WorksEngineering
From Choirs to Solos: Reducing Multi-Cell Cooperation via Pinching Antennas
Abstract
This article investigates the potential of the pinching-antenna system (PASS) to reduce multi-cell cooperation requirements. Flexible pinching-antenna (PA) placement can enhance desired channel gains and reduce the required transmit power, which consequently alleviates inter-cell interference and the need for cooperative transmission. A two-cell PASS is considered, where the cooperation cost is quantified by the number of additional base station-user data associations. The cooperation cost is minimized subject to user signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio requirements and individual transmit-power constraints. Joint PA placement and transmission designs are developed using alternating optimization and second-order cone programming, while low-complexity zero-forcing-based alternatives are also proposed. Numerical results demonstrate that PASS substantially reduces cooperation requirements compared with the conventional fixed-antenna system. These findings highlight the potential of PASS to transform cooperative multi-cell *choirs*'' into independent solos''.
Introduction
The pinching-antenna system (PASS) has recently attracted considerable attention due to its ability to enhance wireless channel gains [1]. PASS employs dielectric waveguides to convey radio-frequency signals and pinching antennas (PAs) attached to the waveguides to radiate these signals into free space [2]. By flexibly adjusting the PA positions along the waveguides, PASS provides a much larger spatial reconfiguration range than conventional reconfigurable antenna systems. In particular, a PA can be placed close to its intended user to establish a favorable line-of-sight (LoS) link and mitigate propagation loss and signal blockage [1, 2].
These advantages have motivated extensive research on PASS, as summarized in recent surveys [3, 4, 5]. Most existing studies have focused on single-cell systems and investigated various physical-layer transmission designs. More recently, researchers have extended PASS to multi-cell networks. For example, stochastic-geometry-based studies have characterized network throughput [6, 7], while other works have investigated joint precoding, PA placement, and base station (BS)-user association [8, 9, 10]. Despite these advances, the potential of PASS to reduce inter-cell cooperation requirements remains largely unexplored.
In conventional fixed-antenna systems, serving cell-edge users often requires high transmit power due to large propagation distances. The resulting inter-cell interference (ICI) further increases the power needed to satisfy users’ quality-of-service (QoS) requirements in neighboring cells. A conventional solution is cooperative transmission, where multiple BSs jointly transmit user data through cooperative precoding.
However, this approach incurs additional overhead associated with user-data sharing, cooperative signal processing, and inter-BS synchronization. PASS offers an alternative through flexible PA placement. By placing PAs close to their intended users, PASS shortens the wireless propagation distances and establishes stronger LoS links [1]. The enhanced desired channel gains reduce the required transmit power [11] and consequently alleviate ICI [12]. Moreover, flexible PA placement can reshape the interference channels between neighboring cells. These advantages motivate an important question: Can PASS reduce or even eliminate the need for cooperative transmission while satisfying users’ QoS requirements?
Motivated by this question, we investigate cooperation reduction in multi-cell PASS through joint PA placement and transmission design. We consider a representative two-cell system, where each cell employs one waveguide with one active PA to serve its associated user. We quantify the cooperation cost by the number of additional BS-user data associations and aim to minimize this cost subject to user signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) and individual BS power constraints. To this end, we investigate three transmission modes: independent transmission, one-sided cooperation, and full cooperation. For each mode, we jointly optimize PA placement and transmit power or cooperative precoding to minimize the required peak transmit power. We develop an alternating optimization (AO) framework with second-order cone programming (SOCP) for the cooperative designs and further propose low-complexity zero-forcing (ZF)-based alternatives. Numerical results demonstrate that PASS substantially reduces cooperation requirements compared with the conventional fixed-antenna system and enables independent per-cell transmission even under stringent QoS requirements. These findings highlight the potential of PASS to transform multi-cell cooperative “choirs” into independent “solos”.
System Model
Consider the two-cell PASS illustrated in Figure 1. Each cell has length along the -axis and along the -axis. The center of cell is located at , and its service region is defined as . Each BS is equipped with a dielectric waveguide deployed along the -axis at height above the user plane. The waveguide spans the entire cell length, and one PA is activated on each waveguide. Let denote the PA position relative to the center of cell . Its three-dimensional location is given by . User is located at in cell and is primarily associated with BS . Both users are simultaneously served over the same time-frequency resource. A central controller has perfect knowledge of the user locations and position-dependent channel coefficients and jointly determines the PA positions and transmission configurations of both cells. The user locations and propagation environment remain unchanged during each scheduling period.

Figure 1. Illustration of a two-cell PASS.
Channel Model
PASS is particularly attractive for high-frequency communications [2], where LoS propagation typically dominates [13]. We thus consider LoS propagation between the PAs and users. The free-space channel coefficient from the PA in cell to user is modeled as follows [13]:
where , is the free-space wavelength, and is the free-space wavenumber. In addition to free-space propagation, the signal propagates along the dielectric waveguide from the feed point to the activated PA. Let denote the feed-point location of waveguide . The corresponding in-waveguide channel coefficient is modeled as follows:
where is the effective refractive index of the dielectric waveguide. The end-to-end channel coefficient from BS to user is therefore given by . Accordingly, the channel power gain is expressed as follows:
where and .
Cooperative Transmission
Let denote the unit-power information symbol intended for user . When cooperation is enabled, each BS may also transmit the neighboring user’s data, as illustrated in Figure 2. Let denote the digital precoding coefficient applied to at BS . The transmitted signal from BS is given by . In particular, for indicates that BS does not transmit user ’s data. The received signal at user is expressed as follows:

Figure 2. Illustration of two-cell cooperation.
where denotes the additive noise with power . Coherent inter-BS phase synchronization is assumed whenever joint transmission is activated. The SINR of user is given by
where . In conventional fixed-antenna systems, serving cell-edge users often requires high transmit power, which can cause substantial ICI. Cooperative precoding can mitigate ICI but incurs additional overhead due to inter-BS data sharing, signal processing, and synchronization.
Remark 1. PASS can substantially shorten the wireless propagation distances through flexible PA placement, which enhances the desired channel gains and reduces the required transmit power [11]. The reduced transmit power alleviates ICI [12]. Consequently, PASS may satisfy the same QoS requirements with less cooperative transmission than conventional fixed-antenna systems.
Define the cooperative precoding matrix as follows:
Under independent transmission, each BS transmits only its own user’s data, and is diagonal. When for , user ’s data must additionally be shared with BS . We therefore define the cooperation cost as follows:
where denotes the indicator function. Moreover, , , and correspond to independent transmission, one-sided cooperation, and two-sided cooperation, respectively, as illustrated in Figure 2.
Remark 2. The cooperation cost quantifies the number of additional cross-cell user-data associations beyond the primary BS-user associations. For an equal scheduled payload of bits per user, the associated additional user-data delivery requirement is bits per scheduling interval. In particular, eliminates additional cross-cell user-stream delivery and the requirement for coherent joint transmission. The proposed metric therefore captures a concrete component of cooperation-related operational burden.
Problem Formulation
Our objective is to minimize the cooperation cost required to satisfy both users’ QoS requirements under a per-BS transmit power budget . Let and let denote the common SINR target. The optimization problem can be formulated as follows:
To solve problem (1), we consider three cooperation levels and define the corresponding feasible precoding sets as follows:
, .
For each cooperation level , the minimum required peak transmit power is defined as follows:
We set if the corresponding problem is infeasible. Since , the minimum required powers satisfy . Consequently, the minimum cooperation cost is determined by
provided that . Otherwise, the QoS requirements cannot be satisfied even under full cooperation.
Joint PA Placement and Transmission Design
No Cooperation: C = 0
We first consider independent transmission, where . Let denote the transmit power of BS . For fixed PA positions , the SINR constraints reduce to
The componentwise minimum feasible power solution is obtained when both inequalities hold with equality. For notational simplicity, the arguments of the channel power gains are omitted hereafter. Define . When , the minimum required transmit powers are
Otherwise, no finite feasible power solution exists. The minimum required peak transmit power under independent transmission is thus given by , where
To address the coupling between the two PA positions, we adopt an element-wise AO method. Specifically, each PA position is optimized while the other is fixed:
Since each subproblem involves only one variable over a bounded interval, we employ a one-dimensional search. Specifically, the feasible interval is discretized into a -point grid . The PA position is then updated as follows:
where denotes the PA-position vector with its th entry replaced by . Candidate positions that do not yield finite feasible power solutions are discarded. The two PA positions are updated sequentially until convergence.
One-Sided Cooperation: C = 1
Under one-sided cooperation, at most one cross-cell data stream is allowed, i.e., either or . We optimize the two possible cooperation directions separately and select the one with the smaller required peak transmit power. For either direction, the joint design is addressed through AO between digital precoding and PA placement.
Digital Precoding Optimization
For fixed PA positions , the minimum peak-power precoding problem is formulated as follows:
together with the corresponding zero-entry constraint on . By rotating the phase of each user-stream precoder, the SINR constraints can be equivalently expressed as follows:
where and . Thus, the precoding problem can be reformulated as an SOCP and solved optimally for fixed using convex optimization solvers such as CVX.
PA Placement Optimization
For the optimized precoding matrix , define , where denotes the total power allocated to user stream . Let denote the normalized precoding directions. For fixed , define the effective channel gains . The SINR constraints then reduce to
Define . For , the minimum required stream powers are given by
Accordingly, for fixed precoding directions , the minimum required peak BS power is expressed as follows:
where if . We then optimize the two PA positions sequentially to minimize using the element-wise AO and one-dimensional search described in Section III-A. After convergence, the stream powers are updated by (3), and the precoding matrix is reconstructed as . The digital precoding and PA placement updates are repeated until convergence. The procedure is performed for both cooperation directions, and the solution with the smaller required peak power is selected.
Full Cooperation: C = 2
Under full cooperation, both BSs may transmit both users’ data streams, and the precoding matrix is unrestricted. The AO algorithm developed for one-sided cooperation directly applies to this case, except that the zero-entry constraint on is removed from (2).
ZF-Based Low-Complexity Design
To reduce the computational complexity of the SOCP-based design, we further develop a ZF-based approach that admits explicit peak-power expressions. Define the channel matrix
where and . We consider in the following ZF designs.
One-Sided Cooperation
We first consider , where BS 2 additionally transmits user 1’s data. By imposing , the interference caused by user 1’s stream at user 2 is eliminated. The resulting partial-ZF precoder is
where . It follows that
Thus, both users achieve the target SINR , and the required peak BS power can be written as follows:
where .
Similarly, for the opposite cooperation direction , the partial-ZF precoder is
where . The corresponding required peak BS power can be written as follows:
where . Both partial-ZF constructions achieve the target SINRs with equality.
The minimum required peak power under one-sided partial-ZF transmission is therefore
We optimize the two cooperation directions separately and select the better solution.
Full Cooperation
Under full cooperation, conventional ZF eliminates the inter-user interference at both users. The corresponding precoding matrix is given by
Since , both users achieve the target SINR . The required peak BS power is given by
The corresponding PA-placement problem is
PA Placement Optimization
The above designs yield three explicit peak-power objectives: , , and . Each objective depends only on the two PA positions. We therefore apply the element-wise AO method developed in Section III-A. Specifically, for , the PA positions are updated sequentially as
Candidates with are excluded. Since the current PA position is included in each search, the objective value is non-increasing over successive updates.
Remark 3. Unlike the SOCP-based design, the proposed ZF-based approach only requires evaluations of closed-form power expressions during PA placement. However, the additional interference-nulling constraints may increase the required transmit power. Therefore, the ZF-based solutions provide low-complexity feasible designs rather than globally optimal solutions to the original problem.
Computational Complexity Analysis
Let , , and denote the numbers of AO iterations for independent transmission, SOCP-based cooperation, and ZF-based cooperation, respectively. Their computational complexities are , , and , respectively, where is the number of inner PA-position AO iterations and is an interior-point complexity estimate for one SOCP, with and real optimization variables for one-sided and full cooperation, respectively, and the solution accuracy. Thus, both cooperative designs scale linearly with , while the ZF-based design avoids the additional SOCP complexity.
Numerical Results
In this section, we evaluate the cooperation cost of PASS and compare it with the conventional fixed-antenna system, where each antenna is deployed at the cell center. Unless otherwise stated, the carrier frequency is GHz, the noise power is dBm, the effective refractive index is , and the waveguide height is m. Two adjacent cells are considered, each with dimensions m and m and one uniformly distributed user, as illustrated in Figure 1. The proposed SOCP-based design is initialized using the ZF-based solutions. Each one-dimensional PA search employs a uniform grid of points. The target rate is , where Gaussian signaling is assumed and interference is treated as noise. The power budget is set to the 60th percentile of the minimum peak transmit power required by the conventional fixed-antenna system with ZF-based full cooperation. This value is estimated using Monte-Carlo realizations and recalculated as or varies. The cooperation cost is capped at for all realizations where the SINR requirements cannot be satisfied.
Figure 3(a) compares the average cooperation cost of the conventional fixed-antenna system, nearest-PA placement, and optimized PA placement under SOCP-based and ZF-based precoding. Here, nearest-PA placement positions each PA at the projection of its intended user onto the corresponding waveguide, i.e., for . All four PASS schemes achieve substantially lower cooperation costs than their conventional counterparts. This improvement is primarily attributed to the spatial flexibility of PASS, which enhances the desired channels and alleviates ICI. The proposed optimized PA placement further outperforms nearest-PA placement, particularly for small cell lengths. For example, at m, the average cooperation cost is reduced from 0.69 to 0.57 under SOCP-based precoding. As increases, the cooperation costs decrease for all schemes, while the performance gap between the two PA placement strategies becomes negligible. Furthermore, ZF-based precoding achieves performance close to that of SOCP-based precoding, which demonstrates its effectiveness for cooperation reduction. Figure 3(b) shows the average cooperation cost versus the target rate . As expected, the cooperation cost increases with , since higher SINR requirements make independent transmission more difficult. Nevertheless, PASS consistently outperforms the conventional fixed-antenna system. Remarkably, even at bps/Hz, the proposed PASS achieves an average cooperation cost below 0.2, compared with approximately 1.6 for the conventional fixed-antenna system. The relatively small difference between nearest-PA and optimized PA placement further indicates that simple geometry-based PA placement can capture most of the cooperation reduction benefits. This highlights the practicality of PASS, as substantial cooperation savings can be achieved without sophisticated PA placement optimization.

Figure 3. Average cooperation cost.
To further characterize the potential of PASS for independent transmission, Figure 4 presents the probability of zero cooperation, . As shown in Figure 4(a), this probability increases with for all schemes, but PASS achieves a substantially higher probability than the conventional fixed-antenna system. Figure 4(b) shows that decreases with due to the increasingly stringent SINR requirements. Nevertheless, the proposed PASS maintains a probability above 0.8 even at bps/Hz, whereas the conventional fixed-antenna system achieves less than 0.1. These results demonstrate that PASS can substantially reduce inter-BS data sharing and enable a transition from cooperative transmission

Figure 4. Probability of zero cooperation .
to independent cell operation.
Conclusion
This article has demonstrated that flexible PA placement can substantially reduce multi-cell cooperation requirements and transform cooperative “choirs” into independent “solos”. Moreover, nearest-PA placement achieves performance close to that of the proposed joint design, which makes it an attractive low-complexity alternative.
References
References
- [1]Y. Liu, Z. Wang, X. Mu, C. Ouyang, X. Xu, and Z. Ding, “Pinching antenna systems (PASS): Architectures, opportunities, and outlook,” IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 64, no. 1, pp. 190–196, Jan. 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2501.18409
- [2]A. Fukuda, H. Yamamoto, H. Okazaki, Y. Suzuki, and K. Kawai, “Pinching antenna: Using a dielectric waveguide as an antenna,” NTT DOCOMO Technical J., vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 5–12, Jan. 2022.
- [3]Y. Liu, H. Jiang, X. Xu, Z. Wang, J. Guo, C. Ouyang, X. Mu, Z. Ding, A. Nallanathan, G. K. Karagiannidis et al., “Pinching-antenna systems (PASS): A tutorial,” IEEE Trans. Commun., vol. 74, pp. 4881–4918, 2026.DOI
- [4]Y. Lu, W. Mao, X. Xie, S. Liao, X. Xu, Y. Lin, R. Zhang, B. Ai, X. Wang, and Z. Ding, “A survey on pinching-antenna systems: Optimization techniques, intelligent designs, and multifunctional applications,” IEEE Commun. Surveys Tuts., vol. 28, pp. 6592–6627, 2026.DOI
- [5]Y. Liu, H. Jiang, X. Gan, X. Xu, J. Guo, Z. Wang, C. Ouyang, X. Mu, Z. Ding, A. Nallanathan, O. A. Dobre, G. K. Karagiannidis, and R. Schober, “A survey on pinching-antenna systems (PASS),” IEEE Commun. Surveys Tuts., vol. 28, pp. 7250–7280, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2601.18927
- [6]Y. Zhu, Z. Ding, and X. You, “Topological perspective of large-scale multi-cell deployment of excitable waveguide dielectrics,” IEEE Wireless Commun. Lett., vol. 15, pp. 151–155, 2026.DOI
- [7]Y. Sun, Z. Ding, and G. K. Karagiannidis, “A stochastic geometric analysis on multi-cell pinching-antenna systems under blockage effect,” IEEE Wireless Commun. Lett., vol. 15, pp. 1085–1089, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2510.06972
- [8]Y. Chen, Q. Xue, M. Hua, B. Zhou, and S. Ma, “Pinching-antenna enabled multicell wireless systems,” IEEE Trans. Wireless Commun., vol. 25, pp. 24226–24240, 2026.DOI
- [9]H. Li, J. Lei, C. Zeng, Z. Hu, C. Dong, and Y. Liu, “Pinching antenna systems (PASS) for cell-free communications,” IEEE Trans. Veh. Tech., Early Access, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2510.03628
- [10]Y. Jiang, J. Zhang, Z. Liu, C. Ouyang, J. Zheng, Y. Liu, A. Nallanathan, and B. Ai, “Pinching antennas-enabled cell-free massive MIMO: Two-stage AP–UE association and pinching beamforming optimization,” IEEE Trans. Veh. Tech., Early Access, 2026.DOI
- [11]Z. Ding, “Toward a quiet wireless world: Multi-cell pinching-antenna transmission,” IEEE Wireless Commun. Lett., vol. 15, pp. 3791–3795, 2026.
- [12]——, “Characterizing multi-cell pinching-antenna transmission: Revealing the other side of the coin,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.09585, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.09585
- [13]C. Ouyang, Z. Wang, Y. Chen, X. Mu, and P. Zhu, “Cooperation for near-field communications for next-generation multiple access,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 112, no. 9, pp. 1527–1565, Sep. 2024.