WorksPhysics and Astronomy
The nuclear charge radius of
Abstract
The size is a key property of a nucleus. Accurate nuclear radii are extracted from elastic electron scattering, laser spectroscopy, and muonic atom spectroscopy. The results are not always compatible, as the proton-radius puzzle has shown most dramatically. Beyond helium, precision data from muonic and electronic sources are scarce in the light-mass region. The stable isotopes of carbon are an exception. We present a laser spectroscopic measurement of the root-mean-square (rms) charge radius of and compare this with ab initio nuclear structure calculations. Measuring all hyperfine components of the fine-structure triplet in ions referenced to a frequency comb allows us to determine its center-of-gravity with accuracy better than although second-order hyperfine-structure effects shift individual lines by several . We improved the uncertainty of determined with electrons by a factor of and found a discrepancy with the muonic atom result of similar accuracy.
Introduction
The main sources for absolute nuclear charge radii of stable isotopes are elastic electron scattering [1] and muonic atom spectroscopy [2, 3], i.e., the energy determination of X-rays emitted in transitions in muonic atoms. The combination of both is considered to deliver the most accurate values, which serve as anchor points for the determination of charge radii along an isotopic chain using isotope-shift measurements in rare and short-lived species [4, 5]. For the proton’s size, electronic measurements, i.e., laser spectroscopy of hydrogen [6] and elastic electron scattering [7] on one side, and laser spectroscopy of muonic hydrogen on the other side [8], led to a surprising discrepancy of the proton’s charge radius, which became famously known as the “proton radius puzzle”. Even though laser and microwave spectroscopy of ordinary hydrogen become increasingly consistent with the smaller radius from muonic hydrogen [9, 10, 11], there are still measurements reporting larger radii [12, 13]. Similarly, the source of the discrepancy to electron scattering is still under debate [14, 15, 16] and is a motivation for the MUSE experiment at PSI [17] with the goal to perform muon-proton scattering to test lepton universality in the electromagnetic interaction. Contrary, in , electron scattering and muonic atom laser spectroscopy are in good agreement [18, 19], while the resulting difference in mean-square (ms) charge radius is in tension with several results from laser spectroscopy of ordinary helium [20]. These are, however, affected by a long-standing disagreement – depending on the transition and the applied technique, they scatter by several [21]. Very recently, these tensions in charge radii differences of and are partially resolved by taking into account second-order hyperfine corrections [22, 23]. For the next elements, Li, Be, and B, nuclear charge radii are about two orders of magnitude less precise than in hydrogen or He and for N, O, and F, it is only slightly better [5, 24]. Second-generation muonic X-ray experiments are in preparation that will apply magnetic calorimeters and use improved theoretical calculations to extract absolute nuclear radii of stable isotopes from beryllium to neon [24].
The only exception in the second row of the periodic table is carbon. The charge radius of was determined with exceptional 2 and 1 per mille accuracy by electron scattering [25] and muonic atom X-ray spectroscopy [26], respectively, but a small discrepancy between the two values is observed. For , the second stable isotope, results from both methods agree within the comparably large uncertainty of the electron-scattering result. Thus, there is a demand for more precise knowledge of the charge radius of from the electronic sector. Moreover, radii of light nuclei are also particularly interesting for nuclear structure theory as they are accessible to different ab initio methods and show substantial structural changes between neighboring isotopes [27]. A reason for this is the tendency of the nucleons to form clusters, which in light nuclei constitute a large portion of the nucleus [28, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35] [29]. To reproduce the size of the firmly bound subshell-closed nucleus of with ab initio nuclear structure calculations, a significant admixture of a -cluster configuration is required that is governed by the Hoyle state [36, 37, 38, 39, 40]. This characteristic structure is essential in the -nucleosynthesis process in stars and supernovae [41, 42, 43]. In , the additional neutron may be thought to act as a covalent bond inside the structure [32], explaining the smaller radius of compared with as it was determined consistently by elastic electron scattering and muonic atom spectroscopy. The experimental accuracy of the radius solely based on electronic measurements can be improved by combining the accurate electron scattering result with a precise determination of the differential ms charge radius extracted from an isotope-shift measurement.
So far, there is no laser-spectroscopic nuclear-structure information for the elements beyond Be [44, 45] up to neon [46]. This holds for the stable and short-lived isotopes except for a measurement of the isotope shift in stable [35]. Efforts in the laser spectroscopic determination of charge radii in this region have to face three main challenges: Firstly, the electronic level schemes of the elements above boron are complicated, and excitation from the ground state of atoms or singly charged ions is not feasible with currently available high-precision lasers. Secondly, high-accuracy mass-shift calculations for the systems beyond boron, which are required to extract the nuclear charge radius, are unavailable. Finally, due to their chemical reactivity, most of these elements can only be extracted in the form of molecules at on-line isotope separator (ISOL) facilities, while at in-flight facilities the stopping of such light products requires large stopping cells and the yields are comparably low. Here, we demonstrate an approach that opens up prospects for such measurements by simultaneously overcoming all three hurdles.
Our experimental method is based on generating He-like ions – in this case ions – in the excited metastable state. From here, laser excitation into the manifold is possible with ultraviolet light. This transition has been previously studied in to perform a test of non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics (NRQED) calculations and to demonstrate that an “all-optical” nuclear charge radius extraction with high accuracy is potentially possible [47, 48]. While the charge radius of can, in principle, be extracted directly from the transition frequency, theory is not yet sufficiently advanced to make this “all-optical” approach competitive with the alternative methods [47]. In this work, we present a measurement of the charge radius of based on an optical isotope-shift measurement and NRQED mass-shift calculations with accuracy that already exceeds the available electron-scattering data on . Since the isotope shift, i.e., the difference in transition frequency between two isotopes
with mass numbers and
it thus follows that the change in the ms nuclear charge radius can be extracted according to
in a nuclear-model independent way, provided that the mass shift and the field-shift factor can be reliably calculated.
This approach is currently only possible for up to five-electron systems [35]. Hence, spectroscopy on neutral carbon atoms is not an option, but mass-shift calculations for the He-like system are readily available and the field-shift factor of in the laser-accessible transition provides a high sensitivity to the charge radius. Our measurement of the charge radius of makes the pair the nuclei with the currently best-known nuclear charge radii besides the stable isotopes of hydrogen and helium, for which laser spectroscopy was performed on muonic atoms [18, 19, 49]. We finally note that this has been achieved despite strong perturbations by hyperfine-induced fine-structure mixing and required high-precision measurements of all nine hyperfine components in the three fine-structure lines.
Results
We performed the measurements at the COLlinear Apparatus for Laser Spectroscopy and Applied Sciences (COLLAPS) at the Institute for Nuclear Physics at TU Darmstadt. The setup and the recent extensions for highly charged ions are described in [48, 50] and we only briefly summarize the most relevant aspects for our work. A sketch of COALA and the measurement principle is depicted in Figure 1. A continuous beam of ions with a beam current of approximately and an energy of is produced in our electron beam ion source (EBIS-A, DREEBIT GmbH). We feed -enriched methane gas () at a pressure of into the EBIS. The molecules are cracked and charge states up to fully stripped ions are reached through subsequent collisions of the ions with the electron beam. The ions are confined by the electrostatic potentials of the trap electrodes and the electron beam’s space charge in axial and radial directions, respectively. The starting point for laser spectroscopy is the metastable state in He-like with a lifetime of [51]. It is dominantly populated through electron-capture processes of [48]. The electrode generating the axial trapping potential at the trap exit is only above the central trap potential (). Thus, a small fraction of the trapped ions continuously leaks out of the trap and is accelerated toward ground potential. A velocity filter (Wien filter) formed by crossed magnetic and electric fields is used to separate the C ions from other charge states and ion species. Behind the source region, an electrostatic 60°-bender followed by -steerers and a quadrupole doublet are used to super-
Figure 1. Experimental setup. Sketch of the measurement principle including the electron-beam ion source (EBIS), the electrostatic switchyard, the beam alignment irises, the laser system, and the fluorescence detection region (FDR). The laser system consists of two Millennia pump lasers (Nd:YVO) that drive two Ti:Sapphire lasers, each followed by two frequency doublers, one operated with lithium-triborate (LBO) and second one with barium betaborate (BBO). The lasers are locked to a wavemeter and a frequency comb. The 227-nm light is then transported through air to the COALA beamline. The two charge-breeding processes, electron-impact ionization and electron capture, are shown in the inset above the EBIS potential.
impose the ion beam with the laser beams and to shape the ion beam, respectively. The fluorescence detection region (FDR) is floated on a scan voltage to adjust the ion velocity and thereby scan the laser frequency in the rest-frame of the ions (Doppler tuning).
Two continuous-wave Ti:sapphire lasers produce light between 906 and 914 nm that is twice frequency doubled to create the range from 226.5 to 228.5 nm required to perform collinear and anticollinear laser spectroscopy on the ions in fast alternation. We note that the lines are shifted by nm due to the Doppler shift. The exact frequency depends on the ion velocity but this dependency is eliminated if the resonance frequencies in both collinear and anticollinear direction are determined. The geometric average of the observed resonance frequencies in the laboratory frame is the transition frequency in the rest frame of the ion. Both Ti:sapphire lasers are simultaneously locked to a frequency comb to obtain and with high accuracy. A schematic of the hyperfine structure in the multiplet is shown in Figure 2 (a), and the observed spectrum is depicted in (b). The HFS is well resolved in all transitions and spans 60 to 90 GHz. The relative peak heights vary based on their dipole transition strengths with the peak of the weakest transition being ten times smaller than that of the strongest. Due to the large hyperfine splitting and the narrow full width of half maximum of 150 MHz, the individual transitions are compressed to a line in the overview plot. Therefore, the fits are shown in the inset for the smallest (left) and the strongest (right) hyperfine components to indicate the typical statistical significance. Resonances are fitted with a pure Gaussian lineshape since the natural linewidth of 9 MHz [51] and possible homogeneous broadening mechanisms are negligible compared to the width of the velocity distribution of the ions. The total statistical uncertainty of the resonance center is in all cases MHz and therefore significantly smaller than potential systematic shifts.
Figure 2. Atomic spectroscopy data of C. a Level scheme of C and the electric dipole transitions that are addressed by the laser. b Hyperfine structure (HFS) spectrum of the transitions in C simulated with the experimentally determined frequencies and linewidths. The -axis represents the laser frequency in the rest-frame of the ion relative to the center-of-gravity frequency of the respective fine-structure transition. The peak heights were set to the theoretical transition strengths used in Eq. (7). The two insets show measured spectra of the marked transitions. Next to the resonances, the contributing quantum numbers of the lower and upper state are shown, respectively.
The largest systematic uncertainty originates from the imperfect alignment of the two laser beams. If the collinear and the anticollinear laser beam are slightly offset in the detection region, they address different ion velocities and the Doppler shift is not fully canceled in the geometric average. Experimental verification of this effect provided a conservative limit of 1.7 MHz under the given experimental conditions [48]. This is the dominant contribution to the systematic uncertainty. Adding all systematics in square (beam alignment, Zeeman effect, uncorrected photon recoils) yields a total systematic uncertainty of 1.8 MHz. Due to the linear dependence of the frequency shift on the statistical misalignment of the laser beams and the daily realignment of the ion and laser beams, we expect the dominant systematic uncertainty to fluctuate centered around the atomic transition frequency. Thus, the statistical and systematic uncertainties are added in square to obtain the total uncertainties. For details, see Methods.
The transition frequencies of all hyperfine-structure lines are compiled in Table I. The individual transition frequencies of from [47] and the center-of-gravity (cg) frequency of the fine-structure multiplet are also included. For each fine structure component of , the hyperfine cg was first obtained assuming the usual first-order hyperfine structure splitting (for details, see Methods) and is listed in the table indicated as . A look at the individual isotope shifts relative to the corresponding fine-structure transition in shows that these vary over 2.4 GHz even though they are expected to be equal. Second-order effects cause this discrepancy, i.e., the mixing of hyperfine states with the same quantum number belonging to different fine-structure levels. Including second-order HFS explicitly, using the theoretical magnetic dipole matrix elements tabulated in [52] (see Methods), we obtain the cg as provided in the table indicated by . In this case, the isotope shift of all three fine-structure components agree to MHz, demonstrating that the calculated magnetic properties capture the shifts induced by state mixing well. We attribute the remaining difference to the “splitting isotope shift” that provides an important benchmark for NRQED calculations [53]. The comparison between the values obtained with and without hyperfine mixing reveals that the shifts of the levels are much larger than the shift of the more separated level.
| 1 316 147 920.6 (1.9) | — | |
| 1 316 084 566.3 (1.8) | — | |
| 1 316 105 684.4 (1.4) | 53 465.1 (2.3) | |
| 1 316 103 946.9 (1.3) | 51 727.6 (2.3) | |
| , [47] | 1 316 052 219.3 (1.9) | — |
| 1 315 749 143.7 (1.9) | — | |
| 1 315 781 189.1 (2.0) | — | |
| 1 315 685 791.2 (2.0) | — | |
| 1 315 717 838.5 (1.8) | — | |
| 1 315 728 273.3 (1.1) | 51 080.5 (2.0) | |
| 1 315 728 925.4 (1.0) | 51 732.6 (2.0) | |
| , [47] | 1 315 677 192.8 (1.7) | — |
| 1 319 813 468.4 (1.8) | — | |
| 1 319 750 116.8 (1.8) | — | |
| 1 319 798 680.5 (1.8) | — | |
| 1 319 800 372.2 (1.2) | 51 800.8 (2.1) | |
| 1 319 800 329.2 (1.2) | 51 757.8 (2.1) | |
| , [47] | 1 319 748 571.4 (1.7) | — |
| 1 318 032 485.0 (0.8) | 51 745.6 (1.4) | |
| 1 318 032 485.5 (0.8) | 51 746.1 (1.4) | |
| , | 1 317 980 739.4 (1.1) | — |
Table I. TABLE I. Electronic transition frequencies and isotope shifts of the transitions in . The center-of-gravity (cg) frequencies below the individual resonance frequencies are calculated using Eq. (7) and (8), with and without hyperfine-induced mixing considered, respectively. The isotope shifts in the third column are the differences between the absolute transition frequencies in this table and the results in [47]. All values are given in MHz.
The isotope shifts of the fine-structure centroid determined by the two approaches differ by only 500 kHz. This difference is ascribed to the small contribution of the well-separated level. The excellent agreement, much smaller than our uncertainty, demonstrates that measuring all hyperfine components is a reliable way to circumvent the impact of hyperfine mixing and to extract the charge radius with high accuracy, which is particularly important for upcoming measurements on .
The differential ms nuclear charge radius is determined from the isotope shift of the cg frequency of the entire fine structure using Eq. (2) and Eq. (7). The required NRQED atomic structure calculations of the mass-shift contribution MHz and the field-shift constant MHz/fm were carried out by Yerokhin et al. up to the order of [54]. The finite-nuclear-size effect in the isotope shift is the difference between our experimental value and the calculated mass shift contribution. It amounts to only 26.3(1.4) MHz, which is a fraction of the transition frequency. From the results described above, we derive a differential nuclear charge radius of
Our results for the rms charge radii of and the change in rms charge radii are plotted in Figure 3 and compared to results from electron scattering and muonic atom X-ray spectroscopy. The numerical values are included in Table II. For , the most accurate muonic measurement by Ruckstuhl et al. [26] disagrees from the weighted average of all electron-scattering results by about of the combined uncertainty. Combining the e-scattering charge radius of with the isotope-shift measurement provides a charge radius for that is in excellent agreement with the result of the e-scattering [55] but has 6 times reduced uncertainty, which is now similar to the uncertainty of the muonic atom result [56]. The discrepancy in terms of the combined uncertainty is even slightly larger than in ( compared to ). obtained from the difference in the muonic radii is smaller and has three times larger uncertainty than the laser spectroscopic result, and just agrees within the combined uncertainty. Thus, we find a systematic offset in radii based on electromagnetic interaction with electrons versus those with muons. This is a different situation as in the -helion discrepancy, since the charge radius difference measured in ordinary ions agrees with that observed in muonic atoms but the absolute charge radius from electron scattering does not. In the past, was always considered an excellent reference for charge radii measurements due to the high accuracy of the e scattering result. This calls for verifying the e-scattering and the muonic atom results.
Figure 3. Absolute and differential nuclear charge radii of . Experimentally determined absolute , and nuclear charge radius difference of determined with elastic electron scattering (blue), muonic atom spectroscopy (-atoms, purple) and collinear laser spectroscopy (CLS, black). Results from CLS and -scattering were combined to obtain an improved (black & blue) purely from electronic measurements. The differential rms nuclear charge radii from -scattering and -atoms are differences of absolute radii while the CLS result is determined directly from the isotope shift and ab initio atomic structure calculations using Eq. (2). is also compared to ab initio valence-space in-medium similarity renormalization group (VS-IMSRG, red) and in-medium no-core shell model (IM-NCSM, orange) calculations. The lower-order IM-NCSM results are plotted with open symbols. Results from nuclear-lattice effective field theory (NLEFT, brown) were published by Elhatisari et al. [61]. The numerical values of this plot are listed in Table II.
Discussion
From a theoretical point of view, the carbon isotopes, especially due to their pronounced cluster structure, have long been theoretically interesting and challenging to describe via ab initio methods. Early explorations within the framework of fermionic molecular dynamics provided a quantitative description of various structures of including the Hoyle state, albeit with necessary phenomenological tuning of the interaction to a broad range of nuclear-structure properties [57, 58, 59]. More recent lattice simulations based on nuclear interactions from chiral effective field theory (EFT) predicted the structure of the ground and Hoyle state of without adjustment based on the natural description of -clustering in such simulations [38, 60, 61]. Over the past fifteen years, ab initio calculations of nuclei as heavy as have been performed using systematically improvable many-body methods [62, 63, 64] like the in-medium similarity renormalization group (IMSRG) [65]. Early IMSRG studies that included calculations of found atypically large differences in ground-state energies predicted by different approaches, indicating that the many-body description of is challenging [66, 67, 68]. New experimental measurements and theoretical predictions of and provide an interesting avenue to study not only the changing structure of carbon isotopes, but also how it emerges from nuclear forces and many-body methods.
We predict the properties of using an ab initio valence-space IMSRG (VS-IMSRG) [67] and in-medium no-core shell model (IM-NCSM) [68] nuclear structure calculations, which solve the many-body Schrödinger equation for a given input nuclear Hamiltonian in an approximate, but systematically improvable manner. We employ Hamiltonians with nucleon-nucleon and three-nucleon interactions from chiral EFT, using seven Hamiltonians that differ in their construction and how they are fitted to data to give insight into interaction uncertainties. VS-IMSRG(2) calculations were performed using 1.8/2.0 (EM), 2.0/2.0 (EM), 2.2/2.0 (EM) [73], NLO [74], and NLO [75], while for IM-NCSM calculations a family of non-local interactions up to NLO was employed [76]. We confirm the consistency of the two approaches by comparing VS-IMSRG(2) and IM-NCSM calculations with the 1.8/2.0 (EM) Hamiltonian. More details on the Hamiltonians, methods and charge radii calculations are provided in Table II and Methods. Here, we concentrate on the results for the charge radii difference between the isotopes, which are shown in the right part of Figure 3 and are compared with the experimental results. A plot of the absolute nuclear charge radii is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4. Theoretical absolute nuclear charge radii of . The radii have been determined from ab initio valence-space in-medium similarity renormalization group (VS-IMSRG, red) and in-medium no-core shell model (IM-NCSM, orange) calculations. The lower-order IM-NCSM results are plotted with open symbols. Results from nuclear-lattice effective field theory (NLEFT, brown) were published by Elhatisari et al. [61]. The numerical values of this plot are listed in Table II.
| Method | |||
| NLEFT [NLO] [61] | 2.490(12) | 2.521(41) | 0.027(43) |
| VS-IMSRG(2) [1.8/2.0 (EM)] | 2.416(1) | 2.361(1) | −0.056(1) |
| VS-IMSRG(2) [2.0/2.0 (EM)] | 2.421(1) | 2.370(1) | −0.051(2) |
| VS-IMSRG(2) [2.2/2.0 (EM)] | 2.423(1) | 2.377(1) | −0.046(2) |
| VS-IMSRG(2) [NLO] | 2.405(1) | 2.366(6) | −0.039(6) |
| VS-IMSRG(2) [NLO] | 2.396(3) | 2.354(2) | −0.042(5) |
| IM-NCSM [1.8/2.0 (EM)] | 2.421(16) | 2.363(12) | −0.058(5) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 500] | 2.348(249) | 2.302(248) | −0.046(7) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 500] | 2.521(103) | 2.464(101) | −0.057(16) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 500] | 2.532(38) | 2.479(27) | −0.052(14) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 500] | 2.550(13) | 2.513(20) | −0.036(13) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 550] | 2.471(239) | 2.413(229) | −0.058(11) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 550] | 2.426(63) | 2.364(62) | −0.063(5) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 550] | 2.457(31) | 2.397(30) | −0.060(4) |
| IM-NCSM [NLO, 550] | 2.482(23) | 2.423(20) | −0.059(6) |
| -scattering [25, 55, 69, 70, 71] | 2.4717(42) | 2.440(25) | −0.023(10) |
| -atom [72] | 2.472(16) | 2.480(20) | 0.008(26) |
| -atom [26, 56] | 2.4829(19) | 2.4628(39) | −0.0201(43) |
| CLS [this work] | — | 2.4464(45) | −0.0253(14) |
Table 2. Absolute and differential nuclear charge radii of determined with different ab initio nuclear structure calculations and experiments. The maximum employed many-body orders or interactions of the theory results are given in square brackets. Radii are given in fm.
The experimentally observed size reduction of 0.0253(14) fm is overestimated by up to a factor of 2 in our calculations. The closest results are obtained with the VS-IMSRG using NLO and the IM-NCSM calculations with the NLO(500) interactions. We note that the VS-IMSRG(2) calculations have uncertainties that are estimated solely from the model-space convergence. The uncertainties of the IM-NCSM calculations additionally include the Hamiltonian uncertainty and the convergence of the many-body expansion, with the exception of the 1.8/2.0 (EM) Hamiltonian where only the many-body uncertainty is quantified. Thus, the scatter of the VS-IMSRG results beyond uncertainties is not unexpected. The VS-IMSRG(2) calculations underestimate the absolute charge radii for all Hamiltonians, suggesting a systematic underprediction due to the VS-IMSRG(2) approximation. VS-IMSRG(3) calculations were performed with the 1.8/2.0 (EM) interaction to investigate the many-body uncertainty [77]. This brings the absolute radii in better agreement with the experiment, but further increases the discrepancy to the observed by almost a factor of 2.
The IM-NCSM calculations in Table II show interesting dependencies of the charge radii, increasing with chiral order and decreasing with higher cutoff scale. For 550 MeV/ we find good agreement with the muonic atom experiment for the charge radii of both isotopes at NLO, but for the radius difference the situation is reversed, providing a value compatible with experiment for cutoff 500 MeV/. At NLO and NLO, however, both cutoffs provide a similar radius difference pointing more towards the overestimated value.
We highlight that the theoretical prediction of the charge radius difference benefits from the cancellation of correlated systematic uncertainties in the predictions of the absolute charge radii and . This is clearly visible in the uncertainties of our IM-NCSM calculations, where Hamiltonian and many-body convergence uncertainties are quantified. To quantify these uncertainties for , we apply a Bayesian uncertainty quantification protocol (based on Ref. [78] and described in Methods) directly to the charge radius difference, implicitly accounting for the cancellation of correlated uncertainties. As a result, the charge radius difference uncertainty is typically smaller than that of the absolute charge radii and also smaller than the resulting uncertainty if the uncertainties on and were uncorrelated.
All our ab initio calculations consistently predict a negative charge radius difference. The underprediction by both methods for all Hamiltonians, however, suggests that some relevant many-body correlations necessary for the precise prediction of this small difference are missing, requiring the development of improved many-body approximations to resolve.
The systematic discrepancy between the charge radii obtained in using electron or muon interactions, uncovered by our measurements, must be consolidated or resolved by improved measurements on muonic atoms that are currently prepared by the QUARTET collaboration [24]. Laser spectroscopy of is currently ongoing at COALA and will provide the nuclear charge radius of this isotope with comparable precision as obtained here for and thus improve it by more than an order of magnitude compared to previous measurements.
Methods
Determination of the isotope shift. The absolute transition frequencies used in Eq. (7) are determined using frequency-comb-referenced quasi-simultaneous collinear (c) and anticollinear (a) laser spectroscopy. Fluorescence spectra are typically taken with 61 steps across a span of 800 MHz. All recorded spectra were fitted using the least-square algorithm optimize.leastsq provided by the scipy Python package [79]. A pure Gaussian model
was used to fit the data, since the natural linewidths of 9 MHz [51] of the transitions are negligible compared with the width of the velocity distribution of the ions. The typical full width at half maximum of a resonance is 150 MHz. The resonance centers and obtained from the corresponding anticollinear and collinear spectra, respectively, are combined to calculate the rest-frame frequency
The small second term, which amounts to 0.3 MHz for , takes care of the photon-recoil contribution that is transferred into kinetic energy of the ion during absorption. At least 28 anticollinear-collinear (ac) or collinear-anticollinear (ca) measurement pairs were taken for each hyperfine transition to minimize statistical fluctuations and in all cases the standard deviation of the mean was MHz.
There is some freedom in the choice of the isotope shift as it can be defined as any difference of linear combinations of transition frequencies sensitive to the nuclear charge radius. To get the smallest possible uncertainty, we calculate the weighted mean of all (hyper)fine-structure transition frequencies for . The weights are the theoretical transition strengths assuming no hyperfine-induced mixing. The cg frequency of the multiplet for each isotope is calculated as
where , and , are the electronic and total angular momentum quantum numbers of lower and upper state, respectively, and is the nuclear spin. This weighted mean is insensitive to hyperfine-induced mixing between the states and gives the same result as fitting the standard formula for HFS splittings to the resonance frequencies. In a second analysis, we have considered hyperfine-induced mixing explicitly applying the theoretical magnetic dipole matrix elements tabulated in [52]. By fitting
to the resonance frequencies, where are the eigenvalues of the matrices with the entries [52]
hypothetical cg frequencies can be extracted that would result from Eq. (7) if there was no mixing between different states. Here is a label for the experimentally accessible mixed- states, is the HFS constant of the magnetic dipole contribution to the energy of the state, is the Kronecker delta, is the Wigner-6j symbol, [80] is the magnetic dipole moment of the nucleus and is the spin multiplicity of the state . In the fit of Eq. (8) to the resonance frequencies, , and the diagonal elements are taken as free parameters. Mixing with the state was taken into account using a fixed and . This procedure relies on the calculated off-diagonal matrix elements , for which no uncertainty is specified in Ref. [52]. Assuming a relative uncertainty of for the matrix elements of , which are specified to five significant digits, yields shifts of the cg frequencies of MHz, and are, thus, considerably smaller than the experimental uncertainty. The combined cg frequency of all transitions is additionally affected by mixing with the level. This contribution is expected to be small due to its large distance in energy from the levels. It can be estimated from the difference between including and excluding the state in the diagonalization and amounts to only 0.4 MHz, completely resolving the difference to the standard cg from Eq. (7). We note that the finite magnetic-moment distribution, included in the Zemach radius of a nucleus, will change the size of the hyperfine constant but does not affect the center of gravity of the transition.
Systematic uncertainties
In our experiment, the ion velocity and, hence, the laser frequencies in the rest-frame of the ions were scanned by changing the voltage potential in the fluorescence detection region (Doppler tuning). The frequencies of the lasers for collinear and anticollinear excitation were stabilized at frequencies that ensure resonant excitation at nearly the same ion velocity and, thus, the same Doppler tuning voltage. The uncertainties of the laser frequencies itself are determined from the statistics of the continuously measured beat signals of the frequency comb and directly considered in the Gaussian error propagation of Eq. (6). Systematic drifts of the laser frequencies are avoided by ensuring a sufficiently high beat signal used for stabilization to the atomic clock reference. Remaining differences of the resonance positions were always below 0.5 V. The exact is determined from the peak position parameter of the Gaussian lineshape model, which is fitted separately to both the collinear and anticollinear resonance signals. All other parameters of the lineshape model, such as the Gaussian linewidth , can also differ between collinear and anticollinear measurements, e.g., due to differences in frequency stability, laser power or laser-beam vibrations. The Gaussian width might differ, even for exact beam overlap, because of slightly differ-
| Contribution | Symbol | Uncertainty (MHz) |
| Spatial velocity distribution | 1.72 | |
| Laser-/Ion-beam alignment | 0.09 | |
| Photon recoils | 0.41 | |
| Laser polarization | 0.24 | |
| Absolute voltage | 0.00 | |
| Amplification factor | 0.00 | |
| Total systematic uncertainty | 1.79 |
Table 3. Summary of all systematic uncertainties of the transition frequency measurements in . The total systematic uncertainty is given by the geometric sum of all individual uncertainties.
ent beam sizes and therefore additional velocity classes that are addressed by the larger beam. These parameters are, however, uncorrelated to the peak position parameter. To resolve both signals and to get the best signal-to-noise ratio, collinear and anticollinear measurements are recorded only quasi-simultaneously, meaning in quick succession. This has the disadvantage that a drifting high-voltage potential in the ion source is directly visible in . The main contribution to the drift is a changing electron beam current in the EBIS. To compensate for this effect, measurements were always taken in the order ac-ca, which eliminates this error entirely as long as the voltage drift is linear. Additionally, the applied acceleration voltage was stabilized with a simple proportional regulator [81]. As a result, no systematic frequency shift due to uncompensated nonlinear voltage drifts were observed.
The largest systematic uncertainty originates from the imperfect alignment of the two laser beams. To make sure both laser beams are interacting with the same ion velocities, the profiles of the laser beams were adjusted to be roughly of the same size in the fluorescence detection region with a radius of 0.7 mm and superposed outside of the beamline at two points in the beam paths, 14 m apart from each other. The maximum displacement of 0.5 mm corresponds to an angle of mrad. During a single day of measurements, drifts of the laser beam positions at the points of alignment, originating e.g., from angular drifts of the Nd:YVO pump lasers or thermal drifts inside the Ti-sapphire cavity, remained below the estimated maximum displacement and were regularly checked and corrected once or twice per day. The ion beam was aligned with the collinear laser using a combination of multi-channel plates (MCPs) and phosphor screens in the two beam diagnostic stations, which are 2.6 m apart. Here, a maximum misalignment of 0.62 mrad was estimated.
While Doppler-induced frequency shifts due to the angular deviation are suppressed and amount to MHz, the concomitant spatial separation at the detection region can lead to larger effects due to the horizontal velocity dispersion in the ion beam caused by the -bender at the entrance of the collinear beamline. The frequency shift associated with this effect is directly proportional to the horizontal positional difference of the two laser beams at the points of alignment, including a change in sign at perfect alignment, and was simulated and measured to appear as an additional statistical fluctuation centered around the atomic transition frequency with a standard deviation of 1.72 MHz. Due to the daily realignment of the ion and laser beams over the course of the three month measurement period, the symmetric distribution of laser alignment configurations was adequately sampled. Additional uncertainties due to the Zeeman effect, photon recoils beyond the considered correction in Eq. (6) and the residual Doppler shift caused by the angular misalignment of the ion- and laser beams are listed in Table III and are added in square to yield a total systematic uncertainty of 1.8 MHz. For further details, see [47, 48, 82]. Due to the statistical nature of the systematic uncertainties, the total uncertainties of provided in Table I are the systematic and statistical uncertainties added in square.
Nuclear Hamiltonians
We employ Hamiltonians with nucleon-nucleon and three-nucleon interactions from chiral effective field theory (EFT), where the full intrinsic Hamiltonian has the form with the total kinetic energy , the center-of-mass kinetic energy of the -body nucleus , the nucleon-nucleon (NN) potential , and the three-nucleon (3N) potential . Chiral EFT Hamiltonians are truncated at a finite order in the EFT expansion, making nuclear Hamiltonians intrinsically uncertain. We employ several Hamiltonians that differ in their construction and fitted to data to probe this uncertainty.
The 1.8/2.0 (EM), 2.0/2.0 (EM), and 2.2/2.0 (EM) Hamiltonians are constructed from the NLO NN potential developed by Entem and Machleidt (EM) in Ref. [83] unitarily transformed to the resolution scales , 2.0, and 2.2 fm, respectively, via the similarity renormalization group [84] and 3N potentials at NLO with a regulator cutoff of 2.0 fm [73]. The NN potential is fitted to NN scattering data and the deuteron binding energy, and the 3N potentials are fitted to reproduce the binding energy of H and the point-proton radius of He for each of the transformed NN potentials. The names of these Hamiltonians are constructed from the NN resolution scale and the 3N cutoff , “ (EM)”, with the “(EM)” indicating the starting NN potential [83]. The NLO Hamiltonian is constructed from NLO NN and 3N potentials with a regulator cutoff of MeV/ and is fitted to NN scattering data, deuteron properties, ground-state energies and charge radii of few-body systems with , and selected ground-state energies and charge radii for C and O [74], where the fit to medium-mass nuclei helps to improve nuclear matter saturation properties of the interaction.
The NLO Hamiltonian, developed by the GOTHEN-burg and Oak Ridge groups (GO), is constructed from NLO NN and 3N potentials with a cutoff of fm with the explicit inclusion of isobars in the EFT [75]. It is fitted to NN scattering data, properties of few-body systems with , and nuclear matter properties and additionally optimized to reproduce bulk properties of medium-mass nuclei.
The family of non-local interactions up to NLO [76] used in the IM-NCSM are constructed using the NN potentials from Ref. [85] up to NLO and 3N interactions at NLO and NLO [86] with non-local regulators of and 550 MeV/, where NLO indicates a hybrid interaction with NN at NLO and 3N at NLO. The NN and 3N interactions are consistently unitarily transformed using the similarity renormalization group to a resolution scale of (corresponding to ). The NN interactions are fitted to NN scattering data and deuteron properties, and the 3N interactions are fitted to the ground-state energies of and .
Nuclear structure calculations.
Both the VS-IMSRG and the IM-NCSM are variants of the IMSRG [65, 87], which produces a unitary transformation of the Hamiltonian to solve the Schrödinger equation. This transformation, generally parametrized as , is normal ordered with respect to a reference state , allowing it in practice to be truncated at the normal-ordered two-body level. All other operators, in particular charge-radius operators, are consistently transformed using the same transformation, allowing for the computation of ground-state expectation values.
In this work, nuclear charge radii are determined with [88]
with the point-proton squared charge radius , the proton and neutron squared charge radii and [89], the relativistic Darwin-Foldy correction , and the spin-orbit correction . Our IM-NCSM calculations neglect spin-orbit charge radius corrections, which contribute for , for , and for depending on the interaction, well within the assessed uncertainties.
We note that in the optimization of the NLO Hamiltonian, a larger proton radius has been used, while here we employ the most recent value reported by the particle data group. This might lead to slightly smaller absolute radii but will largely cancel in . All theoretical nuclear charge radii are compiled in Table II. The differential and absolute radii are plotted in Figure 3 and 4, respectively.
The VS-IMSRG [67, 90] transforms the Hamiltonian such that a nucleus-specific valence-space Hamiltonian is decoupled, which can then be diagonalized using standard shell-model techniques. Our VS-IMSRG calculations start from a Hartree-Fock (HF) reference state. In particular, we employ Hartree-Fock single-particle states for states occupied in our reference state. For the remaining states, we employ the perturbatively improved natural orbital (NAT) basis [91], orthogonalizing the NAT basis with respect to the occupied HF states. We use the VS-IMSRG truncated at the normal-ordered two-body level, the VS-IMSRG(2), to decouple a -shell valence space. A final diagonalization is performed with KSHELL [92]. Recent developments have made the VS-IMSRG calculations truncated at the normal-ordered three-body level available [77], and we explore the effect of the normal-ordered two-body truncation in our calculations by performing VS-IMSRG(3)- calculations. This captures induced three-body terms, leading to a more accurate solution of the many-body Schrödinger equation. For the final shell-model diagonalization, we truncate the residual three-body terms of all operators and perform the diagonalization with up to two-body operators.
The IM-NCSM [68] starts out with a standard NCSM calculation in a small reference space with , using a natural orbital basis [93]. In a second step, this reference space is decoupled from higher-lying many-body states using the Magnus version of the multi-reference IMSRG truncated at the normal-ordered two-body level. The resulting Hamiltonian and consistently transformed operators are then used in a final NCSM calculation with to obtain the relevant observables. The uncertainties due to many-body truncations are probed by an explicit variation of the reference-space and the final model-space truncation, as well as a variation of the IMSRG flow parameter. The chiral truncation uncertainties are extracted from the order-by-order variation of the observables through a Bayesian model [78]. For this we use IM-NCSM calculations for all chiral orders starting at NLO for the aforementioned family of non-local interactions. Note that we apply this uncertainty quantification protocol directly to the radius differences as well, thus expliciting correlations of the radii in the two isotopes.
Data availability
The data sets generated in the experiment and analyzed for the current study are publicly available at https://doi.org/10.48328/tudatalib-1500.
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) – Project-ID 279384907 – SFB 1245. The experiment (P.I., K.K., B.M., P.M., W.N.) was supported in part also by the BMBF under Contract Nos. 05P19RDFN1 and 05P21RDFNA. P.M. and P.I. acknowledge support from HGS-HIRE. M.H., T.M., and A.S. were supported in part by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant Agreement No. 101020842).
Author contributions
The experiment was planned, prepared and performed by P.I., K.K., B.M., P.M. and W.N. The data analysis was performed by P.M. The theoretical calculations were developed and performed by M.H., T.M., R.R. and A.S. The draft was written by P.M., M.H., T.M., W.N., R.R. and A.S. All authors read and approved the manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
References
- [1]R. Hofstadter, Electron Scattering and Nuclear Structure, Reviews of Modern Physics 28, 214 (1956).DOI
- [2]V. L. Fitch and J. Rainwater, Studies of X-Rays from Mu-Mesonic Atoms, Physical Review 92, 789 (1953).DOI
- [3]E. Borie and G. A. Rinker, The energy levels of muonic atoms, Reviews of Modern Physics 54, 67 (1982).DOI
- [4]G. Fricke, C. Bernhardt, K. Heilig, L. A. Schaller, L. Schellenberg, E. B. Shera, and C. W. Dejager, Nuclear Ground State Charge Radii from Electromagnetic Interactions, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 60, 177 (1995).DOI
- [5]G. Fricke and K. Heilig, Nuclear Charge Radii, in Landolt-Börnstein, Group I: Elementary Particles, Nuclei and Atoms Vol. 20 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, 2004).
- [6]T. Udem, A. Huber, B. Gross, J. Reichert, M. Prevedelli, M. Weitz, and T. W. Hänsch, Phase-Coherent Measurement of the Hydrogen 1S−2S Transition Frequency with an Optical Frequency Interval Divider Chain, Physical Review Letters 79, 2646 (1997).
- [7]J. C. Bernauer, P. Achenbach, C. Ayerbe Gayoso, R. Böhm, D. Bosnar, L. Debenjak, M. O. Distler, L. Doria, A. Esser, H. Fonvieille, J. M. Friedrich, J. Friedrich, M. La Gómez Rodríguez de Paz, M. Makek, H. Merkel, D. G. Middleton, U. Müller, L. Nungesser, J. Pochodzalla, M. Potokar, S. Sánchez Majos, B. S. Schlimme, S. Sirca, T. Walcher, and M. Weinriefer, High-Precision Determination of the Electric and Magnetic Form Factors of the Proton, Physical Review Letters 105, 242001 (2010).
- [8]R. Pohl, A. Antognini, F. Nez, F. D. Amaro, F. Biraben, J. M. R. Cardoso, D. S. Covita, A. Dax, S. Dhawan, L. M. P. Fernandes, A. Giesen, T. Graf, T. W. Hänsch, P. Indelicato, L. Julien, C.-Y. Kao, P. Knowles, E.-O. Le Bigot, Y.-W. Liu, J. A. M. Lopes, L. Ludhova, C. M. B. Monteiro, F. Mulhauser, T. Nebel, P. Rabi-nowitz, J. M. F. Dos Santos, L. A. Schaller, K. Schuhmann, C. Schwob, J. F. C. A. Veloso, and F. Kottmann, The size of the proton, Nature 466, 213 (2010).
- [9]A. Beyer, L. Maisenbacher, A. Matveev, R. Pohl, K. Khabarova, A. Grinin, T. Lamour, D. C. Yost, T. W. Hänsch, N. Kolachevsky, and T. Udem, The Rydberg constant and proton size from atomic hydrogen, Science 358, 79 (2017).
- [10]A. Grinin, A. Matveev, D. C. Yost, L. Maisenbacher, V. Wirthl, R. Pohl, T. W. Hänsch, and T. Udem, Two-photon frequency comb spectroscopy of atomic hydrogen, Science 370, 1061 (2020).
- [11]N. Bezginov, T. Valdez, M. Horbatsch, A. Marsman, A. C. Vutha, and F. A. Hessels, A measurement of the atomic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton charge radius, Science 365, 1007 (2019).DOI
- [12]H. Fleurbaey, S. Galtier, S. Thomas, M. Bonnaud, L. Julien, F. Biraben, F. Nez, M. Abgrall, and J. Guéna, New Measurement of the 1S − 3S Transition Frequency of Hydrogen: Contribution to the Proton Charge Radius Puzzle, Physical Review Letters 120, 183001 (2018).DOI
- [13]A. D. Brandt, S. F. Cooper, C. Rasor, Z. Burkley, A. Matveev, and D. C. Yost, Measurement of the 2S1/2 − 8D5/2 Transition in Hydrogen, Physical Review Letters
- [14]128, 023001 (2022). [14] W. Xiong, A. Gasparian, H. Gao, D. Dutta, M. Khan-daker, N. Liyanage, E. Pasyuk, C. Peng, X. Bai, L. Ye, K. Gnanvo, C. Gu, M. Levillain, X. Yan, D. W. Higginbotham, M. Meziane, Z. Ye, K. Adhikari, B. Al-jawrneh, H. Bhatt, D. Bhetuwal, J. Brock, V. Burk-ert, C. Carlin, A. Deur, D. Di, J. Dunne, P. Ekanayaka, L. El-Fassi, B. Emmich, L. Gan, O. Glamazdin, M. L. Kabir, A. Karki, C. Keith, S. Kowalski, V. Lagerquist, I. Larin, T. Liu, A. Liyanage, J. Maxwell, D. Meekins, S. J. Nazeer, V. Nelyubin, H. Nguyen, R. Pedroni, C. Perdrisat, J. Pierce, V. Punjabi, M. Shabestari, A. Shahinyan, R. Silwal, S. Stepanyan, A. Subedi, V. V. Tarasov, N. Ton, Y. Zhang, and Z. W. Zhao, A small proton charge radius from an electron-proton scattering experiment, Nature 575, 147 (2019).DOI
- [15]Y.-H. Lin, H.-W. Hammer, and U.-G. Meißner, New Insights into the Nucleon’s Electromagnetic Structure, Physical Review Letters 128, 052002 (2022).DOI
- [16]H. Gao and M. Vanderhaeghen, The proton charge radius, Reviews of Modern Physics 94, 015002 (2022).DOI
- [17]R. Gilman, E. J. Downie, G. Ron, S. Strauch, A. Afanasev, A. Akmal, J. Arrington, H. Atac, C. Ayerbe Gayoso, F. Benmokhtar, N. Bennouna, J. Bernauer, A. Blomberg, W. J. Briscoe, D. Cioffi, E. Cline, D. Cohen, E. O. Cohen, C. Collicott, K. Deiters, J. Diefenbach, B. Dongwi, D. Ghosal, A. Golossanov, R. Gothe, D. Higinbotham, D. Hornidge, Y. Ilieva, N. Kalantarians, M. Kohl, B. Krusche, G. Kumbartzki, I. Lavrukhin, L. Li, J. Lichtenstadt, W. Lin, A. Liyanage, W. Lorenzon, K. E. Mesick, Z. E. Meziani, P. Monahmurthy, P. Moran, J. Nazeer, E. Piasetzky, R. Ransome, R. Raymond, D. Reggiani, P. E. Reimer, A. Richter, T. Rostomyan, P. Roy, A. Sarty, Y. Shamai, N. Sparveris, N. Steinberg, I. Strakovsky, V. Sulkosky, A. S. Tadepalli, and M. Taragin, Technical Design Report for the Paul Scherrer Institute Experiment R-12-01.1: Studying the Proton “Radius” Puzzle with μp Elastic Scattering (2017), arXiv:1709.09753 [physics.ins-det].
- [18]J. J. Krauth, K. Schuhmann, M. A. Ahmed, F. D. Amaro, P. Amaro, F. Biraben, T.-L. Chen, D. S. Covita, A. J. Dax, M. Diepold, L. M. P. Fernandes, B. Franke, S. Galtier, A. L. Gouvea, J. Götzfried, T. Graf, T. W. Hänsch, J. Hartmann, M. Hildebrandt, P. Indelicato, L. Julien, K. Kirch, A. Knecht, Y.-W. Liu, J. A. Machado, C. M. B. Monteiro, F. Mulhauser, B. Naar, T. Nebel, F. Nez, J. M. F. Dos Santos, J. P. Santos, C. I. Szabo, D. Taqqu, J. F. C. A. Veloso, J. Vogelsang, A. Voss, B. Weichelt, R. Pohl, A. Antognini, and F. Kottmann, Measuring the α-particle charge radius with muonic helium-4 ions, Nature 589, 527 (2021).DOI
- [19]K. Schuhmann, L. M. P. Fernandes, F. Nez, M. Abdou Ahmed, F. D. Amaro, P. Amaro, F. Biraben, T.-L. Chen, D. S. Covita, A. J. Dax, M. Diepold, B. Franke, S. Galtier, A. L. Gouvea, J. Götzfried, T. Graf, T. W. Hänsch, M. Hildebrandt, P. Indelicato, L. Julien, K. Kirch, A. Knecht, F. Kottmann, J. J. Krauth, Y.-W. Liu, J. Machado, C. M. B. Monteiro, F. Mulhauser, B. Naar, T. Nebel, J. M. F. Dos Santos, J. P. Santos, C. I. Szabo, D. Taqqu, J. F. C. A. Veloso, A. Voss, B. Weichelt, A. Antognini, and R. Pohl, The helium charge radius from laser spectroscopy of muonic helium-3 ions, Science 388, 854 (2025).DOI
- [20]S. S. Li Muli, T. R. Richardson, and S. Bacca, Revisiting the Helium Isotope-Shift Puzzle with Improved Uncertainties from Nuclear Structure Corrections, Physical Review Letters 134, 035202 (2025).
- [21]Y. van der Werf, K. Steinebach, R. Jannin, H. L. Bethlem, and K. S. E. Eikema, Alpha and helium particle charge radius difference determined from quantum-degenerate helium, Science 388, 850 (2025).DOI
- [22]X.-Q. Qi, P.-P. Zhang, Z.-C. Yan, L.-Y. Tang, A.-X. Chen, T.-Y. Shi, and Z.-X. Zhong, Toward resolving the discrepancy in helium-3 and helium-4 nuclear charge radii, Physical Review Research 7, L022020 (2025).DOI
- [23]K. Pachucki, V. Patkós, and V. A. Yerokhin, Second-order hyperfine correction to H, D, and 3He energy levels (2024), arXiv:2411.05621 [physics.atom-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2411.05621
- [24]B. Ohayon, A. Abeln, S. Bara, T. E. Cocolios, O. Eizenberg, A. Fleischmann, L. Gastaldo, C. Godinho, M. Heines, D. Hengstler, G. Hupin, P. Indelicato, K. Kirch, A. Knecht, D. Kreuzberger, J. Machado, P. Navratil, N. Paul, R. Pohl, D. Unger, S. M. Vogliatzi, K. von Schoeler, and F. Wauters, Towards Precision Muonic X-ray Measurements of Charge Radii of Light Nuclei, Physics 6, 206 (2024).DOI
- [25]I. Sick, Precise nuclear charge radii from electron scattering, Physics Letters B 116, 212 (1982).DOI
- [26]W. Ruckstuhl, B. Aas, W. Beer, I. Beltrami, K. Bos, P. Goudsmit, H. J. Leisi, G. Strassner, A. Vacchi, F. de Boer, U. Kiebele, and R. Weber, Precision measurement of the 2p-1s transition in muonic 12C: Search for new muon-nucleon interactions or accurate determination of the rms nuclear charge radius, Nuclear Physics A 430, 685 (1984).DOI
- [27]Z.-T. Lu, P. Mueller, G. W. F. Drake, W. Nörtershäuser, S. C. Pieper, and Z.-C. Yan, Colloquium: Laser probing of neutron-rich nuclei in light atoms, Reviews of Modern Physics 85, 1383 (2013).DOI
- [28]J. A. Wheeler, On the Mathematical Description of Light Nuclei by the Method of Resonating Group Structure, Physical Review 52, 1107 (1937).DOI
- [30]Y. Kanada-En’yo and H. Horiuchi, Structure of Light Unstable Nuclei Studied with Antisymmetrized Molecular Dynamics, Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement 142, 205 (2001).DOI
- [31]K. Ikeda, N. Takigawa, and H. Horiuchi, The Systematic Structure-Change into the Molecule-like Structures in the Self-Conjugate 4N Nuclei, Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement E68, 464 (1968).
- [32]W. von Oertzen, M. Freer, and Y. Kanada En’Yo, Nuclear clusters and nuclear molecules, Physics Reports 432, 43 (2006).
- [33]W. Nörtershäuser, T. Neff, R. Sánchez, and I. Sick, Charge radii and ground state structure of lithium isotopes: Experiment and theory reexamined, Physical Review C 84, 024307 (2011).DOI
- [34]A. Krieger, W. Nörtershäuser, C. Geppert, K. Blaum, M. L. Bissell, N. Frömmgen, M. Hammen, K. Kreim, M. Kowalska, J. Krämer, R. Neugart, G. Neyens, R. Sánchez, D. Tiedemann, D. T. Yordanov, and M. Záková, Frequency-comb referenced collinear laser spectroscopy of Be+ for nuclear structure investigations and many-body QED tests, Applied Physics B 123, 15 (2017).
- [35]B. Maaß, T. Hüther, K. König, J. Krämer, J. Krause, A. Lovato, P. Müller, K. Pachucki, M. Puchalski, R. Roth, R. Sánchez, F. Sommer, R. B. Wiringa, and W. Nörtershäuser, Nuclear Charge Radii of 10,11B, Physical Review Letters 122, 182501 (2019).
- [36]F. Hoyle, On Nuclear Reactions Occurring in Very Hot STARS.I. the Synthesis of Elements from Carbon to Nickel, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 1, 121 (1954).DOI
- [37]T. Neff, H. Feldmeier, and R. Roth, Clusters And Shell-Structure In Light Nuclei, AIP Conf. Proc. 764, 387 (2005).DOI
- [38]E. Epelbaum, H. Krebs, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, and U.-G. Meißner, Structure and rotations of the Hoyle state, Physical Review Letters 109, 252501 (2012).DOI
- [39]M. Freer and H. Fynbo, The Hoyle state in 12C, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 78, 1 (2014).
- [40]T. Otsuka, T. Abe, T. Yoshida, Y. Tsunoda, N. Shimizu, N. Itagaki, Y. Utsuno, J. Vary, P. Maris, and H. Ueno, α-Clustering in atomic nuclei from first principles with statistical learning and the Hoyle state character, Nature Communications 13, 2234 (2022).
- [41]G. Wallerstein, I. Iben, P. Parker, A. M. Boesgaard, G. M. Hale, A. E. Champagne, C. A. Barnes, F. Käppeler, V. V. Smith, R. D. Hoffman, F. X. Timmes, C. Sneden, R. N. Boyd, B. S. Meyer, and D. L. Lambert, Synthesis of the elements in stars: forty years of progress, Reviews of Modern Physics 69, 995 (1997).
- [42]H. O. U. Fynbo, C. A. A. Diget, U. C. Bergmann, M. J. G. Borge, J. Cederkäll, P. Dendooven, L. M. Fraile, S. Franchoo, V. N. Fedosseyev, B. R. Fulton, W. Huang, J. Huikari, H. B. Jeppesen, A. S. Jonkinen, P. Jones, B. Jonson, U. Köster, K. Langanke, M. Meister, T. Nilsson, G. Nyman, Y. Prezado, K. Riisager, S. Rinta-Antila, O. Tengblad, M. Turrion, Y. Wang, L. Weissman, K. Wilhelmsen, and J. Aystö, Revised rates for the stellar triple-α process from measurement of 12C nuclear resonances, Nature 433, 136 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15650733
- [43]S. Jin, L. F. Roberts, S. M. Austin, and H. Schatz, Enhanced triple-α reaction reduces proton-rich nucleosynthesis in supernovae, Nature 588, 57 (2020).DOI
- [44]W. Nörtershäuser, D. Tiedemann, M. Záková, Z. Andjelkovic, K. Blaum, M. L. Bissell, R. Cazan, G. W. F. Drake, C. Geppert, M. Kowalska, J. Krämer, A. Krieger, R. Neugart, R. Sánchez, F. Schmidt-Kaler, Z.-C. Yan, D. T. Yordanov, and C. Zimmermann, Nuclear Charge Radii of 7,9,10Be and the One-Neutron Halo Nucleus 11Be, Physical Review Letters 102, 062503 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19257582
- [45]A. Krieger, K. Blaum, M. L. Bissell, N. Frömmgen, C. Geppert, M. Hammen, K. Kreim, M. Kowalska, J. Krämer, T. Neff, R. Neugart, G. Neyens, W. Nörtershäuser, C. Novotny, R. Sánchez, and D. T. Yordanov, Nuclear charge radii of 12Be, Physical Review Letters 108, 142501 (2012).
- [46]W. Geithner, T. Neff, G. Audi, K. Blaum, P. Delahaye, H. Feldmeier, S. George, C. Guénaut, F. Herfurth, A. Herlert, S. Kappertz, M. Keim, A. Kellerbauer, H.-J. Kluge, M. Kowalska, P. Lievens, D. Lunney, K. Marinova, R. Neugart, L. Schweikhard, S. Wilbert, and C. Yazidjian, Masses and charge radii of 17–22Ne and the two-proton-halo candidate 17Ne, Physical Review Letters 101, 252502 (2008).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19113701
- [47]P. Ingram, K. König, B. Maaß, P. Müller, and W. Nörtershäuser, Collinear Laser Spectroscopy of 2³S₁ → 2³P₁ transitions in helium-like ¹²C⁴⁺, Physical Review Letters 131, 243001 (2023).
- [48]P. Ingram, K. König, B. Maaß, P. Müller, and W. Nörtershäuser, Collinear laser spectroscopy of highly charged ions produced with an electron-beam ion source, Physical Review A 108, 062809 (2023).
- [49]R. Pohl, F. Nez, L. M. P. Fernandes, F. D. Amaro, F. Biraben, J. M. R. Cardoso, D. S. Covita, A. Dax, S. Dhawan, M. Diepold, A. Giesen, A. L. Goueva, T. Graf, T. W. Hänsch, P. Indelicato, L. Julien, P. Knowles, F. Kottmann, E.-O. Le Bigot, Y.-W. Liu, J. A. M. Lopes, L. Ludhova, C. M. B. Monteiro, F. Mulhauser, T. Nebel, P. Rabinowitz, J. M. F. Dos Santos, L. A. Schaller, K. Schuhmann, C. Schwob, D. Taqqu, J. F. C. A. Veloso, and A. Antognini, Laser spectroscopy of muonic deuterium, Science 353, 669 (2016).
- [50]K. König, J. Krämer, C. Geppert, P. Ingram, B. Maaß, T. Ratajczyk, and W. Nörtershäuser, A new Collinear Apparatus for Laser Spectroscopy and Applied Science (COALA), Review of Scientific Instruments 91, 081301 (2020).DOI
- [51]A. Kramida, Y. Ralchenko, J. Reader, and NIST ASD Team, NIST Atomic Spectra Database (ver. 5.10) (2022).
- [52]W. R. Johnson, K. T. Cheng, and D. R. Plante, Hyperfine structure of 2³P levels of heliumlike ions, Physical Review A 55, 2728 (1997).DOI
- [53]W. Nörtershäuser, C. Geppert, A. Krieger, K. Pachucki, M. Puchalski, K. Blaum, M. L. Bissell, N. Frömmgen, M. Hammen, M. Kowalska, J. Krämer, K. Kreim, R. Neugart, G. Neyens, R. Sánchez, and D. T. Yordanov, Precision Test of Many-Body QED in the Be⁺ 2p Fine Structure Doublet Using Short-Lived Isotopes, Physical Review Letters 115, 033002 (2015).
- [54]V. A. Yerokhin, V. Patkós, and K. Pachucki, QED calculations of energy levels of heliumlike ions with 5 ≤ Z ≤ 30, Physical Review A 106, 022815 (2022).DOI
- [55]J. Heisenberg, J. S. McCarthy, and I. Sick, Elastic electron scattering from ¹³C, Nuclear Physics A 157, 435 (1970).DOI
- [56]F. de Boer, B. Aas, P. Baertschi, W. Beer, I. Beltrami, K. Bos, P. Goudsmit, U. Kiebele, B. Jeckelmann, H. J. Leisi, W. Ruckstuhl, G. Strassner, A. Vacchi, and R. Weber, Precision measurement of the 2p-1s transition wavelength in muonic ¹³C, Nuclear Physics A 444, 589 (1985).DOI
- [57]R. Roth, T. Neff, H. Hergert, and H. Feldmeier, Nuclear structure based on correlated realistic nucleon–nucleon potentials, Nuclear Physics A 745, 3 (2004).DOI
- [58]T. Neff and H. Feldmeier, Cluster structures within Fermionic Molecular Dynamics, Nuclear Physics A 738, 357 (2004).DOI
- [59]M. Chernykh, H. Feldmeier, T. Neff, P. von Neumann-Cosel, and A. Richter, Structure of the Hoyle State in ¹²C, Physical Review Letters 98, 032501 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17358679
- [60]E. Epelbaum, H. Krebs, D. Lee, and U.-G. Meißner, Ab initio calculation of the Hoyle state, Physical Review Letters 106, 192501 (2011).DOI
- [61]S. Elhatisari, L. Bovermann, Y.-Z. Ma, E. Epelbaum, D. Frame, F. Hildenbrand, M. Kim, Y. Kim, H. Krebs, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, N. Li, B.-N. Lu, U.-G. Meißner, G. Rupak, D. Shen, Y.-H. Song, and G. Stellin, Wavefunction matching for solving quantum many-body problems, Nature 630, 59 (2024).
- [62]H. Hergert, A Guided Tour of ab initio Nuclear Many-Body Theory, Frontiers in Physics 8, 379 (2020).DOI
- [63]B. Hu, W. Jiang, T. Miyagi, Z. Sun, A. Ekström, C. Forssén, G. Hagen, J. D. Holt, T. Papenbrock, S. R. Stroberg, and I. Vernon, Ab initio predictions link the neutron skin of ²⁰⁸Pb to nuclear forces, Nature Physics 18, 1196 (2022).DOI
- [64]K. Hebeler, V. Durant, J. Hoppe, M. Heinz, A. Schwenk, J. Simonis, and A. Tichai, Normal ordering of three-nucleon interactions for ab initio calculations of heavy nuclei, Physical Review C 107, 024310 (2023).
- [65]H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, T. D. Morris, A. Schwenk, and K. Tsukiyama, The In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group: A novel ab initio method for nuclei, Physics Reports 621, 165 (2016).DOI
- [66]H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, T. D. Morris, S. Binder, A. Calci, J. Langhammer, and R. Roth, Ab initio multi-reference in-medium similarity renormalization group calculations of even calcium and nickel isotopes, Physical Review C 90, 041302 (2014).DOI
- [67]S. R. Stroberg, A. Calci, H. Hergert, J. D. Holt, S. K. Bogner, R. Roth, and A. Schwenk, Nucleus-Dependent Valence-Space Approach to Nuclear Structure, Physical Review Letters 118, 032502 (2017).DOI
- [68]E. Geberfuael, K. Vobig, H. Hergert, and R. Roth, Ab Initio Description of Open-Shell Nuclei: Merging No-Core Shell Model and In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group, Physical Review Letters 118, 152503 (2017).
- [69]L. S. Cardman, J. W. Lightbody, S. Penner, S. P. Fivozinsky, X. K. Maruyama, W. P. Trower, and S. E. Williamson, The charge distribution of ¹²C, Physics Letters B 91, 203 (1980).DOI
- [70]W. Reuter, G. Fricke, K. Merle, and H. Miska, Nuclear charge distribution and rms radius of ¹²C from absolute elastic electron scattering measurements, Physical Review C 26, 806 (1982).DOI
- [71]E. A. Offermann, L. S. Cardman, C. W. de Jager, H. Miska, C. de Vries, and H. de Vries, Energy dependence of the form factor for elastic electron scattering from ¹²C, Physical Review C 44, 1096 (1991).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9967510
- [72]L. A. Schaller, L. Schellenberg, T. Q. Phan, G. Piller, A. Ruetschi, and H. Schnewly, Nuclear charge radii of the carbon isotopes ¹²C, ¹³C and ¹⁴C, Nuclear Physics A 379, 523 (1982).DOI
- [73]K. Hebeler, S. K. Bogner, R. J. Furnstahl, A. Nogga, and A. Schwenk, Improved nuclear matter calculations from chiral low-momentum interactions, Physical Review C 83, 031301 (2011).DOI
- [74]A. Ekström, G. R. Jansen, K. A. Wendt, G. Hagen, T. Papenbrock, B. D. Carlsson, C. Forssén, M. Hjorth-Jensen, P. Navrátil, and W. Nazarewicz, Accurate nuclear radii and binding energies from a chiral interaction, Physical Review C 91, 051301 (2015).DOI
- [75]W. G. Jiang, A. Ekström, C. Forssén, G. Hagen, G. R. Jansen, and T. Papenbrock, Accurate bulk properties of nuclei from A = 2 to ∞ from potentials with Δ isobars, Physical Review C 102, 054301 (2020).DOI
- [76]T. Hüther, K. Vobig, K. Hebeler, R. Machleidt, and R. Roth, Family of chiral two- plus three-nucleon interactions for accurate nuclear structure studies, Physics Letters B 808, 135651 (2020).
- [77]M. Heinz, A. Tichai, J. Hoppe, K. Hebeler, and A. Schwenk, In-medium similarity renormalization group with three-body operators, Physical Review C 103, 044318 (2021).
- [78]J. A. Melendez, R. J. Furnstahl, D. R. Phillips, M. T. Pratola, and S. Wesolowski, Quantifying correlated truncation errors in effective field theory, Physical Review C 100, 044001 (2019).DOI
- [79]P. Virtanen, R. Gommers, T. E. Oliphant, M. Haberland, T. Reddy, D. Cournapeau, E. Burovski, P. Peterson, W. Weckesser, J. Bright, S. J. van der Walt, M. Brett, J. Wilson, K. J. Millman, N. Mayorov, A. R. J. Nelson, E. Jones, R. Kern, E. Larson, C. J. Carey, I. Polat, Y. Feng, E. W. Moore, J. VanderPlas, D. Laxalde, J. Pertold, R. Cirmman, I. Henriksen, E. A. Quintero, C. R. Harris, A. M. Archibald, H. Ribeiro, F. Pedregosa, and P. van Mulbregt, SciPy 1.0: fundamental algorithms for scientific computing in Python, Nature Methods 17, 261 (2020).
- [80]N. J. Stone, Table of recommended nuclear magnetic dipole moments (2019).DOI
- [81]P. Müller, K. König, P. Imgram, J. Krämer, and W. Nörtershäuser, Collinear laser spectroscopy of Ca+: Solving the field-shift puzzle of the 4s²S₁/₂ → 4p²P₁/₂,₃/₂ transitions, Physical Review Research 2, 043351 (2020).
- [82]P. Müller, Laser-spectroscopic determination of the nuclear charge radius of ¹³C, Doctoral thesis (PhD thesis), Technische Universität Darmstadt (2024).
- [83]D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Accurate charge-dependent nucleon-nucleon potential at fourth order of chiral perturbation theory, Physical Review C 68, 041001 (2003).
- [84]S. K. Bogner, R. J. Furnstahl, and R. J. Perry, Similarity renormalization group for nucleon-nucleon interactions, Physical Review C 75, 061001 (2007).
- [85]D. R. Entem, R. Machleidt, and Y. Nosyk, High-quality two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order of the chiral expansion, Physical Review C 96, 024004 (2017).
- [86]K. Hebeler, H. Krebs, E. Epelbaum, J. Golak, and R. Skibiński, Efficient calculation of chiral three-nucleon forces up to N3LO for ab initio studies, Physical Review C 91, 044001 (2015).
- [87]K. Tsukiyama, S. K. Bogner, and A. Schwenk, In-medium similarity renormalization group for nuclei, Physical Review Letters 106, 222502 (2011).
- [88]A. Ong, J. C. Berengut, and V. V. Flambaum, Effect of spin-orbit nuclear charge density corrections due to the anomalous magnetic moment on halonuclei, Physical Review C 82, 014320 (2010).
- [89]R. L. Workman, V. D. Burkert, V. Crede, E. Klempt, U. Thoma, L. Tiator, K. Agashe, G. Aielli, B. C. Allanach, C. Amsler, M. Antonelli, E. C. Aschenauer, D. M. Asner, H. Baer, S. Banerjee, R. M. Barnett, L. Baudis, C. W. Bauer, J. J. Beatty, V. I. Belousov, J. Beringer, A. Bettini, O. Biebel, K. M. Black, E. Blucher, R. Bonventre, V. V. Bryzgalov, O. Buchmueller, M. A. Bychkov, R. N. Cahn, M. Carena, A. Ceccucci, A. Cerri, R. S. Chivukula, G. Cowan, K. Cranmer, O. Cremonesi, G. D’Ambrosio, T. Damour, D. de Florian, A. de Gouvêa, T. DeGrand, P. de Jong, S. Demers, B. A. Dobrescu, M. D’Onofrio, M. Doser, H. K. Dreiner, P. Erola, U. Egede, S. Eidelman, A. X. El-Khadra, J. Ellis, S. C. Eno, J. Erler, V. V. Ezhela, W. Fetscher, B. D. Fields, A. Freitas, H. Gallagher, Y. Gershtein, T. Gherghetta, M. C. Gonzalez-Garcia, M. Goodman, C. Grab, A. V. Gritsan, C. Grojean, D. E. Groom, M. Grünewald, A. Gurtu, T. Gutsche, H. E. Haber, M. Hamel, C. Hanhart, S. Hashimoto, Y. Hayato, A. Hebecker, S. Heinemeyer, J. J. Hernández-Rey, K. Hikasa, J. Hisano, A. Höcker, J. Holder, L. Hsu, J. Huston, T. Hyodo, A. Ianni, M. Kado, M. Karliner, U. F. Katz, M. Kenzie, V. A. Khoze, S. R. Klein, F. Krauss, M. Krebs, P. Krizan, B. Krusche, Y. Kwon, O. Lahav, J. Laiho, L. P. Lelouch, J. Lesgourgues, A. R. Liddle, Z. Ligeti, C.-J. Lin, C. Lippmann, T. M. Liss, L. Littenberg, C. Lourenço, K. S. Lugovsky, S. B. Lugovsky, A. Lusiani, Y. Makida, F. Maltoni, T. Mannel, A. V. Manohar, W. J. Marciano, A. Masoni, J. Matthews, U.-G. Meißner, I.-A. Melzer-Pellmann, M. Mikhasenko, D. J. Miller, D. Milstead, R. E. Mitchell, K. Mönig, P. Molaro, F. Moortgat, M. Moskovic, K. Nakamura, M. Narain, P. Nason, S. Navas, A. Nelles, M. Neubert, P. Nevsky, Y. Nir, K. A. Olive, C. Patrignani, J. A. Peacock, V. A. Petrov, E. Pianori, A. Pich, A. Piepke, F. Pietropaolo, A. Pomarol, S. Pordes, S. Profumo, A. Quadt, K. Rabbertz, J. Rademacker, G. Raffelt, M. Ramsey-Musolf, B. N. Ratcliff, P. Richardson, A. Ringwald, D. J. Robinson, S. Roesler, S. Rolli, A. Romanıouk, L. J. Rosenberg, J. L. Rosner, G. Rybka, M. G. Ryskin, R. A. Ryutin, Y. Sakai, S. Sarkar, F. Sauli, O. Schneider, S. Schöner, K. Scholberg, A. J. Schwartz, J. Schwiening, D. Scott, F. Sefkow, U. Seljak, V. Sharma, S. R. Sharpe, V. Shiltsev, G. Signorelli, M. Silari, F. Simon, T. Sjöstrand, P. Skands, T. Skwarnicki, G. F. Smoot, A. Soffer, M. S. Sozzi, S. Spanier, C. Spiering, A. Stahl, S. L. Stone, Y. Sumino, M. J. Syphers, F. Takahashi, M. Tanabashi, J. Tanaka, M. Taševský, K. Terao, K. Terashi, J. Terning, R. S. Thorne, M. Titov, N. P. Tkachenko, D. R. Tovey, K. Trabelsi, P. Urquijo, G. Valencia, R. van de Water, N. Varelas, G. Venanzoni, L. Verde, I. Vivarelli, P. Vogel, W. Vogelsang, V. Vorobyev, S. P. Wakely, W. Walkowiak, C. W. Walter, D. Wand, D. H. Weinberg, E. J. Weinberg, N. Wermes, M. White, L. R. Wiencke, S. Willocq, C. G. Wohl, C. L. Woody, W.-M. Yao, M. Yokoyama, R. Yoshida, G. Zanderighi, G. P. Zeller, O. V. Zenin, R.-Y. Zhu, S.-L. Zhu, F. Zimmermann, and P. A. Zyła, Review of Particle Physics, Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics 2022, 083C01 (2022).
- [90]S. R. Stroberg, H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, and J. D. Holt, Nonempirical Interactions for the Nuclear Shell Model: An Update, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science 69, 307 (2019).
- [91]J. Hoppe, A. Tichai, M. Heinz, K. Hebeler, and A. Schwenk, Natural orbitals for many-body expansion methods, Physical Review C 103, 014321 (2021).DOI
- [92]N. Shimizu, T. Mizusaki, Y. Utsuno, and Y. Tsunoda, Thick-restart block Lanczos method for large-scale shell-model calculations, Computer Physics Communications 244, 372 (2019).
- [93]A. Tichai, J. Müller, K. Vobig, and R. Roth, Natural orbitals for ab initio no-core shell model calculations, Physical Review C 99, 034321 (2019).