betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Distinguishing the importance of different charge trapping centers in CaF2-based 2D material MOSFETs

Abstract

Crystalline CaF2 is drawing huge attentions due to its great potential of being the gate dielectric of two-dimensional (2D) material MOSFETs. It is deemed to be much superior than boron nitride and traditional SiO2 because of its larger dielectric constant, wider band gap, and lower defect density. Nevertheless, the CaF2-based MOSFETs fabricated in experiment still present notable reliability issues, and the underlying reason remains unclear. Here we studied the various intrinsic defects and adsorbates in CaF2/MoS2 and CaF2/MoSi2N4 interface systems to reveal the most active charge trapping centers in CaF2-based 2D material MOSFETs. An elaborate Table that comparing the importance of different defects in both n-type and p-type device is provided. Most impressively, the oxygen molecules adsorbed at the interface or surface, which are inevitable in experiments, are as active as the intrinsic defects in channel materials, and they can even change the MoSi2N4 to p-type spontaneously. These results mean that it is necessary to develop high vacuum packaging process as well as preparing high-quality 2D materials for better device performance.

Introduction

Two-dimensional (2D) materials offer new possibilities for more Moore due to their ultra-thin thickness and smooth surface with no dangling bonds.[1, 2, 3] With the ultra-scaled channel, higher requirements are raised for the quality and reliability of gate dielectric materials.

To match the silicon technologies, oxides (such as SiO2SiO_{2}[4], HfO2HfO_{2}[5] and Al2O3Al_{2}O_{3}[6]) are usually used, but these materials are non-layered, which makes it difficult to form a good interface with the 2D channels. To deal with the problem, 2D dielectrics such as h-BN have been studied.[7] However, the band gap (~6 eV) and dielectric constant (5.06 ε) of h-BN are not satisfying for dielectric materials.[8] Its band offset with 2D materials is not large enough, which will lead to many reliability problems.[9]

Excitingly, the recent experimental preparation of crystalline CaF2CaF_{2} provides a strong support for the solution of this dilemma.10,11 By using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE), crystalline CaF2CaF_{2} can be grown on a silicon or germanium substrate.12 It has a larger bandgap (12.1 eV) and larger dielectric constant (8.43 ε) than h-BN.13 The grown CaF2CaF_{2} is terminated by F atoms, which means that there is no dangling bond on its surface.14 Another important point is that CaF2CaF_{2} itself is stable in air, and is not easily dissolved in water.15 CaF2CaF_{2} can form good type I band alignment with many 2D materials, which means that it will be very advantageous as a gate dielectric of semiconductor devices.

Nevertheless, notable device reliability issues were still observed in CaF2CaF_{2}-based MOSFETs,13,15–17 which contradicts the perfect electrical properties of CaF2CaF_{2}. For example, the IDI_{D}-VGV_{G} hysteresis is significant (although lower than that in MoS2/SiO2MoS_{2}/SiO_{2} FET), and it shows obvious variability when the same device is operated at different scanning times. On the other hand, if different devices are operated under the same VDV_{D}, the IDI_{D}-VGV_{G} characteristics such as on/off current ratio and subthreshold swing (SS) (150–90 mV dec−1^{-1}) differ greatly.13 In addition, some devices with large negative threshold voltage (VthV_{th}) are prone to fail due to the bias overload of the CaF2CaF_{2} layer. The physical origin of hysteresis and threshold voltage shift is widely attributed to the charge trapping and de-trapping of microscopic defects,18–24 and the strength of the charge trapping effect is closely related to the type of defects.25–28 Therefore, it is very urgent to distinguishing the activity of various defects in CaF2CaF_{2}-based transistors so that corresponding strategies can be proposed to deal with them.

Method

Among the 2D materials, MoS2_2 is one of the most widely used semiconductor. It has a direct band gap of 1.8 eV, and has been used to design high-performance electronic as well as optoelectronic devices.29 On the other hand, there are also some new materials being synthetized, such as the MoSi2_2N4_4. MoSi2_2N4_4 is very promising because of the excellent photocatalytic performance,31 mechanical strength,32 and electrical transportability.33 Therefore, we construct both MoS2_2/CaF2_2 and MoSi2_2N4_4/CaF2_2 interface models to make the simulation results representative. The lattice parameter of CaF2_2, MoS2_2 and MoSi2_2N4_4 is 3.90 Å, 3.16 Å, and 2.91 Å, respectively. To obtain good lattice matching, the primary cell of MoS2_2 is repeated by five times to contact with the CaF2_2 cell that is repeated by four times. The final CaF2_2 deformation is only 1.28%. Similarly, the primary cell of MoSi2_2N4_4 is repeated by four times to contact the CaF2_2 that is repeated by three times, and the CaF2_2 deformation is only 0.52%. All the first-principles calculations are performed by the software PWmat.34,35 The SG15 pseudopotential36 is adopted, and the plane wave cutoff energy is 50 Ry. The Heyd–Scuseria–Ernzerhof (HSE)37 functional is used in the calculation of electronic structures to improve the accuracy of calculations. The vdW force between the layers of the material is also considered.

Results and Discussion

The interface models are shown in Figure 1(a) and (c). A 5-layer CaF2_2 is adopted because the experimental MBE grown CaF2_2 is about 2 nm thick. The band alignments that manifested by the projected density of states (PDOS) are shown in Figure 1(b) and (d). It can be seen that the VBM (valence band maximum) and CBM (conduction band minimum) are provided by MoS2_2 and MoSi2_2N4_4, and the band offsets are greater than 2 eV, which makes charge tunneling difficult. This confirms that using CaF2_2 as the gate of 2D material MOSFET is likely to obtain good device reliability.38 Therefore, when considering practical applications, we believe that the reliability issues should stem from some intrinsic or external charge trapping centers.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Atomic structure and type-I band alignment of the two kinds of interface models.

Intuitively, we should first study the F vacancy defect in the CaF2_2 layer. However, it has been demonstrated in experiment that CaF2_2 is not easy to generate defects.13 Besides, it has been proved by first principle calculation that even though F vacancies (VF_{\mathrm{F}}) and Ca vacancies (VCa_{\mathrm{Ca}}) exist, there is no defect state near the band edge of channel material due to the large band offset between the two materials.39 Consequently, we turn our attention to the trapping centers inside the channel material, in the semiconductor/dielectric interface, and at the dielectric surface. For MoS2_2, we considered S vacancy defect (VS_{\mathrm{S}}), Mo vacancy defects (VMo_{\mathrm{Mo}}), MoS3_3 vacancy defect (VMoS3_{\mathrm{MoS3}}) and MoS6_6 vacancy defect (VMoS6_{\mathrm{MoS6}}) at different spatial locations. On the other hand, considering that gas adsorption is very easy to occur in the process of device manufacturing, we also studied the water and oxygen molecules that adsorbed at different positions. For a more intuitive display of defects and adsorption, the related structural diagrams are shown in Figure 2.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. The different defects in MoS2_2 from (a) to (d) are VS_{\mathrm{S}}, VMo_{\mathrm{Mo}}, VMoS3_{\mathrm{MoS3}}, and VMoS6_{\mathrm{MoS6}} defects. Oxygen molecules (e) and water molecules (f) are adsorbed between the CaF2_2-MoS2_2 interface, respectively. Oxygen is adsorbed on the interlayer of MoS2_2(g) and the surface of CaF2_2(h), respectively. The atoms highlighted in red in the figure represent defects and adsorption sites.

shown in Figure 3. First, there is an occupied defect state denoted by d1 for the VS_{\mathrm{S}} in MoS2_2, whose energy is 0.38 eV below VBM, and there are two empty defect states with similar energy denoted by d2, whose energy is 0.57 eV below CBM. According to charge transfer theories, the charge trapping rate will decrease exponentially with the increasing energy barrier between the initial and final electronic states, thus we can consider that only the defect levels that locate less than 1 eV away from the Si band edge are active trapping centers. Therefore, it can be concluded that d1 is an important hole trapping state when negative gate voltage is applied, and d2 is an important electron trapping state when positive gate voltage is applied. Similarly, the Mo vacancy are active in trapping holes and electrons, but they not as active as the S vacancy in electron trapping, because the VMo_{\mathrm{Mo}} defect levels are farther away the CBM. In addition to the common VS_{\mathrm{S}} and VMo_{\mathrm{Mo}},

Image not extracted

Figure 3. The energy level distribution of different defects. (a) S vacancy (VS_{\mathrm{S}}), (b) Mo vacancy (VMo_{\mathrm{Mo}}), (c) MoS3_3 vacancy (VMoS3_{\mathrm{MoS3}}), and (d) MoS6_6 vacancy (VMoS6_{\mathrm{MoS6}}).

experiments have reported that complex vacancy defects (such as VMoS3V_{\mathrm{MoS_3}} and VMoS6V_{\mathrm{MoS_6}}) are found in MoS2_2.40 These two complex vacancies contain many dangling bonds, and thus can introduce a series of defect states (up to 13) that locate either close to VBM or to CBM. Consequently, they will be very active charge trapping centers. Nevertheless, the formation energy of these complex defects is very high, which makes them low in density. More details of the defect levels have been listed in Table 1.

Defect TypeDefect StateΔEVBM\Delta E_{\mathrm{VBM}} (eV)ΔECBM\Delta E_{\mathrm{CBM}} (eV)NBTI ImportancePBTI ImportanceFormation/Adsorption energy (eV)Comprehensive Importance
VSV_{\mathrm{S}}d1-0.38-1.91✓×
d20.95-0.57✓✓2.91✓
VMoV_{\mathrm{Mo}}d1-0.06-1.63×✓
d20.40-1.17×✓8.52✓
d30.71-0.86×✓
VMoS3V_{\mathrm{MoS_3}}d1-0.25-1.78✓×
d20.89-0.64×✓11.81✓
d30.99-0.53×✓
VMoS6V_{\mathrm{MoS_6}}type 1<0.50< 0.50>1.50> 1.50✓×
type 2<1.00< 1.00>1.00> 1.00××21.41×
type 3>1.75> 1.75>0.25> 0.25××
O2O_2 at interfaced1-0.92-2.45✓×
d2-0.55-2.00✓×0.68✓
d3-0.85-2.31✓×
H2OH_2O at interface-3.42-4.91××0.61×
O2O_2 in MoS2_2-0.37-2.01✓×2.35✓
O2O_2 at surface1.11-0.41×✓2.25✓

Table 1. Importance of different trapping centers in CaF2_2-MoS2_2.

It has been mentioned in previous reports that the hysteresis of CaF2_2-MoS2_2 devices can be reduced after they are heated and dried.13 This indicate that molecules had been adsorbed during device preparation, so the activity of these adsorbates need to be discussed. Figure 4(a) shows the adsorption of O2O_2 in the CaF2_2-MoS2_2 interface, and three defect levels that denoted by d1, d2 and d3 are observed. They are only 1 eV, 0.85 eV and 0.54 eV below VBM, respectively. Therefore, they will be active hole traps in p-MOSFETs. In contrast, the adsorption of water molecules on the interface is much less important. It can be seen from Figure 4(b) that there is no obvious defect state near the band edge of MoS2_2. To further check the importance of oxygen, we studied the oxygens that adsorbed in other positions. Figure 4(c) shows the situation that the oxygen molecules are adsorbed in the interlayer of MoS2_2. It can be seen that the defect state is only 0.37 eV below VBM, which will trap holes easily and thus affects the device performance. Figure 4(d) shows the case that the oxygen is adsorbed on the surface of CaF2_2. An occupied defect state that is close to CBM rather than CBM is seen. Considering that the negative gate voltage in a p-FET will drag the defect level down towards the VBM, the oxygen on the CaF2_2 surface will be very active hole trapping centers with large gate voltage.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. The energy level distribution of different adsorbents. The contributions of defect energy levels in Figures (a) to (d) correspond to the cases (a) to (d) in Fig. 4, respectively.

To exhibit the importance of different defects more clearly, Table 1 summarizes and compares the information of all defects. The defect levels that are more than 1 eV away from the MoS2_2 band edge are regarded as electronically unimportant.41–43 Moreover, the formation energy/adsorption energy is considered to provide an overall evaluation of their importance.

Moreover, the formation energy/adsorption energy is considered to provide an overall evaluation of their importance. Now we study the MoSi2_2N4_4/CaF2_2 system. MoSi2_2N4_4 is a 2D material with 7 atomic layers. One Mo atomic layer lies in the middle while two Si-N-Si tri-layers lie on top and bottom surface symmetrically. Vacancy defects caused by the shedding of N (Figure 5a) and Si (Figure 5b) atoms on the surface layer are the primary problems to be considered. At the same time, the influence of oxygen molecules (Figure 5c) and water molecules (Figure 5d) adsorption during device manufacturing is also considered here. The atoms highlighted in red in the figure represent defects and adsorption sites.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Common defects and adsorption in CaF2_2-MoSi2_2N4_4. (a) and (b) are VNV_{\mathrm{N}} and VSiV_{\mathrm{Si}} in MoSi2_2N4_4 respectively. Figures (c) and (d) are the adsorption of water molecules and oxygen molecules.

For the N vacancy (VNV_{\mathrm{N}}) (Figure 6a), two defect levels are induced into the band gap, of which the half-occupied d1 state is 0.98 eV above VBM and the empty d2 state is 0.45 eV below CBM. Such small energy barriers make them very active hole/electron trapping centers. In contrast, the VSiV_{\mathrm{Si}} defect induce no defect levels close to the CBM, as is shown in Figure 6(b), but it induces many defect levels below the VBM. Specially, the electrons in VBM have spontaneously transferred to the defect sites, making the Fermi level shifted below the VBM, and making the CaF2_2-MoSi2_2N4_4 as a whole P-type heterostructure. Interestingly, the adsorption of an oxygen in the CaF2_2-MoSi2_2N4_4 interface has very similar effect, as is shown in Figure 6(c), the electrons in VBM are spontaneously captured by the oxygen, and the MoSi2_2N4_4 becomes a p-type material. If the oxygen density is high, this will greatly impair the performance and reliability of the device. In comparison, the adsorption of water

Image not extracted

Figure 6. The energy level distribution of common defects and adsorption in CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2}-MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4}. The contributions of defect energy levels in (a) to (d) correspond to the cases (a) to (d) in Figure 4, respectively.

molecules in the interface does not have such effect, as is shown in Figure 6(d). The water related defect energy level is far away from the band edge of MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4}. This further confirms that the water molecules adsorption is less important than oxygen adsorption in impacting device performance and reliability.

To present the importance of different defects more intuitively, Table 2 summarizes and compares the information of all defects in CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2}-MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4} system.

Defect TypesDefect StateΔE\Delta E-CBM (eV)ΔE\Delta E-VBM (eV)NBTI ImportantPBTI ImportantFormation/Adsorption energy (eV)Comprehensive Importance
VN\mathrm{V_N}d10.98-1.83✓×5.97✓
VN\mathrm{V_N}d22.36-0.45×✓
VSi\mathrm{V_{Si}}d1-1.01-3.23××11.15✓
VSi\mathrm{V_{Si}}d20.00-2.22✓×
O2\mathrm{O_2} at interface-0.32-3.07✓×0.19✓
H2O\mathrm{H_2O} at interface-2.29-5.17××0.34×

Table 2. Importance of different capture centers in CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2}-MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4}.

Conclusion

In conclusion, we have investigated the various defects and adsorbates in CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2}-based 2D material MOSFET structures to distinguish their importance in degrading the device performance and reliability. First, the intrinsic defects in channel materials, including the VS\mathrm{V_S} and VMo\mathrm{V_{Mo}} in MoS2\mathrm{MoS_2}, and VSi\mathrm{V_{Si}} and VN\mathrm{V_N} in MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4} are very active charge trapping centers. Second, the adsorbed oxygen molecule in the channel/CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2} interface or CaF2\mathrm{CaF_2} surface is very important trap centers, and they can even spontaneously change the MoSi2N4\mathrm{MoSi_2N_4} to p-type. Third, the adsorbed water molecules are very inactive in capture charges, and thus is much less important in affecting device performance. An elaborate Table that comparing the detailed properties of different defects is provided so that both the researchers in experiment and in theory can refer to easily. These results mean that the exclusion of adsorbates in device fabrication is as important as growing high-quality channel material to obtain better device performance.

Author Contributions

Zhe Zhao: Conceptualization, Methodology, Data collection, Writing – original draft. Tao Xiong: Writing – review & editing. Jian Gong and Yue-Yang Liu: Supervision, Writing – review & editing.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Acknowledgements

This work was financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China Grant No. 12004375, in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China Grant No. 62174155, the National Natural Science Foundation of China Grant No. 62004193, the National Natural Science Foundation of China Grant No. 62125404, the Inner Mongolia Natural Science Foundation No. 2023ZD27, and the National Natural Science Foundation of China Grant No. 11964022.

References

  1. [1]K. S. Novoselov, A. Mishchenko, A. Carvalho and A. H. Castro Neto, 2D materials and van der Waals heterostructures, Science (80- .), , DOI:10.1126/science.aac9439.DOI
  2. [2]K. S. Novoselov, A. K. Geim, S. V. Morozov, D. Jiang, M. I. Katsnelson, I. V. Grigorieva, S. V. Dubonos and A. A. Firsov, Two-dimensional gas of massless Dirac fermions in graphene, Nature, 2005, 438, 197–200.DOI
  3. [3]J. Ortiz Balbuena, P. Tutor de Ureta, E. Rivera Ruiz and S. Mellor Pita, Enfermedad de Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada, Med. Clin. (Barc.), 2016, 146, 93–94.DOI
  4. [4]L. Wse, A. Allain and A. Kis, Terms of Use Electron and Hole Mobilities in Single-, ACS Nano. 2014, 7, 7180–7185.
  5. [5]Y. Pan, K. Jia, K. Huang, Z. Wu, G. Bai, J. Yu, Z. Zhang, Q. Zhang and H. Yin, Near-ideal subthreshold swing MoS₂ back-gate transistors with an optimized ultrathin HfO₂ dielectric layer, Nanotechnology, , DOI:10.1088/1361-6528/aaf956.DOI
  6. [6]P. Bolshakov, P. Zhao, A. Azcatl, P. K. Hurley, R. M. Wallace and C. D. Young, Improvement in top-gate MoS₂ transistor performance due to high quality backside Al₂O₃ layer, Appl. Phys. Lett., , DOI:10.1063/1.4995242.DOI
  7. [7]C. Lee, S. Rathi, M. A. Khan, D. Lim, Y. Kim, S. J. Yun, D. H. Youn, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi and G. H. Kim, Comparison of trapped charges and hysteresis behavior in hBN encapsulated single MoS₂ flake based field effect transistors on SiO₂ and hBN substrates, Nanotechnology, , DOI:10.1088/1361-6528/aac6b0.
  8. [8]G. Cassabois, P. Valvin and B. Gil, Hexagonal boron nitride is an indirect bandgap semiconductor, Nat. Photonics, 2016, 10, 262–266.DOI
  9. [9]R. Geick, C. H. Perry and G. Rupprecht, Normal modes in hexagonal boron nitride, Phys. Rev., 1966, 146, 543–547.

Paper details

vlnc:W_xvzpx8zx
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents