betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Multiparticle entanglement in a time-dependent electron–ion–photon system

Abstract

Photoionization provides a natural setting for entanglement transfer in the time domain: an outgoing electron can become entangled with the residual ion, while subsequent spontaneous emission may transfer these correlations to an emitted photon. We quantify the entanglement dynamics of the composite electron–ion–photon system using the von Neumann entropy of the one-versus-rest bipartitions, showing that the initially entangled electron–ion system evolves through a genuinely multiparticle-entangled state before approaching an entangled electron–photon state. Logarithmic negativity further resolves the pairwise entanglement, revealing in particular transient ion–photon entanglement. Further, its enhanced sensitivity to weakly populated Schmidt modes additionally exposes high-dimensional entanglement associated with the photon-energy continuum.

Entanglement may be redistributed between the constituents of a composite quantum system without being destroyed, forming the basis for entanglement transfer and quantum-state transfer protocols [1, 2]. Photoionization provides a natural setting for studying this process in the time domain: the outgoing electron can become entangled with residual ionic degrees of freedom in atoms [3, 4, 5, 6], as well as with electronic and nuclear degrees of freedom in molecules [7, 8, 9, 10, 11]; see also Ref. [12] for a broader perspective. Radiative decay may subsequently introduce a third, photonic, subsystem [13]. In our previous work, we showed that fluorescence can transfer entanglement from an electron–ion pair to an electron–photon pair and identified an intermediate regime of multiparticle correlations [14]. However, the genuine multiparticle-entangled regime was not explicitly quantified. While photoionization-induced decoherence has been studied in the ionic [15, 16] and photoelectron subsystems [3, 17, 18], the three-particle nature of our scheme has unique properties.

In this letter, two advances in the interpretation of composite electron–ion–photon states are presented. First, we explicitly compute the genuine multiparticle entanglement for pure states using the von Neumann entropy [19] and compare it to the corresponding logarithmic negativity [20]. Second, we extend the analysis to mixed states, which allows us to regard any of the three particles as an environment that disrupts the coherent dynamics of the other two particles and alters the dynamics of their quantum entanglement. More explicitly, this allows us to distinguish entanglement of one particle with the remaining two from the pairwise entanglement retained when the third particle is unresolved.

The system and the relevant amplitudes are illustrated in Figure 1(a). A short intense pulse ionizes the atomic ground state ∣g⟩|g\rangle and subsequently strongly couples two ionic states ∣a⟩↔∣b⟩|a\rangle\leftrightarrow|b\rangle [5, 6, 21, 22, 23, 24]. On a timescale longer than this ultrafast laser interaction, τsp>τmax⁡\tau_{\mathrm{sp}} > \tau_{\max}, the excited ionic state decays radiatively, producing a photon in mode ℓ\ell, with energy ϵℓ\epsilon_\ell. Due to the different timescales, the probability for spontaneous emission of two photons is small. Thus, we restrict the radiation field to the vacuum and one-photon sectors, yielding the truncated wave function

Entanglement transfer in the conditioned electron–ion–photon system

Figure 1. Entanglement transfer in the conditioned electron–ion–photon system. (a) Level scheme illustrating the wave function in Eq. (1). The driving field ionizes the atom and couples ionic states aa and bb, while spontaneous emission transfers population from ∣b,ϵ,0⟩\lvert b,\epsilon,0\rangle to ∣a,ϵ,1ℓ⟩\lvert a,\epsilon,1_{\ell}\rangle. Subsequently, the driving field strongly couples the states ∣a,ϵ,1ℓ⟩↔∣b,ϵ,1ℓ⟩\lvert a,\epsilon,1_{\ell}\rangle\leftrightarrow\lvert b,\epsilon,1_{\ell}\rangle. Due to the ultrashort laser interaction higher-order spontaneous-emission processes are neglected. (b) Population dynamics of the ionized wave-function components and the total ionized population 1−∣g(t)∣21-\lvert g(t)\rvert^2. (c) Entanglement of the three one-versus-rest bipartitions quantified by the von Neumann entropy. The gray region shows EGMEE_{\mathrm{GME}} from Eq. (4). (d) Corresponding logarithmic negativities, together with the pairwise electron–ion, electron–photon, and ion–photon negativities.

∣Ψ(t)⟩≈g(t)∣g⟩+∫dϵ{α(t,ϵ)∣a,ϵ,0⟩+β(t,ϵ)∣b,ϵ,0⟩+∫dϵℓ[γ(t,ϵ,ϵℓ)∣a,ϵ,1ℓ⟩+δ(t,ϵ,ϵℓ)∣b,ϵ,1ℓ⟩]}.(1)|\Psi(t)\rangle\approx g(t)|g\rangle+\int d\epsilon\left\{\alpha(t,\epsilon)|a,\epsilon,0\rangle+\beta(t,\epsilon)|b,\epsilon,0\rangle +\int d\epsilon_\ell\left[\gamma(t,\epsilon,\epsilon_\ell)|a,\epsilon,1_\ell\rangle+\delta(t,\epsilon,\epsilon_\ell)|b,\epsilon,1_\ell\rangle\right]\right\}. \tag*{(1)}

Here ϵ\epsilon denotes the photoelectron energy and ∣1ℓ⟩|1_\ell\rangle a single photon in mode ℓ\ell. The calculation of the amplitudes gg, α\alpha, β\beta, γ\gamma, and δ\delta follows Ref. [14] and is not repeated here. The ion–photon dynamics are described using the adiabatic-elimination approach applied by Mollow [13]. This yields an effective non-Hermitian treatment of spontaneous emission, which accounts for irreversible decay to increasing photon numbers, as detailed in Ref. [14].

Figure 1(b) shows the corresponding population dynamics. Ionization occurs during the ultrashort Gaussian driving pulse, the pulse duration of which is scanned up to the maximal value τmax⁡=44 fs\tau_{\max}=44\ \mathrm{fs}, denoted by the vertical line. At the end of the pulse the α\alpha and β\beta branches have approximately equal populations. On the much longer radiative time scale, the excited-ion contribution β\beta decays while the one-photon amplitude γ\gamma grows correspondingly. The α\alpha population remains unchanged and δ\delta remains small. Spontaneous emission thus irreversibly converts the branch ∣b,ϵ,0⟩|b,\epsilon,0\rangle into ∣a,ϵ,1ℓ⟩|a,\epsilon,1_\ell\rangle.

We condition Eq. (1) on ionization by projecting out the neutral contribution g(t)∣g⟩g(t)|g\rangle and renormalizing the remaining wave function. No further conditioning is performed: both ionic states, the complete electron spectrum, and both the vacuum and one-photon sectors are retained. The calculated entanglement consequently characterizes the complete ionized ensemble. This distinction is important because conditioning is a non-unitary operation and may alter the entanglement of the selected state. Additional postselection on, for example, the ionic state or photon number would lead to different quantum states, which may correspond to different degrees of entanglement.

Within the complete Hilbert space, the post-pulse evolution factorizes as U≃Ue⊗UIγU\simeq U_e\otimes U_{I_\gamma}, which is local with respect to the bipartition e∣Iγe|I\gamma. The electron entanglement with the combined ion–photon system must therefore remain unchanged. In contrast, the ion–photon evolution cannot be factorized as UIγ≠UI⊗UγU_{I\gamma}\ne U_I\otimes U_\gamma. Spontaneous emission couples the two subsystems through ∣b,0⟩→∣a,1ℓ⟩\lvert b,0\rangle\to\lvert a,1_{\ell}\rangle. In the effective non-Hermitian description this is repre-

sented by the term ∣a,1ℓ⟩⟨b,0∣\lvert a,1_{\ell}\rangle\langle b,0\rvert, while the reverse coupling ∣b,0⟩⟨a,1ℓ∣\lvert b,0\rangle\langle a,1_{\ell}\rvert is eliminated. The ion–photon dynamics can therefore redistribute entanglement between the two subsystems.

For a pure bipartite state with density matrix ρAB\rho_{AB}, where AA and BB denote the subsystems, entanglement can be quantified by the von Neumann entropy

SA∣B≡−Tr⁡(ρAlog⁡2ρA),(2)S_{A|B}\equiv-\operatorname{Tr}(\rho_A\log_2\rho_A), \tag*{(2)}

where ρA\rho_A is the reduced density matrix of AA (or BB). Because the conditioned electron–ion–photon state is pure, Se∣IγS_{e|I\gamma}, SI∣eγS_{I|e\gamma}, and Sγ∣eIS_{\gamma|eI} are entanglement measures for the corresponding bipartitions. This is no longer true for the pairwise states, attained by tracing out the third particle, for example ρeI=Tr⁡γρeIγ\rho_{eI}=\operatorname{Tr}_{\gamma}\rho_{eI\gamma}. Because these reduced pairwise states are generally mixed, their von Neumann entropy quantifies mixedness rather than entanglement alone and is therefore not an entanglement measure. Their entanglement may instead be quantified using logarithmic negativity,

EN(A∣B)=log⁡2∥ρABTA∥1,(3)E_N(A|B)=\log_2\left\|\rho_{AB}^{T_A}\right\|_1, \tag*{(3)}

where TAT_A is the partial transpose of subsystem AA. The logarithmic negativity therefore allows all three pairwise combinations e∣Ie|I, e∣γe|\gamma, and I∣γI|\gamma to be investigated. We additionally apply the multiparticle entanglement indicator

EGME=min⁡{Ee∣Iγ,EI∣eγ,Eγ∣eI}.(4)E_{\mathrm{GME}}=\min\left\{E_{e|I\gamma},E_{I|e\gamma},E_{\gamma|eI}\right\}. \tag*{(4)}

where EE denotes either SS or ENE_N. A pure state is genuinely multiparticle entangled precisely when it is entangled across every bipartition; consequently EGME>0E_{\mathrm{GME}}>0 provides a direct indicator of this regime [25, 26].

The von Neumann entropies in Figure 1(c) expose the resulting transfer particularly clearly. During photoionization, Se∣IγS_{e|I\gamma} and SI∣eγS_{I|e\gamma} approach unity while Sγ∣eIS_{\gamma|eI} remains close to zero, corresponding to an approximately maximally entangled electron–ion state with the photon still factorized as a vacuum state, ∣0⟩\lvert0\rangle. During spontaneous decay, Se∣IγS_{e|I\gamma} remains equal to unity, as required because UIγU_{I\gamma} is local with respect to this bipartition. At the same time, SI∣eγS_{I|e\gamma} decreases and Sγ∣eIS_{\gamma|eI} increases. The two cross near S≈0.8S\approx0.8, but their values should not be interpreted as direct fractions of a conserved entanglement: different bipartitions contain overlapping information about the same correlations. In the intermediate region all three entropies are nonzero, giving the shaded multiparticle-entangled region. Once decay is complete, the ion factorizes in state ∣a⟩\lvert a\rangle and SI∣eγ→0S_{I|e\gamma}\to0, whereas the electron and photon retain approximately one bit of entanglement.

Figure 1(d) shows the same one-versus-rest partitions using logarithmic negativity, together with the three pairwise entanglements. While the logarithmic negativities reproduce the qualitative entanglement transfer found from the von Neumann entropy, we additionally find that EN(e∣Iγ)E_N(e|I\gamma) increases slightly above unity near the end of the pulse and remains above unity during the subsequent fluorescence. This increase arises from weak high-dimensional correlations associated with the photon-energy continuum, beyond an effective qubit description. This raises the question of why the different measures of entanglement show different sensitivity to the continuum part of the state. For the pure system the von Neumann entropy is [19]

SA∣B=−∑kλklog⁡2λk.(5)S_{A|B}=-\sum_k \lambda_k\log_2\lambda_k. \tag*{(5)}

where λk\lambda_k are eigenvalues of ρA\rho_A (or ρB\rho_B), also known as Schmidt probabilities. A similar expression for the logarithmic negativity is [20]

EN(A∣B)=2log⁡2∑kλk.(6)E_N(A|B)=2\log_2\sum_k\sqrt{\lambda_k}. \tag*{(6)}

Adding a weakly populated Schmidt mode to the NN dominant modes: λ0≪λ1,λ2,…,λN\lambda_0 \ll\lambda_1,\lambda_2,\ldots,\lambda_N, leads to an additional entanglement that scales as ΔSVN∝−λ0log⁡2λ0\Delta S_{\mathrm{VN}}\propto-\lambda_0\log_2\lambda_0 and ΔEN∝λ0\Delta E_N\propto\sqrt{\lambda_0}, respectively. Thus, it is clear that ΔSVN≪ΔEN\Delta S_{\mathrm{VN}}\ll\Delta E_N, which explains why the logarithmic negativity is more sensitive to weakly populated Schmidt modes. In our case, such additional weak modes are generated during the laser interaction due to Mollow-triplet-like dynamics [14, 27], leading to a sizeable increase in logarithmic negativity. The von Neumann entropy also includes such effects, yielding a value that is slightly larger than one, but the effect is too weak to be seen in Figure 1(c). After the laser interaction, fluorescence acts locally with respect to the e∣Iγe|I\gamma bipartition and consequently redistributes, rather than removes, the entanglement. In exact calculations this implies that the entanglement should be constant. It should be noted that the slight decrease of EN(e∣Iγ)E_N(e|I\gamma) in Figure 1(d) is due to irreversible decay to photon number two, an effect that is beyond the scope of the present work.

The pairwise negativities reveal how the entanglement is distributed between the individual particles. Initially, the pairwise entanglement is almost entirely between the electron and ion. We note that its maximal value cannot exceed one because the ion is a qubit in our model. During fluorescence, EN(e∣I)E_N(e|I) decreases while

EN(e∣γ)E_N(e|\gamma) increases, directly demonstrating transfer from the electron–ion to the electron–photon pair. At the same time, a transient EN(I∣γ)>0E_N(I|\gamma)>0 develops, showing that the emitted photon also becomes directly entangled with the ion during the transfer process. Once spontaneous decay is complete, both EN(e∣I)E_N(e|I) and EN(I∣γ)E_N(I|\gamma) vanish, while EN(e∣γ)E_N(e|\gamma) approaches the surviving one-versus-rest negativities: EN(e∣γ)≃EN(e∣Iγ)≃EN(γ∣eI)E_N(e|\gamma)\simeq E_N(e|I\gamma)\simeq E_N(\gamma|eI). The transfer therefore proceeds through a genuinely multiparticle-entangled intermediate state before reducing to an entangled electron–photon pair, ∣Ψ⟩≃∣a⟩I⊗∣Φ⟩eγ|\Psi\rangle\simeq|a\rangle_I\otimes|\Phi\rangle_{e\gamma}.

In conclusion, these results reveal the structure underlying fluorescence-mediated entanglement transfer in photoionization. Conditioning only on ionization, we find that the initially entangled electron–ion pair evolves through a genuinely multiparticle-entangled state before approaching an entangled electron–photon pair. The one-versus-rest bipartitions show how spontaneous emission redistributes entanglement within the ion–photon subsystem while preserving the electron entanglement with the combined system, whereas the pairwise logarithmic negativities resolve the transfer from electron–ion to electron–photon entanglement and reveal a transient direct entanglement between the ion and photon. Logarithmic negativity additionally exposes weak high-dimensional correlations carried by the photon-energy continuum that are suppressed in the von Neumann entropy. The resulting dynamics therefore cannot be understood as a simple transfer of a single bipartite resource, but instead proceed through a transient three-particle state in which entanglement is shared among all constituents, with additional weak high-dimensional correlations carried by the photon-energy continuum.

Acknowledgement

This work was supported by the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation: 2024.0212; and the Swedish Research Council: 2024-04247.

References

References

  1. [1]L. Banchi, T. J. G. Apollaro, A. Cuccoli, R. Vaia, and P. Verrucchi, Optimal dynamics for quantum-state and entanglement transfer through homogeneous quantum systems, Phys. Rev. A 82, 052321 (2010).DOI
  2. [2]S. B. Giddings and M. Rota, Quantum information or entanglement transfer between subsystems, Phys. Rev. A 98, 062329 (2018).DOI
  3. [3]H. Laurell et al., Continuous-variable quantum state tomography of photoelectrons, Phys. Rev. Research 4, 033220 (2022).DOI
  4. [4]S. Mehmood, E. Lindroth, and L. Argenti, Ionic coherence in resonant above-threshold attosecond ionization spectroscopy, Physical Review A 107, 033103 (2023).DOI
  5. [5]S. Nandi et al., Generation of entanglement using a short-wavelength seeded free-electron laser, Sci. Adv. 10, eado0668 (2024).DOI
  6. [6]A. Stenquist and J. M. Dahlström, Harnessing time symmetry to fundamentally alter entanglement in photoionization, Phys. Rev. Research 7, 013270 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2405.03339
  7. [7]M. J. J. Vrakking, Control of Attosecond Entanglement and Coherence, Physical Review Letters 126, 113203 (2021).DOI
  8. [8]M. J. J. Vrakking, Ion-photoelectron entanglement in photoionization with chirped laser pulses, Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 55, 134001 (2022).DOI
  9. [9]M. Ruberti, S. Patchkovskii, and V. Averbukh, Quantum coherence in molecular photoionization, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 24, 19673 (2022).DOI
  10. [10]I. Makos et al., Entanglement in photoionisation reveals the effect of ionic coupling in attosecond time delays, Nat. Commun 16, 8554 (2025).DOI
  11. [11]L.-M. Koll, A. J. Suñer-Rubio, T. Witting, R. Y. Bello, A. Palacios, F. Martín, and M. J. J. Vrakking, Entanglement and electronic coherence in attosecond molecular photoionization, Nature 652, 82 (2026).DOI
  12. [12]M. C. Tichy, F. Mintert, and A. Buchleitner, Essential entanglement for atomic and molecular physics, Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 44, 192001 (2011).DOI
  13. [13]B. R. Mollow, Pure-state analysis of resonant light scattering: Radiative damping, saturation, and multiphoton effects, Phys. Rev. A 12, 1919 (1975).DOI
  14. [14]A. Stenquist, J. N. Bruhnke, F. Zapata, and J. M. Dahlström, Entanglement transfer in a composite electron–ion–photon system, Rep. Prog. Phys. 88, 080502 (2025).DOI
  15. [15]E. Goulielmakis et al., Real-time observation of valence electron motion, Nature 466, 739 (2010).DOI
  16. [16]S. Pabst, L. Greenman, P. J. Ho, D. A. Mazziotti, and R. Santra, Decoherence in attosecond photoionization, Physical Review Letters 106, 053003 (2011).DOI
  17. [17]D. Busto et al., Probing electronic decoherence with high-resolution attosecond photoelectron interferometry, European Physical Journal D 76, 112 (2022).DOI
  18. [18]H. Laurell et al., Measuring the quantum state of photoelectrons, Nat. Photon. 19, 352 (2025).DOI
  19. [19]S. Haroche and J.-M. Raimond, Exploring the quantum: atoms, cavities and photons, Oxford graduate texts (Oxford University Press, Oxford ; New York, 2006).
  20. [20]G. Vidal and R. F. Werner, Computable measure of entanglement, Phys. Rev. A 65, 032314 (2002).DOI
  21. [21]R. Grobe and J. H. Eberly, Observation of coherence transfer by electron-electron correlation, Phys. Rev. A 48, 623 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9909636
  22. [22]B. Walker, M. Kaluža, B. Sheehy, P. Agostini, and L. F. DiMauro, Observation of Continuum-Continuum Autler-Townes Splitting, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 633 (1995).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10060075
  23. [23]S. B. Zhang and N. Rohringer, Photoemission spectroscopy with high-intensity short-wavelength lasers, Physical Review A 89, 013407 (2014).
  24. [24]C. Yu and L. B. Madsen, Core-resonant ionization of helium by intense XUV pulses: Analytical and numerical studies on channel-resolved spectral features, Phys. Rev. A 98, 033404 (2018).DOI
  25. [25]M. Huber and J. I. De Vicente, Structure of Multidimensional Entanglement in Multipartite Systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 035001 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23373906
  26. [26]G. Cobucci and A. Tavakoli, Detecting the dimensionality of genuine multipartite entanglement, Sci. Adv. 10, eadd4467 (2024).DOI
  27. [27]A. Stenquist, F. Zapata, E. Olofsson, Y. Liao, E. Sveg-bორჂorn, J. N. Bruhnke, C. Verdozzi, and J. M. Dahlström, Mollow-like Triplets in Ultrafast Resonant Absorption, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 063202 (2024).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_wxy2vhrz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents