WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Rational design of nanoscale stabilized oxide catalysts for OER with OC22
Abstract
The efficiency of production via water electrolysis is typically limited to the sluggish oxygen evolution reaction (OER). As such, significant emphasis has been placed upon improving the rate of OER through the anode catalyst. More recently, the Open Catalyst 2022 (OC22) framework has provided a large dataset of density functional theory (DFT) calculations for OER intermediates on the surfaces of oxides. When coupled with state-of-the-art graph neural network models, total energy predictions can be achieved with a mean absolute error as low as 0.22 eV. In this work, we interpolated a database of the total energy predictions for all slabs and OER surface intermediates for 4,119 oxide materials in the original OC22 dataset using pre-trained models from the OC22 framework. This database includes all terminations of all facets up to a maximum Miller index of 1. To demonstrate the full utility of this database, we constructed a flexible screening framework to identify viable candidate anode catalysts for OER under varying reaction conditions for bulk, surface, and nanoscale Pourbaix stability as well as material cost, overpotential, and metastability. From our assessment, we were able to identify 122 and 68 viable candidates for OER under the bulk and nanoscale regime respectively.
Introduction
As the global focus shifts increasingly towards renewable energy, there has been a significant rise in the demand for cost-effective and environmentally sustainable energy storage and transmission methods. Electrochemical water splitting, or water electrolysis, is a sustainable and promising means of evolving thanks to the wide abundance of water. This process involves two coupled half-reactions: hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and the significantly slower oxygen evolution reaction (OER) which has primarily been the bottleneck in advancing water-splitting technology. The search for a highly active anode catalyst for OER is therefore paramount to the realization of practical water splitting technology.[1, 2, 3, 4]
Transition metal oxides are a promising class of catalysts for OER due to their varying oxidation states for more efficient multi-electron transfer, stability under highly acidic conditions favorable towards OER, and active undercoordinated transition metals sites. In regard to commercialized catalysts, and are the benchmark catalysts for OER, exhibiting low overpotentials (an indicator of activity) of 0.25 to 0.5 V under acidic conditions.[5] However, the material cost of precious metals ($18,315 and $155,727 per kg for and respectively as of March 2021[6, 7, 8] with a price variation of $9,969 for and + $80,370 for in the last 24 years) limits their widespread adoption. Consequently, there is much desire to identify cheaper materials for catalysts in OER while maintaining similar performance.
Despite the abundance of unary and binary oxides, very few are capable of exhibiting both high catalytic activity and stability under operating conditions. Computational analysis performed by Wang et al.⁹ indicated only 68 bimetallic oxides from a pool of 47,814 were stable with a Pourbaix decomposition energy () of 0.5 eV/atom or less under acidic conditions (pH = 0) and an applied potential cycle between 1.2 and 2.0 V. Gunasooriya and Nørskov¹⁰ calculated the overpotential of these candidate oxides and identified only 11 nonbinary metal oxides with a promising overpotential of less than 0.85 V.
It is possible that many materials filtered out by the highly discriminant electrochemical stability criteria can also exhibit competitive overpotentials if stabilized. Nanoscale stability, elemental doping, and the introduction of oxygen vacancies have been demonstrated to be effective means of improving stability.[1, 11, 12] Nanoscacling in particular presents a promising avenue for stabilizing oxides under operating conditions while exposing a greater number of active sites through the increasing surface area-to-volume ratio (SA:V).[13, 14, 15]
However, an accurate evaluation of the nanoparticle formation energy not only requires the thermodynamic contributions of the bulk, but the surface as well. Doing so requires an ensemble of expensive Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations of the bare surfaces for one material. Likewise, accurate evaluations of the overpotential requires an even larger set of calculations for all the surface intermediates participating in OER. As such, doing so for the massive pool of binary and unary oxide materials available will quickly become computationally expensive and unfeasible.
Machine learning (ML) potentials and screening frameworks have recently contributed significantly in rapidly predicting candidate catalysts without the need for expensive systematic DFT screening.[16, 17, 18, 19, 20] Among these efforts, the Open Catalyst Project (OCP)[21] framework has stood out as having the largest dataset of carefully curated DFT calculations for non-oxide slabs and surface intermediates to-date. ML models pretrained with the OCP has allowed for large scale interpolation efforts to predict binding energies, enabling high-throughput screening efforts to identify viable catalyst candidates[22] and explore fundamental surface chemistry.[23] More recently, the Open Catalyst 2022 (OC22) framework has expanded upon this dataset by incorporating random combinations of 4,728 oxide materials, Miller indices up to 3, and surface intermediates involved in OER.[24] These efforts have yielded predictive ML models with total energy mean absolute error (MAE)s of less than 0.22 and 0.69 eV for in domain (materials observed during training) and out of domain predictions, respectively. In this manuscript, we utilized a pre-trained model from the OC22 framework to interpolate the surface energies and OER binding energies for 4,119 in domain oxide materials on all facets up to a maximum Miller index (MMI) of 1. To demonstrate the applicability of our interpolated database, we constructed a high-throughput screening framework with a set of progressive criteria that can be modified or expanded upon for ease of customizeability in order to evaluate the commercial and practical viability of each material for OER. Our general framework evaluates materials based on thermodynamic stability, overpotential, and material cost. We also expand upon other screening criteria such as the possibility of nanoscale stabilization or the faceting of surfaces on the equilibrium crystal structure. We propose 190 possible candidates for OER under the bulk and nanoscale regime respectively that warrant further experimental investigation.
Methods
All analysis were performed using the python materials genomics (pymatgen) [25, 26, 27, 28] and Atomic Simulation Environment (ASE)[29] packages.
Slab generation
We described all facets up to a MMI of 1 containing an atomic and vacuum layer of 12.5 Å thick. The bulk materials used for slab construction in this study were obtained from the Materials Project.[30] We also considered all terminations for each facet (sans slabs exceeding 200 atoms) while maintaining equivalent surfaces on both sides of the slab which consequently resulted in non-stoichiometric slabs with respect to the bulk formula. Although the original OC22 dataset covered 4,732 distinct bulk oxide materials, the conventional unit cell of some of these materials contains over 100 atoms making the construction of slabs exceed our 200 atom limit for the majority of facets considered. As such, we limit our study to slabs constructed from unit cells of less than 100 atoms. Furthermore, slabs constructed from a select number of materials resulted in the forces in the ML model being unconverged. Thus, we ommitted 609 from the original 4,732 materials in the OC22 dataset that exhibited these behaviors, with our final bulk set containing 3,823 binary (A-B-O) and 296 unary (A-O) oxides. For all slabs constructed, we modelled the surface intermediates of , , and . To avoid periodic interactions between the adsorbates, all slabs were expanded along the length and width to at least 8 Å. We assumed all adsorbates bind through the O atom on available undercoordinated metal sites. All bare surface and surface intermediate models were constructed using the python framework adapted from OC22[24, 31, 32].
DFT and machine learning settings
All DFT calculations were performed using the Vienna Ab Initio Simulation Package (VASP)[33, 34, 35, 36] within the Projected Augmented Wave (PAW)[37] approach. We modeled the exchange-correlation effects with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) generalized gradient approximation (GGA) functional.[38] All calculations were performed with spin-polarization with a plane wave energy cut-off of 500 eV. The energies and atomic forces of all calculations were converged to within eV and eV Å, respectively. We used -centered k-point meshes of for slab calculations, with non-integer values rounded up to the nearest integer. We also apply a Hubbard U correction to chemical systems as suggested by the Materials Project[39] to account for missing electron interactions.
We used a pre-trained model for the Structure to Energy and Forces (S2EF)-Total task from the OC22 framework to perform all machine learning predictions of the relaxed structure and total energy. The entirety of the Open Catalyst 2020 (OC20) dataset (1,281,040 DFT relaxations) was used to train an S2EF-Total model which was subsequently fine-tuned with the OC22 dataset (62,331 DFT relaxations) to better predict the total energies of oxide surfaces and surface intermediates. The model was trained using the GemNet-OC architecture[40] due to its superior performance in energy predictions when compared to other graph neural network (GNN) architectures as a consequence of its improved capturing of long-range and quadruplet interactions.
For further details regarding additional parameters used in VASP or the construction of the machine learning model, we refer the reader to Tran et al.[24]
All OC22 S2EF predictions and DFT calculations of slabs were performed with selective dynamics. In regards to surface energy predictions, both the bottom most and topmost layer of atoms within 1.25 Å were allowed to relax in the bare slab in order to ensure both surfaces had equal surface energy contributions. For the adsorption energies, only the topmost layer of atoms within 1.25 Å and any adsorbates were allowed to relax in the bare slab and surface intermediates. To avoid inadvertent desorption and dissociation of adsorbates during our ML relaxation, we applied a spring constant of 7.5 eV Å between all adsorbate atoms to preserve the identity of the molecule and between the adsorbate and host surface atoms whenever the adsorbate drifts 2 Å away from its initial position along the axis perpendicular to the surface.[41, 42] Similarly, we also applied the same restorative force to all surface atoms when the relaxed trajectory exceeds 1 Å from the initial position of the ions to avoid drastic surface reconstruction. While this approach yields better interpretability for relaxed adsorption geometries, we recognize the inherent artificiality of these constraints and acknowledge the potential for desorption and dissociation. Consequently, we further implemented ML relaxation without such constraints on relaxed geometries exhibiting low overpotentials to verify the absence of desorption and dissociation phenomena. All values of overpotentials and Gibbs free energies reported in the main manuscript as well as Tables S1-S14 are relaxed without these additional constraints unless stated otherwise.
Additional constraints, unless stated otherwise. Comparisons of the overpotential and Gibbs free energy obtained with and without these constraints can be found in the ESI.
Surface thermodynamics
All bare slabs of formula ABO, with A and B being two metal components, are constructed from a bulk ternary oxide of ABO. We can calculate the surface energy of any slab of ABO with the following:
where is the total energy of the bare slab, is the total energy per formula unit of the bulk crystal, and is the surface area. We used correction values from the Materials Project when evaluating to account for the mixing of quantities determined with GGA and GGA+U.[26, 39, 43] The chemical potentials, , accounts for any nonstoichiometric species (with respect to bulk stoichiometry) in the slab formula. The chemical potential of oxygen () can be referenced to the electrochemical decomposition of water to :
which allows us to rewrite (and thereby ) as a function of and applied potential () as such:
where corrects for the Gibbs free energy of excess or deficient oxygen at the surface (see Tran et al.[24] and Gunasooriya and Nørskov[10] for details). We will assume typically employed operating conditions for acidic OER ( and at or )[9, 44] () when assessing the surface energy of all materials as illustrated in Figure 1(a and b). For slabs containing excess or deficient metal (B) species, the chemical potential of component B is conventionally referenced with respect to the per atom energy of the ground state bulk crystal of pure component B (e.g. ). By varying the chemical potential of component B, we can stabilize different surface terminations of the same facet as shown in the surface Pourbaix diagram in Figure 1(a and b).
Figure 1. Surface Pourbaix diagram of the (001) facet of CaCrO at C under eV (a) and eV (b). The blue dashed line indicates the equilibrium conditions for OER while the black box indicates the desired conditions for OER ( and V). The phases in (a) and (b) are color coded with the corresponding terminations of the (001) facet in (c).
To determine the nanoscale stability of metastable and unstable materials under operating conditions, we assessed the nanoparticle formation energy given by:
whereby is the Pourbaix formation energy per volume of the unit cell, is the weighted surface energy of the Wulff shape (an analogue to the nanoparticle morphology), and
r is the radius of the nanoparticle. Detailed explanation of these quantities can be found in the ESI. Figure 2 demonstrates how a less stable compound (CaTiO) can become more stable than the ground state compound as nanoparticle size and decreases. The size effect will change the relative contribution of surface energy and bulk Pourbaix formation energy to while changes the overall particle morphology and thereby surface energy of the particle.

Figure 2. Nanoscale stability phase diagram for the Ca-Ti-O chemical system plotted using as a function of the chemical potential of Ti () and nanoparticle radius. The red region represents the less stable (higher ) phase (CaTiO) while the cyan region represents the ground state phase (CaTiO). The nanoparticle morphology and surface energy change as a function of indicated by the inset Wulff shapes.
The scope of this study will explore the water nucleophilic attack (WNA) mechanism for OER, a four step mechanism where two water molecules sequentially bind to a metal at the surface and release an electron-proton pair at each step as shown in Figure 3.[45] We realize and emphasize that the WNA mechanism is one of many approximations for modeling OER and that it is possible for certain materials to prefer alternative mechanisms e.g. the oxo-coupling mechanism or lattice oxygen evolution reaction.[46, 47, 48, 49, 50] However, we focus on the WNA mechanism on account of its ubiquity in computational studies[51, 52, 53, 54, 55] and supporting experimental evidence.[47, 56] We can determine the overpotential for this reaction by identifying the largest energy difference between each step, reaction energy () with the following:

Figure 3. Reaction diagram for the WNA on an ideal catalyst (dashed lines) and LaMnO(100) surface (solid lines) at 0 V (black) and the equilibrium potential of OER (red). An illustration of each reaction step is shown at the bottom (red circles are oxygen while grey circles are hydrogen/protons). Reaction energies for LaMnO were derived from Man et al. [45]. The chemical equation between each reaction step (1-4) is listed on the right (i-iv).
where , , and are the Gibbs free energy of each reaction step, 4.92 eV is the Gibbs free energy to dissociate two water molecules into and shown in Equation 2, and 1.23 V is the equilibrium potential for water decomposition. Here, the step corresponding to the largest value of is also called the potential determining step (PDS). We can derive the Gibbs free energy of each step listed in Equations – (see Figure 3) as such:
References
- [1]Jamesh, M. I.; Sun, X. Recent progress on earth abundant electrocatalysts for oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in alkaline medium to achieve efficient water splitting – A review. Journal of Power Sources 2018, 400, 31–68.
- [2]Yuan, N.; Jiang, Q.; Li, J.; Tang, J. A review on non-noble metal based electrocatalysis for the oxygen evolution reaction. Arabian Journal of Chemistry 2020, 13, 4294–4309.
- [3]Kim, J. S.; Kim, B.; Kim, H.; Kang, K. Recent Progress on Multimetal Oxide Catalysts for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Advanced Energy Materials 2018, 8, 1–26.
- [4]Suen, N. T.; Hung, S. F.; Quan, Q.; Zhang, N.; Xu, Y. J.; Chen, H. M. Electrocatalysis for the oxygen evolution reaction: Recent development and future perspectives. Chemical Society Reviews 2017, 46, 337–365.DOI
- [5]Lee, Y.; Suntivitch, J.; May, K. J.; Perry, E. E.; Shao-Horn, Y. Synthesis and activities of rutile IrO 2 and RuO 2 nanoparticles for oxygen evolution in acid and alkaline solutions. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2012, 3, 399–404.
- [6]Free Metal Price Tables and Charts. https://www.dailymetalprice.com/.
- [7]Precious Metals Dealer. https://www.apmex.com/.
- [8]Latest and Historical Metal Prices. www.metalary.com.
- [9]Wang, Z.; Zheng, Y. R.; Chorkendorff, I.; Nørskov, J. K. Acid-Stable Oxides for Oxygen Electrocatalysis. ACS Energy Letters 2020, 5, 2905–2908.DOI
- [10]Gunasooriya, G. T. K.; Nørskov, J. K. Analysis of Acid-Stable and Active Oxides for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction. ACS Energy Letters 2020, 5, 3778–3787.
- [11]Abed, J.; Heras-Domingo, J.; Luo, M.; Sanspeur, R.; Alnoush, W.; Meira, D.; Wang, H.-T.; Wang, J.; Zhou, J.; Zhou, D., et al. Multi-Descriptor Design of Ruthenium Catalysts for Durable Acidic Water Oxidation. Preprint 2023, 23.DOI
- [12]Fu, J.; Jiang, X.; Han, W.; Cao, Z. Enhancing the Cycling Stability of Transition-Metal-Oxide-Based Electrochemical Electrode via Pourbaix Diagram Engineering. Energy Storage Materials 2021, 42, 252–258.DOI
- [13]Kang, S.; Mo, Y.; Ong, S. P.; Ceder, G. Nanoscale stabilization of sodium oxides: Implications for Na-O2 batteries. Nano Letters 2014, 14, 1016–1020.DOI
- [14]Sun, W. Theoretical Advancements towards Understanding Crystalline Metastability during Materials Synthesis. Ph.D. thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2016.
- [15]Navrotsky, A. Nanoscale effects on thermodynamics and phase equilibria in oxide systems. ChemPhysChem 2011, 12, 2207–2215.DOI
- [16]Li, Z.; Achenie, L. E.; Xin, H. An Adaptive Machine Learning Strategy for Accelerating Discovery of Perovskite Electrocatalysts. ACS Catalysis 2020, 10, 4377–4384.DOI
- [17]Rao, K. K.; Do, Q. K.; Pham, K.; Maiti, D.; Grabow, L. C. Extendable Machine Learning Model for the Stability of Single Atom Alloys. Topics in Catalysis 2020, 63, 728–741.
- [18]Abdelfatah, K.; Yang, W.; Vijay Solomon, R.; Rajbanshi, B.; Chowdhury, A.; Zare, M.; Kundu, S. K.; Yonge, A.; Heyden, A.; Terejianu, G. Prediction of Transition-State Energies of Hydrodeoxygenation Reactions on Transition-Metal Surfaces Based on Machine Learning. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2019, 123, 29804–29810.DOI
- [19]Malek, A.; Wang, Q.; Baumann, S.; Guillon, O.; Eikerling, M.; Malek, K. A Data-Driven Framework for the Accelerated Discovery of CO2 Reduction Electrocatalysts. Frontiers in Energy Research 2021, 9, 1–15.
- [20]Back, S.; Yoon, J.; Tian, N.; Zhong, W.; Tran, K.; Ulissi, Z. W. Convolutional Neural Network of Atomic Surface Structures to Predict Binding Energies for High-Throughput Screening of Catalysts. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2019, 10, 4401–4408.DOI
- [21]Chanuissot, L. et al. Open Catalyst 2020 (OC20) Dataset and Community Challenges. ACS Catalysis 2021, 11, 6059–6072.
- [22]Tran, R.; Wang, D.; Kingsbury, R.; Palizhati, A.; Persson, K. A.; Jain, A.; Ulissi, Z. W. Screening of bimetallic electrocatalysts for water purification with machine learning. The Journal of Chemical Physics 2022, 157, 074102.DOI
- [23]Price, C. C.; Singh, A.; Frey, N. C.; Shenoy, V. B. Efficient catalyst screening using graph neural networks to predict strain effects on adsorption energy. Science Advances 2022, 8, 1–12.
- [24]Tran, R. et al. The Open Catalyst 2022 (OC22) Dataset and Challenges for Oxide Electrocatalysts. ACS Catalysis 2022, 13, 3066–3084.DOI
- [25]Ong, S. P.; Richards, W. D.; Jain, A.; Hautier, G.; Kocher, M.; Cholia, S.; Gunter, D.; Chevrier, V. L.; Persson, K. A.; Ceder, G. Python Materials Genomics (pymatgen): A robust, open-source python library for materials analysis. Computational Materials Science 2013, 68, 314–319.DOI
- [26]Persson, K. a.; Waldwick, B.; Lazic, P.; Ceder, G. Prediction of solid-aqueous equilibria: Scheme to combine first-principles calculations of solids with experimental aqueous states. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2012, 85, 1–12.DOI
- [27]Singh, A. K.; Zhou, L.; Shinde, A.; Suram, S. K.; Montoya, J. H.; Winston, D.; Gregoire, J. M.; Persson, K. A. Electrochemical Stability of Metastable Materials. Chemistry of Materials 2017, 29, 10159–10167.
- [28]Patel, A. M.; Nørskov, J. K.; Persson, K. A.; Montoya, J. H. Efficient Pourbaix diagrams of many-element compounds. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2019, 21, 25323–25327.DOI
- [29]Hjorth Larsen, A. et al. The atomic simulation environment - A Python library for working with atoms. Journal of Physics Condensed Matter 2017, 29, 1–30.DOI
- [30]Jain, A.; Ong, S. P.; Hautier, G.; Chen, W.; Richards, W. D.; Dacek, S.; Cholia, S.; Gunter, D.; Skinner, D.; Ceder, G.; Persson, K. A. Commentary: The materials project: A materials genome approach to accelerating materials innovation. APL Materials 2013, 1, 011002 1.DOI
- [31]Sun, W.; Ceder, G. Efficient creation and convergence of surface slabs. Surface Science 2013, 617, 53–59.DOI
- [32]Montoya, J. H.; Persson, K. A. A high-throughput framework for determining adsorption energies on solid surfaces. npj Computational Materials 2017, 3, 14.DOI
- [33]Kresse, G.; Hafner, J. Ab initio molecular dynamics for liquid metals. Physical Review B 1993, 47, 558–561.
- [34]Kresse, G.; Hafner, J. Ab initio molecular-dynamics simulation of the liquid-metalamorphous-semiconductor transition in germanium. Physical Review B 1994, 49, 14251–14269.
- [35]Kresse, G.; Furthmüller, J. Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. Physical review B, Condensed matter 1996, 54, 11169–11186.
- [36]Kresse, G., Furthmuller, J. Software VASP, Vienna. Physical Review B 1996, 54, 169.
- [37]Blöchl, P. E. Projector augmented-wave method. 1994.
- [38]Perdew, J.; Burke, K.; Ernzerhof, M. Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple. Physical review letters 1996, 77, 3865–3868.
- [39]Jain, A.; Hautier, G.; Ong, S. P.; Moore, C. J.; Fischer, C. C.; Persson, K. A.; Ceder, G. Formation enthalpies by mixing GGA and GGA+U calculations. Physical Review B 2011, 84, 045115.DOI
- [40]Gasteiger, J.; Sriram, A.; Günnemann, S.; Ulissi, Z. GemNet-OC : Developing Graph Neural Networks for Large and Diverse Molecular Simulation Datasets. Transactions on Machine Learning Research 2022, 1–22.
- [41]Peterson, A. A. Global optimization of adsorbate-surface structures while preserving molecular identity. Topics in Catalysis 2014, 57, 40–53.
- [42]Musielewicz, J.; Wang, X.; Tian, T.; Ulissi, Z. FINETUNA: fine-tuning accelerated molecular simulations. Machine Learning: Science and Technology 2022, 3, 03LT01.arxiv.org/abs/2205.01223
- [43]Wang, A.; Kingsbury, R.; McDermott, M.; Horton, M.; Jain, A.; Ong, S. P.; Dwaraknath, S.; Persson, K. A. A framework for quantifying uncertainty in DFT energy corrections. Scientific Reports 2021, 11, 1–10.DOI
- [44]Shi, G.; Tano, T.; Tryk, D. A.; Yamaguchi, M.; Iiyama, A.; Uchida, M.; Iida, K.; Arata, C.; Watanabe, S.; Kakinuma, K. Temperature Dependence of Oxygen Evolution Reaction Activity in Alkaline Solution at Ni-Co Oxide Catalysts with Amorphous/Crystalline Surfaces. ACS Catalysis 2022, 12, 14209–14219.
- [45]Man, I. C.; Su, H.-Y.; Calle-Vallejo, F.; Hansen, H. A.; Martínez, J. I.; Inoglu, N. G.; Kitchin, J.; Jaramillo, T. F.; Nørskov, J. K.; Rossmeisl, J. Universality in Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis on Oxide Surfaces. ChemCatChem 2011, 3, 1159–1165.
- [46]Fabbri, E.; Habereder, A.; Waltar, K.; Kötz, R.; Schmidt, T. J. Developments and perspectives of oxide-based catalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction. Catalysis Science and Technology 2014, 4, 3800–3821.
- [47]Reier, T.; Nong, H. N.; Teschner, D.; Schlögl, R.; Strasser, P. Electrocatalytic Oxygen Evolution Reaction in Acidic Environments – Reaction Mechanisms and Catalysts. Advanced Energy Materials 2017, 7, 1–18.
- [48]Dau, H.; Limberg, C.; Reier, T.; Risch, M.; Roggan, S.; Strasser, P. The Mechanism of Water Oxidation: From Electrolysis via Homogeneous to Biological Catalysis. ChemCatChem 2010, 2, 724–761.
- [49]Fabbri, E.; Schmidt, T. J. Oxygen Evolution Reaction - The Enigma in Water Electrolysis. ACS Catalysis 2018, 8, 9765–9774.
- [50]González, D.; Heras-Domingo, J.; Sodупе, M.; Rodríguez-Santiago, L.; Solans-Monfort, X. Importance of the oxyl character on the IrO2 surface dependent catalytic activity for the oxygen evolution reaction. Journal of Catalysis 2021, 396, 192–201.
- [51]Zhang, J.; Tao, H. B.; Kuang, M.; Yang, H. B.; Cai, W.; Yan, Q.; Mao, Q.; Liu, B. Advances in Thermodynamic-Kinetic Model for Analyzing the Oxygen Evolution Reaction. ACS Catalysis 2020, 10, 8597–8610.
- [52]Fornaciari, J. C.; Weng, L. C.; Alia, S. M.; Zhan, C.; Pham, T. A.; Bell, A. T.; Ogitsu, T.; Danilovic, N.; Weber, A. Z. Mechanistic understanding of pH effects on the oxygen evolution reaction. Electrochimica Acta 2022, 405, 1–8.
- [53]Huang, J.; Li, M.; Eslamibidgoli, M. J.; Eikerling, M.; Groß, A. Cation Overcrowding Effect on the Oxygen Evolution Reaction. JACS Au 2021, 1, 1752–1765.
- [54]Nishimoto, T.; Shinagawa, T.; Naito, T.; Takanabe, K. Microkinetic assessment of electrocatalytic oxygen evolution reaction over iridium oxide in unbuffered conditions. Journal of Catalysis 2020, 391, 435–445.
- [55]Mefford, J. T.; Zhao, Z.; Bajdich, M.; Chueh, W. C. Interpreting Tafel behavior of consecutive electrochemical reactions through combined thermodynamic and steady state microkinetic approaches. Energy and Environmental Science 2020, 13, 622–634.
- [56]Naito, T.; Shinagawa, T.; Nishimoto, T.; Takanabe, K. Recent advances in understanding oxygen evolution reaction mechanisms over iridium oxide. Inorganic Chemistry Frontiers 2021, 8, 2900–2917.
- [57]Tran, R. Replication Data for: Rational design of oxide catalysts for OER with OC22, 2023; https://doi.org/10.18738/T8/APJFTM.
- [58]Jain, A.; Wang, Z.; Nørskov, J. K. Stable Two-Dimensional Materials for Oxygen Reduction and Oxygen Evolution Reactions. ACS Energy Letters 2019, 4, 1410–1411.
- [59]Sanspeur, R. Y.; Heras-Domingo, J.; Kitchin, J. R.; Ulissi, Z. WhereWulff: A Semiautonomous Workflow for Systematic Catalyst Surface Reactivity under Reaction Conditions. Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling 2023, 63, 2427–2437.
- [60]Aykol, M.; Dwaraknath, S. S.; Sun, W.; Persson, K. A. Thermodynamic limit for synthesis of metastable inorganic materials. Science Advances 2018, 4, 1–8.
- [61]Joya, K. S.; Ahmad, Z.; Joya, Y. F.; Garcia-Esparza, A. T.; De Groot, H. J. Efficient electrochemical water oxidation in neutral and near-neutral systems with a nanoscale silver-oxide catalyst. Nanoscale 2016, 8, 15033–15040.
- [62]Simondson, D.; Chatti, M.; Gardiner, J. L.; Kerr, B. V.; Hoogeveen, D. A.; Cherepanov, P. V.; Kuschnerus, I. C.; Nguyen, T. D.; Johannessen, B.; Chang, S. L.; Macfarlane, D. R.; Hocking, R. K.; Simonov, A. N. Mixed Silver-Bismuth Oxides: A Robust Oxygen Evolution Catalyst Operating at Low pH and Elevated Temperatures. ACS Catalysis 2022, 12, 12912–12926.
- [63]Huang, X.; Xie, M.; Chen, Y.; Zong, Q.; Liu, Z.; Jin, Y. Copper-silver oxide nanowires grown on an alloy electrode as an efficient electrocatalyst for water oxidation. RSC Advances 2015, 5, 26150–26156.
- [64]Yu, M.; hee Moon, G.; Castillo, R. G.; DeBeer, S.; Weidenthaler, C.; Tüysüz, H. Dual Role of Silver Moieties Coupled with Ordered Mesoporous Cobalt Oxide towards Electrocatalytic Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 2020, 59, 16544–16552.
- [65]Zhao, X.; Zhang, H.; Yan, Y.; Cao, J.; Li, X.; Zhou, S.; Peng, Z.; Zeng, J. Engineering the Electrical Conductivity of Lamellar Silver-Doped Cobalt(II) Selenide Nanobelts for Enhanced Oxygen Evolution. Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 2017, 56, 328–332.
- [66]Tian, L.; Zhai, X.; Wang, X.; Li, J.; Li, Z. Advances in manganese-based oxides for oxygen evolution reaction. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2020, 8, 14400–14414.
- [67]Teng, Y.; Wang, X. D.; Liao, J. F.; Li, W. G.; Chen, H. Y.; Dong, Y. J.; Kuang, D. B. Atomically Thin Defect-Rich Fe–Mn–O Hybrid Nanosheets as High Efficient Electrocatalyst for Water Oxidation. Advanced Functional Materials 2018, 28, 1–8.
- [68]Hong, J. S.; Seo, H.; Lee, Y. H.; Cho, K. H.; Ko, C.; Park, S.; Nam, K. T. Nickel-Doping Effect on Mn3O4 Nanoparticles for Electrochemical Water Oxidation under Neutral Condition. Small Methods 2020, 4, 1–7.
- [69]Hu, C.; Zhang, L.; Zhao, Z. J.; Li, A.; Chang, X.; Gong, J. Synergism of Geometric Construction and Electronic Regulation: 3D Se-(NiCo)Sx/(OH)x Nanosheets for Highly Efficient Overall Water Splitting. Advanced Materials 2018, 30, 1–8.
- [70]Zhou, L.; Wang, Y.; Kan, K.; Lucana, D. M.; Guevarra, D.; Lai, Y.; Gregoire, J. M. Surveying Metal Antimonate Photoanodes for Solar Fuel Generation. ACS Sustainable Chemistry and Engineering 2022, 10, 15898–15908.
- [71]Zhou, L.; Li, H.; Lai, Y.; Richter, M.; Kan, K.; Haber, J. A.; Kelly, S.; Wang, Z.; Lu, Y.; Kim, R. S.; Li, X.; Yano, J.; Nørskov, J. K.; Gregoire, J. M. Stability and Activity of Cobalt Antimonate for Oxygen Reduction in Strong Acid. ACS Energy Letters 2022, 7, 993–1000.
- [72]Luke, S.; Chatti, M.; Yadav, A.; Kerr, B. V.; Kangsabanik, J.; Williams, T.; Cherepanov, P. V.; Johannessen, B.; Tanksale, A.; MacFarlane, D. R.; Hocking, R. K.; Alam, A.; Yella, A.; Simonov, A. N. Mixed metal-antimony oxide nanocomposites: low pH water oxidation electrocatalysts with outstanding durability at ambient and elevated temperatures. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2021, 9, 27468–27484.
- [73]Gupta, S.; Fernandes, R.; Patel, R.; Spreitzer, M.; Patel, N. A review of cobalt-based catalysts for sustainable energy and environmental applications. Applied Catalysis A: General 2023, 661, 23.
- [74]Si, C.; Zhang, Y.; Zhang, C.; Gao, H.; Ma, W.; Lv, L.; Zhang, Z. Mesoporous nanostructured spinel-type MFe2O4 (M = Co, Mn, Ni) oxides as efficient bi-functional electrocatalysts towards oxygen reduction and oxygen evolution. Electrochimica Acta 2017, 245, 829–838.
- [75]Li, M.; Xiong, Y.; Liu, X.; Bo, X.; Zhang, Y.; Han, C.; Guo, L. Facile synthesis of electrospun MFe2O4 (M = Co, Ni, Cu, Mn) spinel nanofibers with excellent electrocatalytic properties for oxygen evolution and hydrogen peroxide reduction. Nanoscale 2015, 7, 8920–8930.
- [76]Müllner, M.; Riva, M.; Kraushofer, F.; Schmid, M.; Parkinson, G. S.; Mertens, S. F.; Diebold, U. Stability and Catalytic Performance of Reconstructed Fe 3 O 4 (001) and Fe 3 O 4 (110) Surfaces during Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2019, 123, 8304–8311.
- [77]Hirai, S.; Yagi, S.; Seno, A.; Fujioka, M.; Ohno, T.; Matsuda, T. Enhancement of the oxygen evolution reaction in Mn3+-based electrocatalysts: Correlation between Jahn-Teller distortion and catalytic activity. RSC Advances 2016, 6, 2019–2023.
- [78]Al-Mamun, M.; Su, X.; Zhang, H.; Yin, H.; Liu, P.; Yang, H.; Wang, D.; Tang, Z.; Wang, Y.; Zhao, H. Strongly Coupled CoCr2O4/Carbon Nanosheets as High Performance Electrocatalysts for Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Small 2016, 12, 2866–2871.
- [79]Quan, Z.; Wang, Y.; Fang, J. High-index faceted noble metal nanocrystals. Accounts of Chemical Research 2013, 46, 191–202.
- [80]Wang, Z.; Guo, X.; Montoya, J.; Nørskov, J. K. Predicting aqueous stability of solid with computed Pourbaix diagram using SCAN functional. npj Computational Materials 2020, 6, 1–7.
- [81]Konno, Y.; Yamamoto, T.; Nagayama, T. Nanoporous manganese ferrite films by anodising electroplated Fe-Mn alloys for bifunctional oxygen electrodes. Nanoscale 2021, 13, 12738–12749.
- [82]Han, J.; Zhang, M.; Bai, X.; Duan, Z.; Tang, T.; Guan, J. Mesoporous Mn-Fe oxyhydroxides for oxygen evolution. Inorganic Chemistry Frontiers 2022, 3559–3565.
- [83]Sun, L.; Dai, Z.; Zhong, L.; Zhao, Y.; Cheng, Y.; Chong, S.; Chen, G.; Yan, C.; Zhang, X.; Tan, H.; Zhang, L.; Dinh, K. N.; Li, S.; Ma, F.; Yan, Q. Lattice strain and atomic replacement of CoO6 octahedra in layered sodium cobalt oxide for boosted water oxidation electrocatalysis. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 2021, 297, 120477.
- [84]Toxic Metals - Overview. https://www.osha.gov/toxic-metals.
- [85]Yu, X.; Qu, L.; Lee, C.; Peng, J.; Yan, Q.; Bai, H.; Yao, M. Bismuth-nickel bimetal nanosheets with a porous structure for efficient hydrogen production in neutral and alkaline media. Nanoscale 2022, 5.
- [86]Kuznetsov, D. A.; Peng, J.; Giordano, L.; Román-Leshkov, Y.; Shao-Horn, Y. Bismuth Substituted Strontium Cobalt Perovskites for Catalyzing Oxygen Evolution. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2020, 124, 6562–6570.
- [87]Thorarinsdottir, A. E.; Costentin, C.; Veroneau, S. S.; Nocera, D. G. P-Block Metal Oxide Noninnocence in the Oxygen Evolution Reaction in Acid: The Case of Bismuth Oxide. Chemistry of Materials 2022, 34, 826–835.
- [88]Bibi, I.; Alrowaily, A. W.; Alyousef, H. A.; Alotaibi, B. M.; Alqurashi, H.; Dahshan, A. Reduced graphene oxide-based silver selenide nanocomposite synthesized through hydrothermal method for oxygen evolution reaction. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 2024, 993, 174626.
- [89]Jiang, S.; Suo, H.; Zheng, X.; Zhang, T.; Lei, Y.; Wang, Y. X.; Lai, W. H.; Wang, G. Lightest Metal Leads to Big Change: Lithium-Mediated Metal Oxides for Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Advanced Energy Materials 2022, 12.
- [90]Zan, L.; Amin, H. M.; Mostafa, E.; Abd-El-Latif, A. A.; Iqbal, S.; Baltruschat, H. Electrodeposited Cobalt Nanosheets on Smooth Silver as a Bifunctional Catalyst for OER and ORR: In Situ Structural and Catalytic Characterization. ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces 2022, 14, 55458–55470.
- [91]Arslan Hamat, B.; Aydinol, M. K. Experimental investigation on the electro-catalytic behavior of Ag-based oxides, Ag2XO4 (X= Cr, Mo, W), for the oxygen reduction reaction in alkaline media. Journal of Solid State Chemistry 2020, 290.
- [92]Singh, R. N.; Koenig, J. F.; Poillerat, G.; Chartier, P. Electrochemical Studies on Protective Thin Co3O4 and NiCo2O4 Films Prepared on Titanium by Spray Pyrolysis for Oxygen Evolution. Journal of The Electrochemical Society 1990, 137, 1408–1413.
- [93]Ahmed, J.; Alhokbany, N.; Ahamad, T.; Alshehri, S. M. Investigation of enhanced electro-catalytic HER/OER performances of copper tungsten oxide@reduced graphene oxide nanocomposites in alkaline and acidic media. New J. Chem. 2022, 46, 1267–1272.
- [94]Arora, A.; Wadhwa, R.; Yadav, K. K.; Ankush,; Jha, M. Enhanced electrochemical oxygen generation from sillenite phase of bismuth iron oxide (Bi24Fe2O39) ultrafine particles stabilised at room temperature. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 2024, 958, 118154.
- [95]Menezes, P. W.; Indra, A.; Bergmann, A.; Chernev, P.; Walter, C.; Dau, H.; Strasser, P.; Driess, M. Uncovering the prominent role of metal ions in octahedral: Versus tetrahedral sites of cobalt-zinc oxide catalysts for efficient oxidation of water. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2016, 4, 10014–10022.
- [96]Kim, T. W.; Woo, M. A.; Regis, M.; Choi, K. S. Electrochemical synthesis of spinel type ZnCo2O4 electrodes for use as oxygen evolution reaction catalysts. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2014, 5, 2370–2374.
- [97]Du, C.; Yang, J.; Yang, J.; Zhao, Y.; Chen, R.; Shan, B. An iron oxide-copper bismuth oxide photoelectrochemical cell for spontaneous water splitting. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 2018, 43, 22807–22814.
- [98]Balaghi, S. E.; Triana, C. A.; Patzke, G. R. Molybdenum-Doped Manganese Oxide as a Highly Efficient and Economical Water Oxidation Catalyst. ACS Catalysis 2020, 10, 2074–2087.
- [99]Hausmann, J. N.; Ashton, M.; Mebs, S.; Walter, C.; Selve, S.; Haumann, M.; Sontheimer, T.; Dau, H.; Driess, M.; Menezes, P. W. Intermetallic Cobalt Indium Nanoparticles as Oxygen Evolution Reaction Pre catalyst: A Non-Leaching p-Block Element. Small 2024, 2309749, 1–7.
- [100]Lima, A. J.; Silva, V. D.; Raimundo, R. A.; Morales, M. A.; Simões, T. A.; Loureiro, F. J.; Fagg, D. P.; Macedo, D. A.; Nascimento, R. M. Fe-doped calcium cobaltites as electrocatalysts for oxygen evolution reaction. Ceramics International 2021, 47, 26109–26118.
- [101]Bagheri, S.; Ramimoghadam, D.; Yousefi, A. T.; Hamid, S. B. A. Synthesis, characterization and electrocatalytic activity of silver doped-titanium dioxide nanoparticles. International Journal of Electrochemical Science 2015, 10, 3088–3097.
- [102]Simondson, D.; Ghatti, M.; Bonke, S. A.; Tesch, M. F.; Golnak, R.; Xiao, J.; Hoogeveen, D. A.; Cherepanov, P. V.; Gardiner, J. L.; Tricoli, A.; MacFarlane, D. R.; Simonov, A. N. Stable Acidic Water Oxidation with a Cobalt–Iron–Lead Oxide Catalyst Operating via a Cobalt-Selective Self-Healing Mechanism. Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 2021, 60, 15821–15826.
- [103]Li, Y.; Zhang, X.; Zheng, Z. A Review of Transition Metal Oxygen-Evolving Catalysts Decorated by Cerium-Based Materials: Current Status and Future Prospects. CCS Chemistry 2022, 4, 31–53.
- [104]Tabassum, L.; Tasnim, H.; Shub-hashish, S.; Perera, I.; Bhosale, T.; Li, M.; March, S.; Islam, M. K.; Suid, S. L. Selenium-doped copper oxide nanoarrays: Robust electrocatalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction with ultralow overpotential. Applied Materials Today 2022, 27, 101485.
- [105]Xu, Z.; Li, W.; Wang, X.; Wang, B.; Shi, Z.; Dong, C.; Yan, S.; Zou, Z. Novel Cobalt Germanium Hydroxide for Electrochemical Water Oxidation. ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces 2018, 10, 30357–30366.
- [106]Rajput, A.; Kundu, A.; Chakraborty, B. Recent Progress on Copper-Based Electrode Materials for Overall Water-Splitting. ChemElectroChem 2021, 8, 1698–1722.
- [107]Yu, M.; Budiyanto, E.; Tüysüz, H. Principles of Water Electrolysis and Recent Progress in Cobalt-, Nickel-, and Iron-Based Oxides for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 2022, 61.
- [108]Cui, B.; Lin, H.; Li, J. B.; Li, X.; Yang, J.; Tao, J. Core-ring structured NiCo2O4 nanoplatelets: Synthesis, characterization, and electrocatalytic applications. Advanced Functional Materials 2008, 18, 1440–1447.
- [109]Lin, X.; Bao, H.; Zheng, D.; Zhou, J.; Xiao, G.; Guan, C.; Zhang, L.; Wang, J. Q. An Efficient Family of Misfit-Layered Calcium Cobalt Oxide Catalyst for Oxygen Evolution Reaction. Advanced Materials Interfaces 2018, 5, 1–7.
- [110]Yue, Y.; Niu, J.; Yang, C.; Qin, J.; Zhang, X.; Liu, R. The OER/ORR activities of copper oxyhydroxide series electrocatalysts. Molecular Catalysis 2023, 537, 112942.
- [111]Wang, L.; Ge, X.; Li, Y.; Liu, J.; Huang, L.; Feng, L.; Wang, Y. Nickel enhanced the catalytic activities of amorphous copper for the oxygen evolution reaction. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2017, 5, 4331–4334.
- [112]Zhang, Q.; Liu, N.; Guan, J. Charge-Transfer Effects in Fe-Co and Fe-Co-Y Oxides for Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation Reaction. ACS Applied Energy Materials 2019, 2, 8903–8911.
- [113]Huang, L.; Chen, D.; Luo, G.; Lu, Y. R.; Chen, C.; Zou, Y.; Dong, C. L.; Li, Y.; Wang, S. Zirconium-Regulation-Induced Bifunctionality in 3D Cobalt–Iron Oxide Nanosheets for Overall Water Splitting. Advanced Materials 2019, 31, 1–10.
- [114]Zhou, Z.; Li, X.; Li, Q.; Zhao, Y.; Pang, H. Copper-based materials as highly active electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction. Materials Today Chemistry 2019, 11, 169–196.
- [115]Frydendal, R.; Paoli, E. A.; Chorkendorff, I.; Rossmeisl, J.; Stephens, I. E. Toward an Active and Stable Catalyst for Oxygen Evolution in Acidic Media: Ti-Stabilized MnO2. Advanced Energy Materials 2015, 5.
