WorksMathematics
Finite Cyclic Fundamental Groups and Exotic Universal Covers from the Cartwright–Steger Surface
Abstract
We use a particular nodal curve on the Cartwright-Steger surface to construct minimal symplectic four-manifolds with arbitrary nontrivial finite cyclic fundamental group and fixed topological invariants . Using these symplectic four-manifolds as building blocks, we construct a symplectic 4-manifold that is homeomorphic to for any integer .
Introduction
The Cartwright–Steger surface is a compact complex ball quotient , where is the complex two-ball and is a torsion-free cocompact lattice. Here a lattice means a discrete subgroup of the Lie group with finite covolume; cocompactness means that the corresponding quotient is compact. Since the ball is contractible, is aspherical and . Its basic topological invariants are
(cf. [8]). We use a nodal totally geodesic curve in to construct symplectic four-manifolds with controlled fundamental groups.
The constructions of Akhmedov–Sakallı–Yeung [5], and the subgroup and complement calculations in [6], use this curve to obtain simply connected examples and examples with fundamental groups and . Here we introduce a further symplectic sum that permits arbitrary finite cyclic groups while retaining a Cartwright–Steger building block.
The covering degree of a curve and the order of the final fundamental group play different roles. Once the curve subgroup is the mod-two kernel in the Cartwright–Steger lattice, passing to larger covers does not produce larger cyclic quotients by the same surface-sum argument. We first make this restriction explicit. We then use a genus-two surface of square in the simply connected fourfold-cover construction. Summing along this surface with a genus-two surface of square in a one-point blowup of produces a new simply connected symplectic manifold with an essential Lagrangian torus whose complement is simply connected.
Theorem 1.1. For every integer , there is a closed minimal symplectic four-manifold satisfying
Its universal cover is symplectic and is homeomorphic, but not diffeomorphic, to
the connected sum of copies of the complex projective plane and copies of the complex projective plane equipped with the noncomplex orientation. The deck transformations give a free symplectic -action on .
The cyclic group is introduced by a symplectic torus bundle over a torus. Its monodromy matrix (see (8) below) has cokernel after subtracting the identity. We will make use of a genus-two symplectic sum producing the required torus complement from the Cartwright–Steger construction. We also prove a parity lemma (Lemma 4.2) that applies to any such torus whenever the signature of the simply connected manifold is nonzero modulo eight. This avoids inferring the parity of an even-degree cover from the parity of its quotient.
We do not assert that the displayed characteristic numbers are optimal, or classify the homeomorphism types of the non-simply connected quotients in this paper. We plan to deal with these issues in a sequel paper. The only finite-index lattice calculation used below is the subgroup identification established in [6], and in particular, no new coset enumeration is required.
Exotic symplectic non-spin four-manifolds with cyclic fundamental group and negative signature were studied in [15]. More recently, exotic non-spin four-manifolds with positive signature and cyclic fundamental group of order were constructed in [7]. Positive-signature non-spin examples with cyclic fundamental group of order were constructed in [12].
Curves, covers, and the simply connected building block
Let be the Cartwright–Steger surface and . The invariants and curve data used here are
Choose the type A nodal curve used in [5, 6]. Its normalization has genus four, it has one positive ordinary node, and
These numerical data come from [8]. Write
The subgroup computation of [6 Proposition 6.3] identifies
Here means the fundamental group of the singular curve, not of its normalization. Smoothing the node preserves this ambient image: the new handle contains a branch-joining loop, and its dual vanishing cycle is nullhomotopic in the ambient coordinate ball. This is the local calculation in [6 Lemma 6.8].
Numerical behavior in covers
For an unramified holomorphic cover of degree , the full pullback of the nodal curve satisfies
When the full pullback is connected, smoothing its positive nodes gives an embedded symplectic surface of genus in the same homology class. The smoothing genus equals the arithmetic genus . For a divisor on a smooth complex surface , we use
It differs from the genus of the normalization, which removes the nodes without joining their branches. If the pullback of the normalization has components of degrees , then
where is the genus of the -th component. Connectedness of the singular pullback does not imply connectedness of its normalization.
Let be the cover corresponding to . Equation (2) implies that the inverse image of consists of four disjoint copies, each mapping with degree one. For a further cover of degree , the full pullback of a chosen copy is connected. After smoothing, it has genus and square . A regular blowup at a point of the smoothing gives square and an exceptional geometric dual. Blowing up regular points instead gives square . The exceptional spheres meet the surface once each. This order of operations supplies the meridian relation used in [6].
We now specify the surface sum used to compare the possible quotients. Let have finite index, and let be its connected cover. Choose a connected lift of the smoothed curve and blow up a regular point of it. Denote the resulting manifold by and the proper transform of the chosen curve by . Suppose that a simply connected symplectic four-manifold contains a symplectic surface of the same genus as and of opposite self-intersection. For an admissible normal-bundle gluing, form the symplectic sum (cf. [10])
The following proposition applies whenever this matching positive block exists.
Proposition 2.1. The image of in is , up to conjugacy, and the symplectic sum just defined satisfies
In particular, this symplectic sum construction gives only the trivial group, , or .
Proof. The smoothed surface still has image in . The restriction of its cover to the chosen component has subgroup given by the inverse image of under its fundamental-group homomorphism. Its image in is . Since is normal in , this subgroup is normal in . The exceptional geometric dual kills the meridian of . The fundamental group of the complement of is normally generated by the meridian of , because is simply connected. The gluing kills this group and imposes precisely the surface subgroup on . Van Kampen gives the displayed quotient, and the final isomorphism is the first isomorphism theorem. □
We use the fourfold cover, so that this quotient is trivial.
Proposition 2.2. There is a simply connected minimal symplectic four-manifold with
containing a symplectic genus-two surface of square .
Proof. Smooth one lifted nodal curve in , and blow up a regular point. The proper transform in has genus five and square ; its exceptional sphere meets it once. Blowing up a point does not change the fundamental group, so
Under these identifications, the image of is all of .
The minimal simply connected symplectic block of [5] has , and square-zero symplectic surfaces of genera two and three, intersecting positively once.
Their symplectic resolution has genus five and square . A sufficiently small parallel symplectic copy of has
The geometric intersection statement, including the choice of the parallel copy, is verified in [6 Lemma 4.1].
Form the symplectic sum
Choose an admissible gluing matching the marked intersections with and and their local normal framings. The meridian of is trivial, since the punctured is a bounding disk. The fundamental group of the complement of dies with its meridian, and the loops on kill on the side. Hence . The symplectic sum formulas give
Glue the punctured surfaces and along their boundary circles, and call the resulting embedded surface . Here the symplectic property requires compatible local data, in addition to the oriented framing calculation. By a local symplectic isotopy, arrange that both dual surfaces meet their summing surfaces symplectically orthogonally at the marked points. Choose matching Darboux charts and take the base gluing to be the identity on the marked disks and the normal-fiber phase to be constant, and rescale the forms on the summands to match the areas of the summing surfaces. In the local symplectic sum model , the base coordinate is and the two dual disks are on the respective sides. Their punctured parts join through the annulus , . This annulus is complex for the standard local compatible structure and is therefore symplectic. It agrees with the dual surfaces near the ends of the neck, so the standard sum form makes the whole joined surface symplectic (cf. [10]). Thus is symplectic, has genus two, and its normal Euler number is
The constant-phase matching of the local normal framings makes the relative Euler numbers additive, as in [6 Lemma 5.2].
Finally, is aspherical, and hence . Let be the blowdown map, and let be any embedded exceptional sphere in the blowup. The composite map is nullhomotopic, so . The kernel of on integral second homology is , the subgroup of integer multiples of the exceptional class. Thus for an integer . Since , we have . Consequently , and no exceptional sphere is disjoint from . The other summand is minimal. Neither summand is an -bundle with the summing surface as a section. Usher’s theorem in [16] proves that is minimal. □
A genus-two sum with simply connected torus complement
The next sum produces the torus needed to prescribe the cyclic group. We write
with its product symplectic form and circle coordinates . Let and . Resolve their single positive intersection to obtain a genus-two symplectic surface with . Blow up a regular point of , and let denote its proper transform in
Then , , and the exceptional sphere meets once.
Choose and set
It is a Lagrangian torus disjoint from . Choose the local chart used for the resolution, and the ball used for the blowup, with closures disjoint from . These operations then leave a neighborhood of unchanged, so is disjoint from and remains Lagrangian in . Its normal bundle is trivial.
The statement below holds for any pair with the indicated properties. We subsequently apply it to the pair constructed in Proposition 2.2.
Theorem 3.1. Let be a simply connected minimal symplectic four-manifold containing a symplectic genus-two surface of square . Form
Then is minimal and simply connected. The torus survives as an essential Lagrangian torus, and
Moreover,
Proof. Choose the symplectic sum away from . The complement of this product torus has a particularly simple form:
Consequently,
Here and are infinite cyclic groups, so their product is , and is the free group on . We use the commutator convention . The meridian of is therefore , up to orientation. Blowing up at a point away from does not change this group.
Put and . The exceptional sphere of punctured at its unique intersection with gives a disk in bounded by the meridian . Thus in . Filling back kills only the normal closure of this meridian, so
Choose the deleted disk in the torus disjoint from the coordinate wedge . The punctured torus retracts onto this wedge, whose loops give the free generators . The coordinate tori carry the four loops ; resolving their intersection only changes their based representatives inside a ball disjoint from . Choose the blowup point away from these loops. Their images therefore normally generate the full group in (5), including its nonabelian punctured-torus factor. The boundaries of the summing surfaces are circle bundles of Euler numbers and ; the loops used in van Kampen are lifts of these surface generators, together with the circle fiber.
Because is simply connected, is normally generated by the meridian . The gluing identifies with the inverse of the trivial , so the entire -side group dies. The remaining boundary relations kill the four surface loops on the side, and hence . Equations (5) and (6) now give . This proof does not assume that itself is simply connected. Restoring also gives .
Let . The long exact homology sequence of the pair , excision and Künneth theorems give
Thus the homology class is primitive and nonzero. The local product form makes Lagrangian before the sum, and the sum preserves the symplectic form in a neighborhood of .
The summand is minimal. Every exceptional sphere in has class , by the same asphericity argument applied to , and intersects . If a summand were an -bundle with the genus-two summing surface as a section, its base would have genus two and its fundamental group would be the genus-two surface group. This is incompatible with and with . Usher’s theorem therefore gives minimality.
Since , , and , the sum formulas give and . The formulas for and follow. □
Applying Theorem 3.1 to Proposition 2.2 gives
The minimal simply connected symplectic manifold is irreducible by [11], in the usual convention allowing homotopy-sphere summands.
Introducing cyclic groups and controlling parity
We introduce the group by monodromy, using a torus bundle with a square-zero symplectic section.
Lemma 4.1. Let be a simply connected irreducible minimal symplectic four-manifold containing an essential Lagrangian torus with simply connected exterior . For every there is a minimal symplectic manifold with and with the same Euler characteristic and signature as . The construction retains as a submanifold.
Proof. Consider the matrix
Choose an orientation-preserving diffeomorphism of the torus , inducing , which is the identity on a neighborhood of a small closed disk . Such a representative exists because the mapping class group of the torus with a disk fixed maps onto . We may choose it to be area preserving: start with a fixed area form ; the difference vanishes near and has integral zero. Relative Moser isotopy on the complement of corrects the map without changing its mapping class or its restriction near .
Let
Write for the mapping-torus coordinate and for the last circle coordinate. Projection to makes a torus bundle . Since preserves , the form descends to a symplectic form on . For , the torus is the image of a section of . Its tangent plane is the base plane, on which restricts to ; thus is symplectic. It has trivial normal bundle. Its product neighborhood comes from the disk on which is the identity.
Let generate the fundamental group of the punctured fiber and let be the automorphism induced by , using a basepoint on the boundary of the fixed disk. Since the map is the identity there, fixes the boundary commutator . With positively oriented in the mapping-torus coordinate, the section exterior has presentation
The section-boundary longitudes are , and its meridian is , up to orientation. Perturb the form on to make the essential Lagrangian torus symplectic, and match its area with that of by rescaling the form on [10 Lemma 1.6]. Form
The simply connected exterior kills the entire boundary image. Consequently van Kampen imposes and . After abelianization of the fundamental group of the punctured fiber, the remaining monodromy relations are precisely . Thus
Indeed,
The cyclic quotient can also be read directly from the columns of : in additive notation the generators satisfy
The second relation eliminates , and the first then becomes . Thus the quotient is cyclic of order .
The torus bundle is aspherical, by the homotopy exact sequence of its torus fibration over . It therefore has no exceptional spheres. It has and : Euler characteristic is multiplicative for the bundle, and the product with admits an orientation-reversing diffeomorphism. Neither summand is a ruled surface with the summing torus as a section: is simply connected, whereas a ruled surface with a torus section has fundamental group ; is aspherical. The perturbed form on is still minimal because smooth irreducibility excludes exceptional spheres. Usher’s theorem therefore gives minimality of the sum. A torus sum adds neither Euler characteristic nor signature in this case. Finally, the entire exterior is retained, and no modification affects its interior. □
Non-spinness of alone would not determine the parity of an even-degree cover of . The following lemma provides a class in the retained exterior.
Lemma 4.2. Let be a closed simply connected smooth oriented four-manifold, and let be a square-zero torus with simply connected exterior . If , then contains a closed embedded oriented surface of odd self-intersection.
Proof. Write with its unimodular intersection pairing, , and . The exact sequence
shows that is surjective and is primitive. Let . Suppose, for contradiction, that every vector in has even square. The function
is linear. The mod-two image of is exactly : when is even, choose with and replace by , which has the same mod-two class and lies in . Thus for .
If , the lattice is even, so its signature is divisible by eight. If , then is characteristic, and van der Blij’s lemma in [13] gives . Both cases contradict and the signature hypothesis. Therefore contains an element of odd square. Exactness lifts it to . Represent this class by an immersed closed oriented surface in the interior, resolve its double points, and join components by tubes if necessary. This gives an embedded surface representing the same class, with odd square. □
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Construct as above, and apply Lemma 4.1. Equation (7) gives the invariants of . Lemma 4.2 applies because . The odd-square surface is retained in . Its fundamental group has trivial image in , since its inclusion factors through the simply connected exterior . Let be the universal covering map. Its degree is , since . The image of is trivial, so its monodromy action on the points of a covering fiber is trivial. Consequently the restricted covering is the disjoint union of degree-one coverings:
The normal bundle of each is the degree-one pullback of the normal bundle of . Their normal Euler numbers therefore agree, so is odd. An even intersection form would make every integral homology class have even square; the class excludes this. Thus the intersection form of is odd for every , including even .
The symplectic form pulls back to , and
Since the cover is simply connected,
Its intersection form is odd, indefinite and unimodular, hence
Freedman’s theorem in [9], together with the vanishing Kirby–Siebenmann invariant of the smooth cover, gives the stated homeomorphism. Taubes’s theorem in [14] gives a nonzero Seiberg–Witten invariant because . The standard connected sum has vanishing Seiberg–Witten invariants: it splits into two summands with positive . The cover is therefore not diffeomorphic to the standard model. The deck group preserves the pulled-back symplectic form and acts freely.
Geography and integral homology
The construction separates the choice of group order from the characteristic numbers of the quotient. For every ,
where the Betti numbers are taken over . Integral duality gives
Indeed, abelianization determines ; the free rank of follows from ; and Poincaré duality with the universal coefficient theorem identifies its torsion with . For a summary of the topological invariants, we have the following table.
| Manifold | ||||
| Cartwright–Steger seed | 38 | 2 | 10 | 82 |
| Genus-two sum | 43 | 1 | 11 | 89 |
| Cyclic quotient | 43 | 1 | 11 | 89 |
| Universal cover |
Table 1.
For , the universal cover is an exotic ; for , it is an exotic . These examples have free symplectic cyclic actions with quotients of positive signature one. For comparison, exotic with signature 2 were constructed for all odd in [5]. Exotic with signature 3 were constructed for all odd in [4]. We refer to [1], [2] and [3] for the existence of exotic smooth structures for other signatures. It is not known to the authors whether the exotic smooth structures that we constructed in this paper are in fact diffeomorphic to the exotic smooth structures in [5], [4] and [1]. Finally, our construction differs from the intermediate-double-cover sum in [6]: the extra genus-two sum changes the quotient invariants and supplies the torus needed to prescribe the cyclic order.
Acknowledgments
Magma was used to assist with fundamental group computations, and an LLM-based tool was used solely for grammar checking. All mathematical ideas are due to the authors, who reviewed the material and take full responsibility for the content of the manuscript.
References
(A. Akhmedov) School of Mathematics, University of Minnesota, 206 Church Street SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA
Email address: [email protected]
(B. D. Park) Department of Pure Mathematics, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue W, Waterloo, ON, N2L 3G1, Canada
Email address: [email protected]
(S. Sakallı) Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of South Florida, 4202 E. Fowler Avenue, Tampa, FL 33620, USA
Email address: [email protected]
(S.-K. Yeung) Department of Mathematics, Purdue University, 150 N. University Street, West Lafayette, IN 47907-2067, USA
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]A. Akhmedov, M. C. Hughes and B. D. Park, Geography of simply connected nonspin symplectic 4-manifolds with positive signature, Pacific J. Math. 261 (2013), no. 2, 257–282.DOI
- [2]A. Akhmedov and B. D. Park, New symplectic 4-manifolds with nonnegative signature, J. Gökova Geom. Topol. GGT 2 (2008), 1–13.
- [3]A. Akhmedov and B. D. Park, Geography of simply connected nonspin symplectic 4-manifolds with positive signature, II, Canad. Math. Bull. 64 (2021), no. 2, 418–428.DOI
- [4]A. Akhmedov, S. Sakallı, On the geography of simply connected nonspin symplectic 4-manifolds with nonnegative signature, Topology Appl. 206 (2016), 24–45.arxiv.org/abs/1506.00230
- [5]A. Akhmedov, S. Sakallı, and S.-K. Yeung, Complex ball quotients and new symplectic 4-manifolds with nonnegative signatures, Taiwanese J. Math. 28 (2024), no. 1, 29–53.arxiv.org/abs/2102.05265
- [6]A. Akhmedov and S.-K. Yeung, Torus surgery constraints and intermediate covers of the Cartwright-Steger surface, arXiv:2610.06442. Subgroup computation and supporting files at: https://github.com/akhmedov-coder/cartwright-steger-torus-surgery.arxiv.org/abs/2610.06442
- [7]R. İ. Baykur and A. I. Stipsicz and Z. Szabó, Smooth structures on four-manifolds with finite cyclic fundamental groups, arXiv:2406.09007.arxiv.org/abs/2406.09007
- [8]D. I. Cartwright, V. Koziarz, and S.-K. Yeung, On the Cartwright–Steger surface, J. Algebraic Geom. 26 (2017), no. 4, 655–689.arxiv.org/abs/1412.4137
- [9]M. H. Freedman, The topology of four-dimensional manifolds, J. Differential Geom. 17 (1982), no. 3, 357–453.DOI
- [10]R. E. Gompf, A new construction of symplectic manifolds, Ann. of Math. (2) 142 (1995), no. 3, 527–595.DOI
- [11]M. J. D. Hamilton and D. Kotschick, Minimality and irreducibility of symplectic four-manifolds, Int. Math. Res. Not. (2006), Art. ID 35032.DOI
- [12]R. Ladu and S. Tagliente, On smooth structures over 4-manifolds with fundamental group of even order, arXiv:2603.29794.arxiv.org/abs/2603.29794
- [13]J. Milnor and D. Husemoller, Symmetric bilinear forms, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete, vol. 73, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1973.DOI
- [14]C. H. Taubes, The Seiberg–Witten invariants and symplectic forms, Math. Res. Lett. 1 (1994), no. 6, 809–822.DOI
- [15]R. Torres, Geography and botany of irreducible non-spin symplectic 4-manifolds with abelian fundamental group, Glasg. Math. J. 56 (2014), no. 2, 261–281.DOI
- [16]M. Usher, Minimality and symplectic sums, Int. Math. Res. Not. (2006), Art. ID 49857.arxiv.org/abs/math/0606543