figure 4. Brittle-ductile phase diagram in the χ\chi-ν\nu plane under unconstrained uniaxial tension. (a) χ\chi vs. the stiffness parameter kλk_\lambda of FSP glasses. (b) The corresponding ν(kλ)\nu(k_\lambda). (c) Unconstrained uniaxial tension stress-strain curves for glasses with rc=1.5r_c=1.5, prepared with different stiffness kλk_\lambda as indicated in the legend. Snapshots show the non-affine deformation at 15% strain. See text for additional discussion. (d) Ductile-brittle phase diagram in the χ\chi-ν\nu plane for FSP glasses, where ductile-like glasses correspond to full symbols and brittle-like to empty ones. (inset) the same, but for glasses prepared via a conventional MD quench. The results presented in the inset correspond to those already presented in Figure 3c-Figure 3d.

The merit of FSP glasses in the present context is evident from panels (a) and (b) of Figure 4. That is, we have at hand glasses with Ag→0A_g \to0 (in the low kλk_\lambda regime), whose χ\chi and ν\nu can be systematically varied. Consequently, FSP glasses are most suitable for exploring the ductile-to-brittle transition in terms of both χ\chi and ν\nu, providing access to broader region of the brittle-like phase. In Figure 4c, we present the stress-strain curves of FSP glasses with rc=1.5r_c=1.5 for three value of kλk_\lambda, together with spatial snapshots of each glass at a late stage in the loading process. For the largest kλk_\lambda value (kλ=1000k_\lambda=1000), the behavior is ductile-like, exhibiting extensive (system covering) plastic deformation and steady-state flow, essentially being insensitive to the initial crack. For the smallest kλk_\lambda value (kλ=50k_\lambda=50), we enter into the brittle-like regime, where catastrophic failure takes place, accompanied by localized plastic deformation near the crack (which is perpendicular to the tensile axis) and an abrupt drop in the stress when the sample loses its load-bearing capacity. Interestingly, for the intermediate kλk_\lambda value (kλ=100k_\lambda=100), the initial crack started growing along an inclined shear-band (resulting in a finite abrupt stress drop), but eventually plastic deformation in the shear-band took over (resulting in a gradual stress relaxation towards a plateau), with no catastrophic failure.

We performed an extensive analysis of all FSP glasses at hand (the four rcr_c values studied earlier and a broad range of kλk_\lambda values) and present the results in Figure 4d in a phase-diagram in the χ\chi-ν\nu plane, where a ductile-like behavior corresponds to full squares (color code as in Figure 1) and a brittle-like behavior corresponds to empty squares. First, it is observed that indeed FSP glasses allow to explore a broader region of the brittle-like phase. Second, and most importantly, it is observed that both χ\chi and ν\nu (more precisely some effect that is related to ν\nu) play a role in the ductile-to-brittle transition, as is evident from the curved phase boundary (a blurry region is added as a guide to the eye).

Finally, we add in the inset the results for the glasses formed by quenching a liquid — presented earlier in Figure 3 (but not in the χ\chi-ν\nu plane). Interestingly, despite the widely different glass formation protocols involved, the two classes of glasses appear to reveal a qualitatively similar ductile-brittle phase diagram in the χ\chi-ν\nu plane, where both decreasing χ\chi and ν\nu promote a brittle-like behavior. It is important to note again that the results presented in Figure 4d were obtained for our choice of initial crack of fixed geometry and dimensions (see also Supplementary material); varying the latter may change quantitative aspects of the results, but the combined effect of χ\chi and ν\nu on the fracture toughness under unconstrained uniaxial tension conditions is general. Once this is established, we focus our attention on the question posed above regarding the physical (and causal) effect of ν\nu on the fracture toughness, which is addressed next.

The interplay of loading geometry and plastic deformability: Constrained tension and soft defects again

Poisson’s ratio ν\nu is a linear elastic (reversible) response coefficient that quantifies the relative transverse contraction of a material under unconstrained (transversely-free) uniaxial tension. In assessing the relevance of ν\nu to the fracture toughness of glasses, one can a priori distinguish two qualitatively different classes of physical effects. First, ν\nu can be viewed as a directly and easily measurable quantity that allows to indirectly probe nonlinear irreversible response coefficients that are relevant for plastic deformability and toughness. Indeed, ν\nu is expected to vary when the material structure and interactions vary, and in particular it exhibits systematic variations with AgA_g and χ\chi, as demonstrated in Figure 3-Figure 4. Second, ν\nu — as a linear elastic coefficient — may affect the geometry of deformation glasses experience under external driving forces. In particular, in the unconstrained uniaxial tension tests exclusively considered up to now, ν\nu controls the degree of Poisson contraction, which in turn determines

the relative magnitude of tensile and shear deformation. That is, ν\nu in this loading geometry will affect the activation of soft defects (whose number is controlled by AgA_g), which are generally more sensitive to shear deformation.

As physically relevant disorder measures such as AgA_g and χ\chi have been identified and quantified, we hypothesize that a linear elastic response coefficient such as ν\nu does not contain additional physical information about plastic deformability, on top of AgA_g and/or χ\chi. Consequently, while in the absence of well-founded quantifiers of glassy disorder one may use ν\nu as some rough proxy of disorder, when these are at hand and taken into account — as is the case here — the effect of ν\nu in the phase diagram of Figure 4d strongly points towards the second possibility discussed above. That is, one needs to understand the role of the deformation/loading geometry on the fracture toughness, both in relation to ν\nu and in more general terms.

To address the latter, we introduce here the biaxiality ratio RR (cf. Figure 5), defined as R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥R=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}, where ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} is the tensile/extensional strain and ϵ⊥\epsilon_{\perp} corresponds to the transverse strains, i.e. the strain components in the directions perpendicular to the applied tension axis. The main utility of RR is that it quantifies the relative importance of tensile and shear deformation imposed by the loading geometry, and since soft defects (STZs) are most sensitive to shear deformation [3], RR offers a simple measure of the fraction of soft defects being activated under a certain loading geometry (while their number is controlled by AgA_g). Since, in principle, ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} and ϵ⊥\epsilon_{\perp} can be independently controlled, RR can take any value (and can even evolve during a mechanical test). Yet, we focus here on a few cases that are most relevant to our discussion. For pure shear deformation, defined by the absence of linear dilatational strain (ϵ∥+2ϵ⊥=0\epsilon_{\parallel}+2\epsilon_{\perp}=0), we have R=1/2R=1/2. As plastic deformation in glasses is most sensitive to shearing [3], this value of RR is expected to facilitate a more plastic response, see Figure 5c. For the unconstrained uniaxial tension loading geometry considered up to now, we have R=ν≤1/2R=\nu\leq1/2; that is, RR in this loading geometry is determined by a material property, quantified by ν\nu. Therefore, we see that reducing ν\nu in the unconstrained loading configuration tends to increase the relative importance of tensile deformation (cf. Figure 5a), which may facilitate more brittle-like behavior, in qualitative agreement with the results of Figure 4d.

Different loading geometries and their effect on the imposed deformation

Figure 5. Different loading geometries and their effect on the imposed deformation. (a) An illustration of a 2D projection of a 3D system (top), where the grey square of dimensions L0×L0L_0 \times L_0 represents the undeformed state. Under unconstrained uniaxial tension loading (applied strain ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} in the vertical direction), the system is free to contract in the two transverse/lateral directions (the out-of-plane direction is not shown), resulting in strain of magnitude ϵ⊥<0\epsilon_{\perp}<0, see the empty rectangle (illustrating the deformed state). In this loading geometry, one has R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥=ν≤1/2R=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}=\nu\leq1/2, i.e. the relative importance of tensile and shear deformation is determined in this loading geometry by Poisson’s ratio ν\nu. (b) The same as panel (a), but for constrained tension loading. In this loading geometry, one has ϵ⊥=0\epsilon_{\perp}=0, resulting in R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥=0R=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}=0 (see empty rectangle, and note that the grey L0×L0L_0\times L_0 square is the same as in panel (a)). (c) The same as panels (a) and (b), but for pure shear loading. In this loading geometry, one has ϵ⊥=−1/2ϵ∥\epsilon_{\perp}=-1/2\epsilon_{\parallel}, resulting in R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥=1/2R=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}=1/2 (see empty rectangle, and note that again the grey L0×L0L_0\times L_0 square is the same as in panels (a) and (b)). At the bottom of each panel we present a pair of ϵ∥=0.15\epsilon_{\parallel}=0.15 snapshots, with ν=0.367\nu=0.367 (red, left) and ν=0.275\nu=0.275 (blue, right), deformed under the stated RR value. It is observed that the smaller RR, the more localized plastic deformation is, and correspondingly the more brittle-like failure is.

As RR is in general not a material property, but can rather be controlled through the imposed loading geometry, one can use it to disentangle the roles of AgA_g (or χ\chi) — i.e. the role of soft defects — and of the loading geometry on the fracture toughness. To that aim, we performed constrained tension tests, where the transverse/lateral boundaries (perpendicular to the main tensile axis) are held fixed, i.e. ϵ⊥=0\epsilon_{\perp}=0. This case corresponds to R=0R=0, see Figure 5b and Methods for additional discussion. The loading geometry corresponding to R=0R=0 allows to eliminate the role of ν\nu as a linear response coefficient that controls Poisson contraction. Consequently, we expect the fracture toughness in this case to be determined by AgA_g. Since for R=0R=0, which obviously favors tensile deformation, catastrophic failure is unavoidable, AgA_g is expected to affect the value of the fracture toughness, not strictly a brittle-to-ductile transition. In particular, we expect iso-AgA_g glasses to feature very similar toughness under constrained tension, despite having different ν\nu’s, and the toughness to systematically increase with AgA_g for the same glass cooled at different rates T˙\dot{T}.

These predictions are tested in Figure 6, where we first show in panel (a) that different glasses (i.e. different rcr_c values) feature rather large variability in their failure behavior under constrained tension for a fixed cooling rate T˙\dot{T} (here we present stress-strain curves; a quantitative measure of the fracture resistance is presented in panels (c) and (d)). The discussion above predicts that if one repeats the calculations of Figure 6a for different glasses featuring nearly the same AgA_g, under the same constrained tension loading geometry (R=0R=0), most of the variability in the failure behavior would be gone. The results of these calculations are presented in Figure 6b, where it is indeed observed that the stress-strain curves of iso-AgA_g glasses featuring different ν\nu values, approximately collapse, as predicted. These results should be compared to — and contrasted with — the results shown in Figure 3c obtained under unconstrained uniaxial tension. We stress that these results strongly suggest that once the geometrical Poisson contraction is eliminated (or more generally when RR is prescribed), Poisson’s ratio ν\nu does not play a major role in determining the toughness of glasses.

Stress-strain curves and toughness plots for constrained tension

Figure 6. Disentangling the effect of soft defects and loading geometry on the toughness. (a) Stress-strain curves under constrained tension, for glasses prepared at a high quench rate T˙=0.02\dot{T}=0.02 and different rcr_c’s. See text and Methods for the exact definitions of σ∥\sigma_{\parallel}, ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} and E∥E_{\parallel}. (b) The same as in panel (a), but for iso-AgA_g glasses, featuring approximate collapse. (c) The Toughness (computed as the integral over the stress-strain curve and normalized by E∥E_{\parallel}, see text for details) vs. AgA_g. (d) The Toughness vs. T˙\dot{T}.

Another prediction discussed above is that the fracture toughness is expected to systematically increase with AgA_g under constrained tension. In order to test this prediction, we quantify the fracture resistance through the “Toughness” [60], which is defined as the integral under the stress-strain curve up to failure (it has the dimensions of energy density, and should be distinguished from the “Fracture toughness” KcK_c [2], which has the dimensions of stress times the square root of length, see Supplementary material). Note that the Toughness is usually employed for samples that do not contain an initial crack (as it obviously depends on the crack geometry and dimensions); here we do apply it to such samples, but as done throughout this work, the initial crack geometry and dimensions are strictly kept fixed. In Figure 6c, we plot the Toughness vs. AgA_g for our entire glasses ensemble, calculated under constrained tension. As predicted, we observe systematic increase of the Toughness with AgA_g. Finally, we expect that the T˙\dot{T} dependence of AgA_g, previously presented in Figure 1f, is fully and transparently mirrored in the dependence of the Toughness on T˙\dot{T}. This is strongly supported by the results shown in Figure 6d.

Discussion and conclusion

In this work, employing extensive atomistic simulations and recently developed concepts, we studied the physical origin of the failure resistance of glasses, and in particular the emerging brittle-to-ductile transitions. We showed that these are controlled by both the abundance of soft defects — as quantified by AgA_g, the prefactor of the universal ω4\omega^4 vDOS of nonphononic excitations in glasses (and indirectly by χ\chi) — and by the loading geometry of the fracture test employed to extract the toughness. The loading geometry/configuration is shown to affect the relative magnitude of shear and tensile deformation experienced by the material near the initial crack, and consequently the emerging plastic dissipation, for a fixed AgA_g. Roughly speaking, AgA_g controls the number of soft defects/STZs in a glass, and the loading geometry controls the fraction of soft defects/STZs being actually activated, and hence both affect plastic deformation and consequently the fracture toughness.

We find that only under a certain choice of loading geometry, where Poisson contraction can take place, Poisson’s ratio ν\nu can be sensibly used to quantify the fracture toughness together with AgA_g (or χ\chi). These results suggest that brittle-to-ductile transitions in glasses are not controlled by a critical Poisson’s ratio, as previously proposed, and elucidate the physical role ν\nu might play in affecting the fracture toughness of glasses.

Our findings thus provide basic insights into the physical origin of the failure resistance of glasses, and should serve as important input for theories that aim at predicting it. Such theories should include the number of soft defects, as quantified here by AgA_g, and its deformation-induced spatiotemporal evolution as important ingredients. Our findings also call for additional future investigations, along the lines we delineate next.

In this work we employed an athermal (T=0T=0) and quasistatic (i.e. we approach the limit of vanishing deformation rates) glass-deformation protocol [31, 61]. While this choice is suitable for identifying structural and loading geometry effects on the fracture toughness, it completely suppresses thermal and rate effects, and might therefore introduce uncontrolled artefacts. It is obviously desirable to extend the present study to more physically realistic loading protocols that involve both finite temperatures and strain-rates.

Equally important for future work are mechanical tests on computer glasses that trace out the role of sample size and thickness in determining the failure resistance to failure; in this work we employed glassy slabs of small thickness (see Methods), hence systematically studying possible thickness effects is in place. In the Supplementary material we show that increasing the glass in-plane dimensions — other than the slab thickness — does not appear to affect the fracture behavior. In addition, as our results were obtained for an initial crack of fixed geometry and dimensions (but see also Supplementary material), it would be important in future work to sufficiently increase both the system size and the initial crack size to obtain quantitative results that are entirely independent of both.

We selected to study a rather flexible computer glass model system — introduced first in [50] — that features a very large variability of glasses’ mechanical properties [29, 51]. While we are unable at this point to single out a particular deficiency of this model, the employed pairwise interactions might be too simple to capture the emergent effects of more complex and realistic particle interactions of laboratory glasses in their entirety. For example, the Poisson ratio of our computer glasses does not fall below ν=1/4\nu=1/4, while other (network) computer glasses (e.g. those employed in [6]) can feature ν<1/4\nu<1/4.

At the same time, the power of computer simulations allows us to probe and measure generally applicable quantifiers of mechanical disorder such as AgA_g and χ\chi; while the former does not appear to be directly accessible experimentally, the latter could be — in principle — indirectly accessed in future experiments via transverse sound attenuation measurements at wavenumbers ≲1 nm−1\lesssim1\,\mathrm{nm}^{-1}, or via other experimental techniques [62, 63]. As new and more informative quantifiers of STZ-densities are being developed (cf., e.g., [21, 36, 64]), we cannot rule out that more informative dimensionless quantifiers of mechanical disorder can shed further light on the relation between mechanical disorder and plastic deformability, and hence on the fracture toughness.

In our analysis of the abundance of STZs as captured by AgA_g, we have not considered the effect of geometric/mechanical coupling of STZs to different deformation modes. In [29] it was shown that varying rcr_c can dramatically affect the ratio of dilatational to shear eigenstrains associated with STZs viewed as Eshelby inclusions. These changes in the intrinsic geometric properties of soft defects can potentially play a role in the failure of glasses. For example, the coupling of soft defects to different deformation modes can affect the susceptibility to cavitation, which is in fact observed in our simulations (but will be discussed elsewhere) as predicted in [7].

Finally, our work constitutes a step towards a quantitative understanding of deformation-induced failure in disordered solids. Future investigations should aim at better understanding the role of deformation-induced rejuvenation of glassy structures — going beyond AgA_g that characterizes the initial glass structure — in controlling the ductile or brittle nature of failure. That is, plastic deformation itself could be limited — in some cases — in its ability to generate new soft defects that facilitate further plastic flow in the material, as typically happens within shear bands [65].

Materials and Methods

Here we provide details about the computer glass models employed, about the methods used to deform the glass samples, and about the observables considered.

Computer glass models

We employ a glass model put forward in [50]; in this model, particles of equal mass mm interact via the following pairwise potential

φ(rij,λij)={4ε[(λijrij)12−(λijrij)6],rijλij<xmin⁡ε[a(λijrij)12−b(λijrij)6+∑ℓ=03c2ℓ(rijλij)2ℓ],xmin⁡≤rijλij<xc0,xc≤rijλij(1)\varphi(r_{ij},\lambda_{ij})= \begin{cases} 4\varepsilon\left[\left(\frac{\lambda_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right)^{12}-\left(\frac{\lambda_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right)^6\right], & \frac{r_{ij}}{\lambda_{ij}}<x_{\min}\\ \varepsilon\left[a\left(\frac{\lambda_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right)^{12}-b\left(\frac{\lambda_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right)^6+\sum_{\ell=0}^{3}c_{2\ell}\left(\frac{r_{ij}}{\lambda_{ij}}\right)^{2\ell}\right], & x_{\min}\le\frac{r_{ij}}{\lambda_{ij}}<x_c\\ 0, & x_c\le\frac{r_{ij}}{\lambda_{ij}} \end{cases} \tag*{(1)}

where ε\varepsilon is a microscopic energy scale, xmin⁡,xcx_{\min},x_c are the (dimensionless) locations of the minimum of the Lennard-Jones potential and modified cutoff, respectively, and the λij\lambda_{ij}’s are the length parameters, described further below. We express the dimensionless cutoff xcx_c in terms of xmin⁡=21/6x_{\min}=2^{1/6}, for simplicity, by defining rc≡xc/xmin⁡r_c\equiv x_c/x_{\min}. rcr_c serves as one of the key control parameters in our study; we refer readers to [29, 51] for a comprehensive study of the elastic properties of glasses formed with this model, under variations of rcr_c and of glass preparation protocol. The coefficients aa, bb, {c2ℓ}\{c_{2\ell}\} are chosen such that the attractive and repulsive parts of φ\varphi, and its first two derivatives, are continuous at xmin⁡x_{\min} and at xcx_c, see Table I for the coefficients’ numerical values. Unless specified otherwise, we employ simulational units, where energies are expressed in terms of ε\varepsilon, temperature in terms of ε/kB\varepsilon/k_B, lengths in terms of λ\lambda (see further discussion below), elastic moduli in terms of ε/λ3\varepsilon/\lambda^3, and times in terms of (mλ2/ε)1/2(m\lambda^2/\varepsilon)^{1/2}.

We employ the pairwise potential in Eq. (1) in two distinct protocols for creating glasses. For the first procedure, we follow the conventional computer glass formation route: high-temperature equilibrium liquid configurations at pressure P=1P=1 are generated at an initial temperature Tinitial=0.7T_{\mathrm{initial}}=0.7. Those equilibrium configurations are then quenched at fixed zero pressure P=0P=0, and at a constant cooling rate T˙\dot{T} (as specified in the figure legends) until a temperature Tfinal=0.05T_{\mathrm{final}}=0.05 is reached. Any residual heat is subsequently removed using a standard energy minimization algorithm. For this protocol, we employ a 50:50 binary mixture of ‘large’ (l) and ‘small’ (s) particles, and fix the effective size parameters λss=λ\lambda_{ss}=\lambda, λsl=λls=1.18λ\lambda_{sl}=\lambda_{ls}=1.18\lambda, and λsl=1.4λ\lambda_{sl}=1.4\lambda, for small-small, small-large, and large-large interactions, respectively.

Glasses formed with the second procedure — introduced next — are referred to as Fluctuating-Size-Particles (FSP) glasses. They were created by employing the algorithm put forward in [7]; within this algorithm, an augmented potential energy is employed for creating glasses with very high variability of their mechanical stability. This variability is achieved during glass formation by allowing particle sizes λi\lambda_i to fluctuate about a preferred effective size λi(0)\lambda_i^{(0)} at an energetic penalty determined by a potential of the form

φ~(λi)=kλ2(λi−λi(0))2[(λi(0)λi)2+14](2)\tilde{\varphi}(\lambda_i)=\frac{k_\lambda}{2}\left(\lambda_i-\lambda_i^{(0)}\right)^2\left[\left(\frac{\lambda_i^{(0)}}{\lambda_i}\right)^2+\frac{1}{4}\right] \tag*{(2)}

where the stiffness kλk_\lambda constitutes the main control parameter of FSP glasses. Notice that this form is slightly different from the effective-size potential used in [7]; the latter turns out to be unstable for small kλk_\lambda and small confining pressures. We set the preferred sizes of half the particles at λi(0)=λ/2\lambda_i^{(0)}=\lambda/2 (as before, λ\lambda forms the microscopic units of length), the other half at λi(0)=7λ/10\lambda_i^{(0)}=7\lambda/10, and used the convention λij=λi+λj\lambda_{ij}=\lambda_i+\lambda_j. Crucially, once a glass is created with the FSP algorithm, all subsequent analyses and mechanical tests are performed under fixed particle sizes λi\lambda_i, namely using the exact same pairwise potential as given by Eq. (1). Importantly, local minima (glassy states in mechanical equilibrium) of the augmented potential also constitute local minima of the potential given by Eq. (1). Finally, we note that the particles of FSP glasses are polydispersed in size, since during glass formation the effective particle sizes fluctuate, see [7] for further discussion and details. We employ the FSP algorithm to create zero pressure glasses, starting from high temperature liquid states and minimizing the augmented potential using a variety of stiffnesses kλk_\lambda (and various values of rcr_c) as reported in the figure legends. In general, decreasing the stiffness parameter kλk_\lambda results in stiffer glasses featuring less mechanical fluctuations.

coefficientrc=1.2r_c = 1.2rc=1.3r_c = 1.3rc=1.4r_c = 1.4rc=1.5r_c = 1.5
aa-106.991613526652-17.7556513878655-2.9420145359605281.1582440286928275
bb-304.918469059567-50.37332289908061-12.11892507229410-2.2619482444770567
c0c_0-939.388037994211-138.58271673010657-35.72455291073821740-12.414700446492716
c2c_21190.70962256002161.7157606462763538.7007197932934599612.584354590303674
c4c_4-541.3001315875512-66.7252832098764-14.5415594738601088-4.320508006050397
c6c_685.868493691471279.502830974880971.862014650495687220.49862551162881885

Table 1. Pairwise potential coefficients

Using the two protocols described above we created two sets of ensembles: one set was created for extracting the micromechanical properties of each ensemble as reported in Figure 1 for glasses formed with a finite cooling-rate, and in Figure 4 for glasses formed using the FSP protocol. For these calculation we prepared between 256 to 5000 glasses of N=4096N=4096 particles (except for lowest cooling rate T˙=2.10−5\dot{T}=2.10^{-5} for which N=2197N=2197). The second set of ensembles — prepared for our mechanical tests — were larger, rectangular glass slabs of dimensions Lx×Ly×LzL_x \times L_y \times L_z, with Lx=Ly=L0=60a0L_x=L_y=L_0=60a_0 and Lz=15a0L_z=15a_0 (recall that a0≡(V/N)1/3a_0 \equiv(V/N)^{1/3}), containing N=54000N=54000 particles in total.

Mechanical loading simulations

Mechanical loading is carried out via athermal quasistatic simulations, i.e. zero strain-rate and temperature. For both unconstrained uniaxial tension and constrained tension (see also Figure 5 and “Mechanical and structural observables” below), the glass is affinely deformed by imposing an extensional strain along the yy-axis (regarded as the parallel direction in the text). We define the extensional strain as ϵ∥=(L−L0)/L0\epsilon_{\parallel}=(L-L_0)/L_0, where LL and L0L_0 are the current and initial box length along e⃗y\vec{e}_y, respectively. Particle positions are changed according to yi→yi+δϵ∥yiy_i \to y_i+\delta\epsilon_{\parallel}y_i, where the strain step δϵ∥\delta\epsilon_{\parallel} is fixed at each step such that the accumulated extensional strain ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} increases by 10−310^{-3}. Subsequently, we minimize the potential energy UU, where periodic boundary conditions are applied in all directions. For constrained tension, we employ the conventional conjugate gradient algorithm. For unconstrained uniaxial tension, we combine the FIRE minimization algorithm [66] with the Berendsen barostat. The latter keeps the stress in the transverse directions, i.e. along the xx- and zz-axis, zero, with a time constant τBer=10.0\tau_{\mathrm{Ber}}=10.0. For both loading geometries, the minimization is stopped once the ratio between the typical gradient of the potential and the typical interparticle force drops below 10−1010^{-10}. During each simulations, and closely following Ref. [3], we monitor the non-affine part of the plastic deformation based on the commonly used Dmin⁡2D^2_{\min} field [3] between the initial configuration (ϵ∥=0\epsilon_{\parallel}=0) and the current state.

Mechanical and structural observables

The potential energy of our glasses is given by U=∑i<jφij(rij)U=\sum_{i<j}\varphi_{ij}(r_{ij}), where the pairwise potential we employed is described in Eq. (1). As we focus on athermal conditions, the shear modulus is defined as [67]

μ≡1V(∂2U∂γ2−∂2U∂γ∂x⋅H−1⋅∂2U∂x∂γ),(3)\mu\equiv\frac{1}{V}\left(\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\gamma^2}-\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\gamma\partial\mathbf{x}}\cdot\mathcal{H}^{-1}\cdot\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\mathbf{x}\partial\gamma}\right), \tag*{(3)}

where

H≡∂2U∂x∂x(4)\mathcal{H}\equiv\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\mathbf{x}\partial\mathbf{x}} \tag*{(4)}

is the Hessian matrix of the potential UU, and x\mathbf{x} denotes particle coordinates. The latter are considered to transform via x→H(γ)⋅x\mathbf{x}\to H(\gamma)\cdot\mathbf{x} with the parameterized shear transformation

H(γ)=(1γ0010001).(5)H(\gamma)=\begin{pmatrix} 1 & \gamma& 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(5)}

The pressure is given by

p≡−1Vd∂U∂η,(6)p\equiv-\frac{1}{Vd}\frac{\partial U}{\partial\eta}, \tag*{(6)}

where d=3d=3 is the dimension of space, and η\eta is the isotropic dilatational strain that parameterizes the suitable transformation of coordinates x→H(η)⋅x\mathbf{x}\to H(\eta)\cdot\mathbf{x} as

H(η)=(eη000eη000eη).(7)H(\eta)=\begin{pmatrix} e^\eta& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & e^\eta& 0 \\ 0 & 0 & e^\eta\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(7)}

The athermal bulk modulus K=−1ddpdηK=-\frac{1}{d}\frac{dp}{d\eta} is given by

K=1Vd2(∂2U∂η2−d∂U∂η−∂2U∂η∂x⋅H−1⋅∂2U∂x∂η).(8)K=\frac{1}{Vd^2}\left(\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\eta^2}-d\frac{\partial U}{\partial\eta}-\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\eta\partial\mathbf{x}}\cdot\mathcal{H}^{-1}\cdot\frac{\partial^2 U}{\partial\mathbf{x}\partial\eta}\right). \tag*{(8)}

With the definitions of the shear and bulk moduli in hand, the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu of a 3D solid is given by

ν≡3K−2μ6K+2μ.(9)\nu\equiv\frac{3K-2\mu}{6K+2\mu}. \tag*{(9)}

As explained above (see “Mechanical loading simulations”) and in the main text, we employed two different types of loading geometries, namely unconstrained uniaxial tension and constrained tension (cf. Figure 5). In the former, uniaxial tension of magnitude σ∥\sigma_{\parallel} is applied, while keeping the transverse stresses (in the two perpendicular directions) zero, i.e. σ⊥=0\sigma_{\perp}=0. The resulting extensional strain ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} satisfies σ∥=Eϵ∥\sigma_{\parallel}=E\epsilon_{\parallel}, where E=2μ(1+ν)E=2\mu(1+\nu) is the conventional Young’s modulus. In this loading geometry, the biaxiality ratio is set by Poisson’s ratio, i.e. R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥=νR=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}=\nu.

In the latter case, i.e. in the constrained tension loading configuration (cf. Figure 5), the transverse boundaries (perpendicular to the applied tension direction) are held fixed, i.e. ϵ⊥=0\epsilon_{\perp}=0, and consequently the transverse stresses σ⊥\sigma_{\perp} are no longer zero (in fact, they are tensile, i.e. σ⊥>0\sigma_{\perp}>0). Note that since σ⊥≠0\sigma_{\perp}\ne0, i.e. the resulting state of stress is no longer uniaxial (though uniaxial stress σ∥>0\sigma_{\parallel}>0 is applied), we term this loading geometry ‘constrained tension’, omitting ‘uniaxial’). In this loading geometry, one can define two different moduli (linear response coefficients) E∥E_{\parallel} and E⊥E_{\perp}, according to σ∥=E∥ϵ∥\sigma_{\parallel}=E_{\parallel}\epsilon_{\parallel} and σ⊥=E⊥ϵ⊥\sigma_{\perp}=E_{\perp}\epsilon_{\perp}. Using Hooke’s law, one finds

E∥=2μ1−ν1−2νandE⊥=2μν1−2ν.(10)E_{\parallel}=2\mu\frac{1-\nu}{1-2\nu} \qquad\text{and}\qquad E_{\perp}=2\mu\frac{\nu}{1-2\nu}. \tag*{(10)}

These expressions are verified against numerical simulations in the Supplementary material. Note that E∥(μ,ν)≥E(μ,ν)E_{\parallel}(\mu,\nu)\ge E(\mu,\nu) for every μ\mu and ν\nu, and that in this case we have a zero biaxiality ratio, i.e. R=−ϵ⊥/ϵ∥=0R=-\epsilon_{\perp}/\epsilon_{\parallel}=0.

Quantifiers of mechanical disorder

In our work we consider two dimensionless quantifiers of mechanical disorder. The first quantifier is defined as

χ≡Δμ⟨μ⟩N,(11)\chi\equiv\frac{\Delta\mu}{\langle\mu\rangle}\sqrt{N}, \tag*{(11)}

where Δμ\Delta\mu is the ensemble-standard-deviation of the shear modulus μ\mu (of glasses created with the exact same protocol), NN is the system size, and ⟨μ⟩\langle\mu\rangle denotes the ensemble-average shear modulus. χ\chi has been studied in [29] under variations of glasses’ interparticle interaction potential, and under different glass annealing protocols in [39, 52].

The second quantifier of mechanical disorder considered in our work is the prefactor AgA_g of the nonphononic spectrum of a glass, which is of the form D(ω)=Agω4\mathcal{D}(\omega)=A_g\omega^4, independent of spatial dimension [25] or microscopic details [26]. The latter is obtained by performing a partial diagonalization of the Hessian matrix H\mathcal{H}, defined in Eq. (4), and calculated for each member of our glass ensembles, to obtain the eigenfrequencies ωℓ\omega_\ell that solve the eigenvalue problem H⋅ψℓ=ωℓ2ψℓ\mathcal{H}\cdot\psi_\ell=\omega_\ell^2\psi_\ell (all masses are all set to unity). We then histogram the eigenfrequencies for each glass ensemble, to obtain their distribution D(ω)\mathcal{D}(\omega) over the frequency axis. Importantly, we note that the scaling form of D(ω)∼ω4\mathcal{D}(\omega)\sim\omega^4 is most readily observable in glasses of sizes small enough to suppress the otherwise-dominant phononic waves that emerge in the low-frequency spectrum of any elastic solid, as explained in detail in [19].

Acknowledgments and declaration of conflicts and other disclosures D.R. acknowledges support of the Simons Foundation for the “Cracking the Glass Problem Collaboration” Award No. 348126. E.L. acknowledges support from the NWO (Vidi grant no. 680-47-554/3259). E.B. acknowledges support from the Ben May Center for Chemical Theory and Computation and the Harold Perlman Family.

References

Supplementary material: “Brittle to ductile transitions in glasses: Roles of soft defects and loading geometry”

The goal of this document is to provide additional supporting data to the results presented in the manuscript, as detailed in the table of contents.

Scaling arguments for the AgA_g-χ\chi relation

In Figure 3d of the main text we show that for our computer glasses made by quenching liquids at finite cooling rates T˙\dot{T}, the quantifiers of mechanical disorder AgA_g and χ\chi are approximately related by

Ag∼χ10/3.(12)A_g \sim\chi^{10/3}. \tag*{(12)}

Here we explain the origin of this approximate scaling law. In [29] it was shown that χ∼ξ2/3\chi\sim\xi^{2/3} where ξ\xi is a glassy lengthscale that characterizes responses to local perturbations. In [15] it was demonstrated that ξ∼ωg−1\xi\sim\omega_g^{-1}, with ωg\omega_g being a characteristic frequency scale of soft quasilocalized excitations. Finally, in [51] it was shown that Ag∼ωg−10/3A_g \sim\omega_g^{-10/3}, implying together with the rest of the aforementioned scaling laws that Ag∼χ10/3A_g \sim\chi^{10/3}, consistent with our data of Figure 3d of the main text.

Crack geometry and validation of the tip square root singularity

In Figure S1, we present a 2D projection of the typical starting configuration used throughout our study. The initial crack geometry follows a diamond shape (see sketch in the inset of Figure S1) with semi-axis cc and total crack length 2c2c. The vertex angle β\beta is set to 18.4∘18.4^\circ. For such a geometry, the stress singularity at the crack tip will scale with 1/(2πr)λI1/(2\pi r)^{\lambda_I}, with rr being the distance from the crack tip and λI\lambda_I being the mode-I fracture singularity order [S4]. The latter depends on the vertex angle β\beta, and can be approximated by the following form [S4]

Crack geometry and square root stress singularity

Figure S1. Crack geometry and square root stress singularity. (a) Snapshot showing the typical starting configuration of a glass with a diamond shape crack. (b) Dependence of the singularity exponent λI\lambda_{\mathrm{I}} in mode-I fracture on the vertex angle 2β2\beta (see sketch for definition). The vertical red dashed line indicates the angle used throughout this work. (c) Local extensional strain ϵ\epsilon along the xx-axis, as indicated in (a), for various crack lengths cc and fixed global extensional strain ϵ∞=0.02\epsilon_{\infty}=0.02. (d) Same data as in (c), plotted on double logarithmic scales against x−cx-c, demonstrating the square root singularity of the strain close to the notch tip.

λI(β)≃1.247cos⁡(β)−1.312cos⁡2(β)+0.8532cos⁡3(β)−0.2882cos⁡4(β),(13)\lambda_I(\beta) \simeq1.247\cos(\beta) - 1.312\cos^2(\beta) + 0.8532\cos^3(\beta) - 0.2882\cos^4(\beta), \tag*{(13)}

which is plotted in Figure S1. It is clear that, for our chosen vertex angle β=18.4∘\beta= 18.4^\circ (indicated by the vertical dashed line), λI(18.4∘)≈1/2\lambda_I(18.4^\circ) \approx1/2, and so we can expect to observe the well-known ∼1/r\sim1/\sqrt{r} singularity at distance rr from the crack tip.

To confirm this expectation, we compute the local strain along the xx-axis (perpendicular to the loading direction) for a fixed strain of ϵ=2%\epsilon=2\%, and different crack lengths 2c2c. In practice, the local strain ϵ(x)\epsilon(x) is extracted from the Dmin⁡2D^2_{\min} procedure proposed by Falk and Langer in Ref. [3], and the distance xx is measured from the center of the crack, as illustrated in Figure S1. For a thin crack, one expects the local strain to take the following form [S6]

ϵ(x)=ϵ∞1−(c/x)2.(14)\epsilon(x) = \frac{\epsilon_\infty}{\sqrt{1-(c/x)^2}}. \tag*{(14)}

with ϵ∞\epsilon_{\infty} denoting the remote loading strain. Despite the limited size offered by atomistic simulations, we observe in Figure S1 a good agreement between the local strain and Eq. (14). Shifting the xx-axis of Figure S1 by the semi-crack length cc, we indeed observe in Figure S1 the expected square root singularity of the strain approaching the crack tip.

Constrained uniaxial tension vs. constrained tension

In Figure S2-Figure S2, we validate our expression for the different moduli under constrained uniaxial tension and constrained tension (see Methods in the main text). The predicted linear response (dashed lines in Figure S2) follows directly from computing independently the athermal shear modulus μ\mu and the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu.

Elastic moduli under unconstrained uniaxial tension and constrained tension

Figure S2. Elastic moduli: unconstrained uniaxial tension vs. constrained tension. (a) We plot a typical stress-strain curve of a glass under unconstrained uniaxial tension. Black dashed line indicates the linear response controlled by the Young modulus. (b) Typical stress-strain curve under constrained tension. The stress parallel and perpendicular to the loading direction are colored in black and purple, respectively. Dashed lines indicate the predicted linear response based on Hooke’s law.

χ\chi-ν\nu and μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu-ν\nu relations for MD-quenched- and FSP-glasses

In Figure S3, we compare the dependence of the disorder quantifier χ\chi on the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu between molecular-dynamics (MD) quenches and FSP glasses. We observe that our the χ\chi-ν\nu curves for FSP glasses and MD-quenched glasses do not fall on the same curves. Instead, we find that χ\chi measured for FSP glasses is generally lower than that measured for MD-quenched glasses, at the same ν\nu. This discrepancy could be explained by the gapped nonphononic vibrational spectra featured by FSP glasses, as shown in [S7].

Figure S3. χ\chi vs. ν\nu and μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu vs. ν\nu relations. (a) Disorder quantifier χ\chi that encapsulates the shear modulus fluctuations, plotted against the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu. (b) The ratio μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu is plotted against ν\nu. Filled and empty symbols correspond to ductile-like and brittle-like failure, in glass samples with an initial crack length c=6c=6. Circles and squares correspond to MD-quenched and FSP glasses, respectively.

We also report in Figure S3 the ratio μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu between the ‘non-affine’ shear modulus μna\mu_{\mathrm{na}} and the total shear modulus μ\mu, plotted against the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu. In contrast to χ\chi, we observe that the μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu-ν\nu relation featured by MD-quenched glasses and FSP glasses agree very well, with some small deviation observed for the rc=1.2r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.2 glasses. Interestingly, for rc=1.3r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.3 we observe that some MD-quenched and FSP glasses do not fail in the same way despite having the same μna/μ\mu_{\mathrm{na}}/\mu and ν\nu. We leave for future investigation the use of the SWAP-Monte-Carlo algorithm [S8] to create deeply aged glasses, which do not exhibit a gapped nonphononic vibrational spectra, in contrast to FSP glasses.

Effect of crack length on the brittle-to-ductile transition

The ductile-to-brittle transition presented in Figure 4 of the main text under unconstrained uniaxial tension pertains to glasses with an initial crack length of c=6c=6. Here we present additional data obtained under variations of the crack length. For MD-quenched glasses, and in the absence of an initial crack, only samples of the rc=1.2r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.2 glasses break before 15% uniaxial strain is reached. Different from our results in the main text for rc=1.4r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.4 — for an initial crack length of c=6c=6 —, rc=1.4r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.4 glasses with an initial crack length of c=9c=9 all exhibit crack propagation.

We perform the same analysis for FSP glasses. We find that without the presence of an initial crack, we observe cavitation for all rcr_{\mathrm{c}}’s, but only for glasses featuring extremely low disorder, namely χ<0.8\chi< 0.8. As for MD-quenched glasses, the ductile-to-brittle transition moves toward higher χ\chi values when increasing the crack length. This trend highlights the effect of stress focusing at the crack tip, facilitating void nucleation and subsequently crack propagation.

Effect of crack length $c$ on the ductile-to-brittle transition

Figure S4. Effect of crack length cc on the ductile-to-brittle transition. (a1-c1) Snapshots of the non-affine plastic deformation at 15% uniaxial strain for MD-quenched glasses in the rc−T˙r_c-\dot{T} plane, for crack lengths c=0c=0 (a1), c=6c=6 (b1), and c=9c=9 (c1). (a2-c2) Ductile-brittle phase diagram in the χ−ν\chi-\nu plane for MD-quenched glasses and crack lengths c=0c=0 (a2), c=6c=6 (b2), and c=9c=9 (c2). Glasses featuring ductile-like (brittle-like) failure are represented by full (empty) symbols. Blurry regions are added only as guides to the eye. (a3-c3) Same as (a2-c2), for FSP glasses. (a4-c4) Snapshots of the non-affine plastic deformation at 15% strain for FSP glasses in the rc−kλr_c-k_\lambda plane, for c=0c=0 (a4), c=6c=6 (b4), and c=9c=9 (c4).

Effect of slab thickness on toughness

Throughout our study presented in the main text, the sample thickness was fixed to 15 particles diameters. It is well known that the fracture toughness of a material does depend on the sample thickness. A complete study of the effect of sample thickness on the toughness and failure mode is beyond the scope of our present manuscript. We nevertheless report here the effect of sample thickness on the toughness under unconstrained uniaxial test for one glass realization: an FSP-glass prepared with kλ=1000k_{\lambda}=1000 and potential cutoff rc=1.2r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.2. We find a noticeable increase of the toughness for a small crack length (c=6c=6, see Figure S5 and Figure S5), whereas we observe for thicker samples an enhanced necking during fracture (see Figure S5). For a larger crack length, namely c=9c=9, we find the toughness to be nearly independent of the sample thickness (see Figure S5 and Figure S5).

Stress-strain curves, toughness measurements, and snapshots of non-affine plastic deformation for samples with varying slab thicknesses

Figure S5. Effect of sample thickness on the toughness under unconstrained uniaxial tension. (a) Stress-strain curves under unconstrained uniaxial tension for FSP glasses (rc=1.2r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.2 and kλ=1000k_{\lambda}=1000) with various slab thicknesses and a fixed initial crack length c=6c=6. (b) Same data as in (a) but for an initial crack length of c=9c=9. (c) Toughness as a function of the sample thickness for a fixed initial crack length c=6c=6. (d) Same data as in (c) but for a crack length of c=9c=9. (e) Snapshots of the non-affine plastic deformation at 15% uniaxial strain for samples with different thicknesses and a fixed initial crack of c=6c=6.

Effect of initial crack length on glass toughness

The results for glass toughness under constrained tension — presented in Figure 6 of the main text — were only reported for an initial crack length with c=6c = 6. Here we provide additional data pertaining to various initial crack lengths. Figure S6 is organized as follows; we first show in columns (axa_x) typical stress-strain curves for poorly and well-aged MD-quenched glasses. Columns (bxb_x) show the influence of the crack length on the stress-strain curves for a fixed quench rate (here T˙=0.02\dot{T} = 0.02). In columns (cxc_x) we report the dimensionless toughness as a function of the dimensionless crack length c~=c/a0\tilde{c}=c/a_0 (a0a_0 is an interparticle distance) for poorly (circles) and well-aged (squares) glasses. Finally, we show that the dimensionless toughness measure times the square root of the crack length c~\sqrt{\tilde{c}} is largely independent of the crack size, and thus controlled by the square root singularity of the stress at the tip.

Effect of initial crack length on glass toughness under constrained tension

Figure S6. Effect of initial crack length on glass toughness under constrained tension. (a) Stress-strain curves under constrained tension, for glasses prepared at a high quench rate (thin curve) and low quench rate (thick curve). See text and Methods for the exact definitions of σ∥\sigma_{\parallel}, ϵ∥\epsilon_{\parallel} and E∥E_{\parallel}. (b) The same as in panel (a), but for for glasses prepared at a high quench rate T˙=0.02\dot{T}=0.02 and different crack length cc. (c) The Toughness (computed as the integral over the stress-strain curve, see text for details, and normalized by E∥E_{\parallel}) as a function of the normalized crack length c~=c/a0\tilde{c}=c/a_0 (with a0=ρ−1/3a_0=\rho^{-1/3}) for glasses prepare at a high (circles) and low (squares) quench rates. (d) Same data as in panel (c) but where the toughness is scaled by the square root of the crack length. Error-bars are estimated from sample-to-sample fluctuations. From the top to the bottom row are data for rc=1.5r_c=1.5, 1.41.4, 1.31.3, and 1.21.2, respectively.

Correlations between the abundance of soft defects and the elastic-moduli susceptibility to thermal aging

In this final Section we discuss the relation between macroscopic and microscopic materials properties, and the susceptibility of a glass’s shear modulus to thermal annealing. In particular, we consider the number density of soft spots — as embodied in the prefactor AgA_{\mathrm{g}} — and the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu, in as-cast, highly disordered glasses. As explained in the Methods section of the main text, the athermal shear modulus can be decomposed into an affine term μaf\mu_{\mathrm{af}} (Born term) and a non-affine term μna\mu_{\mathrm{na}} as μ=μaf−μna\mu=\mu_{\mathrm{af}}-\mu_{\mathrm{na}}. The total modulus reads

μ=1V(∂2U∂γ2−∂2U∂γ∂x⋅H−1⋅∂2U∂x∂γ)(15)\mu= \frac{1}{V}\left(\frac{\partial^{2}U}{\partial\gamma^{2}}-\frac{\partial^{2}U}{\partial\gamma\partial x}\cdot\mathcal{H}^{-1}\cdot\frac{\partial^{2}U}{\partial x\partial\gamma}\right) \tag*{(15)}

where H≡∂2U∂x∂x\mathcal{H}\equiv\frac{\partial^{2}U}{\partial x\partial x} is the Hessian matrix of the potential energy UU, which captures the physics of soft excitations (plasticity carriers) in the system. In the case of highly disordered samples, H\mathcal{H} embodies a high density of soft excitations that are known to couple with the shear-induced forces ∂2U∂x∂γ\frac{\partial^{2}U}{\partial x\partial\gamma}. The effect of soft modes is to increase μna\mu_{\mathrm{na}} and decrease μ\mu, which ultimately decreases the shear to bulk moduli ratio μ/K\mu/K and therefore increases the Poisson’s ratio ν\nu. Overall, we thus expect that samples with a high AgA_{\mathrm{g}} will feature a large Poisson’s ratio.

Upon thermal aging, AgA_{\mathrm{g}} decreases (up to one order of magnitude for rc=1.5r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.5, and a factor 2−32-3 for rc=1.2r_{\mathrm{c}}=1.2), which in turn lowers μna\mu_{\mathrm{na}} and increases the total shear modulus. Therefore, glasses with the largest variation in AgA_{\mathrm{g}} are excepted to also show the largest stiffening of μ\mu. Finally, we also expect that as-cast glasses with the largest Poisson’s ratio will exhibit a large variability in their shear modulus upon thermal aging. These trends are demonstrated in Figure S7-Figure S7 with experimental data for bulk metallic glasses (digitized from Refs. [54 S10]), and in Figure S7 for our computer glasses with various interaction parameters rcr_{\mathrm{c}} as indicated by the legend.

Figure S7. Effect of thermal aging on macroscopic elasticity: laboratory bulk metallic glasses vs. computer glasses. (a) Correlation between the aging-induced stiffening of the shear modulus μ/μ0\mu/\mu_{0} and as-cast Poisson’s ratio ν0\nu_{0} for various bulk metallic glasses (BMGs) annealed for 48 hours (taken from Ref. [54]). (b) Rescaled shear modulus μ/μ0\mu/\mu_{0} plotted against ν\nu for two BMGs, showing either a weak or substantial aging-induced stiffening (taken from Ref. [S10]). (c) Same as in (b) but for our MD-quenched glasses with various rcr_{\mathrm{c}}, where the shear modulus is normalized by the high-quench-rate modulus μ∞\mu_{\infty}.

References

† Corresponding author: [email protected]

Corresponding author: [email protected]

References

  1. [1]J. S. Harmon, M. D. Demetriou, W. L. Johnson, and M. Tao, Deformation of glass forming metallic liquids: Configurational changes and their relation to elastic softening, Appl. Phys. Lett. 90, 131912 (2007).DOI
  2. [2]B. Lawn, Fracture of brittle solids (Cambridge university press, 1993).DOI
  3. [3]M. L. Falk and J. S. Langer, Dynamics of viscoplastic deformation in amorphous solids, Phys. Rev. E 57, 7192 (1998).DOI
  4. [4]J. J. Lewandowski, W. H. Wang, and A. L. Greer, Intrinsic plasticity or brittleness of metallic glasses, Philos Mag Lett. 85, 77 (2005).DOI
  5. [5]S. Madge, D. Louzguine-Luzgin, J. Lewandowski, and A. Greer, Toughness, extrinsic effects and poisson’s ratio of bulk metallic glasses, Acta Mater. 60, 4800 (2012).DOI
  6. [6]Y. Shi, J. Luo, F. Yuan, and L. Huang, Intrinsic ductility of glassy solids, J. Appl. Phys. 115, 043528 (2014).DOI
  7. [7]C. H. Rycroft and E. Bouchbinder, Fracture toughness of metallic glasses: Annealing-induced embrittlement, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 194301 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23215386
  8. [8]M. Vasoya, C. H. Rycroft, and E. Bouchbinder, Notch fracture toughness of glasses: Dependence on rate, age, and geometry, Phys. Rev. Applied 6, 024008 (2016).
  9. [9]J. Ketkaew, W. Chen, H. Wang, A. Datye, M. Fan, G. Pereira, U. D. Schwarz, Z. Liu, R. Yamada, W. Dmowski, M. D. Shattuck, C. S. O’Hern, T. Egami, E. Bouchbinder, and J. Schroers, Mechanical glass transition revealed by the fracture toughness of metallic glasses, Nat. Commun. 9, 3271 (2018).DOI
  10. [10]J. Sethna, Statistical mechanics: entropy, order param- eters, and complexity, Vol. 14 (Oxford University Press, 2006).
  11. [11]D. Coslovich and G. Pastore, Understanding fragility in supercooled lennard-jones mixtures. I. locally preferred structures, J. Chem. Phys. 127, 124504 (2007).DOI
  12. [12]H. Tong and H. Tanaka, Role of attractive interactions in structure ordering and dynamics of glass-forming liquids, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 225501 (2020).DOI
  13. [13]C. P. Royall and S. R. Williams, The role of local structure in dynamical arrest, Phys. Rep. 560, 1 (2015).DOI
  14. [14]L. Wang, A. Ninarello, P. Guan, L. Berthier, G. Szamel, and E. Flenner, Low-frequency vibrational modes of stable glasses, Nat. Commun. 10, 26 (2019).DOI
  15. [15]C. Rainone, E. Bouchbinder, and E. Lerner, Pinching a glass reveals key properties of its soft spots, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 117, 5228 (2020).DOI
  16. [16]B. B. Laird and H. R. Schober, Localized low-frequency vibrational modes in a simple model glass, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 636 (1991).
  17. [17]H. R. Schober and C. Oligschleger, Low-frequency vibrations in a model glass, Phys. Rev. B 53, 11469 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9982765
  18. [18]J. Ding, S. Patinet, M. L. Falk, Y. Cheng, and E. Ma, Soft spots and their structural signature in a metallic glass, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 111, 10452 (2014).DOI
  19. [19]E. Lerner, G. Düring, and E. Bouchbinder, Statistics and properties of low-frequency vibrational modes in structural glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 035501 (2016).DOI
  20. [20]H. Mizuno, H. Shiba, and A. Ikeda, Continuum limit of the vibrational properties of amorphous solids, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 114, E9767 (2017).DOI
  21. [21]D. Richard, G. Kapteijns, J. A. Giannini, M. L. Manning, and E. Lerner, Simple and broadly applicable definition of shear transformation zones, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 015501 (2021).DOI
  22. [22]A. Moriel, Y. Lubomirsky, E. Lerner, and E. Bouchbinder, Extracting the properties of quasilocalized modes in computer glasses: Long-range continuum fields, contour integrals, and boundary effects, Phys. Rev. E 102, 033008 (2020).DOI
  23. [23]V. L. Gurevich, D. A. Parshin, and H. R. Schober, Anharmonicity, vibrational instability, and the boson peak in glasses, Phys. Rev. B 67, 094203 (2003).DOI
  24. [24]D. A. Parshin, H. R. Schober, and V. L. Gurevich, Vibrational instability, two-level systems, and the boson peak in glasses, Phys. Rev. B 76, 064206 (2007).DOI
  25. [25]G. Kapteijns, E. Bouchbinder, and E. Lerner, Universal nonphononic density of states in 2d, 3d, and 4d glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 055501 (2018).DOI
  26. [26]D. Richard, K. González-López, G. Kapteijns, R. Pater, T. Vaknin, E. Bouchbinder, and E. Lerner, Universality of the nonphononic vibrational spectrum across different classes of computer glasses, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 085502 (2020).DOI
  27. [27]C. Rainone, P. Urbani, F. Zamponi, E. Lerner, and E. Bouchbinder, Mean-field model of interacting quasilocalized excitations in glasses, arXiv preprint 2010.11180 (2020).DOI
  28. [28]E. Bouchbinder, E. Lerner, C. Rainone, P. Urbani, and F. Zamponi, Low-frequency vibrational spectrum of mean-field disordered systems, arXiv preprint 2012.11558 (2020).DOI
  29. [29]K. González-López, M. Shivam, Y. Zheng, M. P. Ciamarra, and E. Lerner, Mechanical disorder of sticky-sphere glasses. I. effect of attractive interactions, Phys.
  30. [30]W. Ji, T. W. J. de Geus, M. Popović, E. Agoritsas, and M. Wyart, Thermal origin of quasilocalized excitations in glasses, Phys. Rev. E 102, 062110 (2020).DOI
  31. [31]C. Maloney and A. Lemaitre, Universal breakdown of elasticity at the onset of material failure, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 195501 (2004).DOI
  32. [32]A. Tanguy, B. Mantisi, and M. Tsamados, Vibrational modes as a predictor for plasticity in a model glass, EPL 90, 16004 (2010).DOI
  33. [33]M. L. Manning and A. J. Liu, Vibrational modes identify soft spots in a sheared disordered packing, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 108302 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21981537
  34. [34]J. Rottler, S. S. Schoenholz, and A. J. Liu, Predicting plasticity with soft vibrational modes: From dislocations to glasses, Phys. Rev. E 89, 042304 (2014).
  35. [35]L. Gartner and E. Lerner, Nonlinear plastic modes in disordered solids, Phys. Rev. E 93, 011001 (2016).DOI
  36. [36]D. Richard, M. Ozawa, S. Patinet, E. Stanifer, B. Shang, S. A. Ridout, B. Xu, G. Zhang, P. K. Morse, J.-L. Barrat, L. Berthier, M. L. Falk, P. Guan, A. J. Liu, K. Martens, S. Sastry, D. Vandembroucq, E. Lerner, and M. L. Manning, Predicting plasticity in disordered solids from structural indicators, Phys. Rev. Materials 4, 113609 (2020).DOI
  37. [37]M. Tsamados, A. Tanguy, C. Goldenberg, and J.-L. Barrat, Local elasticity map and plasticity in a model lennard-jones glass, Phys. Rev. E 80, 026112 (2009).DOI
  38. [38]H. Mizuno, S. Mossa, and J.-L. Barrat, Measuring spatial distribution of the local elastic modulus in glasses, Phys. Rev. E 87, 042306 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23679413
  39. [39]G. Kapteijns, D. Richard, E. Bouchbinder, and E. Lerner, Elastic moduli fluctuations predict wave attenuation rates in glasses, J. Chem. Phys. 154, 081101 (2021).DOI
  40. [41]W. Schirmacher, Thermal conductivity of glassy materials and the boson peak, Europhys. Lett. 73, 892 (2006).
  41. [42]W. Schirmacher, G. Ruocco, and T. Scopigno, Acoustic attenuation in glasses and its relation with the boson peak, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 025501 (2007).
  42. [43]J. Schroers and W. L. Johnson, Ductile bulk metallic glass, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 255506 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15697909
  43. [44]A. Castellero S, D. Uhlenhaut, B. Moser, and J. F. Löffler, Critical poisson ratio for room-temperature embrittlement of amorphous mg85cu5y10, Philos. Mag. Lett. 87, 383 (2007).
  44. [45]G. N. Greaves, A. Greer, R. S. Lakes, and T. Rouxel, Poisson’s ratio and modern materials, Nat. Mater. 10, 823 (2011).DOI
  45. [46]B. Deng and Y. Shi, On measuring the fracture energy of model metallic glasses, J. Appl. Phys. 124, 035101 (2018).DOI
  46. [47]C. H. Rycroft and E. Bouchbinder, Fracture toughness of metallic glasses: Annealing-induced embrittlement, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 194301 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23215386
  47. [48]G. Kumar, P. Neibecker, Y. H. Liu, and J. Schroers, Critical fictive temperature for plasticity in metallic glasses, Nat. Commun. 4, 1 (2013).DOI
  48. [49]Y. H. Liu, G. Wang, R. J. Wang, D. Q. Zhao, M. X. Pan, and W. H. Wang, Super plastic bulk metallic glasses at room temperature, Science 315, 1385 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17347434
  49. [50]O. Dauchot, S. Karmakar, I. Procaccia, and J. Zyl- berg, Athermal brittle-to-ductile transition in amorphous solids, Phys. Rev. E 84, 046105 (2011).
  50. [51]K. González-López, M. Shivam, Y. Zheng, M. P. Ciamarra, and E. Lerner, Mechanical disorder of sticky-sphere glasses. II. thermomechanical inannealability, Phys. Rev. E 103, 022606 (2021).
  51. [52]K. González-López, E. Bouchbinder, and E. Lerner, Minimally disordered glasses, arXiv preprint arXiv:2012.03634 (2020).
  52. [53]M. Falk, Molecular-dynamics study of ductile and brittle fracture in model noncrystalline solids, Phys. Rev. B 60, 7062 (1999).DOI
  53. [54]D. Wang, D. Zhao, D. Ding, H. Bai, and W. Wang, Understanding the correlations between poisson’s ratio and plasticity based on microscopic flow units in metallic glasses, J. Appl. Phys. 115, 123507 (2014).
  54. [55]F. Yuan and L. Huang, Molecular dynamics simulation of amorphous silica under uniaxial tension: From bulk to nanowire, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 358, 3481 (2012).DOI
  55. [56]W. Li, Y. Gao, and H. Bei, On the correlation between microscopic structural heterogeneity and embrittlement behavior in metallic glasses, Sci. Rep. 5, 1 (2015).DOI
  56. [57]E. Y. Lin and R. A. Riggleman, Distinguishing failure modes in oligomeric polymer nanoparticles, Soft matter 15, 6589 (2019).DOI
  57. [58]Ashwin J., E. Bouchbinder, and I. Procaccia, Cooling-rate dependence of the shear modulus of amorphous solids, Phys. Rev. E 87, 042310 (2013).DOI
  58. [59]E. Lerner and E. Bouchbinder, A characteristic energy scale in glasses, J. Chem. Phys. 148, 214502 (2018).DOI
  59. [60]M. A. Meyers and K. K. Chawla, Mechanical behavior of materials (Cambridge university press, 2008).
  60. [61]D. L. Malandro and D. J. Lacks, Relationships of shear-induced changes in the potential energy landscape to the mechanical properties of ductile glasses, J. Chem. Phys. 110, 4593 (1999).DOI
  61. [62]L. Huo, J. Zeng, W. Wang, C. T. Liu, and Y. Yang, The dependence of shear modulus on dynamic relaxation and evolution of local structural heterogeneity in a metallic glass, Acta Mater 61, 4329 (2013).DOI
  62. [63]F. Zhu, A. Hirata, P. Liu, S. Song, Y. Tian, J. Han, T. Fujita, and M. Chen, Correlation between local structure order and spatial heterogeneity in a metallic glass, Phys. Rev. lett. 119, 215501 (2017).DOI
  63. [64]Z. Schwartzman-Nowik, E. Lerner, and E. Bouchbinder, Anisotropic structural predictor in glassy materials, Phys. Rev. E 99, 060601 (2019).
  64. [65]A. Barbot, M. Lerbinger, A. Lemaitre, D. Vandembroucq, and S. Patinet, Rejuvenation and shear banding in model amorphous solids, Phys. Rev. E 101, 033001 (2020).DOI
  65. [66]E. Bitzek, P. Koskinen, F. Gähler, M. Moseler, and P. Gumbsch, Structural relaxation made simple, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 170201 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17155444
  66. [67]J. F. Lutsko, Generalized expressions for the calculation of elastic constants by computer simulation, J. Appl. Phys. 65, 2991 (1989).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wqjxb8yz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents