betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Contact 3-manifolds with infinitely many rational homology ball Stein fillings

Abstract

We construct the first examples of contact 33-manifolds admitting infinitely many pairwise non-homeomorphic Stein fillings which are rational homology balls. Our examples are planar. They are obtained by a simple modification of Baykur's recent planar contact 33-manifold (Y,ξ)(Y,ξ) with infinitely many pairwise non-homeomorphic Stein fillings, and the fillings are distinguished by their fundamental groups. For one of these rational homology balls we give an explicit Kirby diagram, with a single 11-handle and a single 22-handle attached along a trefoil, which exhibits its boundary as (0,−8)(0,-8)-surgery on a two-component link. We also identify the smooth topology of Baykur's example: YY is obtained by (0,−8)(0,-8)-surgery on the link 7427^2_4, and it is Seifert fibered over the Klein bottle with one exceptional fiber. Finally, we construct further Stein fillings of (Y,ξ)(Y,ξ), which realize all the groups Z/m⋊−1Z\mathbb Z/m\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb Z, m≥0m\ge0, as their fundamental groups.

Introduction

A contact 33–manifold is said to be planar if it is supported by a planar open book—an open book whose pages have genus zero. Wendl showed that if a contact 33–manifold is supported by a planar open book (Σ,ϕ)(\Sigma,\phi), then every minimal strong symplectic filling of it, after attaching a trivial symplectic cobordism to its boundary, admits an allowable Lefschetz fibration over D2D^2 with fiber Σ\Sigma and monodromy ϕ\phi, inducing the given open book on the boundary [35]. As a consequence, the Stein fillings of a planar contact 33–manifold are governed by the positive factorizations of the monodromy of any planar open book supporting the contact 33–manifold at hand.

Contact 33–manifolds with infinitely many pairwise non-homeomorphic Stein fillings were first constructed by Stipsicz and the author [32], more than twenty years ago. Baykur [20] recently constructed planar examples, answering Problem 4.105 of the K3 problem list [21]. His basic example (Y,ξ)(Y,\xi) is supported by the open book

(Σ06,ϕ),ϕ=td B,B=tutvtwtz,(\Sigma_0^6,\phi),\qquad \phi=t_d\,B,\qquad B=t_ut_vt_wt_z,

whose page Σ06\Sigma_0^6 is a sphere with six holes, and tct_c denotes the right-handed Dehn twist along a simple closed curve cc on the page. The curves u,v,w,z,d⊂Σ06u,v,w,z,d \subset \Sigma_0^6 are depicted below in Figure 1. A crucial observation of Baykur is that the curve α\alpha of Figure 6 satisfies [B,tα]=1[B,t_\alpha]=1. The Stein fillings XnX_n, for n≥0n\ge0, are given by the Lefschetz fibrations corresponding to the positive factorizations td tα nB tα−nt_d\,t_\alpha^{\,n}B\,t_\alpha^{-n} of ϕ\phi, and Baykur distinguishes them by their fundamental groups Z/(2n+1)⋊−1Z\mathbb Z/(2n+1)\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb Z. Here and below, for cyclic groups AA and BB, we write A⋊−1BA\rtimes_{-1}B for the semidirect product in which a generator of BB acts on AA by inversion.

Throughout, for an allowable positive factorization μ=tc1⋯tcn\mu=t_{c_1}\cdots t_{c_n} (with every cic_i homologically nontrivial) of a mapping class of a compact surface Σ\Sigma with boundary, M(Σ,μ)M(\Sigma, \mu) denotes the 33–manifold given by the open book with page Σ\Sigma and monodromy μ\mu, and X(Σ;c1,…,cn)X(\Sigma;c_1,\ldots,c_n) denotes the total space of the Lefschetz fibration over the disk with fiber Σ\Sigma and vanishing cycles c1,…,cnc_1,\ldots,c_n, in the order of the factors, equipped with the Stein structure provided by [19, 30]. Note that X(Σ;c1,…,cn)X(\Sigma;c_1,\ldots,c_n) is a Stein filling of the contact manifold supported by the open book (Σ,μ)(\Sigma,\mu).

Rational homology ball fillings. Our main result is obtained by varying Baykur’s construction. Recall that α\alpha is the round curve enclosing the holes δ1,δ2\delta_1,\delta_2 (see Figure 6). For a homologically nontrivial simple closed curve cc on the page, let (Yc,ξc)(Y_c,\xi_c) be the planar contact 33–manifold supported by the open book (Σ06,tcB)(\Sigma_0^6,t_cB), and let

Xn(c)=X(Σ06;c, tα n(u), tα n(v), tα n(w), tα n(z)),n≥0,X_n(c)=X(\Sigma_0^6;c,\,t_\alpha^{\,n}(u),\,t_\alpha^{\,n}(v),\,t_\alpha^{\,n}(w),\,t_\alpha^{\,n}(z)),\qquad n\ge0 ,

which are Stein fillings of (Yc,ξc)(Y_c,\xi_c), since tαt_\alpha commutes with BB. For c=dc=d these are Baykur’s (Y,ξ)(Y,\xi) and XnX_n. The fundamental groups of the fillings Xn(c)X_n(c) can be computed directly from a word representing cc, and we do this for two natural families of curves. Let c12c_{12} and c345c_{345} be the round curves enclosing the holes δ1,δ2\delta_1,\delta_2 and δ3,δ4,δ5\delta_3,\delta_4,\delta_5, respectively, and recall that the vanishing cycle uu is the round curve enclosing δ2,δ3\delta_2,\delta_3. For a positive integer mm we set

dm=tum(c12),dm′=tum(c345).d_m=t_u^m(c_{12}),\qquad d'_m=t_u^m(c_{345}).

The simplest members are d1=tu(c12)d_1=t_u(c_{12}), and d1′=tu(c345)d'_1=t_u(c_{345}) (see Figure 10). We write (Ym,ξm)(Y_m,\xi_m) and (Ym′,ξm′)(Y'_m,\xi'_m) for the contact 33–manifolds (Yc,ξc)(Y_c,\xi_c) with c=dmc=d_m and c=dm′c=d'_m, and Xm,nX_{m,n} and Xm,n′X'_{m,n} for their Stein fillings Xn(c)X_n(c).

Theorem 1.1. Let mm be a positive integer. Then the following hold.

  1. The planar contact 33–manifolds (Ym,ξm)(Y_m,\xi_m) and (Ym′,ξm′)(Y'_m,\xi'_m) are rational homology spheres with H1(Ym;Z)≅Z/4⊕Z/4,H1(Ym′;Z)≅Z/2⊕Z/2⊕Z/4.H_1(Y_m;\mathbb Z)\cong\mathbb Z/4\oplus\mathbb Z/4,\qquad H_1(Y'_m;\mathbb Z)\cong\mathbb Z/2\oplus\mathbb Z/2\oplus\mathbb Z/4 . In particular, no YmY_m is homeomorphic to any Ym′′Y'_{m'}.

  2. The Stein fillings Xm,nX_{m,n} of (Ym,ξm)(Y_m,\xi_m), n≥0n\ge0, are rational homology balls with π1(Xm,n)≅Z/(4mn+1)⋊−1Z/4,H1(Xm,n;Z)≅Z/4.\pi_1(X_{m,n})\cong\mathbb Z/(4mn+1)\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb Z/4,\qquad H_1(X_{m,n};\mathbb Z)\cong\mathbb Z/4 .

  3. The Stein fillings Xm,n′X'_{m,n} of (Ym′,ξm′)(Y'_m,\xi'_m), n≥0n\ge0, are rational homology balls with π1(Xm,n′)≅⟨r,b∣brb−1=r−1, b2=r4mn⟩,H1(Xm,n′;Z)≅Z/2⊕Z/2.\pi_1(X'_{m,n})\cong\langle r,b\mid brb^{-1}=r^{-1},\ b^2=r^{4mn}\rangle,\qquad H_1(X'_{m,n};\mathbb Z)\cong\mathbb Z/2\oplus\mathbb Z/2 . For n≥1n\ge1 the group π1(Xm,n′)\pi_1(X'_{m,n}) is the dicyclic group of order 16mn16mn, and for n=0n=0 it is the infinite dihedral group Z⋊−1Z/2\mathbb Z\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb Z/2.

  4. The Stein fillings of each of these contact 33–manifolds are pairwise non-homeomorphic.

The fillings in each family have the same homology, so they are distinguished only by their fundamental groups. The orders of the first homology groups fit together as they must: ∣H1(Ym;Z)∣=∣H1(Ym′;Z)∣=16\lvert H_1(Y_m;\mathbb Z)\rvert=\lvert H_1(Y'_m;\mathbb Z)\rvert=16 is the square of ∣H1(Xm,n;Z)∣=∣H1(Xm,n′;Z)∣=4\lvert H_1(X_{m,n};\mathbb Z)\rvert=\lvert H_1(X'_{m,n};\mathbb Z)\rvert=4, in accordance with the fact that ∣H1(∂W;Z)∣=∣H1(W;Z)∣2\lvert H_1(\partial W;\mathbb Z)\rvert=\lvert H_1(W;\mathbb Z)\rvert^2 for every rational homology ball WW with H2(W;Z)=0H_2(W;\mathbb Z)=0, for example a Stein one.

References

  1. [19]S. Akbulut and B. Ozbagci, Lefschetz fibrations on compact Stein surfaces, Geom. Topol. 5 (2001), 319--334.
  2. [20]R. İ. Baykur, Planar contact $3$--manifolds with infinitely many Stein fillings, arXiv:2607.21303v1 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.21303
  3. [21]R. İ. Baykur, R. C. Kirby, and D. Ruberman (eds.), K3: a new problem list in low-dimensional topology, Math. Surveys Monogr., vol. 295, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2026.
  4. [22]M. Bhupal and A. I. Stipsicz, Weighted homogeneous singularities and rational homology disk smoothings, Amer. J. Math. 133 (2011), no. 5, 1259--1297.
  5. [23]B. A. Burton, R. Budney, W. Pettersson, et al., Regina: Software for low-dimensional topology, https://regina-normal.github.io.regina-normal.github.io
  6. [24]M. Culler, N. M. Dunfield, M. Goerner and J. R. Weeks, SnapPy, a computer program for studying the geometry and topology of $3$--manifolds, http://snappy.computop.org.snappy.computop.org
  7. [25]J. B. Etnyre and B. Ozbagci, Invariants of contact structures from open books, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 360 (2008), no. 6, 3133--3151.
  8. [26]J. B. Etnyre, B. Ozbagci and B. Tosun, Symplectic rational homology ball fillings of Seifert fibered spaces, Adv. Math. 482 (2025), Paper No. 110572.
  9. [27]J. B. Etnyre, B. Ozbagci and B. Tosun, Complementary legs and symplectic rational balls, J. London Math. Soc. (2) 114 (2026): e70744.
  10. [28]R. E. Gompf and A. I. Stipsicz, $4$-manifolds and Kirby calculus, Graduate Studies in Mathematics, vol. 20, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1999.
  11. [29]C. Livingston and A. H. Moore, LinkInfo: Table of Link Invariants, https://linkinfo.sitehost.iu.edu.linkinfo.sitehost.iu.edu
  12. [30]A. Loi and R. Piergallini, Compact Stein surfaces with boundary as branched covers of $B^4$, Invent. Math. 143 (2001), 325--348.
  13. [31]T. Oba and B. Ozbagci, Canonical contact unit cotangent bundle, Adv. Geom. 18 (2018), no. 4, 405--424.
  14. [32]B. Ozbagci and A. I. Stipsicz, Contact $3$--manifolds with infinitely many Stein fillings, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 132 (2004), no. 5, 1549--1558.
  15. [33]D. Rolfsen, Knots and links, Mathematics Lecture Series, vol. 7, Publish or Perish, Berkeley, CA, 1976.
  16. [34]F. Swenton, KLO (Knot-Like Objects), software, https://KLO-software.net.KLO-software.net
  17. [35]C. Wendl, Strongly fillable contact manifolds and $J$-holomorphic foliations, Duke Math. J. 151 (2010), no. 3, 337--384.
  18. [36]G. Wilkes, Profinite rigidity for Seifert fibre spaces, Geom. Dedicata 188 (2017), 141--163.

Paper details

vlnc:W_xhupbbbu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

LLM tools

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents