betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Effective operators for valence space calculations from the {\itshape ab initio} No-Core Shell Mode

Abstract

In recent years, remarkable progress has been achieved in developing novel non-perturbative techniques for constructing valence space shell model Hamiltonians from realistic internucleon interactions. One of these methods is based on the Okubo–Lee–Suzuki (OLS) unitary transformation applied to no-core shell model (NCSM) solutions. In the present work, we implement the corresponding approach to solve for valence space effective electromagnetic operators. To this end, we use the NCSM results for A=16−18A=16-18, obtained at Nmax=4N_{\rm max}=4, to derive a charge-dependent version of the effective interaction for the sdsd shell, which allows us to exactly reproduce selected NCSM spectra of 18^{18}O, 18^{18}F and 18^{18}Ne within the two valence nucleon space. We then deduce effective single-particle matrix elements of electric quadrupole (E2E2) and magnetic dipole (M1M1) operators by matching them to the electromagnetic transitions and moments for 17^{17}O and 17^{17}F from the NCSM at Nmax=4N_{\rm max}=4. Thus, effective E2E2 and M1M1 operators are obtained as sets of single-particle matrix elements for the valence space (sdsd shell) which allow us to reproduce the NCSM results for A=17A=17 exactly. Systematic comparison of a large set of sdsd shell results on quadrupole and magnetic dipole moments and transitions for A=18A=18 using effective E2E2 and M1M1 operators that we derive from the full NCSM calculations demonstrates a remarkable agreement.

####### Preamble

The authors wish to express their appreciation for the opportunity to participate in this honorary volume for Prof. Akito Arima. Indeed, Prof. Arima led many pioneering works in the microscopic theory of nuclear forces and effective interactions. Several of the authors had the great pleasure to discuss these fundamental physics topics with him and to receive his sage advice. With this contribution, we propose extensions to microscopic theory of valence interactions including electromagnetic effective operators that follow lines of thinking that can trace their origin to the fundamental works of Prof. Akito Arima.

####### Introduction

Outstanding progress in nuclear many-body computations and in construction of highly accurate realistic internucleon interactions during the last couple of decades has made it possible to describe light nuclei and intermediate-mass nuclei near closed shells from first principles.[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] Among all these ab initio approaches, the no-core shell model[1] (NCSM), being a full configuration-interaction type method, solves the eigenvalue problem by exact diagonalization of the Hamiltonian matrix constructed in a large-dimensional many-body harmonic-oscillator basis. The latest state-of-the-art computations, such as those made possible by the Many-fermion dynamics code for nuclei (MFDn),[8, 9, 10, 11, 12] are capable of providing converged or nearly-converged solutions for nuclei up to A∼18A\sim18, setting benchmarks for other nuclear structure models.[7, 13, 14] However, for heavier nuclei the eigenproblem has still to be solved in a more restricted model space, typically for a few valence nucleons occupying one or two harmonic oscillator shells beyond a closed-shell core. This approach with an assumed core of passive nucleons is known as a traditional interacting shell-model (see, e. g., Refs.[15, 16, 17]). Severe truncation of the model space requires construction of an appropriate effective Hamiltonian and effective electroweak operators. From the 1960’s, for more than fifty years, the many-body perturbation theory (see, e. g., Refs.[18, 19] and references therein) was the dominant approach to deal with the microscopic derivation of effective Hamiltonians. It was, however, noticed that when derived from two-nucleon interaction, an effective valence-space Hamiltonian could not compete in precision with empirically obtained effective Hamiltonians,[20, 21] mainly because of its deficient monopole part.[22] One of possible reasons was identified as the absence of three-nucleon forces.[23]

New non-perturbative techniques for deriving effective valence-space interactions have been developed during the last decade, such as similarity-renormalization group (SRG) inspired methods,[24] or application of Okubo–Lee–Suzuki (OLS) unitary transformation[25, 26, 27] to either a NCSM solution[28, 29, 30] or to a solution found within the coupled cluster theory.[31, 32] Recent inclusion of three-nucleon forces via different approaches[19, 24, 31, 33, 34, 35] seems to cure the deficiency of the monopole part of the effective interactions and brings encouraging improvement to the theoretical description.

Construction of appropriate effective electroweak operators to be used in a valence space has been another long-standing challenge. Since the earlier work by Arima and collaborators,[36, 37] the importance of accounting for the restricted model space has been realized. Many efforts were devoted to the construction of effective electromagnetic and Gamow–Teller operators both microscopically[38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43] or empirically by a fit of the optimum form of a corresponding operator to the data.[20, 44, 45, 46, 47]

In this work, we use the NCSM solutions for A=16A = 16–1818 nuclei in order to construct an effective interaction and effective E2E2 and M1M1 operators for the valence sdsd-shell model space. We construct here a charge-dependent version of the effective interaction presented earlier[30] based on the Daejeon16 nucleon-nucleon (NNNN) potential,[48] using 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} to derive neutron-neutron, neutron-proton and proton-proton two-body matrix elements (TBMEs). Effective E2E2 and M1M1 single-particle matrix elements are obtained by matching them to the corresponding NCSM results for 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F} obtained with basis spaces including all many-body excitation oscillator quanta up to Nmax⁡=4N_{\max} = 4. These constructed effective operators are tested on a large number of transitions and moments for A=18A = 18 nuclei.

####### Microscopic effective interaction from the NCSM

The derivation of valence-space effective interactions from the NCSM is described in detail in Refs.[29, 30] and references therein. We start with a translationally-invariant non-relativistic Hamiltonian for AA point-like nucleons, containing relative kinetic energies and NNNN interactions:

H=∑i<jA(p⃗i−p⃗j)22mA+∑i<jAVijNN.(1)H = \sum_{i<j}^{A} \frac{(\vec{p}_i-\vec{p}_j)^2}{2mA} + \sum_{i<j}^{A} V_{ij}^{NN}. \tag*{(1)}

Here mm is the nucleon mass (approximated here as the average of the neutron and proton mass), p⃗i\vec{p}_i are nucleonic momenta and VijNNV_{ij}^{NN} denotes the bare NNNN interaction. To our chosen Daejeon16 NNNN interactions we have added the two-body Coulomb interaction between the protons.

The eigenproblem for HH is solved by diagonalizing the Hamiltonian matrix, constructed in a many-body spherical harmonic-oscillator basis, using the MFDn code.[8, 9, 10, 11, 12] All nucleons are considered as active particles and are treated equally. The model space is defined by two parameters: (i) by a given oscillator quantum, ℏΩ\hbar\Omega, and (ii) by the maximum total many-body harmonic-oscillator excitation quanta, Nmax⁡N_{\max}. This means that we retain only many-body configurations satisfying the condition ∑i=1A(2ni+li)≤Nmin⁡+Nmax⁡\sum_{i=1}^{A}(2n_i+l_i) \leq N_{\min}+N_{\max}, where nin_i is the single-particle radial harmonic-oscillator quantum number, lil_i is the single-particle orbital angular momentum quantum number, while Nmin⁡N_{\min} is the minimal many-body oscillator quanta satisfying the Pauli principle for the chosen nucleus. The use of the harmonic-oscillator basis allows us to remove states with center-of-mass excitations by using the Lawson method.[49]

In the present study, we select ℏΩ=14\hbar\Omega= 14 MeV, which is close to the empirical value[50] in the vicinity of A=16A = 16, and which was also adopted in our previous work.[30]

In principle, one may apply the OLS transformation[25, 26, 27] to a “cluster” of nucleons to develop an effective interaction for the chosen NCSM space (the “PP-space”).[1] This is referred to as the cluster approximation. A compact presentation of the OLS method is presented in Ref.[51] The goal is to achieve an effective interaction at fixed cluster size (conventionally two-nucleon or three-nucleon) for which the NCSM calculations converge more rapidly with increasing PP-space than using the original (non-transformed) interaction.

In this work we adopt the Daejeon16 NNNN interaction[48] which is based on a chiral N3LO interaction[52, 53] and which has been softened already by an SRG transformation[54, 55] that improves convergence. Hence, following our procedure[30] we elect to use Daejeon16 directly, without an additional OLS transformation for our NCSM calculations.

For this work, we adopt the NCSM calculations at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 for the A=16A=16, 1717 and 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F}. In addition, to obtain a charge-dependent valence effective interaction for the first time, we perform new NCSM calculations at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 for 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O} and 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne}.

The resulting NCSM eigenvalues and eigenvectors are then employed to define a new effective interaction for the Nmax⁡=0N_{\max}=0 space (the “P′P'-space”) through the application of the OLS method. The NCSM results dominated by sdsd-shell configurations are appropriate for adoption to define the P′P'-space. That is, from the NCSM results for A=16A=16–1818 we apply the OLS method to obtain an effective valence space (sdsd-shell) Hamiltonian consisting of a core, a single-particle and a two-particle interaction.[29, 30] This effective interaction is guaranteed to reproduce the NCSM results for the 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} core and the states of A=17A=17 and 1818 selected to be included in the definition of the P′P'-space.

From the A=18A=18 NCSM results we select the number of eigenpairs (eigenvalues and eigenvectors) for each JJ governed by the number of needed two-body matrix elements. Let us label the total number of eigenpairs (adding up the dimensions for each JJ) as dnnd_{nn}, dppd_{pp} and dnpd_{np} for valence space configurations of 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} respectively. These are the states, selected from among the NCSM candidates, which have the largest valence space (0ℏΩ0\hbar\Omega in the present study) probability. It should be noted that these are not necessarily the states with the lowest NCSM eigenvalues. The exact dimensions are dnn=14d_{nn}=14 for 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, dpp=14d_{pp}=14 for 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne}, and dnp=28d_{np}=28 for 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F}, since it includes both T=0T=0 and T=1T=1 states.

The OLS transformation leads to a two-nucleon effective Hamiltonian defined in the Nmax⁡=0N_{\max}=0 model space by its TBMEs which in the angular momentum JJ and isospin TT coupled form read ⟨ab;JT∣Heff∣cd;JT⟩\langle ab;JT|H_{\mathrm{eff}}|cd;JT\rangle, where aa, bb, cc, dd denote a full set of single-particle spherical quantum numbers which label an orbital, e.g. a=(na,la,ja,tza)a=(n_a,l_a,j_a,t_{za}), with tzt_z distinguishing protons and neutrons.

To obtain the one-body neutron and proton contributions (single-particle energies, ϵ\epsilon), we subtract the ground-state energy of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} (core energy, EcoreE_{\mathrm{core}}) from 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F}, respectively. To get the TBMEs of the effective interaction in the valence space, we have to subtract this core energy and the one-body contributions from diagonal TBMEs of the OLS-derived effective valence space Hamiltonian HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}},

⟨ab;JT∣Veff∣ab;JT⟩=⟨ab;JT∣Heff∣ab;JT⟩−Ecore−(ϵa+ϵb),(2)\langle ab;JT|V_{\mathrm{eff}}|ab;JT\rangle= \langle ab;JT|H_{\mathrm{eff}}|ab;JT\rangle- E_{\mathrm{core}} - (\epsilon_a+\epsilon_b), \tag*{(2)}

while for non-diagonal TBMEs, we have

⟨ab;JT∣Veff∣cd;JT⟩=⟨ab;JT∣Heff∣cd;JT⟩.(3)\langle ab;JT|V_{\mathrm{eff}}|cd;JT\rangle= \langle ab;JT|H_{\mathrm{eff}}|cd;JT\rangle. \tag*{(3)}

In this way, from NCSM calculations for 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F}, we derive a set of neutron-neutron, proton-proton and proton-neutron TBMEs, respectively, to be used in the valence space shell-model calculations.

The resulting core energy, proton and neutron single-particles energies, as well as T=0,1T = 0, 1 proton-neutron TBMEs obtained from Daejeon16 have been published in an earlier study (see column “bare” of Table II and column “bare” of Table XI in Ref. 30), while the neutron-neutron and proton-proton TBMEs obtained specifically for this work. For the convenience of the reader, we present the whole set of TBMEs in Table 1 and Table 2. By construction, the sdsd-shell spectra of 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} obtained with the derived effective Hamiltonian exactly reproduce the results of the NCSM for the chosen P′P'-space eigenvalues. Comparison of the low-energy T=1T=1 states are shown in Figure 1 in comparison with experiment[56] and with the results from a phenomenological interaction USDB.[46] The latter produces identical T=1T=1 spectra for all three A=18A=18 isobars, because the USDB Hamiltonian is charge-independent, including the single-particle energies which are the same for protons and neutrons.

2ja2j_a2jb2j_b2jc2j_c2jd2j_dJJTTVnnV_{nn}VpnT=1V_{pn}^{T=1}VppV_{pp}
111101−2.018−1.989−1.536
113301−0.713−0.769−0.797
115501−1.446−1.422−1.344
333301−1.350−1.317−0.847
335501−2.377−2.500−2.582
555501−2.618−2.590−2.046
1313110.1370.1360.482
133511−0.151−0.151−0.152
3535110.0690.0620.441
131321−0.500−0.500−0.116
131521−1.519−1.498−1.438
133321−0.090−0.099−0.089
1335210.4590.4520.428
135521−1.183−1.164−1.120
151521−1.358−1.341−0.908
153321−0.854−0.853−0.828
1535210.3660.3600.336
155521−0.549−0.542−0.509
333321−0.187−0.1850.180
3335210.8610.8550.824
335521−0.818−0.837−0.836
353521−0.108−0.1160.267
3555210.2520.2590.263
555521−1.140−1.132−0.695
1515310.4350.4330.799
1535310.3100.3020.289
3535310.1860.1690.508
353541−1.628−1.621−1.196
3555411.3881.3711.323
555541−0.212−0.2110.184

Table 1. Neutron-neutron, proton-neutron (T=1T = 1) and proton-proton TBMEs of the derived effective interaction ⟨ab;J,T=1∣Veff∣cd;J,T=1⟩\langle ab;J,T=1|V_{\mathrm{eff}}|cd;J,T=1\rangle in the sdsd shell from Daejeon16. Note that the Coulomb interaction is included in the NCSM calculations. See text for details.

2ja2j_a2jb2j_b2jc2j_c2jd2j_dJJTTVpnT=0V_{pn}^{T=0}
111110−2.909
1113100.381
1133100.573
113510−2.196
115510−1.224
131310−3.565
1333102.176
1335101.458
135510−0.761
333310−1.343
3335100.305
3355102.465
353510−5.702
355510−3.375
555510−1.043
131320−1.839
1315203.045
133520−2.290
151520−0.497
1535201.887
353520−3.370
151530−3.935
153330−0.004
153530−1.537
155530−2.011
333330−3.144
333530−1.743
3355300.977
353530−0.646
355530−2.071
555530−0.690
353540−4.218
555550−4.448

Table 2. Proton-neutron (T=0T = 0) TBMEs of the derived effective interaction ⟨ab;J,T=0∣Veff∣cd;J,T=0⟩\langle ab; J, T = 0|V_{\mathrm{eff}}|cd; J, T = 0\rangle in the sdsd shell from Daejeon16. See text for details.

Low-energy theoretical excitation spectra of $^{18}$O, $^{18}$Ne and the $T=1$ part of the $^{18}$F spectrum

Figure 1. Low-energy theoretical excitation spectra of 18^{18}O, 18^{18}Ne and the T=1T=1 part of the 18^{18}F spectrum obtained within the NCSM with Daejeon16 at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 (identical to the sdsd-shell calculation with the proposed effective valence-space interaction). The USDB T=1T=1 spectrum for A=18A=18 and low-energy experimental spectra of positive-parity states[56] are shown for comparison. The 02+0^{+}_{2} state shown in red in experimental spectrum in 18^{18}O is most probably an intruder state as evidenced by the electromagnetic transition pattern.[56] Its isobaric analogue states in 18^{18}F and 18^{18}Ne are also marked in red, and, therefore, should not be compared with nearby theoretical spectra.

Since there are only small differences among the corresponding proton-proton, neutron-neutron and proton-neutron (T=1T=1) TBMEs, as seen from Table 1, (aside from the expected, approximately constant, diagonal Coulomb shift for the proton-proton TBMEs), the excitation spectra support the approximate validity of isospin symmetry (see Figure 1).

The low-lying T=0T=0 spectrum of 18^{18}F, obtained from the NCSM, contains states with the same JπJ^{\pi} quantum numbers as the USDB spectrum, however, it is more extended in energy than the USDB spectrum, with different ordering, and the lowest 3+3^{+} state, being almost degenerate with 1+1^{+} state, becomes the ground state (see Figure 2). Except for the three lowest states, the experimental T=0T=0 spectrum is noticeably more dense and it is challenging to find theoretical counterparts in the sdsd shell calculation. This may hint at a possible intruder character of some of those states. In the NCSM calculation at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4, states dominated by 2ℏΩ2\hbar\Omega configurations are still located at much higher energy and therefore too far from being converged to shed light on this intruder state issue. Since the present study is focused on the construction of effective operators and to the comparison between the NCSM and valence space results, we do not investigate potential intruder states in the current work. In future applications with larger PP-spaces, one may anticipate, however, that as these intruders fall further into the region of the valence-space dominated states, the mixing that is likely to occur will lead to complications in identifying the appropriate eigenpairs for retention in the P′P^{\prime} space.

Figure 2. Low-energy excitation spectra of 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} (up to 6.2 MeV): theoretical spectrum obtained within the NCSM with Daejeon16 at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 (identical to the sdsd-shell calculation with the effective interaction of Ref.[30]), in comparison with the positive-parity experimental spectrum[56] and the one obtained from USDB. The 0+0^{+}, T=1T=1 state in 18F^{18}\mathrm{F}, analogue to the intruder state in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, is shown in red color.

####### Effective electromagnetic operators in the sdsd shell

Considering nucleons as non-relativistic point-like particles and assuming a long-wavelength approximation for emitted or absorbed radiation, one can deduce the following expressions for one-body electric quadrupole and magnetic dipole operators:

O^(E2)=∑k=1Aekrk2Y^2(r^k),(4)\hat{O}(E2) = \sum_{k=1}^{A} e_k r_k^2 \hat{Y}_2(\hat{r}_k), \tag*{(4)}

and

O^(M1)=∑k=1AμN[gkss⃗k+gkll⃗k],(5)\hat{O}(M1) = \sum_{k=1}^{A} \mu_N \left[g_k^s \vec{s}_k + g_k^l \vec{l}_k\right], \tag*{(5)}

where Y^2(r^k)\hat{Y}_2(\hat{r}_k) are spherical harmonics of rank 2, r^k=(θk,ϕk)\hat{r}_k = (\theta_k,\phi_k) being a spherical angle, s⃗k\vec{s}_k and l⃗k\vec{l}_k are spin and orbital angular momenta operators of a nucleon, respectively, eke_k denotes the electric charge of the kkth nucleon, with the bare values being ep=ee_p=e for a proton and en=0e_n=0 for a neutron, while gsg^s and glg^l are spin and orbital gyro-magnetic factors (gg-factors) with bare values being gps=5.586g_p^s=5.586, gpl=1g_p^l=1, gns=−3.826g_n^s=-3.826, gnl=0g_n^l=0 for protons and neutrons, respectively. For valence space calculations, epe_p and ene_n are conventionally understood to be effective proton and neutron electric charges, while gkl,sg_k^{l,s} have to be effective gg-factors. In principle one could follow the same procedure as we use to develop the valence space effective two-nucleon interaction to develop valence space effective E2E2 and M1M1 operators. The procedures for doing so would follow those demonstrated in Refs.[51, 57] The results, for the P′P'-space we define here, would be represented as TBMEs for these operators. That is, there are, in theory, both one-body and two-body contributions to such derived effective valence electromagnetic operators. Here, we will obtain approximate theoretical one-body effective valence space operators for E2E2 and M1M1. We then test those approximate operators in a number of ways.

Our starting point is the NCSM calculation of E2E2 and M1M1 transitions and moments in 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F} at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4. The three lowest states are 1/2+1/2^+, 5/2+5/2^+ and 3/2+3/2^+ states which are mapped into single-particle 1s1/21s_{1/2}, 0d5/20d_{5/2} and 0d3/20d_{3/2} states in the sdsd-shell calculation. Therefore, we require that the matrix elements of the E2E2 and M1M1 operator with bare electric charges and gg-factors between the many-body eigenstates from the NCSM at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 be exactly reproduced by effective single-particle matrix elements in the valence space.

Effective E2 operator

To obtain an effective one-body valence-space E2E2 operator, we use the NCSM results for E2E2 transitions and quadrupole moments for 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F}. For 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F}, we define a valence-state-dependent proton effective charge such that it exactly reproduces the NCSM values for transitions and moments. Next, we develop a state-dependent effective charge for the valence neutron. We note that the NCSM uses bare electric charges, so only protons contribute to the matrix elements of the E2E2 operator. In contrast, in the valence space 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} has only one valence neutron and therefore we require that it carries an effective charge to be able to reproduce electromagnetic transitions and moments by the valence space calculations. These rules can be summarized as follows:

en(a,b)⟨b∥r2Y2(r^)∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(E2)∥Ji⟩(from 17O)ep(a,b)⟨b∥r2Y2(r^)∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(E2)∥Ji⟩(from 17F)(6)\begin{aligned} e_n(a,b)\langle b\Vert r^2Y_2(\hat{r})\Vert a\rangle&= \langle J_f\Vert\hat{O}(E2)\Vert J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{O}\text{)} \\ e_p(a,b)\langle b\Vert r^2Y_2(\hat{r})\Vert a\rangle&= \langle J_f\Vert\hat{O}(E2)\Vert J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{F}\text{)} \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where en(a,b)e_n(a,b) and ep(a,b)e_p(a,b) are neutron and proton effective state-dependent charges, JiJ_i and JfJ_f are the initial and final state obtained within the NCSM, which are mapped onto single-particle states aa and bb, while the E2E2 operator O^(E2)\hat{O}(E2) is defined by Eq. (4). Double bars in this equation and below refer to the matrix element reduced in angular momentum.

Matching the NCSM results for E2E2 transitions and quadrupole moments for 17O{}^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F{}^{17}\mathrm{F}, we have deduced the values for effective electric charges which are summarized in Table 3. These effective charges ep(a,b)e_p(a,b) and en(a,b)e_n(a,b) depend on the quantum numbers of the initial and final states, aa and bb, so the effective E2E2 operator is deduced as a set of individually parameterized single-particle matrix elements ⟨b∣O^(E2)∣a⟩\langle b|\hat{O}(E2)|a\rangle. However, the state dependence of the effective charges is not strong as is seen from Table 3: the difference between neutron effective charges en(a,b)e_n(a,b) does not exceed ∼0.12e\sim0.12e and the maximal difference between various proton effective charges ep(a,b)e_p(a,b) is ∼0.25e\sim0.25e. The weak state dependence of effective charges tends to support the use of state-independent effective neutron and proton charges as is conventionally done in the valence-space calculations, see, e. g., Ref.47. We present in Table 3 average theoretical effective neutron, eˉn\bar{e}_n, and proton, eˉp\bar{e}_p, charges which are seen to be smaller than the commonly accepted values[47] for 0ℏΩ0\hbar\Omega model space calculations, ep=1.36(5)ee_p=1.36(5)e and en=0.45(5)ee_n=0.45(5)e.

(a,b)(a,b)en(a,b)e_n(a,b)ep(a,b)e_p(a,b)gns(a,b)g_n^s(a,b)gnl(a,b)g_n^l(a,b)gps(a,b)g_p^s(a,b)gpl(a,b)g_p^l(a,b)
bare0.01.0-3.8260.05.5861.0
(0d5/2,1s1/2)(0d_{5/2},1s_{1/2})0.1811.171
(0d5/2,0d3/2)(0d_{5/2},0d_{3/2})0.2811.236-3.6080.0205.2520.916
(1s1/2,0d3/2)(1s_{1/2},0d_{3/2})0.1681.297
(0d5/2,0d5/2)(0d_{5/2},0d_{5/2})0.1791.060-3.7510.0265.4990.976
(0d3/2,0d3/2)(0d_{3/2},0d_{3/2})0.1721.248-3.6900.0335.3320.957
(1s1/2,1s1/2)(1s_{1/2},1s_{1/2})-3.7295.468
e‾n\overline{e}_ne‾p\overline{e}_pg‾ns\overline{g}_n^sg‾nl\overline{g}_n^lg‾ps\overline{g}_p^sg‾pl\overline{g}_p^l
average0.1961.202-3.6950.0265.3880.950

Table 3. Effective charges (in units of ee) and effective gg-factors in the sdsd-shell valence space found by the respective NCSM calculations for 17O^{17}\mathrm{O} and 17F^{17}\mathrm{F}. The bare values used in the NCSM calculations are also indicated for reference. Hermiticity requires symmetry of these effective quantities under the interchange of aa and bb. See text for details.

To assess the quality of the operator constructed above, we calculate reduced transition matrix elements and quadrupole moments in A=18A=18 sdsd-shell nuclei using both state-dependent and average effective charges.

Reduced transition matrix elements, ⟨αfJf∥O^(E2)∥αiJi⟩\langle\alpha_f J_f\Vert\hat{O}(E2)\Vert\alpha_i J_i\rangle, are required to express the corresponding B(E2)B(E2) values of a transition from an initial state ∣αiJi⟩\lvert\alpha_i J_i\rangle to the final state ∣αfJf⟩\lvert\alpha_f J_f\rangle as

B(E2;Ji→Jf)=12Ji+1∣⟨αfJf∥O^(E2)∥αiJi⟩∣2,(7)B(E2; J_i \to J_f) = \frac{1}{2J_i+1}\left\lvert\langle\alpha_f J_f\Vert\hat{O}(E2)\Vert\alpha_i J_i\rangle\right\rvert^2, \tag*{(7)}

where JiJ_i, JfJ_f are the initial (final) angular momenta and αi\alpha_i (αf\alpha_f) are other quantum numbers of the initial (final) states. The standard definition of a quadrupole moment in a state ∣αJ⟩\lvert\alpha J\rangle reads

Q(J)=16π5⟨αJ,MJ=J∣O^(E2,ML=0)∣αJ,MJ=J⟩.(8)Q(J) = \sqrt{\frac{16\pi}{5}}\langle\alpha J,M_J=J\vert\hat{O}(E2,M_L=0)\vert\alpha J,M_J=J\rangle. \tag*{(8)}

We have calculated 66 E2E2 transitions in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 66 E2E2 transitions in 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 269 E2E2 transitions in 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} within the NCSM at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 using the bare E2E2 operator and in the sdsd-shell model space using the effective operators. The results are compared in Figure 3 and Figure 4 where we present absolute values of reduced E2E2 matrix elements and signed electric quadrupole moments for different states obtained in the sdsd-shell valence space calculations with the effective operators versus those obtained by the NCSM. We observe an excellent correlation between the NCSM and valence-space values with the root-mean-square (rms) differences between them being very small, especially for the state-dependent parameterization of the operator, as can be

Comparison of reduced E2 transition matrix elements between shell-model and NCSM calculations

Figure 3. Comparison of the sdsd-shell results for the absolute values of reduced E2E2 transition matrix elements between various states in 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} obtained using effective E2E2 operators within shell model with a core with those obtained by the NCSM (top); the same in the vicinity of zero in order to provide details on an enlarged scale for the weaker transitions (bottom).

Comparison of sd-shell results for electric quadrupole moments

Figure 4. Comparison of the sdsd-shell results for electric quadrupole moments of various states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} obtained using effective E2E2 with those obtained by the NCSM. An outlier in 18F^{18}\mathrm{F}, which is discussed in the text, is flagged with its spin and sequence in the spectrum indicated.

seen from Table 4. The B(E2)B(E2) values, used to calculate the rms difference, have been obtained for Ji≥JfJ_i \geq J_f. Table 5 shows B(E2)B(E2) values for transitions between the lowest states and electric quadrupole moments for the lowest J≠0J \ne0 states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} in comparison with the experimental data, when available. We clearly see missing strength in the E2E2 transitions between the lowest T=1T=1 states, which may signify a need for larger Nmax⁡N_{\max} values, because of the very slow convergence of E2E2 observables.[59] At the same time, the relative order of magnitude of theoretical B(E2)B(E2) values qualitatively resemble experimental findings. In particular, our calculation suggests that the quadrupole moment of the 51+5^+_1 state in 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} is negative. It is worth noting here that the agreement is worse for a couple of cases. In particular, one of them is seen in Figure 4 where the quadrupole moment of the 17+1^+_7 state in 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} with Q=0.78 e⋅fm2Q = 0.78\ e \cdot\mathrm{fm}^2 from the NCSM and Q=2.54 e⋅fm2Q = 2.54\ e \cdot\mathrm{fm}^2 from the valence-space calculations. The discrepancy is most likely related to the fact that this state is the highest lying 1+1^+ state (at around 25 MeV excitation energy) which has only 30% of the valence-space component in the NCSM calculations. Without this point, the rms error for QQ in 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} reduces to from 0.370 to 0.114 e⋅fm2e \cdot\mathrm{fm}^2 for the state-dependent and from 0.478 to 0.339 e⋅fm2e \cdot\mathrm{fm}^2 for the average parameterization of the operator.

rms difference18O^{18}\mathrm{O} st-dep18O^{18}\mathrm{O} average18F^{18}\mathrm{F} st-dep18F^{18}\mathrm{F} average18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} st-dep18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} average
Red E2E2 M.E. [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]0.0720.1680.1140.3350.2210.267
B(E2)B(E2) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]0.0170.0390.1890.2400.2080.583
QQ [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]0.0630.1180.3700.4780.0640.443
Red M1M1 m.e. [μN\mu_N]0.0700.0880.0500.0710.1080.118
B(M1)B(M1) [μN2\mu_N^{2}]0.0630.0810.0920.1060.0600.085
μ\mu [μN\mu_N]0.0230.0320.1890.1820.0200.099
Exp56,58^{56,58}NCSMsdsd shell st-depsdsd shell average
18O^{18}\mathrm{O}
B(E2;21+→01+)B(E2;2^{+}_{1}\rightarrow0^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]9.3(3)0.5270.5350.634
B(E2;22+→01+)B(E2;2^{+}_{2}\rightarrow0^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]3.6(6)0.0010.0010.001
B(E2;41+→21+)B(E2;4^{+}_{1}\rightarrow2^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]3.3(2)0.3390.3590.434
Q(21+)Q(2^{+}_{1}) [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]−3.6(9)−1.40−1.46−1.55
18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne}
B(E2;21+→01+)B(E2;2^{+}_{1}\rightarrow0^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]49.6(50)21.9421.7623.79
B(E2;22+→01+)B(E2;2^{+}_{2}\rightarrow0^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]1.9(9)0.070.070.007
B(E2;41+→21+)B(E2;4^{+}_{1}\rightarrow2^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]24.9(34)14.4314.4216.07
Q(21+)Q(2^{+}_{1}) [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]−9.16−9.23−9.65
18F^{18}\mathrm{F}
B(E2;31+→11+)B(E2;3^{+}_{1}\rightarrow1^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]16.3(6)8.298.519.05
B(E2;32+→11+)B(E2;3^{+}_{2}\rightarrow1^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]1.9(3)0.0140.0100.030
B(E2;51+→31+)B(E2;5^{+}_{1}\rightarrow3^{+}_{1}) [e2⋅fm4e^{2}\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{4}]16.2(7)7.817.958.64
Q(11+)Q(1^{+}_{1}) [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]0.320.190.28
Q(31+)Q(3^{+}_{1}) [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]−5.75−5.93−6.36
Q(51+)Q(5^{+}_{1}) [e⋅fm2e\cdot\mathrm{fm}^{2}]±7.7(5)−7.19−7.34−8.29

Table 4. Root-mean-square (rms) differences between the results on E2E2 and M1M1 transitions and moments from valence-space calculations with either the state-dependent (st-dep) or the average parameterizations of the effective E2E2 or effective M1M1 operator and the respective NCSM results. See text for details.

Effective M1 operator

We proceed in a like manner for the effective M1M1 operator. From comparison of the NCSM results on magnetic dipole moments and transitions for A=17A = 17 at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max} = 4 with single-particle values, we have deduced state-dependent matrix elements of the orbital and spin contribution of the M1M1 operator as well as respective state-dependent effective gg-factors gkj(a,b)g_k^j(a,b), k=n,pk = n,p and j=l,sj = l,s. The rules can be summarized as follows:

gns(a,b)⟨b∥μNs⃗∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(M1)spin∥Ji⟩(from 17O)gnl(a,b)⟨b∥μNl⃗∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(M1)orbit∥Ji⟩(from 17O)gps(a,b)⟨b∥μNs⃗∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(M1)spin∥Ji⟩(from 17F)gpl(a,b)⟨b∥μNl⃗∥a⟩=⟨Jf∥O^(M1)orbit∥Ji⟩(from 17F)(9)\begin{aligned} g_n^s(a,b)\langle b\|\mu_N\vec{s}\|a\rangle&= \langle J_f\|\hat{O}(M1)_{\mathrm{spin}}\|J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{O}\text{)} \\ g_n^l(a,b)\langle b\|\mu_N\vec{l}\|a\rangle&= \langle J_f\|\hat{O}(M1)_{\mathrm{orbit}}\|J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{O}\text{)} \\ g_p^s(a,b)\langle b\|\mu_N\vec{s}\|a\rangle&= \langle J_f\|\hat{O}(M1)_{\mathrm{spin}}\|J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{F}\text{)} \\ g_p^l(a,b)\langle b\|\mu_N\vec{l}\|a\rangle&= \langle J_f\|\hat{O}(M1)_{\mathrm{orbit}}\|J_i\rangle\quad\text{(from }{}^{17}\mathrm{F}\text{)} \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}

where spin and orbital part are referring to the first and second term of the M1M1 operator, given by Eq. (5), while JiJ_i and JfJ_f are the initial and final states obtained within the NCSM which are mapped onto the single-particle states aa and bb in the valence space. Note that these equations help to exactly reproduce M1M1 matrix elements between the NCSM states for A=17A = 17 within the valence space, except for those which involve the s1/2s_{1/2} orbital due to the fact that it is characterized by l=0l = 0 orbital quantum number and therefore there is no way to reproduce a small, but non-zero value of ⟨Jf∥O^(M1)orbit∥Ji⟩\langle J_f\|\hat{O}(M1)_{\mathrm{orbit}}\|J_i\rangle. To overcome this difficulty, we can require that in the case when aa or bb refers to the s1/2s_{1/2} single-particle state, the valence space matrix element due to non-zero spin part would exactly reproduce the NCSM matrix element of the full M1M1 operator. Because of the smallness of the orbital contribution to the NCSM results, both definitions lead to almost identical results for magnetic moments and, therefore, their use is practically equivalent. We choose the latter method in the present work. The corresponding effective gg-factors are summarized in Table 3. We notice that there is a more modest quenching of the spin operators than the quenching obtained in the previous studies in the sdsd-shell.[41, 42, 47, 60] We notice also that the modifications to orbital gg-factors found (positive for neutrons and negative for protons) are opposite in sign from the corresponding corrections found in the same cited works. For reference, the best fitted empirical values found for the same form of the M1M1 operator using the USDB wave functions in the sdsd shell are gns=−3.55(10)g_n^s=-3.55(10), gnl=−0.09(26)g_n^l=-0.09(26), gps=5.15(9)g_p^s=5.15(9), gpl=1.159(23)g_p^l=1.159(23).[47]

As a next step, we have calculated reduced M1M1 transition probabilities and magnetic moments in A=18A=18 sdsd-shell nuclei. A reduced M1M1 transition matrix element, ⟨αfJf∥O^(M1)∥αiJi⟩\langle\alpha_fJ_f\Vert\hat{O}(M1)\Vert\alpha_iJ_i\rangle, is required to express the corresponding B(M1)B(M1) value of a transition from an initial state ∣αiJi⟩\lvert\alpha_iJ_i\rangle to the final state ∣αfJf⟩\lvert\alpha_fJ_f\rangle as

B(M1;Ji→Jf)=12Ji+1∣⟨αfJf∥O^(M1)∥αiJi⟩∣2(10)B(M1;J_i\to J_f)=\frac{1}{2J_i+1}\left\lvert\langle\alpha_fJ_f\Vert\hat{O}(M1)\Vert\alpha_iJ_i\rangle\right\rvert^2 \tag*{(10)}

while the magnetic moment reads

μ(J)=4π3⟨αJ,MJ=J∣O^(M1,ML=0)∣αJ,MJ=J⟩.(11)\mu(J)=\sqrt{\frac{4\pi}{3}}\langle\alpha J,M_J=J\vert\hat{O}(M1,M_L=0)\vert\alpha J,M_J=J\rangle. \tag*{(11)}

The absolute values of reduced M1M1 matrix elements of 43 M1M1 transitions in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 43 M1M1 transitions in 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 212 M1M1 transitions in 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} obtained within the NCSM at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4 using the bare M1M1 operator, and in the sdsd shell model space using the effective operators are compared in Figure 5. The magnetic moments of all J≠0J\ne0 states (11 states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 11 states in 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 25 states in 18F^{18}\mathrm{F}) are compared in Figure 6. We notice again a remarkable agreement between the two sets of results. The state-dependent parameterization of the M1M1 single-particle matrix elements leads to smaller rms differences as compared to those provided by the average parameterization with an exception of the 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} magnetic moments where both parameterizations provide nearly the same rms differences (see Table 4). The B(M1)B(M1) values, used to compute the rms difference, have been generated for Ji≥JfJ_i\ge J_f.

Comparison of reduced M1 matrix elements for sd-shell results and NCSM calculations

Figure 5. Comparison of the sdsd-shell results for the reduced M1M1 matrix elements between various states in 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} obtained using effective M1M1 operators within shell model with a core with those obtained by the NCSM (top); the same in the vicinity of zero in order to provide details on an enlarged scale for the weaker transitions (bottom). Two outliers in 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} are flagged in the top panel with their state identifications and are discussed in the text.

Comparison of the $sd$-shell results for magnetic dipole moments

Figure 6. Comparison of the sdsd-shell results for magnetic dipole moments of various states in 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{Ne} obtained using effective M1M1 operators with those obtained by the NCSM. Two outliers in 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} are flagged with their state identifications and are discussed in the text.

Table 6 shows B(M1)B(M1) values for transitions between the lowest states and magnetic dipole moments of the lowest states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne} and 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} in comparison with the experimental data, when available. In particular, there is a good agreement with the measured magnetic moment values. We attribute this to the fact that the M1M1-observables converge faster in the NCSM calculations.

Table 6. B(M1)B(M1) values for transitions between the lowest states and magnetic moments of the lowest states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne}: NCSM versus valence-space results obtained using either state-dependent or average gg-factors. The experimental values are shown when available (only the latest result is retained in the table below when a few experimental values are given in Ref.58).

Exp[56, 58]NCSMsdsd shell st-depsdsd shell average
18O^{18}\mathrm{O}
B(M1;22+→21+)B(M1;2^+_2 \to2^+_1) [μN2][\mu_N^2]0.25(4)0.0720.0720.071
B(M1;11+→01+)B(M1;1^+_1 \to0^+_1) [μN2][\mu_N^2]0.1010.1190.125
μ(21+)\mu(2^+_1) [μN][\mu_N]−0.57(3)−0.53−0.54−0.52
μ(41+)\mu(4^+_1) [μN][\mu_N]±\pm2.5(4)−2.41−2.41−2.35
18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne}
B(M1;22+→21+)B(M1;2^+_2 \to2^+_1) [μN2][\mu_N^2]0.0920.0920.090
B(M1;11+→01+)B(M1;1^+_1 \to0^+_1) [μN2][\mu_N^2]0.0790.0890.093
μ(21+)\mu(2^+_1) [μN][\mu_N]2.622.632.55
18F^{18}\mathrm{F}
B(M1;11+→01+)B(M1;1^+_1 \to0^+_1) [μN2][\mu_N^2]5.4285.3665.256
μ(31+)\mu(3^+_1) [μN][\mu_N]+1.77(12)1.8571.8521.803
μ(51+)\mu(5^+_1) [μN][\mu_N]+2.86(3)2.8782.8782.798

Table 6. B(M1)B(M1) values for transitions between the lowest states and magnetic moments of the lowest states in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 18F^{18}\mathrm{F} and 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne}: NCSM versus valence-space results obtained using either state-dependent or average gg-factors. The experimental values are shown when available (only the latest result is retained in the table below when a few experimental values are given in Ref.58).

Two outlying 18F{}^{18}\mathrm{F} points are clearly seen in Figure 6 and these are magnetic moments of the first two 2+2^{+} states: they are only 130 keV separated in energy and appear to be mixed in isospin. The 21+2^{+}_{1} state contains 88% of T=1T=1 component and 11% T=0T=0 component and vice versa for 22+2^{+}_{2}. The values of the reduced M1M1 transition matrix elements between these two states are also significantly different between the NCSM (4.258 μN24.258\ \mu_{N}^{2}) and valence space calculations (3.297 μN23.297\ \mu_{N}^{2}) as seen from Figure 5.

####### Conclusions and Prospects

In this contribution we present a novel method for deriving effective one-body electromagnetic operators for valence space calculations from the NCSM results. The effective E2E2 and M1M1 one-body operators are obtained as a set of parameterized effective single-particle matrix elements to be used with many-body states in the valence space. Comparison of a large number of reduced E2E2 and M1M1 matrix elements, as well as electric quadrupole and magnetic dipole moments in A=18A=18 sdsd-shell nuclei shows a very good agreement with the NCSM values. Further exploration of these operators in systems with more valence particles is in progress. One also anticipates systematically increasing the space for the NCSM calculations as computational resources allow.

Acknowledgments

Z. Li and N. A. Smirnova acknowledge the financial support of CNRS/IN2P3 via ENFIA Master project, France. The work of A. M. Shirokov is supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research under Grant No. 20-02-00357. The work of I. J. Shin was supported by the Rare Isotope Science Project of Institute for Basic Science funded by Ministry of Science and ICT and National Research Foundation of Korea (2013M7A1A1075764). This work was supported in part by the US Department of Energy (DOE) under Grant Nos. DE-FG02-87ER40371, DESC0018223 (SciDAC-4/NUCLEI). Computational resources were provided by the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), which is supported by the US DOE Office of Science under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231, and also provided by the National Supercomputing Center, Republic of Korea, including technical support (KSC-2020-CRE-0027). N. A. Smirnova and A.M. Shirokov thank the Institute for Basic Science, Daejeon, for a hospitality and financial support of their visits.

####### References

References

  1. [1]B. R. Barrett, P. Navrátil, and J. P. Vary, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 69, 131 (2013).
  2. [2]G. Hagen, T. Papenbrock, M. Hjorth-Jensen, and D. J. Dean, Rept. Prog. Phys. 77, 096302 (2014).
  3. [3]J. Carlson, S. Gandolfi, F. Pederiva, S. C. Pieper, R. Schiavilla, K. E. Schmidt, and R. B. Wiringa, Rev. Mod. Phys. 87, 1067 (2015).
  4. [4]H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, T. D. Morris, A. Schwenk, and K. Tsukiyama, Phys. Rept. 621, 165 (2016).
  5. [5]W. H. Dickhoff and C. Barbieri, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 52, 377 (2004).
  6. [6]A. Tichai, R. Roth, and T. Duquette, Front. Phys. 8, 164 (2020).
  7. [7]P. Maris, E. Epelbaum, R. J. Furnstahl, J. Golak, K. Hebeler, T. Hüther, H. Kamada, H. Krebs, U.-G. Meißner, J. A. Melendez, A. Nogga, P. Reinert, R. Roth, R. Skibiński, V. Soloviev, K. Topolnicki, J. P. Vary, V. Volkotrub, H. Witala, and T. Wolfgruber, Phys. Rev. C 103, 054001 (2021).
  8. [8]P. Sternberg, E. G. Ng, C. Yang, P. Maris, J. P. Vary, M. Sosonkina, and H. V. Le, Procedia of the 2008 Conference on Supercomputing (SC 2008), (IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ, 2008). 15, 1 (2008).
  9. [9]P. Maris, M. Sosonkina, J. P. Vary, E. G. Ng, and C. Yang, Procedia Computer Science (May 2010, ICCS 2010) (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2010). 1, 97 (2010).
  10. [10]H. M. Aktulga, C. Yang, E. G. Ng, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Lecture Notes in Computer Science (Springer, Heidelberg, 2012). 7484, 830 (2012).
  11. [11]H. M. Aktulga, C. Yan, E. G. Ng, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Concurrency Computat.: Pract. Exper. 26, 2631 (2014).
  12. [12]M. Shao, H. Aktulga, C. Yang, E. G. Ng, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Comput. Phys. Commun. 222, 1 (2018).
  13. [13]A. Saxena and P. C. Srivastava, J. Phys. G. 47, 055113 (2020).
  14. [14]I. J. Shin et al. (in preparation) .
  15. [15]B. A. Brown, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 47, 517 (2001).
  16. [16]T. Otsuka, M. Honma, T. Mizusaki, N. Shimizu, and Y. Utsuno, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 47, 319 (2001).
  17. [17]E. Caurier, G. Martínez-Pinedo, F. Nowacki, A. Poves, and A. P. Zuker, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 427 (2005).
  18. [18]M. Hjorth-Jensen, T. T. S. Kuo, and E. Osnes, Phys. Rep. 261, 125 (1995).
  19. [19]S. R. Stroberg, H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, and J. D. Holt, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 69, 307 (2019).
  20. [20]B. A. Brown and B. H. Wildenthal, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 38, 29 (1988).
  21. [21]M. Homma, T. Otsuka, B. A. Brown, and T. Mizusaki, Phys. Rev. C 69, 034335 (2004).
  22. [22]A. Poves and A. P. Zuker, Phys. Rep. 70, 235 (1981).
  23. [23]A. P. Zuker, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 042502 (2003).
  24. [24]S. R. Stroberg, A. Calci, H. Hergert, J. D. Holt, S. Bogner, R. Roth, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 032502 (2017).
  25. [25]S. Okubo, Prog. Theor. Phys. 12, 603 (1954).
  26. [26]K. Suzuki and S. Y. Lee, Prog. Theor. Phys. 64, 2091 (1980).
  27. [27]K. Suzuki, Prog. Theor. Phys. 68, 246 (1982).
  28. [28]A. F. Lisetskiy, M. K. G. Kruse, B. R. Barrett, P. Navrátil, I. Stetcu, and J. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 80, 024315 (2009).
  29. [29]E. Dikmen, A. F. Lisetskiy, B. R. Barrett, P. Maris, A. M. Shirokov, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 91, 064301 (2015).
  30. [30]N. A. Smirnova, B. R. Barrett, Y. Kim, I. J. J. Shin, A. M. Shirokov, E. Dikmen, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 100, 054329 (2019).
  31. [31]G. R. Jansen, M. Schuster, A. Signoracci, G. Hagen, and P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. C 94, 011301 (2016).
  32. [32]Z. H. Sun, T. D. Morris, G. Hagen, G. R. Jansen, and T. Papenbrock, Phys. Rev. C 98, 054320 (2018).
  33. [33]T. Otsuka, T. Suzuki, J. D. Holt, A. Schwenk, and Y. Akaishi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 032501 (2010).
  34. [34]J. D. Holt, T. Otsuka, A. Schwenk, and T. Suzuki, J. Phys. G 39, 085111 (2012).
  35. [35]T. Fukui, L. D. Angelis, Y. Z. Ma, L. Coraggio, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and F. R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 98, 044305 (2018).
  36. [36]A. Arima and H. Horie, Prog. Theor. Phys. 11, 509 (1954).
  37. [37]A. Arima and H. Horie, Prog. Theor. Phys. 12, 623 (1954).
  38. [38]T. T. S. Kuo and E. Osens, Nucl. Phys. A 205, 1 (1973).
  39. [39]B. Brown, A. Arima, and J. McGrory, Nucl. Phys. A 77, 277 (1977).
  40. [40]E. Oset and M. Rho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 42, 47 (1979).
  41. [41]A. Arima, K. Shimizu, W. Bentz, and H. Hyuga, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 18, 1 (1987).
  42. [42]I. Towner, Phys. Rep. 155, 264 (1987).
  43. [43]N. M. Parzuchowski, S. R. Stroberg, P. Navrátil, H. Hergert, and S. K. Bogner, Phys. Rev. C 96, 034324 (2017).
  44. [44]B. A. Brown, B. H. Wildenthal, W. Chung, S. E. Massen, M. Bernas, A. M. Bernstein, R. Miskimen, V. R. Brown, and V. A. Madsen, Phys. Rev. C 26, 2247–2272 (1982).
  45. [45]M. Carchidi, B. Wildenthal, and B. Brown, Phys. Rev. C 34, 2280 (1986).
  46. [46]B. A. Brown and W. A. Richter, Phys. Rev. C 74, 034315 (2006).
  47. [47]W. A. Richter, S. Mkhize, and B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. C 78, 064302 (2008).
  48. [48]A. Shirokov, I. Shin, Y. Kim, M. Sosonkina, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Lett. B 761, 87 (2016).
  49. [49]D. H. Gloeckner and D. R. Lawson, Phys. Lett. B 53, 313 (1974).
  50. [50]M. W. Kirson, Nucl. Phys. A 781, 350 (2007).
  51. [51]J. P. Vary, R. Basili, W. Du, M. Lockner, P. Maris, S. Pal, and S. Sarker, Phys. Rev. C 98, 065502 (2018).
  52. [52]D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Phys. Lett. B 524, 93 (2002).
  53. [53]D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 68, 041001 (2003).
  54. [54]S. D. Glazek and K. G. Wilson, Phys. Rev. D 48, 5863 (1993).
  55. [55]F. Wegner, Annalen der Physik. 506, 77 (1994).
  56. [56]NNDC. http://www.nndc.bnl.gov .
  57. [57]I. Stetcu, B. R. Barrett, P. Navrátil, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 71, 044325 (2005).
  58. [58]N. J. Stone, At. Data Nucl. Data Sci. 90, 75 (2005).
  59. [59]I. J. Shin, Y. Kim, P. Maris, J. P. Vary, C. Forssén, J. Rotureau, and N. Michel, J. Phys. G 44, 075103 (2017).
  60. [60]B. A. Brown and B. H. Wildenthal, Nucl. Phys. A 474, 290–306 (1987).

Paper details

vlnc:W_xsf7gd2h
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents