betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Vacuum laser acceleration of super-ponderomotive electrons using relativistic transparency injection

Abstract

Intense lasers can accelerate electrons to very high energy over a short distance. Such compact accelerators have several potential applications including fast ignition, high energy physics, and radiography. Among the various schemes of laser-based electron acceleration, vacuum laser acceleration has the merits of super-high acceleration gradient and great simplicity. Yet its realization has been difficult because injecting free electrons into the fast-oscillating laser field is not trivial. Here we demonstrate free-electron injection and subsequent vacuum laser acceleration of electrons up to 20 MeV using the relativistic transparency effect. When a high-contrast intense laser drives a thin solid foil, electrons from the dense opaque plasma are first accelerated to near-light speed by the standing laser wave in front of the solid foil and subsequently injected into the transmitted laser field as the opaque plasma becomes relativistically transparent. It is possible to further optimize the electron injection/acceleration by manipulating the laser polarization, incident angle, and temporal pulse shaping. Our result also sheds new light on the fundamental relativistic transparency process, crucial for producing secondary particle and light sources.

Introduction

Table-top petawatt-class lasers provide a large electric field (>10>10 TV/m) capable of accelerating electrons to near-light speed over a very short distance [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Such compact accelerators have several potential applications including fast ignition, high energy physics, radiography, and secondary ion/neutron sources [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. Existing schemes of laser-based electron acceleration falls into two broad categories: (1) Laser Wakefield Acceleration (LWFA) [13, 14, 15, 16, 17] that uses the wake plasma field (∼10\sim10 GV/m) driven by the laser to accelerate the electrons and (2) Direct or Vacuum Laser Acceleration (DLA or VLA) [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28] where the injected electrons are directly accelerated by the intense laser field (>10> 10 TV/m). Both the VLA and DLA schemes are similar except that in DLA a small plasma field assists the electron acceleration by reducing the electron de-phasing.

In VLA, the laser electric field initially drives the electrons in the transverse direction, and subsequently the Lorentz force (v×Bv \times B) quickly accelerates the electron in the forward direction along the laser beam. VLA normally occurs in free space, where the plasma field effect is either minimized or completely ruled out. The simplicity of the VLA scheme has attracted fundamental interest and extensive studies in the last few decades [21, 29, 30, 31, 32]. However, the grand challenge of VLA lies in how to properly load free electrons into the fast-varying laser field such that the injected electron remains within a given half cycle of the laser wave and sees a unipolar field for continuous acceleration. This requirement necessitates the injected electron to be pre-accelerated close to the speed of light (i.e., the laser speed) before it can be captured and accelerated by the intense laser field. Several schemes have been proposed to facilitate electron injection in VLA, for example, by tailoring the laser profile or using highly charged ions [33, 34]. Nevertheless, clear experimental demonstration of VLA has been difficult [19, 35, 36]. Recently, a breakthrough was made in VLA using a plasma mirror injector accelerating electrons to relativistic energies around 10 MeV [25]. This injector essentially peels the surface electrons off a thick solid plasma mirror upon oblique laser incidence and then injects them into the specularly reflected laser field.

Here we demonstrate VLA of electrons up to 20 MeV using a qualitatively different injection method that exploits the plasma relativistic transparency (RT) effect [37] – where dense opaque plasma becomes transparent to the driving laser due to relativistic electron mass increase – by driving a thin solid foil at normal laser incidence. For thicker foils that remain opaque to the entire duration of the incident laser pulse, the laser-plasma interaction is constrained to the front plasma surface, resulting in the well-known ponderomotive scaling of electron energy [38], ⟨γhot⟩=1+a02/2\langle\gamma_{\mathrm{hot}}\rangle= \sqrt{1 + a_0^2/2}, where ⟨γhot⟩\langle\gamma_{\mathrm{hot}}\rangle is the average Lorentz factor of hot electrons and a0a_0 is the laser strength parameter. In contrast, when the laser interacts with a thin foil, super-ponderomotive electrons can be generated from VLA by using the novel RT effect as the injector. Our experimental results show 20 MeV super-ponderomotive electrons with four times higher flux from thin plastic foils (5 nm thick) undergoing RT injection and subsequent VLA compared to only 10 MeV electrons from thicker foils (thickness 20 nm and above) that remains opaque for the entire laser pulse duration. Therefore, our work not only solves an outstanding problem in VLA by demonstrating a viable injection method, but also provides insight into the electron acceleration in relativistically transparent plasmas which serves as the primary driver for laser-foil based ion accelerators, x-ray source, and relativistic optics [8, 9, 11, 12].

Relativistic transparency injection

The phenomenon of RT occurs when the plasma electrons are heated to near-light speed, increased in their mass, and eventually become unable to shield the plasma quickly from the driving laser [37]. It is nominally achieved as the effective plasma density, ne/⟨γ⟩n_e/\langle\gamma\rangle, drops below the plasma critical density (nc=1.1×1021/λ02 cm−3n_c = 1.1 \times10^{21}/\lambda_0^2\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} with λ0\lambda_0 being the laser wavelength in microns), transforming a classically overdense plasma to be relativistically underdense. In the present work, we identify that the RT effect plays a central role in regulating the VLA as schematically shown in Figure 1(a-Figure 1c). When a high-contrast intense laser is incident on a thin solid foil, it first drives surface electrons from the foil in the laser direction due to the ponderomotive J×BJ \times B heating [39]. The resulting charge separation establishes a sheath field at the rear side of the foil, which acts as a barrier to the electrons and sends them back towards the incoming laser (Figure 1a). Meanwhile, as the dense foil plasma (ne≫ncn_e \gg n_c) reflects the incident laser, a standing wave is formed in the front side of the plasma, where the refluxing electrons undergo a violent stochastic (discussed in detail later) and are again sent towards the target rear side with a large forward momentum. As the interaction advances, the plasma density (nen_e) continues to decrease due to plasma expansion and the electron Lorentz factor ⟨γ⟩\langle\gamma\rangle increases. Near the peak of the laser pulse, the condition for the onset of the RT, ne/γ∼ncn_e/\gamma\sim n_c, is met (Figure 1b). The onset of RT both allows the incident laser to pass through the otherwise overdense plasma and reduces the strength of the sheath field. As such, the stochastically accelerated electrons can easily escape the sheath field barrier and be injected into the transmitted laser field where they undergo phase-stable VLA until leaving the laser pulse radially via ponderomotive scattering (Figure 1c).

Schematic of the vacuum laser acceleration using relativistic transparency injection and experimental setup

Figure 1. Schematic of the vacuum laser acceleration using relativistic transparency injection (a-c) and the experimental setup (d). (a) An intense laser drives a sheath field at the rear side of the target that refluxes the electrons towards the incident laser. (b) The refluxed electrons undergo stochastic acceleration from the laser standing wave at the front of the target and get injected again towards the target rear side. (c) Injected electrons undergo vacuum laser acceleration in the laser field that passes through the target due to relativistic transparency. (d) An ultra-thin nanometer target is irradiated by a 400nm-wavelength, high-contrast, high-intensity laser pulse at normal incidence. An optical fiber, positioned at the laser beam center, collects a small portion of the light reflected from the target. The transmitted laser beam is captured by a calibrated MACOR sheet used as a calorimeter. The electrons, shown by tiny spheres, gain energy while co-propagating with the transmitted laser pulse, as indicated by a change of their color from blue to red. During propagation, the low energy electrons are deflected away from the central laser axis by the ponderomotive force of the transmitted laser pulse. An electron spectrometer measures the kinetic energy spectrum of the on-axis electrons as they pass through a hole in the MACOR sheet. The spatial profile of the electron beam is captured by replacing MACOR with a stack of image-plates (IP-stack).

Experimental results

A schematic of the experimental setup is shown in Figure 1d and the details are described in the Methods. Accessing the RT regime requires both a high-contrast laser pulse to avoid premature target expansion and a relatively lower plasma density than a solid foil to more easily satisfy the RT turn-on condition (ne/⟨γ⟩<n_e/\langle\gamma\rangle< ncn_c). Here, we use a unique frequency-doubled (λ0\lambda_0=400nm) intense laser pulse from the ALEPH petawatt laser facility at the Colorado State University (CSU) [40] to access the RT regime. The frequency-doubling both sharply increases the laser contrast and decreases the effective plasma density seen by the laser; a plastic foil has an initial target density of 280ncn_c at λ0\lambda_0=800nm whereas it is only 70ncn_c at 400nm (4× lower).

To verify the high-contrast interaction, the back-reflected laser light is monitored (Figure 1d and also supplemented Fig. S1). The associated spectra are indicative of the dynamics of the plasma critical surface before the onset of RT, as they encode the motion of the critical surface relative to the driving laser. Initially, the plasma expands toward the incident laser causing a blue-shift to the reflected light. As the laser intensity increases and the plasma density decreases, the plasma critical surface is driven away from the laser imprinting a red-shift [37]. Overall, the spectra are significantly broadened as confirmed in Figure 1d. Most prominently, little difference is found in the spectra by varying the foil thickness. This result demonstrates negligible pre-pulse effects and the interaction of the main pulse with a high-density plasma even for the thinnest 5 nm target.

The fast electron spectra from the opaque foils (thickness of 20nm to 200nm) show a similar temperature of 3.8 +/- 0.5 MeV and cut-off energy of 10-12 MeV (the grey region in Figure 2a). In contrast, the partially transparent 5nm foils (transmitted laser energy 10-20% with the spread induced by thickness uncertainty of the thinnest targets) result in much hotter fast electrons up to 20 MeV with an electron temperature of 6.1 +/- 0.5 MeV. A similar contrast also appears in the transverse beam profile of the accelerated electrons. The 200nm opaque foil produces a more uniform electron beam profile (Figure 2d) with a 20-degree FWHM and a slight elongation along the laser polarization axis (Figure 2b), whereas a distinct doughnut-shaped beam profile is observed for the 5nm thick foil (Figure 2c and Figure 2e). The FWHM of the doughnut hole is about 30 degrees (white circle in Figure 2c and lineout in Figure 2e), consistent with the F/2 off-axis-parabola laser beam size. This coincidence indicates that the doughnut-shaped beam profile may be related to ponderomotive scattering from the transmitted laser pulse.

Spectral and spatial influence of transparency on MeV electrons

Figure 2. Spectral and spatial influence of transparency on MeV electrons. (a) The kinetic energy spectrum of electrons is recorded on-axis for different target thickness. The grey shaded region shows the spectral bounds from all opaque targets (20 to 2000 nm thick). The angular profile of the electron beam recorded on the third layer of the image plates (energy >1> 1 MeV), in a plane perpendicular to the laser propagation direction, is shown for (b) the opaque 200 nm and (c) partially transparent 5 nm targets. The black squares in the center of (b, c) represent the acceptance window of the electron spectrometer, and the vertical arrows indicate the laser polarization direction. The white dotted circle in (c) represents the size of the transmitted laser beam. (d) and (e) show lineouts of corresponding electron beam profiles taken along the black horizontal lines in (b) and (c). The dashed curves in (d, e) represent Gaussian fits to the solid curves.

Using simultaneous measurements of the transmitted laser energy and electron spectrum, we obtain a direct correlation between the fast electron heating and the amount of laser transmission. At 10%-20% transmission, the maximum electron energy quickly rises to ~22MeV, a factor of two higher than from the opaque targets (Fig. 3a). A similar trend is also observed for the integrated electron flux in the 6-20MeV range (Fig. 3b), which increases by a factor of four as compared to the opaque regime.

Modeling of the experimental results

To understand the dynamics of electron acceleration in the RT regime, we perform particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations using the SMILEI code [41]. The two-dimensional (2D) simulations adopting experiment-like conditions show qualitatively the same physics of electron acceleration for 5∼305\mathord{\sim}30 nm foils despite varying amounts of laser transmission (see supplemented Fig. S3). Here we take the 20nm and 200nm cases as representative of the RT and opaque regime, respectively. In both cases, the electron density (nen_e) first rises due to the radiation pressure compression[42, 43] followed by a continuous drop as the foil undergoes expansion (Figure 4a). Comparing to the effective density (ne/⟨γ⟩n_e/\langle\gamma\rangle), however, the thicker 200nm case shows only marginal drop, indicating limited bulk electron heating. This latter point is illustrated in Figure 4c by a snapshot of the cell-averaged ⟨γ⟩\langle\gamma\rangle at t=10T0t = 10T_0 (T0T_0 being the laser cycle), where the electron heating is constrained to the front surface with the foil bulk being largely cold. For this 200nm case, the foil stays opaque throughout the 50 fs driving laser by retaining ne/⟨γ⟩>20ncn_e/\langle\gamma\rangle> 20n_c at t=50T0t=50T_0, the end of the laser interaction.

Relativistic transparency versus opaque regime with 2D PIC simulations

Figure 4. Relativistic transparency versus opaque regime with 2D PIC simulations. (a) Temporal evolution of maximum on-axis electron density (both normal density nen_\mathrm{e} and effective density ne/⟨γ⟩n_\mathrm{e}/\langle\gamma\rangle) for laser-driven 20 nm and 200 nm foils. The driving laser is 100T0100T_0 long and t=0t=0 refers to the arrival of the laser peak at the initial target position. (b) The resulting electron energy spectra at the simulation end, obtained from a virtual detector placed 35λ035\lambda_0 behind the foil. The acceptance width is limited to Δy=2λ0\Delta y=2\lambda_0 around the central laser axis. (c, d) Snapshots of electron density at t=10T0t=10T_0 for the 200 nm and 20 nm case, respectively. Also overlaid in (c) is cell-averaged γ\gamma of all electrons and in (d) instantaneous γ\gamma for fast electrons acquiring a maximum px/mec>25p_x/m_\mathrm{e}c>25 during the interaction. The right panels of (c, d) are the angular beam profile obtained at the simulation end on the same detector (but without yy limitation) as for (b).

In contrast, the thinner 20nm foil nearly matches the condition, d≤a0πncneλ0d \leq\frac{a_0}{\pi}\frac{n_c}{n_e}\lambda_0, for the radiation pressure acceleration[44], where a0a_0 is the laser amplitude. Consequently, the foil center including both electrons and ions is pushed more efficiently from its initial position. Direct laser heating of the resulting bowed plasma surface then leads to rapid foil expansion causing the sharp density drop around t=−15T0t=-15T_0 (Figure 4a). Most prominently, this trend is greatly amplified by the relativistic ⟨γ⟩\langle\gamma\rangle-correction arising from the strong heating (compare the red lines), and the RT quickly sets in as the condition ne/⟨γ⟩nc<1n_e/\langle\gamma\rangle n_c < 1 is reached at t=−5T0t=-5T_0, shortly before the arrival of the laser peak. The plasma becomes classically underdense (ne/nc<1n_e/n_c < 1) in another 35 laser cycles, during which the laser transmits through the plasma and drives a significant portion of electrons that co-propagate with the pulse (Figure 4d). As we shall see, these electrons are responsible for the greatly extended energy spectrum (Figure 4b) and the doughnut-shaped profile as opposed to that from the opaque regime (right panels of Figure 4c and Figure 4d). These major imprints of the distinct interaction regimes are in good agreement with the experimental observations (Figure 2).

Overview of electron acceleration in the relativistic transparency regime

Next, we discuss electron acceleration in the RT regime in more detail by tracking representative electrons from the simulation. The resulting trajectories (Figure 5a) show that the strongest acceleration (colors turn red) occurs away from the initial foil position (x>25λ0x > 25\lambda_0). This is an indication of VLA [18, 25] by the transmitted laser pulse as the plasma sheath field lags due to the slow ion motion. The trajectories also reveal deflections from the central laser axis (y=20λ0y = 20\lambda_0), inversely correlated to their final energy gain. This phenomenon explains our on-axis (acceptance angle 50 μ\muSr) electron spectrometer measurements which missed many of the deflected electrons in the RT regime and accordingly recorded a lower flux in the energy range below 8 MeV (Figure 2a and Fig. 4b).

Multi-stage electron acceleration in the relativistic transparency regime

Figure 5. Multi-stage electron acceleration in the relativistic transparency regime. (a) Trajectories of the electrons that acquire a maximum px/mec>35p_x/m_e c > 35 in laser-driven 20 nm foil, with colors representing instantaneous energy variation. (b) Corresponding phase-space (px−xp_x - x) trajectories with the inset providing a closer look around the initial foil position (x=20λ0x = 20\lambda_0). (c) Temporal evolution of pxp_x and experienced Ex,EyE_x, E_y fields for a selected electron (blue line in b). We have also checked with a lower threshold pxmax⁡/mec>25p_x^{\max}/m_e c > 25 (e.g., in Figure 4d), which results in similar dynamics except for greatly more particles. This latter condition almost covers the entire extended-spectrum (Figure 4b), thus the presented dynamics is representative of the observed fast electrons.

Displayed as the phase-space of pxp_x versus xx (Figure 5b), all the tracked electrons strikingly follow the same dynamics despite the spread in their final energy gain. The full dynamics may be divided into (1) a phase-space rotation around the foil (including refluxing and foil front acceleration), (2) a brief deceleration as electrons escape the rear sheath barrier, and (3) a final injection and acceleration in the transmitted laser pulse, as labeled in Figure 5b. When the laser interacts with the foil, the J×BJ \times B heating[39] first drives electrons into the target. Some of them may return to the front side after bouncing off the resulting sheath (charge-separation) field. The refluxed electrons get accelerated again in front of the foil (detailed below), thus closing the loop of the phase-space rotation. Before the onset of RT, electrons may undergo several cycles of rotation but gain no further acceleration in the rear side with the transmitted laser field yet to appear. Therefore, the presented cycle of rotation leading to the enhanced acceleration must be near the onset of RT. By checking the temporal information of a typical electron (blue line in Figure 5b) as shown in Figure 5c, the reflux is indeed initiated shortly before the laser starts to transmit through (t=−5T0t = -5T_0 as explained in Figure 4a).

Stochastic electron acceleration in front of the foil and RT injection

The ensuing sharp reversal of pxp_x in front of the foil (Figure 5b) is found to be mainly caused by the interfering incident and plasma-reflected laser pulses. Test-particle simulations (see the Methods for details) reveal that the acceleration in the standing laser wave depends critically on the laser amplitude, the injection momentum, and injection time/phase while being less dependent on detailed laser spatiotemporal profile, the plasma sheath field, as well as minor spectral shifts of the reflected pulse. More specifically, the electron phase-space dynamics evolve around the closed orbits (blue buckets in Figure 6a) arising from the ponderomotive force of the standing wave. Such buckets mapped out by actual electron trajectories can be clearly seen in both the test-particle (Figure 6b) and PIC results (inset of Figure 5b). For injection px0p_{x0} smaller than the bucket height (magenta line in Figure 6a), the electrons leave the standing wave after a half-cycle rotation due to the blocking foil. This type of dynamics is responsible for the normal J×BJ \times B heating, generating electron pulses at every half cycle. For px0p_{x0} beyond the bucket height (red/green lines), the electrons can penetrate deeper into the left. Some of them (red) may be temporarily trapped away from the foil, whereas others (green) continue to wander around the buckets, resulting in the sharp acceleration at the foil front. For even larger px0p_{x0} (cyan), the electrons may not be trapped by any buckets but simply form backward ejections.

Stochastic acceleration in front of the foil identified with test-particle simulation and Poincare-map analysis

Figure 6. Stochastic acceleration in front of the foil identified with test-particle simulation and Poincare-map analysis. (a) Schematic of typical phase-space trajectories of the refluxing electrons (px<0p_x < 0) that are injected into the standing laser wave formed in front of the foil. (b) Similar trajectories were obtained from a test-particle simulation. A group of 200 electrons is injected at x=0x = 0 with uniformly distributed px0=[−12,−4]mecp_{x0} = [-12, -4]m_{\mathrm{e}}c (red line). The injection time is randomly sampled over the first T0/2T_0/2. To mimic the laser fields close to the transparency point, the laser wave takes a time delay of td=−40T0t_d = -40T_0. (c) Poincare map of the same electron dynamics (pxp_x versus ξ1\xi_1) displayed periodically at the surface of the section ξ=ξ1+ξ2=2Nπ\xi= \xi_1 + \xi_2 = 2N\pi where ξ1\xi_1 and ξ2\xi_2 are the phase of the incident and reflected laser, respectively. (d) Maximum pxp_x achievable via the stochastic acceleration (red circles) versus laser amplitude with the latter also mapped to the timing of the onset of relativistic transparency. The solid line is a linear fitting to the circles. See the Methods for more details of the simulation setup and analysis.

To further clarify the acceleration mechanism, we transform these dynamics into a Poincare map (Figure 6c), where two sets of electrons are initialized. The electrons with smaller px0p_{x0} (red dots) become quickly dispersed after just one laser cycle, indicating the onset of stochasticity. That is, these electrons may be randomly accelerated to any point of the area in a few laser cycles. In contrast, the electrons with much larger px0p_{x0} (black dots) show only regular traces underneath the stochastic area with pxp_x being kept negative. Therefore, the sharp pxp_x reversal to positive values as found in the simulations must be caused by the stochastic acceleration [45]. At relativistic laser intensities, even the normal J×BJ \times B heating could be stochastic if it were not terminated by the blocking foil. The phase dependence of the acceleration can be illustrated by the blue dots (Figure 6c) with a π/2\pi/2 shift in the injection phase; despite having similar px0p_{x0} with the red dots, they share the same regular motion as the black dots (thus not shown). We have found numerically that the maximum pxp_x achievable via the stochastic acceleration scales linearly with the laser amplitude (Figure 6d), giving px/mec∼20p_x/m_e c \sim20 at a=5a = 5. This result accounts for about 75% of the front-side acceleration as observed in the PIC simulation, with the rest coming from the accelerating sheath field at the front surface (see Figure 5c for the relative weights of ExE_x and EyE_y during t=[−10,−4]T0t = [-10, -4]T_0). Moreover, the short timescale involved suggests that the laser amplitude can be mapped to the timing of the onset of RT (Figure 6d), which predicts strongest front-side acceleration if the RT is induced near the laser peak.

Vacuum laser acceleration in the transmitted laser pulse

The sharp front-side acceleration ensures that the electrons retain a positive pxp_x after briefly traversing the plasma-sheath barrier in the rear side. Indeed, nearly all of the tracked electrons in the PIC simulation have minimum px>10mecp_x > 10m_e c at x∼23λ0x \sim23\lambda_0 (Figure 5b). The residual pxp_x favors subsequent injection into the transmitted laser pulse by reducing the electron-laser dephasing rate [46]. As a result, the electrons experience a slow-varying laser field EyE_y in the rear space of vanished plasma field ExE_x (red/green lines in Figure 5c at t>0t>0). Such phase-locked acceleration of all tracked electrons is revealed by plotting electron trajectories in the co-moving laser frame, x−ctx - ct (Figure 7a). Electrons stream from right to left in this frame and substantial energy gain only happens after the onset of RT (vertical line). Importantly, the accelerations complete in just half laser wavelengths (Figure 7b) despite tens of wavelengths propagation in the lab frame (Figure 5a). The ponderomotive deflection angle is related to the specific laser phase into which the electrons are injected and overall displays up-down symmetry by integrating over many laser cycles (see also Figure 4d). Also depending on the injection condition, the acceleration spreads widely over the latter half of the laser pulse (x−ct<−50T0x - ct < -50T_0). Nevertheless, more quantitative insight into the vacuum laser acceleration[18, 25] can be obtained by relating the energy gain to their injection momenta. Figure 7c shows the analytical result for a plane-wave laser of a0=1a_0 = 1, where the smaller laser amplitude (than incident laser a0=5a_0 = 5) is used to account for the rapid laser diffraction as well as the ponderomotive deflection that prevents electrons from fully exploiting the laser fields. As a comparison, the corresponding simulation result by taking (px0,py0)(p_{x0}, p_{y0}) at x=23λ0x = 23\lambda_0 (Figure 7d) shows good agreement with Figure 7c, not only in the pattern of pxp_x gains but also in the peculiar triangular distribution of (px0,py0)(p_{x0}, p_{y0}) that favors strong acceleration.

Electron acceleration in the transmitted laser pulse

Figure 7. Electron acceleration in the transmitted laser pulse. (a) Trajectories of the same set of electrons are shown in Figure 5 but displayed now in the co-moving frame of the laser. (b) Zoom-in of the rectangular area marked out in (a). The background shows the laser electric field. (c) Analytical maximum pxp_x achieved in vacuum plane-wave laser acceleration versus initial injection momenta (px0p_{x0}, py0p_{y0}) for normalized laser amplitude of a0=1a_0=1. (d) The same type of distribution as (c), but obtained for the tracked particles shown in (a).

Outlook

We have presented an elegant method to inject near-light speed electrons into a relativistic laser pulse and demonstrated clear evidence of VLA using the novel RT effect of laser-foil interaction. This method results in 10s MeV super-ponderomotive electrons, and the energy could be much higher by scaling to higher laser intensities. The scaling is expected to work because the RT effect is ubiquitous as long as the laser-plasma conditions are properly matched[12, 37] and the VLA bears almost linear dependence with the laser intensity [18, 33]. It thus implies great flexibility in optimization of the RT-injection based VLA by manipulating the laser polarization, incident angle, and spatiotemporal profile, as well as the plasma conditions. We hope the present work will stimulate considerable interest in VLA demonstration and optimization. Finally, the detailed dynamics of fast electrons uncovered in this work offers a unique viewpoint of the RT process which is normally difficult to probe via conventional optical methods [37]. These new understandings will be crucial for further development in intense laser interaction with thin foils and associated secondary particle and photon sources.

Methods

Experimental setup. The experiment was performed using the PW laser at the Advanced Beam Laboratory of CSU. The fundamental (λ0=800\lambda_0 = 800 nm) laser beam is frequency-doubled in a 0.8 mm thick type-1 KDP crystal of 10J maximum energy, which drastically improves the temporal contrast from 5×10−65 \times10^{-6} to 10−1210^{-12} at -25ps. The resulting 400nm pulse of 50fs duration is separated from the fundamental beam by using a sequence of five dichroic mirrors (99.9 % reflective @ 400 nm and 99.5 % transmissive @ 800 nm) and then focused by an f/2f/2 off-axis-parabolic (OAP) dielectric mirror onto the target at near-normal incidence (Figure 1). The OAP focal spot is measured, both at low and full laser power levels, to be less than 2 μ\mum using a magnified long-working-distance objective lens coupled to a CCD camera. Before each shot, the target is imaged using the same objective camera to ensure precise positioning at the laser focal plane. The targets are mainly Formvar films (5 nm to 2000 nm thick), purchased from Electron Microscopy Science (EMS). A small fraction of the laser light back-reflected from the target is captured by an optical fiber sitting in the central part of the laser beam. The optical fiber is tapered to minimize degradation in the focal spot quality of the laser. The transmitted laser pulse is monitored by an imaging camera looking at a Ceramic (MACOR) sheet kept along the laser axis. The imaging system is calibrated by firing the laser pulse in a vacuum without targets. The MACOR calibration is found to be linear for laser energy up to 3J. A hole of 7 mm diameter is made at the center of the MACOR sheet to perform simultaneous spectral measurement of onaxis electrons using a magnetic spectrometer. The spectrometer positioned at a distance of 50 cm from the target has a 2 mm×\times2 mm sized aperture (made of 12.7 mm thick Stainless steel) and hence a collection angle of about 50 μ\muSr. The angular distribution of all fast electrons including those deflected beyond the hole/spectrometer is measured separately using a multi-layer image plate (BAS-IP MS), shielded with a 220 μ\mum thick Cu foil to block low-energy x-rays, ions, and electrons.

Particle-in-cell simulations. The 2D SMILEI simulations have a box dimension of 60λ0×40λ060\lambda_0 \times40\lambda_0 divided into 12000 ×\times 1600 cells along the laser propagation axis xx and transverse axis yy, respectively. The foil consisted of fully ionized carbon ions (10nc10n_c), protons (10nc10n_c) and electrons (70nc70n_c) is initially placed at x=20λ0x = 20\lambda_0 with the ion species sampled by 100 macro-particles per cell (ppc) and electron species by 400 ppc. Fourth-order interpolation and isotropic temperatures of 10 eV are applied to all species. A p-polarized laser (electric field along yy) is launched from the left box edge with a peak intensity 2.14×10202.14 \times10^{20} W/cm2^2, corresponding to a0=5a_0 = 5 for λ0=400\lambda_0 = 400 nm. The laser field takes sine-squared temporal profile with full duration 100T0100T_0 and Gaussian transverse profile of spot radius 3λ03\lambda_0. A virtual detector placed 35λ035\lambda_0 behind the foil is used to collect accelerated particles. The convergence of the simulations is tested against doubling the spatiotemporal resolution as well as the total particle number. A full 3D simulation for the 20 nm foil case is also performed which confirms the 2D p-polarization result with very close laser transmission and electron acceleration.

Test-particle simulation and Poincare-map analysis. The simulation solves the electron dynamics by directly integrating the relativistic equations of motion: dp⃗/dt=−E⃗−p⃗/γ×B⃗d\vec{p}/dt = -\vec{E} - \vec{p}/\gamma\times\vec{B}, dr⃗/dt=p⃗/γd\vec{r}/dt = \vec{p}/\gamma, dγ/dt=−E⃗⋅p⃗/γd\gamma/dt = -\vec{E} \cdot\vec{p}/\gamma, where the vectors denote the three Cartesian components and the quantities are normalized as p→mecp \rightarrow m_e c, r→c/ω0r \rightarrow c/\omega_0, t→1/ω0t \rightarrow1/\omega_0, E→meω0c/eE \rightarrow m_e\omega_0c/e, B→meω0/eB \rightarrow m_e\omega_0/e. A perfect light reflector is defined at x=0 to mimic the foil before the onset of RT. As a result, the laser fields in front of the foil (x<0) include the incident laser Ey1=Bz1=−af1(t)g(r)cos⁡(t−x−td+ϕ1)E_{y1} = B_{z1} = -a f_1(t)g(r)\cos(t - x - t_d + \phi_1) and the reflected laser Ey2=−Bz2=−af2(t)g(r)cos⁡[ω2(t+x)−td+ϕ2]E_{y2} = -B_{z2} = -a f_2(t)g(r)\cos[\omega_2(t + x) - t_d + \phi_2], where f1(t)=sin⁡2[π(t−x−td)/τ]×[H2(t−x−τ−td)−H(x)]f_1(t) = \sin^2[\pi(t - x - t_d)/\tau] \times[H_2(t - x - \tau- t_d) - H(x)], f2(t)=sin⁡2[π(t+x−td)/τ]×[H(t+x−td)−H(x)]f_2(t) = \sin^2[\pi(t + x - t_d)/\tau] \times[H(t + x - t_d) - H(x)], g(r)=exp⁡[−(y2+z2)/σ2]g(r) = \exp[-(y^2 + z^2)/\sigma^2] define the temporal and spatial profiles, HH is the Heaviside step function, H2=1−HH_2 = 1 - H, ω2\omega_2 is the angular frequency of the reflected laser normalized to that of the incident laser, and the initial phases satisfy ϕ2=ϕ1+π\phi_2 = \phi_1 + \pi. The pulse duration τ\tau and spot radius σ\sigma follow that of the PIC simulation. The parameter tdt_d introduces a time delay for the incident laser to arrive at the foil, thus td<0t_d < 0 means the laser has impinged on the foil for a period of ∣td∣|t_d|. To obtain the Poincare map shown in Figure 6c, we transform the independent variable of the above equations of motion from tt to ξ=ξ1+ξ2\xi= \xi_1 + \xi_2 where ξ1=t−x+ϕ1\xi_1 = t - x + \phi_1 and ξ2=ω2(t+x)+ϕ2\xi_2 = \omega_2(t + x) + \phi_2 are the phase of the incident and reflected laser, respectively. The resulting equations of motion become

dp⃗dξ=(−E⃗−p⃗γ×B⃗)dξ/dt,dγdξ=(−E⃗⋅p⃗γ)dξ/dt,dξ1dξ=1−px/γdξ/dt,\frac{d\vec{p}}{d\xi} = \frac{\left(-\vec{E} - \frac{\vec{p}}{\gamma} \times\vec{B}\right)}{d\xi/dt},\quad\frac{d\gamma}{d\xi} = \frac{\left(-\vec{E} \cdot\frac{\vec{p}}{\gamma}\right)}{d\xi/dt},\quad\frac{d\xi_1}{d\xi} = \frac{1-p_x/\gamma}{d\xi/dt},
dξ2dξ=ω2(1+px/γ)dξ/dt\frac{d\xi_2}{d\xi} = \frac{\omega_2(1+p_x/\gamma)}{d\xi/dt}

and are solved only at periodic ξ=2Nπ\xi= 2N\pi where

dξdt=(1−px/γ)+ω2(1+px/γ).\frac{d\xi}{dt} = (1-p_x/\gamma) + \omega_2(1+p_x/\gamma).

Acknowledgments

The research was supported by the Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) Program of Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) under the project 20190124ER and partially by LANL Science Campaign-3. This research used resources provided by the Los Alamos National Laboratory Institutional Computing Program, which is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration under Contract No. 89233218CNA000001. The experiments were conducted at the CSU ALEPH laser facility supported by the US Department of Energy LaserNet US grant DE-SC-0019076. CSU researchers acknowledge the support of AFOSR award FA9550-17-1-0278. We also thank Juan C. Fernandez for useful discussions.

Author Contributions

P.K.S and F.Y.L. contributed equally to this work. S.P. designed the experiment. S.P., C.K.H., and J.R. provided the overall guidance of the project. P.K.S., A.M., and R.H. carried out the experiment with support from S.W., Y.W., and H.S. F.Y.L. performed the numerical simulations and clarified the acceleration mechanism with inputs from C.K.H., P.K.S., and S.P. The manuscript was prepared by P.K.S., F.Y.L., S.P., and C.K.H., and reviewed by all authors.

Competing financial interests

The authors declare no competing financial interests.

Palaniyappan, S., et al., Efficient quasi-monoenergetic ion beams from laser-driven relativistic plasmas. Nature communications, 2015. 6(1): p. 1-12.

Yin, L., et al., Three-Dimensional Dynamics of Breakout Afterburner Ion Acceleration Using High-Contrast Short-Pulse Laser and Nanoscale Targets. Physical Review Letters, 2011. 107(4).

Maximum electron energy and electron flux as a function of laser transmission

Figure 3.

Image not extracted

Figure 3 (PDF p. 15). Transparency dependent electron acceleration. (a) Maximum electron energy and (b) total electron flux per μSr\mu\mathrm{Sr} for energy greater than 6 MeV as a function of laser-transmission ratio.

References

  1. [1]Esarey, E., C. Schroeder, and W. Leemans, Physics of laser-driven plasma-based electron accelerators. Reviews of modern physics, 2009. 81(3): p. 1229.DOI
  2. [2]Tajima, T., X. Yan, and T. Ebisuzaki, Wakefield acceleration. Reviews of Modern Plasma Physics, 2020. 4(1): p. 1-72.DOI
  3. [3]Hooker, S.M., Developments in laser-driven plasma accelerators. Nature Photonics, 2013. 7(10): p. 775-782.DOI
  4. [4]Malka, V., Laser plasma accelerators. Physics of Plasmas, 2012. 19(5): p. 055501.
  5. [5]Joshi, C., S. Corde, and W. Mori, Perspectives on the generation of electron beams from plasma-based accelerators and their near and long term applications. Physics of Plasmas, 2020. 27(7): p. 070602.
  6. [6]Tabak, M., et al., Review of progress in fast ignition. Physics of Plasmas, 2005. 12(5): p. 057305.
  7. [7]Palaniyappan, S., et al., MeV bremsstrahlung X rays from intense laser interaction with solid foils. Laser and Particle Beams, 2018. 36(LA-UR-18-25214).DOI
  8. [8]Palaniyappan, S., et al., Efficient quasi-monoenergetic ion beams from laser-driven relativistic plasmas. Nature communications, 2015. 6(1): p. 1-12.DOI
  9. [9]Yin, L., et al., Three-Dimensional Dynamics of Breakout Afterburner Ion Acceleration Using High-Contrast Short-Pulse Laser and Nanoscale Targets. Physical Review Letters, 2011. 107(4).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21867015
  10. [10]Jung, D., et al., Laser-driven 1 GeV carbon ions from preheated diamond targets in the break-out afterburner regime. Physics of plasmas, 2013. 20(8): p. 083103.DOI
  11. [11]Roth, M., et al. Ultra-bright laser-driven neutron source. in APS Division of Plasma Physics Meeting Abstracts. 2015.
  12. [12]Higginson, A., et al., Near-100 MeV protons via a laser-driven transparency-enhanced hybrid acceleration scheme. Nature communications, 2018. 9(1): p. 1-9.DOI
  13. [13]Mangles, S.P., et al., Monoenergetic beams of relativistic electrons from intense laser–plasma interactions. Nature, 2004. 431(7008): p. 535-538.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15457251
  14. [14]Faure, J., et al., A laser–plasma accelerator producing monoenergetic electron beams. Nature, 2004. 431(7008): p. 541-544.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15457253
  15. [15]Geddes, C., et al., High-quality electron beams from a laser wakefield accelerator using plasma-channel guiding. Nature, 2004. 431(7008): p. 538-541.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15457252
  16. [16]Faure, J., et al., Controlled injection and acceleration of electrons in plasma wakefields by colliding laser pulses. Nature, 2006. 444(7120): p. 737-739.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17151663
  17. [17]Tajima, T. and J.M. Dawson, Laser electron accelerator. Physical Review Letters, 1979. 43(4): p. 267.DOI
  18. [18]Esarey, E., P. Sprangle, and J. Krall, Laser acceleration of electrons in vacuum. Physical Review E, 1995. 52(5): p. 5443.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9964041
  19. [19]Malka, G., E. Lefebvre, and J. Miquel, Experimental observation of electrons accelerated in vacuum to relativistic energies by a high-intensity laser. Physical review letters, 1997. 78(17): p. 3314.DOI
  20. [20]Cline, D., et al., First Observation of Acceleration of Electrons by a Laser in a Vacuum. 2013.DOI
  21. [21]Quesnel, B. and P. Mora, Theory and simulation of the interaction of ultraintense laser pulses with electrons in vacuum. Physical Review E, 1998. 58(3): p. 3719.DOI
  22. [22]Arefiev, A., A. Robinson, and V. Khudik, Novel aspects of direct laser acceleration of relativistic electrons. Journal of Plasma Physics, 2015. 81(4).DOI
  23. [23]Gahn, C., et al., Multi-MeV electron beam generation by direct laser acceleration in high-density plasma channels. Physical Review Letters, 1999. 83(23): p. 4772.DOI
  24. [24]Arefiev, A., et al., Beyond the ponderomotive limit: Direct laser acceleration of relativistic electrons in sub-critical plasmas. Physics of Plasmas, 2016. 23(5): p. 056704.DOI
  25. [25]Thévenet, M., et al., Vacuum laser acceleration of relativistic electrons using plasma mirror injectors. Nature Physics, 2016. 12(4): p. 355-360.
  26. [26]Sprangle, P., et al., Vacuum Laser Acceleration. 1995, NAVAL RESEARCH LAB WASHINGTON DC.
  27. [27]Liu, Y., D. Cline, and P. He, Vacuum laser acceleration using a radially polarized CO2 laser beam. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1999. 424(2-3): p. 296-303.DOI
  28. [28]Pukhov, A., Z.-M. Sheng, and J. Meyer-ter-Vehn, Particle acceleration in relativistic laser channels. Physics of Plasmas, 1999. 6(7): p. 2847-2854.DOI
  29. [29]Hartemann, F., et al., Nonlinear ponderomotive scattering of relativistic electrons by an intense laser field at focus. Physical Review E, 1995. 51(5): p. 4833.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9963196
  30. [30]Wang, J., et al., High-intensity laser-induced electron acceleration in vacuum. Physical Review E, 1999. 60(6): p. 7473.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11970695
  31. [31]Salamin, Y.I., F.H. Faisal, and C.H. Keitel, Exact analysis of ultrahigh laser-induced acceleration of electrons by cyclotron autoresonance. Physical Review A, 2000. 62(5): p. 053809.DOI
  32. [32]Wong, L.J. and F.X. Kärtner, Direct acceleration of an electron in infinite vacuum by a pulsed radially-polarized laser beam. Optics express, 2010. 18(24): p. 25035-25051.DOI
  33. [33]Salamin, Y.I. and C.H. Keitel, Electron acceleration by a tightly focused laser beam. Physical review letters, 2002. 88(9): p. 095005.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11864020
  34. [34]Hu, S. and A.F. Starace, GeV electrons from ultraintense laser interaction with highly charged ions. Physical review letters, 2002. 88(24): p. 245003.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12059309
  35. [35]DiChiara, A., et al., Relativistic MeV photoelectrons from the single atom response of argon to a 10 19 W/cm 2 laser field. Physical review letters, 2008. 101(17): p. 173002.
  36. [36]Braenzel, J., et al., Amplification of relativistic electron bunches by acceleration in laser fields. Physical review letters, 2017. 118(1): p. 014801.DOI
  37. [37]Palaniyappan, S., et al., Dynamics of relativistic transparency and optical shuttering in expanding overdense plasmas. Nature Physics, 2012. 8: p. 763-769.DOI
  38. [38]Wilks, S., et al., Absorption of ultra-intense laser pulses. Physical review letters, 1992. 69(9): p. 1383.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10047203
  39. [39]Kruer, W. and K. Estabrook, Jx B heating by very intense laser light. The Physics of fluids, 1985. 28(1): p. 430-432.DOI
  40. [40]Wang, Y., et al., 0.85 PW laser operation at 3.3 Hz and high-contrast ultrahigh-intensity λ = 400 nm second-harmonic beamline. Optics Letters, 2017. 42(19): p. 3828-3831.DOI
  41. [41]Derouillat, J., et al., Smilei: A collaborative, open-source, multi-purpose particle-in-cell code for plasma simulation. Computer Physics Communications, 2018. 222: p. 351-373.
  42. [42]Macchi, A., M. Borghesi, and M. Passoni, Ion acceleration by superintense laser-plasma interaction. Reviews of Modern Physics, 2013. 85(2): p. 751-793.DOI
  43. [43]Robinson, A.P.L., et al., Radiation pressure acceleration of thin foils with circularly polarized laser pulses. New Journal of Physics, 2008. 10(1): p. 013021.DOI
  44. [44]Vshivkov, V.A., et al., Nonlinear electrodynamics of the interaction of ultra-intense laser pulses with a thin foil. Physics of Plasmas, 1998. 5(7): p. 2727-2741.DOI
  45. [45]Sheng, Z.-M., et al., Stochastic heating and acceleration of electrons in colliding laser fields in plasma. Physical review letters, 2002. 88(5): p. 055004.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11863737
  46. [46]Arefiev, A.V., et al., Parametric amplification of laser-driven electron acceleration in underdense plasma. Physical review letters, 2012. 108(14): p. 145004.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22540801

Paper details

vlnc:W_y2pzt6hm
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents