betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The Klein-Gordon equation in projective geometry

Abstract

We discuss a geometric method by which Hörmander's result on the asymptotics of a Klein-Gordon field, on an asymptotically flat spacetime, can be related to some partial peeling, à la Penrose, along an extended projective boundary, embedded in a spacetime with one dimension higher.

Introduction

In 1987, Hörmander published a fascinating paper [Hör87]1 giving precise asymptotics for solutions to the Klein–Gordon equation:

(□−m2)u=0,(\Box- m^2)u = 0,

with Cauchy data, u=u0u = u_0, ∂tu=u1\partial_t u = u_1 in the Schwartz class S(Rd+1)\mathcal{S}(\mathbb{R}^{d+1}). A full Fourier transform of the equation leads to a natural Lorentz invariant splitting: u=u++u−u = u_+ + u_- of the solution uu into positive and negative frequency parts, where the spectral projections are given by pseudo-differential operators:

u+=12(u+im∂tu−Δ+1),u−=12(u−im∂tu−Δ+1).(1)u_+ = \frac{1}{2}\left(u + \frac{i}{m}\frac{\partial_t u}{\sqrt{-\Delta+1}}\right), \qquad u_- = \frac{1}{2}\left(u - \frac{i}{m}\frac{\partial_t u}{\sqrt{-\Delta+1}}\right). \tag*{(1)}

If the solution is assumed to be real-valued then u+=u−‾u_+ = \overline{u_-}; for the purpose of the present discussion, let us make this assumption and restrict our attention to u+u_+ which admits an integral formula:

u+(t,x)=1(2π)d∫Rda+(ξ)1+∣ξ∣2e−imt1+∣ξ∣2+im⟨x,ξ⟩ dξ.(2)u_+(t,x) = \frac{1}{(2\pi)^d}\int_{\mathbb{R}^d}\frac{a_+(\xi)}{\sqrt{1+|\xi|^2}}e^{-imt\sqrt{1+|\xi|^2}+im\langle x,\xi\rangle}\,d\xi. \tag*{(2)}

One can observe that:

ξ↦1md−1a+(ξm)m2+∣ξ∣2,\xi\mapsto\frac{1}{m^{d-1}}\frac{a_+\left(\frac{\xi}{m}\right)}{\sqrt{m^2+|\xi|^2}},

is the Fourier transform of the initial value u+(0,⋅)u_+(0,\cdot). In his paper, Hörmander gives a very precise analysis of the asymptotic behaviour based on a formal application of the stationary phase method to this integral2 and shows that, up to a function in S(Rd+1)\mathcal{S}(\mathbb{R}^{d+1}), we have an asymptotic expansion:

u+∼(0+−iϱ)d2e−imϱ∑jϱjwj(t,x),(3)u_+ \sim(0^+ - i\varrho)^{\frac{d}{2}}e^{-\frac{im}{\varrho}}\sum_j \varrho^j w_j(t,x), \tag*{(3)}

where ϱ=sgn⁡(t)(t2−∣x∣2)−12\varrho= \operatorname{sgn}(t)(t^2-|x|^2)^{-\frac{1}{2}} and, importantly, wj(t,x)=wj(1,xϱ)w_j(t,x) = w_j\left(1,\frac{x}{\varrho}\right). The leading order term is given by:

w0(t,x)={(2π)−d2a+(xϱ)if t2>∣x∣2,0if t2≤∣x∣2.(4)w_0(t,x) = \begin{cases} (2\pi)^{-\frac{d}{2}}a_+(x\varrho) & \text{if } t^2 > |x|^2,\\ 0 & \text{if } t^2 \le|x|^2. \end{cases} \tag*{(4)}

The dependence of the expansion coefficients wjw_j on the ratio xt\frac{x}{t} (rather than xx, tt separately) is one of the first hints that projective geometry may play some role in a geometric interpretation of these asymptotics.

In the spirit of Penrose’s conformal method [28, 29], one might look to the projective compactification [ČGM14; ČG14; ČG16] as a means to tie this result to the asymptotic geometry of Minkowski spacetime. This compactification is instead based on the projective class of the Levi-Civita connection, made up of all torsion-free affine connections on TMTM that share the same unparametrised geodesics, and constructs a boundary at infinity equipped with rich geometric structure, see Figure 1.

The projective compactification of Minkowski spacetime

Figure 1. The projective compactification of Minkowski space time: I±≃Hd\mathcal{I}^{\pm} \simeq\mathbb{H}^{d} correspond to past and future time-like infinity, I0≃Sd\mathcal{I}^{0} \simeq\mathbb{S}^{d} is space-like infinity, and ς±\varsigma^{\pm}, projective null infinity, are conformal spheres. Reproduced from [8].

The function ϱ=(t2−∣x∣2)12\varrho= (t^2 - \lvert x\rvert^2)^{\frac{1}{2}} is of specific relevance with respect to this construction: it constitutes a distinguished boundary defining function at (future/past) timelike infinity (denoted by I±\mathcal{I}^{\pm}) that puts the Minkowski metric in the (Beig-Schmidt [9]) asymptotic form:

ϱ2η=−dϱ2ϱ2+h,(5)\varrho^2\eta= -\frac{\mathrm{d}\varrho^2}{\varrho^2} + h, \tag*{(5)}

where hh is the hyperbolic metric. Introducing y=ϱxy = \varrho x, we can define a boundary coordinate chart (ϱ,y)(\varrho,y) on the interior of the future/past lightcone, compatible with a hyperboloidal foliation such that ϱ=0\varrho= 0 is identified with timelike infinity. From here, it is clear that the leading order coefficient w0w_0 in Eq. (4), can be interpreted as a function on I±\mathcal{I}^{\pm}.

In this geometric framework, it is extremely tempting to try to interpret the function a+a_+ as asymptotic data at timelike infinity, which enable to reconstruct the full solution via the integral formula (2), and to identify the “scattering operator”, that maps initial data on {t=0}\{t = 0\} to the asymptotic data, with a warped Fourier transform (up to normalisation constants). However, the story is incomplete: as observed in [3], the limiting procedure producing the function a+a_+ is sensitive to the choice of boundary defining function ϱ\varrho (preserving the asymptotic form (5)). Although, it turns out, in a very controlled manner: only the lowest order change in the boundary defining function has an effect:

ϱ↦ϱ(1+u(y)ϱ+O(ϱ2)),\varrho\mapsto\varrho(1+u(y)\varrho+O(\varrho^2)),

and obeys a very precise transformation rule:

a+↦a+eimu.a_+ \mapsto a_+e^{\mathrm{i}mu}.

This can be interpreted geometrically in terms of an extended boundary Ti\mathcal{T}_i, which we refer to as Ti\mathcal{T}_i, that is designed to encode geometrically this ambiguity, see Definition 3.1. It is in fact a R\mathbb{R}-principal bundle Ti⟶I±\mathcal{T}_i\longrightarrow\mathcal{I}^{\pm}: the transformation rule indicates that the “scattering data” is, rather than a function on its base, in fact, an equivariant function on Ti\mathcal{T}_i with respect to the one-dimensional representation3^{3}: (x,v)↦eimxv(x,v)\mapsto e^{\mathrm{i}mxv} of R\mathbb{R}. With this understanding of the scattering data, the interpretation of Eq. (2) as a reconstruction formula from the boundary is even more striking. The integral is instead understood as being taken over a section of Ti\mathcal{T}_i (determined by the point of interest (x,t)(x,t)) and Eq. (2) is then assimilated with a Kirchoff–Adémar formula for massive fields, we refer the reader to [3 Proposition 4.1] for more details.

In the case of Minkowski spacetime, it is therefore apparent that Ti\mathcal{T}_i was, to some extent, a missing piece in the puzzle. Similar extended boundaries can be shown to exist for a class of manifolds defined to be asymptotically flat at time/spacelike infinity [8, 3] whose definition is inspired by the work of Ashtekar and Romano [1]. It is therefore natural to wonder what can be said about the Klein-Gordon equation in a curved setting.

This paper is our first foray into this question with the goal to lay the foundations for a geometric framework for the study of the asymptotic behaviour of massive fields on Ricci-flat Lorentzian manifolds; emphasising the role of projective geometry throughout. For the sake of the present paper, which we believe should be thought of as a “proof of concept” rather than a definitive result, we return to the ambient space framework discussed in detail [7], in which the Ricci-flat Lorentzian manifold (Q,h)(\mathcal{Q},h) is obtained as a quotient structure from a holonomy reduction of a projective geometry on a higher-dimensional manifold M⟶QM\longrightarrow\mathcal{Q}. These assumptions imply projective compactness of the metric hh in the sense of Čap–Gover [ČG14], which is well-known to be too strong an assumption for many physically relevant cases, but which already showcases the important features of what can be recovered in an appropriately relaxed setting [14].

The focus of our paper will be to exploit the ambient projective structure on MM to study the Klein-Gordon equation

(hab∇a∇b−m2)φ=0,(h^{ab}\nabla_a\nabla_b-m^2)\varphi=0,

on the open set QO+=QO∪{σ>0}\mathcal{Q}_O^+ = \mathcal{Q}_O \cup\{\sigma> 0\} of the base manifold, where we have denoted the Levi-Civita connection of hh by ∇‾\overline{\nabla}. As in the Penrose conformal method, this boundary behaviour will be understood to describe the asymptotic behaviour of the field.

After briefly recalling some elements of projective geometry in § 4, we complete, in § 5, the results developed [7] by studying more precisely the geometry of the ambient space MM near its boundary Σ\Sigma which, by construction, covers4 that of Q\mathcal{Q}. Σ\Sigma splits into curved orbits which are identified with the extended boundaries mentioned above. We recall that MM is equipped with a solution ζab\zeta^{ab} to the metrisability equation, the main result of this section is Proposition 3.4 in which we derive a normal form for ζab\zeta^{ab} when expressed in distinguished projective scales linked to special local coordinate charts in a neighbourhood of the boundary.

§ 6 is devoted to studying the Klein-Gordon equation on the base from the perspective of the ambient space. The first step is to find an appropriate projectively invariant differential operator that will, in some sense, englobe this equation. The natural candidate, the “projective Laplacian”, HABDADBH^{AB}D_A D_B, does the trick, provided it is restricted to an appropriate subspace of projective densities that we call Em(−n−12)\mathcal{E}_m\left(-\frac{n-1}{2}\right). Enforcing the condition HABDADBϕ=0H^{AB}D_A D_B\phi= 0 on ϕ∈Em(−n−12)\phi\in\mathcal{E}_m\left(-\frac{n-1}{2}\right) shows that, when pulled-back to the base along any section of the (trivial) principal bundle O+⟶QO+\mathcal{O}^+ \longrightarrow\mathcal{Q}_{O^+}, we obtain a solution of the Klein-Gordon equation.

The structure of the space Em(−n−12)\mathcal{E}_m\left(-\frac{n-1}{2}\right), studied in § 6.2, is particularly interesting: the ambient space fields admit a natural decomposition ϕ=ϕ++ϕ−\phi= \phi_+ + \phi_- that recalls the positive/negative frequency decomposition (1) of Hörmander. However, this decomposition is only recovered on the Klein-Gordon field on the base asymptotically. These considerations lead us to Theorems 4.2 and 4.3, that we would like to highlight: they constitute partial peeling [29, 27] results, within our framework, that relate the leading order asymptotic behaviour in Eq. (3) to regularity extensions of the ambient fields ϕ±\phi_\pm up to the projective boundary. These results are only partial as we do not consider, in this paper, the question of reconstructing the ambient field from the base field. Indeed, our positive and negative frequency decomposition is only recovered asymptotically (see Lemma (4.3)), and hence we believe that reconstructing the solution from this data is a question of a different analytical nature and choose here to emphasise the geometric and structural aspects, postponing these considerations to future work.

In § 7, we show that the geometric framework also provides a boundary calculus for the Klein-Gordon equation. This result is to be related to the works of [21, 20] on Poincaré-Einstein manifolds in conformal geometry (see also [13] for a pedagogical introduction). They exploit a natural sl2\mathfrak{sl}_2-algebra associated with the Degenerate Laplacian that can be used to solve boundary value problems, formally off the boundary by a natural iterative procedure. The algebra here is not sl2\mathfrak{sl}_2 nor its Inönü contraction: it is instead the Heisenberg algebra.

Finally, we conclude the article in § 8 by studying the important model case.

We would like to mention that, in the course of writing this work, we became aware of independent work [6] who have obtained similar results by completely different methods, we look forward to discussing with these authors.

Links between the ambient and quotient structures

Figure 2. Links between the ambient and quotient structures

Acknowledgements

Although already two years ago, the first ideas for this work were discussed on the tram in Vienna during the workshop “Carrollian physics and holography” (2024); the authors are thankful once more to the Erwan Schrödinger for hosting them during this period. This work is supported by the ANR project ANR-25-CE40-4883 ScattHoloGR. JB would like to thank Andréas Čap for several interesting discussions on the results in this work.

AI disclosure

All the ideas of the paper are those of the authors and no genAI technology was used at any point in the writing process of this paper. Rights to engage with this manuscript using generative AI technology are not granted. JB refuses permission to use this manuscript in training AI models.

Notations

It should be understood that all affine connections on the tangent bundle are torsion-free. We make extensive use of the Penrose abstract index notation [31]. In index notation, tractor indices (see below) will be denoted by capital Latin letters, AA, BB, C…C \ldots.

Projective geometry and tractor calculus

Let MM be a manifold of dimension n+1n+1 endowed with an equivalence class of projectively equivalent torsion-free connections [∇][\nabla]. It is a standard result5 that two torsion-free affine connections ∇^\widehat{\nabla} and ∇\nabla are projectively equivalent if and only if there is a 1-form Υa\Upsilon_a such that for any vector field ξb\xi^b:

∇^aξb=∇aξb+Υaξb+Υcξcδab\widehat{\nabla}_a \xi^b = \nabla_a \xi^b + \Upsilon_a \xi^b + \Upsilon_c \xi^c \delta_a^b

We will use ∇^=∇+Υ\widehat{\nabla} = \nabla+ \Upsilon as shorthand for this condition.

References

  1. [1]A. Ashtekar and J. D. Romano. “Spatial Infinity as a Boundary of Space-time”. Classical and Quantum Gravity 9.4 (Apr. 1992), pp. 1069–1100. (Visited on 06/27/2019).
  2. [2]S. Armstrong. “Projective holonomy I: principles and properties”. Annals of Global Analysis and Geometry 33.1 (Mar. 2008), pp. 47–69.DOI
  3. [3]J. Borthwick, M. Chantreau, and Y. Herfray. “Ti and Spi, Carrollian Extended Boundaries at Timelike and Spatial Infinity”. Classical and Quantum Gravity 42.20 (Oct. 2025), p. 205012. (Visited on 10/17/2025).DOI
  4. [4]T. Bailey, M. Eastwood, and A. Gover. “Thomas’s Structure Bundle for Conformal, Projective and related structures”. Rocky Mountain Journal of Mathematics 24.4 (1994), pp. 1191–1217.DOI
  5. [5]X. Bekaert et al. “A geometrical invitation to BMS group theory” (Feb. 2026). arXiv: 2602.12965 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2602.12965
  6. [6]X. Bekaert, M. Grigoriev, and M. Markov. “Two-scale system: compactified ambient metrics and Scri/Spi/Ti”. Nov. 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2611.19377
  7. [7]J. Borthwick and Y. Herfray. “Asymptotic symmetries of projectively compact order one Einstein Manifolds”. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 382.2267 (Mar. 2024).DOI
  8. [8]J. Borthwick and Y. Herfray. “Projective and Carrollian geometry at time/space-like infinity on projectively compact Ricci flat Einstein manifolds”. en. Geometriae Dedicata 219.1 (Feb. 2025), p. 12.DOI
  9. [9]R. Beig and B. G. Schmidt. “Einstein’s Equations near Spatial Infinity”. Communications in Mathematical Physics 87.1 (Mar. 1982), pp. 65–80. (Visited on 02/22/2023).
  10. [10]É. Cartan. “Sur les variétés à connexion projective”. Bulletin de la Société Mathématique de France 52.205-241 (1924).DOI
  11. [13]S. N. Curry and A. R. Gover. “An Introduction to Conformal Geometry and Tractor Calculus, with a view to Applications in General Relativity”. en. In: Asymptotic Analysis in General Relativity. Ed. by T. Daudé, D. Häfner, and J.-P. Nicolas. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, Jan. 2018, pp. 86–170. ISBN: 978-1-108-18661-2.arxiv.org/abs/1412.7559
  12. [14]A. Cap and A. R. Gover. Projective Infinities and B-Calculus. June 2026. arXiv: 2606.17597 [math.DG]. (Visited on 06/17/2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.17597
  13. [15]A. Čap, A. R. Gover, and H. Macbeth. “Einstein metrics in projective geometry”. Geometriae Dedicata 168.1 (2014), pp. 235–244.DOI
  14. [16]C. Duval, G. W. Gibbons, and P. A. Horvathy. “Conformal Carroll Groups and BMS Symmetry”. Classical and Quantum Gravity 31.9 (Apr. 2014), p. 092001. (Visited on 05/08/2019).DOI
  15. [17]C. Duval et al. “Carroll versus Newton and Galilei: Two Dual Non-Einsteinian Concepts of Time”. Classical and Quantum Gravity 31.8 (Apr. 2014), p. 085016. (Visited on 05/08/2019).DOI
  16. [20]A. R. Gover, E. Latini, and A. Waldron. Poincare-Einstein Holography for Forms via Conformal Geometry in the Bulk. Vol. 235–1106. Memoirs of the AMS. American Mathematical Soc., Apr. 2015. ISBN: 978-1-4704-1092-6.arxiv.org/abs/1205.3489
  17. [21]A. R. Gover and A. Waldron. “Boundary calculus for conformally compact manifolds”. Indiana Univ. Math. J 63 (2014), pp. 119–163.arxiv.org/abs/1104.2991
  18. [22]Y. Herfray. “Carrollian manifolds and null infinity: a view from Cartan geometry”. Class. Quant. Grav. 39.21 (2022), p. 215005.DOI
  19. [25]S. Kobayashi. Transformation Groups in Differential Geometry. Vol. 70. Ergebnisse der Mathematik, 2.Folge. Springer Berlin, Heidelberg, 1995. ISBN: 978-3-540-58659-3.
  20. [26]J. Mikes. “Geodesic mappings of affine-connected and Riemannian spaces”. Journal of Mathematical Sciences 78.3 (Feb. 1996), pp. 311–333.DOI
  21. [27]L. J. Mason and J.-P. Nicolas. “Regularity at space-like and null infinity”. Journal of the Institute of Mathematics of Jussieu 8.1 (2009), pp. 179–208.arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0701049
  22. [28]R. Penrose. “Asymptotic Properties of Fields and Space-Times”. Physical Review Letters 10.2 (Jan. 1963), pp. 66–68. (Visited on 06/24/2019).DOI
  23. [29]R. Penrose. “Zero Rest-Mass Fields Including Gravitation: Asymptotic Behaviour”. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences 284.1397 (Feb. 1965), pp. 159–203. (Visited on 06/26/2019).DOI
  24. [30]S. Porath. “Boundary operators on Klein manifolds”. PhD thesis. Auckland University, 2023.
  25. [31]R. Penrose and W. Rindler. Spinors and Space-Time Volume 2: Spinor and Twistor Methods in Space-Time Geometry. Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics. Cambridge University Press, 1984. ISBN: 9780511524486.
  26. [32]R. Sharpe. Differential Geometry: Cartan’s Generalization of Klein’s Erlangen Program. Vol. 166. Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer-Verlag New York, 1997. ISBN: 978-0-387-94732-7.
  27. [33]N. Sinjukov. “Geodesic mappings of Riemannian spaces (Russian)”. Nauka, Moscow (1979).

Paper details

vlnc:W_x8zzmkcd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

None listed by the authors

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents