betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Pathways to crystal chirality An algorithm to identify new displacive chiral phase transitions

Abstract

We present an algorithm that integrates pseudosymmetry search with first-principles calculations to systematically identify achiral parent structures and establish potential chiral displacive transitions linking them to their corresponding chiral phases within the 22 enantiomorphic space groups. This approach enables a robust exploration of structural relationships, offering new insights into symmetry-driven properties. Our workflow streamlines the discovery of displacive chiral phase transitions driven by soft phonon modes, providing insights into the mechanisms of structural chirality in inorganic materials. We apply this methodology on the chiral phases of TeO2_2, Na2_2SeO9_9, Sr2_2As2_2O7_7, As2_2O5_5, Rb2_2Be2_2O3_3, and CaTe2_2O3_3. Demonstrating that some do not have a minimal supergroup that allows for an achiral phase; some can have a minimal supergroup, still, no unstable phonon mode exists in the achiral phase; and somewhere the minimal supergroup exists with a soft phonon mode connecting the identified achiral phase and the chiral phase through small continuous displacements.

Introduction

Chirality in periodic solids is characterized by structures belonging to space groups that include only operations of the first kind [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], i.e., those which map a right (left)-handed coordinate system to another right (left)-handed system. This fundamental property distinguishes chiral structures from their achiral counterparts [6, 7]. The concept of chirality in crystallography extends beyond mere point group symmetry and encompasses the complete three-dimensional periodicity of the crystal lattice [8]. Chiral space groups, also known as Sohncke groups, comprise 65 of the 230 crystallographic space groups and are characterized by the absence of improper symmetry operations such as inversion centers, mirror planes, and rotoinversion axes [1, 6, 9]. This inherent asymmetry gives rise to unique physical properties in chiral materials, including optical activity [10, 11] or nonlinear optical effects [12], which have significant implications in various fields ranging from materials science to pharmaceutical research [13]. Recently, the study of chiral effects in crystals has gained considerable attention, particularly concerning phenomena such as chiral phonons [14, 15, 16, 17], which are phonons that exhibit rotational motion (clockwise or counterclockwise) that are locked with the particle’s momentum. Another area of interest is spin selectivity [18], where one spin state is favored over another when electrons pass through chiral magnetic structures. Additionally, a recent research focus is polar and magnetic skyrmions [19], topologically protected textures of spin or electric dipoles. There is a growing interest in exploring topological states, such as those associated with Kramers–Weyl fermions [20], alongside the emerging field of altermagnetism [21, 22].

Chiral crystal structures, characterized by the absence of inversion symmetry and mirror planes, are particularly promising in this context. These unique structures can give rise to distinctive magnetic properties, positioning them as natural candidates for altermagnetic phenomena [21] while also profoundly influencing the electronic structure and band dispersion [23].

Theoretically, irreducible representations (irreps) that satisfy the group theoretical conditions for chiral objects formally exist [24], as these irreps inherently possess characteristics that align with the symmetry requirements for chirality. This implies that symmetry-based frameworks can differentiate between chiral and achiral states. Consequently, phase transitions involving spontaneous symmetry breaking, characterized by an order parameter that distinguishes between chiral and achiral phases, also exist and should be observed in nature, as the order parameter is a physical quantity that changes during the transition, reflecting the emergence of chirality [3]. The crystallization process within a chiral symmetry group plays a decisive role in determining the material’s chirality and its associated properties, making it a crucial area of investigation [25, 26, 27]. Therefore, understanding such structural phase transitions from an achiral to a chiral phase is essential for identifying the material’s final symmetry and its electronic, magnetic, and optical properties [28].

A fascinating case occurs when such transition is driven by an unstable phonon mode that transitions from an achiral to a chiral phase, as recently proposed for K3NiO2\mathrm{K}_3\mathrm{NiO}_2 [29]. In this case, the phase transition is displacive or order-disorder (i.e., not reconstructive), and a group-supergroup relation between the two phases exists, which also means it preserves the internal connectivity and does not break any bonds [30]. However, despite significant theoretical and experimental efforts in this field, only a very few number of candidate materials exhibiting transitions between chiral and achiral phases have been identified to date [3]: MgTi2_2O4_4 [31, 32], K3_3NiO2_2 [29], CsCuCl2_2 [33], Na2_2Ca2_2(SiO3_3)3_3 [34, 35, 36] or Ag4_4P2_2O7_7 [37]. Although Pb5_5Ge3_3O11_{11} has also been reported to exhibit an achiral-to-chiral phase transition through a polar soft mode [38], it is excluded from the present discussion as we focus specifically on the 22 enantiomorphic crystal space groups.

Therefore, several fundamental questions arise: Are there intrinsic physical or chemical barriers inhibiting the existence of such phase transitions naturally occurring in nature, or have they been overlooked due to limitations in our search methodologies [39, 40]? Could a more meticulous and systematic exploration of diverse crystal structures leverage advanced computational screening techniques [41, 42] uncover additional candidates for chiral phase transitions? Do we possess the appropriate theoretical frameworks and experimental techniques to effectively investigate and characterize these potential transitions? The answers to these questions could significantly impact our understanding of chirality in condensed matter systems and potentially lead to the discovery of novel materials with unique properties [28].

In this study, we propose a systematic methodology for identifying achiral parent structures from known chiral crystalline phases belonging to the 22 enantiomorphic space groups and capable of exhibiting displacive phase transitions. We employ both rigorous symmetry analysis and first-principles calculations. For simplicity and clarity, we restrict our focus to non-magnetic crystals displaying chiral enantiomorphic space groups as magnetic chirality can be at play as well [3]. We use group-theoretical approaches to derive the parent structure from the atomic positions of the low-symmetry chiral phase. While illustrated here on a proof-of-concept set of six compounds, the methodology is well suited for future high-throughput implementation, offering the potential to uncover novel candidates for chiral transitions. Once the parent achiral structure has been identified relying on symmetry arguments, subsequent density functional theory (DFT) calculations are conducted to compute phonon instabilities and check the existence of soft modes connecting the achiral reference and the chiral structures. By presenting this framework, we aim to stimulate the scientific community to identify and investigate novel materials exhibiting chiral transitions. This could potentially lead to discoveries with implications for applications such as optoelectronics, spintronics, and nonlinear optics.

The article is organized as follows: First, we will present the systematic procedure to obtain high-symmetry parent structures belonging to achiral space groups for a given low-symmetry chiral phase. In the following sections, we will apply this technique to some candidates within the 22 enantiomorphic space groups. Our methodology helps identify crystals that can exhibit displacive chiral phase transitions from the combination of symmetry and first-principles analysis.

Results

Finding an achiral reference for a given chiral crystal

In this section, we will outline the necessary steps to obtain an achiral reference structure starting from the atomic positions of a low-symmetry chiral crystal. We will restrict ourselves to crystals from the 22 enantiomorphic space groups, but the methodology could be applied to all Sohncke groups. To this end, we will conduct a symmetry analysis following the successful methodology already employed in the determination of new displacive ferroelectric materials [43, 44, 45] or high-temperature structural transitions of PnnmPnnm or P212121P2_12_12_1 symmetries [46, 47]. This method acts as a screening test; if no candidate structures are found, we can confirm that the crystal in question cannot be connected to an achiral reference through phonon distortions. However, if candidate structures are identified, further first-principles stability calculations and phonon analysis must be performed to confirm the presence of an unstable chiral phonon that can lower the energy of the achiral phase to the chiral one.

Suppose we have a chiral crystal belonging to a particular group G\mathcal{G} occupying the atomic positions rir_i. If we require this material to show a displacive phase transition from a higher symmetry achiral reference, then the atomic positions need to comply

ri=ri0+ui,(1)r_i = r_i^0 + u_i, \tag*{(1)}

where ri0r_i^0 are the positions of the atoms in the parent structure belonging to a higher symmetry achiral space group H\mathcal{H}, and uiu_i are the set of individual atomic displacements that drive the displacive phase transition. Moreover, the enantiomorphic spacegroup G~\widetilde{\mathcal{G}} would present a similar relation r~i=ri0+u~i\widetilde{r}_i = r_i^0 + \widetilde{u}_i where uiu_i and u~i\widetilde{u}_i are related by an improper rotation.

In this context, the original structure exhibits pseudosymmetry, denoted as H\mathcal{H} [48]. The atomic positions, ri0r_i^0, may correspond to the high-symmetry, high-temperature phase within the phase diagram, which, in our case, serves as the achiral reference structure. Therefore, finding crystalline structures belonging to supergroups H\mathcal{H} complying with the restrictions imposed by Eq. (1) can give candidates for displacive phase transitions towards the low-symmetry phase under consideration. Indeed, such methodology has proven effective in predicting displacive ferroelectric phase transitions [43, 44, 45] or high-temperature structural transitions [46, 47].

However, searching among all the possible supergroups H\mathcal{H} of a given spacegroup G\mathcal{G} is unnecessary. A better strategy is to start screening among the minimal supergroups of G\mathcal{G}. Indeed any group-supergroup relation (G<H\mathcal{G} < \mathcal{H}) can be decomposed by a chain of minimal supergroups G<K1<K2...<H\mathcal{G} < \mathcal{K}_1 < \mathcal{K}_2... < \mathcal{H} [49]. Therefore, finding no candidates among the minimal supergroups of G\mathcal{G} guarantees the absence of displacive phase transitions for the given crystalline structure. Conversely, if candidates are identified using the minimal supergroup approach, further searches can be conducted following the same strategy.

The search of minimal supergroups of G\mathcal{G} conveying with Eq. (1) can be done with the tool Pseudosymmetry search [50] of the Bilbao Crystallographic server [51, 52] which not only accounts for the symmetry of the initial subgroup but also takes into account the information of the Wyckoff positions occupied by the crystal to provide a list of consistent candidates. First, the determination of all minimal supergroups of a given space group can be performed by inverting the data on the maximal subgroups of space groups available in volume A1 (Symmetry Relations Between Space Groups) of the International Tables for Crystallography [53]. Then, splitting the Wyckoff positions is considered an increase of site-symmetry may cause atoms belonging to distinct special positions in the subgroup to become equivalent in the higher-symmetry supergroup [54]. Hence, we can apply this method to the chiral crystals reported in the International Crystal Structure Database (ICSD) [55] to find novel structures displaying displacive chiral phase transitions.

Once the parent achiral reference has been determined, subsequent DFT calculations are required to complement the symmetry analysis. First, a relaxation of the atomic structure ri0r_i^0 is performed, followed by a phonon calculation to identify a potentially unstable phonon. These phonon modes are then analyzed to determine whether any of the instabilities could drive a transition to a chiral phase. Finally, the eigendisplacements associated with the unstable modes are condensed in the direction of the chiral phase to confirm the connection with the structure reported in the databases.

We summarize the methodology workflow algorithm in Figure 1. As previously mentioned, we start with the atomic positions of the chiral phase and perform a pseudosymmetry search to identify potential achiral reference structures. The algorithm terminates if no compatible achiral reference structure is found, as a phase transition would be impossible. However, we proceed with DFT relaxations if an achiral reference is identified. Symmetry-adapted mode (SAM) analysis follows this step to identify at which special kk-points an irrep can drive the high-symmetry structure to the low-symmetry chiral structure. Hence, only phonon calculations at those special kk-points should be done, which helps to save computational time by avoiding doing the full phonon dispersion curve. A phonon calculation is then conducted at those kk-points where we know that an irrep can give the achiral to chiral phase transition if phonon mode instability with this irrep is present. If no instabilities are detected, the algorithm stops; if instabilities are present, the algorithm condenses these modes to determine whether any lead to the chiral phase. If successful, the material is added to the list of candidates for displacive chiral transitions, completing the process.

Figure 1. Algorithmic view of the methodology described in the article to search for new displacive chiral phase transitions.

The case of TeO2_2

In this section, we apply our methodology to the interesting case of TeO2_2 crystal. Among the three commonly reported polymorphs at ambient conditions [56, 57], this material has an enantiomorphic low-symmetry phase of either P41212P4_12_12 or P43212P4_32_12 space groups. To our knowledge, no parent structure has yet been reported for this compound at the bulk level. Still, a rutile P42/mnmP4_2/mnm high symmetry phase has been reported recently when grown epitaxially on FeTe substrate [58]. Our pseudosymmetry search predicts that the high symmetry P42/mnmP4_2/mnm achiral structure can be linked to the chiral low-symmetry P41212P4_12_12 (space group number 92) and P43212P4_32_12 (space group number 96) phases through the Z3Z_3 irrep from the zone boundary ZZ point, similarly to the case of K3_3NiO2_2[29]. The calculated structural data of the converged P42/mnmP4_2/mnm structure computed with a kk-mesh of 10×10×1010 \times10 \times10 can be found in the appendix.

We can therefore study from DFT calculations whether a soft phonon mode is present at the ZZ point of the P42/mnmP4_2/mnm achiral phase of TeO2_2. As shown in Figure 2(b), a double degenerate unstable phonon mode is encountered at ZZ, showing a frequency of 370i370i cm−1^{-1}. The symmetry of this unstable mode corresponds to the irrep Z3Z_3, which is the right one to link the high-symmetry rutile phase and the low-symmetry chiral phases. Due to the double degeneracy of the Z3Z_3 mode, different linear combinations (a,b)(a,b) can be constructed. Diagonal distortions (a,a)/(−a,−a)(a,a)/(-a,-a) and (a,−a)/(−a,a)(a,-a)/(-a,a) domains are associated to the P41212P4_12_12 and P43212P4_32_12 space groups respectively. Similarly to the case of K3_3NiO2_2, non-diagonal distortions (a,b)(a,b) drives the system to a C2221C222_1 phase whenever a≠0a \ne0 and b≠0b \ne0 whereas CmcmCmcm phases are encountered when a=0a=0 or b=0b=0. The condensation of the Z3Z_3 unstable mode eigenvector give an energy gain of ΔE=−0.127\Delta E=-0.127 eV per atom for the (a,a)(a,a) phase as shown in Figure 2(c).

Schematic representation of the TeO$_2$ crystal structure, phonon band structure, and energy surface

Figure 2. (a) Schematic representation of the TeO2_2 crystal structure where atoms occupy the P42/mnmP4_2/mnm high symmetry positions. Arrows indicate the direction of the atom displacements that bring the system to the P41212P4_12_12 chiral phase. Gold and red balls represent Te and O atoms, respectively. (b) Calculated phonon band structure along the Γ−Z\Gamma- Z path of the high symmetry phase of TeO2_2. The color of the different branches are weighted according to the contribution of each chemical species to the dynamical matrix eigenvector (red for the O atom, and blue for the Te atom). (c) Energy surface when we condense the Z3Z_3 unstable mode along the (a,a)(a,a) directions in normalized units.

We also obtained that the (a,b)(a,b) case has the same energy gain as the (a,a)(a,a) case, so we can conclude that the case a≠ba \ne b does not give a local minimum. The (a,0)(a,0) case shows a higher energy (ΔE=0.06\Delta E=0.06 eV) than the (a,a)(a,a) case such that we can conclude that, through the Z3Z_3 irrep, the chiral (a,a)(a,a) domains are those giving the lowest energy.

A SAM analysis of our relaxed chiral phase reveals that the distortion for the P42/mnmP4_2/mnm phase decomposes into Z3Z_3 and Γ1\Gamma_1 irreps where the amplitude of the Γ1\Gamma_1 mode (0.004 Å per ion) is two orders of magnitude smaller than that of the Z3Z_3 mode (0.093 Å per ion). The Γ1\Gamma_1 mode is a secondary SAM that appears through invariant coupling with the Z3Z_3 unstable mode as this mode is not unstable at the zone center.

The Z3Z_3 mode induces a slight in-plane displacements of the Te atoms, as well as both out-of-plane and in-plane displacements of the O atoms. However, the in-plane component of the O displacement is smaller than the out-of-plane one. As shown in the weighted phonon band structure of Figure 2(b) and the magnitude of the arrows in Figure 2(a) the distortion is mostly dominated by the O movements. Similarly to K3_3NiO2_2, the associated distortions produce a helical structure as shown in Figure 2(a). In Figure 2(a), we show a schematic representation of the TeO2_2 crystal and its chiral Z3Z_3 (a,a)(a,a) distortion. Atomic positions correspond to the high-symmetry P42/mnmP4_2/mnm phase, and the arrows indicate how the atoms move when transitioning from the achiral rutile phase to the chiral P41212P4_1 2_1 2 phase. The handedness of the chiral phase has been computed following the helicity method described in Ref. [59, 60]. This helicity is well-defined within the context of displacive phase transitions, allowing for a reference-independent comparison between different compounds. By normalizing its value to the number of atoms in the unit cell, the reference becomes intrinsically determined by the physical nature of the transition. For TeO2_2 a value of 7.38⋅10−37.38 \cdot10^{-3} is found, which is similar to the one found in K3_3NiO2_2 (7.75⋅10−37.75 \cdot10^{-3}) for a similar type of transition.

Interestingly, an analysis of the band structure and electronic density of states (see Figure 3) reveals that a significant change in the electronic structure also accompanies the structural phase transition. Indeed, the electronic band gap is substantially increased from a value of only 0.110.11 eV in the high symmetry phase to a value of 1.931.93 eV in the chiral structure contrary to the case of K3_3NiO2_2 where the band gap is essentially unaffected by the chiral transition [29]. Therefore, inducing a chiral transition in this material would also tune its band gap by one order of magnitude, which might be interesting for applications. Clearly, this behavior is material dependent and cannot be extrapolated to other compounds emphasizing the need to evaluate these properties on a case-by-case basis.

Calculated projected electronic density of states of the TeO$_2$ crystal in the high symmetry achiral rutile phase and in the low symmetry chiral phase

Figure 3. Calculated projected electronic density of states (DOS) of the TeO2_2 crystal (a) in the high symmetry achiral rutile phase and (b) in the low symmetry chiral phase.

This example illustrates how our methodology provides a clear pathway for identifying potential candidates for chiral displacive transitions in the case of TeO2_2 crystal. We will now apply this approach to other types of compounds.

The case of Sr2_2As2_2O7_7

Here, we shall present another example of chiral phase transition predicted with the pseudosymmetry search algorithm. The Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 compound exhibits experimentally a low symmetry phase of either P41P4_1 or P43P4_3 chiral space groups [61, 62]. We could identify an achiral parent structure of P42P4_2 symmetry by applying the pseudosymmetry search algorithm. We have relaxed this new parent structure with a kk-mesh of 4×4×24 \times4 \times2 and the obtained structural parameters can be found in the appendix.

As in the previous case, a symmetry analysis of the supergroup-subgroup relationship reveals that this parent structure can be connected to the enantiomorphic space groups P41P4_1 and P43P4_3 through two different irreps at the ZZ point. Indeed a SAM analysis gives Z3Z_3 (with an amplitude of 0.0540.054 Å per ion) and Γ1\Gamma_1 (with an amplitude of 0.0160.016 Å per ion) for the P41P4_1 space group and Z4Z_4 and Γ1\Gamma_1 for the P43P4_3 space group but with the same SAM amplitudes as Z3Z_3 and Γ1\Gamma_1 in the P41P4_1 case. As for TeO2_2, the Γ1\Gamma_1 mode appears to be secondary while the Z3Z_3 and Z4Z_4 are the primary main modes. Unlike K3_3NiO2_2 and TeO2_2, where the transition to chiral enantiomorphic phases is driven by the same irreducible representation (irrep), the two chiral space groups in this case are associated with two distinct irreps. Our phonon calculations in the P42P4_2 achiral reference of Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 are consistent with these results as two unstable modes are found, one with an imaginary frequency of −503i-503i cm−1^{-1} and the Z3Z_3 label and the other one with an imaginary frequency of −501i-501i cm−1^{-1} and the Z4Z_4 label as shown in Figure 4. These two modes of different symmetry have the same frequency, and condensing their respective eigenvectors and relaxing the structure gives the same gain of energy (ΔE=−0.18\Delta E = -0.18 eV per atom), as we would expect for two pairs of enantiomorphic crystals. The substantial unstable frequencies and significant energy gain suggest that achieving experimental stability for the achiral parent structure may be challenging. However, these findings could motivate further experimental efforts to enhance the stability of this phase, potentially through the application of tensile strain or by optimizing growth conditions, as was successfully demonstrated for TeO2_2 [58].

Schematic representation of the Sr$_2$As$_2$O$_7$ crystal structure, calculated phonon band structure, and energy surface

Figure 4. (a) Schematic representation of the Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 crystal structure where atoms occupy the P42P4_2 high symmetry positions. Arrows indicate the direction of the atom displacements that bring the system to the P43P4_3 chiral phase. Green, yellow, and red balls represent Sr, As, and O atoms, respectively. (b) Calculated phonon band structure along the Γ−Z\Gamma- Z path of the high symmetry phase of Sr2_2As2_2O7_7. The color of the different branches are weighted according to the contribution of each chemical species to the dynamical matrix eigenvector (red for the O atom, green for the Sr and blue for the As atoms). (c) Energy surface when we condense the Z4Z_4 unstable mode in normalized units.

The Z3Z_3 and Z4Z_4 modes involve mainly the layer-by-layer nonpolar in-plane and the polar out-of-plane movement of the atoms. In contrast, the Γ1\Gamma_1 involves mainly the atoms’ polar in-plane and nonpolar out-of-plane movement. The composition of these movements generates a helical structure as shown in Figure 4. By probing the helicity amplitude of the structure [59], we found a value of 0.81⋅10−30.81 \cdot10^{-3}, with, as we would expect, a simple sign change between the P41P4_1 and P43P4_3 phases.

A study of the electronic band structure reveals a substantial band gap increase accompanying the transition, similar to the case of TeO2_2. The band gap is 0.950.95 eV in the high-symmetry phase and 3.033.03 eV in the low-symmetry phase.

This new example is interesting because it shows that our methodology can find displacive chiral phase transitions in which two different phonon modes are responsible for the two enantiomorphic space groups. In the limit of our knowledge, such a possibility has not been previously discussed in the literature.

The case of Na2_2SeO9_9

We shall now discuss the case of Na2_2SeO9_9. This material is only reported in the Materials Project and with the P4122P4_122 and P4322P4_322 pair of enantiomorphic space groups [63]. While no experimental report exists for this crystal, DFT calculations predict it to be stable. Given the scarcity of reported crystals within the enantiomorphic space groups, we can use it as a new test case for our search method for displacive chiral phase transition.

After applying the pseudosymmetry search and relaxing the structures with a kk-mesh sampling of 4×4×44 \times4 \times4, we obtain a high symmetry parent structure with the space group P42/mmcP4_2/mmc and with structural data reported in the appendix, that can be connected to the enantiomorphic space groups by phonon modes at the ZZ point.

By performing the phonon calculations at the ZZ-point, we found several unstable modes, as shown in Figure 5. The irreps of the two most unstable modes are Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2, which gives a nonchiral phase transition to space group PmmmPmmm and PccmPccm respectively, with a degenerate frequency of −237 cm−1-237\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}. The third and fourth modes correspond to the Z3Z_3 and Z4Z_4 irreps, which are also degenerate and drive a chiral phase transition showing the same frequency of −217 cm−1-217\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} and similar symmetry. In contrast to TeO2_2 or K3_3NiO2_2, diagonal distortion domains (a,a)(a,a) or (−a,−a)(-a,-a) in this system lead to a PmmaPmma achiral space group symmetry, whereas distortions along (a,0)(a,0) or (0,a)(0,a) drive the chiral transition towards the P4122P4_122 and P4322P4_322 space groups, respectively.

Schematic representation of the Na₂SeO₉ crystal structure, calculated phonon band structure, and energy surface

Figure 5. (a) Schematic representation of the Na₂SeO₉ crystal structure where atoms occupy the high symmetry positions (P42/mmcP4_{2}/mmc space group). Arrows indicate the direction of the atom displacements that bring the system to the P4322P4_{3}22 chiral phase. Gold, green, and red balls represent Na, Se, and O atoms. (b) Calculated phonon band structure along the Γ−Z\Gamma- Z path of the high symmetry phase of Na₂SeO₉. The color of the different branches are weighted according to the contribution of each chemical species to the dynamical matrix eigenvector (red for the O atom, green for the Na and blue for the Se atoms). (c) Energy surface when we condense the Z3Z_{3} unstable mode in normalized units.

Upon relaxing the previous unstable modes, we observe that, despite exhibiting the highest instability, the Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 modes do not lead to the most stable phase, as they provide an energy gain of ΔE1=−0.007 eV\Delta E_1 = -0.007\ \mathrm{eV} per atom versus ΔE2=−0.45 eV\Delta E_2 = -0.45\ \mathrm{eV} per atom for the Z3Z_3 and Z4Z_4 modes in the chiral phase. A SAM decomposition of the relaxed Z3Z_3 mode in (0,a)(0,a) domain gives Γ1\Gamma_1 (with amplitude 0.150.15Å per ion) and Z3Z_3 (with amplitude 0.300.30Å per ion). The relaxation of the Z3Z_3 and Z4Z_4 modes along the diagonal domains (a,a)(a,a) or (−a,−a)(-a,-a) with the achiral PmmaPmma phase gives an energy gain of E3=−0.18E_3 = -0.18 eV per atom, which is larger than the relaxation coming from the Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 modes but lower than the chiral phase. Hence, Na2_2SeO9_9 has the potential to exhibit a displacive chiral phase transition.

Computing the handedness of the chiral structure, we obtain a value of 2.70⋅10−22.70 \cdot10^{-2}. This significant handedness, compared to that of TeO2_2 or K3_3NiO2_2, is explained by the increased magnitude of the distortion, which is three times larger. The magnitude of the handedness amplitude is quadratic concerning the chiral distortion amplitude [59], which explains the large helicity value obtained for Na₂SeO₉. In Figure 5, we give a schematic representation of the crystal helical distortion from the P42/mmcP4_{2}/mmc phase towards the P4322P4_{3}22 phase.

Lastly, regarding the band structure, the electronic band gap is reduced from 0.61 eV in the high symmetry phase to gap closure in the chiral phase. This contrasts the previous three examples, where the chiral distortion strongly increased the band gap.

Other materials showing no displacive chiral transitions

This last section will discuss additional crystal structures for which either no candidates for parent structures were found using a pseudosymmetry search approach or no unstable phonon modes driving the chiral transition could be identified.

First, let us consider the case of As₂O₅. The reported low symmetry chiral phase corresponds to a P41212P4_{1}2_{1}2 or P43212P4_{3}2_{1}2 space group [64], and we found a parent phase of symmetry P42/mnmP4_{2}/mnm following a pseudosymmetry search approach. From symmetry considerations, we found that

the irrep that can connect with the chiral phase should be observed at the ZZ point. However, unlike previous cases, no unstable mode is found when we compute the phonons at the ZZ point as it is shown in Figure 6. This suggests that displacive chiral phase transitions in this system are not physically present, at least at the bulk level.

Calculated phonon band structure of As₂O₅

Figure 6. Calculated phonon band structure along the Γ−Z\Gamma- Z path of the high symmetry phase of As₂O₅. The color of the different branches are weighted according to the contribution of each chemical species to the dynamical matrix eigenvector (red for the O atom, and blue for the As atoms).

CompoundChiral groupAchiralRef.Irrepν\nu (cm−1^{-1})EE (eV/atom)H\mathcal{H}
TeO2_2P41212P4_12_12P42/mnmP4_2/mnmZ4Z_4 (a,aa,a)-370-0.137.38⋅10−37.38 \cdot10^{-3}
P43212P4_32_12Z4Z_4 (a,−aa,-a)
Sr2_2As2_2O7_7P41P4_1P42P4_2Z3Z_3 (aa)-503
P43P4_3Z4Z_4 (aa)-501-0.180.81⋅10−30.81 \cdot10^{-3}
Na2_2SeO9_9P4122P4_122P42/mmcP4_2/mmcZ3Z_3 (a,0a,0)-217-0.452.70⋅10−22.70 \cdot10^{-2}
P4322P4_322Z3Z_3 (0,a0,a)
As2_2O5_5P41212P4_12_12P42/mnmP4_2/mnmZ4Z_4 (a,aa,a)%%%
P43212P4_32_12Z3Z_3 (a,aa,a)
Rb2_2Be2_2O3_3P41212P4_12_12%%%%%
P43212P4_32_12
CaTe2_2O3_3P41212P4_12_12%%%%%
P43212P4_32_12

Table 1. Summary table collecting chiral space groups, achiral parent structures found with pseudosymmetry, irreps, and corresponding domains driving the phase transition, frequency of the instabilities, energy gains and helicity. The % sign indicates that either no parent phase was found or no soft phonon modes driving the transition were identified. Energy differences between high-symmetry and chiral phases after relaxation of the eigendisplacements are given per atom.

Another reason a material may not exhibit a displacive chiral phase transition is because it is impossible to identify any achiral parent structures through a pseudosymmetry search. We found that this is the case for the Rb2_2Be2_2O3_3 compound that presents P41212P4_12_12 or P43212P4_32_12 low-symmetry chiral phases [65] or CaTeO3_3 that shows P41P4_1 or P43P4_3 chiral space groups [66]. In this second situation, we have a clear symmetry demonstration that no achiral phase can be built from the chiral one.

Discussion

In this work, we have proposed a method combining pseudosymmetry search and first-principles calculations to identify achiral parent structures from known chiral phases connected through a soft phonon mode as present in displacive phase transitions. Our methodology, schematized in Figure 1, helps discover new candidates for such phase transitions and disregards those where such a transition is impossible. In Table I, we summarize the different cases where we have applied our methodology collecting the most important results of the study. The methodology helps to identify whether a soft phonon mode with the right symmetry can connect the achiral and chiral phases through continuous and relatively small displacements, e.g., TeO2_2, Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 or Na2_2SeO9_9. It also helps to disregard the cases where the pseudosymmetry would predict a possible achiral-to-chiral connection according to the symmetry. Still, no unstable mode is observed in the achiral phase from the DFT calculation, so it is physically improbable that a displacive phase transition exists, e.g., in the case of As2_2O5_5. Although, other mechanisms not captured by the present workflow, such as electronic instabilities like the Jahn-

Teller one, could also potentially lead to chiral phase transitions [31]. Finally, it also helps to quickly show that no achiral phase can be constructed from the pseudosymmetry approach, which guarantees the absence of any smooth achiral to chiral transition as no high symmetry phase can be constructed, e.g., the cases of CaTeO3_3 and Rb2_2Be2_2O3_3. We could identify three new possible candidates (TeO2_2, Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 or Na2_2SeO9_9) that can have a soft phonon mode connecting the achiral and the chiral phase. This suggests that many more materials may display this behavior beyond the few examples reported in the literature so far. Interestingly, Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 appears to belong to a new class of systems where different irreps govern the chiral transitions to each of the enantiomorphic space groups. This discovery underscores the potential of our algorithm to reveal novel and intriguing chiral transitions. Further theoretical investigations would be valuable to determine whether similar behavior exists in other compounds, and to explore the possibility of additional new mechanisms for chiral transitions, thus opening exciting avenues for future research.

Our methodology provides a systematic and accurate way to screen various materials to search for new candidates for displacive chiral phase transitions. As only one soft-mode driven chiral transition has been reported within the 22 enantiomorphic space groups, this methodology is well-suited to be implemented on a high-throughput scheme and check whether the lack of reported structures is due to an overlooked problem or if it is related to some chemical or physical reason [3]. We hope this work will inspire the community to explore new soft-mode-driven chiral phase transitions together with the non-linear phononics ones [16] and to motivate experimentalists to check our predictions.

Methods

Computational details

For all the calculations we converged the structural data of the parent structure with the Abinit code [67] (version 9.10.5) with a PBEsol exchange-correlation functional, following a plane wave-pseudopotential approach with optimized norm-conserving pseudopotentials as taken from the PseudoDojo server v4 [68, 69] and an energy cutoff of 40 Hartrees. Details about the kk-mesh sampling employed specifically for each compound will be given for each case in respective sections. A value of 10−610^{-6} Har/Bohr was employed on the forces to stop the structural relaxations and a value of 10−710^{-7} Ha was used for the electronic residual self-consistent cycle stop. Phonon instabilities and Born effective charges were computed within the density functional perturbation theory framework as implemented in abinit [67, 70].

Data Availability

All data regarding the structural properties of the high symmetry and low symmetry phases are provided in the appendix and in the dedicated supplementary file in plain text format.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge helpful discussions with Luis Elcoro, administrator of the Bilbao Crystallographic Server. F.G.O. acknowledges financial support from MSCA-PF 101148906 funded by the European Union and the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique (FNRS) through the FNRS-CR 1.B.227.25F grant. F.G.-O. and E.B. acknowledge the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique (FNRS) for financial support, the PDR project CHRYSALID No.40003544 and the Consortium des Equipements de Calcul Intensif (CECI), funded by the F.R.S.-FNRS under Grant No. 2.5020.11 and the Tier-1 Lucia supercomputer of the Walloon Region, infrastructure financed by the Walloon Region under the grant agreement No. 1910247. F.G.-O. and E. B. also acknowledge support from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under Grant Agreement No. 964931 (TSAR). We also thank the Pittsburgh Supercomputer Center (Bridges2) and San Diego Supercomputer Center (Expanse) through allocation DMR140031 from the Advanced Cyberinfrastructure Coordination Ecosystem: Services & Support (ACCESS) program, which National Science Foundation supports grants #2138259, #2138286, #2138307, #2137603, and #2138296. We also recognize the computational resources provided by the WVU Research Computing Dolly Sods HPC cluster, which is funded in part by NSF OAC-2117575. We also recognize the support of the West Virginia High Education Policy Commission under the call Research Challenge Grand Program 2022, Award RCG 23-007 and NASA EPSCoR Award 80NSSC22M0173

Structural data

In this appendix we report the structural data of the high-symmetry phases encountered for the TeO2_2, Na2_2SeO9_9 and Sr2_2As2_2O7_7 crystals together with their associated displacements towards their respective chiral phases as reported in the main text.

Atomxyzδx\delta_xδy\delta_yδz\delta_z
Te0.00000.00000.0000-0.0204-0.02040.0000
Te0.50000.50000.50000.0204-0.02040.0000
O0.69760.30240.0000-0.0417-0.03720.0419
O0.30240.69760.0000-0.0372-0.0417-0.0419
O0.80240.80240.50000.0417-0.0372-0.0419
O0.19760.19760.50000.0372-0.04170.0419

Table II. Structural data in reduced coordinates for the high symmetry parent phase of TeO2_2 found with the pseudosymmetry search algorithm and after DFT relaxation. Unit cell parameters for the tetragonal structure are a=b=5.060a=b=5.060Å, c=3.401c=3.401Å. Forces and stresses where converged up to 10−610^{-6} Har/Bohr (5.14⋅10−55.14\cdot10^{-5} eV/Å). The last three columns represent the unrelaxed eigenvector displacements following the Z3Z_3 mode towards space group number 92 (P41212P4_12_12) in the home unit cell.

AtomWyckoffxyzδx\delta_xδy\delta_yδz\delta_z
Na4b0.50000.50000.00000.00000.14470.0000
Na4a0.00000.50000.50000.0000-0.03220.0000
Se4b0.50000.00000.00000.00000.04740.0000
O4c0.50000.50000.62500.07490.07490.0000
O8d0.00000.17530.2500-0.10750.05970.0109
O8d0.00000.50000.1471-0.0814-0.0164-0.0206
O8d0.28080.14480.5000-0.0416-0.2538-0.0589
O8d0.28080.14480.00000.1342-0.1193-0.0131

Table III. Structural data in reduced coordinates for the high symmetry parent phase of Na2_2SeO9_9 found with the pseudosymmetry search algorithm and after relaxation in the low symmetry basis. Unit cell parameters for the tetragonal structure are a=b=7.755a=b=7.755Å, c=16.079c=16.079Å. Forces and stresses where converged up to 10−610^{-6} Har/Bohr (5.14⋅10−55.14\cdot10^{-5} eV/Å). The last three columns represent the displacement following the chiral mode towards space group 95 (P4322P4_32_2).

AtomWyckoffxyzδx\delta_xδy\delta_yδz\delta_z
Sr4a0.23660.86260.1870-0.01540.0674-0.0019
Sr4a0.76340.13740.18700.03310.0558-0.0008
Sr4a0.50000.00000.33270.10170.0745-0.0057
Sr4a0.50000.50000.3388-0.06980.05360.0008
As4a0.40960.74310.46790.03660.0222-0.0139
As4a0.59040.25700.46790.0314-0.00230.0135
As4a0.22590.96720.05950.00810.01840.0029
As4a0.77410.03280.0595-0.0250-0.00250.0027
O4a0.32090.58860.2583-0.00010.0068-0.0073
O4a0.67910.41140.25830.02810.02380.0144
O4a0.50840.76650.40520.05660.0528-0.0101
O4a0.49160.23350.40520.04240.04770.0076
O4a0.31230.95830.48400.0032-0.0029-0.0029
O4a0.68770.04180.4840-0.0029-0.03570.0019
O4a0.50000.00000.22970.0529-0.0040-0.0130
O4a0.00000.50000.33430.08230.1301-0.0057
O4a0.00000.00000.01870.01060.0772-0.0015
O4a0.23550.72810.0678-0.00060.0011-0.0172
O4a0.76450.27200.06780.0083-0.01170.0154
O4a0.22240.59930.44990.0806-0.0185-0.0046
O4a0.77760.40070.44990.0528-0.00820.0181
O4a0.00000.00000.11820.0343-0.06650.0073

Table 4. Structural data in reduced coordinates for the high symmetry parent phase of Sr2As2O7\mathrm{Sr}_2\mathrm{As}_2\mathrm{O}_7 found with the pseudosymmetry search algorithm after relaxation expressed in the low symmetry basis. Unit cell parameters are a=b=7.098a=b=7.098 Å, c=24.805c=24.805 Å. Forces and stresses where converged up to 10−610^{-6} Ha/Bohr (5.14⋅10−55.14\cdot10^{-5} eV/Å). The last three columns represent the unrelaxed eigenvector displacements following the Z4Z_4 mode towards space group number 78 (P43P4_3).

References

References

  1. [1]M. Nespolo, M. I. Aroyo, and B. Souvignier, Crystallographic shelves: space-group hierarchy explained, Journal of Applied Crystallography 51, 1481 (2018).DOI
  2. [2]Souvignier, B. (2003). Enantiomorphism of crystallographic groups in higher dimensions with results in dimensions up to 6. Acta Crystallographica Section A: Foundations of Crystallography, 59, 210.
  3. [3]Bousquet, E., Fava, M., Romestan, Z., Gómez-Ortiz, F., McCabe, E. E., & Romero, A. H. (2025). Structural chirality and related properties in periodic inorganic solids: review and perspectives. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 37, 163004.
  4. [4]G. H. Fecher, J. Kübler, and C. Felser, Chirality in the solid state: Chiral crystal structures in chiral and achiral space groups, Materials 15, 10.3390/ma15175812 (2022).DOI
  5. [5]D. Avnir, Chiral minerals, Minerals 14, 10.3390/min14100995 (2024).DOI
  6. [6]Sohncke, L. (1879). Entwickelung einer Theorie der Krystallstruktur. In BG Teubner.
  7. [7]Le Guennec, P. (1998). On the concept of chirality. Journal of Mathematical Chemistry, 23, 429.
  8. [8]Flack, H., & Bernardinelli, G. (1999). Absolute structure and absolute configuration. Acta Crystallographica Section A: Foundations of Crystallography, 55, 908.
  9. [9]Flack, H. D. (2003). Chiral and achiral crystal structures. Helvetica Chimica Acta, 86, 905.
  10. [10]Arago, F. (1811). Mémoire sur la polarisation colorée. In Œuvres complètes de François Arago.
  11. [11]Pasteur, L. (1848). Sur les relations qui peuvent exister entre la forme crystalline, la composition chimique et le sens de la polarization rotatoire. Annales Chimie Phys., 24, 442.
  12. [12]Verbiest, T., Elshocht, S. V., Kauranen, M., Hellemans, L., Snauwaert, J., Nuckolls, C., Katz, T. J., & Persoons, A. (1998). Strong enhancement of nonlinear optical properties through supramolecular chirality. Science, 282, 913.
  13. [13]Barron, L. D., Hecht, L., McColl, I. H., & Blanch, E. W. (2004). Raman optical activity comes of age. Molecular Physics, 102, 731.
  14. [14]L. Zhang and Q. Niu, Chiral phonons at high-symmetry points in monolayer hexagonal lattices, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 115502 (2015).DOI
  15. [15]H. Zhu, J. Yi, M.-Y. Li, J. Xiao, L. Zhang, C.-W. Yang, R. A. Kaindl, L.-J. Li, Y. Wang, and X. Zhang, Observation of chiral phonons, Science 359, 579 (2018).DOI
  16. [16]Romao, C. P., & Juraschek, D. M. (2024). Phonon-induced geometric chirality. ACS Nano, 18, 29550.
  17. [17]T. Wang, H. Sun, X. Li, and L. Zhang, Chiral phonons: Prediction, verification, and application, Nano Letters 24, 4311 (2024).DOI
  18. [18]S. Dalum and P. Hedegård, Theory of chiral induced spin selectivity, Nano Lett. 19, 5253 (2019).DOI
  19. [19]Junquera, J., Nahas, Y., Prokhorenko, S., Bellaiche, L., Íñiguez, J., Schlom, D. G., Chen, L.-Q., Salahuddin, S., Muller, D. A., Martin, L. W., & Ramesh, R. (2023). Topological phases in polar oxide nanostructures. Rev. Mod. Phys., 95, 025001.
  20. [20]Chang, G., Wieder, B. J., Schindler, F., Sanchez, D. S., & Belopol... (2022). Topological quantum properties of chiral crystals. Nat. Mater., 17, 978.
  21. [21]Šmejkal, L., Sinova, J., & Jungwirth, T. (2022). Emerging research landscape of altermagnetism. Phys. Rev. X, 12, 040501.
  22. [22]I. Mazin et al., Altermagnetism—a new punch line of fundamental magnetism, Phys. Rev. X 12, 040002 (2022).DOI
  23. [23]D. S. Sanchez, I. Belopolski, T. A. Cochran, X. Xu, J.-X. Yin, G. Chang, W. Xie, K. Manna, V. Şub, C.-Y. Huang, et al., Topological chiral crystals with helicoid-arc quantum states, Nature 567, 500 (2019).DOI
  24. [24]Hlinka, J. (2014). Eight types of symmetrically distinct vectorlike physical quantities. Phys. Rev. Lett., 113, 165502.
  25. [25]M. Uwaha, Introduction to the bcf theory, Progress in Crystal Growth and Characterization of Materials 62, 58 (2016).DOI
  26. [26]H. Katsuno and M. Uwaha, Mechanism of chirality conversion by periodic change of temperature: Role of chiral clusters, Physical Review E 93, 013002 (2016).DOI
  27. [27]Viedma, C. (2005). Chiral symmetry breaking during crystallization: Complete chiral purity induced by nonlinear autocatalysis and recycling. Physical Review Letters, 94, 065504.
  28. [28]Wagnière, G. H., & Rikken, G. L. (2011). Chirality and magnetism II: Free electron on an infinite helix, inverse faraday effect and inverse magnetochiral effect. Chemical Physics Letters, 502, 126.
  29. [29]M. Fava, E. E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, and E. Bousquet, Phonon-driven mechanism for the chiral phase transition of K₃NiO₂, Phys. Rev. B 111, 174102 (2025).DOI
  30. [30]Dove, M. T. (1997). Theory of displacive phase transitions in minerals. American Mineralogist, 82, 213.
  31. [31]Isobe, M., & Ueda, Y. (2002). Observation of phase transition from metal to spin-singlet insulator in $MgTi_2O_4$ with $s=1/2$ pyrochlore lattice. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., 71, 1848.
  32. [32]M. Schmidt, W. Ratcliff, P. G. Radaelli, K. Refson, N. M. Harrison, and S. W. Cheong, Spin singlet formation in MgTi₂O₄: Evidence of a helical dimerization pattern, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 056402 (2004).DOI
  33. [33]Schlueter, A. W., Jacobson, R. A., & Rundle, R. E. (1966). A redetermination of the crystal structure of CsCuCl₃. Inorg. Chem., 5, 277.
  34. [34]M. I. and T. Sugimura, Metasilicates in the ternary system Na₂O-CaO-SiO₂, J. Ceram. Assoc. Japan 76, 144 (1968).DOI
  35. [35]R. X. Fischer and E. Tillmanns, Revised data for combeite, Na₂Ca₂Si₃O₉, Acta Crystallographica Section C 43, 1852 (1987).DOI
  36. [36]Ohsato, H., Takeuchi, T., & Maki, I. (1990). Structural study of the phase transition of Na₄Ca₄[Si₆O₁₈]. Acta Crystallographica Section B, 46, 125.
  37. [37]Yamada, T., & Koizumi, H. (1983). Czochralski growth of Ag₄P₂O₇ crystals. J. Cryst. Growth, 64, 558.
  38. [38]Fava, M., Lafargue-Dit-Hauret, W., Romero, A. H., & Bousquet, E. (2024). Ferroelectricity and chirality in the Pb₅Ge₃O₁₁ crystal. Phys. Rev. B, 109, 024113.
  39. [39]E. Wachter, E. C. Glazer, S. Parkin, and C. P. Brock, An exceptional 5: 4 enantiomeric structure, Acta Crystallographica Section B: Structural Science, Crystal Engineering and Materials 72, 223 (2016).DOI
  40. [40]Brock, C. P. (2016). High-z′ structures of organic molecules: their diversity and organizing principles. Acta Crystallographica Section B: Structural Science, Crystal Engineering and Materials, 72, 807.
  41. [41]Jain, A., Shin, Y., & Persson, K. A. (2016). Computational predictions of energy materials using density functional theory. Nature Reviews Materials, 1, 1.
  42. [42]Butler, K. T., Frost, J. M., Skelton, J. M., Svane, K. L., & Walsh, A. (2016). Computational materials design of crystalline solids. Chemical Society Reviews, 45, 6138.
  43. [43]Kroumova, E., Aroyo, M. I., Pérez-Mato, J. M., Igartua, J. M., & Ivantchev, S. (2000). Systematic search of displacive ferroelectrics. Ferroelectrics, 241, 295.
  44. [44]Kroumova, E., Aroyo, M. I., & Perez-Mato, J. M. (2002). Prediction of new displacive ferroelectrics through systematic pseudosymmetry search. Results for materials with Pba2 and Pmc21 symmetry. Acta Crystallographica Section B, 58, 921.
  45. [45]Capillas, C., Aroyo, M. I., & Perez-Mato, J. M. (2004). Search for new Pna21 ferroelectrics. Ferroelectrics, 301, 203.
  46. [46]Igartua, J. M., Aroyo, M. I., Kroumova, E., & Perez-Mato, J. M. (1999). Search for Pnma materials with high-temperature structural phase transitions. Acta Crystallogr B, 55, 177.
  47. [47]Igartua, J. M., Aroyo, M. I., & Perez-Mato, J. M. (1996). Systematic search of materials with high-temperature structural phase transitions: Application to space group P212121. Phys. Rev. B, 54, 12744.
  48. [48]Kroumova, E., Aroyo, J. M., Perez-Mato, J. M., Ivantchev, S., Igartua, J. M., & Wondratschek, H. (2001). PSEUDO: a program for a pseudosymmetry search. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 34, 783.
  49. [49]Dummit, D., & Foote, R. (2003). Abstract Algebra. In Wiley.
  50. [50]C. Capillas, E. S. Tasci, G. de la Flor, D. Orobengoa, J. M. Perez-Mato, and M. I. Aroyo, A new computer tool at the bilbao crystallographic server to detect and characterize pseudosymmetry, Z. Krist. 226, 186 (2011).DOI
  51. [51]M. I. Aroyo, J. M. Perez-Mato, C. Capillas, E. Kroumova, S. Ivantchev, G. Madariaga, A. Kirov, and H. Wondratschek, Bilbao crystallographic server: I. databases and crystallographic computing programs, Z. Krist. 221, 15 (2006).DOI
  52. [52]Aroyo, M. I., Kirov, A., Capillas, C., Perez-Mato, J. M., & Wondratschek, H. (2006). Bilbao Crystallographic Server. II. Representations of crystallographic point groups and space groups. Acta Crystallographica Section A, 62, 115.
  53. [53]Wondratschek, H., & Müller, U. (2010). International Tables for Crystallography, Volume A1: Symmetry Relations Between Space Groups. In International Tables for Crystallography.
  54. [54]Wondratschek, H. (1993). Splitting of Wyckoff positions (orbits). Mineralogy and Petrology, 48, 87.
  55. [55]Zagorac, D., Müller, H., Ruehl, S., Zagorac, J., & Rehme, S. (2019). Recent developments in the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database: theoretical crystal structure data and related features. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 52, 918.
  56. [56]J. Leciejewicz, The crystal structure of tellurium dioxide. a redetermination by neutron diffraction, Zeitschrift für Kristallographie - Crystalline Materials 116, 345 (1961).DOI
  57. [57]P. A. Thomas, The crystal structure and absolute optical chirality of paratellurite, α-TeO2, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 21, 4611 (1988).DOI
  58. [58]K. Peng, W. Ren, Y. Hu, H. Ru, S. Lu, A. Chen, P. Wang, X. Fang, H. Li, L. Chi, S. Ding, L. Wang, Y. Wang, and F. Li, Observation of metallic teo2 thin film with rutile structure on fete surface, Journal of Materials Science 57, 10225 (2022).DOI
  59. [59]F. Gómez-Ortiz, M. Fava, E. E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, and E. Bousquet, Structural chirality measurements and computation of handedness in periodic solids, Phys. Rev. B 110, 174112 (2024).DOI
  60. [60]Gómez-Ortiz, F. (n.d.). Helicity computation. <a href="https://doi.org/https://github.com/Gomez-OrtizF/Helicity_Computation_Crystals/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://doi.org/https://github.com/Gomez-OrtizF/Helicity_Computation_Crystals/</a>
  61. [61]Edhokkar, F., Hadrich, A., Graia, M., & Mhiri, T. (2012). Synthesis and crystal structure of Sr2As2O7 from single-crystal data. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 28, 012017.
  62. [62]Mbarek, A., & Edhokkar, F. (2013). The P43 enantiomorph of Sr2As2O7. Acta Crystallographica Section E, 69, i84.
  63. [63]Project, M. (2023). Data retrieved from the materials project for Na2SeO9 (mp-1211530).
  64. [64]M. Jansen, Über eine neue modification von As2O5/on a new modification of As2O5, Zeitschrift für Naturforschung B 34, 10 (1979).DOI
  65. [65]Project, M. (2023). Data retrieved from the materials project for Rb2Be2O3 (mp-771976).
  66. [66]Giester, G., Stöger, M., Zobetz, E., & Weil, M. (2009). Polymorphism of CaTeO3 and solid solutions CaxSr1−xTeO3. Acta Crystallographica. Section B: Structural Science, 65, 167.
  67. [67]Gonze, X., Amadon, B., Antonius, G., Arnardi, F., Baguet, L., Beuken, J.-M., Bieder, J., Bottin, F., Bouchet, J., Bousquet, E., Brouwer, N., Bruneval, F., Brunin, G., Cavignac, T., Charraud, J.-B., Chen, W., Côté, M., Cottenier, S., Denier, J., … Zwanziger, J. W. (2020). The Abinitproject: Impact, environment and recent developments. Computer Physics Communications, 248, 107042.
  68. [68]Hamann, D. (2013). Optimized norm-conserving vanderbilt pseudopotentials. Physical Review B, 88, 085117.
  69. [69]Van Setten, M. J., Gianotmassi, M., Bousquet, E., Verstraete, M. J., Hamann, D. R., Gonze, X., & Rignanese, G.-M. (2018). The pseudodojo: Training and grading a 85 element optimized norm-conserving pseudopotential table. Computer Physics Communications, 226, 39.
  70. [70]Gonze, X., & Lee, C. (1997). Dynamical matrices, Born effective charges, dielectric permittivity tensors, and interatomic force constants from density-functional perturbation theory. Physical Review B, 55, 10355.

Paper details

vlnc:W_x6bq6szb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents