betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Incorporating the weak mixing angle dependence to reconcile the neutron skin measurement on 208Pb by PREX-II

Abstract

The only available electroweak measurement of the 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} neutron skin, ΔRnpΔR_{\rm{np}}, performed by the PREX-II Collaboration through polarized electron-lead scattering, shows a mild tension with respect to both the theoretical nuclear-model predictions and a host of measurements. However, the dependence on the weak mixing angle should be incorporated in the calculation, since its low-energy value is experimentally poorly known. We first repeat the PREX-II analysis confirming their measurement by fixing the weak mixing angle to its standard model value. Then, we show the explicit dependence of the PREX-II measurement on the weak mixing angle, obtaining that it is fully degenerate with the neutron skin. To break this degeneracy, we exploit the weak mixing angle measurement from atomic parity violation on lead, obtaining a slightly thinner neutron skin but with about doubled uncertainties, possibly easing the PREX tension. Relying on the theoretical prediction, ΔRnpth≈0.13−0.19 fmΔR_{\rm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}}\approx 0.13-0.19\ \mathrm{fm}, and using it as a prior in the fit, we find a weak mixing angle value about 1.2σ1.2σ smaller than the standard model prediction. Thus, we suggest a possible solution of the PREX-II tension by showing that, considering its underlying dependence on the weak mixing angle, the PREX-II neutron skin determination could be in agreement with the other available measurements and predictions if the weak mixing angle at the proper energy scale is smaller than the standard model prediction.

Introduction

Introduction.— The neutron skin, ΔRnp≡Rn−Rp\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}} \equiv R_{\mathrm{n}}-R_{\mathrm{p}}, of a nucleus quantifies the difference between the neutron and the proton nuclear distribution radii, RnR_{\mathrm{n}} and RpR_{\mathrm{p}}, respectively. Polarized electron-nucleus scattering happens through both the weak and the electromagnetic currents, therefore it provides an interesting way to assess the nuclear structure. Indeed, it is possible to isolate the weak interaction contribution, which strongly depends on the neutron nuclear density, from the electromagnetic one, which mainly probes the already highly-tested proton nuclear density.

Recently, the PREX-II Collaboration released their new measurement of the lead neutron skin through polarized electron-lead scattering, namely ΔRnpPREX−II(208Pb)=0.278±0.078\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{PREX-II}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 0.278 \pm0.078 fm [1], after a previous less precise measurement, ΔRnpPREX−I(208Pb)=0.30±0.18\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{PREX-I}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 0.30 \pm0.18 fm [2, 3]. The combination of these results leads to ΔRnpPREX,comb(208Pb)=0.283±0.071\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{PREX,comb}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 0.283 \pm0.071 fm [1] indicating a preference for relatively large values of the skin. In particular, our analysis is focused on the PREX-II measurement, which is significantly more precise.

The PREX-II measurement is in tension with the other available determinations, such as those coming from electric-dipole polarizability [4, 5, 6], antiprotonic atoms [7, 8, 9], proton-nucleus scattering [10, 11], coherent pion photoproduction [12] and the indirect measurements of neutron star observables [13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24]. All these non-electroweak measurements are in fair agreement with each other, being also compatible with the predictions of different energy density functional (EDF) nuclear models [4, 5, 6], ΔRnpth(208Pb)=0.13\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 0.13-0.190.19 fm, and the first abab-initioinitio estimate of the lead neutron skin, ΔRnpab-initio(208Pb)=0.14\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{ab\text{-}initio}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 0.14-0.200.20 fm [25]. Although the hadronic probes have been shown to be affected by uncontrolled theoretical uncertainties [26], and the astrophysical constraints are rather indirect, the global picture that emerges indicates a preference for a thinner lead neutron skin with respect to PREX, which however is considered to be model independent being a non-hadronic probe. So far, no solution to such a dilemma has been found, even if a reasonable compromise seems to be allowed for a specific set of quantified EDFs [27]. Motivated by such a tension, we attempt to reconcile the PREX observation with all the other determinations by incorporating the so far neglected dependence on the weak mixing angle, sin⁡2θW≡sW2\sin^2\theta_{\mathrm{W}} \equiv s_{\mathrm{W}}^2, which is a key parameter of the electroweak theory [28].

PREX-II analysis

The PREX-II Collaboration measures the lead neutron skin exploiting 953953 MeV polarized electrons scattering at forward angles on 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nuclei [1]. The polarization of the incoming electrons permits to isolate the weak-interaction contribution by building a parity violating asymmetry, ApvA_{\mathrm{pv}}, as discussed in Ref. [1]. Adopting the plane-wave Born approximation, the asymmetry shows explicitly its dependence on the nuclear weak charge, QWQ_W, and the weak, FWF_W, and charge, FchF_{\mathrm{ch}}, form factors

APV≈GFQ24πα2QWFW(Q2)ZFch(Q2),(1)\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{PV}} \approx\frac{G_F Q^2}{4\pi\alpha\sqrt{2}}\frac{Q_W F_W(Q^2)}{Z F_{\mathrm{ch}}(Q^2)}, \tag*{(1)}

where GFG_F is the Fermi constant, QQ the momentum transfer, α\alpha the fine-structure constant and ZZ the atomic number of the target nucleus. In particular, the weak and charge form factors represent the Fourier transforms of the corresponding weak and charge densities, ρW\rho_W and ρch\rho_{\mathrm{ch}}. The charge distribution of a lead nucleus has already been precisely tested through electromagnetic scattering processes, resulting in a charge distribution radius of Rch(208Pb)=5.503±0.002R_{\mathrm{ch}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 5.503 \pm0.002 fm [29]. The charge distribution mainly depends on the proton nuclear density, so that RchR_{\mathrm{ch}} can be translated into a determination of the proton root-mean-squared radius [3, 30], leading to Rp(208Pb)=5.449R_p(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) = 5.449 fm [3].

However, the distorted-wave Born approximation (DWBA) [31, 32, 33], which incorporates the Coulomb distortion effects on the incoming electron approaching the target nucleus, must be adopted to properly describe heavy nuclei, such as lead [34].

From Eq. (1), it is clear that PREX-II determines the weak form factor value at the experimental mean momentum transfer, QPREX−II≃78Q_{\mathrm{PREX-II}} \simeq78 MeV [1]. After adopting a symmetrized two-parameter Fermi (2pF) function for the weak nuclear density [35], it is possible to translate the weak form factor measurement into a determination of the weak nuclear radius, RWR_W. In particular, the employed weak nuclear density reads [35]

ρW(r,c,a)=3QW4πc(c2+π2a2)sinh⁡(c/a)cosh⁡(c/a)+cosh⁡(r/a)(2)\rho_W(r,c,a)=\frac{3Q_W}{4\pi c(c^2+\pi^2a^2)}\frac{\sinh(c/a)}{\cosh(c/a)+\cosh(r/a)} \tag*{(2)}

where rr is the radius, cc represents the half density radius and aa is the so-called diffuseness, related to the thickness parameter tt through t=4aln⁡(3)t=4a\ln(3). We fixed the diffuseness parameter to the EDFs average value a=0.605±0.025a=0.605\pm0.025 fm, as done by the PREX Collaboration in Ref. [1]. The corresponding weak charge radius RWR_W can be obtained using [3, 35]

RW2=1QW∫d3r r2ρW(r,c,a)=35c2+75π2a2,(3)R_W^2=\frac{1}{Q_W}\int d^3r\,r^2\rho_W(r,c,a)=\frac{3}{5}c^2+\frac{7}{5}\pi^2a^2, \tag*{(3)}

which in turn can be translated into the neutron distribution radius by the relation [3]

Rn2=QWQWn,NRW2−QWpQWn,NZNRch2−⟨rp2⟩−ZN⟨rn2⟩+Z+NQWn,NN⟨rs2⟩,(4)R_n^2=\frac{Q_W}{Q_W^{n,N}}R_W^2-\frac{Q_W^p}{Q_W^{n,N}}\frac{Z}{N}R_{\mathrm{ch}}^2-\langle r_p^2\rangle-\frac{Z}{N}\langle r_n^2\rangle+\frac{Z+N}{Q_W^{n,N}N}\langle r_s^2\rangle, \tag*{(4)}

where NN is the neutron number, ⟨rp(n)2⟩\langle r_{p(n)}^2\rangle is the charge radius of a single proton (neutron), namely, ⟨rp2⟩=0.7071\langle r_p^2\rangle=0.7071 fm2^2 and ⟨rn2⟩=−0.1161\langle r_n^2\rangle=-0.1161 fm2^2 [28], ⟨rs2⟩\langle r_s^2\rangle the nucleon strangeness radius (⟨rs2⟩≃−0.013\langle r_s^2\rangle\simeq-0.013 fm2^2 [36]) and QWn,pQ_W^{n,p} is the weak nucleon charges, defined as twice the opposite of the couplings of electrons to nucleons, gAVepg_{AV}^{ep} and gAVeng_{AV}^{en}. Using the standard model (SM) prediction of the weak mixing angle at low energies, sW2SM=0.23857±0.00005s_W^2{}_{\mathrm{SM}}=0.23857\pm0.00005, and taking into account radiative corrections [28, 37, 38], one obtains gAV,SMen=−0.0357g_{AV,\mathrm{SM}}^{en}=-0.0357 and gAV,SMep=0.495g_{AV,\mathrm{SM}}^{ep}=0.495, where the coupling to protons is suppressed. The weak charge of the nucleus, which enters directly both ρW\rho_W and APV\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{PV}}, is the weak coupling to the nucleus, and it is defined as

QWth(N,Z,sW2)=−2[ZgAVep(sW2)+NgAVen]+□γZPb.(5)Q_W^{\mathrm{th}}(N,Z,s_W^2)=-2[Zg_{AV}^{ep}(s_W^2)+Ng_{AV}^{en}]+\square_{\gamma Z}^{\mathrm{Pb}}. \tag*{(5)}

For 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}, Z=82Z=82 and N=126N=126. Thus, taking into account the radiative corrections and the total γ\gamma-ZZ correction, □γZ\square_{\gamma Z}, for lead, the weak charge is predicted to be QWSM(208Pb)=−117.9(3)Q_W^{\mathrm{SM}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb})=-117.9(3) [39] in the case of polarized electron scattering.

As shown in Eq. (1), PREX-II depends on the weak mixing angle at its experimental energy scale, where the latter is not well constrained. Indeed, despite the PREX-II measurement is said to be negligibly dependent on sW2s_W^2 [40], its dependence should be taken into account.

To do so, we modified the DREPHADREPHA code [41] to calculate the asymmetry and cross-section values under the DWBA, giving ρW\rho_W as an input evaluated for a variety of RWR_W and sW2s_W^2 values using the symmetrized 2pF parametrization [35]. Then, the asymmetries have been averaged considering the experimental angular acceptance ϵ(θ)\epsilon(\theta), following the PREX-II procedure [1]. We fit the measured asymmetry APVmeas=550±16A_{\mathrm{PV}}^{\mathrm{meas}}=550\pm16 (stat.) ±8\pm8 (syst.) ppb [1], computing the following χ2\chi^2 function

χPREX−II2(sW2,Rn)=(APV(sW2,Rn)−APVmeasσAPVmeas)2,(6)\chi^2_{\mathrm{PREX-II}}(s_W^2,R_n)=\left(\frac{A_{\mathrm{PV}}(s_W^2,R_n)-A_{\mathrm{PV}}^{\mathrm{meas}}}{\sigma_{A_{\mathrm{PV}}^{\mathrm{meas}}}}\right)^2, \tag*{(6)}

where σpvAmeas\sigma_{\mathrm{pv}}^{A\mathrm{meas}} is the total experimental uncertainty obtained summing in quadrature the statistical and systematical uncertainties.

We first perform a fit of the neutron skin fixing sW2=sW2SMs_W^2=s_{W}^{2\mathrm{SM}}, leading to ΔRnp(sW2SM)=0.276±0.078 fm\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}(s_W^{2\mathrm{SM}})=0.276\pm0.078\ \mathrm{fm}, which confirms the PREX-II published result, ΔRnpPREX−II(208Pb)=0.278±0.078 fm\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{PREX-II}}({}^{208}\mathrm{Pb})=0.278\pm0.078\ \mathrm{fm} [1], via an independent analysis.

Then, leaving sW2s_W^2 free to vary, we obtain the result presented in Figure 1. The introduction of sW2s_W^2 as a parameter in the fit produces a fully degenerate diagonal band. Therefore, smaller values of the neutron skin can be accessed for lower values of sW2s_W^2, so that a neutron skin compatible with ΔRnpth(208Pb)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}}({}^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) can be obtained if sW2≈0.225s_W^2\approx0.225.

Favored regions in the $\sin^2\theta_W$ vs $\Delta R_{np}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb})$ plane

Figure 1. Favored regions in the sin⁡2θW\sin^2\theta_W vs ΔRnp(208Pb)\Delta R_{np}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) plane given by our reanalysis of the PREX-II data. The gray, brown and red shaded areas represent the 1, 2 and 3σ3\sigma confidence level contours. The red horizontal bar shows the PREX-II result [1] for sW2SMs_W^2{}_{\mathrm{SM}} (blue line). The green vertical band corresponds to the theoretical prediction, ΔRnpth(208Pb)\Delta R_{np}^{\mathrm{th}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}).

Atomic Parity Violation experiment on lead.— To break the degeneracy, we exploit the atomic parity violation (APV) experiment on 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb}, a weak-interaction process between the electrons and the nucleus, sensitive to the nuclear weak charge. Indeed, these probes represent the lowest energy determinations of sW2s_W^2, being the momentum transfer of few MeVs [42], i.e., QAPV(Cs)∼2.4 MeVQ_{\mathrm{APV}}(\mathrm{Cs})\sim2.4\ \mathrm{MeV} for cesium atoms and QAPV(Pb)∼8 MeVQ_{\mathrm{APV}}(\mathrm{Pb})\sim8\ \mathrm{MeV} for lead atoms. So far, the most precise APV measurement was performed on cesium and it is extracted from the ratio of the parity violating amplitude, EAPVE_{\mathrm{APV}}, to the Stark vector transition polarizability, β\beta, and by calculating theoretically EAPVE_{\mathrm{APV}} [28, 43, 44]. The parity nonconserving nuclear-spin-independent part of the electron-nucleus interaction Hamiltonian [45] depends on ρW(r)\rho_W(r). In the original calculation of EAPVE_{\mathrm{APV}}, a charge-density distribution has been used instead of ρW(r)\rho_W(r) since the charge radius was better determined. To keep this into account, a so-called neutron-skin correction was applied to the final calculation using the proper density distribution [46, 47, 48, 49, 50]. For the amplitude calculation of APV(Pb)\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb}), a uniformly charged ball density was assumed [45], with Rch(208Pb)=5.5010 fmR_{\mathrm{ch}}({}^{208}\mathrm{Pb})=5.5010\ \mathrm{fm} [45].

Once EAPVE_{\mathrm{APV}} is obtained, the quantity Rth=(Im⁡EAPV/M1)thR_{\mathrm{th}}=(\operatorname{Im}E_{\mathrm{APV}}/M_1)_{\mathrm{th}} can be defined, where M1M_1 is the reduced electric-dipole transition of the magnetic-dipole operator for the 6p2 3P0→6p2 3P16p^2\,{}^3P_0\to6p^2\,{}^3P_1 transition relevant for lead. The theoretical calculated value is Rth=−10.6(4)×10−8(−QWAPV(Pb)/N)R_{\mathrm{th}}=-10.6(4)\times10^{-8}(-Q_W^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}/N) [45] while experimentally two measurements are available, Rexp=−9.86(12)×10−8R_{\mathrm{exp}}=-9.86(12)\times10^{-8} [51] and Rexp=−9.80(33)×10−8R_{\mathrm{exp}}=-9.80(33)\times10^{-8} [52], therefore we consider the experimental average value, Rexpav.R_{\mathrm{exp}}^{\mathrm{av.}}. The lead weak charge is then obtained through the ratio between RexpR_{\mathrm{exp}} and RthR_{\mathrm{th}}, which gives QWAPV(Pb)=−117(5)Q_W^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}=-117(5) [45]. The neutron skin correction can be defined as

δEAPVn.s.(Rn)=[NQWAPV(Pb)(1−qn(Rn)qp)EAPV],(7)\delta E_{\mathrm{APV}}^{\mathrm{n.s.}}(R_n)=\left[\frac{N}{Q_W^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}}\left(1-\frac{q_n(R_n)}{q_p}\right)E_{\mathrm{APV}}\right], \tag*{(7)}

where qp(n)q_{p(n)} are the integrals over the proton and neutron nuclear densities [46, 47, 48, 49, 50], respectively, determined as discussed in detail in Refs. [53, 54]. In the qpq_p calculation, we employ the charge density used in the original determination [45], while for qnq_n calculation the symmetrized 2pF was adopted.

The weak charge measurement is then obtained through

QWAPV(Pb)(Rn)=−NRexpav.(M1Im⁡(EAPV+δEAPVn.s.(Rn)))th.(8)Q_W^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}(R_n)=-N R_{\mathrm{exp}}^{\mathrm{av.}}\left(\frac{M_1}{\operatorname{Im}(E_{\mathrm{APV}}+\delta E_{\mathrm{APV}}^{\mathrm{n.s.}}(R_n))}\right)_{\mathrm{th}}. \tag*{(8)}

This procedure has already been exploited in the case of cesium [53, 54].

The APV measurement, contrary to PREX, is mainly sensitive to sW2s_W^2 and only feebly on ΔRnp\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}. We build the following χ2\chi^2 function for APV(Pb)\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})

χAPV(Pb)2(sW2,Rn)=(QWth,APV(sW2)−QWAPV(Pb)(Rn)σAPV(Pb)(sW2,Rn))2,(9)\chi_{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}^2(s_W^2,R_n)=\left(\frac{Q_W^{\mathrm{th,APV}}(s_W^2)-Q_W^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}(R_n)}{\sigma^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}(s_W^2,R_n)}\right)^2, \tag*{(9)}

where σAPV(Pb)(sW2,Rn)\sigma^{\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Pb})}(s_W^2,R_n) is the total uncertainty. The weak charge QWth,APVQ_W^{\mathrm{th,APV}} for APV experiments is slightly different from the one given for polarized electron scattering in Eq. (5), due to different radiative corrections. In particular, adopting the description in Refs. [28, 54], QWth,APV=−118.79(5)Q_W^{\mathrm{th,APV}}=-118.79(5). We perform a combined fit of the APV(Pb) and PREX-II measurements by summing the χ2\chi^2 functions in Eqs. (6) and (9) to fully exploit their correlations, requiring sW2s_W^2 to be constant between the corresponding experimental momentum transfers, 8≲Q≲78 MeV8\lesssim Q\lesssim78\ \mathrm{MeV}.

In Figure 2, we show the combined fit result through the dashed contours. In particular, the different sensitivities on sW2s_W^2 and ΔRnp\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}} of the two experiments allow us to find an elliptical closed region in the parameter space with best-fit values equal to

Figure 2. Combined fit results of APV(Pb)+PREX-II (dashed orange and dark red contours) and APV(Pb)+PREX-II+theory (solid cyan and blue contours, with their corresponding best fits (orange square and cyan star, respectively), shown in the sin⁡2θW\sin^2\theta_W vs ΔRnp(208Pb)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) plane at 1σ1\sigma and 3σ3\sigma confidence levels. The side panels show the one-dimensional marginalizations (red line for APV(Pb)+PREX-II, cyan line for APV(Pb)+PREX-II+theory) for both the fits. The red horizontal bar shows the PREX-II result [1] for sW2 SMs_W^{2\,\mathrm{SM}} (blue line).

ΔRnpcomb=0.262±0.136 fm,(10)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{comb}}=0.262\pm0.136\ \mathrm{fm}, \tag*{(10)}
sin⁡2θW(8≲Q≲78 MeV)=0.237±0.014.(11)\sin^2\theta_W(8\lesssim Q\lesssim78\ \mathrm{MeV})=0.237\pm0.014. \tag*{(11)}

The neutron skin value obtained is slightly smaller than the PREX-II one [1], but with about double the uncertainty, so that now it is in agreement with ΔRnpth\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}} as with other nonrel ectroweak measurements [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24]. From Figure 2, it is clear that, to allow for thinner neutron skins, sW2s_W^2 should be lower than its SM value. In Ref. [54], this has already been observed for a combined fit of APV(Cs)\mathrm{APV}(\mathrm{Cs}) and the coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering data from the COHERENT experiment [55]. Surprisingly enough, looking at Fig. 3 of Ref. [54], it can be observed that to obtain a cesium skin value around 0.13 fm0.13\ \mathrm{fm}, sW2s_W^2 should be smaller than the SM prediction, in agreement with the results found in this work.

Finally, we combine the two experimental determinations with a Gaussian prior input on the neutron skin given by ΔRnpth(208Pb)=0.16±0.03 fm\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}}({}^{208}\mathrm{Pb})=0.16\pm0.03\ \mathrm{fm}. The result of this combined fit is shown in Figure 2 through the solid contours. Clearly, the prior forces the fit to favor smaller values of sW2s_W^2. The best-fit values correspond to

ΔRnpcomb+th=0.164±0.029 fm,(12)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{comb+th}}=0.164\pm0.029\ \mathrm{fm}, \tag*{(12)}
sin⁡2θW(8≲Q≲78 MeV)=0.228±0.008.(13)\sin^2\theta_W(8\lesssim Q\lesssim78\ \mathrm{MeV})=0.228\pm0.008. \tag*{(13)}

The sW2s_W^2 best fit results in a value lower than the SM predicted one, and with smaller uncertainty with respect to the PREX-II+APV(Pb) combined fit result.

Main results and discussion.— The 1σ1\sigma confidence level contours obtained by the three presented analysis are summarized in Figure 3 to underline how thinner skins are allowed for lower values of sW2s_W^2. Focusing on the implications for sW2s_W^2, in Figure 4 we summarize the state of the art of the weak mixing angle measurements in the low-energy regime (Q≲200Q \lesssim200 MeV) through processes involving electrons. The lowest energy determination belongs to APV(Cs), which is 1σ1\sigma lower than the SM value [28]. The APV(Cs) value corresponds to a neutron skin correction determined from an extrapolation of neutron skin measurements from antiprotonic data [7, 43, 56, 57], which is compatible with the EDF estimate on cesium. Let us note that the APV(Cs) result is currently debated in the community. The theoretical calculations have gone through many reevaluations, leading to different weak mixing angle determinations. For completeness, see the work presented in Ref. [58] and the recent calculation performed in Ref. [59]. At higher energies (Q≈160Q \approx160 MeV), the combined QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} [60] and the E158 [61] measurements precisely determine sW2s_W^2 to be compatible with the SM prediction. The orange square and the light blue star points are the results obtained in this work for the combined PREX-II+APV(Pb) fit, see Eq. (11), and the PREX-II+APV(Pb)+theory fit, see Eq. (13), respectively. The horizontal error bars indicate that we assume sW2s_W^2 to remain constant between the APV(Pb) and PREX-II experimental energy scales.

Summary of the PREX-only, combined, and combined+theory confidence level contours

Figure 3. Summary of the PREX-only (grey long dashed), combined (orange dashed) and combined+theory (cyan solid) 1σ1\sigma confidence level contours in the sin⁡2θW\sin^2\theta_W vs ΔRnp(208Pb)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) plane. The orange square and the cyan star points are the best fits of combined and combined+theory, respectively. The green vertical band shows ΔRnp\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}, while the red dot the PREX-II result [1] for sW2 SMs_W^{2\,\mathrm{SM}} (blue line).

Figure 4. Weak mixing angle running with the energy scale QQ. The SM prediction (solid blue curve) is compared with some experimental determinations (black dots) [28, 43, 60, 61, 65, 66], and future measurements (purple dots) [62, 63, 64]. The orange dashed and the cyan solid points come from the combined and the combined+theory fits, respectively. The cyan result is shifted towards lower energies for illustrative purposes, as indicated by the arrows. The vertical arrows indicate the momentum transfer for APV(Pb), PREX-II and CREX, while the green dashed curve represents the modified running of sin⁡2θW\sin^2\theta_W in a scenario involving a new mediator [67].

Since PREX-II and APV(Pb) are not so precise in measuring the weak mixing angle, future determinations at the same energy scale are awaited. In particular, the P2 [62, 63] and the MOLLER [64] experiments are going to measure sW2s_W^2 with high precision at energies slightly smaller than the PREX-II one.

The sW2s_W^2 dependence on the energy scale is fundamental in our discussion. In fact, the presence of beyond the SM light particles could significantly modify the running of sW2s_W^2 only at low-energies. The green dashed curve in Figure 4 shows an example of a dark ZZ boson [68, 69] of mass around 50 MeV as discussed in Ref. [67]. It shows that sW2s_W^2 can sensibly differ from the SM at low energies while remaining compatible for Q≳150Q \gtrsim150 MeV, so that QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} and PREX-II could be measuring different sW2s_W^2 values.

The PREX twin experiment on calcium, CREX [70, 71, 72], is performed at Q≈170Q \approx170 MeV, so near the QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} energy scale. In this regime, the value of sW2s_W^2 is rather precisely measured to be close to sW2 SMs_W^{2\,\mathrm{SM}}, thus, if our interpretation is correct, CREX is expected to measure a thin calcium neutron skin, compatible with the prediction of coupled cluster calculations, ΔRnpcorr(48Ca)=0.12\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{corr}}(^{48}\mathrm{Ca}) = 0.12-0.150.15 fm [73].

Conclusions.— In summary, we confirm the PREX-II neutron skin measurement via an independent analysis at fixed weak mixing angle. Questioning the assumptions behind this measurement, we show the PREX-II neutron skin dependence on sW2s_W^2, resulting in a fully degenerate band in the sW2s_W^2 vs ΔRnp(208Pb)\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}(^{208}\mathrm{Pb}) plane. Nevertheless, the fit suggests that a much smaller (or larger) lead neutron skin

could be found if sW2(QPREX−II)s_W^2(Q_{\mathrm{PREX-II}}) is small (or large) enough, so that neglecting such a dependence the experimental result might be misinterpreted. A combined fit with APV(Pb) allows us to to break this degeneracy and to obtain a closed favored region in the parameter space. The best fit is in great agreement with sW2 SMs_W^{2\,\mathrm{SM}} and we find a slightly thinner neutron skin with respect to the PREX-II result, even if with double the uncertainty, showing that the PREX-II tension can be eased. We find a smaller favored region in the parameter space by inserting ΔRnpth\Delta R_{\mathrm{np}}^{\mathrm{th}} as a prior, obtaining that a sW2s_W^2 value 1.2σ\sigma smaller than the SM one is needed to accommodate for smaller neutron skins. Further sW2s_W^2 measurements are needed, such as the upcoming P2 and MOLLER experiments [62, 63, 64], as well as new neutron skin determinations, such as the one by the MREX experiment [62], to shed light on this tension.

In conclusion, we discuss the possibility that the upcoming CREX result could be only feebly affected by the sW2s_W^2 dependence thanks to the higher experimental energy scale, where sW2s_W^2 is experimentally constrained at the SM value, reconciling eventual conflicting results between the two twin experiments.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank M. Gorchtein and J. Erler for the fruitful discussions on the lead weak charge. Moreover, the useful discussions with F. Dordei, W. Bonivento and C. Giunti are kindly acknowledged. The work at Brookhaven National Laboratory was sponsored by the Office of Nuclear Physics, Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-98CH10886 with Brookhaven Science Associates, LLC.

References

  1. [1]D. A. et al. (PREX Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 172502 (2021).
  2. [2]S. Abrahamyan, Z. Ahmed, H. Albataineh, K. Aniol, D. S. Armstrong, W. Armstrong, T. Averett, B. Babineau, A. Barbieri, V. Bellini, and et al., Physical Review Letters 108 (2012), 10.1103/physrevlett.108.112502.
  3. [3]C. J. Horowitz et al., Phys. Rev. C 85, 032501 (2012), arXiv:1202.1468 [nucl-ex].DOI
  4. [4]J. Piekarewicz, B. K. Agrawal, G. Colò, W. Nazarewicz, N. Paar, P.-G. Reinhard, X. Roca-Maza, and D. Vretenar, Phys. Rev. C 85, 041302 (2012).
  5. [5]X. Roca-Maza, X. Viñas, M. Centelles, B. K. Agrawal, G. Colò, N. Paar, J. Piekarewicz, and D. Vretenar, Phys. Rev. C 92, 064304 (2015).
  6. [6]J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 104, 024329 (2021).
  7. [7]A. Trzcińska, J. Jastrzębski, P. Lubiński, F. J. Hartmann, R. Schmidt, T. von Egidy, and B. Kłos, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 082501 (2001).
  8. [8]J. T. Zhang, X. L. Tu, P. Sarriguren, K. Yue, Q. Zeng, Z. Y. Sun, M. Wang, Y. H. Zhang, X. H. Zhou, and Y. A. Litvinov, Phys. Rev. C 104, 034303 (2021), arXiv:2109.03417 [nucl-th].DOI
  9. [9]B. Kłos et al., Phys. Rev. C 76, 014311 (2007), arXiv:nucl-ex/0702016.DOI
  10. [10]J. Zenihiro, H. Sakaguchi, T. Murakami, M. Yosoi, Y. Yasuda, S. Terashima, Y. Iwao, H. Takeda, M. Itoh, H. P. Yoshida, and M. Uchida, Phys. Rev. C 82, 044611 (2010).
  11. [11]V. E. Starodubsky and N. M. Hintz, Phys. Rev. C 49, 2118 (1994).
  12. [12]C. M. Tarbert et al. (Crystal Ball at MAMI and A2 Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 242502 (2014).
  13. [13]R. Essick, I. Tews, P. Landry, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 192701 (2021).
  14. [14]F. J. Fattoyev, J. Piekarewicz, and C. J. Horowitz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 172702 (2018).
  15. [15]B. T. Reed, F. J. Fattoyev, C. J. Horowitz, and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 172503 (2021).
  16. [16]W. G. Newton and G. Crocombe, Phys. Rev. C 103, 064323 (2021).
  17. [17]J. R. Stone, Universe 7, 257 (2021).
  18. [18]R. Essick, P. Landry, A. Schwenk, and I. Tews, (2021), arXiv:2107.05528 [nucl-th].DOI
  19. [19]T. E. Riley et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 918, L27 (2021), arXiv:2105.06980 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  20. [20]M. C. Miller et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 918, L28 (2021), arXiv:2105.06979 [astro-ph.HE].
  21. [21]B. Biswas, Astrophys. J. 921, 63 (2021), arXiv:2105.02886 [astro-ph.HE].
  22. [22]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 161101 (2017), arXiv:1710.05832 [gr-qc].
  23. [23]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 161101 (2018), arXiv:1805.11581 [gr-qc].
  24. [24]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Astrophys. J. Lett. 892, L3 (2020), arXiv:2001.01761 [astro-ph.HE].
  25. [25]B. Hu, W. Jiang, T. Miyagi, Z. Sun, A. Ekström, C. Forssén, G. Hagen, J. D. Holt, T. Papenbrock, S. R. Stroberg, and I. Vernon, “Ab initio predictions link the neutron skin of 208Pb to nuclear forces,” (2021), arXiv:2112.01125 [nucl-th].
  26. [26]M. Thiel, C. Shfienti, J. Pieka rewicz, C. J. Horowitz, and M. Vanderhaeghen, J. Phys. G 46, 093003 (2019), arXiv:1904.12269 [nucl-ex].
  27. [27]P.-G. Reinhard, X. Roca-Maza, and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 232501 (2021).
  28. [28]P. Zyla et al. (Particle Data Group), PTEP 2020, 083C01 (2020).
  29. [29]H. De Vries, C. De Jager, and C. De Vries, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 36, 495 (1987).
  30. [30]A. Ong, J. C. Berengut, and V. V. Flambaum, Phys. Rev. C 82, 014320 (2010).
  31. [31]H. Überall, Electron Scattering from Complex Nuclei (Academic Press, New York, 1971) https://catalogue.library.cern/literature/84w67-hj966.
  32. [32]D. R. Yennie, D. G. Ravenhall, and R. N. Wilson, Phys. Rev. 95, 500 (1954).
  33. [33]C. Ciofi degli Atti, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 3, 163 (1980).
  34. [34]C. J. Horowitz, Phys. Rev. C 57, 3430 (1998), arXiv:nucl-th/9801011.
  35. [35]J. Piekarewicz, A. R. Linero, P. Giuliani, and E. Chicken, Phys. Rev. C 94, 034316 (2016).
  36. [36]C. J. Horowitz, Phys. Lett. B 789, 675 (2019), arXiv:1809.06478 [nucl-th].
  37. [37]J. Erler and S. R. P. Grant, J. Phys. G 71, 119 (2013), arXiv:1303.5522 [hep-ph].
  38. [38]J. Erler, C. J. Horowitz, S. Mantry, and P. A. Souder, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 64, 269 (2014), arXiv:1401.6199 [hep-ph].
  39. [39]J. Erler and M. Gorchtein, private communication (2021).
  40. [40]T. W. Donnelly, J. Dubach, and I. Sick, Nucl. Phys. A 503, 589 (1989).
  41. [41]S. Klein, B. Dreher, and J. Friedrich, “Drepha: A phase-shift calculation code for elastic electron scattering,” (1986).
  42. [42]C. Bouchiat and C. Piketty, Physics Letters B 128, 73 (1983).
  43. [43]V. A. Dzuba, J. C. Berengut, V. V. Flambaum, and B. Roberts, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 203003 (2012), arXiv:1207.5864 [hep-ph].
  44. [44]S. C. Bennett and C. E. Wieman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2484 (1999), [Erratum: Phys. Rev. Lett.83,889(1999)].
  45. [45]S. G. Porsev, M. G. Kozlov, M. S. Safronova, and I. I. Tupitsyn, Phys. Rev. A 93, 012501 (2016).
  46. [46]S. J. Pollock, E. N. Fortson, and L. Wilets, Phys. Rev. C 46, 2587 (1992).
  47. [47]S. Pollock and M. Welliver, Physics Letters B 464, 177–182 (1999).
  48. [48]J. James and P. G. H. Sandars, Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 32, 3295 (1999).
  49. [49]C. J. Horowitz, S. J. Pollock, P. A. Souder, and R. Michaels, Physical Review C 63 (2001), 10.1103/phys-rev.c.63.025501.
  50. [50]A. V. Viatkina, D. Antypas, M. G. Kozlov, D. Budker, and V. V. Flambaum, Phys. Rev. C 100, 034318 (2019).
  51. [51]D. M. Meekhof, P. Vetter, P. K. Majumder, S. K. Lamoreaux, and E. N. Fortson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3442 (1993).
  52. [52]S. J. Phipp, N. H. Edwards, P. E. G. Baird, and S. Nakayama, Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 29, 1861 (1996).
  53. [53]M. Cadeddu and F. Dordei, Phys. Rev. D 99, 033010 (2019), arXiv:1808.10202 [hep-ph].
  54. [54]M. Cadeddu, N. Carg ioli, F. Dordei, C. Giunti, Y. F. Li, E. Picciau, C. A. Ternes, and Y. Y. Zhang, Phys. Rev. C 104, 065502 (2021).
  55. [55]D. Akimov et al., (2021), arXiv:2110.07730 [hep-ex].DOI
  56. [56]A. Derevianko, Phys. Rev. A 65, 012106 (2001).
  57. [57]A. Derevianko, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 1618 (2000).
  58. [58]S. G. Porsev, K. Beloy, and A. Derevianko, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 181601 (2009), arXiv:0902.0335 [hep-ph].
  59. [59]B. K. Sahoo, B. P. Das, and H. Spiesberger, Phys. Rev. D 103, L111303 (2021).
  60. [60]D. Androic et al. (Qweak), Nature 557, 207 (2018).
  61. [61]P. L. Anthony et al. (SLAC E158), Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 081601 (2005), hep-ex/0504049 [hep-ex].
  62. [62]D. Becker et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 54, 208 (2018), arXiv:1802.04759 [nucl-ex].
  63. [63]P. S. B. Dev, W. Rodejohann, X.-J. Xu, and Y. Zhang, “Searching for Z’ bosons at the P2 experiment,” (2021), arXiv:2103.09067 [hep-ph].
  64. [64]J. Benesch et al. (MOLLER), “The MOLLER Experiment: An Ultra-Precise Measurement of the Weak Mixing Angle Using Moller Scattering,” (2014), arXiv:1411.4088 [nucl-ex].
  65. [65]C. S. Wood, S. C. Bennett, D. Cho, B. P. Masterson, J. L. Roberts, C. E. Tanner, and C. E. Wieman, Science 275, 1759 (1997).
  66. [66]M. Tanabashi et al. (Particle Data Group), Phys. Rev. D 98, 030001 (2018).
  67. [67]M. Cadeddu, N. Carg ioli, F. Dordei, C. Giunti, and E. Picciau, Phys. Rev. D 104, 011701 (2021), arXiv:2104.03280 [hep-ph].
  68. [68]H. Davoudiasl, H.-S. Lee, and W. J. Marciano, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 031802 (2012).
  69. [69]H. Davoudiasl, H.-S. Lee, and W. J. Marciano, Phys. Rev. D 85, 115019 (2012).
  70. [70]S. Riordan et al., JLAB-PR- 40-12-004, TJNAF, 2013 (2013).
  71. [71]K. S. Kumar (PREX, CREX), Annals Phys. 412, 168012 (2020).
  72. [72]C. J. Horowitz, K. S. Kumar, and R. Michaels, Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 48 (2014), arXiv:1307.3572 [nucl-ex].
  73. [73]G. Hagen et al., Nature Phys. 12, 186 (2015), arXiv:1509.07169 [nucl-th].

Paper details

vlnc:W_y47w6gqw
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents