betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Bifurcation analysis of particulate Rayleigh-Benard convection

Abstract

Particles carried through a convecting fluid layer exchange momentum and heat with the fluid, and so change not only where convection starts but also how it saturates. We study this coupling in the particulate Rayleigh-Benard system, in which a dilute stream of thermally inertial particles is injected at one wall and removed at the other. An Eulerian two-fluid model retaining drag, pressure-gradient, added-mass, and buoyancy forces and interphase heat exchange describes heavy particles and bubbles through a single density parameter beta. After reproducing the linear stability results of Raza et al. (2025a), we use a multiple-scale expansion and a Fredholm solvability condition to compute the first Landau coefficient a1 near onset. At low and moderate particle loading, the bifurcation is supercritical for every density ratio considered, extending the conclusion of Srinivas and Tomar (2025) for very heavy particles. At higher flux, however, Re(a1) changes sign, and the onset becomes subcritical over a broad band of density ratios, from moderately heavy particles injected below their terminal speed to most light particles. In the plane of density ratio and injection velocity, this band is bounded by lines of tricritical points. Splitting a1 by the balance equation shows that its sign is set almost entirely by the fluid energy equation, while the direct nonlinear terms of the particle equations are five to six orders of magnitude smaller. The particles thus change the nature of the bifurcation indirectly, through the base state and the linear mode they help to shape, rather than through their own nonlinear dynamics.

Introduction

A horizontal layer of fluid heated from below is perhaps the most studied example of a hydrodynamic instability. Since the work of Lord Rayleigh [13] it has been known that the quiescent conducting state loses stability once the Rayleigh number exceeds a critical value, which for two rigid, isothermal walls is Rac≈1708Ra_c \approx1708 (Chandrasekhar [8]). What happens just beyond this threshold was settled by the weakly nonlinear theories of Malkus & Veronis [14], Stuart [26], Watson [27] and Schlüter et al. [22]. In the Boussinesq limit the bifurcation to two-dimensional rolls is a supercritical pitchfork: the amplitude of convection grows continuously from zero as the square root of the distance from onset, and nothing is observed below RacRa_c. This picture is robust, but it is not universal. Effects that break the up–down symmetry of the layer, such as the temperature dependence of the fluid properties, introduce quadratic interactions that can make the onset of hexagonal convection subcritical [6]. Reviews of the pattern-forming and turbulent regimes are given by Bodenschatz et al. [5] and Ahlers et al. [1].

In many settings the convecting fluid is not pure. Water droplets and ice crystals in clouds, ash in volcanic plumes, sediment in lakes and estuaries, bubbles in boiling and electrolytic cells, and the solid particles used as heat carriers in solar receivers all move through a thermally stratified fluid while exchanging momentum and heat with it. The dispersed phase can modify the flow appreciably even at small volume fractions [4]. For thermal convection, this has been studied mostly by simulation. Oresta & Prosperetti [16] considered settling, thermally coupled point particles in weakly turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection, Park et al. [17] separated the roles of momentum and thermal coupling, Lakkaraju et al. [12] examined how vapour bubbles change the heat transport, and Chen & Prosperetti [9] resolved the particles directly. These studies describe developed convection; they say little about how convection first appears.

The onset problem was posed in a clean form by Prakhar & Prosperetti [18]. In their particulate Rayleigh–Bénard (pRB) system, particles much denser than the fluid are injected uniformly through the upper wall at a prescribed velocity and temperature and leave through the lower wall, so that the base state is steady and horizontally uniform. Using a two-fluid model, they found that the particles always delay the onset of convection. Raza et al. [20] extended the model to particles of arbitrary density, including bubbles, by adding the pressure-gradient and added-mass forces of the Maxey–Riley equation [15, 3] through the density parameter β\beta commonly used for inertial particles and bubbles [7]. They showed that both heavy and light particles stabilise the layer. Raza et al. [19] then examined the role of the injection velocity. Injecting heavy particles below their terminal speed destabilises the system further, while slow injection of light particles destabilises it; for bubbles, the critical Rayleigh number can even become negative, meaning that the layer convects when heated from above. Thermal inertia of the particles adds a further stabilising effect [21].

Linear theory identifies the threshold but not the type of bifurcation, and the type matters. If the bifurcation is subcritical, finite-amplitude convection can be sustained below RacRa_c, the transition is hysteretic, and the linear threshold is no longer a reliable guide to when convection will be seen. In a previous study [25] we carried out a weakly nonlinear analysis of particle-laden convection for water droplets in air, a case in which the particles are about a thousand times denser than the fluid, so that drag and gravity are the only forces that matter. There the bifurcation was always supercritical. It is not obvious that this conclusion survives once the density contrast is reduced. For light particles the Archimedes force on the dispersed phase is no longer negligible; the pressure-gradient and added-mass forces enter the momentum balance, and the results of Raza et al. [19] show that particles alone can drive the instability. Each of these effects can feed into the nonlinear saturation of the convective mode, and there is no a priori reason why they should all act in the stabilising direction.

The aim of this paper is to determine the nature of the bifurcation in the pRB system over the full range of density ratios, from very heavy particles to bubbles, and to identify where the bifurcation changes from supercritical to subcritical. We use the two-fluid model of Raza et al. [20, 19] and extend the multiple-scale analysis of Srinivas & Tomar [25] to include the additional forces. The governing equations and the base state are presented in § 2 and § 3, where we also summarise the linear stability results that the weakly nonlinear theory builds on. The derivation of the cubic Landau equation is outlined in § 5, with the details collected in the appendices. The results are discussed in § 6, and the main conclusions are drawn in § 8.

Problem definition and the governing equations

∇⋅u=0,(1)\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u}=0, \tag*{(1)}
dtα=−α(∇⋅w),(2)d_t\alpha=-\alpha\left(\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{w}\right), \tag*{(2)}
Dtu=−1ρ∇p+ν∇2u+[1−βT(T−Tr)]g+α[Dtu−g+ρpρ(g−dtw)],(3)D_t\boldsymbol{u}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla p+\nu\nabla^2\boldsymbol{u}+\left[1-\beta_T\left(T-T_r\right)\right]\boldsymbol{g}+\alpha\left[D_t\boldsymbol{u}-\boldsymbol{g}+\frac{\rho_p}{\rho}\left(\boldsymbol{g}-d_t\boldsymbol{w}\right)\right], \tag*{(3)}
dtw=βDtu+u−wτp+(1−β)g,(4)d_t\boldsymbol{w}=\beta D_t\boldsymbol{u}+\frac{\boldsymbol{u}-\boldsymbol{w}}{\tau_p}+(1-\beta)\boldsymbol{g}, \tag*{(4)}
DtT=κ∇2T+α[DtT−ET−TpτT],(5)D_tT=\kappa\nabla^2T+\alpha\left[D_tT-E\frac{T-T_p}{\tau_T}\right], \tag*{(5)}
dtTp=T−TpτT,(6)d_tT_p=\frac{T-T_p}{\tau_T}, \tag*{(6)}

for all (x,t)∈{R×(−H/2,H/2)×(0,∞)}(\boldsymbol{x},t)\in\{\mathbb{R}\times(-H/2,H/2)\times(0,\infty)\} with position vector x=xe^x+ze^z\boldsymbol{x}=x\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_x+z\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z. Where u=uxe^x+uze^z\boldsymbol{u}=u_x\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_x+u_z\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z is the fluid velocity vector with uxu_x and uzu_z being the horizontal and vertical components. Similarly, the particulate velocity field is represented by w=wxe^x+wze^z\boldsymbol{w}=w_x\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_x+w_z\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z. The time scales τp=dp2/(12βν)\tau_p=d_p^2/(12\beta\nu) and τT=Edp2/(12κ)\tau_T=Ed_p^2/(12\kappa) represent the momentum and thermal relaxation time scales, with particle size dpd_p, kinematic viscosity ν\nu, thermal diffusion coefficient κ\kappa, density ratio parameter β\beta and heat capacity ratio EE. The time derivative operators Dt()=∂t()+u⋅∇()D_t()=\partial_t()+\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\nabla() and dt()=∂t()+w⋅∇()d_t()=\partial_t()+\boldsymbol{w}\cdot\nabla() are the material derivatives following the fluid and particle path lines, respectively. The gradient operator is defined as ∇()=e^x∂x()+e^z∂z()\nabla()=\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_x\partial_x()+\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z\partial_z().

Non-dimensional equations

The length is taken as the distance between the hot and cold surfaces HH, and the time scale is taken as the thermal diffusion time scale T=H2/κ\mathcal{T}=H^2/\kappa. The non-dimensional variables are defined in the following form:

(X,Z,T)=(xH,zH,tH2/κ),(U,W)=(uκ/H,wκ/H),(7)(X,Z,\mathcal{T})=\left(\frac{x}{H},\frac{z}{H},\frac{t}{H^2/\kappa}\right),\qquad(U,W)=\left(\frac{u}{\kappa/H},\frac{w}{\kappa/H}\right), \tag*{(7)}
P=pρ(κ2/H2)+GaPr2Z,(Θ,Θp)=(T−TrΔT,Tp−TrΔT).(8)P=\frac{p}{\rho(\kappa^2/H^2)}+GaPr^2Z,\qquad(\Theta,\Theta_p)=\left(\frac{T-T_r}{\Delta T},\frac{T_p-T_r}{\Delta T}\right). \tag*{(8)}

The resulting non-dimensional equations are given by

∇⋅U=0,(9)\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{U}=0, \tag*{(9)}
dTα=−α(∇⋅W),(10)d_{\mathcal{T}}\alpha=-\alpha(\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{W}), \tag*{(10)}
DTU=−∇P+Pr∇2U+RaPr Θ e^z+α2[(β−1)(DTU+GaPr2e^z)−12Pr(3−β)Φ−2(U−W)],(11)D_{\mathcal{T}}\boldsymbol{U}=-\nabla P+Pr\nabla^2\boldsymbol{U}+RaPr\,\Theta\,\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z+\frac{\alpha}{2}\left[(\beta-1)\left(D_{\mathcal{T}}\boldsymbol{U}+GaPr^2\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z\right)-12Pr(3-\beta)\Phi^{-2}(\boldsymbol{U}-\boldsymbol{W})\right], \tag*{(11)}
dTW=βDTU+12PrβΦ−2(U−W)−(1−β)GaPr2e^z,(12)d_{\mathcal{T}}\boldsymbol{W}=\beta D_{\mathcal{T}}\boldsymbol{U}+12Pr\beta\Phi^{-2}(\boldsymbol{U}-\boldsymbol{W})-(1-\beta)GaPr^2\hat{\boldsymbol{e}}_z, \tag*{(12)}
DTΘ=∇2Θ+α[DTΘ−12Φ−2(Θ−Θp)],(13)D_{\mathcal{T}}\Theta= \nabla^2\Theta+ \alpha\left[D_{\mathcal{T}}\Theta- 12\Phi^{-2}(\Theta-\Theta_p)\right], \tag*{(13)}
dTΘp=12E−1Φ−2(Θ−Θp)(14)d_{\mathcal{T}}\Theta_p = 12E^{-1}\Phi^{-2}(\Theta-\Theta_p) \tag*{(14)}

for all (X,T)∈{R×(−1/2, 1/2)×(0, ∞)}(X,\mathcal{T}) \in\{\mathbb{R}\times(-1/2,\,1/2)\times(0,\,\infty)\} with position vector X=Xe^x+Ze^zX=X\hat{\mathbf{e}}_x+Z\hat{\mathbf{e}}_z. The boundary conditions are given by

At Z=1/2: U=0 and Θ=0,At Z=−1/2: U=0 and Θ=1,At Z=Z∗: W=W∗=W∗e^z, Θp=Θp∗, and α=F/∣W∗∣,(15)\begin{aligned} &\text{At } Z=1/2:\ U=0\text{ and }\Theta=0,\\ &\text{At } Z=-1/2:\ U=0\text{ and }\Theta=1,\\ &\text{At } Z=Z^*:\ \mathbf{W}=\mathbf{W}^*=W^*\hat{\mathbf{e}}_z,\ \Theta_p=\Theta_p^*,\text{ and }\alpha=\mathcal{F}/\lvert W^*\rvert, \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

where Z∗Z^* is the vertical location of the particle injection. In the present work, we consider the injection of heavy (β<1\beta<1) particles at the top cold surface Z∗=1/2Z^*=1/2, whereas the lighter (β>1\beta>1) particles are injected at the bottom hot surface Z∗=−1/2Z^*=-1/2. Here, W∗W^* is the particle injection velocity, and it can be negative (positive) for heavy (lighter) particles. The particle injection flux is represented by F\mathcal{F}, which is always positive. The non-dimensional parameters are represented by

References

  1. [1]AHLERS, G., GROSSMANN, S. & LOHSE, D. 2009 Heat transfer and large scale dynamics in turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Reviews of Modern Physics 81 (2), 503–537.DOI
  2. [2]Aleria, A., Khan, A. & Bera, Premananda 2024 Finite amplitude analysis of poiseuille flow in fluid overlying porous domain. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics 84 (2), 433–463.DOI
  3. [3]Auton, T. R., Hunt, J. C. R. & Prud’homme, M. 1988 The force exerted on a body in inviscid unsteady non-uniform rotational flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 197, 241–257.DOI
  4. [4]Balachandar, S. & Eaton, J. K. 2010 Turbulent dispersed multiphase flow. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 42, 111–133.DOI
  5. [5]Bodenschatz, E., Pesch, W. & Ahlers, G. 2000 Recent developments in Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 32, 709–778.DOI
  6. [6]Busse, F. H. 1978 Non-linear properties of thermal convection. Reports on Progress in Physics 41 (12), 1929–1967.DOI
  7. [7]Calzavarini, E., Kerscher, M., Lohse, D. & Toschi, F. 2008 Dimensionality and morphology of particle and bubble clusters in turbulent flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 607, 13–24.DOI
  8. [8]Chandrasekhar, S. 1961 Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  9. [9]Chen, X. & Prosperetti, A. 2024 Particle-resolved multiphase Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Physical Review Fluids 9 (5), 054301.DOI
  10. [10]Drazin, Philip G & Reid, William Hill 2004 Hydrodynamic stability. Cambridge university press.
  11. [11]Khandelwal, Manish K & Bera, P 2015 Weakly nonlinear stability analysis of non-isothermal poiseuille flow in a vertical channel. Physics of Fluids 27 (6).DOI
  12. [12]Lakkaraju, R., Stevens, R. J. A. M., Oresta, P., Verzicco, R., Lohse, D. & Prosperetti, A. 2013 Heat transport in bubbling turbulent convection. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110 (23), 9237–9242.DOI
  13. [13]Lord Rayleigh 1916 On convection currents in a horizontal layer of fluid, when the higher temperature is on the under side. The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 32 (192), 529–546.DOI
  14. [14]Malkus, W. V. R. & Veronis, G. 1958 Finite amplitude cellular convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 4 (3), 225–260.DOI
  15. [15]Maxey, M. R. & Riley, J. J. 1983 Equation of motion for a small rigid sphere in a nonuniform flow. Physics of Fluids 26 (4), 883–889.DOI
  16. [16]Oresta, P. & Prosperetti, A. 2013 Effects of particle settling on Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Physical Review E 87 (6), 063014.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23848779
  17. [17]Park, H. J., O’Keefe, K. & Richter, D. H. 2018 Rayleigh–Bénard turbulence modified by two-way coupled inertial, nonisothermal particles. Physical Review Fluids 3 (3), 034307.DOI
  18. [18]Prakhar, S. & Prosperetti, A. 2021 Linear theory of particulate Rayleigh–Bénard instability. Physical Review Fluids 6 (8), 083901.DOI
  19. [19]Raza, Saad, Freitas, Rômulo B, Alves, Leonardo SB, Calzavarini, Enrico & Hirata, Silvia C 2025a Impact of particle injection velocity on the stability of the particulate rayleigh–bénard system. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1015, R2.DOI
  20. [20]Raza, S., Hirata, S. C. & Calzavarini, E. 2024 Stabilization of the Rayleigh–Bénard system by injection of thermal inertial particles and bubbles. arXiv preprint, arXiv: 2411.07891.DOI
  21. [21]Raza, S., Lemoine, A., Zhang, Y., Calzavarini, E., Freitas, R. B., Alves, L. S. de B. & Hirata, S. C. 2025b Particle thermal inertia delays the onset of convection in particulate Rayleigh–Bénard system. arXiv preprint, arXiv: 2511.02112.arxiv.org/abs/2511.02112
  22. [22]Schlüter, A., Lortz, D. & Busse, F. 1965 On the stability of steady finite amplitude convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 23 (1), 129–144.
  23. [23]Sharma, Abhishek K, Khandelwal, Manish K & Bera, P 2018 Finite amplitude analysis of non-isothermal parallel flow in a vertical channel filled with a highly permeable porous medium. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 857, 469–507.DOI
  24. [24]Shukla, Priyanka & Alam, Meheboob 2011 Weakly nonlinear theory of shear-banding instability in a granular plane couette flow: analytical solution, comparison with numerics and bifurcation. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 666, 204–253.DOI
  25. [25]Srinivas, Thota & Tomar, Gaurav 2025 Weakly nonlinear analysis of particle-laden rayleigh–bénard convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1025, A40.arxiv.org/abs/2503.15411
  26. [26]Stuart, John Trevor 1960 On the non-linear mechanics of wave disturbances in stable and unstable parallel flows part 1. the basic behaviour in plane poiseuille flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 9 (3), 353–370.DOI
  27. [27]Watson, J. 1960 On the non-linear mechanics of wave disturbances in stable and unstable parallel flows part 2. the development of a solution for plane poiseuille flow and for plane couette flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 9 (3), 371–389.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_xrgnbhds
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 3

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents