WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Adjustable 3D magnetic configuration in ferrimagnetic multilayers with competing interactions visualized by soft X-ray vector tomography
Abstract
Soft X-ray magnetic vector tomography has been used to visualize with unprecedented detail and solely from experimental data the 3D magnetic configuration of a ferrimagnetic Gd12Co88/Nd17Co83/Gd24Co76 multilayer with competing anisotropy, exchange and magnetostatic interactions at different depths. The trilayer displays magnetic stripe domains, arranged in a chevron pattern, which are imprinted from the central Nd17Co83 into the bottom Gd12Co88 layer with a distorted closure domain structure across the thickness. Near the top Gd24Co76 layer, local exchange springs with out-of-plane magnetization reversal, modulated ripple patterns and magnetic vortices and antivortices across the thickness are observed. The detailed analysis of the magnetic tomogram shows that the effective strength of the exchange spring at the NdCo/GdCo interface can be finely tuned by GdxCo1-x composition and anisotropy (determined by sample fabrication) and in-plane stripe orientation (adjustable), demonstrating the capability of 3D magnetic visualization techniques in magnetic engineering research.
Introduction
Advanced spintronic devices and magnetic recording media require control and characterization of multilayer magnetic systems in which the desired magnetic behaviour has to be precisely adjusted by properly tuning magnetic interactions such as exchange and magnetostatics [1, 2]. For example, ferrimagnetic materials such as Gd-Co alloys [3, 4] with their adjustable magnetization offer the possibility of controlling spin-wave modes [5], spin-orbit torque, skyrmion nucleation and fast domain wall motion [6, 7, 8, 9].
Exchange springs are very interesting features to tune the magnetic behavior of a system: when two exchange coupled magnetic layers have very different magnetic anisotropy [10], they originate characteristic domain walls at the interfaces to accommodate the reversible rotation of the soft magnetic layer under an applied field, while the hard layer stays pinned in its original magnetic configuration. They are versatile magnetic systems since they can be easily tuned adjusting the individual layer thickness and interlayer coupling strength [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. Exchange springs exist in ferrimagnetic multilayers both in materials with in-plane [11, 12] and out-of-plane [13, 14, 15, 16] magnetic anisotropy, or even crossed [17] and chiral anisotropies [18].
Most of the previous studies are based in measurements of hysteresis loops and the domain structures, which are instrumental for the understanding magnetization reversal, are inferred indirectly from comparisons with micromagnetic simulations [17]. Microscopy techniques such as Magnetic Force microscopy (MFM) can also be used to disentangle magnetization reversal at the nanoscale as has been recently reported in ferro/ferrimagnetic NiCoPt/TbFeCo but, again, with the support of micromagnetic simulations of the observed magnetic contrast [20]. In-depth characterization of magnetization profiles of interfacial domain walls can be obtained by magnetic reflectometry with either neutron [19] or X-ray based techniques [11, 21, 22] but mainly in systems with homogeneous or periodic configuration.
Full control of global and local magnetic properties in exchange coupled multilayers requires a good understanding of the 3D magnetic structures with appropriate lateral and in-depth resolutions. An initial approach based on element specific Magnetic Transmission X-ray Microscopy (MTXM) allowed to identify different magnetization reversal processes across the thickness of GdCo/NdCo/NiFe multilayers [23, 24, 25] and the physics of magnetic vortex imprinting in NiFe/CoPt nanostructures [26]. More recently, the development of Transmission X-ray Vector Tomography and Laminography [27, 28] has allowed resolving magnetization vector fields in 3D and has opened a fully experimental approach to study complex magnetization textures. These methods exploit X-ray Magnetic Circular Dichroism and differently oriented projections of the sample to be able to reconstruct its inner magnetic configuration [29, 30]. It has also been extended to dynamics allowing for 4D mapping of the magnetization [31]. MTXM has demonstrated to be excellent for revealing the nature of magnetic singularities, non-trivial magnetic topological textures and complex magnetization configurations [27, 32, 33].
In this report we have exploited the capabilities of magnetic vector tomography to determine the magnetization of a complex magnetic trilayer engineered to have competing or favoring exchange/magnetostatic interactions at different depths. The detailed analysis of the remnant magnetic configuration reveals a 3D structure that combines stripe domains, exchange spring walls across the thickness and modulated ripple patterns. In plane stripe domain orientation, adjustable through magnetic history, appears as the relevant parameter to control the strength of global interlayer coupling.
Results and Discussion
Multilayer design
We have prepared an 80 nm GdCo/80 nm NdCo/80 nm GdCo multilayer designed to support an exchange spring at the top layer. Ferrimagnetic GdCo alloys present a soft magnetic behaviour with in-plane uniaxial anisotropy, whereas the stoichiometry of the central NdCo layer corresponds to a ferromagnetic alloy with weak perpendicular anisotropy (see Figure 1(a)). The purpose of the central layer, which had the largest anisotropy in the multilayer, is to create a pattern of stripe domains with alternating up-down magnetization orientation [23] that can be used to control the configuration in the neighbouring GdCo layers via interfacial exchange and magnetostatic interactions. Also, the stripe pattern provides an interesting possibility for external adjustment of the system after sample fabrication: stripe orientation can be rotated at will with large enough in-plane magnetic fields and becomes locked at low fields by the so-called rotatable anisotropy [34, 35] which is an in-plane pseudo-uniaxial anisotropy of magnetostatic origin with easy axis along the direction of the stripes.
Figure 1. (a) Sketch of multilayer structure. Black/white thin arrows indicate magnetization of Co and Gd atom sublattices, and , respectively. Thick arrows indicate net magnetization . Double orange arrows indicate anisotropy easy axis. (b) Room temperature MOTKE hysteresis loop of 50 nm control sample, sensitive only to Co atom sublattice. Note the negative signal at saturation in a positive field, indicating the antiparallel alignment between and , i.e. . (c) Room temperature MOTKE hysteresis loop of 50 nm control sample with positive signal at positive saturation field, corresponding to parallel and , i.e. .
The magnetization of the ferrimagnetic GdCo alloy is given by the sum of the contributions of Co and Gd atom sublattices [11]. The magnetization vectors of each sublattice can be written as and , where and are the magnetization magnitudes and and are unit vectors. In these GdCo alloys, Gd and Co moments are collinear and antiparallel, so that . The net magnetization of the alloy is given by
where is a scalar factor that relates with . The saturation magnetization of the alloy is . Depending on temperature and composition, may be either positive () or negative (). In-plane magnetized GdCo/GdCo exchange springs are usually designed by finely tuning the alloy composition so that has opposite signs at each layer [11].
Here, the composition of the bottom GdCo layer has been chosen so that its saturation magnetization is large and is positive at room temperature. On the contrary, the top layer GdCo composition is selected so that its compensation temperature is slightly above room temperature which implies that is small and is negative. The sign of was determined by Magnetooptical Transverse Kerr effect (MOTKE) hysteresis loops (see Figure 1(b-Figure 1c)), measured at room temperature with white light, on 50 nm thick GdCo control samples with the same composition as top/bottom layers in the trilayer. For incident light in the visible, MOTKE is only sensitive to Co magnetic moments [11]. Then, at positive applied fields, implies a positive MOTKE signal and parallel to (see Figure 1(c)). On the contrary, implies negative MOTKE signal at positive applied fields since is antiparallel to (see Figure 1(b)).
The magnetization configuration of GdCo layers will depend on three competing interactions across the sample thickness related with the magnetic parameters selected for each layer in these GdCo/NdCo/GdCo multilayers (see sketch in Figure 1(a)). The first one is the exchange interaction at the interfaces, which in Rare Earth-Transition Metal alloys is dominated by , the exchange between Co moments [11] and favours the parallel alignment of at the different layers. The second is the uniaxial anisotropy with out-of-plane easy axis at the central layer and in-plane easy axis at the outer layers. Finally, magnetostatic interactions will try to minimize magnetic charges (i.e. discontinuities in the magnetization), creating closure domains and favouring parallel alignment of and at the interfaces, which may either compete or cooperate with interfacial exchange depending on the sign of .
In summary, our multilayer design includes a laterally modulated domain structure (stripe domains) that can be adjusted with magnetic history, and competing exchange, anisotropy and magnetostatic interactions across the multilayer thickness. As described in what follows, vector tomography has allowed visualizing the complex domain structure demonstrating its capabilities in magnetic engineering research.
Soft X-ray MTXM and Vector Tomography
Figure 2 shows several MTXM images, measured at the Gd M absorption edge with different angles of incidence so that they are sensitive to the different components of the magnetic moment (angle geometry as sketched in Figure 2). Figure 2(a-Figure 2c) correspond to a first series of images measured with (Tilt series 1) and Figure 2(d-Figure 2f) to a second series of images measured with (Tilt series 2). A clear chevron pattern of alternating out-of-plane stripe domains is observed at normal incidence with period nm (see Figure 2(b) and Figure 2(d) at ). In Tilt series 1 at oblique incidence (sensitive to and ), we observe groups of parallel stripes with similar average contrast that is reversed for opposite values of (see regions labelled as MD1-MD4 in Figure 2(a) and Figure 2(c) at ). This indicates that the sample magnetization is broken into a structure of larger magnetic domains (several m wide) with similar average in-plane magnetization superimposed on the fast out-of-plane magnetization oscillation of the magnetic stripe pattern. These in-plane magnetization domains will be denoted as MD in the following.
Figure 2. MTXM images at different angular orientations at Gd M edge. Sketch of X-ray beam/sample geometry at the MISTRAL microscope indicating angles and . Tilt series 1 (): a) ; b) ; c) . Tilt series 2 (): d) ; e) ; f) . Dashed line indicates rotation axis for each tilt series. Labels indicate Magnetic Domains (MD) with different average in-plane magnetization.
However, in Tilt series 2 at oblique incidence (sensitive approximately to and to ), average in-plane magnetic contrast is much weaker than in Tilt series 1, with only slight differences between the pairs MD1/MD4 and MD3/MD2, indicating that the average in-plane magnetization of these MDs is mostly oriented along the -axis, which is reasonable since the sample was mounted with the easy anisotropy axis of the layers approximately perpendicular to the rotation axis for Tilt series 1 (i.e. along the direction).
The 3D configuration of the magnetic moment, , in the multilayer has been obtained from the reconstruction of the MTXM data sets with a vectorial tomography algorithm described in [29, 32]. Since the Co magnetic moment is collinear and antiparallel with in alloys, its configuration can also be estimated from vector maps. The physics of the multilayer will be analysed in terms of the magnetic moments of the individual Gd and Co sublattices, i. e. and and, depending on magnetic layer, the net magnetization will either be parallel or antiparallel to each of them. We will focus on the differences in configuration between the upper and lower regions of the multilayer (i.e. GdCo layers), with a more qualitative discussion of the evolution across the thickness.
Out of plane magnetic moment: the role of effective magnetostatic coupling
Analysis of experimental vector tomograms
The vector map of magnetic moments at MD1 obtained from the tomographic reconstruction reveals a complex 3D configuration as shown in Figure 3. There is a pattern of parallel stripe domains with alternating positive/negative with a period nm both at the top GdCo layer (Figure 3(a)) and at the bottom GdCo one (Figure 3(b)). However, the oscillation at the bottom layer is in antiphase with the oscillation at the top (see e. g. sign along points to marked in Figure 3(a-Figure 3b) for comparison), and its amplitude is almost three times larger at the bottom than at the top layer.
Figure 3. Vectorial tomographic reconstruction of at MD1 ( contrast). (a) View of the plane (Top Gd-Co layer); (b) View of the (bottom Gd-Co layer); (c) Cross-section across yellow arrow in (a). Note the reversed contrast across the sample thickness; (d) Profile of average magnetization oscillation across the thickness (measured as within each plane). Inset shows a sketch of out-of-plane magnetic moment oscillation within a plane with amplitude ; (e) Sketch of multilayer configuration and out-of-plane competing interactions.
Figure 3(c) shows a cross section of the magnetic moment vector map taken along a line transverse to the stripe domain pattern (i. e. along the yellow solid arrow in Figure 3(a-Figure 3b)). In a large fraction of the sample volume, we observe a typical stripe domain pattern configuration: alternating up/down magnetic domains bounded by Bloch walls with a closure domain structure [36]. This shows up in the transverse cross section of Figure 3(c) as a circulation of the magnetic moment across the thickness in a series of vortices with opposite circulation sense. However, the characteristic stripe configuration does not extend over the whole sample volume. Near the top, we observe a boundary in the magnetic moment vector map where locally reverses its sign. At the topmost part of the multilayer, contrast becomes much weaker indicating that the magnetic moment is mostly oriented parallel to the sample plane and the stripe pattern is almost suppressed.
The evolution of the amplitude of oscillation across the thickness can be quantified by the average angle of oscillation of the stripe pattern at MD1. As sketched in the inset of Figure 3(d), , so that the angular oscillation of the stripe pattern can be determined by the average within each plane, where indicates the plane position through the sample thickness. Figure 3(d) shows a profile of the angle vs. at MD1. Near the top of the sample, the amplitude of oscillation is about 20°, it decreases to a minimum of 15° at the reversal boundary and reaches a maximum of 55° at a vertical position 120 nm below this boundary. That is, the minimum occurs near the GdCo/NdCo interface whereas its maximum is located near the GdCo/NdCo interface, suggesting that the opposite signs of and are responsible for the changes in magnetic moment configuration across the multilayer thickness.
Magnetostatic vs. exchange interactions
We will now rationalize the previous finding on the oscillation amplitudes. First let us consider the central NdCo layer which generates the stripes due to a competition between out-of-plane anisotropy and magnetostatics. Then, there are two energy terms that contribute to imprint the stripe domains into the neighbouring GdCo layers: exchange interaction and magnetostatic coupling (see sketch in Figure 3(e)). The exchange between Co moments in each layer ( and ) can be written as
and will favour the parallel alignment of at both sides of the interfaces since .
Next, we consider the magnetostatic energy of the exchange coupled multilayer [36] that, in general, is the sum of two contributions: intralayer energy due to the self-interaction of each magnetic layer and interlayer energy due to the interactions between the layers [37]. In particular, magnetostatic coupling between GdCo and NdCo layers is given by [38], i. e. it depends on the interaction between , the net magnetization at the GdCo layer, and , the field created by magnetic charges at the NdCo layer. Here, it can be written as
where we have explicitly introduced the proportionality factor between and . In this way, magnetostatic coupling can be described as an effective field acting on .
At the GdCo/NdCo interface, and are parallel (since ) and with strong out-of-plane components. Thus, they cooperate to imprint the out-of-plane stripe domain oscillation into the bottom GdCo layer as seen in Figure 3(d). Below the GdCo/NdCo interface, the circulating will create the characteristic closure domain pattern observed in Figure 3(c) near the bottom of the multilayer to reduce magnetostatic energy of the sample.
The role of this effective field is qualitatively different at the top GdCo layer. At the GdCo/NdCo interface, is antiparallel to (since ) so that magnetostatic and exchange couplings compete with each other, as is typical in ferrimagnetic exchange spring walls [11]. The exchange coupling should decay faster than the magnetostatic one above the interface so that, at some point, will change sign under the effect of as observed in Figure 3(a) and Figure 3(b). The vertical location of this boundary is given by the minimum in observed in Figure 3(d).
Thus, the magnetic boundary observed in the magnetic vectorial tomograms in Figure 3 is the signature of a locally modulated exchange spring wall across the multilayer thickness driven by the magnetostatic coupling with the stripe domain pattern of the NdCo layer. The qualitative differences between the magnetic moment configuration near the top and bottom of the sample give further confirmation of the opposite signs of effective interlayer coupling at both GdCo/NdCo and GdCo/NdCo interfaces in agreement with the multilayer design.
In plane magnetic moments: uniaxial anisotropy vs. interfacial exchange
Analysis of experimental vector tomograms
Figure 4 shows similar views of the vector tomogram at MD1 as discussed above but now contrast is given by the in-plane component of the magnetic moment in order to analyze the in-plane magnetic configuration. Near the top of the multilayer (Figure 4(a)) we observe an almost uniform contrast, with a smooth oscillation of the magnetic moment around an average in-plane orientation. At the bottom of the multilayer (Figure 4(b)), the in-plane magnetic moment configuration is less homogeneous and a periodic pattern of closure domains is observed. A cross section of the magnetic moment vector map taken along the solid line in Figure 4(a) reveals again qualitative differences in the Gd magnetic moment configuration across the thickness (see Figure 4(c)). Above the exchange spring boundary, there is an in-plane magnetic domain with almost uniform contrast. Below this boundary, we find the closure domain pattern made of triangular domains with opposite senses of the in-plane magnetic moment transverse to the stripe pattern (see sketch in Figure 4(e)). However, there are subtle deviations from the standard symmetric closure domains configuration that usually surrounds the Bloch domain walls between stripe domains [32, 36]. Here, cores of closure domain vortices are placed in a zig-zag pattern across the thickness and closure domains are larger than domains (see vorticity map in Figure 4(d), where vorticity is calculated as ). This closure domain asymmetry is enhanced near the exchange spring boundary (where the asymmetry in size between domains reaches ) and implies a non-zero in-plane magnetic moment transverse to the stripe domain pattern [22].
Figure 4. Vectorial tomographic reconstruction of at MD1 ( contrast). (a) View of the (, , 14 nm) plane (Top Gd-Co layer); (b) View of the (, , 255 nm) plane (bottom Gd-Co layer); Insets are histograms of in-plane angular orientations respect to the -axis () within top/bottom layers respectively. Vertical line marks stripe domain orientation (). (c) Cross-section across yellow arrow in (a). Note the uniform contrast at top layer and the asymmetric size of opposite closure domains. (d) Detail of the vorticity map at cross section in (c). Note the zig-zag configuration of high vorticity regions corresponding to cores of closure domain vortices. (e) Sketch of domain configuration across the thickness
Asymmetries of the in-plane configuration can be quantified in more detail by histograms of the in-plane moment orientations for different reconstructed planes, as shown in the insets of Figure 4(a-Figure 4b). Near the top of the multilayer, we find a relatively narrow distribution of in-plane angles centered at the average angle (calculated from the average of the histogram) within an interval (estimated from the FWHM of the histogram). Two maxima are observed in the angular histogram indicating a smooth ripple oscillation of the in-plane magnetic moment around . The aperture of the ripple can be estimated from the distance between these two maxima in the angular distribution as . Note that the average magnetic moment orientation in MD1 is not aligned with the stripe pattern orientation (marked by a vertical line at at the inset of Figure 4(a)). Near the bottom of the multilayer, the angular histogram shows two well-spaced maxima ( and ) corresponding to opposite in-plane closure domains located at symmetric positions relative to the stripe pattern orientation . A certain asymmetry appears between the relative weights of these two maxima in the angular histogram that favours the closure domains nearer to the top layer orientation.
Model of competing interfacial exchange and in-plane anisotropy
Several relevant characteristics of the magnetic configuration of the multilayer can be extracted from the analysis of the vector tomogram: a) closure domains are larger for parallel alignment with the magnetic moment at the top MD1; b) the angular distribution of in-plane magnetic moments at the top MD1 is relatively narrow and not far from the stripe pattern orientation; c) the average in-plane magnetic moment transverse to the stripe pattern is non-zero.
These facts suggest a positive effective interlayer coupling between in-plane moments at the GdCo/NdCo interface dominated by acting on and with a negligible contribution from magnetostatic coupling. In-plane demagnetization fields are maximum in the plane transverse to the stripe pattern (and are almost negligible in the direction longitudinal to the stripes), therefore their effect would be very small at the observed orientation. Also, the average in-plane moment transverse to the stripes points to a relevant role of in-plane anisotropy not aligned with the stripe domain pattern. In this framework, we propose a simple analytical model to describe the main qualitative features of the multilayer magnetic configuration based in the balance between the interfacial exchange at GdCo/NdCo and the in-plane uniaxial anisotropy. The geometry of our model is sketched in Figure 5(a-Figure 5b): at a certain magnetic domain MD, the stripe domain pattern in the NdCo layer is oriented at , determined by magnetic history, while the in-plane anisotropy axis of the top GdCo layer, defined by oblique incidence during sample fabrication, is oriented at . The misorientation between the stripe domains and the easy axis can be defined as taking the shortest angular interval between them.
Figure 5. Model of in-plane interactions. a) Sketch of cross section of the multilayers with asymmetric closure domains. (b) Sketch of relevant exchange interactions between asymmetric closure domains (width and ) at the top surface of the NdCo layer and ripple domains at GdCo top layer (oriented at and ). Double arrow indicates in-plane easy axis at top GdCo layer oriented at an angle relative to stripe domain pattern. (c) Dependence of effective exchange energy and exchange angle on for and . (d) Dependence of average magnetization orientation and ripple amplitude on . Dashed black line corresponds to the condition of symmetric ripple around easy anisotropy axis.
Now, we assume that this in-plane MD within the top GdCo layer is broken up into a periodic pattern of smaller domains of width , aligned with the underlying closure domain pattern at the top surface of the NdCo layer (see Figure 5(a)) in order to model the observed ripple oscillation. The orientation of the magnetic moment in these two domains relative to the stripe pattern orientation is given by the in-plane angles and . The average orientation of the magnetic moment relative to the stripes direction will be and the ripple aperture . Then, the anisotropy energy at the top GdCo layer in each stripe period can be written as
which has the form
in terms of and . Thus, the effective anisotropy energy acting on the average magnetic moment of MD oriented at decreases as a function of ripple aperture by a factor .
Now, considering only in-plane components of the magnetic moment, we may write the exchange coupling at GdCo/NdCo interface as
The first term in eq. (6) corresponds to the exchange between the closure domain of width at the top surface of the NdCo layer with the ripple domain oriented at within the top GdCo layer, whereas the second term describes the exchange interaction between the opposite closure domain of width and the ripple domain oriented at . If and are written in terms of the average MD parameters and , equation (6) can be expressed as
with and . Thus, exchange interactions at the GdCo/NdCo interface take the form of an effective exchange energy that depends on closure domain asymmetry and on the ripple domain aperture. The sign of the effective exchange angle depends on the closure domain asymmetry , indicating that drives the average in-plane towards the net in-plane of the closure domain structure.
The total energy of the average magnetic moment of the MD is a combination of uniaxial anisotropy and effective exchange
that must be minimized in terms of and for each stripe pattern configuration (given by the closure domain asymmetry and the misalignment between the easy anisotropy axis and the stripe pattern orientation ). In general, uniaxial anisotropy will try to minimize and make , whereas exchange interactions will favour large values and . Figure 5(c-Figure 5d) show the results of minimization for and , given by the experimental configuration in Figure 4, as a function of .
The evolution of vs. is a consequence of the lateral averaging of exchange interactions, which fluctuate strongly within each period of the stripe pattern, on the larger length scale of a MD modulated by the ripple oscillation around the easy axis. At small , i. e. for stripe domains almost aligned with easy anisotropy axis, minimum energy corresponds to and large . This results in relatively large and small , so that the ripple oscillation is symmetric around the stripe pattern and with a large angular aperture. As increases, we observe slight deviations of from the easy axis orientation and a strong reduction of the ripple aperture . Effective exchange decreases and the effective exchange angle approaches the orientation of the easy anisotropy axis. Thus, for large , the magnetic moment at the top GdCo layer would perform a low amplitude ripple oscillation around the easy anisotropy axis far away from the stripe domain orientation.
It is interesting to mention that a key feature of this model is that , the misorientation between the in-plane easy axis and the stripe domains, is the relevant parameter that determines the effective coupling between layers and the global configuration of GdCo layer. can be easily varied with the direction of the last saturating field, providing an external knob to adjust the multilayer configuration with the remanent stripe domain orientation.
Global view of in-plane magnetic domains at top GdCo layer
Figure 6 shows a large view of the magnetic tomogram at the top GdCo layer that includes several in-plane MDs with different signs of average contrast, different stripe orientation and different aperture of the ripple oscillations. We will use our analytical model to provide a unified picture of these different MDs and approximately determine the orientation of the in-plane easy axis of the multilayer.
Figure 6. Statistics of magnetic moment orientation in the ripple states. (a) Vectorial tomogram reconstruction of at the plane (Top Gd-Co layer) with contrast. Double arrow indicates the easy anisotropy axis derived from the analytical model. (b-c) Histograms of in-plane angular orientations () respect to the -axis for the different MDs. Vertical solid lines indicate stripe orientation in each MD region and vertical dashed lines indicate easy axis orientation . (d) Ripple domain orientation and vs. . Solid lines are calculated from the analytical model with the same parameters as in Figure 5. Symbols correspond to experimental and obtained from the shortest angular distance between maxima in the histograms and . The parameter in each MD is obtained from the shortest angular distance between and as indicated in (c).
MD1 and MD2 are two domains with similar stripe orientation but opposite signs of average contrast, i. e. opposite signs of their average in-plane orientation. Angular histograms at MD1 and MD2 (see Figure 6(b)) show the same qualitative behavior as in Figure 4: two clear maxima in the angular distribution with an aperture and average magnetic moment orientation not too far from the stripe pattern orientation, indicated as vertical continuous lines in Figure 6(b). Note that for each domain there are two possible values of , separated , and we have selected the closest one to the measured average orientation for each domain, i.e. and (instead of the equivalent ). With this criterium, the misorientation between the average in-plane magnetization and the stripe pattern is , relatively small in both cases, suggesting that is not very large for MD1 and MD2.
Magnetic domains MD3 and MD4 correspond to the other branch of the zig-zag stripe patterns observed in Figure 2 with stripe orientation (and the similar ). In this case, the ripple aperture is smaller and, actually, in MD4 a single maximum is observed in the angular distribution centred at . This reduction in ripple aperture and the large angular difference between and stripe pattern orientation, suggest that should be the largest at MD4 and that its average in-plane moment should be oriented along the easy anisotropy axis, i.e. (and, consequently, ).
We have tested this hypothesis with a comparison between the experimental ripple oscillations observed in the tomogram and and values calculated from the analytical model (with the same parameters used in Figure 5). The experimental and of the ripple domains have been defined by the positions of the maxima in Figure 6(b-Figure 6c) measured as the shortest angular interval from at each MD. is estimated from the shortest interval as indicated in Figure 6(c) for each of the four MDs, so that we can make a plot of the experimental vs. values for each particular as shown in Figure 6(d). The best qualitative agreement is found for , with most experimental data points lying within the angular interval defined by the theoretical and trends. It corresponds to the easy axis located at the large double arrow in Figure 6(a), and at the dashed vertical lines at the histograms in Figure 6(b-Figure 6c). In all cases, the average magnetization orientation lies close to the easy axis with a slight displacement towards the stripe domain orientation, in line with the predictions from the analytical model based on the lateral averaging of exchange interactions within the ripple pattern. That is, our multilayer is an experimental realization of an exchange spring system in which effective coupling is not simply determined by material parameters fixed during sample fabrication but, rather, it can be externally adjusted with magnetic history (i. e. with the orientation of the stripe pattern at remanence).
Domain wall between chevron magnetic domains
Finally, let us discuss the magnetic configuration at the corners of the stripe domain chevron pattern (e.g. at the boundary between MD1 and MD4 as sketched in Figure 7(a)). Here, the stripe pattern rotates by whereas the average magnetic moment orientation changes by creating a high angle domain wall between MD1 and MD4. This wall is oriented at , i.e. it is almost parallel to the average in-plane magnetic moment at the top GdCo layer of MD1 and MD4 and makes similar angles with the stripe patterns in both chevron MDs so that it is a low energy wall from the magnetostatic point of view.
Figure 7. Tomographic reconstruction of at the domain wall between MD1 and MD4. a) Sketch of the boundary between MD1 and MD4 at a zig-zag corner of the stripe pattern and zoom view of magnetic tomogram at the plane (Top Gd-Co layer) with contrast. (b-c) Vertical cross-section along domain wall (dashed line in (a)) with and contrast, respectively. Note the antiparallel alignment of the magnetic moments at the exchange spring wall across the thickness both in and components and the symmetric configuration of closure domains. (d-e) Details of localized vortices (orange circle in (b)) and antivortices (green circle in (b)) at the interface.
The domain wall has a complex 3D configuration with a peculiar undulating pattern of period of interleaving regions. Also, the vertical cross section along the domain wall core (Figure 7(b-Figure 7c)) presents clear differences from the configuration within each MD (shown in Figure 4).
First, note that the size of closure domains is similar and closure vortex cores are aligned at a constant position within the multilayer. This can be attributed to the continuous transition between MD1 and MD4. Within each MD, the sign of the average in plane magnetic component is directly related with the sign of , the closure domain asymmetry. Since and, consequently, have opposite signs at MD1 and MD4, must become zero at the domain wall, resulting in the same size closure patterns observed in Figure 7(b).
Second, at the exchange spring wall near the top of the multilayer, there is a sign reversal in both and components (within each MD the reversal takes place only in ). This indicates that the dominant coupling term at the GdCo/NdCo interface favours an antiparallel alignment both for in-plane and out-of-plane magnetic moments (within each MD antiparallel coupling dominates only in ).
These observations can be attributed to a subtle change in the competition between the relevant energy terms at the domain wall driven by the rotation of the stripe pattern at the corner of the zig-zag: as the stripe pattern turns from to it becomes perpendicular to the in plane anisotropy easy axis. This fact has two consequences: 1) in-plane anisotropy axis becomes aligned with the closure domain pattern, 2) in-plane components of are strongest at the orientation favoured by in-plane anisotropy. Thus, in-plane anisotropy enhances the in-plane antiparallel coupling term proportional to the effective field resulting in the sign reversal of at the exchange spring wall. The enhancement of in-plane antiparallel coupling allows the closure domain pattern to emerge at the top GdCo layer and creates the undulating domain wall profile seen in Figure 7(a).
At the intersection between the exchange spring wall and the closure domain pattern, the configuration is highly disordered and a high density of vortices and antivortices appears to accommodate these different competing interactions. For example, several antivortices across the thickness are observed at the tip of out-of-plane domains whereas at other locations the system has nucleated closely spaced vortex/antivortex pairs (see Figure 7(d-Figure 7e)).
Conclusions
A GdCo/NdCo/GdCo multilayer has been prepared with competing magnetostatic, exchange and anisotropy interactions and its 3D magnetic configuration has been determined from experimental data by X-ray magnetic vector tomography at the Gd M absorption edges.
The general view of the magnetization at MTXM images shows stripe domains with alternating up and down magnetization arranged in a chevron type of pattern with alternate positive and negative in-plane magnetizations.
The vector tomogram reveals a strong out-of-plane magnetization oscillation at the bottom GdCo layer with a closure domain structure across the thickness. It is caused by the cooperation between ferromagnetic exchange and magnetostatic coupling at the GdCo/NdCo interface that imprints stripe domains into the GdCo layer and, also, by the need to reduce magnetostatic energy at the multilayer/vacuum interface.
The magnetization of the top GdCo layer is mostly in-plane, with a weak out-of-plane oscillation, and medium sized in-plane MDs that extend over the different sections of the chevron zig-zags. Local exchange springs, characterized by the sign reversal of across the thickness, are observed near the GdCo/NdCo interface as a result of the effective antiparallel magnetostatic coupling between NdCo and top GdCo.
Ripple patterns within chevron-like domains are observed at the top GdCo layer, separated by undulating domain walls decorated by magnetic vortices and antivortices across the thickness. They are the result of the subtle balance between effective antiparallel magnetostatic coupling (which is maximum perpendicular to the stripe domains and minimum along them), uniaxial anisotropy defined during the sample fabrication process and interfacial ferromagnetic exchange (isotropic).
In summary, the detailed description of the trilayer magnetization provided by vector magnetic tomography has allowed us to unravel experimentally the complex behavior of the system without a priori assumption. It is found that the relevant parameters to obtain an adjustable exchange spring are the fine tuning of interlayer coupling by GdCo stoichiometry, defined during sample fabrication, and the orientation of the magnetic stripes relative to in-plane uniaxial anisotropy, adjustable by magnetic history.
Acknowledgements
Alba light source is funded by the Ministry of Research and Innovation of Spain, by the Generalitat de Catalunya and by European FEDER funds. This project has been supported by Spanish MICINN under grant PID2019-104604RB/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Methods
Sample Fabrication and Magnetic characterization. GdCo/NdCo/GdCo multilayers to create exchange springs at the top GdCo layer were grown by sputtering on 50 nm thick SiN membranes as reported before [23, 39]. In-plane uniaxial anisotropy of top/bottom GdCo layers was defined during sample deposition by the oblique projection of the direction of the atomic beams relative to the sample surface [40]. The easy axis orientations are parallel at top/bottom layers. Saturation magnetization and uniaxial anisotropy at room temperature in each layer have been obtained from Vibrating Sample Magnetometry (VSM) and MOTKE hysteresis loops [11]: A/m, J/m and A/m, J/m. At the central NdCo layer, typical parameters are A/m and out of plane anisotropy J/m [25], which is an order of magnitude larger than in GdCo layers. Thus, the NdCo layer with its stripe domain pattern will provide the pinned magnetic configuration within the multilayer.
The 80 nm GdCo/80 nm NdCo/80 nm GdCo multilayer was prepared in a multidomain state after out-of-plane demagnetization allowing the system to explore the complex energy landscape created by the competing interactions and observe it in a single experiment.
MTXM and soft X-ray vector tomography. The sample was mounted in the high precision rotary stage of the full field X-ray transmission microscope at the MISTRAL beamline of ALBA Synchrotron [32]. 100 nm gold nanoparticles dispersed on its surface serve as fiducials accurate projection alignment to a common rotation axis prior to the tomography reconstruction. It was illuminated with circularly polarized X-rays with fixed polarization in order to exploit magnetic contrast from X-ray circular dichroism [41] and it was rotated around an axis parallel to the sample surface and perpendicular to the horizontal X ray beam, in order to acquire a tilt series of images, i.e. a set of closely spaced MTXM images at intervals in the angular range and at intervals in the angular ranges and (see sketch in Figure 2, when the multilayer normal is parallel to the X ray direction). Tomographic reconstruction of the magnetization vector requires two orthogonal tilt series [29, 30]. Thus, the sample was manually rotated in-plane by an angle and a second tilt series was acquired. Fine alignment of the two tilt series together was also performed as a part of the tomographic reconstruction process with the aid of the gold fiducials [32]. The actual in-plane angle between the two-tilt series was measured as . At each orientation, 2D transmitted images were sequentially acquired at the Gd M (wavelength 1.0198 nm) and Gd M (wavelength 1.0456 nm) absorption edges since they present opposite signs of the X-ray magnetic circular dichroic factor. Then, either charge (TXM) or magnetic (MTXM) contrast images were obtained by the addition/subtraction of the logarithm of individual transmittance images at Gd M and M edges with a proper normalization to minimize magnetic contrast in the charge images [32, 42]. In general, magnetic contrast is given by the projection of the magnetic moment along the X-ray beam direction [41]. Normal incidence images are only sensitive to the out-of-plane component of the magnetic moment whereas tilted incidence images also provide information of the in-plane component of the magnetic moment perpendicular to the rotation axis. Thus, images in Tilt series 1 are sensitive to and , whereas images in Tilt series 2 are sensitive to and approximately .
We can obtain the 3D magnetic moment configuration in the multilayer from the reconstruction of the MTXM data sets in Tilt series 1 and 2 with a tomography algorithm using the method reported in [29, 32]. The total reconstructed volume is 2700 × 2700 × 2025 nm (with a total of 200 × 200 × 150 voxels), which is much larger than the multilayer thickness. The tomography algorithm properly locates, without any a priori assumptions, the magnetic signal from the multilayer just below the plane defined by the gold fiducials that were placed on the sample surface. The result is a 3D vector map of the magnetic moments of Gd, , convoluted with the lateral resolution function of the microscope (~30 nm) and the axial resolution of the measurement. The latter has been estimated to be of ~60 nm which is comparable with individual layer thickness [32]. An important methodological issue that has to be clear is the following: as we do not impose any a priori condition (i.e., we do not set at the NdCo central layer), our tomographic reconstruction generates a continuous field of magnetic moments that, due to the finite axial resolution is non zero in the central layer in spite of not having Gd atoms. This continuity mimics the effect of exchange coupling between layers [30]. Here, we have focused on the differences in configuration between the upper and lower regions of the multilayer (i.e., GdCo layers), with a more qualitative discussion of the evolution across the thickness.
Data availability
The datasets generated during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing financial interests.
Author contributions
C.Q., J. I. M., M.V. and S.F. designed and planned the experiments, J. H., C.Q. and J.I.M. prepared the samples. J. H., A.H.-R., C.Q., A.S., S.R., E.P. and S.F carried out the synchrotron experiment. J. H. and A.H.-R. performed the tomographic reconstructions. J. H., A.H.-R., L.M.A.P., J.I.M., C.Q., M.V. and S.F. analyzed the data. All the authors participated in the interpretation and discussion of the results. A.H.-R., M.V. and S.F. wrote the article.
References
- [1]Coexistence of distinct skyrmion phases observed in hybrid ferromagnetic/ferrimagnetic multilayers Andrada-Oana Mandru, Oğuz Yildirim, Riccardo Tomasello, Paul Heistracher, Marcos Penedo, Anna Giordano, Dieter Suess, Giovanni Finocchio & Hans Josef Hug, Nat. Commun. 11 (2020) 6365
- [2]Domain wall assisted magnetic recording, A. Yu. Dobin and H. J. Richter, J. Appl. Phys. 101, 09K108 (2007)DOI
- [3]M. Beens, M. L. M. Lalieu, A. J. M. Deenen, R. A. Duine, and B. Koopman, Phys. Rev. B 100, 220409(R) (2019)DOI
- [4]Robin Bläsing, Tianping Ma, See-Hun Yang, Chirag Garg, Fasil Kidane Dejene, Alpha T N’Diaye, Gong Chen, Kai Liu & Stuart S.P. Parkin, Nat. Commun. 9 (2018) 4984DOI
- [5]Boris Divinskiy, Guanxiong Chen, Sergei Urazhdin, Sergej O. Demokritov, and Vladislav E. Demidov, Phys. Rev. Applied 14, 044016 (2020)DOI
- [6]J. Brandão, D. A. Dugato, M. V. Puydinger dos Santos, and J. C. Cezar, ACS Appl. Nano Matter. 2 (2019) 7532.DOI
- [7]Lucas Caretta, Maxwell Mann, Felix Büttner, Kohei Ueda, Bastian Pfau, Christian M. Günther, Piet Hessing, Alexandra Churikova, Christopher Klose, Michael Schneider, Dieter Engel, Colin Marcus, David Bono, Kai Bagschik, Stefan Eisebitt and Geoffrey S. D. Beach, Nat. Nanotech. 13 (2018) 1154.DOI
- [8]Seonghoon Woo, Kyung Mee Song, Xiahao Zhang, Yan Zhou, Motohiko Ezawa, Xiaoxi Liu, S. Finizio, J. Raabe, Nyun Jong Lee, Sang-Il Kim, Seung-Young Park, Younghak Kim, Jae-Young Kim, Dongjoon Lee, OukJae Lee, Jun Woo Choi, Byoung-Chul Min, Hyun Cheol Koo and Joonyeon Chang, Nat. Commun. 9 (2018) 959.DOI
- [9]Kab-Jin Kim, Se Kwon Kim, Yuushou Hirata, Se-Hyeok Oh, Takayuki Tono, Duck-Ho Kim, Takaya Okuno,Woo Seung Ham, Sanghoon Kim, Gyoungchoon Go, Yaroslav Tserkovnyak, Arata Tsukamoto, Takahiro Moriyama, Kyung-Jin Lee and Teruo Ono, Nat. Mater. 16 (2017) 1187.DOI
- [10]A. Billa and H.B. Braun, J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 272–276 (2004) 1266–1267.
- [11]C. Blanco-Roldán, Y. Choi, C. Quirós, S. M. Valvidares, R. Zarate, M. Vélez, J. M. Alameda, D. Haskel, and J. I. Martín, Phys. Rev. B 92, 224433 (2015)
- [12]F. Magnus, M.E. Brooks-Bartlett, R. Moubah, R.A. Procter, G. Andersson, T.P.A Hase, S.T. Banks & B. Hjörvarsson, Nat. Commun. 7, 11931 (2016)DOI
- [13]B. Hebler, P. Reinhardt, G. L. Katona, O. Hellwig, and M. Albrecht, Phys. Rev. B 95, 104410 (2017)DOI
- [14]A. Quesada, G. Delgado, L. Pascual, A. M. Aragón, P. Marín, C. Granados-Miralles, M. Foerster, L. Aballe, J. E. Prieto, J. de la Figuera, J. F. Fernández, and P. Prieto, Phys. Rev. B 98, 214435 (2018).DOI
- [15]Interfacial magnetic domain wall formation in perpendicular-anisotropy, exchange-spring films, S. M. Watson, T. Hauet, J. A. Borchers, S. Mangin, and Eric E. Fullerton, Appl. Phys. Lett. 92, 202507 (2008)DOI
- [16]Strain-Modulated Exchange-Spring Magnetic Behavior in Amorphous Tb-Fe Thin Films, Taehwan Lee, Mohanchandra Kotekar Panduranga, Chang Wan Han, Volkan Ortalan, and Gregory Paul Carman, Phys. Rev. Applied 8, 024024 (2017).DOI
- [17]Amorphous exchange-spring magnets with crossed perpendicular and in-plane anisotropies, K. A. Thórarinsdóttir, T. Hase, B. Hjörvarsson, and F. Magnus, Phys. Rev. B 103, 014440 (2021)
- [18]Direct observation of magnetic exchange-spring development in epitaxial DyFe2/YFe2 superlattices by magneto-optical Kerr effect, Ke Wang, Yang Xiang, Chuanwen Chen, Fengjiang Zhuang, Xuefeng Wu and Roger Ward, Funct. Mat. Lett. 8, 1550053 (2015).DOI
- [19]Magnetic structure in Fe/Sm-Co exchange spring bilayers with intermixed interfaces Yaohua Liu, S. G. E. te Velthuis, J. S. Jiang, Y. Choi, S. D. Bader, A. A. Parizzi, H. Ambaye, and V. Lauter, Phys. Rev. B 83, 174418 (2011).DOI
- [20]Microscopic Origin of Magnetization Reversal in Nanoscale Exchange-Coupled Ferri/Ferromagnetic Bilayers: Implications for High Energy Density Permanent Magnets and Spintronic Devices, Michael Heigl, Christoph Vogler, Andrada-Oana Mandru, Xue Zhao, Hans Josef Hug, Dieter Suess, and Manfred Albrecht, ACS Appl. Nano Mater. 2020, 3, 9218–9225DOI
- [21]Characterization of FePd bilayers and trilayers using soft x-ray resonant magnetic scattering and micromagnetic modelling, G. Beutier, G. van der Laan, K. Chesnel, A. Marty, M. Belakhovsky, S. P. Collins, E. Dudzik, J.-C. Toussaint, and B. Gilles, Phys. Rev. B 71, 184436 (2005)
- [22]In-plane rotation of magnetic stripe domains in Fe₁₋ₓGaₓ thin films, S. Fin, R. Tomasello, D. Bisero, M. Marangolo, M. Sacchi, H. Popescu, M. Eddrief, C. Hepburn, G. Finocchio, M. Carpentieri, A. Rettori, M. G. Pini, and S. Tacchi, Phys. Rev. B 92, 224411 (2015).
- [23]Deterministic propagation of vortex-antivortex pairs in magnetic trilayers, A. Hierro-Rodriguez, C. Quirós, A. Sorrentino, R. Valcárcel, I. Estébanez, L. M. Alvarez-Prado, J. I. Martín, J. M. Alameda, E. Pereiro, M. Vélez, and S. Ferrer, Appl. Phys. Lett. 110, 262402 (2017)DOI
- [24]Nanoscale imaging of buried topological defects with quantitative X-ray magnetic microscopy C. Blanco-Roldán, C. Quirós, A. Sorrentino, A. Hierro-Rodríguez, L. M. Álvarez-Prado, R. Valcárcel, M. Duch, N. Torras, J. Esteve, J. I. Martín, M. Vélez, J. M. Alameda, E. Pereiro & S. Ferrer, Nat. Commun. 6, 8196 (2015)
- [25]Cycloidal Domains in the Magnetization Reversal Process of Ni₈₀Fe₂₀/Nd₁₆Co₈₄/Gd₁₂Co₈₈ Trilayers, C. Quiros, A. Hierro-Rodriguez, A. Sorrentino, R. Valcarcel, L. M. Alvarez-Prado, J. I. Martín, J. M. Alameda, E. Pereiro, M. Vélez, and S. Ferrer, Phys. Rev. Applied 10, 014008 (2018)DOI
- [26]Nanoscale switch for vortex polarization mediated by Bloch core formation in magnetic hybrid systems. Phillip Wohlhüter, Matthew Thomas Bryan, Peter Warnicke, Sebastian Gliga, Stephanie Elizabeth Stevenson, Georg Heldt, Lalita Saharan, Anna Kinga Suszka, Christoforos Moutafis, Rajesh Vilas Chopdekar, Jörg Raabe, Thomas Thomson, Gino Hrkač & Laura Jane Heyderman, Nat. Commun. 6, 7836 (2015).
- [27]Three-dimensional magnetization structures revealed with X-ray vector nanotomography, Claire Donnelly, Manuel Guizar-Sicairos, Valerio Scagnoli, Sebastian Gliga, Mirko Holler, Jörg Raabe, Laura J Heyderman, Nature 547, 328–331 (2017).DOI
- [28]From 2D STXM to 3D Imaging: Soft X-ray Laminography of Thin Specimens, Katharina Witte, Andreas Späth, Simone Finizio, Claire Donnelly, Benjamin Watts, Blagoj Sarafimov, Michal Odstrčil, Manuel Guizar-Sicairos, Mirko Holler, Rainer H. Fink, and Jörg Raabe, Nano Lett., 20, 1305–1314 (2020).DOI
- [29]3D reconstruction of magnetization from dichroic soft X-ray transmission tomography, Aurelio Hierro-Rodriguez, Doga Gürsoy, Charudatta Phatak, Carlos Quiros, Andrea Sorrentino, Luis Manuel Alvarez-Prado, Maria Velez, Jose Ignacio Martin, Jose Maria Alameda, Eva Pereiro and Salvador Ferrer, J. Synchrotron Rad. 25, 1144–1152 (2018).DOI
- [30]Tomographic reconstruction of a three-dimensional magnetization vector field, Claire Donnelly, Sebastian Gliga, Valerio Scagnoli, Mirko Holler, Jörg Raabe, Laura J Heyderman and Manuel Guizar-Sicairos, New J. Phys. 20, 083009 (2018).DOI
- [31]Time-resolved imaging of three-dimensional nanoscale magnetization dynamics, Claire Donnelly, Simone Finizio, Sebastian Gliga, Mirko Holler, Aleš Hrabec, Michal Odstrčil, Sina Mayr, Valerio Scagnoli, Laura J. Heyderman, Manuel Guizar-Sicairos, Jörg Raabe, Nat. Nanotechnol. 15, 356–360 (2020).DOI
- [32]Revealing 3D magnetization of thin films with soft X-ray tomography: magnetic singularities and topological charges, A. Hierro-Rodriguez, C. Quirós, A. Sorrentino, L. M. Alvarez-Prado, J. I. Martín, J. M. Alameda, S. McVitie, E. Pereiro, M. Vélez & S. Ferrer, Nature Comm. 11, 6382 (2020)DOI
- [33]Curvature-mediated spin textures in magnetic multi-layered nanotubes, Elisabeth Josten, David Raftrey, Aurelio Hierro-Rodriguez, Andrea Sorrentino, Lucia Aballe, Marta Lipińska-Chwałek, Thomas Jansen, Katja Höflich, Hanno Kröncke, Catherine Dubourdieu, Daniel E. Bürgler, Joachim Mayer, Peter Fischer, arXiv:2103.13310v1 (2021).arxiv.org/abs/2103.13310
- [34]Mechanism of rotatable anisotropy in thin magnetic films of Ni, Fe, and Ni–Fe, H. Fujiwara, Y. Sugita, and N. Saito, Appl. Phys. Lett. 4, 199 (1964)DOI
- [35]Controlled nucleation of topological defects in the stripe domain patterns of Lateral multilayers with Perpendicular Magnetic Anisotropy: competition between magnetostatic, exchange and misfit interactions, A. Hierro-Rodriguez, M. Velez, R. Morales, N. Soriano, G. Rodriguez-Rodriguez, L. M. Alvarez-Prado, J. I. Martin, and J. M. Alameda, Phys. Rev. B 88, 174411 (2013)
- [36]A. Hubert and R. Schafer. Magnetic Domains: The Analysis of Magnetic Microstructures (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1998)
- [37]Effects of magnetostatic coupling on stripe domain structures in magnetic multilayers with perpendicular anisotropy K. Janicka, J. D. Burton, and E. Y. Tsymbal, J. Appl. Phys. 101, 113921 (2007).DOI
- [38]General Micromagnetic Theory and Applications, H. Kronmüller in “Handbook of Magnetism and Advanced Magnetic Materials (eds H. Kronmüller, S. Parkin, J.E. Miltat and M.R. Scheinfein)”, Wiley online (2007). https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470022184.hmm201
- [39]Magnetic textures and singularities in ferri/ferromagnetic multilayers, J. Hermosa, A. Hierro-Rodríguez, C. Quirós, L.M. Álvarez-Prado, A. Sorrentino, R. Valcárcel, S. Rehbein, E. Pereiro, J.I. Martín, M. Vélez, S. Ferrer, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 539, 168384 (2021).DOI
- [40]Asymmetric grazing incidence small angle x-ray scattering and anisotropic domain wall motion in obliquely grown nanocrystalline Co films, C Quirós, L Peverini, J Díaz, A Alija, C Blanco, M Vélez, O Robach, E Ziegler and J M Alameda, Nanotechnology 25 (2014) 335704DOI
- [41]Stöhr, Joachim, Siegmann, Hans Christoph "Magnetism. From Fundamentals to Nanoscale Dynamics" Springer 2006.DOI
- [42]Imaging of magnetic domains by transmission x-ray microscopy, P Fischer, T Eimüller, G Schütz, P Guttmann, G Schmahl, K Pruegl and G Bayreuther, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 31, 649-655 (1998).DOI