betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Large electro-opto-mechanical coupling in VO2 neuristors

Abstract

Biological neurons are electro-mechanical systems, where the generation and propagation of an action potential is coupled to generation and transmission of an acoustic wave. Neuristors, such as VO2, characterized by insulator-metal transition (IMT) and negative differential resistance, can be engineered as self-oscillators, which are good approximations of biological neurons in the domain of electrical signals. In this study, we show that these self-oscillators are coupled electro-opto-mechanical systems, with better energy conversion coefficients than the conventional electromechanical or electrooptical materials. This is due to the significant contrast in the material's resistance, optical refractive index and density across the induced temperature range in a Joule heating driven IMT. We carried out laser interferometry to measure the opto-mechanical response while simultaneously driving the devices electrically into self-oscillations of different kinds. We analyzed films of various thicknesses, engineered device geometry and performed analytical modelling to decouple the effects of refractive index change vis-a-vis mechanical strain in the interferometry signal. We show that the effective piezoelectric coefficient (d13*) for our neuristor devices is 660 pm/V, making them viable alternatives to Pb-based piezoelectrics for MEMS applications. Furthermore, we show that the effective electro-optic coefficient (r13*) is ~22 nm/V, which is much larger than that in thin-film and bulk Pockels materials.

One sentence summary: VO2_2 neuristors are coupled electro-opto-mechanical systems, with better energy conversion coefficients than the conventional electromechanical or electrooptical materials.

INTRODUCTION

Action potentials (AP) in biological neurons, measured through electrophysiological techniques, are electrical signals that emerge and propagate along the axonal membrane[1, 2]. Significant evidence suggests that the AP generation and propagation is accompanied by rapid and transient mechanical alterations[3]. These result in mechanical changes including modifications in the axonal radius[4, 5], the release and reabsorption of a small amount of heat[6], pressure[7] and contraction of the axon at its terminus upon the arrival of the AP[8]. It has been shown that close to the temperatures of physiological interest, a chain melting phase transition in the neuronal membrane accompanied by a change in density and heat capacity, is responsible for the creation and propagation of mechanical displacements and sound waves, which cause the aforementioned alterations[9, 10]. It has been argued that the change in membrane capacitance during such a phase transition can explain the associated action potential (contrasting hypothesis to Hodgkin-Huxley models)[11], making neurons coupled electro-mechanical systems[12].

Correlated electronic systems[13] such as VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} exhibit temperature dependent first-order phase transitions, analogous to lipid membranes(14). This is an insulator-to-metal transition (IMT), accompanied by a structural change from monoclinic to rutile phase(15), signified by substantial contrast in electrical resistance(16, 17), density(18) and refractive index(19, 20) between the two phases. In a device setting, this transition occurs through current-induced Joule heating(21), resulting in volatile switching in voltage-controlled I-V measurements, and a negative differential resistance (NDR) region in current-controlled measurements(22). It has been shown by several groups, that by suitably operating the devices in the NDR regions, self-oscillations can be engineered (23–26). Infact, Yi et al., (27) have shown 23 different types of electrical signals in this neuristor system, emulating a complex portfolio of electrical activity exhibited by biological neurons. In particular, three types of neuronal signals i.e. tonic spiking, tonic bursting and phasic spiking are of interest to the current work. Tonic spiking refers to a sustained oscillatory response, throughout the period of stimulus, and is observed in retinal ganglion cells(28) and vertebrate olfactory epithelium(29). Tonic bursting refers to clusters of tonic spiking interspersed with periods of non-activity (resting) during a single stimulus. Interneurons(30) and thalamic neurons(31) are examples where tonic bursting is generally observed. Phasic spiking refers to a transient response with one or few action potentials at the outbreak of stimulus followed by resting, and is also seen in retinal ganglion neuron cells (28).

In VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} neuristors, thus far the analogy with biological neurons has been shown only in the electrical domain(27, 32). This motivated us to ask the following questions: a) whether VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} neuristors are also coupled electro-mechanical systems, especially given the large volume change occurring during IMT, b) whether these are coupled electro-optical systems, given the refractive index changes across IMT, and c) if so, more importantly, what is the magnitude of energy conversion coefficients in both the domains, and how would they compare with conventional piezoelectric and electrooptic materials. To that end, we drove the devices electrically using a DC bias into self-oscillations, and simultaneously measured the opto-mechanical response using laser interferometry. We show tonic spiking, tonic bursting and phasic spiking behaviors (from 100s kHz to MHz frequencies), and clearly demonstrate a coupled opto-mechanical response with the same power spectrum as that of the electrical oscillations, and significantly large coupling coefficients. Through systematic experiments based on varying sample thickness, device designs and analytical modelling, we understand the contributions of mechanical and optical effects to the combined response.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Thin films of VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} were grown epitaxially on sapphire (and TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2}) substrates via Pulsed Laser Deposition (PLD) (see supplementary methods for details of the growth). Cross-sectional electron transparent samples were prepared using focused ion beam technique. STEM-EELS depth profiling analysis was carried out on these lamellae to understand the chemical inhomogeneities in the film (details in Supplementary text S1, Figure S1). L2,3\mathrm{L}_{2,3} of peaks of Vanadium appear at lower energies in about the first ∼10\sim10 nm close to the surface of the film, compared to the bulk, consistent with the surface layer being at a lower oxidation state than bulk(33). This interpretation is further in line with the larger L3/L2\mathrm{L}_{3}/\mathrm{L}_{2} (white line ratios) at the surface than the bulk. (Figure S1).

Figure S1. STEM-EELS analysis: (A) Low-magnification HAADF-STEM image, different regions of FIB lamella are marked (B) High-resolution HAADF-STEM image within the thin film (Inset: FFT. (C) High-resolution HAADF-STEM image from the surface (Inset: FFT), Marked arrows show the growth direction of the film. (D) EELS spectrum imaging (SI) area on the surface (E) EELS spectrum imaging (SI) area near the interface. (F) Summed Spectra of the interface and bulk surface. (Depth profile analysis direction is marked by arrow) (G) L2L_2 and L3L_3 peak positions extracted using NLLS fitting of the bulk surface SI. Depth profiling follows the direction of the arrow shown in (D). (H) White line ratio and peak separation between L2L_2 and L3L_3 edge of V on the bulk surface. (I) L2L_2 and L3L_3 peak positions extracted using NLLS fitting of the interface SI. (J) White line ratio and peak separation between L2L_2 and L3L_3 edge of V on the interface.

On this platform, we fabricated two terminal lateral nano-gap devices (Figure 1(B)) using e-beam lithography (gap sizes: 500 nm to 900 nm), with Pt electrodes (see supplementary methods) similar to the devices discussed in (34). We measured resistance as a function of temperature (R-T) on representative devices and found atleast two different transition temperatures (Figure S2), both close to the bulk TIMTT_{\mathrm{IMT}} in VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 (68°C). Our R-T measurements along with the EELS depth profiling, allow us to propose a simple model to visualize our thin-film as a heterostructure of slightly reduced VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 (~10 nm)/VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 (~90 nm) on Sapphire substrate (Figure 1(C)).

Correlating VO2 chemistry with I-V characteristics

Figure 1. Correlating VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 chemistry with I-V characteristics (A) Cross-sectional TEM image of VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 on Sapphire. (B) Optical micrograph of the fabricated device. (C) Schematic illustrating that VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 film on Sapphire is a heterostructure consisting of a surface layer (~10 nm) with V in a slightly lower oxidation state, and bulk layer (for EELS and transport data that support this conclusion see Figure S1 and Supplementary text S1). (D) Current-Voltage characteristics of the device, in both current controlled (red) and voltage controlled (blue) modes.

Resistance versus temperature of a lateral two-terminal device

Figure S2. Resistance vs temperature of a lateral two-terminal device: This shows double hysteresis loops indicating the presence of two transition temperatures. Transition temperatures extracted as the mid points of these sub-loops are about 61 and 68 °C respectively. 68 °C is also bulk VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} transition, which in conjunction with EELS data suggests that the majority of the film is VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2}, and at the surface is reduced to an oxidation state(s) that lowers the transition temperature very slightly.

The voltage-controlled I-V measurements show a volatile switching, and current-controlled I-V profiles exhibit multiple negative differential resistance (NDR) regions (Figure 1(D)). We simulated the double NDR behavior by slightly adapting the electro-thermal model (ETM) developed by us in reference (35) (also see Figure S3), by including two heat sources, one corresponding to VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 layer, and another to the reduced VO2\mathrm{VO}_2 layer. The details of this simulation are described in the Supplementary text S2 and S3. More generally, our modelling allows us to suggest that multiple NDRs observed in various neuristors (32, 36) may be a result of heterogeneity in the cationic oxidation state in these films.

Electro-thermal simulations with electrical and thermal circuits, simulated DC I–V characteristic, and voltage and current oscillations

Figure S3. Electro-thermal simulations. (A) Electrical circuit with two variable resistors (Rd1R_{\mathrm{d1}} and Rd2R_{\mathrm{d2}}). The two variable resistors are used for two different oxidation states of Vanadium. RxR_{\mathrm{x}} is the fixed core-shell resistance (resistance outside the filament). CdC_{\mathrm{d}} is the combined device and parasitic capacitance. Current (IdI_{\mathrm{d}}) is applied to the circuit and voltage across the channel is measured as VdV_{\mathrm{d}}. (B) Thermal circuit with two heat sources Q1Q_{1} and Q2Q_{2}, one for reduced VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} and other for VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2}. The ambient temperature (ground potential) was set at room temperature (300 K). (C) Simulated DC I-V characteristic obtained from pumping current and measuring voltage (VdV_{\mathrm{d}}) using the circuit in (A). (D) Simulated voltage and current periodic (Tonic spiking) oscillations with input as constant current bias of 1mA.

To observe the current oscillations, a 20 kΩ20\ \mathrm{k}\Omega biasing resistor was connected in series with the device (along with parasitic capacitance) and voltage pulses were applied (see supplementary methods). In Figure S4 we show electrical oscillations on a representative device (gap size: 700 nm) among all the tested devices (~20), as a function of applied voltage (VaV_{\mathrm{a}}). At Va<9V_{\mathrm{a}} < 9 V, we see a simple capacitive charging and discharging of the VO2_2 neuristor (Figure S4(A)). However, for 1010 V <Va<13< V_{\mathrm{a}} < 13 V, we observe current oscillations in the form of tonic spiking (Figure S4(B)), which exhibits frequency encoding behavior of voltage, typical of neuristors (Figure S5)(35). These electrical oscillations are manifestations of device temperature oscillations across the phase transition between insulating and metallic phases in Mott insulators, and were simulated using our ETM framework ((35), Fig. S3 (D)). Interestingly, for 13.113.1 V <Va<13.8< V_{\mathrm{a}} < 13.8 V, bunched activity of current oscillations, also known as tonic bursting behavior (Figure S4(C)) appears. Finally, at Va>13.8V_{\mathrm{a}} > 13.8 V, phasic spiking (or initial spiking followed by non-activity) is observed (Figure S4(D)). Thus, in a single neuristor (not coupled to any other neuristor as in (27)) we show three different neural spiking behaviors that evolve with the application of external voltage (tonic spiking to tonic bursting to phasic spiking). Tonic bunching is captured in ETM upon inclusion of floating terminals, modeled as parallel inductors and capacitors, as shown in Figure S6(A and B) (also see supplementary text S3). It may be noted that Yi et al. have shown 23 different spiking behaviors using two coupled VO2_2 neuristors (27).

Measured different types of current oscillations

Figure S4. Measured different types of current oscillations. Y-axis left- Voltage applied. Y-axis right-Current measured. (A) Current at input voltage less than 9V. (B) Current oscillations (Tonic spiking) at 12 V. (C) Current oscillations at 13.2 V (Tonic Bursting). (D) Current response at 14V (Phasic spiking).

Frequency of current oscillations at different voltages

Figure S5. Frequency of current oscillations at different voltages.

Electrical circuit and simulated current response showing tonic-burst like behavior

Figure S6. Simulated Tonic-burst like behavior. (A) Electrical circuit used for simulating tonic bursting current oscillations. L and C are the inductors and capacitors which act as a floating terminal of the cables. (B) Simulated Current response from the circuit in (A) showing tonic-burst like behavior.

The insulator to metal transition (IMT) is also signified by a corresponding structural phase transition between the monoclinic phase and the rutile phase of VO2_2, which involves volumetric strain (mechanical displacement) and refractive index contrast. To understand and measure the possible coupled electro-mechanical and electro-optical nature of these signals, we synchronized our laser interferometry set up (in a Laser Doppler Vibrometer (LDV) system) with the parameter analyzer, as shown in Figure S7 (also see supplementary methods). We simultaneously measured the current oscillations through the parameter analyzer and optical path difference (OPD) oscillations (originating from mechanical displacements and refractive index oscillations, to be referred to as effective displacement from here on) through the interferometer as shown in Figure 2(A) (see supplementary text S4). For a representative device (D1, with channel length 850 nm) set to tonic spiking in electrical domain (Figure 2(B)), corresponding (filtered) opto-mechanical response of devices is shown in Figure 2(C) [see supplementary text S4, Figure S9(A-D) for raw signal and filtering procedures], with the amplitudes of effective displacement oscillation ∼5\sim5 nm. The fundamental frequency and the harmonics of the opto-mechanical oscillations (Figure 2(E)) are strikingly similar to the electrical oscillations (Figure 2(D)), corroborating their coupled electro-opto-mechanical nature. For another representative device D2, with channel length 700 nm set to tonic bursting, the temporal profiles of both the current oscillations (Figure 2(F)) and the effective displacement oscillations (Figure 2(G)) are the same.

Electrical and Opto-Mechanical oscillations

Figure 2. Electrical and Opto-Mechanical oscillations. (A) Schematic of measurement setup for synchronized electrical and opto-mechanical measurements. (B) Tonic spiking of current oscillations of device D1 with channel length 850nm. (C) Filtered tonic spiking of optical path difference (effective displacement) signal measured using LDV (see supplementary text S4 for details on filtering and raw signals). (D) Normalized FFT of current oscillations shown in (B). (E) Normalized FFT of filtered effective displacement shown in (C). (F) Tonic Bursting of current oscillations. (G) Tonic Bursting of displacement oscillations (raw signal) on a representative device D2 with channel length 700nm.

Synchronized LDV and Keithley parameter analyzer setup

Figure S7. Synchronized LDV and Keithley parameter analyzer setup. Both the instruments were synchronized by connecting trigger out channel of PA to the reference in port of LDV.

Comparison of original and filtered effective displacement response

Figure S9. Comparison of original and filtered effective displacement response (A) Effective displacement of as obtained response of 100 nm thick VO2_2 on Sapphire. (B) Normalized FFT of original data of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire. (C) Comparison of effective displacement of as original and filtered response of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire. (D) Normalized FFT of filtered response of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire. (E) Displacement of as obtained data of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire coated with resist and Pt on top of the channel. (F) Normalized FFT of original data of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire coated with resist and Pt on top of the channel. (G) Comparison of displacement of original and filtered response of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire coated with resist and Pt on top of the channel. (H) Normalized FFT of filtered response of 100 nm VO2_2 on Sapphire coated with resist and Pt on top of the channel. (I) Effective displacement of as obtained response of 10 nm VO2_2 on TiO2_2. (J) FFT of original data of 10 nm VO2_2 on TiO2_2. (K) Comparison of effective displacement of original and filtered response of 10 nm VO2_2 on TiO2_2. (L) Normalized FFT of filtered response of 10 nm VO2_2 on TiO2_2.

Next, we designed structures and performed experiments to uniquely understand and isolate only the coupled electro-mechanical displacements (from electro-optical effect). The device design is shown schematically in Figure S10(A), where the device is first coated by an insulator followed by a metal on the top (supplementary methods). The metal does not allow light to penetrate into the VO2_2 layer, and the insulator isolates the device electrically from the top metal. Thus, any measured path differences in the interferometry signal can only be attributed to the device mechanical displacements. This structure was achieved by spin coating PMMA (polymethyl methacrylate) as an insulating layer, and patterning Pt metal on the top using focussed ion beam technique (see supplementary methods and Figure S10).

Schematic and SEM of fabricated device

Figure S10. Device fabrication to measure the response of only mechanical oscillations. (A) Schematic of fabricated device. (B) SEM of the fabricated device.

Upon geometrically engineering the same representative device discussed in Figure 2, and resetting it to tonic spiking (Figure 3(A), see FFT in Figure 3(C)), the effective displacement amplitude (noise filtered) which corresponds solely to mechanical displacement reduced to ~0.22 nm (Figure 3(B), see FFT in Figure 3(D), also see supplementary text S4 for details on filtering and raw signals, Figure S9 (E-H)).

Plots of current oscillations, filtered displacement oscillations, normalized FFTs, and in-situ XRD

Figure 3. Isolating mechanical oscillations. (A) Current oscillations after depositing metal on top of PMMA. (B) Filtered displacement oscillations corresponding to (A) (see supplementary text S4 for raw signal and filtering procedure). (C) Normalized FFT of current oscillations in (A). (D) Normalized FFT of effective filtered displacement oscillations in (B). (E) In-situ XRD at 30°C and 100°C.

To validate if such mechanical displacements are reasonable, we performed θ\theta-2θ2\theta x-ray diffraction measurements, while heating our VO2_2 thin-films in situ across the phase transition temperature ~68°C (Figure 3(E)). The 2θ2\theta decreases from 39.89° at 30°C (monoclinic phase) to 39.80° at 100°C (rutile phase). The complete evolution of 2θ2\theta as a function of temperature is shown in Figure S11. This corresponds to 0.22% change in the out-of-plane lattice parameter, or 0.22 nm displacement amplitude for a 100 nm thick film, similar to our interferometry measurements (Figure 3(B) and S9 (D)).

Two-dimensional temperature-dependent XRD patterns of θ-2θ

Figure S11. Two-dimensional temperature-dependent XRD patterns of θ\theta-2θ2\theta. Here, 2θ2\theta is plotted as a function of temperature during heating from 30∘C30^\circ\mathrm{C} to 100∘C100^\circ\mathrm{C}. There is a clear shift in 2θ2\theta from monoclinic to rutile phase of VO2\mathrm{VO}_2.

So far, we reported the current oscillations across the device, when it is set to self-oscillations. However, to compare the electro-mechanical effect with standard piezoelectric materials, we independently measured the voltage oscillations across several DUTs of various channel lengths. Figure S12 shows measured voltage oscillations on a DUT of ~280 nm channel length (see also supplementary text S5) corresponding to a current oscillation of ~7 mA and mechanical displacement of ~0.22 nm. Using this, we estimated an effective piezoelectric coefficient (d13∗d_{13}^*) in all these devices to be ~660 ±\pm20 pm/V (see supplementary text S4 and Figure S12 (D) for estimation and error analysis), which is larger than piezoelectric thin films such as PZT (~150 pm/V)(37). Thus, more fundamentally, our results suggest that large electromechanical effects with responses larger than Pb-based piezoelectric materials can be engineered with phase-changing neuristors such as VO2_2. It is worth noting that both the metallic (rutile) and the insulating (monoclinic) phases of VO2_2 are both centrosymmetric.

Electrical circuit, voltage and current oscillations, DC-IV characteristics, and effective $d_{13}$ measurements

Figure S12. Effective d13d_{13} for 100 nm thick VO2_2 film with 278 nm channel length measured via oscilloscope with constant input current source. Voltage oscillations measured across device using differential measurement in oscilloscope (high termination resistance of 1 MΩ\Omega resistor was chosen for both ports of oscilloscope). Current oscillations measured across load resistor (50Ω\Omega). (A) Electrical circuit with input constant current to devices with different channel lengths. (B) Voltage and current oscillations with constant input current of 250uA. (C) DC-IV characteristics (V-controlled) with 700 cycles. The cycle marked with green is after all acquiring all the voltage oscillations runs. (D) Effective d13d_{13} of initial 35 cycles (marked with yellow) and 36,37 cycles after 700 DC-IV cycles (marked with green).

To uniquely quantify the refractive index oscillations experimentally, and assess these materials for electro-optic applications, we performed synchronized interferometry on another set of devices fabricated on ultra-thin VO2_2 films (~10 nm), epitaxially grown on TiO2_2 (101) ((38)), see methods). Owing to their ultra-thin nature, the mechanical displacements on these samples are negligible. Figure 4 shows data on a representative device, with filtered effective displacement oscillation amplitude of ~2.5 nm (also see Figure S9 (I-L)), corresponding to a refractive index contrast of Δn=0.115\Delta n = 0.115, between the metallic and insulating phases in this system (as obtained from analytical modelling framework described next). Electro-optic(EO) coefficient defined as r13=Δn/Emax⁡r_{13}=\Delta n/E_{\max}, where Emax⁡E_{\max} is the amplitude of electric field oscillation in the DUT (see measured voltage oscillation data in Figure S14 corresponding to a current oscillation of ~5.1 mA) is estimated as ~22 nm/V. Note that largest Pockels coefficients were reported on epitaxial thin films of BaTiO3_3, and these values r42∼943r_{42}\sim943 pm/V(39), are much smaller in comparison with EO coefficients on phase-change neuristors.

Probing refractive index oscillations on ultrathin films

Figure 4. Probing refractive index oscillations on ultrathin films. (A) Current oscillations of VO2_2 (10 nm) on TiO2_2. (B) Filtered effective displacement oscillations corresponding to current oscillations in (A). (C) FFT of current oscillations in (A). (D) FFT of effective displacement oscillations in (B). (E) Schematic of multiple reflections from thin film.

Voltage and current oscillations of a device with 600 nm channel length

Figure S14. Voltage and current oscillations of device with 600 nm channel length (VO2_2 (10 nm) on TiO2_2). For ΔV\Delta V-max =3.11=3.11 V and Δn=0.115\Delta n = 0.115, Electric field (EE-max) =5.18= 5.18 MV/m and r13=r_{13}= Δn/E\Delta n/E-max =22= 22 nm/V.

Next, we analytically modelled the path difference oscillations using optical transfer matrix framework to gain insights into the individual contributions of refractive index changes vs mechanical displacements (supplementary text S4). Given that our phase transition oscillations are non-linear (with Fourier components at Ω\Omega, 2Ω2\Omega, 3Ω3\Omega,..., see FFT of current oscillations in Figure 2(D)), we considered the change in refractive index (N+iK)(N+iK) upon phase transition from insulator-to-metal upto 4th^{\mathrm{th}} harmonic as follows:

N=n1+n22+n1−n22(A1sin⁡(Ωt)+A2sin⁡(2Ωt)+A3sin⁡(3Ωt)+A4sin⁡(4Ωt))(1)N = \frac{n_1+n_2}{2}+\frac{n_1-n_2}{2}\left(A_1\sin(\Omega t)+A_2\sin(2\Omega t)+A_3\sin(3\Omega t)+A_4\sin(4\Omega t)\right) \tag*{(1)}
K=k1+k22+k1−k22(A1sin⁡(Ωt)+A2sin⁡(2Ωt)+A3sin⁡(3Ωt)+A4sin⁡(4Ωt))(2)K = \frac{k_1+k_2}{2}+\frac{k_1-k_2}{2}\left(A_1\sin(\Omega t)+A_2\sin(2\Omega t)+A_3\sin(3\Omega t)+A_4\sin(4\Omega t)\right) \tag*{(2)}

where, n1n_1 and n2n_2 are the refractive index in insulating phase and metallic phase respectively(20), A1A_1, A2A_2, A3A_3 and A4A_4 are the Fourier components obtained from experimental current oscillations of a representative device (Figure 2(C)), and Ω\Omega is the frequency of current oscillations.

The mechanical oscillation of the membrane is also captured by the same Fourier components as follows:

Δs=ds∗(A1sin⁡(Ωt)+A2sin⁡(2Ωt)+A3sin⁡(3Ωt)+A4sin⁡(4Ωt))(3)\Delta s = d_s * \left(A_1 \sin(\Omega t) + A_2 \sin(2\Omega t) + A_3 \sin(3\Omega t) + A_4 \sin(4\Omega t)\right) \tag*{(3)}

where dsd_s is chosen to be 0.11 nm (based on in-situ XRD data in Figure 3(E)).

Assuming normal incidence with VO2_2 film on Sapphire (Figure 4(E)) we solved this problem using optical transfer matrix formalism. When light with frequency ω\omega strikes (E0=E00sin⁡(ωt)E_0 = E_{00}\sin(\omega t)) on a surface of thin film (VO2_2), it either gets reflected or transmitted and absorbed (Reflected component: Er1E_{r1}, Transmitted component: Et1E_{t1}). The membrane mechanical oscillation is solely captured in first reflection (Er1E_{r1}) as follows:

Er1=nVO2−nairnVO2+nairei(2πλΔs∗sin⁡(Ωt))E0(4)E_{r1} = \frac{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}-n_{\mathrm{air}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}+n_{\mathrm{air}}} e^{i\left(\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}\Delta s * \sin(\Omega t)\right)} E_0 \tag*{(4)}

After multiple reflections(r) and transmissions(t) (i=2, 3, ...inf), electric field components from the film interface can be written as,

Et1=4nairnVO2nVO2+nairei(2πλ((N+iK)s+Δs∗sin⁡(Ωt)))E0(5)E_{t1} = \frac{\sqrt{4n_{\mathrm{air}}n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}+n_{\mathrm{air}}} e^{i\left(\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}\left((N+iK)s+\Delta s * \sin(\Omega t)\right)\right)} E_0 \tag*{(5)}
Er2=4nairnVO2nVO2+nairnSapphire−nVO2nSapphire+nVO2ei(2πλ(N+iK)s)Et1(6)E_{r2} = \frac{\sqrt{4n_{\mathrm{air}}n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}+n_{\mathrm{air}}} \frac{n_{\mathrm{Sapphire}}-n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}}{n_{\mathrm{Sapphire}}+n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}} e^{i\left(\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}(N+iK)s\right)} E_{t1} \tag*{(6)}
Et2=nVO2−nairnVO2+nairnSapphire−nVO2nSapphire+nVO2ei(4πλ(N+iK)s)ei(2πλΔs∗sin⁡(Ωt))Et1(7)E_{t2} = \frac{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}-n_{\mathrm{air}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}+n_{\mathrm{air}}} \frac{n_{\mathrm{Sapphire}}-n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}}{n_{\mathrm{Sapphire}}+n_{\mathrm{VO}_2}} e^{i\left(\frac{4\pi}{\lambda}(N+iK)s\right)} e^{i\left(\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}\Delta s * \sin(\Omega t)\right)} E_{t1} \tag*{(7)}
Er3=4nairnVO2nVO2+nair(nsapphire−nVO2nsapphire+nVO2)2nVO2−nairnVO2+nairei(6πλ(N+iK)s+4πλΔs∗sin⁡(Ωt))Et1(8)E_{r3}=\frac{\sqrt{4n_{\mathrm{air}}n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}+n_{\mathrm{air}}}\left(\frac{n_{\mathrm{sapphire}}-n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}}{n_{\mathrm{sapphire}}+n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}}\right)^2\frac{n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}-n_{\mathrm{air}}}{n_{\mathrm{VO_2}}+n_{\mathrm{air}}}e^{i\left(\frac{6\pi}{\lambda}(N+iK)s+\frac{4\pi}{\lambda}\Delta s^{*}\sin(\Omega t)\right)}E_{t1} \tag*{(8)}

After infinite reflections at the film-air interface, and film-substrate interface, the signal E∞E_{\infty} (reaching the photodetector) is given by Eq. (9)

E∞=Er1+Er21−Er3Er2(9)E_{\infty}=E_{r1}+\frac{E_{r2}}{1-\frac{E_{r3}}{E_{r2}}} \tag*{(9)}

We calculate that the effective displacement oscillations (related to the phase of E∞E_{\infty} vs time shown in Figure 5(A), also see Supplementary text S4) have an amplitude of 5.46 nm (similar with our measurements, Figure 2(B)). The amplitude of mechanical oscillations is 0.22 nm (Er1E_{r1} vs time in Figure 5(B)) in accordance to our measured displacements (Figure 3(B)). Analytical simulations were also carried out for ultra-thin film VO2(10 nm)/TiO2\mathrm{VO_2}(10\ \mathrm{nm})/\mathrm{TiO_2} (shown in Figure S15). These results also issue a cautionary note on the interpretations of laser interferometry measurements on transparent electromechanical samples, in which electro-optic effects need to be considered. Conversely, our simple modelling framework, combined with synchronized interferometry, can be a simple and useful tool to estimate electro-optic refractive index contrast in newer materials systems.

Analytical simulations for refractive index oscillations on 100 nm thick films

Figure 5. Analytical simulations for refractive index oscillations on 100 nm thick films (A) Effective displacement oscillations including the effects of refractive index and mechanical oscillations. (B) Mechanical displacement considering only Er1E_{r1} of VO2\mathrm{VO_2} (100 nm) on sapphire.

Analytical simulations showing effective displacement and normalized FFT plots

Figure S15. Analytical simulations (A) Effective displacement considering infinite reflections of VO2_2 (10 nm) on TiO2_2. (B) Normalized FFT corresponding to (A). (C) Effective displacement considering only E1 of VO2_2 (10 nm) on TiO2_2. (D) Normalized FFT corresponding to (C).

CONCLUSION

In this work, we show that VO2\mathrm{VO_2} neuristors are not only coupled electro-mechanical systems similar to biological neurons but are coupled electro-opto-mechanical systems. First, we show in electrical domain, three different types of neuronal oscillatory behaviors from a single VO2\mathrm{VO_2} neuristor device. By adapting an electrothermal modelling framework developed earlier by us(35),and taking insights from our structural data about the chemistry of VO2\mathrm{VO_2}, we simulated the various oscillatory behaviors engineered in our VO2\mathrm{VO_2} neuristors. By synchronizing our electrical system with laser interferometry measurements, we show corresponding opto-mechanical response of VO2\mathrm{VO_2} when driven into all these types of oscillations. By a suitable geometric design of the films, we were able to measure mechanical displacement amplitudes of these self-oscillators of ∼0.22\sim0.22 nm, with their electro-mechanical response (∼660\sim660 pm/V) larger than or comparable to piezoelectric Pb-based materials. In ultrathin films, we established a simple way of estimating refractive index contrast across the phase transition, and estimated the electro-optic coefficients to be ∼25\sim25 nm/V much larger than conventional Pockels materials. Finally, we analytically modelled simple lateral two terminal devices to separate the contribution of optical response from mechanical response in one device, using optical transfer matrix formalism, and understood that refractive index modulations in these neuristors are significant. That neuristors are important neuromorphic elements has been already well established. The magnitude of effective electromechanical and electrooptic coefficients we were able to sensitively measure opens up VO2_2 neuristors as promising devices for MEMS and electrooptic applications. We advertise for VO2_2 as a great candidate for neuromorphic computing in electro-opto-mechanical domains, using MEMS and electrooptic platforms.

Acknowledgements: This work was partly carried out at Micro and Nano Characterization Facility (MNCF), and National Nanofabrication Center (NNfC) located at CeNSE, IISc Bengaluru, funded by NPMAS-DRDO and MCIT, MeitY, Government of India; and benefitted from all the help and support from the staff. P.N. acknowledges Start-up grant from IISc, Infosys Young Researcher award, and DST-starting research grant SRG/2021/000285. The authors acknowledge funding support from the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD) through NIEIN project, from Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) and Department of Science and Technology (DST) through NNetRA and the Thematic Unit of Excellence for Nano Science and Technology project from DST Nano Mission. All the authors acknowledge the usage of national nanofabrication center, micro nano characterization center, and advanced facility for microscopy and microanalysis of IISc for various fabrication and characterization studies.

Supplementary Materials for Large electro-opto-mechanical coupling in VO2_2 neuristors

Upanya Khandelwal; Rama Satya Sandilya; Rajeev Kumar Rai; Deepak Sharma; Smruti Rekha Mahapatra; Debasish Mondal; Navakanta Bhat; Naga Phani Aetkuri; Sushobhan Avasthi; Saurabh Chandorkar; Pavan Nukala

Materials and Methods

Synthesis by Pulsed Laser Deposition

Growth of VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} on Sapphire:

VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} thin films were grown on Al2O3(0001)\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}(0001) substrates through pulsed laser deposition (PLD). V2O5\mathrm{V}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5} powders (99.6% purity) were pressed at a load of 8 tons into a shape of 1 inch diameter pellet which is then sintered at 600°C in ambient atmosphere for 12hrs. This sintered V2O5\mathrm{V}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5} pellet is used as a PLD target. Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} (sapphire) substrates were cleaned thoroughly by standard solvent cleaning process (acetone, IPA and DI water) before loading into the PLD chamber. The chamber is pumped down to a base pressure of 5e-6 mbar. Substrate is then heated to 700°C. The deposition pressure of 3e-2 mbar was maintained by flowing O2\mathrm{O}_{2} gas into the chamber. V2O5\mathrm{V}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5} target was ablated by KrF excimer laser with an energy fluence close to 1J/cm2. Laser repetition rate, duration of the pulse, spot size and the energy of the laser pulse on the target are 3 Hz, 25 ns, 9 mm2 and 90 mJ respectively.

Growth of VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} on TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2}:

VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} thin films were deposited on single-crystalline rutile TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2} (101) substrates (Shinkosha, Japan) using PLD (NEOCERA) with a 248 nm KrF laser. Prior to deposition, single crystalline TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2} (101) substrates were treated using the procedure reported previously [1]. A sintered V2O5\mathrm{V}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5} pellet was used as the target. The chamber was pumped down to a base pressure of ~5×10^{-8} Torr. The laser energy density during deposition was ~ 1.5 J/cm2, a laser repetition rate of 2 Hz, deposition oxygen pressure of 10 mTorr and the substrate temperature of 425 °C was used for all the depositions. Under these conditions, the growth rate was calculated to be ~5×10^{-2} Å/pulse.

TEM imaging

Electron transparent cross-sectional samples were prepared using focused ion beam (FIB). High-angle annular dark-field (HAADF) scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) imaging and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) were performed using a probe corrected TITAN Themis microscope (60-300 kV) operating at 300 kV with a convergence angle of 24.5 mrad. HAADF-STEM images were acquired at 160 mm camera length with a probe current of 160 pA. For EELS, a probe current of 300 pA, 38 mm camera length and 0.1 eV/channel dispersion were used to maximize the signal-to-noise ratio and sufficient energy resolution. A GIF quantum ER camera provided by GATAN Inc. was used to collect the EELS spectra, using a 5 mm collection aperture on Gatan imaging filter (GIF). The images and spectra were further processed with Gatan Digital Micrograph software. Standard EELS tuning procedure was employed before acquiring real spectra, with the width of the Zero Loss Peak being 0.8 eV.

Device fabrication

Two terminal lateral devices were fabricated on VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2}/Sapphire and VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2}/TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2} using e-beam lithography (EBL). Samples were first spin-coated with PMMA 495A4 followed by patterning for electrodes via EBL with channel lengths ranging from 700-900 nm. After developing the patterned electrodes, 30nm Platinum (Pt) was sputtered for the metal contacts followed by lift-off. The optical image of the patterned device is shown in Figure 1(B).

Experimental setup for measuring current oscillations

To measure current oscillations, we use Keithley 4200 SCS parameter analyzer (PA) with two PMU’s (Pulse measuring units). PMU 1(used to generate voltage pulses) was connected to a bias resistor of 20kΩ\Omega and this bias resistor is then connected to one terminal of the device. The other terminal of the device was connected to PMU 2 which was grounded. Current was measured through PMU 2.

Synchronized setup for Current and Displacement Measurements

For measuring current oscillations, LDV and PA were synchronized to measure current and displacement simultaneously (Figure 2A). To synchronize LDV with PA, trigger output of the PA was fed to the reference channel of LDV setup. Optical path difference oscillations were measured as an output of displacement from LDV. Measurement setup is shown in Figure S7.

Device fabrication to measure the effect of only mechanical motion

The device fabricated as described in the device fabrication section was used and coated with 80nm thick e-beam resist PMMA 950A2. Patterning was done using EBL to develop the regions for probing the electrodes. After this 50-80 nm e-beam Pt was deposited using focused ion beam (FIB). Schematic and SEM image shown in Figure S10 (A and B) respectively.

Supplementary Text

S1. STEM-EELS Analysis

The overview HAADF-STEM image of the 100 nm thick VO2_2 film on sapphire is shown in Figure S1(A). High-resolution HAADF-STEM images of VO2_2 film in the bulk and on the surface is shown in Figure S1 (B and C) respectively, with corresponding FFTs in the inset. The film is oriented along [10] (Zone axis: [100]), and there are no resolvable lattice parameter changes from the bulk of the film to the surface.

Spatially resolved Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS) was employed to examine the oxidation state variation of V in the VO2_2 film. Spectrum images were recorded from the interface between sapphire and VO2_2 film, and close to the surface V L2,3_{2,3}-edges are shown in Figure S1(F). L3_3 and L2_2 peaks arise at 518.5 eV, 525.1 eV at the interface, and at 517.6 and 524.2 eV at the surface. These peaks correspond to the energy loss caused due to excitation of 2p3/2_{3/2} and 2p1/2_{1/2} states, respectively to unoccupied 3d bands[2]. O K edge (appears as two broad peaks in 528-550 eV) and can also be observed alongside V L2,3_{2,3}. Peak position and intensity ratio of L3_3/L2_2, also known as white line ratio, is a good indicator of the oxidation state of V[3, 4, 5]. The appearance of V L2,3_{2,3} peaks at lower values at the surface compared to the interface, indicates that V at the surface is at a lower oxidation state compared to the interface. To get more insight into the variation of the peak position and white line ratio along the film, a depth profile EELS analysis was performed. The spectrum image near the surface is summed within 0.81 nm thickness, and non-linear least square (NLLS) fitting[6] using DM software was performed to extract the intensity and peak position of L3L_3 and L2L_2 edges. The extracted peak positions are shown in Figure S1(G). L2L_2 peak (for e.g.) evolves from a peak position of 525.1 eV to 524.2 eV over a length scale of ~8 to 10 nm near surface (from 12-15 nm away from the surface to ~5 nm away from the surface). L3L_3 also follows a similar trend. The first 5 nm close to the surface shows saturation in the L2L_2 (also L3L_3) peak positions at 524.2 eV. White line ratio (IL3/IL2I_{L3}/I_{L2}) also increases on moving towards the surface as shown in Figure S1(H). This is also consistent with a decrease in Vanadium oxidation state when proceeding towards the surface from the bulk [3, 4, 5]. Similar NLLS fitting and depth profiling was performed on V L2,3L_{2,3} lines from the Sapphire interface to 15 nm into the bulk of the film (Total SI of 20 nm including 5 nm of Sapphire) (Figure S1(E)). The peak positions and intensity ratio, Figure S1 (I, J), don’t change, revealing no oxidation state changes in V in the bulk of VO2_2. All in all, EELS data reveals that the film is reduced in the first 12-15 nm (5 nm of constant peak position + 10 nm of gradual change) close to the surface.

That the oxidation state of Vanadium on the surface is less than that in the bulk is also consistent with a slight left shift of O-K edge from surface to the bulk (Figure S1(F)). It must be noted that we hesitate here to give the exact oxidation states, given that the fine structure is more complex, and would require detailed theoretical support. By comparing the values of peak positions studied in literature [4], we believe that the V in the entire film is in an oxidation state close to 4 (~4 in bulk and 4-δ at the surface). This is further substantiated by our van der Pauw measurements, that clearly show a transition at 68°C corresponding to VO2_2 (or V in 4+), and at 61°C, corresponding to V in 4-δ. This allows us to model our thin film as two parallel layers, VO2(1−δ)_{2(1-\delta)} with a thickness of 10 nm (Figure 1(C)), and VO2_2 with a thickness of 90 nm, electrically in parallel to each other. Such visualization allows us to model the multiple NDR regions that we observe experimentally.

Electro-thermal Modelling (ETM)

We modelled the electrical circuit with two variable resistors, Rd1_{d1} and Rd2_{d2}, corresponding to the two layers discussed above (Figure 1C). The thermal circuit consists of two input heat sources, Q1_1 and Q2_2 corresponding to Joule heating in the two layers.

ETM simulations were adapted from the single layer system in [6] to the two-layer system. The transition temperatures of these two variable resistors were kept as 335 K and 340 K (As confirmed from Figure S2).

In the simulated electrical circuit illustrated in Figure S3(A), current (Id_d) is applied to the device with one fixed resistor (RX_X), two variable resistors (Rd1_{d1} and Rd2_{d2}) and a capacitor (Cd_d, device + parasitic). The thermal circuit in Figure S3(B) is similar to [7] other than the additional heat source with its corresponding heat resistors and capacitors for the second layer. The output power of electrical circuit in Figure S3(A) (Q1_1(Id1_{d1}(Rd1_{d1}) * Vd_d)) is fed to the node A of thermal circuit while the output power Q2_2(Id2_{d2}(Rd2_{d2})*Vd_d) is fed to the node B of the thermal circuit.

Subscript 1 in the notation for thermal resistors and thermal capacitors indicates the region of the device(channel) under the active area while subscript 2 indicates the region outside the channel. Here, RV and CV refer to the thermal resistors and capacitors of reduced VO2_2 respectively while RVO and CVO refer to the thermal resistors and capacitors of bulk VO2_2 respectively. RS and CS respectively refer to the thermal resistors and capacitors of Sapphire (or TiO2_2) substrate. To maintain the symmetry in the circuit, capacitors are connected in the middle of two thermal resistors as per standard practice. In the thermal circuit, the ambient temperature of the sample was simulated using a DC voltage source. In particular, the illustrated model has a 300 V DC voltage source representing ambient temperature of 300 K. The two NDRs in the DC I-V characteristic obtained using this electro-thermal model are shown in Figure S3(C). It should be noted here that no artificial fitting parameters were used to arrive at this characteristic and that the I-V characteristic emerges naturally from the model by utilising physically measured properties. The specific details and values for each parameter used in the model is given in Table S1.

ParametersDescriptionValueReference
σins−V\sigma_{ins-\mathrm{V}}Insulating state electrical conductivity of reduced vanadium oxide1e51\mathrm{e}^{5} S/mEstimated
σm−V\sigma_{m-\mathrm{V}}Metallic state electrical conductivity of reduced vanadium oxide5e55\mathrm{e}^{5} S/mEstimated
Ts−VT_{s-\mathrm{V}}Transition temperature of reduced vanadium oxide335 KEstimated
αV\alpha_{\mathrm{V}}Spread about transition temperature of reduced vanadium oxide1Estimated
κins\kappa_{ins}Insulating state thermal conductivity3.6 W/m/K[11]
κm\kappa_mMetallic state thermal conductivity5.4 W/m/K[11]
ρ\rhoMass density of both vanadium layers4571 kg/m3^{3}
CCHeat capacity of both vanadium layers690 J/kg/K[12]
Thickness_VThickness of reduced vanadium oxide10e−910\mathrm{e}^{-9} mEstimated
σins−VO\sigma_{ins-\mathrm{VO}}Insulating state electrical conductivity of vanadium oxide1e31\mathrm{e}3 S/mEstimated
σm−VO\sigma_{m-\mathrm{VO}}Metallic state electrical conductivity of vanadium oxide3e53\mathrm{e}5 S/mEstimated
Ts−VOT_{s-\mathrm{VO}}Transition temperature of vanadium oxide340 KEstimated
αVO\alpha_{\mathrm{VO}}Spread about transition temperature of vanadium oxide4Estimated
Thickness_VOThickness of vanadium oxide90e−990\mathrm{e}^{-9} mEstimated
Channel widthWidth of the device2e−62\mathrm{e}^{-6} mFabricated
Filament widthWidth of filament formed0.1e−60.1\mathrm{e}^{-6} mFabricated
Sample LengthLength of the sample1e−21\mathrm{e}^{-2} mFabricated
Sample WidthWidth of the sample1e−21\mathrm{e}^{-2} mFabricated
ρ\rho_sapphireMass density of Sapphire3.97e33.97\mathrm{e}^{3} kg/m3^{3}[13]
CC_sapphireHeat capacity of sapphire763 J/kg/K[13]
Thickness sapphireThickness of sapphire250e−6250\mathrm{e}^{-6} m
Cp+CdC_{\mathrm{p}}+C_{\mathrm{d}}Parasitic and device capacitances2e−92\mathrm{e}^{-9} FEstimated

Table S1.

Simulated current oscillations

The ETM model leads to tonic spiking behavior as shown in Figure S3(D). Using our electro-thermal modelling approach, we also simulate tonic burst-like behavior as seen in our measurements. The electrical circuit used to achieve this behavior is shown in Figure S6(A) has L∥CL \mathbin{\|} C which is used to simulate the floating terminal of the cables in the measurements. The thermal circuit and the values of components used are same as in Figure S3(B). The values for the components used in the electrical circuit have been listed in Table S2. The current output depicting tonic burst like behavior is simulated for a given voltage pulse in Figure S6(B).

ParametersValue
VsV_{\mathrm{s}}47.64 V47.64\ \mathrm{V}
RsR_{\mathrm{s}}10 kΩ10\ \mathrm{k}\Omega
L1L_10.1 H0.1\ \mathrm{H}
L2L_20.01 H0.01\ \mathrm{H}
C1C_16e−9 F6\mathrm{e}^{-9}\ \mathrm{F}
C2C_21e−5 F1\mathrm{e}^{-5}\ \mathrm{F}
CdC_{\mathrm{d}}1.5e−9 F1.5\mathrm{e}^{-9}\ \mathrm{F}
13. S. Al, SAPPHIRE (Al₂O₃), 213.

Table S2.

Synchronized setup for Current and Displacement Measurements

To study the coupled effect of oscillations, we measured the out of plane displacement of VO₂ using laser interferometry on a laser doppler vibrometer (LDV) with 632 nm laser. To simultaneously measure oscillations, both PA and LDV were synchronized (measurement set-up shown in Figure S7). Double beam laser interferometry is a widely used technique for measuring mechanical motion detected as changes in the optical path difference at the photodetector. However, on transparent samples that show refractive index modulations, refractive index modulations also contribute to the optical path difference modulations. In our case, VO₂ is transparent to light in both insulating and metallic phases of λincident=632\lambda_{\mathrm{incident}} = 632 nm (λplasma=909\lambda_{\mathrm{plasma}} = 909 nm in the metallic phase >λincident> \lambda_{\mathrm{incident}})[8]. Thus our optical path difference modulations include both refractive index modulations and mechanical oscillations in VO₂ across the phase transition.

The raw time domain signal of effective displacement shows a significantly high noise floor (~100 pm). In order to extract the signal more effectively, we employed a time domain filtering technique using the ‘designfilt’ and ‘filtfilt’ functions in MATLAB. The ‘designfilt’ function is used to design the filter by specifying its characteristics and returns a filter object that represent the designed filter. Whereas ‘filtfilt’ is used to apply filter to the input signal. The objective was twofold: to effectively suppress the noise components while preserving the integrity of the harmonic responses, and to extract the output signal representing the effective displacement by summing over the harmonics displacement signals.

Figs. S9 (A,E and I) shows the as obtained experimental effective displacement response with their normalized FFT’s in Figs. S9 (B,F and G). Figs. S9 (C, G and K) shows the comparison between the original and the filtered effective displacement response. Furthermore, we performed FFT on filtered signal and visualized the results in Figs. S9 (D, H and L). These plots demonstrates the time domain filtering on the frequency content, revealing the improvements in the signal to noise ratio post filtering.

Refractive index modulations in effective displacement

These modulations were modeled in a simple transfer matrix formulation described in the manuscript. From Figure 4E, Er1E_{r1} gives contribution to only mechanical motion whereas Er1+Er2+…∞E_{r1}+E_{r2}+\ldots\infty terms contributes to both optical and mechanical oscillations. We used the values of NN and KK as given by Eqn’s. S1 and S2:

NVO2=2.325+0.115{sin⁡(wt)+0.75(sin⁡2wt)+0.5(sin⁡3wt)+0.4(sin⁡4wt)}(10)N_{VO_2}=2.325+0.115\{\sin(wt)+0.75(\sin2wt)+0.5(\sin3wt)+0.4(\sin4wt)\} \tag*{(10)}
KVO2=0.244−0.036{sin⁡(wt)+0.75(sin⁡2wt)+0.5(sin⁡3wt)+0.4(sin⁡4wt)}(11)K_{VO_2}=0.244-0.036\{\sin(wt)+0.75(\sin2wt)+0.5(\sin3wt)+0.4(\sin4wt)\} \tag*{(11)}

The values of n1n_1 and n2n_2 in Eqs. (1) and (2) are used from [9] and fourier components from Figure 2D.

To estimate the effective path difference from the electric field component (E∞E_{\infty}, interference of all the electric field components), we separate real and imaginary part of E∞E_{\infty}. Phase difference between E0E_0 and E∞E_{\infty} is given by Eq. (12), Velocity and Displacement (Eq. S4 (A) and (B)) are estimated from phase difference as in [10]:

Phase difference=tan⁡−1imag(E∞)real(E∞)(12)\mathit{Phase\ difference}=\tan^{-1}\frac{\mathit{imag}(E_{\infty})}{\mathit{real}(E_{\infty})} \tag*{(12)}
Velocity=ddt(Phase difference)∗λ2∗π(13)\mathit{Velocity}=\frac{\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}(\mathit{Phase\ difference})*\lambda}{2*\pi} \tag*{(13)}
Displacement=∫(Velocity) dt(14)\mathit{Displacement}=\int(\mathit{Velocity})\ \mathrm{d}t \tag*{(14)}

Here, λ\lambda = wavelength of the incident light. Path difference is the effective displacement which is measured by the LDV.

Estimation of d13∗d_{13}^* from Voltage oscillations

To estimate the effective d13∗d_{13}^* coefficient, we measured voltage and current oscillations via oscilloscope (Figure S12(A)) with constant bias current on device with channel length 278 nm. Here, constant current (I, corresponding to NDR region) was applied to the device under test (DUT), voltage across the DUT (with 1MΩ\Omega termination) and current flowing through DUT (with 50 Ω\Omega termination) were measured (Figure S12 (B)). It must be noted that the amplitude of current oscillations (~7mA) is much higher than the input current (0.25 mA). The presence of parasitic and device capacitances contributes to the observed phenomenon as explained next in S6.

We measured voltage oscillations for 35 cycles (1 cycle of 5ms) shown in yellow region of Figure S12 (D). Following this, we performed DC-IV cycling for 700 cycles as shown in white region of Figure S12(C), during which threshold voltage for insulator to metal transition fluctuated between 1.3 and 1.4 V, and metal to insulator transition fluctuated in a very narrow range between 0.35 and 0.38 V. Voltage amplitude fluctuations measured before (35 cycles, Figure S12(D)-yellow) and after (36th and 37th cycle, Figure S12 (D), green) DC IV cycling are less than 3%. From this data, we estimated d13∗d_{13}^* 660 ±\pm20 pm/V.

Explanation for the amplified current across load resistor

The circuit used to explain this phenomenon is shown in Figure S13(A) along with the current controlled II-VV in Figure S13 (B). The capacitors C1C_1 and C3C_3 are considered as parasitic capacitors while C2C_2 represents device capacitance. These are inherent to the system and cannot be eliminated during the analysis.

Circuit with constant-current source, DUT, capacitors $C_1$, $C_2$, and $C_3$, and load resistor $R_l$, alongside the I–V characteristic showing the NDR region between $V_h$ and $V_{th}$

Figure S13. Circuit used to explain the amplification of current flowing across load resistor (RlR_l) (A) The circuit configuration involves the application of constant current to the circuit, which includes DUT and RlR_l (50Ω50 \Omega). The load resistor is used to measure voltage drop and hence to output current. The values of C1C_1-C3C_3 determine the frequency of oscillation. (B) The II-VV characteristic of DUT with NDR region between VhV_h and VthV_{th}.

Initially, when the biasing current (corresponding to NDR region) is applied to the circuit, the DUT is in high resistance state. Capacitors C1C_1 and C2C_2 begin to charge, and voltage across DUT starts increasing from VhV_h (hold voltage) to VthV_{th} (threshold voltage).

As the voltage reaches VthV_{th}, the DUT undergoes a sudden transition from an insulating state to a metallic state. This transition results in huge current flowing through the DUT and subsequently through the load resistor, RlR_l and the capacitor C3C_3 gets charged as well. The current is supplied by the discharge of capacitor C1C_1 and C2C_2.

At this stage, all the capacitors including C1C_1 start getting discharged through resistors, causing the voltage across DUT to drop from VthV_{th} to VhV_h. Simultaneously, with much lower heat being generated by the device due to low resistance state, the temperature starts dropping.

At VhV_h, the DUT switches back to its insulating state due to temperature dropping below the transition temperature, causing the current passing through the load resistance to diminish. From here on out, the cycle repeats.

Supplementary Figures

Fig. S1

Figure S2

Figure S4

Figure S5

Figure S6

Figure S7

Figure S8

Current and effective displacement oscillations

Figure S8. Zoomed-in images of (A) Current oscillations in Figure 2(B). (B) Effective displacement oscillations in Figure 2(C).

Fig. S9

Figure S10

Figure S11

Fig. S12

Figure S13

Figure S14

Fig. S15

Table S1

The table provides the description and the values of the parameters used in the ETM for reduced VO2_2, VO2_2 and sapphire substrate. Here, V is used as an abbreviation for reduced VO2_2 layer and VO for VO2_2.

Table S2

References

  1. [1]D. Mondal, S. R. Mahapatra, T. Ahmed, S. K. Podapangi, A. Ghosh, N. P. B. Aetukuri, Atomically-smooth single-crystalline VO2 (101) thin films with sharp metal-insulator transition. J. Appl. Phys. 126 (2019), doi:10.1063/1.5124106.DOI
  2. [2]C. Ahn, O. Krivanek, R. Burgner, M. D.-(No Title), undefined 1983, EELS atlas: a reference collection of electron energy loss spectra covering all stable elements. cir.nii.ac.jp (available at https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1130282269511841152).
  3. [3]R. Egerton, Electron energy-loss spectroscopy in the electron microscope (2011; https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=C8OZsABSk2sC&oi=fnd&pg=PR5&dq=Egerton,+R.+F.+(2011).+Electron+energy-loss+spectroscopy+in+the+electron+microscope.+Springer+Science+%26+Business+Media&ots=W1tamZ_H6j&sig=iN24W2dhLFL76yyAKe7Kux-Ys7U).
  4. [4]A. Gloskovskii, S. A. Nepijiko, G. Schönhense, H. A. Therese, A. Reiber, H. C. Kandpal, G. H. Fecher, C. Felser, W. Tremel, M. Klimenkov, Spectroscopic and microscopic study of vanadium oxide nanotubes. J. Appl. Phys. 101 (2007), doi:10.1063/1.2716157.DOI
  5. [5]S. Kalavathi, S. Amirthapandian, S. Chandra, P. C. Sahu, H. K. Sahu, Valence state, hybridization and electronic band structure in the charge ordered AlV2O4. J. Phys. Condens. Matter. 26 (2014), doi:10.1088/0953-8984/26/1/015601.DOI
  6. [6]R. D. Leapman, C. R. Swyt, Separation of overlapping core edges in electron energy loss spectra by multiple-least-squares fitting. Ultramicroscopy. 26, 393–403 (1988).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3238813
  7. [7]U. Khandelwal, Q. Guo, B. Noheda, P. Nukala, S. Chandorkar, Dynamics of Voltage Driven Self-Sustained Oscillations in NdNiO3 Neuristors.
  8. [8]T. Peterseim, M. Dressel, M. Dietrich, A. Polity, Optical properties of VO2 films at the phase transition: Influence of substrate and electronic correlations. J. Appl. Phys. 120 (2016), doi:10.1063/1.4961406.DOI
  9. [9]M. Currie, M. A. Mastro, V. D. Wheeler, Characterizing the tunable refractive index of vanadium dioxide. Opt. Mater. Express. 7, 1697 (2017).DOI
  10. [10]T. Vo-dinh, Laser Doppler Vibrometry for Non-Contact Diagnostics.DOI
  11. [11]D. W. Oh, C. Ko, S. Ramanathan, D. G. Cahill, Thermal conductivity and dynamic heat capacity across the metal-insulator transition in thin film VO2. Appl. Phys. Lett. 96 (2010), doi:10.1063/1.3394016.
  12. [12]J. Ordonez-Miranda, Y. Ezzahri, K. Joulain, J. Drevil lon, J. J. Alvarado-Gil, Modeling of the electrical conductivity, thermal conductivity, and specific heat capacity of VO2. Phys. Rev. B. 98, 1–7 (2018).
  13. [13]S. Al, SAPPHIRE (Al₂O₃), 213.

Paper details

vlnc:W_yfc583zv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents