betaFeedback

WorksEconomics, Econometrics and Finance

Polynomial-Preserving Processes and Volatility Modelling in Discrete Time

Abstract

This paper develops a discrete-time framework for volatility modelling and derivative pricing based on polynomial preservation. The framework provides exact moments of arbitrary order and serial cross-moments of variance and return processes over any finite horizon through finite-dimensional matrix representations. This analytical tractability is maintained while accommodating flexible leverage and variance-of-variance dynamics and non-Gaussian innovations. We introduce two novel classes of stochastic volatility models that nest widely used discrete-time specifications and study their statistical properties. Under two distinct scaling regimes, we establish weak convergence to polynomial diffusions and jump-diffusions and convergence of polynomial moments, linking discrete-time moment recursions to continuous-time matrix-exponential formulas. An empirical analysis of S&P~500 returns and a large panel of options spanning 1996–2023 shows that the proposed specifications improve return fit and reduce mean weekly implied volatility root mean squared errors by approximately 8–41% relative to their nested benchmarks, depending on the variance dynamics and innovation distribution.

Manuscript

Introduction

Although volatility is a central determinant of the dynamics of asset returns and option prices, the leverage effect and the volatility of the conditional variance also play an important role in shaping the asymmetry and heavy-tailedness of conditional return distributions, as well as volatility smiles. Models with similar expected variance paths can therefore imply markedly different return tails and smiles because they impose different responses to return shocks and different uncertainty about future variance.4 Capturing these features, however, involves a well-known trade-off between flexibility and tractability: specifications rich enough to reproduce them often lack closed-form expressions for key quantities, whereas tractable specifications typically restrict how return shocks and variance uncertainty can interact. We address this challenge by developing a general discrete-time polynomial-preserving framework in which conditional moments can be computed exactly at any horizon, and we use it to construct new stochastic volatility (SV) models, establish their weak limits, and characterize polynomial preservation under the pricing measure. Exact moments are valuable because they make the link between model parameters and the term structures of variance, skewness, and kurtosis explicit, and they provide multi-horizon forecasts and inputs for derivative valuation without simulation error or the associated computational burden. Relative to their nested benchmarks, the proposed models improve the fit to returns and a large panel of equity index options.

Polynomial preservation means that the conditional expectation of any polynomial in the future state is a polynomial of no higher degree in the current state. Consequently, conditional moments of any given order can be computed through a finite-dimensional system involving only moments of that order or lower. Polynomial processes have been extensively studied in continuous time. Their foundations are developed by Cuchiero et al. (2012); Filipović and Larsson [6] (2020), with conditional polynomial moments obtained from finite-dimensional matrix exponentials. Financial and econometric applications include density approximations for likelihood inference and option pricing (see, e.g., Filipović et al. (2013)), variance-swap term structures (see, e.g., Filipović et al. [6]), option-price expansions (see, e.g., Ackerer et al. [1]; ); Ackerer and Filipović (2020)), and moment-based simulation (see, e.g., Brignone (2026)). Only recently have Kallsen and Richert (2026a,b) developed a general discrete-time polynomial state-space framework for filtering and estimation. Their framework includes the standard symmetric GARCH(1,1) model as a special case, but their primary focus is on inference rather than on characterizing the dynamics that preserve polynomiality in discrete-time SV models with leverage effects. We address this important modelling question and its implications for derivative pricing and continuous-time limits.

First, following the operator approach of Filipović and Larsson [6], we characterize polynomial preservation for a class of discrete-time Markov chains and use the resulting restrictions to construct two new classes of volatility models. We consider hybrid GARCH–SV models whose variance dynamics involve the first two nonconstant Hermite polynomials of the innovation, with state-dependent coefficient functions (henceforth innovation loadings).5 For jointly symmetric innovations with finite moments of all orders, we identify the restrictions on conditional means and innovation loadings that preserve polynomial moments of variance alone or jointly with returns. The framework accommodates non-Gaussian innovations and distinct, correlated return and variance shocks. In the Gaussian case, the first class, variance-polynomial hybrid GARCH–SV (VPGARCH-SV), extends the NGARCH dynamics of Engle and Ng (1993), used for option valuation, for example, by Duan (1995), while the second, jointly polynomial hybrid GARCH–SV (JPGARCH-SV), extends the affine HNGARCH model of Heston and Nandi [7] and its SV counterpart studied by Heston et al. (2024). We establish necessary and sufficient conditions for nonnegative conditional variance within the maintained parameter domains. Both specifications assume affine conditional mean variance dynamics while allowing richer variance-of-variance functions and state-dependent leverage effects. Both specifications yield exact conditional moments and serial cross-moments of variance, cumulative variance, and squared conditionally demeaned returns, while JPGARCH-SV also provides cumulative-return moments.6 Such higher-order and cross-date moments can be cumbersome to derive even for standard GARCH specifications. For the proposed classes, the model-specific task is to construct the one-step transition matrices from the model parameters and innovation moments; the same matrix formulas then apply across specifications and forecast horizons. At any fixed moment order, the matrix dimensions do not grow with the horizon.

Second, we connect our proposed discrete-time models to polynomial diffusions and jump-diffusions, with convergence of both the dynamics and their polynomial moments. Building on the weak-limit literature (see, e.g., Nelson [9]; Corradi (2000); Duan (1997); Duan et al. (2006b); Augustyniak et al. [2]), we derive two limiting regimes under the physical measure. Both regimes preserve polynomial variance dynamics and yield joint polynomiality in log price and variance for JPGARCH-SV. Its diffusion limit combines quadratic variance of variance with linear instantaneous return–variance covariance on an unbounded variance state space, distinct from the bounded-state Jacobi model of Ackerer et al. [1]. Scaling with standardized Lévy increments yields members of the polynomial jump-diffusion class of Filipović and Larsson (2020). This construction includes a COGARCH variance specification (see, e.g., Klüppelberg et al. (2004); Kallsen and Vesenmayer (2009)) and allows Brownian and jump components in both state coordinates. We give sufficient conditions for nonnegative approximations and global weak convergence. For the corresponding polynomial states, moment recursions converge to continuous-time matrix-exponential formulas. These results provide a new discrete-time construction of continuous-time stochastic volatility models with polynomial variance dynamics.

Third, we characterize polynomial preservation under the pricing measure. We adopt variancedependent pricing kernels, which are widely used in discrete-time option valuation and allow separate equity and variance risk-preference parameters (see, e.g., Christoffersen et al., 2013; Corsi et al., 2013; Majewski et al., 2015; Badescu et al., 2017). Specifically, we derive the transformed dynamics under the required cumulant-generating-function conditions and characterize simultaneous polynomial preservation under jointly Gaussian innovations. Preservation imposes additional restrictions on risk preferences and innovation loadings and can fail even under a monotonic pricing kernel. The results identify when exact risk-neutral moment recursions are available and clarify why polynomial physical dynamics can remain useful for derivative valuation when the pricing dynamics are nonpolynomial. Corresponding local risk-neutral diffusion limits are established under additional regularity conditions.

Finally, we assess the empirical relevance of the additional flexibility of the proposed models using daily S&P 500 returns and 664,592 option observations across 1,443 weekly dates spanning 1996–2023. Return estimation by maximum likelihood and weekly option calibration use the GARCH special cases under Gaussian and symmetric normal inverse Gaussian (NIG) innovations. Both proposed specifications substantially improve the fit relative to their nested benchmarks. JPGARCH reduces the mean weekly implied volatility root mean squared error (IVRMSE) relative to HNGARCH by approximately 41% under Gaussian innovations and 8% under NIG innovations; the corresponding gains of VPGARCH over NGARCH are 11% and 14%, respectively. VPGARCH achieves the lowest mean weekly pricing error under both distributions. NIG innovations improve option fit much more for HNGARCH and JPGARCH than for NGARCH and VPGARCH, suggesting that the value of heavier innovation tails depends on the variance dynamics. Exact physical moments further reveal differences in the persistence of variance uncertainty that expected-variance term structures alone do not capture.

Section 2 presents the moment framework, characterizes polynomial-preserving hybrid GARCH–SV dynamics, and derives their moment implications. Section 3 develops the diffusion and jump limits. Section 4 presents the empirical illustration, and Section 5 concludes. Appendix B studies the pricing kernel and risk-neutral preservation.

Polynomial-Preserving Hybrid GARCH–SV Models

This section characterizes hybrid GARCH–SV dynamics with analytically tractable moments under the physical measure. After presenting the general moment framework, we identify the innovation loading specifications that ensure polynomial preservation and construct two canonical model classes. We then establish positivity and moment conditions and derive moment formulas for variance and return-based quantities, including cumulative variance and returns.

Discrete-time polynomial-preserving Markov chains

We formulate polynomial preservation for time-homogeneous Markov chains using transition operators, with the same degree restriction on conditional moments as in Kallsen and Richert (2026a). Let τ=1/n\tau= 1/n, where n≥1n \ge1 is an integer, and fix an integer horizon L≥1L \ge1. On a filtered probability space (Ω(n),F(n),F(n),P(n))(\Omega^{(n)}, \mathcal{F}^{(n)}, \mathbb{F}^{(n)}, \mathbb{P}^{(n)}), with F(n)={Fkτ(n)}k=0nL\mathbb{F}^{(n)} = \{\mathcal{F}^{(n)}_{k\tau}\}_{k=0}^{nL} and physical measure P(n)\mathbb{P}^{(n)}, consider a time-homogeneous Markov chain X(n)={Xkτ(n)}k=0nL\mathbf{X}^{(n)} = \left\{\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{k\tau}\right\}_{k=0}^{nL} on a Borel state space E⊆RdE \subseteq\mathbb{R}^{d}, adapted and Markov with respect to F(n)\mathbb{F}^{(n)}. Its one-step transition kernel Π(n)(x,⋅)\Pi^{(n)}(x,\cdot) gives the conditional distribution of the next state given the current state x∈Ex \in E. Throughout this subsection, nn is fixed; its indexing is retained for the weak-limit analysis in § 2. Let Pol⁡m(E)\operatorname{Pol}_{m}(E) denote the restrictions to EE of real polynomials on Rd\mathbb{R}^{d} of total degree at most mm, write Pol⁡(E)=⋃m≥0Pol⁡m(E)\operatorname{Pol}(E) = \bigcup_{m\geq0}\operatorname{Pol}_{m}(E), and set Nm=dim⁡Pol⁡m(E)N_m = \dim\operatorname{Pol}_{m}(E).⁴ Throughout, R+:=[0,∞)\mathbb{R}_{+} := [0,\infty). For p∈Pol⁡(E)p \in\operatorname{Pol}(E) satisfying the one-step integrability condition

∫E∣p(z)∣Π(n)(x,dz)<∞,x∈E,(1)\int_E |p(z)|\Pi^{(n)}(x,dz) < \infty,\qquad x \in E, \tag*{(1)}

define the one-step transition operator by

G(n)p(x):=∫Ep(z)Π(n)(x,dz)=EP(n)[p(X(k+1)τ(n))|Xkτ(n)=x],x∈E.(2)\mathcal{G}^{(n)}p(x) := \int_E p(z)\Pi^{(n)}(x,dz) = \mathbb{E}^{\mathbb{P}^{(n)}}\left[p\left(\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{(k+1)\tau}\right)\middle|\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{k\tau}=x\right],\qquad x \in E. \tag*{(2)}

The following definition requires this conditional expectation to remain polynomial without increasing degree.

Definition 1. Let m≥0m \geq0 be an integer. The process X(n)\mathbf{X}^{(n)} is mm-polynomial preserving if Condition (1) holds for every p∈Pol⁡m(E)p \in\operatorname{Pol}_{m}(E) and

G(n)Pol⁡r(E)⊆Pol⁡r(E),r=0,…,m.\mathcal{G}^{(n)}\operatorname{Pol}_{r}(E) \subseteq\operatorname{Pol}_{r}(E),\qquad r = 0,\ldots,m.

It is polynomial preserving if it is mm-polynomial preserving for every integer m≥0m \geq0.

The following illustration shows what polynomial preservation means for a two-dimensional state.

Example 1. Take d=2d = 2 and m=2m = 2, with E=R2E = \mathbb{R}^{2}. The polynomial p(x)=x1x2p(x) = x_{1}x_{2} has total degree two, so a polynomial-preserving chain satisfies

EP(n)[X1,(k+1)τ(n)X2,(k+1)τ(n)|Xkτ(n)=x]=c0+c1x1+c2x2+c3x12+c4x1x2+c5x22,\mathbb{E}^{\mathbb{P}^{(n)}}\left[X^{(n)}_{1,(k+1)\tau}X^{(n)}_{2,(k+1)\tau}\middle|\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{k\tau}=x\right] = c_{0} + c_{1}x_{1} + c_{2}x_{2} + c_{3}x_{1}^{2} + c_{4}x_{1}x_{2} + c_{5}x_{2}^{2},

for constants c0,…,c5c_{0},\ldots,c_{5}. For example, in a jointly polynomial SV model where X1X_{1} represents the return and X2X_{2} the variance state, the same polynomial form gives their one-step conditional cross-moment.

The degree restriction closes the moment system under repeated conditioning; the proofs below use full polynomial preservation to establish conditional integrability over multiple steps and for products at different dates. Conditional expectations of signed random variables are understood in the generalized sense whenever the conditional expectation of their absolute value is finite almost surely.

For each m≥0m \ge0, choose a basis Hm=(Hm,1,…,Hm,Nm)T\mathbf{H}_m = (\mathbf{H}_{m,1}, \ldots, \mathbf{H}_{m,N_m})^{\mathsf{T}} of Pol⁡m(E)\operatorname{Pol}_m(E), with H0≡1\mathbf{H}_0 \equiv1, such that the first NrN_r entries of Hm\mathbf{H}_m coincide with Hr\mathbf{H}_r for every 0≤r≤m0 \le r \le m. Each p∈Pol⁡m(E)p \in\operatorname{Pol}_m(E) has a unique coordinate vector p∈RNm\mathbf{p} \in\mathbb{R}^{N_m} satisfying

p(x)=Hm(x)Tp.(3)p(\mathbf{x}) = \mathbf{H}_m(\mathbf{x})^{\mathsf{T}}\mathbf{p}. \tag*{(3)}

If X(n)\mathbf{X}^{(n)} is mm-polynomial preserving, the restriction of G(n)\mathcal{G}^{(n)} to Pol⁡m(E)\operatorname{Pol}_m(E) has a unique coordinate matrix Qm(n)\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m, characterized by

G(n)Hm(x)=(Qm(n))THm(x),(4)\mathcal{G}^{(n)}\mathbf{H}_m(\mathbf{x}) = \left(\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m\right)^{\mathsf{T}}\mathbf{H}_m(\mathbf{x}), \tag*{(4)}

where G(n)\mathcal{G}^{(n)} acts componentwise. Degree preservation makes Qm(n)\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m block upper triangular; the transpose reflects the convention that Qm(n)\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m acts on polynomial coordinate vectors. In a monomial basis, its columns contain the coefficients of the one-step conditional moments. The following proposition records the corresponding matrix-power moment formula in our notation; see Kallsen and Richert (2026a).

Proposition 1. Suppose that X(n)\mathbf{X}^{(n)} is polynomial preserving. Let p∈Pol⁡m(E)p \in\operatorname{Pol}_m(E) have coordinate vector p\mathbf{p} as in Equation (3). Then, for all integers k≥0k \ge0 and s≥0s \ge0 such that k+s≤nLk+s \le nL,

EP(n)[p(X(k+s)τ(n))|Fkτ(n)]=Hm(Xkτ(n))T(Qm(n))sp,(5)\mathbb{E}^{\mathbf{P}^{(n)}}\left[p\left(\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{(k+s)\tau}\right)\middle|\mathcal{F}^{(n)}_{k\tau}\right] = \mathbf{H}_m\left(\mathbf{X}^{(n)}_{k\tau}\right)^{\mathsf{T}}\left(\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m\right)^s\mathbf{p}, \tag*{(5)}

with the convention (Qm(n))0=INm\left(\mathbf{Q}^{(n)}_m\right)^0 = \mathbf{I}_{N_m}.

Proof. See Supplementary Material SM.F.2.

Example 1 (continued). The space Pol⁡2(E)\operatorname{Pol}_2(E) has dimension N2=1+2+3=6N_2 = 1 + 2 + 3 = 6. Choose the degree-ordered monomial basis

H2(x)=(1⏟degree 0,x1,x2⏟degree 1,x12,x1x2,x22⏟degree 2)T.\mathbf{H}_2(\mathbf{x}) = \left( \underbrace{1}_{\text{degree 0}}, \underbrace{x_1,x_2}_{\text{degree 1}}, \underbrace{x_1^2,x_1x_2,x_2^2}_{\text{degree 2}} \right)^{\mathsf{T}}.

The corresponding one-step transition matrix has the block form

References

  1. [1]Ackerer, D., D. Filipović, and S. Pulido (2018). The Jacobi stochastic volatility model. Finance and Stochastics 22(3), 667–700.
  2. [2]Augustyniak, M., A. Baddeley, J. F. Bégin, and S. K. Jayaraman (2026). On the relation between discrete- and continuous-time affine option pricing models. Econometric Theory, 1–65. First View.
  3. [3]Christoffersen, P., C. Dorion, K. Jacobs, and Y. Wang (2010). Volatility components, affine restrictions, and nonnormal innovations. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 28(4), 483–502.
  4. [4]Christoffersen, P., K. Jacobs, C. Ornthanalai, and Y. Wang (2008). Option valuation with long-run and short-run volatility components. Journal of Financial Economics 90(3), 272–297.
  5. [5]Daw, A. and J. Pender (2023). Matrix calculations for moments of Markov processes. Advances in Applied Probability 55(1), 126–150.arxiv.org/abs/1909.03320
  6. [6]Filipović, D. and M. Larsson (2016). Polynomial diffusions and applications in finance. Finance and Stochastics 20(4), 931–972.
  7. [7]Heston, S. and S. Nandi (2000). A closed-form GARCH option valuation model. Review of Financial Studies 13(3), 585–625.DOI
  8. [9]Nelson, D. B. (1990). ARCH models as diffusion approximations. Journal of Econometrics 45(1–2), 7–38.
  9. [10]Stroock, D. W. and S. R. Varadhan (1979). Multidimensional Diffusion Processes. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.

Paper details

vlnc:W_y9djm3nf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Economics, Econometrics and Finance

ChatGPT (OpenAI)

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents