Preface
Over the last few decades, Born-Oppenheimer (BO) and Born-Oppenheimer-Huang (BOH) treatments for electron-nuclear equation of motion have been considered as the cornerstone for qualitative as well as quantitative exploration and understanding of chemical and physical processes. The BO approximation due to the large mass difference between electrons and nuclei as well as the energy separation among the electronic states could able to predict some of the processes (chemical and physical) satisfactorily at lower energy regime. Such approximation (BO) quite often fails for those cases with the involvement of excited electronic states, in particular, due to the coupling among the states. On the other hand, the BO treatment provides two important quantities, namely, the adiabatic potential energy surfaces (PESs) and the nonadiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) determining the forces, which control the motion of the nuclei in a molecule. The NACTs play a major role in photoexcitation spectra, charge transfer chemical reactions, ferroelectric property and other processes, where significant anomalies are observed between single and multiple PES(s) results. Since the NACTs often exhibit singularity at the close vicinity of degenerate states forming conical intersections (CIs), such coupling terms could break the symmetry of the molecular processes changing the observables qualitatively.
The BOH treatment brings the electron-nuclear equation of motion from time-independent/time-dependent Schrödinger Equation (TISE/TDSE) known as adiabatic representation, where the NACTs could raise the issue of conservation of energy as well as numerical inaccuracies due to their (often) singular nature in the configuration space (CS). While traversing along a contour of nuclear coordinates enclosing CI(s), BO adiabatic eigenfunction undergoes phase change and such multivalued feature of the wavefunction can be taken care by multiplying a complex phase factor known as Longuet-Higgins (LH) phase. Later on, such phase could be correlated with the topological feature of NACTs originating from the BO treatment. In all practical purposes, such singular terms are of real concern and can be removed by adapting a different representation known as diabatic SE. In other words, a transition to beyond Born-Oppenheimer (BBO) regime is indeed necessary to provide an equivalent description of the molecular processes, where the equations of motion are theoretically “exact” and numerically “accurate”. Such transition can be achieved through a unitary transformation of the adiabatic SE to diabatic one known as adiabatic-to-diabatic transformation (ADT). In BBO treatment, the kinetically coupled matrix equations are transformed to the potentially coupled ones possessing well-behaved smooth functions of nuclear coordinates. Later on, BBO theory has been generalized for three or more coupled electronic states with explicit expressions of NACTs, ADT equations, curl-divergence equations and diabatic PESs as functions of nuclear coordinate dependent ADT angles. For a given sub-Hilbert space (SHS), an accurate transformation to the diabatic framework is ensured if the NACT vector fields fulfill curl condition . Though the ADT transformation does not provide unique diabatic Hamiltonian (DH) and those DHs depend on the path of the contour integration, calculated observables from DHs for spectroscopy and scattering processes will be unique and can be compared with experimental result as those DHs are related with each other through an orthogonal similarity transformation.
As a complete theory, BBO treatment has been explored for various floppy molecules of spectroscopic interest, like Na3 _3 3 , K3 _3 3 , NO2 _2 2 , NO3 _3 3 , C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + , 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^+ 3 + and C4 _4 4 N2 _2 2 H4 _4 4 ; reaction dynamics involving multiple electronic states, like H3 + _3^+ 3 + , HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + , F+H2 _2 2 and H3 _3 3 as well as solid state systems, like MnO6 9 − _6^{9-} 6 9 − and TiO6 8 − _6^{8-} 6 8 − exhibiting phase transition. Such systems are rich in exhibiting strong Jahn-Teller (JT), Renner-Teller (RT) and pseudo Jahn-Teller (PJT) effects. Since the first principle based BBO theory is expected to generate single-valued, continuous and smooth diabatic PESs to perform nuclear dynamics, this approach could able to reproduce experimental spectroscopic (spectra) and scattering results (cross-sections and rate constants).
The aim of this book is to reach the broad community, who are working in the realm of nonadiabatic dynamics connected with the development and application of BBO theory as well as other contemporary approaches over the last few decades. Chapter 1 depicts an extensive review in the field of BBO and other theories, triatomic scattering and molecule-surface reaction dynamics. On the other hand, Chapters 2 to 5 demonstrate the detailed theoretical development on the formulation of BBO treatment as well as its associated basic mathematical theorems. Chapters 6 and 7 present the applications of BBO theory on nonadiabatic chemistry in spectroscopic and reactive scattering, respectively. The NACTs as friction in classical EOM for reaction dynamics is described in Chapter 8. Chapters 9 and 10 display the theory and application of Jahn-Teller effect (JTE) in phase transition of solids as well as electron-phonon and electron-hole pair couplings in molecule-surface scattering, respectively.
Our work on nonadiabatic chemistry and in physical phenomena employing BBO vis-a-vis JTE theory are presented as below:
The Period, 2003 - 2011: In this period, my former Ph.D students, Professors Dr. Panchanan Puzari (Tezpur Central University), Dr. Manabendra Sarma (IITG, Guwahati), Dr. Biplab Sarkar (North Eastern Hill University) and Dr. Amit Kumar Paul (Bose Institute, Kolkata) were primarily involved in generalizing the BBO theory for three and four coupled electronic manifold with explicit expressions of NACTs, ADT equations, curl-divergence equations and diabatic PESs as functions of nuclear coordinate dependent ADT angles. In order to explore the workability of such formalism, model diabatic Hamiltonian and non-adiabatic coupling matrix (NACM) were chosen for spectroscopic and scattering systems, like, Na3 _3 3 (Cocchini model), C2 _2 2 H (a b i n i t i o ab\ initio ab ini t i o data from Baer et. al. ) etc. In addition, Prof. Dr. Panchanan Puzari (Tezpur Central University) and Dr. Subhankar Sardar (Bhatter College, West Bengal) contributed in the development of the program for time-dependent discrete variable representation (TDDVR) dynamics and applied this approach on the vibronic coupling model (VCM) based diabatic Hamiltonian of several molecules, like, pyrazine, butatriene, benzene, allene, monofluoro benzene, isomers of difluoro benzene, trifluoro acetonitrile and many others. On the other hand, Dr. Tapas Sahoo (Haldia Institute of Technology) was engaged in the development of fully closed-coupled (FCC) reactive scattering and molecule-surface scattering formalism.
The Period, 2011 - 2019: During this time, Dr. Saikat Mukherjee (Nicolaus Copernicus University, Poland), Dr. Satyam Ravi (Vellore Institute of Technology, Bhopal), Dr. Srijeeta Talukder (Adamas University, Kolkata), Dr. Sandip Ghosh (Ram Ratan Singh College, Patna), Dr. Bijit Mukherjee (NISER, Bhubaneswar) and Dr. Soumya Mukherjee (Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology, Bhopal) were involved in calculating a b i n i t i o ab\ initio ab ini t i o PESs and NACTs for realistic molecular systems of spectroscopic interest, like Na3 _3 3 , K3 _3 3 (Dr. Saikat Mukherjee), NO2 _2 2 (Dr. Saikat Mukherjee and Dr. Subhankar Sardar) and NO3 _3 3 (Dr. Bijit Mukherjee) as well as triatomic reactive scattering processes involving multiple electronic states, like H+ ^+ + (Dr. Saikat Mukherjee and Dr. Sandip Ghosh) and F+H2 _2 2 (Dr. Bijit Mukherjee). In case of spectroscopic systems, adiabatic PESs and NACTs were diabatized followed by dynamical calculations using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) - Lanczos and TDDVR approaches to generate the spectral envelop. For scattering processes, the BBO based diabatic Hamiltonian were constructed to carry out FCC dynamics to compute reaction cross-sections and rate constants. On the other hand, Dr. Sandip Ghosh executed FCC scattering dynamics on D+ ^+ + +H2 _2 2 , O+OH, H+O2 _2 2 systems to calculate the reaction attributes. Dr. Souvik Mandal (University of Strasbourg, France) applied the molecule-surface scattering formalism on D2 _2 2 -Cu(111) and H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 -Ni(111) systems. The JTE theory for the ground and excited state of d4 ^4 4 /d9 ^9 9 systems was reformulated to evaluate the roto-vibrational states as function of barrier height including anharmonicity and the satelite peaks of ellipsometric experiment were reproduced by Dr. Joy Dutta (Durham University,
UK). The model Hamiltonian based approach was modified through ab initio calculations for the same manganate systems by Dr. Joy Dutta (Durham University, UK) and Dr. Satyam Ravi (Vellore Institute of Technology, Bhopal).
The Period, 2019 - 2026: (a) A generalized algorithm and user-friendly OpenMP parallelized program, “ADT” (see doi:10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00948 or https://github.com/AdhikariLAB/ADT-Program ) has been developed to perform symbolic manipulation for the formulation of ADT equations and to carry out numerical calculation of various ADT quantities (like ADT equations, ADT matrix elements, diabatic potential energy matrix elements, etc.). This program package can interface various quantum chemistry softwares, like, Molpro, Columbus, Gamess and Gaussian to produce adiabatic PESs and NACTs (input data) and thereafter, to construct diabatic PESs matrices. The development of “ADT” software is primarily carried out by Dr. Koushik Naskar (NextGen Invent, India), where Dr. Soumya Mukherjee (Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology, Bhopal) and Dr. Satyam Ravi (Vellore Institute of Technology, Bhopal) were involved for smooth implementation of the package. In addition, BBO theory was applied to construct diabatic Hamiltonian of spectroscopic systems, namely, C 6 H 6 + \mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}^{+} C 6 H 6 + , 1 , 3 , 5 - C 6 H 3 F 3 + 1,3,5\text{-}\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{3}\mathrm{F}_{3}^{+} 1 , 3 , 5 - C 6 H 3 F 3 + (Dr. Soumya Mukherjee), C 4 N 2 H 4 \mathrm{C}_{4}\mathrm{N}_{2}\mathrm{H}_{4} C 4 N 2 H 4 (Dr. Saikat Hazra) and C 5 H 4 N \mathrm{C}_{5}\mathrm{H}_{4}\mathrm{N} C 5 H 4 N (Dr. Tirthendu Sen and Mr. Avik Guchait), scattering processes, like H e H 2 + \mathrm{HeH}_{2}^{+} HeH 2 + and F + H 2 \mathrm{F}+\mathrm{H}_{2} F + H 2 (Dr. Koushik Naskar), H 3 + \mathrm{H}_{3}^{+} H 3 + (Dr. Sandip Ghosh and Dr. Saikat Hazra) and H 3 \mathrm{H}_{3} H 3 (Mr. Amarendra Ghosh and Mr. Ahitagni Roy) as well as unit cell of perovskites, like M n O 6 9 − \mathrm{MnO}_{6}^{9-} MnO 6 9 − (Dr. Joy Dutta) and T i O 8 − \mathrm{TiO}_{8}^{-} TiO 8 − (Dr. Mantu Kumar Sah). The implementation of BBO as well as JTE theory on perovskites was primarily carried out by Dr. Mantu Kumar Sah and Dr. Joy Dutta.
(b) The multi-state classical equation of motion considering NACTs as friction has been formulated and investigated to explore the formation of triatomic molecular species and to calculate cross-sections for H 3 + \mathrm{H}_{3}^{+} H 3 + and H e H 2 + \mathrm{HeH}_{2}^{+} HeH 2 + systems (Mr. Avik Guchait and Dr. Soumya Mukherjee in collaboration with Professor N. Satyamurthy and Professor M. Baer) in comparison with Trajectory Surface Hopping (TSH) and experimental data. Recently, a mixed Open-MP as well as MPI parallelized program, “abc_hyp” has been developed to carry out triatomic reactive scattering calculations, which can perform both adiabatic (single) as well as diabatic (multi-state) FCC time-dependent wave packet (TDWP) quantum dynamics in hyperspherical coordinates and generate reaction probabilities, state-to-state and integral cross-sections, rate constants as well as differential cross-sections for comparison with other theoretical and experimental data.
This book is a followup of our works carried out in collaboration and discussion with national and international colleagues, where other contemporary theoretical developments as well experimental results are discussed in length. In particular, we wish to thank the internationally well-known scientists, Professor Michael Baer, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel; Professor António Joaquim de Campos Varandas, University of Coimbra, Portugal; Professor Jörn Manz, Freie Universität, Berlin; Professor Kazuo Takatsuka, The University of Tokyo, Japan; Professor Peter Saalfrank, University of Potsdam, Germany; Professor Natalia N. Kovaleva, Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Professor Geert-Jan Kroes, Professor Mark Somers and Professor Jörg Meyer, Leiden University; and Professor Jean Christophe Tremblay, Theoretical and Physical Chemistry Lab, Université de Lorraine, France. We also thank Professor N. Sathyamurthy and Dr. K. R. Shamasundar, IISER Mohali, Mohali; Professor Debasis Mukhopadhyay and Professor Pinaki Chowdhuri, University of Calcutta; Dr. Rahul Sharma, St. Xavier’s College for collaborative research works. On various occasions, we discuss on critical topics in quantum mechanics with senior colleagues, Professor Debashis Mukherjee, IACS Kolkata; Professor Sankar Prasad Bhattacharya, IACS Kolkata; Professor K. L. Sebastian, IISc Bangalore; Professor Deb Shankar Ray, IACS Kolkata; Professor Sourav Pal, Ashoka University.
I am grateful to extramural funding agencies, namely, Science and Engineering Research Board (SERB), Anusandhan National Research Foundation (ANRF), Board of Research in Nuclear Sciences (BRNS), Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) as well as our institute, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science (IACS), Kolkata for research grants to make a summary of our teaching and research work in the form of a book.
Professor Satrajit Adhikari IACS, Kolkata, India
Abbreviations
Table 1.
Chapter 1
Introduction
Theory of Electron-Nuclear Couplings
For over a century, Born-Oppenheimer (BO) theory1 and its generalization by Born and Huang2 appear as a cornerstone in Quantum Chemistry for investigating static and dynamic properties of molecular species, chemical reactions and the phenomena in solid state physics. As per the BO treatment, the electronic motion shows parametric dependence on the nuclei due to the huge mass difference of electrons and nuclei. Such difference introduces the BO approximation, which is expected to be applicable successfully only for few chemical and physical processes occurring at lower energy domain of ground electronic state. On the contrary, a wide variety of molecular phenomena can be observed, which clearly indicates breakdown of BO approximation, specifically at the close vicinity of conical intersection(s) (CIs) / seam(s) arising from degeneracy(ies) between the electronic states. In other words, such failure primarily originates due to the coupling between electronic and nuclear motion leading to nonadiabatic events. Those degeneracies (CIs/seams) are omnipresent in various processes, namely, photosynthesis, vision, charge transfer chemical reactions, solar energy conversion to photochemical reactions engaging multiple electronic states,3–6 which cannot be probed with enough “precision" from single electronic state BO perspective. As a result, the nonadiabatic phenomena and the breakdown of BO approximation are frequently observed in nature, which demands an extensive consideration of electron-nuclear couplings for accurate description of chemical and physical processes.
The adiabatic potential energy surfaces (PESs) and the nonadiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) are the two major outcomes of BO treatment, where both the quantities (PESs and NACTs) govern the nuclear motion in a molecular event. In this treatment, the electron Hamiltonian produces adiabatic PESs, which are physically realizable dictating the movement of the nuclei on a specific PES. On the other hand, the momentum couplings between the nuclear and electronic motion represented by NACTs dictate the transition of the nuclei among the PESs and thereby, multiple state processes, can only be understood by incorporating such couplings in the structure and dynamics calculations. Several earlier research works unveiled that calculations on photoexcitation spectra,7–9 charge transfer chemical reactions,10,11 scattering cross sections5,12–18 and phase transition of solids19 exhibit substantial disparities between single and multiple surface cases along with experimental results, which indicates the necessity of transition from BO approximation to beyond Born-Oppenheimer (BBO) treatment for more accurate calculations of any molecular process.
In order to investigate multi-state nuclear dynamics involving electronic transitions from one surface to another, one needs to incorporate the NACTs in the nuclear Schrödinger Equation (SE), which often appear as singular functions20,21 at the close neighborhood of degenerate point(s)/seam(s). As a matter of fact, the major bottleneck of adiabatic framework is the non-conservation of energy22 and numerical inaccuracies originating from the singularities of NACTs. On the other hand, one can overcome such issues by transforming the SE from adiabatic to diabatic picture. This can be achieved with the aid of a unitary transformation of the adiabatic SE known as adiabatic-to-diabatic transformation (ADT). In the new framework known as diabatic representation of SE, those often singular kinetic couplings transform into smooth, continuous and single-valued potential couplings. The study of CIs vis-à-vis NACTs and their effects in polyatomic species on spectroscopic and scattering events are the most important areas of nonadiabatic chemistry, which drew the attention of allied scientific community over decades.
In the early 1960s, Longuet-Higgins (LH) unveiled that a BO adiabatic eigenfunction undergoes sign flipping along a closed contour of nuclear coordinates encapsulating a CI23,24 and accumulates a geometric phase. In order to resolve such inconsistency arising from multi-valuedness of the BO eigenfunction, Herzberg and Longuet-Higgins introduced a complex phase factor25 in the adiabatic eigenfunction26 in an ad hoc manner. Alternatively, Mead and Truhlar27 incorporated a vector potential in the nuclear kinetic energy operator to remove the multi-valued property of the adiabatic eigenfunctions, which is a reminiscent of LH phase. Varandas et al.28 first numerically investigated the LH phase for a triatomic molecule (LiNaK) by following the dominant coefficient of the electronic eigenfunction while roaming adiabatically around the CI, whereas Adhikari and coworkers29 showed sign inversions of such coefficient of adiabatic electronic eigenfunction along a contour encircling symmetry-driven and accidental Jahn-Teller (JT) CI for Na3 _3 3 cluster.
The Methods of Diabatization
In the adiabatic representation,30,31 the singular nature of the NACTs around the CI point(s), in principle, results non-conservation of energy22 and numerical inaccuracies in the dynamical calculations. Since the electron-nuclear couplings play a vital role for the electronic transition and show molecule specific functional features with multiple CIs over configuration space (CS), it is necessary to reformulate the nuclear SE to avoid the singular kinetic coupling terms in an alternative way, known as diabatic representation. Hobey and McLachlan attempted to carry out a transformation to recast the NACTs from the BO close-coupling32 to potentially coupled diabatic33 SE. Later on, Smith extended such formulation for a diatomic molecule by successfully eliminating NACTs from the adiabatic representation to achieve the corresponding diabatic one34. In addition, several other diabatization schemes have been developed for realistic systems throughout the last three/four decades, namely, vibronic coupling model (VCM), exact factorization (EF) scheme, direct dynamics (DD) approaches, and many others.
In VCM approach,35–37 diagonal and off-diagonal diabatic matrix elements are expanded with linear, bilinear as well as higher order polynomials of nuclear coordinates with respect to the minima of ground adiabatic PES (V 0 ( R ) V_0(\mathbf{R}) V 0 ( R ) ) or more preferably, the CI point (R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 ) between the first two adiabatic states. The bottleneck of such formalism is its limited applicability around the domain of Franck-Condon (FC) region at the close vicinity of reference geometry R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 for the dynamics of spectral features, namely, photoelectron (PE), emission/absorption, Mass-Analyzed Threshold Ionization (MATI) spectra, etc, but for the reactive scattering dynamics, the accuracy of the model is not guaranteed. On the other hand, in the exact factorization method developed by Gross and coworkers,38,39 the electronic and nuclear SEs are solved simultaneously with the aid of time-dependent PESs, vector potential and a coupling operator, which essentially represent the coupling between electron-nuclear coordinates. In this approach, the asymptotic wavefunctions do not represent any specific adiabatic quantum state and thereby, it is difficult to initialize the dynamics of the multi-dimensional system in correlation with experimental conditions. Several direct-dynamics (DD) methods, namely, on-the-fly diabatization version of multi-configurational time-dependent Hartree (MCTDH)40,41 and DD variational multi-configurational Gaussian (DD-vMCG)42,43 approaches were also developed to include the contribution of nonadiabatic couplings in the dynamics. Martinez and co-workers44,45 have developed Ab Initio Multiple Spawning (AIMS) method for nonadiabatic dynamics, where the Gaussian Wave Packets (GWPs) follow classical trajectories, which are spawned during the bifurcation of wavepacket in a region with strong nonadiabatic coupling. Nevertheless, among all the proposed theories of diabatization, the first principle based approach developed by M. Baer3,26,46,47 and later on, generalized and widely applied by Adhikari and coworkers15,16,48–51 has been proven to be theoretically “exact” and numerically “accurate” one.
Generalization on First Principle Diabatization
In order to formulate the nuclear equations of motion for atom-diatom collision process, M. Baer proposed a set of differential equations for ADT within a given sub-Hilbert space, where those equations are integrated along a contour over two-dimensional cross-sections of the multi-dimensional nuclear CS46,52. While computing the transformation angle(s), the NACTs are required for integrating those differential equations along a closed contour encapsulating the CI point(s) or seam(s) resulting those angle(s) as n π n\pi nπ with n n n being an integer47,53. On the other hand, Mead, Truhlar and Kendrick explored the removable and non-removable components of NACTs27,54 depicting only the longitudinal (removable) component of NACTs could be wiped out. Furthermore, Yarkony and co-workers unveiled that at the close neighborhood of a CI, the removable part of the derivative coupling vector appear as a singular function and non-removable component remains insignificant55.
Later on, the BBO approach was generalized by Adhikari and co-workers for any three or more coupled electronic states with extensive formulation of ADT equations, NACT expressions, curl conditions, curl-divergence equations and diabatic PESs matrices in terms of such mixing (ADT) angles7,16,48,56–64. In other words, this generalization is a non-trivial formulation of ADT equations for non-Abelian cases, where curl of the nonadiabatic coupling elements appears non-zero for more than two-dimensional sub-space of electronic manifold. Moreover, a generalized algorithm and user-friendly OpenMP parallelized program, “ADT” (see https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00948 or https://github.com/AdhikariLAB/ADT-Program)51 has been developed to carry out symbolic manipulation for the formulation of ADT equations and perform numerical calculation of various ADT quantities (like ADT equations, ADT matrix elements, diabatic potential energy matrix elements, etc.). The program package can interface with various quantum chemistry softwares, like, Molpro,65 Columbus,66 Gamess67 and Gaussian68 to obtain the input data (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) to construct diabatic PESs matrices. For a given sub-Hilbert space (SHS), an accurate transformation to the diabatic framework can be ensured if and only if a condition known as curl condition is satisfied by the NACT vector fields26,47,69. Later on, Adhikari and coworkers developed a practical way of using curl condition for the formulation of approximated Extended Born-Oppenheimer (EBO) equation15,18, which essentially connect the origin of geometric phase. In subsequent works, a detailed study of molecular symmetry (MS) and its relevance for exploring exact sign of NACTs was carried out. In other words, appropriate irreducible representations (IREPs) of the MS group are used for correcting the signs of the couplings58,59 at different geometries over the nuclear CS.
Spectroscopy, Reactive Scattering and Phase Transition
The first principle based BBO formalism has been employed to construct diabatic Hamiltonian for spectroscopically interesting molecules7–9,48,50,58,59,61–64,70–73, triatomic scattering processes49,50,60,72,74 as well as solid state perovskites19 exhibiting a wide variety of nonadiabatic interactions, namely, JT75–77 CIs/seams (symmetry driven63 degeneracies), Jahn-Teller (JT) type accidental CIs/seams (symmetry allowed63 or no symmetry63 degeneracies), Renner-Teller (RT)78,79 interactions and pseudo Jahn-Teller (PJT)76 interactions (no degeneracy, but non-zero NACTs between the electronic states). It is interesting to note that for (a) JT or JT type accidental CIs/seams, the ADT angles acquire the magnitude of integer multiple of π \pi π ; (b) for RT interactions, those angles attain the value of integer multiple of 2 π 2\pi 2 π ; and finally, (c) for PJT interactions, such angles attain zero (0) value at the end of closed contour. It is important to highlight that the theoretically “exact” and numerically “accurate” BBO theory is equally applicable in Franck-Condon (FC) domain as well as in the asymptotic limit. In other words, BBO constructed diabatic PESs and couplings have been used in nuclear dynamics to simulate photoelectron spectra of several molecules and transition metal complexes (Na3 _3 3 , K3 _3 3 , NO2 _2 2 , NO3 _3 3 , C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + , 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^+ 3 + , C4 _4 4 N2 _2 2 H4 _4 4 , MnO6 9 − _6^{9-} 6 9 − and TiO6 8 − _6^{8-} 6 8 − ) as well as to calculate various reaction attributes (reaction probabilities, integral cross-sections and rate constants) for triatomic reactive systems, namely, H3 + _3^+ 3 + (three states), HeH+ ^+ + (four states) and F+H2 _2 2 (three states).58, 59, 62, 7,80, 48, 9,64, 73, 19, 81, 60,74, 82,83, 49,84
Phonons and Electron-Hole Pair Effects on Surface Reactions
Metal surfaces at finite temperatures impart crucial effects on heterogeneous catalyzed reactions, which is broadly acknowledged since the days of Haber process, i.e., production of ammonia (NH3 _3 3 ) from hydrogen (H2 _2 2 ) and nitrogen (N2 _2 2 ) in presence of iron catalyst at 450 K. The importance of gas-surface chemical reactions also ranges from growth of semiconductor devices to hydrogen storage in metals. As a result of the wide-ranging relevance, the nature and mechanism of elementary reactions taking place over metal surface have been critically investigated both experimentally85–94 and theoretically95–118 for the past few decades. In this context, dissociation/scattering of H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 on/from various facets of different transition metal surfaces are being considered as the prototypes for studying physisorption, activated chemisorption, and elastic/inelastic collision phenomena. Traditionally, the approximate adiabatic (BO)-PESs for such dissociative scattering systems are constructed by using density functional theory (DFT), which are then incorporated in time - dependent dynamical [quantum dynamical (QD)105,107,113,119–122, quasi-classical trajectory (QCT)106,108,111,123–125] calculations. However, at finite surface temperature situations, effects of surface mode vibrations (phonons) and electron-hole pair (elhp) excitations (non - adiabatic effect) on experimental outcomes become significant. In this regard, there are just few theoretical approaches [e.g., ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD)104,107,126–128, lattice reconstruction sudden (LRS) model129,130, single/modified oscillator (SO) models95,97,98,131, electron friction (EF)124,132 approach, independent electron surface hopping (IESH) model133–135] to take into account the effects of these two channels (phonon modes and elhp excitations).
Adhikari and coworkers developed a time and temperature dependent effective Hamiltonian (EH)-based model by incorporating molecular degrees of freedom (DOFs)-phonon modes (for linear and quadratic) couplings as well as molecular DOFs-elhp couplings within the framework of mean-field approximation.99–103,110–111,116–118,136,137 In this approach, effective Hartree potentials (EHPs) are constructed by using quantum state distributions [Bose-Einstein statistics (for phonon modes) and Fermi-Dirac statistics (elhps)] of respective dissipation channels (i.e., phonon modes and elhps) at a particular surface temperature situation. During the entire time course of diatom-metal collision, this method considers six (6) DOFs of incoming diatomic projectile as well as phonon modes/elhps, and thereby constituting a seven dimensional (6+1)D quantum scattering problem. An efficient scheme was developed by using MPI-OpenMP parallelization technique (which can solve 10 9 10^9 1 0 9 number of coupled differential equations) to calculate observables, i.e., reaction probabilities and state-to-state transition probabilities for various collision energies of diatom. In recent time, with the aid of such EH (linear) model and accurate potential, novel vibrational quantum effects on scattering outcomes were revealed. On the other hand, amalgamation of our EH (linear-quadratic) model110,115,116,118 with a chemically accurate PES106 is on the process to investigate effects of anharmonic molecular DOFs-surface modes couplings and anharmonic phonon modes on dissociative scattering processes in a more accurate way.
This book is focused on a concise overview of the theoretical developments vis-á-vis applications of the BBO approach in conjunction with JT theory, TDDVR approach, Fully Close Coupled (FCC) dynamical approach as well as TSH theory, which is expected to be beneficial for the associated scientific community. This book focuses on the theoretical background of the aforementioned theories, followed by implementation of such approaches in spectroscopic systems, triatomic scattering processes as well as solid state systems exhibiting phase transition phenomenon. Finally, the accuracy of the theoretical results is compared with the available experimental as well as other theoretical findings.
Quantum Mechanics and Group Theory of Symmetry Breaking
Degenerate Perturbation Theory
Any non-linear molecular system with degenerate electronic states undergoes distortion to form a system of lower symmetry and energy by removing the said degeneracy. Before going into the physical insight of Jahn-Teller (JT) 1,2 problem, we need to discuss the fundamentals of degenerate perturbation theory.
The unperturbed time-independent Schrödinger Equation (TISE) for m m m -fold degenerate states can be written as:
H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) , 1 ≤ n ≤ m . (1) \hat{H}^{0}\phi_{n}^{(0)} = E_{n}^{(0)}\phi_{n}^{(0)}, \qquad1 \leq n \leq m. \tag*{(1)} H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) , 1 ≤ n ≤ m . (1)
On the other hand, the perturbed Hamiltonian and the associated TISE are:
H ^ ϕ n = E n ϕ n (2) \hat{H}\phi_{n} = E_{n}\phi_{n} \tag*{(2)} H ^ ϕ n = E n ϕ n (2)
H ^ = H ^ 0 + λ V ^ , (3) \hat{H} = \hat{H}^{0} + \lambda\hat{V}, \tag*{(3)} H ^ = H ^ 0 + λ V ^ , (3)
where λ \lambda λ represents the extent of perturbation and V ^ \hat{V} V ^ signifies the perturbation, namely, electric, magnetic, ligand-field, crystal-field, etc.
The perturbed molecular wave function and total energy can be expanded in terms of λ \lambda λ .3
ϕ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … (4) \phi_{n} = \psi_{n}^{(0)} + \lambda\phi_{n}^{(1)} + \lambda^{2}\phi_{n}^{(2)} + \ldots \tag*{(4)} ϕ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … (4)
E n = E n ( 0 ) + λ E n ( 1 ) + λ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … 1 ≤ n ≤ m , (5) E_{n} = E_{n}^{(0)} + \lambda E_{n}^{(1)} + \lambda^{2}E_{n}^{(2)} + \ldots\qquad1 \leq n \leq m, \tag*{(5)} E n = E n ( 0 ) + λ E n ( 1 ) + λ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … 1 ≤ n ≤ m , (5)
where ψ n ( 0 ) \psi_{n}^{(0)} ψ n ( 0 ) represents the zeroth order wavefunction and can be written as linear combination of the m m m -fold unperturbed eigenfunctions:
ψ n ( 0 ) = ∑ i = 1 m c i n ϕ i ( 0 ) (6) \psi_{n}^{(0)} = \sum_{i=1}^{m} c_{i}^{n}\phi_{i}^{(0)} \tag*{(6)} ψ n ( 0 ) = i = 1 ∑ m c i n ϕ i ( 0 ) (6)
In other words, one can construct m m m -fold orthogonal wavefunctions (ψ n ( 0 ) \psi_{n}^{(0)} ψ n ( 0 ) ) from a set of m m m -fold linearly independent eigenfunctions (ϕ i ( 0 ) \phi_{i}^{(0)} ϕ i ( 0 ) ). Moreover, the higher order corrections on wavefunctions are assumed to be orthogonal with the zeroth order, ⟨ ψ n ( 0 ) ∣ ψ n ( m ) ⟩ = δ 0 m \langle\psi_{n}^{(0)}|\psi_{n}^{(m)}\rangle= \delta_{0m} ⟨ ψ n ( 0 ) ∣ ψ n ( m ) ⟩ = δ 0 m .
Therefore, we can write:
( H ^ 0 + λ V ^ ) ( ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) = ( E n ( 0 ) + λ E n ( 1 ) + λ 2 E n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) ( ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) (7) \left(\hat{H}^{0}+\lambda\hat{V}\right)\left(\psi_{n}^{(0)}+\lambda\phi_{n}^{(1)}+\lambda^{2}\phi_{n}^{(2)}+\cdots\right)
=
\left(E_{n}^{(0)}+\lambda E_{n}^{(1)}+\lambda^{2}E_{n}^{(2)}+\cdots\right)\left(\psi_{n}^{(0)}+\lambda\phi_{n}^{(1)}+\lambda^{2}\phi_{n}^{(2)}+\cdots\right) \tag*{(7)} ( H ^ 0 + λ V ^ ) ( ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) = ( E n ( 0 ) + λ E n ( 1 ) + λ 2 E n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) ( ψ n ( 0 ) + λ ϕ n ( 1 ) + λ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + ⋯ ) (7)
While equating the first order terms, one can arrive:
H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 1 ) + V ^ ψ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) + E n ( 1 ) ψ n ( 0 ) (8) \hat{H}^{0}\phi_{n}^{(1)}+\hat{V}\psi_{n}^{(0)}=E_{n}^{(0)}\phi_{n}^{(1)}+E_{n}^{(1)}\psi_{n}^{(0)} \tag*{(8)} H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 1 ) + V ^ ψ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) + E n ( 1 ) ψ n ( 0 ) (8)
Multiplying the above equation by ϕ i ( 0 ) ∗ \phi_{i}^{(0)*} ϕ i ( 0 ) ∗ and subsequently, integrating over electronic space:
⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | H ^ 0 | ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ + ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | V ^ | ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = E n ( 0 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ + E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ , ⇒ E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | V ^ | ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ . \begin{aligned}
\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{H}^{0}\middle|\phi_{n}^{(1)}\right\rangle+\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{V}\middle|\psi_{n}^{(0)}\right\rangle=E_{n}^{(0)}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\phi_{n}^{(1)}\right\rangle+E_{n}^{(1)}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\psi_{n}^{(0)}\right\rangle, \\
&\Rightarrow E_{n}^{(1)}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\psi_{n}^{(0)}\right\rangle=\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{V}\middle|\psi_{n}^{(0)}\right\rangle.
\end{aligned} ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ + ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) V ^ ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = E n ( 0 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ + E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ , ⇒ E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) V ^ ψ n ( 0 ) ⟩ .
Using the expansion of ψ n ( 0 ) \psi_{n}^{(0)} ψ n ( 0 ) in terms of the zeroth-order eigenfunctions (see Eq. (6) ), the following equation arrives:
∑ j = 1 m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | V ^ | ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 ⇒ ∑ j = 1 m [ V i j − E n ( 1 ) δ i j ] c j n = 0 , 1 ≤ i ≤ m , 1 ≤ n ≤ m . (9) \begin{aligned}
\sum_{j=1}^{m}\left[\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{V}\middle|\phi_{j}^{(0)}\right\rangle-E_{n}^{(1)}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\phi_{j}^{(0)}\right\rangle\right]c_{j}^{n}=0 \\
&\Rightarrow\sum_{j=1}^{m}\left[V_{ij}-E_{n}^{(1)}\delta_{ij}\right]c_{j}^{n}=0,\quad1\leq i\leq m,\quad1\leq n\leq m. \tag*{(9)}
\end{aligned} j = 1 ∑ m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) V ^ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 ⇒ j = 1 ∑ m [ V ij − E n ( 1 ) δ ij ] c j n = 0 , 1 ≤ i ≤ m , 1 ≤ n ≤ m . (9)
Thus, m m m number of linear, homogeneous equations for c 1 n , c 2 n , … , c m n c_{1}^{n},c_{2}^{n},\ldots,c_{m}^{n} c 1 n , c 2 n , … , c m n become:
( V 11 − E n ( 1 ) ) c 1 n + V 12 c 2 n + ⋯ + V 1 m c m n = 0 \left(V_{11}-E_{n}^{(1)}\right)c_{1}^{n}+V_{12}c_{2}^{n}+\cdots+V_{1m}c_{m}^{n}=0 ( V 11 − E n ( 1 ) ) c 1 n + V 12 c 2 n + ⋯ + V 1 m c m n = 0
V 21 c 1 n + ( V 22 − E n ( 1 ) ) c 2 n + ⋯ + V 2 m c m n = 0 V_{21}c_{1}^{n}+\left(V_{22}-E_{n}^{(1)}\right)c_{2}^{n}+\cdots+V_{2m}c_{m}^{n}=0 V 21 c 1 n + ( V 22 − E n ( 1 ) ) c 2 n + ⋯ + V 2 m c m n = 0
V m 1 c 1 n + V m 2 c 2 n + ⋯ + ( V m m − E n ( 1 ) ) c m n = 0 (10) V_{m1}c_{1}^{n}+V_{m2}c_{2}^{n}+\cdots+\left(V_{mm}-E_{n}^{(1)}\right)c_{m}^{n}=0 \tag*{(10)} V m 1 c 1 n + V m 2 c 2 n + ⋯ + ( V mm − E n ( 1 ) ) c m n = 0 (10)
The solution of the above set of equations will exist if and only if the determinant constituted by the coefficients does not vanish. Therefore, the secular determinant is defined as:
\begin{vmatrix}
V_{11}-E_{n}^{(1)} & V_{12} & \cdots& V_{1m}\\
V_{21} & V_{22}-E_{n}^{(1)} & \cdots& V_{2m}\\
\vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\
V_{m1} & V_{m2} & \cdots& V_{mm}-E_{n}^{(1)}
\end{vmatrix}=0 \tag*{(11)}\end{vmatrix}
where the m m m roots, E 1 ( 1 ) , E 2 ( 1 ) , … , E m ( 1 ) E_{1}^{(1)},E_{2}^{(1)},\ldots,E_{m}^{(1)} E 1 ( 1 ) , E 2 ( 1 ) , … , E m ( 1 ) are the first order corrections to the eigenvalues (E n ( 0 ) E_{n}^{(0)} E n ( 0 ) ) lifting the degeneracies.
For a doubly degenerate system, one can write:
\begin{vmatrix}
V_{11}-E_{n}^{(1)} & V_{12}\\
V_{21} & V_{22}-E_{n}^{(1)}
\end{vmatrix}=0 \tag*{(12)}\end{vmatrix}
where the two roots of the equation will be:
E n , ± ( 1 ) = 1 2 [ V 11 + V 22 ± ( V 11 − V 22 ) 2 + 4 ∣ V 12 ∣ 2 ] (13) E_{n,\pm}^{(1)}=\frac{1}{2}\left[V_{11}+V_{22}\pm\sqrt{(V_{11}-V_{22})^{2}+4\lvert V_{12}\rvert^{2}}\right] \tag*{(13)} E n , ± ( 1 ) = 2 1 [ V 11 + V 22 ± ( V 11 − V 22 ) 2 + 4 ∣ V 12 ∣ 2 ] (13)
The fundamental result of degenerate perturbation theory is that the roots correspond to the correction (E n , ± ( 1 ) E_{n,\pm}^{(1)} E n , ± ( 1 ) ) over the unperturbed energies (E n ( 0 ) E_{n}^{(0)} E n ( 0 ) ) and hence, there is a possibility of getting degeneracy lifted.
Degenerate Perturbation Theory: JT Distortion
If there is coupling between vibrational modes and electronic Hamiltonian (vibronic coupling) of a molecular system, the electron-nuclear Hamiltonian [ H ^ 0 = H ^ e ( { Q k } = 0 ) ] [\hat{H}^{0}=\hat{H}_{e}(\{Q_{k}\}=0)] [ H ^ 0 = H ^ e ({ Q k } = 0 )] can be expanded in terms of normal mode coordinates:
H ^ = H ^ 0 + ∑ k V ^ k Q k + 1 2 ∑ k l V ^ k l Q k Q l + ⋯ , (14) \hat{H}=\hat{H}^{0}+\sum_{k}\hat{V}_{k}Q_{k}+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{kl}\hat{V}_{kl}Q_{k}Q_{l}+\cdots, \tag*{(14)} H ^ = H ^ 0 + k ∑ V ^ k Q k + 2 1 k l ∑ V ^ k l Q k Q l + ⋯ , (14)
H ^ 0 \hat{H}^{0} H ^ 0 represents electronic Hamiltonian at equilibrium nuclear configuration. On the other hand, V ^ k ( = ∂ H ∂ Q k ) \hat{V}_{k}\left(=\frac{\partial H}{\partial Q_{k}}\right) V ^ k ( = ∂ Q k ∂ H ) and V ^ k l ( = ∂ 2 H ∂ Q k ∂ Q l ) \hat{V}_{kl}\left(=\frac{\partial^{2}H}{\partial Q_{k}\partial Q_{l}}\right) V ^ k l ( = ∂ Q k ∂ Q l ∂ 2 H ) are the first and second order perturbations, respectively, due to normal modes, { Q k } \{Q_{k}\} { Q k } s.
In such case, unperturbed TISE is defined as in Eq. (1) :
H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) , 1 ≤ n ≤ m , \hat{H}^{0}\phi_{n}^{(0)}=E_{n}^{(0)}\phi_{n}^{(0)},\qquad1\leq n\leq m, H ^ 0 ϕ n ( 0 ) = E n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) , 1 ≤ n ≤ m ,
where E n ( 0 ) E_{n}^{(0)} E n ( 0 ) is the eigenvalue of m m m -fold degenerate electronic states and { ϕ n ( 0 ) } \{\phi_{n}^{(0)}\} { ϕ n ( 0 ) } s form a complete set of orthogonal eigenfunctions. In a particular nuclear configuration, the m m m -fold degenerate eigenvalue E n ( 0 ) E_{n}^{(0)} E n ( 0 ) may either split into number of different energy levels E n , m E_{n,m} E n , m or it may get lifted without removing the degeneracy.
The matrix elements for first order energy correction on the n t h n^{th} n t h state ( E n ( 1 ) ) (E_{n}^{(1)}) ( E n ( 1 ) ) are expressed in the following equation:
∑ j = 1 m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | V ^ | ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 (15) \sum_{j=1}^{m}\left[\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{V}\middle|\phi_{j}^{(0)}\right\rangle-E_{n}^{(1)}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\phi_{j}^{(0)}\right\rangle\right]c_{j}^{n}=0 \tag*{(15)} j = 1 ∑ m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) V ^ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 (15)
When only the linear perturbation w.r.t the normal mode coordinates is considered (see Eq. 9.1), the matrix elements for the perturbation can be expressed as:
V i j = ∑ k Q k ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) | V ^ k | ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ . (16) V_{ij}=\sum_{k}Q_{k}\left\langle\phi_{i}^{(0)}\middle|\hat{V}_{k}\middle|\phi_{j}^{(0)}\right\rangle. \tag*{(16)} V ij = k ∑ Q k ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) V ^ k ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ . (16)
If Q 0 ( { Q k } = 0 ) Q^{0}(\{Q_{k}\}=0) Q 0 ({ Q k } = 0 ) coincides with the most stable nuclear configuration of a molecule, the first order perturbation matrix elements should vanish. On the other hand, if the direct product on the irreducible representations (IREPs) of the components of the integrand, Γ ( ϕ i ( 0 ) ) ⊗ Γ ( V ^ k ) ⊗ Γ ( ϕ j ( 0 ) ) \Gamma(\phi_{i}^{(0)})\otimes\Gamma(\hat{V}_{k})\otimes\Gamma(\phi_{j}^{(0)}) Γ ( ϕ i ( 0 ) ) ⊗ Γ ( V ^ k ) ⊗ Γ ( ϕ j ( 0 ) ) does not contain the totally symmetric representation ( Γ 0 ) (\Gamma^{0}) ( Γ 0 ) , the perturbation will be zero. Since V i j V_{ij} V ij is a number, it is invariant under the transformation of all symmetry elements of a group.
In other words, let (a) V ^ k ( = ∂ H ∂ Q k ) \hat{V}_{k}\left(=\frac{\partial H}{\partial Q_{k}}\right) V ^ k ( = ∂ Q k ∂ H ) and Q k Q_{k} Q k transform according to irreducible IREP Γ β \Gamma^{\beta} Γ β of the symmetry group at configuration Q ( 0 ) Q^{(0)} Q ( 0 ) ; (b) degenerate wave functions ϕ i ( 0 ) \phi_{i}^{(0)} ϕ i ( 0 ) transform according to Γ α \Gamma^{\alpha} Γ α , the necessary condition for JT effect takes the following form: [1,2,4,5]
Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] , (17) \Gamma^{0}\in\Gamma^{\beta}\otimes\left[(\Gamma^{\alpha})^{2}\right], \tag*{(17)} Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] , (17)
where [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] [(\Gamma^{\alpha})^{2}] [( Γ α ) 2 ] represents the symmetrized product of the representation Γ α \Gamma^{\alpha} Γ α .
Employing Eq. 9.3, one can define four different cases for JT distortion, namely,
Electronic state is non-degenerate [i.e. ( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 (\Gamma^{\alpha})^{2}=\Gamma^{0} ( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 ] and nuclear displacement ( Q k ) (Q_{k}) ( Q k ) is totally symmetric [i.e. Γ β = Γ 0 \Gamma^{\beta}=\Gamma^{0} Γ β = Γ 0 ]. For such case, the contribution of perturbation is not necessarily zero but system will readjust until the contribution vanishes, since it involves a symmetric mode and does not destroy the symmetry of the system.
Electronic state is degenerate [( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 + ⋯ (\Gamma^\alpha)^2 = \Gamma^0 + \cdots ( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 + ⋯ ] and nuclear displacement ( Q k ) (Q_k) ( Q k ) is totally symmetric Γ 0 \Gamma^0 Γ 0 . For such case, the contribution of perturbation is not necessarily zero, but situation is analogous to the first case.
Electronic state is degenerate [( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 + ⋯ + Γ β + ⋯ (\Gamma^\alpha)^2 = \Gamma^0 + \cdots+ \Gamma^\beta+ \cdots ( Γ α ) 2 = Γ 0 + ⋯ + Γ β + ⋯ ] and nuclear displacement ( Q k ) (Q_k) ( Q k ) is non totally symmetric [i.e. Γ β ≠ Γ 0 \Gamma^\beta\ne\Gamma^0 Γ β = Γ 0 ]. For such case, the contribution of perturbation will be non zero and show the Jahn-Teller effect, if the symmetrized product of the states contains the symmetry Γ β \Gamma^\beta Γ β . In the case of linear molecules, the product does not contain the symmetry of the nuclear displacement and hence does not show JT effect.
JT Condition and Symmetry Breaking
While exploring the symmetry breaking of electronic states in a molecule, one can use the concept of direct product between the electronic states and the normal modes, and analyze the survivality of the direct product integral in terms of their irreducible representation.
Symmetry Breaking in H2 _2 2 O Molecule
In case of H2 _2 2 O molecule, Cartesian coordinates of each atom and symmetry elements are depicted in Figure 2.1 and Figure 2.2 , respectively.
Figure 2.1. Cartesian coordinates of H2 _2 2 O molecule
Figure 2.2. Symmetry elements of H 2 O \mathrm{H}_2\mathrm{O} H 2 O molecule
While constructing the reducible representation of 3 N 3N 3 N (= 9 = 9 = 9 for H2 _2 2 O) coordinates, the transformation matrix for identity operation ( E ) (E) ( E ) takes the following form:
JT CONDITION AND SYMMETRY BREAKING
E : ( 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 ) ( x H 1 y H 1 z H 1 x O y O z O x H 2 y H 2 z H 2 ) = ( x H 1 ′ y H 1 ′ z H 1 ′ x O ′ y O ′ z O ′ x H 2 ′ y H 2 ′ z H 2 ′ ) E:
\begin{pmatrix}
1&0&0&0&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&1&0&0&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&1&0&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&1&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&1&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&1&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&0&1&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&0&0&1&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&0&0&0&1
\end{pmatrix}
\begin{pmatrix}
x_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
y_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
z_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
x_{\mathrm{O}}\\
y_{\mathrm{O}}\\
z_{\mathrm{O}}\\
x_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
y_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
z_{\mathrm{H}_2}
\end{pmatrix}
=
\begin{pmatrix}
x'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
y'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
z'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
x'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
y'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
z'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
x'_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
y'_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
z'_{\mathrm{H}_2}
\end{pmatrix} E : 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 x H 1 y H 1 z H 1 x O y O z O x H 2 y H 2 z H 2 = x H 1 ′ y H 1 ′ z H 1 ′ x O ′ y O ′ z O ′ x H 2 ′ y H 2 ′ z H 2 ′
Therefore, reducible character for E E E operation appears as χ ( E ) = 9 \chi(E)=9 χ ( E ) = 9 . On the other hand, transformation matrix for C 2 C_2 C 2 operation becomes:
C 2 : ( 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 ) ( x H 1 y H 1 z H 1 x O y O z O x H 2 y H 2 z H 2 ) = ( x H 1 ′ y H 1 ′ z H 1 ′ x O ′ y O ′ z O ′ x H 2 ′ y H 2 ′ z H 2 ′ ) C_2:
\begin{pmatrix}
0&0&0&0&0&0&-1&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&0&0&-1&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&0&0&0&1\\
0&0&0&-1&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&-1&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&0&0&0&1&0&0&0\\
-1&0&0&0&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&-1&0&0&0&0&0&0&0\\
0&0&1&0&0&0&0&0&0
\end{pmatrix}
\begin{pmatrix}
x_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
y_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
z_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
x_{\mathrm{O}}\\
y_{\mathrm{O}}\\
z_{\mathrm{O}}\\
x_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
y_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
z_{\mathrm{H}_2}
\end{pmatrix}
=
\begin{pmatrix}
x'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
y'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
z'_{\mathrm{H}_1}\\
x'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
y'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
z'_{\mathrm{O}}\\
x'_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
y'_{\mathrm{H}_2}\\
z'_{\mathrm{H}_2}
\end{pmatrix} C 2 : 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 x H 1 y H 1 z H 1 x O y O z O x H 2 y H 2 z H 2 = x H 1 ′ y H 1 ′ z H 1 ′ x O ′ y O ′ z O ′ x H 2 ′ y H 2 ′ z H 2 ′
Hence, reducible character for C 2 C_2 C 2 operation becomes χ ( C 2 ) = − 1 \chi(C_2)=-1 χ ( C 2 ) = − 1 . In a similar way, χ ( σ x z ) \chi(\sigma_{xz}) χ ( σ x z ) and χ ( σ y z ) \chi(\sigma_{yz}) χ ( σ y z ) appear as 1 and 3, respectively. Finally, the reducible representation by 3 N 3N 3 N vectors takes the following form (Table 2.1 ):
Table 2.1. Reducible representation of 3 N 3N 3 N vectors
In a reducible representation, the number (a i a_i a i ) of IREPs is obtained by the following expression:
a i = 1 g ∑ R χ ( R ) χ i ( R ) , (18) a_i = \frac{1}{g} \sum_{R} \chi(R)\chi_i(R), \tag*{(18)} a i = g 1 R ∑ χ ( R ) χ i ( R ) , (18)
where a i a_i a i represents no of a particular i i i th IREP in the reducible representation. On the other hand, g g g signifies total number of symmetry operations in a given point group, whereas χ ( R ) \chi(R) χ ( R ) and χ i ( R ) \chi_i(R) χ i ( R ) signify characters of operation R R R in reducible representation and i i i th IREP, respectively.
The character table for C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v point group is given in Table 2.2
Table 2.2. Character table for C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v point group
Using Eq. (18) , the number of each IREPs is obtained as: n ( a 1 ) = 3 n(a_1) = 3 n ( a 1 ) = 3 , n ( a 2 ) = 1 n(a_2) = 1 n ( a 2 ) = 1 , n ( b 1 ) = 2 n(b_1) = 2 n ( b 1 ) = 2 , n ( b 2 ) = 3 n(b_2) = 3 n ( b 2 ) = 3 . Hence, one can write:
Γ H 2 O = 3 a 1 + a 2 + 2 b 1 + 3 b 2 \Gamma_{H_2O} = 3a_1 + a_2 + 2b_1 + 3b_2 Γ H 2 O = 3 a 1 + a 2 + 2 b 1 + 3 b 2
Γ T r a n s = a 1 + b 1 + b 2 \Gamma_{Trans} = a_1 + b_1 + b_2 Γ T r an s = a 1 + b 1 + b 2
Γ R o t = a 2 + b 1 + b 2 \Gamma_{Rot} = a_2 + b_1 + b_2 Γ R o t = a 2 + b 1 + b 2
Γ V i b = 2 a 1 + b 2 \Gamma_{Vib} = 2a_1 + b_2 Γ V ib = 2 a 1 + b 2
The H2 _2 2 O molecule has three normal modes, namely, symmetric stretching (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), asymmetric stretching (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) and bending (Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 ) (see Figure 2.3 and Table 2.3 ).
Table 2.3. IREPs of vibrational modes for C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v point group
Figure 2.3. Vibrational modes of H2 _2 2 O molecule with vectorial displacements
In order to hold the condition for first order coupling (Eq. 9.3), Γ β \Gamma^\beta Γ β will be b 2 b_2 b 2 symmetry as it can not be totally symmetric IREP (a 1 a_1 a 1 ). Since H2 _2 2 O has two a 1 a_1 a 1 and one b 2 b_2 b 2 symmetric modes, the different conditions for linear couplings are revisited in the light of C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v system (H2 _2 2 O). The condition:1
Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] \Gamma^0 \in\Gamma^\beta\otimes[(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [( Γ α ) 2 ]
As per the above condition, if the normal mode is b 2 b_2 b 2 symmetric, JT type distortion can be observed only if one electronic state belongs to A 1 A_1 A 1 symmetry and another one is of B 2 B_2 B 2 symmetry:
a 1 ∈ b 2 ⊗ [ A 1 ⊗ B 2 ] a_1 \in b_2 \otimes[A_1 \otimes B_2] a 1 ∈ b 2 ⊗ [ A 1 ⊗ B 2 ]
.
Symmetry Breaking in NO3 _3 3 Molecule
We consider another non-linear molecule to understand the JT condition in some more details. NO3 _3 3 radical1 is an example of D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h molecule which has six normal modes, namely, totally symmetric (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), umbrella (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ), degenerate asymmetric stretching (Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x and Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y ) and degenerate asymmetric bending (Q 4 x Q_{4x} Q 4 x and Q 4 y Q_{4y} Q 4 y ) modes. The lowest five electronic states of this doublet system (NO3 _3 3 ) are X ~ 2 A 2 ′ \tilde{X}^{2}A_2' X ~ 2 A 2 ′ , A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}E'' A ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E' B ~ 2 E ′ among which E ′ ′ E'' E ′′ and E ′ E' E ′ states exhibit JT symmetry breaking. The JT active modes lift the degeneracy of the E ′ ′ E'' E ′′ and E ′ E' E ′ states are Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x , Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y , Q 4 x Q_{4x} Q 4 x and Q 4 y Q_{4y} Q 4 y .
While exploring the JT condition (Eq. 9.3), one can find: Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] \Gamma^0 \in\Gamma^\beta\otimes[(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [( Γ α ) 2 ] , where [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] [(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] [( Γ α ) 2 ] represents symmetrized product of the IREP of the degenerate state and Γ β \Gamma^\beta Γ β signifies IREP of the normal mode. In case of E ′ ′ E'' E ′′ state, [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] ≡ E ′ ′ ⊗ E ′ ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ [(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] \equiv E'' \otimes E'' = A_1' + A_2' + E' [( Γ α ) 2 ] ≡ E ′′ ⊗ E ′′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ and for E ′ E' E ′ state, [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] ≡ E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ [(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] \equiv E' \otimes E' = A_1' + A_2' + E' [( Γ α ) 2 ] ≡ E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ .
In order to hold JT condition (Eq. 9.3), Γ β \Gamma^\beta Γ β will be either a 2 ′ a_2' a 2 ′ or e ′ e' e ′ mode as it can not be totally symmetric IREP (a 1 ′ a_1' a 1 ′ ). Since NO3 _3 3 has four e ′ e' e ′ but no a 2 ′ a_2' a 2 ′ modes, the four e ′ e' e ′ modes, namely, Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x , Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y , Q 4 x Q_{4x} Q 4 x and Q 4 y Q_{4y} Q 4 y vibrations are JT active ones.
Therefore, the four different situations of JT condition are revisited in the light of D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h system (NO3 _3 3 ). The JT condition:1
Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] \Gamma^0 \in\Gamma^\beta\otimes[(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [( Γ α ) 2 ]
While applying this condition, the following four situations will arise:
Ground state (non-degenerate, A 2 ′ A_2' A 2 ′ ) couples with the (totally) symmetric stretching mode, Γ β = a 1 ′ \Gamma^\beta= a_1' Γ β = a 1 ′ and [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = A 2 ′ ⊗ A 2 ′ = A 1 ′ [(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] = A_2' \otimes A_2' = A_1' [( Γ α ) 2 ] = A 2 ′ ⊗ A 2 ′ = A 1 ′ . Therefore, the contribution of the perturbation will not be zero. Nevertheless this will not lift the degeneracy of the system and hence, would not show JT effect.
Ground state (non-degenerate, A 2 ′ A_2' A 2 ′ ) couples with a non totally symmetric mode, Γ β ≠ a 1 ′ \Gamma^\beta\ne a_1' Γ β = a 1 ′ and [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = A 2 ′ ⊗ A 2 ′ = A 1 ′ [(\Gamma^\alpha)^2] = A_2' \otimes A_2' = A_1' [( Γ α ) 2 ] = A 2 ′ ⊗ A 2 ′ = A 1 ′ . Thus, the contribution of the perturbation will be zero.
(3) A degenerate state (E ′ ′ E^{\prime\prime} E ′′ or E ′ E^{\prime} E ′ ) couples with the (totally) symmetric stretching mode, Γ β = a 1 ′ \Gamma^{\beta}=a_{1}^{\prime} Γ β = a 1 ′ and [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = E ′ ′ ⊗ E ′ ′ [(\Gamma^{\alpha})^{2}]=E^{\prime\prime}\otimes E^{\prime\prime} [( Γ α ) 2 ] = E ′′ ⊗ E ′′ or E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ E^{\prime}\otimes E^{\prime}=A_{1}^{\prime}+A_{2}^{\prime}+E^{\prime} E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ . It will be analogous to the first case.
(4) A degenerate state (E ′ ′ E^{\prime\prime} E ′′ or E ′ E^{\prime} E ′ ) couples with a non totally symmetric mode, Γ β ≠ a 1 ′ \Gamma^{\beta}\ne a_{1}^{\prime} Γ β = a 1 ′ , and [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = E ′ ′ ⊗ E ′ ′ [(\Gamma^{\alpha})^{2}]=E^{\prime\prime}\otimes E^{\prime\prime} [( Γ α ) 2 ] = E ′′ ⊗ E ′′ or E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ E^{\prime}\otimes E^{\prime}=A_{1}^{\prime}+A_{2}^{\prime}+E^{\prime} E ′ ⊗ E ′ = A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ . Such product will survive and leads to symmetry breaking.
If the umbrella mode (a 2 ′ ′ a_{2}^{\prime\prime} a 2 ′′ ) of NO3 _3 3 molecule is considered, Γ β = a 2 ′ ′ \Gamma^{\beta}=a_{2}^{\prime\prime} Γ β = a 2 ′′ . Since a 2 ′ ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) a_{2}^{\prime\prime}\otimes(A_{1}^{\prime}+A_{2}^{\prime}+E^{\prime}) a 2 ′′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) does not contain A 1 ′ A_{1}^{\prime} A 1 ′ , a 2 ′ ′ a_{2}^{\prime\prime} a 2 ′′ mode will not show up JT effect. In case of asymmetric stretching and bending modes, (e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ ), Γ β = e ′ \Gamma^{\beta}=e^{\prime} Γ β = e ′ . Since e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) e^{\prime}\otimes(A_{1}^{\prime}+A_{2}^{\prime}+E^{\prime}) e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) contains A 1 ′ A_{1}^{\prime} A 1 ′ , all e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ modes are JT active.
Figure 2.4. Molecular orbitals of NO3 _3 3 radical
Symmetry Breaking in CO2 _2 2 Molecule
CO2 _2 2 is an example of D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h molecule due to linear geometry, which has ( 3 N − 5 = 4 ) (3N-5=4) ( 3 N − 5 = 4 ) four normal modes, namely, symmetric stretching (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), anti-symmetric stretching (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) and degenerate bending (Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 and Q 4 Q_4 Q 4 ). The symmetry elements are depicted in Figure 2.8 . In order to obtain IREPs of normal modes, we explore the symmetry operations in D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group, which is a sub-group of D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h . For CO2 _2 2 , the reducible representation is depicted in Table 2.4 . On the other hand, character table for D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group is depicted in Table 2.5 .
Table 2.4. Reducible representation of 3 N 3N 3 N vectors
Table 2.5. Character table for D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group
Figure 2.8. Symmetry elements of CO2 _2 2 molecule
Figure 2.5. Low lying electronic states of NO3 _3 3 radical
Figure 2.6. Normal modes of N O 3 \mathrm{NO}_{3} NO 3 radical. The results are adopted from Ref. [6] and permission has been taken from Taylor & Francis.
Table 2.7. Character table of D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h point group.
JT CONDITION AND SYMMETRY BREAKING
While resolving Γ 3 N \Gamma^{3N} Γ 3 N into the IREPs by using the character table (see Table 2.5 ), we find:
Γ 3 N = a g + b 2 g + b 3 g + 2 b 1 u + 2 b 2 u + 2 b 3 u (19) \Gamma^{3N}=a_g+b_{2g}+b_{3g}+2b_{1u}+2b_{2u}+2b_{3u} \tag*{(19)} Γ 3 N = a g + b 2 g + b 3 g + 2 b 1 u + 2 b 2 u + 2 b 3 u (19)
On the other hand, the character table shows that:
Γ t r a n s = b 1 u + b 2 u + b 3 u Γ r o t = b 2 g + b 3 g Γ v i b = a g + b 1 u + b 2 u + b 3 u \begin{aligned}
\Gamma_{\mathrm{trans}} &= b_{1u}+b_{2u}+b_{3u}\\
\Gamma_{\mathrm{rot}} &= b_{2g}+b_{3g}\\
\Gamma_{\mathrm{vib}} &= a_g+b_{1u}+b_{2u}+b_{3u}
\end{aligned} Γ trans Γ rot Γ vib = b 1 u + b 2 u + b 3 u = b 2 g + b 3 g = a g + b 1 u + b 2 u + b 3 u
The symmetry of the vibrational modes of CO2 _2 2 are represented in Figure 2.9 , where it is clearly evident:
Figure 2.9. Vibrational modes of CO₂ molecule with vectorial displacements
Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 belongs to totally symmetric IREP, a g a_g a g .
Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 is symmetric with respect to E E E , C 2 ( z ) C_2(z) C 2 ( z ) , σ x z \sigma_{xz} σ x z and σ y z \sigma_{yz} σ y z operations, and anti-symmetric with respect to C 2 ( y ) C_2(y) C 2 ( y ) , C 2 ( x ) C_2(x) C 2 ( x ) , i i i and σ x y \sigma_{xy} σ x y operations, i.e. Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 belongs to b 1 u b_{1u} b 1 u IREP.
Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 is symmetric with respect to E E E , C 2 ( y ) C_2(y) C 2 ( y ) , σ x y \sigma_{xy} σ x y and σ y z \sigma_{yz} σ y z operations, and anti-symmetric with respect to C 2 ( z ) C_2(z) C 2 ( z ) , C 2 ( x ) C_2(x) C 2 ( x ) , i i i and σ x z \sigma_{xz} σ x z operations, i.e. Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 belongs to b 2 u b_{2u} b 2 u IREP.
Q 4 Q_4 Q 4 is symmetric with respect to E E E , C 2 ( x ) C_2(x) C 2 ( x ) , σ x y \sigma_{xy} σ x y and σ x z \sigma_{xz} σ x z operations, and anti-symmetric with respect to C 2 ( z ) C_2(z) C 2 ( z ) , C 2 ( y ) C_2(y) C 2 ( y ) , i i i and σ y z \sigma_{yz} σ y z operations, i.e. Q 4 Q_4 Q 4 belongs to b 3 u b_{3u} b 3 u IREP.
As D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group is a sub-group of D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h , a g a_g a g becomes σ g + \sigma_g^+ σ g + (non-degenerate), b 1 u b_{1u} b 1 u becomes σ u + \sigma_u^+ σ u + (non-degenerate) and the remaining two (b 2 u b_{2u} b 2 u and b 3 u b_{3u} b 3 u ) turn into π u \pi_u π u (degenerate) in D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h point group.
While analysing the JT interaction in CO2 _2 2 molecule, we need to consider the D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group as D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h point group contains infinite number of irreducible representations. The character table of D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h point group takes following form as depicted in Table 2.6 .
Table 2.6. Character table of D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h point group
On the other hand, the partial correlation table between D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h and D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point groups is presented in Table 2.7.
In D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h symmetry, Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 and Q 4 Q_4 Q 4 normal mode of CO2 _2 2 molecule are degenerate (π u \pi_u π u symmetry). On the other hand, ground (S 0 S_0 S 0 ), first excited (S 1 S_1 S 1 ) and second excited (degenerate, S 2 S_2 S 2 and S 3 S_3 S 3 ) electronic states belong to 1 Σ g + ^1\Sigma_g^+ 1 Σ g + , 1 Σ u − ^1\Sigma_u^- 1 Σ u − and 1 Π g ^1\Pi_g 1 Π g IREPs, respectively.
Table 2.7 (PDF p. 32). Partial correlation table between D ∞ h D_{\infty h} D ∞ h and D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point groups
In D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group, π u \pi_u π u symmetry turns into b 2 u + b 3 u b_{2u}+b_{3u} b 2 u + b 3 u and Π g 2 \Pi_g^2 Π g 2 symmetry appears as 2 a g + 2 b 1 g 2a_g+2b_{1g} 2 a g + 2 b 1 g . While considering the JT active feature of π u \pi_u π u (Γ β \Gamma^\beta Γ β , see Eq. 9.3) symmetric normal modes for the 1 Π g ^1\Pi_g 1 Π g states (Γ α \Gamma^\alpha Γ α , see Eq. 9.3), the JT condition (Eq. 9.3) takes the following form:
Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = π u ⊗ [ Π g 2 ] in D ∞ h symmetry = ( b 2 u + b 3 u ) ⊗ ( 2 A g + 2 B 1 g ) in D 2 h symmetry \Gamma^\beta\otimes\left[(\Gamma^\alpha)^2\right] = \pi_u \otimes\left[\Pi_g^2\right] \quad\text{in } D_{\infty h}\text{ symmetry}
\\
= (b_{2u}+b_{3u}) \otimes(2A_g+2B_{1g}) \quad\text{in } D_{2h}\text{ symmetry} Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] = π u ⊗ [ Π g 2 ] in D ∞ h symmetry = ( b 2 u + b 3 u ) ⊗ ( 2 A g + 2 B 1 g ) in D 2 h symmetry
Therefore, A g ∉ ( b 2 u + b 3 u ) ⊗ ( 2 A g + 2 B 1 g ) A_g \notin(b_{2u}+b_{3u}) \otimes(2A_g+2B_{1g}) A g ∈ / ( b 2 u + b 3 u ) ⊗ ( 2 A g + 2 B 1 g ) , i.e. Γ 0 ∉ Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] \Gamma^0 \notin\Gamma^\beta\otimes\left[(\Gamma^\alpha)^2\right] Γ 0 ∈ / Γ β ⊗ [ ( Γ α ) 2 ] and this implies that normal modes of CO2 _2 2 are not JT active.
Chapter 3
Symmetry Breaking and Jahn-Teller Theory
Jahn-Teller Model
When any two electronic states of a molecular system are degenerate at some point of the nuclear configuration space (CS), the situation was modeled by two-dimensional (2D) harmonic oscillator for the unperturbed Hamiltonian (H ^ 0 \hat{H}_0 H ^ 0 ) as defined below:2
H ^ 0 = T ^ ⋅ I + U ^ 0 (20) \hat{H}_0 = \hat{T} \cdot I + \hat{U}_0 \tag*{(20)} H ^ 0 = T ^ ⋅ I + U ^ 0 (20)
U ^ 0 = ω 2 ( x 2 + y 2 + ϵ 0 0 x 2 + y 2 − ϵ ) (21) \hat{U}_0 = \frac{\omega}{2}
\begin{pmatrix}
x^2+y^2+\epsilon& 0 \\
0 & x^2+y^2-\epsilon
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(21)} U ^ 0 = 2 ω ( x 2 + y 2 + ϵ 0 0 x 2 + y 2 − ϵ ) (21)
where T ^ \hat{T} T ^ is the kinetic energy operator, I I I is the 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 unit matrix and the functional forms of U ^ 0 \hat{U}_0 U ^ 0 matrix elements are depicted in Figure 3.1 . If such a Hamiltonian (H ^ 0 \hat{H}_0 H ^ 0 ) is perturbed due to nuclear degrees of freedom (see Eq. (14) ), the 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 matrix only within the linear perturbations for 2D nuclear CS is modeled by:
Figure 3.1. Potential energy surfaces without any JT distortion
H ^ = H ^ 0 + W ^ (22) \hat{H} = \hat{H}_0 + \hat{W} \tag*{(22)} H ^ = H ^ 0 + W ^ (22)
W ^ = k ( y x x − y ) , y = q cos θ ; x = q sin θ (23) \hat{W} = k
\begin{pmatrix}
y & x \\
x & -y
\end{pmatrix}, \qquad y=q\cos\theta;\quad x=q\sin\theta \tag*{(23)} W ^ = k ( y x x − y ) , y = q cos θ ; x = q sin θ (23)
On diagonalization of Jahn-Teller (JT) model Hamiltonian (W ^ \hat{W} W ^ ), the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions can be written as:
W ^ Φ = Λ Φ , λ = ± k q (24) \hat{W}\Phi= \Lambda\Phi,\qquad\lambda= \pm kq \tag*{(24)} W ^ Φ = ΛΦ , λ = ± k q (24)
ϕ 1 = ( cos θ / 2 sin θ / 2 ) ϕ 2 = ( − sin θ / 2 cos θ / 2 ) (25) \phi_1 =
\begin{pmatrix}
\cos\theta/2 \\
\sin\theta/2
\end{pmatrix}
\qquad
\phi_2 =
\begin{pmatrix}
-\sin\theta/2 \\
\cos\theta/2
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(25)} ϕ 1 = ( cos θ /2 sin θ /2 ) ϕ 2 = ( − sin θ /2 cos θ /2 ) (25)
It could be noted that if θ \theta θ becomes θ + 2 π \theta+2\pi θ + 2 π , the adiabatic nuclear wavefunctions (ϕ 1 \phi_1 ϕ 1 and ϕ 2 \phi_2 ϕ 2 ) change sign as per Figure 3.3 2,3.
Figure 3.3. Sign inversion property of adiabatic nuclear eigenfunction along a closed loop encircling degenerate point.
While removing the multi-valuedness of the nuclear eigenfunctions, Longuet-Higgins introduced a complex phase factor in an ad-hoc manner,4 which takes care of the sign of the wavefunctions:
ζ 1 = e i θ / 2 ϕ 1 = e i θ / 2 ( cos θ / 2 sin θ / 2 ) ζ 2 = e i θ / 2 ϕ 2 = e i θ / 2 ( − sin θ / 2 cos θ / 2 ) \zeta_1=e^{i\theta/2}\phi_1=e^{i\theta/2}
\begin{pmatrix}
\cos\theta/2 \\
\sin\theta/2
\end{pmatrix}
\qquad
\zeta_2=e^{i\theta/2}\phi_2=e^{i\theta/2}
\begin{pmatrix}
-\sin\theta/2 \\
\cos\theta/2
\end{pmatrix} ζ 1 = e i θ /2 ϕ 1 = e i θ /2 ( cos θ /2 sin θ /2 ) ζ 2 = e i θ /2 ϕ 2 = e i θ /2 ( − sin θ /2 cos θ /2 )
Hence, ζ i ( θ + 2 π ) = ζ i ( θ ) \zeta_i(\theta+2\pi)=\zeta_i(\theta) ζ i ( θ + 2 π ) = ζ i ( θ ) , i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 and the eigenfunctions become single-valued.
Figure 3.2. Potential energy surfaces with JT distortion
Van Vleck's Approach on JT Model for Realistic Systems
To explore the validity of the JT model, an octahedral complex, X Y 6 XY_6 X Y 6 is considered having fifteen (15) normal modes. Since such a complex contains a center of symmetry, the modes can be classified into gerade (g g g ) and ungerade (u u u ) symmetry.5 On using the JT condition (Eq. 9.3), one can write:
Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ Γ α 2 ] (26) \Gamma^{0} \in\Gamma^{\beta} \otimes\left[\Gamma^{\alpha2}\right] \tag*{(26)} Γ 0 ∈ Γ β ⊗ [ Γ α 2 ] (26)
Since the symmetrised product of the degenerate electronic states (d d d orbitals) of the central metal atom ([ Γ α 2 ] [\Gamma^{\alpha2}] [ Γ α 2 ] ) gives Γ ( g ) \Gamma^{(g)} Γ ( g ) IREP, JT condition will be true only if: Γ β = Γ ( g ) \Gamma^{\beta} = \Gamma^{(g)} Γ β = Γ ( g ) .
As mentioned before, in case of linear perturbation term in the Hamiltonian, the gerade modes will be JT active lifting the degeneracy of the unperturbed Hamiltonian, whereas the ungerade ones will not contribute. As a consequence, the following six (6) modes out of fifteen (15) are of even or ‘g g g ’ type, where Q 2 − Q 6 Q_2-Q_6 Q 2 − Q 6 are the five JT active modes. On the contrary, Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 is not JT active, since it is the totally symmetric one:
Q 1 = [ X 1 − X 4 + Y 2 − Y 5 + Z 3 − Z 6 ] / 6 Q 2 = 1 2 [ X 1 − X 4 − Y 2 + Y 5 ] Q 3 = [ 1 2 ( X 1 − X 4 + Y 2 − Y 5 ) − Z 3 + Z 6 ] / 3 Q 4 = 1 2 [ Y 1 − Y 4 + X 2 − X 5 ] Q 5 = 1 2 [ Z 1 − Z 4 + X 3 − X 6 ] Q 6 = 1 2 [ Z 2 − Z 5 + Y 3 − Y 6 ] \begin{aligned}
Q_1 &= [X_1-X_4+Y_2-Y_5+Z_3-Z_6]/\sqrt{6} \\
Q_2 &= \frac{1}{2}[X_1-X_4-Y_2+Y_5] \\
Q_3 &= [\frac{1}{2}(X_1-X_4+Y_2-Y_5)-Z_3+Z_6]/\sqrt{3} \\
Q_4 &= \frac{1}{2}[Y_1-Y_4+X_2-X_5] \\
Q_5 &= \frac{1}{2}[Z_1-Z_4+X_3-X_6] \\
Q_6 &= \frac{1}{2}[Z_2-Z_5+Y_3-Y_6]
\end{aligned} Q 1 Q 2 Q 3 Q 4 Q 5 Q 6 = [ X 1 − X 4 + Y 2 − Y 5 + Z 3 − Z 6 ] / 6 = 2 1 [ X 1 − X 4 − Y 2 + Y 5 ] = [ 2 1 ( X 1 − X 4 + Y 2 − Y 5 ) − Z 3 + Z 6 ] / 3 = 2 1 [ Y 1 − Y 4 + X 2 − X 5 ] = 2 1 [ Z 1 − Z 4 + X 3 − X 6 ] = 2 1 [ Z 2 − Z 5 + Y 3 − Y 6 ]
where X i , Y i , Z i X_i,Y_i,Z_i X i , Y i , Z i represent displacements of i i i th ligand from the ideal octahedral arrangement (see Figure 3.4 ). Therefore, the JT distorted Hamiltonian can be written as:5
Figure 3.4. Vectorial displacements of atoms in octahedral molecule for six gerade (g) symmetric vibrational modes.
H = W 0 + V t r i g + 1 2 α Q 1 2 + 1 2 β ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) + 1 2 γ Q 4 ′ 2 + 1 2 δ ( Q 5 2 + Q 6 2 ) + V 2 Q 2 + V 3 Q 3 + V 4 ′ Q 4 ′ + V 5 ′ Q 5 ′ + V 6 ′ Q 6 ′ + θ Q 1 Q 4 ′ + κ ( Q 2 Q 5 ′ + Q 3 Q 6 ′ ) + ∑ i = 7 15 ∑ j = 7 15 ξ i j Q i Q j , \begin{aligned}
H ={}& W_0+V_{\mathrm{trig}} \\
&+ \frac{1}{2}\alpha Q_1^2+\frac{1}{2}\beta(Q_2^2+Q_3^2)+\frac{1}{2}\gamma Q_4'^2+\frac{1}{2}\delta(Q_5^2+Q_6^2) \\
&+V_2Q_2+V_3Q_3+V_4'Q_4'+V_5'Q_5'+V_6'Q_6' \\
&+\theta Q_1Q_4'+\kappa(Q_2Q_5'+Q_3Q_6')+\sum_{i=7}^{15}\sum_{j=7}^{15}\xi_{ij}Q_iQ_j,
\end{aligned} H = W 0 + V trig + 2 1 α Q 1 2 + 2 1 β ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) + 2 1 γ Q 4 ′2 + 2 1 δ ( Q 5 2 + Q 6 2 ) + V 2 Q 2 + V 3 Q 3 + V 4 ′ Q 4 ′ + V 5 ′ Q 5 ′ + V 6 ′ Q 6 ′ + θ Q 1 Q 4 ′ + κ ( Q 2 Q 5 ′ + Q 3 Q 6 ′ ) + i = 7 ∑ 15 j = 7 ∑ 15 ξ ij Q i Q j ,
where Q i ′ = ∑ j = 1 6 c j Q j Q'_i=\sum_{j=1}^{6}c_jQ_j Q i ′ = ∑ j = 1 6 c j Q j , i = 4 , 5 , 6 i=4,5,6 i = 4 , 5 , 6 . W 0 W_0 W 0 is the unperturbed Hamiltonian for rotational and translational modes and also contains electronic Hamiltonian of the cluster at octahedral geometry of cubic symmetry. V t r i g V_{\mathrm{trig}} V trig defines the potential where the central atom experiences perturbation due to the bulk crystal atoms. On the other hand, V 2 V_2 V 2 to V 6 V_6 V 6 are the coefficients of the first order perturbation term resulting the JT effect.
While applying the degenerate perturbation theory (Eq. (11) ) and incorporating the above Hamiltonian, the secular equation can be formed and the degeneracy of the d d d orbitals of the central metal atom will be split exhibiting the JT effect:
∑ j = 1 m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ V ^ ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 (27) \sum_{j=1}^{m}\left[\langle\phi_i^{(0)}|\hat{V}|\phi_j^{(0)}\rangle-E_n^{(1)}\langle\phi_i^{(0)}|\phi_j^{(0)}\rangle\right]c_j^n=0 \tag*{(27)} j = 1 ∑ m [ ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ V ^ ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ − E n ( 1 ) ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ ] c j n = 0 (27)
V i j = ∑ k Q k ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ V ^ k ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ . (28) V_{ij}=\sum_k Q_k\langle\phi_i^{(0)}|\hat{V}_k|\phi_j^{(0)}\rangle. \tag*{(28)} V ij = k ∑ Q k ⟨ ϕ i ( 0 ) ∣ V ^ k ∣ ϕ j ( 0 ) ⟩ . (28)
E m n = E n 0 + E m n ( 1 ) (29) E_{mn}=E_n^0+E_{mn}^{(1)} \tag*{(29)} E mn = E n 0 + E mn ( 1 ) (29)
Dynamic JT Effect
The distortion phenomenon in the phase transition of rare-earth manganites
Orthorhombic rare-earth manganites, namely, R E M n O 3 \mathrm{REMnO}_3 REMnO 3 (RE= La, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy) are perovskites with M n 3 + \mathrm{Mn}^{3+} Mn 3 + (d 4 d^4 d 4 ) ions with t 2 g 3 e g 1 t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{1} t 2 g 3 e g 1 electronic configuration. Its high temperature phase is nearly cubic, which at T O O T_{\mathrm{OO}} T OO (orbital ordering temperature), undergoes a transition into the orthorhombic orbitally ordered P b n m Pbnm P bnm structure with an antiferrodistortive ordering of M n O 6 \mathrm{MnO}_6 MnO 6 octahedra as depicted in Figure 3.5 .1
Figure 3.5. (a) Structure of the high-temperature pseudo-cubic perovskite phase of rare-earth manganites R E M n O 3 \mathrm{RE}\mathrm{MnO}_{3} RE MnO 3 . (b) Structure of the orthorhombic P b n m \mathit{Pbnm} Pbnm phase of R E M n O 3 \mathrm{RE}\mathrm{MnO}_{3} RE MnO 3 below the orbital ordering temperature T O O T_{\mathrm{OO}} T OO .6
Recent ab initio studies7 demonstrate that superexchange (SE)8,9 interaction cannot initiate the transition at T O O T_{\mathrm{OO}} T OO . SE favors the occupation of the e g e_g e g orbital with the orbital angle θ ∠ M n − O − M n = 90 ∘ \theta_{\angle\mathrm{Mn}-\mathrm{O}-\mathrm{Mn}} = 90^\circ θ ∠ Mn − O − Mn = 9 0 ∘ , whereas the orbital angle determined from the neutron scattering for L a M n O 3 \mathrm{LaMnO}_{3} LaMnO 3 is θ ∠ M n − O − M n = 180 ∘ \theta_{\angle\mathrm{Mn}-\mathrm{O}-\mathrm{Mn}} = 180^\circ θ ∠ Mn − O − Mn = 18 0 ∘ for cubic structure (non-antiferromagnetic) and θ ∠ M n − O − M n ∼ 108 ∘ \theta_{\angle\mathrm{Mn}-\mathrm{O}-\mathrm{Mn}} \sim108^\circ θ ∠ Mn − O − Mn ∼ 10 8 ∘ for orthorhombic P b n m \mathit{Pbnm} Pbnm structure (antiferrodistortive). For comparison, the orbital angle of an isolated JT distorted M n O 6 \mathrm{MnO}_{6} MnO 6 complex is θ ∠ M n − O − M n = 120 ∘ \theta_{\angle\mathrm{Mn}-\mathrm{O}-\mathrm{Mn}} = 120^\circ θ ∠ Mn − O − Mn = 12 0 ∘ .
Figure 3.6. Superexchange antiferromagnetic interaction
The Jahn-Teller Effect In Octahedrally Co-ordinated Complex
The phenomenon of JT effect can be modelled5 by the following potential energy operator:
V = A [ − Q 3 − Q 2 − Q 2 Q 3 ] + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) , (30) V=A\begin{bmatrix}-Q_{3} & -Q_{2}\\-Q_{2} & Q_{3}\end{bmatrix}+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\text{-}vib}^{2}(Q_{2}^{2}+Q_{3}^{2}), \tag*{(30)} V = A [ − Q 3 − Q 2 − Q 2 Q 3 ] + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) , (30)
which operates on the column matrix [ a b ] \begin{bmatrix}a\\b\end{bmatrix} [ a b ] with a ∣ x 2 − y 2 ⟩ + b ∣ 3 z 2 − r 2 ⟩ a|x^{2}-y^{2}\rangle+b|3z^{2}-r^{2}\rangle a ∣ x 2 − y 2 ⟩ + b ∣3 z 2 − r 2 ⟩ as the electronic state. The term A A A is the Jahn-Teller term, which shows linear dependence on the nuclear coordinates, Q Q Q s. The two new variables ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ are defined as Q 3 = ρ cos ϕ , Q 2 = ρ sin ϕ Q_{3}=\rho\cos\phi,Q_{2}=\rho\sin\phi Q 3 = ρ cos ϕ , Q 2 = ρ sin ϕ . The eigenvalues of the system under the linear Jahn-Teller perturbation are ± A ρ \pm A\rho ± A ρ .
On the other hand, the vibronic potential energy surface appears as a ‘Mexican Hat’ with the following functional form:
V ± = ± A ρ + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ρ 2 (31) V_{\pm}=\pm A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\text{-}vib}^{2}\rho^{2} \tag*{(31)} V ± = ± A ρ + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ρ 2 (31)
and can be demonstrated pictorially in Figure 3.7 .
Figure 3.7. Diagram indicating JT splitting of nuclear potential function into two branches 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ρ 2 ± A ρ \frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\text{-}vib}^{2}\rho^{2}\pm A\rho 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ρ 2 ± A ρ with E J T = A 2 2 M ω b - v i b 2 E_{JT}=\frac{A^{2}}{2M\omega_{b\text{-}vib}^{2}} E J T = 2 M ω b - v ib 2 A 2 . The diagram has been adopted from Ref. [10] and permission has been taken from Royal Society.
The JT distortion stabilizes the ground state with the amount of energy, E J T = ( A 2 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ) E_{JT} = \left(\frac{A^2}{2M\omega_{b,\mathrm{vib}}^2}\right) E J T = ( 2 M ω b , vib 2 A 2 ) 10 As a consequence, the molecular species can adapt a new geometry, which may be elongated or compressed.
A treatment for coupled electron-nuclear motion
The motion of singly occupied electron in E g E_g E g electronic state for the d 4 d^4 d 4 and d 9 d^9 d 9 transition metal ions (Mn3 + ^{3+} 3 + , Cu2 + ^{2+} 2 + ) resembles as a particle in a ring motion with electronic angular coordinate, θ \theta θ . When the circular motion of the electron is elliptically deformed by a doubly degenerate vibrational modes Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 and Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 of e g e_g e g symmetry, the nature of coupling potential energy between electron and nuclear motion should be an even function of 2 θ − ϕ 2\theta-\phi 2 θ − ϕ .10
Figure 3.8. Model system exhibiting the Jahn-Teller effect. The diagrams have been extracted from Ref. [10] and permission has been taken from Royal Society.
For such systems, one can write:
H ′ = 2 A ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) = A ρ { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } (32) H' = 2A\rho\cos(2\theta-\phi) = A\rho\left\{e^{i(2\theta-\phi)} + e^{-i(2\theta-\phi)}\right\} \tag*{(32)} H ′ = 2 A ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) = A ρ { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } (32)
It is assumed that there is no coupling between the motions of the electron and the ring. The wave function for the system then takes the following expression:
Ψ = 1 2 π χ e i j θ ( j = 0 , ± 1 , ± 2 , … ) (33) \Psi= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}\chi e^{ij\theta} \qquad(j = 0,\pm1,\pm2,\ldots) \tag*{(33)} Ψ = 2 π 1 χ e ij θ ( j = 0 , ± 1 , ± 2 , … ) (33)
where χ \chi χ represents wavefunction for an isotropic two dimensional harmonic oscillator and 1 2 π e i j θ \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}e^{ij\theta} 2 π 1 e ij θ defines the quantum mechanical solution of a particle in a ring. In other words, an electron is moving in a circular path with a constant radius, where j j j is the set of integers representing the rotational quantum number.
In polar co-ordinate, the unperturbed nuclear Schrödinger equation transforms as:
[ − ℏ 2 2 M ( ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ ∂ ∂ ρ + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 ) + 1 2 M ω ρ 2 ρ 2 ] χ = E χ . (34) \left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}\right)+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_\rho^2\rho^2\right]\chi= E\chi. \tag*{(34)} [ − 2 M ℏ 2 ( ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + ρ 1 ∂ ρ ∂ + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 ) + 2 1 M ω ρ 2 ρ 2 ] χ = E χ . (34)
The solutions of this equation are of the following form:
χ n m ( ρ , ϕ ) = τ n ∣ m ∣ ( ρ ) e i m ϕ , E m n = n (35) \chi_{nm}(\rho,\phi)=\tau_{n|m|}(\rho)e^{im\phi}, \qquad E_{mn}=n \tag*{(35)} χ nm ( ρ , ϕ ) = τ n ∣ m ∣ ( ρ ) e im ϕ , E mn = n (35)
where n = 1 , 2 , … n=1,2,\ldots n = 1 , 2 , … , and m = n − 1 , n − 3 , … , − n + 1 m=n-1,n-3,\ldots,-n+1 m = n − 1 , n − 3 , … , − n + 1 .
Evaluation of non-vanishing matrix element lh-opik
The total wavefunction of the uncoupled system for a particular j j j value can be written as: 10
Ψ n m j = 1 2 π χ n m e i j θ = 1 2 π τ n ∣ m ∣ e i ( m ϕ + j θ ) (36) \Psi_{nm}^{j} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}\chi_{nm}e^{ij\theta} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}\tau_{n|m|}e^{i(m\phi+j\theta)} \tag*{(36)} Ψ nm j = 2 π 1 χ nm e ij θ = 2 π 1 τ n ∣ m ∣ e i ( m ϕ + j θ ) (36)
where the matrix element is defined as:
⟨ Ψ n m j | H ′ | Ψ n ′ m ′ j ′ ⟩ = 1 2 π τ n ∣ m ∣ τ n ′ ∣ m ′ ∣ A ρ ⟨ e i ( m ϕ + j θ ) | { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } | e i ( m ′ ϕ + j ′ θ ) ⟩ (37) \left\langle\Psi_{nm}^{j}\middle|H'\middle|\Psi_{n'm'}^{j'}\right\rangle= \frac{1}{2\pi}\tau_{n|m|}\tau_{n'|m'|}A\rho\left\langle e^{i(m\phi+j\theta)}\middle|\left\{e^{i(2\theta-\phi)}+e^{-i(2\theta-\phi)}\right\}\middle|e^{i(m'\phi+j'\theta)}\right\rangle \tag*{(37)} ⟨ Ψ nm j H ′ Ψ n ′ m ′ j ′ ⟩ = 2 π 1 τ n ∣ m ∣ τ n ′ ∣ m ′ ∣ A ρ ⟨ e i ( m ϕ + j θ ) { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } e i ( m ′ ϕ + j ′ θ ) ⟩ (37)
Such integral would not vanish, if the following conditions fulfill:
j ′ = j − 2 , m ′ = m + 1 j'=j-2,\ m'=m+1 j ′ = j − 2 , m ′ = m + 1
j ′ = j + 2 , m ′ = m − 1 j'=j+2,\ m'=m-1 j ′ = j + 2 , m ′ = m − 1
Therefore, it can be readily realized that only for the case, ∣ j ∣ = ∣ j ′ ∣ = 1 |j|=|j'|=1 ∣ j ∣ = ∣ j ′ ∣ = 1 , two vibrational levels of the same electronic state interact under the perturbation H ′ H' H ′ .
Figure 3.9. Interaction scheme between the levels of ψ n m ( ρ , ϕ ) \psi_{nm}(\rho,\phi) ψ nm ( ρ , ϕ ) for ∣ j ∣ = 1 |j|=1 ∣ j ∣ = 1 under H ′ = 2 A ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) H'=2A\rho\cos(2\theta-\phi) H ′ = 2 A ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) . The diagram has been adapted from Ref. [10] and permission has been taken from Royal Society.
The interesting fact is that levels do not interact together, but only those with the same value of l = m + 1 2 j l=m+\frac{1}{2}j l = m + 2 1 j . The new quantum number l l l defines the electron-vibration coupling.
The perturbation H ′ H' H ′ mixes levels together whose j j j values are + 1 +1 + 1 and − 1 -1 − 1 . Thereby, the wavefunction for given l l l is of the following form:
Ψ = χ + ( ρ , ϕ ) ψ + ( θ ) + χ − ( ρ , ϕ ) ψ − ( θ ) , (38) \Psi= \chi_{+}(\rho,\phi)\psi_{+}(\theta) + \chi_{-}(\rho,\phi)\psi_{-}(\theta), \tag*{(38)} Ψ = χ + ( ρ , ϕ ) ψ + ( θ ) + χ − ( ρ , ϕ ) ψ − ( θ ) , (38)
where χ ± \chi_{\pm} χ ± and ψ ± \psi_{\pm} ψ ± are the nuclear and electronic wavefunctions, respectively, with
χ + = τ l + ( ρ ) e i ( l − 1 2 j ) ϕ , χ − = τ l − ( ρ ) e i ( l + 1 2 j ) ϕ . (39) \chi_{+} = \tau_{l}^{+}(\rho)e^{i(l-\frac{1}{2}j)\phi}, \qquad\chi_{-} = \tau_{l}^{-}(\rho)e^{i(l+\frac{1}{2}j)\phi}. \tag*{(39)} χ + = τ l + ( ρ ) e i ( l − 2 1 j ) ϕ , χ − = τ l − ( ρ ) e i ( l + 2 1 j ) ϕ . (39)
Under the linear Jahn-Teller perturbation, H ′ = A ρ { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } H' = A\rho\{e^{i(2\theta-\phi)}+e^{-i(2\theta-\phi)}\} H ′ = A ρ { e i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) + e − i ( 2 θ − ϕ ) } , the χ + \chi_{+} χ + and χ − \chi_{-} χ − are coupled through the following matrix, which is known as Dynamic Jahn-Teller matrix:
\begin{pmatrix}
H_{0}-E & A\rho e^{-i\phi} \\
A\rho e^{i\phi} & H_{0}-E
\end{pmatrix}
\begin{pmatrix}
\chi_{+} \\
\chi_{-}
\end{pmatrix}
= 0 \tag*{(40)}\end{pmatrix}
leading to
[ ℏ 2 2 M { − d 2 d ρ 2 − 1 ρ d d ρ + ( l − 1 2 ) 2 ρ 2 } − E + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 ] τ l + ( ρ ) + A ρ τ l − ( ρ ) = 0 (41) \left[\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2M}\left\{-\frac{d^{2}}{d\rho^{2}}-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{d}{d\rho}+\frac{(l-\frac{1}{2})^{2}}{\rho^{2}}\right\}-E+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b,vib}^{2}\rho^{2}\right]\tau_{l}^{+}(\rho)+A\rho\tau_{l}^{-}(\rho)=0 \tag*{(41)} [ 2 M ℏ 2 { − d ρ 2 d 2 − ρ 1 d ρ d + ρ 2 ( l − 2 1 ) 2 } − E + 2 1 M ω b , v ib 2 ρ 2 ] τ l + ( ρ ) + A ρ τ l − ( ρ ) = 0 (41)
and
A ρ τ l + ( r ) + [ ℏ 2 2 M { − d 2 d ρ 2 − 1 ρ d d ρ + ( l + 1 2 ) 2 ρ 2 } − E + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 ] τ l − ( ρ ) = 0. (42) A\rho\tau_{l}^{+}(r)+\left[\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2M}\left\{-\frac{d^{2}}{d\rho^{2}}-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{d}{d\rho}+\frac{(l+\frac{1}{2})^{2}}{\rho^{2}}\right\}-E+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b,vib}^{2}\rho^{2}\right]\tau_{l}^{-}(\rho)=0. \tag*{(42)} A ρ τ l + ( r ) + [ 2 M ℏ 2 { − d ρ 2 d 2 − ρ 1 d ρ d + ρ 2 ( l + 2 1 ) 2 } − E + 2 1 M ω b , v ib 2 ρ 2 ] τ l − ( ρ ) = 0. (42)
Subtracting the above two equations and multiplying with ( − 1 ) l − 1 2 (-1)^{l-\frac{1}{2}} ( − 1 ) l − 2 1 , we get the following compact form:
( H l − A ρ − E ) u g ( ρ ) = ( − 1 ) l − 1 2 ( ℏ 2 l 2 M ρ 2 ) u e ( ρ ) , (43) (H_l-A\rho-E)u_g(\rho)=(-1)^{l-\frac{1}{2}}\left(\frac{\hbar^{2}l}{2M\rho^{2}}\right)u_e(\rho), \tag*{(43)} ( H l − A ρ − E ) u g ( ρ ) = ( − 1 ) l − 2 1 ( 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l ) u e ( ρ ) , (43)
where u e ( ρ ) ≡ τ l + + τ l − u_e(\rho)\equiv\tau_l^{+}+\tau_l^{-} u e ( ρ ) ≡ τ l + + τ l − and u g ( ρ ) ≡ ( − 1 ) l − 1 2 ( τ l + − τ l − ) u_g(\rho)\equiv(-1)^{l-\frac{1}{2}}(\tau_l^{+}-\tau_l^{-}) u g ( ρ ) ≡ ( − 1 ) l − 2 1 ( τ l + − τ l − ) signify the wavefunctions for upper and lower branches of the PES, respectively. The associated nuclear Hamiltonian for l t h l^{th} l t h quantum number takes the following form:
H l = ℏ 2 2 M [ − d 2 d ρ 2 − 1 ρ d d ρ + l 2 + 1 4 ρ 2 ] + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 . (44) H_l=\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2M}\left[-\frac{d^{2}}{d\rho^{2}}-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{d}{d\rho}+\frac{l^{2}+\frac{1}{4}}{\rho^{2}}\right]+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b,vib}^{2}\rho^{2}. \tag*{(44)} H l = 2 M ℏ 2 [ − d ρ 2 d 2 − ρ 1 d ρ d + ρ 2 l 2 + 4 1 ] + 2 1 M ω b , v ib 2 ρ 2 . (44)
When ρ min = A 2 M ω 2 \rho_{\min}=\frac{A^{2}}{M\omega^{2}} ρ m i n = M ω 2 A 2 is large and E E E is low, the system is placed on lower Born-Oppenheimer surface. Hence, a good approximation is u e ( ρ ) = 0 u_e(\rho)=0 u e ( ρ ) = 0 and Eq. (43) turns into:
( H l − A ρ − E g ) u g ( ρ ) = 0 , (45) (H_l-A\rho-E^{g})u_g(\rho)=0, \tag*{(45)} ( H l − A ρ − E g ) u g ( ρ ) = 0 , (45)
where E g E^{g} E g corresponds to lower energy surface. While using u g ( ρ ) = ρ − 1 / 2 ψ g ( ρ ) u_g(\rho)=\rho^{-1/2}\psi_g(\rho) u g ( ρ ) = ρ − 1/2 ψ g ( ρ ) and substituted in above equation, we get the following radial Schrödinger equation:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ d 2 ψ g ( ρ ) d ρ 2 − l 2 ρ 2 ψ g ( ρ ) ] − E g ψ g ( ρ ) + ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ψ g ( ρ ) = 0. (46) -\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2M}\left[\frac{d^{2}\psi_g(\rho)}{d\rho^{2}}-\frac{l^{2}}{\rho^{2}}\psi_g(\rho)\right]-E^{g}\psi_g(\rho)+\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b,vib}^{2}\rho^{2}\right)\psi_g(\rho)=0. \tag*{(46)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ d ρ 2 d 2 ψ g ( ρ ) − ρ 2 l 2 ψ g ( ρ ) ] − E g ψ g ( ρ ) + ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b , v ib 2 ρ 2 ) ψ g ( ρ ) = 0. (46)
Thus, the total Schrödinger equation for the ground state becomes:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ ∂ 2 χ g ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 χ g ∂ ϕ 2 ] − E g χ g + ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 ) χ g = 0 , (47) -\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2M}\left[\frac{\partial^{2}\chi_g}{\partial\rho^{2}}+\frac{1}{\rho^{2}}\frac{\partial^{2}\chi_g}{\partial\phi^{2}}\right]-E^{g}\chi_g+\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b,vib}^{2}\rho^{2}\right)\chi_g=0, \tag*{(47)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 χ g + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 χ g ] − E g χ g + ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b , v ib 2 ρ 2 ) χ g = 0 , (47)
with χ g = ψ g ( ρ ) e i l ϕ \chi_g=\psi_g(\rho)e^{il\phi} χ g = ψ g ( ρ ) e i l ϕ . Moreover, while substituting the expressions of χ ± \chi_{\pm} χ ± , ψ g ( ρ ) \psi_g(\rho) ψ g ( ρ ) and u g ( ρ ) u_g(\rho) u g ( ρ ) as shown above, χ g \chi_g χ g can be written in terms of χ + \chi_+ χ + and χ − \chi_- χ − as
χ g = ρ ( − 1 ) l − 1 2 { χ + e i ϕ / 2 − χ − e − i ϕ / 2 } = ρ ( − 1 ) l − 1 2 { τ l + ( ρ ) − τ l − ( ρ ) } e i l ϕ (48) \begin{aligned}
\chi_g &= \sqrt{\rho}(-1)^{l-\frac{1}{2}}\{\chi_+e^{i\phi/2}-\chi_-e^{-i\phi/2}\}\\
&= \sqrt{\rho}(-1)^{l-\frac{1}{2}}\{\tau_l^+(\rho)-\tau_l^-(\rho)\}e^{il\phi} \tag*{(48)}
\end{aligned} χ g = ρ ( − 1 ) l − 2 1 { χ + e i ϕ /2 − χ − e − i ϕ /2 } = ρ ( − 1 ) l − 2 1 { τ l + ( ρ ) − τ l − ( ρ )} e i l ϕ (48)
On the other hand, the Schrödinger equation for excited state takes the following form:
( H l + A ρ − E ) u e ( ρ ) = ( − 1 ) − ( l − 1 2 ) ( ℏ 2 l 2 M ρ 2 ) u g ( ρ ) , (49) (H_l+A\rho-E)u_e(\rho)=(-1)^{-(l-\frac{1}{2})}\left(\frac{\hbar^2l}{2M\rho^2}\right)u_g(\rho), \tag*{(49)} ( H l + A ρ − E ) u e ( ρ ) = ( − 1 ) − ( l − 2 1 ) ( 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l ) u g ( ρ ) , (49)
When the energy (E E E ) is substantially high, the Eq. (49) turns into the following form:
( H l + A ρ − E e ) u e ( ρ ) = 0. (50) (H_l+A\rho-E^e)u_e(\rho)=0. \tag*{(50)} ( H l + A ρ − E e ) u e ( ρ ) = 0. (50)
Employing u e ( ρ ) = ρ − 1 / 2 ψ e ( ρ ) u_e(\rho)=\rho^{-1/2}\psi_e(\rho) u e ( ρ ) = ρ − 1/2 ψ e ( ρ ) , the following expression of radial nuclear SE for excited state is obtained:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ d 2 ψ e ( ρ ) d ρ 2 − l 2 ρ 2 ψ e ( ρ ) ] − E e ψ e ( ρ ) + ( A ρ + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ψ e ( ρ ) = 0. (51) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left[\frac{d^2\psi_e(\rho)}{d\rho^2}-\frac{l^2}{\rho^2}\psi_e(\rho)\right]-E^e\psi_e(\rho)+\left(A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}\rho^2\right)\psi_e(\rho)=0. \tag*{(51)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ d ρ 2 d 2 ψ e ( ρ ) − ρ 2 l 2 ψ e ( ρ ) ] − E e ψ e ( ρ ) + ( A ρ + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ρ 2 ) ψ e ( ρ ) = 0. (51)
As a consequence, the total SE for the excited state can be expressed as:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ ∂ 2 χ e ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 χ e ∂ ϕ 2 ] − E e χ e + ( A ρ + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ρ 2 ) χ e = 0 , (52) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left[\frac{\partial^2\chi_e}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2\chi_e}{\partial\phi^2}\right]-E^e\chi_e+\left(A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}\rho^2\right)\chi_e=0, \tag*{(52)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 χ e + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 χ e ] − E e χ e + ( A ρ + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ρ 2 ) χ e = 0 , (52)
with χ e = ψ e ( ρ ) e i l ϕ \chi_e=\psi_e(\rho)e^{il\phi} χ e = ψ e ( ρ ) e i l ϕ . Similarly, we have defined χ e \chi_e χ e in terms of χ + \chi_+ χ + and χ − \chi_- χ − :
χ e = ρ { χ + e i ϕ / 2 + χ − e − i ϕ / 2 } = ρ { τ l + ( ρ ) + τ l − ( ρ ) } e i l ϕ (53) \begin{aligned}
\chi_e &= \sqrt{\rho}\{\chi_+e^{i\phi/2}+\chi_-e^{-i\phi/2}\}\\
&= \sqrt{\rho}\{\tau_l^+(\rho)+\tau_l^-(\rho)\}e^{il\phi} \tag*{(53)}
\end{aligned} χ e = ρ { χ + e i ϕ /2 + χ − e − i ϕ /2 } = ρ { τ l + ( ρ ) + τ l − ( ρ )} e i l ϕ (53)
Ground state adiabatic Schrödinger equation under cubic perturbation
The radial Schrödinger equation for the ground electronic state is defined as:10
− ℏ 2 2 M [ d 2 ψ g ( ρ ) d ρ 2 − l 2 ρ 2 ψ g ( ρ ) ] − E g ψ g ( ρ ) + ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ψ g ( ρ ) = 0. (54) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left[\frac{d^2\psi_g(\rho)}{d\rho^2}-\frac{l^2}{\rho^2}\psi_g(\rho)\right]-E^g\psi_g(\rho)+\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}\rho^2\right)\psi_g(\rho)=0. \tag*{(54)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ d ρ 2 d 2 ψ g ( ρ ) − ρ 2 l 2 ψ g ( ρ ) ] − E g ψ g ( ρ ) + ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ρ 2 ) ψ g ( ρ ) = 0. (54)
Since the centrifugal term ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 \frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 appears as constant ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 0 2 \frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho_0^2} 2 M ρ 0 2 ℏ 2 l 2 at the minima (ρ 0 = A M ω b - v i b 2 \rho_0=\frac{A}{M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}} ρ 0 = M ω b - v ib 2 A ) of the lower ‘Mexican hat’ PES, the above equation can be transformed with shifted coordinate s ( = ρ − ρ 0 ) s(=\rho-\rho_0) s ( = ρ − ρ 0 ) as:
( − ℏ 2 2 M d 2 d s 2 + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 s 2 ) w g ( s ) = ( E g + A 2 2 M ω b - v i b 2 − ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 0 2 ) w g ( s ) , (55) \left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\frac{d^2}{ds^2}+\frac{1}{2}M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}s^2\right)w_g(s)=\left(E^g+\frac{A^2}{2M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}}-\frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho_0^2}\right)w_g(s), \tag*{(55)} ( − 2 M ℏ 2 d s 2 d 2 + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 s 2 ) w g ( s ) = ( E g + 2 M ω b - v ib 2 A 2 − 2 M ρ 0 2 ℏ 2 l 2 ) w g ( s ) , (55)
where the corresponding expression for the eigenvalues takes the following form:
E p l g = ℏ ω b - v i b ( p + 1 2 ) − A 2 2 M ω b - v i b 2 + ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 0 2 , p = 0 , 1 , 2 , ⋯ (56) E^g_{pl}=\hbar\omega_{b\text{-}vib}\left(p+\frac{1}{2}\right)-\frac{A^2}{2M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}}+\frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho_0^2},\qquad p=0,1,2,\cdots \tag*{(56)} E pl g = ℏ ω b - v ib ( p + 2 1 ) − 2 M ω b - v ib 2 A 2 + 2 M ρ 0 2 ℏ 2 l 2 , p = 0 , 1 , 2 , ⋯ (56)
Therefore, at the minima of ground state PES, nuclei behave as a rotating oscillator.
On the other hand, the potential energy operator in presence of anharmonicity can be defined as:11
V = A [ − Q 3 − Q 2 − Q 2 Q 3 ] + 1 2 M ω b - v i b 2 ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) + A 3 Q 3 ( Q 3 2 − 3 Q 2 2 ) . (57) V=A\begin{bmatrix}-Q_3 & -Q_2\\-Q_2 & Q_3\end{bmatrix}+\frac{1}{2}M\omega^2_{b\text{-}vib}(Q_2^2+Q_3^2)+A_3Q_3(Q_3^2-3Q_2^2). \tag*{(57)} V = A [ − Q 3 − Q 2 − Q 2 Q 3 ] + 2 1 M ω b - v ib 2 ( Q 2 2 + Q 3 2 ) + A 3 Q 3 ( Q 3 2 − 3 Q 2 2 ) . (57)
In polar coordinate, the anharmonic term transforms as:3
A 3 Q 3 ( Q 3 2 − 3 Q 2 2 ) ⟹ A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ (58) A_3 Q_3\left(Q_3^2-3Q_2^2\right) \Longrightarrow A_3\rho^3\cos3\phi \tag*{(58)} A 3 Q 3 ( Q 3 2 − 3 Q 2 2 ) ⟹ A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ (58)
and the lowest potential surface (see Figure 3.10 ) appears as:
Figure 3.10. Lower-sheet of the cubic perturbed Mexican hat surface in normal coordinate Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 and Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 , where V − = − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) + ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 V_-=-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\_vib}^2\rho^2+A_3\rho^3\cos(3\phi)+\frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} V − = − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b _ v ib 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) + 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 . Data has been taken from Ref. [12].
V − = − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ + ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 (59) V_-=-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\_vib}^2\rho^2+A_3\rho^3\cos3\phi+\frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} \tag*{(59)} V − = − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b _ v ib 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ + 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 (59)
Such surfaces possesses three minima as follows:
ϕ = 0 , 2 π 3 , 4 π 3 ; A 3 < 0 and ϕ = π 3 , π , 5 π 3 ; A 3 > 0. \phi=0,\frac{2\pi}{3},\frac{4\pi}{3};A_3<0\ \text{and}\ \phi=\frac{\pi}{3},\pi,\frac{5\pi}{3};A_3>0. ϕ = 0 , 3 2 π , 3 4 π ; A 3 < 0 and ϕ = 3 π , π , 3 5 π ; A 3 > 0.
In the above figure (Figure 3.10 ), since the ground adiabatic potential (V − V_- V − ) blows up at the vicinity r ∼ 0 r\sim0 r ∼ 0 due to the centrifugal term ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 \frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 though its width is very small, it doesn’t affect the three minima away from the center (ρ ∼ 0.3 \rho\sim0.3 ρ ∼ 0.3 Å) 6,12 arising at 120°(ϕ \phi ϕ ) interval. As a consequence, we neglect the centrifugal term and the solution of the radial part would be a harmonic oscillator one.
The Schrödinger equation for lower-sheet of the Mexican hat including the cubic perturbation term is of the following form:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 ] ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) − E ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) + ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) = 0 , (60) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left[\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}\right]\xi_g(\rho,\phi)-E\xi_g(\rho,\phi)
+\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{b\_vib}^2\rho^2+A_3\rho^3\cos(3\phi)\right)\xi_g(\rho,\phi)=0, \tag*{(60)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 ] ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) − E ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) + ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b _ v ib 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) = 0 , (60)
Dynamic JT Effect
If the cubic term is sufficiently small and the difference of the frequencies of the radial and rotational motion is sufficiently large, an approximation for separation of these variables is possible in the adiabatic approach.
The operator
− ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ (61) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}+A_3\rho^3\cos3\phi \tag*{(61)} − 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ (61)
acts as a perturbation within the unperturbed eigenstates, χ g ( ρ , ϕ ) \chi_g(\rho,\phi) χ g ( ρ , ϕ ) (see Eq. (47) ), where the perturbed eigenfunction ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) = [ w g 0 ( ρ ) γ ( ϕ ) ] \xi_g(\rho,\phi)=[w_g^0(\rho)\gamma(\phi)] ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) = [ w g 0 ( ρ ) γ ( ϕ )] is restricted with the lowest radial eigenfunction, w g 0 ( ρ ) w_g^0(\rho) w g 0 ( ρ ) .
Plugging the above form of wavefunction ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) \xi_g(\rho,\phi) ξ g ( ρ , ϕ ) , in the Eq. (60) , we obtain:
ℏ 2 2 M d 2 d ρ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 d 2 d ϕ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + E ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ − ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ = 0 (62) \frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\frac{d^2}{d\rho^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}\frac{d^2}{d\phi^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+E|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle-\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{\mathrm{b\_vib}}^2\rho^2+A_3\rho^3\cos(3\phi)\right)|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle=0 \tag*{(62)} 2 M ℏ 2 d ρ 2 d 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 d ϕ 2 d 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + E ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ − ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b_vib 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ = 0 (62)
After averaging over the radial part, the above equation ended up into the following form:
⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ d 2 d ϕ 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ℏ 2 2 M d 2 d ρ 2 + ϵ 0 − ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ = 0 (63) \langle w_g^0(\rho)|\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\frac{d^2}{d\phi^2}|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+\langle w_g^0(\rho)|-A_3\rho^3|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\cos(3\phi)|\gamma(\phi)\rangle
+\langle w_g^0(\rho)|\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\frac{d^2}{d\rho^2}+\epsilon_0-\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{\mathrm{b\_vib}}^2\rho^2\right)|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle
+\langle w_g^0(\rho)|\epsilon|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle=0 \tag*{(63)} ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ d ϕ 2 d 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ 2 M ℏ 2 d ρ 2 d 2 + ϵ 0 − ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b_vib 2 ρ 2 ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ = 0 (63)
It is necessary to mention that E = ϵ 0 + ϵ E=\epsilon_0+\epsilon E = ϵ 0 + ϵ , where ϵ 0 \epsilon_0 ϵ 0 defines energy without cubic perturbation and ϵ \epsilon ϵ represents energy of cubic perturbation:
ℏ 2 2 M d 2 d ρ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ + ϵ 0 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ − ( − A ρ + 1 2 M ω b _ v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ = 0 , (64) \frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\frac{d^2}{d\rho^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle+\epsilon_0|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle-\left(-A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{\mathrm{b\_vib}}^2\rho^2\right)|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle=0, \tag*{(64)} 2 M ℏ 2 d ρ 2 d 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ + ϵ 0 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ − ( − A ρ + 2 1 M ω b_vib 2 ρ 2 ) ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ = 0 , (64)
Using Eq. (64) , Eq. (63) turns into:
⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ d 2 d ϕ 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ = 0 ⟹ α d 2 d ϕ 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + β cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ + ϵ ∣ γ ( ϕ ) ⟩ = 0 , (65) \langle w_g^0(\rho)|\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\frac{d^2}{d\phi^2}|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+\langle w_g^0(\rho)|-A_3\rho^3|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\cos(3\phi)|\gamma(\phi)\rangle
+\langle w_g^0(\rho)|\epsilon|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle|\gamma(\phi)\rangle=0
\Longrightarrow\alpha\frac{d^2}{d\phi^2}|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+\beta\cos(3\phi)|\gamma(\phi)\rangle+\epsilon|\gamma(\phi)\rangle=0, \tag*{(65)} ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ d ϕ 2 d 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ = 0 ⟹ α d ϕ 2 d 2 ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + β cos ( 3 ϕ ) ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ + ϵ ∣ γ ( ϕ )⟩ = 0 , (65)
where
ϵ = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ⟹ Eigenvalue after perturbation α = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ⟹ Splitting parameter β = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ ) ⟩ ⟹ Barrier parameter (66) \begin{aligned}
\epsilon&= \langle w_g^0(\rho)|\epsilon|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\Longrightarrow\text{Eigenvalue after perturbation}\\
\alpha&= \langle w_g^0(\rho)|\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\Longrightarrow\text{Splitting parameter}\\
\beta&= \langle w_g^0(\rho)|-A_3\rho^3|w_g^0(\rho)\rangle\Longrightarrow\text{Barrier parameter} \tag*{(66)}
\end{aligned} ϵ α β = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ ϵ ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ⟹ Eigenvalue after perturbation = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ⟹ Splitting parameter = ⟨ w g 0 ( ρ ) ∣ − A 3 ρ 3 ∣ w g 0 ( ρ )⟩ ⟹ Barrier parameter (66)
The solutions of Eq. (65) can conveniently be written as a Fourier series:
γ = ∑ l a l e i l ϕ , (67) \gamma=\sum_l a_l e^{il\phi}, \tag*{(67)} γ = l ∑ a l e i l ϕ , (67)
l + 1 2 ≡ l+\frac{1}{2}\equiv l + 2 1 ≡ integer
The boundary condition can be defined as:
γ ( ϕ + 2 π ) = − γ ( ϕ ) . \gamma(\phi+2\pi)=-\gamma(\phi). γ ( ϕ + 2 π ) = − γ ( ϕ ) .
On the other hand, the coefficients satisfy the following recurrence relation
a l ( ϵ − α l 2 ) + 1 2 β ( a l − 3 + a l + 3 ) = 0. (68) a_l\left(\epsilon-\alpha l^2\right)+\frac{1}{2}\beta(a_{l-3}+a_{l+3})=0. \tag*{(68)} a l ( ϵ − α l 2 ) + 2 1 β ( a l − 3 + a l + 3 ) = 0. (68)
The equation (68) can be written in the following matrix form:
( ( ϵ − 49 α 4 ) 0 0 β 2 0 0 0 0 0 ( ϵ − 25 α 4 ) 0 0 β 2 0 0 0 0 0 ( ϵ − 9 α 4 ) 0 0 β 2 0 0 β 2 0 0 ( ϵ − α 4 ) 0 0 β 2 0 0 β 2 0 0 ( ϵ − α 4 ) 0 0 β 2 0 0 β 2 0 0 ( ϵ − 9 α 4 ) 0 0 0 0 0 β 2 0 0 ( ϵ − 25 α 4 ) 0 0 0 0 0 β 2 0 0 ( ϵ − 49 α 4 ) ) ( a − 7 / 2 a − 5 / 2 a − 3 / 2 a − 1 / 2 a 1 / 2 a 3 / 2 a 5 / 2 a 7 / 2 ) = 0 \begin{pmatrix}
\left(\epsilon-\frac{49\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{25\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{9\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 \\
\frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 \\
0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} \\
0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{9\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 & 0 \\
0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{25\alpha}{4}\right) & 0 \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{\beta}{2} & 0 & 0 & \left(\epsilon-\frac{49\alpha}{4}\right)
\end{pmatrix}
\begin{pmatrix}
a_{-7/2}\\
a_{-5/2}\\
a_{-3/2}\\
a_{-1/2}\\
a_{1/2}\\
a_{3/2}\\
a_{5/2}\\
a_{7/2}
\end{pmatrix}
=0 ( ϵ − 4 49 α ) 0 0 2 β 0 0 0 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 25 α ) 0 0 2 β 0 0 0 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 9 α ) 0 0 2 β 0 0 2 β 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 α ) 0 0 2 β 0 0 2 β 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 α ) 0 0 2 β 0 0 2 β 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 9 α ) 0 0 0 0 0 2 β 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 25 α ) 0 0 0 0 0 2 β 0 0 ( ϵ − 4 49 α ) a − 7/2 a − 5/2 a − 3/2 a − 1/2 a 1/2 a 3/2 a 5/2 a 7/2 = 0
Hence, the corresponding determinant can be diagonalised in order to find the eigenvalues of the Eq. (69) .
For the above equations, three kinds of solution are possible, namely, { l = ± 3 2 , ± 9 2 , ± 15 2 , … } \{l=\pm\frac{3}{2},\pm\frac{9}{2},\pm\frac{15}{2},\ldots\} { l = ± 2 3 , ± 2 9 , ± 2 15 , … } , { l = + 1 2 , − 5 2 , + 7 2 , − 11 2 , … } \{l=+\frac{1}{2},-\frac{5}{2},+\frac{7}{2},-\frac{11}{2},\ldots\} { l = + 2 1 , − 2 5 , + 2 7 , − 2 11 , … } and { l = − 1 2 , + 5 2 , − 7 2 , + 11 2 , … } \{l=-\frac{1}{2},+\frac{5}{2},-\frac{7}{2},+\frac{11}{2},\ldots\} { l = − 2 1 , + 2 5 , − 2 7 , + 2 11 , … } , and the solutions of the last two sets are degenerate pairs. The solution can be classified by representations of the symmetry group C 3 v C_{3v} C 3 v to which the equation belongs if ϕ \phi ϕ supposed to be a rotation about an axis.
l = ± 3 2 , ± 9 2 , ± 15 2 , … l=\pm\frac{3}{2},\pm\frac{9}{2},\pm\frac{15}{2},\ldots l = ± 2 3 , ± 2 9 , ± 2 15 , … transforms as A 1 A_1 A 1 if a l = a − l a_l=a_{-l} a l = a − l and transforms as A 2 A_2 A 2 if a l = − a − l a_l=-a_{-l} a l = − a − l . l = + 1 2 , − 5 2 , + 7 2 , − 11 2 , … ⟹ l=+\frac{1}{2},-\frac{5}{2},+\frac{7}{2},-\frac{11}{2},\ldots\Longrightarrow l = + 2 1 , − 2 5 , + 2 7 , − 2 11 , … ⟹ transforms as E E E (labeled as E E E ). l = − 1 2 , + 5 2 , − 7 2 , + 11 2 , … ⟹ l=-\frac{1}{2},+\frac{5}{2},-\frac{7}{2},+\frac{11}{2},\ldots\Longrightarrow l = − 2 1 , + 2 5 , − 2 7 , + 2 11 , … ⟹ transforms as E E E (labeled as E ′ E' E ′ ).
Excited state adiabatic Schrödinger equation under cubic perturbation
The nuclear SE for radial Hamiltonian of upper sheet of APES can be written as 13:
H ψ e ( ρ ) = ( − ℏ 2 2 M ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 + A ρ + 1 2 M ω b , v i b 2 ρ 2 ) ψ e ( ρ ) = E ψ e ( ρ ) , (69) H\psi_e(\rho)=\left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2}+A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{\mathrm{b,vib}}^2\rho^2\right)\psi_e(\rho)=E\psi_e(\rho), \tag*{(69)} H ψ e ( ρ ) = ( − 2 M ℏ 2 ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 + A ρ + 2 1 M ω b , vib 2 ρ 2 ) ψ e ( ρ ) = E ψ e ( ρ ) , (69)
where A A A and ω b , v i b \omega_{\mathrm{b,vib}} ω b , vib are the linear Jahn-Teller term and bond vibrational frequency, respectively. Contrary to the ground state with ‘Mexican hat’ PES, effect of centrifugal energy, ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 \frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 cannot be neglected in excited state, since the linear Jahn-Teller (A ρ A\rho A ρ ) term increases with ρ \rho ρ (contrast to the ground state) and gravitates the wavepacket to be localized at the vicinity of ρ ∼ 0 \rho\sim0 ρ ∼ 0 , where the centrifugal energy ℏ 2 l 2 2 M ρ 2 \frac{\hbar^2l^2}{2M\rho^2} 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 l 2 is of very large magnitude. In other words, the excited minima ({ ρ 0 l } \{\rho_0^l\} { ρ 0 l } ) are mainly formed due to two opposing forces, namely, centrifugal (F c e n t r i f u g a l = − ℏ 2 l 2 M ρ 3 F_{centrifugal} = -\frac{\hbar^{2}l^{2}}{M\rho^{3}} F ce n t r i f ug a l = − M ρ 3 ℏ 2 l 2 ) and linear Jahn-Teller (F J T = A F_{JT} = A F J T = A ) ones, where the resulted bound states are called centrifugally stabilized vibronic states13. The expression of minima and eigenvalues of radial Hamiltonian for such centrifugally stabilized states (excluding bond vibration) take the following forms within harmonic approximation13:
Figure 3.11. The variation of roto-vibrational energy levels for pseudo rotational quantum number l = 1 2 l = \frac{1}{2} l = 2 1 to l = 17 2 l = \frac{17}{2} l = 2 17 with respect to barrier parameter β \beta β for (a) [Cu(H2 _2 2 O)6 _6 6 ]2 + ^{2+} 2 + and (b) LaMnO3 _3 3 complexes. In case of [Cu(H2 _2 2 O)6 _6 6 ]2 + ^{2+} 2 + complex, α \alpha α and β \beta β values are 11 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 and 544 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , whereas for LaMnO3 _3 3 complex, α \alpha α and β \beta β values are 25 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 and 375 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , respectively.6,12 The figures have been taken from Ref. [12] and permission has been granted from American Institute of Physics (AIP).
∂ V + ∂ ρ = − ℏ 2 l 2 M ρ 3 + A = 0 ρ 0 l = ( ℏ 2 l 2 A M ) 1 3 (70) \begin{aligned}
\frac{\partial V_{+}}{\partial\rho} &= -\frac{\hbar^{2}l^{2}}{M\rho^{3}}+A=0\\
\rho_{0}^{l} &= \left(\frac{\hbar^{2}l^{2}}{AM}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}} \tag*{(70)}
\end{aligned} ∂ ρ ∂ V + ρ 0 l = − M ρ 3 ℏ 2 l 2 + A = 0 = ( A M ℏ 2 l 2 ) 3 1 (70)
E s , l ≅ ( ℏ A ) 2 / 3 M 1 / 3 [ 3 2 ∣ l ∣ 2 / 3 + 3 ( s + 1 2 ) ∣ l ∣ 1 / 3 ] , (71) E_{s,l} \cong\frac{(\hbar A)^{2/3}}{M^{1/3}}\left[\frac{3}{2}|l|^{2/3}+\sqrt{3}\frac{\left(s+\frac{1}{2}\right)}{|l|^{1/3}}\right], \tag*{(71)} E s , l ≅ M 1/3 ( ℏ A ) 2/3 [ 2 3 ∣ l ∣ 2/3 + 3 ∣ l ∣ 1/3 ( s + 2 1 ) ] , (71)
where s = 0 , 1 , 2 , . . . s = 0, 1, 2, ... s = 0 , 1 , 2 , ... and l = ± 1 2 , ± 3 2 , ± 5 2 , . . . l = \pm\frac{1}{2}, \pm\frac{3}{2}, \pm\frac{5}{2}, ... l = ± 2 1 , ± 2 3 , ± 2 5 , ... are the centrifugally stabilized vibrational and pseudo-rotational quantum numbers, respectively.
Incorporation of harmonic bond vibrational energy into the interaction Hamiltonian would lead to modulate the centrifugally stabilized roto-vibrational states with the following elastically coupled oscillation frequency12:
Ω l = [ 3 A 4 / 3 ( ℏ ∣ l ∣ M ) 2 / 3 + ω b _ v i b 2 ] 1 / 2 , (72) \Omega_l = \left[\frac{3A^{4/3}}{(\hbar|l| M)^{2/3}}+\omega_{b\_\mathrm{vib}}^{2}\right]^{1/2}, \tag*{(72)} Ω l = [ ( ℏ∣ l ∣ M ) 2/3 3 A 4/3 + ω b _ vib 2 ] 1/2 , (72)
and the eigenvalues of such entangled states satisfy the following form12:
E s , l b , v i b = 3 2 ( ℏ A ∣ l ∣ ) 2 / 3 M 1 / 3 + ℏ [ 3 A 4 / 3 ( ℏ ∣ l ∣ M ) 2 / 3 + ω b − v i b 2 ] 1 / 2 ( s + 1 2 ) . (73) E^{\mathrm{b,vib}}_{s,l}=\frac{3}{2}\frac{(\hbar A\lvert l\rvert)^{2/3}}{M^{1/3}}+\hbar\left[\frac{3A^{4/3}}{(\hbar\lvert l\rvert M)^{2/3}}+\omega_{\mathrm{b-vib}}^2\right]^{1/2}\left(s+\frac{1}{2}\right). \tag*{(73)} E s , l b , vib = 2 3 M 1/3 ( ℏ A ∣ l ∣ ) 2/3 + ℏ [ ( ℏ ∣ l ∣ M ) 2/3 3 A 4/3 + ω b − vib 2 ] 1/2 ( s + 2 1 ) . (73)
It is evident from Eqs. (71) , (72) and (73) that unlike usual oscillators, such centrifugally stabilized vibronic states are very much parametrically dependent on pseudo - rotational quantum number, l l l and thereby, lead to alteration of energy order of roto - vibrational levels in an interesting way. Moreover, the singularity of energy spectrum located at l = 0 l=0 l = 0 (see Eq. (73) ) emerges due to cone PES of the centrifugally stabilized excited state.
The striking difference between ground and excited electronic state is that in the upper sheet of ‘Mexican hat’ APES, centrifugal term contributes substantially, where the minima are determined by such centrifugal and linear Jahn-Teller forces (centrifugally stabilized state). As a result, determination of minima of cubic perturbed centrifugally stabilized vibronic states requires the entire spectrum of anharmonically perturbed pseudo - rotational energy on each grid point ( ρ i ) (\rho_i) ( ρ i ) of radial vibrational coordinate ( ρ ) (\rho) ( ρ ) Dutta et al. 12. Consequently, the nuclear SE of cubic perturbed excited state:
− ℏ 2 2 M [ ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 ] ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) − E ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) + ( A ρ + 1 2 M ω b − v i b 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) = 0 (74) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left[\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}\right]\xi_e(\rho,\phi)-E\xi_e(\rho,\phi)+\left(A\rho+\frac{1}{2}M\omega_{\mathrm{b-vib}}^2\rho^2+A_3\rho^3\cos(3\phi)\right)\xi_e(\rho,\phi)=0 \tag*{(74)} − 2 M ℏ 2 [ ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 ] ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) − E ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) + ( A ρ + 2 1 M ω b − vib 2 ρ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) = 0 (74)
has been averaged radially at every grid point ({ ρ i } \{\rho_i\} { ρ i } ) within adiabatic approximation, where − ℏ 2 2 M ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ -\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}+A_3\rho^3\cos3\phi − 2 M ρ 2 ℏ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 + A 3 ρ 3 cos 3 ϕ represents the perturbation and the radial part (w e ( ρ ) w_e(\rho) w e ( ρ ) ) of product type eigenfunction ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) ( = w e 0 ( ρ ) γ ( ϕ ) ) \xi_e(\rho,\phi)(=w_e^0(\rho)\gamma(\phi)) ξ e ( ρ , ϕ ) ( = w e 0 ( ρ ) γ ( ϕ )) is constrained to be at lowest harmonic vibrational state w e 0 ( ρ ) w_e^0(\rho) w e 0 ( ρ ) . The corresponding angular SE (Mathieu equation) for each ρ \rho ρ grid point turns into12:
α i ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 γ ( ϕ ) + β i cos ( 3 ϕ ) γ ( ϕ ) + ϵ ( ρ i ) γ ( ϕ ) = 0 , (75) \alpha_i\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}\gamma(\phi)+\beta_i\cos(3\phi)\gamma(\phi)+\epsilon(\rho_i)\gamma(\phi)=0, \tag*{(75)} α i ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 γ ( ϕ ) + β i cos ( 3 ϕ ) γ ( ϕ ) + ϵ ( ρ i ) γ ( ϕ ) = 0 , (75)
where both splitting α i ( = ℏ 2 2 M ρ i 2 ) \alpha_i(=\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho_i^2}) α i ( = 2 M ρ i 2 ℏ 2 ) and barrier β i ( = − A 3 ρ i 3 ) \beta_i(=-A_3\rho_i^3) β i ( = − A 3 ρ i 3 ) parameters become variables unlike for the ground state case ( α ( = ℏ 2 2 M ρ 0 2 ; ρ 0 ≡ ground state minima ) (\alpha(=\frac{\hbar^2}{2M\rho_0^2};\ \rho_0\equiv\text{ground state minima}) ( α ( = 2 M ρ 0 2 ℏ 2 ; ρ 0 ≡ ground state minima ) is constant and β \beta β is the variable). The spectrum of ϵ ( ρ ) \epsilon(\rho) ϵ ( ρ ) is obtained by solving the following secular equation of angular SE (Eq. (75) ) [employing γ ( ϕ ) = ∑ l a l exp ( i l ϕ ) \gamma(\phi)=\sum_l a_l\exp(il\phi) γ ( ϕ ) = ∑ l a l exp ( i l ϕ ) ] at every grid point ( { ρ i } ) (\{\rho_i\}) ({ ρ i }) :
a l ( ϵ ( ρ i ) − α i l 2 ) + 1 2 β i ( a l − 3 + a l + 3 ) = 0. (76) a_l\left(\epsilon(\rho_i)-\alpha_i l^2\right)+\frac{1}{2}\beta_i(a_{l-3}+a_{l+3})=0. \tag*{(76)} a l ( ϵ ( ρ i ) − α i l 2 ) + 2 1 β i ( a l − 3 + a l + 3 ) = 0. (76)
Such cubic perturbed roto - vibrational energies ( ϵ l ( ρ ) ) (\epsilon_l(\rho)) ( ϵ l ( ρ )) of various pseudo - rotational levels ( l ) (l) ( l ) form bound states with the association of linear Jahn-Teller energy ( A ρ ) (A\rho) ( A ρ ) . Thereby, the expression of cubic perturbed centrifugally stabilized excited state eigenvalues takes the following form within harmonic approximation (expanding V + = ( ϵ l ( ρ ) + A ρ ) V_+=(\epsilon_l(\rho)+A\rho) V + = ( ϵ l ( ρ ) + A ρ ) upto second order)12:
E s , l c p = ϵ l ( ρ 0 l ) + A ρ 0 l + ℏ [ 1 M 1 / 2 ( ∂ 2 V + ∂ ρ 2 ) ρ = ρ 0 l ] 1 / 2 ( s + 1 2 ) , (77) E^{\mathrm{cp}}_{s,l}=\epsilon_l(\rho_0^l)+A\rho_0^l+\hbar\left[\frac{1}{M^{1/2}}\left(\frac{\partial^2 V_+}{\partial\rho^2}\right)_{\rho=\rho_0^l}\right]^{1/2}\left(s+\frac{1}{2}\right), \tag*{(77)} E s , l cp = ϵ l ( ρ 0 l ) + A ρ 0 l + ℏ [ M 1/2 1 ( ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 V + ) ρ = ρ 0 l ] 1/2 ( s + 2 1 ) , (77)
where ρ 0 l \rho_0^l ρ 0 l represents the minimum of cubic perturbed centrifugally stabilized excited state PES for particular pseudo-rotational level, l l l . Such cubic perturbed centrifugally stabilized oscillators are dressed with the bond vibration resulting elastically entangled roto - vibrational levels with the following eigenvalues12:
E s , l c p + b v i b = ϵ l ( ρ 0 l ) + A ρ 0 l + ℏ [ 1 M ( ∂ 2 V + ∂ ρ 2 ) ρ = ρ 0 l ] 1 / 2 + ω 0 , v i b 2 ( s + 1 2 ) (78) E_{s,l}^{\mathrm{cp}+\mathrm{b}_{\mathrm{vib}}}=\epsilon_l(\rho_0^l)+A\rho_0^l+\hbar\left[\frac{1}{M}\left(\frac{\partial^2 V_+}{\partial\rho^2}\right)_{\rho=\rho_0^l}\right]^{1/2}+\omega_{0,\mathrm{vib}}^2\left(s+\frac{1}{2}\right) \tag*{(78)} E s , l cp + b vib = ϵ l ( ρ 0 l ) + A ρ 0 l + ℏ [ M 1 ( ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 V + ) ρ = ρ 0 l ] 1/2 + ω 0 , vib 2 ( s + 2 1 ) (78)
where s s s and l l l representing the centrifugally stabilized elastically coupled vibrational and roto-vibrational quantum numbers, respectively.
Chapter 4
Beyond Born-Oppenheimer Theory
Born-Oppenheimer Treatment
While advancing for Beyond Born-Oppenheimer (BBO) theory, first we need to formulate the first principle based Born-Oppenheimer (BO) treatment1,2. Since the total electron - nuclear Hamiltonian governs the molecular properties, such treatment was made with the aid of double perturbative theory on the molecular Hamiltonian.
Considering M M M , m m m , X X X , x x x , P P P and p p p as nuclear mass, electronic mass, nuclear coordinates, electronic coordinates, nuclear momenta and electronic momenta, respectively, the kinetic energy of the nuclei can be written as:
T N = ∑ 1 2 M P 2 = − ∑ ℏ 2 2 M ( ∂ 2 ∂ X 2 ) , (79) T_N = \sum\frac{1}{2M}P^2 = -\sum\frac{\hbar^2}{2M}\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial X^2}\right), \tag*{(79)} T N = ∑ 2 M 1 P 2 = − ∑ 2 M ℏ 2 ( ∂ X 2 ∂ 2 ) , (79)
where the kinetic energy of the electrons takes the following form:
T e = ∑ 1 2 m p 2 = − ∑ ℏ 2 2 m ( ∂ 2 ∂ x 2 ) . (80) T_e = \sum\frac{1}{2m}p^2 = -\sum\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^2}\right). \tag*{(80)} T e = ∑ 2 m 1 p 2 = − ∑ 2 m ℏ 2 ( ∂ x 2 ∂ 2 ) . (80)
The interaction energy between nuclei and electrons is defined by Coulomb potential represented as U ( x , X ) U(x,X) U ( x , X ) .
Thus total electronic Hamiltonian with fixed nuclear arrangement can be written as :
T e + U = H 0 ( x , ∂ ∂ x ; X ) (81) T_e + U = H_0\left(x,\frac{\partial}{\partial x};X\right) \tag*{(81)} T e + U = H 0 ( x , ∂ x ∂ ; X ) (81)
Since T N T_N T N is very small due to large nuclear mass, H 0 H_0 H 0 can be considered as the zeroth order Hamiltonian,
H = ( T e + U ) + T N = H 0 + T N , (82) H = (T_e + U) + T_N = H_0 + T_N, \tag*{(82)} H = ( T e + U ) + T N = H 0 + T N , (82)
and then, T N T_N T N acts as perturbation. In the above perturbation, expansion parameter is considered as,
κ = ( m M 0 ) 1 / 4 , (83) \kappa= \left(\frac{m}{M_0}\right)^{1/4}, \tag*{(83)} κ = ( M 0 m ) 1/4 , (83)
where M 0 M_0 M 0 is the mass of any one nucleus or the mean mass. In other words, one can write the following expression,
T N = κ 4 H 1 , (84) T_N = \kappa^4 H_1, \tag*{(84)} T N = κ 4 H 1 , (84)
where
H 1 = − ∑ ( M 0 M ) ( ℏ 2 2 m ) ( ∂ 2 ∂ X 2 ) (85) H_1 = -\sum\left(\frac{M_0}{M}\right)\left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\right)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial X^2}\right) \tag*{(85)} H 1 = − ∑ ( M M 0 ) ( 2 m ℏ 2 ) ( ∂ X 2 ∂ 2 ) (85)
Therefore, the total Hamiltonian turns into,
H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 . (86) H = H_0 + \kappa^4 H_1. \tag*{(86)} H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 . (86)
As a result, molecular Schrödinger Equation (SE) can be written as,
( H − E ) ψ ( x , X ) = 0 , (87) (H-E)\psi(x,X)=0, \tag*{(87)} ( H − E ) ψ ( x , X ) = 0 , (87)
where the SE of electronic motion for arbitrary fixed nuclear position is as follows:
( H 0 − E 0 ) ϕ ( x ; X ) = 0 , (88) (H_0-E^0)\phi(x;X)=0, \tag*{(88)} ( H 0 − E 0 ) ϕ ( x ; X ) = 0 , (88)
with the eigenfunctions depending on nuclear coordinates (X X X ) parametrically.
For n t h n^{th} n t h electronic state, one can write:
E 0 = ϵ n ( X ) , (89) E^0 = \epsilon_n(X), \tag*{(89)} E 0 = ϵ n ( X ) , (89)
ϕ = ϕ n ( x ; X ) . (90) \phi= \phi_n(x;X). \tag*{(90)} ϕ = ϕ n ( x ; X ) . (90)
By considering a nuclear geometry (X 0 X^0 X 0 ) very close to X X X , we can define
X − X 0 = κ u , (91) X-X^0=\kappa u, \tag*{(91)} X − X 0 = κ u , (91)
κ u \kappa u κ u appears as the deviation in nuclear coordinate from reference geometry.
Therefore, one can write,
ϵ n ( X ) = ϵ n ( X 0 + κ u ) = ϵ n ( 0 ) + κ ϵ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϵ n ( 2 ) + … . (92) \epsilon_n(X)=\epsilon_n(X^0+\kappa u)=\epsilon_n^{(0)}+\kappa\epsilon_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\epsilon_n^{(2)}+\ldots. \tag*{(92)} ϵ n ( X ) = ϵ n ( X 0 + κ u ) = ϵ n ( 0 ) + κ ϵ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϵ n ( 2 ) + … . (92)
ϕ n ( x ; X ) = ϕ n ( x ; X 0 + κ u ) = ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … . (93) \phi_n(x;X)=\phi_n(x;X^0+\kappa u)=\phi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\phi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\phi_n^{(2)}+\ldots. \tag*{(93)} ϕ n ( x ; X ) = ϕ n ( x ; X 0 + κ u ) = ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … . (93)
where { ϵ n ( 0 ) , ϕ n ( 0 ) } \{\epsilon_n^{(0)},\phi_n^{(0)}\} { ϵ n ( 0 ) , ϕ n ( 0 ) } are independent of u u u , { ϵ n ( 1 ) , ϕ n ( 1 ) } \{\epsilon_n^{(1)},\phi_n^{(1)}\} { ϵ n ( 1 ) , ϕ n ( 1 ) } are linearly dependent on u u u and { ϵ n ( 2 ) , ϕ n ( 2 ) } \{\epsilon_n^{(2)},\phi_n^{(2)}\} { ϵ n ( 2 ) , ϕ n ( 2 ) } are quadratically dependent on u u u .
On the other hand, H 0 ( x , ∂ ∂ x ; X ) H_0\left(x,\frac{\partial}{\partial x};X\right) H 0 ( x , ∂ x ∂ ; X ) can be expanded around the reference geometry, X 0 X^0 X 0 as,
H 0 ( x , ∂ ∂ x ; X ) = H 0 ( x , ∂ ∂ x ; X 0 + κ u ) = ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + … ) . (94) H_0\left(x,\frac{\partial}{\partial x};X\right)=H_0\left(x,\frac{\partial}{\partial x};X^0+\kappa u\right)=\left(H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2H_0^{(2)}+\ldots\right). \tag*{(94)} H 0 ( x , ∂ x ∂ ; X ) = H 0 ( x , ∂ x ∂ ; X 0 + κ u ) = ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + … ) . (94)
Substituting Eq. (92) , Eq. (93) and Eq. (94) in Eq. (88) [ ( H 0 − E 0 ) ϕ ( x ; X ) = 0 ] [(H_0-E^0)\phi(x;X)=0] [( H 0 − E 0 ) ϕ ( x ; X ) = 0 ] , we arrive,
[ ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + … ) − ( ϵ n ( 0 ) + κ ϵ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϵ n ( 2 ) + … ) ] [ ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … ] = 0. (95) \left[\left(H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2H_0^{(2)}+\ldots\right)-\left(\epsilon_n^{(0)}+\kappa\epsilon_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\epsilon_n^{(2)}+\ldots\right)\right]
\left[\phi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\phi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\phi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\right]=0. \tag*{(95)} [ ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + … ) − ( ϵ n ( 0 ) + κ ϵ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϵ n ( 2 ) + … ) ] [ ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … ] = 0. (95)
While comparing zeroth, first and second power of κ \kappa κ , one can obtain,
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) = 0 (96) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\phi_n^{(0)}=0 \tag*{(96)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) = 0 (96)
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (97) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\phi_n^{(1)}=-\left(H_0^{(1)}-\epsilon_n^{(1)}\right)\phi_n^{(0)} \tag*{(97)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (97)
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 2 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ( H 0 ( 2 ) − ϵ n ( 2 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (98) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\phi_n^{(2)}=-\left(H_0^{(1)}-\epsilon_n^{(1)}\right)\phi_n^{(1)}-\left(H_0^{(2)}-\epsilon_n^{(2)}\right)\phi_n^{(0)} \tag*{(98)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 2 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ( H 0 ( 2 ) − ϵ n ( 2 ) ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (98)
If we approach this perturbation originating from nuclear kinetic energy operator on the electronic Hamiltonian in a different way, the above formulation can be carried out as presented below.
Since the partial derivative takes the following form:
∂ ∂ X = 1 κ ∂ ∂ u , (99) \frac{\partial}{\partial X}=\frac{1}{\kappa}\frac{\partial}{\partial u}, \tag*{(99)} ∂ X ∂ = κ 1 ∂ u ∂ , (99)
Eq. (84) turns into the following expression:
T N = κ 4 H 1 = κ 4 [ − ∑ ( M 0 M ) ( ℏ 2 2 m ) ( ∂ 2 ∂ X 2 ) ] = κ 4 [ − 1 κ 2 ∑ ( M 0 M ) ( ℏ 2 2 m ) ( ∂ 2 ∂ u 2 ) ] = κ 2 H 1 ( 2 ) (100) \begin{aligned}
T_N &= \kappa^4 H_1 \\
&= \kappa^4\left[-\sum\left(\frac{M_0}{M}\right)\left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\right)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial X^2}\right)\right]\\
&= \kappa^4\left[-\frac{1}{\kappa^2}\sum\left(\frac{M_0}{M}\right)\left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\right)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial u^2}\right)\right]\\
&=\kappa^2 H_1^{(2)} \tag*{(100)}
\end{aligned} T N = κ 4 H 1 = κ 4 [ − ∑ ( M M 0 ) ( 2 m ℏ 2 ) ( ∂ X 2 ∂ 2 ) ] = κ 4 [ − κ 2 1 ∑ ( M M 0 ) ( 2 m ℏ 2 ) ( ∂ u 2 ∂ 2 ) ] = κ 2 H 1 ( 2 ) (100)
where,
H 1 ( 2 ) = − ∑ ( M 0 M ) ( ℏ 2 2 m ) ( ∂ 2 ∂ u 2 ) H_1^{(2)}=-\sum\left(\frac{M_0}{M}\right)\left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\right)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial u^2}\right) H 1 ( 2 ) = − ∑ ( M M 0 ) ( 2 m ℏ 2 ) ( ∂ u 2 ∂ 2 )
Putting Eq. (100) and Eq. (94) in Eq. (86) [ H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 ] [H=H_0+\kappa^4H_1] [ H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 ] , we arrive to the following perturbative form of the molecular Hamiltonian,
H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] + κ 4 H 1 = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] + κ 2 H 1 ( 2 ) = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] . (101) \begin{aligned}
H &= H_0+\kappa^4H_1\\
&=\left[H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2H_0^{(2)}+\kappa^3H_0^{(3)}+\ldots\right]+\kappa^4H_1\\
&=\left[H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2H_0^{(2)}+\kappa^3H_0^{(3)}+\ldots\right]+\kappa^2H_1^{(2)}\\
&=\left[H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2\left(H_0^{(2)}+H_1^{(2)}\right)+\kappa^3H_0^{(3)}+\ldots\right]. \tag*{(101)}
\end{aligned} H = H 0 + κ 4 H 1 = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] + κ 4 H 1 = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 H 0 ( 2 ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] + κ 2 H 1 ( 2 ) = [ H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ] . (101)
In this perturbative treatment, the electronic Hamiltonian [ H 0 ] [H_0] [ H 0 ] is the zeroth order Hamiltonian of molecular SE [ ( H − E n ) ψ n = 0 ] [(H-E_n)\psi_n=0] [( H − E n ) ψ n = 0 ] . In this Taylor series expansion of molecular Hamiltonian, κ H 0 ( 1 ) \kappa H_0^{(1)} κ H 0 ( 1 ) and κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) \kappa^2(H_0^{(2)}+H_1^{(2)}) κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) are the first and second order correction on the electronic Hamiltonian ( H 0 ( 0 ) ) (H_0^{(0)}) ( H 0 ( 0 ) ) at reference geometry ( X 0 ) (X_0) ( X 0 ) .
One can write,
E n = E n ( 0 ) + κ E n ( 1 ) + κ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … (102) E_n=E_n^{(0)}+\kappa E_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2E_n^{(2)}+\ldots \tag*{(102)} E n = E n ( 0 ) + κ E n ( 1 ) + κ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … (102)
ψ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … (103) \psi_n=\psi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\psi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\psi_n^{(2)}+\ldots \tag*{(103)} ψ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … (103)
Substituting Eq. 9.4a, Eq. 9.4b and Eq. (101) in [ ( H − E n ) ψ n = 0 ] [(H-E_n)\psi_n=0] [( H − E n ) ψ n = 0 ] , we arrive,
[ ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ) − ( E n ( 0 ) + κ E n ( 1 ) + κ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … ) ] [ ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … ] = 0. (104) \left[\left(H_0^{(0)}+\kappa H_0^{(1)}+\kappa^2(H_0^{(2)}+H_1^{(2)})+\kappa^3H_0^{(3)}+\ldots\right)-\left(E_n^{(0)}+\kappa E_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2E_n^{(2)}+\ldots\right)\right]\left[\psi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\psi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\psi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\right]=0. \tag*{(104)} [ ( H 0 ( 0 ) + κ H 0 ( 1 ) + κ 2 ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) ) + κ 3 H 0 ( 3 ) + … ) − ( E n ( 0 ) + κ E n ( 1 ) + κ 2 E n ( 2 ) + … ) ] [ ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … ] = 0. (104)
While collecting coefficients of κ 0 \kappa_0 κ 0 , κ 1 \kappa_1 κ 1 and κ 2 \kappa_2 κ 2 , the following equations are obtained,
( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) = 0 , (105) \left(H_0^{(0)}-E_n^{(0)}\right)\psi_n^{(0)}=0, \tag*{(105)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) = 0 , (105)
( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − E n ( 1 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) , (106) \left(H_0^{(0)}-E_n^{(0)}\right)\psi_n^{(1)}=-\left(H_0^{(1)}-E_n^{(1)}\right)\psi_n^{(0)}, \tag*{(106)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − E n ( 1 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) , (106)
( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 2 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − E n ( 1 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) − ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) − E n ( 2 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) . (107) \left(H_0^{(0)}-E_n^{(0)}\right)\psi_n^{(2)}=-\left(H_0^{(1)}-E_n^{(1)}\right)\psi_n^{(1)}-\left(H_0^{(2)}+H_1^{(2)}-E_n^{(2)}\right)\psi_n^{(0)}. \tag*{(107)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − E n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 2 ) = − ( H 0 ( 1 ) − E n ( 1 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) − ( H 0 ( 2 ) + H 1 ( 2 ) − E n ( 2 ) ) ψ n ( 0 ) . (107)
From Eq. (96) , ϕ n ( 0 ) \phi_n^{(0)} ϕ n ( 0 ) represents function of x x x only (at a fixed nuclear position, X 0 X^0 X 0 ), whereas from Eq. (105) , ψ n ( 0 ) \psi_n^{(0)} ψ n ( 0 ) appears as function of both x x x and u u u (as ψ n ( 0 ) \psi_n^{(0)} ψ n ( 0 ) is the molecular wavefunction at the zeroth order), but both are eigenfunctions of same Hamiltonian with same eigenvalue ϵ n ( 0 ) \epsilon_n^{(0)} ϵ n ( 0 ) [= E n ( 0 ) = E_n^{(0)} = E n ( 0 ) ].
Therefore, one can write
ψ n ( 0 ) ( x , u ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) , (108) \psi_n^{(0)}(x,u)=\chi_n^{(0)}(u)\phi_n^{(0)}(x;X^0), \tag*{(108)} ψ n ( 0 ) ( x , u ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) , (108)
where χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) \chi_n^{(0)}(u) χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) is a multiplier, which is a function of u u u .
While projecting Eq. (97) and Eq. (106) by ϕ n ( 0 ) \phi_n^{(0)} ϕ n ( 0 ) , the corresponding equations take the following form,
⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) ∣ H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ∣ ϕ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = 0 (109) \left\langle\phi_n^{(0)}\left|H_0^{(1)}- \epsilon_n^{(1)}\right|\phi_n^{(0)}\right\rangle=0 \tag*{(109)} ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = 0 (109)
χ n ( 0 ) ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) ∣ H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ∣ ϕ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = 0 (110) \chi_n^{(0)}\left\langle\phi_n^{(0)}\left|H_0^{(1)}- \epsilon_n^{(1)}\right|\phi_n^{(0)}\right\rangle=0 \tag*{(110)} χ n ( 0 ) ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) H 0 ( 1 ) − ϵ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ⟩ = 0 (110)
since ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) ∣ H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ∣ ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ = 0 \left\langle\phi_n^{(0)}\left|H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right|\phi_n^{(1)}\right\rangle=0 ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ⟩ = 0 and ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) ∣ H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ∣ ψ n ( 1 ) ⟩ = 0 \left\langle\phi_n^{(0)}\left|H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right|\psi_n^{(1)}\right\rangle=0 ⟨ ϕ n ( 0 ) H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ψ n ( 1 ) ⟩ = 0
Therefore, comparing Eq. (109) and Eq. (110) , one can obtain:
ϵ n ( 1 ) = E n ( 1 ) (111) \epsilon_n^{(1)}=E_n^{(1)} \tag*{(111)} ϵ n ( 1 ) = E n ( 1 ) (111)
If the equilibrium geometry is chosen as the reference nuclear geometry, first order correction on energy will be zero:
ϵ n ( 1 ) = E n ( 1 ) = 0 (112) \epsilon_n^{(1)}=E_n^{(1)}=0 \tag*{(112)} ϵ n ( 1 ) = E n ( 1 ) = 0 (112)
Therefore, Eq. (97) and Eq. (106) become,
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) = − H 0 ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (113) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\phi_n^{(1)}=-H_0^{(1)}\phi_n^{(0)} \tag*{(113)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ϕ n ( 1 ) = − H 0 ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) (113)
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) = − H 0 ( 1 ) ψ n ( 0 ) (114) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\psi_n^{(1)}=-H_0^{(1)}\psi_n^{(0)} \tag*{(114)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ψ n ( 1 ) = − H 0 ( 1 ) ψ n ( 0 ) (114)
While multiplying Eq. (113) by χ n ( 0 ) \chi_n^{(0)} χ n ( 0 ) and then, subtracting Eq. (114) , we get,
( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ( χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) ) = 0. (115) \left(H_0^{(0)}-\epsilon_n^{(0)}\right)\left(\chi_n^{(0)}\phi_n^{(1)}-\psi_n^{(1)}\right)=0. \tag*{(115)} ( H 0 ( 0 ) − ϵ n ( 0 ) ) ( χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) ) = 0. (115)
From Eq. (96) , ϕ n ( 0 ) \phi_n^{(0)} ϕ n ( 0 ) appears as function of x x x only (at a fixed nuclear position), whereas from Eq. (115) , it is evident that χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) \chi_n^{(0)}\phi_n^{(1)}-\psi_n^{(1)} χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) is function of both x x x and u u u . Nevertheless, both are eigenfunctions of same Hamiltonian (H 0 ( 0 ) H_0^{(0)} H 0 ( 0 ) ) with same eigenvalue ϵ n ( 0 ) \epsilon_n^{(0)} ϵ n ( 0 ) [= E n ( 0 ) =E_n^{(0)} = E n ( 0 ) ]. Therefore, we can write
χ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) , (116) \chi_n^{(1)}\phi_n^{(0)}=\chi_n^{(0)}\phi_n^{(1)}-\psi_n^{(1)}, \tag*{(116)} χ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) − ψ n ( 1 ) , (116)
where χ n ( 1 ) \chi_n^{(1)} χ n ( 1 ) signifies an arbitrary function of u u u . In other words, the first order correction of electronic eigenfunction takes the following form:
ψ n ( 1 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 1 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) (117) \psi_n^{(1)}=\chi_n^{(0)}(u)\phi_n^{(1)}(x;u)+\chi_n^{(1)}(u)\phi_n^{(0)}(x;X^0) \tag*{(117)} ψ n ( 1 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 1 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) (117)
In a similar way, the second order correction takes the following form,
ψ n ( 2 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 2 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 1 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 2 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) (118) \psi_n^{(2)}=\chi_n^{(0)}(u)\phi_n^{(2)}(x;u)+\chi_n^{(1)}(u)\phi_n^{(1)}(x;u)+\chi_n^{(2)}(u)\phi_n^{(0)}(x;X^0) \tag*{(118)} ψ n ( 2 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 2 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 1 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 1 ) ( x ; u ) + χ n ( 2 ) ( u ) ϕ n ( 0 ) ( x ; X 0 ) (118)
Finally, total molecular wavefunction upto second order correction can be written as,
ψ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … = χ n ( 0 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … } + κ χ n ( 1 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + … } + κ 2 χ n ( 2 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + … } + … = { χ n ( 0 ) + κ χ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 χ n ( 2 ) + … } { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … } = χ n ( u ) ϕ n ( x ; u ) (119) \begin{aligned}
\psi_n &= \psi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\psi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\psi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\\
&= \chi_n^{(0)}\{\phi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\phi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\phi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\}\\
&\quad+\kappa\chi_n^{(1)}\{\phi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\phi_n^{(1)}+\ldots\}+\kappa^2\chi_n^{(2)}\{\phi_n^{(0)}+\ldots\}+\ldots\\
&=\{\chi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\chi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\chi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\}\\
&\quad\{\phi_n^{(0)}+\kappa\phi_n^{(1)}+\kappa^2\phi_n^{(2)}+\ldots\}\\
&=\chi_n(u)\phi_n(x;u) \tag*{(119)}
\end{aligned} ψ n = ψ n ( 0 ) + κ ψ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ψ n ( 2 ) + … = χ n ( 0 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … } + κ χ n ( 1 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + … } + κ 2 χ n ( 2 ) { ϕ n ( 0 ) + … } + … = { χ n ( 0 ) + κ χ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 χ n ( 2 ) + … } { ϕ n ( 0 ) + κ ϕ n ( 1 ) + κ 2 ϕ n ( 2 ) + … } = χ n ( u ) ϕ n ( x ; u ) (119)
In the above expression, the first factor describes nuclear motion and the second one shows the electronic movement with parametric dependence on nuclear coordinates. Therefore, total wavefunction can be written as a product of nuclear and electronic wavefunction.
Nevertheless, the third order correction is,
ψ n ( 3 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 3 ) + χ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 2 ) + χ n ( 2 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) + χ n ( 3 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) + F ( x , u ) , (120) \psi_n^{(3)} = \chi_n^{(0)}\phi_n^{(3)}+\chi_n^{(1)}\phi_n^{(2)}+\chi_n^{(2)}\phi_n^{(1)}
+\chi_n^{(3)}\phi_n^{(0)}+F(x,u), \tag*{(120)} ψ n ( 3 ) = χ n ( 0 ) ϕ n ( 3 ) + χ n ( 1 ) ϕ n ( 2 ) + χ n ( 2 ) ϕ n ( 1 ) + χ n ( 3 ) ϕ n ( 0 ) + F ( x , u ) , (120)
where the extra term, F ( x , u ) F(x,u) F ( x , u ) does not contain x x x solely through a factor of the type ϕ n ( r ) ( x , u ) \phi_n^{(r)}(x,u) ϕ n ( r ) ( x , u ) . Therefore, the molecular wavefunction is corrected up to fourth power of the expansion parameter, κ \kappa κ known as ‘Adiabatic Approximation’. On the other hand, as per Born-Huang expansion, one can write the molecular wavefunction by considering the entire Hilbert space,
∣ ψ ( x , X ) ⟩ = ∑ i χ i ( X ) ∣ ϕ i ( x ; X ) ⟩ (121) |\psi(x,X)\rangle= \sum_i \chi_i(X)|\phi_i(x;X)\rangle \tag*{(121)} ∣ ψ ( x , X )⟩ = i ∑ χ i ( X ) ∣ ϕ i ( x ; X )⟩ (121)
so that contribution of higher excited electronic states are incorporated in the molecular wavefunction.
Adiabatic Representation
The Born-Oppenheimer (BO) treatment1,2 is based on the fact that slow moving nuclei could be distinguished from fast moving electrons in molecular species, chemical reactions and solid state processes. This distinction leads to the BO approximation, i.e., the non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) are assumed to be negligibly small. On the contrary, the excited electronic states affect the ground and/or any other state dynamics very strongly due to the so-called NACTs, and the BO approximate equation fails to calculate correct transition probabilities.3–5 The coupling terms between the electronic states are fundamentally important, particularly when degenerate states are involved through single or multiple conical intersections (CIs) in the nuclear configuration space (CS). The NACTs become a natural requirement in the context of BO treatment, what we call the Adiabatic picture, to introduce physically meaningfulness in representing any molecular/chemical process. Since the NACTs play an important role in the description of scattering and radiationless processes in molecular systems, the NACTs should be gracefully taken care of, rather than neglecting them forcibly.
The time independent total molecular SE is represented as,
H ^ ( s e , s n ) ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ = E ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ , (122) \hat{H}(s_e,s_n)|\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle= E|\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle, \tag*{(122)} H ^ ( s e , s n ) ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ = E ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ , (122)
where H ^ ( s e , s n ) \hat{H}(s_e,s_n) H ^ ( s e , s n ) and ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ represent molecular Hamiltonian and molecular wave function, respectively (s e s_e s e and s n s_n s n signify electronic and nuclear coordinates). On the other hand, molecular Hamiltonian, H ^ ( s e , s n ) \hat{H}(s_e,s_n) H ^ ( s e , s n ) symbolizes sum of nuclear kinetic energy and electronic Hamiltonian:
H ^ ( s e , s n ) = T ^ n ( s n ) + H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) . (123) \hat{H}(s_e,s_n) = \hat{T}_n(s_n) + \hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n). \tag*{(123)} H ^ ( s e , s n ) = T ^ n ( s n ) + H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) . (123)
On the other hand, nuclear kinetic energy (KE) in atomic units is given by
T ^ n ( s n ) = − 1 2 ∑ A ( ∇ s n , A 2 M A ) , (124) \hat{T}_n(s_n) = -\frac{1}{2}\sum_A\left(\frac{\nabla^2_{s_n,A}}{M_A}\right), \tag*{(124)} T ^ n ( s n ) = − 2 1 A ∑ ( M A ∇ s n , A 2 ) , (124)
and the electronic Hamiltonian is:
H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) = − 1 2 ∑ i ∇ s e , i 2 − ∑ i ∑ A Z A r i A + ∑ i ∑ j > i 1 r i j + ∑ A ∑ B > A Z A Z B R A B , (125) \hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n) = -\frac{1}{2}\sum_i\nabla^2_{s_e,i}-\sum_i\sum_A\frac{Z_A}{r_{iA}}+\sum_i\sum_{j>i}\frac{1}{r_{ij}}+\sum_A\sum_{B>A}\frac{Z_A Z_B}{R_{AB}}, \tag*{(125)} H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) = − 2 1 i ∑ ∇ s e , i 2 − i ∑ A ∑ r i A Z A + i ∑ j > i ∑ r ij 1 + A ∑ B > A ∑ R A B Z A Z B , (125)
where the first, second, third and fourth terms signify electronic kinetic energy operator, electron-nuclear Coulombic attraction, electron-electron Coulombic repulsion and nuclear-nuclear Coulombic repulsion, respectively.
The electronic Hamiltonian satisfies the time-independent electronic SE:
H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ . (126) \hat{H}_{e}(s_e \mid s_n)|\xi_i(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle= u_i(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle. \tag*{(126)} H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ . (126)
where ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ |\xi_i(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ and u i ( s n ) u_i(s_n) u i ( s n ) represent electronic eigenfunctions and adiabatic potential energy surfaces, respectively. It is to note that both the quantities depend parametrically on the nuclear coordinates. Since the electronic eigenfunctions form complete set, those will satisfy:
⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = δ i j ; ∑ i ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⟨ ξ i ∣ = I . (127) \langle\xi_i|\xi_j\rangle= \delta_{ij}; \qquad\sum_i |\xi_i\rangle\langle\xi_i| = \mathbf{I}. \tag*{(127)} ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = δ ij ; i ∑ ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⟨ ξ i ∣ = I . (127)
The total molecular wave function ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ can be expanded in terms of electronic eigenfunctions:
∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ = ∑ i ψ i a d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ , (128) |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle= \sum_i \psi_i^{ad}(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle, \tag*{(128)} ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ = i ∑ ψ i a d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ , (128)
which is known as the Born-Oppenheimer2 expansion. In the above equation, ψ i ( s n ) \psi_i(s_n) ψ i ( s n ) and ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ |\xi_i(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ depict nuclear wave functions and adiabatic electronic eigenfunctions, respectively.
One can use the above expansion of ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ [Eq. (4.48)] and substituting it in the molecular Schrödinger Equation [Eq. (4.42)], we arrive:
( T ^ n + H ^ e ) ∑ i ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ = E ∑ i ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ . (129) (\hat{T}_n+\hat{H}_e)\sum_i \psi_i^{ad}|\xi_i\rangle= E\sum_i \psi_i^{ad}|\xi_i\rangle. \tag*{(129)} ( T ^ n + H ^ e ) i ∑ ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ = E i ∑ ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ . (129)
Applying ⟨ ξ j ∣ \langle\xi_j| ⟨ ξ j ∣ from the left on the above equation, the SE takes the following form,
∑ i ⟨ ξ j ∣ ( T ^ n + H ^ e ) ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ = E ∑ i ψ i a d ⟨ ξ j ∣ ξ i ⟩ (130) \sum_i \langle\xi_j|(\hat{T}_n+\hat{H}_e)\psi_i^{ad}|\xi_i\rangle= E\sum_i \psi_i^{ad}\langle\xi_j|\xi_i\rangle \tag*{(130)} i ∑ ⟨ ξ j ∣ ( T ^ n + H ^ e ) ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ = E i ∑ ψ i a d ⟨ ξ j ∣ ξ i ⟩ (130)
⇒ ∑ i ( ⟨ ξ j ∣ T ^ n ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i ) = 0. (131) \Rightarrow\sum_i \left(\langle\xi_j|\hat{T}_n\psi_i^{ad}|\xi_i\rangle+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\psi_i\right)=0. \tag*{(131)} ⇒ i ∑ ( ⟨ ξ j ∣ T ^ n ψ i a d ∣ ξ i ⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i ) = 0. (131)
where u i u_i u i are the adiabatic PESs.
The nuclear KE term ( T ^ n ) (\hat{T}_n) ( T ^ n ) in atomic units:
T ^ n ( s n ) = − 1 2 ∑ A ( ∇ s n , A 2 M A ) , (132) \hat{T}_n(s_n)=-\frac{1}{2}\sum_A\left(\frac{\nabla_{s_{n,A}}^2}{M_A}\right), \tag*{(132)} T ^ n ( s n ) = − 2 1 A ∑ ( M A ∇ s n , A 2 ) , (132)
can be written in terms of mass-weighted coordinates by taking a transformation, s ~ n , A = M A s n , A \tilde{s}_{n,A}=\sqrt{M_A}s_{n,A} s ~ n , A = M A s n , A :
T ^ n ( s ~ n ) = − 1 2 ∑ A ∇ s ~ n , A 2 = − 1 2 ∇ n 2 . (133) \hat{T}_n(\tilde{s}_n)=-\frac{1}{2}\sum_A\nabla_{\tilde{s}_{n,A}}^2=-\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n^2. \tag*{(133)} T ^ n ( s ~ n ) = − 2 1 A ∑ ∇ s ~ n , A 2 = − 2 1 ∇ n 2 . (133)
Using the form of T n T_n T n in Eq. (133) , we have,
∑ i { − 1 2 ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ∇ n 2 ψ i a d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i a d ( s n ) } = 0 ⇒ ∑ i { − 1 2 δ j i ∇ n 2 − ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⋅ ∇ ⃗ n − 1 2 ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ i ⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0 ⇒ ∑ i { − 1 2 δ j i ∇ n 2 − τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ∇ ⃗ n − 1 2 τ j i ( 2 ) + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0. (134) \begin{aligned}
\sum_i\left\{-\frac{1}{2}\langle\xi_j(s_e\mid s_n)|\nabla_n^2\psi_i^{ad}(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e\mid s_n)\rangle+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\psi_i^{ad}(s_n)\right\}=0 \\
&\Rightarrow\sum_i\left\{-\frac{1}{2}\delta_{ji}\nabla_n^2-\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle\cdot\vec{\nabla}_n-\frac{1}{2}\langle\xi_j|\nabla_n^2|\xi_i\rangle+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\right\}\psi_i^{ad}=0 \\
&\Rightarrow\sum_i\left\{-\frac{1}{2}\delta_{ji}\nabla_n^2-\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)}\cdot\vec{\nabla}_n-\frac{1}{2}\tau_{ji}^{(2)}+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\right\}\psi_i^{ad}=0. \tag*{(134)}
\end{aligned} i ∑ { − 2 1 ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ∇ n 2 ψ i a d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i a d ( s n ) } = 0 ⇒ i ∑ { − 2 1 δ j i ∇ n 2 − ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⋅ ∇ n − 2 1 ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ i ⟩ + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0 ⇒ i ∑ { − 2 1 δ j i ∇ n 2 − τ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ∇ n − 2 1 τ j i ( 2 ) + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0. (134)
where ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) \langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle=\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)} ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = τ j i ( 1 ) signifies NACTs of first order and ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ i ⟩ = τ j i ( 2 ) \langle\xi_j|\nabla_n^2|\xi_i\rangle=\tau_{ji}^{(2)} ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ i ⟩ = τ j i ( 2 ) represents NACTs of second order.
Properties of NACT
Since the first order NACTs, τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) \vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)} τ ij ( 1 ) acts as vector field, one needs to examine the connection between NACTs and standard properties of vector fields. The nature of vector fields are thoroughly discussed in Appendix A.
On the other hand, while simplifying Eq. (134) , we explore some crucial properties of the NACTs. The elements τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) \vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)} τ ij ( 1 ) constitute a skew-symmetric matrix6,7 as follows:
τ ⃗ ( 1 ) = − τ ⃗ ( 1 ) (135) \vec{\tau}^{(1)}=-\vec{\tau}^{(1)} \tag*{(135)} τ ( 1 ) = − τ ( 1 ) (135)
which can be shown as follows:
⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = δ i j ⇒ ∇ ⃗ n ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = 0 ⇒ ⟨ ∇ ⃗ n ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ξ j ⟩ = 0 , ⇒ τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) = − τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) . (136) \begin{aligned}
\langle\xi_i|\xi_j\rangle=\delta_{ij} \\
&\Rightarrow\vec{\nabla}_n\langle\xi_i|\xi_j\rangle=0 \\
&\Rightarrow\langle\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_i|\xi_j\rangle+\langle\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_j\rangle=0, \\
&\Rightarrow\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)}=-\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}. \tag*{(136)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = δ ij ⇒ ∇ n ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ = 0 ⇒ ⟨ ∇ n ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n ξ j ⟩ = 0 , ⇒ τ j i ( 1 ) = − τ ij ( 1 ) . (136)
On the other hand, second order NACT elements satisfy the following condition:
τ ( 2 ) = τ ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ( 1 ) + ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ( 1 ) (137) \boldsymbol{\tau}^{(2)}=\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)}+\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)} \tag*{(137)} τ ( 2 ) = τ ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ( 1 ) + ∇ n ⋅ τ ( 1 ) (137)
which can be established from the first order term through the following way:
⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ = τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) , \langle\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_j\rangle=\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}, ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ = τ ij ( 1 ) ,
and then, applying ∇ ⃗ n \vec{\nabla}_n ∇ n on both sides of the above equation, we obtain:
∇ ⃗ n ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) ⇒ ⟨ ∇ ⃗ n ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) ⇒ τ i j ( 2 ) = ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) − ⟨ ∇ ⃗ n ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ξ j ⟩ ⇒ τ i j ( 2 ) = ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) − ∑ k ⟨ ∇ ⃗ n ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⋅ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ξ j ⟩ ⇒ τ i j ( 2 ) = ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) − ∑ k τ ⃗ k i ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ⃗ k j ( 1 ) . (138) \begin{aligned}
\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\langle\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_j\rangle=\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)} \\
&\Rightarrow\langle\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_j\rangle+\langle\xi_i|\nabla_n^2|\xi_j\rangle=\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)} \\
&\Rightarrow\tau_{ij}^{(2)}=\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}-\langle\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_j\rangle\\
&\Rightarrow\tau_{ij}^{(2)}=\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}-\sum_k\langle\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_i|\xi_k\rangle\cdot\langle\xi_k|\vec{\nabla}_n\xi_j\rangle\\
&\Rightarrow\tau_{ij}^{(2)}=\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}-\sum_k\vec{\tau}_{ki}^{(1)}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{kj}^{(1)}. \tag*{(138)}
\end{aligned} ∇ n ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) ⇒ ⟨ ∇ n ξ i ∣ ∇ n ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n 2 ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) ⇒ τ ij ( 2 ) = ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) − ⟨ ∇ n ξ i ∣ ∇ n ξ j ⟩ ⇒ τ ij ( 2 ) = ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) − k ∑ ⟨ ∇ n ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⋅ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ n ξ j ⟩ ⇒ τ ij ( 2 ) = ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) − k ∑ τ k i ( 1 ) ⋅ τ k j ( 1 ) . (138)
Using Eq. (136) in Eq. (138) , we have
τ i j ( 2 ) = ∑ k τ ⃗ i k ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ⃗ k j ( 1 ) + ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) . (139) \tau_{ij}^{(2)}=\sum_k\vec{\tau}_{ik}^{(1)}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{kj}^{(1)}+\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)}. \tag*{(139)} τ ij ( 2 ) = k ∑ τ ik ( 1 ) ⋅ τ k j ( 1 ) + ∇ n ⋅ τ ij ( 1 ) . (139)
In matrix notation, one can write:
τ ( 2 ) = τ ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ( 1 ) + ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ( 1 ) . \boldsymbol{\tau}^{(2)}=\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)}+\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{(1)}. τ ( 2 ) = τ ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ( 1 ) + ∇ n ⋅ τ ( 1 ) .
On the other hand, the above equation can be rewritten in the following form:
∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ ( 1 ) = τ ( 2 ) − ∣ τ ⃗ ( 1 ) ∣ 2 , (140) \vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau}^{(1)}=\tau^{(2)}-\lvert\vec{\tau}^{(1)}\rvert^2, \tag*{(140)} ∇ n ⋅ τ ( 1 ) = τ ( 2 ) − ∣ τ ( 1 ) ∣ 2 , (140)
which is known as Divergence Equation6,7.
It needs to mention that the NACT matrix elements satisfy the Curl condition,6,7 known as Yang-Mill field:
∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q = [ τ p , τ q ] (141) \nabla_q\cdot\tau_p-\nabla_p\cdot\tau_q=[\tau_p,\tau_q] \tag*{(141)} ∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q = [ τ p , τ q ] (141)
where p p p and q q q are any two pair of the nuclear coordinates and the right hand side of the above equation is the commutator of the NACT components along p p p and q q q . In order to verify such expression, we can consider the i j t h ij^{th} i j t h component of the left hand side expression as,
( ∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q ) i j = ∇ q ⋅ τ p i j − ∇ p ⋅ τ q i j = ∇ q ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ p ∣ ξ j ⟩ − ∇ p ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ q ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ q ⋅ ∇ p ∣ ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ p ⋅ ∇ q ∣ ξ j ⟩ . \begin{aligned}
(\nabla_q\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_p-\nabla_p\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_q)_{ij}
&=\nabla_q\cdot\tau_p^{ij}-\nabla_p\cdot\tau_q^{ij}\\
&=\nabla_q\cdot\langle\xi_i|\nabla_p|\xi_j\rangle-\nabla_p\cdot\langle\xi_i|\nabla_q|\xi_j\rangle\\
&=\langle\nabla_q\xi_i|\nabla_p\xi_j\rangle+\langle\xi_i|\nabla_q\cdot\nabla_p|\xi_j\rangle\\
&\quad-\langle\nabla_p\xi_i|\nabla_q\xi_j\rangle-\langle\xi_i|\nabla_p\cdot\nabla_q|\xi_j\rangle.
\end{aligned} ( ∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q ) ij = ∇ q ⋅ τ p ij − ∇ p ⋅ τ q ij = ∇ q ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ p ∣ ξ j ⟩ − ∇ p ⋅ ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ q ∣ ξ j ⟩ = ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ + ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ q ⋅ ∇ p ∣ ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ p ⋅ ∇ q ∣ ξ j ⟩ .
Since the ∣ ξ k ⟩ |\xi_k\rangle ∣ ξ k ⟩ s are analytic functions, the commutator [ ∇ p , ∇ q ] [\nabla_p,\nabla_q] [ ∇ p , ∇ q ] vanishes and the above expression turns into:
( ∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q ) i j = ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ = ∑ k ( ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ ) = − ∑ k ( τ q ( i k ) ⋅ τ p ( k j ) − τ p ( i k ) ⋅ τ q ( k j ) ) = ( τ p ⋅ τ q ) i j − ( τ q ⋅ τ p ) i j = [ τ p , τ q ] i j . \begin{aligned}
(\nabla_q\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_p-\nabla_p\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_q)_{ij}
&=\langle\nabla_q\xi_i|\nabla_p\xi_j\rangle-\langle\nabla_p\xi_i|\nabla_q\xi_j\rangle\\
&=\sum_k\left(\langle\nabla_q\xi_i|\xi_k\rangle\langle\xi_k|\nabla_p\xi_j\rangle-\langle\nabla_p\xi_i|\xi_k\rangle\langle\xi_k|\nabla_q\xi_j\rangle\right)\\
&=-\sum_k\left(\tau_q^{(ik)}\cdot\tau_p^{(kj)}-\tau_p^{(ik)}\cdot\tau_q^{(kj)}\right)\\
&=(\boldsymbol{\tau}_p\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_q)^{ij}-(\boldsymbol{\tau}_q\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_p)^{ij}\\
&=[\boldsymbol{\tau}_p,\boldsymbol{\tau}_q]_{ij}.
\end{aligned} ( ∇ q ⋅ τ p − ∇ p ⋅ τ q ) ij = ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ = k ∑ ( ⟨ ∇ q ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ p ξ j ⟩ − ⟨ ∇ p ξ i ∣ ξ k ⟩ ⟨ ξ k ∣ ∇ q ξ j ⟩ ) = − k ∑ ( τ q ( ik ) ⋅ τ p ( k j ) − τ p ( ik ) ⋅ τ q ( k j ) ) = ( τ p ⋅ τ q ) ij − ( τ q ⋅ τ p ) ij = [ τ p , τ q ] ij .
Eqs. (140) and (141) are collectively known as the Curl-Div Equations, 6,7 which establishes the validity of the sub-Hilbert space.
The NACTs satisfy the following definition which is reminiscent of the Hellmann-Feynman Theorem8,9:
τ ⃗ j i = ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ u i − u j (142) \vec{\tau}_{ji}=\frac{\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e|\xi_i\rangle}{u_i-u_j} \tag*{(142)} τ j i = u i − u j ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ (142)
Considering the electronic SE in Eq. (126) ,
H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ , (143) \hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle=u_i(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle, \tag*{(143)} H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ , (143)
and applying ∇ ⃗ n \vec{\nabla}_n ∇ n on both sides of the equation, we obtain the following equation:
∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = ∇ ⃗ n u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ ⇒ ( ∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ) ∣ ξ i ⟩ + H ^ e ( ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ) = ( ∇ ⃗ n u i ) ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u i ( ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ) . \begin{aligned}
\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle
&=\vec{\nabla}_n u_i(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle\\
\Rightarrow\left(\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e\right)|\xi_i\rangle+\hat{H}_e\left(\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle\right)
&=\left(\vec{\nabla}_n u_i\right)|\xi_i\rangle+u_i\left(\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle\right).
\end{aligned} ∇ n H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ ⇒ ( ∇ n H ^ e ) ∣ ξ i ⟩ + H ^ e ( ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ) = ∇ n u i ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = ( ∇ n u i ) ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u i ( ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ) .
Projecting ⟨ ξ j ∣ \langle\xi_j| ⟨ ξ j ∣ (where, j ≠ i j\ne i j = i ) on both sides, we will have then:
⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ + ⟨ ξ j ∣ H ^ e ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = ( ∇ ⃗ n u i ) ⟨ ξ j ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u i ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⇒ ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u j ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = 0 + u i ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⇒ τ ⃗ j i = ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ ⃗ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ u i − u j . (144) \begin{aligned}
\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e|\xi_i\rangle+\langle\xi_j|\hat{H}_e\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle
&=\left(\vec{\nabla}_n u_i\right)\langle\xi_j|\xi_i\rangle+u_i\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle\\
\Rightarrow\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e|\xi_i\rangle+u_j\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle
&=0+u_i\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i\rangle\\
\Rightarrow\vec{\tau}_{ji}
&=\frac{\langle\xi_j|\vec{\nabla}_n\hat{H}_e|\xi_i\rangle}{u_i-u_j}. \tag*{(144)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ + ⟨ ξ j ∣ H ^ e ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⇒ ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u j ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ ⇒ τ j i = ( ∇ n u i ) ⟨ ξ j ∣ ξ i ⟩ + u i ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = 0 + u i ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ⟩ = u i − u j ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ n H ^ e ∣ ξ i ⟩ . (144)
The above equation is a reminiscent of the Hellmann-Feynman Theorem, which shows that the NACTs become singular at any degenerate point (u i = u j u_i=u_j u i = u j ) in the nuclear CS.
Diabatic Representation
When we substitute the expression of τ ⃗ i j ( 2 ) \vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(2)} τ ij ( 2 ) in terms of τ ⃗ i j ( 1 ) \vec{\tau}_{ij}^{(1)} τ ij ( 1 ) , Eq. (134) turns into:
∑ i { − 1 2 δ j i ∇ n 2 − τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ∇ n − 1 2 ∑ k τ ⃗ j k ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ⃗ k i ( 1 ) − 1 2 ∇ n ⋅ τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0 ⇒ − 1 2 ∑ i { δ j i ∇ n 2 ψ i a d + 2 τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ( ∇ n ψ i a d ) + ∑ k τ ⃗ j k ( 1 ) ⋅ τ ⃗ k i ( 1 ) ψ i a d + ( ∇ n ⋅ τ ⃗ j i ( 1 ) ) ψ i a d − 2 δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i a d } = 0. \begin{aligned}
\sum_i \left\{-\frac{1}{2}\delta_{ji}\nabla_n^2-\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)}\cdot\nabla_n-\frac{1}{2}\sum_k\vec{\tau}_{jk}^{(1)}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ki}^{(1)}-\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)}+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\right\}\psi_i^{ad}=0 \\
&\Rightarrow-\frac{1}{2}\sum_i\{\delta_{ji}\nabla_n^2\psi_i^{ad}+2\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)}\cdot(\nabla_n\psi_i^{ad})+\sum_k\vec{\tau}_{jk}^{(1)}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ki}^{(1)}\psi_i^{ad} \\
&+(\nabla_n\cdot\vec{\tau}_{ji}^{(1)})\psi_i^{ad}-2\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\psi_i^{ad}\}=0.
\end{aligned} i ∑ { − 2 1 δ j i ∇ n 2 − τ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ∇ n − 2 1 k ∑ τ j k ( 1 ) ⋅ τ k i ( 1 ) − 2 1 ∇ n ⋅ τ j i ( 1 ) + δ j i ( u i − E ) } ψ i a d = 0 ⇒ − 2 1 i ∑ { δ j i ∇ n 2 ψ i a d + 2 τ j i ( 1 ) ⋅ ( ∇ n ψ i a d ) + k ∑ τ j k ( 1 ) ⋅ τ k i ( 1 ) ψ i a d + ( ∇ n ⋅ τ j i ( 1 ) ) ψ i a d − 2 δ j i ( u i − E ) ψ i a d } = 0.
The aforementioned expression can be further simplified to:
∑ i [ − 1 2 ∑ k { ( δ j k ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ j k ) ⋅ ( δ k i ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ k i ) } + δ j i ( u i − E ) ] ψ i a d = 0 , (145) \sum_i\left[-\frac{1}{2}\sum_k\left\{\left(\delta_{jk}\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau}_{jk}\right)\cdot\left(\delta_{ki}\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau}_{ki}\right)\right\}+\delta_{ji}(u_i-E)\right]\psi_i^{ad}=0, \tag*{(145)} i ∑ [ − 2 1 k ∑ { ( δ j k ∇ n + τ j k ) ⋅ ( δ k i ∇ n + τ k i ) } + δ j i ( u i − E ) ] ψ i a d = 0 , (145)
In matrix notation, the above equation is represented as6,7:
[ − 1 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) 2 + u − E ] ψ a d = 0. (146) \left[-\frac{1}{2}\left(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau}\right)^2+\mathbf{u}-E\right]\boldsymbol{\psi}^{ad}=0. \tag*{(146)} [ − 2 1 ( ∇ n + τ ) 2 + u − E ] ψ a d = 0. (146)
Here, τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ is the non-adiabatic coupling matrix (NACM) and u \mathbf{u} u is the adiabatic potential energy matrix. When the NACT matrix (τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ ) is neglected in Eq. (146) , the nuclear SE becomes decoupled (known as the BO approximation):
( − 1 2 ∇ n 2 + u − E ) ψ a d = 0. (147) \left(-\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n^2+\mathbf{u}-E\right)\boldsymbol{\psi}^{ad}=0. \tag*{(147)} ( − 2 1 ∇ n 2 + u − E ) ψ a d = 0. (147)
It is evident from Hellmann-Feynman Theorem [Eq. 4.64] that close to any degenerate point or along a seam in the nuclear CS, the NACT takes up substantial magnitudes tending to blow up its magnitude. One can not just neglect those terms from the SE by imposing the BO approximation since the degeneracies at CI points are ubiquitous rather than exceptions. Within the adiabatic representation, NACTs are not numerically amenable and hence, the pursuit for a different representation is an attempt to avoid such singularities.
It becomes a natural choice to find out a unitary transformation matrix that transforms the adiabatic representation to the diabatic one, where the kinetically coupled SE transforms to potentially coupled Hamiltonian. There are two ways through which one can carry out such a transformation. Indeed, it can be shown that the two approaches are equivalent to each other.
In Method I, choosing an electronic basis set, parameterized by a fixed nuclear coordinate (s 0 s_0 s 0 ), the total molecular wave function is written as:
∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ = ∑ i ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ , (148) |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle=\sum_i\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle, \tag*{(148)} ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ = i ∑ ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ , (148)
where ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ≡ ϕ ~ i d ( s n ∣ s 0 ) \tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)\equiv\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n|s_0) ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ≡ ϕ ~ i d ( s n ∣ s 0 ) , depends parametrically on s 0 s_0 s 0 , and ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ |\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ ’s satisfy the corresponding electronic SE:
H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ = u i ( s 0 ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ . \hat{H}_e(s_e|s_0)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle=u_i(s_0)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle. H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ = u i ( s 0 ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ .
Using the above form of ∣ Ψ ( s e , s n ) ⟩ |\Psi(s_e,s_n)\rangle ∣Ψ ( s e , s n )⟩ , Eq. (129) becomes:
( T ^ n ( s n ) + H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ) ∑ i ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ = E ∑ i ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ . \left(\hat{T}_n(s_n)+\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)\right)\sum_i\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle=E\sum_i\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle. ( T ^ n ( s n ) + H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ) i ∑ ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ = E i ∑ ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ .
While projecting ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ \langle\xi_j(s_e|s_0)| ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ from the left on the above equation, one can obtain:
∑ i [ δ j i ( T ^ n ( s n ) − E ) + ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ ] ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) = 0 ⇒ ∑ i [ δ j i ( − 1 2 ∇ n 2 − E ) + V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) ] ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) = 0 , (149) \begin{aligned}
\sum_i \left[\delta_{ji}\left(\hat{T}_n(s_n)-E\right)+\langle\xi_j(s_e|s_0)|\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle\right]\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)=0 \\
&\Rightarrow\sum_i\left[\delta_{ji}\left(-\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n^2-E\right)+V_{ji}(s_n|s_0)\right]\tilde{\phi}_i^d(s_n)=0, \tag*{(149)}
\end{aligned} i ∑ [ δ j i ( T ^ n ( s n ) − E ) + ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ ] ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) = 0 ⇒ i ∑ [ δ j i ( − 2 1 ∇ n 2 − E ) + V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) ] ϕ ~ i d ( s n ) = 0 , (149)
where
V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ . (150) V_{ji}(s_n|s_0)=\langle\xi_j(s_e|s_0)|\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle. \tag*{(150)} V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ . (150)
On the other hand, one can write
H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) = T ^ e ( s e ) + U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) , H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) = T ^ e ( s e ) + U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) , H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) = H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) + ( U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) − U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ) . (151) \begin{aligned}
\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)&=\hat{T}_e(s_e)+\hat{U}(s_e|s_n),\\
\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_0)&=\hat{T}_e(s_e)+\hat{U}(s_e|s_0),\\
\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_n)&=\hat{H}_e(s_e|s_0)+\left(\hat{U}(s_e|s_n)-\hat{U}(s_e|s_0)\right). \tag*{(151)}
\end{aligned} H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) H ^ e ( s e ∣ s n ) = T ^ e ( s e ) + U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) , = T ^ e ( s e ) + U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) , = H ^ e ( s e ∣ s 0 ) + ( U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) − U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ) . (151)
Therefore, the following equation turns into,
V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = u i ( s 0 ) + ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ( U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) − U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ . V_{ji}(s_n|s_0)=u_i(s_0)+\langle\xi_j(s_e|s_0)|\left(\hat{U}(s_e|s_n)-\hat{U}(s_e|s_0)\right)|\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle. V j i ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = u i ( s 0 ) + ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ( U ^ ( s e ∣ s n ) − U ^ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ) ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ .
Thus, Eq. (149) becomes potentially coupled which in the matrix representation appears as 6,7:
( − 1 2 ∇ n 2 + V − E ) ϕ ~ d = 0. (152) \left(-\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n^2+\mathbf{V}-E\right)\tilde{\boldsymbol{\phi}}^d=0. \tag*{(152)} ( − 2 1 ∇ n 2 + V − E ) ϕ ~ d = 0. (152)
In this way, one can transform Eq. (146) into Eq. (152) where the couplings in the kinetic energy term turn into potential energy one known as diabatic representation of SE. In this process, the SE appears to be continuous and single-valued, which is expected to be numerically solvable within desired level of accuracy.
Using the above formulations, one can observe that,
∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = ∑ j ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ (153) \vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle=\sum_j|\xi_j(s_e|s_n)\rangle\langle\xi_j(s_e|s_n)|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle \tag*{(153)} ∇ n ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = j ∑ ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ ⟨ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ (153)
= ∑ j τ ⃗ j i ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = − ∑ j τ ⃗ i j ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ . (154) \begin{aligned}
&=\sum_j\vec{\tau}_{ji}|\xi_j(s_e|s_n)\rangle\\
&=-\sum_j\vec{\tau}_{ij}|\xi_j(s_e|s_n)\rangle. \tag*{(154)}
\end{aligned} = j ∑ τ j i ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = − j ∑ τ ij ∣ ξ j ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ . (154)
In matrix notation, it can be expressed as, ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = − τ ⃗ ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ \vec{\nabla}_n|\boldsymbol{\xi}(s_e|s_n)\rangle=-\vec{\tau}|\boldsymbol{\xi}(s_e|s_n)\rangle ∇ n ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = − τ ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ . In other words, we have to solve the following differential equation:
∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ + τ ⃗ ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = 0 , (155) \vec{\nabla}_n|\boldsymbol{\xi}(s_e|s_n)\rangle+\vec{\tau}|\boldsymbol{\xi}(s_e|s_n)\rangle=0, \tag*{(155)} ∇ n ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ + τ ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = 0 , (155)
to establish the relation between ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ |\xi_i(s_e|s_0)\rangle ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ and ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ |\xi_i(s_e|s_n)\rangle ∣ ξ i ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ .
On the other hand, a first order vectorial linear differential equation can be written as:
∇ ⃗ Ω + τ ⃗ Ω = 0 , (156) \vec{\nabla}\boldsymbol{\Omega}+\vec{\tau}\boldsymbol{\Omega}=0, \tag*{(156)} ∇ Ω + τ Ω = 0 , (156)
where Ω \boldsymbol{\Omega} Ω is a scalar matrix. One can show that the approximated solution can be written in the form 6,7:
Ω ( s ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s τ ⃗ ( s ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ ′ ) Ω ( s 0 ) . (157) \boldsymbol{\Omega}(s)=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s}\vec{\tau}(s')\cdot d\vec{s}'\right)\boldsymbol{\Omega}(s_0). \tag*{(157)} Ω ( s ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s τ ( s ′ ) ⋅ d s ′ ) Ω ( s 0 ) . (157)
where ζ → \zeta\to ζ → represents ordering operator that defines the order of integration along the given contour (s 0 → s 1 → s 2 , … → s s_0 \to s_1 \to s_2,\ldots\to s s 0 → s 1 → s 2 , … → s ).
Introducing the above form of the solution of the linear differential equation [Eq. (156) ], the solution of Eq. (155) can be written as:
∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ , \lvert\xi(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle= \zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)\lvert\xi(s_e \mid s_0)\rangle, ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ ,
or, alternatively,
∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ = A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ , (158) \lvert\xi(s_e \mid s_n)\rangle= \widetilde{A}(s_n\mid s_0)\lvert\xi(s_e \mid s_0)\rangle, \tag*{(158)} ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ = A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ , (158)
where,
A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) , (159) \widetilde{A}(s_n\mid s_0)=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right), \tag*{(159)} A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) , (159)
is the transformation matrix operating on the electronic eigenstate ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ⟩ \lvert\xi(s_e\mid s_0)\rangle ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s 0 )⟩ to give ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n ) ⟩ \lvert\xi(s_e\mid s_n)\rangle ∣ ξ ( s e ∣ s n )⟩ . Moreover, it can be shown that the matrix A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) \widetilde{A}(s_n\mid s_0) A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) is orthogonal:
A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) † A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) † ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ † ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) = ζ exp ( ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) = I (160) \begin{aligned}
\widetilde{A}(s_n\mid s_0)^\dagger\widetilde{A}(s_n\mid s_0)
&=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)^\dagger
\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)\\
&=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}^{\dagger}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)
\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)\\
&=\zeta\exp\left(\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)
\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot\mathrm{d}\vec{s}'_n\right)\\
&=\mathbf{I} \tag*{(160)}
\end{aligned} A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) † A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) † ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ † ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) = ζ exp ( ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) = I (160)
On the other hand, in Method II, we carry out a transformation of the nuclear wave function (ψ a d \psi^{ad} ψ a d ) in the adiabatic representation to another wave function (ϕ d \phi^d ϕ d ) for the diabatic representation and those can be related through an orthogonal transformation matrix, A A A in the following way:
ψ a d ( s n ) = A ( s n ) ϕ d ( s n ) (161) \psi^{ad}(s_n)=A(s_n)\phi^d(s_n) \tag*{(161)} ψ a d ( s n ) = A ( s n ) ϕ d ( s n ) (161)
Using the above expression of ψ a d \psi^{ad} ψ a d in Eq. (146) , the SE in Eq. (146) becomes:
− 1 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) 2 A ϕ d + ( u − E ) A ϕ d = 0 (162) -\frac{1}{2}(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})^2 A\phi^d+(\mathbf{u}-E)A\phi^d=0 \tag*{(162)} − 2 1 ( ∇ n + τ ) 2 A ϕ d + ( u − E ) A ϕ d = 0 (162)
( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) 2 A ϕ d = ( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) ⋅ ( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) A ϕ d = ( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) ⋅ { A ∇ ⃗ n ϕ d + ( ∇ ⃗ n A ) ϕ d + τ ⃗ A ϕ d } = A ∇ ⃗ n 2 ϕ d + 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n A ) ⋅ ∇ ⃗ n ϕ d + 2 τ ⃗ ⋅ A ( ∇ ⃗ n ϕ d ) + ( ∇ ⃗ n 2 A ) ϕ d + ( ∇ ⃗ n ⋅ τ ⃗ ) A ϕ d + 2 τ ⃗ ⋅ ( ∇ ⃗ n A ) ϕ d + τ ⃗ 2 A ϕ d \begin{aligned}
(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})^2A\phi^d
&=(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})\cdot(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})A\phi^d\\
&=(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})\cdot\left\{A\vec{\nabla}_n\phi^d+(\vec{\nabla}_nA)\phi^d+\vec{\tau}A\phi^d\right\}\\
&=A\vec{\nabla}_n^2\phi^d+2(\vec{\nabla}_nA)\cdot\vec{\nabla}_n\phi^d+2\vec{\tau}\cdot A(\vec{\nabla}_n\phi^d)\\
&\quad+(\vec{\nabla}_n^2A)\phi^d+(\vec{\nabla}_n\cdot\vec{\tau})A\phi^d+2\vec{\tau}\cdot(\vec{\nabla}_nA)\phi^d+\vec{\tau}^{\,2}A\phi^d
\end{aligned} ( ∇ n + τ ) 2 A ϕ d = ( ∇ n + τ ) ⋅ ( ∇ n + τ ) A ϕ d = ( ∇ n + τ ) ⋅ { A ∇ n ϕ d + ( ∇ n A ) ϕ d + τ A ϕ d } = A ∇ n 2 ϕ d + 2 ( ∇ n A ) ⋅ ∇ n ϕ d + 2 τ ⋅ A ( ∇ n ϕ d ) + ( ∇ n 2 A ) ϕ d + ( ∇ n ⋅ τ ) A ϕ d + 2 τ ⋅ ( ∇ n A ) ϕ d + τ 2 A ϕ d
which can be simplified to:
( ∇ ⃗ n + τ ⃗ ) 2 A ϕ d = A ∇ ⃗ n 2 ϕ d + 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n A + τ ⃗ A ) ⋅ ∇ ⃗ n ϕ d + { ( τ ⃗ + ∇ ⃗ n ) ⋅ ( ∇ ⃗ n A + τ ⃗ A ) } ϕ d (163) \begin{aligned}
(\vec{\nabla}_n+\vec{\tau})^2A\phi^d
&=A\vec{\nabla}_n^2\phi^d+2(\vec{\nabla}_nA+\vec{\tau}A)\cdot\vec{\nabla}_n\phi^d\\
&\quad+\left\{(\vec{\tau}+\vec{\nabla}_n)\cdot(\vec{\nabla}_nA+\vec{\tau}A)\right\}\phi^d \tag*{(163)}
\end{aligned} ( ∇ n + τ ) 2 A ϕ d = A ∇ n 2 ϕ d + 2 ( ∇ n A + τ A ) ⋅ ∇ n ϕ d + { ( τ + ∇ n ) ⋅ ( ∇ n A + τ A ) } ϕ d (163)
One can choose the matrix A A A such that it satisfies the following equation:
∇ ⃗ n A + τ ⃗ A = 0 , (164) \vec{\nabla}_nA+\vec{\tau}A=0, \tag*{(164)} ∇ n A + τ A = 0 , (164)
known as the ADT condition. Therefore Eq. (162) reduces to:
− 1 2 A ∇ n 2 ϕ d + ( u − E ) A ϕ d = 0. (165) -\frac{1}{2}A\nabla_n^2\phi^d+(\mathbf{u}-E)A\phi^d=0. \tag*{(165)} − 2 1 A ∇ n 2 ϕ d + ( u − E ) A ϕ d = 0. (165)
The nature of ADT matrix, A A A can be found out by multiplying Eq. (164) by A † A^\dagger A † from the left:
A † ∇ ⃗ n A + A † τ ⃗ A = 0 , (166) A^\dagger\vec{\nabla}_nA+A^\dagger\vec{\tau}A=0, \tag*{(166)} A † ∇ n A + A † τ A = 0 , (166)
and similarly, by taking dagger of Eq. (164) and then, multiplying A A A from the right, we get:
( ∇ ⃗ n A † ) A − A † τ ⃗ A = 0. (167) (\vec{\nabla}_nA^\dagger)A-A^\dagger\vec{\tau}A=0. \tag*{(167)} ( ∇ n A † ) A − A † τ A = 0. (167)
Adding Eq. (167) with (166) , we obtain:
A † ∇ ⃗ n A + ( ∇ ⃗ n A † ) A = 0 ⇒ ∇ ⃗ n ( A † A ) = 0 ⇒ A † A = c o n s t , \begin{aligned}
A^\dagger\vec{\nabla}_nA+(\vec{\nabla}_nA^\dagger)A&=0\\
\Rightarrow\vec{\nabla}_n(A^\dagger A)&=0\\
\Rightarrow A^\dagger A&=\mathrm{const},
\end{aligned} A † ∇ n A + ( ∇ n A † ) A ⇒ ∇ n ( A † A ) ⇒ A † A = 0 = 0 = const ,
which can be normalized to unity (I) and therefore, A A A is an orthogonal matrix.
Being A A A is an orthogonal matrix, Eq. (165) is left multiplied by A † A^\dagger A † and the SE is transformed into diabatic representation:
− 1 2 ∇ n 2 ϕ d + ( W − E ) ϕ d = 0 (168) -\frac{1}{2}\nabla_n^2\phi^d+(\mathbf{W}-E)\phi^d=0 \tag*{(168)} − 2 1 ∇ n 2 ϕ d + ( W − E ) ϕ d = 0 (168)
W = A † u A (169) \mathbf{W}=A^\dagger\mathbf{u}A \tag*{(169)} W = A † u A (169)
The W \mathbf{W} W matrix is, in principle, full matrix with non-zero off-diagonal terms in the diabatic representation. Thus, the kinetic couplings in Eq. (146) in adiabatic representation turn into potential couplings in Eq. (168) in diabatic representation through various nuclear DOFs.
In summary, both the methods (I) and (II) provide the routes for adiabatic-to-diabatic transformation (ADT). Indeed, one can show that the two methods are equivalent resulting into the same diabatic representation as below:
The condition in Eq. (164) is known as ADT equation, which can be written by exploiting the form of the solution given in Eq. (157) :
A ( s n ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) A ( s 0 ) . (170) A(s_n)=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot d\vec{s}'_n\right)A(s_0). \tag*{(170)} A ( s n ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) A ( s 0 ) . (170)
While choosing appropriate boundary conditions, A ( s 0 ) = I A(s_0)=I A ( s 0 ) = I , Eq. (170) is simplified as:
A ( s n ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) . (171) A(s_n)=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s_n}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot d\vec{s}'_n\right). \tag*{(171)} A ( s n ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s n τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) . (171)
Equating Eqs. (159) and (171) , we get:
A ~ ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = A ( s n ) . (172) \widetilde{A}(s_n|s_0)=A(s_n). \tag*{(172)} A ( s n ∣ s 0 ) = A ( s n ) . (172)
On recalling the expression for the total molecular wave function (see Eq. (128) ), we can write in the following matrix form:
Ψ ( s e , s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s n ) ϕ a d ( s n ) . (173) \Psi(s_e,s_n)=\xi^{T}(s_e|s_n)\phi^{ad}(s_n). \tag*{(173)} Ψ ( s e , s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s n ) ϕ a d ( s n ) . (173)
Using Eqs. (158) , (172) and (161) consecutively, Eq. (173) can be rewritten as:
Ψ ( s e , s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) A ~ † ψ a d ( s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) A † ψ a d ( s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ϕ d ( s n ) (174) \begin{aligned}
\Psi(s_e,s_n) &= \xi^T(s_e|s_0)\widetilde{A}^{\dagger}\psi^{ad}(s_n) \\
&= \xi^T(s_e|s_0)A^{\dagger}\psi^{ad}(s_n) \\
&= \xi^T(s_e|s_0)\phi^d(s_n) \tag*{(174)}
\end{aligned} Ψ ( s e , s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) A † ψ a d ( s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) A † ψ a d ( s n ) = ξ T ( s e ∣ s 0 ) ϕ d ( s n ) (174)
Comparing the above expression (Eq. (174) ) with the matrix form of Eq. (148) , we affirm that:
ϕ ~ d ( s n ) = ϕ d ( s n ) . \widetilde{\phi}^{d}(s_n)=\phi^{d}(s_n). ϕ d ( s n ) = ϕ d ( s n ) .
As a result, the diabatic wavefunctions in the two different methods becomes actually same which would lead to the same diabatic representation of the SE. Therefore, it is needless to mention that the potentials in this particular representation from the two methods are also same:
Properties of Path Dependent Diabatic Hamiltonian Matrices
Method I:
While depicting the path-dependence of diabatic Hamiltonian matrices, we consider the scalar form of ADT equations characterized by nuclear coordinates p p p and q q q :
∂ ∂ p A ( p , q ) + τ p A ( p , q ) = 0 (175) \frac{\partial}{\partial p}A(p,q)+\tau_pA(p,q)=0 \tag*{(175)} ∂ p ∂ A ( p , q ) + τ p A ( p , q ) = 0 (175)
∂ ∂ q A ( p , q ) + τ q A ( p , q ) = 0 (176) \frac{\partial}{\partial q}A(p,q)+\tau_qA(p,q)=0 \tag*{(176)} ∂ q ∂ A ( p , q ) + τ q A ( p , q ) = 0 (176)
The integral form of each of the above equations is given by Eq. (170) :
A ( s ∣ Γ ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s τ ⃗ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s ⃗ n ′ ) A ( s 0 ) , (177) A(s|\Gamma)=\zeta\exp\left(-\int_{s_0}^{s}\vec{\tau}(s'_n)\cdot d\vec{s}'_n\right)A(s_0), \tag*{(177)} A ( s ∣Γ ) = ζ exp ( − ∫ s 0 s τ ( s n ′ ) ⋅ d s n ′ ) A ( s 0 ) , (177)
where Γ \Gamma Γ is the contour of integration from s 0 s_0 s 0 to s s s and ζ \zeta ζ is the ordering operator for integration. We can carry out two consecutive steps of integration in two different paths Γ 1 \Gamma_1 Γ 1 and Γ 2 \Gamma_2 Γ 2 to reach a specific point. Subsequently, we will find the corresponding ADT matrices, A 1 ( p , q ) A_1(p,q) A 1 ( p , q ) and A 2 ( p , q ) A_2(p,q) A 2 ( p , q ) by employing Eq. (177) .
The two different paths on the p − q p-q p − q plane are chosen as follows:
S . I : ( p 0 , q 0 ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) \mathrm{S.I:}\quad(p_0,q_0)\rightarrow(p_0+\Delta p,q_0)\rightarrow(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q) S.I : ( p 0 , q 0 ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q )
S . I I : ( p 0 , q 0 ) → ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) \mathrm{S.II:}\quad(p_0,q_0)\rightarrow(p_0,q_0+\Delta q)\rightarrow(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q) S.II : ( p 0 , q 0 ) → ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) → ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q )
which is presented in the following figure (Figure 4.1 ):
Figure 4.1. Two different paths of calculating ADT matrix. The figure has been adapted from Ref. [10] and permission has been granted from The Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
The corresponding ADT matrices for both the paths are given by:
S . I : A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (178) \mathrm{S.I:}\quad A(p_0+\Delta p,q_0)=\exp\left(-\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\tau_p(p,q_0)\,dp\right)A(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(178)} S.I : A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (178)
Diabatic Representation
A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) (179) \mathbf{A}(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q)=\exp\left(-\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0+\Delta p,q)\,dq\right)\mathbf{A}(p_0+\Delta p,q_0) \tag*{(179)} A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 ) (179)
S.II: A ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) \mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0+\Delta q)=\exp\left(-\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0,q)\,dq\right)\mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0) A ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 )
A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) (180) \mathbf{A}(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q)=\exp\left(-\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0+\Delta q)\,dp\right)\mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0+\Delta q) \tag*{(180)} A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 + Δ q ) (180)
When Eqs. (178) and (4.98a) are substituted in Eqs. (179) and (180) , respectively, the corresponding ADT matrices for two different chosen paths take the following form:
S.I: A 1 ≡ A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (181) \begin{aligned}
\text{S.I:}\quad\mathbf{A}_1&\equiv\mathbf{A}(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q)\\
&=\exp\left(-\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0+\Delta p,q)\,dq-\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0)\,dp\right)\mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(181)}
\end{aligned} S.I: A 1 ≡ A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (181)
S.II: A 2 ≡ A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) d p − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (182) \begin{aligned}
\text{S.II:}\quad\mathbf{A}_2&\equiv\mathbf{A}(p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q)\\
&=\exp\left(-\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0+\Delta q)\,dp-\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0,q)\,dq\right)\mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(182)}
\end{aligned} S.II: A 2 ≡ A ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) = exp ( − ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) d p − ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (182)
While taking dagger on Eq. (181) , we can obtain:
A 1 † = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) × exp ( ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q + ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) (183) \mathbf{A}_1^\dagger=\mathbf{A}^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\times\exp\left(\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0+\Delta p,q)\,dq+\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0)\,dp\right) \tag*{(183)} A 1 † = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) × exp ( ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) d q + ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p τ p ( p , q 0 ) d p ) (183)
and then, it is multiplied with Eq. (182) to achieve:
A 1 † A 2 = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp [ ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p ( τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) − τ p ( p , q 0 ) ) d p + ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q ( τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) − τ q ( p 0 , q ) ) d q ] A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (184) \begin{aligned}
\mathbf{A}_1^\dagger\mathbf{A}_2={}&\mathbf{A}^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\exp\Bigg[\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\left(\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0+\Delta q)-\boldsymbol{\tau}_p(p,q_0)\right)\,dp\\
&+\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\left(\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0+\Delta p,q)-\boldsymbol{\tau}_q(p_0,q)\right)\,dq\Bigg]\mathbf{A}(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(184)}
\end{aligned} A 1 † A 2 = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp [ ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p ( τ p ( p , q 0 + Δ q ) − τ p ( p , q 0 ) ) d p + ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q ( τ q ( p 0 + Δ p , q ) − τ q ( p 0 , q ) ) d q ] A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (184)
Considering a midpoint ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) (\bar{p},\bar{q}) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) in the planer interval as p 0 ≤ p ˉ ≤ p 0 + Δ p p_0 \le\bar{p} \le p_0+\Delta p p 0 ≤ p ˉ ≤ p 0 + Δ p and q 0 ≤ q ˉ ≤ q 0 + Δ q q_0 \le\bar{q} \le q_0+\Delta q q 0 ≤ q ˉ ≤ q 0 + Δ q and assuming that Δ p , Δ q \Delta p,\Delta q Δ p , Δ q are small enough, we employ the definition of numerical differentiation as well as integration around the midpoint ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) (\bar{p},\bar{q}) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) and write Eq. (4.101a) as:
A 1 † A 2 = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) × exp ( − Δ q ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p ∂ τ p ( p , q ˉ ) ∂ q d p + Δ p ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q ∂ τ q ( p ˉ , q ) ∂ p d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp [ − Δ p Δ q ( ∂ τ p ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) ∂ q − ∂ τ q ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) ∂ p ) ] A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (185) \begin{aligned}
A_1^\dagger A_2=A_1^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\times
\exp\left(-\Delta q\int_{p_0}^{p_0+\Delta p}\frac{\partial\tau_p(p,\bar{q})}{\partial q}\,dp+\Delta p\int_{q_0}^{q_0+\Delta q}\frac{\partial\tau_q(\bar{p},q)}{\partial p}\,dq\right)A(p_0,q_0) \\
&=A_1^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\exp\left[-\Delta p\Delta q\left(\frac{\partial\tau_p(\bar{p},\bar{q})}{\partial q}-\frac{\partial\tau_q(\bar{p},\bar{q})}{\partial p}\right)\right]A(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(185)}
\end{aligned} A 1 † A 2 = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) × exp ( − Δ q ∫ p 0 p 0 + Δ p ∂ q ∂ τ p ( p , q ˉ ) d p + Δ p ∫ q 0 q 0 + Δ q ∂ p ∂ τ q ( p ˉ , q ) d q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp [ − Δ p Δ q ( ∂ q ∂ τ p ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) − ∂ p ∂ τ q ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) ) ] A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (185)
which in turn takes the following form:
A 1 † A 2 = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( − Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) p q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (186) A_1^\dagger A_2=A_1^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\exp\left(-\Delta p\Delta q(\operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau})_{pq}\right)A(p_0,q_0) \tag*{(186)} A 1 † A 2 = A 1 † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( − Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) pq ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) (186)
The argument of the exponential in Eq. (186) is not a null matrix and therefore, the product matrix ( B = A 1 † A 2 ) (B=A_1^\dagger A_2) ( B = A 1 † A 2 ) does not appear as unit matrix. The ADT matrices, A 1 ( p , q ) A_1(p,q) A 1 ( p , q ) and A 2 ( p , q ) A_2(p,q) A 2 ( p , q ) , are not the same at the point ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) (p_0+\Delta p,q_0+\Delta q) ( p 0 + Δ p , q 0 + Δ q ) for two different chosen paths of integration, S.I and S.II .
B † B = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) p q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) × A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( − Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) p q ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) = I (187) \begin{aligned}
B^\dagger B&=A^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\exp\left(\Delta p\Delta q(\operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau})_{pq}\right)A(p_0,q_0)\times\\
&\quad A^\dagger(p_0,q_0)\exp\left(-\Delta p\Delta q(\operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau})_{pq}\right)A(p_0,q_0)\\
&=I \tag*{(187)}
\end{aligned} B † B = A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) pq ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) × A † ( p 0 , q 0 ) exp ( − Δ p Δ q ( curl τ ) pq ) A ( p 0 , q 0 ) = I (187)
where curl τ \operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau} curl τ is a skew - symmetric matrix, i.e. ( curl τ ) † = − curl τ (\operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau})^\dagger=-\operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau} ( curl τ ) † = − curl τ . Therefore, the ADT matrices, A 1 ( p , q ) A_1(p,q) A 1 ( p , q ) and A 2 ( p , q ) A_2(p,q) A 2 ( p , q ) , are related through an orthogonal transformation matrix, B B B .3
Therefore, there are infinite number of possible different diabatic potential matrices depending upon the chosen paths, but as these are related by orthogonal transformation matrix, observables will be identical on dynamical calculations.
Method II:
Since BBO theory based diabatization involves skew-symmetric non-Abelian non-adiabatic coupling matrices (NACM) of three or higher dimensional sub-Hilbert spaces, the solutions of the coupled differential (ADT) equations appear as path-dependent over two-dimensional cross-sections of any multi-dimensional space of nuclear degrees of freedom. As for example, if one carries out even multi-step integration in two different paths (let’s say paths I and II, see Figure 4.1 ) towards a specific final ending point and the resulting ADT matrices are assigned as A 1 A_1 A 1 and A 2 11 A_2^{11} A 2 11 at the same point, the associated diabatic PESs matrices at the end point take the following forms:
W 1 = A 1 † U A 1 and W 2 = A 2 † U A 2 , (188) W_1=A_1^\dagger U A_1 \quad\text{and}\quad W_2=A_2^\dagger U A_2, \tag*{(188)} W 1 = A 1 † U A 1 and W 2 = A 2 † U A 2 , (188)
leading to
A 1 W 1 A 1 † = A 2 W 2 A 2 † = U , (189) A_1W_1A_1^\dagger=A_2W_2A_2^\dagger=U, \tag*{(189)} A 1 W 1 A 1 † = A 2 W 2 A 2 † = U , (189)
which results into
W 1 = B W 2 B † . (190) W_1 = B W_2 B^\dagger. \tag*{(190)} W 1 = B W 2 B † . (190)
The ADT matrices A 1 ( p , q ) A_1(p,q) A 1 ( p , q ) and A 2 ( p , q ) A_2(p,q) A 2 ( p , q ) are orthogonal transformation matrices and thereby, the product B = ( A 1 † A 2 ) B = (A_1^\dagger A_2) B = ( A 1 † A 2 ) in Eq. (190) also appears to be an orthogonal matrix.12,13
B † B = A 2 † A 1 A 1 † A 2 = I . (191) B^\dagger B = A_2^\dagger A_1 A_1^\dagger A_2 = I. \tag*{(191)} B † B = A 2 † A 1 A 1 † A 2 = I . (191)
Consequently, infinite number of different diabatic potential matrices (W W W ) is possible depending upon the chosen paths. On the contrary, those matrices are related by orthogonal transformation matrix (B B B ) and therefore, one can get same observables on dynamical calculations (see Eq. (190) ). In other words, the above discussion affirms path independence of the calculated observables originating from different diabatic PESs matrices (W 1 W_1 W 1 and W 2 W_2 W 2 ).10,12,13
Curl Condition and Quantization of NACTs
While performing BBO based diabatization of adiabatic PESs and NACTs, it is indeed necessary to verify whether the involved number of electronic states (N N N ) over the interested domain of nuclear space constitutes a “true" SHS within the numerical precision. We can examine the existence of such SHS by calculating matrix elements of derived Curl Condition of the associated NACTs as depicted below. Over p p p -q q q (p p p and q q q are nuclear degrees of freedom) nuclear plane, Eq. (164) can be written as,
∇ p A + τ p A = 0 (192) \nabla_p A + \tau_p A = 0 \tag*{(192)} ∇ p A + τ p A = 0 (192)
∇ q A + τ q A = 0 (193) \nabla_q A + \tau_q A = 0 \tag*{(193)} ∇ q A + τ q A = 0 (193)
Since the elements of ADT matrix (A A A ) are analytical functions with respect to nuclear coordinates (p p p and q q q ), the cross-derivatives on Eqs. (192) and (193) can lead to the following equation known as Curl Condition:
(a) Curl condition:
∂ ∂ p τ q i j − ∂ ∂ q τ p i j = ( τ q τ p ) i j − ( τ p τ q ) i j , (194) \frac{\partial}{\partial p}\tau_q^{ij} - \frac{\partial}{\partial q}\tau_p^{ij} = (\tau_q\tau_p)_{ij} - (\tau_p\tau_q)_{ij}, \tag*{(194)} ∂ p ∂ τ q ij − ∂ q ∂ τ p ij = ( τ q τ p ) ij − ( τ p τ q ) ij , (194)
which is known as molecular field equation (similar to Yang-Mills field equation) over p − q p-q p − q plane that can be represented as,
F p q i j = [ ∂ ∂ p τ q i j − ∂ ∂ q τ p i j ] − [ ( τ q τ p ) i j − ( τ p τ q ) i j ] , (195) F_{pq}^{ij} = \left[\frac{\partial}{\partial p}\tau_q^{ij} - \frac{\partial}{\partial q}\tau_p^{ij}\right] - \left[(\tau_q\tau_p)_{ij} - (\tau_p\tau_q)_{ij}\right], \tag*{(195)} F pq ij = [ ∂ p ∂ τ q ij − ∂ q ∂ τ p ij ] − [ ( τ q τ p ) ij − ( τ p τ q ) ij ] , (195)
and such components should acquire the magnitude of zero (0) as the condition for the existence of SHS.
(b) Quantization of non-adiabatic coupling:
In case of symmetry driven or accidental degeneracy between the electronic states at a point or along a seam, Hellmann-Feynmann8,9 theorem (see Eq. (144) ) depicts the singularity of NACT. Such singular function obeys the Cauchy’s residue theorem along a closed contour of the singular point or seam:
∫ 0 2 π τ ϕ i j ( ρ , ϕ ) d ϕ = n π or n . ( 2 π ) , (196) \int_0^{2\pi} \tau_\phi^{ij}(\rho,\phi)d\phi= n\pi\text{ or } n.(2\pi), \tag*{(196)} ∫ 0 2 π τ ϕ ij ( ρ , ϕ ) d ϕ = nπ or n . ( 2 π ) , (196)
which is known as quantization of NACT. In the above expression, n n n represents the number of CIs, i , j i,j i , j specifies two electronic states for a specific sub-Hilbert space [ { i , j } ∈ N ] [\{i,j\} \in N] [{ i , j } ∈ N ] , p p p and q q q designate Cartesian coordinates, and ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ define their polar counterparts. On the other hand, the scalar components of NACTs along Cartesian coordinates, p p p and q q q , and the polar transformed circular coordinate, ϕ \phi ϕ are denoted as τ p i j \tau_{p}^{ij} τ p ij , τ q i j \tau_{q}^{ij} τ q ij and τ ϕ i j ( ρ , ϕ ) \tau_{\phi}^{ij}(\rho,\phi) τ ϕ ij ( ρ , ϕ ) , respectively.
If the conditions (Eqs. (194) and (196) ) are validated by the NACT components, one can consider those states form a SHS as well as depict the number of CI(s) in the sub-space. Since the entire magnitude of ab initio NACTs is incorporated in first principle based diabatization using ADT, the validity of the above conditions predicts absence of any non-removable component for the chosen sub-Hilbert space. It affirms the calculated ADT matrix A A A as well as the diabatic PES matrix W W W as theoretically “exact” and numerically “accurate” ones. On the contrary, when those conditions (Eqs. (194) and (196) ) are not satisfied over the chosen domain of nuclear CS, expansion of the SHS is indeed necessary to achieve desired level of accuracy.
Sub-Hilbert Space: Theoretical and Algorithmic Details on the Calculation of Curl Condition
While computing NACTs and adiabatic PESs, the accuracy of electronic structure calculation plays a major role as implemented in the quantum chemistry packages like Molpro14 or Columbus15. In order to calculate the adiabatic PESs, complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) followed by multi-reference configuration interaction (MRCI) approaches can be opted to solve electronic SE at each nuclear geometry. In CASSCF (coupled-perturbed multi-configuration self-consistent field, CP-MCSCF) and MRCI (numerical finite difference, DDR) approaches, NACTs are evaluated by taking derivatives of the energies and derivatives of wavefunction, respectively. Since we are interested to calculate multiple adiabatic PESs and couplings between those states, the use of multi-reference electronic structure calculations (CASSCF/CP-MCSCF or MRCI/DDR) is a necessity.
The accuracy of NACTs can be explored by performing closed contour integration of those ab initio quantities over the nuclear CS, where such integration leads to n π n\pi nπ (for symmetry driven or accidental JT CI/seam) or n .2 π n.2\pi n .2 π (for RT CI/seam) or 0 [for Pseudo Jahn-Teller (PJT)] validating the quantization properties of NACTs. In other words, the following integral needs to be evaluated:
∫ 0 2 π τ ϕ i j ( ρ 0 , ϕ ) d ϕ = 0 or n π or n .2 π , (197) \int_{0}^{2\pi}\tau_{\phi}^{ij}(\rho_{0},\phi)d\phi= 0\ \text{or}\ n\pi\ \text{or}\ n.2\pi, \tag*{(197)} ∫ 0 2 π τ ϕ ij ( ρ 0 , ϕ ) d ϕ = 0 or nπ or n .2 π , (197)
where τ ϕ i j \tau_{\phi}^{ij} τ ϕ ij symbolizes the NACT between { i , j } \{i,j\} { i , j } electronic states along the circular nuclear coordinate ϕ \phi ϕ for a fixed value of ρ ( = ρ 0 ) \rho(=\rho_{0}) ρ ( = ρ 0 ) . For any molecular process or chemical reaction, the above integral needs to be satisfied by the ab initio calculated NACTs if the electronic structure calculations are executed using complete active space (CAS) with appropriate choice of basis set for a specific system. In other words, the quantization rule validates the accuracy of ab initio calculated NACTs.
On the other hand, the accuracy of diabatic Hamiltonian matrix (obtained by ADT calculations) is dependent on the “numerical” truncation of Hilbert space for a specific system. In principle, the diabatic Hamiltonian is theoretically exact for the M M M -dimensional complete Hilbert space, but for practical purposes, a N N N -dimensional truncated Hilbert space can be used to generate finite [N N N ( < < M ) (<< M) ( << M ) ] dimensional “accurate” diabatic Hamiltonian matrix. Even though the curl condition (difference between Mathematical and Commutator Curls) appears as zero (0) by construction for the complete matrix (Hilbert) space, one needs to verify the validity of such condition for a truncated Hilbert space prior to the construction of BBO based diabatic Hamiltonian (BBO-DH).
While computing the curl condition for a truncated Hilbert space, direct use of ab initio calculated NACTs may often leads to erroneous results due to numerical error at few nuclear geometries, more specifically, at the close vicinity of CI domain. As a matter of fact, taking derivatives of singular or very small values of ab initio NACTs for calculating Mathematical Curl may introduce inaccuracies and practical difficulty. On the contrary, while solving the ADT equations using backward differentiation formula [integration of differential equations for (a) two state, (b) three state, (c) four state and (d) five state (see the following section for details)], the numerical inaccuracies of NACTs over nuclear geometries could be wiped out to obtain the ADT angles fulfilling the quantization rule as discussed below.
(a) Once the ab initio NACTs are calculated between the multiple electronic states as functions of vibrational modes, those quantities are substituted in the ADT equations (see Eqs. (198) , (199) and Appendix B.1) and solved to obtain the ADT angles.
(b) Those ADT angles are plugged into the explicit expressions of NACTs (see Eqs. (200) , (201) and Appendix B.1) and Mathematical Curls (see Eqs. (202) , (203) and Appendix B.1) to evaluate those quantities with greater accuracy.
(c) The recalculated NACTs are substituted in the commutator relation (RHS of Eq. (194) ) to evaluate the matrix elements of ADT Curl.
(d) The matrix elements of Curl Condition are computed by subtracting Mathematical and ADT Curls (Eq. (195) ).
Such approach is a unique tool of BBO based diabatization for predicting the size of the truncated space known as sub-Hilbert space ensuring the “accuracy" of diabatic Hamiltonian for a molecular process or chemical reaction.
Explicit Expressions of ADT Equations, NACTs and Curl Equations
We present the explicit expressions of ADT Equations, NACTs and Mathematical Curls for two to three state SHS, 16,17 where the expressions for four to six state SHS are illustrated in the Appendix B.1 18–20.
The ADT equations for two (N = 2 N = 2 N = 2 ) and three (N = 3 N = 3 N = 3 ) electronic state sub-Hilbert space take the following form: 16,17
∇ R Θ 12 = − τ 12 (198) \nabla_{R}\Theta^{12}=-\tau^{12} \tag*{(198)} ∇ R Θ 12 = − τ 12 (198)
∇ R Θ 12 = − τ 12 − tan Θ 13 ( τ 13 sin Θ 12 + τ 23 cos Θ 12 ) , ∇ R Θ 13 = − ( τ 13 cos Θ 12 − τ 23 sin Θ 12 ) , ∇ R Θ 23 = − 1 cos Θ 13 ( τ 13 sin Θ 12 + τ 23 cos Θ 12 ) , (199) \begin{aligned}
\nabla_{R}\Theta^{12}&=-\tau^{12}-\tan\Theta^{13}\left(\tau^{13}\sin\Theta^{12}+\tau^{23}\cos\Theta^{12}\right),\\
\nabla_{R}\Theta^{13}&=-\left(\tau^{13}\cos\Theta^{12}-\tau^{23}\sin\Theta^{12}\right),\\
\nabla_{R}\Theta^{23}&=-\frac{1}{\cos\Theta^{13}}\left(\tau^{13}\sin\Theta^{12}+\tau^{23}\cos\Theta^{12}\right), \tag*{(199)}
\end{aligned} ∇ R Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 13 ∇ R Θ 23 = − τ 12 − tan Θ 13 ( τ 13 sin Θ 12 + τ 23 cos Θ 12 ) , = − ( τ 13 cos Θ 12 − τ 23 sin Θ 12 ) , = − cos Θ 13 1 ( τ 13 sin Θ 12 + τ 23 cos Θ 12 ) , (199)
On the other hand, NACT expressions can be written as 16,17:
τ 12 = − ∇ R Θ 12 (200) \tau^{12}=-\nabla_{R}\Theta^{12} \tag*{(200)} τ 12 = − ∇ R Θ 12 (200)
τ 12 = − ∇ R Θ 12 + sin Θ 13 ∇ R Θ 23 , τ 13 = − cos Θ 13 sin Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 23 − cos Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 13 , τ 23 = − cos Θ 12 cos Θ 13 ∇ R Θ 23 + sin Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 13 (201) \begin{aligned}
\tau^{12}&=-\nabla_{R}\Theta^{12}+\sin\Theta^{13}\nabla_{R}\Theta^{23},\\
\tau^{13}&=-\cos\Theta^{13}\sin\Theta^{12}\nabla_{R}\Theta^{23}-\cos\Theta^{12}\nabla_{R}\Theta^{13},\\
\tau^{23}&=-\cos\Theta^{12}\cos\Theta^{13}\nabla_{R}\Theta^{23}+\sin\Theta^{12}\nabla_{R}\Theta^{13} \tag*{(201)}
\end{aligned} τ 12 τ 13 τ 23 = − ∇ R Θ 12 + sin Θ 13 ∇ R Θ 23 , = − cos Θ 13 sin Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 23 − cos Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 13 , = − cos Θ 12 cos Θ 13 ∇ R Θ 23 + sin Θ 12 ∇ R Θ 13 (201)
Finally, the Mathematical Curl equations take the following forms:
Z ρ ϕ 12 = ∇ ϕ ∇ ρ Θ 12 − ∇ ρ ∇ ϕ Θ 12 (202) Z_{\rho\phi}^{12}=\nabla_{\phi}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{12}-\nabla_{\rho}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{12} \tag*{(202)} Z ρϕ 12 = ∇ ϕ ∇ ρ Θ 12 − ∇ ρ ∇ ϕ Θ 12 (202)
Z ρ ϕ 12 = − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) Z_{\rho\phi}^{12} = -\cos\Theta^{23}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{13}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{13}\right) Z ρϕ 12 = − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 )
Z ρ ϕ 13 = sin Θ 12 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 12 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) − cos Θ 12 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ) \begin{aligned}
Z_{\rho\phi}^{13} ={}& \sin\Theta^{12}\cos\Theta^{23}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{13}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{13}\right) \\
&+\cos\Theta^{12}\sin\Theta^{23}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{13}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{13}\right) \\
&-\cos\Theta^{12}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{23}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{23}\right)
\end{aligned} Z ρϕ 13 = sin Θ 12 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 12 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) − cos Θ 12 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 23 )
Z ρ ϕ 23 = cos Θ 12 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) − sin Θ 12 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) + sin Θ 12 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ) (203) \begin{aligned}
Z_{\rho\phi}^{23} ={}& \cos\Theta^{12}\cos\Theta^{23}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{13}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{13}\right) \\
&-\sin\Theta^{12}\sin\Theta^{23}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{13}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{23}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{13}\right) \\
&+\sin\Theta^{12}\left(\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{23}-\nabla_{\rho}\Theta^{12}\nabla_{\phi}\Theta^{23}\right) \tag*{(203)}
\end{aligned} Z ρϕ 23 = cos Θ 12 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) − sin Θ 12 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 13 − ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ϕ Θ 13 ) + sin Θ 12 ( ∇ ϕ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 − ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ϕ Θ 23 ) (203)
Molecular Symmetry Adaptation of Nonadiabatic Coupling Terms
While performing the electronic structure calculations for a molecular process or chemical reaction, the IREPs of the adiabatic states can be assigned as per the point group of the system at the equilibrium geometry and therefore, it is possible to define the IREP of the adiabatic potential energy at that point. When one moves from the equilibrium geometry to any other geometry of the nuclear CS, one can assign the IREPs of the adiabatic PESs, which would also be found out from the correlation of the associated (point) groups. It is to note that the IREPs of the adiabatic PESs change from equilibrium geometry to other geometry, in particular, because the symmetry of the molecular process changes from one nuclear configuration to another. On the contrary, in case of NACTs, since those terms are evaluated by taking the derivatives of the electronic eigenfunctions with respect to nuclear coordinates, it is not straightforward to define the IREPs of those coupling terms. While defining the IREPs of the NACTs, we need to consider higher symmetry groups known as molecular symmetry (MS), 21, where the symmetry elements of the point group are modified by multiplying Rigid Rotation and Nuclear Permutations of the molecular/chemical processes. For high amplitude nuclear (vibrational) motions of a species, the point group concept has limited applicability, where a larger set of symmetry operations is required to examine the floppy molecular processes. If the time scale of a given laboratory experiment appears shorter to allow certain nuclear permutations, 21, it is necessary to construct the MS group using the feasible ones among the elements of complete group of Hamiltonian.
Generally, a molecular symmetry (MS) group consists of h h h symmetry operations, O ^ i \hat{O}_i O ^ i , i = 1 , 2 , … , h i=1,2,\ldots,h i = 1 , 2 , … , h , namely, the identity operation E E E , all feasible permutations P P P of the spatial and spin coordinates of the equivalent nuclei, the inversion E ⋆ E^\star E ⋆ of all nuclear (R \mathbf{R} R ) and electronic (r \mathbf{r} r ) coordinates, and the inversion-permutation P ⋅ E ⋆ P\cdot E^\star P ⋅ E ⋆ operation. Any such operation, O ^ \hat{O} O ^ can be expressed as a product of three different operations, 22, i.e., O ^ = O ^ a O ^ b O ^ c \hat{O}=\hat{O}_a\hat{O}_b\hat{O}_c O ^ = O ^ a O ^ b O ^ c , where O ^ a \hat{O}_a O ^ a is associated with vibronic DOFs, O ^ b \hat{O}_b O ^ b involves rotation of the Euler angles and O ^ c \hat{O}_c O ^ c leads to permutation of the nuclear spin. On the contrary, in the point group, symmetry operations transform only the vibronic DOFs of a molecule.
As a representative example of symmetric triatomic molecule, we consider Na3 _3 3 cluster possessing D3 h _{3h} 3 h symmetric equilibrium structure. In this molecular system, the body fixed x − y − z x-y-z x − y − z axes are situated in the cluster in such a way so that plane of symmetry, σ h \sigma_h σ h passes through the molecular plane (x y xy x y plane) and z z z axis coincides with the threefold symmetry axis, C 3 C_3 C 3 , which are demonstrated in Figure 4.2 using coordinate axes, symmetry elements and stereographic projection for D3 h _{3h} 3 h point group. For such case, the Cartesian coordinates x − y − z x-y-z x − y − z symbolize the normal modes, Q x Q_x Q x (bending), Q y Q_y Q y (antisymmetric stretching) and Q s Q_s Q s (symmetric stretching), respectively. On the other hand, Figure 4.3 depicts atomic displacements for those vibrational modes. In case of Na3 _3 3 cluster, polar counterparts of x x x (= Q x Q_x Q x ) and y y y (= Q y Q_y Q y ) coordinates (ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ ) are chosen keeping the magnitude of z z z (= Q s Q_s Q s ) fixed at 3.7 Å. The MS group [D3 h _{3h} 3 h (M)] and the corresponding point group (D3 h _{3h} 3 h ) can be related through the following relations 22:
Figure 4.2. The left panel (a) shows symmetry elements of D 3 h \mathrm{D}_{3h} D 3 h point group and the coordinate axes in N a 3 \mathrm{Na}_{3} Na 3 system. The right one (b) presents the effects of those symmetry operations in N a 3 \mathrm{Na}_{3} Na 3 cluster. The figure has been adapted from Ref. [10] and permission has been granted from The Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
Figure 4.3. Vectorial displacements of the atoms in N a 3 \mathrm{Na}_{3} Na 3 cluster are depicted for three vibrational modes, namely Q x Q_x Q x (bending), Q y Q_y Q y (antisymmetric stretching) and Q s Q_s Q s (symmetric stretching). The figure has been taken from Ref. [10] and permission has been granted from The Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
Molecular Symmetry Adaptation of Nonadiabatic Coupling Terms
E = E ⋅ R 0 ⋅ p 0 , (204) E = E \cdot R^{0} \cdot p_{0}, \tag*{(204)} E = E ⋅ R 0 ⋅ p 0 , (204)
( 123 ) = C 3 1 ⋅ R 2 π 3 ⋅ p 123 , (205) (123) = C_{3}^{1} \cdot R^{\frac{2\pi}{3}} \cdot p_{123}, \tag*{(205)} ( 123 ) = C 3 1 ⋅ R 3 2 π ⋅ p 123 , (205)
( 23 ) = C 2 x ⋅ R π z ⋅ p 23 , (206) (23) = C_{2x} \cdot R_{\pi z} \cdot p_{23}, \tag*{(206)} ( 23 ) = C 2 x ⋅ R π z ⋅ p 23 , (206)
E ∗ = σ x y ⋅ R π z ⋅ p 0 , (207) E^{*} = \sigma_{xy} \cdot R_{\pi z} \cdot p_{0}, \tag*{(207)} E ∗ = σ x y ⋅ R π z ⋅ p 0 , (207)
( 132 ) ∗ = S 3 − 1 ⋅ R z π 3 ⋅ p 132 , (208) (132)^{*} = S_{3}^{-1} \cdot R_{z}^{\frac{\pi}{3}} \cdot p_{132}, \tag*{(208)} ( 132 ) ∗ = S 3 − 1 ⋅ R z 3 π ⋅ p 132 , (208)
( 23 ) ∗ = σ x z ⋅ R y π ⋅ p 23 , (209) (23)^{*} = \sigma_{xz} \cdot R_{y}^{\pi} \cdot p_{23}, \tag*{(209)} ( 23 ) ∗ = σ x z ⋅ R y π ⋅ p 23 , (209)
where “R ϕ R^{\phi} R ϕ ”s represent molecular rotations and “p p p ”s signify nuclear permutations. While defining 1D IREPs of NACTs for C 2 v ( M ) \mathrm{C}_{2v}(\mathrm{M}) C 2 v ( M ) group, Al-Jabour and his coworkers 23 introduced two important theorems, which were extended for D 3 h ( M ) \mathrm{D}_{3h}(\mathrm{M}) D 3 h ( M ) group by Adhikari and coworkers for 2D IREPs. 11
Theorem 1: If the IREP of a NACT, τ l i j \tau_l^{ij} τ l ij is known along a specific symmetry adapted nuclear degree of freedom (DOF), R l R_l R l , the IREP of the another one, τ k i j \tau_k^{ij} τ k ij along a different symmetry adapted nuclear coordinate, R k R_k R k can be found with the aid of following relationship: 23
Γ ( τ k i j ) = Γ ( ∂ ∂ R k ) × Γ ( ∂ ∂ R l ) × Γ ( τ l i j ) , (210) \Gamma(\tau_k^{ij}) = \Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial R_k}\right) \times\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial R_l}\right) \times\Gamma(\tau_l^{ij}), \tag*{(210)} Γ ( τ k ij ) = Γ ( ∂ R k ∂ ) × Γ ( ∂ R l ∂ ) × Γ ( τ l ij ) , (210)
where
τ k i j = ⟨ ξ i | ∂ ξ j ∂ R k ⟩ . (211) \tau_k^{ij} = \left\langle\xi_i \middle| \frac{\partial\xi_j}{\partial R_k} \right\rangle. \tag*{(211)} τ k ij = ⟨ ξ i ∂ R k ∂ ξ j ⟩ . (211)
Using the above criterion, we can determine tentative combinations of the IREPs by assigning each of the NACTs [τ k \tau_k τ k 's (k = ρ k = \rho k = ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ or x x x and y y y )] to the totally symmetric one (A 1 ′ A_1' A 1 ′ ), successively. In case of D 3 h ( M ) D_{3h}(M) D 3 h ( M ) MS group, if τ ρ \tau_\rho τ ρ is considered as A 1 ′ A_1' A 1 ′ , Table 4.1 and Eq. (210) show that τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ ′ \tau_\phi\in A_1'' τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′′ and τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ ′ \tau_x, \tau_y \in E'' τ x , τ y ∈ E ′′ . In a similar way, if τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_\phi\in A_1' τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ , one can obtain τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′ ′ \tau_\rho\in A_1'' τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′′ and τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ \tau_x, \tau_y \in E' τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ . Nevertheless, for other two possibilities (τ x ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_x \in A_1' τ x ∈ A 1 ′ or τ y ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_y \in A_1' τ y ∈ A 1 ′ ), τ y \tau_y τ y or τ x \tau_x τ x belongs to reducible representation contradicting the construction of character table 24 as presented in Table 4.1 .
Table 4.1. Extended character table of D 3 h ( M ) D_{3h}(M) D 3 h ( M ) molecular symmetry group with different components of NACT. This table is adapted from Ref. [11].
Among the two possible combinations as presented above, the second one (τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_\phi\in A_1' τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ , τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′ ′ \tau_\rho\in A_1'' τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′′ and τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ \tau_x, \tau_y \in E' τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ ) fulfills the quantization rule, which is illustrated below:
The nodal patterns of NACTs22,24 for all possible IREPs are presented in Figure 4.4 , which show functional dependence on the normal mode coordinates, Q x Q_x Q x (bending) and Q y Q_y Q y (asymmetric stretching) of Na3 _3 3 cluster. The inner and outer concentric circles of Figure 4.4 depict Q x − Q y Q_x-Q_y Q x − Q y plane for positive and negative values of Q s Q_s Q s (symmetric stretching), respectively. While obtaining the correct combination of IREPs from the two possible ones (see Table 4.1 ), the smaller circles of Figure 4.4 are considered and thereby, the following quantization rule25 is applied along a closed path L g L_g L g of nuclear coordinate R \mathbf{R} R encapsulating a single CI:
Figure 4.4. Nodal patterns of IREPs of D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h point group are presented. The figure has been granted from Ref. [10] and permission has been taken from The Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
∮ d R ⋅ τ ( R ; L g ) = ± π (212) \oint d\mathbf{R}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}(\mathbf{R};L_g) = \pm\pi \tag*{(212)} ∮ d R ⋅ τ ( R ; L g ) = ± π (212)
On the other hand, Figure 4.5 depicts that the closed contour can be constructed by three components, 23 namely, one torsional (tor) and two radial (rad) lines and then, the contour integral can be written as:
Figure 4.5. For 1st combination of IREPs of the NACTs, the radial and torsional parts of a closed loop L g L_g L g enclosing a CI point in ( ρ , ϕ ) (\rho,\phi) ( ρ , ϕ ) plane are presented in upper panel ((a) and (b)). On the other hand, the same quantities for the 2nd combination are illustrated in lower panel ((c) and (d)). Figures are taken from Ref. [11].
∮ d R ⋅ τ ( R ; L g ) = I r a d , 1 + I t o r + I r a d , 2 = ± π , \oint d\mathbf{R}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}(\mathbf{R};L_g) = I_{\mathrm{rad},1}+I_{\mathrm{tor}}+I_{\mathrm{rad},2} = \pm\pi, ∮ d R ⋅ τ ( R ; L g ) = I rad , 1 + I tor + I rad , 2 = ± π ,
where
I r a d , 1 = ∫ 0 ρ 1 d ρ τ ρ ( ρ , ϕ 1 ; L g ) , I t o r = ∫ ϕ 1 ϕ 2 d ϕ τ ϕ ( ρ 1 , ϕ ; L g ) I_{\mathrm{rad},1} = \int_{0}^{\rho_1}d\rho\ \tau_\rho(\rho,\phi_1;L_g),\ I_{\mathrm{tor}} = \int_{\phi_1}^{\phi_2}d\phi\ \tau_\phi(\rho_1,\phi;L_g) I rad , 1 = ∫ 0 ρ 1 d ρ τ ρ ( ρ , ϕ 1 ; L g ) , I tor = ∫ ϕ 1 ϕ 2 d ϕ τ ϕ ( ρ 1 , ϕ ; L g )
and
I r a d , 2 = ∫ ρ 1 0 d ρ τ ρ ( ρ , ϕ 2 ; L g ) . I_{\mathrm{rad},2} = \int_{\rho_1}^{0}d\rho\ \tau_\rho(\rho,\phi_2;L_g). I rad , 2 = ∫ ρ 1 0 d ρ τ ρ ( ρ , ϕ 2 ; L g ) .
Figure 4.5 (a-Figure 4.5 b) show that for the first combination (τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_\rho\in A_1' τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′ , τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ ′ \tau_\phi\in A_1'' τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′′ , τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ ′ \tau_x, \tau_y \in E'' τ x , τ y ∈ E ′′ ), I r a d , 1 + I r a d , 2 = 0 I_{\mathrm{rad},1}+I_{\mathrm{rad},2}=0 I rad , 1 + I rad , 2 = 0 and I t o r = 0 I_{\mathrm{tor}}=0 I tor = 0 . On the contrary, for the second combination (τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ \tau_\phi\in A_1' τ ϕ ∈ A 1 ′ , τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′ ′ \tau_\rho\in A_1'' τ ρ ∈ A 1 ′′ and τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ \tau_x, \tau_y \in E' τ x , τ y ∈ E ′ ), the integral produces non-zero residue [see Figure 4.5 (c-Figure 4.5 d)]. Therefore, it is worth mentioning that only the second set of IREPs provides physically meaningful data.
Theorem 2: For a specific nuclear DOF (l l l ), if we are able to known or assume the IREP of a particular NACT within two electronic states (p p p and q q q ), τ l p q \tau_l^{pq} τ l pq , it is possible to speculate the IREP of another one (τ l q r \tau_l^{qr} τ l q r ) within two electronic states, q q q and r r r .
If we consider a loop-type sequence of N N N molecular states with same spin multiplicity, namely, N N N doublet states of Na3 _3 3 cluster, D a D_a D a , D b D_b D b , D c D_c D c ,..., D y D_y D y , D z = a D_{z=a} D z = a , multiplication of the NACTs (τ k a , b \tau_k^{a,b} τ k a , b , τ k b , c \tau_k^{b,c} τ k b , c , ..., τ k y , z = a \tau_k^{y,z=a} τ k y , z = a ) can be expressed as:
τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a = τ k a , b τ k b , c … τ k y , z = a , (213) \tau_k^{a,b,c,\ldots,y,z=a} = \tau_k^{a,b}\tau_k^{b,c}\ldots\tau_k^{y,z=a}, \tag*{(213)} τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a = τ k a , b τ k b , c … τ k y , z = a , (213)
where the associated IREPs are related as:
Γ ( τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a ) = Γ ( τ k a , b ) × Γ ( τ k b , c ) × … × Γ ( τ k y , z = a ) = Γ ( ξ a ) 2 × Γ ( ξ b ) 2 × … × Γ ( ξ y ) 2 × Γ ( ∂ ∂ R k ) N (214) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma\left(\tau_k^{a,b,c,\ldots,y,z=a}\right) &= \Gamma\left(\tau_k^{a,b}\right)\times\Gamma\left(\tau_k^{b,c}\right)\times\ldots\times\Gamma\left(\tau_k^{y,z=a}\right) \\
&= \Gamma(\xi_a)^2\times\Gamma(\xi_b)^2\times\ldots\times\Gamma(\xi_y)^2\times\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial R_k}\right)^N \tag*{(214)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a ) = Γ ( τ k a , b ) × Γ ( τ k b , c ) × … × Γ ( τ k y , z = a ) = Γ ( ξ a ) 2 × Γ ( ξ b ) 2 × … × Γ ( ξ y ) 2 × Γ ( ∂ R k ∂ ) N (214)
In case of 1D IREPs23, the above relation takes the following form:
Γ ( τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a ) = { Γ ( ∂ ∂ R k ) when N is odd A 1 ′ when N is even (215) \Gamma\left(\tau_k^{a,b,c,\ldots,y,z=a}\right)=
\begin{cases}
\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial R_k}\right) & \text{when } N \text{ is odd} \\
A_1' & \text{when } N \text{ is even}
\end{cases} \tag*{(215)} Γ ( τ k a , b , c , … , y , z = a ) = { Γ ( ∂ R k ∂ ) A 1 ′ when N is odd when N is even (215)
On the other hand, if a conical intersection (CI) point is present between two electronic states i i i and i + 1 i+1 i + 1 , the corresponding electronic wavefunctions change their signs while encapsulating that point. It is worth mentioning that those adiabatic wavefunctions and the NACTs, τ k i , j \tau_k^{i,j} τ k i , j and τ k ( i + 1 ) , j \tau_k^{(i+1),j} τ k ( i + 1 ) , j belong to same IREP (crossing-rule), which is given as,
Γ ( τ k i , j ) = Γ ( τ k ( i + 1 ) , j ) . (216) \Gamma\left(\tau_k^{i,j}\right)=\Gamma\left(\tau_k^{(i+1),j}\right). \tag*{(216)} Γ ( τ k i , j ) = Γ ( τ k ( i + 1 ) , j ) . (216)
For Na3 _3 3 cluster, the three electronic states, namely, 2 2 E ′ 2\,{}^2E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1\,{}^2A_1' 1 2 A 1 ′ are non-adiabatically coupled with each other, where multiple CIs can be observed within 2 2 E ′ 2\,{}^2E' 2 2 E ′ state. Hence, for such cluster, the second theorem appears as :
Γ ( τ k 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( τ k 12 ) × Γ ( τ k 23 ) × Γ ( τ k 31 ) = Γ ( τ k 12 ) × Γ ( τ k 23 ) 2 (217) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_k^{1,2,3,1}) &= \Gamma(\tau_k^{12}) \times\Gamma(\tau_k^{23}) \times\Gamma(\tau_k^{31}) \\
&= \Gamma(\tau_k^{12}) \times\Gamma(\tau_k^{23})^2 \tag*{(217)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ k 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( τ k 12 ) × Γ ( τ k 23 ) × Γ ( τ k 31 ) = Γ ( τ k 12 ) × Γ ( τ k 23 ) 2 (217)
with the aid of the conditions, Γ ( τ k 31 ) = Γ ( τ k 13 ) \Gamma(\tau_k^{31}) = \Gamma(\tau_k^{13}) Γ ( τ k 31 ) = Γ ( τ k 13 ) and Γ ( τ k 13 ) = Γ ( τ k 23 ) \Gamma(\tau_k^{13}) = \Gamma(\tau_k^{23}) Γ ( τ k 13 ) = Γ ( τ k 23 ) as per the crossing rule Eq. (216) . As per the second combination of Table 4.1 , it can be observed that Γ ( τ ρ 23 ) = A 1 ′ ′ \Gamma(\tau_\rho^{23}) = A_1^{\prime\prime} Γ ( τ ρ 23 ) = A 1 ′′ and Γ ( τ ϕ 23 ) = A 1 ′ \Gamma(\tau_\phi^{23}) = A_1^{\prime} Γ ( τ ϕ 23 ) = A 1 ′ . Hence, by employing Eqs. (215) and (217) , the IREPs of τ ρ 12 \tau_\rho^{12} τ ρ 12 and τ ϕ 12 \tau_\phi^{12} τ ϕ 12 are given by,
Γ ( τ ρ 12 ) × ( A 1 ′ ′ ) 2 = Γ ( ∂ ∂ ρ ) = A 2 ′ ′ ⇒ Γ ( τ ρ 12 ) = A 2 ′ ′ (218) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_\rho^{12}) \times(A_1^{\prime\prime})^2 = \Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}\right) = A_2^{\prime\prime} \\
&\Rightarrow\Gamma(\tau_\rho^{12}) = A_2^{\prime\prime} \tag*{(218)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ ρ 12 ) × ( A 1 ′′ ) 2 = Γ ( ∂ ρ ∂ ) = A 2 ′′ ⇒ Γ ( τ ρ 12 ) = A 2 ′′ (218)
and
Γ ( τ ϕ 12 ) × ( A 1 ′ ) 2 = Γ ( ∂ ∂ ϕ ) = A 2 ′ ⇒ Γ ( τ ϕ 12 ) = A 2 ′ (219) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_\phi^{12}) \times(A_1^{\prime})^2 = \Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\phi}\right) = A_2^{\prime} \\
&\Rightarrow\Gamma(\tau_\phi^{12}) = A_2^{\prime} \tag*{(219)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ ϕ 12 ) × ( A 1 ′ ) 2 = Γ ( ∂ ϕ ∂ ) = A 2 ′ ⇒ Γ ( τ ϕ 12 ) = A 2 ′ (219)
On the other hand, for 2D IREPs, the following relation can be obtained for Γ ( τ x 23 ) \Gamma(\tau_x^{23}) Γ ( τ x 23 ) :¹¹
Γ ( τ x 23 ) = Γ ( ⟨ ξ 2 ∣ ∂ ξ 3 ∂ x ⟩ ) ⇒ Γ ( τ x 23 ) = Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ∂ ∂ x ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) ⇒ E ′ = Γ ( ξ 2 ) × E ′ × Γ ( ξ 3 ) . (220) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_x^{23}) &= \Gamma\left(\left\langle\xi_2 \left|\frac{\partial\xi_3}{\partial x}\right.\right\rangle\right) \\
\Rightarrow\Gamma(\tau_x^{23}) &= \Gamma(\xi_2) \times\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\right) \times\Gamma(\xi_3) \\
\Rightarrow E' &= \Gamma(\xi_2) \times E' \times\Gamma(\xi_3). \tag*{(220)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ x 23 ) ⇒ Γ ( τ x 23 ) ⇒ E ′ = Γ ( ⟨ ξ 2 ∂ x ∂ ξ 3 ⟩ ) = Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ∂ x ∂ ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = Γ ( ξ 2 ) × E ′ × Γ ( ξ 3 ) . (220)
Therefore, Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′ \Gamma(\xi_2) \times\Gamma(\xi_3) = A_1^{\prime} Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′
Γ ( ξ 1 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′ . (221) \Gamma(\xi_1) \times\Gamma(\xi_3) = A_1^{\prime}. \tag*{(221)} Γ ( ξ 1 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′ . (221)
In a similar way, one can write for Γ ( τ x 13 ) \Gamma(\tau_x^{13}) Γ ( τ x 13 ) ,
The above expressions (Eqs 4.132b and 4.132c) imply that,
Γ ( ξ 1 ) × Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′ . (222) \Gamma(\xi_1) \times\Gamma(\xi_2) \times\Gamma(\xi_3) = A'_1. \tag*{(222)} Γ ( ξ 1 ) × Γ ( ξ 2 ) × Γ ( ξ 3 ) = A 1 ′ . (222)
Finally, with the help of Eqs 4.126 and 4.133, we arrive at the following relation for the Na3 _3 3 case:
Γ ( τ x 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( ξ 1 ) 2 × Γ ( ξ 2 ) 2 × Γ ( ξ 3 ) 2 × Γ ( ∂ ∂ x ) 3 = A 1 ′ × Γ ( ∂ ∂ x ) 3 = Γ ( ∂ ∂ x ) 3 = ( E ′ ) 3 (223) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_x^{1,2,3,1}) &= \Gamma(\xi_1)^2 \times\Gamma(\xi_2)^2 \times\Gamma(\xi_3)^2 \times\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\right)^3 \\
&= A'_1 \times\Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\right)^3 = \Gamma\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\right)^3 = (E')^3 \tag*{(223)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ x 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( ξ 1 ) 2 × Γ ( ξ 2 ) 2 × Γ ( ξ 3 ) 2 × Γ ( ∂ x ∂ ) 3 = A 1 ′ × Γ ( ∂ x ∂ ) 3 = Γ ( ∂ x ∂ ) 3 = ( E ′ ) 3 (223)
On the other hand, we can write from Table 4.1 and Eq. (217) ,
Γ ( τ x 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( τ x 12 ) × Γ ( τ x 23 ) 2 = Γ ( τ x 12 ) × ( E ′ ) 2 (224) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma(\tau_x^{1,2,3,1}) &= \Gamma(\tau_x^{12}) \times\Gamma(\tau_x^{23})^2 \\
&= \Gamma(\tau_x^{12}) \times(E')^2 \tag*{(224)}
\end{aligned} Γ ( τ x 1 , 2 , 3 , 1 ) = Γ ( τ x 12 ) × Γ ( τ x 23 ) 2 = Γ ( τ x 12 ) × ( E ′ ) 2 (224)
and then, by comparing Eqs. 4.134 and 4.135, we come across Γ ( τ x 12 ) = E ′ \Gamma(\tau_x^{12}) = E' Γ ( τ x 12 ) = E ′ as well as Γ ( τ y 12 ) = E ′ \Gamma(\tau_y^{12}) = E' Γ ( τ y 12 ) = E ′ . The IREPs for all kind of NACTs for Na3 _3 3 cluster11,26 are presented in Table 4.2 .
Table 4.2. Extended character table of molecular symmetry group D 3 h ( M ) D_{3h}(M) D 3 h ( M ) is presented with different NAC elements.11
Extended Born-Oppenheimer Theory for Abelian and Non-abelian Cases
The single-surface extended Born-Oppenheimer (EBO) equation is formulated to capture the effects of other electronic states on a specific one through nonadiabatic couplings. Such formulation is useful to explore the nature of nonadiabatic coupling contributing on a specific state at sufficiently low energy process.
EBO formalism presents an intermediate representation between adiabatic and diabatic ones, which includes the contribution of nonadiabatic effects originated from other electronic states on a specific single-surface equation. While formulating such equation, one needs to incorporate the effect of off-diagonal elements of τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ matrix on the diagonal and then, classical inaccessibility condition for a specific state from others can be invoked considering the molecular process occurring at and around a particular energy. It is worth mentioning that such a concept is applicable only when τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ can be expressed as the product of a vector function with an antisymmetric scalar matrix. In other words, two different components of NACM commute with each other, curl τ ⃗ = 0 ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau} = \vec{0} curl τ = 0 , which is true for two coupled electronic states (Abelian case). On the other hand, for non-Abelian situation (three or higher dimensional sub-Hilbert spaces), curl τ ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau} curl τ acquires non-zero values, which demands the necessity of an approximation to express the NACM in product form. The parametric representation of a vector equation of a conical surface at the close vicinity of CI point(s) is employed and hence, the determinant (Jacobian) for coordinate transformation (let say, between Cartesian and polar) appears as zero (0) at the close vicinity of those point(s). As a matter of fact, curl τ ⃗ ≃ 0 ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau} \simeq\vec{0} curl τ ≃ 0 turns into zero (0) around a degenerate point for non-Abelian cases. 17,18 A transformation matrix, G (ψ = G χ \psi= G\chi ψ = G χ ) should exist, which diagonalizes the product form of antisymmetric vector matrix (τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ ) with eigenvalues i ω ⃗ i\vec{\omega} i ω and accordingly, the nuclear SE in Eq. (146) can be written as,
[ − 1 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n + Ω ⃗ ) 2 + V − E ] χ = 0 , (225) \left[-\frac{1}{2}\left(\vec{\nabla}_{n}+\vec{\Omega}\right)^{2}+\mathbf{V}-E\right]\chi=0, \tag*{(225)} [ − 2 1 ( ∇ n + Ω ) 2 + V − E ] χ = 0 , (225)
where Ω ⃗ = i ω ⃗ = G ∗ τ ⃗ G \vec{\Omega}=i\vec{\omega}=G^{*}\vec{\tau}G Ω = i ω = G ∗ τ G and V = G ∗ U G \mathbf{V}=G^{*}\mathbf{U}G V = G ∗ U G . It is important to note that the derivation of ω ⃗ \vec{\omega} ω can be achieved only when the calculated angular component of ω ⃗ \vec{\omega} ω obeys the relationship of gauge invariance (GI) as follows,
∫ 0 2 π ω ϕ d ϕ = n π . (226) \int_{0}^{2\pi}\omega_{\phi}d\phi=n\pi. \tag*{(226)} ∫ 0 2 π ω ϕ d ϕ = nπ . (226)
If G slowly varies with respect to nuclear coordinates, it commutes with ∇ ⃗ n \vec{\nabla}_{n} ∇ n . On the other hand, V appears as a full matrix possessing both diagonal and off-diagonal terms. As per BO approximation, other electronic states can be considered as classically forbidden due to the width of a specific energy and hence, their contribution in the total wavefunction can be taken as negligibly small i.e., ∣ ψ i ∣ ≫ ∣ ψ j ∣ |\psi_i| \gg|\psi_j| ∣ ψ i ∣ ≫ ∣ ψ j ∣ , where j ≠ i j \ne i j = i , but i , j ∈ N i,j \in N i , j ∈ N . While invoking this approximation, V χ V\chi V χ in Eq. (225) can be written as,
( V χ ) i = { ( G ∗ U G ) ( G ∗ Ψ ) } i = ∑ j = 1 N G i j ∗ u j ψ j = u i χ i − u i ∑ j = 1 j ≠ i N G i j ∗ ψ j + ∑ j = 1 j ≠ i N G i j ∗ u j ψ j = u i χ i + ∑ j = 1 j ≠ i N G i j ∗ ( u j − u i ) ψ j . (227) \begin{aligned}
(V\chi)_i &= \{(G^{*}UG)(G^{*}\Psi)\}_i \\
&= \sum_{j=1}^{N}G_{ij}^{*}u_j\psi_j \\
&= u_i\chi_i-u_i\sum_{\substack{j=1\\j\ne i}}^{N}G_{ij}^{*}\psi_j+\sum_{\substack{j=1\\j\ne i}}^{N}G_{ij}^{*}u_j\psi_j \\
&= u_i\chi_i+\sum_{\substack{j=1\\j\ne i}}^{N}G_{ij}^{*}(u_j-u_i)\psi_j. \tag*{(227)}
\end{aligned} ( V χ ) i = {( G ∗ U G ) ( G ∗ Ψ ) } i = j = 1 ∑ N G ij ∗ u j ψ j = u i χ i − u i j = 1 j = i ∑ N G ij ∗ ψ j + j = 1 j = i ∑ N G ij ∗ u j ψ j = u i χ i + j = 1 j = i ∑ N G ij ∗ ( u j − u i ) ψ j . (227)
In Eq. (227) , the first term symbolizes product of the i t h i^{\mathrm{th}} i th state adiabatic PES with the wavefunction, χ i \chi_i χ i , while the rest of the summation provides a negligible contribution appearing from other states at a specific energy. For a two-dimensional sub-Hilbert space, this summation is exactly zero (0) [u 1 = u 2 u_1=u_2 u 1 = u 2 ] at a degenerate point and the EBO equations are completely decoupled. Even for three state degeneracy at a single point [u 1 = u 2 = u 3 u_1=u_2=u_3 u 1 = u 2 = u 3 ], the above summation is identically zero. In any case, one can approximate the second term of Eq. (227) considering the molecular process at a specific energy and the EBO equation can be written as:
− 1 2 ( ∇ ⃗ n + i ω ⃗ i ) 2 χ i + ( u i − E ) χ i = 0 , i = 1 , 2 , … , N (228) -\frac{1}{2}\left(\vec{\nabla}_{n}+i\vec{\omega}_{i}\right)^{2}\chi_i+(u_i-E)\chi_i=0,\quad i=1,2,\ldots,N \tag*{(228)} − 2 1 ( ∇ n + i ω i ) 2 χ i + ( u i − E ) χ i = 0 , i = 1 , 2 , … , N (228)
EBO treatment decouples SEs of ‘N N N ’ number of nuclear wavefunctions, χ \chi χ s to formulate ‘N N N ’ independent nuclear SEs.
For two electronic state sub-Hilbert space, components of τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ commute with each other (Abelian case) and hence, τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ can be written as a product of a vector function and an antisymmetric scalar matrix. Therefore, one can formulate the EBO equations in terms of the eigenvalues of NACM (± i τ ⃗ 12 \pm i\vec{\tau}_{12} ± i τ 12 ) by imposing the classical inaccessibility of the other electronic state beyond the width of a specific energy.
For non-Abelian cases, the determinant for the transformation between coordinates (as for example, Cartesian and polar), namely, the Jacobian turns into zero (0) at the CI point(s) considering parametric representation of a vector equation for a conical surface. Thereby, one may approximate curl τ ⃗ ≃ 0 ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau}\simeq\vec{0} curl τ ≃ 0 at and around those point(s) for sub-Hilbert spaces, N ≥ 3 N\geq3 N ≥ 3 17,18 and it is possible to derive the corresponding EBO equations.
For multiple electronic states (N ≥ 3 N \ge3 N ≥ 3 ), 17,18 the following conditions need to be checked: (a) when CIs are at the same point of nuclear CS and intensely coupled through singular functions of NACTs, the GI condition should be perfectly fulfilled; (b) if CIs are at different nuclear CS, substantially apart from each other and almost decoupled due to specific NACM element(s) with small magnitudes, the corresponding eigenvalues of NACM show gauge invariance; (c) when the CIs are not at the same position, but close to each other and substantially coupled through singular functions of NACTs, the required GI condition is difficult to attain for the formulation of EBO equations.
While exploring the validity of EBO equation, it is necessary to study the fulfillment of three conditions, namely, curl τ ⃗ ≃ 0 ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau} \simeq\vec{0} curl τ ≃ 0 at and around CI(s), the GI of the eigenvalues of NACM (Ω ⃗ i = i ω ⃗ i \vec{\Omega}_i=i\vec{\omega}_i Ω i = i ω i ) and the classical inaccessibility of a state from other states for a process occurring at specific energy, among which the first two appear as complementary with each other. As representative examples, we demonstrated the applicability of such EBO formalism (for non-Abelian systems) for two realistic molecular Hamiltonian namely, NO3 _3 3 radical and 1,3,5-trifluorobenzene radical cation (TFBz+ ^+ + ) by computing curl τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ as functions of pairwise normal modes and the GI for the eigenvalues (Ω ⃗ i = i ω ⃗ i \vec{\Omega}_i=i\vec{\omega}_i Ω i = i ω i ) of the NACM over the chosen domain of nuclear plane.
Two Electronic State Sub-Hilbert Space: Abelian Case
For a two coupled electronic manifold, the 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 antisymmetric square matrix, τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ takes the following form,
τ ⃗ = ( 0 τ ⃗ 12 − τ ⃗ 12 0 ) = τ ⃗ 12 ( 0 1 − 1 0 ) . (229) \vec{\tau} =
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & \vec{\tau}_{12} \\
-\vec{\tau}_{12} & 0
\end{pmatrix}
= \vec{\tau}_{12}
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & 1 \\
-1 & 0
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(229)} τ = ( 0 − τ 12 τ 12 0 ) = τ 12 ( 0 − 1 1 0 ) . (229)
with curl τ ⃗ = 0 ⃗ \operatorname{curl}\vec{\tau}=\vec{0} curl τ = 0 for any arbitrary pair of nuclear geometry (Abelian case). In other words, τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ can be expressed as a product of a vector function and an antisymmetric scalar matrix. As a consequence, the EBO equations (Eq. (228) ) can be formulated by computing the eigenvalues of NACM (± i ω ⃗ i \pm i\vec{\omega}_i ± i ω i ) followed by imposition of the classical inaccessibility of the other electronic states beyond the width of a specific energy.
Three Electronic State Sub-Hilbert Space: Non-Abelian Case
For three state sub-Hilbert space, the expressions of elements of NACM (τ ⃗ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ \vec{\tau}_{ij}=\langle\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_j\rangle τ ij = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ ) takes the following forms in terms of ADT angles (see Eq. (201) ),
τ ⃗ 12 = − cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 ∇ ⃗ n Θ 12 − sin Θ 23 ∇ ⃗ n Θ 13 (230) \vec{\tau}_{12}=-\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{12}-\sin\Theta_{23}\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{13} \tag*{(230)} τ 12 = − cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 ∇ n Θ 12 − sin Θ 23 ∇ n Θ 13 (230)
τ ⃗ 13 = cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 ∇ ⃗ n Θ 12 − cos Θ 23 ∇ ⃗ n Θ 13 (231) \vec{\tau}_{13}=\cos\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{23}\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{12}-\cos\Theta_{23}\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{13} \tag*{(231)} τ 13 = cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 ∇ n Θ 12 − cos Θ 23 ∇ n Θ 13 (231)
τ ⃗ 23 = − sin Θ 13 ∇ ⃗ n Θ 12 − ∇ ⃗ n Θ 23 (232) \vec{\tau}_{23}=-\sin\Theta_{13}\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{12}-\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{23} \tag*{(232)} τ 23 = − sin Θ 13 ∇ n Θ 12 − ∇ n Θ 23 (232)
where the explicit forms of curl τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ appear as (see Eq. (203) ):
curl τ 12 p q = ( ∇ ⃗ n × τ ⃗ 12 ) ⊥ = sin Θ 13 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) (233) \operatorname{curl}\tau_{12}^{pq}=(\vec{\nabla}_n\times\vec{\tau}_{12})_{\perp}
=\sin\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{13}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{13})
+\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{13}(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{23})
-\cos\Theta_{23}(\nabla_p\Theta_{13}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{13}\nabla_p\Theta_{23}) \tag*{(233)} curl τ 12 pq = ( ∇ n × τ 12 ) ⊥ = sin Θ 13 cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) (233)
curl τ 13 p q = ( ∇ ⃗ n × τ ⃗ 13 ) ⊥ = − sin Θ 13 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 23 cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) (234) \operatorname{curl}\tau_{13}^{pq}=(\vec{\nabla}_n\times\vec{\tau}_{13})_{\perp}
=-\sin\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{23}(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{13}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{13})
+\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{13}(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{23})
+\sin\Theta_{23}(\nabla_p\Theta_{13}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{13}\nabla_p\Theta_{23}) \tag*{(234)} curl τ 13 pq = ( ∇ n × τ 13 ) ⊥ = − sin Θ 13 sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 23 cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) (234)
curl τ 23 p q = ( ∇ ⃗ n × τ ⃗ 23 ) ⊥ = − cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) , (235) \operatorname{curl}\tau_{23}^{pq}=(\vec{\nabla}_n\times\vec{\tau}_{23})_{\perp}
=-\cos\Theta_{13}(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{13}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{13}), \tag*{(235)} curl τ 23 pq = ( ∇ n × τ 23 ) ⊥ = − cos Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) , (235)
considering p p p and q q q as two Cartesian coordinates.
Using the parametric representation of a vector equation of a surface containing CI point(s), the transformation determinant between coordinates (as for example, Cartesian and polar), namely, the Jacobian attains the zero (0) value at those point(s) and hence, the equations for curl τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ become null vector (0 ⃗ \vec{0} 0 ) at the close vicinity of those point(s) for non-Abelian sub-Hilbert spaces, N ≥ 3 N \ge3 N ≥ 3 . 17,18 If curl τ i j p q \tau_{ij}^{pq} τ ij pq can be approximately equated to zero at the neighborhood of CI point(s), one can write the following relations of the ADT angles using Eq. 4.142:
( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 12 ) and ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 23 ∇ q Θ 12 ) , (236) \left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)=\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right)
\quad\text{and}\quad
\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)=\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right), \tag*{(236)} ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 ) and ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 ) , (236)
which lead to the following product form of NACM, i.e., Eq. 4.141 can be expressed as,
τ ⃗ = ∇ ⃗ n Θ 12 ( 0 − sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 12 ) − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 12 ) − cos Θ 23 0 − sin Θ 13 − ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) cos Θ 23 sin Θ 13 + ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) 0 ) (237) \vec{\tau}=\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{12}
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & -\sin\Theta_{23}\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right) & -\cos\Theta_{23}\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)\\
-\cos\Theta_{23} & 0 & -\sin\Theta_{13}-\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)\\
\cos\Theta_{23} & \sin\Theta_{13}+\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right) & 0
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(237)} τ = ∇ n Θ 12 0 − cos Θ 23 cos Θ 23 − sin Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) 0 sin Θ 13 + ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) − cos Θ 23 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) − sin Θ 13 − ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) 0 (237)
It is important to note that the eigenvalues are − i ω ⃗ -i\vec{\omega} − i ω , 0 ⃗ \vec{0} 0 and i ω ⃗ i\vec{\omega} i ω , where
ω ⃗ = ∇ ⃗ n Θ 12 [ 1 + ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 12 ) 2 + ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) 2 + 2 sin Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) ] 1 / 2 . (238) \vec{\omega}=\vec{\nabla}_n\Theta_{12}\left[1+\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+2\sin\Theta_{13}\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)\right]^{1/2}. \tag*{(238)} ω = ∇ n Θ 12 [ 1 + ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) 2 + ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) 2 + 2 sin Θ 13 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) ] 1/2 . (238)
Foursarkarjpca112 Electronic State Sub-Hilbert Space
In case of four coupled electronic manifold, one representative element of NACM (τ ⃗ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ ⃗ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ \vec{\tau}_{ij}=\langle\xi_i|\vec{\nabla}_n|\xi_j\rangle τ ij = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ n ∣ ξ j ⟩ ) can be written as functions of ADT angles as follows,
τ ⃗ 12 = − cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ∇ ⃗ Θ 12 − sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ∇ ⃗ Θ 13 − sin Θ 24 ∇ ⃗ Θ 14 , (239) \vec{\tau}_{12}=-\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\vec{\nabla}\Theta_{12}-\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\vec{\nabla}\Theta_{13}-\sin\Theta_{24}\vec{\nabla}\Theta_{14}, \tag*{(239)} τ 12 = − cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ∇ Θ 12 − sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ∇ Θ 13 − sin Θ 24 ∇ Θ 14 , (239)
and the associated “curl” equation takes the following forms,
curl τ 12 p q = sin Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 14 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 14 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 24 ) − cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 14 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 14 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 24 ) − cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 14 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 14 ∇ p Θ 24 ) . (240) \begin{aligned}
\operatorname{curl}\tau_{12}^{pq}
={}&\sin\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{13}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{13})\\
&+\cos\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{23})\\
&+\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{14}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{14})\\
&+\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\sin\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{12}\nabla_q\Theta_{24}-\nabla_q\Theta_{12}\nabla_p\Theta_{24})\\
&-\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{13}\nabla_q\Theta_{23}-\nabla_q\Theta_{13}\nabla_p\Theta_{23})\\
&+\sin\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{13}\nabla_q\Theta_{14}-\nabla_q\Theta_{13}\nabla_p\Theta_{14})\\
&+\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\sin\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{13}\nabla_q\Theta_{24}-\nabla_q\Theta_{13}\nabla_p\Theta_{24})\\
&-\cos\Theta_{24}
(\nabla_p\Theta_{14}\nabla_q\Theta_{24}-\nabla_q\Theta_{14}\nabla_p\Theta_{24}). \tag*{(240)}
\end{aligned} curl τ 12 pq = sin Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) + cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 14 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 14 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 24 ) − cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 23 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 23 ) + sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 14 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 14 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 24 ) − cos Θ 24 ( ∇ p Θ 14 ∇ q Θ 24 − ∇ q Θ 14 ∇ p Θ 24 ) . (240)
On the other hand, based on the parametric representation of vector function for a conical surface and zero (0) value of the Jacobian, the following identities are valid at the CI point(s) as per the Eq. (240) :
( ∇ p Θ 13 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 13 ∇ q Θ 12 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 14 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 14 ∇ q Θ 12 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 23 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 23 ∇ q Θ 12 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 24 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 24 ∇ q Θ 12 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 34 ∇ p Θ 12 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 34 ∇ q Θ 12 ) (241) \left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)
=
\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right),
\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{14}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)
=
\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{14}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right),
\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)
=
\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right),
\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)
=
\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right),
\left(\frac{\nabla_p\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_p\Theta_{12}}\right)
=
\left(\frac{\nabla_q\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_q\Theta_{12}}\right) \tag*{(241)} ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 13 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 13 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 14 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 14 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 23 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 23 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 24 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 24 ) , ( ∇ p Θ 12 ∇ p Θ 34 ) = ( ∇ q Θ 12 ∇ q Θ 34 ) (241)
It is interesting to note that the vector matrix, τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ can be partitioned into a product form with a vector function and a scalar matrix, which provides eigenvalues for a four dimensional SHS to formulate the EBO equation:
ω i = ± K 2 ± 1 2 K 2 − 4 L 2 , (242) \omega_i = \pm\sqrt{\frac{K}{2} \pm\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{K^2-4L^2}}, \tag*{(242)} ω i = ± 2 K ± 2 1 K 2 − 4 L 2 , (242)
K = τ ⃗ 12 ⋅ τ ⃗ 12 + τ ⃗ 13 ⋅ τ ⃗ 13 + τ ⃗ 23 ⋅ τ ⃗ 23 + τ ⃗ 14 ⋅ τ ⃗ 14 + τ ⃗ 24 ⋅ τ ⃗ 24 + τ ⃗ 34 ⋅ τ ⃗ 34 = ∇ ⃗ Θ 12 ⋅ ∇ ⃗ Θ 12 { 1 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 13 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 14 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) 2 + 2 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 13 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + 2 sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 13 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + 2 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + 2 sin Θ 13 ( ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + 2 cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + 2 ( sin Θ 13 sin Θ 24 − cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) } (243) \begin{aligned}
K \; =\;& \vec{\tau}_{12}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{12}+\vec{\tau}_{13}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{13}+\vec{\tau}_{23}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{23}+\vec{\tau}_{14}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{14}+\vec{\tau}_{24}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{24}+\vec{\tau}_{34}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{34}\\
=\;& \vec{\nabla}\Theta_{12}\cdot\vec{\nabla}\Theta_{12}\left\{1+\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{14}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)^2\right.\\
&\left.+2\cos\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+2\sin\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right.\\
&\left.+2\sin\Theta_{24}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+2\sin\Theta_{13}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+2\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right.\\
&\left.+2\left(\sin\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{24}-\cos\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{23}\sin\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right\} \tag*{(243)}
\end{aligned} K = = τ 12 ⋅ τ 12 + τ 13 ⋅ τ 13 + τ 23 ⋅ τ 23 + τ 14 ⋅ τ 14 + τ 24 ⋅ τ 24 + τ 34 ⋅ τ 34 ∇ Θ 12 ⋅ ∇ Θ 12 { 1 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 14 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) 2 + ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) 2 + 2 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) + 2 sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) + 2 sin Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) + 2 sin Θ 13 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 ) + 2 cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 sin Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) + 2 ( sin Θ 13 sin Θ 24 − cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 sin Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) } (243)
and
L = τ ⃗ 14 ⋅ τ ⃗ 23 − τ ⃗ 13 ⋅ τ ⃗ 24 + τ ⃗ 12 ⋅ τ ⃗ 34 = ∇ ⃗ Θ 12 ⋅ ∇ ⃗ Θ 12 { ( ∇ ρ Θ 23 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + sin Θ 13 ( ∇ ρ Θ 14 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) − cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 13 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 24 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 13 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) + sin Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 14 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 34 ∇ ρ Θ 12 ) } (244) \begin{aligned}
L \; =\;& \vec{\tau}_{14}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{23}-\vec{\tau}_{13}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{24}+\vec{\tau}_{12}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{34}\\
=\;& \vec{\nabla}\Theta_{12}\cdot\vec{\nabla}\Theta_{12}\left\{\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{23}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+\sin\Theta_{13}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{14}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+\cos\Theta_{13}\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right.\\
&\left.-\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{24}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+\cos\Theta_{13}\cos\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right.\\
&\left.+\sin\Theta_{23}\cos\Theta_{14}\cos\Theta_{24}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{13}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)+\sin\Theta_{24}\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{14}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\left(\frac{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{34}}{\nabla_{\rho}\Theta_{12}}\right)\right\} \tag*{(244)}
\end{aligned} L = = τ 14 ⋅ τ 23 − τ 13 ⋅ τ 24 + τ 12 ⋅ τ 34 ∇ Θ 12 ⋅ ∇ Θ 12 { ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 23 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) + sin Θ 13 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 14 ) + cos Θ 13 sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) − cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 24 ) + cos Θ 13 cos Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) + sin Θ 23 cos Θ 14 cos Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 13 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) + sin Θ 24 ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 14 ) ( ∇ ρ Θ 12 ∇ ρ Θ 34 ) } (244)
The workability of EBO formalism for a tri-state system has been explored using the model diabatic Hamiltonian for Na3 _3 3 cluster proposed by Cocchini et al. 27 Such system exhibits profound nonadiabatic couplings within 2 E ′ ^2E' 2 E ′ and 1 A 1 ′ ^1A'_1 1 A 1 ′ states over the ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ nuclear plane constituted with bending (Q x Q_x Q x ) and asymmetric stretching (Q y Q_y Q y ) modes. The model diabatic Hamiltonian is represented as:27
V d i a ( ρ , ϕ ) = ( ρ 2 2 + U 2 U 1 W 1 − W 2 U 1 ρ 2 2 − U 2 W 1 + W 2 W 1 − W 2 W 1 + W 2 ϵ 0 + ρ 2 2 ) (245) V^{\mathrm{dia}}(\rho,\phi)=
\begin{pmatrix}
\frac{\rho^2}{2}+U_2 & U_1 & W_1-W_2\\
U_1 & \frac{\rho^2}{2}-U_2 & W_1+W_2\\
W_1-W_2 & W_1+W_2 & \epsilon_0+\frac{\rho^2}{2}
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(245)} V dia ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 ρ 2 + U 2 U 1 W 1 − W 2 U 1 2 ρ 2 − U 2 W 1 + W 2 W 1 − W 2 W 1 + W 2 ϵ 0 + 2 ρ 2 (245)
where
U 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = K ρ cos ϕ + 1 2 g ρ 2 cos ( 2 ϕ ) U 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = K ρ sin ϕ − 1 2 g ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ ) W 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = P ρ cos ϕ + 1 2 f ρ 2 cos ( 2 ϕ ) W 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = P ρ sin ϕ − 1 2 f ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ ) \begin{aligned}
U_1(\rho,\phi)&=K\rho\cos\phi+\frac{1}{2}g\rho^2\cos(2\phi)\\
U_2(\rho,\phi)&=K\rho\sin\phi-\frac{1}{2}g\rho^2\sin(2\phi)
\end{aligned}
\qquad
\begin{aligned}
W_1(\rho,\phi)&=P\rho\cos\phi+\frac{1}{2}f\rho^2\cos(2\phi)\\
W_2(\rho,\phi)&=P\rho\sin\phi-\frac{1}{2}f\rho^2\sin(2\phi)
\end{aligned} U 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) U 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = K ρ cos ϕ + 2 1 g ρ 2 cos ( 2 ϕ ) = K ρ sin ϕ − 2 1 g ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ ) W 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) W 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = P ρ cos ϕ + 2 1 f ρ 2 cos ( 2 ϕ ) = P ρ sin ϕ − 2 1 f ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ )
It is important to note that JT coupling constants [ K [K [ K (= 4.9) and g g g (= 0.035)] ] ] 27 and PJT coupling parameters [ P [P [ P (= 3.46) and f f f (= 0.025)] ] ] 27 of the above expressions appear as dimensionless, since the nuclear coordinates are dimensionless. On the other hand, the energy separation (Δ \Delta Δ ) between second and third states modulates the adjustable parameter, ϵ 0 \epsilon_0 ϵ 0 (= 2 Δ 2\Delta 2Δ ).
In presence of only JT interaction (P = f = 0 P=f=0 P = f = 0 , no PJT couplings), the 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 model Hamiltonian reduces to a 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 block matrix as follows:
V d i a ( ρ , ϕ ) = ( ρ 2 2 + U 2 U 1 0 U 1 ρ 2 2 − U 2 0 0 0 ϵ 0 + ρ 2 2 ) (246) V^{\mathrm{dia}}(\rho,\phi)=\begin{pmatrix}
\frac{\rho^{2}}{2}+U_{2} & U_{1} & 0 \\
U_{1} & \frac{\rho^{2}}{2}-U_{2} & 0 \\
0 & 0 & \epsilon_{0}+\frac{\rho^{2}}{2}
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(246)} V dia ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 ρ 2 + U 2 U 1 0 U 1 2 ρ 2 − U 2 0 0 0 ϵ 0 + 2 ρ 2 (246)
and accordingly, the adiabatic PESs take the following form:
u 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = ρ 2 2 − K 2 ρ 2 + g 2 ρ 4 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) (247) u_{1}(\rho,\phi)=\frac{\rho^{2}}{2}-\sqrt{K^{2}\rho^{2}+\frac{g^{2}\rho^{4}}{4}+K g\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi)} \tag*{(247)} u 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 ρ 2 − K 2 ρ 2 + 4 g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) (247)
u 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = ρ 2 2 + K 2 ρ 2 + g 2 ρ 4 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) (248) u_{2}(\rho,\phi)=\frac{\rho^{2}}{2}+\sqrt{K^{2}\rho^{2}+\frac{g^{2}\rho^{4}}{4}+K g\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi)} \tag*{(248)} u 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 ρ 2 + K 2 ρ 2 + 4 g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) (248)
The 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 diabatic Hamiltonian leads to the following explicit expressions of ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs:
τ ρ 12 = − K g ρ 2 4 ν 2 sin ( 3 ϕ ) (249) \tau_{\rho}^{12}=-\frac{K g\rho^{2}}{4\nu^{2}}\sin(3\phi) \tag*{(249)} τ ρ 12 = − 4 ν 2 K g ρ 2 sin ( 3 ϕ ) (249)
τ ϕ 12 = − − 2 K 2 ρ 2 + g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) 4 ν 2 (250) \tau_{\phi}^{12}=-\frac{-2K^{2}\rho^{2}+g^{2}\rho^{4}+K g\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi)}{4\nu^{2}} \tag*{(250)} τ ϕ 12 = − 4 ν 2 − 2 K 2 ρ 2 + g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) (250)
With the above form of the NAC matrices, the curl appears identically zero, i.e. curl τ = 0 \operatorname{curl}\boldsymbol{\tau}=0 curl τ = 0 as [ ( τ ρ τ ϕ ) 12 − ( τ ϕ τ ρ ) 12 ] = 0 [(\tau^{\rho}\tau^{\phi})_{12}-(\tau^{\phi}\tau^{\rho})_{12}]=0 [( τ ρ τ ϕ ) 12 − ( τ ϕ τ ρ ) 12 ] = 0 , where the corresponding ADT matrix takes the following form:
A = ( ν + U 2 2 ν − ν − U 2 2 ν ν − U 2 2 ν ν + U 2 2 ν ) (251) A=\begin{pmatrix}
\sqrt{\frac{\nu+U_{2}}{2\nu}} & -\sqrt{\frac{\nu-U_{2}}{2\nu}} \\
\sqrt{\frac{\nu-U_{2}}{2\nu}} & \sqrt{\frac{\nu+U_{2}}{2\nu}}
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(251)} A = 2 ν ν + U 2 2 ν ν − U 2 − 2 ν ν − U 2 2 ν ν + U 2 (251)
with ν = ( K 2 ρ 2 + 1 4 g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) 1 / 2 \nu=(K^{2}\rho^{2}+\frac{1}{4}g^{2}\rho^{4}+K g\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi))^{1/2} ν = ( K 2 ρ 2 + 4 1 g 2 ρ 4 + K g ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) ) 1/2 and U 2 = K ρ sin ϕ − 1 2 g ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ ) U_{2}=K\rho\sin\phi-\frac{1}{2}g\rho^{2}\sin(2\phi) U 2 = K ρ sin ϕ − 2 1 g ρ 2 sin ( 2 ϕ ) .
On the other hand, for PJT situation (K = g = 0 K=g=0 K = g = 0 , no JT couplings), the diabatic Hamiltonian (Eq. (245) ) leads to the following analytic expressions of ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs:
τ ρ 12 = − A 0 2 w B − , τ ρ 13 = − A 0 2 w B + , τ ρ 23 = A 1 Δ 2 2 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) (252) \tau_{\rho}^{12}=-\frac{A_{0}}{\sqrt{2wB_{-}}},\qquad\tau_{\rho}^{13}=-\frac{A_{0}}{\sqrt{2wB_{+}}},\qquad\tau_{\rho}^{23}=\frac{A_{1}\Delta}{2\sqrt{2}w(\Delta^{2}+2w)} \tag*{(252)} τ ρ 12 = − 2 w B − A 0 , τ ρ 13 = − 2 w B + A 0 , τ ρ 23 = 2 2 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) A 1 Δ (252)
τ ϕ 12 = A 2 2 w B − , τ ϕ 13 = A 2 2 w B + , τ ϕ 23 = − 3 ρ A 0 Δ 2 2 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) (253) \tau_{\phi}^{12}=\frac{A_{2}}{\sqrt{2wB_{-}}},\qquad\tau_{\phi}^{13}=\frac{A_{2}}{\sqrt{2wB_{+}}},\qquad\tau_{\phi}^{23}=-\frac{3\rho A_{0}\Delta}{2\sqrt{2}w(\Delta^{2}+2w)} \tag*{(253)} τ ϕ 12 = 2 w B − A 2 , τ ϕ 13 = 2 w B + A 2 , τ ϕ 23 = − 2 2 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) 3 ρ A 0 Δ (253)
where
A 0 ( ρ , ϕ ) = P f ρ 2 sin ( 3 ϕ ) A_{0}(\rho,\phi)=P f\rho^{2}\sin(3\phi) A 0 ( ρ , ϕ ) = P f ρ 2 sin ( 3 ϕ )
A 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 P 2 ρ + f 2 ρ 3 + 3 P f ρ 2 cos ( 3 ϕ ) A_{1}(\rho,\phi)=2P^{2}\rho+f^{2}\rho^{3}+3P f\rho^{2}\cos(3\phi) A 1 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 P 2 ρ + f 2 ρ 3 + 3 P f ρ 2 cos ( 3 ϕ )
A 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 P 2 ρ 2 − f 2 ρ 4 − P f ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) A_{2}(\rho,\phi)=2P^{2}\rho^{2}-f^{2}\rho^{4}-P f\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi) A 2 ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 P 2 ρ 2 − f 2 ρ 4 − P f ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ )
B ± ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 w + ( Δ ± Δ 2 + 2 w ) 2 B_{\pm}(\rho,\phi)=2w+\left(\Delta\pm\sqrt{\Delta^{2}+2w}\right)^{2} B ± ( ρ , ϕ ) = 2 w + ( Δ ± Δ 2 + 2 w ) 2
w ( ρ , ϕ ) = W 1 2 + W 2 2 = P 2 ρ 2 + f 2 ρ 4 4 + P f ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ ) w(\rho,\phi)=W_{1}^{2}+W_{2}^{2}=P^{2}\rho^{2}+\frac{f^{2}\rho^{4}}{4}+P f\rho^{3}\cos(3\phi) w ( ρ , ϕ ) = W 1 2 + W 2 2 = P 2 ρ 2 + 4 f 2 ρ 4 + P f ρ 3 cos ( 3 ϕ )
On the other hand, analytical forms of curls can be represented as:
curl τ ρ ϕ 12 = − ( 3 ρ A 0 2 − A 1 A 2 ) Δ 4 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) B + ; curl τ ρ ϕ 13 = ( 3 ρ A 0 2 − A 1 A 2 ) Δ 4 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) B − ; curl τ ρ ϕ 23 = 0. (254) \operatorname{curl}\tau_{\rho\phi}^{12}=-\frac{(3\rho A_{0}^{2}-A_{1}A_{2})\Delta}{4w(\Delta^{2}+2w)\sqrt{B_{+}}};\qquad\operatorname{curl}\tau_{\rho\phi}^{13}=\frac{(3\rho A_{0}^{2}-A_{1}A_{2})\Delta}{4w(\Delta^{2}+2w)\sqrt{B_{-}}};\qquad\operatorname{curl}\tau_{\rho\phi}^{23}=0. \tag*{(254)} curl τ ρϕ 12 = − 4 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) B + ( 3 ρ A 0 2 − A 1 A 2 ) Δ ; curl τ ρϕ 13 = 4 w ( Δ 2 + 2 w ) B − ( 3 ρ A 0 2 − A 1 A 2 ) Δ ; curl τ ρϕ 23 = 0. (254)
The above functional forms show that curl τ ρ ϕ i j \tau_{\rho\phi}^{ij} τ ρϕ ij become identically zero (0) at Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 , i.e., at the point of three-state degeneracy between A A A and E E E states. Furthermore, numerically calculated curls using the gradient of ADT angles take negligibly small magnitude (curl τ ρ ϕ i j ≈ 0 \tau_{\rho\phi}^{ij} \approx0 τ ρϕ ij ≈ 0 ) up to certain nonzero Δ \Delta Δ (≤ 172 \le172 ≤ 172 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 ). In other words, a common diagonalizing matrix, G G G is expected to exist at Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 for both the components of NACT matrices (τ ρ \tau_{\rho} τ ρ and τ ϕ \tau_{\phi} τ ϕ ), and therefore, the adiabatic SE can be transformed to the following form:
− ℏ 2 2 ( ∇ R + Ω ) 2 Φ + ( V − E ) Φ = 0 , (255) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2}\left(\nabla_R+\boldsymbol{\Omega}\right)^2\Phi+(V-E)\Phi=0, \tag*{(255)} − 2 ℏ 2 ( ∇ R + Ω ) 2 Φ + ( V − E ) Φ = 0 , (255)
where ψ a d = G Φ \psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=G\Phi ψ ad = G Φ , Ω = G † τ G \boldsymbol{\Omega}=G^\dagger\boldsymbol{\tau}G Ω = G † τ G and V = G † U G V=G^\dagger UG V = G † U G .
In case three state degenerate point (Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 ), one can write the diagonalizing matrix (G G G ) as follows:
G = ( 0 − i 2 i 2 − 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 ) G=
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & -\frac{i}{\sqrt{2}} & \frac{i}{\sqrt{2}}\\
-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} & \frac{1}{2} & \frac{1}{2}\\
\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} & \frac{1}{2} & \frac{1}{2}
\end{pmatrix} G = 0 − 2 1 2 1 − 2 i 2 1 2 1 2 i 2 1 2 1
For low value of Δ \Delta Δ (≤ 172 \le172 ≤ 172 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 ), the magnitude of curl τ \boldsymbol{\tau} τ also appears as negligible (curl τ ≈ 0 \boldsymbol{\tau}\approx0 τ ≈ 0 ), which affirms the validity of the above formulation. While imposing classical inaccessibility condition for each electronic state from others at the close neighborhood of a specific energy (∣ ψ i ∣ ≫ ∣ ψ j ∣ |\psi_i|\gg|\psi_j| ∣ ψ i ∣ ≫ ∣ ψ j ∣ (i ≠ j i\ne j i = j )), the single-surface EBO equations turn into,
− ℏ 2 2 m { ( ∂ ∂ ρ + i ω ρ ) 2 + 1 ρ ( ∂ ∂ ρ + i ω ρ ) + 1 ρ 2 ( ∂ ∂ ϕ + i ω ϕ ) 2 } Φ 1 + ( u 1 − E ) Φ 1 = 0 , (256) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left\{\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}+i\omega_\rho\right)^2+\frac{1}{\rho}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}+i\omega_\rho\right)+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\phi}+i\omega_\phi\right)^2\right\}\Phi_1+(u_1-E)\Phi_1=0, \tag*{(256)} − 2 m ℏ 2 { ( ∂ ρ ∂ + i ω ρ ) 2 + ρ 1 ( ∂ ρ ∂ + i ω ρ ) + ρ 2 1 ( ∂ ϕ ∂ + i ω ϕ ) 2 } Φ 1 + ( u 1 − E ) Φ 1 = 0 , (256)
− ℏ 2 2 m { ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 1 ρ ∂ ∂ ρ + 1 ρ 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ϕ 2 } Φ 2 + ( u 2 − E ) Φ 2 = 0 , (257) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left\{\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\rho^2}+\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\phi^2}\right\}\Phi_2+(u_2-E)\Phi_2=0, \tag*{(257)} − 2 m ℏ 2 { ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + ρ 1 ∂ ρ ∂ + ρ 2 1 ∂ ϕ 2 ∂ 2 } Φ 2 + ( u 2 − E ) Φ 2 = 0 , (257)
− ℏ 2 2 m { ( ∂ ∂ ρ − i ω ρ ) 2 + 1 ρ ( ∂ ∂ ρ − i ω ρ ) + 1 ρ 2 ( ∂ ∂ ϕ + i ω ϕ ) 2 } Φ 3 + ( u 3 − E ) Φ 3 = 0 , (258) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left\{\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}-i\omega_\rho\right)^2+\frac{1}{\rho}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}-i\omega_\rho\right)+\frac{1}{\rho^2}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial\phi}+i\omega_\phi\right)^2\right\}\Phi_3+(u_3-E)\Phi_3=0, \tag*{(258)} − 2 m ℏ 2 { ( ∂ ρ ∂ − i ω ρ ) 2 + ρ 1 ( ∂ ρ ∂ − i ω ρ ) + ρ 2 1 ( ∂ ϕ ∂ + i ω ϕ ) 2 } Φ 3 + ( u 3 − E ) Φ 3 = 0 , (258)
where adiabatic PESs are symbolized by u 1 u_1 u 1 , u 2 u_2 u 2 and u 3 u_3 u 3 , and components of NACM eigenvalues are represented as ω ρ \omega_\rho ω ρ and ω ϕ \omega_\phi ω ϕ . At this junction, it is worth mentioning that the angular component, ω ϕ \omega_\phi ω ϕ (= A 2 2 w =\frac{A_2}{2w} = 2 w A 2 ) appears as gauge invariant (∫ 0 2 π ω ϕ d ϕ = 2 π \int_0^{2\pi}\omega_\phi d\phi=2\pi ∫ 0 2 π ω ϕ d ϕ = 2 π ) for three state degeneracy, affirming the workability of the EBO equations (Eq. 4.161) for the specific domain of nuclear CS.
Once the SEs for ordinary BO, EBO (Eq. 4.161) and diabatic Hamiltonian (Eq. (245) , with Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 and 172 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 ) for the above mentioned model systems are in hand, photoabsorption spectra have been computed for the lowest state, which are depicted in Figure 4.6 . The spectral envelops obtained from EBO and diabatic surfaces at Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 28 exhibit good agreement, but approximate accord can be observed between the profiles for Δ = 172 \Delta= 172 Δ = 172 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 case. On the other hand, ordinary BO equation generated spectral bands exhibit large deviations from the diabatic ones for both the cases, namely, Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 and 172 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 .
Figure 4.6. The left panel [(a), (b) and (c)] depicts the photoabsorption spectra of Na3 _3 3 cluster employing ordinary BO equations, diabatic SEs and single-surface EBO equations, respectively for Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 between E ′ E^\prime E ′ and A 1 ′ A^\prime_1 A 1 ′ states. On the other hand, the right panel [(d), (e) and (f)] presents the same quantities for Δ = 172 c m − 1 \Delta= 172\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} Δ = 172 cm − 1 . In case of Δ = 0 \Delta= 0 Δ = 0 , good agreement between the EBO and diabatic spectral profiles can be observed, whereas for Δ = 172 c m − 1 \Delta= 172\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} Δ = 172 cm − 1 , those bands show approximate matching. Nevertheless, BO profiles encounter substantial deviation from the diabatic ones. The figures have been taken from Ref. [10] with permission from American Institute of Physics (AIP).
EBO Formalism for Model Calculations on Quasi-scattering Processes
In order to explore the usability of three-state EBO formalism, quasi-Jahn-Teller scattering models have been considered, where two CIs are located among three adiabatic PESs over two-dimensional nuclear CSs 17. Among the two models, model A shows two well-separated CIs between two different pairs of states and model B demonstrates non-adiabatic couplings between three states at a single point of the CS.
Model A
In the first model of non-adiabatically coupled three electronic states, a CI is assumed between first and second states, whereas another CI is present between second and third ones at different nuclear geometries. It is important to note that the separation between the two CIs has been tuned to investigate two extreme situations, namely, two 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 and one 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 BBO systems. Such model PESs can be observed for C2 _2 2 H molecular system with respect to the NACT profiles, where the couplings have been computed as functions of C-C-H bond angle and C-H bond distance 29. The model is manifested in Figure 4.7 (a) with the three adiabatic PESs, where those take the following forms:
Figure 4.7. The upper panel (a) shows adiabatic PESs for model A with two well-separated CIs by a finite distance, whereas the lower panel (b) depicts two CIs at the same nuclear configuration. The figures have been taken from Ref. [10] with permission from AIP.
u 1 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ [ ω 0 − ω ~ 1 ( x ) ] 2 y 2 + A 1 × f 1 ( x , y ) , u 2 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f 1 ( x , y ) + A 1 × f 2 ( x , y ) + D 1 , u 3 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f 2 ( x , y ) + D 2 , ω ~ 1 ( x ) = ω 1 exp [ − ( x − x 0 ) 2 σ 1 2 ] , f 1 ( x , y ) = exp [ − ( x − x 0 ) 2 + y 2 σ 2 ] , f 2 ( x , y ) = exp [ − ( x + x 0 ) 2 + y 2 σ 2 ] . \begin{aligned}
u_1(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu[\omega_0-\widetilde{\omega}_1(x)]^2 y^2 + A_1 \times f_1(x,y),\\
u_2(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu\omega_0^2 y^2 - (D_1-A_1)\times f_1(x,y) + A_1 \times f_2(x,y) + D_1,\\
u_3(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu\omega_0^2 y^2 - (D_1-A_1)\times f_2(x,y) + D_2,\\
\widetilde{\omega}_1(x) &= \omega_1\exp\left[-\frac{(x-x_0)^2}{\sigma_1^2}\right],\\
f_1(x,y) &= \exp\left[-\frac{(x-x_0)^2+y^2}{\sigma^2}\right],\\
f_2(x,y) &= \exp\left[-\frac{(x+x_0)^2+y^2}{\sigma^2}\right].
\end{aligned} u 1 ( x , y ) u 2 ( x , y ) u 3 ( x , y ) ω 1 ( x ) f 1 ( x , y ) f 2 ( x , y ) = 2 1 μ [ ω 0 − ω 1 ( x ) ] 2 y 2 + A 1 × f 1 ( x , y ) , = 2 1 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f 1 ( x , y ) + A 1 × f 2 ( x , y ) + D 1 , = 2 1 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f 2 ( x , y ) + D 2 , = ω 1 exp [ − σ 1 2 ( x − x 0 ) 2 ] , = exp [ − σ 2 ( x − x 0 ) 2 + y 2 ] , = exp [ − σ 2 ( x + x 0 ) 2 + y 2 ] .
In the above expression, the parameters are μ = 0.58 \mu= 0.58 μ = 0.58 amu, A 1 = 3.0 A_1 = 3.0 A 1 = 3.0 eV, D 1 = 5.0 D_1 = 5.0 D 1 = 5.0 eV, D 2 = 10.0 D_2 = 10.0 D 2 = 10.0 eV, ω 0 = 39.14 × 10 13 s − 1 \omega_0 = 39.14 \times10^{13}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} ω 0 = 39.14 × 1 0 13 s − 1 , ω 1 = 7.83 × 10 13 s − 1 \omega_1 = 7.83 \times10^{13}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} ω 1 = 7.83 × 1 0 13 s − 1 , σ = 0.3 \sigma= 0.3 σ = 0.3 Å, and σ 1 = 0.75 \sigma_1 = 0.75 σ 1 = 0.75 Å. As a matter of fact, the above model demonstrates a two-arrangement channel system showing x → ∞ x \to\infty x → ∞ and − ∞ -\infty − ∞ as the reactant and product asymptotes, respectively. The separation between the two CIs is 2 x 0 2x_0 2 x 0 Å, which is variable to explore the
flexibility of the model indicating a 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 BBO system turning into two 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 BBO systems.
a Diabatic b EBO
While formulating the EBO equations for the above three electronic manifold, linearly independent functional forms of ADT angles have been chosen to introduce the couplings among them, which fulfill the following properties:
The functional forms should be simple enough to efficiently capture the essential physical process of the system, more specifically, around the CIs between the three states.
Those functions should depend on the separation between the CIs (2 x 0 2x_0 2 x 0 ) in such a way so that the given 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 BBO system can be transformed into two simpler 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 BBO systems.
The associated NACM eigenvalues should obey the correct gauge-invariance condition.
Based on the above criteria, the functional forms of ADT angles have been taken as:
Θ 12 ( x , y ) = 1 2 tan − 1 ( y x − x 0 ) Θ 23 ( x , y ) = 1 2 tan − 1 ( y x + x 0 ) \Theta_{12}(x,y) = \frac{1}{2}\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{y}{x-x_0}\right) \qquad\Theta_{23}(x,y) = \frac{1}{2}\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{y}{x+x_0}\right) Θ 12 ( x , y ) = 2 1 tan − 1 ( x − x 0 y ) Θ 23 ( x , y ) = 2 1 tan − 1 ( x + x 0 y )
where Θ 13 ( x , y ) \Theta_{13}(x,y) Θ 13 ( x , y ) is taken as zero (0) value for both the cases. In other words, such functional forms result into a breakable 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 to two 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 BBO models. In order to generate the diabatic Hamiltonian, 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 BBO model necessitates ∇ Θ 12 ≠ 0 \nabla\Theta_{12} \ne0 ∇ Θ 12 = 0 and ∇ Θ 23 ≈ 0 \nabla\Theta_{23} \approx0 ∇ Θ 23 ≈ 0 around the first CI as well as ∇ Θ 23 ≠ 0 \nabla\Theta_{23} \ne0 ∇ Θ 23 = 0 and ∇ Θ 12 ≈ 0 \nabla\Theta_{12} \approx0 ∇ Θ 12 ≈ 0 around the other one, where ∇ Θ 13 \nabla\Theta_{13} ∇ Θ 13 can be taken as negligible for the entire range, 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2 π 0 \le\theta\le2\pi 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2 π . If the separation of CIs becomes infinity (x 0 → ∞ x_0 \to\infty x 0 → ∞ ) or the CIs coalesce (x 0 → 0 x_0 \to0 x 0 → 0 ), the eigenvalues (ω \omega ω ) of NACM are expected to fulfill the gauge invariance condition ∮ ω ⋅ d R = π \oint\boldsymbol{\omega}\cdot d\mathbf{R} = \pi ∮ ω ⋅ d R = π and 2 π 2\pi 2 π bearing the signature of two-state and three-state degeneracy, respectively. For x 0 → ∞ x_0 \to\infty x 0 → ∞ , we have performed dynamical studies on diabatic as well as EBO based PESs to compute state-to-state reactive transition probabilities at various total energies. It is important to note that the computed transition probabilities perfectly obey the correct symmetry (even → \to → odd or odd → \to → even) as well as good agreement can be observed between diabatic and EBO results (see Table 4.3 ). The calculated results indicate that the EBO equations formulated by introducing zero curl are able to produce correct symmetry-allowed transition probabilities, provided the eigenvalues of NACM are gauge invariant.
Table 4.3. Reactive state-to-state transition probabilities with various total energies (E E E ) are compared in tabulated form while executing the calculations on diabatic surfaces as well as EBO based surfaces keeping the distance between (1,2) and (2,3) CIs by 4.0 Å. The upper row for each total energy E E E depicts the diabatic results whereas the lower one indicates the corresponding EBO results. The data are taken from Ref. [10].
a a a Diabatic b b b EBO
Model B
In Figure 4.7 b, three BO states are coupled at a single nuclear configuration point, which can be considered as the second model (model B). As a representative example, one can choose Na3 _3 3 cluster possessing CIs between three coupled PESs (lower and upper 2 2 E ′ 2\,^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ states and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1\,^{2}A'_1 1 2 A 1 ′ state) at close vicinity^{11,27}. For such model system, the adiabatic PESs can be written as:
u 1 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ [ ω 0 − ω ~ 1 ( x ) ] 2 y 2 + A 1 × f ( x , y ) , u 2 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f ( x , y ) + D 1 , u 3 ( x , y ) = 1 2 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 2 − A 1 ) × f ( x , y ) + D 2 , \begin{aligned}
u_1(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu[\omega_0-\widetilde{\omega}_1(x)]^2y^2+A_1\times f(x,y),\\
u_2(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu\omega_0^2y^2-(D_1-A_1)\times f(x,y)+D_1,\\
u_3(x,y) &= \frac{1}{2}\mu\omega_0^2y^2-(D_2-A_1)\times f(x,y)+D_2,
\end{aligned} u 1 ( x , y ) u 2 ( x , y ) u 3 ( x , y ) = 2 1 μ [ ω 0 − ω 1 ( x ) ] 2 y 2 + A 1 × f ( x , y ) , = 2 1 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 1 − A 1 ) × f ( x , y ) + D 1 , = 2 1 μ ω 0 2 y 2 − ( D 2 − A 1 ) × f ( x , y ) + D 2 ,
with
ω ~ 1 ( x ) = ω 1 exp [ − ( x σ 1 ) 2 ] ; f ( x , y ) = exp [ − x 2 + y 2 σ 2 ] \widetilde{\omega}_1(x)=\omega_1\exp\left[-\left(\frac{x}{\sigma_1}\right)^2\right];\quad f(x,y)=\exp\left[-\frac{x^2+y^2}{\sigma^2}\right] ω 1 ( x ) = ω 1 exp [ − ( σ 1 x ) 2 ] ; f ( x , y ) = exp [ − σ 2 x 2 + y 2 ]
Such model deals with the couplings between three BO states at a point and therefore, one needs to consider all the three ADT angles around that region. Similar to model A, model B requires careful choice on the functional form of the ADT angles leading to meaningful EBO equation and accurate diabatic PESs. If the ADT angles are considered as Θ 12 = Θ 13 = Θ 23 = 1 2 tan − 1 ( y x ) \Theta_{12}=\Theta_{13}=\Theta_{23}=\frac{1}{2}\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{y}{x}\right) Θ 12 = Θ 13 = Θ 23 = 2 1 tan − 1 ( x y ) , the eigenvalue of the NACM becomes ω = ∇ Θ 12 3 + 2 sin Θ 12 \boldsymbol{\omega}=\nabla\Theta_{12}\sqrt{3+2\sin\Theta_{12} } ω = ∇ Θ 12 3 + 2 sin Θ 12 . It is interesting to note that gauge invariance condition for the three-state CI, i.e. ∮ ω ⋅ d R ≈ 2 π \oint\boldsymbol{\omega}\cdot d\mathbf{R}\approx2\pi ∮ ω ⋅ d R ≈ 2 π is approximately fulfilled for the computed NACM eigenvalue. Once the EBO and diabatic surfaces were in hand, those have been employed to carry out dynamical studies and the calculated state-to-state vibrational transition probabilities for various total energies are presented in Table 4.4 As per the tabulated data, EBO generated probabilities obey the correct symmetry as well as exhibit quantitative agreement with the diabatic ones.
Table 4.4. Reactive state-to-state transition probabilities with various total energies (E E E ) are compared in tabulated form while performing the dynamical calculations on both diabatic as well as EBO based surfaces where (1,2) and (2,3) CIs are located in same point leading to three-state degeneracy. The upper row for each total energy E E E designates the diabatic results and the lower one specifies the corresponding EBO results. The results are taken from Ref. [10].
Contemporary Diabatization Methodologies
Though we have discussed the detailed formulation of BBO based diabatization theory including non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) explicitly, it would be appropriate to outline other contemporary diabatization schemes to incorporate the couplings among the electronic states on various molecular and chemical processes.
Vibronic Coupling Model (VCM): As per VCM30 methodology, diagonal and off-diagonal elements of diabatic Hamiltonian are expanded with respect to the ground adiabatic PES (V 0 ( R ) V_0(\mathbf{R}) V 0 ( R ) ) minima or more preferably, the CI point (R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 ) as functions of linear, bilinear or even higher order polynomials of nuclear DOFs. 31–35 It is worth mentioning that Zeng et al. 36,37 expanded the VCM based diabatic Hamiltonian upto arbitrary order and applied the formalism for trigonal and tetragonal systems. In case of linear VCM, the Taylor series expanded diabatic matrix elements at the close vicinity of a reference nuclear geometry, R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 can be expanded as:
W i i ( R ) = T ^ n u c + V 0 ( R ) + W i i ( R 0 ) + ∑ s κ s ( i ) R s W_{ii}(\mathbf{R})=\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}+V_0(\mathbf{R})+W_{ii}(\mathbf{R}_0)+\sum_s \kappa_s^{(i)}R_s W ii ( R ) = T ^ nuc + V 0 ( R ) + W ii ( R 0 ) + s ∑ κ s ( i ) R s
W i j ( R ) = ∑ s λ s ( i , j ) R s i ≠ j , (259) W_{ij}(\mathbf{R})=\sum_s \lambda_s^{(i,j)}R_s \quad i\ne j, \tag*{(259)} W ij ( R ) = s ∑ λ s ( i , j ) R s i = j , (259)
where diagonal and off-diagonal diabatic Hamiltonian elements are represented as W i i ( R ) W_{ii}(\mathbf{R}) W ii ( R ) and W i j ( R ) W_{ij}(\mathbf{R}) W ij ( R ) , respectively. On the other hand, the combining coefficients (κ s ( i ) \kappa_s^{(i)} κ s ( i ) and λ s ( i , j ) \lambda_s^{(i,j)} λ s ( i , j ) ) indicate linear vibronic coupling constants. It needs to be noted that being a Taylor series expansion, the VCM based diabatization approach is applicable only in a limited domain of Frank-Condon (FC) region close to the reference geometry R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 .
Exact Factorisation (EF) Method: In the EF approach proposed and developed by Gross et al. 38–40, simultaneous solution of the electronic and nuclear SEs takes place using time-dependent PESs, vector potential and a coupling operator. It is necessary to note that the wavefunctions in EF methodology cannot represent a specific quantum state and therefore, the physical significance of such functions is ambiguous with respect to the adiabatic states and the correlations within them. Agostini and coworkers 41,42 have applied such approach to investigate the contribution of CI(s) on dynamical calculations for 2D model systems as well as realistic species. For the later cases (realistic species), the electronic structure calculations have been carried out with the aid of Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TDDFT).43
Direct Dynamics (DD): Apart from the VCM or EF based diabatization followed by nuclear dynamics, direct dynamical methods, like on-the-fly diabatization version of MCTDH,44,45 DD variational multi-configurational Gaussian (DD-vMCG),46–48 etc. are also used now-a-days, where the following expression is numerically solved to compute the ADT matrix, A ( R ) A(\mathbf{R}) A ( R ) at every step during time propagation:47
∇ R A ( R ) = − τ ( R ) A ( R ) . (260) \nabla_{\mathbf{R}}A(\mathbf{R})=-\tau(\mathbf{R})A(\mathbf{R}). \tag*{(260)} ∇ R A ( R ) = − τ ( R ) A ( R ) . (260)
The solution of the above equation can be written as:6,49
A ( R + Δ R ) = exp ( − ∫ R R + Δ R τ ⋅ d R ) A ( R ) A(\mathbf{R}+\Delta\mathbf{R})=\exp\left(-\int_{\mathbf{R}}^{\mathbf{R}+\Delta\mathbf{R}}\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\mathrm{d}\mathbf{R}\right)A(\mathbf{R}) A ( R + Δ R ) = exp ( − ∫ R R + Δ R τ ⋅ d R ) A ( R )
In order to obtain a more formal solution of Eq. (260) , ADT equations (see Eq. (164) ) of BBO formalism50 can be employed engaging all the electronic states forming the sub-space instead of only two states possessing CI point/seam.
Simultaneous Electron-Nuclear Dynamics: Apart from the above mentioned diabatization approaches, Takatsuka and coworkers 51–53 developed a unified formalism to decompose the components of nonadiabatic interactions along fast and slow modes in multi-dimensional multi-state dynamical studies. Such mathematical framework provides (local) collective coordinates needed for the interconnection between slow and fast modes and therefore, it can be involved to investigate multi-dimensional nonadiabatic transition, resonance, chaos and many other intrinsic phenomenon. The derivatives of nuclear coordinate vectors, μ ˙ \dot{\boldsymbol{\mu}} μ ˙ can naturally or artificially govern the nonadiabatic dynamics at a given point x ( t ) μ ( t ) x(t)\boldsymbol{\mu}(t) x ( t ) μ ( t ) . The nuclear coordinates are transformed into a new set of variables, s I s_I s I and the relative symmetry between the vectors, s I s_I s I and μ ˙ \dot{\boldsymbol{\mu}} μ ˙ dictates the excited state chemical reactions in many-dimensional and (quasi-)degenerate nonadiabatic dynamics.
Features of BBO Theory: Advantages and Challenges
The theoretically “exact" and numerically “accurate" first principle based BBO theory is equally applicable for the generation of diabatic Hamiltonian for spectroscopic systems as well as scattering processes using ab initio computed adiabatic surfaces and NACTs. 10,50 In other words, one can employ the BBO formalism at and around the FC domain as well as at the asymptotic limit of nuclear CS, where bond breaking and formation occur. Therefore, it is indeed necessary to thoroughly compare the BBO theory with other contemporary methodologies, which are presented in the earlier subsection.
In BBO formalism, the BO expanded total molecular wavefunction takes the following form,
Ψ ( r , R ) = ∑ i ψ i a d ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) = ∑ i ψ i a d ( R ) A ( R ) ξ ~ i ( r ) = ∑ i ψ i d i a ( R ) ξ ~ i ( r ) , \Psi(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) = \sum_i \psi_i^{\mathrm{ad}}(\mathbf{R})\xi_i(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}) = \sum_i \psi_i^{\mathrm{ad}}(\mathbf{R})A(\mathbf{R})\widetilde{\xi}_i(\mathbf{r})
= \sum_i \psi_i^{\mathrm{dia}}(\mathbf{R})\widetilde{\xi}_i(\mathbf{r}), Ψ ( r , R ) = i ∑ ψ i ad ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) = i ∑ ψ i ad ( R ) A ( R ) ξ i ( r ) = i ∑ ψ i dia ( R ) ξ i ( r ) ,
where ξ ~ i ( r ) \widetilde{\xi}_i(\mathbf{r}) ξ i ( r ) s represent functions of electronic coordinates (r \mathbf{r} r ). In other words, the derivatives of ξ ~ i ( r ) \widetilde{\xi}_i(\mathbf{r}) ξ i ( r ) s with respect to nuclear coordinates (R \mathbf{R} R ) do not survive. The exact form of A ( R ) A(\mathbf{R}) A ( R ) matrix can be evaluated using Eq. (164) and then, the ADT matrix needs to be incorporated into Eq. (168) to calculate the diabatic PES matrix at each nuclear configuration, R \mathbf{R} R . On the contrary, in VCM approach, diabatic potential matrix elements (W i j ( R ) W_{ij}(\mathbf{R}) W ij ( R ) ) are expressed in Taylor series expansion containing linear, bilinear or even higher order terms around the ground state minima or a CI point (R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 ). Nevertheless, the BBO-DH matrix elements (diabatic PESs and coupling terms) are highly accurate upto all order even around the accidental CIs for spectroscopic systems. Furthermore, such a complete theory can also be used to construct global diabatic PESs for scattering processes, which involves even the asymptotic domain of nuclear CS.
The adiabatic PESs, NACTs as well as BBO-DH matrix elements (diabatic PESs and couplings) for realistic molecules often exhibit even-parity functional form along one of the components in most of the degenerate pair of asymmetric stretching/bending modes or even some specific non-degenerate asymmetric stretching modes. 10–12,16,20,50,54–57 In other words, only even power polynomials can be used to fit the potential couplings for those modes, where such unique property cannot be explored for the well-known traditional JT model 30,34,36,58–65 (linear, bilinear or higher order). For such specific normal mode (say Q l Q_l Q l ) of Q k − Q l Q_k-Q_l Q k − Q l nuclear plane, one of the off-diagonal elements take the following form:
W i j ( Q k , Q l ) = ∑ n = 0 N ∑ m = 0 M c n m Q k n Q l 2 m , n , m ∈ { 0 , 1 , 2 , … } (261) W_{ij}(Q_k,Q_l)=\sum_{n=0}^{N}\sum_{m=0}^{M}c_{nm}Q_k^nQ_l^{2m}, \qquad n,m\in\{0,1,2,\ldots\} \tag*{(261)} W ij ( Q k , Q l ) = n = 0 ∑ N m = 0 ∑ M c nm Q k n Q l 2 m , n , m ∈ { 0 , 1 , 2 , … } (261)
where i i i , j j j represent two electronic states and Q k Q_k Q k , Q l Q_l Q l signify two normal modes. The above fitted polynomial clearly shows that the contributing coefficients (c 01 c_{01} c 01 , c 11 c_{11} c 11 , c 21 c_{21} c 21 , ...), associated with Q l Q_l Q l , Q k Q l Q_kQ_l Q k Q l , Q k 2 Q l Q_k^2Q_l Q k 2 Q l , ... appear as zero within the numerical precision. As a matter of fact, according to BBO formalism, the first non-zero term of some specific modes in the diabatic coupling can be quadratic (not linear), which can be observed for a wide range of molecules.10–12,16,20,50,54–57
In BBO formalism, the quantized nature of NACTs indicates the number of enclosed JT CI(s)/seam(s) (symmetry allowed or accidental) or RT interaction(s) over the nuclear plane inside a closed contour. The resulting ADT angles at the end of the closed loop attain the magnitude of zero (0) or n π n\pi nπ or n ⋅ 2 π n\cdot2\pi n ⋅ 2 π (n n n is an integer) bearing the signature of the encapsulated degenerate point(s). Such unique feature of BBO theory is helpful to explore the nature and accuracy of the diabatic Hamiltonian. On the other hand, other diabatization methods do not have similar procedure to unveil the accuracy of diabatic PESs.
The BBO theory has been truly generalized by developing an algorithm and user-friendly OpenMP parallelized program, “ADT” (see https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00948 or https://github.com/AdhikariLAB/ADT-Program )56. User can install and execute such software package to formulate analytic expressions of various ADT quantities (like ADT equations, ADT matrix elements, diabatic potential energy matrix elements, etc.) as well as to compute the numerical values of those parameters for ‘N’ coupled electronic states with ‘M’ number of nuclear DOFs. During diabatization, user can provide the ab initio inputs, namely, adiabatic PESs and NACTs to the program or such input files can be generated with the aid of in-built python codes interfacing standard quantum chemistry packages, like Molpro,14 Columbus,15 Gamess66 and Gaussian67. At this junction, it needs to mention that calculation of highly accurate ab initio inputs, namely, adiabatic PESs and NACTs needs sophisticated electronic structure approaches, which are further used in BBO based diabatization. Till now, the “ADT” algorithm56 is not interfaced with DD approaches44–48, but such interfacing is expected to be done in near future to reduce the computation time and cost.
Generalization of Beyond Born Oppenheimer Theory in External Fields
The field-dressed potential energy surfaces (PESs) raise immense interest among the scientific community with the idea of carrying out chemical processes in presence of laser fields. Even though the first experiment was attempted in 1980s1 using low intensity and continuous (as opposed to pulsed) lasers, George and coworkers 2,3 carried out the first theoretical/numerical investigations to study atom-diatom inelastic collisions governed by continuous lasers and such formulations were later extended for other types of collisions4–8. In case of F+H2 _2 2 reaction, it was observed that fields with different frequencies alters the quantum yields of the reactive (electronic non-adiabatic) process F(2 P 1 / 2 ^2P_{1/2} 2 P 1/2 ) + H2 _2 2 → \rightarrow → HF(v f v_f v f ) + H2 _2 2 significantly.8 Later on, various theoretical frameworks were introduced, which mainly deal with short-pulsed high-intensity fields applied on various systems in different situations.9–11
Adhikari et al. 12–18 have developed a rigorous first principle based theory to apply for general field dressed poly-atomic system. In order to carry out such development, the following two aspects are taken care: (a) Extension of the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) treatment has been carried out to incorporate quantum states of light beyond the usual coherent-state distribution.15–17,19–21 Such states are widely known as non-coherent Fock (or, also, as the non-classical photon) states. It is important to explore the effects of such states on measured magnitudes such as kinetic energy release (KER) distributions and time-dependent dissociation probabilities (DP). This type of photon states mainly arise in presence of short-pulsed, high intensity laser systems and thereby, significantly affect the KER distribution of the products. (b) It has been explored whether external fields can affect conical intersections (CIs),12–14 where such studies have been executed comprehensively within the new gauge.
The present chapter deals with Beyond BO (BBO) approach for a molecular system, which interacts with an external field. This treatment is carried out in two different ways: (a) using a time-independent (or field-free) electronic basis set, termed as the time-dependent ordinary treatment; (b) employing a time-dependent (or field-dressed) electronic basis set, known as time-dependent field-dressed treatment.
Time-Dependent Ordinary BBO Theory PAULPR496
For both the time-dependent BBO treatments (ordinary and field-dressed), the time-dependent Schrödinger Equation (SE) for the total wave-function (Ψ ( r , R , t ) \mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t) Ψ ( r , R , t ) ) takes the following form:
i ℏ ∂ Ψ ( r , R , t ) ∂ t = ( − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ R 2 + H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ) Ψ ( r , R , t ) , (262) i\hbar\frac{\partial\mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t)}{\partial t}=\left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}^2+H_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\right)\mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t), \tag*{(262)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Ψ ( r , R , t ) = ( − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ R 2 + H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ) Ψ ( r , R , t ) , (262)
where the electronic Hamiltonian H e ( r ∣ R ) H_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R}) H e ( r ∣ R ) appears as time dependent. On the other hand, one can assume that the effect of the external field can be represented in terms of the interaction of the electric field with the electronic Hamiltonian. As a result, the associated time-dependent electronic Hamiltonian takes the form:22,23
H e ( r ∣ R , t ) = H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) + μ e ( r , R ) . E ( t ) (263) H_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)=H_{e0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})+\boldsymbol{\mu}_e(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}).\mathbf{E}(t) \tag*{(263)} H e ( r ∣ R , t ) = H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) + μ e ( r , R ) . E ( t ) (263)
It is important to note that Ψ ( r , R , t ) \mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t) Ψ ( r , R , t ) can be expanded in terms of a time-independent electronic basis set originated from the adiabatic eigenfunctions of H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) H_{e0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R}) H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) :
Ψ ( r , R , t ) = ξ T ( r ∣ R ) ψ ( R , t ) (264) \mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t)=\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) \tag*{(264)} Ψ ( r , R , t ) = ξ T ( r ∣ R ) ψ ( R , t ) (264)
where ξ T ( r ∣ R ) \boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R}) ξ T ( r ∣ R ) and ψ ( R , t ) \boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) ψ ( R , t ) appear as row and column vectors, respectively, and ψ ( R , t ) \boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) ψ ( R , t ) signifies field-dressed nuclear wave-functions. While substituting Eq. (264) in Eq. (262) , it produces time-dependent SE for the nuclear wave-functions as follows:
i ℏ ξ T ( r ∣ R ) ∂ ψ ( R , t ) ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 ( ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) ) + H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) (265) i\hbar\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t)}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla^2\left(\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t)\right)+H_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) \tag*{(265)} i ℏ ξ T ( r ∣ R ) ∂ t ∂ ψ ( R , t ) = − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ 2 ( ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) ) + H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) (265)
or
i ℏ ξ T ∂ ψ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ( ξ T ∇ 2 ψ + ∇ 2 ξ T ψ + 2 ∇ ξ T ∇ ψ ) + H e ξ T ψ (266) i\hbar\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi}+\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}\boldsymbol{\psi}+2\nabla\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}\nabla\boldsymbol{\psi}\right)+H_e\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}\boldsymbol{\psi} \tag*{(266)} i ℏ ξ T ∂ t ∂ ψ = − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ξ T ∇ 2 ψ + ∇ 2 ξ T ψ + 2∇ ξ T ∇ ψ ) + H e ξ T ψ (266)
While projecting Eq. (266) by ξ † ( r ∣ R ) \boldsymbol{\xi}^{\dagger}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R}) ξ † ( r ∣ R ) (column vector containing the complex conjugate eigenfunctions) and integrating over the electronic coordinates r \mathbf{r} r , one can arrive the following time-dependent adiabatic SE for the nuclear wavefunctions:
i ℏ ∂ ψ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ( ∇ + τ ( R ) ) 2 ψ + ( u ( R ) + μ ~ ( R ) . E ~ ( t ) ) ψ (267) i\hbar\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\nabla+\boldsymbol{\tau}(\mathbf{R})\right)^2\boldsymbol{\psi}+\left(\mathbf{u}(\mathbf{R})+\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\mu}}(\mathbf{R}).\widetilde{\mathbf{E}}(t)\right)\boldsymbol{\psi} \tag*{(267)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ ψ = − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ∇ + τ ( R ) ) 2 ψ + ( u ( R ) + μ ( R ) . E ( t ) ) ψ (267)
where τ ( R ) \boldsymbol{\tau}(\mathbf{R}) τ ( R ) and u ( R ) \mathbf{u}(\mathbf{R}) u ( R ) correspond to the time-independent non-adiabatic coupling matrix (NACM) and diagonal adiabatic PESs matrix. On the other hand, the associated dipole moment matrix takes the following form:
μ ~ j k ( R ) = e ⟨ ξ j ( r ∣ R ) ∣ r ∣ ξ k ( r ∣ R ) ⟩ (268) \widetilde{\mu}_{jk}(\mathbf{R})=e\langle\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})|\mathbf{r}|\xi_k(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\rangle \tag*{(268)} μ j k ( R ) = e ⟨ ξ j ( r ∣ R ) ∣ r ∣ ξ k ( r ∣ R )⟩ (268)
Similar to the time-independent approach, the adiabatic-to-diabatic transformation (ADT) can be carried out to eliminate τ \boldsymbol{\tau} τ matrix and ψ ( R , t ) \boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) ψ ( R , t ) is replaced by A ( s ) Φ ( R , t ) A(s)\boldsymbol{\Phi}(\mathbf{R},t) A ( s ) Φ ( R , t ) , which leads to the following time-dependent nuclear SE:22
i ℏ ∂ Φ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 Φ + W ~ e ( R , t ) Φ , (269) i\hbar\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\Phi}}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\Phi}+\widetilde{\mathbf{W}}_e(\mathbf{R},t)\boldsymbol{\Phi}, \tag*{(269)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Φ = − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ 2 Φ + W e ( R , t ) Φ , (269)
where W ~ e = A † H ~ e A \widetilde{\mathbf{W}}_e=A^{\dagger}\widetilde{H}_eA W e = A † H e A and H ~ e ( R , t ) = u ( R ) + μ ~ ( R ) . E ~ ( t ) \widetilde{H}_e(\mathbf{R},t)=\mathbf{u}(\mathbf{R})+\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\mu}}(\mathbf{R}).\widetilde{\mathbf{E}}(t) H e ( R , t ) = u ( R ) + μ ( R ) . E ( t ) . It is important to note that A A A is time-independent in the field-free case.
Time-Dependent Field-Dressed BBO Theory 18
In case of field-dressed condition, the time-dependent electronic basis set, ξ ( r ∣ R , t ) \boldsymbol{\xi}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t) ξ ( r ∣ R , t ) can be used to expand the total wavefunction as follows:22,23
Ψ ( r , R , t ) = ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) (270) \mathbf{\Psi}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R},t)=\boldsymbol{\xi}^{T}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t) \tag*{(270)} Ψ ( r , R , t ) = ξ T ( r ∣ R , t ) ψ ( R , t ) (270)
On the other hand, the electronic eignefunctions obey the following time-dependent SE:
i ℏ ∂ ∂ t ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) ⟩ = H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) ⟩ (271) i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}|\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\rangle=H_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)|\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\rangle \tag*{(271)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t )⟩ = H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t )⟩ (271)
At t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , the electric field is turned on and therefore, H e \mathbf{H}_e H e is independent of time (and diagonal) at t ≤ 0 t \le0 t ≤ 0 . As a consequence, for t ≤ 0 t \le0 t ≤ 0 , the j t h j^{th} j t h eigenfunction, ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) \xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t) ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) takes the following form:
∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) ⟩ = exp ( − i u j ( R ) t ℏ ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R ) ⟩ , (272) |\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\rangle= \exp\left(-\frac{i u_j(\mathbf{R})t}{\hbar}\right)|\xi_{j0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\rangle, \tag*{(272)} ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t )⟩ = exp ( − ℏ i u j ( R ) t ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R )⟩ , (272)
where ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R ) \xi_{j0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R}) ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R ) s are the eigenvalues of the following j t h j^{th} j t h eigenvalue equation:
( H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) − u j ( R ) ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R ) ⟩ = 0. (273) \left(\mathbf{H}_{e0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})-u_j(\mathbf{R})\right)|\xi_{j0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\rangle= 0. \tag*{(273)} ( H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) − u j ( R ) ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R )⟩ = 0. (273)
Here u j ( R ) u_j(\mathbf{R}) u j ( R ) s are time-independent potential energy surfaces.
While solving Eq. (271) for t > 0 t>0 t > 0 (considering Eq. (272) as initial condition), ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) \xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t) ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) can be expressed in terms of L L L eigenfunctions of H e \mathbf{H}_e H e as calculated at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . Therefore,
∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) ⟩ = ∑ k = 1 L ∣ ξ k 0 ( r ∣ R ) ⟩ ω k j ( R , t ) , (274) |\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\rangle= \sum_{k=1}^{L}|\xi_{k0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\rangle\omega_{kj}(\mathbf{R},t), \tag*{(274)} ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t )⟩ = k = 1 ∑ L ∣ ξ k 0 ( r ∣ R )⟩ ω k j ( R , t ) , (274)
where the square matrix, ω k j ( R , t ) \omega_{kj}(\mathbf{R},t) ω k j ( R , t ) possesses the expansion coefficients. If the expression of ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t ) ⟩ |\xi_j(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\rangle ∣ ξ j ( r ∣ R , t )⟩ of Eq. (274) is substituted in Eq. (271) , it results into the differential equation for ω ( R , t ) \omega(\mathbf{R},t) ω ( R , t ) ,
i ℏ ∂ ∂ t ω ( R , t ) = H ~ e ( R , t ) ω ( R , t ) , (275) i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\omega(\mathbf{R},t)=\widetilde{\mathbf{H}}_e(\mathbf{R},t)\omega(\mathbf{R},t), \tag*{(275)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ ω ( R , t ) = H e ( R , t ) ω ( R , t ) , (275)
where H ~ e \widetilde{\mathbf{H}}_e H e is represented as:
H ~ e ( R , t ) k j = ⟨ ξ k 0 ( r ∣ R ) ∣ H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R ) ⟩ (276) \widetilde{\mathbf{H}}_e(\mathbf{R},t)_{kj}=\langle\xi_{k0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})|\mathbf{H}_e(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)|\xi_{j0}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R})\rangle \tag*{(276)} H e ( R , t ) k j = ⟨ ξ k 0 ( r ∣ R ) ∣ H e ( r ∣ R , t ) ∣ ξ j 0 ( r ∣ R )⟩ (276)
The solution of Eq. (275) is as follows,
ω ( R , t ) = T exp { − i ℏ ∫ − ∞ t d t ′ H e ( R , t ′ ) } I (277) \omega(\mathbf{R},t)=\mathcal{T}\exp\left\{-\frac{i}{\hbar}\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt'\,\mathbf{H}_e(\mathbf{R},t')\right\}\mathbf{I} \tag*{(277)} ω ( R , t ) = T exp { − ℏ i ∫ − ∞ t d t ′ H e ( R , t ′ ) } I (277)
where T \mathcal{T} T represents time ordering operator and I \mathbf{I} I is the unit matrix. On the other hand, for t ≤ 0 t \le0 t ≤ 0 , the matrix ω ( R , t ) \omega(\mathbf{R},t) ω ( R , t ) becomes:
ω k j ( R , t ≤ 0 ) = exp ( i u j ( R ) t ℏ ) δ j k . (278) \omega_{kj}(\mathbf{R},t\le0)=\exp\left(\frac{i u_j(\mathbf{R})t}{\hbar}\right)\delta_{jk}. \tag*{(278)} ω k j ( R , t ≤ 0 ) = exp ( ℏ i u j ( R ) t ) δ j k . (278)
If Eqs. Eqs. (270) and (271) are substituted in Eq. (262) , the resulting equation is integrating over the electronic coordinates, which produces the following field-dressed nuclear SE:
i ℏ ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) ∂ ψ ( R , t ) ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ( ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) ∇ 2 ψ ( R , t ) ) (279) i\hbar\xi^{\dagger}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t)}{\partial t}
=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\xi^{\dagger}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t)\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi}(\mathbf{R},t)\right) \tag*{(279)} i ℏ ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) ∂ t ∂ ψ ( R , t ) = − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) ∇ 2 ψ ( R , t ) ) (279)
It is interesting to note that the above equation is entirely dictated by the nuclear kinetic energy operator. Eq. (279) turns into the following form:
i ℏ ξ † ∂ ψ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ( ξ † ∇ 2 ψ + ( ∇ 2 ξ † ) ψ + 2 ∇ ξ † ∇ ψ ) (280) i\hbar\xi^{\dagger}\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}}{\partial t}
=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\xi^{\dagger}\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi}+(\nabla^2\xi^{\dagger})\boldsymbol{\psi}+2\nabla\xi^{\dagger}\nabla\boldsymbol{\psi}\right) \tag*{(280)} i ℏ ξ † ∂ t ∂ ψ = − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ξ † ∇ 2 ψ + ( ∇ 2 ξ † ) ψ + 2∇ ξ † ∇ ψ ) (280)
Projecting the above equation by ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) \xi^{\dagger}(\mathbf{r}|\mathbf{R},t) ξ † ( r ∣ R , t ) leads to the following expression:
i ℏ ∂ ψ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m ( ∇ + τ ~ ) 2 ψ . (281) i\hbar\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\psi}}{\partial t}
=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}(\nabla+\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\tau}})^2\boldsymbol{\psi}. \tag*{(281)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ ψ = − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ∇ + τ ) 2 ψ . (281)
In the above equation, the field-dressed NACM (τ ~ ( R , t ) \widetilde{\boldsymbol{\tau}}(\mathbf{R},t) τ ( R , t ) ) can be written as:
τ ~ = ω † τ ω + ω † ∇ ω , (282) \widetilde{\boldsymbol{\tau}}=\boldsymbol{\omega}^{\dagger}\boldsymbol{\tau}\boldsymbol{\omega}+\boldsymbol{\omega}^{\dagger}\nabla\boldsymbol{\omega}, \tag*{(282)} τ = ω † τ ω + ω † ∇ ω , (282)
where τ \tau τ is the field-free NACM. As a matter of fact, Eq. (281) presents the SE in absence of any potential energy matrix and the nuclear dynamics is solely governed by a vector potential.
As per the structures of Eqs. (281) and (282) , it appears easier to remove the (full) field-dressed NACM, τ ~ \tilde{\tau} τ ~ compared to its field-free analogue, τ \tau τ . In order to perform the ADT for Eq. (281) , we follow the similar procedure as the time-independent case, but for the present case (time-dependent field-dressed), ADT matrix (A ~ ( R , t ) \tilde{A}(R,t) A ~ ( R , t ) ) is considered as time-dependent. Considering the orthogonal transformation, Ψ = A ~ Φ \Psi= \tilde{A}\Phi Ψ = A ~ Φ , Eq. (281) produces the following expression:
i ℏ A ~ ∂ Φ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m [ A ~ ∇ 2 + 2 ( G A ~ ) ∇ + ( G 2 A ~ ) ] Φ − i ℏ ∂ A ~ ∂ t Φ . (283) i\hbar\tilde{A}\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left[\tilde{A}\nabla^2+2(G\tilde{A})\nabla+(G^2\tilde{A})\right]\Phi-i\hbar\frac{\partial\tilde{A}}{\partial t}\Phi. \tag*{(283)} i ℏ A ~ ∂ t ∂ Φ = − 2 m ℏ 2 [ A ~ ∇ 2 + 2 ( G A ~ ) ∇ + ( G 2 A ~ ) ] Φ − i ℏ ∂ t ∂ A ~ Φ. (283)
In the above expression, G G G represents the space covariant derivative operator acting only on A ~ \tilde{A} A ~ , which is given in the form,
G = ∇ + τ ~ . (284) G=\nabla+\tilde{\tau}. \tag*{(284)} G = ∇ + τ ~ . (284)
Then, we add as well as subtract a product form of undetermined matrix τ ~ t \tilde{\tau}_t τ ~ t and A ~ Ψ \tilde{A}\Psi A ~ Ψ simultaneously so that Eq. (283) turns into:
i ℏ A ~ ∂ Φ ∂ t = − ℏ 2 2 m [ A ~ ∇ 2 + 2 ( G A ~ ) ∇ + ( G 2 A ~ ) ] Φ − ( G t A ~ − τ ~ t A ~ ) Φ , (285) i\hbar\tilde{A}\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial t}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left[\tilde{A}\nabla^2+2(G\tilde{A})\nabla+(G^2\tilde{A})\right]\Phi-(G_t\tilde{A}-\tilde{\tau}_t\tilde{A})\Phi, \tag*{(285)} i ℏ A ~ ∂ t ∂ Φ = − 2 m ℏ 2 [ A ~ ∇ 2 + 2 ( G A ~ ) ∇ + ( G 2 A ~ ) ] Φ − ( G t A ~ − τ ~ t A ~ ) Φ , (285)
where G t G_t G t signifies the corresponding time covariant derivative operator as follows,
G t = i ℏ ∂ ∂ t + τ ~ t (286) G_t=i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}+\tilde{\tau}_t \tag*{(286)} G t = i ℏ ∂ t ∂ + τ ~ t (286)
and τ ~ t \tilde{\tau}_t τ ~ t is considered as a Hermitian operator.
At this junction, the A ~ \tilde{A} A ~ matrix can be chosen to be a solution of the space-time first-order differential equations, where the space and time dependent equations are as follows
G A ~ = 0 ⇒ ∇ A ~ + τ ~ A ~ = 0 (287) G\tilde{A}=0\Rightarrow\nabla\tilde{A}+\tilde{\tau}\tilde{A}=0 \tag*{(287)} G A ~ = 0 ⇒ ∇ A ~ + τ ~ A ~ = 0 (287)
and
G t A ~ = 0 ⇒ i ℏ ∂ A ~ ∂ t + τ ~ t A ~ = 0 (288) G_t\tilde{A}=0\Rightarrow i\hbar\frac{\partial\tilde{A}}{\partial t}+\tilde{\tau}_t\tilde{A}=0 \tag*{(288)} G t A ~ = 0 ⇒ i ℏ ∂ t ∂ A ~ + τ ~ t A ~ = 0 (288)
On the other hand, if Eqs. (287) and (288) are plugged into Eq. (285) , the corresponding diabatic equation appears as:
i ℏ ∂ Φ ∂ t = ( − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 + W ~ e ) Φ , (289) i\hbar\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial t}=\left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla^2+\tilde{W}_e\right)\Phi, \tag*{(289)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Φ = ( − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ 2 + W ~ e ) Φ , (289)
where W ~ e ( R , t ) \tilde{W}_e(R,t) W ~ e ( R , t ) symbolizes the recovered field-dressed diabatic Hamiltonian:
W ~ e = A ~ † τ ~ t A ~ . (290) \tilde{W}_e=\tilde{A}^{\dagger}\tilde{\tau}_t\tilde{A}. \tag*{(290)} W ~ e = A ~ † τ ~ t A ~ . (290)
It is necessary to mention that the two approaches, namely, the time-dependent ordinary and field-dressed approaches produce exactly the same diabatic potential indicating that the field-dressed approach have limited advantages over the first straightforward simple field-free approach. The second approach becomes important in cases where the approximations are used to cut down the number of SE equations (Eq. (290) ), which reduces the computational time. Such approximations are thoroughly discussed in the next subsection.
Approximations for Solution of ADT Matrix 18
Eq. 5.29 contains L L L equations with the following L L L unknown functions:
Φ ~ T = ( ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , ⋯ , ϕ j , ⋯ , ϕ L ) T (291) \widetilde{\boldsymbol{\Phi}}^{T}=(\phi_{1},\phi_{2},\cdots,\phi_{j},\cdots,\phi_{L})^{T} \tag*{(291)} Φ T = ( ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , ⋯ , ϕ j , ⋯ , ϕ L ) T (291)
Eq. 5.29 is valid for the first N N N equations (N < L N<L N < L ) till the RHS is considered as full vector, Φ ~ \widetilde{\boldsymbol{\Phi}} Φ . While converting the reduced set of N N N equalities into an ordinary system of N N N equations, the lower tail of Φ ~ \widetilde{\boldsymbol{\Phi}} Φ (last L − N L-N L − N elements) can be considered as negligible and therefore, can be ignored. On the other hand, the squared system of L L L equations (see Eq. (290) ) appears as reduced squared system of N N N equation as follows:
i ℏ ∂ Φ ~ r ∂ t = ( − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 + W ~ r ) Φ ~ r , (292) i\hbar\frac{\partial\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\Phi}}_{r}}{\partial t}=\left(-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\nabla^{2}+\widetilde{W}_{r}\right)\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\Phi}}_{r}, \tag*{(292)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Φ r = ( − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ 2 + W r ) Φ r , (292)
Even though there are several ways to generate the reduced N × N N\times N N × N diabatic PESs matrix, the present approach is more advantageous due to the formulation of W ~ r ( R , t ) \widetilde{W}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R},t) W r ( R , t ) from original unaltered L × L L\times L L × L PESs matrix,
W ~ r = A ~ r † H ~ e A ~ r (293) \widetilde{W}_{r}=\widetilde{A}_{r}^{\dagger}\widetilde{H}_{e}\widetilde{A}_{r} \tag*{(293)} W r = A r † H e A r (293)
where H ~ e = ω † H ~ e ω \widetilde{H}_{e}=\boldsymbol{\omega}^{\dagger}\widetilde{H}_{e}\boldsymbol{\omega} H e = ω † H e ω . In other words, the diabatic PESs matrix of reduced dimension, W ~ r ( R , t ) \widetilde{W}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R},t) W r ( R , t ) can be generated with the aid of a rectangular N × L N\times L N × L ADT matrix, A ~ r ( R , t ) \widetilde{A}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R},t) A r ( R , t ) . Since the original full matrix, H ~ e ( R , t ) \widetilde{H}_{e}(\boldsymbol{R},t) H e ( R , t ) is still employed, the errors appearing due to reduced final diabatic PESs matrix is negligible. In order to derive A ~ r \widetilde{A}_{r} A r , one can assume a space-time contour, Γ s t \Gamma_{st} Γ s t and the solution is propagated as per the following equation:
A ~ r ( R , t ∣ Γ s t ) = ϱ ∏ n = 1 M [ exp { − ∫ R n − 1 R n τ ~ ( R , t n ) ⋅ d R } exp { i ℏ ∫ t n − 1 t n H ~ e ( R n − 1 , t ) d t } ] A ~ r ( R 0 , t 0 ) (294) \widetilde{A}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R},t\mid\Gamma_{st})=\varrho\prod_{n=1}^{M}\left[\exp\left\{-\int_{\boldsymbol{R}_{n-1}}^{\boldsymbol{R}_{n}}\widetilde{\boldsymbol{\tau}}(\boldsymbol{R},t_{n})\cdot d\boldsymbol{R}\right\}\exp\left\{\frac{i}{\hbar}\int_{t_{n-1}}^{t_{n}}\widetilde{H}_{e}(\boldsymbol{R}_{n-1},t)dt\right\}\right]\widetilde{A}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R}_{0},t_{0}) \tag*{(294)} A r ( R , t ∣ Γ s t ) = ϱ n = 1 ∏ M [ exp { − ∫ R n − 1 R n τ ( R , t n ) ⋅ d R } exp { ℏ i ∫ t n − 1 t n H e ( R n − 1 , t ) d t } ] A r ( R 0 , t 0 ) (294)
where M M M represents the number of space-time segments along the contour, Γ s t \Gamma_{st} Γ s t :
Γ s t ≡ ( R 0 , t 0 ) → ( R 0 + δ R , t 0 + δ t ) → ( R M , t M − δ t ) → ( R M , t M ) . (295) \Gamma_{st}\equiv(\boldsymbol{R}_{0},t_{0})\rightarrow(\boldsymbol{R}_{0}+\delta\boldsymbol{R},t_{0}+\delta t)\rightarrow(\boldsymbol{R}_{M},t_{M}-\delta t)\rightarrow(\boldsymbol{R}_{M},t_{M}). \tag*{(295)} Γ s t ≡ ( R 0 , t 0 ) → ( R 0 + δ R , t 0 + δ t ) → ( R M , t M − δ t ) → ( R M , t M ) . (295)
Eq. 5.33 applies for one single contour, but the ADT matrix needs to be calculated for the entire space-time region. Even though there are numerous ways to construct such networks, some of them appear as more efficient than others, but all paths are expected to produce same results. In other words, all the paths are initiated from one single point ( R 0 , t 0 ) (\boldsymbol{R}_{0},t_{0}) ( R 0 , t 0 ) with the same initial ADT matrix, A ~ r ( R 0 , t 0 ) \widetilde{A}_{r}(\boldsymbol{R}_{0},t_{0}) A r ( R 0 , t 0 ) .
Are External Fields Capable of Creating or Annihilating CIs in a Given Region of Space–Time Nuclear Configuration Space?
External fields can shift the potential energy curves or surfaces as well as can change the spatial distributions of NACTs over nuclear space. In other words, it has been explored that whether the strong external field is capable of removing or creating singularities.
Lemma 1.1: A space–time region defined by a closed contour made-up of one Cartesian coordinate (X X X ) and the time t t t is not hosting any CI over R − t R-t R − t plane.
Proof. Generally, the Curl equation arises from the necessity that the ADT matrix, A ~ ( X , t ) \tilde{A}(X,t) A ~ ( X , t ) will be an analytic function with respect to the space coordinates and time. It is interesting to note that the Curl equation:
F X t ( X , t ) = i ℏ ∂ τ ~ X ∂ t − ∂ ∂ R H ~ e + [ H ~ e , τ ~ X ] = 0 (296) F_{Xt}(X,t)=i\hbar\frac{\partial\tilde{\tau}_{X}}{\partial t}-\frac{\partial}{\partial R}\tilde{H}_{e}+[\tilde{H}_{e},\tilde{\tau}_{X}]=0 \tag*{(296)} F X t ( X , t ) = i ℏ ∂ t ∂ τ ~ X − ∂ R ∂ H ~ e + [ H ~ e , τ ~ X ] = 0 (296)
is fulfilled at any point in the X − t X-t X − t plane for any number of states.
It is evident from the fulfillment of the X − t X-t X − t Curl equation at each and every point over the chosen domain of X − t X-t X − t plane that the pathological points (Curl expressions are invalid) are absent over the X − t X-t X − t region. If the functions involved in the Curl equation (ω ( X , t ) \omega(X,t) ω ( X , t ) , H ~ e ( X , t ) \tilde{H}_{e}(X,t) H ~ e ( X , t ) and τ ( X ) \tau(X) τ ( X ) ) are examined, those quantities as well as their derivatives (see Eq. (296) ) are well-defined at every point. On the contrary, CI point is a pathological point and therefore, CIs are not included on the X − t X-t X − t plane.
Lemma 1.2 : If a planar, spacial region, Λ X Y \Lambda_{XY} Λ X Y is defined by a closed contour constructed by two Cartesian coordinates ( X , Y ) (X,Y) ( X , Y ) and if one CI is present at time, t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , one CI will present also at any later time, t > 0 t>0 t > 0 .
Proof: As representative case, we assume that one CI is present at the origin in Λ X Y \Lambda_{XY} Λ X Y so that the t t t axis hosts such CI at { X = 0 , Y = 0 , t = 0 } \{X=0,Y=0,t=0\} { X = 0 , Y = 0 , t = 0 } . The intention is to prove the appearance of similar CI at any later time t > 0 t>0 t > 0 (after activation of the field) along the t t t axis. In order to validate such statement, a planar (spatial) region is constructed at time t = t s t=t_s t = t s parallel to the { X , Y , t = 0 } \{X,Y,t=0\} { X , Y , t = 0 } plane. After that, the t t t -axis is surrounded with a small contour, Γ X Y ( t = t s ) \Gamma_{XY}(t=t_s) Γ X Y ( t = t s ) over that plane and then, the spatial ( X , Y ) (X,Y) ( X , Y ) component of the tensorial Curl equation is analyzed for any point enclosed by Γ X Y ( t = t s ) \Gamma_{XY}(t=t_s) Γ X Y ( t = t s ) . As per the analysis:
∂ ∂ Y τ ~ X ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) − ∂ ∂ X τ ~ Y ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) − [ τ ~ X , τ ~ Y ] ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) = 0 (297) \frac{\partial}{\partial Y}\tilde{\tau}_{X}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s)-\frac{\partial}{\partial X}\tilde{\tau}_{Y}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s)-[\tilde{\tau}_{X},\tilde{\tau}_{Y}](\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s)=0 \tag*{(297)} ∂ Y ∂ τ ~ X ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) − ∂ X ∂ τ ~ Y ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) − [ τ ~ X , τ ~ Y ] ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) = 0 (297)
According to Lemma 1.1, one needs to look for the pathological points, where Eq. (297) is not valid. Such equation encounters three matrices, namely, ω ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) \omega(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s) ω ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) , τ ~ X ( X ~ , Y ~ ) \tilde{\tau}_{X}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}) τ ~ X ( X ~ , Y ~ ) and τ ~ Y ( X ~ , Y ~ ) \tilde{\tau}_{Y}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}) τ ~ Y ( X ~ , Y ~ ) forming τ ~ u ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) \tilde{\tau}_{u}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s) τ ~ u ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) ; ( u = X , Y ) (u=X,Y) ( u = X , Y ) . It is interesting to note that ω ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) \omega(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s) ω ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) represents a regular matrix, but the other two are singular at the origin ( ( X ~ , Y ~ ) = ( 0 , 0 ) ) ((\tilde{X},\tilde{Y})=(0,0)) (( X ~ , Y ~ ) = ( 0 , 0 )) at initial time ( t = 0 ) (t=0) ( t = 0 ) as well as later time ( t = t s ) (t=t_s) ( t = t s ) , since those are time-independent. As a consequence, Eq. (297) is well-defined at every point except for the point of singularity, ( X ~ , Y ~ , t s ) = ( 0 , 0 , t s ) (\tilde{X},\tilde{Y},t_s)=(0,0,t_s) ( X ~ , Y ~ , t s ) = ( 0 , 0 , t s ) , indicating the existence of a CI (single CI) at this point on the above mentioned plane at t = t s t=t_s t = t s . Such finding unveils that, for the case, the t t t -axis generates a (virtual) seam with infinite number of CI points.
Lemma 1.3 : If a planar, spatial region Λ X Y \Lambda_{XY} Λ X Y , defined by a closed contour constituted with two Cartesian coordinates ( X , Y ) (X,Y) ( X , Y ) and if numerous CIs are present at n n n points ( X ~ j , Y j , j = { 1 , n } ) (\tilde{X}_j,Y_j,j=\{1,n\}) ( X ~ j , Y j , j = { 1 , n }) at time, t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , same number of CIs can be observed at any later time t = t s t=t_s t = t s .
Proof: A situation is considered at t = t s t=t_s t = t s , where Eq. (297) is still valid except at the n n n pathological points ( τ ~ u ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) ; ( u = X , Y ) ; j = { 1 , n } (\tilde{\tau}_{u}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y}|t_s);(u=X,Y);j=\{1,n\} ( τ ~ u ( X ~ , Y ~ ∣ t s ) ; ( u = X , Y ) ; j = { 1 , n } are not well-defined). While applying Eq. (282) for the present n n n points, we obtain:
τ ~ ( X ~ , Y ~ , t s ) = ω † τ ~ ( X ~ , Y ~ ) ω + ω † ∇ ω (298) \tilde{\tau}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y},t_s)=\omega^\dagger\tilde{\tau}(\tilde{X},\tilde{Y})\omega+\omega^\dagger\nabla\omega \tag*{(298)} τ ~ ( X ~ , Y ~ , t s ) = ω † τ ~ ( X ~ , Y ~ ) ω + ω † ∇ ω (298)
As per the above equation, all pathological points are encountered at any time, which already exist at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . In summary, pathological points can neither be formed nor annihilated by applying an external field.
Numerical Verification of CIs in Presence of External Field
The potential term due to the external field (E ( r ∣ R , t ) E(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R},t) E ( r ∣ R , t ) ) for a single electron system can be expressed as a line integral in the electronic space:
U E ( r ∣ R , t ) = − e ℏ ∫ Γ e d r ⋅ E ( r ∣ R , t ) (299) U_E(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R},t)=-\frac{e}{\hbar}\int_{\Gamma_e}d\boldsymbol{r}\cdot E(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R},t) \tag*{(299)} U E ( r ∣ R , t ) = − ℏ e ∫ Γ e d r ⋅ E ( r ∣ R , t ) (299)
Here, e e e represents the electronic charge and Γ e \Gamma_e Γ e signifies the corresponding electronic contour. On the other hand, the electronic Hamiltonian in presence of external field interacting with electrons takes the following form:
H e ( r ∣ R , t ) = H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) + U E ( r ∣ R , t ) (300) H_e(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R},t)=H_{e0}(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R})+U_E(\boldsymbol{r}|\boldsymbol{R},t) \tag*{(300)} H e ( r ∣ R , t ) = H e 0 ( r ∣ R ) + U E ( r ∣ R , t ) (300)
Prior to discuss any numerical example, one needs to specify the intense/strong field, which indicates the population of several electronic time independent states. For the present case, the field is capable for populating four states, whereas incorporation of even ten states reaches to the same outcome.
In order to carry out the numerical calculations, a model is considered based on the Mathieu equation:
( − 1 2 d 2 d θ 2 − ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) − u j ( ϕ , ρ ) ) ξ j ( θ ∣ ϕ , ρ ) = 0 (301) \left(-\frac{1}{2}\frac{d^2}{d\theta^2}-\rho\cos(2\theta-\phi)-u_j(\phi,\rho)\right)\xi_j(\theta|\phi,\rho)=0 \tag*{(301)} ( − 2 1 d θ 2 d 2 − ρ cos ( 2 θ − ϕ ) − u j ( ϕ , ρ ) ) ξ j ( θ ∣ ϕ , ρ ) = 0 (301)
where θ \theta θ represents an electronic coordinate, and ϕ \phi ϕ and ρ \rho ρ signify the nuclear coordinates. It is important to note that the variable ρ \rho ρ shows linear dependence on the nuclear radial coordinate. Generally ρ \rho ρ is kept as constant so that the space segments of the contour appear only as a function of ϕ \phi ϕ . The detailed solution of Eq. (301) are present elsewhere24,25.
Once the Mathieu equation is introduced, the next task is to propose the electric field and the associated electric potential, which are employed in this model. In order to present those equations, the electronic contour, Γ e \Gamma_e Γ e is considered to be a circle so that the associated electronic coordinate becomes same as previously mentioned angular vector, θ \theta θ . As a consequence, Eq. (299) is integrated along the angular (tangential) component, whereas the planar components of the field appears as:
E x e ( x e , y e ∣ t ) = − x e E ~ ( t ) (302) E_{x_e}(x_e,y_e|t)=-x_e\widetilde{E}(t) \tag*{(302)} E x e ( x e , y e ∣ t ) = − x e E ( t ) (302)
E y e ( x e , y e ∣ t ) = y e E ~ ( t ) . (303) E_{y_e}(x_e,y_e|t)=y_e\widetilde{E}(t). \tag*{(303)} E y e ( x e , y e ∣ t ) = y e E ( t ) . (303)
Such formulations guarantee that curl E = 0 \operatorname{curl} E=0 curl E = 0 and div E = 0 \operatorname{div} E=0 div E = 0 . Employing such choice, the tangential component of the field appears as:
E θ ( θ , t ) = q e 2 E ~ ( t ) sin 2 θ . (304) E_\theta(\theta,t)=q_e^2\widetilde{E}(t)\sin2\theta. \tag*{(304)} E θ ( θ , t ) = q e 2 E ( t ) sin 2 θ . (304)
Substituting this expression in Eq. (299) , one can obtain the following functional form of the electric potential:
U E ( θ ∣ ϕ , t ) ( ≡ U E ( θ ∣ t ) ) = − e 2 ℏ q e 2 E ~ ( t ) cos 2 θ (305) U_E(\theta|\phi,t)\;(\equiv U_E(\theta|t))=-\frac{e}{2\hbar}q_e^2\widetilde{E}(t)\cos2\theta \tag*{(305)} U E ( θ ∣ ϕ , t ) ( ≡ U E ( θ ∣ t )) = − 2ℏ e q e 2 E ( t ) cos 2 θ (305)
where q e q_e q e represents the electronic radial coordinate. On the other hand, E ~ ( t ) \widetilde{E}(t) E ( t ) takes the following form:
E ~ ( t ) = E 0 sin 2 ( π t / T ) sin ( 2 π t / T ) , (306) \widetilde{E}(t)=E_0\sin^2(\pi t/T)\sin(2\pi t/T), \tag*{(306)} E ( t ) = E 0 sin 2 ( π t / T ) sin ( 2 π t / T ) , (306)
where T T T represents the cycle of the field and E 0 E_0 E 0 contains the other constants in Eq. (305) . In all the calculations, the field intensity is taken as E 0 = 20 E_0=20 E 0 = 20 , which is sufficient to populate several electronic states.
In the space-time framework (space and time segments are mixed), the D D D -matrix (or A A A matrix) needs be calculated using Eq. (294) , where a series of products of exponentiated line integrals is taken (M M M in Eq. (294) is considered as 4) over the space coordinate, ϕ \phi ϕ and time coordinate, t t t . In order to compute the D D D matrix elements, one needs to divide ϕ \phi ϕ and t t t into small sub-segments, and diagonalize τ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\tau}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{H}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) along a grids of angle and time, respectively. Figure 5.1 presents the fourth eigenvalues, τ ~ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{\tau}}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{H}}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) originated from τ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\tau}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{H}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) , respectively along Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ . The red-coloured and grey components represent τ ~ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{\tau}}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{H}}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) , respectively. On the other hand, the contour, Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ is provided in the inset.
Figure 5.1. The fourth eigenvalues τ ~ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{\tau}}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{H}}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) associated with two matrices, τ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\tau}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{H}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) are presented along a closed contour, Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ . The red and grey area show τ ~ ~ ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{\tau}}(\phi,t) τ ( ϕ , t ) and H ~ ~ e ( ϕ , t ) \widetilde{\widetilde{H}}_e(\phi,t) H e ( ϕ , t ) , respectively. The contour, Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ is given in inset. This figure has been taken from Ref. [12] and permission has been taken from AIP.
If one assumes the spatial segments of Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ , (namely, those associated with the fixed-time segments of the contour) to be identical to the field-free, time-independent one, Γ \Gamma Γ , the two D D D -matrices appearing from field-free and field-dressed cases should be identical if and only if the number and/or the positions of the CIs is not affected by the field. Such outcome is reflected in Figure 5.1 . While repeating such calculations for any space-time contour in the assigned domain of nuclear CS, one obtains the same D D D matrices for both cases (field-dressed and field-free), which validates the outcome presented in Figure 5.1 . Along all the contours, even a large number of space/time (i.e., ϕ / t \phi/t ϕ / t ) flippings take place, the final D D D -matrix appears as the unit matrix − I -\mathbf{I} − I . It is important to note that an identical D D D matrix is computed for the field-free Mathieu equation.
Bibliography
Spectroscopic Systems: BBO Based Diabatic Hamiltonian and Quantum Dynamics
Vibronic Coupling Model (VCM)1 had been developed to derive diagonal and off-diagonal elements of diabatic Hamiltonian to generate photodetachment (PD)/photoelectron (PE)/photoabsorption (PA)/Mass-Analyzed Threshold Ionization (MATI) spectra originating from multi-mode multi-electronic systems. While developing such model, 2–6 adiabatic PESs are expanded in Taylor series with respect to the ground adiabatic PES (V 0 ( R 0 ) V_0(\mathbf{R}_0) V 0 ( R 0 ) ) minima or CI (R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 ) and then, the coefficients of linear and bilinear coupling terms are obtained by fitting with the functional forms of couplings calculated in diabatic basis. Zeng et al. 7,8 generalized the VCM based quasi-diabatic Hamiltonian upto arbitrary order and implemented the formalism for trigonal and tetragonal systems. Since VCM based quasi-diabatization approach is based on Taylor series expansion, such model, in principle, is applicable only in a limited domain of Frank-Condon (FC) region close to the reference geometry R 0 \mathbf{R}_0 R 0 . On the contrary, the construction of diabatic Hamiltonian employing Beyond Born-Oppenheimer (BBO) theory is based on ab initio calculated adiabatic potential energy surfaces (PESs) and non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) among all the coupled electronic states and vibrational degrees of freedom (DOFs) over the entire/interested domain of nuclear configuration space (CS), which can not only include the effect of symmetry-driven as well as accidental Jahn-Teller (JT) conical intersections (CIs) and Renner-Teller (RT) interactions, but also locate their positions in the CS within highest level of accuracy.
The first principle based BBO formalism has been employed to construct diabatic Hamiltonian for various spectroscopically interesting molecules 9–24 exhibiting a wide variety of nonadiabatic interactions, namely, JT25–30 CIs/seams (symmetry driven 14 degeneracies), JT type accidental CIs/seams (symmetry allowed 14 or no symmetry 14 degeneracies), RT29,31 interactions and PJT26 interactions. In the last two decades, the BBO based diabatic Hamiltonians (BBO-DH) of alkali trimers (Na3 _3 3 , K3 _3 3 ), 9,10 nitrogen oxides (NO2 _2 2 , NO3 _3 3 ),12,16 benzene radical cation (C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + ), 13,22 1,3,5-trifluorobenzene radical cation (1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^+ 3 + ), 17,23 pyrazine molecule (C4 _4 4 N2 _2 2 H4 _4 4 )24 and ortho-difluorobenzene (o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 _2 2 )32 were constructed to calculate the PD/PE/PA/MATI spectra of their neutral/anionic counterpart using Time-Dependent Discrete Variable Representation (TD DVR)22–24,33–40 approaches.
In order to carry out quantum dynamical calculations for predicting photoelectron/photoabsorption/photo-emission/MATI spectra of realistic molecular species, TD DVR methodology appears as the most suitable approach due to involvement of variable number of time-dependent basis functions along different nuclear coordinates depending upon their role on simultaneous ongoing classical and quantum dynamics. In the recent years, quantum dynamics of nonadiabatic processes 41–47 has been receiving attention of the allied scientific community, specifically for relatively large molecular systems. Though theoretical investigation of nonadiabatic dynamics involving CI(s) requires rigorous quantum mechanical (QM) treatment48, traditional full QM treatment appears as impractical even for three - or four - particle systems, especially when the atoms are heavy, the energy is high and multiple PESs are involved. In order to get rid of such shortcomings, a quantum-classical molecular dynamics approach49–51 were implemented to include quantum correction to the classical mechanics leading to a first principle based theory of dynamics. Such a theory can efficiently distinguish dynamical strong quantum regimes of a system from quasi-classical one, where the later incorporates mild quantum corrections as per the requirement. The quantum-classical approaches with time-dependent basis functions/grid-points effectively attain convergence very fast saving a huge computation time.
At the end of the nineties of the last century, Adhikari and Billing52,53 introduced a unique approach, namely, TDDVR methodology to perform multi-state (electronic) multi-dimensional (vibrational) quantum dynamics considering all the parameters of Gauss-Hermite (GH) basis functions as time dependent. Later on, such approach was reformulated40,51,54 using time-independent width parameters of GH basis functions, where rest of the parameters, viz., center of the wavepacket and its momentum were introduced as time-dependent. In this formalism, blending of classical and quantum dynamics effectively becomes beneficial to reduce the necessity of higher number of basis functions (grid points) for each mode in contrary to Fast-Fourier Transformation (FFT) based algorithms. Over the decades, TDDVR dynamics were being carried out over VCM based quasi-diabatic PESs and couplings to generate high resolution spectral envelops of a variety of prototypical multi-mode multi-surface molecular systems, viz., pyrazine,55,56 butatriene,37 benzene,22,38,39,57 allene,33 monofluoro benzene,58 isomers of difluoro benzene,35 trifluoro acetonitrile36 and many others. In addition, the better accuracy and computational advantage of the TDDVR approach over certain versions of the Multi-Configuration Time-Dependent Hartree (MCTDH) method were depicted for two well-known aromatic molecules, napthalene and anthracene.34 Adhikari and coworkers have executed TDDVR dynamics using BBO generated diabatic Hamiltonians of benzene radical cation (C 6 H 6 + \mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}^{+} C 6 H 6 + ),22 trifluorobenzene radical cation (1 , 3 , 5 - C 6 H 3 F 3 + \mathrm{1,3,5\text{-}C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{3}\mathrm{F}_{3}^{+} 1 , 3 , 5 - C 6 H 3 F 3 + ),23 pyrazine (C 4 H 4 N 2 \mathrm{C}_{4}\mathrm{H}_{4}\mathrm{N}_{2} C 4 H 4 N 2 ),24 and ortho-difluorobenzene (o - C 6 H 4 F 2 + \mathrm{o\text{-}C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{4}\mathrm{F}_{2}^{+} o - C 6 H 4 F 2 + )32 compute the PE / PA / MATI spectra of their neutral or higher negative analogue. Once those quantities (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) are in hand, those are employed in BBO based diabatization and the newly generated first principle based diabatic Hamiltonian is used for the execution of dynamical calculations with the aim of generating PE/PA/MATI spectra.
Outline of BBO Theory for Spectroscopic Processes
Since the molecular properties originate from the total electron-nuclear Hamiltonian, one can start the formulation of BBO theory from the time independent molecular SE. Even though an extensive discussion on the theoretical background of such theory is done in Chapter 4, we present a brief outline of such formalism here for the sake of completeness as well as to bring its compatibility for constructing diabatic Hamiltonian to calculate molecular spectra. Such spectroscopically interesting Hamiltonian involves multiple electronic states as well as multiple nuclear degrees of freedom (normal modes). The formalism starts from the following time independent molecular SE:
H ^ ( q e , Q n ) Ψ ( q e , Q n ) = E Ψ ( q e , Q n ) , (307) \hat{H}(q_e,Q_n)\Psi(q_e,Q_n)=E\Psi(q_e,Q_n), \tag*{(307)} H ^ ( q e , Q n ) Ψ ( q e , Q n ) = E Ψ ( q e , Q n ) , (307)
where q e q_e q e and Q n Q_n Q n collectively represent the electronic and nuclear coordinate vectors, respectively. In the above equation, the non-relativistic molecular Hamiltonian [ H ^ ( q e , Q n ) ] [\hat{H}(q_e,Q_n)] [ H ^ ( q e , Q n )] can be partitioned into two parts, namely, nuclear kinetic energy operator [ T ^ n u c ( Q n ) ] [\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(Q_n)] [ T ^ nuc ( Q n )] and electronic Hamiltonian [ H ^ e l ( q e ; Q n ) ] [\hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(q_e;Q_n)] [ H ^ el ( q e ; Q n )] as follows,
H ^ ( q e , Q n ) = T ^ n u c ( Q n ) + H ^ e l ( q e ; Q n ) . (308) \hat{H}(q_e,Q_n)=\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(Q_n)+\hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(q_e;Q_n). \tag*{(308)} H ^ ( q e , Q n ) = T ^ nuc ( Q n ) + H ^ el ( q e ; Q n ) . (308)
On the other hand, well known Born-Oppenheimer-Huang (BOH) expansion59,60 tells that total molecular wavefunction [ Ψ ( q e , Q n ) ] [\Psi(q_e,Q_n)] [ Ψ ( q e , Q n )] for any n n n -state SHS achieves the following form:
Ψ ( q e , Q n ) = ∑ i = 1 n ψ i a d ( Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) , (309) \Psi(\mathbf{q}_{e},\mathbf{Q}_{n}) = \sum_{i=1}^{n} \psi_{i}^{\mathrm{ad}}(\mathbf{Q}_{n})\xi_{i}(\mathbf{q}_{e};\mathbf{Q}_{n}), \tag*{(309)} Ψ ( q e , Q n ) = i = 1 ∑ n ψ i ad ( Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) , (309)
where the combining coefficients { ψ i a d ( Q n ) } \{\psi_{i}^{\mathrm{ad}}(\mathbf{Q}_{n})\} { ψ i ad ( Q n )} represent nuclear wavefunctions. In the above BOH expanded molecular wavefunction, the eigenfunctions of the electronic SE can be presented as { ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) } \{\xi_{i}(\mathbf{q}_{e};\mathbf{Q}_{n})\} { ξ i ( q e ; Q n )} :
H ^ e l ( q e ; Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) = u i ( Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) , ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e = δ i j , (310) \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{q}_{e};\mathbf{Q}_{n})\xi_{i}(\mathbf{q}_{e};\mathbf{Q}_{n}) = u_{i}(\mathbf{Q}_{n})\xi_{i}(\mathbf{q}_{e};\mathbf{Q}_{n}), \qquad\langle\xi_{i}|\xi_{j}\rangle_{\mathbf{q}_{e}} = \delta_{ij}, \tag*{(310)} H ^ el ( q e ; Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) = u i ( Q n ) ξ i ( q e ; Q n ) , ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e = δ ij , (310)
The adiabatic PESs (u i ( Q n ) u_{i}(\mathbf{Q}_{n}) u i ( Q n ) ) originate from the eigenvalues of electronic SE ({ u i ( Q n ) } \{u_{i}(\mathbf{Q}_{n})\} { u i ( Q n )} ), whereas the integral, ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e \langle\xi_{i}|\xi_{j}\rangle_{\mathbf{q}_{e}} ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e depicts the inner product between two electronic states over electronic coordinates only.
If Eqs. (308) , (309) and (310) are plugged in the time independent molecular SE (Eq. (307) ) followed by projecting with various electronic eigenfunctions, the kinetically coupled (adiabatic) nuclear SE takes the following matrix form:
− ℏ 2 2 ( ∇ Q n + τ ) 2 ψ a d + ( U − E ) ψ a d = 0 , (311) -\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2}(\nabla_{\mathbf{Q}_{n}}+\boldsymbol{\tau})^{2}\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}+(U-E)\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=0, \tag*{(311)} − 2 ℏ 2 ( ∇ Q n + τ ) 2 ψ ad + ( U − E ) ψ ad = 0 , (311)
where U i j ( Q n ) ( = u j ( Q n ) δ i j ) U_{ij}(\mathbf{Q}_{n}) (=u_{j}(\mathbf{Q}_{n})\delta_{ij}) U ij ( Q n ) ( = u j ( Q n ) δ ij ) symbolizes the adiabatic PESs matrix elements. On the other hand, for n n n electronic state sub-Hilbert space, the skew-symmetric NACM can be written as:
τ = ( 0 τ 12 τ 13 ⋯ − τ 12 0 τ 23 ⋯ − τ 13 − τ 23 0 ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ) (312) \boldsymbol{\tau} =
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & \tau_{12} & \tau_{13} & \cdots\\
-\tau_{12} & 0 & \tau_{23} & \cdots\\
-\tau_{13} & -\tau_{23} & 0 & \cdots\\
\cdots& \cdots& \cdots& \cdots
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(312)} τ = 0 − τ 12 − τ 13 ⋯ τ 12 0 − τ 23 ⋯ τ 13 τ 23 0 ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ (312)
It is interesting to note that the NACM elements exhibits singular behavior at the close neighborhood of CI point(s) or along seam(s) of degeneracy between two electronic states. Such singular characteristics can be unveiled from the following expression as per Hellmann-Feynman theorem.61,62
τ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ Q n H ^ e l ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e u j − u i . (313) \tau_{ij}=\frac{\langle\xi_{i}|\nabla_{\mathbf{Q}_{n}}\hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}|\xi_{j}\rangle_{\mathbf{q}_{e}}}{u_{j}-u_{i}}. \tag*{(313)} τ ij = u j − u i ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ Q n H ^ el ∣ ξ j ⟩ q e . (313)
In order to overcome the bottleneck of such singularity(ies), a paradigm shift from adiabatic to diabatic SE can be done using the transformation ψ a d = A ψ d i a \psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=A\psi^{\mathrm{dia}} ψ ad = A ψ dia leading to the orthogonal features of A A A for the chosen SHS. Using such transformation, one can arrive the following matrix form of diabatic nuclear SE:
( − ℏ 2 2 ∇ Q 2 + W − E ) ψ d i a = 0 , W = A † U A (314) \left(-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2}\nabla_{\mathbf{Q}}^{2}+W-E\right)\psi^{\mathrm{dia}}=0,\qquad W=A^{\dagger}UA \tag*{(314)} ( − 2 ℏ 2 ∇ Q 2 + W − E ) ψ dia = 0 , W = A † U A (314)
invoking the ADT condition:
∇ Q n A + τ A = 0. (315) \nabla_{\mathbf{Q}_{n}}A+\boldsymbol{\tau}A=0. \tag*{(315)} ∇ Q n A + τ A = 0. (315)
The explicit expression of ADT equations for two and three electronic states are presented in Eqs. (198) and (199) , whereas the ADT equations for four to six states are presented in Appendix B.1.
In order to carry out the BBO based diabatization, ab initio computed NACTs are substituted into ADT equations and then, those equations are numerically solved to obtain the ADT angles. Once the mixing angles are in hand, those are used to form the ADT matrices and thereby, similarity transformation (Eq. (314) ) is executed for the construction of smooth, single-valued and continuous diabatic PESs and couplings.
Theoretical Background of TDDVR Methodology
Once diabatic Hamiltonian is constructed, those matrices (PESs and couplings) can be used in nuclear dynamical calculations. In this context, TDDVR approach appears as the most suitable one. Such formalism can be applied for low dimensional model problems 33,63 as well as multi-dimensional multi-surface realistic systems, 34,38,39,57 equally, which endorses that the complexity of the Hamiltonian is not a matter of concern. In case of a multi-dimensional multi-surface molecular system, the time dependent Schrödinger Equation (TDSE) in the diabatic representation takes the following form:
i ℏ ∂ ∂ t Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) = [ T ^ n u c ( { Q k } ) + W ^ ( { Q k } ) ] Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) , (316) \mathrm{i}\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\Xi(\{Q_k\},t)=\left[\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\{Q_k\})+\hat{W}(\{Q_k\})\right]\Xi(\{Q_k\},t), \tag*{(316)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) = [ T ^ nuc ({ Q k }) + W ^ ({ Q k }) ] Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) , (316)
where T ^ n u c ( { Q k } ) = ( T ^ n u c ( { Q k } ) ⋅ I ) \hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\{Q_k\})=(\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\{Q_k\})\cdot\mathbf{I}) T ^ nuc ({ Q k }) = ( T ^ nuc ({ Q k }) ⋅ I ) and W ^ ( { Q k } ) \hat{W}(\{Q_k\}) W ^ ({ Q k }) represent kinetic energy operator and diabatic PESs matrices, respectively, which are functions of the normal mode coordinates, { Q k } \{Q_k\} { Q k } . On the other hand, the nuclear wavefunction for l l l electronic states appears as:
Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) ≡ ( ψ 1 d ( { Q k } , t ) ψ 2 d ( { Q k } , t ) ⋮ ψ l d ( { Q k } , t ) ⋮ ) (317) \Xi(\{Q_k\},t)\equiv
\begin{pmatrix}
\psi^{d}_{1}(\{Q_k\},t)\\
\psi^{d}_{2}(\{Q_k\},t)\\
\vdots\\
\psi^{d}_{l}(\{Q_k\},t)\\
\vdots
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(317)} Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) ≡ ψ 1 d ({ Q k } , t ) ψ 2 d ({ Q k } , t ) ⋮ ψ l d ({ Q k } , t ) ⋮ (317)
where ∫ Ξ † ( { Q k } , t ) Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) ∏ k = 1 p d Q k = 1 \int\Xi^{\dagger}(\{Q_k\},t)\Xi(\{Q_k\},t)\prod_{k=1}^{p}dQ_k=1 ∫ Ξ † ({ Q k } , t ) Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) ∏ k = 1 p d Q k = 1 holds true at any time t t t . While expanding the l t h l^{\mathrm{th}} l th element of the above column matrix (see Eq. (317) ), i.e., the wavefunction for the l t h l^{\mathrm{th}} l th surface (ψ l d ( { Q k } , t ) \psi^{d}_{l}(\{Q_k\},t) ψ l d ({ Q k } , t ) ), one can obtain the following form,
ψ l d ( { Q k } , t ) = ∑ i 1 i 2 … i p c i 1 i 2 … i p , l d ( t ) ∏ k = 1 p χ i k ( Q k , t ) , (318) \psi^{d}_{l}(\{Q_k\},t)=\sum_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p}c^{d}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}(t)\prod_{k=1}^{p}\chi_{i_k}(Q_k,t), \tag*{(318)} ψ l d ({ Q k } , t ) = i 1 i 2 … i p ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i p , l d ( t ) k = 1 ∏ p χ i k ( Q k , t ) , (318)
where p p p represents the number of normal modes and χ i k ( Q k , t ) \chi_{i_k}(Q_k,t) χ i k ( Q k , t ) symbolizes the TDDVR basis function associated with k t h k^{\mathrm{th}} k th normal mode. On the other hand, that basis function is originated from multiplication of Discrete Variable Representation (DVR) basis and time-dependent plane wave as follows,
χ i k ( Q k , t ) = ϕ ( Q k , t ) ∑ n = 0 N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) ζ n ( x k ) (319) \chi_{i_k}(Q_k,t)=\phi(Q_k,t)\sum_{n=0}^{N_k}\zeta_n^{*}(x_{i_k})\zeta_n(x_k) \tag*{(319)} χ i k ( Q k , t ) = ϕ ( Q k , t ) n = 0 ∑ N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) ζ n ( x k ) (319)
= ∑ n = 0 N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) , (320) =\sum_{n=0}^{N_k}\zeta_n^{*}(x_{i_k})\Phi_n(Q_k,t), \tag*{(320)} = n = 0 ∑ N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) , (320)
where
ϕ ( Q k , t ) = π 1 / 4 exp ( i ℏ { p Q k c ( t ) [ Q k − Q k c ( t ) ] } ) . (321) \phi(Q_k,t)=\pi^{1/4}\exp\left(\frac{\mathrm{i}}{\hbar}\left\{p_{Q_k}^{c}(t)[Q_k-Q_k^{c}(t)]\right\}\right). \tag*{(321)} ϕ ( Q k , t ) = π 1/4 exp ( ℏ i { p Q k c ( t ) [ Q k − Q k c ( t )] } ) . (321)
In Eq. (319) , the following harmonic oscillator eigenfunctions can be used as the primitive bases to construct DVR functions,
ζ n ( x k ) = ( 2 I m A k π ℏ ) 1 / 4 1 n ! 2 n π exp { − ( x k ) 2 / 2 } H n ( x k ) , (322) \zeta_n(x_k)=\left(\frac{2ImA_k}{\pi\hbar}\right)^{1/4}\frac{1}{\sqrt{n!2^n\sqrt{\pi}}}\exp\left\{-(x_k)^2/2\right\}H_n(x_k), \tag*{(322)} ζ n ( x k ) = ( π ℏ 2 I m A k ) 1/4 n ! 2 n π 1 exp { − ( x k ) 2 /2 } H n ( x k ) , (322)
where
x k = 2 I m A k ℏ ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) . (323) x_k=\sqrt{\frac{2ImA_k}{\hbar}}(Q_k-Q_k^{c}(t)). \tag*{(323)} x k = ℏ 2 I m A k ( Q k − Q k c ( t )) . (323)
In a similar way, x i k x_{ik} x ik takes the following form,
x i k = 2 Im A k ℏ ( Q i k ( t ) − Q k c ( t ) ) . (324) x_{ik}=\sqrt{\frac{2\operatorname{Im}A_k}{\hbar}}\left(Q_{ik}(t)-Q_k^c(t)\right). \tag*{(324)} x ik = ℏ 2 Im A k ( Q ik ( t ) − Q k c ( t ) ) . (324)
It is interesting to note that throughout the above expressions (Eqs. (318) - (324) ), the center of the wavepacket ({ Q k c } \{Q_k^c\} { Q k c } ) and its momentum ({ p Q k c } \{p_{Q_k}^c\} { p Q k c } ) are considered as time-dependent, whereas imaginary part of the width ({ Im A k } \{\operatorname{Im}A_k\} { Im A k } ) is taken as time-independent.54 In Eq. (320) , the Gauss-Hermite (G-H) basis for the k t h k^{th} k t h mode is denoted as Φ n ( Q k , t ) \Phi_n(Q_k,t) Φ n ( Q k , t ) satisfying the orthonormal condition,
∫ d Q k Φ m ∗ ( Q k , t ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) = δ m n k , (325) \int dQ_k\Phi_m^*(Q_k,t)\Phi_n(Q_k,t)=\delta_{mn}^k, \tag*{(325)} ∫ d Q k Φ m ∗ ( Q k , t ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) = δ mn k , (325)
where GWP is the ground state of G-H basis. On the other hand, the TDDVR basis functions, χ i k \chi_{i_k} χ i k s, in Eq. (319) for the k t h k^{th} k t h mode constitute an orthogonal set, but not normalized,
∫ d Q k χ i k ∗ ( Q k , t ) χ i k ′ ( Q k , t ) = δ i k i k ′ k A i k ′ i k ′ k , (326) \int dQ_k\chi_{i_k}^*(Q_k,t)\chi_{i'_k}(Q_k,t)=\delta_{i_ki'_k}^k A_{i'_ki'_k}^k, \tag*{(326)} ∫ d Q k χ i k ∗ ( Q k , t ) χ i k ′ ( Q k , t ) = δ i k i k ′ k A i k ′ i k ′ k , (326)
where prefactor A k A^k A k indicates the normalization factor. If Eq. (324) is rearranged, one can obtain the TDDVR grid-point, Q i k Q_{ik} Q ik using the root (x i k k x_{i_k}^k x i k k ) of N k t h N_k^{th} N k t h Hermite polynomial, H N k ( x k ) H_{N_k}(x_k) H N k ( x k ) :
Q i k ( t ) = Q k c ( t ) + ℏ 2 Im A k x i k k . (327) Q_{ik}(t)=Q_k^c(t)+\sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{2\operatorname{Im}A_k}}x_{i_k}^k. \tag*{(327)} Q ik ( t ) = Q k c ( t ) + 2 Im A k ℏ x i k k . (327)
Even though roots (x i k x_{i_k} x i k s) are fixed values, Q i k Q_{ik} Q ik s appear as time-dependent due to involvement of time in the variables, Q k c ( t ) Q_k^c(t) Q k c ( t ) .
If the TDDVR representation of wavefunctions (Eqs. (317) - (324) ) are plugged in the TDSE (Eq. (316) ), the classical path picture as well as quantum equation of motion appear simultaneously. For the quantum equation of motion on the l t h l^{th} l t h PES, the following matrix form of TDDVR equation can be obtained,
i ℏ A C ˙ l d = H l l t C l d + A ∑ l ′ ≠ l W l l ′ C l ′ d (328) i\hbar A\dot{C}_l^d=H_{ll}^tC_l^d+A\sum_{l'\ne l}W_{ll'}C_{l'}^d \tag*{(328)} i ℏ A C ˙ l d = H l l t C l d + A l ′ = l ∑ W l l ′ C l ′ d (328)
which can be transformed into a more compact form with the help of a similarity transformation,
i ℏ D ˙ l d ( t ) = A − 1 / 2 H l l t A − 1 / 2 D l d + ∑ l ′ ≠ l W l l ′ D l ′ d (329) i\hbar\dot{D}_l^d(t)=A^{-1/2}H_{ll}^tA^{-1/2}D_l^d+\sum_{l'\ne l}W_{ll'}D_{l'}^d \tag*{(329)} i ℏ D ˙ l d ( t ) = A − 1/2 H l l t A − 1/2 D l d + l ′ = l ∑ W l l ′ D l ′ d (329)
considering D l d = A 1 / 2 C l d D_l^d=A^{1/2}C_l^d D l d = A 1/2 C l d . The superscript ‘d’ specifies the diabatic representation and the elements of D d D^d D d are denoted as d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l} d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d . The expressions of the TDDVR coefficients, d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l} d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d take the following form,
i ℏ d ˙ i 1 i 2 … i p , l d = 1 2 { ∑ k Q ˙ k c ℏ Im A k X ˉ i k i k ′ k } d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + { ∑ k μ ( s ˙ c k ) 2 2 } d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + W l l ( i 1 i 2 … i p ) d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + ∑ l ′ ≠ l W l l ′ ( i 1 i 1 … i p ) d i 1 i 2 … i p , l ′ d + ∑ k { ℏ Im A k 2 μ ∑ i 1 ′ i 2 ′ … i p ′ Y ˉ i k i k ′ k d i 1 ′ i 2 ′ … i p ′ , l d ∏ k ′ ≠ k δ i k ′ i k ′ ′ } . (330) \begin{aligned}
i\hbar\dot{d}^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}
={}&\frac{1}{2}\left\{\sum_k\dot{Q}_k^c\sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{\operatorname{Im}A^k}}\bar{X}^k_{i_ki'_k}\right\}d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}
+\left\{\sum_k\frac{\mu(\dot{s}_c^k)^2}{2}\right\}d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}\\
&+W_{ll}(i_1i_2\ldots i_p)d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}
+\sum_{l'\ne l}W_{ll'}(i_1i_1\ldots i_p)d^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l'}\\
&+\sum_k\left\{\frac{\hbar\operatorname{Im}A^k}{2\mu}\sum_{i'_1i'_2\ldots i'_p}\bar{Y}^k_{i_ki'_k}d^d_{i'_1i'_2\ldots i'_p,l}\prod_{k'\ne k}\delta_{i_{k'}i'_{k'}}\right\}. \tag*{(330)}
\end{aligned} i ℏ d ˙ i 1 i 2 … i p , l d = 2 1 { k ∑ Q ˙ k c Im A k ℏ X ˉ i k i k ′ k } d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + { k ∑ 2 μ ( s ˙ c k ) 2 } d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + W l l ( i 1 i 2 … i p ) d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d + l ′ = l ∑ W l l ′ ( i 1 i 1 … i p ) d i 1 i 2 … i p , l ′ d + k ∑ ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 2 μ ℏ Im A k i 1 ′ i 2 ′ … i p ′ ∑ Y ˉ i k i k ′ k d i 1 ′ i 2 ′ … i p ′ , l d k ′ = k ∏ δ i k ′ i k ′ ′ ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ . (330)
where
X ˉ i k i k ′ k = X i k i k ′ k A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k , Y ˉ i k i k ′ k = Y i k i k ′ k A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k , 2 E i k i k ′ k − F i k i k ′ k A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k \bar{X}^k_{i_ki'_k}=\frac{X^k_{i_ki'_k}}{\sqrt{A^k_{i_k,i_k}A^k_{i'_k,i'_k}}},\qquad
\bar{Y}^k_{i_ki'_k}=\frac{Y^k_{i_ki'_k}}{\sqrt{A^k_{i_k,i_k}A^k_{i'_k,i'_k}}},\qquad
\frac{2E^k_{i_ki'_k}-F^k_{i_ki'_k}}{\sqrt{A^k_{i_k,i_k}A^k_{i'_k,i'_k}}} X ˉ i k i k ′ k = A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k X i k i k ′ k , Y ˉ i k i k ′ k = A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k Y i k i k ′ k , A i k , i k k A i k ′ , i k ′ k 2 E i k i k ′ k − F i k i k ′ k
d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d = c i 1 i 2 … i p , l d ∏ k = 1 p ( A i k , i k k ) 1 2 , d^{d}_{i_{1}i_{2}\ldots i_{p},l}=c^{d}_{i_{1}i_{2}\ldots i_{p},l}\prod_{k=1}^{p}\left(A^{k}_{i_{k},i_{k}}\right)^{\frac{1}{2}}, d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d = c i 1 i 2 … i p , l d k = 1 ∏ p ( A i k , i k k ) 2 1 ,
A i k , i k ′ k = ∑ n = 0 N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) , A^{k}_{i_{k},i'_{k}}=\sum_{n=0}^{N^{k}}\xi^{*}_{n}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}}), A i k , i k ′ k = n = 0 ∑ N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) ,
X i k , i k ′ k = ∑ n = 0 N k − 1 ξ n + 1 ∗ ( x i k k ) n + 1 ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + ∑ n = 1 N k ξ n − 1 ∗ ( x i k k ) n ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) , X^{k}_{i_{k},i'_{k}}=\sum_{n=0}^{N^{k}-1}\xi^{*}_{n+1}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})\sqrt{n+1}\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}})+\sum_{n=1}^{N^{k}}\xi^{*}_{n-1}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})\sqrt{n}\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}}), X i k , i k ′ k = n = 0 ∑ N k − 1 ξ n + 1 ∗ ( x i k k ) n + 1 ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + n = 1 ∑ N k ξ n − 1 ∗ ( x i k k ) n ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) ,
E i k , i k ′ k = ∑ n = 0 N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) 2 n ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) , E^{k}_{i_{k},i'_{k}}=\sum_{n=0}^{N^{k}}\xi^{*}_{n}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})2n\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}}), E i k , i k ′ k = n = 0 ∑ N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) 2 n ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) ,
F i k , i k ′ k = ∑ n = 0 N k − 2 ξ n + 2 ∗ ( x i k k ) ( n + 1 ) ( n + 2 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + ∑ n = 2 N k ξ n − 2 ∗ ( x i k k ) n ( n − 1 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + ∑ n = 0 N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) ( 2 n + 1 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) \begin{aligned}
F^{k}_{i_{k},i'_{k}}={}&\sum_{n=0}^{N^{k}-2}\xi^{*}_{n+2}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})\sqrt{(n+1)(n+2)}\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}})+\sum_{n=2}^{N^{k}}\xi^{*}_{n-2}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})\sqrt{n(n-1)}\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}})\\
&+\sum_{n=0}^{N^{k}}\xi^{*}_{n}(x^{k}_{i_{k}})(2n+1)\xi_{n}(x^{k}_{i'_{k}})
\end{aligned} F i k , i k ′ k = n = 0 ∑ N k − 2 ξ n + 2 ∗ ( x i k k ) ( n + 1 ) ( n + 2 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + n = 2 ∑ N k ξ n − 2 ∗ ( x i k k ) n ( n − 1 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k ) + n = 0 ∑ N k ξ n ∗ ( x i k k ) ( 2 n + 1 ) ξ n ( x i k ′ k )
The time-independent components ({ A k } \{A^{k}\} { A k } , { X k } \{X^{k}\} { X k } , { E k } \{E^{k}\} { E k } , { F k } \{F^{k}\} { F k } ) of the TDDVR Hamiltonian matrix [Eq. 6.24] need to be calculated once for all, which are highly significant due to the quantum-classical nature of this approach. The diagonal { X k } \{X^{k}\} { X k } matrix is multiplied with the “classical” variables, { p ˙ Q k c ( t ) } \{\dot{p}_{Q^{c}_{k}}(t)\} { p ˙ Q k c ( t )} and hence, no non-linearity appears in the quantum equations of motion due to “classical” motion. In other words, “classical” mechanics can only govern the convergence of the quantum dynamics. On the other hand, the full matrices, { E k } \{E^{k}\} { E k } and { F k } \{F^{k}\} { F k } posses the couplings among the grid-points, which are free from any non-linearity due to “classical” propagation due to time-independent variable, { Im A k } \{\operatorname{Im}A^{k}\} { Im A k } . Eq. (330) clearly shows that { E k } \{E^{k}\} { E k } and { F k } \{F^{k}\} { F k } matrices couple grid-points or basis function for the k k k th mode only indicating that one can employ parallel computation while solving the differential equation for each mode numerically. This can become helpful for reducing the computational cost even for large dimensional calculations.
On the other hand, the classical equations of motion (EOMs) for the k t h k^{th} k t h mode can be written as,
Q ˙ k c ( t ) = p Q k c ( t ) μ , (331) \dot{Q}^{c}_{k}(t)=\frac{p^{c}_{Q_{k}}(t)}{\mu}, \tag*{(331)} Q ˙ k c ( t ) = μ p Q k c ( t ) , (331)
p ˙ Q k c ( t ) = − d W ( { Q k } ) d Q k ∣ Q k ( t ) = Q k c ( t ) . (332) \dot{p}^{c}_{Q_{k}}(t)=-\left.\frac{dW(\{Q_{k}\})}{dQ_{k}}\right|_{Q_{k}(t)=Q^{c}_{k}(t)}. \tag*{(332)} p ˙ Q k c ( t ) = − d Q k d W ({ Q k }) Q k ( t ) = Q k c ( t ) . (332)
The first principle based rigorous expression of p ˙ Q k c \dot{p}^{c}_{Q_{k}} p ˙ Q k c for multi-dimensional multi-surface systems can be derived employing Dirac-Frenkel variational principle,64 in the following way:
I = ∫ ( − i ℏ ∂ Ξ ∗ ( { Q k } , t ) ∂ t − H ( { p Q k } , { Q k } ) Ξ ∗ ( { Q k } , t ) ) × ( i ℏ ∂ Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) ∂ t − H ( { p Q k } , { Q k } ) Ξ ( { Q k } , t ) ) ∏ k = 1 p d Q k , (333) \begin{aligned}
I={}&\int\left(-i\hbar\frac{\partial\Xi^{*}(\{Q_{k}\},t)}{\partial t}-H(\{p_{Q_{k}}\},\{Q_{k}\})\Xi^{*}(\{Q_{k}\},t)\right)\\
&\times\left(i\hbar\frac{\partial\Xi(\{Q_{k}\},t)}{\partial t}-H(\{p_{Q_{k}}\},\{Q_{k}\})\Xi(\{Q_{k}\},t)\right)\prod_{k=1}^{p}dQ_{k}, \tag*{(333)}
\end{aligned} I = ∫ ( − i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Ξ ∗ ({ Q k } , t ) − H ({ p Q k } , { Q k }) Ξ ∗ ({ Q k } , t ) ) × ( i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) − H ({ p Q k } , { Q k }) Ξ ({ Q k } , t ) ) k = 1 ∏ p d Q k , (333)
with respect to { p ˙ Q k c } \{\dot{p}^{c}_{Q_{k}}\} { p ˙ Q k c } . The explicit form of { p ˙ Q k c } \{\dot{p}^{c}_{Q_{k}}\} { p ˙ Q k c } appears as:
Theoretical Background of TDDVR Methodology
p ˙ Q k ( t ) = [ 2 ( Im A k ) 2 μ { ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ ′ i k ′ ( 2 ) A i k ′ i k ′ k S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) S i k ′ ′ i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) A i k i k k c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 3 ) } − ℏ Im A k μ { ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ( t ) R i k ′ i k ′ ′ ∗ A i k ′ i k ′ k S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) R i k ′ ′ i k ′ ∗ A i k i k k c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) T i k i k ′ ∗ } / [ ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ ′ i k ′ ( 1 ) A i k ′ i k ′ k S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ i k ′ ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ ′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) S i k ′ ′ i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) A i k i k k c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) ] . (334) \begin{aligned}
\dot{p}_{Q_k}(t)={}&[\frac{2(\operatorname{Im}A^k)^2}{\mu}\{\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{(2)}_{i''_k i'_k}}{A^k_{i'_k i'_k}}\;S^{*(1)}_{i_k i'_k}\\
&+\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(2)}_{i''_k i'_k}}{A^k_{i_k i_k}}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(1)}_{i'_k i_k}\\
&-2\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(3)}_{i_k i'_k}\}\\
&-\frac{\hbar\operatorname{Im}A^k}{\mu}\{\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)R^*_{i'_k i''_k}}{A^k_{i'_k i'_k}}S^{*(1)}_{i_k i'_k}\\
&+\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)R^*_{i''_k i'_k}}{A^k_{i_k i_k}}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(1)}_{i'_k i_k}\\
&-2\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)T^*_{i_k i'_k}\}\\
&\bigg/[\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{(1)}_{i''_k i'_k}}{A^k_{i'_k i'_k}}S^{*(1)}_{i_k i'_k}\\
&+\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}\frac{\sum_{i''_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i''_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(1)}_{i''_k i'_k}}{A^k_{i_k i_k}}c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(1)}_{i'_k i_k}\\
&-2\sum_l\sum_{i_k i'_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2\ldots i_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)c^d_{i_1i_2\ldots i'_k\ldots i_p,l}(t)S^{*(2)}_{i_k i'_k}]. \tag*{(334)}
\end{aligned} p ˙ Q k ( t ) = [ μ 2 ( Im A k ) 2 { l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) A i k ′ i k ′ k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′′ i k ′ ( 2 ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ A i k i k k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) S i k ′′ i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 3 ) } − μ ℏ Im A k { l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) A i k ′ i k ′ k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ( t ) R i k ′ i k ′′ ∗ S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ A i k i k k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) R i k ′′ i k ′ ∗ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) T i k i k ′ ∗ } / [ l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) A i k ′ i k ′ k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′′ i k ′ ( 1 ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) + l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ A i k i k k ∑ i k ′′ c i 1 i 2 … i k ′′ … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) S i k ′′ i k ′ ∗ ( 1 ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k ′ i k ∗ ( 1 ) − 2 l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 … i k … i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 … i k ′ … i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) ] . (334)
where c d ∗ c^{d*} c d ∗ is the complex conjugate of c d c^d c d and
R i k i k ′ = ∑ p ζ p ∗ ( x i k k ) ζ p ( x i k ′ k ) 2 p R_{i_k i'_k}=\sum_p\zeta_p^*(x^k_{i_k})\zeta_p(x^k_{i'_k})2p R i k i k ′ = p ∑ ζ p ∗ ( x i k k ) ζ p ( x i k ′ k ) 2 p
S i k i k ′ ( n ) = ∑ p q ζ p ∗ ( x i k k ) ζ q ( x i k ′ k ) ∫ Φ q ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) n Φ p ( Q k , t ) d Q k S^{(n)}_{i_k i'_k}=\sum_{pq}\zeta_p^*(x^k_{i_k})\zeta_q(x^k_{i'_k})\int\Phi_q^*(Q_k,t)(Q_k-Q_k^c(t))^n\Phi_p(Q_k,t)dQ_k S i k i k ′ ( n ) = pq ∑ ζ p ∗ ( x i k k ) ζ q ( x i k ′ k ) ∫ Φ q ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) n Φ p ( Q k , t ) d Q k
T i k i k ′ = ∑ p q ζ p ( x i k k ) ζ q ∗ ( x i k ′ k ) 2 p ∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k (335) T_{i_k i'_k}=\sum_{pq}\zeta_p(x^k_{i_k})\zeta_q^*(x^k_{i'_k})2p\int\Phi_p^*(Q_k,t)(Q_k-Q_k^c(t))\Phi_q(Q_k,t)dQ_k \tag*{(335)} T i k i k ′ = pq ∑ ζ p ( x i k k ) ζ q ∗ ( x i k ′ k ) 2 p ∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t )) Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k (335)
with
∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = 1 2 ℏ Im A k { p + 1 δ p + 1 , q + p δ p − 1 , q } \int\Phi_p^*(Q_k,t)(Q_k-Q_k^c(t))\Phi_q(Q_k,t)dQ_k
=\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{\operatorname{Im}A^k}}\left\{\sqrt{p+1}\delta_{p+1,q}+\sqrt{p}\delta_{p-1,q}\right\} ∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t )) Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = 2 1 Im A k ℏ { p + 1 δ p + 1 , q + p δ p − 1 , q }
∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) 2 Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = ℏ 4 Im A k { ( p + 1 ) ( p + 2 ) δ p + 2 , q + ( 2 p + 1 ) δ p , q + p ( p − 1 ) δ p − 2 , q } \begin{aligned}
\int\Phi_p^*(Q_k,t)(Q_k-Q_k^c(t))^2\Phi_q(Q_k,t)dQ_k
={}&\frac{\hbar}{4\operatorname{Im}A^k}\left\{\sqrt{(p+1)(p+2)}\delta_{p+2,q}\right.\\
&\left.+(2p+1)\delta_{p,q}+\sqrt{p(p-1)}\delta_{p-2,q}\right\}
\end{aligned} ∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) 2 Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = 4 Im A k ℏ { ( p + 1 ) ( p + 2 ) δ p + 2 , q + ( 2 p + 1 ) δ p , q + p ( p − 1 ) δ p − 2 , q }
∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) 3 Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = 1 8 ( ℏ Im A k ) 3 / 2 { ( p + 1 ) ( p + 2 ) ( p + 3 ) δ p + 3 , q + 3 ( p + 1 ) p + 1 δ p + 1 , q + 3 p p δ p − 1 , q + p ( p − 1 ) ( p − 2 ) δ p − 3 , q } (336) \begin{aligned}
\int\Phi_p^*(Q_k,t)(Q_k-Q_k^c(t))^3\Phi_q(Q_k,t)dQ_k
={}&\frac{1}{8}\left(\frac{\hbar}{\operatorname{Im}A^k}\right)^{3/2}\left\{\sqrt{(p+1)(p+2)(p+3)}\delta_{p+3,q}\right.\\
&\left.+3(p+1)\sqrt{p+1}\delta_{p+1,q}+3p\sqrt{p}\delta_{p-1,q}\right.\\
&\left.+\sqrt{p(p-1)(p-2)}\delta_{p-3,q}\right\} \tag*{(336)}
\end{aligned} ∫ Φ p ∗ ( Q k , t ) ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) 3 Φ q ( Q k , t ) d Q k = 8 1 ( Im A k ℏ ) 3/2 { ( p + 1 ) ( p + 2 ) ( p + 3 ) δ p + 3 , q + 3 ( p + 1 ) p + 1 δ p + 1 , q + 3 p p δ p − 1 , q + p ( p − 1 ) ( p − 2 ) δ p − 3 , q } (336)
The time-independent matrices, R R R , S ( n ) S^{(n)} S ( n ) , T T T and A A A in Eq. (334) need to be calculated only once. On the other hand, time-dependence of p ˙ Q k c \dot{p}_{Q_k}^{c} p ˙ Q k c arises due to the time-dependent coefficient { c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ( t ) } \{c^{d}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)\} { c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ( t )} . While substituting S i k ′ i k ( 1 ) S^{(1)}_{i_k'i_k} S i k ′ i k ( 1 ) by S i k ′ i k ( 1 ) δ i k ′ i k S^{(1)}_{i_k'i_k}\delta_{i_k'i_k} S i k ′ i k ( 1 ) δ i k ′ i k [as the first order term ( Q k − Q k c ( t ) ) (Q_k-Q_k^c(t)) ( Q k − Q k c ( t )) is diagonal in DVR65], p ˙ Q k c \dot{p}_{Q_k}^{c} p ˙ Q k c in Eq. (334) takes the following simplified form:
p ˙ Q k c ( t ) = ∑ l ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 . . . i k ′ . . . i p , l d ( t ) { 2 ( Im A k ) 2 μ [ S i k i k ′ ( 1 ) ∗ A i k i k − S i k i k ′ ( 3 ) A i k i k ] − ℏ Im A k μ [ R i k i k ′ S i k i k ′ ( 1 ) ∗ A i k i k − T i k i k ′ ∗ ] } / [ ∑ l ∑ i k c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ( 1 ) ∗ S i k i k ( 1 ) A i k i k − ∑ i ∑ i k i k ′ c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 . . . i k ′ . . . i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) ] . (337) \dot{p}_{Q_k}^{c}(t)=\sum_l\sum_{i_k i_k'}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)c^{d}_{i_1i_2...i_k'...i_p,l}(t)
\left\{\frac{2(\operatorname{Im}A^k)^2}{\mu}\left[\frac{S^{(1)*}_{i_k i_k'}}{A_{i_k i_k}}-\frac{S^{(3)}_{i_k i_k'}}{A_{i_k i_k}}\right]-\frac{\hbar\operatorname{Im}A^k}{\mu}\left[R_{i_k i_k'}\frac{S^{(1)*}_{i_k i_k'}}{A_{i_k i_k}}-T^*_{i_k i_k'}\right]\right\}
\bigg/\left[\sum_l\sum_{i_k}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)c^{d}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)\frac{S^{(1)*}_{i_k i_k}S^{(1)}_{i_k i_k}}{A_{i_k i_k}}-\sum_i\sum_{i_k i_k'}c^{d*}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)c^{d}_{i_1i_2...i_k'...i_p,l}(t)S^{*(2)}_{i_k i_k'}\right]. \tag*{(337)} p ˙ Q k c ( t ) = l ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 ... i k ′ ... i p , l d ( t ) ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ μ 2 ( Im A k ) 2 A i k i k S i k i k ′ ( 1 ) ∗ − A i k i k S i k i k ′ ( 3 ) − μ ℏ Im A k R i k i k ′ A i k i k S i k i k ′ ( 1 ) ∗ − T i k i k ′ ∗ ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ / l ∑ i k ∑ c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ( t ) A i k i k S i k i k ( 1 ) ∗ S i k i k ( 1 ) − i ∑ i k i k ′ ∑ c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ∗ ( t ) c i 1 i 2 ... i k ′ ... i p , l d ( t ) S i k i k ′ ∗ ( 2 ) . (337)
Initially (t = 0 t=0 t = 0 ), since the denominator of Eq. (337) is very small, the large “quantum force” results into numerical inaccuracies in “classical” variables (see Eq. (331) and (337) ) and quantum equation of motion (see Eq. (330) ). In order to overcome such bottleneck, it is necessary to propagate the “classical” equation of motion in Newtonian sense (see Eq. (331) and Eq. (332) ) until the amplitudes of the wavefunction are spread over the expansion coefficient ({ c i 1 i 2 . . . i k . . . i p , l d ( t ) } \{c^{d}_{i_1i_2...i_k...i_p,l}(t)\} { c i 1 i 2 ... i k ... i p , l d ( t )} ). Once the amplitudes are sufficiently distributed, one can carry out dynamics employing the quantum force as calculated in Eq. (337) .
Initialization and Propagation
On the process of initialization of TDDVR dynamics, the starting wavefunction is defined in the adiabatic representation for a specific electronic state, which is represented as the product of Gaussian wavepackets ({ Φ G W P ( Q k ) } \{\Phi_{GWP}(Q_k)\} { Φ G W P ( Q k )} ) and their center is located around the equilibrium geometry ({ Q 0 = 0 } \{Q_0=0\} { Q 0 = 0 } ):
∏ k = 1 p Φ G W P ( Q k ) = ∑ i 1 i 2 . . . i p c i 1 i 2 . . . i p , l a d ∏ k = 1 p χ i k ( Q k , t ) = ∑ i 1 i 2 . . . i p c i 1 i 2 . . . i p , l a d ∏ k = 1 p ∑ n = 0 N k ζ n ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) . (338) \begin{aligned}
\prod_{k=1}^{p}\Phi_{GWP}(Q_k)=\sum_{i_1i_2...i_p}c^{ad}_{i_1i_2...i_p,l}\prod_{k=1}^{p}\chi_{i_k}(Q_k,t) \\
&=\sum_{i_1i_2...i_p}c^{ad}_{i_1i_2...i_p,l}\prod_{k=1}^{p}\sum_{n=0}^{N_k}\zeta_n(x_{i_k})\Phi_n(Q_k,t). \tag*{(338)}
\end{aligned} k = 1 ∏ p Φ G W P ( Q k ) = i 1 i 2 ... i p ∑ c i 1 i 2 ... i p , l a d k = 1 ∏ p χ i k ( Q k , t ) = i 1 i 2 ... i p ∑ c i 1 i 2 ... i p , l a d k = 1 ∏ p n = 0 ∑ N k ζ n ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) . (338)
While using the following property of TDDVR basis,
χ i k ( Q i k , t ) = ∑ n = 0 N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) ⋅ δ ( Q k − Q i k ) , (339) \chi_{i_k}(Q_{i_k},t)=\sum_{n=0}^{N_k}\zeta_n^*(x_{i_k})\Phi_n(Q_k,t)\cdot\delta(Q_k-Q_{i_k}), \tag*{(339)} χ i k ( Q i k , t ) = n = 0 ∑ N k ζ n ∗ ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q k , t ) ⋅ δ ( Q k − Q i k ) , (339)
Eq. (338) turns into the following form,
∏ k = 1 p Φ G W P ( Q i k ) = c i 1 i 2 . . . i p , l a d ∏ k = 1 p ∑ n = 0 N k ζ n ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q i k ) = c i 1 i 2 . . . i p , l a d ∏ k = 1 p A i k i k . (340) \begin{aligned}
\prod_{k=1}^{p}\Phi_{GWP}(Q_{i_k})=c^{ad}_{i_1i_2...i_p,l}\prod_{k=1}^{p}\sum_{n=0}^{N_k}\zeta_n(x_{i_k})\Phi_n(Q_{i_k}) \\
&=c^{ad}_{i_1i_2...i_p,l}\prod_{k=1}^{p}A_{i_k i_k}. \tag*{(340)}
\end{aligned} k = 1 ∏ p Φ G W P ( Q i k ) = c i 1 i 2 ... i p , l a d k = 1 ∏ p n = 0 ∑ N k ζ n ( x i k ) Φ n ( Q i k ) = c i 1 i 2 ... i p , l a d k = 1 ∏ p A i k i k . (340)
Hence, using Eq. (340) , one can arrive the following expression of the vector ( d n a d ) (d_n^{ad}) ( d n a d ) on one of the surfaces (let say n n n ):
d i 1 i 2 … i p , n a d = c i 1 i 2 … i p , n a d ∏ k = 1 p A i k i k = ∏ k = 1 p Φ G W P ( Q i k ) ∏ k = 1 p A i k i k , (341) d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,n}^{ad}=c_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,n}^{ad}\sqrt{\prod_{k=1}^{p}A_{i_k i_k}}=\frac{\prod_{k=1}^{p}\Phi_{GWP}(Q_{i_k})}{\sqrt{\prod_{k=1}^{p}A_{i_k i_k}}}, \tag*{(341)} d i 1 i 2 … i p , n a d = c i 1 i 2 … i p , n a d k = 1 ∏ p A i k i k = ∏ k = 1 p A i k i k ∏ k = 1 p Φ G W P ( Q i k ) , (341)
where the initial expansion coefficient vectors ( d i 1 i 2 … i p , l a d (d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}^{ad} ( d i 1 i 2 … i p , l a d , where l ≠ n ) l\ne n) l = n ) on other surfaces (except state n n n ) take the following form,
⋯ , d i 1 i 2 … i p , n − 1 a d = 0 , d i 1 i 2 … i p , n + 1 a d = 0 ⋯ . (342) \cdots,d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,n-1}^{ad}=0,\quad d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,n+1}^{ad}=0\cdots. \tag*{(342)} ⋯ , d i 1 i 2 … i p , n − 1 a d = 0 , d i 1 i 2 … i p , n + 1 a d = 0 ⋯ . (342)
In order to perform dynamical evolution of any molecular system, the set of differential equations (see Eqs. (329) , (331) , (332) ) are simultaneously solved with initial coefficient vectors, D d \mathbf{D}^{d} D d .
Since the initial amplitudes of the wavepacket are in the adiabatic representation (see Eqs. (341) and (342) ), those quantities need to be transformed to the diabatic ones for propagation by employing the transformation matrix, X X X . In other words, D d = X D a d \mathbf{D}^{d}=X\mathbf{D}^{ad} D d = X D a d , where V a d = X † W X V^{ad}=X^{\dagger}WX V a d = X † W X with X X X being the diagonalizing matrix for the diabatic PESs matrix.
While calculating the diabatic population on a particular surface ( l ) (l) ( l ) , one needs to perform the following grid summation over the amplitudes,
P l d ( t ) = ∑ i 1 i 2 … i p ∣ d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d ∣ 2 , l = 1 , 2 , … l . (343) P_l^d(t)=\sum_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p}\left|d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}^{d}\right|^2,\ l=1,2,\ldots l. \tag*{(343)} P l d ( t ) = i 1 i 2 … i p ∑ d i 1 i 2 … i p , l d 2 , l = 1 , 2 , … l . (343)
whereas in adiabatic representation, the population is defined as,
P l a d ( t ) = ∑ i 1 i 2 … i p ∣ d i 1 i 2 … i p , l a d ∣ 2 , l = 1 , 2 , … l . (344) P_l^{ad}(t)=\sum_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p}\left|d_{i_1i_2\ldots i_p,l}^{ad}\right|^2,\ l=1,2,\ldots l. \tag*{(344)} P l a d ( t ) = i 1 i 2 … i p ∑ d i 1 i 2 … i p , l a d 2 , l = 1 , 2 , … l . (344)
at any time, t t t .
Calculation of Theoretical PE, PD, PA and MATI Spectra
While performing nuclear dynamics by TDDVR methodology, TDSE is numerically integrated to calculate the nuclear wavefunctions (Eq. (317) ) at different time, which are further employed to compute the autocorrelation function ( C ( t ) ) (C(t)) ( C ( t )) . Once C ( t ) C(t) C ( t ) s are in hand, the following Fourier transformation is executed,
I ( ω ) ∝ ω ∫ − ∞ ∞ C ( t ) exp ( i ω t ) d t , (345) I(\omega)\propto\omega\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}C(t)\exp(i\omega t)\,dt, \tag*{(345)} I ( ω ) ∝ ω ∫ − ∞ ∞ C ( t ) exp ( iω t ) d t , (345)
where
C ( t ) = ⟨ Ξ ( t ) ∣ Ξ ( 0 ) ⟩ (346) C(t)=\langle\Xi(t)|\Xi(0)\rangle \tag*{(346)} C ( t ) = ⟨ Ξ ( t ) ∣Ξ ( 0 )⟩ (346)
= ⟨ Ξ ∗ ( t 2 ) | Ξ ( t 2 ) ⟩ . (347) =\left\langle\Xi^{\ast}\left(\frac{t}{2}\right)\middle|\Xi\left(\frac{t}{2}\right)\right\rangle. \tag*{(347)} = ⟨ Ξ ∗ ( 2 t ) Ξ ( 2 t ) ⟩ . (347)
It is interesting to note that Eq. (6.40b) is more accurate and computationally cost-effective with respect to the other one (Eq. (6.40a)), though the former one (Eq. (6.40b)) can be applied only for real initial wavefunction and totally symmetric Hamiltonian. In order to encapsulate the effects of phenomenological broadening of the experimental spectral lines arising due to the resolution of the spectrometer in the time-dependent picture, the autocorrelation function is multiplied by a time-dependent damping function as follows:
h ( t ) = exp [ − ( ∣ t ∣ τ ) 2 ] (348) h(t)=\exp\left[-\left(\frac{|t|}{\tau}\right)^2\right] \tag*{(348)} h ( t ) = exp [ − ( τ ∣ t ∣ ) 2 ] (348)
where the unit of τ \tau τ is 10 − 14 10^{-14} 1 0 − 14 sec. The value of τ \tau τ should be properly tuned to correctly describe the experimental broadening. The details of the calculation of theoretical spectra is extensively illustrated elsewhere. [40,65]
Two State : NO2 _2 2
The two low-lying electronic states (X 2 A 1 X\,^{2}A_1 X 2 A 1 and A 2 B 2 A\,^{2}B_2 A 2 B 2 ) of nitrogen dioxide (NO2 _2 2 ) radical exhibits JT and RT interactions, which dictate the details of its photodetachment spectrum. 11,12,66–74 Adhikari and coworkers had generated highly precise diabatic surfaces of NO2 _2 2 12 using MRCI based adiabatic PESs and NACTs obtained from MOLPRO 75 quantum chemistry package followed by ADT calculation. Finally, nuclear dynamics had been performed to compute the theoretical photodetachment spectrum 12 of NO2 _2 2 and such spectrum is compared with the experimental one 76.
In NO2 _2 2 molecule, one can observe JT type accidental CIs and RT interactions over three 2D nuclear planes (Q i − Q j Q_i-Q_j Q i − Q j ) consisting of symmetric bending (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), symmetric (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) and asymmetric (Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 ) stretching normal modes belonging to a 1 a_1 a 1 , a 1 a_1 a 1 and b 2 b_2 b 2 irreducible representations (IREPs). While exploring JT interactions in NO2 _2 2 , it should be noted that it exhibits C 2 v / C s C_{2v}/C_s C 2 v / C s symmetry and therefore, all the electronic states and normal modes can be assigned under 1D IREPs. In other words, no symmetry-driven JT CI can be observed in this radical, whereas JT type accidental CIs and RT interactions are located between the electronic states. In order to construct JT/RT active diabatic Hamiltonian, the direct product of irreducible representations for the electronic state and the vibrational mode should contain the totally symmetric representation (A 1 A_1 A 1 ). Therefore, the couplings between X 2 A 1 X\,^{2}A_1 X 2 A 1 and A 2 B 2 A\,^{2}B_2 A 2 B 2 states via b 2 b_2 b 2 symmetric Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 normal mode are allowed through accidental CIs between those states:
A 1 ∈ A 1 ⊗ b 2 ⊗ B 2 . A_1 \in A_1 \otimes b_2 \otimes B_2. A 1 ∈ A 1 ⊗ b 2 ⊗ B 2 .
In ab initio calculation, JT type accidental CIs and RT interactions are observed over three 2D nuclear configuration space (Q i − Q j Q_i-Q_j Q i − Q j ) consisting of symmetric bending (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), symmetric (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) and asymmetric (Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 ) stretching normal modes. For each pair of normal modes, we transform the ab initio quantities (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) in terms of the corresponding polar coordinates (ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ ) to explore the nature of the CIs. The ρ \rho ρ component of NACT (τ ρ 12 \tau_{\rho}^{12} τ ρ 12 ) over the polar plane (ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ ) associated with Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 and Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 normal modes is depicted in Figure 6.1 a showing the existence of one JT type seam passing through the C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v point with three peaks [one at C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v (peak 1) and the other two at C s C_s C s (peaks 2 and 3) nuclear geometries]. On the other hand, the RT intersections are prominent at the linear geometries (peaks 4 and 5).11,12
Figure 6.1. For Q 1 − Q 3 Q_1-Q_3 Q 1 − Q 3 pair of NO2 _2 2 radical, (a) τ ρ 12 \tau_\rho^{12} τ ρ 12 shows singularities at the close vicinity of the semicircular JT type seam (peaks 1 to 3) as well as in the RT regions (peaks 4 and 5) over ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ configuration space. Panel (b) depicts 1D variation of ADT angle, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at a fixed ρ \rho ρ value 0.45 Å. Such angle acquires the numerical value of 3 π 3\pi 3 π due to the JT and RT couplings. The results are adopted from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
Once the ab initio quantities (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) are in hand, those are plugged into the ADT equations (see Eq. (198) ) and solved those equations. While performing the first principle based ADT calculation along a closed contour at ρ = 0.45 \rho= 0.45 ρ = 0.45 Å, the resulting ADT angle (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 ) is displayed in Figure 6.1 b, which attends the magnitude of 3 π 3\pi 3 π at the end of the closed contour (ϕ = 2 π \phi= 2\pi ϕ = 2 π ) bearing the signature of JT type CI seam (π \pi π ) and RT interaction (2 π 2\pi 2 π ).12,77 On the other hand, for other two pairs, namely, Q 1 − Q 2 Q_1-Q_2 Q 1 − Q 2 and Q 2 − Q 3 Q_2-Q_3 Q 2 − Q 3 , two JT type accidental CIs and one RT intersection are located for each case over the Franck-Condon (FC) domain of nuclear configuration space, which can be found out from the singularities of the NACT landscapes. 12 Finally, the ADT matrix has been used to generate a two-state three-mode diabatic Hamiltonian, where PESs and coupling elements are smooth, single-valued and continuous over the chosen portion of nuclear CS. Moreover, it is worth mentioning that along Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 normal mode, the diabatic coupling element exhibits symmetric form (see Figure 6.2 ), which can only be fitted with even parity polynomial 12 unlike the traditional JT model 66.
Figure 6.2. For NO₂ radical, diabatic coupling (W 12 W_{12} W 12 ) shows even parity functional forms along Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 normal mode. The results are adopted from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
The accuracy of the diabatic Hamiltonian and the existence of two state SHS can be validated by computing Curl condition. 78 For two state SHS, ADT Curl (Commutator, C ρ ϕ 12 = ( τ ϕ τ ρ ) 12 − ( τ ρ τ ϕ ) 12 C_{\rho\phi}^{12}=(\tau_\phi\tau_\rho)_{12}-(\tau_\rho\tau_\phi)_{12} C ρϕ 12 = ( τ ϕ τ ρ ) 12 − ( τ ρ τ ϕ ) 12 ) is “trivially” zero (0) and the calculated Mathematical Curl (Z ρ ϕ 12 = ∂ ∂ ϕ τ ρ 12 − ∂ ∂ ρ τ ϕ 12 Z_{\rho\phi}^{12}=\frac{\partial}{\partial\phi}\tau_\rho^{12}-\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}\tau_\phi^{12} Z ρϕ 12 = ∂ ϕ ∂ τ ρ 12 − ∂ ρ ∂ τ ϕ 12 ) has been shown to be numerically zero (0)78 using the cross-derivatives on the recalculated NACTs from ADT angles. Since both ADT Curl (C ρ ϕ 12 C_{\rho\phi}^{12} C ρϕ 12 ) and numerically calculated Mathematical Curl (Z ρ ϕ 12 Z_{\rho\phi}^{12} Z ρϕ 12 ) become zero (0), Curl Condition (F ρ ϕ 12 F_{\rho\phi}^{12} F ρϕ 12 ) is obeyed (0)
for two state SHS of NO2 _2 2 .
Once the first principle based accurate diabatic PESs for NO2 _2 2 radical are obtained, nuclear dynamics has been carried out to generate bands of X ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}A_{1} X 2 A 1 and A ~ 2 B 2 \widetilde{A}^{2}B_{2} A 2 B 2 states in the photodetachment spectrum. Dynamical calculations have been executed at the close neighborhood of equilibrium geometry (FC region), where Gaussian wave packets (GWPs) can be used to represent molecular vibrations. Therefore, a product wavefunction with GWPs for each normal mode of NO2 − _2^- 2 − has been taken as the initial wavefunction for solving the time dependent SE. During dynamical calculations, 79–84 time dependent nuclear wavefunctions vis-á-vis autocorrelation function have been calculated at different time and then, Fourier transformation has been carried out to generate the photodetachment spectra of NO2 _2 2 radical. The overall spectral profile12 exhibits good agreement with the experimental one recorded by Weaver et al. 76 (see Figure 6.3 ). The asymmetric stretching mode (Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 ) is mainly responsible for vibronic transitions in the spectral profile, whereas symmetric bending (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ) and stretching (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) vibrations dictate the peak progressions. It is necessary to mention that absence of Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 normal mode in the diabatic Hamiltonian broadens the spectral band of X ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}A_{1} X 2 A 1 state. 12 In summary, our theoretical results specify the details of the effects due to the JT and RT couplings to the overall nonadiabaticity of NO2 _2 2 , which modulates its photodetachment spectrum.12
Figure 6.3. The BBO calculated spectrum (panel (b)) incorporating all nonadiabatic interactions (JT and RT couplings) is compared with the experimental finding (panel a)76. The results are taken from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
Three State : Na3 _3 3
While unveiling the applicability of BBO-DH for a three coupled electronic manifold, prototypical alkali trimer, like Na3 _3 3 has been chosen to investigate its inherent JT and PJT couplings and their effects on the spectral profiles. Over the last three decades, several theoretical 85–91 as well as experimental 92,93 research groups are involved in the study of Na3 _3 3 cluster due to its simple electronic structure and presence of only three vibrational modes. Adhikari and coworkers94 had performed dynamical calculations employing model diabatic Hamiltonian constructed by Cocchini et al. 89 and then, theoretical spectra were calculated using the associated BO, EBO and diabatic surfaces. Later on, the same group had generated first principle based adiabatic PESs and NACTs of three excited electronic states (2 2 E ′ 2^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^{2}A'_{1} 1 2 A 1 ′ ) using MRCI methodology as implemented in MOLPRO75. Such electronic structure study has been followed by ADT calculations over 2D nuclear plane (ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ ) arising from bending (Q x Q_x Q x ) - asymmetric stretching (Q y Q_y Q y ) pair keeping the value of symmetric stretching (Q s Q_s Q s ) mode fixed at 3.7 Å. The Na3 _3 3 cluster exhibits accidental CIs within two branches of 2 2 E ′ 2^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ state as well as profound PJT interaction among 2 2 E ′ 2^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^{2}A'_{1} 1 2 A 1 ′ states. Among the accidental CIs, three appear at C2 v _{2v} 2 v geometry, whereas the other three symmetry-driven CIs merge at D3 h _{3h} 3 h point. Therefore, one can consider total four CIs over the nuclear CS.12
On the process of exploring the conditions to understand the properties related to the distortions of Na3 _3 3 molecule, it appears that the vibrational modes (e ′ e' e ′ symmetric Q x − Q y Q_x-Q_y Q x − Q y ) are responsible for JT interactions. The JT effects originate due to the coupling of electronic states with vibrational modes of appropriate symmetry. In other words, the direct product of irreducible representations for the electronic states and the vibrational modes contains the totally symmetric representation (A 1 ′ A'_{1} A 1 ′ ). The JT distortion takes place between 2 E ′ ^{2}E' 2 E ′ states via e ′ e' e ′ normal modes:
A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ ( E ′ ) 2 ] = e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) A'_{1} \in e' \otimes[(E')^2] = e' \otimes(A'_{1}+A'_{2}+E') A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [( E ′ ) 2 ] = e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ )
While performing BBO theory based diabatization of three excited states (2 2 E ′ 2^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^{2}A'_{1} 1 2 A 1 ′ ) of Na3 _3 3 cluster, the adiabatic PESs and MS adapted NACTs (see § 7.8 for details) were substituted in the ADT equations 95,96 for three state electronic manifold (see Eq. (199) ). Furthermore, those equations had been numerically solved over the 2D nuclear planes to compute the ADT angles. Once the mixing angles were obtained, those ADT angles had been plugged into the ADT matrix, which had been further used to calculate diabatic Hamiltonian for Na3 _3 3 cluster. It has been observed that the diabatic coupling elements show even parity functional forms along Q y Q_y Q y normal mode, which can be fitted only with even power polynomials of Q y Q_y Q y coordinate.9,20
After carrying out BBO theory based diabatization, nuclear wave packet dynamics had been performed over Q x − Q y Q_x-Q_y Q x − Q y plane with the aid of GWP as the time-independent solution of the unperturbed Hamiltonian [ H ^ 0 ( Q x , Q y ) = T ^ n u c + ( 1 / 2 ) ( Q x 2 + Q y 2 ) ] [\hat{H}_0(Q_x,Q_y)=\hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}+(1/2)(Q_x^2+Q_y^2)] [ H ^ 0 ( Q x , Q y ) = T ^ nuc + ( 1/2 ) ( Q x 2 + Q y 2 )] . While executing the dynamical calculations, FFT-Lanczos method had been employed to compute the autocorrelation function, C ( t ) C(t) C ( t ) s and such function was further Fourier transformed to compute the theoretical spectral envelop. In order to obtain individual (2 2 E ′ 2^{2}E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^{2}A'_{1} 1 2 A 1 ′ ) state spectra, three different calculations had been carried out and then, the resulting spectra were convoluted to obtain the overall spectra.9 The experimental two-photon ionization (TPI) spectrum for system B of Na3 _3 3 cluster93 was well reproduced by the calculation of Adhikari et al. 9 as displayed in Figure 6.5 . In addition, it had been explored that the diabatic population profiles show a crossing with each other as function of time affirming the existence of CIs between those states.9
Figure 6.5. The diagram presents a comparison of absorption spectrum for system B of Na₃ cluster originated from from BBO based diabatic surfaces [panel (a)] with the experimental two-photon ionization spectrum93 [panel (b)]. This figure has been taken from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
Four State : C4 _4 4 N2 _2 2 H4 _4 4
Over the last few decades, immense interest has been grown to investigate the photophysics of pyrazine molecule, which is enriched with vibronic phenomena, namely, JT type CI on a point(s) or along a seam(s)
Figure 6.4. For N a 3 Na_{3} N a 3 cluster, diabatic coupling (W 12 W_{12} W 12 ) shows symmetric functional forms along Q y Q_y Q y normal mode, which can only be fitted with even power polynomials. The results are adopted from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
and PJT couplings. Several experimental techniques, namely, Resonance Raman (RR),97 Fluorescence98 and PA99 spectroscopy were employed to investigate the underneath electronic structure and nuclear dynamics of such molecule. In other words, the electronic structure and PA spectra of pyrazine appear as a long standing point of interest for theoretical chemists also over several decades. 100–108 Adhikari and coworkers24 have employed first principle based BBO theory to explore the wide variety of non-adiabatic interactions present within the low-lying four excited electronic states [1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u (S 1 S_{1} S 1 ), 1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u (S 2 S_{2} S 2 ), 1 1 A u 1^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u (S 3 S_{3} S 3 ) and 1 1 B 2 g 1^{1}B_{2g} 1 1 B 2 g (S 4 S_{4} S 4 )] and to construct theoretically “exact" and numerically “accurate" 4 × 4 4 \times4 4 × 4 diabatic PESs matrices of pyrazine molecule. It is important to note that “1-2", “2-3" and “3-4" CI(s)/seam(s) can be observed over six 2D nuclear planes constituted with four normal modes (Q 1 Q_{1} Q 1 , Q 6 a Q_{6a} Q 6 a , Q 9 a Q_{9a} Q 9 a and Q 10 a Q_{10a} Q 10 a ). The direct product of irreducible representations for the electronic state and the vibrational mode must belong to the totally symmetric representation (A g A_{g} A g for D 2 h D_{2h} D 2 h point group). Therefore, b 1 g b_{1g} b 1 g symmetric Q 10 a Q_{10a} Q 10 a normal modes can couple 1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u and 1 1 A u 1^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u electronic states due to the following relation:
A g ∈ B 1 u ⊗ b 1 g ⊗ A u A_{g} \in B_{1u} \otimes b_{1g} \otimes A_{u} A g ∈ B 1 u ⊗ b 1 g ⊗ A u
Among all the normal mode pairs of C4 _{4} 4 N2 _{2} 2 H4 _{4} 4 molecule, Q 9 a − Q 1 Q_{9a}-Q_{1} Q 9 a − Q 1 pair is constituted with non-degenerate normal modes, namely, in-plane C-H bending and out-of-plane C-H bending. Over the polar counterpart, ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ (Q 9 a Q_{9a} Q 9 a and Q 1 Q_{1} Q 1 ) one can observe accidental CI(s)/seam(s), but no symmetry driven JT interaction is present at the equilibrium nuclear configuration (ρ = 0.0 \rho= 0.0 ρ = 0.0 ). Figure 6.6(a-c) presents 1D curves of adiabatic PESs for 1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u and 1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u electronic states (u 1 u_{1} u 1 and u 2 u_{2} u 2 ) and the corresponding ϕ \phi ϕ component of NACTs (τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 ) along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate keeping the value of ρ \rho ρ fixed at 0.31 Å, 0.41 Å and 0.51 Å.24 It is interesting to note that two seams between ϕ = 0 \phi= 0 ϕ = 0 and ϕ = π \phi= \pi ϕ = π are gradually approaching to each other at lower ρ \rho ρ value leading to only one seam passing through ϕ = π / 2 \phi= \pi/2 ϕ = π /2 . Similarly, other two seams between ϕ = π \phi= \pi ϕ = π and ϕ = 2 π \phi= 2\pi ϕ = 2 π join at ϕ = 3 π / 2 \phi= 3\pi/2 ϕ = 3 π /2 to generate only one seam.24 The locations of the seams are clearly identified in the 2D functional form of τ 12 \tau^{12} τ 12 in Figure 6.6d exhibiting singular NACTs along two semi-circular seams. This nuclear plane also exhibits two “3-4" (1 1 A u 1^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u - 1 1 B 2 g 1^{1}B_{2g} 1 1 B 2 g ) accidental CIs at ρ = 0.15 \rho= 0.15 ρ = 0.15 Å and ϕ = π / 2 \phi= \pi/2 ϕ = π /2 and 3 π / 2 3\pi/2 3 π /2 . On the other hand, another nuclear plane, Q 10 a − Q 6 a Q_{10a}-Q_{6a} Q 10 a − Q 6 a is extremely rich in showing “1-2" (1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u - 1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u ) accidental CI, “2-3" accidental seams (1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u -1 1 A u 1^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u ) and “3-4" (Q 10 a − Q 6 a Q_{10a}-Q_{6a} Q 10 a − Q 6 a ) accidental seams.24
The ab initio calculated functions (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) had been plugged into the ADT equations for four electronic state SHS (see Appendix B.1) and then, those equations were solved to obtain the ADT angles, which lead to ADT and diabatic PESs matrices. Since Q 9 a − Q 1 Q_{9a}-Q_{1} Q 9 a − Q 1 exhibits two “1-2" accidental seams and two “3-4" accidental CIs, the functional forms of both the ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 and Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 attend the magnitude of 2 π 2\pi 2 π (see Figure 6.7 a) at the end of the closed contour (ϕ = 2 π \phi= 2\pi ϕ = 2 π ). In case of Q 10 a − Q 6 a Q_{10a}-Q_{6a} Q 10 a − Q 6 a , the magnitudes of ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 and Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 reach the value as π \pi π , 2 π 2\pi 2 π and 2 π 2\pi 2 π , respectively at ϕ = 2 π \phi= 2\pi ϕ = 2 π which is clear from Figure 6.7 b. For both cases, the 1D curves (Figure 6.7 ) of the ADT angles appear as topological (e i ϕ ϕ ( ϕ ) e^{i\phi_{\phi}(\phi)} e i ϕ ϕ ( ϕ ) ) instead of geometric109–111 [e ± i n ( ϕ / 2 ) e^{\pm i n(\phi/2)} e ± in ( ϕ /2 ) , n n n is the number of enclosed CI(s)/seam(s)]. The diabatic PESs and couplings have been obtained from CASSCF as well as MRCI computed adiabatic PESs and CP-MCSCF calculated NACTs, which appear as smooth, continuous and single-valued.
Figure 6.7. The left panel (a) depicts 1D functional forms of ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 , Θ 13 \Theta_{13} Θ 13 and Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 for Q 9 a − Q 1 Q_{9a}-Q_{1} Q 9 a − Q 1 pair, whereas the right one (b) shows Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 and Θ 14 \Theta_{14} Θ 14 for Q 10 a − Q 6 a Q_{10a}-Q_{6a} Q 10 a − Q 6 a pair along ϕ \phi ϕ at various fixed values of ρ \rho ρ . This figure has been adapted from Ref. [24] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
While depicting the size of the sub-Hilbert space for C4 _{4} 4 N2 _{2} 2 H4 _{4} 4 molecule, Mathematical Curls (Z ρ ϕ i j Z_{\rho\phi}^{ij} Z ρϕ ij ) and ADT Curls (C ρ ϕ i j C_{\rho\phi}^{ij} C ρϕ ij ) were computed involving the ADT angles24 into their explicit expressions (see Appendix B.1). Figure 6.8 a and 6.8c show Mathematical Curls associated with the “1-2" and “3-4" interaction (Z ρ ϕ 12 Z_{\rho\phi}^{12} Z ρϕ 12 and Z ρ ϕ 34 Z_{\rho\phi}^{34} Z ρϕ 34 ), respectively, whereas the corresponding ADT Curls (C ρ ϕ 12 C_{\rho\phi}^{12} C ρϕ 12 and C ρ ϕ 34 C_{\rho\phi}^{34} C ρϕ 34 ) are depicted in Figure 6.8 b and 6.8d. Since the functional forms of Mathematical and ADT Curls are appeared superimposable with each other for both the cases, Curl Conditions (F ρ ϕ 12 F_{\rho\phi}^{12} F ρϕ 12 and F ρ ϕ 34 F_{\rho\phi}^{34} F ρϕ 34 ) turn into the values close to zero (< 10 − 12 − 2 < 10^{-12} - 2 < 1 0 − 12 − 2 ) validating the existence of four-state SHS.
Figure 6.8. The left column shows Mathematical Curls, (a) Z ρ ϕ 12 Z_{\rho\phi}^{12} Z ρϕ 12 and (c) Z ρ ϕ 34 Z_{\rho\phi}^{34} Z ρϕ 34 , whereas the right one depicts the corresponding ADT Curls, (b) C ρ ϕ 12 C_{\rho\phi}^{12} C ρϕ 12 and (d) C ρ ϕ 34 C_{\rho\phi}^{34} C ρϕ 34 along the ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at three different ρ \rho ρ values for Q 9 a − Q 1 Q_{9a}-Q_{1} Q 9 a − Q 1 normal mode pair. This figure has been adapted from Ref. [112] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Once diabatic PESs and couplings were obtained, nuclear dynamics were performed over the diabatic Hamiltonian by placing the initial wavepacket on each of the electronic (1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u , 1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u , 1 1 A u 1^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u and 1 1 B 2 g 1^{1}B_{2g} 1 1 B 2 g )
Figure 6. The diagram exhibits the location of “1-2” (1 1 B 1 u 1^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u - 1 1 B 2 u 1^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u ) accidental seams over the polar plane (ρ \rho ρ -ϕ \phi ϕ ) of Q 9 a Q_{9a} Q 9 a -Q 1 Q_{1} Q 1 pair. 1D curves of adiabatic PESs (u 1 u_{1} u 1 and u 2 u_{2} u 2 ) and the corresponding τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 are presented along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at three values of ρ \rho ρ = (a) 0.31 Å, (b) 0.41 Å and (c) 0.51 Å. τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 , where the later ones (NACTs) shows singular feature at the points of degeneracies. Diagram (d) shows the associated 2D functional forms of τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 . This figure has been taken from [24] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
FOUR STATE: C 4 N 2 H 4 \mathrm{C}_{4}\mathrm{N}_{2}\mathrm{H}_{4} C 4 N 2 H 4
states to calculate the autocorrelation functions for each case. The time-dependent autocorrelation functions were transformed into energy space (Fourier Transformation) and then, the spectra for each state were convoluted to obtain the overall spectra. TDDVR calculated envelops arising from BBO theory based diabatic Hamiltonian exhibit better agreement with the experimental ones 99 in comparison with the MCTDH results obtained from 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 VCM Hamiltonian 104,113, as presented in Figure 6.9 . It is worth mentioning that the PA spectra for 1 1 B 2 u 1\,^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u state are broadened mainly due to strong PJT couplings between second and the remaining three electronic states (1 1 B 1 u 1\,^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u , 1 1 A u 1\,^{1}A_{u} 1 1 A u and 1 1 B 2 g 1\,^{1}B_{2g} 1 1 B 2 g ). The first principle based study unveils the “accuracy" and “exactness" of BBO formalism vis-á-vis TDDVR dynamics for “correct" assignments of peaks in PA spectra for spectroscopically important system, like pyrazine.
Figure 6.9. The diagram depicts (a) experimental PA spectrum 99 of pyrazine molecule for 1 1 B 1 u 1\,^{1}B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u (S 1 S_{1} S 1 ) state in comparison with (b) MCTDH spectrum calculated by VCM based 2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 quasi-diabatic surfaces 104 as well as (c) TDDVR spectrum evaluated from BBO based 4 × 4 4 \times4 4 × 4 diabatic surfaces. In a similar way, the right panel (d-e) demonstrates spectral bands for 1 1 B 2 u 1\,^{1}B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u (S 2 S_{2} S 2 ) state, where MCTDH calculated spectra have been obtained from both four104 and twenty-four113 mode Hamiltonian. This figure has been taken from Ref. [24] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Five State : NO3 _3 3 , o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 + _2^+ 2 +
Nitrate radical (NO3 _3 3 ) and ortho-difluorobenzene radical cation (o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 + _2^+ 2 + ) are two representative spectroscopically interesting systems, which were extensively investigated over the past few decades 14,32,114–116 due to the highly complex spectral bands of NO3 _3 3 and o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 _2 2 molecules. In the following section, BBO based diabatization and TDDVR dynamics are explored for NO3 _3 3 14 and o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 + _2^+ 2 + 32 systems.
N O 3 NO_3 N O 3 Radical
Due to the presence of profound vibronic coupling between the low-lying (within 2 eV) five electronic states, X ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{X}^{2}A_{2} X ~ 2 A 2 (1 2 B 2 1^{2}B_{2} 1 2 B 2 ), A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 E ′′ (1 2 A 2 1^{2}A_{2} 1 2 A 2 and 1 2 B 1 1^{2}B_{1} 1 2 B 1 ) and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ (1 2 A 1 1^{2}A_{1} 1 2 A 1 and 2 2 B 2 2^{2}B_{2} 2 2 B 2 ) of N O 3 NO_3 N O 3 radical, it shows highly complex spectral features. Several theoretical groups 13,14,16,114,117–120 attempted to explore and understand experimentally recorded complex spectral envelop obtained from various techniques, like dispersed fluorescence spectroscopy, 121,122 Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, 123,124 photoelectron spectroscopy 125 and also from cavity ringdown spectroscopy (CRDS) 126,127. Recently, Adhikari and coworkers 13,14 unveiled that JT interactions exist within the A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ states at equilibrium D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h point, whereas accidental CIs can be observed within ‘3-4’ and ‘4-5’ electronic states at C s C_s C s and C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v geometries. Apart from the symmetry-allowed and accidental JT type CIs, N O 3 NO_3 N O 3 shows substantial PJT coupling between X ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{X}^{2}A_{2} X ~ 2 A 2 and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ states. 13,14 Such highly nonadiabatically coupled electronic manifold appears to be challenging even to predict the correct ground state equilibrium geometry of this radical, but finally, Eisfeld and Morokuma concluded to be of D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h symmetry. 117
Adhikari and coworkers carried out an extensive study to investigate all the contributing nonadiabatic interactions present over the nuclear planes constituted with symmetric stretching (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 ), umbrella (Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 ) and degenerate asymmetric stretching (Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x and Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y ) modes. 13,14 It had been explored from the JT condition that e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ symmetric (Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x , Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y ) vibrational modes are mainly responsible for the JT distortion, which originates from the coupling of electronic states with vibrational modes of appropriate symmetry. In other words, the direct product of irreducible representations for the electronic state and the vibrational mode contains the totally symmetric representation (A 1 ′ A_1^{\prime} A 1 ′ ). The JT distortion takes place between 2 E ′ ^{2}E^{\prime} 2 E ′ states via e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ normal modes:
A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ ( E ′ ) 2 ] ≡ e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ ) A_1^{\prime} \in e^{\prime} \otimes[(E^{\prime})^2] \equiv e^{\prime} \otimes(A_1^{\prime} + A_2^{\prime} + E^{\prime}) A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [( E ′ ) 2 ] ≡ e ′ ⊗ ( A 1 ′ + A 2 ′ + E ′ )
The adiabatic PESs and NACTs were computed as functions of polar counterparts (ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ ) of each normal mode pair (Q i Q_i Q i and Q j Q_j Q j ) with the use of MRCI approach in MOLPRO quantum chemistry package 75. Those ab initio calculated NACTs were substituted into the ADT equations for five-state SHS (see Appendix B.1) resulting into mixing angles at each nuclear configuration points over those 2D nuclear planes. 16 N O 3 NO_3 N O 3 radical possesses one “2-3” JT CI as well as one “4-5” JT and three accidental CIs over Q 3 x − Q 3 y Q_{3x}-Q_{3y} Q 3 x − Q 3 y plane, which are evident from the 2D plots of ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs as depicted in Figure 6.10 . Figure 6.11 shows that angular variation (ϕ \phi ϕ ) of ADT angles [ Θ 23 ( Q 3 x , Q 3 y ) [\Theta_{23}(Q_{3x}, Q_{3y}) [ Θ 23 ( Q 3 x , Q 3 y ) and Θ 45 ( Q 3 x , Q 3 y ) ] \Theta_{45}(Q_{3x}, Q_{3y})] Θ 45 ( Q 3 x , Q 3 y )] at fixed ρ \rho ρ (= 0.21 Å) fulfills the quantization property of NACTs, where such angles attend the magnitude of π \pi π and 4 π 4\pi 4 π , respectively. This calculation validates the presence of enclosed ‘2-3’ CI (JT CI at D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h point) and ‘4-5’ CIs (one JT CI at D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h geometry and three accidental CIs at equivalent C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v points) inside the circular loop. On the other hand, the diagonal elements of ADT matrices, namely, A 22 A_{22} A 22 [= A 33 = A_{33} = A 33 ] and A 44 A_{44} A 44 [= A 55 = A_{55} = A 55 ] exhibit one and four sign inversions, respectively, indicating the presence of aforementioned CIs. As per Figure 6.11 , the functional behaviour of ADT angles shows molecule-specific nonadiabatic features [ ω ϕ ( ϕ ) [\omega_{\phi}(\phi) [ ω ϕ ( ϕ ) , see Eq. (226) of Subchapter 4.7] that could be termed as topological (e ± i ω ϕ ( ϕ ) e^{\pm i\omega_{\phi}(\phi)} e ± i ω ϕ ( ϕ ) ) phase rather than geometric (e ± i ϕ e^{\pm i\phi} e ± i ϕ ) 109–111 (indicated by the dashed lines). Apart from the ‘2-3’ and ‘4-5’ CIs, two “3-4” C s C_s C s CIs and one “3-4” C s C_s C s CI can be observed over Q 2 − Q 3 x Q_2-Q_{3x} Q 2 − Q 3 x and Q 2 − Q 3 y Q_2-Q_{3y} Q 2 − Q 3 y planes, respectively. 13,16 The diabatic Hamiltonian matrix elements appear as smooth, single-valued and continuous over the nuclear CS. It is worthwhile to note that diabatic PESs as well as the couplings show symmetric functional forms along Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x normal mode, which can be fitted only with even power polynomial terms, 15 in contrast to the traditional JT model (see Figure 6.12 for Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x mode).
Figure 6.10. Figure 6.10: 2D functional forms of (a) τ ϕ 23 \tau_{\phi}^{23} τ ϕ 23 , (b) τ ϕ 45 \tau_{\phi}^{45} τ ϕ 45 , (c) τ ϕ 14 \tau_{\phi}^{14} τ ϕ 14 and (b) τ ϕ 15 \tau_{\phi}^{15} τ ϕ 15 are presented over ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ plane of Q 3 x − Q 3 y Q_{3x}-Q_{3y} Q 3 x − Q 3 y pair. This data has been taken from Ref. [14].
Figure 6.11. 1D curves of (a) Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 and (b) Θ 45 \Theta_{45} Θ 45 for Q 3 x − Q 3 y Q_{3x}-Q_{3y} Q 3 x − Q 3 y normal mode pair are plotted along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at definite ρ \rho ρ (= 0.21 Å) attaining the value of π \pi π and 4 π 4\pi 4 π , respectively due to the presence of encapsulated one ‘2-3’ JT CI and four ‘4-5’ CIs (one JT and three accidental ones). On the other hand, (a) A 22 A_{22} A 22 [= A 33 A_{33} A 33 ] and (b) A 44 A_{44} A 44 [= A 55 A_{55} A 55 ] encounter one and four sign inversions, respectively, according to the number of encapsulated CI. This data has been taken from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC
Figure 6.12. 1D curve of diabatic coupling element, namely, W 23 W_{23} W 23 among A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 E ′′ states along Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x mode of N O 3 \mathrm{NO}_{3} NO 3 radical is presented. The coupling term exhibits symmetric functional form, which can be fitted with even parity polynomials. This data has been taken from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
In order to generate the photodetachment spectra of N O 3 NO_3 N O 3 molecule, dynamical calculations were performed over the BBO theory based diabatic PESs of five coupled electronic manifold. The initial wavepacket was constituted with the product of GWP for each normal mode of N O 3 − NO_3^{-} N O 3 − , which was placed over each of the five low-lying electronic states (X ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{X}^{2}A_{2} X ~ 2 A 2 , A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ ) one by one, produced the time-dependent wavefunction vis-à-vis autocorrelation functions (C ( t ) C(t) C ( t ) s) at various time. Finally, Fourier transformation of C ( t ) C(t) C ( t ) s were
carried out to generate the spectral envelop for each wavepacket initiated from various electronic states. Then, the individual state spectra were convoluted to get the entire spectral profile. Figure 6.13 depicts theoretical spectrum for E ′ ′ E^{\prime\prime} E ′′ state 16 obtained from BBO-DH in comparison with the experimental outcome 125. For most of the peaks, both the spectra exhibit satisfactory agreement with each other, but some deviations appear due to the hot bands. It is interesting to note that the highly structured profile of E ′ ′ E^{\prime\prime} E ′′ state is enriched with A 2 ′ → E ′ ′ A_2^{\prime} \to E^{\prime\prime} A 2 ′ → E ′′ dipole forbidden transitions, which are mainly governed by umbrella mode, Q 2 Q_2 Q 2 . On the other hand, Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 vibration mediated JT distortion, more specifically along Q 3 y Q_{3y} Q 3 y normal mode as well as other symmetry allowed accidental CIs produce some anharmonicity in the PESs and thereby, result into many dipole forbidden transitions.
Figure 6.13. The upper column presents (a) theoretically calculated photodetachment spectra of N O 3 \mathrm{NO}_{3} NO 3 molecule originating from BBO theory based diabatic PESs for E ′ ′ E^{\prime\prime} E ′′ states, which is compared with the experimental one 125 in panel b. The results are taken from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 + _2^{+} 2 + Radical Cation
Over the last five decades, a wide variety of experimental techniques, namely, calorimetry, NMR, X-ray photoelectron and photoabsorption spectroscopy, and many others were employed to explore the geometrical parameters, normal mode frequencies, vibrational levels of various electronic states as well as spectral properties of o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 _2 2 (o-DFBz) and o-DFBz+ ^{+} + species. 128–139 Clark and co-workers 131 as well as Shirley group 132 recorded the X-ray photoelectron spectra (XPS) to unveil the binding energies of core molecular orbitals of the titled system. On the other hand, Gilbert and Sandorfy 133 measured photoabsorption spectra, where those bands originates from the lowest ionization potentials of the π \pi π electrons. In the early eighties, Bieri et al. 134 carried out the photoelectron spectra of low-lying eighteen (18) electronic states of the titled system. Furthermore, several other experimental techniques, namely, photoabsorption spectroscopy 135–137 and Mass-Analysed Threshold Ionization (MATI) spectroscopy 139 were utilized to reveal the complex electronic structure and energy spectrum of the neutral analogue. On the other hand, Köppel and coworkers 115 derived VCM based quasi-diabatic Hamiltonian involving five low-lying doublet electronic states (X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_1 X ~ 2 B 1 , A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_2 A ~ 2 A 2 , B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^{2}B_1 B ~ 2 B 1 , C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_1 C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_2 D ~ 2 B 2 ) of the cationic species, o-DFBz+ ^{+} + as functions of twelve coupling modes (Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 , Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 , Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 , Q 12 + 15 Q_{12+15} Q 12 + 15 , Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 , Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 , Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 , Q 22 Q_{22} Q 22 , Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 , Q 25 Q_{25} Q 25 and Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ). The MCTDH dynamics 140 on this Hamiltonian had been performed to calculate the photoelectron and MATI spectra of the neutral molecule, o-DFBz, and then, the spectral envelops were compared with the available experimental spectral profiles 134,139. Later on, Adhikari and co-workers 116 executed TDDVR dynamics over the same VCM based model Hamiltonian 115 for the cationic species. The simulated spectra were compared together with experimental 134,139 as well as theoretical 140 results to depict the accuracy of TDDVR dynamics.
Adhikari et al. 32 carried out ab initio calculation followed by BBO based diabatization over eight (8) 2D nuclear planes constituted with eight (8) non-adiabatically active normal modes (i.e., Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 , Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 , Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 , Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 , Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 , Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 , Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 and Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ), where those normal modes are defined as in plane C-C bending (Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 and Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 ), out of plane C-C-C bending (Q 07 Q_{07} Q 07 ), out of plane C-H bending (Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 and Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 ), in plane C-F stretching (Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 ) and in plane C-C stretching (Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 and Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ). Among these normal modes, the totally symmetric modes (Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 , Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 , Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 and Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ) behave as tuning ones, where the non-totally symmetric ones (Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 , Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 , Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 and Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 ) serve as coupling modes. The adiabatic PESs were calculated using CASSCF methodology, followed by MRCI with the aid of correlation-consistent polarized valence double-ζ \zeta ζ (cc-pvDZ) basis set in no symmetry situation (C 1 C_1 C 1 condition). The state-average calculation incorporates the low-lying five electronic states (X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_1 X ~ 2 B 1 , A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_2 A ~ 2 A 2 , B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^{2}B_1 B ~ 2 B 1 , C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_1 C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_2 D ~ 2 B 2 ), with an active space of eleven electrons in six orbitals (11e, 6o), which involves lone pairs of fluorine and the π \pi π orbitals of the o-DFBz+ ^{+} + moiety.
While scanning adiabatic PESs and NACTs, the pair of normal modes (Q k Q_k Q k , Q l Q_l Q l ) for a nuclear plane were converted into their mass weighted dimensionless polar counterparts (ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ ), where ρ \rho ρ and ϕ \phi ϕ coordinates span from 0.2 to 10.0 and 0 to 2 π 2\pi 2 π , respectively, possessing 50 × 181 grid points at and around the FC region of the nuclear CS. In reality, the normal mode coordinates range from -0.8 to +0.8. It is interesting to note that various non-adiabatic interactions, such as accidental conical intersections (CIs), accidental seams, and pseudo-Jahn-Teller (PJT) couplings can be observed over the eight chosen normal mode (Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 , Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 , Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 , Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 , Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 , Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 , Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 and Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ), whereas the other four appear to be less contributing ones (Q 12 Q_{12} Q 12 , Q 15 Q_{15} Q 15 , Q 22 Q_{22} Q 22 and Q 25 Q_{25} Q 25 ). Figure 6.14 presents 1D curves of adiabatic PESs of X ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X 2 B 1 and A ~ 2 A 2 \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A 2 A 2 state and the associated ϕ \phi ϕ component of NACTs (τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ ) as functions of ρ \rho ρ coordinate at fixed value of ϕ = 8 ∘ \phi= 8^\circ ϕ = 8 ∘ . The τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ exhibits a sharp rise at the point of CI (ρ = 0.67 \rho= 0.67 ρ = 0.67 Å) for Q 6 − Q 7 Q_{6}-Q_{7} Q 6 − Q 7 plane. For this nuclear plane, the figure clearly depicts the presence of accidental CI between electronic states (i.e., X ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X 2 B 1 and A ~ 2 A 2 \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A 2 A 2 ) along a particular value of ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate. On the other hand, Figure 6.15 (a–c) manifests 1D variation of adiabatic PESs for B ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B 2 B 1 - C ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C 2 A 1 electronic states (u 3 u_{3} u 3 and u 4 u_{4} u 4 ) and the associated ϕ \phi ϕ component of NACTs (τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ ) along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate keeping the values of ρ \rho ρ fixed at three different values (0.24 Å, 0.382 Å and 0.54 Å). As per these three figures (6.15(a–c)), the semicircular “3-4" accidental seam is located over ρ \rho ρ -space from 3.6 to 0.67 Å and ϕ \phi ϕ -space from 24° to 160°, respectively. Furthermore, in Figure 6.15 (d), the overall characteristic of the seam and the CI are manifested in the 2D functional form of τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ , exhibiting singular NACTs along the semi-circular seam as well as at the CI point. For the sake of better clarification, Figure 6.15 (e) are presented to show 1D variation of adiabatic PESs and the corresponding NACTs (τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ ) along the ρ \rho ρ coordinate at a fixed magnitude of ϕ \phi ϕ (= 270 ∘ = 270^\circ = 27 0 ∘ ). Finally, two “4-5" (C ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C 2 A 1 - D ~ 2 B 2 \widetilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D 2 B 2 ) accidental CIs are portrayed in Figure 6.16 at ρ = 0.67 \rho= 0.67 ρ = 0.67 Å with ϕ = 90 ∘ \phi= 90^\circ ϕ = 9 0 ∘ and 262 ∘ 262^\circ 26 2 ∘ . Not only JT interactions, but also profound PJT couplings are reflected in the functional forms of NACTs, specifically, τ 13 ϕ \tau_{13}^{\phi} τ 13 ϕ , τ 14 ϕ \tau_{14}^{\phi} τ 14 ϕ , τ 15 ϕ \tau_{15}^{\phi} τ 15 ϕ , τ 23 ϕ \tau_{23}^{\phi} τ 23 ϕ , τ 24 ϕ \tau_{24}^{\phi} τ 24 ϕ , τ 25 ϕ \tau_{25}^{\phi} τ 25 ϕ and τ 35 ϕ \tau_{35}^{\phi} τ 35 ϕ .
Figure 6.14. The 1D curves of adiabatic PESs (u 1 u_{1} u 1 and u 2 u_{2} u 2 ) and the corresponding NACTs (τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ ) between X ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X 2 B 1 and A ~ 2 A 2 \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A 2 A 2 electronic states are depicted along ρ \rho ρ coordinate at ϕ = 8 ∘ \phi= 8^\circ ϕ = 8 ∘ . The τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ rises sharply at the point of CI (ρ = 0.67 \rho= 0.67 ρ = 0.67 Å). The figure is adapted from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Figure 6.15. For the “3-4" (B ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B 2 B 1 - C ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C 2 A 1 ) electronic states, 1D curves of adiabatic PESs (u 3 u_{3} u 3 and u 4 u_{4} u 4 ) and the corresponding ϕ \phi ϕ component of NACTs (τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ ) are presented as function of ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at three different values of ρ \rho ρ = (a) 0.24 Å (b) 0.382 Å and (c) 0.54 Å, where τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ exhibits singular feature at the points of seam. Diagram (d) shows the location of “3-4" seam over 2D functional form of τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ and (e) manifests the “3-4" CI along ρ \rho ρ coordinate at ϕ \phi ϕ = 270° (τ 34 ϕ \tau_{34}^{\phi} τ 34 ϕ , which shows a steep rise at the point of CI i.e., ρ \rho ρ = 3.6). The figure is adapted from [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Figure 6.16. The 1D curves of adiabatic PESs (u 4 u_4 u 4 and u 5 u_5 u 5 ) and the corresponding NACTs (τ 45 ϕ \tau_{45}^{\phi} τ 45 ϕ ) between C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D ~ 2 B 2 electronic states are plotted along ρ \rho ρ coordinate at ϕ = 90 ∘ \phi=90^\circ ϕ = 9 0 ∘ and 262 ∘ 262^\circ 26 2 ∘ , where τ 45 ϕ \tau_{45}^{\phi} τ 45 ϕ rises sharply at the close vicinity of the CI (ρ = 0.67 \rho=0.67 ρ = 0.67 Å). The figure is adapted from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Since Q 6 Q_{6} Q 6 -Q 7 Q_{7} Q 7 normal mode pair shows one “1-2" CI, one “3-4" CI, one “3-4" seam as well as two “4-5" CIs, the closed contour integration along the ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at a fixed values of ρ \rho ρ leads to π \pi π , 2 π 2\pi 2 π and 2 π 2\pi 2 π , respectively for the associated ADT angles, namely Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 and Θ 45 \Theta_{45} Θ 45 (see Figure 6.17 (a)). On the other hand, Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 representing “2-3" PJT is also presented, which acquires zero (0) value at ϕ = 2 π \phi= 2\pi ϕ = 2 π in spite of non-zero intermediate values at other ϕ \phi ϕ -coordinates. It is worth mentioning that the ADT angles appear topological in nature (depicted by the solid line) rather than geometric one (represented by the dashed line) in Figure 6.17 . On the other hand, diagonal elements of ADT matrices, A 11 [ = A 22 ] A_{11}[=A_{22}] A 11 [ = A 22 ] , A 33 A_{33} A 33 and A 55 A_{55} A 55 are presented in Figure 6.17 (b), where the associated 1D curves undergo one (1), two (2) and two (2) sign inversions, respectively encapsulating one “1-2" accidental CI, one “3-4" accidental CI along with one seam and two “4-5" accidental CIs, respectively. It needs to mention that the numerical values of Curl condition becomes zero (0) (see Figure 6.18 ) validating the existence of five state SHS for o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F+ ^{+} + radical cation.
Figure 6.17. 1D functional forms of ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 and Θ 45 \Theta_{45} Θ 45 , and diagonal elements of ADT matrices, namely, A 11 A_{11} A 11 [= A 22 A_{22} A 22 ], A 33 A_{33} A 33 and A 55 A_{55} A 55 for Q 6 − Q 7 Q_6-Q_7 Q 6 − Q 7 normal mode pairs are plotted as function of the angular coordinate, ϕ \phi ϕ at specific ρ \rho ρ -values, which affirms the presence or absence of the CIs/seams encapsulated by the closed loop of integration. The figure is adapted from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Figure 6.18. The Mathematical Curls [(a) Z ρ ϕ 45 Z_{\rho\phi}^{45} Z ρϕ 45 and (d) Z ρ ϕ 15 Z_{\rho\phi}^{15} Z ρϕ 15 ], ADT Curls [(b) C ρ ϕ 45 C_{\rho\phi}^{45} C ρϕ 45 and (e) C ρ ϕ 15 C_{\rho\phi}^{15} C ρϕ 15 ] and the Curl Condition [(c) F ρ ϕ 45 F_{\rho\phi}^{45} F ρϕ 45 and (f) F ρ ϕ 15 F_{\rho\phi}^{15} F ρϕ 15 ] corresponding to “4-5” accidental CIs and “1-5” PJT interactions are shown as functions of ϕ \phi ϕ -coordinate for three different values of ρ \rho ρ -coordinate of Q6 _6 6 -Q7 _7 7 normal mode pair. The figure is adapted from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Once BBO based diabatization was completed, the initial product wavepacket was placed on each of the five electronic states, X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 , A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A ~ 2 A 2 , B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B ~ 2 B 1 , C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D ~ 2 B 2 to perform five separate dynamical calculations yielding individual state spectra, which were then convoluted to produce the overall spectral profile for the five lowest electronic states of o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 _2 2 molecule as depicted in left panel of Figure 6.19 . The individual state spectra for X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 and A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A ~ 2 A 2 states (see Figure 6.19 (c)) are merged into Figure 6.19 (b) showing the convoluted spectra for B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B ~ 2 B 1 , C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D ~ 2 B 2 states. On the other hand, the entire spectral profile is presented in Figure 6.19 (a). Furthermore, in the right panel, TDDVR calculated photoelectron spectra of o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 _2 2 obtained from BBO-DH are compared with the existing theoretical115,140 and experimental134 spectra. It is interesting to note that the TDDVR calculated profile exhibits good agreement with the experimental data reported by Beiri et al. 134. Most peaks in BBO based theoretical calculated spectra exhibit better accord with the experimental findings in comparison with the spectra obtained from MCTDH dynamics over VCM-based quasi-diabatic Hamiltonian115,140 [see Figure 6.19 (d-Figure 6.19 f)]. The non-adiabatic interactions (JT CI/seam, accidental CI/seam and PJT interactions) present in this molecule are mainly responsible for the structured spectral bands of the first two (i.e., X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 -A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A ~ 2 A 2 ) and the other three (i.e., B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B ~ 2 B 1 -C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C ~ 2 A 1 -D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D ~ 2 B 2 ) states. In addition, the vibrational fine structure in the spectrum originates from the electronic transitions between different vibrational levels of the neutral and cationic forms of the o-DFBz molecule.
Figure 6.19. The left column (a-c) demonstrates TDDVR computed spectral envelops calculated from BBO constructed 5×5 diabatic Hamiltonian for X ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X 2 B 1 - A ~ 2 A 2 \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A 2 A 2 (X-A spectra) and B ~ 2 B 1 \widetilde{B}^{2}B_{1} B 2 B 1 - C ~ 2 A 1 \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{1} C 2 A 1 - D ~ 2 B 2 \widetilde{D}^{2}B_{2} D 2 B 2 (B-C-D spectra), whereas the right column (d-f) presents the comparison of calculated spectra obtained from (f) TDDVR dynamics over BBO diabatic Hamiltonian with (d) the experimental one 134 as well as with (e) other theoretical spectra 140 originated from MCTDH dynamics over VCM based quasi-diabatic surfaces 115. The figure is taken from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Mass-analyzed threshold ionization (MATI) technique can be used to identify zero kinetic energy ions produced by pulsed field ionization of neutral molecules, which are excited to high Rydberg states via an intermediate electronic state. 141 MATI spectra provide detailed vibrational information of this molecular cation, since PE spectra alone is not sufficient to provide adequate insight. In the recent work, 32 MATI spectra were calculated by initiating the product-type wave-function on the ground state (X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 ) to carry out quantum dynamics by considering 2×2 diabatic Hamiltonian for the lowest two electronic states, X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 -A ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2} A ~ 2 A 2 of o-DFBz+ ^{+} + cation. Figure 6.20 exhibits the calculated MATI spectra depicting good agreement with both the experimentally measured139 and the reported theoretical140 spectra. The experimental “0-0” peak at 74995 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , along with few other peaks at 75287 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , 75547 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 and 75746 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 etc. are well captured in the theoretical spectral profile, appearing at 75027 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 (“0-0” peak), 75264 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , 75552 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 and 75780 cm− 1 ^{-1} − 1 , respectively. Few other small peaks are also observed in the calculated MATI spectra32 in comparison with the experimental one139, which are mainly originated from fundamental transitions as well as numerous overtones and combination bands. In comparison to the PE spectra, the MATI spectra exhibit more prominent vibronic fine structure, where the intense peaks arise from electronic transitions appearing due to more populated vibrational states corresponding to low-frequency modes.
Figure 6.20. The MATI spectra calculated from the ground state (X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^{2}B_{1} X ~ 2 B 1 ) of the [2 × 2 2 \times2 2 × 2 ] diabatic Hamiltonian for the o-DFBz+ ^{+} + molecule are shown in comparison with other theoretical result 140 and experimentally measured one 139. The figure is adapted from Ref. [32] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
Six State : 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^{+} 3 +
The intense vibronic couplings prevailing within the low-lying six electronic states of 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^{+} 3 + (TFBz+ ^{+} + ) radical cation, namely, X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \widetilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X 2 E ′′ , A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} A 2 A 2 ′′ , B ~ 2 E ′ \widetilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B 2 E ′ and C ~ 2 A 2 ′ \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime} C 2 A 2 ′ in the FC region are the key mechanistic elements for dictating the position and width of bands in the photoelectron spectrum. 142,143 Several groups 144–146 selectively chose the neutral analogue of this radical cation to explore the impact of fluorine substitution during the emission process from the excited states as well as to study the JT and PJT effects, which have substantial implications on the dynamical process. Recently, it has been unveiled that among the lowest six electronic states, X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \widetilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \widetilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B 2 E ′ encounter JT splitting resulting into lowering of symmetry followed by stabilization in energy due to the e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ vibrational modes. 23,147 On the other hand, e ′ ′ e^{\prime\prime} e ′′ modes are responsible for PJT effects, which are more predominant within A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \widetilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} A 2 A 2 ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \widetilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B 2 E ′ states. 17 Similarly, e ′ ′ e^{\prime\prime} e ′′ , e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ modes are
also responsible for X ~ 2 E ′ ′ − A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime}-\tilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ − A ~ 2 A 2 ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 2 ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime}-\tilde{C}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 2 ′ PJT interactions.147
As per the recent findings,23 the e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ normal modes, namely, asymmetric C-C stretching (Q 9 x − Q 9 y Q_{9x}-Q_{9y} Q 9 x − Q 9 y ) and C-C-C in-plane bending (Q 13 x − Q 13 y Q_{13x}-Q_{13y} Q 13 x − Q 13 y ) are responsible for the JT interactions with doubly degenerate electronic states, X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ , which can be validated using symmetrized direct product analysis for the electronic states (X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ ) and the e ′ e^{\prime} e ′ normal modes (Q 9 x Q_{9x} Q 9 x , Q 9 y Q_{9y} Q 9 y , Q 13 x Q_{13x} Q 13 x and Q 13 y Q_{13y} Q 13 y ):
A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ E ′ ′ ⊗ E ′ ′ ] A_{1}^{\prime} \in e^{\prime} \otimes[E^{\prime\prime} \otimes E^{\prime\prime}] A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ E ′′ ⊗ E ′′ ]
and
A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ E ′ ⊗ E ′ ] A_{1}^{\prime} \in e^{\prime} \otimes[E^{\prime} \otimes E^{\prime}] A 1 ′ ∈ e ′ ⊗ [ E ′ ⊗ E ′ ]
In case of Q 13 x − Q 13 y Q_{13x}-Q_{13y} Q 13 x − Q 13 y nuclear plane, JT distortions are prominent within X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ (“1-2”) and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ (“4-5”) electronic states near equilibrium nuclear configuration (ρ → 0.0 \rho\to0.0 ρ → 0.0 ) leading to the stabilization of energy for the respective lower sheets (ground and third excited states) by lowering the symmetry of the nuclear geometry. Figure 6.21 depicts 1D functional forms of adiabatic PESs and the corresponding ϕ \phi ϕ component of NACTs as functions of the ρ \rho ρ coordinate at a specific value of ϕ \phi ϕ (= 60°). The presence of “1-2” and “4-5” JT CIs can be observed in Figure 6.21 a and Figure 6.21 b, respectively, where the NACTs (τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 and τ ϕ 45 \tau_{\phi}^{45} τ ϕ 45 ) attain singular characteristics at the close vicinity of those CIs. On the other hand, 1D functional forms of the corresponding ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 and Θ 45 \Theta_{45} Θ 45 along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate (at ρ \rho ρ = 0.08 Å) attain the magnitude of π \pi π at ϕ \phi ϕ = 2 π 2\pi 2 π (see Figure 6.22 a). In addition, ADT angles associated with the PJT interactions (Θ 13 \Theta_{13} Θ 13 and Θ 56 \Theta_{56} Θ 56 ) become zero (0) at ϕ \phi ϕ = 2 π 2\pi 2 π , even though such angles take non-zero magnitude at intermediate values of ϕ \phi ϕ . Furthermore, Figure 6.22 b exhibits relevant diagonal elements of ADT matrices, namely, A 11 A_{11} A 11 [= A 22 A_{22} A 22 ] and A 44 A_{44} A 44 [= A 55 A_{55} A 55 ] leading to one sign inversion along the ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate affirming the presence of “1-2” and “4-5” JT CIs inside the closed contour. In case of TFBz+ ^{+} + cation, the adiabatic PESs, NACTs, diabatic PESs and couplings exhibit even parity functional variation along various asymmetric normal modes, like Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x (see Figure 6.23 )
Figure 6.21. In case of Q 13 x − Q 13 y Q_{13x}-Q_{13y} Q 13 x − Q 13 y pair of TFBz+ ^{+} + , (a) left and (b) right panels display 1D cuts of adiabatic PESs of X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ (u 1 u_{1} u 1 and u 2 u_{2} u 2 ) and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ (u 4 u_{4} u 4 and u 5 u_{5} u 5 ) electronic states and the associated NACTs (τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 and τ ϕ 45 \tau_{\phi}^{45} τ ϕ 45 ) along ρ \rho ρ coordinate at ϕ \phi ϕ = 60°. The “1-2” and “4-5” JT CIs are located at the equilibrium geometry (ρ → 0.0 \rho\to0.0 ρ → 0.0 ). The figure is adapted from Ref. [23] and permission has been taken from RSC.
Figure 6.22. The left diagram (a) displays 1D functional form of ADT angles, Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 45 \Theta_{45} Θ 45 , Θ 13 \Theta_{13} Θ 13 and Θ 56 \Theta_{56} Θ 56 for Q 13 x − Q 13 y Q_{13x}-Q_{13y} Q 13 x − Q 13 y pair along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at a fixed value of ρ \rho ρ (= 0.08 Å). The right diagram (b) demonstrates 1D cuts of diagonal elements of ADT matrices, viz., (b) A 11 [ = A 22 ] A_{11}[= A_{22}] A 11 [ = A 22 ] and A 44 [ = A 55 ] A_{44}[= A_{55}] A 44 [ = A 55 ] for the same pair. In each case, the ADT angles and diagonal elements of the ADT matrices unveil the presence or absence of the encapsulated CIs/seams inside the closed loop of integration. The figure has been adapted from Ref. [23] and permission has been taken from RSC.
Figure 6.23. 1D functional form of diabatic coupling element, namely, W 12 W_{12} W 12 among X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \widetilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X 2 E ′′ states along Q 9 x Q_{9x} Q 9 x mode of TFBz+ ^{+} + radical cation is displayed. The coupling term possesses symmetric functional form, which can be fitted only with even parity polynomials. The figure has been adapted from Ref. [21] and permission has been taken from RSC.
The calculated ADT angles23 were further employed to calculate Mathematical Curls (Z ϕ ϕ i j Z_{\phi\phi}^{ij} Z ϕϕ ij ) and ADT Curls (C ρ ϕ i j C_{\rho\phi}^{ij} C ρϕ ij ) using their explicit expressions in terms of those mixing angles (see Appendix B.1). Figure 6.24
Figure 6.24. 1D cuts of Mathematical Curl (Z ρ ϕ 56 Z_{\rho\phi}^{56} Z ρϕ 56 ) and ADT Curl (C ρ ϕ 56 C_{\rho\phi}^{56} C ρϕ 56 ) associated with “5-6" accidental seam are plotted along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate at three different ρ \rho ρ values for Q 9 y − Q 18 y Q_{9y}-Q_{18y} Q 9 y − Q 18 y plane of 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^+ 3 + radical cation. The figure has been adapted from Ref. [112] and permission has been taken from Wiley.
presents 1D variation of those quantities (Z ρ ϕ 56 Z_{\rho\phi}^{56} Z ρϕ 56 and C ρ ϕ 56 C_{\rho\phi}^{56} C ρϕ 56 ) along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate for three different values of ρ \rho ρ acquiring large non-zero values, whereas their difference (F ρ ϕ 56 F_{\rho\phi}^{56} F ρϕ 56 ) appears as negligibly zero (< 10 − 12 < 10^{-12} < 1 0 − 12 ) validating the six state SHS as a “true" subspace.
TDDVR dynamics over BBO-DH provides theoretically calculated PE spectra as presented in Figure 6.25 , which are found to be in good accord with the available experimental spectra recorded by Gilbert et al.142 as well as the outcome of MCTDH dynamics using VCM based quasi-diabatic Hamiltonian. 147 As a matter of fact, most of the peaks in our theoretical spectra exhibit better agreement with experiment,142 which justifies the “exactness" and “accuracy" of the BBO formalism in conjunction with TDDVR approach over the VCM model147 followed by MCTDH dynamics. It is interesting to observe that the experimental spectrum for X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ state contains three peaks at 9.7086 eV, 9.7696 eV and 9.8281 eV (Figure 6.25 a) among which the third one has the highest intensity. Similarly, our theoretically calculated spectra (Figure 6.25 c) also show three peaks at 9.7223 eV, 9.7670 eV and 9.8273 eV, where the third peak exhibits the highest intensity. On the other hand, Figure 6.25 f depicts our theoretically calculated PE spectra for A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 A 2 ′′ state in comparison with the experimental ones (Figure 6.25 d) and other theoretical findings (Figure 6.25 e). In both cases (X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ and A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 A 2 ′′ ), one can observe a broad spectral envelop at relatively higher energy (> 10.0 > 10.0 > 10.0 eV and > 12.7 > 12.7 > 12.7 eV) without any well-defined peak positions, which are mainly arising from the overtones of various vibrational frequencies. Finally, the PE spectra for B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 1 ′ \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime}-\tilde{C}^{2}A_{1}^{\prime} B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 1 ′ states (Figure 6.25 (g-Figure 6.25 i)) appear as a broad band with diffused structure, which is originating from profound electron-nuclear (nonadiabatic) couplings.
Figure 6.25. Figure 6.25: The left column displays (c) theoretical spectrum for the ground degenerate state (X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^{2}E^{\prime\prime} X ~ 2 E ′′ ) obtained from TDDVR dynamics over BBO-DH in comparison with (a) experimental PE spectrum of TFBz142 and other (b) theoretical spectrum obtained from MCTDH approach on VCM based quasi-diabatic surfaces147. The middle column (d-f) and the right one (g-i) depict the same quantities for A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \tilde{A}^{2}A_{2}^{\prime\prime} A ~ 2 A 2 ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 2 \tilde{B}^{2}E^{\prime}-\tilde{C}^{2}A_{2} B ~ 2 E ′ − C ~ 2 A 2 states. For all the three cases, TDDVR calculated spectra exhibit better peak by peak correspondence with the experimental ones over MCTDH147 dynamics. The figure has been taken from Ref. [23] and permission has been taken from RSC.
Path Dependence of BBO Based Diabatic Hamiltonians and Associated Observables: C6H6+ Radical Cation
Brief Overview
C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + (Bz+ ^+ + ) radical cation drew attention of the allied scientific communities due to its highly complex spectral bands originating from intense vibronic couplings between its low-lying five electronic states (X ~ 2 E 1 g \tilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X ~ 2 E 1 g , B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u ) through its vibrational modes. In order to explore the dynamical features, several theoretical calculations38,39,57,148–151 were carried out considering nonadiabatic interactions prevalent within
those states. It is interesting to note that the low lying doublet states of Bz+, namely, X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g and B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g exhibit JT stabilization along the e ′ e' e ′ modes. 13,149 On the other hand, profound PJT couplings and accidental CIs can be observed within B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u electronic states over the FC region of nuclear CS. 13,148
Ab Initio Calculations and BBO Theory Based Diabatization
In order to perform BBO based diabatization followed by nuclear dynamics, seven normal modes were considered including two e 2 g e_{2g} e 2 g (in D 6 h D_{6h} D 6 h ) symmetric degenerate pairs, namely, in-plane asymmetric stretching (Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x and Q 16 y Q_{16y} Q 16 y ) and asymmetric ring deformation (Q 18 x Q_{18x} Q 18 x and Q 18 y Q_{18y} Q 18 y ). The symmetrized direct products for the X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g and B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g electronic states with e 2 g e_{2g} e 2 g normal modes depict the JT active interactions,
A 1 g ∈ e 2 g ⊗ [ E 1 g ⊗ E 1 g ] A_{1g} \in e_{2g} \otimes[E_{1g} \otimes E_{1g}] A 1 g ∈ e 2 g ⊗ [ E 1 g ⊗ E 1 g ]
and
A 1 g ∈ e 2 g ⊗ [ E 2 g ⊗ E 2 g ] A_{1g} \in e_{2g} \otimes[E_{2g} \otimes E_{2g}] A 1 g ∈ e 2 g ⊗ [ E 2 g ⊗ E 2 g ]
Adhikari and coworkers 38,39,57 performed TDDVR dynamical calculations to predict the theoretical photoelectron spectra of benzene molecule using VCM based model diabatic Hamiltonian 148–150. Later on, the same group 22 carried out extensive ab initio electronic structure calculations to compute ab initio adiabatic PESs and NACTs followed by BBO-DH for lowest five electronic states (X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g , B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u ) over various 2D nuclear planes constituted with seven normal modes, namely, breathing (Q 2 Q_{2} Q 2 ), ring deformation (Q 8 Q_{8} Q 8 ) degenerate in-plane asymmetric stretching (Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x and Q 16 y Q_{16y} Q 16 y ), degenerate in-plane bending (Q 18 x Q_{18x} Q 18 x and Q 18 y Q_{18y} Q 18 y ) and one component of degenerate out-of-plane bending (Q 19 x Q_{19x} Q 19 x ) modes. The 2D functional features of ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs over the ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ plane of Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y pair are depicted in Figure 6.26 . While carrying out BBO based diabatization, five state ADT equations (see Appendix B.1) are solved numerically to calculate mixing angles followed by construction of ADT matrices and diabatic potential energy matrices. 13,22 The 1D functional forms of ADT angles are demonstrated in Figure 6.27 a and Figure 6.27 c for Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y and Q 18 x − Q 19 x Q_{18x}-Q_{19x} Q 18 x − Q 19 x pairs, where the ADT angles (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 and Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 ) attain the magnitude of π \pi π due to “1-2” and “3-4” CIs/seams. On the other hand, the ADT angles appearing due to PJT couplings (Θ 15 \Theta_{15} Θ 15 and Θ 25 \Theta_{25} Θ 25 for Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y , and Θ 13 \Theta_{13} Θ 13 and Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 for Q 18 x − Q 19 x Q_{18x}-Q_{19x} Q 18 x − Q 19 x ) become zero (0) at ϕ = 2 π \phi=2\pi ϕ = 2 π , even though such angles attain non-zero magnitudes at other values of ϕ \phi ϕ (see Figures. Figure 6.27 a and Figure 6.27 c). On the other hand, it is worth mentioning that A 11 [ = A 22 ] A_{11} [= A_{22}] A 11 [ = A 22 ] and A 33 [ = A 44 ] A_{33} [= A_{44}] A 33 [ = A 44 ] exhibit one sign flipping due to the presence of “1-2” and “3-4” JT CIs/seams, respectively for those nuclear planes (see Figures. Figure 6.27 b and Figure 6.27 d for Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y and Q 18 x − Q 19 x Q_{18x}-Q_{19x} Q 18 x − Q 19 x pairs). The diabatic PESs and couplings computed from those ADT angles display symmetric functional behaviour along Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x and Q 18 y Q_{18y} Q 18 y normal modes, which can only be fitted with even power polynomials 15 in contrast to traditional JT model (see Figure 6.28 for Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x mode).
Figure 6.26. Figure 6.26: 2D functional features of (a) τ ϕ 12 \tau_{\phi}^{12} τ ϕ 12 , (b) τ ϕ 34 \tau_{\phi}^{34} τ ϕ 34 , (c) τ ϕ 15 \tau_{\phi}^{15} τ ϕ 15 and (b) τ ϕ 25 \tau_{\phi}^{25} τ ϕ 25 are plotted over ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ plane of Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y pair. The permission for the results of Ref. [22] has been taken from AIP.
Figure 6.27. The left panel depicts 1D variation of (a) ADT angles (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 , Θ 15 \Theta_{15} Θ 15 and Θ 25 \Theta_{25} Θ 25 ) and (b) diagonal elements of ADT matrix, A 11 [ = A 22 ] A_{11}[=A_{22}] A 11 [ = A 22 ] and A 33 [ = A 44 ] A_{33}[=A_{44}] A 33 [ = A 44 ] for Q 16 x − Q 16 y Q_{16x}-Q_{16y} Q 16 x − Q 16 y pair along ϕ \phi ϕ axis keeping the value of ρ \rho ρ fixed at 0.17 Å. On the other hand, the right panel (c-d) shows the same quantities (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 , Θ 34 \Theta_{34} Θ 34 , Θ 13 \Theta_{13} Θ 13 , Θ 23 \Theta_{23} Θ 23 and A 11 [ = A 22 ] A_{11}[=A_{22}] A 11 [ = A 22 ] , A 33 [ = A 44 ] A_{33}[=A_{44}] A 33 [ = A 44 ] ) for Q 18 x − Q 19 x Q_{18x}-Q_{19x} Q 18 x − Q 19 x pair at ρ = 0.24 \rho= 0.24 ρ = 0.24 Å. For all cases, ADT angles and diagonal ADT matrix elements reflect the quantization property of NACTs. The results have been taken from Ref. [22] with permission from AIP.
Figure 6.28. 1D plot of diabatic coupling element, namely, W 34 W_{34} W 34 among B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g states along Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x mode of B z + \mathrm{Bz}^{+} Bz + radical cation is depicted. The coupling term shows symmetric functional form, which can be fitted with even parity polynomials. The results have been taken from [21] with permission from RSC.
Once the ADT angles are in hand, 13 those are plugged into the explicit expressions of Curl Conditions to evaluate the Mathematical Curls (Z ρ ϕ i j Z_{\rho\phi}^{ij} Z ρϕ ij ) (see Appendix B.1) and ADT Curls (C ρ ϕ i j C_{\rho\phi}^{ij} C ρϕ ij ) to validate the Curl Condition (F ρ ϕ i j = 0 F_{\rho\phi}^{ij}=0 F ρϕ ij = 0 ) for the five state SHS. Figure 6.29 depicts 1D curves of Z ρ ϕ 45 Z_{\rho\phi}^{45} Z ρϕ 45 and C ρ ϕ 45 C_{\rho\phi}^{45} C ρϕ 45 (exhibiting “4-5” accidental CI) as well as Z ρ ϕ 15 Z_{\rho\phi}^{15} Z ρϕ 15 and C ρ ϕ 15 C_{\rho\phi}^{15} C ρϕ 15 (representing “1-5” PJT interaction) along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinates at three different values of ρ \rho ρ . The differences (F ρ ϕ i j F_{\rho\phi}^{ij} F ρϕ ij ) between those Curls (Z ρ ϕ i j Z_{\rho\phi}^{ij} Z ρϕ ij and C ρ ϕ i j C_{\rho\phi}^{ij} C ρϕ ij ) appear almost zero (0) value for both cases (< 10 − 15 − 2 <10^{-15-2} < 1 0 − 15 − 2 for “4-5” and “1-5” interactions). 78
Figure 6.29. The Mathematical Curls [(a) Z ρ ϕ 45 Z^{45}_{\rho\phi} Z ρϕ 45 and (c) Z ρ ϕ 15 Z^{15}_{\rho\phi} Z ρϕ 15 ] and ADT Curls [(b) C ρ ϕ 45 C^{45}_{\rho\phi} C ρϕ 45 and (d) C ρ ϕ 15 C^{15}_{\rho\phi} C ρϕ 15 ] indicating “4-5” CI and “1-5” PJT interactions are demonstrated along the angular coordinate (ϕ \phi ϕ ) at three different values of ρ \rho ρ for Q 19 x Q_{19x} Q 19 x -Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x plane of C 6 H 6 + C_{6}H_{6}^{+} C 6 H 6 + . The figures have been adapted from Ref. [112] with permission from Wiley.
Quantum Dynamics over Path-Dependent Diabatic Hamiltonians with Unique Observables
The path independence of computed observables obtained from diabatic Hamiltonians constructed along different paths was explored. TDDVR based quantum dynamics 34,40 was carried out over highly “accurate” BBO-DH of low-lying five electronic states of C 6 H 6 + \mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}^{+} C 6 H 6 + radical cation (X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g , B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u ) originating
from three approaches of contour integration along paths I and II ({ W i j I } \{W_{ij}^{I}\} { W ij I } , { W I I a I J } \{W_{IIa}^{I J}\} { W I I a I J } and { W I I b I J } \{W_{IIb}^{I J}\} { W I I b I J } ). In path I, ADT equations were solved along ϕ \phi ϕ coordinate from ϕ min ( = 0 ) \phi_{\min}(=0) ϕ m i n ( = 0 ) to ϕ max ( = ϕ min + 2 π ) \phi_{\max}(=\phi_{\min}+2\pi) ϕ m a x ( = ϕ m i n + 2 π ) at the lowest value of ρ ( = ρ min ) \rho(=\rho_{\min}) ρ ( = ρ m i n ) and then, along the ρ \rho ρ coordinate for each value of ϕ \phi ϕ (see Figure 6.30 a). On the other hand, in path II, ADT equations were solved first along ρ \rho ρ coordinate from higher ( ρ max ) (\rho_{\max}) ( ρ m a x ) to lower ( ρ min ) (\rho_{\min}) ( ρ m i n ) at ϕ = ϕ min ( = 0 ) \phi=\phi_{\min}(=0) ϕ = ϕ m i n ( = 0 ) and then, along the ϕ \phi ϕ grid from ϕ min ( = 0 ) \phi_{\min}(=0) ϕ m i n ( = 0 ) to ϕ max ( = ϕ min + 2 π ) \phi_{\max}(=\phi_{\min}+2\pi) ϕ m a x ( = ϕ m i n + 2 π ) for each ρ \rho ρ value (see Figure 6.30 b). Finally the computed ADT angles ({ Θ i j I } \{\Theta_{ij}^{I}\} { Θ ij I } ) obtained from path I were plugged into the explicit expressions of NACTs for five state SHS (see Appendix B.1) to regenerate the components of NACTs (τ ρ \tau^{\rho} τ ρ and τ ϕ \tau^{\phi} τ ϕ ) and then, the ADT equations were again solved along path II with the help of recalculated NACTs to compute a new set of ADT angles ({ Θ i j I I b } \{\Theta_{ij}^{IIb}\} { Θ ij I I b } ), ADT matrix ({ A i j I I b } \{A_{ij}^{IIb}\} { A ij I I b } ) and diabatic PESs matrix ({ W i j I I b } \{W_{ij}^{IIb}\} { W ij I I b } ) elements.
Figure 6.30. The two different paths over the ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ space are depicted in diagrams (a) and (b) along which we solve the ADT equations for the calculation of ADT angles, ADT matrices and diabatic PESs matrices. For each case, those stiff linear coupled differential (ADT) equations are first integrated along the bold red line and then, along the dotted blue lines. The results have been taken from Ref. [152] with permission from AIP.
Once the diabatic Hamiltonian along path I ({ W i j I } \{W_{ij}^{I}\} { W ij I } ) are in hand, the initial wavepacket was placed on each of the electronic states, X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g , B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u to carry out five different calculations for the generation of the individual state spectra and then, those were convoluted to obtain the overall photoelectron spectral profile for five low-lying electronic states. The TDDVR calculated spectral profiles of C 6 H 6 \mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6} C 6 H 6 obtained from BBO-DH are demonstrated in Figure 6.31 , showing very good peak by peak correspondence with the experimental one observed by Baltzer et al. 153. Furthermore, peak positions of our theoretical spectra (see Figure 6.31 c and 6.31f) show better accord with the experimental results 153 compared to the MCTDH dynamics results obtained from VCM based quasi-diabatic PESs and couplings 149,150,154 (see Figure 6.31 b and 6.31e). Figure 6.31 c shows that the spectral envelop for X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g states possesses the most intense 0-0 peak at 9.2424 eV, which is in very close proximity of the experimental one (9.2453 eV). On the other hand, a broad vibrational structure with few low intense peaks can be observed on the high binding energy side (> 9.4 >9.4 > 9.4 eV), which can be considered as the hot bands. In addition, for B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u states, the peak maxima of the 0-0 band (11.4886 eV) as well as the other vibrational excitations (11.5746 eV, 11.6446 eV, 11.6856 eV, etc.) match well with the experimental results. A pronounced shoulder is present on the low binding energy compared to 0-0 peak for B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g state, which is also observed in the experimentally recorded spectral band. It is worth mentioning that the broad features at high energy binding side (around 12 eV) of B ~ 2 E 2 g − C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g}-\widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} B 2 E 2 g − C 2 A 2 u band (see Figure 6.31 f) do not contain any well defined peak maxima, which bear the signature of C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u electronic states.
Figure 6.31. The left column presents (a) the experimental PE spectrum of benzene 153 for the ground degenerate state (X ~ 2 E 1 g \widetilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X 2 E 1 g ), which is compared with the theoretical spectra by (b) MCTDH approach on VCM based quasi-diabatic surfaces 150,154 and (c) TDDVR methodology on BBO-DH ({ W I } \{W_{I}\} { W I } ). The right panel (d-f) portrays the same quantities for B ~ 2 E 2 g \widetilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \widetilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C 2 A 2 u states. For all cases, TDDVR based theoretical spectra computed from BBO-DH exhibit better agreement with the experimental one. The results have been taken from Ref. [22] with permission from AIP.
On the other hand, in order to explore the path independence property of the calculated observables using
{ W I 1 j } {\left\{W_{I}^{1j}\right\}} { W I 1 j } , { W I I a 1 j } {\left\{W_{IIa}^{1j}\right\}} { W I I a 1 j } and { W I I b 1 j } {\left\{W_{IIb}^{1j}\right\}} { W I I b 1 j } , three different sets of PE spectra of C 6 H 6 {\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}} C 6 H 6 molecule were generated. 152 The left column of Figure 6.32 presents a comparative analysis between experimental spectra of X ~ 2 E 1 g \tilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X ~ 2 E 1 g state of C 6 H 6 {\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}} C 6 H 6 molecule recorded by Baltzer et al. 153 and the TDDVR based spectra obtained from three different diabatic PESs matrices (W I W_{I} W I , W I I a W_{IIa} W I I a and W I I b W_{IIb} W I I b ). It is worth mentioning that all the three theoretical spectra show good agreement within themselves as well as with the experimental one153. On the other hand, the right column of Figure 6.32 depicts similar satisfactory matching of TDDVR calculated spectra for B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g -C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u electronic states and experimental one 153. It is interesting to observe that for the B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g -C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u electronic states, such agreement is prominent even at the region of hot bands (> 11.9 >11.9 > 11.9 eV). Like the peak positions, intensity patterns of the spectral profiles for the five electronic states, X ~ 2 E 1 g \tilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X ~ 2 E 1 g , B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u show similarities for all the three sets of calculations on W I W_{I} W I , W I I a W_{IIa} W I I a and W I I b W_{IIb} W I I b .
Figure 6.32. The left column compares (b-d) TDDVR calculated PE spectra of benzene obtained from three different diabatic PESs matrices (W I W_{I} W I , W I I a W_{IIa} W I I a and W I I b W_{IIb} W I I b ) with the (a) experimental one 153 for X ~ 2 E 1 g \tilde{X}^{2}E_{1g} X ~ 2 E 1 g state. The right panel presents the same observables [(f-h) TDDVR calculated and (e) experimental spectral profiles 153] for B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^{2}E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g - C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^{2}A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u electronic states. The figures have been taken from Ref. [152] with permission from AIP.
Conclusion
Over the last two decades, the role of electron-nuclear couplings among the low-lying electronic states on the PA/PD/PE/MATI spectra were explored with the aid of BBO treatment. After locating the CIs between the electronic states and constructing multi-state multi-mode BBO-DH, TDDVR based quantum dynamics were employed for a series of molecular systems, namely, N O 2 {\mathrm{NO}_{2}} NO 2 , N a 3 {\mathrm{Na}_{3}} Na 3 , C 4 N 2 H 4 {\mathrm{C}_{4}\mathrm{N}_{2}\mathrm{H}_{4}} C 4 N 2 H 4 , N O 3 {\mathrm{NO}_{3}} NO 3 , C 6 H 6 + {\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{6}^{+}} C 6 H 6 + , o o o -C 6 H 4 F 2 + {\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{4}\mathrm{F}_{2}^{+}} C 6 H 4 F 2 + and 1 , 3 , 5 1,3,5 1 , 3 , 5 -C 6 H 3 F 3 + {\mathrm{C}_{6}\mathrm{H}_{3}\mathrm{F}_{3}^{+}} C 6 H 3 F 3 + molecules/cations to evaluate the spectral features.
Conclusion
In case of NO2 _2 2 radical, two lowest electronic states (X 2 A 1 X^2A_1 X 2 A 1 and A 2 B 2 A^2B_2 A 2 B 2 ) possess JT and RT interactions governing its photodetachment spectrum. 11,12,66–74 Adhikari and coworkers constructed highly precise diabatic Hamiltonian for NO2 _2 2 12 employing MRCI based adiabatic PESs and NACTs obtained from MOLPRO 75 quantum chemistry package followed by ADT calculation. On the other hand, first principle based adiabatic PESs and NACTs were generated for three excited electronic states (2 2 E ′ 2^2E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^2A'_1 1 2 A 1 ′ ) of Na3 _3 3 system using MRCI methodology. Electronic structure as well as ADT calculations were carried out over 2D nuclear plane (ρ − ϕ \rho-\phi ρ − ϕ ) originating from bending (Q x Q_x Q x ) - asymmetric stretching (Q y Q_y Q y ) pair at fixed value of symmetric stretching (Q s Q_s Q s ) mode (3.7 Å). The Na3 _3 3 cluster shows accidental CIs within two branches of 2 2 E ′ 2^2E' 2 2 E ′ state as well as profound PJT interaction among 2 2 E ′ 2^2E' 2 2 E ′ and 1 2 A 1 ′ 1^2A'_1 1 2 A 1 ′ states. 12 In order to explore the workability of four electronic state BBO formalism, pyrazine molecule were taken as a benchmark system. 24 The first principle based BBO theory was employed to unveil its wide variety of non-adiabatic interactions present within the low-lying four excited electronic states [1 1 B 1 u 1^1B_{1u} 1 1 B 1 u (S 1 S_1 S 1 ), 1 1 B 2 u 1^1B_{2u} 1 1 B 2 u (S 2 S_2 S 2 ), 1 1 A u 1^1A_u 1 1 A u (S 3 S_3 S 3 ) and 1 1 B 2 g 1^1B_{2g} 1 1 B 2 g (S 4 S_4 S 4 )] and to construct 4×4 diabatic PES matrices, where the “1-2”, “2-3” and “3-4” CI(s)/seam(s) can be located over six 2D nuclear CSs constituted with four normal modes (Q 1 Q_1 Q 1 , Q 6 a Q_{6a} Q 6 a , Q 9 a Q_{9a} Q 9 a and Q 10 a Q_{10a} Q 10 a ). While examining the validity of five state BBO formalism, three species, NO3 _3 3 , C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + and o-C6 _6 6 H4 _4 4 F2 + _2^+ 2 + were selectively chosen to study their rich nonadiabatic features. For NO3 _3 3 radical, 13,14 JT interactions were unveiled within A ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{A}^2E'' A ~ 2 E ′′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^2E' B ~ 2 E ′ states at equilibrium D3 h _{3h} 3 h point and accidental CIs can be observed within ‘3-4’ and ‘4-5’ electronic states at C s C_s C s and C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v geometries. Apart from the JT and accidental CIs, NO3 _3 3 is enriched with substantial PJT coupling between X ~ 2 A 2 ′ \tilde{X}^2A'_2 X ~ 2 A 2 ′ and B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^2E' B ~ 2 E ′ states. 13,14 While exploring Bz+ ^+ + radical cation, the low lying doublet states, namely, X ~ 2 E 1 g \tilde{X}^2E_{1g} X ~ 2 E 1 g and B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^2E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g were observed to show profound “1-2” and “3-4” JT distortion along the e ′ e' e ′ modes. 13,22,149 In addition, strong PJT couplings and accidental CIs are also present within B ~ 2 E 2 g \tilde{B}^2E_{2g} B ~ 2 E 2 g and C ~ 2 A 2 u \tilde{C}^2A_{2u} C ~ 2 A 2 u electronic states (mainly “4-5” PJT) over the FC region of nuclear CS. 13,22,148 Moreover, o-dfbz+ ^+ + was considered as a prototypical system exhibiting rich variety of nonadiabatic interactions, including JT-type accidental CIs/seams (“1-2”, “3-4” and “4-5”) and PJT interactions among these X ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{X}^2B_1 X ~ 2 B 1 , A ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{A}^2B_1 A ~ 2 B 1 , B ~ 2 B 1 \tilde{B}^2B_1 B ~ 2 B 1 , C ~ 2 A 1 \tilde{C}^2A_1 C ~ 2 A 1 and D ~ 2 B 2 \tilde{D}^2B_2 D ~ 2 B 2 states over eight (8) non-adiabatically active nuclear planes (Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 -Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 , Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 -Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 , Q 6 Q_6 Q 6 -Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 , Q 7 Q_7 Q 7 -Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 , Q 8 Q_8 Q 8 -Q 13 Q_{13} Q 13 , Q 14 Q_{14} Q 14 -Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 , Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 -Q 24 Q_{24} Q 24 and Q 20 Q_{20} Q 20 -Q 26 Q_{26} Q 26 ). 32 Finally, intense vibronic couplings (“1-2” JT/accidental CI(s)/seam(s), “4-5” JT/accidental CI(s)/seam(s), “1-3”, “2-3”, “4-6” and “5-6” PJT couplings and many others) were explored within the low-lying six electronic states of TFBz+ ^+ + radical cation, namely, X ~ 2 E ′ ′ \tilde{X}^2E'' X ~ 2 E ′′ , A ~ 2 A 2 ′ ′ \tilde{A}^2A''_2 A ~ 2 A 2 ′′ , B ~ 2 E ′ \tilde{B}^2E' B ~ 2 E ′ and C ~ 2 A 2 ′ \tilde{C}^2A'_2 C ~ 2 A 2 ′ . 23
For each system, once the ab initio quantities (adiabatic PESs and NACTs) were in hand, those had been plugged into the ADT equations (see Eqs. (198) , (199) and Appendix B.1) to solve those equations for the generation of ADT angles vis-à-vis ADT matrices and diabatic PESs matrices. For all cases, the ADT angles attend the magnitude of 0 or n π n\pi nπ or n .2 π n.2\pi n .2 π at the end of the contours representing the PJT, JT and RT situations, respectively, with n n n being the number of CIs. It is important to mention that the functional forms of ADT angles appear topological (depends on the NACT profiles) in nature. 14,22,23 On the other hand, those ADT angles were used to regenerate the NACTs and then, Mathematical as well as ADT curls were calculated validating the Curl condition and affirming the existence of sub-Hilbert spaces for each specific molecular system. 32,78 Furthermore, BBO based diabatization procedure depicts an unique finding, i.e., even parity functional forms of diabatic PESs and couplings along some components of asymmetric normal modes of systems, namely, Q 3 Q_3 Q 3 mode of NO2 _2 2 , Q y Q_y Q y mode of Na3 _3 3 , Q 3 x Q_{3x} Q 3 x mode of NO3 _3 3 , Q 16 x Q_{16x} Q 16 x mode of C6 _6 6 H6 + _6^+ 6 + and Q 9 x Q_{9x} Q 9 x mode of 1,3,5-C6 _6 6 H3 _3 3 F3 + _3^+ 3 + show exclusive symmetric feature in contrary to the “traditional” JT model. 21
After constructing diabatic Hamiltonians of the molecular species/radical cation, quantum dynamics need to be carried out to compute the PE/PA/PD/MATI spectra of the corresponding neutral analogue. Dynamical calculations are performed at the close vicinity of equilibrium geometry (FC region), where Gaussian wave packets (GWPs) are utilized to represent molecular vibrations. In other words, a product wavefunction with GWPs for each normal mode of the neutral/anionic species is considered as the initial wavefunction for solving the time dependent SE. While performing dynamical calculations, time dependent nuclear wavefunctions vis-à-vis autocorrelation function are computed at different time followed by Fourier transformation to generate the PE/PD/PA/MATI spectra for individual state. Then, the individual state spectra are convoluted to get the entire spectral profile. It is worth mentioning that for each system, theoretically calculated spectral profiles 9,16,22–24,32,155 exhibit better agreement with the experimental ones76,93,104,125,134,142,153 in comparison with MCTDH based spectra113,140,147,150,154 obtained from VCM calculated diabatic Hamiltonian. Finally, as per the theoretical prediction, the path-dependent diabatic Hamiltonians are expected to show up unique observables (spectra), which has been explored to confirm the prediction.152
In summary, theoretically “exact" and numerically “accurate" BBO constructed diabatic PES matrix followed by quantum dynamics successfully depicts the contribution of nonadiabatic coupling in various prototype systems. Such theoretical approach consistently depict the importance of nonadiabatic effects to reshape spectral profiles exhibiting good accord with experimental data.
Bibliography
Reactive Scattering Processes: BBO Based Diabatic Hamiltonian and Nuclear Dynamics
The profiles of cross-sections and rate coefficients for several prototype chemical reactions of atom-diatom (A + B C \mathrm{A+BC} A + BC ) collision exhibit substantial deviations between theoretically computed and experimentally measured ones in many cases even at reasonably lower collision energy. Such deviations could be originated due to the neglect of electron-nuclear coupling in the theoretical framework as well as numerical calculations on a specific surface. Such approaches are designated as single surface adiabatic scattering dynamics based on Quasi-Classical Trajectory (QCT) and/or Quantum Mechanical (QM) approaches. In this chapter, a series of reaction attributes is presented for various reactive processes, where calculated cross-sections/rate coefficients exhibit satisfactory agreement with sophisticated experimentally measured data while carrying out the scattering dynamics involving multiple electronic states. Furthermore, during such theoretical calculations on multiple electronic states, it is indeed necessary to include electron-nuclear couplings from the first principle in the respective Hamiltonian. In subsequent paragraphs, recently performed theoretically calculated adiabatic and diabatic results are manifested for few specific reactive processes in comparison with the corresponding experimental data. Such analysis unveils the importance of incorporation of electron-nuclear coupling in the Hamiltonian.
In the 1980s, the landmark molecular beam experiment by Lee et al. 1–3 and subsequently, {citet}`Toennies et al. {citep}`4–8 recorded velocity contour maps of HF and also DF product angular distributions. On the other hand, the temperature dependent rate coefficients for the F + H 2 / D 2 \mathrm{H_2/D_2} H 2 / D 2 reaction were measured by the multiphoton dissociation techniques 9,10 in the temperature range 190-370 K, whereas the rate coefficient over the temperature range 240-373 K was speculated by discharge flow/resonance fluorescence 11. At the same time, Sims et al. 12 reported the rate coefficient for this reaction at the low temperature (11-295 K). Over the extended temperature range (220-960 K), the kinetic isotopic effect for the F + $\mathrm{H_2/D_2}$ reaction was analyzed by {citet}Bedjanian13``. It is worth mentioning that theoretical calculations on single adiabatic surface for rate coefficients 14–17 show deviation far more from the experimental results {citep}11–13 compared to the recent diabatic one {citep}18, where both electron-nuclear as well as spin-orbit (SO) couplings are incorporated. In addition, the diabatic Hamiltonians constructed only with SO coupling {citep}19,20 versus the one {citep}18 both with nonadiabatic as well as SO couplings display that the latter approach is able to better reproduce the experimental rate constant. The presence of Jahn-Teller (JT) type conical intersection (CI) between the ground (${}^{1}{}^{2}\mathrm{A}'$) and the first excited electronic state (${}^{2}\mathrm{A}'$) as well the existence of additional Renner-Teller (RT) CI(s) between the first (${}^{2}\mathrm{A}'$) and second excited electronic states (${}^{1}\mathrm{A}''$) affirm the necessity for the calculation of multi-state (diabatic) Hamiltonian. {citep}21,22`
The initial experimental detection of H 3 + \mathrm{H_3^+} H 3 + by Oka23`` drew the attention of allied scientific community. Even though the species shows molecular simplicity, the quantum mechanical calculations appear as “difficult" due to the presence of an extraordinary deep well (∼ − 4.0 \sim-4.0 ∼ − 4.0 eV) along the reactant channel on the ground electronic state of the H 3 + \mathrm{H}_3^+ H 3 + potential energy surface (PES).24 The guided molecular beam technique yielded integral cross-sections (ICSs) for the reaction H + + D 2 \mathrm{H}^+ + \mathrm{D}_2 H + + D 2 , where Fehsenfeld et al.25 and Villinger et al.26 successfully measured the rate constants for H + + D 2 \mathrm{H}^+ + \mathrm{D}_2 H + + D 2 as well as D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 D + + H 2 reaction at lower collision energy range (< 0.3 < 0.3 < 0.3 eV). On the other hand, Gerlich27 used merged beam technique to record the rate constants for the isotope exchange reaction, D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 D + + H 2 at the low temperature regime. In this perspective, theoretically computed28–30 rate constants at low collisional energies on the ground adiabatic PES demonstrate the appropriate prediction of ortho-para transition on the collision process, H + + H 2 \mathrm{H}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 H + + H 2 . The charge transfer processes involved in D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 D + + H 2 reaction were studied experimentally to obtain ICSs, where for such reaction (D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 D + + H 2 ), the effect of multiple electronic state on reactive and non-reactive charge transfer processes were illustrated31 by initiating the collision process from the ground electronic state. On the other hand, for H + + H 2 \mathrm{H}^+ + \mathrm{H}_2 H + + H 2 reaction, such effects were explored32 by allowing the collision from the excited electronic state. When the calculations of the ICSs for various processes, namely, charge transfer and non charge transfer were performed, the role of electron-nuclear coupling among the electronic states demands the formulation of diabatic Hamiltonian considering first three low-lying electronic states (1 1 A ′ 1^1A' 1 1 A ′ , 2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ and 3 1 A ′ 3^1A' 3 1 A ′ ).24 Dynamical calculations using such diabatic Hamiltonian reveal that in order to reproduce the experimentally measured ICS data, the nonadiabatic couplings play a crucial role in monitoring the reaction mechanism.31 Since the ground and the first excited states are coupled through the symmetry driven CI as well as the accidental CI along a seam, the construction of multi-state diabatic Hamiltonian is indeed necessary for dynamical calculation.24
Chemical reaction involving H e H 2 + \mathrm{HeH}_2^+ HeH 2 + species acts as a prototype system both for experimental measurements33–37 and theoretical calculations38–44, which are necessary to elucidate the underlying reaction mechanism. Initially, Chupka et al.34,35,45 depicted vibrational state assisted cross-sections of the proton transfer reaction, H e + H 2 + ( v ; j ) → H e H + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H \mathrm{He} + \mathrm{H}_2^+(v;j) \rightarrow\mathrm{HeH}^+(v';j') + \mathrm{H} He + H 2 + ( v ; j ) → HeH + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H , where the endothermicity (∼ 0.79 \sim0.79 ∼ 0.79 eV) in the product channel plays a crucial role. Moreover, various experiments were performed employing electron impact ionization46,47, molecular beam48,49 and other techniques36,50,51 to analyze the vibrational enhancement of the cross-sections and its decaying trend with the increase of collision energy for higher initial vibrational states. Over the past few decades, various theoretical studies based on QCT and QM calculations were carried out to explore the reaction dynamics in H e H 2 + \mathrm{HeH}_2^+ HeH 2 + system on its ground electronic state.36,42,52–56 On the contrary, calculated ICSs from QCT and QM approaches for the reaction, H e + H 2 + ( v = 0 ; j = 0 ) → H e H + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H \mathrm{He} + \mathrm{H}_2^+(v=0;j=0) \rightarrow\mathrm{HeH}^+(v';j') + \mathrm{H} He + H 2 + ( v = 0 ; j = 0 ) → HeH + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H show consistently lower values compared to the result obtained from experimental observations34–36,57,58. Such differences display the necessity to construct the multi-state diabatic Hamiltonian59, where the nonadiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) among the first four electronic states were included to study the proton-exchange reaction. While carrying out quantum reactive scattering dynamics employing such diabatic Hamiltonian59, the computed reactive ICSs show satisfactory quantitative agreement with experimental ones in comparison with the calculations performed on other available adiabatic/diabatic Hamiltonian for this system.60 This indicates the crucial contribution of electron-nuclear coupling in the reaction mechanism of H e + H 2 + \mathrm{He} + \mathrm{H}_2^+ He + H 2 + collision. It is worthwhile to mention that the lowest four electronic states (1 2 A ′ 1^2A' 1 2 A ′ , 2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ , 3 2 A ′ 3^2A' 3 2 A ′ and 4 2 A ′ 4^2A' 4 2 A ′ ) of H e H 2 + \mathrm{HeH}_2^+ HeH 2 + are strongly coupled, wherein CIs are prevalent between the first two electronic states at C 2 v \mathrm{C}_{2v} C 2 v geometries59,61,62 and additional CI(s) are found between the second and third as well as the third and fourth electronic states at collinear geometries59,62,63.
The hydrogen exchange reaction in H 3 \mathrm{H}_3 H 3 system appears as a prototype system for collision-induced reaction dynamics, which was thoroughly studied as a benchmark one in theoretical64–68 and experimental investigations69–78. Adiabatic calculations for the H + D 2 \mathrm{H} + \mathrm{D}_2 H + D 2 reaction on the ground state PES at relatively higher (total) energies (1.5 1.5 1.5 eV ≤ E t o t ≤ 4.5 \leq E_{\mathrm{tot}} \leq4.5 ≤ E tot ≤ 4.5 eV) unveiled substantial deviations from experimentally recorded cross-section77,78. Due to the strong coupling among the low lying doublet electronic states (1 2 A ′ 1^2A' 1 2 A ′ , 2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ and 3 2 A ′ 3^2A' 3 2 A ′ ) of H 3 \mathrm{H}_3 H 3 through CI or seam79–81, the applicability of adiabatic calculations64–68 on the ground state is limited even at lower total energy (0.5 0.5 0.5 eV ≤ E t o t ≤ 1.5 \leq E_{\mathrm{tot}} \leq1.5 ≤ E tot ≤ 1.5 eV) compared to the experimental result. Deviations can be observed between computed reaction attributes (such as integral and differential cross-sections) and experimental data 77,82,83 over the energy range (1.5 1.5 1.5 eV ≤ E t o t ≤ 3.5 \leq E_{\mathrm{tot}} \leq3.5 ≤ E tot ≤ 3.5 eV). As a consequence, the inclusion of coupling among the adiabatic states is indeed necessary to explore mechanism of the reaction. 81,84 Calculations of ab initio adiabatic PESs and NACTs were executed for the three electronic states followed by construction of the diabatic Hamiltonian 81 to find out the mechanism of this prototype reaction of H3 _3 3 system. The experimental cross-section/rate constants were compared with those quantities calculated from the diabatic Hamiltonian 81 to understand the contribution of electron-nuclear coupling.
In order to construct the diabatic Hamiltonians for performing scattering calculations on various reactive processes, Beyond Born-Oppenheimer (BBO) theory was employed including electron-nuclear couplings among the electronic states. Once the diabatic Hamiltonians are derived for several systems, it is necessary to use sophisticated approach for scattering calculation for obtaining various quantities, cross-section and rate constants. 85 Over the last few decades, the formulation of methodologies for quantum reactive scattering calculations on triatomic systems were applied employing both time-independent 86 and time-dependent 87 approaches, namely, the S-matrix formalism 88, R-matrix propagation method 89,90, Newton variational principle employing T operator 91 etc. In case of Jacobi coordinate 88,92–94 based methodologies, it is necessary to convert the wavefunction from reactant to product coordinates 95–99, whereas the hyperspherical coordinates 100–110 treat all the channels even handedly. Furthermore, while extending the methodology from single state adiabatic to multi-state diabatic scattering cases, such extension using hyperspherical coordinate based wavepacket approach appears as quite straightforward. On the other hand, all the channels of different electronic states can be denoted without ambiguity. With the aid of Johnson’s hyperspherical coordinate 100, Billing and co-workers 103,104 developed the time-dependent wave packet (TDWP) formalism for the first time depicting its workability on single adiabatic PES of D + H2 _2 2 system for total angular momentum quantum numbers J = 0 J = 0 J = 0 and J = 1 J = 1 J = 1 . In the subsequent research works, Adhikari and co-workers 102 generalized this framework for any non-zero total angular momentum (J ≠ 0 J \ne0 J = 0 cases) 109,111–114 by including all helicity quantum numbers (K K K ) 115 through OpenMP-parallelization algorithm. In addition, such approach was further extended for multi electronic state diabatic Hamiltonian, where the propagation of partial waves are performed by OpenMP scheme and the solution of differential equations for different electronic states are obtained by employing MPI technique. 116
Outline of BBO Theory for Chemical Reactions
Adiabatic-to-Diabatic Transformation Formalism
In the adiabatic representation of BO treatment 117,118, the total molecular wave function for a M-dimensional Hilbert Space can be written in terms of the product of nuclear wave functions ({ ψ i a d } \{\psi_i^{\mathrm{ad}}\} { ψ i ad } ) and electronic eigenfunctions ({ ξ i } \{\xi_i\} { ξ i } ), which is defined as the Born-Oppenheimer-Huang (BOH) expansion:
Ψ ( r , R ) = ∑ i = 1 M ψ i a d ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) , (349) \Psi(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) = \sum_{i=1}^{M} \psi_i^{\mathrm{ad}}(\mathbf{R})\xi_i(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}), \tag*{(349)} Ψ ( r , R ) = i = 1 ∑ M ψ i ad ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) , (349)
The total electron-nuclear Hamiltonian, H ^ ( r , R ) \hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) H ^ ( r , R ) can be segregated into two operators, nuclear kinetic energy operator T ^ n u c ( R ) \hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\mathbf{R}) T ^ nuc ( R ) and electronic Hamiltonian, H ^ e l ( r ; R ) \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}) H ^ el ( r ; R ) as follows:
H ^ ( r , R ) = T ^ n u c ( R ) + H ^ e l ( r ; R ) , (350) \hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) = \hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\mathbf{R}) + \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}), \tag*{(350)} H ^ ( r , R ) = T ^ nuc ( R ) + H ^ el ( r ; R ) , (350)
where r \mathbf{r} r and R \mathbf{R} R symbolize the electronic and nuclear coordinates, respectively.
On the other hand, electronic Schrödinger equation (SE) with orthonormal set of electronic eigenfunctions, { ξ i } \{\xi_i\} { ξ i } can be written as:
H ^ e l ( r ; R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) = u i ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) , ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ r = δ i j , (351) \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R})\xi_i(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}) = u_i(\mathbf{R})\xi_i(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}), \qquad\langle\xi_i \mid\xi_j \rangle_{\mathbf{r}} = \delta_{ij}, \tag*{(351)} H ^ el ( r ; R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) = u i ( R ) ξ i ( r ; R ) , ⟨ ξ i ∣ ξ j ⟩ r = δ ij , (351)
where the eigenvalues at any fixed nuclear geometry, u i ( R ) u_i(\mathbf{R}) u i ( R ) are termed as adiabatic potential energy surface(s) (PESs).
While substituting the molecular wave function [Eq. (9.18)], the total electron-nuclear Hamiltonian [Eq. (350) ] and the electronic eigenvalue equation [Eq. (9.19)] into the molecular SE [H ^ ( r , R ) Ψ ( r , R ) = E H ^ ( r , R ) \hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R})\Psi(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R})=E\hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) H ^ ( r , R ) Ψ ( r , R ) = E H ^ ( r , R ) ] followed by projection with the electronic eigenfunctions { ξ i } \{\xi_i\} { ξ i } leads to the matrix form of the kinetically coupled adiabatic nuclear Schrödinger equation 119 as follows:
− ℏ 2 2 m ( ∇ R + τ ) 2 ψ a d + ( U − E ) ψ a d = 0 , (352) -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}(\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}+\boldsymbol{\tau})^2\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}+(U-E)\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=0, \tag*{(352)} − 2 m ℏ 2 ( ∇ R + τ ) 2 ψ ad + ( U − E ) ψ ad = 0 , (352)
where E E E signifies the total molecular energy, U U U indicates the adiabatic PESs matrix (U i j = u i δ i j U_{ij}=u_i\delta_{ij} U ij = u i δ ij ) and τ \boldsymbol{\tau} τ designates the skew-symmetric nonadiabatic coupling matrix (NACM) showing following anti-symmetric property:
τ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R ξ j ⟩ r = − ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ R ξ i ⟩ r . (353) \tau_{ij}=\langle\xi_i|\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}\xi_j\rangle_r=-\langle\xi_j|\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}\xi_i\rangle_r. \tag*{(353)} τ ij = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R ξ j ⟩ r = − ⟨ ξ j ∣ ∇ R ξ i ⟩ r . (353)
Furthermore, when electronic SE [Eq. (9.19)] is differentiated with respect to the nuclear coordinates (∇ R \nabla_{\mathbf{R}} ∇ R ) and then, projected by the electronic eigenfunctions (⟨ ξ i ∣ \langle\xi_i| ⟨ ξ i ∣ ), the following form of NACTs can be achieved:
τ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R H ^ e l ∣ ξ j ⟩ r u j − u i , (354) \tau_{ij}=\frac{\langle\xi_i|\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}\hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}|\xi_j\rangle_r}{u_j-u_i}, \tag*{(354)} τ ij = u j − u i ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R H ^ el ∣ ξ j ⟩ r , (354)
which indicates singular behavior at and around the degenerate points (u i = u j u_i=u_j u i = u j ), where such relation is a reminiscent of well-known Hellmann-Feynman theorem 120–122. Due to appearance of such singular behavior, adiabatic representation of the SE produces numerical inaccuracies and non-conservation of energy123. Hence elimination of these singular terms is a necessity by converting the adiabatic SE [Eq. (9.20)] into diabatic framework by employing an orthogonal transformation, ψ a d = A ψ d i a \psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=A\psi^{\mathrm{dia}} ψ ad = A ψ dia as demonstrated below:
( − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ R 2 + W − E ) ψ d i a = 0. (355) \left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}^2+W-E\right)\psi^{\mathrm{dia}}=0. \tag*{(355)} ( − 2 m ℏ 2 ∇ R 2 + W − E ) ψ dia = 0. (355)
In the above expression, ψ d i a \psi^{\mathrm{dia}} ψ dia defines the diabatic nuclear wavefunction and W W W indicates the diabatic PESs matrix,
W = A † U A . (356) W=A^\dagger U A. \tag*{(356)} W = A † U A . (356)
In other words, such transformation leads to a paradigm shift from the kinetically coupled adiabatic nuclear SE to potentially coupled diabatic one. In order to carry out such process, the matrix A A A needs to fulfill the following criterion:
∇ R A + τ A = 0 , (357) \nabla_{\mathbf{R}}A+\boldsymbol{\tau}A=0, \tag*{(357)} ∇ R A + τ A = 0 , (357)
which is commonly known as the ADT condition. 124–126 Since τ \tau τ signifies a skew-symmetric matrix, Eq. 9.25 shows that A A A is an orthogonal matrix.
The explicit expression of ADT equations for two and three electronic states are given in Eqs. (198) and (199) , whereas the ADT equations for four to six states are demonstrated in Appendix B.1.
While carrying out BBO based diabatization, ab initio calculated NACTs are substituted into ADT equations and then, those equations are numerically integrated to compute the ADT angles. Once the mixing angles are obtained, those are used to construct the ADT matrices followed by similarity transformation (Eq. (314) ) for the generation of smooth, single-valued and continuous diabatic PESs and couplings.
Diabatic Hamiltonian: Nonadiabatic and Spin-Orbit Couplings
Since the spin-orbit (SO) coupling has crucial role in a chemical reaction, such coupling should be incorporated as perturbation in total molecular Hamiltonian. At first, the molecular wavefunction is written in terms of Born-Oppenheimer Huang expansion (Eq. 9.18) for non-relativistic Hamiltonian and then, the kinetically coupled nuclear SE is formulated to generate the diabatic Hamiltonian through ADT formalism. Once such forms of the equations are available, the SO couplings originated from the adiabatic basis are incorporated as perturbation prior to transformation to the diabatic basis.
The total molecular Hamiltonian, H ^ ( r , R ) \hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) H ^ ( r , R ) can be partitioned into nuclear kinetic energy operator T ^ n u c ( R ) \hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\mathbf{R}) T ^ nuc ( R ) , the electronic Hamiltonian H ^ e l ( r ; R ) \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}) H ^ el ( r ; R ) and the spin-orbit Hamiltonian H ^ S O ( r ; R ) \hat{H}_{\mathrm{SO}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}) H ^ SO ( r ; R ) , as follows:
H ^ ( r , R ) = H ^ 0 + H ^ S O ( r ; R ) , (358) \hat{H}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{R}) = \hat{H}_{0} + \hat{H}_{\mathrm{SO}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}), \tag*{(358)} H ^ ( r , R ) = H ^ 0 + H ^ SO ( r ; R ) , (358)
where
H ^ 0 = T ^ n u c ( R ) + H ^ e l ( r ; R ) . (359) \hat{H}_{0} = \hat{T}_{\mathrm{nuc}}(\mathbf{R}) + \hat{H}_{\mathrm{el}}(\mathbf{r};\mathbf{R}). \tag*{(359)} H ^ 0 = T ^ nuc ( R ) + H ^ el ( r ; R ) . (359)
− ℏ 2 2 ( ∇ R + τ ) 2 ψ a d + ( U + H S O a d − E ) ψ a d = 0 , (360) -\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2}(\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}+\boldsymbol{\tau})^{2}\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}+\left(U+H_{\mathrm{SO}}^{\mathrm{ad}}-E\right)\psi^{\mathrm{ad}}=0, \tag*{(360)} − 2 ℏ 2 ( ∇ R + τ ) 2 ψ ad + ( U + H SO ad − E ) ψ ad = 0 , (360)
where H S O a d H_{\mathrm{SO}}^{\mathrm{ad}} H SO ad indicates the SO coupling matrix appearing from the adiabatic basis ({ ξ i } \{\xi_i\} { ξ i } ) and the rest of the terms have been defined in Subsection 4.2.
Since the NACM elements in Eq. (360) is expected to exhibit singularity around the close vicinity of degenerate point(s) in the nuclear configuration space (CS), ADT is necessary to be performed to calculate the diabatic Hamiltonian in presence of SO coupling so that the potentially coupled SE converts into smooth and continuous functions of nuclear coordinates. While carrying out such transformation of nuclear SE, the example of F + H2 _2 2 reactive system showing both the effects (nonadiabatic and SO couplings) is briefly demonstrated, where three electronic states (1 A ′ {}^{1}A' 1 A ′ , 2 A ′ {}^{2}A' 2 A ′ and 1 A ′ ′ {}^{1}A'' 1 A ′′ ) form a sub-Hilbert space (SHS) at low collision energies.21 For the two possible spin projections (M s = ± 1 2 M_s = \pm\frac{1}{2} M s = ± 2 1 ) of the F (2 P 1 / 2 {}^{2}P_{1/2} 2 P 1/2 and 2 P 3 / 2 {}^{2}P_{3/2} 2 P 3/2 ) atom, the corresponding adiabatic states and their SO coupled counterparts are defined as ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ |\xi_1\rangle ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ , ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ |\xi_2\rangle ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ , ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ |\xi_3\rangle ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ , ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ |\bar{\xi}_1\rangle ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ , ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ |\bar{\xi}_2\rangle ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ and ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ |\bar{\xi}_3\rangle ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ . The 6 × 6 6 \times6 6 × 6 matrix representations of the adiabatic potential energy, U i j = u i δ i j U_{ij}=u_i\delta_{ij} U ij = u i δ ij and the skew-symmetric nonadiabatic coupling, τ i j = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R ξ j ⟩ r = − τ j i \boldsymbol{\tau}_{ij}=\langle\xi_i|\nabla_{\mathbf{R}}\xi_j\rangle_{\mathbf{r}}=-\boldsymbol{\tau}_{ji} τ ij = ⟨ ξ i ∣ ∇ R ξ j ⟩ r = − τ j i , are thoroughly discussed in Appendix B.2.
On the other hand, the general form of the adiabatic SO (coupling) Hamiltonian matrix (H S O a d H_{\mathrm{SO}}^{\mathrm{ad}} H SO ad ) can be expressed as:
H S O a d = ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ ⟨ ξ 1 ∣ 0 D − i B 0 − i F 1 F ⟨ ξ 2 ∣ D 0 − i G i F 1 0 − C ⟨ ξ 3 ∣ i B i G 0 − F C 0 ⟨ ξ ˉ 1 ∣ 0 − i F 1 − F 0 D i B ⟨ ξ ˉ 2 ∣ i F 1 0 C D 0 i G ⟨ ξ ˉ 3 ∣ F − C 0 − i B − i G 0 , (361) H_{\mathrm{SO}}^{\mathrm{ad}} =
\begin{array}{c|cccccc}
& |\xi_1\rangle& |\xi_2\rangle& |\xi_3\rangle& |\bar{\xi}_1\rangle& |\bar{\xi}_2\rangle& |\bar{\xi}_3\rangle\\
\hline
\langle\xi_1| & 0 & D & -iB & 0 & -iF_1 & F \\
\langle\xi_2| & D & 0 & -iG & iF_1 & 0 & -C \\
\langle\xi_3| & iB & iG & 0 & -F & C & 0 \\
\langle\bar{\xi}_1| & 0 & -iF_1 & -F & 0 & D & iB \\
\langle\bar{\xi}_2| & iF_1 & 0 & C & D & 0 & iG \\
\langle\bar{\xi}_3| & F & -C & 0 & -iB & -iG & 0
\end{array}, \tag*{(361)} H SO ad = ⟨ ξ 1 ∣ ⟨ ξ 2 ∣ ⟨ ξ 3 ∣ ⟨ ξ ˉ 1 ∣ ⟨ ξ ˉ 2 ∣ ⟨ ξ ˉ 3 ∣ ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ 0 D i B 0 i F 1 F ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ D 0 i G − i F 1 0 − C ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ − i B − i G 0 − F C 0 ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ 0 i F 1 − F 0 D − i B ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ − i F 1 0 C D 0 − i G ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ F − C 0 i B i G 0 , (361)
where D D D , B B B , G G G , F 1 F_1 F 1 , F F F and C C C specify the real valued functions of nuclear coordinates. The elements of the adiabatic PESs, nonadiabatic coupling and SO coupling matrices are originated127 from ab initio calculations at the MRCI level, as implemented in the MOLPRO quantum chemistry package128.
The 6 × 6 6 \times6 6 × 6 SO coupling matrix (see Eq. (361) ) can be written in terms of two non-interacting 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 sub-blocks leading to reduction of the effective dimensionality of the system to 3 × 3 3 \times3 3 × 3 . In order to achieve such a block-diagonal structure, the time-reversal-adapted Kramers basis needs to be employed and the irreducible representations (IREPs) of each Kramers pair are determined under the C s C_s C s double group. The basis elements associated with the same fermionic IREP are then assembled together129. One can introduce the so-called λ \lambda λ basis18,129 by considering appropriate linear combinations of the original adiabatic electronic basis functions for two set of spin states:
∣ ξ 1 λ ⟩ = 1 2 ( ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ − λ ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ ) (362) \lvert\xi_{1\lambda} \rangle= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert\xi_1 \rangle- \lambda\lvert\bar{\xi}_1 \rangle\right) \tag*{(362)} ∣ ξ 1 λ ⟩ = 2 1 ( ∣ ξ 1 ⟩ − λ ∣ ξ ˉ 1 ⟩ ) (362)
∣ ξ 2 λ ⟩ = 1 2 ( ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ − λ ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ ) (363) \lvert\xi_{2\lambda} \rangle= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert\xi_2 \rangle- \lambda\lvert\bar{\xi}_2 \rangle\right) \tag*{(363)} ∣ ξ 2 λ ⟩ = 2 1 ( ∣ ξ 2 ⟩ − λ ∣ ξ ˉ 2 ⟩ ) (363)
∣ ξ 3 λ ⟩ = i 2 ( ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ + λ ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ ) (364) \lvert\xi_{3\lambda} \rangle= \frac{i}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert\xi_3 \rangle+ \lambda\lvert\bar{\xi}_3 \rangle\right) \tag*{(364)} ∣ ξ 3 λ ⟩ = 2 i ( ∣ ξ 3 ⟩ + λ ∣ ξ ˉ 3 ⟩ ) (364)
where λ = ± 1 \lambda= \pm1 λ = ± 1 . The above transformation can take the following matrix form:
∣ ξ λ ⟩ = K λ ∣ ξ ⟩ , (365) \lvert\xi_\lambda\rangle= K_\lambda\lvert\xi\rangle, \tag*{(365)} ∣ ξ λ ⟩ = K λ ∣ ξ ⟩ , (365)
where the 6 × 6 6 \times6 6 × 6 K λ K_\lambda K λ matrix is depicted in Eq. B.15 in Appendix B.2.
The SO coupling matrix (Eq. (361) ) under such transformation is as follows:
( K λ T ) † H s o a d K λ T = ( 0 D + i F 1 B + i F 0 0 0 D − i F 1 0 − i C + G 0 0 0 B − i F i C + G 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D − i F 1 B − i F 0 0 0 D + i F 1 0 i C + G 0 0 0 B + i F − i C + G 0 ) (366) (K_\lambda^{T})^\dagger H_{\mathrm{so}}^{\mathrm{ad}} K_\lambda^{T} =
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & D+iF_1 & B+iF & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
D-iF_1 & 0 & -iC+G & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
B-iF & iC+G & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & D-iF_1 & B-iF \\
0 & 0 & 0 & D+iF_1 & 0 & iC+G \\
0 & 0 & 0 & B+iF & -iC+G & 0
\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(366)} ( K λ T ) † H so ad K λ T = 0 D − i F 1 B − i F 0 0 0 D + i F 1 0 i C + G 0 0 0 B + i F − i C + G 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D + i F 1 B + i F 0 0 0 D − i F 1 0 − i C + G 0 0 0 B − i F i C + G 0 (366)
In order to reduce the computational complexity, the approach proposed by Werner and co-workers130 is followed, where the spin-orbit (SO) matrix elements are calculated exclusively for linear configurations. In these particular geometries, the parameters B B B , C C C and D D D become virtually zero (0), and F 1 F_1 F 1 reduced to F F F .18 The resulting form of the H s o a d H_{\mathrm{so}}^{\mathrm{ad}} H so ad matrix and the explicit expression of the reduced block diagonal potential matrix is demonstrated in Appendix B.§ 5.1 .
It needs to be noted that the K λ K_\lambda K λ matrix commutes with the kinetic part of the Hamiltonian (see Appendix B.2) and under such conditions, the diabatic representation takes the following form with the help of orthogonal transformation of the adiabatic SE ψ a d = A ψ d i a \psi^{\mathrm{ad}} = A\psi^{\mathrm{dia}} ψ ad = A ψ dia 131–136:
( − ℏ 2 2 ∇ R 2 + W ~ − E ) ψ d i a = 0 , (367) \left(-\frac{\hbar^2}{2}\nabla_R^2+\widetilde{W}-E\right)\psi^{\mathrm{dia}}=0, \tag*{(367)} ( − 2 ℏ 2 ∇ R 2 + W − E ) ψ dia = 0 , (367)
where ψ d i a \psi^{\mathrm{dia}} ψ dia signifies the diabatic nuclear wavefunction (as defined earlier) and W ~ \widetilde{W} W represents the diabatic potential energy matrix131–136 including SO coupling,
W ~ = A † U ~ A = A † U A + A † ( 0 i F i F − i F 0 G − i F G 0 ) A . (368) \widetilde{W}=A^\dagger\widetilde{U}A=A^\dagger U A+A^\dagger
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & iF & iF \\
-iF & 0 & G \\
-iF & G & 0
\end{pmatrix}
A. \tag*{(368)} W = A † U A = A † U A + A † 0 − i F − i F i F 0 G i F G 0 A . (368)
It is worth mentioning that validity of Eq. (367) is guaranteed subject to the fulfillment of the ADT condition shown in Eq. 9.25.
Theoretical Background of Fully Close Coupled (FCC) Approach
The atom-diatom (A + BC) reaction dynamics are carried out with the aid of 3D time-dependent wavepacket approach (TDWP) 102,104 using the framework of Johnson’s hyperspherical coordinates, 137 namely, hyperradius, ρ \rho ρ and hyperangles, θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ . Since the channels in hyperspherical coordinate system is even-handed, it is advantageous for analyzing the reactive and non-reactive processes occurring either on the ground or on the excited electronic states at the asymptotic hyperradius (ρ ≥ 15 \rho\ge15 ρ ≥ 15 Bohr) ranging over the hyperangles, 0 ≤ θ ≤ π 2 0 \le\theta\le\frac{\pi}{2} 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2 π and 2 π ⋅ ( I − 1 ) 3 ≤ ϕ ≤ 2 π ⋅ I 3 \frac{2\pi\cdot(I-1)}{3} \le\phi\le\frac{2\pi\cdot I}{3} 3 2 π ⋅ ( I − 1 ) ≤ ϕ ≤ 3 2 π ⋅ I , I = 1 , 2 I = 1, 2 I = 1 , 2 and 3, where I I I symbolizes different channels. BBO based diabatic Hamiltonian (BBO-DH) vis-á-vis the quantum dynamics for reactive and non-reactive pathways of selected triatomic scattering systems are discussed in Subsections 7.3 and 7.4.
If the wavepacket associated with the reactants is initialized (see Appendix C.1 and Appendix C.2 for details) in channel 2 (reactive channel) of the ground electronic state, channels 1 and 3 represent the product ones. In order to maintain the clarity, the channel index is removed in all subsequent discussions. The wavepacket can be expressed in hyperspherical coordinates using the 3 j 3j 3 j -symbol and the modified spherical harmonics (C j μ C_{j\mu} C j μ ) and such wavepacket can be written as:
Φ K a = 2 π sin η J ( R r η ∣ ρ θ ϕ ) ( 2 l + 1 ) ϕ v j ( r ) χ ( R ) ( − 1 ) j − l ∑ μ ( j l J μ 0 − μ ) C j μ ( η ) A K μ , (369) \Phi^{a}_{K} = \sqrt{2\pi\sin\eta}\,J(Rr\eta|\rho\theta\phi)(2l+1)\phi_{vj}(r)\chi(R)(-1)^{j-l}\sum_{\mu}\begin{pmatrix} j & l & J \\ \mu& 0 & -\mu\end{pmatrix}C_{j\mu}(\eta)A_{K\mu}, \tag*{(369)} Φ K a = 2 π sin η J ( R r η ∣ ρθ ϕ ) ( 2 l + 1 ) ϕ v j ( r ) χ ( R ) ( − 1 ) j − l μ ∑ ( j μ l 0 J − μ ) C j μ ( η ) A K μ , (369)
where, χ ( R ) \chi(R) χ ( R ) signifies the Gaussian wave packet and all the remaining symbols are depicted elsewhere 31,102.
The adiabatic Hamiltonian, H ^ a \hat{H}_{a} H ^ a attains the following form in terms of Johnson’s hyperspherical coordinates 100 as follows:
H ^ a = [ − ℏ 2 2 μ R ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + J ^ 2 − J ^ z 2 μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ + J ^ z 2 − 4 cos θ J ^ z P ^ ϕ 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ + sin θ μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ 1 2 [ J ^ 2 + J ^ z 2 ] + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) + V ^ a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) ] , (370) \hat{H}_{a} = \left[-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2\mu_{R}}\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial\rho^{2}}+\frac{2}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}}\hat{L}^{2}(\theta,\phi)+\frac{\hat{J}^{2}-\hat{J}_{z}^{2}}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}+\frac{\hat{J}_{z}^{2}-4\cos\theta\,\hat{J}_{z}\hat{P}_{\phi}}{2\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}+\frac{\sin\theta}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}\frac{1}{2}\left[\hat{J}^{2}+\hat{J}_{z}^{2}\right]+\Delta V(\rho,\theta)+\hat{V}_{a}(\rho,\theta,\phi)\right], \tag*{(370)} H ^ a = [ − 2 μ R ℏ 2 ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + μ R ρ 2 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ J ^ 2 − J ^ z 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ J ^ z 2 − 4 cos θ J ^ z P ^ ϕ + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ sin θ 2 1 [ J ^ 2 + J ^ z 2 ] + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) + V ^ a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) ] , (370)
where V ^ a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \hat{V}_{a}(\rho,\theta,\phi) V ^ a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) represents the single surface adiabatic potential for the triatomic reactive systems, whereas the other operators are extensively demonstrated elsewhere. 31,102
The wavepacket Φ K a \Phi^{a}_{K} Φ K a [Eq. (369) ] and the Hamiltonian [Eq. (370) ] are substituted into the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) to achieve the following set of coupled differential equations:
i ℏ ∂ Φ K a ∂ t = { − ℏ 2 2 μ R ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + ℏ K ( ℏ K − 4 cos θ P ^ ϕ ) 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ + ℏ 2 [ J ( J + 1 ) − K 2 ] μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ + V a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) } Φ K a + sin θ μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ [ M K , K + 2 Φ K + 2 a + M K , K − 2 Φ K − 2 a ] , (371) i\hbar\frac{\partial\Phi^{a}_{K}}{\partial t}=\left\{-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2\mu_{R}}\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial\rho^{2}}+\frac{2}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}}\hat{L}^{2}(\theta,\phi)+\frac{\hbar K(\hbar K-4\cos\theta\,\hat{P}_{\phi})}{2\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}+\frac{\hbar^{2}[J(J+1)-K^{2}]}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}+V_{a}(\rho,\theta,\phi)+\Delta V(\rho,\theta)\right\}\Phi^{a}_{K}+\frac{\sin\theta}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}\left[M_{K,K+2}\Phi^{a}_{K+2}+M_{K,K-2}\Phi^{a}_{K-2}\right], \tag*{(371)} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Φ K a = { − 2 μ R ℏ 2 ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + μ R ρ 2 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ ℏ K ( ℏ K − 4 cos θ P ^ ϕ ) + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ ℏ 2 [ J ( J + 1 ) − K 2 ] + V a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) } Φ K a + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ sin θ [ M K , K + 2 Φ K + 2 a + M K , K − 2 Φ K − 2 a ] , (371)
where the last term of Eq. (371) couples Φ K a \Phi^{a}_{K} Φ K a component and Φ K ± 2 a \Phi^{a}_{K\pm2} Φ K ± 2 a through the coupling element M K , K ± 2 M_{K,K\pm2} M K , K ± 2 as follows:
M K , K ± 2 = ℏ 2 2 ( J ∓ K ) ( J ± K + 1 ) ( J ∓ K − 1 ) ( J ± K + 2 ) (372) M_{K,K\pm2}=\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2}\sqrt{(J\mp K)(J\pm K+1)(J\mp K-1)(J\pm K+2)} \tag*{(372)} M K , K ± 2 = 2 ℏ 2 ( J ∓ K ) ( J ± K + 1 ) ( J ∓ K − 1 ) ( J ± K + 2 ) (372)
and Δ V ( ρ , θ ) \Delta V(\rho,\theta) Δ V ( ρ , θ ) signifies an additional potential term appearing from the kinetic energy part of the Hamiltonian while performing transformation from Jacobi to hyperspherical coordinates (see Appendix C.3 for details).
Furthermore, the multi-state diabatic Hamiltonian (H ^ d \hat{H}_{d} H ^ d ) for a triatomic reactive system takes the following form (see Appendix C.4 for details):
H ^ d = [ − ℏ 2 2 μ R ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + J ^ 2 − J ^ z 2 μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ + J ^ z 2 − 4 cos θ J ^ z P ^ ϕ 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ + sin θ μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ 1 2 [ J ^ 2 + J ^ z 2 ] + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) ] I ^ + V ^ d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) , (373) \hat{H}_{d}=\left[-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2\mu_{R}}\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial\rho^{2}}+\frac{2}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}}\hat{L}^{2}(\theta,\phi)+\frac{\hat{J}^{2}-\hat{J}_{z}^{2}}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}+\frac{\hat{J}_{z}^{2}-4\cos\theta\hat{J}_{z}\hat{P}_{\phi}}{2\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}+\frac{\sin\theta}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}\frac{1}{2}\left[\hat{J}^{2}+\hat{J}_{z}^{2}\right]+\Delta V(\rho,\theta)\right]\hat{I}+\hat{V}_{d}(\rho,\theta,\phi), \tag*{(373)} H ^ d = [ − 2 μ R ℏ 2 ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + μ R ρ 2 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ J ^ 2 − J ^ z 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ J ^ z 2 − 4 cos θ J ^ z P ^ ϕ + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ sin θ 2 1 [ J ^ 2 + J ^ z 2 ] + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) ] I ^ + V ^ d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) , (373)
where I ^ \hat{I} I ^ and V ^ d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \hat{V}_{d}(\rho,\theta,\phi) V ^ d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) defines ( n × n ) (n \times n) ( n × n ) unit and diabatic potential energy matrices, respectively.
The K K K -component adiabatic wave functions (Φ K a \Phi_{K}^{a} Φ K a ) are transformed into the diabatic ones (Φ K d = X Φ K a \Phi_{K}^{d}=\mathbf{X}\Phi_{K}^{a} Φ K d = X Φ K a ) for the different surfaces employing the transformation matrix X \mathbf{X} X , which is used to diagonalize the BBO-DH according to V ^ a = X † V ^ d X \hat{V}_{a}=\mathbf{X}^{\dagger}\hat{V}_{d}\mathbf{X} V ^ a = X † V ^ d X . As a result, the solutions of the TDSE in the diabatic representation, namely, Φ K , i d \Phi_{K,i}^{d} Φ K , i d (i = 1 , 2 , 3 , … , n i=1,2,3,\ldots,n i = 1 , 2 , 3 , … , n ) can be written from the following set of coupled differential equations:
i ℏ ∂ ∂ t [ Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ ] = { − ℏ 2 2 μ R ∂ 2 ∂ ρ 2 + 2 μ R ρ 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + ℏ K ( ℏ K − 4 cos θ P ^ ϕ ) 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ + ℏ 2 [ J ( J + 1 ) − K 2 ] μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) } [ Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ ] + [ V 11 V 12 V 13 ⋯ V 21 V 22 V 23 ⋯ V 31 V 32 V 33 ⋯ ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ] [ Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ ] + sin θ μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ ( M K , K + 2 [ Φ K + 2 , 1 d Φ K + 2 , 2 d Φ K + 2 , 3 d ⋮ ] + M K , K − 2 [ Φ K − 2 , 1 d Φ K − 2 , 2 d Φ K − 2 , 3 d ⋮ ] ) . (374) \begin{aligned}
i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}
\begin{bmatrix}
\Phi_{K,1}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,2}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,3}^{d}\\
\vdots
\end{bmatrix}
={}&\left\{-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2\mu_{R}}\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial\rho^{2}}+\frac{2}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}}\hat{L}^{2}(\theta,\phi)+\frac{\hbar K(\hbar K-4\cos\theta\hat{P}_{\phi})}{2\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}\right.\\
&\left.+\frac{\hbar^{2}[J(J+1)-K^{2}]}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}+\Delta V(\rho,\theta)\right\}
\begin{bmatrix}
\Phi_{K,1}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,2}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,3}^{d}\\
\vdots
\end{bmatrix}\\
&+\begin{bmatrix}
V_{11}&V_{12}&V_{13}&\cdots\\
V_{21}&V_{22}&V_{23}&\cdots\\
V_{31}&V_{32}&V_{33}&\cdots\\
\vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\ddots
\end{bmatrix}
\begin{bmatrix}
\Phi_{K,1}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,2}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K,3}^{d}\\
\vdots
\end{bmatrix}\\
&+\frac{\sin\theta}{\mu_{R}\rho^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}\left(M_{K,K+2}
\begin{bmatrix}
\Phi_{K+2,1}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K+2,2}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K+2,3}^{d}\\
\vdots
\end{bmatrix}
+M_{K,K-2}
\begin{bmatrix}
\Phi_{K-2,1}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K-2,2}^{d}\\
\Phi_{K-2,3}^{d}\\
\vdots
\end{bmatrix}\right). \tag*{(374)}
\end{aligned} i ℏ ∂ t ∂ Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ = { − 2 μ R ℏ 2 ∂ ρ 2 ∂ 2 + μ R ρ 2 2 L ^ 2 ( θ , ϕ ) + 2 μ R ρ 2 sin 2 θ ℏ K ( ℏ K − 4 cos θ P ^ ϕ ) + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ ℏ 2 [ J ( J + 1 ) − K 2 ] + Δ V ( ρ , θ ) } Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ + V 11 V 21 V 31 ⋮ V 12 V 22 V 32 ⋮ V 13 V 23 V 33 ⋮ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ Φ K , 1 d Φ K , 2 d Φ K , 3 d ⋮ + μ R ρ 2 cos 2 θ sin θ M K , K + 2 Φ K + 2 , 1 d Φ K + 2 , 2 d Φ K + 2 , 3 d ⋮ + M K , K − 2 Φ K − 2 , 1 d Φ K − 2 , 2 d Φ K − 2 , 3 d ⋮ . (374)
The other operators manifested in Eq. (374) are demonstrated elsewhere18,60.
Propagation of Wavefunction, Computation details and Absorbing potential
The Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) technique138 is widely used to formulate kinetic energy operator, which scales as c N log N cN\log N c N log N . It is to be noted that N N N number of grid points are spanned over the ρ \rho ρ , θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ coordinates and such large number of grid points appears as the principal computational bottleneck in the propagation process. Such high computational cost can be significantly decreased by implementing parallel version of the FFT algorithm. On the other hand, while performing time propagation of the wavefunction, the iterative Lanczos reduction scheme139 is adapted, where the recursive process is controlled by governing the magnitude of the wavefunction vectors. Furthermore, generation of the Lanczos vectors is also parallelized to improve efficiency. In order to minimize the numerical instabilities originating due to the singularities in the kinetic term of the Hamiltonian, the wavefunction is propagated using a sine transformation. While carrying out such process, the θ \theta θ grid is extended from π / 2 \pi/2 π /2 to π \pi π , where the amplitudes define as inverse mirror images of those in the interval 0 0 0 to π / 2 \pi/2 π /2 due to the antisymmetric nature about θ = π / 2 \theta= \pi/2 θ = π /2 . As a result, the wavefunction appears as zero (0) at θ = 0 \theta= 0 θ = 0 , π / 2 \pi/2 π /2 , and π \pi π , which is consistent with the sine transformation technique 102. On the other hand, the steep increase in computational time with higher total angular momentum values (J J J ) is substantially resolved by employing Open Multi-Processing (OpenMP) parallelization over the set of K K K -components corresponding to each specific J J J during the propagation.
In order to perform scattering calculations, the grid cannot be extended to infinity and in order to prevent unphysical reflections, the outgoing portion of the wavepacket must be removed from the grid immediately after projection before arriving at the boundary. Such goal can be achieved by using a negative imaginary potential, namely, − i V ^ I m ( ρ ) -i\hat{V}_{\mathrm{Im}}(\rho) − i V ^ Im ( ρ ) , which is placed at few points towards the end of the ρ \rho ρ grid but far from the interaction region. Accordingly, the modified total potential takes the following form:
V ^ ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) = V ^ 0 ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) − i V ^ I m ( ρ ) . (375) \hat{V}(\rho,\theta,\phi) = \hat{V}_{0}(\rho,\theta,\phi) - i\hat{V}_{\mathrm{Im}}(\rho). \tag*{(375)} V ^ ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) = V ^ 0 ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) − i V ^ Im ( ρ ) . (375)
It is worth mentioning that the chosen form of the imaginary potential is not unique, which largely depends on the condition that the outcomes of scattering calculation should become independent of the particular choice of the absorbing potential. One such form of the absorbing potential 18,87,105 is expressed as:
V I m ( ρ ) = { V o p ⋅ ( ρ − ρ s t ) , ρ s t ≤ ρ 0 , otherwise . V_{\mathrm{Im}}(\rho) =
\begin{cases}
V_{\mathrm{op}}\cdot(\rho-\rho_{\mathrm{st}}), & \rho_{\mathrm{st}}\leq\rho\\
0, & \text{otherwise}.
\end{cases} V Im ( ρ ) = { V op ⋅ ( ρ − ρ st ) , 0 , ρ st ≤ ρ otherwise .
Here, ρ s t \rho_{\mathrm{st}} ρ st symbolizes the starting point for such a potential. A thorough discussion on propagation of wavepackets are demonstrated in Appendix C.5 and C.6.
Analysis of the wavepacket
When the atom and the centre of mass of the diatom is largely separated, R = R ∗ R = R^{*} R = R ∗ , 102,104 and the amplitudes of the K K K -component diabatic wavefunction, Φ K , i d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \Phi^{d}_{K,i}(\rho,\theta,\phi) Φ K , i d ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) , are converted back into their adiabatic counterparts, Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \Phi^{a}_{K,i}(\rho,\theta,\phi) Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) [Φ K a = X † Φ K d \boldsymbol{\Phi}^{a}_{K} = \mathbf{X}^{\dagger}\boldsymbol{\Phi}^{d}_{K} Φ K a = X † Φ K d ]. Then, it is projected onto the asymptotic eigenstates at each time step. It is to be noted that the scattering amplitude corresponding to a particular channel, defined by the vibrational, rotational, and orbital quantum numbers v ′ v' v ′ , j ′ j' j ′ and l ′ l' l ′ , respectively, as follows:
u v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( R = R ∗ ; t ) = 4 R ∫ d r ∫ d η η sin ρ − 5 / 2 ( sin 2 θ ) − 1 / 2 ϕ v ′ j ′ ( r ) ∑ K μ ′ g J j ′ l ′ μ ′ A K μ ′ J C J j ′ μ ′ ( η ) Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) . (376) u^{J}_{v'j'l'}(R=R^{*};t) = 4R\int dr\int d\eta\,\eta\sin\rho^{-5/2}(\sin2\theta)^{-1/2}\phi_{v'j'}(r)
\sum_{K\mu'}g_{Jj'l'\mu'}A^{J}_{K\mu'}C_{Jj'\mu'}(\eta)\Phi^{a}_{K,i}(\rho,\theta,\phi). \tag*{(376)} u v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( R = R ∗ ; t ) = 4 R ∫ d r ∫ d η η sin ρ − 5/2 ( sin 2 θ ) − 1/2 ϕ v ′ j ′ ( r ) K μ ′ ∑ g J j ′ l ′ μ ′ A K μ ′ J C J j ′ μ ′ ( η ) Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) . (376)
Since the outgoing wavepacket is projected onto the asymptotic eigenstates at a fixed value of R R R (= R ∗ R^{*} R ∗ ) in Jacobi coordinates, the amplitude of the K K K component waves (Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \Phi^{a}_{K,i}(\rho,\theta,\phi) Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) ) are interpolated on the grid to calculate the value of the (Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) \Phi^{a}_{K,i}(\rho,\theta,\phi) Φ K , i a ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) ) on the ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) (\rho,\theta,\phi) ( ρ , θ , ϕ ) -space at R = R ∗ R=R^{*} R = R ∗ .
Once the wavepacket completely traverses the projection region and then, it is absorbed at the boundary, the scattering amplitudes are Fourier transformed from the time domain to the energy domain and we obtain:
b v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( E ; R ) = 1 2 π ∫ d t u v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( R ; t ) exp ( i E t / ℏ ) , (377) b^{J}_{v'j'l'}(E;R) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}\int dt\,u^{J}_{v'j'l'}(R;t)\exp(iEt/\hbar), \tag*{(377)} b v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( E ; R ) = 2 π 1 ∫ d t u v ′ j ′ l ′ J ( R ; t ) exp ( i E t /ℏ ) , (377)
which are expanded in terms of the incoming and outgoing waves as:
b v ′ j ′ l ′ J = A v ′ j ′ l ′ i n k v ′ j ′ R h − ( k v ′ j ′ R ) + A v ′ j ′ l ′ o u t k v ′ j ′ R h + ( k v ′ j ′ R ) , (378) b^{J}_{v'j'l'} = A^{\mathrm{in}}_{v'j'l'}k_{v'j'}R\,h^{-}(k_{v'j'}R) + A^{\mathrm{out}}_{v'j'l'}k_{v'j'}R\,h^{+}(k_{v'j'}R), \tag*{(378)} b v ′ j ′ l ′ J = A v ′ j ′ l ′ in k v ′ j ′ R h − ( k v ′ j ′ R ) + A v ′ j ′ l ′ out k v ′ j ′ R h + ( k v ′ j ′ R ) , (378)
where
h ± ( k v ′ j ′ R ) = − n l ( k v ′ j ′ R ) ± i j l ( k v ′ j ′ R ) . (379) h^{\pm}(k_{v'j'}R)=-n_l(k_{v'j'}R)\pm i j_l(k_{v'j'}R). \tag*{(379)} h ± ( k v ′ j ′ R ) = − n l ( k v ′ j ′ R ) ± i j l ( k v ′ j ′ R ) . (379)
In the above expression, j l j_l j l and n l n_l n l represent spherical Bessel and Neumann functions, respectively. Since the projection onto the incoming component of the scattering amplitude must be zero at asymptotic time, the reaction probability corresponding to a transition from the initial state ( v j l ) (vjl) ( v j l ) to the product state ( v ′ j ′ l ′ ) (v'j'l') ( v ′ j ′ l ′ ) can be obtained as the ratio of the outgoing to the incoming flux for a given total angular momentum, J J J as follows:
P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J = F v ′ j ′ l ′ J F v j l , (380) P^{J}_{v'j'l'\leftarrow vjl}=\frac{F^{J}_{v'j'l'}}{F_{vjl}}, \tag*{(380)} P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J = F v j l F v ′ j ′ l ′ J , (380)
where
F v ′ j ′ l ′ J = 1 μ o u t k v ′ j ′ ∣ A v ′ j ′ l ′ o u t , J ∣ 2 , (381) F^{J}_{v'j'l'}=\frac{1}{\mu_{\mathrm{out}}}k_{v'j'}\left|A^{\mathrm{out},J}_{v'j'l'}\right|^2, \tag*{(381)} F v ′ j ′ l ′ J = μ out 1 k v ′ j ′ A v ′ j ′ l ′ out , J 2 , (381)
F v j l = 1 μ i n k v j ∣ c E l ∣ 2 . (382) F_{vjl}=\frac{1}{\mu_{\mathrm{in}}}k_{vj}\left|c^{l}_{E}\right|^2. \tag*{(382)} F v j l = μ in 1 k v j c E l 2 . (382)
Here, c E l c^{l}_{E} c E l defines the scattering amplitude of the initial wavepacket at energy E E E , while k v j k_{vj} k v j and k v ′ j ′ k_{v'j'} k v ′ j ′ demonstrate the wavevectors corresponding to the initial ( v j ) (vj) ( v j ) and final ( v ′ j ′ ) (v'j') ( v ′ j ′ ) ro-vibrational states for each channel, respectively. On the other hand, reduced masses of the reactants and products are defined by μ i n \mu_{\mathrm{in}} μ in and μ o u t \mu_{\mathrm{out}} μ out , respectively. The weighting in the energy domain is then associated with the k k k domain through the following relation:
∣ c E l ∣ 2 = ( μ i n ℏ k ) 2 ∣ c k l ∣ 2 , (383) \left|c^{l}_{E}\right|^2=\left(\frac{\mu_{\mathrm{in}}}{\hbar k}\right)^2\left|c^{l}_{k}\right|^2, \tag*{(383)} c E l 2 = ( ℏ k μ in ) 2 c k l 2 , (383)
where the expression for ∣ c k l ∣ 2 \left|c^{l}_{k}\right|^2 c k l 2 for a Gaussian wavepacket takes the following form:
∣ c k l ∣ 2 = 2 π σ exp [ − 2 σ 2 ( k − k 0 ) 2 ] (384) \left|c^{l}_{k}\right|^2=\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi}}\sigma\exp\left[-2\sigma^2(k-k_0)^2\right] \tag*{(384)} c k l 2 = π 2 σ exp [ − 2 σ 2 ( k − k 0 ) 2 ] (384)
with σ \sigma σ being the width of the Gaussian wavepacket.
Once one obtains the reaction probabilities (see Eq. (380) ), the ro-vibrationally resolved cross-sections are computed as functions of the collision energy by taking the summation of the state-to-state reaction probabilities, P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J P^{J}_{v'j'l'\leftarrow vjl} P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J , over all values of J J J up to the convergence limit, J max J_{\max} J m a x .
σ v j v ′ j ′ ( E c o l ) = π k v j 2 ( 2 j + 1 ) ∑ J = 0 J max ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J ( E c o l ) . (385) \sigma^{v'j'}_{vj}(E_{\mathrm{col}})=\frac{\pi}{k_{vj}^{2}(2j+1)}\sum_{J=0}^{J_{\max}}(2J+1)P^{J}_{v'j'l'\leftarrow vjl}(E_{\mathrm{col}}). \tag*{(385)} σ v j v ′ j ′ ( E col ) = k v j 2 ( 2 j + 1 ) π J = 0 ∑ J m a x ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J ( E col ) . (385)
In a similar fashion, the total integral cross-sections (ICSs) for the various rearrangement channels are computed as functions of the collision energy by summing over the ro-vibrationally resolved reaction probabilities.
σ v j ( E c o l ) = π k v j 2 ( 2 j + 1 ) ∑ j ′ = 0 j max ′ ∑ v ′ = 0 v max ′ ∑ J = 0 J max ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J ( E c o l ) . (386) \sigma_{vj}(E_{\mathrm{col}})=\frac{\pi}{k_{vj}^{2}(2j+1)}\sum_{j'=0}^{j'_{\max}}\sum_{v'=0}^{v'_{\max}}\sum_{J=0}^{J_{\max}}(2J+1)P^{J}_{v'j'l'\leftarrow vjl}(E_{\mathrm{col}}). \tag*{(386)} σ v j ( E col ) = k v j 2 ( 2 j + 1 ) π j ′ = 0 ∑ j m a x ′ v ′ = 0 ∑ v m a x ′ J = 0 ∑ J m a x ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ l ′ ← v j l J ( E col ) . (386)
On the other hand, one can evaluate the state-to-state rate coefficients88,140 (k v , j → v ′ , j ′ ( T ) k_{v,j\to v',j'}(T) k v , j → v ′ , j ′ ( T ) ) as follows:
k v , j → v ′ , j ′ ( T ) = ( 8 k B T π μ R ) 1 2 1 ( k B T ) 2 ∫ E 0 E max [ σ v j v ′ j ′ ( E c o l ) exp [ − E c o l / k B T ] ] E c o l d E c o l . (387) k_{v,j\to v',j'}(T)=\left(\frac{8k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{\pi\mu_{R}}\right)^{\frac{1}{2}}\frac{1}{(k_{\mathrm{B}}T)^2}\int_{E_0}^{E_{\max}} \left[\sigma_{vj}^{v'j'}(E_{\mathrm{col}})\exp\left[-E_{\mathrm{col}}/k_{\mathrm{B}}T\right]\right]E_{\mathrm{col}}\,\mathrm{d}E_{\mathrm{col}}. \tag*{(387)} k v , j → v ′ , j ′ ( T ) = ( π μ R 8 k B T ) 2 1 ( k B T ) 2 1 ∫ E 0 E m a x [ σ v j v ′ j ′ ( E col ) exp [ − E col / k B T ] ] E col d E col . (387)
A detailed discussion on the analysis procedure is presented in Appendix C.7 to C.9.
Ab Initio Adiabatic and BBO based Diabatic Hamiltonian
Ab initio calculation in Jacobi coordinates is carried out to locate the conical intersection (symmetry-driven as well as accidental) among the electronic states for triatomic reactive species. On the contrary, the hyperspherical coordinates are used to generate ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs and the NACTs for those systems (see Figure 7.1 ). Hyperradius ρ \rho ρ (0 ≤ ρ ≤ 25 0\leq\rho\leq25 0 ≤ ρ ≤ 25 Bohr) dictates the overall size of the triangle constituted by three atoms, whereas the shape and orientation of the triangle are governed by the two hyperangles, θ \theta θ (0 ≤ θ ≤ 90 ∘ 0\leq\theta\leq90^\circ 0 ≤ θ ≤ 9 0 ∘ ) and ϕ \phi ϕ (0 ≤ ϕ ≤ 360 ∘ 0\leq\phi\leq360^\circ 0 ≤ ϕ ≤ 36 0 ∘ ). Such coordinate system can evenhandedly describes all the reaction channels.
Figure 7.1. Schematic diagram of the Jacobi coordinates for the triatomic system is presented, where the side lengths, R 1 R_1 R 1 , R 2 R_2 R 2 and R 3 R_3 R 3 are defined in terms of hyperspherical coordinates. This figure is taken from Ref. 81 and permission has been taken from American Chemical Society (ACS).
While carrying out the ab initio calculations, the inter-atomic distances (R 1 R_1 R 1 , R 2 R_2 R 2 and R 3 R_3 R 3 ) of triatom can be expressed in terms of the three hyperspherical coordinates as follows,
R 1 = ρ 2 d 3 [ 1 + sin θ cos ( ϕ + ϵ 3 ) ] 1 / 2 , (388) R_1 = \frac{\rho}{\sqrt{2}}d_3\left[1+\sin\theta\cos(\phi+\epsilon_3)\right]^{1/2}, \tag*{(388)} R 1 = 2 ρ d 3 [ 1 + sin θ cos ( ϕ + ϵ 3 ) ] 1/2 , (388)
R 2 = ρ 2 d 1 ( 1 + sin θ cos ϕ ) 1 / 2 , (389) R_2 = \frac{\rho}{\sqrt{2}}d_1\left(1+\sin\theta\cos\phi\right)^{1/2}, \tag*{(389)} R 2 = 2 ρ d 1 ( 1 + sin θ cos ϕ ) 1/2 , (389)
R 3 = ρ 2 d 2 [ 1 + sin θ cos ( ϕ − ϵ 2 ) ] 1 / 2 , (390) R_3 = \frac{\rho}{\sqrt{2}}d_2\left[1+\sin\theta\cos(\phi-\epsilon_2)\right]^{1/2}, \tag*{(390)} R 3 = 2 ρ d 2 [ 1 + sin θ cos ( ϕ − ϵ 2 ) ] 1/2 , (390)
where d i = m i ( m j + m k ) / μ M d_i=\sqrt{m_i(m_j+m_k)/\mu M} d i = m i ( m j + m k ) / μ M , M = ∑ i 3 m i M=\sum_{i}^{3}m_i M = ∑ i 3 m i , μ = m 1 m 2 m 3 / M \mu=\sqrt{m_1m_2m_3/M} μ = m 1 m 2 m 3 / M , ϵ 2 = 2 tan − 1 ( m 3 / μ ) \epsilon_2=2\tan^{-1}(m_3/\mu) ϵ 2 = 2 tan − 1 ( m 3 / μ ) and ϵ 3 = 2 tan − 1 ( m 2 / μ ) \epsilon_3=2\tan^{-1}(m_2/\mu) ϵ 3 = 2 tan − 1 ( m 2 / μ ) .
FH2 _2 2
Stark and Werner (SW) 141–143 first computed global ab initio adiabatic and diabatic PESs of FH2 _2 2 system using multi-reference configuration interaction (MRCI) method with Davidson correction. Such PESs were later refined by incorporating spin-orbit (SO) interactions for describing asymptotic channel more accurately. In the subsequent works, SO coupling of the F atom was corrected in Hartke-Stark-Werner (HSW) 144, Alexander-Stark-Werner (ASW) 145 as well as Li-Werner-Alexander (LWA) 146 PESs, where the ASW is a set of diabatic PESs originated from 6×6 SO electronic basis set. 145 Indeed, accurate ground adiabatic PES was generated by Xu-Xie-Zhang (XXZ) 147 using large scale MRCI calculation with the SO coupling effect. On the other hand, Chen-Sun-Zhang (CSZ) 15 also computed adiabatic PESs with the aid of spin-unrestricted coupled-cluster method [UCCSDT(2)Q], whereas Li et al. 148 introduced a double many-body expansion (DMBE) PES.
On the other hand, Adhikari and co-workers carried out extensive ab initio calculations to generate adiabatic PESs, nonadiabatic and SO couplings for the lowest three electronic states (1 2 A ′ ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ , 1 2 A ′ ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ and 2 2 A ′ 2\,^{2}A^{\prime} 2 2 A ′ ) followed by construction of the diabatic Hamiltonian using BBO theory. 21 While performing such ab initio electronic structure calculations, multi-configuration self-consistent field (MCSCF) approach was employed with an active space of (9e,10o) and Dunning’s correlation-consistent quadruple-ζ \zeta ζ (aug-cc-pVQZ or AVQZ) basis set. It is worth mentioning that the active space is constituted with 6 σ 6\sigma 6 σ and 2 π 2\pi 2 π orbitals, which represents 2 s 2s 2 s , 3 s 3s 3 s , 2 p 2p 2 p and 3 p 3p 3 p orbitals of F atom, and 1 σ g 1\sigma_g 1 σ g and 1 σ u 1\sigma_u 1 σ u orbitals of H2 _2 2 . The adiabatic PESs were further calculated at the MRCI+Q level to incorporate dynamic correlation and reproduce the ground-state collinear barrier height 142. In addition, SO coupling matrix elements for the six spin components associated with the three electronic states were computed employing Breit-Pauli operator as implemented in MOLPRO. On the other hand, numerical finite-difference (DDR) approach was used to compute the NACTs among those lowest three electronic states with the same (9e,10o) active space and basis set. For comparison, few ab initio points were evaluated using analytic gradient method, like state-averaged coupled-perturbed MCSCF (CP-MCSCF) employing the 6-311++G** basis set with the same active space. Figure 7.2 depicts θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs as functions of hyperangles ( θ , ϕ ) (\theta,\phi) ( θ , ϕ ) for a fixed ρ = 4.5 \rho=4.5 ρ = 4.5 Bohr. JT CI between the ground state (1 2 A ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime} 1 2 A ′ ) and the first excited state (2 2 A ′ 2\,^{2}A^{\prime} 2 2 A ′ ) as well as additional RT CIs/seams between the first (2 2 A ′ 2\,^{2}A^{\prime} 2 2 A ′ ) and the second excited state (1 2 A ′ ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ ) are explored. 149 Figure 7.3 depicts location of JT and RT CIs through closed in-plane and out-of-plane contour integrations, respectively, around the linear F + H2 _2 2 configuration in Jacobi coordinate. In the planar loop configuration (see Figure 7.3 (a)), the minimum-energy conical intersection (MECI) between the 1 2 A ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime} 1 2 A ′ and 2 2 A ′ 2\,^{2}A^{\prime} 2 2 A ′ states is present 5.35 Bohr apart from the H2 _2 2 center of mass, whereas the RT CI seam between the 2 2 A ′ 2\,^{2}A^{\prime} 2 2 A ′ and 1 2 A ′ ′ 1\,^{2}A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ states is explored with the tilted loop as shown in Figure 7.3 (b).
Figure 7.2. Functional forms of the swapped NACTs, (a) τ 12 , θ ′ \tau'_{12,\theta} τ 12 , θ ′ and (b) τ 12 , ϕ ′ \tau'_{12,\phi} τ 12 , ϕ ′ originated from the DDR methodology are presented as functions of the hyperangles θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ at ρ = 4.5 \rho= 4.5 ρ = 4.5 Bohr. The figures are taken from Ref. 21 with permission from American Institute of Physics (AIP).
Figure 7.3. The diagrams display contour of radius, q = 1.0 q = 1.0 q = 1.0 Bohr traversed by the F atom taking X as center, which lies on the collinear H2 _2 2 axis. In this arrangement, the magnitude of r H H r_{HH} r H H (H-H distance), R c e R_{ce} R ce (distance from the center of closed contour, X to the center of mass of H-H) and R C I R_{CI} R C I (distance from the CI to the center of mass of H-H) appears as 1.401 Bohr, 5.55 Bohr and 5.35 Bohr, respectively. In upper diagram (a), the contour remains in the plane with the H-H-X axis, whereas in lower one (b), the loop is tilted by 45° with respect to the same axis. The figures are taken from Ref. 150 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC).
Once the ab initio NACTs are in hand, the topologically correct mixing angles among the electronic states were calculated using the ADT equations for three coupled electronic manifold (see Eq. (199) ). Then, adiabatic PESs and NACTs were diabatized to generate the global diabatic Hamiltonian matrix in hyperspherical coordinates. The diabatic PES matrices without SO coupling are depicted in Figure 7.4 , where the matrix elements are smooth, single-valued and continuous functions of the nuclear coordinates. In addition, in order to get more complete and accurate description of the F + H2 _2 2 system, the SO coupling are also included in diabatic PES matrices. 21 The elements of SO coupling matrix, F and G are originated from the same adiabatic basis along the linear geometry in Jacobi coordinates, which are interpolated in hyperspherical (coordinates) as depicted in Figure 7.5 . 21
Figure 7.4. The diabatic PES matrix elements (a): W 11 W_{11} W 11 , (b): W 22 W_{22} W 22 and (c) W 12 W_{12} W 12 are plotted as functions of θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ for ρ = 4.5 \rho= 4.5 ρ = 4.5 Bohr. The figures are adapted from Ref. 21 with the permission of AIP.
Figure 7.5. SO matrix elements, (a) F and (b) G are presented as functions of hyperangle for ρ = 4.5 \rho= 4.5 ρ = 4.5 Bohr. The figures are taken from Ref. 21 with the permission of AIP.
H3+
In the realm of diabatization, several research groups 151–153 took attempts to incorporate the nonadiabatic effects among the coupled (low lying singlet) electronic states semi-empirically. While constructing the BBO-theory-based diabatic Hamiltonian for this system, ab initio calculations are performed for the lowest three singlet electronic states (1 1 A ′ 1^1A' 1 1 A ′ , 2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ and 3 1 A ′ 3^1A' 3 1 A ′ ) along with the NACTs among those states. 154 Such calculations for the three adiabatic PESs are executed in C s C_s C s symmetry with the use of Dunning’s correlation-consistent quintuple-ζ \zeta ζ (cc-pV5Z) basis set 155. First, MCSCF calculations are opted over the lowest six electronic states, considering two electrons distributed among ten active orbitals, followed by more accurate three state MRCI calculation. These surfaces are generated as functions of the hyperangles θ \theta θ (0 ≤ θ ≤ 90 ∘ 0 \leq\theta\leq90^\circ 0 ≤ θ ≤ 9 0 ∘ ) and ϕ \phi ϕ (0 ≤ ϕ ≤ 360 ∘ 0 \leq\phi\leq360^\circ 0 ≤ ϕ ≤ 36 0 ∘ ) over a grid of fixed hyperradii (1.5 ≤ ρ ≤ 20 1.5 \leq\rho\leq20 1.5 ≤ ρ ≤ 20 Bohr). One can observe a semi-circular accidental CI seam of C s C_s C s symmetry passing through a C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v geometry, which is located between the ground (1 1 A ′ 1^1A' 1 1 A ′ ) and first excited (2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ ) states of the H 3 + H_3^+ H 3 + system in the θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ space across the hyperradius range of 5 ≤ ρ ≤ 12 5 \leq\rho\leq12 5 ≤ ρ ≤ 12 Bohr. Figure 7.6 presents the ϕ \phi ϕ components of the NACT between 1 1 A ′ 1^1A' 1 1 A ′ -2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ and 2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ -3 1 A ′ 3^1A' 3 1 A ′ states as functions of hyperangles (θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ ) at ρ = 10 \rho= 10 ρ = 10 Bohr. Furthermore, symmetry driven 2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ -3 1 A ′ 3^1A' 3 1 A ′ D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h CI is observed in Jacobi coordinates by integrating the ADT equations along a circular path of radius q = 0.8 q = 0.8 q = 0.8 Bohr. 150 During the closed contour integration, H − H H-H H − H bond length (r H H r_{HH} r H H ) is taken as 2 Bohr, separation vector (R R R ) from the contour center to the H − H H-H H − H center of mass is fixed at 1.732 Bohr, and the angle γ \gamma γ between r H H r_{HH} r H H and R R R appears as 90 ∘ 90^\circ 9 0 ∘ . The ab initio calculated NACT(s) are plugged into the ADT equations (see Eq. (199) ) 156 and then those are integrated leading to the mixing angles between the electronic states. On the other hand, two-dimensional (2D) variation of ADT angle (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 ) is plotted as function of θ − ϕ \theta-\phi θ − ϕ in Figure 7.7 , where such angle attains the magnitude of π \pi π bearing the signature of 1 1 A ′ 1^1A' 1 1 A ′ -2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ CI/seam. Finally, diabatic PES matrices are computed employing ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs and ADT angles over the θ − ϕ \theta-\phi θ − ϕ plane for each fixed ρ \rho ρ values. Figure 7.8 manifests diabatic PES(s) as functions of hyperangles (θ \theta θ , ϕ \phi ϕ ) at ρ = 10 \rho= 10 ρ = 10 Bohr. It is important to note that the global diabatic PES matrix for H 3 + H_3^+ H 3 + system is available in terms of hyperspherical coordinates elsewhere24,31.
Figure 7.6. ϕ \phi ϕ components of NACTs for H 3 + H_3^+ H 3 + obtained from the DDR methodology are presented in hyperspherical coordinates, namely, (a) τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ , (b) τ 23 ϕ \tau_{23}^{\phi} τ 23 ϕ over θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ configuration space for a fixed value of ρ = 10.0 \rho= 10.0 ρ = 10.0 Bohr. The figures are taken from Ref. 85 with the permission of Wiley.
Figure 7.7. Variation of (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 ) over the θ \theta θ –ϕ \phi ϕ CS is depicted as functions of hyperspherical coordinates at a fixed hyperradius ρ = 10.0 \rho= 10.0 ρ = 10.0 Bohr for the H 3 + \mathrm{H}_{3}^{+} H 3 + system. The data are adapted from Ref. 157.
Figure 7.8. The diabatic PES matrix elements W 11 W_{11} W 11 and W 22 W_{22} W 22 are plotted in hyperspherical coordinates as functions of θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ at ρ = 10.0 \rho= 10.0 ρ = 10.0 Bohr. The figures are reproduced from Ref. 135 with permission from RSC.
HeH2 + _2^+ 2 +
In the last few decades, several calculations were carried out on the HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + system 158,159, which explored the crossings between the ground and excited states as well as computed the nonadiabatic couplings. Such calculations was followed by the development of diabatic representations for the lowest excited states using the diatomics-in-molecules (DIM) approach. 160,161 Double Many-Body Expansion (DMBE) method were employed to generate analytically fitted quasi-diabatic PESs for the two lowest excited states. 162 In the subsequent works, diabatic PES matrices were constructed incorporating multiple electronic states for analyzing the excited states proton-transfer reaction, He+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 → \rightarrow → HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + + H. 163 For such system, topology of the CIs and the associated ADT angles are examined to locate the seams of intersection between the lowest excited states. 61,62 With the help of MOLPRO quantum chemistry package, 128, MRCI level of calculations are performed by Ravi et al. 164 exposing multiple (ten) CIs among the electronic states and validating the contribution of NACTs in the accurate (qualitative and quantitative) description of the species. The NACTs among are computed as functions of hyperangles ($\theta$, $\phi$) for a set of fixed hyperradii ($\rho$). Once the adiabatic PESs and NACTs are obtained, global diabatic Hamiltonian {citep}59 is constructed by involving the NACTs between the lowest four (doublet) adiabatic PESs ($1^{2}A'$, $2^{2}A'$, $3^{2}A'$ and $4^{2}A'$). While performing the *ab initio* calculations, adiabatic PESs are computed employing aug-cc-pVQZ basis set by state-averaged SA-6-MCSCF methodology with the CAS (3e, 8o), whereas such study is followed by internally contracted MRCI calculations for those four low-lying electronic states. NACTs are evaluated at the same MRCI level using the DDR method as implemented in MOLPRO. {xref}Figure 7.9 shows few representative $\phi$- and $\theta$-components of NACTs at the fixed hyperradius, $\rho = 10.0$ Bohr. On the other hand, {xref}Figures 7.9a and 7.9b show $\phi$ and $\theta$ components of $\tau_{12}$ exhibiting peaks at the $C_{2v}$ configuration ($\phi = 0^\circ$ or $360^\circ$, $\theta \approx 45^\circ$). Such steep rise of NACTs reflects an accidental CI between the ground and first excited states, which is further affirmed by carrying out loop-integral quantization leading to ADT angles (see {xref}Figures 7.10a and 7.10b). {xref}Figure 7.10b explores that the ADT angle attains the value of $\pi$ upon closed-contour integration, whereas the diagonal elements of the ADT matrix ($A_{11}$ and $A_{22}$) exhibit sign inversion from +1 to −1, confirming the presence of a conical intersection between the ground and first excited states. In a similar way, presence of additional CIs between the second ($2^{2}A'$) and third ($3^{2}A'$) as well as the third ($3^{2}A'$) and fourth ($4^{2}A'$) electronic state at linear geometries can also be validated. {citep}59 On the other hand, 2D functional forms of mixing angles between the electronic states ($\Theta_{ij}$) over $\theta$-$\phi$ plane for fixed $\rho$ are evaluated by integrating the ADT equations for four coupled electronic states using the *ab initio* calculated NACTs (see {xref}Appendix B.1). Such mixing angles vis-à-vis *ab initio* calculated adiabatic PESs are utilized to generate the diabatic PES matrix as functions of $\theta$ and $\phi$ for a series of $\rho$ values as demonstrated in {xref}Figure 7.11` for a specific case.
Figure 7.9. ϕ \phi ϕ and θ \theta θ components of NACTs for HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + system are presented as functions of hyperspherical coordinates: (a) τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ and (b) τ 12 θ \tau_{12}^{\theta} τ 12 θ over θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ configuration space for a fixed value of ρ = 10.0 \rho= 10.0 ρ = 10.0 Bohr. Such figures are taken from Ref. 59 with the permission from ACS.
Figure 7.10. (a) A schematic representation in Jacobi coordinates is portrayed for identifying the location of 1-2 CI in C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v configuration; (b) the ADT angle and the diagonal elements of the ADT matrix (A 11 A_{11} A 11 and A 22 A_{22} A 22 ) achieve values of π \pi π and − 1 -1 − 1 , respectively, upon close contour integration, thereby affirming the presence of 1-2 CI inside the contour. Such figures are adapted from Ref. 59 with the permission from ACS.
Figure 7.11. Diabatic PES matrix elements are plotted as functions of hyperangles θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ for ρ = 7 \rho= 7 ρ = 7 Bohr: (a) W 11 W_{11} W 11 , (b): W 12 W_{12} W 12 , (c) W 33 W_{33} W 33 and (d) W 34 W_{34} W 34 . The figures are taken from Ref. 59 with the permission from ACS.
H3
In the past few decades, extensive investigations were carried out on the exchange reaction between H/D and H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 /HD over the ground adiabatic PES84,165–167 of H3 _3 3 system. Even though such calculations appear as quite accurate at lower collision energies, construction of multi-state diabatic Hamiltonian is indeed necessary for dynamical calculation around the energy range where the low lying electronic states become close to each other energetically through multiple CIs. Several attempts84,168 were taken to construct diabatic PES matrix, but the accuracy needs to be improved. In order to increase the accuracy, global diabatic PES matrix is constructed, which is highly precise not only at interaction region, but also at the domain of asymptote. For the H3 _3 3 system81, the lowest three (doublet) adiabatic PESs (1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ , 2 2 A ′ 2^{2}A' 2 2 A ′ and 3 2 A ′ 3^{2}A' 3 2 A ′ ) are calculated at the CASSCF followed by MRCI level of approaches, where the NACTs between those electronic states are evaluated with the aid of MRCI wavefunctions via the finite-difference (DDR) procedure as implemented in the MOLPRO quantum chemistry package169,170. The state-averaged multi-configurational self-consistent field (SA-MCSCF) level of calculation is performed with the use of converged CAS constituted with three electrons distributed among sixteen orbitals, namely, twelve a ′ a' a ′ and four a ′ ′ a'' a ′′ orbitals. On the other hand, six electronic states (6) are averaged and thereby, denoted as SA-6-CAS(16o,3e) using aug-cc-pVQZ basis set. At ρ = 9.0 \rho= 9.0 ρ = 9.0 Bohr, the 2D PESs for three electronic states and the ϕ \phi ϕ -component of NACTs are plotted in Figure 7.12 and Figure 7.13 , respectively, as function of θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ . While locating CIs between the electronic states, the ϕ \phi ϕ -component of the NACTs (τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ ) are calculated in Jacobi coordinates (r r r , R R R , γ \gamma γ ) along a circular contour of radius q q q encapsulating the CI.81 After solving ADT equations for three coupled electronic states (see Eq. (199) ), the mixing angle reaches π \pi π and diagonal elements of the ADT matrix attains the value of minus one (-1) validating the resence of D3 h _{3h} 3 h CI between the ground and first excited states (see Figure 7.14 ). In addition, the accidental CIs between the ground and first excited states as well as the first and second excited states at C2 v _{2v} 2 v configurations are also explored.80,81
Figure 7.12. The lowest three adiabatic PESs (u 1 u_1 u 1 , u 2 u_2 u 2 and u 3 u_3 u 3 ) for the H3 _3 3 system are plotted over the θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ plane at fixed ρ = 9 \rho= 9 ρ = 9 Bohr. The figure is adapted from Ref. 81 with permission from ACS.
Figure 7.13. Hyperspherical ϕ \phi ϕ -component of NACT (τ 12 ϕ \tau_{12}^{\phi} τ 12 ϕ ) for the H3 _3 3 system is displayed as function of θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ coordinates, where ρ \rho ρ is fixed at 9 Bohr. The figure is adapted from Ref. 81 with permission from ACS.
Figure 7.14. (a) The closed contour with radius q = 0.5 q = 0.5 q = 0.5 Bohr is illustrated enclosing the D3 h _{3h} 3 h 1-2 CI in Jacobi coordinates. (b) The ADT angle (Θ 12 \Theta_{12} Θ 12 ) and the diagonal ADT matrix elements (A 11 A_{11} A 11 and A 22 A_{22} A 22 ) attain the values of − π -\pi − π and − 1 -1 − 1 , respectively, at the end of closing contour, thereby depicting the topological signature of the 1-2 CI. The figures are adapted from Ref. 81 with permission from ACS.
The ab initio calculated NACTs are substituted into the differential equations (Eq. (199) ) and then, those are numerically integrated156 to compute the mixing angles over θ \theta θ -ϕ \phi ϕ plane for each fixed value of ρ \rho ρ . Such angles and ab initio adiabatic PESs are employed for the construction of diabatic PESs matrix through an orthogonal transformation [see Eq. (356) ]. In Figure 7.15 , the diabatic PESs matrix elements (W11 _{11} 11 , W12 _{12} 12 and W22 _{22} 22 ) are demonstrated as functions of θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ for ρ = 9 \rho= 9 ρ = 9 Bohr, where the diabatic PESs and couplings are single valued, smooth and continuous functions of the hyperangles.
Figure 7.15. Figure 7.15: Diabatic PES matrix elements are plotted as functions of hyperangles θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ for fixed ρ = 9 \rho= 9 ρ = 9 Bohr: (a) W 11 W_{11} W 11 and (b): W 22 W_{22} W 22 and (c): W 12 W_{12} W 12 . The figures are adapted from Ref. 81 with permission from ACS.
Reactive Scattering Calculations
F + H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 reaction
Adhikari and coworkers performed FCC-3D-TDWP quantum scattering calculation on the ground adiabatic PES involving all the helicity quantum numbers (K K K ) for the F + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) and F + D2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) reactions.171 While doing such study, reaction probabilities upto the converged total angular momentum (J J J ) are used to determine the ICSs. Figure 7.16 and Figure 7.17 depict product cross-section for FH and FD species, respectively. It is interesting to note that the ICS profiles exhibit good accord with earlier theoretical studies based on QM centrifugal sudden (CS),172 time independent quantum mechanical (TIQM),173,174 and time dependent quantum mechanical (TDQM)[175 ] approaches. Such calculations involve several variants of FH2 _2 2 PES, including the M5,[176 ] 6SEC,[177 ] SW,[178 ] and HSW[179 ] PESs. In case of F + D2 _2 2 reaction, the ICS profiles[180 , 181 ] [140, 172] originated from various (ground) adiabatic PESs[176 , 177 , 178 , 179 ] exhibit some agreement with crossed-beam experimental measurements[182 ] over the limited range of collision energy (0.03-0.08 eV). On the contrary, experimentally measured rate constants[183 ] [9, 11] over the temperature range (200-400 K) as depicted in Figure 7.21 show substantial difference from the calculated rate constants originated from adiabatic PESs. Furthermore, rate constants involving SO coupling (excluding the effect of non-adiabaticity) also show substantial deviation from the experimentally measured ones (see Figure 7.21 ). Such differences mainly arise from absence of nonadiabatic couplings in the underlying Hamiltonian, which motivates for the calculation of reaction attributes using multi-sheeted diabatic Hamiltonian.21
Figure 7.16. Total integral cross-sections for F+H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) reaction are plotted as functions of collision energy in comparison with previous theoretical calculations obtained from different dynamical approaches and various potential energy surfaces. The figures are adapted from Ref. 171 with permission of ACS.
Figure 7.17. Total integral cross-sections for F + D 2 D_2 D 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) reaction are plotted as function of collision energy in comparison with previous theoretical calculations and experimental measurements. The figures are taken from Ref. 171 with permission of ACS.
Figure 7.21. Temperature dependent rate constant for the product formation (F + H2 _2 2 (v v v = 0; j j j = 0) → HF+H) reaction on the ground state (1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ) of diabatic calculation without (— — — —) and with (— · — · —) the inclusion of SO coupling in comparison with our previous adiabatic calculation 17 (— · — · —) along with existing experimental findings: Wurzberg et al. 9 (— — — —), Anderson et al. 11 (— — — —), Bedjanian [183 ] (— — — —); and theoretical results: Aquilanti et al. 14 (— · — · —), TIQM by Fu et al. 16 (— — — —) and Chen et al. 15 (— · — · —). Adapted with permission of ACS from Ref. 18.
The wave packet is initialized on the ground electronic state [1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ] and then, quantum dynamics are carried out on global diabatic PES matrix, which includes the contributions of ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs, nonadiabatic and SO couplings for F+H2 _2 2 system. Such dynamical calculations lead to various kinds of reaction attributes leading to cross-sections and rate constants of the product (HF) formation as well as the non-reactive excitation process as defined below18:
Reactive process [Ground state (1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ )]:
Without SO coupling: F(2 P ^{2}P 2 P )+H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) [$1^{2}A'] ] ] \rightarrowH F ( HF ( H F ( v';j') + H )+H ) + H [1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ]
With SO coupling: F(2 P 3 / 2 ^{2}P_{3/2} 2 P 3/2 )+H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) [$1^{2}A'] ] ] \rightarrowH F ( HF ( H F ( v';j') + H )+H ) + H [1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ].
Non-reactive excitation process [Excited state (1 2 A ′ ′ 1^{2}A'' 1 2 A ′′ )]:
Without SO coupling: F(2 P ^{2}P 2 P )+H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) [1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ] → \rightarrow → F(2 P ^{2}P 2 P )+H2 _2 2 (v ′ ; j ′ v';j' v ′ ; j ′ ) [1 2 A ′ ′ 1^{2}A'' 1 2 A ′′ ]
With SO coupling: F(2 P 3 / 2 ^{2}P_{3/2} 2 P 3/2 )+H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) [1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ] → \rightarrow → F*(2 P 1 / 2 ^{2}P_{1/2} 2 P 1/2 )+H2 _2 2 (v ′ ; j ′ v';j' v ′ ; j ′ ) [1 2 A ′ ′ 1^{2}A'' 1 2 A ′′ ]
Figure 7.18 depicts calculated ICSs as function of collision energy for the product (HF) formation of the reactive process with and without the inclusion of SO couplings. On the other hand, ICSs for the non-reactive excitation process are shown in Figure 7.19 . For all cases, employed diabatic surfaces matrices include nonadiabatic couplings.18 The ICS profiles show good agreement with other theoretical results at intermediate as well as higher ranges of collision energies.173,174 Once the calculated ICSs with and without the inclusion of SO coupling are in hand, those are employed to calculate temperature dependent rate constants. At higher domain of temperature (~400K - 600K), calculated rate constants without SO coupling exhibit close agreement with the experimentally recorded values of Bedjanian et al. 13 (see Figure 7.20 ). On the other hand, while including SO coupling in diabatic Hamiltonian, the ICS profiles demonstrate better agreement at the lower temperature regime (~200K - 300K), in comparison with recent experimental result13 as presented in Figure 7.21 .18 Table 7.1 presents the mean and RMS deviation of theoretically calculated rate constants in comparison with the experimental data.
Table 7.1. The table summarizes mean (root mean square) relative deviation of theoretically computed rate constants from experimentally recorded ones (Bedjanian[183 ] and Wurzberg et al.9). While calculating such deviation from experiment, the exact temperature range of the available theoretical rate constants is only taken into account (see Figure 7.21 ). The table is taken from Ref. 18 with permission of ACS.
Figure 7.19. Total integral cross section for the excited state non-reactive species [F+H2 _2 2 [1 2 A ′ ′ ^1 2A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ ] (without SO) and F*+H2 _2 2 [1 2 A ′ ′ ^1 2A^{\prime\prime} 1 2 A ′′ ] (with SO)] are presented as function of collision energy with and without the involvement of SO coupling. The figure is adapted from Ref. 18 with permission of ACS.
Figure 7.20. Temperature dependent rate constant for the product formation (F + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → \to → HF+H) reaction on the ground state (12 A ′ {}^{12}A' 12 A ′ ) are portrayed, where diabatic calculation is carried out without and with the inclusion of SO coupling. The profiles are compared with our previous adiabatic calculation17 along with existing experimental findings: Wurzberg et al. 9, Heidner et al. 10, Bedjanian[183 ] . The figure is taken from Ref. 18 with permission of ACS.
Table 7.1 : The table summarizes mean (root mean square) relative deviation of theoretically computed rate constants from experimentally recorded ones (Bedjanian[183 ] and Wurzberg et al.9). While calculating such deviation from experiment, the exact temperature range of the available theoretical rate constants is only taken into account (see Figure 7.21 ). The table is taken from Ref. 18 with permission of ACS.
Figure 7.18. Total integral cross-sections for the product formation (F + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → \to → HF+H) reaction are presented on the ground state (12 A ′ {}^{12}A' 12 A ′ ) of BBO based diabatic calculation as function of collision energy for without (black dash-dot) and with (red dash-dot) the incorporation of SO coupling in comparison with our previous adiabatic calculation17 (light blue dashed) as well as other theoretical results: TIQM by Aoiz et. al. 174 on SW PES[178 ] (green dotted with squares) and HSW PES[179 ] (red dotted); TIQM by Castillo et. al. 173 on SW PES (magenta dashed with squares) and HSW PES (orange dashed with triangles); TDQM by Billing et al. [175 ] (green dashed with squares); QM CS calculation by Baer and co-workers [184 ] on SW PES[178 ] (blue dashed); TIQM by Alexander et. al. 130 (dark green dashed); TDWP by Zhang et al. [185 ] (purple dash-dot). The figure is taken from Ref. 18 with permission of ACS.
H+ ^+ + /D+ ^+ + /H + H2 _2 2 /H2 + _2^+ 2 + reaction
Adhikari and coworkers performed multi-state quantum reactive scattering calculations over ab initio BBO-theory-based diabatic PES matrix 24 for the collision process, D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) system with the aid of fully close coupled (FCC) TDWP approach. 31 While initiating dynamical calculation from the ground electronic state (1 1 A ′ 1\,{}^1A^{\prime} 1 1 A ′ ) with roto-vibrational state, { v = 0 ; j = 0 } \{v = 0; j = 0\} { v = 0 ; j = 0 } , the following competing reaction processes, namely, reactive non-charge transfer (RNCT), non-reactive charge transfer (NRCT) and reactive charge transfer (RCT) are studied, which are as follows. 31
D + + H 2 ( v = 0 ; j = 0 ) ⟶ D H ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H + (391) D^+ + H_2\ (v = 0; j = 0) \longrightarrow DH(v';j') + H^+ \tag*{(391)} D + + H 2 ( v = 0 ; j = 0 ) ⟶ D H ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H + (391)
⟶ H 2 + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + D (392) \longrightarrow H_2^+(v';j') + D \tag*{(392)} ⟶ H 2 + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + D (392)
⟶ D H + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H (393) \longrightarrow DH^+(v';j') + H \tag*{(393)} ⟶ D H + ( v ′ ; j ′ ) + H (393)
Figure 7.22 depicts theoretically calculated ICS profiles for the RNCT, RCT and NRCT processes over the collision energy range, 1.7-2.5 eV and the outcomes are compared with earlier theoretical results [187 , 188 , 189 , 190 ] [116] as well as with available (RNCT and RCT) experimentally measured data [191 ] . Over the entire collision energy range (1.7-2.5 eV), the ICS profiles exhibit decreasing and increasing trend for RNCT (see Figure 7.22a) and RCT (see Figure 7.22b) processes, respectively, which are computed from the dynamical calculation on the BBO based diabatic Hamiltonian matrices 24. Those profiles show very good agreement with the experimental curves [191 ] in comparison with other theoretically calculated ones [188 , 189 ] [31, 116]. On the other hand, ICS profile for NRCT process shows similarity with that of RCT, which shows increasing trend with the collisional energy. In both cases (RCT and NRCT), the profiles possess threshold collision energies (E c o l ≈ 1.8 E_{\mathrm{col}} \approx1.8 E col ≈ 1.8 eV) affirming the accessibility of the first excited state through the CI (and the corresponding NACT) with the ground electronic state. The distinct differences between the ICS profiles for the RCT
process originated from the BBO constructed diabatic Hamiltonian24 and other quasi-diabatic Hamiltonians[192 ] [153] are governed by semi-empirical or ab initio way of incorporation of nonadiabatic effects while generating multi-state Hamiltonians.
On the contrary, while initiating the collision process from the first excited electronic state, 2 1 A ′ 2^{1}A^{\prime} 2 1 A ′ of H 3 + \mathrm{H}_{3}^{+} H 3 + species, with asymptotic roto-vibrational level of H 2 + \mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H 2 + (v = 0 v=0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j=0 j = 0 ), reaction attributes for the charge transfer processes from the first excited state [H 2 + \mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H 2 + (2 Σ g + ^{2}\Sigma_{g}^{+} 2 Σ g + )] to the ground [H 2 \mathrm{H}_{2} H 2 (1 Σ g + ^{1}\Sigma_{g}^{+} 1 Σ g + )] are calculated involving the nonadiabatic couplings among the electronic states (1 1 A ′ 1^{1}A^{\prime} 1 1 A ′ , 2 1 A ′ 2^{1}A^{\prime} 2 1 A ′ and 3 1 A ′ 3^{1}A^{\prime} 3 1 A ′ ), where the competing charge transfer processes are as follows:
(i) Reactive charge transfer (RCT): H ( 1 ) + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) + → ( H ( 2 ) / ( 3 ) ) + + ( H ( 1 ) H ( 3 ) / ( 2 ) ) \mathrm{H}^{(1)} + (\mathrm{H}^{(2)}\mathrm{H}^{(3)})^{+} \rightarrow(\mathrm{H}^{(2)/(3)})^{+} + (\mathrm{H}^{(1)}\mathrm{H}^{(3)/(2)}) H ( 1 ) + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) + → ( H ( 2 ) / ( 3 ) ) + + ( H ( 1 ) H ( 3 ) / ( 2 ) ) ;
(ii) Non-reactive charge transfer (NRCT): H ( 1 ) + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) + → ( H ( 1 ) ) + + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) \mathrm{H}^{(1)} + (\mathrm{H}^{(2)}\mathrm{H}^{(3)})^{+} \rightarrow(\mathrm{H}^{(1)})^{+} + (\mathrm{H}^{(2)}\mathrm{H}^{(3)}) H ( 1 ) + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) + → ( H ( 1 ) ) + + ( H ( 2 ) H ( 3 ) ) .
Figure 7.23 depicts the variation of theoretically calculated ICSs for the charge transfer processes in comparison with other theoretical outcomes[193 ] as function of total energy. Once the ICSs are in hand, those are employed to compute the temperature dependent rate constant, where the values are presented in Table 7.2 . The average rate constant over the range of temperature (250-1000 K) exhibits reasonable agreement with the available experimental data[194 ] . When the excited state species [H 2 + \mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H 2 + (2 Σ g + ^{2}\Sigma_{g}^{+} 2 Σ g + )] relaxes and come down to ground state [H 2 \mathrm{H}_{2} H 2 (1 Σ g + ^{1}\Sigma_{g}^{+} 1 Σ g + )], calculated cross-section for NRCT process shows substantial incorporation of nonadiabatic effects.32 On the other hand, Figure 7.24 shows enhanced cross-section for the intermediate vibrational states (v ′ = 3 v^{\prime}=3 v ′ = 3 -4). The effective overlap of electronic-vibrational-rotational eigenvalues between v ′ = 3 v^{\prime}=3 v ′ = 3 , 4 levels of the ground electronic state of H 2 \mathrm{H}_{2} H 2 and those of the H 2 + \mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H 2 + species (v ′ = 0 v^{\prime}=0 v ′ = 0 ) is mainly responsible for such enhancement, which is demonstrated as function of R R R in Figure 7.25 .
Table 7.2. Rate constants calculated from theoretical study32 are summarized in the temperature range 250K - 1000K. Data are taken from Ref. 32 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.23. Total integral cross-section of the RCT and NRCT process associated with H + H₂⁺ (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) reaction are depicted. The figure is adapted from Ref. 32 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.24. Figure 7.24: State-to-state integral cross-section for v ′ = 0 v' = 0 v ′ = 0 , 3 3 3 , 4 4 4 and 5 5 5 (a)-(d) are plotted as function of final rotational states (j ′ j' j ′ ) for the NRCT process of H + H2 + _2^+ 2 + (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) reaction. The figure clearly demonstrates the enhancement in cross-section for v ′ = 3 v' =3 v ′ = 3 and 4 4 4 . The figures are taken from Ref. 32 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.25. The diagram shows curves depicting the electronic-vibrational-rotational eigenvalue as function of the distance (R R R ) of the third atom from the centre of mass of the diatom, computed using adiabatic PESs. The dashed-dotted lines represent eigenstates of H 2 + H_2^+ H 2 + (2 Σ g + {}^{2}\Sigma_g^+ 2 Σ g + ) while the dashed lines signify H 2 H_2 H 2 (1 Σ g + {}^{1}\Sigma_g^+ 1 Σ g + ) eigenstates. The figures are adapted from Ref. 32 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.22. Total integral cross-section for (a) RNCT; (b) RCT and (c) NRCT processes of D⁺ + H₂ reaction is displayed as a function of collision energy. 31 The figure is taken from Ref. 135 with the permission of RSC.
He + H₂⁺ reaction
The FCC-3D-TDQM wavepacket calculations 102 are performed to explore the proton-transfer reaction, He + H₂⁺ (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → HeH⁺ + H using ab initio calculated ground adiabatic and two-state BBO based diabatic PES matrix for HeH⁺ system[195 ] over the total energy range, 0.94 ≤ E t o t ≤ 1.4 0.94 \le E_{\mathrm{tot}} \le1.4 0.94 ≤ E tot ≤ 1.4 eV. When the total reaction probabilities are computed for various total angular momentum (J J J ) on the adiabatic and diabatic PES(s), the cross-sections are evaluated for both the cases (adiabatic and diabatic) over the converged range of total energy. Figure 7.26 demonstrates that the calculated ICSs on the adiabatic PES is slightly lower than that obtained from the diabatic one around the threshold energies (0.94 ≤ E t o t ≤ 1.05 0.94 \le E_{\mathrm{tot}} \le1.05 0.94 ≤ E tot ≤ 1.05 eV), but for E t o t ≥ 1.1 E_{\mathrm{tot}} \ge1.1 E tot ≥ 1.1 eV onwards, adiabatic cross-section acquires higher values compared to the diabatic case as well as the experimental ones[196 ] [34, 35, 36, 45, 58]. In the total energy range, 1.1-1.4 eV, diabatic calculation based cross-section profile aligns more closely with experimental observations[196 ] [34, 35, 36, 45, 58] in comparison with the corresponding adiabatic results. In other words, contribution of nonadiabatic couplings among the electronic states is significant for construction of diabatic Hamiltonian vis-á-vis reaction dynamics.
Figure 7.26. Total integral cross-section for the He+H₂⁺ (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 , j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → HeH⁺ + H reaction is plotted as function of total energy obtained from the ground electronic adiabatic PES (purple solid line) as well as the 2-state diabatic PESs (black solid line) compared with the available experimental results: (red dashed line) Chupka and Russell (Expt.), 34,35 (red square) Turner et al. (Expt.)[196 ] , (blue downward triangle) Achtenhagen et al. (Expt.)58, (green pentagon) Tang et al. (Expt.)36. The figure is adapted from Ref. 60 and permission is taken from AIP.
H + D₂/H₂ reaction
3D-TDWP quantum dynamics is carried out on the ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs as well as the constructed multi-state diabatic PES matrix to compute the state-resolved reaction probabilities at $J = 0 for the H + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → \rightarrow → H2 _2 2 (v ′ = 0 v' = 0 v ′ = 0 ; j ′ = 0 j' = 0 j ′ = 0 ) + H reaction over the total energy range, 0.6 ≤ E t o t ≤ 4.5 0.6 \le E_{\mathrm{tot}} \le4.5 0.6 ≤ E tot ≤ 4.5 eV. Those probabilities originated from adiabatic and diabatic PESs matrices are compared with earlier theoretical results [197 ] in Figure 7.27 and Figure 7.28 , respectively. The observed differences between the two sets of calculations (adiabatic and diabatic) are mainly governed by the explicit incorporation of nonadiabatic effects in the diabatic Hamiltonian over adiabatic one apart from accuracy of the newly calculated adiabatic and constructed diabatic PESs. Once the reaction probabilities are calculated from adiabatic calculations, state-resolved integral cross-sections are evaluated for H + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → \rightarrow → H2 _2 2 (v ′ = 1 v' = 1 v ′ = 1 ; j ′ = 5 j' = 5 j ′ = 5 ) + H reaction with the aid of FCC-TDWP approach, where the probabilities are fully converged at J = 50 J = 50 J = 50 over the energy range, 0.34 ≤ E c o l ≤ 1.1 0.34 \le E_{\mathrm{col}} \le1.1 0.34 ≤ E col ≤ 1.1 eV. Figure 7.29 shows the presently calculated ICS profiles in comparison with other theoretical result [198 ] for different collision energy upto 1.1 eV exhibiting good accord with each other. On the other hand, the role of nonadiabatic coupling in the reaction, H + D2 _2 2 (v = 0 v = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 j = 0 j = 0 ) → \rightarrow → HD (v ′ ; j ′ v'; j' v ′ ; j ′ ) + D at relatively higher collision energies (0.4 0.4 0.4 eV ≤ E c o l ≤ 3.26 \le E_{\mathrm{col}} \le3.26 ≤ E col ≤ 3.26 eV) is ongoing on the BBO based diabatic Hamiltonian 81. The evaluated cross-section and rate constants will be compared with the existing theoretical predictions 78,82 and available experimental findings 77,78.
Figure 7.27. Ro-vibrationally resolved reaction probabilities at J = 0 J = 0 J = 0 are plotted, which are obtained through adiabatic PES: (a) present; (b) Bouakline et al. (see bottom right panel of FIG. 2 in Ref. [197 ] ). The vertical dotted line signifies the minimum energy of the 12-D3 h _{3h} 3 h CI. The figures are adapted from Ref. 81 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.28. Ro-vibrationally resolved reaction probabilities at J = 0 J = 0 J = 0 are presented, which are originated from diabatic PESs: (a) present; (b) Bouakline et al. (see top left panel of FIG. 4 in Ref. [197 ] ). The vertical dotted line symbolizes the minimum energy of the 12 - D 3 h 12\text{-}\mathrm{D}_{3h} 12 - D 3 h CI. The figures are taken from Ref. 81 with the permission of ACS.
Figure 7.29. Ro-vibrationally resolved integral cross-sections obtained by adiabatic calculations are compared with other theoretical result of Launay et al. [198 ] . Figure is adapted from Ref. 81 with permission from ACS.
Conclusion
In the last few decades, reaction attributes (cross-sections and rate constants) of triatomic chemical reactions are computed including electron-nuclear couplings among the low-lying electronic states, where the CIs are analyzed and diabatic Hamiltonian is constructed by BBO treatment. Once the BBO based diabatic PESs and couplings are in hand, reactive scattering theory is implemented for quantum dynamics calculations.
The presence of CIs between two electronic states can be explored by closed contour integration for different triatomic reactive species. For FH2 _2 2 system, one can locate the presence of a JT CI between the ground state (1 2 A ′ 1^{2}A' 1 2 A ′ ) and the first excited state (2 2 A ′ 2^{2}A' 2 2 A ′ ), together with additional RT CIs/seams between 2 2 A ′ 2^{2}A' 2 2 A ′ and 1 2 A ′ ′ 1^{2}A'' 1 2 A ′′ states using in-plane and out-of-plane contours. 21 On the other hand, H3 + _3^+ 3 + system exhibits a semi-circular accidental CI seam propagating through the C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v geometry between the 1 1 A ′ 1^{1}A' 1 1 A ′ and 2 1 A ′ 2^{1}A' 2 1 A ′ states, whereas the symmetry driven CI can be observed between the 2 1 A ′ 2^{1}A' 2 1 A ′ -3 1 A ′ 3^{1}A' 3 1 A ′ states at D 3 h D_{3h} D 3 h geometries. 24,150 In a similar
way, HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + system shows CIs between the ground (1 2 A ′ 1^2A' 1 2 A ′ ) and first excited (2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ ) electronic states at C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v geometries and also between the first (2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ ) and second (3 2 A ′ 3^2A' 3 2 A ′ ) as well as second (3 2 A ′ 3^2A' 3 2 A ′ ) and third (4 2 A ′ 4^2A' 4 2 A ′ ) excited electronic states at linear geometries.59 On the other hand, H3 _3 3 exhibits both the symmetry driven and accidental CIs/seam between the 1 2 A ′ 1^2A' 1 2 A ′ and 2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ states as well as the accidental C 2 v C_{2v} C 2 v CI seam between the 2 2 A ′ 2^2A' 2 2 A ′ -3 2 A ′ 3^2A' 3 2 A ′ states.81
Once the ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs and NACTs are in hand, ADT equations are solved and the resulting (ADT) angles are employed in the orthogonal transformation to construct the diabatic Hamiltonian. In other words, employing Eqs. (356) , 9.25, (198) , (199) as well as Appendix B.1, ADT angles are computed and thereafter, multi-state diabatic Hamiltonians are generated for the representative triatomic systems such as FH2 _2 2 21, H2 + _2^+ 2 + 24, HeH2 + _2^+ 2 + 59 and H3 _3 3 81. It is worth mentioning that the construction of diabatic PESs21,24,59,81 as well as reactive scattering calculations18,31,32,60,102 are performed in hyperspherical coordinates[199 ] , where all the channels (reactive and non-reactive) are being taken even-handedly leading to the reduction of the computational cost for electronic structure as well as scattering calculation.
Once the multi-state diabatic Hamiltonians are obtained, fully close coupled 3D-TDWP quantum-dynamics calculations are carried out to investigate the triatomic reactions, F + H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 , D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 , H + H2 + _2^+ 2 + , He + H2 + _2^+ 2 + , and H + H2 _2 2 /D2 _2 2 , which capture the influence of NACTs on reaction probabilities, cross-sections and rate constants. For the F + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) reaction, the computed rate constants on diabatic PESs including both nonadiabatic and SO couplings18,21 show good accord with experiment13 across the temperature range (200K - 600K).18 On the other hand, in case of D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) collision, ICSs (RNCT and RCT processes) originated from the multi-state diabatic Hamiltonian exhibit excellent agreement with experimental findings[191 ] over the entire collision energy range (1.7-2.5 eV) in comparison to other theoretical ones[187 , 188 , 189 , 190 ] [116]. Such findings emphasizes the crucial role of accurately including NACTs in the diabatic Hamiltonian.31 While initiating the charge transfer reaction for the H + H2 + _2^+ 2 + (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) system from the first excited electronic state (2 1 A ′ 2^1A' 2 1 A ′ ), the calculated ICSs32 for the competing RCT and NRCT processes match well with other theoretical results[193 ] . Moreover, the rate constant averaged over the temperature range (250 K-1000 K) shows excellent correspondence with the experimental outcomes[194 ] . For the He + H2 + _2^+ 2 + (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) reaction, calculated cross-section obtained from two-state diabatic Hamiltonian59 follow the experimental trend34,35 much better over the energy range, 0.9 - 1.4 eV compared to other theoretical calculations as well as with the results appeared from the same ground adiabatic surface. Since the nonadiabaticity increase the endothermicity of the product channel, the agreement with the experiment appear very close with each other. For H + H2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) → \rightarrow → H2 _2 2 (v ′ ; j ′ v'; j' v ′ ; j ′ ) + H reaction, the recent ab initio constructed single-state adiabatic and multi-state diabatic PES matrix are used to perform scattering calculations at J = 0 J = 0 J = 0 for evaluating state-resolved reaction probabilities over the total energy range, 0.6 - 4.5 eV. Such findings show substantial difference from the earlier work[197 ] due to the explicit involvement of nonadiabatic couplings. The state-resolved cross-sections obtained from single state adiabatic PES are presented with other existing theoretical calculation[198 ] , where the ICS profiles are in good agreement with each other. At present, the investigation of H + D2 _2 2 (v = 0 ; j = 0 v = 0; j = 0 v = 0 ; j = 0 ) → \rightarrow → HD (v ′ ; j ′ v'; j' v ′ ; j ′ ) + D reaction is ongoing over the collision energy range, 0.4 - 3.0 eV with the same diabatic Hamiltonian81 to compute ICSs as well as rate constant. In future, such results will be used for comparison with the available theoretical and experimental data74,77,78.
In summary, workability of BBO based ab initio constructed diabatic PES matrix followed by quantum dynamics and the underlying role of nonadiabatic coupling are successfully explored for triatomic reactive systems such as F + H2 _2 2 , D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 , He + H2 + _2^+ 2 + and H + D2 _2 2 . Such theoretical unveils how nonadiabatic effects (for some cases, SO couplings) reshape the ICS profiles exhibiting much closer agreement with experimental data.
Bibliography
Classical Trajectory Theory for Multi-Surface Systems
Along with the quantum dynamics, semi-classical trajectory surface hopping (TSH) dynamics were introduced and developed parallely, specifically to monitor the triatomic, tetratomic and gas-surface chemical reactions. The TSH approach was first introduced by Tully and Preston 1, which is based on the semiclassical dynamics of Bjerre and Nikitin on Na + N 2 N_2 N 2 2 reaction involving transition probabilities computed by Landau-Zener treatment. On the other hand, a wide variety of theoretical developments were carried out in the arena of TSH approach. 3–12 It is worth mentioning that the TSH formalism was primarily developed for the nonadiabatic dynamics of coupled states within the same spin multiplicity as well as different multiplicities exhibiting prominent spin-orbit effects. 13–16 In order to analyze laser-catalyzed reactions and laser-induced dissociations, the TSH approach was extended for the dressed electronic states by an electric field, whereas such field-induced TSH approach was implemented to a variety of systems. 17–21 Adhikari and coworkers 22 implemented Tully’s fewest switch algorithm to perform TSH dynamics on D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 and H + H2 + _2^+ 2 + reactions using the ab initio (MRCI) calculated adiabatic PESs and NACTs 23 of H3 + _3^+ 3 + for the first time. It is necessary to mention that the energy conservation of such formalism was guaranteed with the aid of kinetic energy adjustment algorithm of Thiel et al. 24 Furthermore, a new set of equations were introduced to analyze the momentum conservation during the hopping process. 22 The TSH based cross-sections for reactive non-charge transfer (RNCT) agree quite well with quantum mechanical results 25,26 and experimental measurements 27,28, but substantial deviation can be observed for the excited state cross-sections, namely, reactive charge transfer (RCT) and non-reactive charge transfer (NRCT) processes. Later on, a different approach of semi-classical dynamics 29 were proposed, where quantum mechanical NACTs were explicitly employed as equivalent to friction in classical mechanics. In order to explore the validity of such newly developed theory, the (D+ ^+ + , H2 _2 2 ) collision dynamics were investigated over the ground and first excited PESs of H3 + _3^+ 3 + system, 23 which demonstrated slowing down of the particles with the formation of the triatomic species, DH2 + _2^+ 2 + , as well as other products (RNCT, RCT and NRCT). 29 Even though three different forms of friction terms (classical, semi-classical and quantum friction) were explored in these calculations, the results of quantum friction show satisfactory accord with the outcome of full quantum dynamics 25 and experimental findings 27.
Trajectory Surface Hopping Approach
In this section, theoretical background of TSH approach 1,12 as well as energy 24 and momentum 22 conservation of the trajectories along with their implementation 22 on D+ ^+ + + H2 _2 2 and H + H2 + _2^+ 2 + reactions are presented. Furthermore, the outcome of TSH calculations are compared with the results of Fully Closed Coupled (FCC) 3D wavepacket based quantum results 25,26 and experimental findings 27.
Initialization of Positions and Momenta
In case of the triatomic reactive system, D+ ^{+} + + H2 _2 2 or H + H+ ^{+} + , the initial positions and momenta are determined as prescribed by Porter et al. 30 for a rotating Morse oscillator. While initializing the trajectories, two sets of coordinates and their associated momenta are required for the diatom (H2 _2 2 or H+ ^{+} + ) and the triatomic species (D+ ^{+} + + H2 _2 2 or H + H+ ^{+} + ). The diatom (H2 _2 2 or H+ ^{+} + ) of length r r r can be treated as a rotating Morse oscillator leading to the first set of initial parameters (r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y and p z p_z p z ). In a similar way, the third atom (D+ ^{+} + or H) and the center of mass of diatom form another rotating Morse oscillator of length R R R with another set of coordinates and momenta (R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y , R z R_z R z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z ). The brief outline of the initialization is depicted in the following paragraphs, where the formalism is thoroughly discussed elsewhere.22,30
While initializing the position and momentum of the diatom with specific roto-vibrational states and the incoming atom with particular kinetic energy, angular representation of the coordinates and momenta of the triatomic species can be conveniently used as random distribution in the configuration space (CS) with a constant total energy of the triatomic species. Therefore, a canonical transformation is needed to obtain another set of positions and momenta (Q k r Q_k^r Q k r , P k r P_k^r P k r , k = 1 , 2 , 3 k = 1,2,3 k = 1 , 2 , 3 ) [P k r P_k^r P k r s are constants of motion], which can be used to redefine the polar coordinates of the diatom (r r r , Θ \Theta Θ , Φ \Phi Φ ) and their associated momenta (p r p_r p r , p Θ p_\Theta p Θ , p Φ p_\Phi p Φ ). P k r P_k^r P k r s are invariant with time and therefore, time-dependence in the old coordinates (r r r , Θ \Theta Θ , Φ \Phi Φ , p r p_r p r , p Θ p_\Theta p Θ , p Φ p_\Phi p Φ ) appears only through the canonically transformed Q k r ( t ) Q_k^r(t) Q k r ( t ) (Q k r Q_k^r Q k r , P k r → r P_k^r \rightarrow r P k r → r , Θ \Theta Θ , Φ \Phi Φ , p r p_r p r , p Θ p_\Theta p Θ , p Φ p_\Phi p Φ ). The polar coordinates (r r r , Θ \Theta Θ and Φ \Phi Φ ) and their momenta (p r p_r p r , p Θ p_\Theta p Θ and p Φ p_\Phi p Φ ) are transformed into the corresponding Cartesian analogues [r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y and p z p_z p z ] through the following matrix equations:22,30
( r x r y r z ) = r ( − sin q 2 r sin Q 3 r + λ cos q 2 r cos Q 3 r sin q 2 r cos Q 3 r + λ cos q 2 r sin Q 3 r 1 − λ 2 cos q 2 r ) (394) \begin{pmatrix}
r_x\\
r_y\\
r_z
\end{pmatrix}
=
r
\begin{pmatrix}
-\sin q_2^r\sin Q_3^r+\lambda\cos q_2^r\cos Q_3^r\\
\sin q_2^r\cos Q_3^r+\lambda\cos q_2^r\sin Q_3^r\\
\sqrt{1-\lambda^2\cos q_2^r} \tag*{(394)}
\end{pmatrix} r x r y r z = r − sin q 2 r sin Q 3 r + λ cos q 2 r cos Q 3 r sin q 2 r cos Q 3 r + λ cos q 2 r sin Q 3 r 1 − λ 2 cos q 2 r (394)
\begin{pmatrix}
p_x\\
p_y\\
p_z
\end{pmatrix}
=
p_r
\begin{pmatrix}
-\sin q_2^r\sin Q_3^r+\lambda\cos q_2^r\cos Q_3^r\\
\sin q_2^r\cos Q_3^r+\lambda\cos q_2^r\sin Q_3^r\\
\sqrt{1-\lambda^2\cos q_2^r}
\end{pmatrix}
+
\frac{L}{r}
\begin{pmatrix}
-\cos q_2^r\sin Q_3^r-\lambda\sin q_2^r\cos Q_3^r\\
\cos q_2^r\cos Q_3^r-\lambda\sin q_2^r\sin Q_3^r\\
-\sqrt{1-\lambda^2}\sin q_2^r
\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(395)}\end{pmatrix}
where q 2 r = Q 2 r + L Δ L q_2^r = Q_2^r + L\Delta_L q 2 r = Q 2 r + L Δ L (L L L signifies the angular momentum of the diatom) and λ = P 3 r / P 2 r \lambda= P_3^r/P_2^r λ = P 3 r / P 2 r . Similar formalism is equally applicable for the other set of coordinates (R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y , R z R_z R z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z ). In order to assign the initial values of the twelve quantities ({r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y , p z p_z p z } and {R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y , R z R_z R z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z }), random numbers are used.
The Miller’s approach as discussed above is utilized to compute the initial values of coordinates (r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y and R z R_z R z ) and momenta (p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y , p z p_z p z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y and P z P_z P z ) while executing classical trajectory based calculations. It is evident from Eqs. 8.1 and 8.2 that the initial parameters (r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y and p z p_z p z ) depend on one radial coordinate (r r r ) and two angular coordinates (q 2 r q_2^r q 2 r and Q 3 r Q_3^r Q 3 r ). The radial coordinate r r r and the associated momentum (p r p_r p r ) are functions of another angular coordinate (Q 1 r Q_1^r Q 1 r ).22,30 Furthermore, λ \lambda λ and 1 − λ 2 \sqrt{1-\lambda^2} 1 − λ 2 can be expressed as cos θ a r b r \cos\theta_{arb}^r cos θ a r b r and sin θ a r b r \sin\theta_{arb}^r sin θ a r b r , where θ a r b r \theta_{arb}^r θ a r b r symbolizes an arbitrary angle. Overall, one has to choose four random numbers (O 1 O_1 O 1 , O 2 O_2 O 2 , O 3 O_3 O 3 and O 4 O_4 O 4 ) between zero (0) and 2 π 2\pi 2 π for those angles (Q 1 r Q_1^r Q 1 r , q 2 r q_2^r q 2 r , Q 3 r Q_3^r Q 3 r and θ a r b r \theta_{arb}^r θ a r b r ) to propose a set of initial values for the diatomic variables (r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y and p z p_z p z ). While initializing the second group of coordinates and momenta (R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y , R z R_z R z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z ), another set of three random numbers (O 5 O_5 O 5 , O 6 O_6 O 6 and O 7 O_7 O 7 ) are employed for the corresponding angular coordinates, q 2 R q_2^R q 2 R , Q 3 R Q_3^R Q 3 R and θ a r b R \theta_{arb}^R θ a r b R . Since the trajectory needs to be started from the asymptote, a large value (~5 Å) can be assigned for the R R R coordinate instead of using any random number (Q 1 R Q_1^R Q 1 R ). The expression of the associated momenta, P R P_R P R takes the following form:
P R = 2 E K E μ t r i , (396) P_R = \sqrt{2E_{KE}\mu_{tri}}, \tag*{(396)} P R = 2 E K E μ t r i , (396)
where μ t r i \mu_{tri} μ t r i represents triatomic center of mass and E K E E_{KE} E K E signifies the kinetic energy of the incoming atom.
Trajectory Surface Hopping between Electronic States
Once the value of initial coordinates (r x r_x r x , r y r_y r y , r z r_z r z , R x R_x R x , R y R_y R y , R z R_z R z ) and the associated momenta (p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y , p z p_z p z , P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z ) are in hand, those are converted to the corresponding Johnson’s hyperspherical coordinates31 to perform TSH dynamics. The classical Hamilton’s equations [ q ˙ ( t ) = p ( t ) μ and p ˙ ( t ) = − d u d q ( t ) ] \left[\dot{q}(t)=\frac{p(t)}{\mu}\text{ and }\dot{p}(t)=-\frac{du}{dq(t)}\right] [ q ˙ ( t ) = μ p ( t ) and p ˙ ( t ) = − d q ( t ) d u ] for triatomic Hamiltonian in terms of those coordinates (ρ \rho ρ , θ \theta θ , ϕ \phi ϕ , α \alpha α , β \beta β and γ \gamma γ ) and momenta (P ρ P_\rho P ρ , P θ P_\theta P θ , P ϕ P_\phi P ϕ , P α P_\alpha P α , P β P_\beta P β and P γ P_\gamma P γ ) can be written as:31
ρ ˙ = P ρ μ t (397) \dot{\rho}=\frac{P_\rho}{\mu_t} \tag*{(397)} ρ ˙ = μ t P ρ (397)
θ ˙ = 4 P θ μ t ρ 2 (398) \dot{\theta}=\frac{4P_\theta}{\mu_t\rho^2} \tag*{(398)} θ ˙ = μ t ρ 2 4 P θ (398)
ϕ ˙ = 4 [ P ϕ − 1 2 P γ cos θ ] μ t ρ 2 sin 2 θ (399) \dot{\phi}=\frac{4\left[P_\phi-\frac{1}{2}P_\gamma\cos\theta\right]}{\mu_t\rho^2\sin^2\theta} \tag*{(399)} ϕ ˙ = μ t ρ 2 sin 2 θ 4 [ P ϕ − 2 1 P γ cos θ ] (399)
α ˙ = 2 P α ( 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ ) ) μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ (400) \dot{\alpha}=\frac{2P_\alpha(1+\sin\theta\cos(2\gamma))}{\mu_t\rho^2\cos^2\theta} \tag*{(400)} α ˙ = μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ 2 P α ( 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ )) (400)
β ˙ = cos − 1 ( P γ J ) (401) \dot{\beta}=\cos^{-1}\left(\frac{P_\gamma}{J}\right) \tag*{(401)} β ˙ = cos − 1 ( J P γ ) (401)
γ ˙ = P γ − 2 P ϕ cos θ μ t ρ 2 sin 2 θ − ( 2 P γ ( 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ ) ) μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ ) (402) \dot{\gamma}=\frac{P_\gamma-2P_\phi\cos\theta}{\mu_t\rho^2\sin^2\theta}-\left(\frac{2P_\gamma(1+\sin\theta\cos(2\gamma))}{\mu_t\rho^2\cos^2\theta}\right) \tag*{(402)} γ ˙ = μ t ρ 2 sin 2 θ P γ − 2 P ϕ cos θ − ( μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ 2 P γ ( 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ )) ) (402)
P ˙ ρ = 2 ρ ( H − P ρ 2 2 μ t − u I ) − ∂ u I ∂ ρ I = 1 , 2 , 3 (403) \dot{P}_\rho=\frac{2}{\rho}\left(H-\frac{P_\rho^2}{2\mu_t}-u_I\right)-\frac{\partial u_I}{\partial\rho}\qquad I=1,2,3 \tag*{(403)} P ˙ ρ = ρ 2 ( H − 2 μ t P ρ 2 − u I ) − ∂ ρ ∂ u I I = 1 , 2 , 3 (403)
P ˙ θ = cos θ μ t ρ 2 sin 3 θ ( 4 P ϕ 2 + P γ 2 − 4 P ϕ P γ cos θ ) − 2 P γ P ϕ μ t ρ 2 sin θ − [ 2 ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) sin θ μ t ρ 2 cos 3 θ [ 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ ) ] + ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) μ t ρ 2 cos θ cos ( 2 γ ) ] − ∂ u I ∂ θ (404) \dot{P}_\theta=\frac{\cos\theta}{\mu_t\rho^2\sin^3\theta}\left(4P_\phi^2+P_\gamma^2-4P_\phi P_\gamma\cos\theta\right)-\frac{2P_\gamma P_\phi}{\mu_t\rho^2\sin\theta}
-\left[\frac{2(P_\alpha^2-P_\gamma^2)\sin\theta}{\mu_t\rho^2\cos^3\theta}\left[1+\sin\theta\cos(2\gamma)\right]+\frac{(P_\alpha^2-P_\gamma^2)}{\mu_t\rho^2\cos\theta}\cos(2\gamma)\right]-\frac{\partial u_I}{\partial\theta} \tag*{(404)} P ˙ θ = μ t ρ 2 sin 3 θ cos θ ( 4 P ϕ 2 + P γ 2 − 4 P ϕ P γ cos θ ) − μ t ρ 2 sin θ 2 P γ P ϕ − [ μ t ρ 2 cos 3 θ 2 ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) sin θ [ 1 + sin θ cos ( 2 γ ) ] + μ t ρ 2 cos θ ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) cos ( 2 γ ) ] − ∂ θ ∂ u I (404)
P ˙ ϕ = − ∂ u I ∂ ϕ (405) \dot{P}_\phi=-\frac{\partial u_I}{\partial\phi} \tag*{(405)} P ˙ ϕ = − ∂ ϕ ∂ u I (405)
P ˙ α = 0 (406) \dot{P}_\alpha=0 \tag*{(406)} P ˙ α = 0 (406)
P ˙ β = 0 (407) \dot{P}_\beta=0 \tag*{(407)} P ˙ β = 0 (407)
P ˙ γ = 2 ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) sin θ sin ( 2 γ ) μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ (408) \dot{P}_\gamma=\frac{2(P_\alpha^2-P_\gamma^2)\sin\theta\sin(2\gamma)}{\mu_t\rho^2\cos^2\theta} \tag*{(408)} P ˙ γ = μ t ρ 2 cos 2 θ 2 ( P α 2 − P γ 2 ) sin θ sin ( 2 γ ) (408)
where μ t \mu_t μ t represents the triatomic reduced mass.
Furthermore, while computing adiabatic population on various electronic states (m m m , n ∈ o n\in o n ∈ o ), the following time-dependent Liouville equation12 of density matrix (s s s ) is used:
i ℏ s ˙ m n = ∑ o [ s o n ( U m o − i ℏ C τ m o ) − s m o ( U o n − i ℏ C τ o n ) ] , (409) i\hbar\dot{s}_{mn}=\sum_o\left[s_{on}(U_{mo}-i\hbar\mathbf{C}\boldsymbol{\tau}_{mo})-s_{mo}(U_{on}-i\hbar\mathbf{C}\boldsymbol{\tau}_{on})\right], \tag*{(409)} i ℏ s ˙ mn = o ∑ [ s o n ( U m o − i ℏ C τ m o ) − s m o ( U o n − i ℏ C τ o n ) ] , (409)
where C C C collectively signifies the hyperspherical coordinates (ρ \rho ρ , θ \theta θ and ϕ \phi ϕ ), τ m o \tau_{mo} τ m o or τ o n \tau_{on} τ o n present the NACM elements and U m o ( = ⟨ m ∣ H ^ e ∣ o ⟩ ) U_{mo}(=\langle m|\hat{H}_e|o\rangle) U m o ( = ⟨ m ∣ H ^ e ∣ o ⟩) or U o n ( = ⟨ o ∣ H ^ e ∣ n ⟩ ) U_{on}(=\langle o|\hat{H}_e|n\rangle) U o n ( = ⟨ o ∣ H ^ e ∣ n ⟩) signify the adiabatic PESs matrix elements, which are non-zero only for diagonal cases (m = o m=o m = o or o = n o=n o = n ). In order to perform TSH dynamics, ab initio calculated adiabatic PESs and NACTs are plugged into the above equation (Eq. (409) ) and then, it is numerically integrated to calculate the density matrix (s m n s_{mn} s mn ) as function of time. The resulting density matrix elements are further employed to evaluate the switching probability (S m n S_{mn} S mn ) for transitions from initial (n n n ) to final (m m m ) state with the aid of the following empirical equation:12
S m n = − 2 Re ( s m n ∗ C ˙ m n ) Δ t s n n (410) S_{mn}=-\frac{2\operatorname{Re}(s_{mn}^{*}\dot{C}_{mn})\Delta t}{s_{nn}} \tag*{(410)} S mn = − s nn 2 Re ( s mn ∗ C ˙ mn ) Δ t (410)
If the calculated probability, S m n S_{mn} S mn at any time step appears as negative, it is considered to be zero (0). On the other hand, since the maximum probability cannot exceed one (1), a random number ζ \zeta ζ between zero (0) and one (1) is necessary to be invoked to dictate the hopping between any two electronic states. According to Eq. (410) , the magnitude of switching probability becomes high at the close neighbourhood of degenerate point(s)/seam(s) due to singular features of NACTs indicating highly probable transition between any two electronic states. If the condition S m n > ζ S_{mn}>\zeta S mn > ζ is satisfied for two adjacent surfaces (as for example, 1 → 2 1\to2 1 → 2 , 2 → 1 2\to1 2 → 1 , 2 → 3 2\to3 2 → 3 , ...), hopping takes place from the initial (n n n ) to final (m m m ) state.4 On the other hand, transition between non-adjacent surfaces (1 → 3 1\to3 1 → 3 or 3 → 1 3\to1 3 → 1 ) occurs if the relation S 12 < ζ < S 12 + S 13 S_{12}<\zeta<S_{12}+S_{13} S 12 < ζ < S 12 + S 13 or S 32 < ζ < S 32 + S 31 S_{32}<\zeta<S_{32}+S_{31} S 32 < ζ < S 32 + S 31 fulfills for those states. In this perspective, it is necessary to mention that direct switching between ground and second excited states (1 → 3 1\to3 1 → 3 or 3 → 1 3\to1 3 → 1 ) is highly improbable for the titled reactions (D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^{+}+\mathrm{H}_{2} D + + H 2 and H + H 2 + \mathrm{H}+\mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H + H 2 + ) due to large energy spacing between those surfaces.
Conservation of Energy by Momentum Adjustment in Trajectory Surface Hopping
In the TSH calculation, once switching occurs between two electronic states (n n n to m m m ), readjusted diatomic (p \mathbf{p} p ) and triatomic (P \mathbf{P} P ) momenta for the m t h m^{\mathrm{th}} m th electronic state can be written in the following form:12,24
p m = p n − ω n m τ n m r P m = P n − ω n m τ n m R , ω n m is an adjustment factor (411) \mathbf{p}_{m}=\mathbf{p}_{n}-\omega_{nm}\boldsymbol{\tau}^{r}_{nm}\qquad\mathbf{P}_{m}=\mathbf{P}_{n}-\omega_{nm}\boldsymbol{\tau}^{R}_{nm},\quad\omega_{nm}\text{ is an adjustment factor} \tag*{(411)} p m = p n − ω nm τ nm r P m = P n − ω nm τ nm R , ω nm is an adjustment factor (411)
where the above equations appear to be true for every components of p \mathbf{p} p (p x p_x p x , p y p_y p y , p z p_z p z ) or P \mathbf{P} P (P x P_x P x , P y P_y P y , P z P_z P z ). Since the gain/loss in potential energy (Δ U = u m − u n \Delta U=u_m-u_n Δ U = u m − u n ) is balanced by the loss/gain in kinetic energy (Δ E K E = ω n m 2 a n m − ω n m b n m \Delta E_{KE}=\omega_{nm}^{2}a_{nm}-\omega_{nm}b_{nm} Δ E K E = ω nm 2 a nm − ω nm b nm ) preserving the conservation of total energy, the following equation can be written:
Δ E K E + Δ U = ω n m 2 a n m − ω n m b n m + ( u m − u n ) = 0 , (412) \Delta E_{KE}+\Delta U=\omega_{nm}^{2}a_{nm}-\omega_{nm}b_{nm}+(u_m-u_n)=0, \tag*{(412)} Δ E K E + Δ U = ω nm 2 a nm − ω nm b nm + ( u m − u n ) = 0 , (412)
where a n m = 1 2 [ ∣ τ n m r ∣ 2 μ d i + ∣ τ n m R ∣ 2 μ t r i ] a_{nm}=\frac{1}{2}\left[\frac{|\boldsymbol{\tau}^{r}_{nm}|^{2}}{\mu_{di}}+\frac{|\boldsymbol{\tau}^{R}_{nm}|^{2}}{\mu_{tri}}\right] a nm = 2 1 [ μ d i ∣ τ nm r ∣ 2 + μ t r i ∣ τ nm R ∣ 2 ] (μ d i \mu_{di} μ d i and μ t r i \mu_{tri} μ t r i represent diatomic reduced mass and triatomic center of mass, respectively) and b n m = v d i ⋅ τ n m r + v t r i ⋅ τ n m R b_{nm}=\mathbf{v}_{di}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{r}_{nm}+\mathbf{v}_{tri}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}^{R}_{nm} b nm = v d i ⋅ τ nm r + v t r i ⋅ τ nm R (v d i \mathbf{v}_{di} v d i and v t r i \mathbf{v}_{tri} v t r i signify diatomic and triatomic velocities, respectively for the initial state). The solution of Eq. (412) takes the following form:
ω n m = 1 2 a n m [ b n m ± b n m 2 + 4 a n m ( u n − u m ) ] , (413) \omega_{nm}=\frac{1}{2a_{nm}}\left[b_{nm}\pm\sqrt{b_{nm}^{2}+4a_{nm}(u_n-u_m)}\right], \tag*{(413)} ω nm = 2 a nm 1 [ b nm ± b nm 2 + 4 a nm ( u n − u m ) ] , (413)
where positive and negative signs are applicable for b n m < 0 b_{nm}<0 b nm < 0 and b n m ≥ 0 b_{nm}\geq0 b nm ≥ 0 , respectively. For negative values of b n m 2 + 4 a n m ( u n − u m ) b_{nm}^{2}+4a_{nm}(u_n-u_m) b nm 2 + 4 a nm ( u n − u m ) , no real solution exists due to insufficient kinetic energy of the system (before hopping) to compensate the potential energy change due to the transition and therefore, the hopping is rejected. Once switching of the nuclei occurs from initial to final electronic state, the trajectory starts to evolve on the new surface and this procedure is repeated until the hyperradius, ρ \rho ρ reaches a predefined threshold value when the triatomic system leading to non-reactive or reactive processes including charge-transfer.
Conservation of Linear Momenta on the Process of Hopping soumyahopp
In order to ensure the conservation of total energy during hopping, the momenta readjustment formalism by Thiel et al.24 is employed as per the previous subsection, where the components of diatomic and triatomic momenta (p \mathbf{p} p and P \mathbf{P} P ) are redefined from initial (n n n ) to final (m m m ) electronic state. Since the components of p \mathbf{p} p and P \mathbf{P} P are different in different electronic states to preserve the energy conservation for n t h n^{\mathrm{th}} n th and m t h m^{\mathrm{th}} m th electronic states, the conservation of linear momenta between the two sets of quantities, ${p_{x,n},p_{y,n},p_{z,n}, P x , n P_{x,n} P x , n , P y , n P_{y,n} P y , n and P z , n P_{z,n} P z , n } and {p x , m p_{x,m} p x , m , p y , m p_{y,m} p y , m , p z , m p_{z,m} p z , m , P x , m P_{x,m} P x , m , P y , m P_{y,m} P y , m and P z , m P_{z,m} P z , m } can be achieved by employing a scaling factor. On the process of hopping, the diatomic and triatomic kinetic energies are scaled as E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣ E_{di} \pm\lvert\Delta E_{di}\rvert E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣ and E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣ E_{tri} \pm\lvert\Delta E_{tri}\rvert E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣ , respectively, where
Δ E d i = ∣ τ n m r ∣ 2 ω n m 2 2 μ d i − ω n m v d i ⋅ τ n m r , (from Eq. xref‘Eq. 8.8‘) (414) \Delta E_{di} = \frac{\lvert\boldsymbol{\tau}_{nm}^{r}\rvert^{2}\omega_{nm}^{2}}{2\mu_{di}}-\omega_{nm}\mathbf{v}_{di}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_{nm}^{r},
\qquad\text{(from Eq. {xref}`Eq. 8.8`)} \tag*{(414)} Δ E d i = 2 μ d i ∣ τ nm r ∣ 2 ω nm 2 − ω nm v d i ⋅ τ nm r , (from Eq. xref ‘Eq. 8.8‘) (414)
Δ E t r i = ∣ τ n m R ∣ 2 ω n m 2 2 μ t r i − ω n m v t r i ⋅ τ n m R , (from Eq. xref‘Eq. 8.8‘) (415) \Delta E_{tri} = \frac{\lvert\boldsymbol{\tau}_{nm}^{R}\rvert^{2}\omega_{nm}^{2}}{2\mu_{tri}}-\omega_{nm}\mathbf{v}_{tri}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_{nm}^{R},
\qquad\text{(from Eq. {xref}`Eq. 8.8`)} \tag*{(415)} Δ E t r i = 2 μ t r i ∣ τ nm R ∣ 2 ω nm 2 − ω nm v t r i ⋅ τ nm R , (from Eq. xref ‘Eq. 8.8‘) (415)
and total change in kinetic energy during hopping appears as Δ E K E ( = ω n m 2 a n m − ω n m b n m \Delta E_{KE}(=\omega_{nm}^{2}a_{nm}-\omega_{nm}b_{nm} Δ E K E ( = ω nm 2 a nm − ω nm b nm , see Eq. (412) ). On the other hand, the associated magnitude of momenta become 2 ( E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣ ) μ d i \sqrt{\frac{2(E_{di}\pm\lvert\Delta E_{di}\rvert)}{\mu_{di}}} μ d i 2 ( E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣) and 2 ( E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣ ) μ t r i \sqrt{\frac{2(E_{tri}\pm\lvert\Delta E_{tri}\rvert)}{\mu_{tri}}} μ t r i 2 ( E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣) and prior to hopping, components of scaled initial momenta attend the following expressions:
p i , n s = p i , n ∣ p n ∣ 2 ( E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣ ) μ d i = p i , n 1 ± ( Δ p ∣ p n ∣ ) 2 i = x , y , z (416) p_{i,n}^{s}=\frac{p_{i,n}}{\lvert\mathbf{p}_{n}\rvert}\sqrt{\frac{2(E_{di}\pm\lvert\Delta E_{di}\rvert)}{\mu_{di}}}=p_{i,n}\sqrt{1\pm\left(\frac{\Delta p}{\lvert\mathbf{p}_{n}\rvert}\right)^{2}}
\qquad i=x,y,z \tag*{(416)} p i , n s = ∣ p n ∣ p i , n μ d i 2 ( E d i ± ∣ Δ E d i ∣) = p i , n 1 ± ( ∣ p n ∣ Δ p ) 2 i = x , y , z (416)
P i , n s = P i , n ∣ P n ∣ 2 ( E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣ ) μ t r i = P i , n 1 ± ( Δ P ∣ P n ∣ ) 2 i = x , y , z , (417) P_{i,n}^{s}=\frac{P_{i,n}}{\lvert\mathbf{P}_{n}\rvert}\sqrt{\frac{2(E_{tri}\pm\lvert\Delta E_{tri}\rvert)}{\mu_{tri}}}=P_{i,n}\sqrt{1\pm\left(\frac{\Delta P}{\lvert\mathbf{P}_{n}\rvert}\right)^{2}}
\qquad i=x,y,z, \tag*{(417)} P i , n s = ∣ P n ∣ P i , n μ t r i 2 ( E t r i ± ∣ Δ E t r i ∣) = P i , n 1 ± ( ∣ P n ∣ Δ P ) 2 i = x , y , z , (417)
where positive and negative signs are employed for transition to lower and upper states, respectively. The above scaling factors result into new magnitude of the initial momenta (p x , n s p_{x,n}^{s} p x , n s , p y , n s p_{y,n}^{s} p y , n s , p z , n s p_{z,n}^{s} p z , n s , P x , n s P_{x,n}^{s} P x , n s , P y , n s P_{y,n}^{s} P y , n s and P z , n s P_{z,n}^{s} P z , n s ), which can be compared with the final ones (p x , m p_{x,m} p x , m , p y , m p_{y,m} p y , m , p z , m p_{z,m} p z , m , P x , m P_{x,m} P x , m , P y , m P_{y,m} P y , m and P z , m P_{z,m} P z , m ) to explore the conservation of linear momenta. In order to show the deviation between scaled initial momenta and final momenta, the root mean square deviation of the initial (scaled) and final momenta is computed at the time of hopping for each collision/total energy:
χ p , i = ∑ i i = 1 N h o p ( p i , m , i i − p i , n , i i s ) 2 N h o p i = x , y , z (418) \chi_{p,i}=\sqrt{\frac{\sum_{ii=1}^{N_{hop}}(p_{i,m,ii}-p_{i,n,ii}^{s})^{2}}{N_{hop}}}
\qquad i=x,y,z \tag*{(418)} χ p , i = N h o p ∑ ii = 1 N h o p ( p i , m , ii − p i , n , ii s ) 2 i = x , y , z (418)
χ P , i = ∑ i i = 1 N h o p ( P i , m , i i − P i , n , i i s ) 2 N h o p i = x , y , z , (419) \chi_{P,i}=\sqrt{\frac{\sum_{ii=1}^{N_{hop}}(P_{i,m,ii}-P_{i,n,ii}^{s})^{2}}{N_{hop}}}
\qquad i=x,y,z, \tag*{(419)} χ P , i = N h o p ∑ ii = 1 N h o p ( P i , m , ii − P i , n , ii s ) 2 i = x , y , z , (419)
where χ p , i \chi_{p,i} χ p , i and χ P , i \chi_{P,i} χ P , i (i = x , y , z i=x,y,z i = x , y , z ) are root mean square deviations between before (scaled) and after hopp momenta, and N h o p N_{hop} N h o p signifies total number of hops for a set of trajectories. The above quantities (χ p , i \chi_{p,i} χ p , i and χ P , i \chi_{P,i} χ P , i , i = x , y , z i=x,y,z i = x , y , z ) are calculated for the D+ ^{+} + + H2 _2 2 and H + H2 + _2^{+} 2 + reactions22 and the outcomes are displayed for nine collision energies (1.7 eV - 2.5 eV) of D+ ^{+} + + H2 _2 2 and thirteen total energies (2.2 eV - 2.8 eV) of H + H2 + _2^{+} 2 + reactions in Table 8.1 and Table 8.2 , respectively. The magnitudes of all the six quantities (χ p , x \chi_{p,x} χ p , x , χ p , y \chi_{p,y} χ p , y , χ p , z \chi_{p,z} χ p , z , χ P , x \chi_{P,x} χ P , x , χ P , y \chi_{P,y} χ P , y and χ P , z \chi_{P,z} χ P , z ) depict the deviation of the order, 10 − 6 10^{-6} 1 0 − 6 or 10 − 7 10^{-7} 1 0 − 7 validating the conservation of linear momentum.
Table 8.1. Root mean square deviations of linear momenta in the collision energy range 1.7 eV to 2.5 eV for D + + H 2 \mathrm{D}^{+}+\mathrm{H}_{2} D + + H 2 reaction are presented.22 The results are adopted from Ref. [22].
Table 8.2. Root mean square deviations of linear momenta in the total energy range 2.2 eV to 2.8 eV for H + + H 2 + \mathrm{H}^{+}+\mathrm{H}_{2}^{+} H + + H 2 + reaction are tabulated.22 The results are adopted from Ref. [22].
TSH Calculation of Integral Cross-Sections and Rate Constant
Integral Cross-Sections (ICSs) at a particular collision energy along a specific channel (I C I_C I C ) of a reaction process can be computed by adding the reaction probabilities [ P v ′ j ′ ← v j J , I ( E c o l ) ] [P^{J,I}_{v'j'\leftarrow vj}(E_{col})] [ P v ′ j ′ ← v j J , I ( E co l )] of all final rovibrational states for all values of total angular momentum, J J J as follows:
σ I ( E c o l ) = π κ v j 2 ∑ j ′ = 0 j max ′ ∑ v ′ = 0 v max ′ ∑ J = 0 J max ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ ← v j J , I ( E c o l ) , (420) \sigma^{I}(E_{col})=\frac{\pi}{\kappa_{v j}^{2}}\sum_{j'=0}^{j'_{\max}}\sum_{v'=0}^{v'_{\max}}\sum_{J=0}^{J_{\max}}(2J+1)P^{J,I}_{v'j'\leftarrow vj}(E_{col}), \tag*{(420)} σ I ( E co l ) = κ v j 2 π j ′ = 0 ∑ j m a x ′ v ′ = 0 ∑ v m a x ′ J = 0 ∑ J m a x ( 2 J + 1 ) P v ′ j ′ ← v j J , I ( E co l ) , (420)
where E c o l E_{\mathrm{col}} E col indicates the collision energy and κ v ′ j ′ \kappa_{v'j'} κ v ′ j ′ represents the wave-vector, 2 μ t r i E c o l ℏ \sqrt{\frac{2\mu_{\mathrm{tri}}E_{\mathrm{col}}}{\hbar}} ℏ 2 μ tri E col (μ t r i \mu_{\mathrm{tri}} μ tri is triatomic center of mass). In order to achieve convergence in the ICS profiles of TSH methodology, it is necessary to perform dynamical calculations over a large number of trajectories on the adiabatic PESs. In “semi-classical” limit, total angular momentum quantum number, J J J can be approximated to the orbital angular momentum quantum number, l v ′ , j ′ l_{v',j'} l v ′ , j ′ , (J ∼ l v ′ , j ′ J \sim l_{v',j'} J ∼ l v ′ , j ′ ).32 The following expression can be employed for orbital angular momentum quantum number:32
l v ′ , j ′ = l max O v ′ , j ′ = ( b max μ t r i v 0 ℏ − 1 2 ) O v ′ , j ′ (421) l_{v',j'}=l_{\max}O_{v',j'}=\left(\frac{b_{\max}\mu_{\mathrm{tri}}v_0}{\hbar}-\frac{1}{2}\right)O_{v',j'} \tag*{(421)} l v ′ , j ′ = l m a x O v ′ , j ′ = ( ℏ b m a x μ tri v 0 − 2 1 ) O v ′ , j ′ (421)
where b max b_{\max} b m a x , μ t r i \mu_{\mathrm{tri}} μ tri and v 0 v_0 v 0 represent maximum impact parameter, triatomic center of mass and initial relative velocity, respectively. A specific random number, O v ′ , j ′ O_{v',j'} O v ′ , j ′ (ranges from 0 to 1) is invoked for a particular trajectory leading to a product or reactant at ro-vibrational state ( v ′ , j ′ ) (v',j') ( v ′ , j ′ ) indicating the dependence of l v ′ , j ′ l_{v',j'} l v ′ , j ′ on the final ro-vibrational state.
On the other hand, reactant/product formation probabilities can be written as ( l v ′ , j ′ + 1 ) 2 1 / N T (l_{v',j'}+1)^2 1/N_T ( l v ′ , j ′ + 1 ) 2 1/ N T (N T N_T N T represents total number of trajectories leading to charge or non-charge transfer reactants/products) in “semi-classical” limit, where the rovibrationally resolved [ σ v ′ , j ′ ( E c o l ) ] [\sigma_{v',j'}(E_{\mathrm{col}})] [ σ v ′ , j ′ ( E col )] , rotationally summed vibrationally resolved