betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Surfactant-laden breaking wave: regular and spilling regimes

Abstract

We investigate the influence of insoluble surfactants on the spatio-temporal evolution of breaking waves, focusing on both regular and spilling regimes. Three-dimensional direct numerical simulations are conducted using an interface-tracking/level-set method that incorporates surfactant-induced Marangoni stresses. The simulations reveal that surfactant gradients, through Marangoni stresses, markedly alter the wave dynamics. While regular breakers exhibit only minor modifications in the presence of surfactants, increasing surfactant-induced Marangoni stresses in spilling breakers leads to pronounced changes in the crest evolution, vorticity generation, and even a transition towards plunging-like behavior. To quantify these effects, we also extend circulation-based theoretical frameworks to account for surfactant contributions. This work demonstrates the crucial role that surfactants play in the dynamics of breaking waves, revealing that their impact is primarily driven by Marangoni stresses rather than surface tension reduction.

Introduction

Surface wave breaking plays a significant role in the exchange of mass, momentum, and energy across the air-sea boundary [56, 40, 21] (Garbe et al. 2014). When waves break, they generate turbulence, entrain air, and enhance mixing, processes that significantly affect oceanic and atmospheric dynamics [56, 21]. The underlying physics of wave breaking, particularly spilling and plunging breakers, has been extensively studied using both experiments and numerical simulations [66, 10, 30, 29, 64, 49, 50, 40, 24, 23].

Early studies by Chen et al. [10] showed that vorticity generation and energy dissipation are strongly localized near the wave crest, corroborating experimental observations of wave-induced turbulence. These findings, obtained through two-dimensional simulations, captured plunging and spilling breaker dynamics. Building on this, Iafrati [40] provided a comprehensive numerical framework for analyzing the mechanics of both plunging and spilling breakers. Their work classified different wave regimes as a function of the initial wave steepness, ϵ\epsilon, for fixed Reynolds and Weber numbers (Re=104Re = 10^{4}, We=100We = 100). Waves remained regular for ϵ<0.33\epsilon< 0.33; transition to spilling breaker when 0.33≤ϵ<0.370.33 \le\epsilon< 0.37 and become plunging breakers for ϵ≥0.37\epsilon\ge0.37. These results agree with the theoretical analysis by Grue & Fructus [36]. Building on earlier studies, Deike et al. (2015, 2016) used direct numerical simulations (DNS) to investigate the mechanisms of energy dissipation in breaking waves, highlighting differences between plunging and spilling regimes. Their work emphasized the transition to turbulence, vorticity generation, and air entrainment as central features of breaking dynamics. It is important to note that the relationship between initial wave steepness and breaking type is not universal. Experimental and numerical studies show that the limiting steepness for breaking spans a wide range, depending on the generation mechanism, spectral bandwidth, and conditions [28, 31, 65, 66, 4] (Wu & Yao 2004). As reviewed comprehensively by Perlin et al. (2013), gravity-capillary wave has been observed over ϵ≈0.15\epsilon\approx0.15–0.48, and in some configurations spilling breakers may exhibit equal or even greater steepness than plunging ones.

Breaking waves undergo a cascade of processes, from jet impact and vortex formation to bubble entrainment and droplet ejection, that enhance mixing and momentum transfer across the interface [50, 21]. High-fidelity simulations by Wang et al. (2016) captured the formation of bubbles, droplets, and spray, offering insight into the multiphase dynamics following wave impact. To model energy dissipation, Mostert & Deike [57] developed a theoretical framework relating dissipation rates to wave height, water depth, and beach slope, which was validated numerically and extended empirically to offshore conditions. For deep-water plunging breakers, however, inertial dissipation is more appropriately described by the crest-length scaling of Drazen et al. (2008), which links dissipation to wave kinematics and breaker geometry. In a follow-up work, Mostert et al. (2022) examined the transition from laminar to turbulent flow, showing that the energy dissipation rates and the size distributions of bubbles and droplets become independent of the Reynolds number once it exceeds a sufficiently high threshold. Recent studies have further examined the dynamics of plunging breakers, such as the work by Di Giorgio et al. (2022), who performed both two- and three-dimensional simulations across different Reynolds numbers, resolving the evolution of the air–water interface and associated bubble structures. Similarly, Hu et al. (2024) investigated the influence of wave slope and Reynolds number on spray formation and air entrainment during breaking.

Most of the recent studies on breaking waves have focused on clean, uncontaminated interfaces. However, natural surface-active agents (surfactants), which are ubiquitous in marine environments due to biological activity and pollution, are often present in the ocean surface [45, 46]. Surfactants may be either insoluble (residing primarily at the air-water interface) or soluble (dissolved in the bulk fluid and can adsorb to and desorb from the interface). In both cases, spatial variations in concentration in the interface result in surface tension gradients, leading to Marangoni stresses driven flow from regions of low to high surface tension Manikantan & Squires [55]. Surfactant-driven Marangoni stresses can modify interfacial phenomena. For example, in capillary singularities, surfactant-induced flows can retard thread thinning and promote the formation of microthreads [1, 19, 47, 78, 42, 15]. In small-scale systems related to wave breaking, such as bubbles and droplets, surfactants have been found to resist jet breakup, slow down the droplet ejection after the bursting of a bubble, and alter aerosol production [73] (Constante-Amores et al. 2021c; Ma et al. 2023).

Surfactants alter every stage of wave breaking, such as capillary wave formation, and the structure of the turbulent flow beneath the crest [8, 50, 51]. Two-dimensional simulations of capillary waves with insoluble surfactant by Ceniceros [8] showed that Marangoni stresses reduce both the bulge size and the wave amplitude while sharpening the toe curvature. Liu & Duncan [49] and Liu & Duncan [50] revealed similar trends with a suppression of capillary ripples, smoother crest evolution and a smaller, blunter bulge even at modest surfactant concentrations in wave-tank experiments on weak spilling breakers with the soluble surfactant (sodium dodecyl sulphate). By tracking the time varying bulge geometry, they linked these macroscopic changes directly to surface-rheological properties, concluding that surfactant-induced surface tension gradients delay toe shedding and reduce energy dissipation. Plunging breakers respond to the presence of surfactants even more dramatically. Erinin et al. [32] did experiments with Triton X-100 and surfactant-depleted water, and showed that surfactants deform the jet tip, fragment the entrained air cavity, and weaken the downward plunge. They also presented numerical simulations that modeled surfactants as tracer particles along the interface. While these confirmed the qualitative trends, they could not capture the fully coupled surfactant-induced Marangoni stresses. Extending this work, Liu et al. [48] demonstrated that soluble surfactants reduce both droplet count and ejection velocity while shifting the size distribution towards larger diameters. Together, these studies establish that even trace amounts of surfactants suppress small scale capillary activity, delay the onset of turbulence beneath the crest and reshape the air entrainment and spray signature of breaking waves.

As revealed by the foregoing review, considerable progress has been made in understanding the role of surfactants in breaking wave dynamics. However, to the best of our knowledge, the specific influence of surfactant-induced Marangoni stresses remains poorly understood. In this study, we investigate the influence of insoluble surfactants on breaking wave dynamics, with a particular focus on regular and spilling regimes, using direct numerical simulations. The rest of this paper is structured as follows: in § 2, the numerical method, governing dimensionless parameters, problem configuration, and validation, are introduced. § 3 presents the results, and concluding remarks are given in § 4.

Problem formulation and numerical method

High-resolution simulations were performed by solving the two-phase incompressible Navier-Stokes equations with surface tension in a three-dimensional Cartesian domain x=(x,y,z)\mathbf{x}=(x,y,z) (see Figure 1). The interface between the gas and liquid is described by a hybrid front-tracking/level-set method, where (insoluble) surfactant transport is explicitly resolved at the interface (Shin et al. (2018)). Here, and in what follows, all variables are made dimensionless (represented by tildes) using the following characteristic scales

Schematic representation of the flow configuration

Figure 1. Schematic representation of the flow configuration. Initial configuration showing the computational domain in a 3D Cartesian coordinate system, x=(x,y,z)\mathbf{x} = (x, y, z).

x~=xλ,t~=ttr,u~=uc,p~=pρlc2,σ~=σσs,Γ~=ΓΓ∞,(1)\tilde{\mathbf{x}}=\frac{\mathbf{x}}{\lambda},\qquad\tilde{t}=\frac{t}{t_r},\qquad\tilde{\mathbf{u}}=\frac{\mathbf{u}}{c},\qquad\tilde{p}=\frac{p}{\rho_l c^2},\qquad\tilde{\sigma}=\frac{\sigma}{\sigma_s},\qquad\tilde{\Gamma}=\frac{\Gamma}{\Gamma_\infty}, \tag*{(1)}

where, tt, u\mathbf{u}, and pp stand for time, velocity, and pressure, respectively. The physical parameters correspond to the liquid density, ρl\rho_l, liquid viscosity, μl\mu_l, and surfactant-free surface tension, σs\sigma_s. The characteristic velocity is c=gλc=\sqrt{g\lambda} with λ\lambda the wavelength of the wave; hence, the characteristic time scale is tr=λ/ct_r=\lambda/c. The interfacial surfactant concentration, Γ\Gamma, is scaled by the saturation interfacial concentration, Γ∞\Gamma_\infty. As a result of this scaling, the dimensionless equations read

∇⋅u~=0,(2)\nabla\cdot\tilde{\mathbf{u}}=0, \tag*{(2)}
ρ~(∂u~∂t~+u~⋅∇u~)+∇p~=−izFr2+1Re∇⋅[μ~(∇u~+∇u~T)]+(3)\tilde{\rho}\left(\frac{\partial\tilde{\mathbf{u}}}{\partial\tilde{t}}+\tilde{\mathbf{u}}\cdot\nabla\tilde{\mathbf{u}}\right)+\nabla\tilde{p}=-\frac{\mathbf{i}_z}{Fr^2}+\frac{1}{Re}\nabla\cdot\left[\tilde{\mu}\left(\nabla\tilde{\mathbf{u}}+\nabla\tilde{\mathbf{u}}^{T}\right)\right]+ \tag*{(3)}
+1We∫A~(t~)(σ~κ~n+∇sσ~)δ(x~−x~f) dA~,(4)+\frac{1}{We}\int_{\tilde{A}(\tilde{t})}(\tilde{\sigma}\tilde{\kappa}\mathbf{n}+\nabla_s\tilde{\sigma})\delta(\tilde{\mathbf{x}}-\tilde{\mathbf{x}}_f)\,\mathrm{d}\tilde{A}, \tag*{(4)}
∂Γ~∂t~+∇s⋅(Γ~u~t)=1Pes∇s2Γ~,(5)\frac{\partial\tilde{\Gamma}}{\partial\tilde{t}}+\nabla_s\cdot(\tilde{\Gamma}\tilde{\mathbf{u}}_t)=\frac{1}{Pe_s}\nabla_s^2\tilde{\Gamma}, \tag*{(5)}

where the density and viscosity are given by ρ~=ρg/ρl+(1−ρg/ρl)H(x~,t~)\tilde{\rho}=\rho_g/\rho_l+(1-\rho_g/\rho_l)\mathcal{H}(\tilde{\mathbf{x}},\tilde{t}) and μ~=μg/μl+(1−μg/μl)H(x~,t~)\tilde{\mu}=\mu_g/\mu_l+(1-\mu_g/\mu_l)\mathcal{H}(\tilde{\mathbf{x}},\tilde{t}) wherein H(x~,t~)\mathcal{H}(\tilde{\mathbf{x}},\tilde{t}) represents a Heaviside function, which is zero in the gas phase and unity in the liquid phase, while the subscript ‘g’ and ‘l’ designate the gas, and liquid phases, respectively, and u~t=(u~s⋅t)t\tilde{\mathbf{u}}_t=(\tilde{\mathbf{u}}_s\cdot\mathbf{t})\mathbf{t} is the tangential velocity at the interface in which u~s\tilde{\mathbf{u}}_s represents the interfacial velocity, and κ\kappa is the curvature, and t\mathbf{t} is the unit tangent vector to the interface. The interfacial gradient is given by ∇s=(I−nn)⋅∇\nabla_s=(\mathbf{I}-\mathbf{n}\mathbf{n})\cdot\nabla wherein I\mathbf{I} is the identity tensor and n\mathbf{n} is the outward-pointing unit normal. In addition, δ\delta is a Dirac delta function, equal to unity at the interface and zero otherwise, and A~(t~)\tilde{A}(\tilde{t}) is the time-dependent interface area. As justified by the final paragraph of Stone [71], in our frame of reference u⋅n=0\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n}=0, which gives rise to equation (5).

The dimensionless groups that appear in the governing equations are defined as

Re=ρlcλμl,We=g1/2λρlσs,Fr=cgλ,Pes=cλDs,βs=RTΓ∞σs,(6)Re=\frac{\rho_l c\lambda}{\mu_l},\quad We=g^{1/2}\lambda\sqrt{\frac{\rho_l}{\sigma_s}},\quad Fr=\frac{c}{\sqrt{g\lambda}},\quad Pe_s=\frac{c\lambda}{D_s},\quad\beta_s=\frac{\mathcal{R}T\Gamma_\infty}{\sigma_s}, \tag*{(6)}

where ReRe, WeWe, FrFr, and PesPe_s stand for the Reynolds, Weber, Froude, and (interfacial) Peclet numbers. As a consequence of our nondimensionalisation, the phase speed is c=gλc=\sqrt{g\lambda}, so the Froude number becomes Fr=c/gλ=1Fr=c/\sqrt{g\lambda}=1, consistent with the formulation of Iafrati [40]. We note that a depth-based definition would yield Fr=2Fr=\sqrt{2} for the present configuration, as described by [76, 9, 35, 67]. The parameter βs\beta_s is the surfactant elasticity number that is a measure of the sensitivity of the surface tension, σ\sigma, to the interface surfactant concentration, Γ\Gamma. Here, R\mathcal{R} is the ideal gas constant value (R=8.314 J K−1 mol−1\mathcal{R}=8.314\ \mathrm{J\,K^{-1}\,mol^{-1}}), TT denotes temperature, and DsD_s stands for the interfacial diffusion coefficient.

The non-linear Langmuir equation is used to describe σ\sigma in terms of Γ\Gamma, this is

σ~=max⁡[0.05,1+βsln⁡(1−Γ~)],(7)\tilde{\sigma}=\max[0.05,1+\beta_s\ln(1-\tilde{\Gamma})], \tag*{(7)}

where a lower limit of σ\sigma has been set to 0.05, below which the Langmuir equation of state may diverge. This formulation is common as previous studies [3, 59, 74, 69] (Constante-Amores et al. 2021c). Finally, the Marangoni stress, τ~\tilde{\boldsymbol{\tau}}, is expressed as a function of Γ~\tilde{\Gamma} as

1We∇sσ~⋅t=τ~We=−Ma(1−Γ~)∇sΓ~⋅t,(8)\frac{1}{We}\nabla_s\tilde{\sigma}\cdot\mathbf{t}=\frac{\tilde{\tau}}{We}=-\frac{Ma}{(1-\tilde{\Gamma})}\nabla_s\tilde{\Gamma}\cdot\mathbf{t}, \tag*{(8)}

where Ma=βs/We=RTΓ∞/ρlc2λMa=\beta_s/We=\mathcal{R}T\Gamma_\infty/\rho_lc^2\lambda is the Marangoni parameter. Tildes are dropped henceforth.

The incompressible Navier-Stokes equation is integrated numerically using a second-order finite difference formulation on a staggered grid [38, 75]. The flow field is represented on a fixed, uniform Eulerian mesh. All spatial derivatives are discretized with second-order centered differences, with the exception of the nonlinear advective terms for which a second-order essentially non-oscillatory (ENO) scheme is employed to ensure numerical stability and limit spurious oscillations [72]. Viscous stresses are likewise evaluated using a second-order centered scheme.

The incompressibility constraint is enforced through a fractional-step projection method, in which the pressure is obtained by solving a Poisson equation using a multigrid iterative solver [11, 43]. To accurately resolve interfacial dynamics, the numerical framework incorporates an adaptive Lagrangian mesh within a hybrid front-tracking/level-set methodology [70, 68]. Coupling between the Lagrangian interface and the Eulerian flow solver is achieved via an immersed boundary formulation [62].

The Lagrangian interface is advanced in time according to dx/dt=Vd\mathbf{x}/dt = \mathbf{V}, where the interface velocity V\mathbf{V} is obtained by second-order bilinear interpolation of the Eulerian velocity field. Time integration of the interface position is performed using a second-order Runge-Kutta scheme. Time integration of the interface position is performed using a second-order Runge-Kutta scheme. Parallel computation is implemented through a domain-decomposition approach, with data communication across subdomains handled using the Message Passing Interface (MPI) [68]. The surfactant conservation equation on the evolving interface is discretised within the hybrid Lagrangian-Eulerian LCRM framework, following Muradoglu & Tryggvason [59] for the transient and convective terms, which are integrated conservatively over each triangular interface element using the Leibniz transport theorem. The surface tension coefficient σ\sigma is evaluated locally on the Lagrangian interface from the surfactant concentration. We refer the reader to Shin et al. [69] for more details of the surfactant implementation, including validation against standard benchmark test cases.

Numerical Setup and parameters

In this work, we study the evolution of a single breaking wave with wavelength λ\lambda. The computational domain is defined as (λ×λ/4×λ)(\lambda\times\lambda/4 \times\lambda), as shown in Figure 1. While previous studies have commonly employed cubic domains of size λ3\lambda^3, the reduced spanwise extent adopted here is intentional, as we are not focusing on the strongly 3D dynamics associated with the plunging regime. By reducing the spanwise dimension, we limit the computational cost while retaining 3D dynamics. This approach has also been adopted by Di Giorgio et al. [26]. No variations in surfactant concentration are observed along the spanwise direction, indicating that the dynamics are effectively two-dimensional. The wave propagates in the xx-direction with periodic boundary conditions in both the streamwise (xx) and spanwise (yy) directions. No-slip and no-penetration conditions are applied at the bottom boundary. We emphasize that the chosen spanwise extent is sufficient to capture the essential dynamics of the breaking wave while maintaining computational efficiency.

The initial free-surface profile η(x,y)\eta(x,y) follows the previous work from Chen et al. [10] and Iafrati [40], which corresponds to a third-order Stokes wave solution that neglects depth effects and third-order corrections to the fundamental frequency component, computed up to third order in the wave amplitude aa. The surface elevation is prescribed as

η(x,y)=aλ(cos⁡(kx)+12εcos⁡(2kx)+38ε2cos⁡(3kx)),(9)\eta(x,y)=\frac{a}{\lambda}\left(\cos(kx)+\frac{1}{2}\varepsilon\cos(2kx)+\frac{3}{8}\varepsilon^2\cos(3kx)\right), \tag*{(9)}

where k=2π/λk=2\pi/\lambda is the wavenumber, and ε=ak\varepsilon=ak is the initial wave steepness. As noted by Iafrati [40], the omission of the third-order correction term has a negligible effect on the resulting dynamics; we therefore adopt this initialization and focus on surfactant-induced effects. The initial velocity field is obtained under the assumption of a free surface (e.g., negligible air pressure). The velocity profile in the water is derived from the velocity potential associated with the free-surface profile and is expressed as

u=Ωaekzcos⁡(kx),v=Ωaekzsin⁡(kx),(10)u=\Omega a e^{kz}\cos(kx),\qquad v=\Omega a e^{kz}\sin(kx), \tag*{(10)}

where Ω=gk(1+ε2)\Omega=\sqrt{gk(1+\varepsilon^2)} accounts for the nonlinear correction by removing higher order terms ([79, 40]). We note that other studies have considered more physically detailed conditions, in which a velocity profile in the air is also defined ([24]). Finally, we note that surface tension forces are not included in the initializations, but their influence will become relevant once the wave propagates in the streamwise direction.

The dimensionless parameters used in this study are consistent with experimentally realizable systems. The density and viscosity ratios are set to ρg/ρl=1/850\rho_g/\rho_l=1/850 and μg/μl=17.4×10−6/8.9×10−4=1.96×10−2\mu_g/\mu_l=17.4\times10^{-6}/8.9\times10^{-4}=1.96\times10^{-2}, respectively, based on standard properties of air and water. The water depth is set to h=λ/2h=\lambda/2, consistent with the configuration used by Deike et al. [24], who showed that this ratio has minimal influence on wave evolution in the regimes of interest. Following Iafrati [40], we fix the Weber and Reynolds numbers at We=100We=100 and Re=104Re=10^4. The chosen Weber number corresponds to water waves with a wavelength of approximately 27 cm, corresponding to Reynolds number of Re≈4.4×105Re\approx4.4\times10^5. Resolving flows at such high Reynolds would require prohibitively fine resolution, which is not feasible within the constraints of our fixed-grid approach. While adaptive mesh refinement has enabled higher ReRe simulations in other studies ([22, 58]), our focus is limited to regular (non-breaking) and weakly spilling breakers. The chosen parameters therefore strike a balance between computational feasibility and physical realism, while capturing the dominant surfactant-laden dynamics. In this work, we have considered insoluble surfactants whose critical micelle concentration (CMC), i.e. Γ∞∼O(10−6) mol m−2\Gamma_{\infty}\sim O(10^{-6})\ \mathrm{mol\,m^{-2}} for NBD-PC (1-palmitoyl-2-[12-(7-nitro-2-1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)amino]dodecanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine); thus, we have explored the range of 0.1<βs<0.50.1<\beta_s<0.5 which corresponds to 2.9×10−6<CMC<1.4×10−5 mol m−22.9\times10^{-6}<\mathrm{CMC}<1.4\times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{mol\,m^{-2}}. The values βs=0.3\beta_s=0.3 and βs=0.5\beta_s=0.5 were selected to ensure that the interface remains strictly below the critical value of the Langmuir equation of state, so that it never enters the saturation (cutoff) regime. This guarantees that the surface tension varies monotonically with surfactant concentration and that Marangoni stresses remain active throughout the simulation. To further avoid operating near the saturation limit of the Langmuir equation of state, where Marangoni stresses are suppressed, the initial surfactant concentration is set to Γ0=Γ∞/4\Gamma_0=\Gamma_{\infty}/4 in all simulations, ensuring that both surface-tension reduction and

Marangoni stresses remain active. Finally, the initial concentration of the surfactant-laden cases is initialized uniformly along the interface as in previous work by Constante-Amores et al. [15, 18]; Kamat et al. [41]. We note that a real Stokes wave at the onset of breaking may possess pre-existing surfactant gradients; our choice of a uniform initial concentration is an idealization. We have set Pes=103Pe_s = 10^3 following Batchvarov et al. [6] and Constante-Amores et al. [15], who showed that the interfacial dynamics are weakly-dependent on PesPe_s beyond this value.

The simulations presented here are mesh independent. A resolution of λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512 was found sufficient to ensure that further mesh refinement does not alter the numerical results. This resolution is consistent with that used in previous studies at the same dimensionless parameters ([40]). We also note that the simulations in the plunging regime are terminated upon the onset of plunging. Although the numerical framework is capable of resolving post-breaking behavior, this is not the focus of the current study. Further investigation would require refining the simulations, which would significantly increase computational cost, and consequently, we do not explore this avenue here.

The numerical validation of the surfactant equations has been previously presented in Shin et al. [69]. Extensive mesh studies for surface-tension-driven phenomena using the same computational method can be found elsewhere, e.g. ([5, 6]; [15, 16, 14, 12]). Additionally, liquid volume and surfactant mass conservation are met under errors of less than 10−1%10^{-1}\%, and 10−2%10^{-2}\%, respectively.

Results

Table 1 summarizes the observed wave behavior as a function of the steepness parameter ϵ\epsilon with Re=104Re = 10^4 and We=100We = 100. We observe that for surfactant-free cases, the wave remains regular for ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, transitions to a spilling-type breakup for ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324, and finally exhibits plunging-type breakup for ϵ=0.37\epsilon= 0.37. These findings agree with previous work by Iafrati [40] and Grue & Fructus [37]. We have included simulations with ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324, which aligns with the onset from regular to spilling-type breaking predicted when accounting for the secular growth term ϵ3/8\epsilon^3/8 by Grue & Fructus [37]. It should be noted that for ϵ=0.37\epsilon= 0.37, the simulation was terminated just prior to the breakup. This choice was made to focus the analysis on the wave behavior leading up to the event. A detailed study of the post-breakup dynamics in the plunging regime is beyond the scope of this study.

ϵ\epsilonβs\beta_sRegularSpillingPlunging
0.3Surfactant-freeX
0.30.3X
0.30.5X
0.324Surfactant-freeX
0.3240.3X
0.3240.5X
0.33Surfactant-freeX
0.330.3X
0.330.5X
0.35Surfactant-freeX
0.350.3X
0.350.5X
0.37Surfactant-freeX

Table 1. Wave behavior as a function of wave steepness ϵ\epsilon and surfactant parameter βs\beta_s. The steepness ϵ\epsilon denotes the initial Stokes-wave steepness prescribed in equation (9). The surfactant parameter βs\beta_s denotes surfactant elasticity.

To investigate the role of wave breaking in energy dissipation, we track the temporal evolution of the kinetic energy. Figure 2 presents the kinetic energy normalised by its initial value Ek0E_{k0}, defined as Ek/Ek0=ρ∫Vu2/2 dVE_k/E_{k0} = \rho\int_V \mathbf{u}^2/2\,dV, as a function of the initial wave steepness ϵ\epsilon. The figure reveals distinct trends corresponding to the different breaking regimes, highlighting the increasing intensity of energy decay with more intense wave breaking. In the regular wave regime, a nearly constant decay rate is observed. The theoretical decay of mechanical energy due to viscous damping is given by Emech(t)=Emech(0)e−2γtE_{\mathrm{mech}}(t) = E_{\mathrm{mech}}(0)e^{-2\gamma t}, where EmechE_{\mathrm{mech}} is the mechanical energy (e.g., equal to twice the kinetic energy for small-amplitude waves) and γ=2k2μl/ρl\gamma= 2k^2\mu_l/\rho_l is the damping coefficient [44] (see Appendix § 9 for more detail). For the wave with steepness ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, the numerical simulation results in γ=0.0091\gamma= 0.0091, which is in good agreement with the theoretical estimate γ≈0.0079\gamma\approx0.0079. At higher steepness ϵ=0.37\epsilon= 0.37, a monotonic decrease in kinetic energy is observed, preceded by a phase of increasing amplitude and enhanced dissipation. Although the simulation is terminated just before the onset of plunging-type breakup, the flow already exhibits intensified velocities and steep velocity gradients near the interface, resulting in large kinetic energy and enhanced energy dissipation. Nonlinear energy exchange in the finite-amplitude wave produces oscillations in Ek/Ek0E_k/E_{k0}, so the linear dissipation theory applies only to the average decay rate rather than the instantaneous dynamics.

Time evolution of kinetic energy as a function of the wave steepness $\epsilon$ for surfactant-free cases

Figure 2. Time evolution of kinetic energy as a function of the wave steepness ϵ\epsilon for surfactant-free cases.

The changes in wave morphology that accompany these energy dissipation trends are illustrated in Figure 3a-Figure 3c, which show the spatiotemporal evolution of the interface in the (x−z)(x-z) plane at y=λ/8y = \lambda/8 for initial steepness values ϵ=[0.3,0.33,0.35]\epsilon= [0.3, 0.33, 0.35]. At ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, the wave evolution remains regular over time. As the steepness increases to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33, weak signs of spilling emerge in the surfactant-free case, which become more pronounced at ϵ=0.35\epsilon= 0.35, where the formation of a forward-facing bulge near the wave crest marks the onset of spilling. The leading edge of this bulge, known as the toe, curves inward due to surface tension effects, consistent with the mechanism described by Duncan [29].

Capillary waves are also form upstream of the toe, as reported by Duncan et al. [30]. For gravity-capillary waves, Deike et al. [24] reported that the breaking threshold depends primarily on the Bond (or Weber) number and the steepness. In the large Weber number regime relevant to our simulations (We=100We = 100, Bo∼253Bo \sim253), their scaling predicts a critical steepness in the range ϵcrit≈0.32\epsilon_{\mathrm{crit}} \approx0.32. The transition observed here in the clean-wave case at ϵcrit≈0.324\epsilon_{\mathrm{crit}} \approx0.324 therefore lies within the gravity-capillary breaking regime reported by Deike et al. [24]. We note, however, that their simulations were performed at a significantly higher Reynolds number (Re≈4×104Re \approx4 \times10^{4}) compared with the present Re=104Re = 10^{4}, so that the agreement should not be interpreted as a strict quantitative match but rather as a consistency of physical regimes.

Figure 3d–Figure 3i) shows the effect of insoluble surfactants on the wave dynamics. At ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3 (see panels 3d-g), the addition of surfactant produces minimal changes compared to the surfactant-free case. This is expected, as the steepness remains below the critical value for Stokes waves (ϵc≈0.32\epsilon_c \approx0.32); although surfactants reduce the surface tension, it is insufficient to generate a noticeable wave deformation. When the wave enters the spilling regime, there are no visually obvious differences between surfactant cases and the surfactant-free case since the spilling signatures remain weak at this stage. The enhancement of spilling signs can be observed for higher steepness (ϵ=0.35\epsilon= 0.35), with the effect being more pronounced at higher values of βs\beta_s (see panels 3f and 3i).

To elucidate the coupling between the interface dynamics and surfactant concentration, Figure 4 presents the spatiotemporal evolution of Γ\Gamma at the same time as in Figure 3. A clear correlation emerges between the interfacial shape and the distribution of Γ\Gamma. As the wave evolves, surfactant initially accumulates at troughs due to surface convergence, then shifts toward the crests (where the interface exhibits divergent flow). Once the crest is formed, the local flow divergence redistributes Γ\Gamma, causing it to diffuse away gradually. Comparing cases with βs=0.3\beta_s = 0.3 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, the crest in the higher βs\beta_s leans forward more prominently, indicative of surfactant-induced modifications to the interfacial dynamics and wave deformation. The largest accumulation of surfactant concentration occurs in the ϵ=0.35\epsilon= 0.35 case, where enhanced crest steepening and incipient spilling intensify interfacial compression, leading to sharper concentration gradients and increased accumulation of Γ\Gamma. Noticeably, a double-peaked distribution of Γ\Gamma emerges (see Figure 4c and Figure 4f), originates from interfacial overturning (see Figure 3f and Figure 3i).

Surfactant-free interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.3$

(a)

Surfactant-free interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.33$

(b)

Surfactant-free interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.35$

(c)

Interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.3$ and $\beta_s = 0.3$

(d)

Interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.33$ and $\beta_s = 0.3$

(e)

Interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.35$ and $\beta_s = 0.3$

(f)

Interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.3$ and $\beta_s = 0.5$

(g)

Interface time-space plot for $\epsilon = 0.33$ and $\beta_s = 0.5$

(h)

(i)

Figure 3. Time-space plots of the interface in the (x−zx-z) plane (y=λ/8y = \lambda/8) at equal time intervals for varying wave steepness ϵ\epsilon, and surfactant elasticity βs\beta_s. The vertical coordinates (yy-axis) are stretched by a factor of 4 and shifted upward by the corresponding time to better illustrate the interface evolution. Colored lines mark selected times analyzed in detail below.

Time-space plots of normalized surfactant concentration for $\epsilon=0.3$, $\epsilon=0.33$, and $\epsilon=0.35$, with $\beta_s=0.3$ and $\beta_s=0.5$

Figure 4. Time-space plots of normalized surfactant concentration Γ\Gamma at time intervals as a function of the steepness ϵ\epsilon, and βs\beta_s. The data are plotted against arclength s∈[0,1]s \in[0,1], with vertical coordinates representing the normalized surfactant concentration Γ\Gamma shifted by the corresponding time to clearly show the evolution of surfactant distribution. For the surfactant-laden cases, Pes=103Pe_s=10^3 and Γ=Γ∞/4\Gamma=\Gamma_\infty/4. Colored lines mark selected times analyzed in detail below.

We now examine the coupling between the interface location, surfactant concentration Γ\Gamma, Marangoni stress, and tangential velocity in the streamwise direction utxu_{tx}. To elucidate the underlying mechanisms, we select representative time instances at which wave features are most pronounced. These times, corresponding to different steepness regimes, are indicated in different colors in Figure 3 and Figure 4. We begin with the regular wave regime. For ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, Figure 5a shows that the presence of surfactant has a minimal effect on the interface location at late times (t=5.6t = 5.6). However, Figure 5b reveals that the surfactant concentration peaks at the wave crest, where surface tension is locally minimized. The resulting Marangoni stresses, driven by surface tension gradients, generate outward tangential flow away from the crest, i.e., τ>0\tau> 0 on the forward part of the crest and τ<0\tau< 0 on the rear part of it. These Marangoni stresses act to suppress further steepening of the wave by opposing interfacial deformation, thereby reducing the wave amplitude at late times (not shown). The influence of Marangoni stresses on the surface flow is evident in Figure 5d, which shows that utxu_{tx} is significantly enhanced near the crest in the presence of surfactants, compared to the clean case, particularly for the high elasticity case (βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5). Despite the enhanced tangential velocity and the non-uniform surfactant distribution, the interface displacement remains small at this particular time. At ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, the inertial forces associated with wave propagation are insufficient to drive significant interface deformation or wave overturn, and the flow remains in a weakly nonlinear regime, where the balance between gravity and surface tension dominates. Moreover, surface tension remains relatively strong and effectively resists interface steepening. As a result, the Marangoni-induced tangential flow primarily redistributes momentum along the interface without producing noticeable changes in the wave shape.

Four-panel plots showing the interface, surfactant concentration, Marangoni stress, and tangential velocity for different surfactant elasticity parameters

Figure 5. Effect of the elasticity parameter βs\beta_s for regular wave regime (ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3) at t=5.6t = 5.6. Two-dimensional projections of the interface, Γ\Gamma, MaMa and utxu_{t x} in the (xx–zz) plane (y=λ/8y = \lambda/8) are shown in (a–d), respectively. Note that the abscissa in (a) corresponds to the xx coordinate, and in (b–d) to the arc length, ss.

We next consider the spilling regime; the interfacial location, Γ\Gamma, τ\tau and utxu_{tx} are shown in Figure 6. For ϵ=0.324\epsilon=0.324, the addition of surfactant significantly modifies the shape and position of the wave crest (see Figure 6a). Surfactants also accumulate near the wave crest, leading to a slightly sharper, and more forward-leaning profile (Figure 6b).

Effect of the elasticity parameter for the spilling regime

Figure 6. Effect of the elasticity parameter for the spilling regime for ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324 at t=4.8t = 4.8, and ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 at t=5.2t = 5.2. Two-dimensional projections of the interface, Γ\Gamma, MaMa and utxu_{t_x} in the (x−z)(x-z) plane (y=λ/8)(y = \lambda/8) are shown. Panels (a–d) correspond to ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324, and panels (e–h) to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33.

This effect becomes more pronounced with increasing surfactant elasticity, which enhances interfacial gradients and promotes stronger Marangoni stresses. The resulting non-uniform surfactant distribution leads to localized peaks in Marangoni stresses near the crest (Figure 6c), and larger tangential velocities utu_t (Figure 6d). At slightly higher steepness, ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33, the addition of surfactant induces significant changes in the interfacial dynamics at t=4.8t = 4.8. As shown in Figure 6e, a small forward jet forms near the crest. Liu & Duncan [50] observed experimentally that, in surfactant-laden spilling breakers, the bulge shape flattens and becomes elongated along the slope of the front face of the wave. We observe similar qualitative behavior in our simulations, and acknowledge that quantitative agreement is not expected due to differences in Reynolds number and surfactant solubility, the geometric trends are consistent with the experimental observations (more details are given in Appendix § 10). We also note that Erinin et al. [32] observed experimentally that the addition of surfactants leads to a jet which curls inward for plunging breakers. The formation of this forward jet significantly reshapes both the surfactant concentration and tangential velocity fields. For βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, the surfactant distribution profile (Figure 6f) peaks in the wave location, with Marangoni stress are larger in the front of the crest. The resulting surfactant gradient enhances the Marangoni stress (Figure 6g), promoting jet elongation, and increases with βs\beta_s. A negative Marangoni peak is observed which promotes this elongation. Figure 6h shows the tangential velocity field utxu_{t x} along the interface. In the surfactant-free case, the tangential surface velocity first accelerates along the front face of the wave but undergoes a localized deceleration near the jet base, where momentum is redirected into the forming jet. Surfactants redistribute

surface momentum by promoting upstream acceleration along the wave front while inducing a sharply localized deceleration near the jet base through Marangoni stresses acting over a short arclength. By partially rigidifying the interface near the jet base, surfactants promote upstream surface stretching, which favors elongation of the bulge along the wave slope and suppresses its vertical growth, consistent with experimental observations.

Finally, in Figure 7, we examine the effect of surfactant in greater detail by analyzing the tangential velocity in the reference frame of the wave crest for both surfactant-free and surfactant-laden cases with ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 at t=[5.2,5.6,6.0]t = [5.2, 5.6, 6.0]. During the onset of spilling, a local minimum develops in the tangential velocity profile near the base of the crest. A feature which is enhanced in the presence of surfactants for spilling breakers. In the surfactant-free case, this secondary peak decays rapidly, and has disappeared by t=6.0t = 6.0 (see Figure 7c). In contrast, for the surfactant-laden case the secondary peak remains clearly visible at the same instant (see Figure 7f), indicating a prolonged effect of surfactant-driven Marangoni stresses near the crest. Although the crest speed is constant, the persistence and increased magnitude of utu_t in the surfactant case reflect enhanced tangential shear along the interface. The extended lifetime and strengthened secondary peak therefore provide direct evidence that surfactants promote and intensify spilling by sustaining near-crest shear through Marangoni stresses.

Two-dimensional projections of the interface location and tangential velocity

Figure 7. Two-dimensional projections of the interface location and tangential velocity in the reference frame of the wave crest for surfactant-free (top panels) with ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33; surfactant-laden case with βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 (middle panels) and surfactant-laden without Marangoni stresses (i.e., ∇sσ~=0\nabla_s\tilde{\sigma} = 0 in equation 2.3) with βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 (bottom panels) at times t=[5.2,5.6,6.0]t = [5.2, 5.6, 6.0], corresponding to columns one-to-three, respectively. Here, ctc_t denotes the tangential component of the average interfacial velocity.

To isolate the role of Marangoni stresses in the interfacial dynamics, we perform additional simulations in which Marangoni stresses are suppressed by imposing ∇sσ=0\nabla_s\sigma= 0 in equation 2.3. This constraint allows surfactant to remain non-uniformly distributed along the interface while preventing the generation of Marangoni stresses (a similar approach has been done by Kamat et al. [41] and Constante-Amores et al. [14] (2021c)). Figure 7 g-Figure 7i shows the cases for ∇sσ=0\nabla_s \sigma= 0 with ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 at times t=[5.2,5.6,6.0]t = [5.2, 5.6, 6.0], allowing the distinct roles of Marangoni stresses and surface tension variations can be inferred in the dynamics. Comparing panels 7d-f (Marangoni stresses allowed) with 7g-i (no Marangoni stresses) shows that the presence of Marangoni stresses enhances the second peak in the tangential velocity distribution, which is associated with the onset of spilling. In contrast, comparison with the surfactant-free cases (Figure 7a-Figure 7c) shows that a local reduction in surface tension, in the absence of Marangoni stresses, suppresses the secondary tangential velocity peak relative to the surfactant-free case. This demonstrates that a decrease in the local surface tension alone does not promote spilling. Instead, the enhancement of spilling observed in surfactant-laden simulations arises from Marangoni stresses, which generate tangential stress gradients, ∇sσ(Γ)\nabla_s \sigma(\Gamma), that locally accelerate the interface and amplify the secondary velocity peak.

Figure 8 shows the spanwise vorticity ωy=(∇×u)y\omega_y = (\nabla\times\mathbf{u})_y in a (x−z)(x - z) plane overlaid with the interface shape for steepness, ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324 (top panels) and ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 (bottom panels). For each case, results are shown for the surfactant-free and the surfactant-laden cases with β=0.3\beta= 0.3 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 (columns one to three, respectively). For ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324, the surfactant-free case exhibits a smooth flow separation near the wave crest, forming a broad region of negative ωy\omega_y loosely coupled to the interface (see Figure 8a). At moderate elasticity number βs=0.3\beta_s = 0.3, a distinct interfacial shear layer forms beneath the interface due to Marangoni-driven flow, characterized by adjacent bands of positive and negative ωy\omega_y straddling the interface, a signature of Marangoni-driven vorticity generation (see Figure 8b). At higher elasticity βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, this vorticity layer becomes more localized, and a secondary vorticity layer of opposite sign develops beneath the interface, a feature absent in the surfactant-free case. For the slightly larger steepness (ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33), separation is more abrupt, and early vortex roll-up occurs near the crest (see Figure 8d). The presence of surfactant significantly amplifies these effects. The interfacial shear layer strengthens, and the vorticity becomes more intense and confined in regions of high Γ\Gamma (see Figure 8e,Figure 8f). At βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, we observe a larger positive vorticity near the base of the wave, coinciding with the location of strongest surfactant accumulation. This correlation is consistent with enhanced interfacial shear and sharper velocity gradients induced by Marangoni stresses acting along the interface. In addition, Figure 8g-Figure 8h shows the corresponding flow fields when Marangoni stresses are suppressed, ∇sσ=0\nabla_s \sigma= 0. In this case, the positive vorticity generated near the crest region is significantly reduced compared to the surfactant-free case. This reduction becomes more pronounced as the elasticity parameter increases from βs=0.3\beta_s = 0.3 to βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, reflecting the stronger decrease in local surface tension at the crest for a given surfactant concentration. These results indicate that a reduction in surface tension alone does not enhance the shear layer at the crest; instead, it weakens vorticity generation. The amplification of vorticity observed in the full surfactant cases therefore requires the presence of Marangoni stresses, which introduce tangential stress gradients along the interface.

Two-dimensional representation of the interfacial location and spanwise vorticity component

Figure 8. Two-dimensional representation of the interfacial location (colored by Γ\Gamma) overlaid with the spanwise vorticity component ωy\omega_y in the (x−z)(x-z) plane. Panels (a–c) correspond to ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324 at t=4.8t = 4.8, while panels (d–f) correspond to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 at t=5.2t = 5.2; and panels (g–h) correspond to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 at t=5.2t = 5.2 with ∇sσ~=0\nabla_s\tilde{\sigma} = 0 in equation 2.3. Columns from left to right represent the surfactant-free case, βs=0.3\beta_s = 0.3, and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, respectively.

Finally, we examine the role of Marangoni stresses in the generation of vorticity at the gas–liquid interface. Vorticity production at free surfaces has been the subject of several studies (Longuet-Higgins [52]; Cresswell & Morton [20]; Peck & Sigurdson [60]; Lundgren & Koumoutsakos [53]; Brøns et al. [7]; Constante-Amores et al. [13]), and is particularly relevant in air–water systems where the free-surface approximation is appropriate. In this work, we adopt a two-dimensional version of the generalized formulation derived by Constante-Amores et al. [12], who described the evolution of circulation at a deformable interface within a three-dimensional control volume in the presence of surfactants. For brevity, we present only the final form of the governing equation used in the analysis in the main text; a full derivation of the two-dimensional form is provided in Appendix. The circulation is given by

DDt(∫Aω dA+∫ab[[u⋅t]] ds)=∮Cν∇ω⋅nc ds−∫abκ[[(u⋅n)(u⋅t)]] ds+12∫ab∂∂s[[(u⋅n)2]] ds−∫ab∂∂s[[pρ]] ds.(11)\frac{D}{Dt}\left(\int_A \omega\,dA+\int_a^b [[\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}]]\,ds\right)=\oint_C \nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds-\int_a^b\kappa[[(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})]]\,ds+\frac{1}{2}\int_a^b\frac{\partial}{\partial s}[[(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})^2]]\,ds-\int_a^b\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left[\left[\frac{p}{\rho}\right]\right]\,ds. \tag*{(11)}

Equation 3.1 describes the rate of change of circulation within a two dimensional control volume intersecting an arbitrary fluid interface of area AA separating two fluids with different material properties. The left-hand side consists of two terms: the integral of vorticity over AA, and the circulation jump along the curve from aa to bb, represented by the jump in tangential velocity [[u⋅t]][[\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}]]. However, under the assumption of velocity continuity across the interface in both normal and tangential directions, and given that the unit normal n\mathbf{n} and tangential t\mathbf{t} vectors are identical on either side of the interface, the jump in tangential velocity [[u⋅t]][[\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}]] vanishes. Similarly, the second term on the right-hand side involving the jump of the product (u⋅n)(u⋅t)(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}) and the third term involving the jump of (u⋅n)2(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})^2 also vanish. Therefore, the second term on the left-hand side and the second and third terms on the right-hand side of equation 3.1 are identically zero.

The last RHS term of equation 3.1 involves a jump in the pressure across the interface. Taking into account the jump in the normal stress condition at the interface, we express ∂[[p/ρ]]/∂s\partial[[p/\rho]]/\partial s as

∂∂s[[pρ]]=−1ρ1∂∂s(κσ)−2ρ1[[μ]](∂2∂s2(u⋅t)+∂∂s(κ(u⋅n)))+[[1ρ]]∂p2∂s.(12)\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left[\left[\frac{p}{\rho}\right]\right]=-\frac{1}{\rho_1}\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\kappa\sigma)-\frac{2}{\rho_1}[[\mu]]\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial s^2}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})+\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\kappa(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n}))\right)+\left[\left[\frac{1}{\rho}\right]\right]\frac{\partial p_2}{\partial s}. \tag*{(12)}

Therefore, the final expression for the circulation is that

DDt(∫Aω dA)=∮Cν∇ω⋅n ds+∫abσρ2∂κ∂s ds+∫abκρ2∂σ∂s ds+∫ab(2ρ1[[μ]](∂2∂s2(u⋅t)+∂∂s(κ(u⋅n^)))−[[1ρ]]∂p2∂s) ds,(13)\frac{D}{Dt}\left(\int_A\omega\,dA\right)=\oint_C\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds+\int_a^b\frac{\sigma}{\rho_2}\frac{\partial\kappa}{\partial s}\,ds+\int_a^b\frac{\kappa}{\rho_2}\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial s}\,ds +\int_a^b\left(\frac{2}{\rho_1}[[\mu]]\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial s^2}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})+\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\kappa(\mathbf{u}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{n}}))\right)-\left[\left[\frac{1}{\rho}\right]\right]\frac{\partial p_2}{\partial s}\right)\,ds, \tag*{(13)}

where the terms of the RHS represent mechanisms that drive the net evolution of circulation. These include the viscous diffusion, curvature gradients, surface tension gradients along the interface (including Marangoni effects), jumps in viscosity and pressure across the interface. We note that Marangoni stresses and variations in the of surface tension are distinct in previous equation, Marangoni stresses arise from the surface tension gradient term, ∂sσ\partial_s\sigma, which generates tangential vorticity, whereas the magnitude of surface tension enters through the curvature term, σ∂sκ\sigma\partial_s\kappa, and modifies the flow via capillary pressure. The results presented below indicate that the observed enhancement is associated with the former mechanism.

Figure 9 shows the RHS terms of equation 3.3, evaluated along the arclength ss in an (x−z)(x-z) plane located at the centerline of the domain, for the two spilling-like regimes considered in this work, ϵ=0.324\epsilon=0.324 (top panels) and ϵ=0.33\epsilon=0.33 (bottom panels). For

Figure 9. Two-dimensional representation of circulation generation mechanisms along the interface in the (x−z)(x-z) plane. Panels (a–c) correspond to ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324 at t=4.8t = 4.8, and panels (d–f) to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 at t=5.2t = 5.2. Columns from left to right show the surfactant-free case, βs=0.3\beta_s = 0.3, and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5, respectively.

each case, results are shown for the surfactant-free and the surfactant-laden cases with β=0.3\beta= 0.3 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 (columns one to three, respectively). This allows identification of the dominant physical mechanisms contributing to circulation generation. The viscous diffusion term is negligible in all conditions, confirming that interfacial mechanisms dominate circulation production. Across all cases, the primary contributor is the term associated with jumps in viscosity and density, which is consistent with the large density ratio in the system. Notably, the magnitude of this term increases in the presence of surfactants, indicating more intense interfacial activity. Contributions from surface tension gradients (Marangoni stresses) become significant only at the largest elasticity number for ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33, and they are spatially localized near regions of strong gradients in Γ\Gamma, particularly along the wave crest.

Conclusions

We present a detailed analysis of the effect of insoluble surfactants on wave breaking dynamics in both regular and spilling regimes, using high-resolution three-dimensional simulations. At We=100We = 100 and Re=104Re = 10^{4}, we explore how wave steepness modulates the flow in the presence of surfactants. The hybrid front-tracking/level-set method employed enables accurate coupling of inertia, capillarity, interfacial diffusion, and Marangoni stresses arising from surfactant-induced surface tension gradients. We find that surfactants have minimal impact on regular breakers, which retain similar shapes to the surfactant-free case, though a gradual interfacial rigidification is observed at longer times. In contrast, for spilling breakers, increasing elasticity induces a marked shift in dynamics, which agrees with previously reported experimental work in the same spilling regime. Surfactants enhance spilling breakers through Marangoni stresses, while surface-tension reduction alone does not reproduce this effect. This is demonstrated by simulations in which Marangoni stresses are suppressed while allowing local variations of surface tension along the interface. We also show that surfactants generate interfacial vorticity through Marangoni stresses driven by surfactant concentration gradients, as quantified by the circulation along the interface.

To our knowledge, this work provides the first direct characterization of the spatiotemporal evolution of surfactant concentration profiles during the spilling transition. Our results demonstrate that surfactant redistribution and the resulting Marangoni stresses play a key role in shaping the interfacial dynamics in the parameter regime considered here. How these mechanisms extend to higher Reynolds and Weber numbers, where inertia becomes increasingly important, remains an open question and warrants further investigation.

Future studies should extend the present analysis beyond the regular and spilling regimes into the fully plunging regime, where bubble entrainment and droplet ejection result from the dynamics. Capturing these processes requires that all relevant length and time scales be resolved, making adaptive mesh refinement indispensable. Higher Reynolds numbers and greater wave steepness must also be explored to reproduce realistic ocean conditions. In addition, incorporating soluble surfactants, with full adsorption/desorption kinetics and bulk transport, would introduce chemical timescales that could either damp or amplify wave breaking events.

Declaration of Interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.

Acknowledgments

This research used the Delta advanced computing and data resource which is supported by the National Science Foundation (award OAC 2005572) and the State of Illinois. CRCA acknowledges with gratitude O. K. Matar for insightful discussions on vorticity production, and L. Kahouadji for initial discussions. D.J. and J.C. acknowledge support through HPC/AI computing time at the Institut du Developpement et des Ressources en Informatique Scientifique (IDRIS) of the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), coordinated by GENCI (Grand Equipement National de Calcul Intensif) grant 2026 A0202B06721. The numerical simulations were performed with code BLUE (Shin et al. [68])

Vorticity generation in two-dimensional flows

Circulation

Before we examine the sources of vorticity flux near an interface, we must first consider the case of a single fluid and the vorticity equation which is given by

∂ω∂t+u⋅∇ω+ω⋅∇u=ν∇2ω.(14)\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\omega}}{\partial t}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\boldsymbol{\omega}+\boldsymbol{\omega}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}=\nu\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\omega}. \tag*{(14)}

Now, for a 2D flow, ω⋅∇u=0\boldsymbol{\omega}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}=0 since ∇u\nabla\mathbf{u} exists only in the (x,y)(x,y) plane whereas ω=(0,0,ω)\boldsymbol{\omega}=(0,0,\omega). Thus, (32) can be expressed as a 2D equation for the scalar quantity ω\omega:

DωDt=ν∇2ω.(15)\frac{D\omega}{Dt}=\nu\nabla^2\omega. \tag*{(15)}

From Stokes’s theorem, we can write ∮Cv⋅ds=∫A(∇×v)⋅da\oint_C \mathbf{v}\cdot d\mathbf{s}=\int_A(\nabla\times\mathbf{v})\cdot d\mathbf{a} for any vector v\mathbf{v} where dsd\mathbf{s} is an infinitesimal displacement along the arclength on a contour CC that encloses a simply connected1 area AA in the fluid and da=ekdAd\mathbf{a}=\mathbf{e}_k dA represents an infinitesimal region in this area; ek\mathbf{e}_k points into the page perpendicularly to the (x,y)(x,y) plane. Thus, if we set v=u\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{u} then

∮Cu⋅ds=∫A(∇×u)⋅ekdA=∫Aω⋅ekdA=∫AωdA≡ΓA,(16)\oint_C \mathbf{u}\cdot d\mathbf{s}=\int_A(\nabla\times\mathbf{u})\cdot\mathbf{e}_k dA=\int_A\boldsymbol{\omega}\cdot\mathbf{e}_k dA=\int_A\omega dA\equiv\Gamma_A, \tag*{(16)}

which relates the total circulation ΓA\Gamma_A to ω\omega. By taking a total derivative of ΓA\Gamma_A and making use of (33), we can write

DΓADt=DDt∫AωdA=∫ADωDtdA=∫Aν∇2ωdA.(17)\frac{D\Gamma_A}{Dt}=\frac{D}{Dt}\int_A\omega dA=\int_A\frac{D\omega}{Dt}dA=\int_A\nu\nabla^2\omega dA. \tag*{(17)}

Using the Divergence Theorem, the final term on the LHS of this equation can re-expressed as follows

∫Aν∇2ωdA=∫A∇⋅(ν∇ω)dA=∮Cnc⋅(ν∇ω)ds,(18)\int_A\nu\nabla^2\omega dA=\int_A\nabla\cdot(\nu\nabla\omega)dA=\oint_C\mathbf{n}_c\cdot(\nu\nabla\omega)ds, \tag*{(18)}

where nc\mathbf{n}_c is the outward-pointing unit normal to the contour CC. As a result, the total rate of change of circulation in area AA, ΓA\Gamma_A, becomes

DΓADt=DDt∫AωdA=∮Cν∇ω⋅ncds.(19)\frac{D\Gamma_A}{Dt}=\frac{D}{Dt}\int_A\omega dA=\oint_C\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}_c ds. \tag*{(19)}

This is an important equation which shows that the change in circulation results directly from the flux of vorticity from the boundary (characterised by the contour CC).

Near-interface Vorticity jump

We consider the case of two fluids separated by an interface. In order to evaluate the LHS of Eq. (19), we follow an approach that relies on a construction similar to that represented by Figure 2 in Brøns et al. [7]. This is necessary because the area AA is no longer simply connected but is instead divided because of the presence of the interface. With reference to Figure 2 in Brøns et al. [7], we write

DDt∫A1∪A2ω dA=∫C1′ν1∇ω1⋅nc ds+∫C2ν2∇ω2⋅nc ds+∫C1′ν1∇ω1⋅nc ds+∫C2′ν2∇ω2⋅nc ds.(20)\frac{D}{Dt}\int_{A_1\cup A_2}\omega\,dA=\int_{C'_1}\nu_1\nabla\omega_1\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds+\int_{C_2}\nu_2\nabla\omega_2\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds+\int_{C'_1}\nu_1\nabla\omega_1\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds+\int_{C'_2}\nu_2\nabla\omega_2\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds. \tag*{(20)}

Here, we distinguish between the normal to the contour CC, nc\mathbf{n}_c, and that to the interface II, n\mathbf{n}.

We now let nc→−n\mathbf{n}_c\to-\mathbf{n} from the fluid 2 side, and nc→n\mathbf{n}_c\to\mathbf{n} from the fluid 1 side, which results in

DDt∫A1∪A2ω dA=∫C1′ν1∇ω1⋅nc ds+∫C2ν2∇ω2⋅nc ds+∫C1′ν1∇ω1⋅n ds−∫C2′ν2∇ω2⋅n ds.(21)\frac{D}{Dt}\int_{A_1\cup A_2}\omega\,dA=\int_{C'_1}\nu_1\nabla\omega_1\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds+\int_{C_2}\nu_2\nabla\omega_2\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds+\int_{C'_1}\nu_1\nabla\omega_1\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds-\int_{C'_2}\nu_2\nabla\omega_2\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds. \tag*{(21)}

We note that in region A1A_1, we march in an anti-clockwise direction along contour C1′C'_1 where nc\mathbf{n}_c is aligned with n\mathbf{n} and then along contour C1C_1. In region A2A_2, we march along contour C2C_2 in an anti-clockwise direction and then along contour C2′C'_2 where nc\mathbf{n}_c points out of fluid 2 into fluid 1 in a direction opposite to that of n\mathbf{n}; the latter explains the minus sign in the fourth term of Eq. (21).

We now let the contours C1′C'_1 and C2′C'_2 approach the interface II so that the union of A1A_1 and A2A_2 approaches AA, i.e. A1∪A2→AA_1\cup A_2\to A, which leads to

DDt∫Aω dA=∮Cν∇ω⋅nc ds−(∫Iν2∇ω2⋅n ds−∫Iν1∇ω1⋅n ds).(22)\frac{D}{Dt}\int_A\omega\,dA=\oint_C\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds-\left(\int_I\nu_2\nabla\omega_2\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds-\int_I\nu_1\nabla\omega_1\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds\right). \tag*{(22)}

By introducing the notation [[q]]=q2−q1[[q]]=q_2-q_1 for the jump across the interface of a quantity qq, this equation can be re-expressed as follows

DDt∫Aω dA=∮Cν∇ω⋅nc ds−∫ab[[ν∇ω⋅n]] ds.(23)\frac{D}{Dt}\int_A\omega\,dA=\oint_C\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds-\int_a^b[[\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}]]\,ds. \tag*{(23)}

Equation (4.10) illustrates the contribution of the jump in the vorticity flux across the interface to the rate of change of the circulation. We can calculate this jump by using

DDt(u⋅t)+κ(u⋅n)(u⋅t)−12∂∂s(u⋅n)2+∇pρ⋅t=ν∇ω⋅n,(24)\frac{D}{Dt}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})+\kappa(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})-\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})^2+\frac{\nabla p}{\rho}\cdot\mathbf{t}=\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}, \tag*{(24)}

which comes from Eq. (23) in Lundgren & Koumoutsakos [53] and Eq. (2.10) in Brøns et al. [7]. Then, we have

DDt[[u⋅t]]+κ[[(u⋅n)(u⋅t)]]+∂∂s[[pρ]]−12∂∂s[[(u⋅n)2]]=[[ν∇ω⋅n]];(25)\frac{D}{Dt}[[\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}]]+\kappa[[(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})]]+\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left[\left[\frac{p}{\rho}\right]\right]-\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial s}[[(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})^2]]=[[\nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}]]; \tag*{(25)}

here, we have used the fact that t⋅∇=(∂/∂s)\mathbf{t}\cdot\nabla=(\partial/\partial s). Substitution of Eq. (25) into Eq. (23) leads to

\frac{D}{Dt}\left(\int_A \omega\,dA+\int_a^b \llbracket\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t}\rrbracket\,ds\right)=\oint_C \nu\nabla\omega\cdot\mathbf{n}_c\,ds-\int_a^b\kappa\llbracket(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})\rrbracket\,ds+\frac{1}{2}\int_a^b\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\llbracket(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})^2\rrbracket\,ds-\int_a^b\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left\llbracket\frac{p}{\rho}\right\rrbracket\,ds. \tag*{(26)}

Equation (4.13) involves a jump in the pressure across the interface. To make progress, we must first consider the jump in the normal stress condition at the interface expressed by

−p1+μ1n⋅D1⋅n+κσ=−p2+μ2n⋅D2⋅n,(27)-p_1+\mu_1\mathbf{n}\cdot\mathbf{D}_1\cdot\mathbf{n}+\kappa\sigma=-p_2+\mu_2\mathbf{n}\cdot\mathbf{D}_2\cdot\mathbf{n}, \tag*{(27)}

in which σ\sigma represents the interfacial tension and μ1\mu_1 and μ2\mu_2 the dynamic viscosities of fluids 1 and 2, respectively. Rearranging (27) yields

⟦p⟧=−κσ−2⟦μ(∂∂s(u⋅t)+κ(u⋅n))⟧;(28)\llbracket p\rrbracket=-\kappa\sigma-2\llbracket\mu\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})+\kappa(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})\right)\rrbracket; \tag*{(28)}

here, we have made use of

n⋅D⋅n=−2∂∂s(u⋅t)−2(u⋅n)κ.(29)\mathbf{n}\cdot\mathbf{D}\cdot\mathbf{n}=-2\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})-2(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})\kappa. \tag*{(29)}

Now, we re-express ⟦p/ρ⟧\llbracket p/\rho\rrbracket as follows

\left\llbracket\frac{p}{\rho}\right\rrbracket=\frac{p_2}{\rho_2}-\frac{p_1}{\rho_1}=\frac{p_2}{\rho_2}-\frac{p_2}{\rho_1}+\frac{p_2}{\rho_1}-\frac{p_1}{\rho_1} =-p_2\left(\frac{1}{\rho_2}-\frac{1}{\rho_1}\right)+\frac{1}{\rho_1}(p_2-p_1) =p_2\left\llbracket\frac{1}{\rho}\right\rrbracket+\frac{\llbracket p\rrbracket}{\rho_1}, \tag*{(30)}

from which we get that

\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left\llbracket\frac{p}{\rho}\right\rrbracket=-\frac{1}{\rho_1}\frac{\partial}{\partial s}(\kappa\sigma)-\frac{2}{\rho_1}\left\llbracket\mu\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial s^2}(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{t})+\frac{\partial}{\partial s}\left[\kappa(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})\right]\right)\right\rrbracket+\left\llbracket\frac{1}{\rho}\right\rrbracket\frac{\partial p_2}{\partial s}. \tag*{(31)}

Equation of state in insoluble surfactants

In this appendix, we assess the the interfacial dynamics at elevated surfactant concentrations as it can lead to artificial numerical results. We emphasis on the role of the equation of state relating surface tension σ\sigma and surfactant concentration Γ\Gamma, by σ=max⁡[0.05,1+βsln⁡(1−Γ)]\sigma=\max[0.05,1+\beta_s\ln(1-\Gamma)]. While the logarithmic equation of state σ=1+βsln⁡(1−Γ)\sigma=1+\beta_s\ln(1-\Gamma) is widely used [55, 41, 18], and appropriate over a broad range of concentrations, the imposed lower bound σ=0.05\sigma=0.05, constitutes an abrupt and nonphysical modification of the system, a regularization also adopted in studies such as [2, 59, 63]. This cutoff becomes active when the concentration exceeds the critical value Γc=1−exp⁡(−0.95/βs)\Gamma_c=1-\exp(-0.95/\beta_s), beyond which the surface tension is artificially pinned. Although such a regularization would be inconsequential if Γ<Γc\Gamma<\Gamma_c everywhere or only in dynamically passive regions, the simulations discussed in this appendix exhibit local concentrations Γ>Γc\Gamma>\Gamma_c, particularly near wave crests. We reiterate that the cutoff is active in these appendix simulations, but is not active in the simulations discussed in the main text. These results are presented to demonstrate that this numerical formulation can yield qualitatively different and non-physical dynamics, underscoring the need for caution in its use and interpretation.

Figure 10 and Figure 11 show the interfacial dynamics in the regular and spilling-like regimes for two values of the surfactant elasticity, βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5 and 0.90.9, corresponding to critical concentrations Γc≈0.85\Gamma_c \approx0.85 and Γc≈0.65\Gamma_c \approx0.65, respectively, for an initial surfactant concentration Γ0=0.5\Gamma_0 = 0.5. In the spilling-like regime, the dynamics exhibit an abrupt qualitative change, with a transition from plunging to spilling-type breaking as βs\beta_s is increased. In key snapshots such as Figure 11f, the surfactant concentration in the vicinity of the wave crest clearly exceeds Γc\Gamma_c for both values of βs\beta_s. Since this crest region governs the dominant interfacial dynamics, the imposed surface tension cutoff becomes active precisely where gradients in surface tension, and subsequently Marangoni stresses are expected to play a central role. As a result, the reported relationship between surface-tension reduction, Marangoni forcing, and the transition between plunging and spilling regimes may be influenced by the numerical regularization inherent in the constitutive model.

Effect of the elasticity parameter for regular wave regime

Figure 10. Effect of the elasticity parameter βs\beta_s for regular wave regime (ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3) at t=5.6t = 5.6. Two-dimensional projections of the interface, Γ\Gamma, MaMa and utxu_{t_x} in the (xx–zz) plane (y=λ/8y = \lambda/8) are shown in (a–d), respectively. Note that the abscissa in (a) corresponds to the xx coordinate, and in (b–d) to the arc length, ss.

Panel (a)

(a)

Panel (b)

(b)

Panel (c)

(c)

Panel (d)

(d)

Panel (e)

(e)

Panel (f)

(f)

Panel (g)

(g)

Panel (h)

(h)

Figure 11. Effect of the elasticity parameter for the spilling regime for ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324 at t=4.8t = 4.8, and ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 at t=4.4t = 4.4. Two-dimensional projections of the interface, Γ\Gamma, MaMa and utxu_{tx} in the (x(x–z)z) plane (y=λ/8)(y = \lambda/8) are shown. Panels (a–d) correspond to ϵ=0.324\epsilon= 0.324, and panels (e–h) to ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33.

We emphasize that these limitations are not specific to the present configuration but are inherent to inertia-dominated flows with insoluble surfactants, where strong interfacial compression can drive the concentration into regimes in which commonly used logarithmic equations of state require numerical regularization. A physically consistent route to modelling such regimes is to extract the equation of state directly from experiments and

to fit a smooth constitutive relation that remains well behaved at high concentrations. This approach has recently been adopted by Eshima et al. [33], leading to improved physical fidelity in simulations. In the absence of such an experimental equation of state, artificial cutoffs may lead to nonphysical effects when high surfactant concentrations are reached. An alternative modelling approach is to allow surfactant solubility, enabling adsorption-desorption dynamics that naturally limit surface accumulation and alleviate the need for ad hoc regularization.

Mesh resolution and spanwise domain length

To demonstrate mesh independent results, we have monitored the temporal variation of the kinetic energy of the system for a resolution of λ/Δx=[256,512,1024]\lambda/\Delta x = [256, 512, 1024] for waves with

ϵ=0.30\epsilon= 0.30 (regular) and ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 (spilling), displayed in Figure 12a and 12b, respectively. For both cases, the coarsest grid, with λ/Δx=256\lambda/\Delta x = 256, exhibits noticeable discrepancies, particularly in the valley regions of the kinetic energy evolution. In contrast, the cases with λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512 and 10241024 collapse almost exactly onto one another, with discrepancies remaining below 1% over the entire simulation window. The λ/Δx=1024\lambda/\Delta x = 1024 resolution was therefore run only for a short time owing to the prohibitive computational cost associated with the much smaller time step. The results for λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512 and λ/Δx=1024\lambda/\Delta x = 1024 are essentially indistinguishable, demonstrating the mesh independence of our results for regular and spilling breaking cases shown in this work. All results presented in this manuscript correspond to simulations performed at λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512. Finally, Figure 13 presents a comparison of key interfacial at t=3.0t = 3.0, including the interface profile, Γ\Gamma, τ\tau and utxu_{tx} for different grid resolutions with ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 and βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5. Excellent agreement is observed between the λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512 and 10241024 cases across all quantities considered, with relative differences of O(10−3)O(10^{-3}). This indicates that the interfacial dynamics are well resolved at λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512, and the results presented in the manuscript are mesh independent.

Grid and spanwise domain-size independence of the kinetic energy evolution

Figure 12. Grid and spanwise domain-size independence of the kinetic energy evolution. The temporal evolution of the normalized kinetic energy Ek/Ek0E_k/E_{k0} is shown for ϵ=0.30\epsilon= 0.30 (regular wave) and ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33 (spilling breaker) corresponding to panels (a) and (b), respectively. In panel (a), spanwise domain widths λ\lambda, λ/2\lambda/2, λ/4\lambda/4, and λ/8\lambda/8 are also added at fixed spatial resolution λ/Δx=512\lambda/\Delta x = 512.

Grid convergence plots for a representative surfactant-laden spilling-breaker

Figure 13. Grid convergence for a representative surfactant-laden spilling-breaker (ϵ=0.33\epsilon= 0.33, βs=0.5\beta_s = 0.5) at time t=3.0t = 3.0. Comparisons of N=256N = 256, 512512, and 10241024 for (a) interface location, (b) Γ\Gamma, (c) τ\tau, and (d) utxu_{tx}.

To verify that the chosen computational width (λ/4\lambda/4) does not influence the dynamics, we performed a width-independence study for the clean-wave case with ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3, measuring the kinetic energy evolution while repeating the simulation using domain widths λ\lambda, λ/2\lambda/2, λ/4\lambda/4, and λ/8\lambda/8, as shown in Figure 12a. The resulting kinetic energy plot collapses onto one another, demonstrating that spanwise confinement does not affect the wave dynamics in the regime studied.

Temporal evolution of the mechanical, kinetic, and gravitational potential energies

Figure 14. Temporal evolution of the mechanical, kinetic, and gravitational potential energies, normalised by their initial values for ϵ=0.3\epsilon= 0.3.

Mechanical energy evolution

In this work, the instantaneous kinetic and gravitational potential energies are defined as

EK(t)=12∫d≥0ρ(u2+v2) dx dy,EP(t)=∫d≥0ρy dx dy,(32)E_K(t) = \frac{1}{2} \int_{d \ge0} \rho\left(u^2 + v^2\right)\,\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y,\qquad E_P(t) = \int_{d \ge0} \rho y\,\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y, \tag*{(32)}

and the mechanical energy is given by

Emech(t)=EK(t)+EP(t).(33)E_{\mathrm{mech}}(t) = E_K(t) + E_P(t). \tag*{(33)}

Following the approach of Iafrati [40], we note that for weakly damped regular gravity waves, EKE_K and EPE_P exchange periodically over a wave period, while their sum EmechE_{\mathrm{mech}} decays monotonically due to viscous dissipation. In this regime, the decay of the mechanical energy is given by

Emech(t)∼Emech(0) e−2γt,E_{\mathrm{mech}}(t) \sim E_{\mathrm{mech}}(0)\,\mathrm{e}^{-2\gamma t},

and the exponential envelope of EK(t)E_K(t) provides an accurate estimate of the decay rate. Figure 14 shows the computed potential energy EP(t)E_P(t) evaluated at discrete times, reflecting the fact that snapshots were saved only at selected instants. For comparison, we also include the predicted mechanical energy Emech(t)E_{\mathrm{mech}}(t). We also find that the decay of EmechE_{\mathrm{mech}} is in excellent agreement with the exponential decay of the kinetic energy. Furthermore, the contribution of surface-tension energy is negligible in this regime, as the Weber number is large; the same assumption was adopted by Iafrati [40].

Comparison of bulge shapes with experimental results

Figure 15 presents a qualitative comparison between the present simulations and the experimental profiles reported by Liu & Duncan [50]. We emphasize that this comparison is not intended as a quantitative validation. The experiments involve soluble surfactants with adsorption–desorption kinetics, whereas the present model assumes an insoluble surfactant with no exchange with the bulk. In addition, the characteristic Reynolds and Bond numbers in the experiments are substantially larger than those considered here. Using the crest height HcH_c as the length scale, Liu & Duncan [50] reported Re≈9.3×104Re \approx9.3 \times10^{4}, Bo≈9.2×102Bo \approx9.2 \times10^{2}, and wave steepness ϵ≈0.44\epsilon\approx0.44. When expressed in terms of the wavelength λ\lambda, these correspond to Re≈1.3×106Re \approx1.3 \times10^{6} and Bo≈1.9×105Bo \approx1.9 \times10^{5}. By contrast, the present simulations are performed at Re=104Re = 10^{4} and Bo=253.3Bo = 253.3 (We=100We = 100), indicating differences of one to two orders of magnitude depending on the choice of length scale. Despite these differences, the overall bulge morphology, including crest elevation, forward leaning of the crest, and the curvature transition near the toe, shows similar qualitative trends across the datasets. This suggests that these large-scale interfacial features are reproduced consistently, even though the surfactant model and operating conditions differ substantially. The comparison should therefore be interpreted as evidence of qualitative consistency in interface shape, rather than as a strict quantitative agreement or a validation of the detailed dynamics.

Comparison of bulge shapes for clean and surfactant-laden conditions

Figure 15. Comparison of bulge shapes for clean and surfactant-laden conditions between the experiments of Liu & Duncan (2006) and the present simulations at ϵ=0.35\epsilon= 0.35, corresponding to panels (a) and (b), respectively.

References

  1. [1]Ambravaneswaran, B. & Basaran, O.A. 1999 Effects of insoluble surfactants on the nonlinear deformation and breakup of stretching liquid bridges. Phys. Fluids 11 (5), 997–1015.DOI
  2. [2]Asadi, H., Asgharzadeh, H. & Borazjani, I. 2018 On the scaling of propagation of periodically generated vortex rings. J. Fluid Mech. 853, 150–170.DOI
  3. [3]Atasi, Omer, Haut, Benoit, Dupont, Annaig, Schied, Benoît & Legendre, Dominique 2018 Influence of soluble surfactants and deformation on the dynamics of centered bubbles in cylindrical microchannels. Langmuir 34 (34), 10048–10062.DOI
  4. [4]Babanin, Alexander V, Chalikov, Dmitry, Young, Ian R & Savelyev, Ivan 2010 Numerical and laboratory investigation of breaking of steep two-dimensional waves in deep water. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 644, 433–463.DOI
  5. [5]Batchvarov, A., Kahouadji, L., Constante-Amores, C.R., Norões Gonçalves, G.F., Shin, S., Chergui, J., Juric, D., Craster, R.V. & Matar, O.K. 2021 Three-dimensional dynamics of falling films in the presence of insoluble surfactants. J. Fluid Mech. 906, A16.DOI
  6. [6]Batchvarov, A., Kahouadji, L., Magnini, M., Constante-Amores, C. R., Craster, R. V., Shin, S., Chergui, J., Juric, D. & Matar, O. K. 2020 Effect of surfactant on elongated bubbles in capillary tubes at high Reynolds number. Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 093605.arxiv.org/abs/2005.12269
  7. [7]Brøns, M., Thompson, M.C., Lewke, T. & Hourigan, K. 2014 Vorticity generation and conservation for two-dimensional interfaces and boundaries. J. Fluid Mech. 758, 63–93.
  8. [8]Ceniceros, H.D. 2003 The effects of surfactants on the formation and evolution of capillary waves. Phys. Fluids 15 (1), 245–256.DOI
  9. [9]Chanson, Hubert 2009 Current knowledge in hydraulic jumps and related phenomena. a survey of experimental results. European Journal of Mechanics-B/Fluids 28 (2), 191–210.DOI
  10. [10]CHEN, G., KHARIF, C., ZALESKI, S. & LI, J. 1999 Two-dimensional navier–stokes simulation of breaking waves. Phys. Fluids 11 (1), 121–133.arxiv.org/abs/comp-gas/9605002
  11. [11]CHORIN, A. L. 1968 Numerical solution of the navier-stokes equations. Mathematics of Computation 22 (104), 745–762.DOI
  12. [12]CONSTANTE-AMORES, C., ABADIE, T., KAHOUADJI, L., SHIN, S., CHERGUI, J., JURIC, D., CASTREJÓN-PITA, A. & MATAR, O. 2023a Direct numerical simulations of turbulent jets: vortex–interface–surfactant interactions. J. Fluid Mech. 955, A42.DOI
  13. [13]CONSTANTE-AMORES, C., BATCHVAROV, A., KAHOUADJI, L., SHIN, S., CHERGUI, J., JURIC, D. & MATAR, O. 2021a Role of surfactant-induced marangoni stresses in drop–interface coalescence. J. Fluid Mech. 925, A15.DOI
  14. [14]CONSTANTE-AMORES, C., CHERGUI, J., SHIN, S., JURIC, D., CASTREJÓN-PITA, J. & CASTREJÓN-PITA, A. 2022 Role of surfactant-induced marangoni stresses in retracting liquid sheets. J. Fluid Mech. 949, A32.DOI
  15. [15]CONSTANTE-AMORES, C.R., KAHOUADJI, L., BATCHVAROV, A., S., S., CHERGUI, J., JURIC, D. & MATAR, O.K. 2020 Dynamics of retracting surfactant-laden ligaments at intermediate ohnesorge number. Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 084007.arxiv.org/abs/2001.11029
  16. [16]CONSTANTE-AMORES, C., KAHOUADJI, L., BATCHVAROV, A., SHIN, S., CHERGUI, J., JURIC, D. & MATAR, O. 2021b Direct numerical simulations of transient turbulent jets: vortex–interface interactions. J. Fluid Mech. 922, A6.DOI
  17. [18]CONSTANTE-AMORES, CR, KAHOUADJI, L, SHIN, S, CHERGUI, J, JURIC, D, CASTREJÓN-PITA, JR, MATAR, OK & CASTREJÓN-PITA, AA 2023b Impact of droplets onto surfactant-laden thin liquid films. J. Fluid Mech. 961, A8.DOI
  18. [19]CRASTER, RV, MATAR, OK & PAPAGEORGIOU, DT 2002 Pinchoff and satellite formation in surfactant covered viscous threads. Physics of Fluids 14 (4), 1364–1376.DOI
  19. [20]CRESSWELL, R.W. & MORTON, B.R. 1995 Drop-formed vortex rings–the generation of vorticity. Phys. Fluids 7 (6), 1363–1370.DOI
  20. [21]DEIKE, L. 2022 Mass transfer at the ocean–atmosphere interface: the role of wave breaking, droplets, and bubbles. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 54 (1), 191–224.DOI
  21. [22]DEIKE, L., GHABACHE, E., LIGER-BELAIR, G., DAS, A.K., ZALESKI, S., POPINET, S. & SÉON, T. 2018 Dynamics of jets produced by bursting bubbles. Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 013603.DOI
  22. [23]DEIKE, LUC, MELVILLE, W KENDALL & POPINET, STÉPHANE 2016 Air entrainment and bubble statistics in breaking waves. J. Fluid Mech. 801, 91–129.DOI
  23. [24]DEIKE, L., POPINET, S. & MELVILLE, W.K. 2015 Capillary effects on wave breaking. J. Fluid Mech. 769, 541–569.DOI
  24. [26]DI GIORGIO, S., PIROZZOLI, S. & IAFRATI, A. 2024 Air entrainment and gas transfer processes in wave breaking. arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.20576 .arxiv.org/abs/2412.20576
  25. [28]DUNCAN, JH 1981 An experimental investigation of breaking waves produced by a towed hydrofoil. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences 377 (1770), 331–348.DOI
  26. [29]DUNCAN, J.H. 2001 Spilling breakers. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 33 (1), 519–547.
  27. [30]DUNCAN, J.H., QIAO, H., PHILOMIN, V. & WENZ, A. 1999 Gentle spilling breakers: crest profile evolution. J. Fluid Mech. 379, 191–222.DOI
  28. [31]DUNCAN, JAMES H 1983 The breaking and non-breaking wave resistance of a two-dimensional hydrofoil. Journal of fluid mechanics 126, 507–520.DOI
  29. [32]ERININ, M., LIU, C., LIU, X., MOSTERT, W., DEIKE, L. & DUNCAN, J. 2023 The effects of surfactants on plunging breakers. J. Fluid Mech. 972, R5.DOI
  30. [33]ESHIMA, JUN, AURÉGAN, TRISTAN, FARSOYIA, PALAS KUMAR, POPINET, STÉPHANE, STONE, HOWARD A. & DEIKE, LUC 2025 Size amplification of jet drops due to insoluble surfactants. Phys. Rev. Fluids 10, 123604.DOI
  31. [35]Gavrilyuk, S.L., Liapidevskii, V Yu & Chesnokov, A.A. 2016 Spilling breakers in shallow water: applications to favre waves and to the shoaling and breaking of solitary waves. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 808, 441–468.DOI
  32. [36]Grue, J. & Fructus, D. 2010a Model for fully nonlinear ocean wave simulations derived using fourier inversion of integral equations in 3d. In Advances in numerical simulation of nonlinear water waves, pp. 1–42. World Scientific.DOI
  33. [37]Grue, John & Fructus, Dorian 2010b MODEL FOR FULLY NONLINEAR OCEAN WAVE SIMULATIONS DERIVED USING FOURIER INVERSION OF INTEGRAL EQUATIONS IN 3D, pp. 1–42.DOI
  34. [38]Harlow, F.H. & Welch, J.E. 1965 Numerical calculation of time-dependent viscous incompressible flow of fluid with free surface. The Phys. Fluids 8 (12), 2182–2189.DOI
  35. [40]Iafrati, A 2009 Numerical study of the effects of the breaking intensity on wave breaking flows. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 622, 371–411.
  36. [41]Kamat, P.M., Wagoner, B.W., Castrejón-Pita, A.A., Castrejón-Pita, J.R., Anthony, C.R. & Basaran, O.A. 2020 Surfactant-driven escape from endpinching during contraction of nearly inviscid filaments. J. Fluid Mech. 899, A28.
  37. [42]Kamat, P.M., Wagoner, B.W., Thete, S.S. & Basaran, O.A. 2018 Role of marangoni stress during breakup of surfactant-covered liquid threads: Reduced rates of thinning and microthread cascades. Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 043602.
  38. [43]Kwak, Do-Young & Lee, Jun S 2004 Multigrid analysis for higher order finite difference scheme. Journal of Numerical Mathematics 12 (4).DOI
  39. [44]Landau, L.D. & Lifshitz, E.M. 1987 Fluid Mechanics: Volume 6, , vol. 6. Elsevier.
  40. [45]Lapham, G.S. 1998 Wave-surfactant interaction. University of Michigan.
  41. [46]Laxague, N.J., Zappa, C.J., Soumya, S. & Wurl, O. 2024 The suppression of ocean waves by biogenic slicks. J. R. Soc. Interface 21 (220), 20240385.DOI
  42. [47]Liao, Y., Franses, E.I. & Basaran, O.A. 2006 Deformation and breakup of a stretching liquid bridge covered with an insoluble surfactant monolayer. Phys. Fluids 18 (2).
  43. [48]Liu, C., Erinin, M., Liu, X. & Duncan, J. 2025 The effect of surfactants on droplet generation in a plunging breaker. J. Fluid Mech. 1009, A31.
  44. [49]Liu, X. & Duncan, J.H. 2003 The effects of surfactants on spilling breaking waves. Nature 421 (6922), 520–523.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12556889
  45. [50]Liu, X. & Duncan, J.H. 2006 An experimental study of surfactant effects on spilling breakers. J. Fluid Mech. 567, 433–455.
  46. [51]Liu, X. & Duncan, J.H. 2007 Weakly breaking waves in the presence of surfactant micelles. Phys. Rev. E 76 (6), 061201.
  47. [52]Longuet-Higgins, M.S. 1992 Capillary rollers and bores. J. Fluid Mech. 240, 659–679.
  48. [53]Lundgren, T. & Koumoutsakos, P. 1999 On the generation of vorticity at a free surface. J. Fluid Mech. 382, 351–366.
  49. [55]Manikantan, H. & Squires, T.M. 2020 Surfactant dynamics: hidden variables controlling fluid flows. J. Fluid Mech. 892, P1.
  50. [56]Melville, W.K. 1996 The role of surface-wave breaking in air-sea interaction .
  51. [57]Mostert, W. & Deike, L. 2020 Inertial energy dissipation in shallow-water breaking waves. J. Fluid Mech. 890, A12.
  52. [58]Mostert, Wouter, Popinet, Stéphane & Deike, Luc 2022 High-resolution direct simulation of deep water breaking waves: transition to turbulence, bubbles and droplets production. J. Fluid Mech. 942, A27.
  53. [59]Muradoglu, Metin & Tryggvason, Gretar 2008 A front-tracking method for computation of interfacial flows with soluble surfactants. Journal of computational physics 227 (4), 2238–2262.
  54. [60]Peck, B. & Sigurdson, L. 1998 On the kinetics at a free surface. IMA J. Appl. Math. 61 (1), 1–13.DOI
  55. [62]Peskin, Charles S 1977 Numerical analysis of blood flow in the heart. Journal of computational physics 25 (3), 220–252.DOI
  56. [63]Pico, P., Kahouadji, L., Shin, S., Chergui, J., Juric, D. & Matar, O.K. 2024 Surfactant-laden bubble bursting: Dynamics of capillary waves and worthington jet at large bond number. Physical Review Fluids 9 (8), 083606.arxiv.org/abs/2404.09196
  57. [64]Qiao, H. & Duncan, J.H. 2001 Gentle spilling breakers: crest flow-field evolution. J. Fluid Mech. 439, 57–85.DOI
  58. [65]Ramberg, Steven E & Griffin, Owen M 1987 Laboratory study of steep and breaking deep water waves. Journal of waterway, port, coastal, and ocean engineering 113 (5), 493–506.DOI
  59. [66]Rapp, R.J. & Melville, W.K. 1990 Laboratory measurements of deep-water breaking waves. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences 331 (1622), 735–800.DOI
  60. [67]Richard, Gaël Loïc, Duran, Arnaud & Fabrèges, B 2019 A new model of shoaling and breaking waves. part 2. run-up and two-dimensional waves. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 867, 146–194.DOI
  61. [68]Shin, S., Chergui, J. & Juric, D. 2017 A solver for massively parallel direct numerical simulation of three-dimensional multiphase flows. J. Mech. Sci. Tech. 31, 1739–1751.arxiv.org/abs/1410.8568
  62. [69]Shin, S., Chergui, J., Juric, D., Kahouadji, L., Matar, O. K. & Craster, R. V. 2018 A hybrid interface tracking – level set technique for multiphase flow with soluble surfactant. J. Comp. Phys. 359, 409–435.DOI
  63. [70]Shin, S. & Juric, D. 2007 High order level contour reconstruction method. J. of Mech. Sci. and Tech. 21 (2), 311–326.DOI
  64. [71]Stone, H.A. 1990 A simple derivation of the time-dependent convective-diffusion equation for surfactant transport along a deforming interface. Phys. Fluids A: Fluid Dynamics 2 (1), 111–112.DOI
  65. [72]Sussman, Mark, Smereka, Peter & Osher, Stanley 1994 A level set approach for computing solutions to incompressible two-phase flow. Journal of Computational physics 114 (1), 146–159.DOI
  66. [73]Takagi, S. & Matsumoto, Y. 2011 Surfactant effects on bubble motion and bubbly flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 43 (1), 615–636.DOI
  67. [74]Teigen, Knut Erik, Song, Peng, Lowengrub, John & Voigt, Axel 2011 A diffuse-interface method for two-phase flows with soluble surfactants. Journal of computational physics 230 (2), 375–393.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21218125
  68. [75]Temam, Roger 1968 Sur la stabilité et la convergence de la méthode des pas fractionnaires. Annali di Matematica pura ed applicata 79 (1), 191–379.DOI
  69. [76]Treske, Andreas 1994 Undular bores (favre-waves) in open channels-experimental studies. Journal of Hydraulic Research 32 (3), 355–370.DOI
  70. [78]Wee, H., Wagoner, B.W., Kamat, P.M. & Basaran, O.A. 2020 Effects of surface viscosity on breakup of viscous threads. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (20), 204501.DOI
  71. [79]Whitham, G.B. 2011 Linear and nonlinear waves. John Wiley & Sons.

Paper details

vlnc:W_ws94uqfu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents