betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

On the experimental description of neutron resonances

Abstract

We present a collection of simple derivations for the neutron-induced resonance cross-sections. These formulae are commonly used to experimentally describe the fundamental properties of resonances for neutron-rich nuclei far from stability and to describe unbound nuclei. The main goal of this article is to illustrate their dependencies with basic observables in order to discuss the pertinence of experimental approaches in the derivation of their properties, especially for "N-body" resonances.

Introduction

The advent of new generation radioactive beam facilities has provided the ability of experimentally measuring resonances far from the valley of stability, and in particular on the neutron-rich side. It also allows neutron unbound nuclei to be produced and studied, and their fundamental characteristics to be deduced. Physicists widely use a set of simple formulae to extract their properties. However theses equations have intrinsic limitations than can lead to misunderstanding when they are compared with their theoretical description. We present in the following sections a simple approach for their derivation, keeping their expression dependent on only simple tabulated functions. We then illustrate and discuss their behavior with experimentally accessible observables and parameters.

Derivation of the main equations

Scattering cross-section

As we will see later, describing neutron states in the continuum and in particular unbound (neutron-rich) nuclei, comes down at first order to describing the resonant scattering of a neutron on a nucleus (Figure 1).

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Schematic (left) and potential (right) of the reaction considered here.

If a priori we should consider a dynamical evolution of the wave packet describing the diffusion of the neutron on the nuclear potential of the nucleus of interest, we can show that the size of the corresponding wave packet is large enough to be decomposed into standing waves [1].

A large part of the formalisms and derivations presented below come from the books of Blatt and Weisskopf [2] or Satchler [3] as well as from the RR–matrix formalism [4, 5].

We can represent the incident beam (here the neutron) by a plane wave:

exp⁡(ik⃗r⃗)=exp⁡(ikz)(1)\exp\left(i\vec{k}\vec{r}\right)=\exp(ikz) \tag*{(1)}

the wave number being calculated from the energy EE of the system fragment plus neutron:

k⃗=μv⃗ℏ⇒k=2μEℏwithμ=MfragMnMfrag+Mn(2)\vec{k}=\frac{\mu\vec{v}}{\hbar}\Rightarrow k=\frac{\sqrt{2\mu E}}{\hbar} \qquad\text{with}\qquad \mu=\frac{M_{\mathrm{frag}}M_n}{M_{\mathrm{frag}}+M_n} \tag*{(2)}

We develop this plane wave on the basis of spherical harmonics Yℓ,m(θ)Y_{\ell,m}(\theta), taking into account that we have a cylindrical symmetric problem and that only the harmonics with m=0m=0 come into play:

exp⁡(ikz)=∑ℓ=0∞Aℓ(r)Yℓ,0(θ)(3)\exp(ikz)=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}A_{\ell}(r)Y_{\ell,0}(\theta) \tag*{(3)}

with

Aℓ(r)=∫Yℓ,0∗(θ)exp⁡(ikrcos⁡θ) dΩ=iℓ4π(2ℓ+1)jℓ(kr)A_{\ell}(r)=\int Y_{\ell,0}^{*}(\theta)\exp(ikr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\Omega=i^{\ell}\sqrt{4\pi(2\ell+1)}j_{\ell}(kr)

and jpj_p the spherical Bessel function of first kind and order pp. The expression of the latter simplifies at large distances (here kr≫ℓkr\gg\ell): jp(x)→sin⁡(x−pπ2)xj_p(x)\rightarrow\frac{\sin\left(x-\frac{p\pi}{2}\right)}{x} and by recalling that sin⁡(x)=eix−e−ix2i\sin(x) = \frac{e^{ix}-e^{-ix}}{2i}, we get:

exp⁡(ikz)≈πkr∑ℓ=0∞2ℓ+1 iℓ+1{exp⁡[−i(kr−π2ℓ)]−exp⁡[+i(kr−π2ℓ)]}Yℓ,0(4)\exp(ikz) \approx\frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{kr} \sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty} \sqrt{2\ell+1}\,i^{\ell+1} \left\{ \exp\left[-i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] - \exp\left[+i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] \right\}Y_{\ell,0} \tag*{(4)}

However, this expression describes an unperturbed wave. As we are trying to describe the scattering of this wave on the nuclear potential of the fragment, we have to modify this expression for the outgoing wave, by allowing the latter to be scaled by a complex factor ηℓ\eta_{\ell}:

ψ(r⃗)=πkr∑ℓ=0∞2ℓ+1 iℓ+1{exp⁡[−i(kr−π2ℓ)]−ηℓexp⁡[+i(kr−π2ℓ)]}Yℓ,0(5)\psi(\vec{r}) = \frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{kr} \sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty} \sqrt{2\ell+1}\,i^{\ell+1} \left\{ \exp\left[-i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] - \eta_{\ell}\exp\left[+i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] \right\}Y_{\ell,0} \tag*{(5)}

The scattered wave is then obtained by ψsc=ψ−exp⁡(ikz)\psi_{\mathrm{sc}} = \psi- \exp(ikz), whose integration of the flux gives the scattering cross-section:

σsc,ℓ=πλ2(2ℓ+1)∥1−ηℓ∥2(6)\sigma_{\mathrm{sc},\ell} = \pi\lambda^{2}(2\ell+1)\left\lVert1-\eta_{\ell}\right\rVert^{2} \tag*{(6)}

The integration of the flux of the total wave function ψ\psi allows us to deduce the expression of the reaction cross-section:

σr,ℓ=πλ2(2ℓ+1)(1−∥ηℓ∥2)(7)\sigma_{\mathrm{r},\ell} = \pi\lambda^{2}(2\ell+1)\left(1-\left\lVert\eta_{\ell}\right\rVert^{2}\right) \tag*{(7)}

A cross-section being necessarily positive, the expression of σr,ℓ\sigma_{\mathrm{r},\ell} implies ∥ηℓ∥≤1\left\lVert\eta_{\ell}\right\rVert\le1.

Expression of energy shift and penetrability

Let us now address the reaction of interest. The radial Schrödinger equation gives:

d2uℓdr2+[k2−ℓ(ℓ+1)r2−2μℏ2V(r)]uℓ=0(8)\frac{d^{2}u_{\ell}}{dr^{2}}+\left[k^{2}-\frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{r^{2}}-\frac{2\mu}{\hbar^{2}}V(r)\right]u_{\ell}=0 \tag*{(8)}

with μ\mu the reduced mass of the system and V(r)V(r) the Coulomb potential. Within the hard sphere approximation, and since neutrons are uncharged, V(r)=0V(r)=0 for r>Rr>R. We can thus write outside the nucleus:

d2uℓdr2+[k2−ℓ(ℓ+1)r2]uℓ=0(9)\frac{d^{2}u_{\ell}}{dr^{2}}+\left[k^{2}-\frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{r^{2}}\right]u_{\ell}=0 \tag*{(9)}

On the experimental description of neutron resonances

With the so-called regular (which goes to 0 when rr goes to 0) and irregular solutions, respectively noted Fℓ(r)F_\ell(r) and Gℓ(r)G_\ell(r)1, written:

Fℓ(r)=πkr2Jℓ+1/2(kr)(10)F_\ell(r)=\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}J_{\ell+1/2}(kr) \tag*{(10)}
Gℓ(r)=−πkr2Yℓ+1/2(kr)=(−1)ℓπkr2J−(ℓ+1/2)(kr)(11)G_\ell(r)=-\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}Y_{\ell+1/2}(kr)=(-1)^\ell\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}J_{-(\ell+1/2)}(kr) \tag*{(11)}

where JpJ_p and YpY_p are the Bessel functions of order pp, respectively of first and second kind.

We then have:

  • incoming term: uℓ(+)=Gℓ(r)+iFℓ(r)=πkr2Hℓ+1/2(2)(kr)u_\ell^{(+)}=G_\ell(r)+iF_\ell(r)=\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}H_{\ell+1/2}^{(2)}(kr)

uℓ(+)=Gℓ(r)+iFℓ(r)=πkr2Hℓ+1/2(2)(kr)(12)u_\ell^{(+)}=G_\ell(r)+iF_\ell(r)=\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}H_{\ell+1/2}^{(2)}(kr) \tag*{(12)}
  • outgoing term: uℓ(−)=uℓ(+)‾=πkr2Hℓ+1/2(1)(kr)u_\ell^{(-)}=\overline{u_\ell^{(+)}}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}H_{\ell+1/2}^{(1)}(kr)

uℓ(−)=uℓ(+)‾=πkr2Hℓ+1/2(1)(kr)(13)u_\ell^{(-)}=\overline{u_\ell^{(+)}}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi kr}{2}}H_{\ell+1/2}^{(1)}(kr) \tag*{(13)}

with Hp(1,2)(z)H_p^{(1,2)}(z) the Hankel functions of order pp, of the first and second kind. Outside the nucleus, the radial part of the wave function is a linear combination of the incoming and outgoing terms:

uℓ=αuℓ(+)+βuℓ(−)(14)u_\ell=\alpha u_\ell^{(+)}+\beta u_\ell^{(-)} \tag*{(14)}

As at large distances the wave function must converge to the shape found in (5):

lim⁡r→∞uℓ=πkr2ℓ+1 iℓ+1{exp⁡[−i(kr−π2ℓ)]−ηℓexp⁡[+i(kr−π2ℓ)]}(15)\lim_{r\to\infty}u_\ell=\frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{kr}\sqrt{2\ell+1}\,i^{\ell+1}\left\{\exp\left[-i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right]-\eta_\ell\exp\left[+i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right]\right\} \tag*{(15)}

By recalling that the asymptotic forms of the Hankel functions are:

Hp1(z)→2πzexp⁡[+i(z−pπ2−π4)]andHp2(z)→2πzexp⁡[−i(z−pπ2−π4)]H_p^{1}(z)\to\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi z}}\exp\left[+i\left(z-\frac{p\pi}{2}-\frac{\pi}{4}\right)\right]\quad\text{and}\quad H_p^{2}(z)\to\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi z}}\exp\left[-i\left(z-\frac{p\pi}{2}-\frac{\pi}{4}\right)\right]

this implies:

lim⁡r→∞uℓ(+)=+iexp⁡[−i(kr−π2ℓ)](16)\lim_{r\to\infty}u_\ell^{(+)}=+i\exp\left[-i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] \tag*{(16)}
lim⁡r→∞uℓ(−)=−iexp⁡[+i(kr−π2ℓ)](17)\lim_{r\to\infty}u_\ell^{(-)}=-i\exp\left[+i\left(kr-\frac{\pi}{2}\ell\right)\right] \tag*{(17)}

and thus we have:

α=i2+1πkr(18)\alpha= i\sqrt{2+1}\frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{kr} \tag*{(18)}
β=−ηℓα(19)\beta= -\eta_{\ell}\alpha \tag*{(19)}

The value of ηℓ\eta_{\ell} is connected to the conditions of continuity at the surface (see a schematics representation in Figure 2). To calculate these conditions, we define fℓf_{\ell}, the logarithmic derivative of the radial part of the wave function at the surface:

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Schematic representation of the radial wave function, separating the inner (red) and outer part (blue).

fℓ=R[duℓ/druℓ]r=R(20)f_{\ell}=R\left[\frac{du_{\ell}/dr}{u_{\ell}}\right]_{r=R} \tag*{(20)}

For the part outside the core, we can define:

R[duℓ(+)/druℓ(+)]r=R=Δℓ+isℓ(21)R\left[\frac{du_{\ell}^{(+)}/dr}{u_{\ell}^{(+)}}\right]_{r=R}=\Delta_{\ell}+is_{\ell} \tag*{(21)}

with Δℓ\Delta_{\ell} and sℓs_{\ell} real, which correspond to the energy shift and the penetrability:

Δℓ=Rvℓ[Gℓ(R)Gℓ′(R)+Fℓ(R)Fℓ′(R)](22)\Delta_{\ell}=Rv_{\ell}\left[G_{\ell}(R)G_{\ell}'(R)+F_{\ell}(R)F_{\ell}'(R)\right] \tag*{(22)}
sℓ=Rvℓ[Gℓ(R)Fℓ′(R)−Fℓ(R)Gℓ′(R)]=kRvℓ(23)s_{\ell}=Rv_{\ell}\left[G_{\ell}(R)F_{\ell}'(R)-F_{\ell}(R)G_{\ell}'(R)\right]=kRv_{\ell} \tag*{(23)}

F′F', G′G' being the derivatives of FF, GG and:

vℓ=1Gℓ2(R)+Fℓ2(R)=2/πkRJℓ+1/22(kR)+Yℓ+1/22(kR)(24)v_{\ell}=\frac{1}{G_{\ell}^{2}(R)+F_{\ell}^{2}(R)}=\frac{2/\pi kR}{J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)+Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)} \tag*{(24)}

the penetrability factor itself. As its name indicates vℓv_\ell is a measure of how much the neutron penetrates the nucleus. So vℓ≪1v_\ell\ll1 means that the neutron does not penetrate enough, resulting in a weak interaction.

We define the phase shift ξℓ\xi_\ell as:

exp⁡(2iξℓ)=uℓ(+)(R)uℓ(−)(R)=Gℓ(R)−iFℓ(R)Gℓ(R)+iFℓ(R)(25)\exp(2i\xi_\ell) = \frac{u_\ell^{(+)}(R)}{u_\ell^{(-)}(R)} = \frac{G_\ell(R) - iF_\ell(R)}{G_\ell(R) + iF_\ell(R)} \tag*{(25)}

Finally we can write the link between ηℓ\eta_\ell and fℓf_\ell, which gives after some rearrangements:

ηℓ=fℓ−Δℓ+isℓfℓ−Δℓ−isℓexp⁡(2iξℓ)(26)\eta_\ell= \frac{f_\ell- \Delta_\ell+ is_\ell}{f_\ell- \Delta_\ell- is_\ell}\exp(2i\xi_\ell) \tag*{(26)}

The equations (6) and (7) then provide the scattering and reaction cross-sections:

σsc,ℓ=(2ℓ+1)πλ2∣Aresℓ+Apotℓ∣2(27)\sigma_{\mathrm{sc},\ell} = (2\ell+ 1)\pi\lambda^2\left|A_{\mathrm{res}}^\ell+ A_{\mathrm{pot}}^\ell\right|^2 \tag*{(27)}

with

Aresℓ=−2isℓRe(fℓ)−Δℓ+i(Im(fℓ)−sℓ)(28)A_{\mathrm{res}}^\ell= \frac{-2is_\ell}{\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}(f_\ell)-\Delta_\ell+i\left(\mathop{\mathrm{Im}}(f_\ell)-s_\ell\right)} \tag*{(28)}
Apotℓ=exp⁡(−2iξℓ)−1(29)A_{\mathrm{pot}}^\ell= \exp(-2i\xi_\ell)-1 \tag*{(29)}

amplitudes for the internal “scattering” (i.e. resonance) and for the external potential. And:

σr,ℓ=(2ℓ+1)πλ2−4sℓIm(fℓ)(Re(fℓ)−Δℓ)2+(Im(fℓ)−sℓ)2(30)\sigma_{\mathrm{r},\ell} = (2\ell+ 1)\pi\lambda^2\frac{-4s_\ell\mathop{\mathrm{Im}}(f_\ell)}{\left(\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}(f_\ell)-\Delta_\ell\right)^2+\left(\mathop{\mathrm{Im}}(f_\ell)-s_\ell\right)^2} \tag*{(30)}

In these equations, only the expression of fℓf_\ell is missing to compute the cross-sections, which we will do later with some approximations. We can nevertheless conclude here, from (30), that fℓf_\ell must be zero or negative. Since sℓs_\ell appears in the numerator, the reaction cross-section follows the evolution of the penetrability. Finally, by looking only at the resonant part of the diffusion (AresℓA_{\mathrm{res}}^\ell) we find that for given sℓs_\ell and Δℓ\Delta_\ell, the amplitude is more important as fℓf_\ell is low.

Expression of the shape of a resonance

The main idea, given the results obtained previously, is to find an expression of fℓf_\ell showing its energy dependence. We will assume that we have purely a resonance and that the input channel of the reaction is equal to the output channel (resonant elastic scattering). Knowing that fℓf_\ell is the derivative of uℓu_\ell we have to find an expression of the latter.

Just inside the core (r≤Rr \le R) we can write, by definition of the phase shift (25):

uℓ(r)∼exp⁡(−ikr)+exp⁡(ikr+2iξℓ)=2exp⁡(iξℓ)cos⁡(kr+ξℓ)(31)u_\ell(r) \sim\exp(-ikr) + \exp(ikr + 2i\xi_\ell) = 2\exp(i\xi_\ell)\cos(kr+\xi_\ell) \tag*{(31)}

We have therefore for its derivative, evaluated in RR:

uℓ′(R)∼−2exp⁡(iξℓ) ksin⁡(kR+ξℓ)(32)u'_{\ell}(R) \sim-2\exp(i\xi_{\ell})\,k\sin(kR+\xi_{\ell}) \tag*{(32)}

and consequently:

fℓ(R)=Ruℓ′(R)uℓ(R)∼−kRtan⁡(kR+ξℓ)(33)f_{\ell}(R)=R\frac{u'_{\ell}(R)}{u_{\ell}(R)}\sim-kR\tan(kR+\xi_{\ell}) \tag*{(33)}

Recalling that ξℓ\xi_{\ell} depends a priori on energy, this function will alternate in energy between two poles and zero values. This last value maximizes a priori the amplitude of the resonant scattering (equation (28)).

We can therefore expand fℓf_{\ell} around the resonance energy E0E_0:

fℓ(E)=(E−E0)[dfℓ(E)dE]E=E0⏟f′(E0)+…(34)f_{\ell}(E)=(E-E_0)\underbrace{\left[\frac{df_{\ell}(E)}{dE}\right]_{E=E_0}}_{f'(E_0)}+\ldots \tag*{(34)}

The expression for the amplitude ((28)) becomes:

Aresℓ=−2isℓ[(E−E0)f′(E0)−Δℓ]−isℓ(35)A^\ell_{\mathrm{res}}=\frac{-2is_{\ell}}{[(E-E_0)f'(E_0)-\Delta_{\ell}]-is_{\ell}} \tag*{(35)}

which can be rewritten:

Aresℓ=iΓ(E−E0−ΔE)+i12Γ(36)A^\ell_{\mathrm{res}}=\frac{i\Gamma}{(E-E_0-\Delta E)+i\frac{1}{2}\Gamma} \tag*{(36)}

with

γ2=−1/f′(E0)(37)\gamma^2=-1/f'(E_0) \tag*{(37)}
Γ=2sℓγ2(38)\Gamma=2s_{\ell}\gamma^2 \tag*{(38)}
ΔE=γ2Δℓ(39)\Delta E=\gamma^2\Delta_{\ell} \tag*{(39)}

The quadratic norm of this amplitude, directly related to the cross-section, has the well-known form of a dispersion described by Breit & Wigner:

∥Aresℓ∥2=Γ2(E−E0′)2+14Γ2(40)\lVert A^\ell_{\mathrm{res}}\rVert^2=\frac{\Gamma^2}{(E-E'_0)^2+\frac{1}{4}\Gamma^2} \tag*{(40)}

where the energy E0′=E0−ΔEE'_0=E_0-\Delta E is the energy of the resonance shifted by a factor ΔE\Delta E.

For a concise development of the equations presented here we can refer the reader for example to F. Gunsing’s lectures at Joliot-Curie School 2014 [6].

Expression of the energy-dependent apparent width and position of the resonant state

We start from the characteristic expression of the cross-section distribution as deduced in the previous section:

dσdE∝Γℓ(E)(E0′−E)2+14Γℓ2(E)(41)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}E} \propto\frac{\Gamma_{\ell}(E)}{(E'_0-E)^2+\frac{1}{4}\Gamma_{\ell}^{2}(E)} \tag*{(41)}

The expression of the width and the energy shift are valid whatever EE is, so in particular for E0E_0

Γℓ(E0)=2sℓ(E0)γ2=Γ0(42)\Gamma_{\ell}(E_0)=2s_{\ell}(E_0)\gamma^2=\Gamma_0 \tag*{(42)}

the reduced width γ\gamma being constructed to be constant in energy we can write:

Γℓ(E)Γℓ(E0)=Γℓ(E)Γ0=sℓ(E)sℓ(E0)(43)\frac{\Gamma_{\ell}(E)}{\Gamma_{\ell}(E_0)}=\frac{\Gamma_{\ell}(E)}{\Gamma_0}=\frac{s_{\ell}(E)}{s_{\ell}(E_0)} \tag*{(43)}

and finally by developing the penetrability expression sℓ(E)s_{\ell}(E):

Γℓ(E)=Γ0kk0Jℓ+1/22(k0R)+Yℓ+1/22(k0R)Jℓ+1/22(kR)+Yℓ+1/22(kR)(44)\Gamma_{\ell}(E)=\Gamma_0\frac{k}{k_0}\frac{J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(k_0R)+Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(k_0R)}{J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)+Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)} \tag*{(44)}

And in the same way for the energy shift:

ΔE=−(sℓ−B)γ2(45)\Delta E=-(s_{\ell}-B)\gamma^2 \tag*{(45)}

equation (42) allows us to extract the reduced width γ2=Γ0/(2sℓ(E0))\gamma^2=\Gamma_0/(2s_{\ell}(E_0)) which we reinject:

ΔE=−Γ0sℓ(E)−B2sℓ(E0)(46)\Delta E=-\Gamma_0\frac{s_{\ell}(E)-B}{2s_{\ell}(E_0)} \tag*{(46)}

BB is a constant that we choose such that at the energy of the resonance the shift is equal to zero, i.e. B=sℓ(E0)B=s_{\ell}(E_0) and thus:

ΔE=−Γ0sℓ(E)−sℓ(E0)2sℓ(E0)(47)\Delta E=-\Gamma_0\frac{s_{\ell}(E)-s_{\ell}(E_0)}{2s_{\ell}(E_0)} \tag*{(47)}

as for sℓ(E)s_{\ell}(E) its expression:

sℓ(E)=Rvℓ[Gℓ(R)Gℓ′(R)+Fℓ(R)Fℓ′(R)](48)s_{\ell}(E)=Rv_{\ell}\left[G_{\ell}(R)G'_{\ell}(R)+F_{\ell}(R)F'_{\ell}(R)\right] \tag*{(48)}

can be written, using the different properties of the Bessel functions:

sℓ(E)=−ℓJℓ+1/22(kR)+Yℓ+1/22(kR)s_{\ell}(E)=\frac{-\ell}{J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)+Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)}
{[Jℓ+1/22(kR)+Yℓ+1/22(kR)]ℓ−kR[Jℓ+1/2(kR)Jℓ−1/2(kR)+Yℓ+1/2(kR)Yℓ−1/2(kR)]}(49)\left\{ \left[J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)+Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)\right]\ell -kR\left[J_{\ell+1/2}(kR)J_{\ell-1/2}(kR)+Y_{\ell+1/2}(kR)Y_{\ell-1/2}(kR)\right]\right\} \tag*{(49)}

The forms of the equations (49) and (44) are therefore simple enough to be implemented in a computer code (there are many libraries for Bessel functions, for example the GSL [7]). In particular their expression is general whatever ℓ\ell is, allowing to study the dependence in ℓ\ell as an additional parameter, possibly without any prior hypothesis.

Systematic studies

General cases

On Figure 3 are given the typical shapes of distributions (in color), compared to a Lorentzian with the same parameters (in gray), for E0=Γ0=1E_0=\Gamma_0=1 MeV. We first recall that these distributions physically represent cross-sections. It seems quite natural that if the energy EE – which corresponds in the case of the scattering of a neutron on a fragment at rest to the kinetic energy of the neutron – is zero then the resonance probability is also zero. At constant integral, if we bring the cross-section to zero for E0=0E_0=0 the “apparent” maximum of the function will therefore shift to low energies.2

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Left: Lorentzian (grey) distribution compared to Breit-Wigner distributions with energy and ℓ\ell dependent widths, taking into account the energy shift. For all curves E0=Γ0=1E_0=\Gamma_0=1 MeV, only ℓ=0\ell=0, 1, 2 and 3 (respectively yellow, blue, magenta and green) change. We assume here a 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B}+n system. Right: illustration of observables used to construct the estimators of figures 4 and 5, see text for details.

Since taking into account the energy shift and the energy dependence of the width significantly modifies the distribution compared to a Lorentzian one, we present on Figure 4 and Figure 5 the evolution of these characteristic distributions as a function of the energies and widths of the resonances. In order to quantify this evolution, we define several estimators:

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Asymmetry (left) and FWHM (right) function of the intrinsic width of a Breit-Wigner centered at E0=1E_0 = 1 MeV for ℓ=0,1,2\ell= 0, 1, 2 and 33 (respectively yellow, blue, magenta and green). We consider here a 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B}+n system. The dashed lines correspond to a Lorentzian function.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Position of maximum (top left), mean energy (top right), asymmetry (bottom left) and FWHM (bottom right) function of energy of a Breit-Wigner of width Γ0=1\Gamma_0 = 1 MeV for ℓ=0,1,2\ell= 0, 1, 2 and 33 (yellow respectively, blue, magenta and green). We assume a 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B}+\mathrm{n} system.

  • the full width half maximum (FWHM), which is directly comparable to the Γ\Gamma of the Lorentzian,

  • the position of the maximum,

  • the mean value,

  • and a measure of the asymmetry.

Concerning this asymmetry, we decided not to take the usual Pearson’s coefficient of skewness (or skewness3) because it was found to be numerically unstable due to the infinite integration. Given the functions studied (analytic and continuous with one maximum) we preferred a more graphical version (noted AA) which consists in measuring the “half”-widths at half maximum on the right Δxr\Delta x_r and left of the maximum Δxl\Delta x_l (see on Figure 3 on the right), calculate the difference and normalize it to the sum (the true FWHM). Then if we call Δxr\Delta x_r and Δxl\Delta x_l the half-widths at half height on the right and on the left respectively, the respectively, so the asymmetry is written A=Δxr−ΔxlΔxr+ΔxlA = \frac{\Delta x_r-\Delta x_l}{\Delta x_r+\Delta x_l}.

This estimator is therefore zero in case of a symmetrical distribution, positive if the distribution has a tail towards high energies and negative in the opposite case.

A simple Lorentzian is symmetric (zero skewness) and its FWHM equals to Γ0\Gamma_0. The position of the maximum and the mean are both equal to E0E_0. All these cases are represented in black dashed lines on Figure 4 and Figure 5. On our illustrations the axes are in MeV and we will take as reference a distribution with E0=Γ0=1E_0 = \Gamma_0 = 1 MeV. We could also have put axes (E/E0E/E_0, Γ/Γ0\Gamma/\Gamma_0 etc) since these distributions can be scaled by theses factors. Note that the result is not necessarily physical since certain combinations/values of E0E_0, Γ0\Gamma_0 and ℓ\ell are not relevant (see § 4.3).

Let’s start with the left panel of Figure 4 i.e. the asymmetry function of the intrinsic width for a resonance at E0=1E_0 = 1 MeV for different ℓ\ell. This one is always positive (or almost zero for very low Γ0\Gamma_0) because the distribution presents a tail always towards high energies. The latter tends to move away from zero for Γ0<E0\Gamma_0 < E_0 to saturate at a at values depending on the ℓ\ell (the lower ℓ\ell is the lower the saturation value). Consequently, on the right panel of Figure 4 which shows the real width as a function of the intrinsic width, we observe a saturation of the real width when the intrinsic width increases. Therefore, even if experimentally our resolution is minimal, we are only marginally sensitive to large widths and this is all the more true as ℓ\ell gets larger, up to “saturation”. We note that the distributions ℓ=0\ell= 0 have a different behavior, in particular the width is maximal around Γ0=E0\Gamma_0 = E_0 and decreases for width greater than E0E_0. This is not surprising given the particular nature of these resonances (see § 4.2).

Concerning the evolution with the intrinsic energy of the resonance (at constant intrinsic width Γ0=1\Gamma_0 = 1 MeV), the different estimators are presented on Figure 5. We first point out that these are not necessarily independent of each other. We note in the upper right corner that except for ℓ=0\ell= 0 the position of the maximum almost systematically coincides with E0E_0. The asymmetry (bottom left) is significant at low E0E_0 then tends to 0 at large E0E_0, which is the counterpart of the left panel of Figure 4: it is equivalent to say that the larger the intrinsic width is compared to the energy of the resonance, the greater the asymmetry. This last observation has a direct consequence on the mean (top right), which is strongly shifted from the maximum to E0≪1E_0 \ll1 MeV. As for the FWHM, it is also away from 1 MeV in the same range of conditions.

Virtual states

The previous systematic studies show that ℓ=0\ell= 0 states follow different trends with respect to ℓ>0\ell> 0 states. This behavior leads to what is called “virtual states” and is well explained by McVoy in his article [8]. To understand it, let’s look at the evolution with energy of the widths of the states, as given by the equation (38). The latter shows the “penetrability” sℓs_\ell whose expression is recalled here:

sℓ=2/πJℓ+1/22(kR)+Yℓ+1/22(kR)(50)s_\ell= \frac{2/\pi}{J_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR) + Y_{\ell+1/2}^{2}(kR)} \tag*{(50)}

The Bessel functions Jp(x)J_p(x) are written as:

Jp(x)=∑m=0∞(−1)mm! Γ(m+p+1)(x2)2m+p(51)J_p(x) = \sum_{m=0}^{\infty} \frac{(-1)^m}{m!\,\Gamma(m+p+1)}\left(\frac{x}{2}\right)^{2m+p} \tag*{(51)}

with Γ\Gamma the gamma function. The Bessel functions JpJ_p and YpY_p being related, for p=ℓ+1/2p = \ell+ 1/2 with ℓ\ell integer positive, by:

J−(ℓ+1/2)(x)=(−1)ℓ+1Yℓ+1/2(x)(52)J_{-(\ell+1/2)}(x) = (-1)^{\ell+1}Y_{\ell+1/2}(x) \tag*{(52)}

this implies that sℓs_\ell, and thus by extension the width Γ\Gamma, evolves in k2ℓ+1k^{2\ell+1}. This is to be compared to the energy which varies in k2k^2 (equation (2)) and so for ℓ>0\ell> 0 the width decreases faster than the energy. In this case the state never overlaps the threshold, so there can not be any ambiguity as to whether it occurs above the threshold (a resonance) or below (a bound state). If ℓ=0\ell= 0 however, the width decreases only as the square root of the energy, so as the energy decreases, there will necessarily be an “overlap” threshold before it becomes a bound state. In some cases it is not clear whether the level is predominantly above or below the threshold, and to describe this situation the term “virtual” state is used. In order to illustrate this situation, we present the evolution of the width as a function of the energy, taking as reference the energy of the resonance E0=1 MeVE_0 = 1\,\mathrm{MeV} (from the equation (44) and with the same logic as the previous systematic analyses). We can see that only for ℓ=0\ell= 0 (in yellow) the width value is greater than the energy (in dotted line).

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Evolution of the width as a function of the energy of the resonance, for ℓ=0,1,2\ell= 0, 1, 2 and 3 (respectively yellow, blue, magenta and green). We consider here a 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B} + n system with E0=1 MeVE_0 = 1\,\mathrm{MeV}. The Γ=E\Gamma= E case is depicted as a dotted black line.

Width of single-particle resonances

Experimentally the width of an independent particle state is often used, knowing the nature of the considered state, to deduce its spectroscopic factor. The link between the two can simply be seen in the definition, here simplified, of the reduced width as given in references [4, 9]:

γℓ,i=ℏ2μR∫ϕi∗χi dS(53)\gamma_{\ell,i} = \frac{\hbar}{\sqrt{2\mu R}}\int\phi_i^{*}\chi_i\,dS \tag*{(53)}

where: dSdS surface element at r=Rr = R {#eq:54}

ϕ\phi surface component of the internal wave function

χi\chi_i internal eigenfunction, for an given energy EiE_i The surface component corresponds to what must be multiplied with the radial wave function uℓu_\ell to obtain the total wave function ψ\psi:

ψ=∑ℓuℓϕℓ=∑iAiχi(54)\psi= \sum_{\ell} u_\ell\phi_\ell= \sum_i A_i \chi_i \tag*{(54)}

Quantitatively, it appears here because γℓ\gamma_\ell, if we refer to equation (37), shows the derivative according to rr of the wave function. Note that in expression (54) presented here the summation is simplified on ℓ\ell but, in particular [4, 9], one must take into account all the quantum numbers of the input channels of the reaction (jj, ll, JJ, etc).

We clearly see in this expression that the spectroscopic factor C2SC^2S, is directly connected to the observed width. Schematically:

C2S=σℓ,exp⁡/σℓ,theo(55)C^2S = \sigma_{\ell,\exp}/\sigma_{\ell,\mathrm{theo}} \tag*{(55)}

with σℓ\sigma_\ell the cross-section of interest, σ∝∥ϕ∥2\sigma\propto\lVert\phi\rVert^2, experimental and theoretical respectively. So schematically again we can write ϕexp⁡=C2S ϕtheo\phi_{\exp} = \sqrt{C^2S}\,\phi_{\mathrm{theo}}, which gives:

C2S=γℓ,exp⁡/γℓ,theo(56)C^2S = \gamma_{\ell,\exp}/\gamma_{\ell,\mathrm{theo}} \tag*{(56)}

Now to really evaluate the width of interest it is necessary to calculate the corresponding wave functions, for example from shell-model calculations, which is beyond this simple introduction. However, with a minimum of assumptions, notably a square well, it is possible to estimate these widths. Bohr and Mottelson then derive [10 page 440]:

Γsp={2ℏ2μR2kR vℓ 2ℓ−12ℓ+1if ℓ>0 and kR<ℓ1/2,2ℏ2μR2kRif ℓ=0(57)\Gamma_{sp} = \begin{cases} \frac{2\hbar^2}{\mu R^2} kR\,v_\ell\,\frac{2\ell-1}{2\ell+1} & \text{if } \ell> 0 \text{ and } kR < \ell^{1/2}, \\ \frac{2\hbar^2}{\mu R^2} kR & \text{if } \ell= 0 \end{cases} \tag*{(57)}

A systematic study, using this formalism, is presented in Figure 7 for the system 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B} + n, with the same conventions as in the § 4, despite the limits of definition of (57), which explains why some values are “missing” (but presented here for information as a dotted line). We see in particular that the larger ℓ\ell the smaller the width, which comes from the penetration factor effect.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Independent particle width as a function of energy of the resonance, according to the formalism of Bohr & Mottelson [10] and for ℓ=0\ell= 0, 1, 2 and 3 (respectively yellow, blue, magenta and green). We assume a 17B+n{}^{17}\mathrm{B} + n system. The dotted lines correspond to the case outside the necessary conditions for kR<ℓ1/2kR < \ell^{1/2}.

Multineutron resonances

The previous section presented two-body resonances and mainly fragment–neutron ones. Simple parametrizations for multi-body cases and three-body in particular are difficult because one of the assumption of the traditional RR-matrix approach is the “absence or unimportance of all processes in which more than two product nuclei are formed” [4] which means that the theory cannot be used immediately for at least three-body decays. More complex modelization and theoretical calculations are thus necessary. One of the difficulties, both theoretical and experimental, is that several decay paths and combinations of them open. We should note however that some attempts have been done in particular when the decay is sequential [11, 12], which in this case can be regarded as a two-step two-body process.

We would like to draw the attention on the fact that in absence of specific calculations authors generally extract the energy and the width of the “N-body” resonance using the parametrization described in the previous sections for two bodies. They sometimes also assume that NnN_n clustered neutrons participate to the resonance, as a multineutron “bound” system. In the authors’ opinion, in absence of any other model, and as far as the resonance shape does not resemble a virtual one, the only acceptable parametrization to be used is ℓ=0\ell= 0 because this one does not exhibit any energy dependence on the position and the width. As shown also on Figure 8 (left) there is also no dependence in the width with the NnN_n neutrons clustered in a two-body resonance. Most of these systems close to the drip line present a substantial extension (halo, skin. . . ) and a study of the effect of the radius r0r_0 (Figure 8, right) also shows that ℓ=0\ell= 0 distributions are independent of this parameter. One would have to be careful with the exact meaning of this width which, even if the experimental resolution is taken into account to extract it, would be difficult to compare to theory. Probably the best approach will then be to produce from the theoretical approach the energy distribution and then fit it with the same ℓ=0\ell= 0 distribution.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Left: dependence of the width for two-body resonances, for different ℓ\ell, function of the fraction of incident clustered neutrons. Right: same plot but function of the r0r_0 parameter used to calculate the fragment radius.

Conclusion

We presented in this paper a series of simple calculations to describe two-body resonances and alike. These results represent a parametrization often used to extract the properties of resonances measured experimentally, in particular for nuclei far from stability or beyond drip-lines. The main purpose of this article was to put them in perspective and illustrate the evolution of the measurable properties with their intrinsic parameters, in particular to the attention of physicists studying resonance properties and comparing them to theoretical models.

References

  1. [1]N. Austern, Direct nuclear reaction theories. Interscience Monographs And Texts In Physics And Astronomy (Wiley-Interscience, 1970). 30620
  2. [2]J.M. Blatt, V.F. Weisskopf, Theoretical Nuclear Physics (John Wiley and Sons, 1984)
  3. [3]G.R. Satchler, Introduction to Nuclear Reactions, 2nd edn. (Oxford University Press, 1990)
  4. [4]A.M. Lane, R.G. Thomas, R-matrix theory of nuclear reactions. Rev. Mod. Phys. 30, 257–353 (1958). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.30.257. URL http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.30.257
  5. [5]P. Descouvemont, D. Baye, The R-matrix theory. Reports on Progress in Physics 73(3), 036,301 (2010). URL http://stacks.iop.org/0034-4885/73/i=3/a=036301DOI
  6. [6]F. Gunsing, in Joliot-Curie School (2014). URL https://ejc2014.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2014/pages/20150420_ejc2014_gunsing_1_2.pdf
  7. [7]B. Gough, GNU Scientific Library Reference Manual - Third Edition, 3rd edn. (Network Theory Ltd., 2009)
  8. [8]K. McVoy, Virtual states and resonances. Nucl. Phys. A 115(3), 481 – 494 (1968). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0375-9474(68)90741-0. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/03759474687907410
  9. [9]A.M. Lane, Reduced widths of individual nuclear energy levels. Rev. Mod. Phys. 32, 519–566 (1960). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.32.519. URL http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.32.519
  10. [10]A. Bohr, B. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure (World Scientific Publishing Comp., Inc., 1998)
  11. [11]F.C. Barker, R-matrix formulas for three-body decay widths 68, 054602. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.68.054602. URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevC.68.054602
  12. [12]H.O.U. Fynbo, R. Álvarez-Rodríguez, A.S. Jensen, O.S. Kirsebom, D.V. Fedorov, E. Garrido, Three-body decays and R-matrix analyses 79, 054009. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.79.054009. URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevC.79.054009

Paper details

vlnc:W_x9vhrnux
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents