betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

N-body Systems with Linear Wind Resistance: Analytic Solutions

Abstract

The attractive and repulsive linear Hookean form of gravity is known to allow for analytic solutions to N-body systems for arbitrary masses and initial conditions. This linear system is very well suited for use in the advanced undergraduate classroom with the position of every particle rj(t) known analytically in terms of only sine, cosine, and exponential functions. Here it is shown that simple analytic solutions are also possible when linear wind resistance is included, provided that the force due to wind resistance force on each particle is proportional to the mass of that particle. Surprising analytic expressions for the behavior of the system if only a single particle in the system is subject to a linear wind resistance are also presented.

Equations of Motion

The equations of motion of a set of masses {mj}\{m_j\} subject to a linear Hookean form of gravity and linear wind resistance are

r¨j≡−JMrj−bjvj+JMR(1)\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_j \equiv-J M \mathbf{r}_j - b_j \mathbf{v}_j + J M \mathbf{R} \tag*{(1)}

where rj\mathbf{r}_j is the position of the particle, JJ is a constant with units of N/kg2^2m can be positive (attractive) or negative (repulsive), MM is the total mass, bjb_j is a constant,1 vj\mathbf{v}_j is the velocity of particle jj, and R\mathbf{R} is the position of the center of mass.2 It is assumed that the wind resistance is proportional to the mass of the particle and the equations of motion become

MR¨=−bjvj≡−∑j2Γmjr˙j=−2ΓMR˙≡−2ΓMV(2)M\ddot{\mathbf{R}} = -b_j\mathbf{v}_j \equiv-\sum_j 2\Gamma m_j\dot{\mathbf{r}}_j = -2\Gamma M\dot{\mathbf{R}} \equiv-2\Gamma M\mathbf{V} \tag*{(2)}
r¨aj=−w2raj−2Γr˙aj+w2R(3)\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_{aj} = -w^2\mathbf{r}_{aj} - 2\Gamma\dot{\mathbf{r}}_{aj} + w^2\mathbf{R} \tag*{(3)}
r¨sj=+w2rsj−2Γr˙sj−w2R(4)\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_{sj} = +w^2\mathbf{r}_{sj} - 2\Gamma\dot{\mathbf{r}}_{sj} - w^2\mathbf{R} \tag*{(4)}
bj≡2mjΓw2≡MJ(5)b_j \equiv2m_j\Gamma\qquad w^2 \equiv MJ \tag*{(5)}

The subscripts of “a” (attractive) and “s” (repulsive = spreading) have been introduced to distinguish the two types of systems, “dots” denote derivatives with respect to time, and V\mathbf{V} is the velocity of the center of mass. The solution for R(t)\mathbf{R}(t) is found by direct integration of Eq. (2)

R(t)=Ro+(Vo2Γ)(1−e−2Γt)≡Rf−(Vo2Γ)e−2Γt(6)\mathbf{R}(t) = \mathbf{R}_o + \left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right)\left(1-e^{-2\Gamma t}\right) \equiv\mathbf{R}_f - \left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t} \tag*{(6)}

where the subscripts “o” and “f” indicate initial and final values. Changing variables to {Zaj}\{\mathbf{Z}_{aj}\} and {Zsj}\{\mathbf{Z}_{sj}\} which represent the vector from rj\mathbf{r}_j to Rf\mathbf{R}_f gives

Zj≡rj−RfZ˙=r˙jZ¨≡r¨j(7)\mathbf{Z}_j \equiv\mathbf{r}_j-\mathbf{R}_f \qquad\dot{\mathbf{Z}}=\dot{\mathbf{r}}_j \qquad\ddot{\mathbf{Z}}\equiv\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_j \tag*{(7)}
Z¨aj=−ω2Zaj−2ΓZ˙aj−ω2(Vo2Γ)e−2Γt(8)\ddot{\mathbf{Z}}_{aj}=-\omega^2\mathbf{Z}_{aj}-2\Gamma\dot{\mathbf{Z}}_{aj}-\omega^2\left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t} \tag*{(8)}
Z¨sj=+ω2Zsj−2ΓZ˙sj+ω2(Vo2Γ)e−2Γt(9)\ddot{\mathbf{Z}}_{sj}=+\omega^2\mathbf{Z}_{sj}-2\Gamma\dot{\mathbf{Z}}_{sj}+\omega^2\left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t} \tag*{(9)}

The solutions for Z(t)\mathbf{Z}(t) are of the form of a “homogeneous” solution (the Vo=0\mathbf{V}_o=0 case) plus a “particular” solution. The particular solutions are found by direct integration of the last terms in Eqs. (8) and (9) respectively

Zap=−(ω2Vo8Γ3)(e−2Γt−1)−(ω2Vo4Γ2)t(10)\mathbf{Z}_{ap}=-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)(e^{-2\Gamma t}-1)-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{4\Gamma^2}\right)t \tag*{(10)}
Zsp=+(ω2Vo8Γ3)(e−2Γt−1)+(ω2Vo4Γ2)t(11)\mathbf{Z}_{sp}=+\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)(e^{-2\Gamma t}-1)+\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{4\Gamma^2}\right)t \tag*{(11)}

Attractive Systems

The expression in Eq. (8) is recognized as a forced, damped simple harmonic oscillator.[2, 3, 4] which allows three different qualitative homogeneous solutions: Underdamped, Overdamped, and Critically Damped.[2] As the critically damped case is a special case, only the Overdamped ZaO\mathbf{Z}_{aO} and Underdamped ZaU\mathbf{Z}_{aU} solutions will be presented here. For the Underdamped case

ZaUj=e−Γt(Ajcos⁡(Ωt)+Bjsin⁡(Ωt))+Cjt+Dj(12)\mathbf{Z}_{aUj}=e^{-\Gamma t}\left(\mathbf{A}_j\cos(\Omega t)+\mathbf{B}_j\sin(\Omega t)\right)+\mathbf{C}_jt+\mathbf{D}_j \tag*{(12)}
Ω2=ω2−Γ2(13)\Omega^2=\omega^2-\Gamma^2 \tag*{(13)}

The constants Cj\mathbf{C}_j and Dj\mathbf{D}_j allow for an overall choice of any inertial coordinate system. Here Cj\mathbf{C}_j is chosen so that the term proportional to tt in the full solution is zero. Also Dj\mathbf{D}_j is chosen so that each Zaj(t)\mathbf{Z}_{aj}(t) meets the condition that it approaches zero as tt approaches infinity,[5]

ZaUj=e−Γt(Ajcos⁡(Ωt)+Bjsin⁡(Ωt))−(ω2Vo8Γ3)e−2Γt(14)\mathbf{Z}_{aUj}=e^{-\Gamma t}\left(\mathbf{A}_j\cos(\Omega t)+\mathbf{B}_j\sin(\Omega t)\right)-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t} \tag*{(14)}
raUj=e−Γt(Ajcos⁡(Ωt)+Bjsin⁡(Ωt))−(ω2Vo8Γ3)e−2Γt+Ro+(Vo2Γ)(15)\mathbf{r}_{aUj}=e^{-\Gamma t}\left(\mathbf{A}_j\cos(\Omega t)+\mathbf{B}_j\sin(\Omega t)\right)-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t}+\mathbf{R}_o+\left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right) \tag*{(15)}

The values of Aj\mathbf{A}_j and Bj\mathbf{B}_j are determined by the initial conditions of each particle. For the attractive overdamped case, one obtains

ZaOj=Aje−(Γ−γ)t+Bje−(Γ+γ)t−(ω2Vo8Γ3)e−2Γt(16)\mathbf{Z}_{aOj}=\mathbf{A}_je^{-(\Gamma-\gamma)t}+\mathbf{B}_je^{-(\Gamma+\gamma)t}-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t} \tag*{(16)}
raOj=Aje−(Γ−γ)t+Bje−(Γ+γ)t−(ω2Vo8Γ3)e−2Γt+Ro+(Vo2Γ)(17)\mathbf{r}_{aOj}=\mathbf{A}_je^{-(\Gamma-\gamma)t}+\mathbf{B}_je^{-(\Gamma+\gamma)t}-\left(\frac{\omega^2\mathbf{V}_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t}+\mathbf{R}_o+\left(\frac{\mathbf{V}_o}{2\Gamma}\right) \tag*{(17)}
γ2≡Γ2−ω2(18)\gamma^2\equiv\Gamma^2-\omega^2 \tag*{(18)}

Repulsive Systems

For repulsive systems described by Eq. (9) the homogeneous equation is

Z¨sj−ω2Zsj+2ΓZ˙sj≡0(19)\ddot{\mathbf{Z}}_{sj}-\omega^2\mathbf{Z}_{sj}+2\Gamma\dot{\mathbf{Z}}_{sj}\equiv0 \tag*{(19)}

Assuming a solution of exponential form and substituting gives

Zsj(t)=Ajeλt(20)\mathbf{Z}_{sj}(t)=\mathbf{A}_j e^{\lambda t} \tag*{(20)}
λ2−ω2+2Γλ≡0(21)\lambda^2-\omega^2+2\Gamma\lambda\equiv0 \tag*{(21)}
λ+=(Γ2+ω2)1/2−Γ>0λ−=−[(Γ2+ω2)1/2+Γ]<0(22)\lambda_+=(\Gamma^2+\omega^2)^{1/2}-\Gamma>0 \qquad\lambda_-=-\left[(\Gamma^2+\omega^2)^{1/2}+\Gamma\right]<0 \tag*{(22)}

The position of each particle is

rsj=(Ajeλ+t+Bje−λ+t)+(ω2Vo8Γ3)e−2Γt−Ro−(Vo2Γ)(23)\mathbf{r}_{sj}=\left(\mathbf{A}_j e^{\lambda_+t}+\mathbf{B}_j e^{-\lambda_+t}\right)+\left(\frac{\omega^2 V_o}{8\Gamma^3}\right)e^{-2\Gamma t}-\mathbf{R}_o-\left(\frac{V_o}{2\Gamma}\right) \tag*{(23)}

and as the time becomes “large” we note that

rsj(t→∞)=Ajeλ+t−Ro−(Vo2Γ)vsj(t→∞)=λ+Ajeλ+t(24)\mathbf{r}_{sj}(t\to\infty)=\mathbf{A}_j e^{\lambda_+t}-\mathbf{R}_o-\left(\frac{V_o}{2\Gamma}\right) \qquad\mathbf{v}_{sj}(t\to\infty)=\lambda_+\mathbf{A}_j e^{\lambda_+t} \tag*{(24)}

Despite an increasingly large wind resistance force every particle moves away from the origin with an exponentially increasing speed. For every component, for example the x-component, one also finds that

(vsj)x(rsj)x(t→∞)=λ+(25)\frac{(v_{sj})_x}{(r_{sj})_x}(t\to\infty)=\lambda_+ \tag*{(25)}

which fixes the ratio of potential energy to kinetic energy.

Single Particle Linear Drag

A system with N particles, but with only one particle, numbered “n,” subject to the linear wind resistance, bn=bb_n=b, allows Eq. (2) to be integrated directly

MddtV=−bddtrn(26)M\frac{d}{dt}\mathbf{V}=-b\frac{d}{dt}\mathbf{r}_n \tag*{(26)}
V−Vo=−bM(rn−rno)(27)\mathbf{V}-\mathbf{V}_o=-\frac{b}{M}\left(\mathbf{r}_n-\mathbf{r}_{no}\right) \tag*{(27)}

Because every particle interacts directly with every other particle, if any particle is subject to linear wind resistance, then it is necessarily true that

V(t→∞)=0(28)\mathbf{V}(t\to\infty)=0 \tag*{(28)}
rn(t→∞)=rno+MVob(29)\mathbf{r}_{n}(t \to\infty) = \mathbf{r}_{no} + \frac{M V_o}{b} \tag*{(29)}

As known previously, in an attractive system with Vo=0V_o = 0 all of the masses will end up at rno\mathbf{r}_{no}, regardless of NN, the values of the individual masses, or the initial conditions of the other N−1N-1 masses.[5]

The expression in Eqs. (28) and (29) are also true for repulsive systems. The one particle “afflicted” with wind resistance in a repulsive system always remains “local,” it is the only particle that remains local, and the final position is its initial position plus the displacement of the center of mass. The remaining N−1N-1 particles must move infinitely far away, while the center of mass moves according to Eq. (6).

References

  1. [2]J. R. Taylor, Classical Mechanics (University Science Books, Mill Valley, CA, 2005), pp. 174-183.
  2. [3]G. R. Fowles and G. L. Cassidy, Analytical Mechanics, 7th ed. (Brooks/Cole, Belmont, CA, 2005), pp. 98-99, 131-139
  3. [4]P. Hamill, Intermediate Dynamics, 2nd ed. (Cambridge U. P., Cambridge, England, 2022), pp. 291-308.DOI
  4. [5]J. West, “N-coupled masses with resistive forces linear in velocity: Exact expression for the final system position,” Am. J. Phys. 71, 402-404, 2003.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_yawrwgqb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents